6 +p jl *4 n m€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($&...

11
6+PJL *4NM,.5 JOIK " 6)$&2!T\U] DHGEF[XVW '*($& $& ;9:A::@718 '*($& '?9-R\YSQZ :=B99^:>B:9 C0%#<3/ !! ;3CQ7,K)MK 4 DR* S!HCQKGLIAa )K 1S7OF=AH=> !Ka7 ,S?C Ga.CN@ I/SCQ:DRS2BFa7 ,K&K%^.J0CQ "-SCQ:<_+(#$[]WUVY'X\TZ?P` ;7,K3JBE)6J5CQ#$[]WUVY< 9 / #$! 8

Upload: others

Post on 05-Mar-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

6����+P� JL�*4�N��M�,.5

JO I K

"� ��� 6��)$&2!T\U] DHGEF[XVW ��

�'�*�($&� ��$&�

;9:A ::�@�718 �'�*�($&� �'?9� -�R\YSQZ:=B99^:>B:9 C�0%#<3/�

����������!� �����!���������� �� ������

;3�CQ7 ���,K�)MK4�DR*�S! HCQKGLIAa�)K1S��7OF=AH=>! K�a7 ���,S�?C�Ga�.CN@�I/�S��CQ:DRS2BFa7 ���,K���&K%�^�.J0CQ"-S��CQ:<_+�(�#$[]WUVY'�X\TZ?P`

;7 ���,K3�J�BE�)6�J5CQ#$[]WUVY<

9 /���� #$!

8

Page 2: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

3�OLIJ1� O;@\alfjmdP��^�:\L89ALQ1alfjmd^�IJ8<O�Y?� C\<^�:\ALKQ7[UD_2E]Q1alfjmdL89blgk��bcei^�9L1MPY9N�B85�:�65�S�6=K>\P<^�:\ALKN@]RNZN8L�8UC2EBJ1EPY9N�B85�:�65�S�6P!�^�\ALEPXP=1�FH"$P5�:\LQ�<65�TLQ�<6L89�8O�C\�:^�WJ8?Y9NXPKN@]RNZN81G<Z1�FHQalfjmd^�&OC\�#=7\L�IJ8UC24 n� ('+/.-('3��Oh`al^�H%V�O4 0)+o

,*����OX

,

C?ovqswp_aZW^0�YPA0�ZFGe^_@ !@)SUJ)SU^OSFMZmOfPLPjSd]iTNkje^YPAGcLH`��J_I[icPJ@31VSF�mPk`�#��eOcPAYPIh@ovqswpm�+]�$PjMZm*HjZK@��]ovqswpmlQSh-2&]\jI[GIJ�5]\jZFG^_@�5^.�^��R^e^J31VXFj�,�JEicPA?x�%y?

ovqswp_@RkmC�^Sd]DC[GGID]4OX@�cY)SUJ(VXFj[n\0�gie"/�J6Fe^YPATIhMR@C�^Sd]DC[GGID^��@Rke��'\urtY^��m� ]O�RGZPj��\O]_@)SU_@ovqswp^�+b^�$^�,�]WFX�BPjMZ_YK\FZFGMZ]\icPADx��87>>:;9<y

=

Page 3: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

C A BD

C ,D

�� �������

�������������

l�51��a\Ydb`b^CeZ`\bZ\e�x;*t,�l�l*{�vl�wos r�z���mos��56��x�y��(o~ktp�?�OdYbe]cd[ \f YaED HFFF�

l%4���w:/1������"7��PVPXvu��.w�8�(���x"7!3}�B<$�TSVNCPTV?��R[W\Z_w��orrj�

lh@#-v��t����02�Q\e`^bCU\e\YdZ_LCOdcgbDCGKKHMCPcaa`beDCGKKH�w~�)=-02t�>-02x���ih�����t�<�5& x&+w~��5x��-�*�-9�i�'�tp�

nxIF�Axh�yxq|x�����&+i02

J

Page 4: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

l8��V-_e�Yim|nz{yW0�8<;75<7����'.2f��cwto�rj�"(Zvpl}U�Z�/U aec,�j�Yi

l9��V�cm|nz{y0�W��8<<759777����`�"(Z�_VgXW��

j0��vpl}�"�UTGDbktx~��

l:��V�cm|nz{y0�j��_[iqsuyW^\h��� aec�dj�[�]�c�dj�Yi

�)*�1�(~�"(c�dj#&�b�Yivpl} ��+�"�?GQJHM5>CQGF3@LOKGLGMRCRJNM3BGQGCPEI=3AGMSGK GR3CK6439788�

�'!�c��$%

Jasper Project

WISE Project

��M�6�a89=;:<Z[WTUY%�K( a�@�H`&$M�J 7Q1�CI2BQ�A�EI-�FP

��^�+$�`47_MXVS\�

l �@ 7?M1�NQ�+,L"NP

l GBDRM2A�@>P

l ��Q/O�E�F�0@>P

l 2#Q�3FP�J)5]�.Q+�

l +�EG)5*Q$'FP!�@>P

�U���:�D,

_�����wa�0r��e)n�n^���*�m�n|w.?ETx�`sabQ\v��Bx����v�d�q����v+~yon$��(kue~�_Pe�w��9��oq�hvLgd`sab*�-8�Gc�^�2uN8�Gc�YvODkqCc��k������r<Mk��;Kas#on-8rNf=m^

�#��-&��

&/���D,�,�w>R�'IF!

• V�}5utvX��1"�'I

���\N7I�wH&• �\����m���$��Z�• N�6|�5{�@d|��

���F%3}Jw��_[ka�\eNh�`_J�x�ziserf�`_D,�,�x vAp`

"/

+),.

��

������Aqw

����\�Ng

↓��]\�ngj�Ng

↓���������*

���*�l�\�Vg4kgNh�_SaW ` ��2Cognition & Technology

Group at Vanderbilt. (1997). The jasper project. Mahwah, N.J.: Laurence Erlbaum Associates.���2�����0� 1�

�*'� (2003). �! �������� �. $�: �%�(.

Page 5: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

1VQW\TG��bDOE��BK��=M��N���%9�8!:=?JG3XUS^T4

�&����C<AG��1���F� 7DKG��N�5M��

l�IH��LRZ^Ya��B�_,-00/.'&)((*`

l3XUS^T4G?J��BG�"EP[]TN ;>a� G#��E�#N�<$6@?2

VQW\TC� G�#

+

l�����¥�|��4E�6�L�y(9zq�

l���¥Zdeib_^`_OYefhc

l�|�wx��C�A�tj,3){.�t��uyjJ�tvo}lDNm�j�|�wxpl=�zK�zml=�zB+tyns�m�o~#"

l�¥�����������$<57!�M�'l��¦�¤�zk�¢���k0�%TT �>#"£ j*?$�S j��T

l$����� -��1I2}HF�L@§�¤&�:������8{���WV¡WW-

�����¥[]\f^\c\ba\ POX_f_ag_fQOTRSU 

/��;r�G�¥Zdeib_^`_OXhab^ad`�4E(9 ������

Page 6: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

���������������

���������������

������������ ���������������

��

Metadiscourse Tool����������� �

��"��$���&()'&

�������

����� ���

�!����

������

�����#%�

��

Page 7: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

;YU[]WM��d��@�JOFGL�RDH�+S��BcEM !S��L#.CQ

�5�+��I��L�+/�X`\;2 )L��@�JOM�NS-IPc�$M��S�Bc%M�$SZVT^BH<A�S�= !

l��_�"_,'�3M�0SJ=�>H<A?@%M14

a���d(&_��_*�a867:bKJb

YU[]WI��M�2

79

+* ��6�;A> QPFJNOR>���

,* !0BDC��(>� ��>LIGOQ���/� ��RS��:<C�?>�&>#$

-* +=�B58,2�"57>1E��93CHMLOK>�):%�

�?>'�>7@=���993C4:

+.

Page 8: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

87 ^PU[]`�FLIO��4H�@�AC23_*I���O)�

Ø %1_�*<�(_��_+"&<�KH�?>&

97 �'# IXTQ]`��$_�/$D =�K`��EGN�KI�0I�-

:7 RZX]VI�5E.�`WSY\UI�

��'��,6H!MBJ

8;

Consortium for Renovating Education of the Future���������������

���������� �

� �� ��

�����

�����

�� ���

������������

�����������

� �!�

�� ���

(�������S������'��������#!�$%��� "��� ����&

Page 9: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

Consortium for Renovating Education of the Future

�������� � �������������

���������� Conversation Analyzer 3.0 (Shirouzu et al., 2016, 2018)

���� ��� ��� � ��� �� �� ��

��

�� �

� ���� ���� ����

� ��� � �

� �� �� �

� �� �� ��

� � ��� ��

��������

�� ������������������� ��

�����������������

�TF-IDF���

Page 10: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

������������ � ����������� ����� ���

�� %(&)'� ��*����,��! ���+���#"⇒��!����������$���"

(��, 2019)

lI��� >eXD3c/2~x�Y46b�_kil9���(���a]jX|�wy{p�}Y46bZ[�m|��ve�'!D

l&*��aeI��� >dhj#;G%d�^lX�fey�u�xso�Ye����(���

l�:x�ue�F�=5� +�x�ue-0��tuxn�re/21�$

�MPNQOR LQWQSTUQVqoz

��:@�e`gex�ue7��8�������C

l�?e`ge,�x�u$

l�<.��<.�Ee�fe�Al"\j1�$

#;G%e�)bBH

KJ

Page 11: 6 +P JL *4 N M€¦ · 6 +p jl *4 n m ,.5 joik" 6 )$&2!t\u]dhgef[xvw ' * ($& $& ;9:a:: @ 718 ' * ($& '?9 - r\ysqz:=b99^:>b:9c 0% #

����

l :O^^\[':-''0..1''MVS['_ZO^`'U^\a]_'TOWY-'A\a^[OY'\T'`VS'CSO^[W[U'IQWS[QS_+'/0�1�+'1.5,137-l :^O[_T\^R+'A-'<-+':^\c[+'9-'C-'(';\QXW[U+'H-'H-'�=R_-��0...�?\c']S\]YS'YSO^[8':^OW[+'ZW[R+'Sd]S^WS[QS'O[R'_QV\\Y-'MO_VW[U`\['<-';-8'EO`W\[OY'9QORSZe'G^S__-

l :^\c[+'9-'C-')/770*-'h<S_WU['Sd]S^WZS[`_8'JVS\^S`WQOY'O[R'ZS`V\R\Y\UWQOY'QVOYYS[US_'W['Q^SO`W[U'Q\Z]YSd'W[`S^bS[`W\[_'W['QYO__^\\Z'_S``W[U_-i JVS'A\a^[OY'\T'`VS'CSO^[W[U'IQWS[QS_+'0)0*+'/2/,/56-

l Cognition & Technology Group at Vanderbilt. (1997). The jasper project. Mahwah, N.J.: Laurence Erlbaum Associates.

l ;\YYW[_+'9-'�/770� J\cO^R'O'RS_WU['_QWS[QS'\T'SRaQO`W\[-'@['=-'IQO[Y\['('J-'FgIVSO �=R_-�+'ESc'RW^SQ`W\[_'W['SRaQO`W\[OY'`SQV[\Y\Ue-':S^YW[8'I]^W[US^, LS^YOU+'/770-

l GS[aSY+'M-'H-+'>W_VZO[+':-'A-+';VS[U+':-'('IOPSYYW+'E-'�0.//�-''F^UO[WfW[U'^S_SO^QV'O[R'RSbSY\]ZS[`'O`'`VS'W[`S^_SQ`W\['\T'YSO^[W[U+'WZ]YSZS[`O`W\[+'O[R'RS_WU[-''=RaQO`W\[OY'HS_SO^QVS^+'2.�5�+'11/,115-

l IQO^ROZOYWO+'D-+'(':S^SW`S^+';-')0./2*-'hB[\cYSRUS':aWYRW[U'O[R'B[\cYSRUS';^SO`W\[-i'@['B-'IOceS^')=R-*+';OZP^WRUS'?O[RP\\X'\T'`VS'CSO^[W[U'IQWS[QS_+'0[R'SRW`W\[-'EN8';OZP^WRUS'K[WbS^_W`e'G^S__+'175,2/5-

l ����0./7�-��p�$�oz�}�{|~�r�sy��mxql��#���n�!��q �lw�����"�+'0./7�7�-

l ������ouv�� ��0./2�-'�!��q�&��sq��y�%�t-'j#���k+'0/�0�+'032,045-

l IVW^\afa+'?-+'IQO^ROZOYWO+'D-+'IOW`\+'D-+'FUOcO+'I-+'@WXaP\+'I-+'?\^W+'E-+'('H\_�+';-'h':aWYRW[U'\[';aY`a^OY';O]OQW`e'T\^'@[[\bO`W\['`V^\aUV'@[`S^[O`W\[OY';\YYOP\^O`W\[8'@['DSZ\^e'\T'EO\ZW'DWeOXSi+'@;CI0./4+'IW[UO]\^S- /.52,/.6/-')0./4*

l IVW^\afa+'?-+'IOW`\+'D-+'@WXaP\+'I-+'EOXOeOZO+'J-+'('?\^W+'B-')0./6*-'HS[\bO`W[U'9__S__ZS[`'T\^'

`VS'>a`a^S8'<S_WU[,:O_SR'@Z]YSZS[`O`W\['HS_SO^QV'T\^'O'CSO^[W[U,W[,;YO__'D\[W`\^W[U'Ie_`SZ':O_SR'\['`VS'CSO^[W[U'IQWS[QS_+'@;CI0./6+'C\[R\[+ /6.5,/6/2-