7-*•.27*52&7.32&0 &2)•7-*•.27*52&7.32&0•(39*2&27 32•*(3231...

of 31 /31
G:KJ:7:A<:9:9GD>I>CI:GC6I>DC6A )11*')ánV[f[a`e7GJNA6CI$7dgjW^^We 7-* .27*52&7.32&0 132*7&5; +82)I6 (32).7.32&0.7; &2) 7-* .27*52&7.32&0(39*2&27 32 *(3231.( 63(.&0 &2) (80785&05.,-76 % &2&77*147 73 )*+.2* 7-* 5*0&7.32 E6G [email protected]=?<>A08(&6 6 KD86I 6J 7 6GG:6J 9: 7 GJM:AA:H $ A&A&B& > CIGD9J8I>DC >& > CIGD9J8I>DC ID I=: E GD7A:B )&)& DSP 3ZYOT_TZYLWT_d ZQ_SP 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW =ZYP_L]d6`YO )&)&)&IZWBSaZ[`Wdk )&)&*&IZWHUabW )&*& DSP 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW 3ZaPYLY_ ZY 5NZYZXTP" CZNTLW LYO 3`W_`]LWBTRS_^ )&*&)& <W`WdS^ )&*&*&IZW:Ua`a_[W$HaU[S^S`V8g^fgdS^7[YZfe )&+& DSP CZNTLW 5QQPN_^ ZQ_SP 9$=$6$ @ZWTNd LYO _SP 9^^`P$ >>& I =: > HHJ: ))&)& 9^ _SP 9$=$6$ 2Z`YO Md _SP 9$3$5$C$7$B$0 ))&)&)&IZW8ZSdfWdaXfZWJ`[fWVCSf[a`e$IZWJ`[hWdeS^9sU^SdSf[a`a` =g_S`G[YZfeS`V>`fWd`Sf[a`S^8gefa_SdkASi ))&)&*&J`[^SfsdS^6Uf[a`TkfZW>&B&;&BW_TWde >>&)&+&IZW>&B&;&SeSHbWU[S^[lWV6YW`UkaXfZWJ&C& ))&*& 9^ _SP 9$=$6$ [ZWTNdTYNZY^T^_PY_ bT_S _SP 9$7$5$C$3$B$5 ))&*&)&LZSfVaWefZW>&8&:&H&8&G&dWcg[dWe5 ))&*&*&>efZW>&B&;&ba^[UkUa`e[efW`fi[fZiZSf[edWcg[dWV5 &))&+& DZ bSL_5c_PY_ T^ _SP 9$=$6$ BP^[ZY^TMWPQZ] _SP q1`^_P]T_d=PL^`]P^r0 8DC8AJH>DC

Author: lekhue

Post on 01-May-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

Embed Size (px)

TRANSCRIPT

  • G:KJ:7:AI>CI:GC6I>DC6A)11*') nV[f[a`e7GJNA6CI$ 7dgjW^^We

    7-* .27*52&7.32&0132*7&5; +82)I6 (32).7.32&0.7;&2) 7-* .27*52&7.32&0(39*2&27

    32*(3231.( 63(.&0&2) (80785&05.,-76 % &2&77*147

    73 )*+.2* 7-* 5*0&7.32

    E6G

    [email protected]=?A08(&6

    6KD86I 6J 76GG:6J 9: 7GJM:AA:H $

    A&A&B&

    >CIGD9J8I>DC

    >& >CIGD9J8I>DC ID I=: EGD7A:B

    )&)& DSP 3ZYOT_TZYLWT_dZQ_SP 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW=ZYP_L]d6`YO)&)&)& IZWBSaZ[`Wdk)&)&*& IZWHUabW

    )&*& DSP9Y_P]YL_TZYLW3ZaPYLY_ZY5NZYZXTP" CZNTLWLYO3 W_ ]LWBTRS_^)&*&)& > & I=: > HHJ:

    ))&)& 9^ _SP 9$=$6$ 2Z`YOMd _SP9$3$5$C$7$B$0))&)&)& IZW 8ZSdfWd aX fZW J`[fWV CSf[a`e$ IZW J [hWdeS^ 9sU^SdSf[a a

    =g_S`G[YZfe S`V>`fWd`Sf[a`S^8gefa_SdkASi))&)&*& J [^SfsdS^6Uf[a`TkfZW>&B&;&BW_TWde>>&)&+& IZW >&B&;& SeSHbWU[S^[lWV6YW`UkaXfZWJ&C&

    ))&*& 9^_SP9$=$6$[ZWTNdTYNZY T _PY_bT_S_SP9$7$5$C$3$B$5))&*&)& LZSfVaWe fZW>&8&:&H&8&G& dWcg[dWe5))&*&*& >e fZW>&B&;& ba^[Uk Ua`e[efW`fi[fZiZSf [edWcg[dWV5

    &))&+& DZbSL_5c_PY_T _SP9$=$6$ BP^[ZY TMWPQZ] _SP q1`^_P]T_d=PL^`]P^r0

    8DC8AJH>DC

  • )(. BI8=6:A AJ86H

    U[fe",# 2 [febd[`U[bS^SUf[h[fkUa`e[efe[`fZWSffd[Tgf[a`aX^aS`efaBW_%TWdHfSfWeXSW[`YegUZbdaT^W_e& IZWS[V[e`afSgfa_Sf[US^S`VfZWHfSfWeiZ[UZi[eZ faTW`WX[fXda_[f_gefUa__[ffZW_eW^hWefa Sbb^k[`YS`g_%TWd aX_WSegdWei[fZ Sh[WifadW%WefST^[eZ[`YfZWTS^S`UW aXbSk_W`fead$ Sf^WSef$ Td[`Y[`Y[fTSU]fa S`SUUWbfST^W^WhW^S`VfaTW[`YST^WfabSkfZW ^aS`TSU]"-#&

    IZSf bdaUWee [e US^^WV Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk".#3 [f Xx`Ve [fe ^sYS^ TSe[e [`Sdf[U^W )"-# aXfZW6df[U^WeaX6YdWW_W`f$iZ[UZefSfWe fZSf a`W aXfZWbgd%baeWe aXfZW;g`V [e

    faY[hWUa`X[VW`UWfaBW_TWdeTk_S][`YfZWYs`sdS^dWeagdUWeaXfZW;g`VfW_badSd[^k ShS[^ST^W fa fZW_ g`VWd LOP\ L_P ^LQPR`L]O " fZge bdah[V[`YfZW_i[fZ fZW abbadfg`[fk fa UaddWUf _S^SV\gef_W`fe [ fZW[d TS^S`UW aXbSk_W`fe &&&"/# "[fS^[Ueegbb^[WV#&

    IZWbdSUf[UW aX_S][`Y^aS`eUa`V[f[a`S^TWYS`WSd^k"0#$ Tgf[fiSeXad%_S^^kdWUaY`[lWVa`^k[`)1.0$i[fZfZWXxdefS_W`V_W`faXfZW6df[U^We"1#&>` )1/1$ fZW:jWUgf[hW7aSdVSVabfWVYg[VW^[`Wea`Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk$ Ua`e[e%f[`Y aXfiW^hW dg^We dWYg^Sf[`Y fZW;g`Ve [`fWdhW`f[a`")(#&

    ,& LW i[^^$ ^SfWd$ Uad`W TSU] fa Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk3 ^Wf ge `ai fg_ fa [feUa`fWjf& ;[def$ [f_gefTW`afWVfZSf fZW >&B&;&e S[V[e`af^WYS^^kS^aS`Tgf S Tgk S`VeW^^ absdSf[a` 2

    fZW>&B&;& eW^^eXadW[Y UgddW`UkfafZWVWTfad`Sf[a`[ WjUZS`YWXadfZSf`Sf[a eai`UgddW`Uk&IZ[e[efZWbdaUWeeaXVdSi[`YXda_fZW>&B&;&&LZW fZWUag`fdkUa`UWd`WVUad WefabSkTSU]fZW>&B&;&$ [fZSefaTgkTSU][feai UgddW`Uk$bSk[`YXad[fi[fZfZWZSdVUgddW U[We"adYa^V#fZSf[fZSeWSd%`WVSTdaSV"))#&

    -& HWUa`V^k$ fZW fWd_ qS[V dWXWde fa S `g_TWd aXiSke [` iZ[UZ fZW;g`V _S]W [fe dWeagdUWe ShS[^ST^W 2 fZW GWeWdhW IdS`UZW "*- aX fZW

    EYT_PO>L_TZY^D]PL_dCP]TP^"ha^&*$+1S`[email protected]]_d2]ZVP]^"DSP9$=$6$LYO>$>&B&;&$LSeZ[`Yfa`9&8&$ )10,$,+/3K : GAD G :C K 6 C I =:B 66I ?&$ Ha`[W`afWe a` >&B&;& 8a`V[f[a`S^[fk$ TY 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW&B&;&WjbWUfeS_W_TWdfaXa^^ai[`adVWdfaTWpT^W fageW fZW;g`VeYs`sdS^dWeagdUWe3 a` Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk$ eWW< DA9 ?&$ 3ZYOT_TZYLWT_d">&B&;&$ LSeZ[`Yfa`9&8&$ )1/1 "ES_bZ^WfHWd[We$ `~+)#&"/# HWW`afW )&"0# H[`UW )1,/$ SUUadV[`Yfa7^SdVa`W3 eWW7 A6G9DC:

  • ; J C 9 H 8 D C 9 > I > D C 6 A > I N 6 C 9 > C I : G C 6 I >D C 6 A 8 D K : C 6 C I )(/

    HfSfWe cgafS#$ fZW ;[def 8dsV[f IdS`UZW S`V fZW fZdWW 8dWV[f IdS`UZWe"*- fZWcgafSXadWSUZ#$ fZW:jfW`VWV;g`V;SU[^[fk"gbfa ),( aXfZWcgafS#$fZWHgbb^W_W`fSdk;[`S`U[`Y;SU[^[fkS`VafZWdebWU[X[UUdsV[fXSU[%^[f[We "D[^ ;SU[^[fk$ 7gXXWd HfaU] ;[`S`U[`Y$ && ")*#& >f _gef TW efdWeeWVfZSf`afS[^fZaeWXSU[^[f[WeSdWUa`V[f[a`S^$ S`VfZSffZWVWYdWWaXUa`V[f[a%`S^[fkhSd[WeSUUadV[`Yfa fZWUSfWYadk")+#&NWf$ [` )10*$ fZdWW%cgSdfWdeaXfZW fafS^ hS^gW aXfZaeW ^aS`eiWdW Ua`V[f[a`S^&

    .& IZ[dV^k$ iW _gef Td[WX^k Ua`e[VWd fZW bdaUWVgdW fZSf ^WSVe fa fZWYdS`f[`Y aXS^aS`& IZW HfSfW SVVdWeeWe SdWcgWef fa fZW:jWUgf[hW7aSdV$TkiZ[UZ[f[`Xad_efZW^SffWdaX[fe[`fW`f[a` fa geWfZW;g`VedWeagdUWe&IZWTaSdVVse[Y`qfWeSfWS_aX[feefSXXfah[e[ffZWdWcgWef[`YUag`fdkS`Vfa YSfZWdS[^ fZWdW^WhS`f[`Xad_Sf[a`STagf fZW e[fgSf[a`aXfZW^aUS^WUa%`a_k&IS^]ei[^^fZW`fS]Wb^SUWTWfiWW`fZW>&B&;& fWS_S`VHfSfWeaXX[%U[S[e dW^Sf[`Y fa fZW ba^[Uk Sbbdabd[SfW Xad dWVgU[`Y fZW TS^S`UW aXbSk%_W`fe VWX[U[f&

    >XfZWfS^]eSdWbdaVgUf[hW$ fZWYahWd`_W`f Ua`UWd`WVi[^^id[fWVai`SVWfS[^WVbdaYdS__W$ Ua`e[efW`fi[fZiZSfZSeTWW`SYdWWV$[`fZWea%US^^WVAWffWdaX>`fW`f&7kSVVdWee[`YfZ[eVaUg_W`ffafZW>&B&;&$fZWYahWd`%_W`f Ua__[fe [feW^Xfa [_b^W_W`f[`YfZW_WSegdWe Ua`fS[`WV[` [f&

    IZW :jWUgf[hW 7aSdVe VsU[e[a` fa YdS`f S ^aS` [e US^^WV S HfS`V%Tk6ddS`YW_W`f "H&7&6 "),#& >f Ua`fS[`e bWdXad_S`UW Ud[fWd[S$ iZ[UZ SdWcgS^[fSf[hW S`V cgS`f[fSf[hW Ud[fWd[S fZSf _gef TW aTeWdhWV Vgd[`Y fZWbWd[aV aX fZW H&7&6& [X fZW Uag`fdki[eZWe fa dWfS[` [fe d[YZf fa geW fZW;g`Ve dWeagdUWe")-#&

    /& ;[`S^^k$ iW _gef SVV fZSf fZW >&B&;&e fZWdSbk [e aXfia ][`Ve 2 [fUa`e[efe$ a`fZWa`WZS`V$[`HfST[^[lSf[a`EdaYdS__We$S`Va`fZWafZWdZS`V$ [` HfdgUfgdS^ 6V\gef_s`f EdaYdS__We "H&6&E& IZW Xad_WdeUa`fS[` TgVYWfSdk S`V_a`WfSdk_WSegdWe S[_WV Sf dWea^h[`Y TS^S`UW aXbSk_W`febdaT^W_e[`fZWeZadffWd_3fZW^SffWdeUa`fS[`_WSegdWedW^Sf[`Y

    ")* # HWW< DA9 ?&Z[$ NT_$"Ka^g_W>$,*. fa,++ S`V6 N : : ?&G&6&$ HiSl[^S`VS`VfZW>`fWd%`Sf[a`S^Ba`WfSdk;g`V$ FP]QL^`YR`YOBPNS_TY fMP]^PP" ha^& *,$ )11($ -,&

    ")+ # HWWIST^W * &) $ 9dSi[`YG[YZfe [` fZW >&B&;& [`@ oGC :G E& S`VafZWde$ Z[$ NT_$" -*&"),# 6H&7&6& [e VWX[`WV Se S VsU[e[a` aXfZW ;g`V TkiZ[UZ S_W_TWd [e SeegdWV fZSf [f

    i[^^TWST^Wfa_S]WbgdUZSeWeXda_fZW

  • )(0 B>8=:A AJ86H

    fabdaVgUf[a`$ V[efd[Tgf[a`S`VWjUZS`YWaXYaaVei[fZSh[WifadWea^h[`YefdgUfgdS^ VsX[U[fe [`fZW ^a`Y fWd_").#&

    6`sha^gf[a`Xda_HfST[^[lSf[a`faiSdVe6V\ge_W`feWW_efaZShWaUUg%dWV[`fZWeWUa`VZS^XaXfZW eWhW`f[We")/# Tgf [fiag^VTWida`Yfa fZ[`]fZSf fZaeW fia USfsYad[We SdW WjU^ge[hW$ e[`UW fZW H&6&E&e S^ea [`ha^hW_a`WfSdk S`V TgVYWfSdk_WSegdWe")0#&

    )&)&*& DSP CNZ[P$

    0& =Sh[`Y VWeUd[TWV fZW absdSf[a` aX Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk$ iW eZS^^ `ai_S]W S XWi aTeWdhSf[a`e dWYSdV[`Y [fe dWS^b^SUW [` fZWiad^V& LZSfVaWeUa`V[f[a`S^[fk_WS`XadfZW Uag`fd[We5 IaiZSfWjfW`fSdWfZWkUa`UWd`WVi[fZ [f5

    1& IaTWY[`i[fZ$[f_gefTW`afWVfZSfdWUagdeWfafZW>&B&;&[eS_WS`eaX^SefdWeadf")1#&6_W_TWdHfSfWi[^^WhW`fgS^^kYafafZW;g`ViZW`S[^fZW afZWd_WS`eZShW TWW` WjZSgefWV 2 `a_adWbgT^[U`adbd[hSfW ^aS`e$`a_adWdWeWdhWSeeWfe$ad`afW`agYZ&>XfZW;g`VeUa`V[f[a`eUS`TWSha[%VWV$ fZWki[^^ TW!

    IZ[e [ebdaTST^ka`W aXfZW dWSea`eiZk$ e[`UWfZW TWY[`[`Y aXfZWW[YZ%f[We$ a`^k AWee 9WhW^abWV 8ag`fd[We "A&9&8&e# ZShW ZSV dWUagdeW fa fZW;g`VedWeagdUWe"*(#&IZWeW[`U^gVW$S_a`YafZWde$fZWEZ[^[bb[`We$hadk 8aSef$ OSxdW$ OS_T[S$ 6dYW`f[`S$ 7dSl[^$ 8Z[^W$ BWj[Ua$ EWdg S`VKW`WlgW^S&

    )(& D`W aXfZW_S[` S`V aXfW`dWUS^^WV XWSfgdWe aXUa`V[f[a`S^[fk [e [feWjfW`e[a` TWka`V [fe [`ef[fgf[a`S^ TadVWde$ Se VWX[`WV [` fZW 6df[U^We aX6YdWW_W`f"*)# 2 fZSf `W_]LaT]P^ fW`VW`Uk[e VgW fa eWhWdS^ XSUfade 2

    fZW>&B&;&^STW^adeWS^aXSbbdahS^ 2fZWUdsV[fiadfZ[`WeeaXSUag`%fdk [ UdWSeWeeZSdb^kiZW [f Ua`Xad_e fa>&B&;&eba^[Uk& H&7&6&eabW fZW

    ").# HWW ? 6 G G : I B&%;& S`VB 6 I= >: J ;&G&$ 6\gefW_W`f efdgUfgdW^$ 8da[eeS`UW Wf GsbSdf[%f[a`2 ^!WjW_b^WVW^S8yfWV[ha[dW$BPa`PO`DTP]^#=ZYOP$`~)*-$)11($,(S`V= : AA:G E&S`VafZWde$ DPY TX[WTNL_TZY^ ZQ6`YO C`[[Z]_PO 1OU`^_XPY_ @]ZR]LX^QZ] @ZaP]_d$ 5c[i]TPYNP^ TYCPWPN_PO 3Z`Y_]TP^$ >&B&;&$LSeZ[`Yfa`9&8&$ )100 "DUUSe[a`S^ESbWde`~-0#$ )+&")/# HWW A = G >I : 6J B&%;&$ &B&;&Ua`V[f[a`eSdWfZW`WUWeeSdkUadds^Sf[a`aXfZWSffd[Tgf[a`aXS>&B&;&^aS`2eWW

    6df[U^WK$ eWUf[a` +&

  • ; J C 9 H 8 D C 9 > I > D C 6 A > I N 6 C 9 > C I : G C 6 I > D C 6 A 8 D K : C 6 C I )(1

    Vaade aXUa__WdU[S^ TS`]e"**#iZ[UZ cgS`f[fSf[hW [_badfS`UWahWdiW[YZfefZWa`W aXfZW>&B&;&"*+#3 fZWXSUffZSf`adWeUZWVg^[`Y$`W[fZWdbgT^[U[`fZWXdS_Wiad]aXfZW

    ESd[e8^gT"*,#`adbd[hSfW"*-# US TWSUZ[WhWVi[fZagffZWWj[efW`UWaXS H&7&6& dW^SfWV fa fZW [`fWdWefWV Uag`fdk& IZW eS_W US TWeS[VSTagfVWTf dsVgUf[a adUS`UW^^[`Y"*.#3 fZW^[`]TWfiWW`>&B&;&ba^[UkS`VfZWLad^V7S`]S[V"*/#3 fZW ;g`Ve Ys`sdS^ [ X^gW`UW$ TSeWV a` [fe [_SYW$ [ XdSefdgUfgdW S`V

    adYS [lSf[a "eW_[`Sde$ fWUZ`[US^ See[efS UW$ && "*0#&

    IZaeW aTeWdhSf[a`e _S]W U^WSd fZSf Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk ZSe TWUa_W S WXXWUf[hW [`efdg_W`f$ iZ[UZ S^^aie fZW;g`V fa dWYg^SfW S`V Ua`fda^$ fa S^SdYW WjfW`f$ fZW WUa`a_[U ba^[Uk aX_S`k A29&8&e"*1#& IZW XdWWVa_ aXfZaeWHfSfWefaZShWad`affaZShWdWUagdeWfafZW;g`VZSeTWUa_WfZWa%dWf[US^&

    )&*& DSP 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW3ZaPYLY_ ZY5NZYZXTN" CZNTLWLYO 3`W_`]LWBTRS_^"+(#

    >&*&)& 7PYP]LW$ J

    >> & IZW >`fWd`Sf[a`S^ 8ahW`S`f a` :Ua`a_[U$ HaU[S^ S`V 8g^fgdS^G[YZfe ">&8&:&H&8&GiSe SVabfWV TkfZWJ`[fWVCSf[a`ef W`fWdWV [`fa XadUW a` ?S`gSdk +$ )1/.& >`9WUW_TWd )11)$ [f Uag`fWV 11 HfSfW ESdf[We"+)#& IZW T[Y STeW`f$ S_a`Y

    "**# HWW86 G G : 6 J 9&$ 8Zda`[cgWVW9da[f[`fWd`Sf[a`S^sUa`a_[cgW$1YY`LT]P6]LYNLT^OP4]ZT_ 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW$ ha^& +)$ )10-$ /(+3 A = : G >I : 6 J B&%;&$ Z[$ NT_$" )+( S`[email protected] oGC :G E& S`VafZWde$ Z[$ NT_&$ -+ 2 IZW;g`V SeS USfS^kefXad afZWd eagdUWe&

    "*+# HWW 9 ?DJ &B&;& SYdWW_W`f Y[hWe fa fZW YahWd`W_W`f WUa`a_[Uba^[Uk&"*,# HWW 7 DI=: B& S`V 7 G >C @ ?&$ EgT^[U 9WTf dWeUZWVg^[`Y$ fZW 8SeW Xad >`fWd`Sf[a`S^

    EgT^[U8aabsdSf[a`$7P]XLY IPL]MZZVZQ9Y_P]YL_TZYLWI : 6 J B&%;&$ Z[$ NT_$" )+)iZa_S[`fS[`e fZSf fZW`Sf[a`S^WUa`a_[Uba^[Uk aXA&9&8&e[eVsead_S[eSbbdaghsW agVseSbbdaghsWbgT^[cgW_W`fbSdg`W [`efS`UW egbdS`Sf[a`S^W&"+(# HWW EYT_PO>L_TZY^D]PL_dCP]TP^" ha^& 11+$ +&"+)# HWW E$>$ 4ZN$" :'8&)*')11)'+$ . fa ).&

  • )) ( B>8=6:A AJ86H

    [`Vgefd[S^[lWVUag`fd[We$ [efZWJ`[fWVHfSfWeaX6_Wd[US"+*#&BaefA&9&8&eUa`UWd`WVi[fZ >&B&;& bdaYdS__WeSdWbSdf[We$kWf$ 7dSl[^ S`VfiSedWb^SUWV$ [` )10.$ TkSUa__[ffWW aXW[YZfWW`[`VW%bW`VW`f WjbWdfe fZW 8a__[ffWW a` :Ua`a_[U$ HaU[S^ S`V 8g^fgdS^G[YZfe $iZ[UZTWYS`faiad][`BSdUZ )10/"+,#$ S`VZW^V[fee[jfZeWe%e[a` [`9WUW_TWd )11)&

    IZW 8a__[ffWW SffW_bfe fa _a`[fad Ua_b^[S`UW Tk HfSfW ESdf[Wei[fZfZW Vgf[We g`VWd 8ahW`S`f [` S Ua`efdgUf[hW S`V UaabsdSf[hW iSk$ iZ[UZUWdfS[`^k Wjb^S[`e fZW bdgVW`UW S`V eaXf`Wee aXfZW WjbWdfe Ud[f[U[e_e S`VfZW STeW`UW aXS`k U^WSd Ua`VW_`Sf[a`&

    )&*&*& DSP 5NZYZXTN" CZNTLW LYO 3`W_`]LWBTRS_^$

    )+& Ha_W SUSVW_[Ue ZShWbdabaeWV fa U^See[Xk fZW d[YZfe dWUaY`[eWV TkfZW8ahW`S`f[`fZdWWUSfsYad[We 2fZWWUa`a_[Ud[YZfe$ fZWeaU[S^d[YZfeS`VfZW Ug^fgdS^ d[YZfe"+-#& 6`V [`VWWV$ fa ea_W WjfW`f$ fZ[e U^See[X[USf[a`eWW_e^aY[US^ 2 [XSUahW`S`fa`:&H&8&G& Wj[efe$ fZSf_WS`efZSfd[YZfeUS`TW WUa`a_[U$ eaU[S^ ad Ug^fgdS^! 7gf fZW 8ahW`S`f VaWe`afbdah[VW V[XXW%dW`fdg^We ebsU[X[s fa WSUZ USfWYadk3 fZge$ [f [egeW^Wee$ [` agdbWdebWUf[hW$fa_S]W S V[ef[`Uf[a`aXS`k][`V&

    ),& LWeZS^^Td[WX^kW`g_WdSfWfZWd[YZfeSefZWkSdWefSfWV[`fZW8ahW%`S`f 2

    fZWd[YZffaiad]$iZ[UZ[`U^gVWefZWd[YZfaXWhWdka`WfafZWabbadfg%`[fkfaYS[ Z[e^[h[`YTkiad]iZ[UZZWXdWW^kUZaaeWeadSUUWbfe"Sdf[U^W.#3 fZW d[YZf fa fZW W`\ak_W`f aX\gef S`V XShadST^W Ua`V[f[a`e aXiad]$

    i[fZ$ S_a`Y afZWde$ XS[d iSYWe$ eSXW S`V ZWS^fZk iad][`Y Ua`V[f[a`e S`VdWef$ ^W[egdWS`VdWSea`ST^W^[_[fSf[a aXiad][`Y "Sdf[U^W /#3 IdSVWJ`[a`XdWWVa_e "Sdf[U^W0# 3

    "+*# HWW6 A HID C E&$ J&H& GSf[X[USf[a`aXfZW8ahW`S`f a`:Ua`a_[U$ HaU[S^ S`V:Ua`a_[UG[YZfe 2 fZW CWWV Xad S` :`f[dW^k CWi HfdSfWYk$ 1XP]TNLY :Z`]YLW ZQ 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW &8&:&H&8&G&$ Sdf[U^We ). fa**&"+,# HWW6 ^ e f a ` E& S`VH >B B 6 7&$ ;[defHWee[a`aXfZWJ&C&8a__[ffWWa`:Ua`a_[U$HaU[S^

    S`V8g^fgdS^G[YZfe$1$:$9$

  • fZWd[YZffaeaU[S^eWUgd[fk "Sdf[U^W1# 3 fZWbdafWUf[a`faTWY[hW`fafZWXS_[^k$_afZWde$ UZ[^VdW S`Vkag`Y

    bWab^W "Sdf[U^W )(#3 fZWd[YZffa S SVWcgSfWefS`VSdVaX^[h[`Y$iZ[UZ[`U^gVWefZWd[YZfe

    fa SVWcgSfW XaaV$ U^afZ[`YS`VZage[`Y "Sdf[U^W ))")## 3 fZWd[YZffaTWXdWWXda_Zg`YWd "Sdf[U^W ))"*## 3 fZWd[YZffafZWW`\ak_W`faXfZWZ[YZWefSffS[`ST^WefS`VSdVaXbZke[%

    US^S`V_W`fS^ZWS^fZ$i[fZSebWU[S^Ua`UWd XadfZW[ XS`f_adfS^[fk$ W`h[%da`_W`fS^ S`V[`Vgefd[S^ZkY[W`W S`VWb[VW_[W$ W`VW_[U$ aUUgbSf[a`S^S`VafZWdV[eWSeWe "Sdf[U^W )*#3 fZWd[Y^[ffabd[_Sdk$eWUa`VSdkS`VZ[YZWdsVgUSf[a S`VfZWXdWWVa_e

    dW^SfWVfa fZSf d[YZf "Sdf[U^We )+ S`V),# 3 fZW Ug^fgdS^d[YZfe "Sdf[U^W )-#&

    6[^ fZaeW d[YZfe eZS^^ TW WjWdU[eWV i[fZagf V[eUd[_[`Sf[a` aX S`k ][`V"Sdf[U^W *"*##&

    )-& IZ[es`g_sdSf[a`_[YZfeZWV^[YZfa`fZW eUabW$ ]L_TZYPXL_P]TLP" aXfZW 8ahW`S`f3 kWf$ [f iag^V TW ida`Y fa Ua`e[VWd fZaeW d[YZfe i[fZagffS][`Y [`fa SUUag`f fZW UaddWeba`V[`Y Vgf[We aXfZW HfSfW& 6UfgS^^k$ fZWWeeW`f[S^ bdah[e[a` aXfZW 8ahW`S`f [e Sdf[U^W *")# iZ[UZ YW`WdS^^k VWXx`WefZaeWVgf[We3 a`WUS`a`^kSbbdaSUZfZW[eegWaXfZW:&H&8&G& Tkfdk[`Yfag`VWdefS`ViZSf HfSfWe SdWWjbWUfWV fa Vag`VWd fZW >&8&:&H&8&G&&

    Baef Ua__W`fSfade ZShW XaUgeWV fZW[d SffW`f[a` a` fZSfba[`f"+.# S`VfZSf [e Wjb^S[`WV Tk fZW bWUg^[Sd `SfgdW aX fZW :&H&8&G& "+/#& ASfWd$ iW

    "+.# HWW6 AHIDC E& S`VF J >CC `fWd`Sf[a`S^8ahW`S`fa`:Ua`a_[W$ HaU[S^ S`V8g^fgdS^G[YZfe$8`XLYBTRS_A`L]_P]Wd"ha^& 1$ )10/$ )-.3:[VW6&$GWS^[lSf[a`aXHaU[S^S`V:Ua`a_[WG[YZfeS`VfZWB[`[_g_IZdWe%Za^V6bbdaSUZ$8`XLYBTRS_

  • ))* B>8=6:A AJ86H

    eZS^^ Uad`W TSU] fa fZ[e_SffWdiZW`WjS_[`[`YiZSf fZW8ahW`S`fdWS^^kdWcg[dWe&

    )&+& DSPCZNTLW5QQPN_^ ZQ_SP 9$=$6$[ZWTNdLYO _SP 9^^`P

    ).& Ia VWfWd_[`W fZW eaU[S^ WXXWUfe fZSf [e$ fZW WXXWUfe a` fZW ^[h[`YUa`V[f[a`e aX S` WUa`a_[U bdaYdS__W [e `af S` WSek g`VWdfS][`Y&>&B&;&e [`fWdhW`f[a` [e Ua__a`^k dW^SfWV fa SgefWd[fk 2 ahWd fZW ^SefVWUSVW$ `WiebSbWdeZShWdWbadfWV>&B&;& d[afeS`VZg`YWdagfTdWS]e[`Ig`[l[S$BadaUUa$7dSl[^$KW`WlgW^SS`VafZWdA&9&8&e"+0#&HgUZdWbadfeY[hWSXxdef[_bdWee[a`"+1#TgfXWiefgV[WeYaTWka`VfZSfX[def[_bdWee[a`2fZWV[XXxUg^fkaXXx`V[`YSiSkfa cgS`f[XkbahWdfkS`VaXVWfWd_[`[`YfZWUSgeWe aXfZW aTeWdhWVbZW`a_W`a`e ef[^^ dW_S[`e",(#&

    )/& >XfZW;g`V dWUaY`[lWe fZSf [fe Ua`V[f[a`e USgeW eaU[S^ Uaefe",)#$ [fS^ea SeeWdfe fZW Wj[efW`UW aXbae[f[hW eaU[S^ Ua`escgW`UWe$ `af a`^k [` fZW^a`Y fWd_ 2 [f[e efSfWVfZSfiZWdW fZWgdTS`babg^Sf[a`i[^^ egXXWd$ [`fZWTWY[``[`Y Sf ^WSef$ g`VWd fZW SgefWd[fk_WSegdWe",*#$ fZW dgdS^babg^S%f[a`i[^^ cg[U]^kTW`WX[f Xda_[f$iZW`fZW WUa`a_k[eSYd[Ug^fgdS^Wjbadfead[W`fWV",+#& Ha_W>&B&;& SVhaUSfWeWhW`Ua`U^gVWfZW[dS`S^ke[eSXXxd_[`YfZSf;g`Ve bdaYdS__WeZShW`a`WYSf[hW [`X^gW`UW a`fZW [`Ua_WV[efd[%Tgf[a`",,#&

    BadWahWd$ iZW` dWUaY`[lWV$ fZW eZadf fWd_ Uaefe SdW$ [` fZW WkWe aXfZW;g`V$ agfiW[YZWV Tk fZW ^a`Y fWd_ SVhS`fSYWe e[`UW [fe ba^[Uk [e fa ^Sk

    ba`V[`Y d[YZfe ZShW TWW` h[a^SfWV$ fZW Vgf[We g`VWd fZW >&8&:&H&8&G& SdW cg[fW Ys`sdS^ S`Vi[fZagfSbdsU[es Ua`fW`f fZWdW[e`a a`WiSkfadWS^[lW fZWeWd[YZfe%$ eafZSf [f[eV[XX[Ug^ffaVWfWd_[`WiZWfZWda`WaXfZWd[YZfeZSeTWW`h[a^SfWV&IZge$[`fZWUSeWaXfZWXad_Wdd[YZfe$a`W US` XaUge a` fZW d[YZfe$ iZ[^ef [` fZW USeW aX fZW ^SffWd a`We$ a`W_gef Ua`UW`fdSfW a`WeSffW`f[a`a`fZWVgf[We$_SkTWi[fZ fZWbgdbaeW fa_S]W fZW_TWffWdVWXx`WV eWW< DD9L 9 < [^^`XSUf$faUS^Ug%^SfWfZ[e$ S^SdYWS_ag`f aXVSfS_gefTWS`S^klWV&",(# HWW7 A6G9D C : &B&;& TW^W[VeSS`TWhW^[`YW`haada`fi[]]W^[`Ye^S`VW`$

    ;$2$ GPPVMP]TNS_PY$ )10.$ `~+-$ -&",+# HWW VW ^SGae[tdW$ ^W Xa`Ve [_baeW%f[^ ^Sgefsd[fs5 U[fWV TkA'=Wd[fWSff$ Z[$ NT_$" *)- 2

    9WfW^^We_WegdWeXShad[eW`f^SYdS`VW_SeeWVW^Sbabg^Sf[a`dgdS^W &&& S`V= W ^^W d E&H& S`VafZWde$ DPY 9X[WTNL_TZY^ ZQ6`YO C`[[Z]_PO 1OU`^_XPY_ @]ZR]LX^QZ] @ZaP]_d - 5c[i]TPYNP TYCPWPN_PO 3Z`Y_]TP^$ >&B&;&$LSeZ[`Yfa`9&8&$ )100 "DUUSe[a`S^ESbWd`~-0#$ )/&",,# HWW H >HHDC 8&6&$ ;g`V HgbbadfWV EdaYdS_e S`V >`Ua_W 9[efd[Tgf[a` [` A&9&8&e$

    6TYLYNP LYO4PaPWZ[XPY_"BSdUZ )10.$ ++&

  • ;JC9H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI ))+

    Vai`fZW Ua`V[f[a`e Xad S dWS^ [_bdahW_W`f [` fZW WUa`a_k aXfZW HfSfWUa`UWd`WV3 [` afZWdiadVe$ fZW US]Wi[^^ TW T[YYWd",-# !

    )0& IZSf h[Wi [e efda`Y^k Ua`fWefWV& IZW_WdW geW aXfZW fWd_ SgefW%d[fkdWX^WUfefZWab[`[a`aX_S`kSgfZadea`fZWeaU[S^Ua`escgW`UWeaXfZW;g`Veba^[Uk",.#& BS`k efSfW_W`fe SdW_SVW$ W_bZSe[l[`Y fZW `WYSf[hW[_bSUfaXfZW>&B&;& [`fWdhW`f[a`a`fZWefS`VSdVaX [h[`Y",/#$efSfW_W`feiZ[UZ SdW$ fa ea_W WjfW`f$ Ua`X[d_WVTkfZW STahW_W`f[a`WVefgV[We&

    >`VWWV$ SUUadV[`Y fa S JC>8:; efgVk$ fZW `g_TWd aX bWdea`e ^[h[`Yg`VWdfZWbahWdfkfZdWeZa^VZSe[`UdWSeWV$ SeSdWeg[faXfZWdWUWee[a`Xa^^a%i[`Y fZW SV\gef_W`f bdaYdS__We",0# 3 >f [e `af ZaiWhWd U^WSd iZWfZWdH&6&E&e SdW fZW a`^k USgeW aXfZW dWUWee[a`$ S`V$_adWahWd$ fZaeW`WYSf[hWWXXWUfeiWdW`af XW^f [` S[^ fZW Uag`fd[We Ua`UWd`WV",1#&

    IZWdWeg^feaXfZWLad^V7S`]efgVkSdWSeiW^^TS^S`UWV 2TWfiWW`)10(S`V )10-$ Ua`eg_bf[a` ZSe VWUdWSeWV S`V `gfd[f[a` ^WhW^ dW_S[`WV fZWeS_W g`^Wee[`egT%HSZSdS`6Xd[US $iZ[^ef[`XS`f_adfS^[fk$^[XWWjbWU%fS`Uk S`VSffW`VS`UW Sfbd[_SdkeUZaa^ [`UdWSeWV"-(#&

    )1& >f[e`afXadgefafS]WbSdf[`fZSfUa`fdahWdek$TWUSgeW[fdS[eWe`a`^sYS^bdaT^W_eiWSdW`afST^Wfaea^hW&BadWahWd$iWeZS^^eWWfZSffZWagf%Ua_We aXfZW Ua`fdahWdek SdW$ Se SiZa^W$ cg[fW [ddW^WhS`ffa fZW cgWef[a`Se fa iZWfZWd ad`af fZW >&8&:&H&8&G& [e dWebWUfWV & CWhWdfZW^Wee$ iWZSVfa _W`f[a` fZSf V[eUgee[a` fa [`fdaVgUs fZW [eegWiZ[UZiW SdW Ua`UWd`WVi[fZ&

    IS][`Y fZW S^^WYWV`WYSf[hW WXXWUfe aXH&6&E&e Se S efSdf[`Yba[`f$ ea_WSgfZadeZShW_S[`fS[`WV$i[fZea_WUSgf[a`$ fZSffZW;g`Viag^VTWh[a%^Sf[`Y fZW >&8&:&H&8&G&& Ha$ B& 8a`]^[` S`V 9& 9Sh[Vea` bdabaeW ea_W

    ",- # HWWL 6C96 I e W ` Y $ I Z W : XXW U fe a X 6 V \g e f_ W` f $6TYLYNPLYO4PaPWZ[XPY_"9 WUW_ TWd )10,$ .&

    ",.# HWW$ Xad [`efS`UW$ E : IG 6 H H?& S`V7 7 >A A =&$ IZW >&B&;&$ 6gefWd[fk S`VfZWHfSfW aXASf[`6_Wd[US$ DST]O GZ]WOA`L]_P]Wd$ ha^& 0$ )10.$ ,+. 2 >&B&;& efk^W SgefWd[fkbdaYdS__W$dWeg^f[`Y[`[`UdWSe[`Yg`W_b^ak_W`fS`VVWU^[`[`Y^[h[`YefS`VSdVeS`VI G JB 6C G&$AWHs`s%YS^ VS`e ^We dWfe Vg ;&B&>&$ 3LSTP]^ O` 3ZXX`YT^XP" ?S`gSdk )10-$ 1/$ U[f[`Y S eW`WYS^WWe_[`[efWd 2 aebSkeVa[hW`f eW eWddWd ^S UW[`fgdW&",/# HWW6kWW?&G&6&$Z[$NT_$".(39W`fWde:&B&&B&;& S`VfZWLad^V7S`]$HWbfW_TWd )100$LWef7Wd^[`$J`WV[fWVKWde[a`$ -&

    ",0# 8DGC >6

  • )), B>8=6:A AJ86H

    Yg[VW^[`WeXadfZW;g`VfaZW^b_WWf[fe^sYS^aT^[YSf[a`eg`VWd &&&fZW8ahW%`S`f"-)#&

    6`afZWd SgfZad$6&BWTdag][`W$ efSfWe fZSf fZWWhWdefda`YWd[`X^gW`UWWjWdU[eWVTk fZW >&B&;& gba`A&9&8&e &&&eWW_e fa TW [`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZ fZWdWebWUfaXfZW=g_S`G[YZfe$ [`fZW[dWUa`a_[US`VeaU[S^V[_W`e[a`"-*#"fdS`e^Sf[a`#& IZW eW`fW`UW aXfZWEWd_S`W`fEWab^We Id[Tg`S^ STagf fZWba^[Uk aX fZW >&B&;& S`V fZW Lad^V 7S`] WjbdWeeWe fZW eS_W \gVYW%_W`f"-+#&

    IZWeW SeeWdf[a`e SdWg`_af[hSfWV3 fZWkdS[eW fZdWW cgWef[a`e 2

    [efZW >&B&;& Tag`VTkfZW>&8&:&H&8&G&5 [e fZW >&B&;& ba^[Uk[`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZfZW >&8&:&H&8&G& 5 faiZSfWjfW`f[e fZW>&B&;& dWeba`e[T^WXadfZWSgefWd[fk_WSegdWe5

    D`^kbae[f[hW S`eiWde fa fZaeW fZdWW cgWef[a`eiag^VYdag`VfZW STahW_W`f[a`WV SeeWdf[a`e& LW eZS^^$ [` fZW eWUa`V bSdf aXfZ[e efgVk$ S`S^klWfZaeW fZdWW_SffWde&

    > > & I = : > HHJ:

    >>&)& 9^ _SP 9$=$6$ 2NXYO Md _SP 9$3$5$C$3$B$0

    *(& IZW >&B&;& [e `af S ESdfk fa fZW >&8&:&H&8&G&$ iZ[UZ _WS`e fZSf$[]TXLQLNTP" [f [e`af Tag`V Tk fZW8ahW`S`f& NWf$ TWUa_[`Y SbSdfkfa SfdWSfk [e`af fZWa`^kiSkfa TW Tag`VTkfZWdg^We efSfWV[`[f$ UWdfS[`^k`af iZW` fZW egT\WUf Ua`UWd`WV [e S J&C& ebWU[S^[lWV SYW`Uk& =W`UW$ iWeZS^^WjS_[`W fZW_WS`eTkiZ[UZ fZW;g`VUag^VTWTag`VTkfZW8ahW%`S`f&

    >>&)&)& DSP 3SL]_P] ZQ _SP EYT_PO >L_TZY^$ _SP EYTaP]^LW 4iNWL]L_TZY ZY8`XLYBTRS_^ LYO9Y_P]YL_TZYLW 3`^_ZXL]dC B&S`V9 6 K >9 HDC 9 &$ IZW>&B&;& S`V:Ua`a_[U$HaU[S^S`V8g^fgdS^G[YZfe 2S8SeW HfgVk aX6dYW`f[`S$8$:B$A$" ha^& 0$ )10.$ *-,&"-*# B : 7GDJ @ >C : 6&$ Z[$ NT_$" .+(&"-+# [email protected]][email protected][WPt D]TM`YLW$Z[$ NT_$" ))&"-,# I G J 7 : 8 @ 9 &B &$ Z[$ NT_$" *)(3 [f[e agdg`VWd^[`[`Y&

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI ))-

    U[S^^kSdf[U^We--S`V-."--# S`ViZ[UZZSebd[`U[bS^^kTWW`SVhaUSfWVTk?& HaZ`"-.#&

    6UUadV[`Y fa fZSf h[Wi$ fZW 8ahW`S`fiag^V TW S` SgfZad[fSf[hW [`fWd%bdsfSf[a`aXfZWSTahW_W`f[a`WVSdf[U^WeaXfZWJ&C&8ZSdfWd&Cai$ SefZW>&B&;& [eeS[VfaTWTag`VTkfZW8ZSdfWd"-/#$ [fiag^VfZWdWXadWTWTag`VTk fZW 8ahW`S`f&

    =aiWhWd$iZSffZWf[e egT%_[ffWV fZSf$ Se bd& K[dS^^kZSeid[ffW`$ fZ[e fWjf$ Se egUZ$ i[^^ a`^kT[`VfZaeW HfSfWeiZ[UZZShW_Wf fZW Xad_S[dWcg[dW_W`feg`VWd >`fWd`Sf[a`S^ASi aXIdWSf[We"-0# "fdS`e^Sf[a`#&

    **& 6UfgS^^k$ iZSfiW SdW Ua`UWd`WVi[fZ ZWdW$ [e `af fZW [`fWdbdsfS%f[hWbaiWdaXfZW`VWWV$ [XfZW>&8&:&H&8&G&ad fZW UaddWeba`V[`Y Sdf[U^We aX fZW J`[hWdeS^ 9sU^SdSf[a` a` =g_S`G[YZfe "J&9&=&G"-1# iZ[UZ dWUaY`[lW$ Tk S`V ^SdYW$ fZW eS_W d[YZfedWX^WUfe fZW efSfW aX[`fWd`Sf[a`S^ Ugefa_$ [fi[^^TW T[`V[`Y a` S[^ HfSfWe$WhW``a`ESdf[We".(#$ S`VZW`UWa`fZW>&B&;&iZ[UZSeegT\WUfaX[`fWd`S%f[a`S^ ^Si$ Uag^V`afWeUSbW fa [fe Sbb^[USf[a`".)#&

    ?& HaZ`_S[`fS[`efZSf fZW8ahW`S`fe e[Y`SfgdW Tk S^SdYW`g_TWd aXHfSfWe Ua`X[d_e fZSf fZW bdah[e[a`e &&& ZShW TWW` YW`WdS^^k SUUWbfWV S`V

    "--# B : GDC IZ&$ 8`XLY BTRS_^ LYO 8`XLYT_L]TLY >Z]X^ L^ 3`^_ZXL]d &B&;& [e S ebWU [S ^[lWV S Y W` Uk a X fZ W J&C& [f _ g ef T W eS [V fZ S f ` W [fZWdfZ W 6 df[U ^We a X 6 YdWW_ W` fe ` a d fZ W SYdWW_ W` f T Wfi WW` fZ W J&C& S`V fZ W >&B&;& g`VWd Sdf[U ^We -/S`V .+a X fZ W 8ZSdfWdeb W U [X[US ^^k T [` V fZ W ; g ` V f a fZ W 8ZSdfWd T g f _ adW Ua` h [` U [` Y ^k $ TWUSgeW S[^_ W_ %

    TWde a X fZ W ; g ` V SdW E S df[We f a fZ W 8ZSdfWd& :&9 W` fWde VaWe ` a f $ Z ai WhWd $ eZSdW fZ S f ab [` [a` 2 & && Xd a_ S ^sYS ^b a [` f a X h [Wi $ [ f US`` af T W Seeg_ WV Se S _ S ffW d a X Uag deW fZ S f >&B&;& Se S` [`ef[%fg f [a` [e T ag ` V T k fZ W 8ZSdfWd i ZW`WhWd _ a e f a X [fe _ W_ TWde S dW T a g ` V 9 :C I: GH :& B&&B&;&Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk 2:Ua`a_[U$HaU[S^S`V8g^fgdS^G[YZfeS`VfZW:ha^h[`YEd[`U[b^WaXHa^[%VSd[fk$ TY9Y_P]YL_TZYLW$GWea^gf[a`e$ /)&".(# HWWSdf[U^W+0aXfZWK[W``S8a`hW`f[a`a`fZW^SiaXIdWSf[We$ **_Sk )1.1$E$>$D$C$$

    ha^& ))--$++)S`V7 GDL C A >: >&[email protected]]TYNT[WP^[email protected]`MWTN9Y_P]YL_TZYLWL_TZY^6Z]NP^ -LL_TZY^@]LN_TNP$

    HfWhW`S`VHa`e$Aa`Va`$ )1.,$-(/ 2 >`eaXSdSefZWUgefa_Sdk^SieaXiSdXSdWSdWSbb^[UST^Wfa fZWJ&C& ;adUWe$ [f [e fa TW Ua`U^gVWV fZSf fZWbdah[e[a`e aXfZWeW Ua`hW`f[a`eSdW e[_[^Sd^kT[`V[`Y$ i[fZagf dWcg[d[`YSUUWee[a` fa fZW_Tk fZWJ&C&&

  • )). B>D=6:A AJ86H

    Ua`ef[fgfWe &&& S`Z[TYTZU`]T^ fZSffZWeWbdah[e[a`e SdW SUUWbfST^W &&&".*#&IZWg`S`[_agehafWaXfZW: >&$ Z[$ NT_$" - S`V86 GG :6J 9&$4]ZT_9Y_P]YL_TZYLW" EWVa`W$ ESd[e$ )101$

    *-)&"..# >f_gef `WhWdfZW^Wee TW `afWV fZSf fZWJ&9&=&G& VaWe `af [`U^gVW S e[_[^Sdbdah[e[a`

    SeSdf[U^W*")#&D`W_SkeWd[age^kia`VWdiZWfZWd:&H&8&G&ZShWS`ke[Y`[XxUS`UW[XfZW[dUaddWe%ba`V[`Y Vgf[WeSdW`afVWXx`WV eWW egbdS&"./# HWW H>: < = 6 G I E&$ DSP 9Y_P]YL_TZYLW &8&?&$ J`[fWV HfSfWe 9[b^a_Sf[U S`V 8a`eg^Sd HfSXX [` IWZWdS`$ ?gVYW_W`f *,

    BSdUZ )10($ 9$?$:$ BP[$" )10($,*&".1# HWWB : GDC IZ&$8`XLYBTRS_^LYO8`XLYT_L]TLY Z[$ NT_$" 1+%1/&

  • ;JC9H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI ))/

    W[VW$ fadfgdW$ _See_gdVWd$ bda^a`YWV SdT[fdSdk [_bd[ea`_W`f$ ekefW_Sf[UdSU[S^ V[eUd[_[`Sf[a` dW^SfW S[^ fa U[h[^ S`V ba^[f[US^ d[YZfe$ iZ[^ef fZWd[YZffaiad]$Xad[`efS`UW$[e`afUa`e[VWdWVfaTWbSdfaX[`fWd`Sf[a`S^Uge%fa_"/(#&

    *+& IZge$ iW TW^[WhW fZSffZW >&8&:&H&8&G&$ Se SiZa^W$ VaWe`afdWX^WUf[`fWd`Sf[a`S^ Ugefa_Sdk^Si&NWf$ S`S`S^ke[eaXegUZVaUg_W`feSeUa`ef[%fgf[a`eaXHbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[WeS`VaXHfSfWbdSUf[UW[`fZW[ddW^Sf[a`ei[fZfZaeW6YW`U[WeeZag^VTWVa`W fa VWfWd_[`WiZWfZWdea_W aXfZW:&H&8&G&ZShW`afTWUa_W$ [`V[h[VgS^^k$ Ugefa_Sdkd[YZfe "Xad[`efS`UW$ fZWd[YZffaTW XdWW Xda_Zg`YWd$ fZWd[YZf fa XdWWbd[_SdksVgUSf[a`$ &&&

    >>&)&*& EYTWL_i]LW1N_TZYMd _SP 9$=$6$ =PXMP]^"/)#&

    *,& D`W Uag^V egefS[` fZSf fZW ;g`V$ iZ[^ef`af V[dWUf^k Tag`VTk fZW8ahW`S`f$ eZag^V TW [`X^gW`UWVTk [f fZdagYZ [fe_W_TWde3 HfSfWESdf[Wefa fZW>&8&:&H&8&G& eZag^VZShWfaY[hW[`efdgUf[a`fafZW[ddWbdseW`fSf[hWeSffZW>&B&;& fadWebWUfS`Vfabda_afWfZWdWebWUfaXfZWbdah[e[a`eaXfZW8ahW`S`f"/*#&

    7gffZW_S[`bdaT^W_$ZWdW$ [efZSf`afS[^fZW>&B&;&_W_TWdeSdWbSd%f[We fa fZW8ahW`S`f 2 fZW >&B&;& Uag`fe )/) _W_TWde"/+#$ iZ[^efa`^k11efSfWeV[VdSf[XkfZW8ahW`S`f3 fZWJ&H&6&$i[fZ )1$.* aXfZWhafWe$ S`VHSgV[6dST[S$ i[fZ +$/1 $ ZShW`af Va`W [f"/,#&

    *-& BadWahWd$ iZWdW fZaeW fia HfSfWe$ i[fZ Xagd afZWde"/-#$ ZShW fZWd[YZf fa YZXTYL_P S9[dWUfad fa fZW :jWUgf[hW 7aSdV$ fZW afZWd Uag`fd[We_gef PWPN_ S 9[dWUfad iZ[UZ dWbdWeW`fe fZW Ydagb fZSf UZaaeWe Z[_"/.#&LZSf[Xea_WHfSfWe[`SYdagbSdW`afTag`V5 >`egUZSUSeW$ fZWdW[e`adWS^baee[T[^[fk fa Y[hW S`k_S`VSfW"//#&

    >`fZaeW Ua`V[f[a`e$ S=g_S`G[YZfeUdgf[`kaX>&B&;&eSUf[a`i[^^bda%TST^kTWXgf[^W&D`^kfZaeWUag`fd[Wei[fZS`a_[`SfWV9[dWUfadS`VbSdf[We

    "/(# HWWH8= 68= I:G ( & $ >` fWd`S f[a` S ^ A Si [` I Z W a dk S` V E dS Uf[UW $ < W`WdS ^8agdeW [` >` fWd %

    `Sf[a`S^EgT^[UASi$BPN`PTW" VWe8agde VW ^6USVs_[W VW9da[f>`fWd`Sf[a`S^$ )10*$ K$ ++.&"/)# HWW9 : C I : G H :&B&&B&;&ba^[UkfaiSdVeS^SdYWddWS^[lSf[a`aX:&H&8&G& eWW< : G H I: G G&$Z[$NT_$"-(,S`V-(/& >f[e[`e%fdgUf[hWfa`afWfZSffZ[e[`[f[Sf[hWUS_WXda_SUag`fdkiZ[UZiSe`afTag`VTkfZW8ahW`S`f$Tgfb^S``[`Y fa dSf[Xk [f eWW6 A HIDC E&$ J&H& GSf[X[USf[a` &&&$ Z[$ NT_$" +.-&"/+# HWW

  • ))0 B>8=6:A AJ86H

    fafZW8ahW`S`fUag^VTWT^S_WVXadZSh[`YSUUWbfWV$ fZdagYZfZW[ddWbds%eW`fSf[hWe$ S H&6&E& [`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZ fZW >&8&:&H&8&G&&

    =aiWhWd$ Uag^VfZSfdWS^^kTW569[dWUfadfdk[`Yfa[`X^gW`UWfZW;g`Veba^[Uk faiSdVe Ua_b^[S`UWi[fZ fZW 8ahW`S`f$ iag^V ZShW fa_S]W ea_WUa_bda_[eWe3 fZW dWeg[f aX [fe WXXadfe iag^V TW ea_WfZ[`Y `af fafS^^kUa`e[efW`fi[fZ fZW >&8&:&H&8&G&& 8ag^VZW dWS^^k TWT^S_WVXad fZSf5

    >f_Sk TW cgWef[a`WV [XfZW 8ahW`S`f dWcg[dWe S HfSfW ad [fe V[dWU%fad fa dWXgeW fZW Ua`X[d_Sf[a` Tk fZW :jWUgf[hW 7aSdV aXS AWffWd aX>`fW`ffZSfiag^VTWUa`fdSdkfafZW8ahW`S`f&IZ[edS[eWefZWcgWef[a`aXfZW`SfgdWaXfZW[`fWd%HfSfWVgf[Weg`VWdfZW8ahW`S`f& >f_SkTWfZSffZW>&8&:&H&8&G& [_baeWe$gba`S[^HfSfWe$ S`aT^[YSf[a`fa Ua%abWdSfW"/0# 3kWffZW bd[_Sdk dWeba`e[T[^[fk Xad fZW dWS^[lSf[a` aX :&H&8&G& ^[We gba` fZWUa`UWd`WVHfSfW"/1#&

    LW^^$ [X fZW ^SffWd VaWe `af Seeg_W [fe dWeba`e[T[^[fk$ Zai Uag^V fZWafZWdeNZ#Z[P]L_P5 D`UWfZWAWffWdaX>`fW`f[`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZfZW8ahW%`S`f [eid[ffW`$ fZWbaee[T[^[fk fa Ua%abWdSfW V[eSbbWSde!

    *.& IZ[e SdYg_W`f dW^[We faa _gUZ a` fZW >&B&;& X[Uf[a` SUUadV[`Y faiZ[UZ fZW SgefWd[fkbdaYdS__We [`U^gVWV [` fZWAWffWd aX>`fW`f[e [_bg%fST^Wfa fZWHfSfWeUa`UWd`WV& IZ[e[e SXS^eWh[WiaXdWS^[fk3A&9&8&eiS`fYW`WdS^^kfZW_WSegdWefaTW^Weeefd[`YW`f3 [f[ea`^kg`VWdfZW>&B&;&bdWe%egdW fZSf fZWk WhW`fgS^^k SUUWbf fZW H&6&E& "0(#&

    Ha$ [XfZWHfSfWUa`UWd`WVeZaie[fei[^^[`Y`WeefaSeeg_W[fedWeba`e[T[^[%f[Weg`VWdfZW8ahW`S`f$ fZW>&B&;&_W_TWdebSdf[WefafZSf8ahW`S`f$S`VWebWU[S^^kfZWJ`[[email protected][`YVa_$ ;dS`UW$ CC 9 : 6 &$ TY4T^N`^^TZYZQL]_TNWP && ZQ_SP9$3$5$C$3$B$" 3ZXXT__PP ZY5NZYZXTN"CZNTLWLYO3`W_`]LWBTRS_^"']OCP^$" E$>$4ZN$":'8&)*')101'-$ /(3TgfeWW$ Ua`fdS$I G J 7 :[email protected] 9 &$ Z[$ NT_$"*)/$ U[f[`YfZWJ&C&HWUdWfSdk

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI ))1

    >>&)&+& DSP 9$=$6$ L^ LC[PNTLWTePO 1RPYNd ZQ_SP EYT_PO >L_TZY^$

    */& Ha_W HbWU[S^[lWV 6YW`U[We ">&A&D&$ L&=&D&$ ;&6&D&$ J&C&:&H&8&DZShWb^SkWVS`[_badfS`fdy^W[`fZWVdSXf[`YaXfZW8ahW`S`f"0*#&&B&;& 5 >f[eSJ&C& HbWU[S^[lWV6YW`Uk$ Tgfiag^V`af XS^^$ SUUadV[`Y fa :& 9W`fWde"0/#$ i[fZ[` fZW Ydagb aX6YW`U[Wei[fZ:&H&8&G& dWeba`e[T[^[f[We& LW V[eSYdWWi[fZ fZSf h[Wi$ Xad fia _S\ad dWS%ea`e&

    *1& ;[def^k$ E& 6^efa` baeWe S ^[`] TWfiWW` HbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[We Xg`U%f[a`eg`VWdfZW8ahW`S`fS`VfZW[dUa`ef[fgf[a` 2 6^^aUSf[a`aXegUZXg`U%f[a`e [e W`f[dW^k [` SUUadVS`UW i[fZ fZW SYW`U[We Ua`ef[fgf[a`S^ aT\WU%f[hWe"00#&

    Cai$ Sdf[U^W a`W aXfZW6df[U^We aX6YdWW_W`fbdah[VWe fZSf a`W aXfZW>&B&;& bgdbaeWe [e fa Ua`fd[TgfW &&&fa fZWbda_af[a` S`V_S[`fW`S`UW aX

    "0*# HWW 6 A HIDC E&$ IZW I? [fWVCSf[a`e HbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[We S`V fZW >_b^W_W`fSf[a` aXfZW >`fWd`Sf[a`S^ 8ahW`S`f a` :Ua`a_[U$ HaU[S^ S`V 8g^fgdS^ G[YZfe$ 3ZW`XMTL :Z`]YLW ZQD]LY^YL_TZYLW&8&:&H&8&G& S`VI G J 7 : 8 @ 9&$ Z[$ NT_$" *+* S`V*,*&"0,# HWW 6 A HIDC E & $ IZWJ`[fWVCSf[a`eHbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[We &&&$ Z[$ NT_$" 0(&"0-# HWWI G J 7 : 8 @ 9&$Z[$ NT_$"*,.S`VE A6C I G&$ IZWG[YZffa;aaVS`VfZW6YdSd[S`Hke%

    fW_ 2ASiS`VEdSUf[UW[`ASf[`6_Wd[US$ TYDSPBTRS__Z6ZZO"Z[$NT_$" )1+$iZ[UZU[fWSefgVkaXfZWLad^V7S`] 2fZW7S`]$L^LYLQQTWTL_PZQ_SPD:YT_PO>L_TZY^"eZag^VbdgVW`f^kTWSeegdWVfZSffZaeWTaddaiWdeiZaSdWe[Y`SfadkfafZWJ&C&8ZSdfWdSdWUa_b^k[`Yi[fZfZWeb[d[faXfZWJ&C& 8ZSdfWd$ >`fWd`Sf[a`S^ 8ahW`S`fe$ IdWSf[We S`V 6YdWW_W`fe iZW` [f ^W`Ve "[fS^[Ue egb%b^[WV#&"0.# I G J 7 : 8 @ 9&$Z[$NT_$"*,.3eWWS^ea>&;&>&H=I=6I6 $DSPGZ]WO2LYVTYL3SLYRTYRGZ]WO"

    HW^WUfWV:eeSke Ua_b[^WVS`VWV[fWV Tk;& IeUZaXW` S`V6&G& ESddS$BSdf[`geC[\ZaXXEgT^[e%ZWde$9adVdWUZf$ 7aefa`$Aa`Va`$ )11) 2 IZW7S`] UWdfS[`^k US`b^Sk$ S`VZSeb^SkWV$i[fZ[`fZW ^[_[fe aX [fe _S`VSfW$ S hWdk e[Y`[X[US`f dy^W [` bda_af[`Y hSd[age WUa`a_[U S`V eaU[S^d[YZfe&

    "0/# HWW9 :C I:GH :&$ Z[$ NT_$" *,( 2 >&B&;&$ fZagYZTW[`YS_S\ad HbWU[S^[lWV6YW`Uk$iSe`af[`ha^hWV[` fZWVdSXf[`YaXfZW8ahW`S`fS`VUa`eWcgW`f^k6^efa`edWSea`[`YVaWe`afbda%h[VW Ydag`VeXad fZWbae[f[a` fZSffZW >&B&;&$ faa$_gef aTeWdhW fZW>&8&:&H&8&G&&"00# HWW6 A HID C E&$ IZWJ&C& HbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[We &&&$ Z[$ NT_$" 0)&

  • )* ( B>8=6:A AJ86H

    Z[YZ ^WhW^e aX W_b^ak_W`f S`V dWS^ [`Ua_W &&&$ S`afZWd TW[`Y fa Y[hWUa`X[VW`UWfa_W_TWdeTk_S][`YfZWYs`sdS^dWeagdUWeaXfZW;g`VfW_ba%dSd[^k ShS[^ST^W &&&&i[fZagf dWefad[`Y fa _WSegdWe VWefdgUf[hW aX `Sf[a`S^S`V[`fWd`Sf[a`S^bdaebWd[fk"01#&

    IZW XSUf fZSf fZ[e [e`af S` Wjb^[U[f dWXWdW`UW fa Zg_S`d[YZfe VaWe`af_SffWd"1(#& > X fZW >&8&:&H&8&G& Sffd[TgfWe S Ys`sdS^ dWeba`e[T[^[fk fa fZWHbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[We$iZkUag^ViW`af Ua`e[VWdfZSf[fZSVS^ea fZW;g`V[`h[Wi$e[`UWfZ[e[eS^eaS`6YW`UkiZ[UZZSeTWW`eWfgbi[fZfZWbgdbaeWaXbda_af[`YYs`sdS^iW^XSdW5

    +(& HWUa`V^k$ fZW [VWS fZSf fZW >&B&;&e SUf[h[fkiag^V TW Ua_b^WfW^kg`]`ai`fa fZW:&H&8&G&$ S`VfZSf$ ZW`UW$ fZW;g`Viag^V`af XS^^[`fZWeUabWaXfZWdW^WhS`f8ahW`S`febdah[e[a`e[e_[eUa`UW[hWV& >f[e fdgW fZSf[fe dy^W Ua`e[efe `af [` fZWbda_af[a` aXS ebWU[X[U Zg_S`d[YZf$ TgfiZaUag^VVW`kfZSf [fe SUf[h[fk[`fWdXWdWei[fZ VWhW^ab_W`f_SffWde"1)# WebW%U[S^^k e[`UW [f ZSe [`fWdhW`WV$ Xad_adW fZS` fW` kWSde$ [` fZW bdaVgUf[hWS`V V[efd[Tgf[hW efdgUfgdW aXA&9&8&e"1*# 5

    BadWahWd$ fZW `WUWee[fk aX UaadV[`Sf[a` S`V Ua%abWdSf[a` TWfiWW` fZW7dWffa`LaaVe[`ef[fgf[a`eZSeTWW`dWUaY`[lWVTkfZW;g`V[feW^X&IZ[e[eS dsUaY`[f[a` fZSf [fe SUf[h[f[We SdW `af ^[_[fWV fa Xx`S`U[S^ _SffWde TgfdWSUZ fZW ebZWdW aXVWhW^ab_W`f$ WhW` [X[f [e`af [` S bae[f[hWiSk& >f [eSeeWdfWV fZSf$ e[`UW fZW ;g`Ve SUf[h[fk [`fWdXWdWe i[fZ VWhW^ab_W`f S`VVWhW^ab_W`f [e`aidWUaY`[lWV Se S XxW^ViZWdW=g_S`G[YZfe$ S`VWebW%U[S^^k fZW :&H&8&G&$ SdW fZW UW`fdS^ bgdbaeW"1+#$ fZW >&B&;& eZag^V fS]WfZaeWd[YZfe [`fa SUUag`f&

    +)& IZagYZ$iW_gefSV_[ffZWdW[eea_WfZ[`YU[dUg^Sd[`agddWSea`[`Y3iZSfiWSdWeSk[`Y[efZSffZW>&B&;& [eTag`VTkfZW>&8&:&H&8&G&TWUSgeWea VaWe fZW8ahW`S`f efSfW&

    6 IdWSfk US``af TW T[`V[`Ygba``a`ESdf[We g`^Wee fZWk SUUWbf fa TWTag`V"1,#TWUSgeWfZSfiag^VTWUa`fdSdkfafZWHfSfWeeahWdW[Y`fk&9aWe

    "01# 6df[U^We )"*# S`V )"-#&"1(# HWW ; &6 &D & e 8a`ef[fgf[a`$iZ[UZ ebWS]e STagf fZW bda_af[a` aXfZW Ua__a`iW^XSdW

    fZdagYZZ[YZWd`gfd[f[a` ^WhW^e S`V ^[h[`Y efS`VSdVe eWW6 AHIDC E&$ Z[$ NT_$" 0/$ Xaaf`afW )*&"1)# HWW A = : G >I : 6 J B&%;&$ Z[$ NT_$" )*/$ U[f[`YSdWbadf aXfZWJ&C&8&I&6&9& 2 Cg^VagfW$

    e[^Sbsd[aVWVS\gefW_W`fWefs^SdY[WWf^WVa_S[`WVWe_WegdWebd[eWesfW`Vg$ [^VWh[W`fV[XX[U[^WVWV[ef[`YgWdW`fdW?WbdaUWeegeVS\gefW_W`f efdgUfgdW^ Wf ^WbdaUWeege VWVshW^abbW_W`f&"1*# HWW 9MTOPX$ )/-S`V7 A6G9DC:

  • @JC9H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )*)

    fZ[e S^ea Sbb^k fa fZW >&B&;& iZ[UZ$ Se [`fWd`Sf[a`S^ adYS`[lSf[a`$ ZSe `aeahWdW[Y`fk"1-#&

    >f [e aTh[age fZSf SfdWSfkTWfiWW` a`^k fia HfSfWe$ Y[h[`YdWeba`e[T[^[%f[We fa fZW;g`V$ iag^V`af$ aX[feW^X$ UdWSfW S`k aT^[YSf[a` Xad fZW ^SffWd&

    NWf$ iZSf iW SdW Ua`UWd`WV i[fZ [e S fdWSfk dSf[X[WV Tk 11 HfSfWeA&9&8&e S`V [`Vgefd[S^[lWV Uag`fd[We $ iZ[UZ _S]W bSdf aX fZW 7[^^ aX=g_S`G[YZfe$ S UadWeWfaXdg^We[`fZWJ&C& ekefW_&>feWW_efagecg[fWefdS`YWfZSfSJ&C& ebWU[S^[lWVSYW`Ukiag^V`afZShWfaaTeWdhWfZWbda%h[e[a`e aXfZSf fdWSfk$ Y[hW`[f [ebdah[VWVfZSf [fe Ua`ef[fgf[a`dWUaY`[lWeSe a`W aX [fe bgdbaeWe$ fZW [_bdahW_W`f aX fZW ^[h[`Y Ua`V[f[a`e aX fZWZg_S`TW[`Ye"1.#&

    +*& Ia VWfWd_[`W fZW ][`V aXdW^Sf[a`eZ[b Wj[ef[`Y TWfiWW`fZWJ`[fWVCSf[a`e S`V fZW >&B&;&$ a`W eZag^V S^ea ^aa] Sf fZW SYdWW_W`f Ua`U^gVWVTWfiWW` fZWJ&C&D& S`VfZW >&B&;&$ g`VWd Sdf[U^We -/ S`V .+ aXfZWJ&C&8ZSdfWd&

    6df[U^W a`W aXfZSffdWSfkefdWeefZW[`VWbW`VW`f UZSdSUfWd aXfZWX[`S`%U[S^[`ef[fgf[a`"1/#& IZWUa`fda^WjWdU[eWVTkfZW&B&;& SYdWW_W`f_gef TWUa`e[VWdWVSefZWTSe[eaXfZWVsX[`[f[a`aXfZWdW^Sf[a`eTWfiWW`TafZ[`ef[%fgf[a`e& IZaeW dg^We US` TW dWYSdVWV Se dWefd[Uf[hW [` fZW eW`eW fZSf fZWk^Sk Vai` fZW ^[_[fe aXfZWJ&C&D& Ua`fda^3 Tgf fZWk SdW S^ea `ad_Sf[hW 2fZW>&B&;&_gefY[hWVgWUa`e[VsdSf[a`fafZW[`U^ge[a`aXS`k[fW_bdaba%eWVTk fZWJ&C&")((#&

    "1- # HWW7aiWff9&L&$DSP f_gef TW aTeWdhWVZaiWhWd fZSf Sdf[U^W *, aXfZW8ahW`S`fbdah[VWe fZSf "`#afZ[`Y[` fZWbdWeW`f8ahW`S`f eZS^^ TW [`fWdbdWfWV Se [_bS[d[`Y fZWbdah[e[a`e aXfZW 8ZSdfWd aXfZWJ`[fWVCSf[a`eS`VaXfZW8a`ef[fgf[a`e aXfZW ebWU[S^[lWVSYW`U[WeiZ[UZVWX[`W fZWdWebWUf[hWdWeba`e[T[^[f[WeaXfZWhSd[ageadYS`eaXfZWJ`[fWVCSf[a`eS`VfZWebWU[S^[lWVSYW`U[We[ dWYSdVfafZW_SffWdeVWS^fi[fZ[`fZW8ahW`S`fr3VaWefZ[eSdf[U^W_WS`fZSfUa`V[f[a`S^[fk Uag^V`afTW SXXWUfWV Tk fZW 8ahW`S`f e[`UW [f [e [_b^[U[f^k bdah[VWV Tk fZW 6df[U^We aX6YdWW_W`f "&&&g`VWdSVWcgSfWeSXWYgSdVe &&lLW^^$ fZW6df[U^We a`^kdWXWd fa fZWbd[`U[b^WaXUa`V[f[a`S^[fk$`af fa [feegTefS`UW3 ea$ WhW` [X[f_[YZfTWfZSffZW8ahW`S`f US``afTW [`fWdbdWfWVSeXadT[V%V[`Y Ua`V[f[a`S^[fk$ [f [e egT_[fWV fZSf [f US` TW [`fWdbdWfWV Se [_bae[`Y dWefd[Uf[a`e a` fZWUa`fW`f aXfZW Ua`V[f[a`e&

    "1/ # HWWB 6C >C 6&$ 8a__W`fS[dW VW ^Sdf[U^W .+ VW ^S 8ZSdfW VWe CSf[a`e J`[We$ TY L_TZY^ EYTP^" 3ZXXPY_LT]P L]_TNWP[L] L]_TNWP" 8af ?&%E& WfE W ^^W f 6&$ :Ua`a_[US%7dgk^S`f$ ESd[e%7dgjW^^We$ )10-$ 1/,&

    "10# HWW A :B D >C ? & $ 8a__W`fS[dW VW ^Sdf[U^W -/ VW ^S8ZSdfW VWeCSf[a`e J`[We$ TY

  • ) * * B>8=6:A AJ86H

    IZge$ fZWSTahW_W`f[a`WVdWefd[Uf[a`eS`VfZWSeeWdfWV[`VWbW`VW`UWaXfZW;g`VeZag^V`afTWahWdefdWeeWV 2 [`bd[`U[b^W$ fZW^[`]TWfiWW`[fS`VfZWJ&C&D& dW_S[`e S ^[`] aXUaadV[`Sf[a`S`VegTadV[`Sf[a`")()#&

    ++& IZW >&8&:&H&8&G& [e`afSXad_S[dWUa__W`VSf[a`fa fZW >&B&;& Tgf[f[eS`[`efdg_W`fiZ[UZS[_e$ S_a`YafZWde$ Sf fZWHbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[We&&B&;&$ [X`af Xad_S^^k Tag`VTk fZW 8ahW`S`f$ ZSe fa bSkVgWdWYSdVfa[f&

    >>&*& 9^ _SP9$=$6$ @ZWTNd")(*# [`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZ fZW >&8&:&H&8&G& 5

    >>&*&)& GSL_OZP^ _SP 9$3$5$C$3$B$ ]P\`T]P^0

    +,& 6e S_SffWd aXbd[`U[b^W$ [f [e efSfWV fZSf fZW 8ahW`S`f [e `WgfdS^$fZSf[e$ [fVaWe`af[_baeWSebWU[XxUWUa`a_[UekefW_")(+#&H[`UW[f[eSeeg%_WV fZSf V[XXWdW`f WUa`a_[U ba^[U[We US` ^WSV fa fZW dWS^[lSf[a` aX fZW:&H&8&G&$ HfSfWe SdW XdWW$ g`VWd fZW 8ahW`S`f$ fa UZaaeW fZW ekefW_ fZWki[eZ&

    IZ[e_WS`efZSffZW>&B&;&ba^[UkUS``afTWUd[f[U[lWV_WdW^ka`S`S^^s%YSf[a`fZSffZWWUa`a_[UfZWadkfZW;g`VW_TdSUWe[e`afS`SVWcgSfWa`WXad fZW dWS^[lSf[a` aXfZWbgdbaeWe aXfZW 8ahW`S`f")(,#&

    +-& =aiWhWd$ [f US``af TW eS[VfZSf fZW8ahW`S`f ^SU]e aXS`k`ad_S%f[hW hS^gW& >f [e fdgW fZSf fZW >&8&:&H&8&G& [_baeWe bae[f[hW Vgf[We gba`

    ")()# G : J I: G E&6&$9Y^_T_`_TZY^9Y_P]YL_TZYLWP^"EdWeeWeJ`[hWde[fS[dWeVW;dS`UW$ESd[e$ )1.1$*/1&")(*# >&B&;& ba^[Uk [egeWVSedWXWdd[`Yfa fZWeWfaX_WSegdWeiZ[UZXa^^aifZWSffd[Tgf[a`

    aXS`kaXfZW;g`VeX[`S`U[S^XSU[^[f[We$ [ddWebWUf[hWaXfZWSgfZadaXfZaeW_WSegdWe& IZ[e^SffWdcgWef[a`i[^^ TW WjS_[`WV [` UZSbfWdIZdWW&")(+# HWW6 ^efa` E& S`VFg[``

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )*+

    HfSfWeESdf[We")(-#&Ha_WaXfZW_SdWaT^[YSf[a`eaXdWeg[f$ afZWdeSdWaT^[%YSf[a`e aXUa`VgUf")(.#&

    +.& 6^fZagYZ`aUa__W`fSfadZSecgS^[XxWVfZW_[`fZSfiSk$ [f_SkTWSeeWdfWVfZSffZW`a`%V[eUd[_[`Sf[a`Vgf[Weg`VWdfZW8ahW`S`fSdWaT^[YS%f[a`e aXdWeg[f& IZW dW^WhS`fbdah[e[a`e SdW Sdf[U^W*"*#$ Sdf[U^W + S`V Sdf[%U^W /"S#"^#& HfSfWe g`VWdfS]W fa YgSdS`fWW ad fa W`egdW fZSf fZW:&H&8&G& i[^^ TW WjWdU[eWVi[fZagf V[eUd[_[`Sf[a` aXS`k ][`V$ WebWU[S^^kTWfiWW`_S` S`Via_S`&

    6`afZWd aT^[YSf[a` aXdWeg[f [e fZW Vgfk fa W`egdW fdSVWg`[a`d[YZfeSdf[U^W 0& LZSf _SffWde ZWdW [e fZW dWeg[f$ fZSf [e$ `a` V[eUd[_[`Sf[a` adfdSVWg`[a` XdWWVa_e$ iZSfWhWd fZW_WS`egeWV fa dWSUZ [f")(/#&

    +/& BadW[`fWdWef[`YXda_agdbWdebWUf[hWSdWfZWaT^[YSf[a`eaXUa`VgUfbdah[VWV Tk fZW 8ahW`S`f& 6df[U^W *")# [e fZW UW`fdS^ bdah[e[a` S`V [f [eiadfZ cgaf[`Y [f 2

    :SUZHfSfWESdfkfafZWEdWeW`f8ahW`S`fg`VWdfS]WefafS]WefWbe$[`V[%h[VgS^^k S`V fZdagYZ [`fWd`Sf[a`S^ See[efS UW S`V UaabsdSf[a $ WebWU[S^^kWUa`a_[US`VfWUZ [US^$fafZW_Sj[_g_aX[feShS[^ST^WdWeagdUWe$i[fZfZWh[Wifa SUZ[Wh[`YbdaYdWee[hW^kfZW Xg^^ dWS^[lSf[a aXfZWd[YZfedWUaY [lWV[ fZWbdWeW`f8ahW`S`fTkS[^Sbbdabd[SfW_WS`e$[`U^gV[`YbSdf[Ug^Sd^kfZWSVabf[a`aX^sY[e^Sf[hW_WSegdWe")(0#&

    Ha_WaXfZWefWbeSHfSfW[eWjbWUfWVfafS]W$[`dWebWUffaebsU[X[sd[YZfe$ZShWTWW`efSfWV[`VWfS[^TkfZW VdSXfWdeaXfZW8ahW`S`f& >`_S`k USeWeZaiWhWd$ fZW >&8&:&H&8&G& [e e[^W`f a` fZW_WS`e TkiZ[UZ Sd[YZf US` TWdWS^[lWV [`_S`k USeWe")(1#&

    >` egUZ S USeW$ a`W _[YZf ia`VWd iZSf [e fZW VWfWd_[`WV UagdeW aXUa`VgUf"))(# fZSf UZSdSUfWd[lWe fZW aT^[YSf[a`e aXUa`VgUf& 6UfgS^^k$ fZW

    ")(-# HWW6 AHIDC E& S`V FI?>CC > "bSdffia#$ )+(3C < >A A < &H &$ Z[$ NT_$" ))*&

  • )*, B>8=6:A AJ86H

    UagdeW aXUa`VgUf [e fa fS]W efWbe fa fZW_Sj[_g_ aXSHfSfWe ShS[^ST^WdWeagdUWe")))#iZ[UZ[eSVgfki[fZfZWeS_W^sYS^XadUWSeS`kafZWdaT^[%YSf[a` aXdWeg[f"))*#&

    +0& 6df[U^We e[j fa X[XfWW` aXfZW8ahW`S`f VWeUd[TW ea_W aXfZW ebsU[X[s_WSegdWe HfSfWeESdf[We SdW WjbWUfWVfa SVabf"))+#& IZ[e [e`affZWb^SUWfa dWefSfWfZW_& HgXX[UW [ffa eSkfZSffZW^[ef[e`afWjZSgef[hW 2 [f[eTSe[%US^^kgbfafZWHfSfWefaVWfWd_[`WiZSfSdWfZWXgdfZWdefWbe`WUWeeSdkXadfZW dWS^[lSf[a` aXfZW:&H&8&G& ")),#&

    +1& >f[e U^WSd fZSffZaeW_WSegdWe US`a`^kTWfS]W`fa fZW WjfW`faXSHfSfWeShS[^ST^WdWeagdUWeS`VfZSffZWkS[_SffZWbdaYdWee[hWdWS^[lSf[a`aXfZW:&H&8&G&&

    IZaeW fia`WUWeeSdk"))-# dWefd[Uf[a`e USddkS` [_badfS`f Ua`escgW`UW 2[f [e `af `WUWeeSdk TWUSgeW [`ZST[fS`fe aXS HfSfW ESdfk Va `af W`\ak S`SVWcgSfW efS`VSdV aX^[h[`Y ad fZSf fZ[e efS`VSdVZSe VWUdWSeWV fZSf fZW8ahW`S`f ZSe `af TWW` aTeWdhWV& 6 VWUdWSeW aX dWeagdUWe US` ^WSV fa SVWUdWSeW aXfZW efS`VSdVaX^[h[`Y$ S`V fZ[e [e SUUWbfWVTkfZW8ahW`S`f&

    D`WeZag^V`afZaiWhWdVWVgUWXda_fZSfSeeWdf[a`fZSfSHfSfW[eW`f[%f^WV fa VWfWd_[`W fZW S_ag`f aX dWeagdUWe [fi[^^ VWhafW fa fZW dWcg[dWV_WSegdWe")).#3 [fZSe fa VWhafW fZW_ _Z _SP XLcTX`X! Iia dg^We Xa^^aiXda_ fZSfbd[`U[b^W&

    ,(& 6T]^_Wd" fZW fa fZW_Sj[_g_ &&& U^SgeW Ua_bW^e HfSfWe fa SUUadV[]TZ]T_d Xad eaU[S^ iW^XSdW [` fZW S^^aUSf[a` aX dWeagdUWe"))/#& Ed[ad[fkVaWe`af_WS`fZSfS[^dWeagdUWe_gefTWVWhafWVfaiW^XSdWWjbW`V[fgdWe&LW TW^[WhW fZW 8ahW`S`f dWcg[dWe fZW Wj[efW`UW aX TS^S`UWV bdabadf[a`eTWfiWW` egUZ WjbW`V[fgdWe S`V afZWde&

    IZW TS^S`UW Uag^V TW SeeWeeWV Tk Ua_bSd[`Y bgT^[U TgVYWfe aX Ua_bS%dST^W"))0# Uag`fd[We& D`^kiZWdW fZWbdabadf[a`eiag^VTWdagYZ^kg_TS%^S`UWV$ iag^V fZWdW TW STdWSUZ aXfZW 8ahW`S`f&

    ")))# HWW6 AHIDC E& S`VFJ >CC 9 :&$ Z[$ NT_$" 00 2 AW XS[f cg[^ eSY[eeW V g`W aT^[YSf[a` VW Ua_badfW_W`f

    `[_b^[cgW bSe cgW^^W ea[f dWhufgW Vg`W \gd[V[U[fW _a[`VdW cg[^ eSY[eeW Vg`W aT^[YSf[a` VWdseg^fSf&"))+# HWW IZW &8&:&H&8&G&E$>$4ZN$":'8&)*')11)')3fZWkiWdWVdSXfWV Tk fZW 8a__[ffWW& >f_[YZf TW [`fWdWef[`Y fa dWSV fZW_ TWUSgeW fZWk Y[hW S` [VWS aXiZSffZ[e adYS` Ua`e[VWdeSe SVWcgSfWefWbe&")),# HWWI GJ 7 :[email protected] 9&B&$ Z[$ NT_$" *)-&"))-# D`WUag^V`afWjbWUfSHfSfWfaebW`V_adWfZS`[fai`eS`VS`[__sV[SfWdWS^[lSf[a`

    aXfZWd[YZfe Ua`UWd`WV [eg`dWS^[ef[U&")).# HWW6 A H I D C E& S`V F J >C C fiag^VaTh[age^kTW`WUWe%

    eSdk fa geW efSf[ef[Uefa TW ST^W fa Ua_bSdW& ;ad Ua_bSd[`Y efSf[ef[US$ eWW= : AA:G E& S`V9 > 6 %

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )*-

    >` fZ[e bWdebWUf[hW$ a`W Uag^V dWSea`ST^k SdYgW fZSf fZW Tg[^V[`Y aX SUabk aXH[`fEWfWdeTSe[^[Ug_ aXGa_W [` S egT%HSZSdS`6Xd[US` Uag`fdk[e [`Ua`e[efW`f i[fZ fZW 8ahW`S`f& 6`afZWd WjS_b^W aX XS[^gdW fa SUUadVbd[ad[fkfaiW^XSdWWjbW`V[fgdWe$iag^VTW fZW Ua`f[`gage[`UdWSeWaX_[^[%fSdk ebW`V[`Y i[fZagf S`k UaddWeba`V[`Y [`UdWSeW [` :&H&8&G& ebW`%V[`Y"))1#&

    ,)& CPNZYOWd" fZW U^SgeW S^^aie HfSfWe fa dWVgUW fZW[diW^XSdW WjbW`V[%fgdWe a`^k _Z _SP Pc_PY_ aX fZW VWUdWSeW aX fZW ShS[^ST^W dWeagdUWe& >X fZW&B&;&$LSeZ[`Yfa` 9&8&$ )11( "DUUSe[a`S^ESbWd `~ .1#$ IST^W )+$ ,*&"))1# HWW EZ[^[b 6^efa`e Ua__W`f$ Se WjbWdf aXfZW 8a__[ffWW a`:&H&8&G&$ a` fZW dWbadf

    aX8Z[^WfafZW8a__[ffWW$E$>$4ZN$":'8&)*')100'H&G& )+$. 2 i[fZdWYSdVfaSdf[U^W))$Lad^V7S`]e efSf[ef[Ue eZaiWV fZSf TWfiWW` )1/* S`V )10-$ VWXW`eW ebW`V[`Y ZSVd[eW` Ua`e[VWdST^kiZWdWSe WjbW`V[fgdW a` sVgUSf[a`$ ZWS^fZ S`V WUa`a_[U eWdh[UWe ZSV TWW` egTefS`f[S^^k dWVg%UWV&&&>fiag^VTW[`fWdWef[`Yfa]`aiiZWfZWdfZW8Z[^WS`$ 4ZN$" :'8&)*')100'H&G&)/$ / 2 &&& WjbW`V[fgdWe a` sVgUSf[a`ZSVTWW` Wgf Xda_ )-&* bWdUW`f [` )1/* fa (&0 bWdUW`f [` )10-& :jbW`V[fgdWe a` Zage[`Y ahWd fZWeS_WbWd[aVZSVTWW`dWVgUWVXda_*bWdUW`ffa (&.bWd UW`f S`Va`Ys`sdS^WUa`a_[UeWdh[UWeXda_ )+&+bWd UW`f fa-&+bWdUW`f& >fiSefdgW fZSfOS[dWZSVdWUadVWVS`WYSf[hWYdaifZdSfW$Tgfe[`UWfZWX[YgdWe "&& cgafWViWdW[`bWdUW`fSYW$ fZSfV[V`af[`hS^[VSfWfZW Ua`U^ge[a`fZSffZWdWZSVTWW`S Ua`eU[ageVsU[e[a`fadWVgUWWjbW`V[fgdWea`eaU[S^d[YZfe&=W"E&6^efa`# cgW%d[WeiZWfZWd fZW

  • )*. B>[email protected] AJ86H

    [eY[hW`fafZWHfSfWeESdf[WefadWS^[lWbdaYdWee[hW^kfZSfbdaYdS__W$fZWdW[e `a daa_ZWdW Xad WjUgeWe TSeWVa` fZW ^SU] aXdWeagdUWe&

    Iiae[fgSf[a`eSdWW`h[eSYWVTkfZW8ahW`S`f 2 W[fZWd$ XdWWS`VUa_bg^%eadk bd[_Sdk sVgUSf[a` Wj[efe Sf fZW f[_W aX dSf[X[USf[a`$ S`V fZW` fZWUa`UWd`WVHfSfWESdfk_gef_S[`fS[`[f3 ad$ [f[e`a`Wj[efW`f SffZW f[_WaXdSf[X[USf[a`$ S`V fZW` fZWHfSfW_gef SVabf Sb^S` aXSUf[a`i[fZ[`fZWfia kWSdei[fZ Sh[Wifa dWS^[l[`YfZW XdWWS`VUa_bg^eadkekefW_i[fZ[`SdWSea`ST^W f[_W")*,#&

    DfZWd_[`[_g__WSegdWe[`U^gVWfZaeWfaTWfS]W`faW`egdWfZWXa`VS%_W`fS^d[YZffaTWXdWWXda_Zg`YWd&IZW8ahW`S`fVaWe`afWjb^[U[f^kefSfWea$ Tgf fZ[e [e fZW a`^kd[YZf fa TW cgS^[XxWVSe Xa`VS_W`fS^")*-#&

    BadWYW`WdS^^k$iWVa`afdW\WUffZW[VWSfZSffZWdWiag^VTWS_[`[_g_^WhW^aXSUf[a`[`dW^Sf[a`fa S[^ fZW:&H&8&G& ")*.#& 9WX^`[`YfZSf_[`[_g`fZdWeZa^V eWW_e `af fa TW S` WSek g`VWdfS][`Y& IZW VsX[`[f[a` iag^VU^WSd^kTWdW^Sf[hW&

    8ag^VXad [`efS`UW Ua`ef[fgfW Sh[a^Sf[a` aXfZSfbd[`U[b^W$ fZW XS[^gdW aXSHfSfW$ [`f[_W aXbWSUW$ fabdah[VW fZWbgT^[UZaeb[fS^ei[fZTSe[U_WV[%U[`Weea fZSf fZWbSf[W`feUS``afTW UgdWV$ ^WfS^a`WabWdSfWVgba` "g ^WeefZWkTd[`YfZW[d ai`_WV[U[`We# ")*/#&

    ")*,# HWW Sdf[U^We )+ S`V ), aXfZW >&8&:&H&8&G&$ S`V 6^efa`e Ua__W`fSdk aXfZW dWbadf aXOS[dW$E$>$4ZN$":'8&)*')100'H&G&)1$+ 2=WUa`f[`gWVfaTWYdWSf^kUa`UWd`WVTkfZWSTa^[f[a`aXXdWW bd[_Sdk sVgUSf[a`$ fZWbdah[e[a` aXegUZ sVgUSf[a`iSe S` aT^[YSf[a`iZ[UZ dW_S[`WV[`Ug_TW`fgba`SHfSfWESdfkiZSfWhWdWUa`a_[UekefW_[fZSVSVabfWV&LWZaiWhWdia`VWdiZk E& 6^efa` Se]WV fZW YahWd`_W`f dWbdseW`fSf[hW [XS b^S` aXSUf[a` ZSV TWW` VdSi` gb&>`VWWV$ OS[dWZSVXdWWbd[_Sdk sVgUSf[a`Tgf[fiSeegbbdWeeWV& 6df[U^W ),$ iZ[UZbdah[VWeXadfZWb^S` aXSUf[a`$ VaWe`afdW^SfW fa fZ[e USeW Tgf fa fZW afZWda`W&")*-# HWWSd[U^W ))"*#& IZ[ebdah[e[a`iSeSVVWV fafZWVdSXf UahW`S`f[`)1.+i[fZfZWS[_$

    [`fZW;&6&D&bWdebWUf[hW$aXbdah[V[`Y^sYS^egbbadfXad[fe;dWWVa_Xda_=g`YWd8S_bS[`eWW 6 A HIDC E&$ >`fWd`Sf[a`S^ASi S`V=g_S`G[YZf fa ;aaV$ TY DSPBTRS__ZQZZO" Z[$ NT_$"++&NWf$ fZWUaWj[efW`UWaXfZWd[YZffaSVWcgSfWXaaVS`VfZWXa`VS_W`fS^d[YZffaTWXdWWXda_Zg`YWdUS`a`^kTWY[hW`dWSea`ST^W_WS`[`YTkUa`e[VWd[`YfZW^SffWdSeS_[`[_g_UadWd[YZf$Xad fZWdWS^[lSf[a`aXiZ[UZHfSfWe_gef$ [`S`kWhW`f$ fS]W fZW`WUWeeSdk_WSegdWe&DTh[age^k$fZWdy^WaX[`fWd`Sf[a`S^S[V[`USeWeaXW_WdYW`Uk[eaXfZWYdWSfWef[_badfS`UW eWW8a__[ffWWa`:&H&8&G&$$4ZN$":'8&)*')101'-$ /)&")*.# HWW8a__[ffWW a`:&H&8&G&$

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )*/

    ,+& ;[`S^^k$ [f [eiadfZ`af[`YfZWWj[efW`UW aXS^[_[fSf[a`bdah[e[a`[`fZW8ahW`S`f3 Sdf[U^W , dWSVe Se Xa^^ai 2

    IZWHfSfWeESdf[WefafZWbdWeW`f8ahW`S`fdWUaY [lWfZSf$ [ fZWW`\ak%_W`faXfZaeWd[YZfebdah[VWVTkfZWHfSfWe[ Ua`Xad_[fki[fZfZWbdWeW f8ahW`S`f$ fZW HfSfWe _Sk egT\WUf egUZ d[YZfe fa egUZ ^[_[fSf[a`e Se SdWVWfWd_[`WVTk ^Si a`^k [`eaXSd Se fZ[e_SkTW Ua_bSf[T^Wi[fZ fZW`SfgdWaXfZWeWd[YZfe S`V ea^W^k Xad fZWbgdbaeW aXbdafWUf[`Y fZW Ys`sdS^iW^XSdW[ VW_aUdSf[WeaU[Wfk&

    IZ[e bdah[e[a` dW^SfWe fa ebsU[X[s ad Xad_S[ dWefd[Uf[a`e Se$ Xad WjS_b^W$fZW Vgfk fa dWS^[lW Ua_bg^eadk eaU[S^ eWdh[UWi[fZagf TW`WXxf[`Y aXS XS[diSYW& >f VaWe [` `a iSk dWXWd fa _WSegdWe ^[_[f[`Y fZW Ys`sdS^ ^WhW^ aXSffS[`_W`f aXfZW:&H&8&G&$ iZ[UZ SdW a`^k Ua`UWd`WVTk Sdf[U^W *")#&

    >>&*&*& 9^ _SP 9$=$6$[ZWTNd TYNZY^T^_PY_bT_S bSL_ T^ ]P\`T]PO5

    ,,& AWfge Seeg_WfZSffZW^[h[`Y Ua`V[f[a`eaXfZWbabg^Sf[a`aXSgeWdaX fZW ;g`Ve dWeagdUWe SdW iadeW`WV Tk fZW >&B&;& fZWdSbk& 6e iWZShW`S^dWSVkeWW`$fZ[e[e`afegXX[U[v`ffaSXX[d_fZWh[a^Sf[a`aXfZW8ahW%`S`f& LW ZShW fa VWfWd_[`W fa iZSf WjfW`f fZW >&B&;& ba^[Uk ^[_[fe fZWbaiWd aXSHfSfW fa fS]W fZW dWcg[dWV_WSegdWe Xad fZW[_b^W_W`fSf[a` aXfZW8ahW`S`f&

    6UUadV[`Yfa fZW>&B&;& S`S^ke[e$ fZWdaafeaXVWX[U[fe[`TS^S`UW aXbSk%_W`fe[e faTW Xag`V[`fZW[_TS^S`UW$i[fZ[`S Uag`fdk$ TWfiWW`[`fWd`S[VW_S`V S`V [`fWd`S[ egbb^k3 Se S_SffWd aXUa`escgW`UW$ fZW TW`WX[fe aXfZWWjbadfe US``afUahWdfZWUaefeaX[_badfe&IZge$iZSf_gefTWVa`W[efa [`UdWSeW egbb^k S`VdWVgUW VW_S`V")*0#&

    ,-& IZWXxdef SebWUf aXfZW>&B&;& ba^[Uk[`UdWSeWegbb^kUS`ZShWea_W TW`WX[fe Xad fZW [_b^W_W`fSf[a` aX fZW 8ahW`S`f 2 fa [_bdahW fZWSYd[Ug^fgdS^ bdaVgUf[a` [e fafS^^k Ua`e[efW`f i[fZ Sdf[U^W ))"*# aX fZW>&8&:&H&8&G& Sf^WSef[XS[^fZW`WibdaVgUf[a`[e`afS[_WVSfWjbadf& Hgb%b^k _WSegdWe eZag^V `ad_S^^k S^ea ZShW S bae[f[hW WXXWUf a` fZW ^WhW^ aXW_b^ak_W`f&

    CWhWdfZW^Wee$ fZaeW _WSegdWe SdW {egS^^k agfiW[YZWV Tk VW_S`V_WS%egdWe")*1# i[fZ SYs`sdS^ S[_ Sf fZW abbae[fW aXfZW8ahW`S`febgdbaeW 2fa dWVgUW VW_S`V!

    ,.& Ha_W aX fZW _WSegdWe [`U^gVWV [` fZW >&B&;& bdaYdS__We Va `afUa`UWd`HfSfWe ebW`V[`Y 2 VshS^gSf[a`aXfZW`Sf[a`S^ UgddW`Uk$V[e[`VWjS%f[a`aXiSYWe[`fZWbd[hSfWeWUfad$ ^[TWdS^[lSf[a`aXbd[lWe$ &&& 3kWf$g`VagT%

    ")*0# [email protected] 6 = C B&H& S`[email protected] C >

  • )*0 B>8=6:A AJ86H

    fWV^k$fZWk_SkSXXWUfea_WaXfZWd[YZfedWUaY`[lWVTkfZW8ahW`S`f$ egUZSe fZW d[YZf fa S` SVWcgSfW efS`VSdVaX^[h[`Y ad fZWd[YZffa S XS[diSYW&

    BWSegdWeaXfZ[e][`V$ ^WSV[`YbdWeg_ST^kfaSdsYdWee[a`[`fZWdWS^[lS%f[a`aXfZW:&H&8&G&$ US``afTW \gef[XxWV$ g`VWdfZW8ahW`S`f$ TkS^SU]aXShS[^ST^W dWeagdUWe TWUSgeW fZWk Wj[ef [`VWbW`VW`f^k aXS`k S^^aUSf[a` aXdWeagdUWe&

    D`fZWafZWdZS`V$ fZWkWeUSbW$ XadfZW eS_W dWSea`$ fa fZWVagT^WfWefaXbdabadf[a`S^[fk S`Vbd[ad[fk& Hf[^^$ fZWki[^^ TW dWYSdVWV Se[`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZfZW8ahW`S`f[XfZWkbdWhW`ffZW_[`[_g_dWS^[lSf[a`aXfZW:&H&8&G&&

    ,/& 6`afZWd h[Wiiag^VTW fa dWYSdV fZWeW][`V aX_WSegdWe Se ^[_[fS%f[a`e aX fZW :&H&8&G& ")+(#& IZWk iag^V fZW` XS^^ g`VWd Sdf[U^W , aX fZW8ahW`S`f$iZ[UZ Ua`V[f[a`eiag^VZShW fa TW aTeWdhWV")+)#&

    :ebWU[S^^k$fZW_WSegdWeiag^VTWS^^aiWVea^W^kXadfZWbgdbaeWaXbda%fWUf[`Y fZW Ys`sdS^iW^XSdW [` S VW_aUdSf[W eaU[Wfk& >fZSe TWW` SeeWdfWVfZSfVW^Sk[`Y[_b^W_W`fSf[a`aXegUZd[YZfeSefZaeWfasVgUSf[a`$ZWS^fZS`V eaU[S^ eWUgd[fk [` adVWd fa Ua`UW`fdSfW S[^ [fe dWeagdUWe a` WUa`a_[UVWhW^ab_W`ffZgeeSUd[Xk[`YfZW[`fWdWefaXfZWbdWeW`fYs`sdSf[a`fafZaeWaX fZW `Wjf")+*# iag^V TW S TdWSUZ aX Sdf[U^W ,& GWSea`e SVhS`UWV TkHfSfWe fa \gef[Xk ^[_[fSf[a`e aX:&H&8&G& _gef TW YW`g[`W^k ek`a`k_agei[fZfZWYs`sdS^iW^XSdW")++# S`VhSYgWS`VabW`%W`VWV`af[a`eSeWUa%`a_[U VWhW^ab_W`fi[^^ TW [`egXX[U[v`f")+,#&

    >efZWbgdbaeWaXdWVgU[`YTS^S`UWaXbSk_W`fVWX[U[feSYW`g[`WiW^XSdWbdafWUf[a` bgdbaeW5 Ha_Wi[^^ bdaTST^k SdYgW fZSf fZ[e \gef[X[USf[a` US`ZSdV^k TW SVhS`UWV e[`UW fZWdWS^[fkZSe eZai` fZSf ^[_[fSf[a`eZShW`afWhW` ^WVfa fZW dWS^[lSf[a`aXfZW Ua`fdahWde[S^bgdbaeW&

    NWf$ US` VshS^gSf[a`$ Xad [`efS`UW$ TW dWYSdVWV Se S WTXT_L_TZY aX fZWd[YZffa S`SVWcgSfWefS`VSdVaX^[h[`Y$ adV[e[`VWjSf[a`SeS^[_[fSf[a`aXfZWd[YZffa SXS[diSYW5LWVa`affZ[`]ea$ TWUSgeW$ SeiWZShWS^dWSVkeS[V$ ^[_[fSf[a`e dWXWd fa ebWU[X[U dWefd[Uf[a`e")+-#&

    ,0& AWfge_ahW`aifafZSfbSdfaXSV\gef_W`fbdaYdS__WeiZ[UZS[_efadWVgUWHfSfWeWjbW`V[fgdWe&LZSfiWSdWUa`UWd`WVi[fZ[efZWYs`sdS^

    ")+(# HWW6 A H I D C E & S` V F J >C C CC $ 4ZN$" :'8C&,'H&G&*+-$ `afW,0&")++# 6 AHIDC E& S`VFJ >C C

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )*1

    ^WhW^aXSffS[`_W`faX:&H&8&G&$iZ[UZXS^^e[`fZWeUabWaXSdf[U^W*")#S`V`af aXSdf[U^W ,")+.#&

    6TS^S`UWaX[LdXPY_^VsX[U[f[`afZWdiadVe$ S^SU]aXXadW[Y`UgddW`%U[We US` UWdfS[`^k TW dWYSdVWV Se S ^SU] aX dWeagdUWe& IZge$ g`VWdSdf[U^W *")#$ S HfSfWi[^^ TW W`f[f^WV fa [`ha]W [feTSVTS^S`UW aXbSk_W`fe[fgSf[a` fa \gef[XkdWefd[Uf[a`e a` [fe WXXadfe fa dWS^[lW fZW:&H&8&G& ")+/#&

    ,1& >X\gef[XxWVSeSiZa^W$ fZaeWdWefd[Uf[a`e_gefZaiWhWdbSeefZWfWefaXfZWdWcg[dW_W`feaXSdf[U^W*")#& ;[def^k$ fZWiSk[`iZ[UZUgfeSdW_SVW_gefdWX^WUfbd[ad[fkY[hW` Tk fZW HfSfW fa fZW dWS^[lSf[a` aX:&H&8&G&&

    6eS`WjS_b^WaXUa_b^[S`UWi[fZfZ[edWcg[dW_W`f$iW_SkdWXWdfafZW6dYW`f[`SeH&6&E&eaX)10,%)10-$iZ[UZebWU[X[US^^kbdah[VWVfZSf_[^[fSdkTgVYWfZSVfaTWWgf$iZ[^WWjbW`V[fgdWeXadZage[`Y$ZWS^fZS`VsVgUSf[a`ZSV fa TW [`UdWSeWV")+0#&

    6bdaYdS__W[`ha^h[`Y Ugfe[`iW^XSdWebW`V[`Y$ Tgf^WSh[`Yg`fagUZWVfZW_[^[fSdk TgVYWfiag^VZShW fa TW Ua`e[VWdWV Se [`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZ fZW>&8&:&H&8&G& WjUWbfbWdZSbe [` ea_W WjUWbf[a`S^ U[dUg_efS`UWe&

    -(& HWUa`V^k$ UgfeeZag^V`afTW_S`[XWef^kV[ebdabadf[a`SfW[`dW^Sf[a`fafZWWjfW`faXfZWbdaT^W_eXSUWVTkfZW[`fWdWefWVUag`fdk&>f[e`afWSekfa cgS`f[XkTS^S`UW aX[LdXPY_^ VWX[U[fe$ S`V fa WefST^[eZ fZW bdabadf[a`efZSfeZag^VTWaTeWdhWV&NWf$iZSf[ebdabaeWV[efabdWhW`fXLYTQP^_WdV[e%bdabadf[a`SfW Ugfe&

    ;ad [`efS`UW$ a`W _Sk ia`VWd iZWfZWd fZW V[e_[eeS^ Tk fZW OS[d[S`&8&:&H&8&G&dWcg[dWe&LWZShWS^dWSVk U[fWV fZW USeW aXfZW egbbdWee[a` aXXdWW bd[_SdksVgUSf[a`"),)#&

    6`afZWd WjS_b^W aXTdWSUZ aXfZ[e dg^W Uag^V TW ?S_S[USe Ugfe [` [feeaU[S^eWUgd[fkWjbW`V[fgdWe& >`VWWVSffZWW`VaXfZWW[YZf[We$ a`^k(&+bWdUW`faX[fe`VWWV$ fZW dWefd[Uf[a`e

    Xa^^ai[` XSUf S` [`UdWSeWaXdWeagdUWe dWeg^f[`YXda_ fZW ShS[^ST[^[fk aXfZW;g`Ve ^aS`e&")+0# [email protected] A >C B& S`V9 6 K >9 HD C 9 &$ Z[$ NT_$" *,*&")+1# [email protected] GDC HI:C &B&;& [`6Xd[US$;SUfadaXHfST[^[fkad;SUfadaXJ`dWefr"DSP

    GZ]WODZOLd" )10/$ )-(&"),(# [email protected] DGC :G E& S`VafZWde$ Z[$ NT_$" 1/&"),)# HWW`afW )*,&

  • )+( B>D=6:A AJ86H

    fa fZW &B&;&Q"),*#& (&+ bWdUW`f eWW_e fa TW ^Wee fZS` fZW _[`[_g` dWcg[%dWV"),+#&

    >`dWebWUf fa fZSf ^SfWefba[`f$ [f_gefTWeS[V$ [`VWXW`eW aXfZW>&B&;&fZSf [f ZSe dWUW`f^k )10/ [`UadbadSfWV eaU[S^ Ua_bW`eSfadk bda%YdS__We [` fZW H&6&E&e"),,#& IZWk S[_ fa UaddWUf fZW `WYSf[hW eaU[S^WXXWUfe aXfZW [_b^W_W`fSf[a` aXH&6&E&e$ Se XSd Se fZWbaadWef SdW Ua`UWd%`WV"),-#&LZWdW fZWeW bdaYdS__We ZShW TWW` [_b^W_W`fWV$ fZWZSdeZWefWXXWUfeiWdW Sha[VWV"),.#&

    >>&+& DZ bSL_ Pc_PY_ T^ _SP 9$=$6$ ]P^[ZY^TMWPQZ] _SP 1`^_P]T_d=PL^`]P^5

    -*& IZW >&B&;& bae[f[a` dW^[We gba` fZW [VWS fZSf S U^WSd Vs_SdUSf[a`Wj[efe TWfiWW` fZW WUa`a_[U ebZWdW S`V fZW eaU[S^ ebZWdW& >fe SUf[a`$ [f_S[`fS[`e$ [e ^[_[fWV fa fZW Xad_WdiZ[^ef fZW [`fWdhW`f[a`[` fZW ^SffWd [eS_SffWd TW^a`Y[`Y fa fZW Ua_bsfW`UWe aXfZW HfSfWe"),/#&

    BadWahWd$ fZW Xg`V g`VWdfaa] fZW Xad_S[ Ua__[f_W`f fa dWebWUf SHfSfWe eaU[S^bd[ad[f[We"),0#&

    >f Xa^^aie$ a` fZ[e h[Wi$ fZSf fZW dWeba`e[T[^[fk Xad fZW eaU[S^ Uaefe aXH&6&E&e_gefTW Sffd[TgfWV fa fZW HfSfWe&

    -+& IZ[eab[`[a`[ecg[fWWjUWee[hW&>`VWWV$fZWSTahW%_W`f[a`WVV[ef[`U%f[a` VaWe`af Wj[ef ea U^WSd^k [` dWS^[fk"),1# 3 [`fWdXWdW`UWe TWfiWW` TafZfZW ebZWdWe SdW ea `g_Wdage fZSf [f [e egdbd[e[`Y fa ZWSd egUZ SV[eUagdeW&Ikb[US^H&6&E&_WSegdWeSe VshS^gSf[a`$iSYWdsVgUf[a`e$ &&&$ZShWg`Sha[%VST^W eaU[S^ dWbWdUgee[a`e")-(#&

    "),*# HWW8a__[ffWWa`:&H&8&G&$GWbadfaXfZWXagdfZeWee[a`$E$>$4ZN$":'8$)*')11('+$+1&"),+# A &9 &8 &e ShWdSYWWjbW`V[fgdWa`eaU[S^eWUgd[fkS_ag`fefa )-&+bWdUW`faXfZWHfSfWe

    TgVYWfeWWA = :G>I:6I?B&%;&$ Z[$ NT_$" *.-& HfSf[ef[Ue eZai fZSf ?S_S[USe [`V[UW XadHaU[S^HWUgd[fk S`VLW^XSdWiSe*/&/ [` )1/-%)1//$ )((TW[`YfZW ShWdSYWWjbW`V[fgdWeWW= : AA:G H& S`V9 >6B DC9 ?&$Z[$ NT_$" ,+& IZWeS_WefSf[ef[UeeZaifZSfea_WUag`fd[WeVa`afWhW`dWSUZfZSf^ai [`V[UW 2 IZWEZ[^[b[`We ")-#[email protected]`kS "/#$ H[`YSbadW "/#$EWdg ")# S`V >`Va`We[S "(#&

    "),,# HWW7 A 6G9D C : I:6II B&%;&$ Z[$ NT_$" *)+&

  • ;JC9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )+)

    BadWahWd$ fZW Xad_S[ Ua__[f_W`f fa dWebWUf HfSfWe eaU[S^ bd[ad[f[We [e`afSdWS^dWefd[Uf[a`fa>&B&;&eSUf[a` fZge$`aYgSdS`fWWaXfZWdWebWUfaXfZaeWbd[ad[f[WeWj[efee[`UWfZW;g`V$fZdagYZ[feXad_Wd^sYS^Uag`eW^$ZSe VWX[`WViZSf [f Ua`e[VWde Se fZW eaU[S^ ebZWdW Se TW[`Y S[^iZSf[e`afUa`UWd`WVi[fZ [fe [`fWdhW`f[a`")-)# !

    -,& =Sh[`Y eS[VfZ[e$ iW TW^[WhW fZSf fZW S`eiWd fa fZW cgWef[a` aXfZWdWeba`e[T[^[fkaXfZWSgefWd[fk_WSegdWedWcg[dWeS`S`S^ke[eaXfiaafZWdba[`fe 2iWZShWfaia`VWd$ a`fZWa`WZS`V$iZSf[efZWV[eUdsf[a`^WXffafZWHfSfWe [` fZW VsfWd_[`Sf[a`aXfZW ebsU[X[s_WSegdWe$ S`Va` fZW afZWdZS`V$ faiZSfWjfW`ffZWYs`sdS^dWcg[dW_W`feaXfZW;g`V^WShWS`kbaee[%T[^[fk Xad fZW HfSfWe fa SVabf WXX[U[W`f Ua_bW`eSfadkbdaYdS__We&

    --& 6eXSd SefZWX[defba[`f[e Ua`UWd`WV$ [f[e cg[fWV[XXxUg^fXadS`agf%e[VWaTeWdhWdfaS`eiWd[fTWUSgeWa`WeZag^VZShWfa]`aiZaifZW`WYa%f[Sf[`YbdaUWeeiZ[UZ^WSVefafZWVdSXfaXS^WffWdaX[`fW`fabWdSfWe 2iZSf[e fZW bae[f[a` aX fZW >&B&;& efSXX5 LZ[UZ SdW fZW ^TYP \`L YZY Ua`V[%f[a`e5 &&&IZ[e [e [_baee[T^WY[hW` fZW eWUdWf UZSdSUfWd aXfZW TSdYS[`[`Y&

    LZSf eWW_e UWdfS[`$ [e fZSf fZW ^[`W TWfiWW` iZSf [e [_baeWV Tk fZW>&B&;& S`ViZSfdW_S[`e[`fZWHfSfWe V[eUdsf[a`hSd[WeXda_USeWfa USeW$VWbW`V[`Y a` fZW bae[f[a` aXfZW dWcgWef[`Y HfSfW 2 Xad WjS_b^W$ fa iZSfWjfW`fVaWe [f`WWVfZW ^aS`5LZSfiSe[febdWh[age WjbWd[W`UW5LZSf[efZW^WhW^ aXVWhW^ab_W`f aXfZWHfSfWe efdgUfgdWe5 &&& ")-*#& >f[e fZSf ^[`WiZ[UZ VWXx`We fZW WjfW`f aXfZW >&B&;&edWeba`e[T[^[fk")-+#&

    IZ[e_WS`efZSfTWka`ViZSf[e[_baeWV$ fZW;g`VTWSde`adWeba`e[T[%^[fk& 7gf[f_SkTWV[eUgeeWViZWfZWd$iZWdWfZW;g`VUS`TWdWYSdVWVSedWeba`e[T^W$ fZWdW [e`abSdS^^W^ dWeba`e[T[^[fkaXfZW HfSfW Ua`UWd`WV& NWf$fZ[e [e S`afZWd cgWef[a`3 fZW S`eiWd fa [f VaWe `af SXXWUf agd Ua`U^ge[a`Ua`UWd`[`Y fZW;g`V&

    Ha_W_WSegdWe$ Y[hW` fZW XdWcW`UkaXfZW[d SbbWSdS`UW[` H&6&E&e$ eWW_faTWWeeW`f[S^S`VfZge[_baeWVTkfZW>&B&;& 2 XdWWlWaXeS^Sd[We$ VshS^gS%f[a`$ egbbdWee[a` aXHfSfWe egThW`f[a` Xad XaaVbd[UWe")-,#&

    Ha_W aXfZW_ US` TW Ua`e[VWdWV Se Ua`fdSdk fa fZW 8ahW`S`f3 Xad [`e%fS`UW$ fZW egbbdWee[a` aXTSe[U XaaV egThW`f[a`e i[^^$ [` UWdfS[` U[dUg_e%fS`UWe$ TW Ua`fdSdkfa fZWXg`VS_W`fS^d[YZffaTWXdWWXda_Zg`YWd&LW^^$[XfZW >&B&;& dWS^^k [_baeWe egUZ_WSegdWe$ [fi[^^ USddkfZW dWeba`e[T[^[fkXad S TdWSUZ aXfZW >&8&:&H&8&G& g`^Wee [f US`TWbdahW` fZSf HfSfWe XdWW%Va_aXSUf[a`[e ef[^^i[VWW`agYZfaSVabffZW Ua_bW`eSfadk_WSegdWeTkiZ[UZ fZWkiag^V Ua_b^ki[fZ fZW8ahW`S`f&

    ")-)# HWW A = : G >I : 6 J B&%;&$ Z[$ NT_$" )**&")-*# HWW7 G >A A =& S`VE : IG 6H ?&$ Z[$ NT_$" ,+- S`V,+.&")-+# HWWA = :G>I:6II B&%;&$ Z[$ NT_$" *)(&")-,# HWW9 6JN:=

  • )+* B>D=6:A AJ86H

    6`afZWd WjS_b^Wiag^VTW$ Xad fZW >&B&;&$ fa dWcg[dWS HfSfW fa dWVgUW[feWjbW`V[fgdWe[`SiSkfafS^^kV[ebdabadf[a`SfWfafZWWjfW`faXfZWbda%T^W_e XSUWVTk fZW HfSfW Ua`UWd`WV&

    DfZWd_WSegdWeSdW fZWdWeg^f aXHfSfWe UZa[UWe& >f[eXadfZW_faVsU[VsiZ[UZ WjbW`V[fgdWei[^^ TW dWVgUWV$ iZ[^ef fZW >&B&;& VWX[`We fZW S_ag`faXfZW Y^aTS^ dsVgUf[a` aXbgT^[U VWX[U[f&

    >f[eg`^[]W^kfZSffZW;g`V[_baeWeegUZ_WSegdWeSefZWegbbdWee[a`aXXdWWbd[_SdksVgUSf[a`& IZge$ [`fZ[eX[W^V$iZWdWS_WSegdW[e[`Ua`e[efW`fi[fZfZW8ahW`S`f$ [f[efZWHfSfWUa`UWd`WViZ[UZ$S^a`W$TWSdefZWdWeba`%e[T[^[fk Xad [f&

    -.& 6eXSdSefZWeWUa`Vba[`f[eUa`UWd`WV$ fZ[e[e$fZWbaee[T[^[fkXadfZWHfSfW fa SVabf Ua_bW`eSfadkbdaYdS__We$ a`W_Skia`VWdiZWfZWd `WiXg`Ve US`TW_SVW ShS[^ST^W fa X[`S`UW Ua_bW`eSfadkbdaYdS__We$ [`fZWUa`fWjfaXSba^[UkiZ[UZS[_efadWVgUWHfSfWe[`fWdhW`f[a`S`VWjbW`V[%fgdWe&

    6eiWZShW eS[V$ fZW>&B&;& eWW_ebdWbSdWVfa ^WShWdaa_a` H&6&E& XadegUZbdaYdS__We&LZWfZWdfZWkSdWegXX[U[v`ffa_WWffZW_[`[_g_dWcg[%dW_W`fe aX fZW 8ahW`S`f [e S`afZWd cgWef[a`& CafW fZSf$ SUUadV[`Y fa SJ&C&>&8&:&;& efgVk$ iZWdW SVabfWV$ fZWk V[VSha[VfZWZSdeZWef WXXWUfe aXSV\gef_W`f$ Se_S^`gfd[f[a`$ iadeW`[`Y aXZWS^fZ Ua`V[f[a`e")--#&

    >`fZ[edWYSdV$ [f[eiadfZ cgaf[`YfZW8a__[ffWWa`:&H&8&G&$ S`S^ke[`Y8a^g_T[Se S`V?S_S[USe dWbadf 2 [fiSe eZai`fZSfh[a^W`UW$ VdgYfdSX%X[U][`YS`VWjfWd`S^[`VWTfWV`Wee P[ 8a^g_T[SQZSV^[_[fWVTgf`afZS^fWVbdaYdWee[`W`\ak_W`faXZg_S`d[YZfe")-.#$iZ[^W [fiSeaTeWdhWVfZSffZW

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )++

    IZWS`S^ke[eU^WSd^ka`^k_S]WeeW`eW[XfZW>&B&&;[eTag`VTkfZW8ahW%`S`f& IZ[e efgVk S^ea Ua`e[VWde fZSfba[`f&

    CWhWdfZW^Wee$ fZWdW [eS_adWXg`VS_W`fS^bd[`U[b^WiZ[UZg`VWd^[WefZ[e^[`WaXSdYg_W`f 2fZWXSUffZSffZW>&B&;&$SeS`[`fWd`Sf[a`S^adYS`[lSf[a`$NLYTW Tag`VTk S`[`efdg_W`f ^[]W fZW8ahW`S`f&

    IZ[eSeeWdf[a`[eaTh[agefaS^SikWd3ZaiWhWd[f[e`afeaaTh[a`efaS`WUa`a_[ef&

    IZSf eS[V$ fZWdW [e`adWSea`iZk fZW >&B&;&$ SegT\WUf aX[`fWd`Sf[a`S^^Si$ eZag^VW`\ak[__g`[fk$ T[^ZQLN_Z" Xda_fZWdg^WeaXfZW>`fWd`Sf[a`S^8a__g`[fk&

    &>Xa`W SUUWbfe fZ[e bd[`U[b^W$ a`W_gef SUUWbf fZW`ad_S^ Ua`escgW`UWeaX[f&

    IZWXa^^ai[`YUa`U^ge[a`eX^aiXda_S`SUUWbfS`UWfZSffZW8ahW`S`f$faS` WjfW`f$ T^ T[`V[`Y a` fZW >&B&;&&

    ;[def^k$ fZW >&B&;& i[^^ ZShW fa aTeWdhW fZW 8ahW`S`f WhW` [X[f Sbb^[Wea`^kfaa`WbSdfaX[feSUf[h[fk& IZW>&B&;&bdaYdS__We_gefTWUa`e[efW`fi[fZfZW8ahW`S`fiZSfWhWdfZWdy^W aXUa`V[f[a`S^[fk[`fZWY^aTS^_a`W%fSdkekefW_&6egT\WUfaX[`fWd`Sf[a`S^^Si[ebdWhW`fWVXda_dW^k[`Ya`fZWea%US^^WV TW`WX[fe aX[fe Y^aTS^ SUf[h[fk fa \gef[Xk UWdfS[` [`Xd[`YW_W`fe aXfZW ^Si& DSP TWWPRLWT_d ]PXLTY^$

    HWUa`V^k$ fZW >&B&;& ZSe T_^ ZbY ]P^[ZY^TMTWT_d TY NL]]dTYR Z`_ NP]_LTYO`_TP^ `YOP] _SP 3ZaPYLY_$ IZW 8ahW`S`f _gef TW aTeWdhWV WhW` [X fZWVWXW`VWdeaXfZW>&B&;& ^[]Wfaba[`fagf$ fZWbae[f[a`aXfZWHfSfWeUa`UWd%`WViag^VTWiadeWaXXi[fZagffZW;g`Ve[`fWdhW`f[a`&6VaUfad[edWcg[%dWV fa SUf bdaXWee[a`S^^ki[fZZ[e bSf[W`fe& IZWdWXadW [f US``af TW SdYgWV[ Z[e VWXW`UW fZSf fZWbSf[W`fiag^VZShW V[WVi[fZagfZ[e [`fWdhW`f[a`&

    IZ[dV^k$ WhW`[X[f [efZWHfSfWUa`UWd`WViZ[UZXad_S^^kSVabfefZWbda%YdS__W$ a`W US``afVW`k fZW [_badfS`fdy^W aXfZW>&B&;& [` fZWO]LQ_TYRS`V fZW YPRZ_TL_TZY aX fZSf bdaYdS__W& 6f fZSf efSYW$ [f US` S`V [`VWWV_gef USddk agf [fe Vgf[We g`VWd fZW8ahW`S`f&

    ;[`S^^k$ fZW >&8&:&H&8&G& [e T[`V[`Y$ [ddWebWUf[hW aX [fe Ua`fW`f& Ha_W`ad_e_Sk SbbWSd STegdVadWUa`a_[US^^kg`dWSea`ST^W Xda_ fZW >&B&;&eba[`f aXh[Wi& NWf fZW[d dS[ea` VufdW [e fa Ua`fWef S UWdfS[` WUa`a_[U^aY[U&

    7Wka`V fZW SXadW_W`f[a`WV Ys`sdS^ dW^gUfS`UW S`V fZW eUWbf[U[e_faiSdVeegUZ[`fWd`Sf[a`S^[`efdg_W`feSefZW>&8&:&H&8&G&$ a`W_Sk`af[UW`WhWdfZW^Wee Xda_ fZWbSdf aXfZW >&B&;&$ S UZS`YW [`fZW_W`fS^[f[We&

    >`VWWV$ e[`UW )10/$ S` sha^gf[a` [` fZW >&B&;& SbbdaSUZ eWW_e fa ZShWaUUgddWV$TkiZ[UZ[f[eTWY[``[`Yfa USddkagf[fedWeba`e[T[^[f[Weg`VWdfZW8ahW`S`f fa fS]W fZW :&H&8&G& [`fa SUUag`f iZW` VdSXf[`Y [fe bda%YdS__We&

  • )+, B>8=6:A AJ86H

    IZW iSk fZW ;g`V ZSe UZaeW` fa Va fZ[e ZSe TWW` Ud[f[U[lWV& Ha_WSgfZade iag^V ^[]W fZaeW d[YZfe `af fa TW fdWSfWV Se ea_WfZ[`Y SUUWeeadkTgffaTW[`fWYdSfWV$ SeSUa`e[efW`fbSdf$ [`fZW;g`VbdaYdS__We&DfZWdeZShW bdabaeWV S _adW SUf[hW dy^W aX fZW >&B&;& [` fZW bda_af[a` aX fZW:&H&8&G&

    D`WUS`ZabWXadegUZVWhW^ab_W`feTgffZ[e[eS`afZWdba[`f& DgdbWde%bWUf[hWiSe S ^sYS^a`W 2iWZShW SeeWeeWV fZW >&B&;& ba^[Uk[`dW^Sf[a`fafZW TSe[U dWcg[dW_W`fe aX fZW 8ahW`S`f bd[ad[fk$ bdabadf[a`S^[fk S`V_[`[_g_$ ZSh[`Y fS]W` [`fa SUUag`f fZSf [f [e `afdWeba`e[T^W Xad S[^ fZWSgefWd[fk_WSegdWeS`VfZSf[f_gefbSkVgWdWYSdVfafZW8ahW`S`fiZ[UZ[e ZaiWhWd`af ^WYS^^kT[`V[`Y fa [f&

    D`fZaeWTSeWe$ [XfZW >&B&;& US`TW Ud[f[U[lWV$ [fi[^^ a`^kTW [` UWdfS[`ebsU[X[sU[dUg_efS`UWe&LWVa`afTW^[WhWfZSffZW8ahW`S`fdWcg[dWeSXa`%VS_W`fS^_aV[X[USf[a` aX[feba^[Uk&

    H:A:8 I:9 7 >7 A >D < 7 6 E= N

    6&DPc_MZZV^

    7 ^S d V a ` W &B&;&$>&B&;&$LSeZ[`Yfa`9&8&$ )10.$ "DUUSe[a`S^ESbWde`~,.#&

    < a ^V ?&$&B&;&$LSeZ[`Yfa 9&8&$ )100$"DUUSe[a`S^ESbWde`~-0#&

    8`XLYBTRS_ TY9Y_P]YL_TZYLW

  • ; J C 9 H 8DC9>I>DC6A>IN 6C9 >CI:GC6I>DC6A 8DK:C6CI )+-

    B :GDC I = &$ 8`XLY]TRS_ LYO8`XLYT_L]TLY>Z]X^L 3 ^_ZXL]d: < = 67 I E&$ DSP9Y_P]YL_TZYLWI: 9 C 6I >DC H 8DBB >II:: DC : 8DCDB >8 $ HD8 >6A 6C 9 8J AIJ G6 A G >< = IH $

    G :EDGIH D; I= : H:HH >D C H $ E$>$ 4ZN$": '8 &)*')10. fa )11)&

    7&1]_TNWP^

    6 AHID C E&$IZWJ`[fWVCSf[a`eHbWU[S^[lWV6YW`U[WeS`VfZW>_b^W_W`fSf[a aXfZW>`fWd`Sf[a`S^8ahW`S`fa`:Ua`a_[U$HaU[S^S`V8g^fgdS^G[YZfe$3ZW`X#MTL:Z`]YLWZQD]LY^YL_TZYLWC C `fWd`Sf[a`S^8ahW`S`fa`:Ua`a_[U$ HaU[S^S`V8g^fgdS^G[YZfe$8`XLYBTRS_A`L]_P]Wd"ha^& 1$ )10/&

    86 7 7 : 6 J 9&$ 8Zda [cgWeVW9da[f>`fWd`Sf[a`S^:Ua`a_[cgW$1YY`LT]P6]LY#hLT OP4]ZT_9Y_P]YL_TZYLW$ ha^& +) fa +.$ )10- fa )11(&

    [email protected] A >C B& 6C 9 9 6K >9 HD C 9 &$ IZW>&B&;& S`V:Ua`a_[U$ eaU[S^ S`V8g^fgdS^G[YZfe 2 68SeWHfgVkaX6dYW`f[`S$8`XLYBTRS_A`L]_P]Wd"ha^& 0$ )10.&

    9 6 K >9 :&$ AW9da[f p^S HS fs Ua__W9da[fVW ^SEWdea``W=g_S[`W$BPa PA iMiNZT^PO 4]ZT_9Y_P]YL_TZYLW" )10-&

    9 ?D J < = A6 > ! 6&$ AS 8d[eW VW ^ :`VWffW_W`f VWe ESke W Ka[W VW 9shW^abbW%_W`f$BPa`P1WRi]TPYYPOP BPWL_TZY 9Y_P]YL_TZYLWP " ha^& )*$ )100&

    : >9 : 6&$ GWS^[lSf[a`aXHaU[S^ S`V:Ua`a_[UG[YZfe S`VfZWB[ [_g_IZdWe%Za^V6bbdaSUZ$8`XLYBTRS_C : 6&$9WffW:jfsd[WgdWWf9da[feVWA=a__WVS`e^WeESkeVgI[WdeBa`VW$ FgW^cgWeGsX^Wj[a`e$1Q]TNLY:Z`]YLWZQ9Y_P]YL_TZYLWLYO3ZX[L]L#_TaPA A =&$ IZW >&B&;& 6gefWd[fk S`VHfSfW aXASf[`6_Wd[US$DST]O GZ]WOA`L]_P]Wd" ha^& 0$ )10.&