(6)library.jsce.or.jp/jsce/open/00565/2010/10-0031.pdf«s Æl Ùøœ‹fi‚š i$å /tm0.1(1/10)...
TRANSCRIPT
� 10�� ������ ������������( 2010� 12�) ����
��������� �����
Proposal for Response Spectrum based on Identical Impulses
!"#*$%&'(** Shigefumi Takeda, Yoshiyuki Kasai
*)*+,-�-�.$+�/0,-�.123371-0816456)*789:; 460<=� 1>
**+?$)*+,-�-�.$+�/0,@A2B8>
Key Words: Momentum, Impact impulse, Impact response spectrum, Impact response displacement
���������� ����������������
��� �������
� C�$����DEF��GHIJ� K�LM��
�N�O$��DPQ$RST�UVW�XY�
Z[\]O$]U�^_`aDbc�de�Pfgh
f���F 1), 2)ijekl�Km nodp
� q�/0 rst$uv wxyldOwz{|�
}~ I\IJ���Y�mv(m�IJ����$v�
O��)������� ���t�d\��$}
~ I\IJ���Y�mvi�n�Cs�G���\(�
�$I�(0.8�1.4)mv)i��yl$���D�sIJ��
�Y� mv�� }~ I�`a����\i��y
ldp
� �G¡��GH]bc¢�F�£¤�k$
}~�� ¥¦�G§�¨©ª�'«��¬®
����¯¢�°±���\�²�\�t$¥¦³
´�je�¯¢\�t}~�µ¶Q �dB·}~
¥¦Q¸¹º»�±¼�t½¾�$ l�¿st
¥¦³´�����¯¢�°±��¬�G��p
�� �����������������
��� ����������������� �
� ½À1 B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»ÁÂ�Ã[½�
��pÄÅ$ÆOÇ(���)�ÈÉ�$Ê-]} Rm$
Ë^Ìͳ´Îel$Ë^ÏÐÑÒ T �b���pÓÔÕ
^HÊ-]}Ö$Ê-]}�×Ø�dÄijÙ��Úf
ÛÜÝÞ\��pß ÆOÇ Á¿yà�}~ I
�·�\�$áLâãWäå�ßæ\³çtáL�
ÆOÇ Á¿yà$ �\§�Ê-¥¦³´Îm�c
���p}~ I�·�\�d�GáLâãWäåi
è«nlÓ$Ê-áL FpHéy«n�pß }
~ I���³ç$Bê áLâãWäå�ßæ\³çt
áL�ÆOÇ Á¿yà$ �\§�Ê-¥¦³
´Îm�c���pQ¸¹º»Á r©�c�HËë
^¥¦Z�ìíîh� SNAP3)�ï¿�$c�ð��ñ�
ò�«ÈóGWæðæ�c��ôodpõö�÷ø��
ùúHËë^ÓÔn�Gûü�¯¢i��i$��GH
ýÒþ^��Þõö�ÈÉ�dp��KmnQ��ì�
����ôot½�ÁÂ��i$}~ I�Ê-]}
Rm\Ë^ÏÐÑÒ T�~ RmTG����\ K���
¾�$��}~h¶�\��� I/(RmT) K� ��
�p}~ I\áLâãWäåHIJ� ���h
¶�$Ê-]} Rm\Ë^ÏÐÑÒ THÆOÇ ���h¶�G��p��G$}~ IHÊ-
áL Fp$áLâãWäå\áLÙ���� K� I=�Fp
å\���\iG§$½À2 ��Km áL�Ùi�
����ùú�=2/�$����ùú�=1/2$�Ù��ù
ú�=1\n�p
F(t)
K C
Fp1
Fp2
Fp3
å1 å2 å3
Rm
KÎel Îm
½À1� B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»ÁÂ�Ã[½
�=Îm/ÎelM
�=2/� �=1/2 �=1 Fp
Fp
Fp
å å å
���� ��� ��
½À2� áL�Ù\áLÙ����
�=2/� �=1/2 �=1
(6)
Äd$}~h¶� I/(RmT)H
\�Z�t���\iG§$Ê-áL Fp\Ê-]}
Rm��Fp/Rm$áLâãWäå\Ë^ÏÐÑÒT��å/T\áLÙ�����~GÂ��ots��\i���p
�
� � ��������������!"�
� B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»(Ö�½À9 � )�!"
HÆOÇ�ë^#�(�=Îm/Îel$Îm�Ê-¥¦³´$
Îel�Ë^Ìͳ´)$$"HáLâãWäå\Ë^ÏÐ
ÑÒ T ��å/T \�t$}~h¶� I/(RmT) K� ��ts�i$����¿stÃ[��p
� ���(�À1$½À3� )GH}~h¶� I/(RmT)
=1\n� 3%¶Q�÷ç$%¶Q&H I\RmTi' -
§sùú$%¶Q(H I\RmTi' )*��ùú$%
¶Q+H I\RmTi' éysùúG��p
� áL�Ù�����\�,õö�ùú�{|�½À4
��p½À4(a)H!"iÊ-¥¦³´Îm (mm)�-Ù"$
$"HáLâãWäå(s)�.�"G��p/�%¶Q¬
áLâãWäåi0s12GHÊ-¥¦³´Îmi��
·�� 34�ts��\i���p�lH 5?6i
78©d}~9:�;Í 4), 5)G$ K�9:HÊ-
áL(<¶¹�)Fp Kot=Ä��GHn«$
}~ I Kot=Ä�\sm¬�G��p�çt>çÓ$
?»@A¶»�?»@¹hBGCD�dE�Ê-á
LH 30kN ¬F��\>�l�i$G� � 30kN�
}�?»@¹hB Á¿yàlÓHI Jl�i$
� Á¿yàlÓ³Ù¬Kn«$Jl��\¬nsi$
Jl�\�lÓ}~ Ii-§s�\ Kot1L�
\smMNG��páLâãWäåiè«n� OlÊ
-¥¦³´ÎmHPQ õK�tr�$áLâãWä\
ÆOÇ�RSÑÒ\�'T 6), 7) K�UVMNH�Å
� 1L���G��pW áLâãWäåiè«n�
\$Ê-¥¦³´ÎmHXetéyn�\n�$ �Ö 0N\34�ts«�\i���p
� ½À4(b)H!"�ë^#��-Ù"$$"�½À4(a)
\BLáLâãWäå(s)�.�"G��d½G��pá
LâãWäåi0s12GH 3 %¶Q\¬ë^#�=20
8C�·�� 34�tr�$W ½À4(c)G$"�á
LâãWäå\Ë^ÏÐÑÒT��å/TG��¾��\
3%¶QH 1¡�Y- 34�ts�pOÄ�$½À4(c)
�Km ë^#��!"$å/T�$"\�$}~h
¶� I/(RmT) Kot ����\G$}~ I$Æ
OÇ�Ê-]} Rm$Ë^ÏÐÑÒ T iüæ Znot
st¬}~h¶� I/(RmT)iB·��G�lÓQ¸
¹º»HBL 1¡�Y-G�yl$üæ�O[\D
$Y�$�G�ÄG�]s^_ �dot·`�
���� ÐaG��põö�÷ø�dùú¬Bê 3
%¶Qi 1¡�Y-(½À5(c))G�yl�p
� Äd$%¶Q( ��tË^¥¦\Ëë^¥¦��b
�½À6 $õö�Ðc��b�½À7 ��p½À6�
k���Km $Ë^ÓÔ�¿sdùú �dtËë^
ÓÔ�¿sdùú�Ê-¥¦³´ÎmHef��\ni
k-§«nots��\$áLâãWäåg0.1s �^_
GH$Ëë^ÓÔ �dtË^ÓÔ�ùú�Ê-¥¦³
´Îm�õK�úsiéys�\i���p]bc
GH��*��ë^³Ù�hH��\÷çkl��G$
Ëë^ÓÔ�¿sd¥¦Q¸¹º»�iM^ijs
�\i���p½À7 �ÆOÇ�õö�kl Ost
H$ë^#�i·�\n�å/Tm0.1(1/10)�^_GHõ
ö�� h=0.03 �÷ø���\ K�,õö�ùú �
dt 2n*��ë^#��op\nots�pW å/T
i-§s^_GHõö K�ë^#��qHéy«no
ts�pRC����r���\õö�� h=0.03*��
÷ø���\isen�G$¥¦Q¸¹º»�ÁÂ
edotHõö�� h=0.03�÷ø���\\��p
� ß áL�Ù�tu K�¥¦�us���p
áL�Ù�����$���$�Ù�\�$,õöG
}~h¶� I/(RmT)=1�ùú�{|�½À8 ��p
å/Tm0.1(1/10)�^_GH$áL�Ù ��n«ë
^#�H��·�� 34�ts��\i���på/T
g0.1(1/10) n�\¥¦� usi1L$���g��
��g�Ù��v ë^#�iéy«nots�p��
�\����GHCs����ts�i$���i��
��K�Ê- 1.5 w*�-§n��\�$���\�Ù
���bGH���i�Ù�K�Ê- 3.2 w*�-§n
��\�p
� x8K�B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»�áL�Ù
\�t����$���$�Ù�� 3üy�ùú�¿z
��pOwz{| KotH$ �sÅl ¬�y�
T
τ
R
Fα
T)(R
I
m
p
m
=
Rm�
Rm�
Rm�
Îel�
Îel� Îel�
&
(
+
½À3� ��� 3%¶Q�ûÓÔÕ^
�À1� ��� 3%¶Q�ûh¶�
(kN{s) (kN{s)
Îm (mm) � �
å(s) å(s) å/T(a) (b) (c)
½À4� I/(RmT)=1$����$,õö�ÁÂ�
&�I-$RmT-
(�I)$RmT)
+�Ié$RmTé
&
(
+
&
(
+
&,(,+
Îm (mm) � �
å(s) å(s) å/T(a) (b) (c)
½À5� I/(RmT)=1$����$õö(h=0.03)�ÁÂ�
&�I-$RmT-
(�I)$RmT)
+�Ié$RmTé
&
(
+
&
(
+ &,(,+
�
å/T
�
å/T
Îm (mm)
å(s)
½À6� Ë^\Ëë^��b ½À7� õöÐc��b ½À8� áL�Ù��b
Ë^
Ëë^
,õö
õö$h=0.03
%¶Q($,õö$Ëë^%¶Q($,õö$���� %¶Q($Ëë^$����
����
���
�Ù�
«sáL�Ù�ùú¬����i$å/Tm0.1(1/10)
�^_GH$áL�Ù� H��n«¥¦³´
i��yl$å/Tg0.1(1/10)�^_GH���� �dt
����ùú�¥¦³´i-§s�\�÷ø�t�
���ÈÉ�lÓ-§²�¥¦³´i��yl�p
� ß }~h¶� I/(RmT)���³¾yàdùú�
B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»�½À9 ��psÅl¬
õö�� h=0.03�÷ø�ts�p½À9(a)i����$
½À9(b)i���$½À9(c)i�Ù��Q¸¹º»G��p
/�áL�Ù�ùú¬}~h¶� I/(RmT)i-§«
nlÓ$ë^#�HU-�ts«på/Tm0.1(1/10)�^
_GH$ë^#�H��·�� 34�ts��\i�
��på/TiU|�ts«\$ë^#�HPQ õK�
ts§$}~h¶� I/(RmT)��i-§s}/õK�
�úsi~�G��på/Tg10�^_GH$ë^#�H
Xetéyn�\n�$ �Ö 0 34�ts«p
� nr$½À9(a) H 3 �G���¿��{|iìí�
ºylts�p
ë^#�HË^Ìͳ´Îel .��Ê-¥¦³´Îm
���=Îm/ÎelG��i$B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»
�¿sd�� rst��³´Îr���dsùú H$
�çÓ�� 8)��÷ �lÓ��³´Îr\Ê-¥¦³´
ÎmH�ÔÎr/Îm= 0.6�0.7*�\notr�Ê-¥¦³
´Îm�k��³´Îr�`a���\¬��_GHns
i$K��òn��iiMG��$�Ö���\�tX
�kl�p
Äd$B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»HÊ-]} F�
dÖ$Ê-]}�×Ø�dÄijÙ��ÚfÛÜÝÞ�
ÓÔÕ^�r��tr�$Y�9:�Kmn�^���
�� .�tH�ú��i$àó�9:$��$��
�î9:T��^�n�� .�t��¿^ OstH
�Ö���\�tX�kl�p��de$B·}~
¥¦Q¸¹º»�ï¿�E H$Y�9:iàó�9:$
��$���î9:K�qô���\�)°\�$�
çÓ$þIJ� .����D���� OstH��9) $�IJ� .�����î9: OstH��10), 11) �dklts��G$�lk��÷ ���¹�
��\i�Äl�p¬�àó�9:$��$���î
9:iqô��Kmnùú H lk�`ai�q��
\÷ç�p
#�� $%&�
� B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»�¿sd�¿�\�t
O[\�Zn� 3%¶Q���p�À2 �¿��û
h¶�\{|���$Äd$wz{|\�òc�{|
�Î'm\�t��pxp$û�¿� OstÃ[��p
$%&'�� ()*+�,-�.�/0�
� RC �N�L ¡pO\�$IJ�DÆOÇT�
[\H�� 12) ¢£ylts�w¤¥RC��L ¡p
Owz �¦stb���pIJ�HL G$��
m=2t$jy h=5m$10m�k§¨¡pOyà$O�
�Hûæv5=9.9m/s$v10=14.0m/s G��pÆOÇH RC
�G$èy 9m(©¤äª� 8m)$�V 1m$�às 0.85m
G��p}~ IHwz{|�� b��$å/THþ
IJ��«¬O�ùú$áLâãWäåH� ms *�
(wz{|�áLâãWäH 3�4ms*�)G$ÆOÇ�
Ë^ÏÐÑÒTK�ñ� 0spOÄ�}~9:�;Í
���Gå/Tm0.1(1/10)�12G=��lÓå/T K
kÅÊ-¥¦³´ÎmH��·���\�de$¡��
GHå/T=0.01(1/100)\�dpQ¸¹º»½HáL�Ù�
����$õö�� h=0.03 �÷ø�dQ¸¹º»(½À
9(a))�¿s�p½À9(a) ¡pjy 5m�{|5m�®
G$¡pjy 10m�{|10m�¯Gìí�º��p
� � �
å/T å/T å/T
I/(RmT)=2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
(a)���� (b)��� (c)��
I/(RmT)=2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
I/(RmT)=2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
½À9� B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»(h=0.03)
°G12.5m
°G10m
5m
10m
°S10m
°S12.5m
$%&1�� 2�3456789-�.�/0�
� ±²��b³�d RCQhBN�L ¡pO\�$
IJ�DÆOÇT�[\H�� 13) �yld´µ��
sH¶·�b³�d-Þ RCQhB�L ¡pOwz
�¦stb���pIJ�HL G$��m=5t$jy
h=10m$12.5m �k§¨¡pOyà�pÆOÇH$
è¸ 5m$0¸ 4m$¹º 0.4m�RCQhBG$©Ø[\
H»¸©ØG©¤äª� 4m�·¯¼QhBG��pÆ
OÇH´µb³�ùú\¶·b³�ùúGBL\�$
}~ IHwz{|�� b���páLâãWäå
H´µb³�ùú�å=70ms$¶·b³�ùú�å
=80ms\�$å/THûæ0.97$1.11\n�pQ¸¹º»
½HáL�Ù�����$õö�� h=0.03�÷ø�dQ
¸¹º»(½À9(a))�¿s$´µb³�ùú�¡pjy
10m �{|°G10m �½G$¡pjy 12.5m �{|°
G12.5m �¾Gìí�º�$¶·b³�ùú�¡pjy
10m �{|°S10m �¿G$¡pjy 12.5m �{|°
S12.5m�ÀGìí�º��p
$%&:�� ;)*+��.�/0�
� ���N�Á²O\�$IJ�DÆOÇT�[
\H�� 14), 15) tô�ldjÃE�N�Á²OZ
� �¦st=���pIJ�H F-4@Ä�º�ÅƲ
G$Çè L=17.7m$��m=19tG$O�� v50=50m/s$
v100=100m/s$v150=150m/sGO��ùú�÷ç�pÆ
OÇH=8 20 È� RC E�G$jy 81.6m$ÉL�H
218MN(É�� 22,245t)G��p1ßʶgi©Ë�n¥
¦\Ìryl� 19ÈO�.N\�$áL�Á¿�
§o�© 1ßʶgGÇÇ¥¦��¬�\��p�I
J�O K�}~ IH$IJ���Y� mv\T
�s(I=mv)\�tb��$áLâãWäåHÁ²�è
y�O��G��dWä }ÍT�s(å=L/v)\�t
ûæb���pÁ²�Kmn�IJ�O�ùú 14), 15)$
áL�ÙH��Ù�Î CÏ���\iG§�de$Q
¸¹º»½HáL�Ù����$õö�� h=0.03�÷ø
�dQ¸¹º»(½À9(b))�¿s�p�¿�ÐH}~h
¶� I/(RmT)��iéysde$ìí�ºHÑÒ��p
� nr$Q¸¹º»½�k{|�je�EH$ñ� Ó
-�d½�¿stë^#��jets�p
� x8��¿��k$B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º» K
ot���d{|HÔÕ�OwzD�òc�{|\'
«·Ö�ts��\i���pB·}~¥¦Q¸¹
º» Kot���N�ûü�IJ�O�¥¦³
´�·`��O® `a���\iG§$]bc
rst×�O¬�\÷ç�p
<=>?��
� q�/0 rstIJ���Y� mv\}~ I�
�Ø Ù²�tÔÕ�Owz{|����t�d\�
�$�Y��³¾i}~ T�s\��Y}���¡¢
Ú�Â�iÛÜyld�G$¡��GH$B·}~
¥¦Q¸¹º»�±¼�t½¾�$ l�¿st¥
¦³´�����¯¢�°±�dp �Â|�M¤Hß
���G��p
1) ¥¦³´�je�¯¢\�táL�<¶¹
� Ýçt}~�µ¶Q �dB·}~¥
¦Q¸¹º»�±¼�dp��Q¸¹º»�!"H
ÆOÇ(���)�ë^#�$$"HáL�âã
Wäå\ÆOÇ�Ë^ÏÐÑÒT��å/T\�$
}~ IH$ÆOÇ�Ê-]} Rm\Ë^ÏÐÑÒ
T�~RmTG��d}~h¶� I/(RmT)\�t�
�¾�dp �{|$}~ I$ÆOÇ�Ê-]
}Rm$Ë^ÏÐÑÒTiüæ Znotst¬}~
h¶� I/(RmT)iB·��G�lÓQ¸¹º»H
BL 1 ¡�Y-\n�$üæ�O[\�·`�
�¿� [\I
(kN{s) Rm
(kN)
T
(s) I/ RmT å/T � Îm
(mm)Î'm
(mm)
5m h=5m 22.2 551 0.11 0.37 0.01 3.0 47.6 45.5
10m h=10m 33.4 551 0.11 0.55 0.01 5.7 90.5 87.9
°G10m´µ
h=10m73.5 1,071 0.072 0.95 0.97 7.4 73.9 64.00
°G12.5m´µ
h=12.5m79.8 1,071 0.072 1.03 0.97 8.6 85.9 85.95
°S10m¶·
h=10m67.8 1,071 0.072 0.88 1.11 5.0 50.0 40.20
°
°S12.5m¶·
h=12.5m79.8 1,071 0.072 1.03 1.11 7.1 70.9 68.45
v=50m/s 950 30,000 2.96 0.011 0.12 0.06 35.3 28
v=100m/s 1,900 30,000 2.96 0.021 0.06 0.125 73.5 64 Ð
v=150m/s 2,850 30,000 2.96 0.032 0.04 0.19 111.7 110
�À2� �¿��ûh¶�\{|
����\i�_\nodp
2) °±�dB·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»�^�\�t$
áL�âãWäå\ÆOÇ�Ë^ÏÐÑÒ T
��å/T iå/Tm0.1(1/10)�^_(s�Þ�}~9:
�;Í)GH$ë^#�H·���ß�$å/Tg0.1(1/10)
�^_GHå/T ��iU|�ts«\$ë^#�H
PQ õK�ts«p�çÓ$¶·D´µ�b³�
dùúD�IJ��O�ùú H$áL�â
ãWäåiè«n��G$ë^#�Hå/Tm0.1(1/10)
�^_ �dt�n�éyn�\n�pW å/Tg10
�^_GH$ë^#�HXetéyn�\n�$
�Ö 0 34�ts«p
3) °±�dB·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»\�tH$Æ
OÇ�õö�� 3%$ÓÔÕ^HÚfÛÜÝÞ\�$
áL�Ù\�t����$���$�Ù�� 3
üy�ùú�¿z�dpOwz{| KotH$
�sÅl ¬�y� «sáL�Ù�ùú¬
����i$å/Tm0.1(1/10)�^_GHáL�Ù
�Ù� H��n«¥¦³´i��yl$å/T
g0.1(1/10)�^_GHáL�Ù�kl�à©$�
��� �dt����ùú�¥¦³´i-§
s�\\n�páL�Ù�Wðá�Ù��b�
� «sùú H$����ùú�ÈÉ�lÓ-§
²�¥¦³´���G§�pÄd$¶·D´µ
�Kmn±²�ib³yl�ùú$FEMDDEM�
Z�GH±²���^�b�� «si$¡¢G
H$ÔÕ�L ¡pOwz�{|��÷ �t
áL�âãWäå�V�Øod�\�tb��l
Ó$ûáLâãWäå .¥�d¥¦³´���
G§��G$]bc�de�`a�ôsD�sp
4) �¿� ��dKm $B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º
» Kot���d{|HÔÕ�OwzD�òc
�{|\'«·Ö���\i��odp
� x8�Â|�Éâ� Ä\e�\$B·}~¥¦
Q¸¹º» Kot���N�ûü�IJ�O�
¥¦³´�·`��O® `a���\iG§$]
bc rst×�O¬�\÷ç�p
� nr$��B·}~¥¦Q¸¹º»H$Y�9:
�.N\�ts�i$àó�9:$��$���î9
:iqô��Kmnùú H lk�`ai�q��\
÷ç�pÄd$Y�����ã��¹hf�ÛÝ�·O
\�të^#�i÷çkl�i$wz K���¬iM
G������\�tX�kl�p
@ABC�
1) ä¡Rå$æ]bcPfghf�¦«� ¼©
tç$2009 ��è¡EF��-�(éê)��ëì(¥
¿}�)í»îïQð��ñ�òóæOôUVn
/��nõ} K���Æö�oõ¾ Ost
÷ç�÷$pp.1-10$2009� 8�.
2) ø!ùú$æáL .�������ß�û�÷$
2009 ��è¡EF��-�(éê)��ëì(¥¿}
�)í»îïQð��ñ�òóæOôUVn/�
�nõ} K���Æö�oõ¾ Ost÷ç
�÷$pp.55-61$2009� 8�.
3) SNAP(üzÙ��Ç@ý¶��Ëë^Z�ìíîh
�)$þ������Q��.
4) 5�$æ}~9:�;ÍÀU� K�����9:
���÷�Àç$EF�����$� 21 $
pp.246-251$1941� 4�.
5) 5�$æ����Y�Z�À]bc�Û¶� 4
Àç$� þ���$1966�.
6) %&'($æáL�r��dwz÷$��¹Û¶
º+�$� 39�$9$pp.74-77$2001� 9�.
7) ������+����wzôZ�¢���¾
���/0é���$æwzôZ����\¥
¿ç$� 4� ]bc ������� 4.1 1�
¤��� r©�¥¦�I`a¢(%&'(
���e)$pp. 349-363$2004� 3�.
8) ����$���»$$!�$æ���áL�à
©� !��¹Û¶ºH��9:^�ç$"#Â"$
%/0&òó$No.1152$pp.1-57$"#Â"$%/0
&$2007� 6�.
9) �'(($æþI)Ç�j�O�à©���¹Û¶
º¹������V1ðÜ��\]*C �
��/0ç$+,-�-?6��$2010� 3�.
10) P. Barr, "Guidelines for the Design and Assessment of
Concrete Structures subjected to Impact", 1990 Edition,
May 1990.
11) .�($%&'($/!0»$æRCN��IJ��
O K���1���� ��� 3O�ÔÕwz
N� UKAEA Pfg�`a¢��¿^��ç$� 9
������� ������������$
pp.187-192$2008� 12�.
12) ������+��������^_ 2Þ]
bc ���/0é���$æ^_bc��3 �¦
«����]bc¢ç$��+��Û¶�$No.52$
2007� 10�.
13) 456$�789$&�[$:;�$<*=>$æ¶
·��sH´µ�b³�d-Þ RCQhB ���
£áwzç$? 21������ê@A©ë�
�BC�$� 66$A-17$4¸¶�$2010� 2�.
14) %&'($DEF$GHj8$æ !��¹Û¶ºj
ÃE�N�áL .��¥¦Õ^ÀÁ²O
K�¥¦\=¥¦\��bÀç$è¡EF��$
%BC�$�22$pp.221-216$2005� 12�.
15) GHj8$%&'($DEF$æ !��¹Û¶ºj
ÃE�N�áL .��¥¦Õ^À � 2� )
¤¥�Á²O K�¥¦Õ^Àç$è¡EF��
$%BC�$�24$pp.143-148$2006� 12�.