39 ÐnÏvi1ñ^n - iri2016/08/03 · Ã~w6, sz@zzz j___ tzçl4]zq-’ ig //// yzúz] ò uc*Ëze...
TRANSCRIPT
-
JZzZ@Zs6,W~Ã ___tZ ’q-Z]4lçGI
//// eZËc*u²Ã]ZúZyAbstract:
"Orientalism emerged and developed in went as a
great movement during 14th century a.d. the
western scholars took interest in the study of the
east, especially the Islamic literature. With the
passage of time, it became a targeted study,
focused to misinterpret Islam and the Holy
Prophet Mohammad (~V ), although a reasonablenumber of orientalists have to admit the reality
that the Prophethood of Mohammad (~V ) is full oftruthfulness by every respect and they became
also the Muslims. The following article is a critical
study in this regard."
Keywords: Orientalism, Islamic l iterature,
Misinterpretation, Truthfulness, Preaching of
Islam.
(Zq-].h+Z˜bì�Š*²!ZŠ[Zzg¸]~ Orientalism t) Z Z]4lçGI
t»Â Z Æ|xÃZŠZ™äÆaZ]4lçGI
Orientalism ñ�Š7ìXZôm,~i!*yÆÂZEwHŠHìXtÂw°âŠ{ÑtÐÃìT»ÈgzÝZzg®ìXtÂWi~sV~Îg`ÆaÌÙìXZϧbÑtZzgætÎg`ƃqƒäÆ£xÃÌë�X™r#—yZ²[ë�:
ZZ]Ö7†ÑV]Ö–çðæ]Ö7†Ñ]Ö7Û‹(æ…æpÂÛ†æÂà]enä]ÞäÎ^Ù]Ö7†Ñ]Ö7Û‹eËjx]Ö7nàæ]Ö7†Ñ]Ö–çð]Ö„pm‚ìØÚà�Ð]Öf^h(�†Îk
))))1111(((( ]Ö7Û‹i7†Ñ�†æÎ^æ�†Î^›×Ãkæ]‰Ü]ÖÛç•Ä]ÖÛ7†ÑXXÑt»pgzÝZzgZϧbÎg`ÌìÔ/zäZL!*\ÆzZWÐÜHì
¼Zg%EÄZsðz²!ÔÍḡ-Eg;ßW!*Š ////
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ93
-
�ZrVä¹:ÑtëÆ�Æ‚BÎg`Ãë�ZzgÑtZkgzÝÃÌë��X»]gÑztZzgÑt iø7ø†$Ñ Zzg �ø†øÎøkô]Ö7$Û‹ ŠgzZi}ÆÎgZcÐZ0+gWCìX
)ƒqƒZ(Æp~ZEwƒ@*ìÔZÏÐZÌøsætìX ›ø×øÃøkû ìtÂÑt~&wzsZ³ÔkZzg@*Y»ZŸ†™ÆZ#ZÐ!*[Z]4©›é GEwÆziy
tÐ%ZŠætÅÔìX Z 6,Ñc*YñÂZkÆZ0+gÔ»|xaZƒY@*ìXªZ]4lçGI
tZ (ÅzŸs#™Dƒñ˜��f!¸]~Z]4lçGI
Orient ¦·�á@ÂZzg•M)Üs'Z5ð|x~ætÅÔÆaÙ7ìÉgzÝÔâgZzg@Ze$ÅÔÆ
aÌZEwƒ@*ìXz{˜�:Êçq‚]Þäm7^…MÖoÚß_Ïè]Ö7†Ñ]ÖÛÏ’çRé DO r i e n t ZZ�†ÑE
DMorgenland e^Ö‚…]‰^l]Ö7†ÎnèeÓ×ÛèijÛnˆe_^eÄÚÃßçpæâçE]Ö’f^|(æÚÆæÍ]á]Ö’f^|i7†ÑÊnä]Ö7Û‹(æi‚Ù æiÃßoe¡R
â„å]ÖÓ×ÛèÂ×njvçÙÚà]ÖÛ‚ÖçÙ]Ördž]Êo]ÖË×ÓoMÖo]Öj†ÒnˆÂ×oÚÃßo]Ö’f^|]Ö„pmj–ÛàÚÃßo]Ößç…æ]ÖnÏ¿è(æÊoæÚÏ^e؃ÖÔ
æiÃßoe¡R]ÖÛŠ^ðÖj‚Ù DAbendland ÞŠjí‚ÝÊo]Ö×Çè!Ò×ÛèEmjÃ×Ü]æ VOrient Â×o]Ö¿¡Ýæ]Ö†]uèýæÊo]Ö¡inßnèiÃßoÒ×Ûè
æqùä]æâ‚p]æ Orienter mfv&ÂàcðÚ^æe^ÖˆފnèiÃßoÒ×Ûè))))2222(((( ]…�‚XX
(ÆÝÆ‚BætÆ´ºÅ§sZ�ág{ Orient ¦·�á@Æ–wÑt)HY@*ì��ѹî]»°ŠìZ(ÝZEw™DƒñT~s~Y\»ZqÐi
(âgXCìTÐ%ZŠðÆ´º�ZzgD!*]ì�ð Morgenland ì��)~Îg`ƒqƒ@*ìXZ[tÝZL'Z5ðZzgÛpƒÐ?Ø™r-÷ NEÆp6,½7gŠÑª™@*ì�ðâgZzgËZg~Æ|xÃ�áïìXZ#�ZkÆ£«~ë
Zzg:6, O (»ÝZEw™D�TÐ%ZŠ�áxÆ´º�@*�t@*g Abendland)»pz{Fìc*ËqÆ!*g}~[™g;ìX Orient ŠÑª™}ÔÑHi!*y~
»pìZkägÉðÅÔgZ3Cc*Zzg¦SgZ{ŠîðX Orienter ²�ÛZú~(ætÆaÙìZzgZzg~Z@Zix Orient Zôm,~ÂZzg~Z•M)
(ÆpÑtÙÏc*æ¹Exz.yZzgZŠ[~'g]qÝ™äÆ� Orientlism)))))3333(((( Ð%ZŠZq-Z(¿ì�/Øæ¹áCƒX àt)Z]4lç
GIZtÆ÷ÐZÌö(
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ04
-
Ô0Z+Ô@*gõÔZŠ[Zzg (Oriental Sciences Z()湬Ý�æ¹Ex)tZzgàtÅ°p™D Z çÑ]z){~Špg‚rƒàtB@*ìXZi+zgeGZ]4lç
GI
ƒñ˜�:"Anyone who teaches, writes about, or reseaches
the orient and this applies whether the person is an
Anthropologis t , Sociologist , Histor ian or
Philologist either in its specific or its general
aspects, is an Orientalist and what he or she says or
does is Orientalism."(4)
·-ŠgZàg~âCÙ¹i|æÜÅ=%]ÅgzÝ~àtÆ|xÅ,h+™Dƒñ˜��àtf[ÆZ,¬ÝÃë��ZsxÔZsò1d$ÔZsò
))))5555(((( çÑ]ZzgZsòi!*âV~Špg‚rƒX·-ŠgZx7g~ÅèÃg{°p~q�ZsxÆaË´ºêc*gc*„ÅuÈ~7ňìX
tÆŸi¬ÝZ0Z',Z�ZÊ-)Ïî EGf!¬ÝÅ,h+™Dƒñë�� Z DZ]4lçGI
àtZ,)›ŠZ›gÃŒÛZgŠï���›âVÆ�Û}ÔZNŠZ]ZzgWŠZ[zgÎxÆ!*g}~ï™}eìz{›y¤/z{Zzģxæ¹´º~g2zZàƒc*†[~eì
))))6666(((( ²!1%zZáƒVc*)²!X¼Š tÅ Z ~Z]4lç
GI …¨mè]Ÿ‰¡ÚnèÖ¡‰j7†]Ñ eZËZ£†Z?¾Z[ZKÂ[°d]»E+™{™äÆp̂Š°p™Dƒñ˜�:
ZZâçR…]‰^l]Ò^RmÛnèmÏçÝeã^ƆençáÒ^ʆæáÚà]âØ]ÖÓj^heçqäì^”Ö¡‰¡Ýæ]ÖÛŠ×Ûnà(Úà�jo]Örç]Þg(ÂÏn‚éæ�†mÃè(æ$Ï^Êè(æu–^…é(æi^…mí÷̂æÞ¿Û^(æ$†æ]læ]ÚÓ^Þ^lýâ‚Íi7çmè]Ÿ‰¡Ý(æÚv^æÖèi7ÓnÔ]ÖÛŠ×ÛnàÊnä(æi–×n×ãÜÂßäæʆš]ÖjfÃnèÖ×džhÂ×nãÜæÚv^æÖèif‚m†â„å]ÖjfÃnèe‚…]‰^læÞ¿†m^li‚Âo]ÖÃ×Ûnèæ]ÖÛç•çÂnè(iˆÂÜ]ÖjËçÑ]ÖÃß’†p
))))7777(((( æ]Ö%Ï^ÊoÖ×džh]ÖÛŠnvoÂ×o]Ö7†Ñ]Ÿ‰¡ÚoXXtZydî]»**xìT»ZÈxZIÂ[Æf!»�Û{mîg6,ZsxZzg›âVÆ0ZUîVЙgì�Xo{zÑ
-
@*gõZzgÄz°ÆZ±gÐZzgñ�Š{ZzgÂz‚bÆ!*g}~XT»@sZsxÅ$+úðÔ›âV~ZkÆ0“uz2]ZVäÅÃÒÔZyÃZsxÐê?**ZzgZy6,f[Åcz~ÃÑiòŒÛZgŠbZzgZkÇÃ�Zi�ÛZë™äÅÃÒZ+î]ZzgÃc*]Æ‚BXÆ!*g}~dZzgñç¬Cƒä»Šúò™D�XZy»ìwì�\f[Ã
ZzgpD',F,~qÝìX ÑtZsò6,K~)Kã(eZ˾Z[Æ_.f!ZIÂ[\f[ÅZsòæt6,#ZzgpD',F,~ÆiøÅãCŠ6,›âV6,ZIf[»º‡ì™äÆa›âVÃZsxÆ!*g}~eZ„Zzg—~2™äZzgZsxÃ*”{ßg]~7™äžnЛâVÆo{ÔpÄÔÑ
-
t»W¸i Z ’q-Z]4lçGI
tÆW¸iÆ!*g}~�t’q-¾Í~ÑzqƒðZzg¾ñµ6, Z ’q-Z]4lçGI
t»¼gZsxÆW¸i Z Zk»¼gƒZZ%sgZñ0*c*Y@*ì‰ZIDÅgZñì�Z]4lçGI
Æ‚B„ƒŠHå·Šz»g~Å#zd',F,~»¹ZsxäÂhZÂZrVäZsx#³ÆçÜ·Šz»g~Å #" t»Ẁ¸iåX9Zsx Z u¤/xVÑzqXZzg¸Z]4lç
GI
#¿ÆˆªWŠòTä!*‡°{îg6,ZsxÆÜs’k,~kBW^,œ~{~~åXZkäŠzÂÁLLõzg{ìZÑsxZzgZg�áŠZ] ÑzqÅz{YyWsŠw)-¦Šb(
))))11111111(((( ZÅ3}é Egò°].wZÁóóKXt»W¸i2131Y~ƒZZ#¢45é EGE~GÅ Z ¼ZIDÅgZñì�’q-Z]4lç
GI
»Ð÷ƒðT~tðƒZ�-g\ÅYç]~²!Ô‡ZãZzguc*ãi!*yÅD+gö))))22221111(((( XN ÆackZzg-g\ŧi6,çi‡ìÅY
‰ZIDÆ4,Šq-Zk’q-»W¸iZkz‰ÜƒZZ#fYf[äZ0+ÖÆd²z`Êكñz;V»gcHeZ˽ZÅk5éE¦˜�:
ZZ]áeØ]Ö†âf^á]ÖdžennàÎ’‚æ]]ŸÞ‚Ö‹ÊoMe^á¿Ûjã^ææÚr‚â^(æi%ÏËç]ÊoÚ‚]…‰ã^(æi†qÛç]]Öφkáæ]ÖÓjg]ÖÆenèMÖoÖÇ^iãÜ(i×Û„æ]Â×oÂ×Û^ð]ÖÛŠ×ÛnàÊo]ÖÃ×çÝæeí^‘èÊo]ÖË׊Ëè
))))33331111(((( æ]Ö_gæ]Ö†m^•n^lXX‰f!gZÖVäZ0+ÖÅÑZzggfÆZc*x~z;V»pHÔZkÆ
æZgk~½qÝÅÔŒÛWyZzg²!ûZKi!*âV~F,ÀHÔZrVäZEx~Zzg{mîg6,,Ô¥Zzggc*M]~›yfYÅ�á¤/Š~Z(gÅX
ZϧbtgZñÌñ�Šì�Zk’q-»W¸iŠÎ,œ~~Zkz‰ÜƒZZ#Zq-(ZeZzgŒÛ\ÅYç]~ Gerbert D'Aurillac �ÛZú0*Šg~̀',^e~Zz&Ò5ë GG)
))))44441111(((( g;X ExZsð6,Š,kqÝ™heÆ9̂99YÐ3001YJ-0*0*ñgzxÆÇ{6,³t»W¸i!*gƒ,œ~{~~ Z tƉâCÙ+Æ_.’q-Z]4lç
GI Z DZ]4lçGI
ÆZZY6,ÑHi!*y~ŒÛWy™*»F,À (Peter The Venerable ƒZXZ#BkHx)))))55551111(((( HŠHX
tZk’q-»W¸i¾ƒ,œ~{~~U*"$™D�Z# Z ¼âCÙ+Z]4lçGI
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ34
-
(Alfonsox) ~».ÞZŠc*yÆjZáÐZq-ZŠZg{ (Murcia)( ZÖ²Šëä9621Y~%(i!*y~ Spainish Z1–ģïÆik,ôZã‡ìHXZÏZŠZg}~ŒÛWy™*»ïâ~)
F,ÀHŠHXZÏŠzg~�Ûi+guŠzxäÌZsòñç¬]6,ŒÃÆF,ZW™ZñZzg))))66661111(((( -g\Æ(ZŠZgzV~5X
ZIf[äZK(ŠgoƒV~²!zZsòExÅSàçi‡ìXX9351Y~�ÛZ÷Ô2361Y~‰`Zzg8361Y~Wxge~!*‡°{çi‡ìÅIX
tÆ̀W¸iÅ”W‚y7ìpdf{],~ Z âIèÃg{WgZYÐ’q-Z]4lçGI
ôp¥â]ÅãCŠ6,t¹YYì�Zk’q-»!*‡°{W¸iW^,œ~{~~ƒZXtÆ!*EV~ZÒe$èI Z qgz!*ÑWgZYÐt!*]Ì¥xƒCì�Z]4lç
GI
§ZƒV)gZÖVZzg0*Šg-V(ŶXtèI§ZZsxÃZq-ç{B¸ZkaZyÅdt~z{|Z]Ì Z u¤/ñV~ZsxÐo�Û]»g8-zZãŠ3ðŠêìÔÍ�fñZ]4lç
GI
tÔ Z �áïgì��XÅd»zØVÐÏ»£gzz‡g—ƒZp¨ù¦Z]4lçGI
Zsx#³’q-Æîg6,wáŠ6,%ŠZgƒZìX
tÅ@*gõ Z ’q-Z]4lçGI
tÅ@*gõZzgà:Ådzó].z4ÃKÆaZÐZ Z ’q-Z]4lçGI
ZŠzZg~„™**¢zg~ìX6,zWÜZ£ÂòäZLZq-z¯£!~à:Å@*gõÃ0*õZŠzZg~„Hì:
1XªŠzgtƬŠzg»mZkiâäÐìZ#›âVäZ0+ÖÃExz.yZzg Z Z]4lç
GI
ÆaZ0+Ö» 1d$zÕy»‘Zg{¯Šc*åXZIf[ZkdzÕã²z`ÐZ.Š{™ägc™D¸XZ0+Öŧsg�q™äzZßVÅ(,~®ZŠZ+̶�Zsx#³_.!*]Ðu�ág¸X
2XŠzuZŠzgŠzu}Šzg»m°lVÆiâäÐìw!xŠ+~“Å0ä
täZkŠzg~ZsxÅ� Z Š*ñ¾Z+MÃZsx#¿~²z`6,àŠc*XfñZ]4lçGI
¦k,7ÅZk»ZW,æÂV-g\ÅW!*Š-V~¸̈g;X
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ44
-
3XŠZŠzgtÆŠ}Šzg»mZkiâäÐìZ#QZz[ä-g8 Z ’q-Z]4lç
GI
Š*~ZEgZzgo/~Å5pZ÷]ÃËZg™Šc*Zzgf!¤!VäZëZŠ~³ZìÆ‚BætÊ9Ñzq™Šc*X
4XaåŠzgaåŠzgz{ìZ#âW!*Šc*CÂx»ŠxzZ¯ÑzqƒZZzg)±ºÆÜsWiZŠ~
(~zZã Methodology tÆZ0+ZiïZzg§i»g) Z Å’rVäÀ1XfñZ]4lçGI
p~%ŠZgƒðZsxÆ‚B„CÙZ'ZxÆ',@*îä�Ûzr0*c*X
5X0*vZVŠzgtÆ0*v,Šzg»mZkiâäÐìZ#Šg]ŧsЛŠ*à Z Z]4lç
GI
))))77771111(((( ig(wÅŠzªÐâÑâwHŠHÂZIf[Åwøó�ZkŠzª6,%ÃiƒIXt~ Z eZË·Z™xa@g~äZgŠzŠZ],{çgsZsð~�áïZL£!Z]4lç
GI
tÆ&ZŠzZgf™G�ÔZyÆ_.¬ŠzgÅZ’ZYZsxÆ‚B„ƒ̂ Z ’q-Z]4lçGI
tƱZzg!*‡°{Šzg»W¸i Z Z#ŠxŠx6,ZsxÃ#¿»‚o™**7,Z²’q-Z]4lçGI
)ŠzuZŠzg(�gzâZzg0*0*áÅu6,4~°lVƈƒZZ#Zk’q-äZq-tÆŠ}Zzgñ�Š{Šzg»W¸iZVgz,œ~{~Ð Z Š’́q-Å̂Z(gÅXZ]4lç
GI
))))88881111(((( ÑzqƒZ�Z[J-Yg~ìX
tÆZ¾Znz£œ Z ’q-Z]4lçGI
tÅ@*gõ»_·™äÐt¥xƒ@*ì�t’q-¼Š£œz Z ’q-Z]4lçGI
Z@ZsÅqïg„ì:
1XŠ´Z@Zs6�âIf™HŠH�ZsxÅgziZ‚ÛzVF,¹ä#5)Sî·Šz»g~(Å
',F,~û™**Ñzq™Šc*ÂZrVäZsxÆÜsî»W¸i™Šc*ÔZsòx]6,“uz2]Æ6,Š}eZáYäÑzqGX
tÆŠ´Z@Zs»E+™{™Dƒñegï]f™™D�: Z eZ˽ZÅk5éE¦’q-Z]4lçGI
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ54
-
»ãCŠ~Ñ›âV~ZLÑÔŒÛWyxÔÑ
-
(Zq-‡.ÞŠgÂ[ Preaching of Islam (»ìXZyÅ"Šú]Zsx) ArnoldìX‰à:äWg&Óå EHÃW»¶K:¯c*ì�Zkät"ZIZsxÅ›~ez[
))))11112222(((( ™èìXZkdZ‹ZsÆ!*z�Š¤/zÓà:Àòîg6,ZID»Zq-Z(¡ìTä
ŒÛWyzug$Ô§]z}ZsòZzgZÜtz¦sÆxŠ+~!*g;TWiâðÅp›ëÃWDg™ä»_./̧̈:WeÉZsxЊzgZzghÆZïgÆ_."äF,¹0*ðÔ(z#kZŠZg}‡ì™Æ‚³ãCŠzV6,Zsx#³î»W¸iHŠHX%*@—�:
"A few outstanding western scholars have devoted
their lives to Islamic studies because of sincere
interest in them. Were it not for their industry,
much valuable knowledge found in ancient Islamic
manuscripts would have been last or lying forgotten
in obscurity. English Orientalists like the late
Reynolds Nicholson and the late Arthur Arberry
accomplished notable work in the field of
translating classics of Islamic literature and making
them the general reader for the first time in a
European language."(22)
%*Æ–w‰**ñgf!>äZsòExÆ_·~À:Øtů6,i0+ŠHV�rŠ,Z¤/z{ÃÒ:™D¹‚gZËuât)Zsò"¤](ʼnƒDc*Í̃¿w~7,}gTXZôm,à:6�gb®$¹Òjè
EEZzgWgêWg',~äZsòZŠ[ÆZzgZyÅ$+zª-g8i!*âV~¬xWŠò ¯ò˜0*gzV»F,ÀH)Tä(,~à]0*ð(
Æ_·ÆaZsòZŠ[Šø7[ƒZX
(ÏZ@Zs¬Ýf[äZL(ÏÂV³ZìÆafñZ]4lç
GIZtÅ}.â]qÝXMVäZK&6V»½7gZEw™DƒñZEgÆjZzgºÆagZ{ûZgÅXà:ui}æt~ZEgÆaZk㢊Z]ŶK0+„™DXâW!*Šc*CŠzg~z{õx´̧VÅi!*yÔZŠ[Ôè
-
%A$™D@*�ZEg~̧'wÅŠk,0*µ/È~™ÃXZEgzZ]4lçGIZtÆZÏ!*b
mŶK0+„™DƒñeZš/âiyäZ*fúŠ�á™ò»¸wf™Hì:ZZÊÏ‚Úç]ÚÃ×çÚ^lÚç‰ÃèæÚË’×èÂà]Ö‚æÙ]Öjo…Æfk]Ö‚æÙ]Ödženè
æ΂]ìj×¼]ŸÚ†Êo . Êo]‰jÃÛ^…â^æ]Ÿ‰jn¡ðÂ×o$†æ]iã^æìn†]iã^Úç¾nËo æÎkÚà]ŸæÎ^lenà]ÖÛvjØæ]ÖÛŠj7†ÑÊÏ‚Ò^áÒ%n†Úà
))))33332222(((( ]Ÿuj¡ÙÂ×oR…]mèe^Ö7†ÑÖÇèæi^…mí÷̂æ‰n^‰èæ]Îj’^R]÷XX)Zyà:äZKî]Æ‚B(›˜´Æ0(,~zWZzg-
¥â]�ÛZëXTäf!̃´ÃZy´̧VÆ�ZâVZzgz‚b6,ïZzg„0*ä6,Z&¼-BïEY
GEGHZzgFŠiÂ-VƒZ�tï™äzZáZzgàtZq-„ÃWñÔZEgƹÐznpgz{¸�ætÅi!*yÔ@*gõÔ(„Zzgu»ZYDgnp¸X
�ÛZ÷~æ¹i!*âVŽ»Zq-ZŠZg{Y~‡ìHŠHZkZŠZg}ÅZÍAó��¼Š u¤/xV̂zZÎÆ!*g}~×ñZŠ%A$™**åXà:ÅZq-)®))
xŠ+ÆâCÙ+6,Œ¶(ä32¢zV~Zq-ñΔîG»g™Šc*TÐ̂~î�ðÆa-g8Z̧Zxä½7gÃZ+{QVc*X�ÛZ÷~‡ìHŠHtZŠZg{�ÛZú¯`ÐzZhåX
eZËZ£¾Z[Z]4lçGIZtÆZEgzmÆ‚B.}m»E+™{™Dƒñ
˜��tmW`̇ììZzgf!Ó‘(Ïz'Z5ðyZâV~µ/‚i~Æaà:ÐæŠfe�Xz{˜�:
"The history of Orientalism shows that it was
closely connected with the needs and purpose of
Colonialism and with Christian missionary. That
connection remains, it has now become apart of
the geo-political strategies of western governments
and their intelligence services."(24)
Šzu~kBxƈZ#âW!*Šc*CZMZg»{؃**ÑzqƒZÂZEgÃZ”V~ZMZgÃgh**7,ZÂZIf[ä5D+ÛZ(gÅZrVäZL\g]{âVÔ̧_Zzg
~à:ÃZëBV6,Ã,̂HMVä (Diplomatic Missions) eøz!n.ç IEEZEg~jÐWiZŠƒäzZá”V~‡ìƒäzZàÓáVðxZPxЊzegGgpp~ZC™ŠZgZŠZHX
Šzg].h+~f!̧ÂVä湊*~ZLZW,zÓfÇìgppZzg¬Ýæt)Sî
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ84
-
ZsòŠ*(Å'Z5ðz(ÏwÃæÃgnpƒñZL˜´~æ¹zZsòExÆ%Zœ/‡ìGXÅî]Ã7ÃgÄ™¬ÝætÆ!*g}~µ/È~ÅYCìXeZËâiy’k,™D�ZyZñg~Ð�à:Ų!zZsòî]Æ(ÏzZEg~Z@ZsÆ‚BmÃzZã™D�Zq-Zë!*]tì�Z%MÅFYç]~Zsòz²!ExÆ%Zœ/‡ìG‰��ÎZ%Ou»gâàZæZŠŠîìZzgÚ´c*bz~ZæZŠ(ÏZ@ZsÆ‚BmÆZ±gÐYg~ìZzgZyZŠZgzV~Åï̂Ã(Ï£œÆaZEwHY@*ìz{˜�:
ZZæÚÛ^mçÒ‚]…if^½]Ö‚…]‰^l]ÖÆenè]Ÿ‰¡Únèe^Ÿâ‚]Í]ÖŠn^‰nè]Ÿuj¡Önè]á]ÖvÓçÚè]ŸÚ†mÓnèÚøç$Öøkû‚R]Úà]ÖÛ†]ÒˆÖׂ…]‰^l]ÖÆenè]Ÿ‰¡ÚnèÊo]ÖÂm‚Úà]Ör^ÚÃ^l]ŸÚ†mÓnè(æÚ^‡]ÖkiÛçÙeÖã^MÚ^iÛçm¡÷Ò^Ú¡÷]æiÛçm¡÷qˆñn÷^æÊÏ^ÖÛ‚p]…if^½]Ö‚…]‰è
))))55552222(((( e^â‚]Í]ÖvÓçÚè]ŸÚ†mÓnèæ‰n^‰jã^XXf!̃´ÅYç]~‡ìG‰%Zœ/',Zñæ¹zZsòExÅî]Æ
‰ÍÚšµ°pzdÆ��p¨ù¦Zyî]Æ}òzWU*gætZzgZsxÅÇF,)ã7™DXeZËZ£¾Z[Æ_.óñç¬]ÆZN!*]~){mîg6,ZsxÔ@*gõz1d$Zsx(›yfYÆ£«~%œ/~w\Zzg·Š~fYc*c*}.Z**Ùk|Z]Ãq݃CìXz{˜�:
"In these centers Atheist, Christian and Jewish
scholars have at least an equal usually greater
authority than Muslims in the choice and framing
of the topics for research in Islamic history and
civilization and in the teaching of Islam."(26)
ZOŠ~zçÙ£œÂZsxÅgziZ‚ÛzVF,¹Ãgz1 ’q-Z]4lç
GIZt»W¸i)6�f™HY[ì(ÆaHŠHåpˆ~ZkÆ£œ~ZŸ†ƒŠHXZIf[äZLçÙ¢ŠZ]
ZzĝgCç5]Å',F,~Æa²!i!*yZzgZsò1d$zpÄ»_·HXZrVä湊*{mîg6,Zsò̃´~Z,qÑ]aZ™äÅÃÒÅ�Zỹ´Æz‚b6,ïHYñÔQŠzg~ŠZ4ƒäƈf[äætÆ{xâwÆf{],6,Ã
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ94
-
)ðX‰ZIDÅgZñì�Z]4lçGIZt»Z‚Ï@sZOŠ~yZy„åZzgŠ+Zzg&4n.ç GEIG~
uÃZ4ZOŠ~Z@ZsÆ”wÆaZEwHŠHXeZËâiy˜�:ZZæâß^ÕÚàm†p]á]Öã‚Í]ŸÎj’^RpÒ^áâç]Ÿ‰^ŒÊo]Ÿ‰j7†]Ñ
))))77772222(((( æ΂]‰jÇØ]Ö‚màæ]Öjß’n†ÖjvÏnÐ]Ÿâ‚]Í]ŸÎj’^RmèXXà:ZKî]Æfg)ætÆ�ZíŶK0+„™DXZϧbZrV
äZ¦ZŠzz‚bÆxŠ+~Z÷æ¹ZzgZsòW!*Š-V~Zˆk²~ìx™äÅ[�ÅX湊*6,f[Ædz„~ºtÅŠJuèä~à:Ã{§pZ{»x!q݃ðX
’q-Z]4lçGIZtÆèÃg{Z@Zs»Y,̂{heÐt!*]‚tWCì�’q-
Z]4lçGIZtZK‰µEVÆ!*z�Š¨ù¦ZsxŠ#Æ_.!*]Ðu�ágìZzg’q-Å]}.â]ÃæÃg3YñÂظì�ZkÅu¤/ñVäZsxÅ)ǦgÉÅTÅzzÐZsxÆÜso�Û]ä�Ûzr0*c*ZϧbZsxÆ!*g}~ï™DƒñŠc*-$zœZ‰ÜÆQßßVÃÃZ0+ZiHŠHX¢zg]ZkZ%Åì�ZsxZzgxŠ+Zsxд]Z]4lç
GIZ¹î]»**ŠZ:Y,̂{1YñZzgZyÅ™Kõ]ŶK0+„ÅYñ@*�ZsxZzg0]Zsx»_·™äzZÑ›ëÐMÙƒX
jZ!Y]ŠZg™ŠgÔwX]Ôm471 Z0àgÔ·0(xÔ—yZ²[ÔÛz]Ô 1X
âiy0&b!‹3¨é EGãÔZÑ]4lçGIZtÔZØCÙ>ÔŠZgZäzZHÔwX]Ôm3 2X
Z&kÔÑsZ−+ÔZsxZzgà:ÔZW¥/|ÔŠZgZ¢Ô4002YÔ2B84Ô05 3X4. Edward Said, Orientalism, New York, Vintage, 1979, P.1
gZàg~Ô·-ŠÔ’q-Z]4lçGIZtÔCŠZgZ‰xŠ-ÈÔâga8891Ôm43Ô53 5X
$»40î GEG Z0Z',Z�ZÊ-)Ïî EÔZÑ]4lçGIZtzZ−gZ‚]Ñs!0îGGÔrŠgZ
Å.h4lçGI:z]g
#-�êGG
ÔZ°c*n: 6XZp!îEGÔ8991YÔm53Z£†Z?¾Z[Ôgƒ!îGGZÑs!0îGGÉÕä]4lç
GIZtÔZ°c*n:ŠZgZÑ™ÈîGÉÒ3¨é IG£îEGzZÉ4lç EIzZÑ´xÔ8891YÔ 7Xm7X8
MYZÅWyXÅÔf“{8141|Ô6&321 MYZÅWyÔуg: ZÑiCÙ~Ô·™x�á{ 8Xâiy0&b!‹3¨é EGãÔZÑ]4lç
GIZtÔm4 9X
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ05
-
Zs 01X MYZÅWyÔ6B621 ZÑiCÙ~Ô·™x�á{ 11X
âiy0&b!‹3¨é EGã¼WZÑ]4lçGIZtÔm4 21X
ZÅk5éE¦ÔZ−Æg·½ÔZÑ]4lçGIZtzZÅ)4lç
GI¸yÔÛz]ÔŠZgZßgZtÔwX]Ôm71Ô81 31XŠZgZ‚gÔ3991YÔm31 ·Z£Šc*[ÔZ−ÆgÔZçZYZZÑ]4lç
GIZtzZÅ.h4lç
GI:ÔZØCÙ>: 41XúŠ£~iLÛztÔZ−ÆgÔZÑ]4lç
GIZtzZÄCÒ3ªî EGEGZËtÉÒ¸çZqZÄB}é Eg~ÔZØCÙ>:9891YÔm23 51XZs 61X
- ÜZ£ÂòÔZsxZzgà:ÔZW¥/|ÔŠZgZ¢Ô4002YÔ2&11X72 71X·Z™xa@g~ÔeZËÔ]ZgŠzŠZ],{çgsZsðÔуg:º[-Eg;Ôâga2002YÔ 81Xm565X475ZÅk5éE¦ÔZ−Æg·!{‹§ö
EWÔZÑ]4lç
GIZtzZÅ.h4lç
GI¸yÔm03Ô13 91Xâiy0&b!‹3¨é EGãÔZÑ]4lç
GIZtÔm8 02XZsÔm33 12X
22. Maryam Jameelah, Islam and Orientalism,Lahore, Mohammad
Yusuf Khan & & Sons, Second Edition, 1990. P.29
âiy0&b!‹3¨é EGãÔZÑ]4lçGIZtÔm9 32X
24. Ahmad Ghorab, Dr. Subverting Islam, Kuala Lumpur, The Open
Press, 1996. P.03
âiy0&b!‹3¨é EGãÔZÑ]4lçGIZtÔm01 52X
26. Ahmad Ghorab, Dr. Subverting Islam, P.04
âiy0&b!‹3¨é EGãÔZÑ]4lçGIZtÔm9 72X
j
•n^ñ1ivÏnÐ15
Print linePage 1Page 2Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7
urdu