37136624-2009-labor-case-digest

80
!""#$% !" $ %&’() $ *$%+, -./ 0/(" 1/+ $**($’ 2%/3 +.( 0(45"5/1 3$, 1/+ /6+$51 $1, $225%3$+57( %(’5(2 2%/3 +.( $**(’’$+( 4/&%+ /+.(% +.$1 -.$+ .( .$" /6+$51(0 2%/3 +.( ’/-(% +%56&1$’) 52 $1,) -./"( 0(45"5/1 5" 6%/&8.+ &* /1 $**($’9 :&( *%/4("" *%(7(1+" +.( 8%$1+ /2 $005+5/1$’ $-$%0" +/ *$%+5(" -./ 050 1/+ $**($’9 !" $1 (;4(*+5/1) .( 3$, $""581 $1 (%%/% -.(%( +.( *&%*/"( 5" +/ 3$51+$51 +.( <&083(1+ /1 /+.(% 8%/&10") 6&+ .( 4$11/+ "((= 3/05254$+5/1 /% %(7(%"$’ /2 +.( <&083(1+ /% $225%3$+57( %(’5(2 &1’("" .( .$" $’"/ $**($’(0 /% 25’(0 $ "(*$%$+( *(+5+5/19 >!?@!A BC@@DED) FAB9 7"9 GDHGDIJC DADHC) !H@KA B!LIFE!:CH) AJDA! LDHMCA $10 NCBD@KA OC@FA!) E9H9 A/9 PQRSTU) N$1&$%, VQ) VTTUW @5=(-5"() 6, $7$5’518 /2 $ -%/18 /% 51$**%/*%5$+( 3/0( /2 $**($’) +.( *(+5+5/1 3(%5+" $1 /&+%58.+ 05"35""$’ *&%"&$1+ +/ B5%4&’$% A/9 VX UT -.54. *%/750(" +.$+) Y$1 $**($’ +$=(1 +/ (5+.(% L&*%(3( B/&%+ /% +.( B/&%+ /2 !**($’" 6, +.( -%/18 /% 51$**%/*%5$+( 3/0( ".$’’ 6( 05"35""(09Z> [!ANFA [D!\K FA:JLIHFDL !A: BCALIHJBIFCA BCMG!AK @I:9 >]CHMDH@K [!ANFA DAEFADDHFAE !A: BCALIHJBIFCA BC9 @I:9W 79 [CACH!^@D BCJHI C] !GGD!@L) E9H9 A/9 P_QUSR) ](6%&$%, PU) VTTUW !+ +.( /&+"(+) 5+ 3&"+ 6( "+$+(0 +.$+ *(+5+5/1(%" $0/*+(0 +.( -%/18 3/0( /2 %(3(0, 51 6%518518 +.( 4$"( 6(2/%( +.5" B/&%+9 F+ 5" -(’’X"(++’(0 +.$+ +.( *%/*(% %(4/&%"( /2 $1 $88%5(7(0 *$%+, +/ $""$5’ +.( 0(45"5/1 /2 +.( B/&%+ /2 !**($’" 5" +/ 25’( $ *(+5+5/1 2/% %(75(- /1 4(%+5/%$%5 &10(% H&’( ‘a /2 +.( H&’(" /2 B/&%+9 I.( H&’(" *%(4’&0(" %(4/&%"( +/ +.( "*(45$’ 4575’ $4+5/1 /2 4(%+5/%$%5 52 $**($’) 6, -$, /2 $ *(+5+5/1 2/% %(75(- 5" $7$5’$6’() $" +.( %(3(05(" /2 $**($’ $10 4(%+5/%$%5 $%( 3&+&$’’, (;4’&"57( $10 1/+ $’+(%1$+57( /% "&44(""57(9 >I!B@C^!A ]!H D!LI M!H?DIFAE BCHGCH!IFCA $10 ]H!ABFLBC K9 HCMJ!@:DO 79 I[D BCJHI C] !GGD!@L) A!IFCA!@ @!^CH HD@!IFCAL BCMMFLLFCA) E9H9 A/9 PRVSVT) L(*+(36(% PP) VTTUW I53( $10 $8$51) 5+ .$" 6((1 .(’0 +.$+ +.( %58.+ +/ $**($’ 5" 1/+ $ 4/1"+5+&+5/1$’ %58.+) 6&+ $ 3(%( "+$+&+/%, *%575’(8(9 [(14() *$%+5(" -./ "((= +/ $7$5’ +.(3"(’7(" /2 5+ 3&"+ 4/3*’, -5+. +.( "+$+&+(" /% %&’(" $’’/-518 5+9 I/ %(5+(%$+() *(%2(4+5/1 /2 $1 $**($’ 51 +.( 3$11(% $10 -5+.51 +.( *(%5/0 *(%35++(0 6, ’$- 5" 3$10$+/%, $10 <&%5"054+5/1$’9 I.( %(b&5%(3(1+" 2/% *(%2(4+518 $1 $**($’ 3&"+) $" $ %&’() 6( "+%54+’, 2/’’/-(09 L&4. %(b&5%(3(1+" $%( 4/1"50(%(0 5105"*(1"$6’( 51+(%054+5/1" $8$51"+ 1((0’("" 0(’$," $10 $%( 1(4(""$%, 2/% +.( /%0(%’, 05"4.$%8( /2 +.( <&0545$’ 6&"51(""9 ]$5’&%( +/ *(%2(4+ +.( $**($’ %(10(%" +.( <&083(1+ /2 +.( 4/&%+ 251$’ $10 (;(4&+/%,9 N&"+ $" $ ’/"518 !

Upload: irish-domingo

Post on 25-Oct-2014

440 views

Category:

Documents


8 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

!""#$%

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

@5=(-5"()#6,#$7$5'518#/2#$#-%/18#/%#51$**%/*%5$+(#3/0(#/2#$**($')#+.(#*(+5+5/1#3(%5+"#$1#/&+%58.+#05"35""$'#*&%"&$1+#+/#B5%4&'$%#A/9#VXUT#-.54.#*%/750("#+.$+)#Y$1#$**($'#+$=(1#+/#(5+.(%#L&*%(3(#B/&%+#/%#+.(#B/&%+#/2#!**($'"#6,#+.(#-%/18#/%#51$**%/*%5$+(#3/0(#".$''#6( #05"35""(09Z> #[!ANFA #[D!\K# FA:JLIHFDL #!A:#BCALIHJBIFCA#BCMG!AK # @I:9 # >]CHMDH@K # [!ANFA # DAEFADDHFAE # !A:#BCALIHJBIFCA#BC9#@I:9W#79#[CACH!^@D#BCJHI#C]#!GGD!@L)#E9H9#A/9#P_QUSR)#](6%&$%,#PU)#VTTUW

!+ # +.( #/&+"(+) # 5+ #3&"+ #6( # "+$+(0# +.$+ #*(+5+5/1(%" #$0/*+(0 # +.(#-%/18#3/0(#/2#%(3(0,#51#6%518518#+.(#4$"(#6(2/%(#+.5"#B/&%+9# # F+# 5"#-(''X"(++'(0#+.$+#+.(#*%/*(%#%(4/&%"(#/2#$1#$88%5(7(0#*$%+,#+/#$""$5'#+.(#0(45"5/1#/2#+.(#B/&%+#/2#!**($'"#5"#+/#25'(#$#*(+5+5/1#2/%#%(75(-#/1#4(%+5/%$%5 #&10(%#H&'(#`a#/2#+.(#H&'("#/2#B/&%+9 # #I.(#H&'("#*%(4'&0("#%(4/&%"(#+/#+.(#"*(45$'#4575'#$4+5/1#/2#4(%+5/%$%5#52#$**($')#6,#-$,#/2#$#*(+5+5/1#2/%#%(75(-#5"#$7$5'$6'()#$"#+.(#%(3(05("#/2#$**($'#$10#4(%+5/%$%5#$%(#3&+&$'',#(;4'&"57(#$10#1/+#$'+(%1$+57(#/%#"&44(""57(9#>I!B@C^!A#]!H#D!LI#M!H?DIFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA#$10#]H!ABFLBC#K9#HCMJ!@:DO#79 # I[D # BCJHI # C] # !GGD!@L) #A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PRVSVT)###L(*+(36(%#PP)#VTTUW

I53(#$10#$8$51)#5+#.$"#6((1#.('0#+.$+#+.(#%58.+#+/#$**($'#5"#1/+#$#4/1"+5+&+5/1$'#%58.+)#6&+#$#3(%(#"+$+&+/%,#*%575'(8(9##[(14()#*$%+5("#-./#"((=#+/#$7$5'#+.(3"('7("#/2#5+&3&"+#4/3*',#-5+.#+.(#"+$+&+("#/%#%&'("#$''/-518#5+9# #I/#%(5+(%$+()#*(%2(4+5/1#/2#$1#$**($'#51#+.(#3$11(%#$10#-5+.51#+.(#*(%5/0#*(%35++(0#6,#'$-#5"#3$10$+/%,#$10#<&%5"054+5/1$'9##I.(#%(b&5%(3(1+" # 2/% # *(%2(4+518 # $1 # $**($' #3&"+) # $" # $ # %&'() # 6( # "+%54+',#2/''/-(09 # # L&4. # %(b&5%(3(1+" # $%( # 4/1"50(%(0 # 5105"*(1"$6'(#51+(%054+5/1"#$8$51"+#1((0'(""#0('$,"#$10#$%(#1(4(""$%,#2/%#+.(#/%0(%',#05"4.$%8( # /2 # +.( # <&0545$' # 6&"51(""9 # # ]$5'&%( # +/ # *(%2(4+ # +.( # $**($'#%(10(%"#+.(#<&083(1+#/2#+.(#4/&%+#251$'#$10#(;(4&+/%,9##N&"+#$"#$#'/"518#

!

Page 2: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

*$%+,#.$"#+.(#*%575'(8(#+/#25'(#$1#$**($'#-5+.51#+.(#*%("4%56(0#*(%5/0)#"/#0/("#+.(#-511(%#$'"/#.$7(#+.(#4/%%('$+57(#%58.+#+/#(1</,#+.(#251$'5+,#/2#+.(#0(45"5/19##I.&")#+.(#*%/*%5(+,#/2#+.(#3/1(+$%,#$-$%0"#/2#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#5"#$'%($0,#6510518#&*/1#+.5"#B/&%+)#3&4.#3/%(#-5+.#+.(#B/&%+#/2#!**($'"9 # >!A:HDc # N!MDL # MB^JHAFD # 79 # DJ@!@FC # E!AOCA) # DEFXM!A!EDHL)FAB9 #$10#D9 #E!AOCA) # FAB9# E9H9 #A/"9 #PQRTS`#d#PQRPPQ)#E9H9#A/"9#PR_UR`XRa)#L(*+(36(%#PR)#VTTUW

]%/3#+.(#533(05$+(',#b&/+(0#*%/1/&14(3(1+#/2#+.(#B/&%+#51#!")#*(+5+5/1(%e" #3(%(#25'518#/2 #+.(#M/+5/1#2/% #H(0&4+5/1#/2 #^/10#050#1/+#"&2254( # +/ #*(%2(4+ #.5" #$**($'9 # # #!" #4/%%(4+', # 2/&10#6,# +.(#$**(''$+(#4/&%+)#*(+5+5/1(%#25'(0#$#M/+5/1#2/%#H(0&4+5/1#/2#^/10#0$+(0#N&1(#V`)#PUUU#>-.54.#-$"#%(4(57(0#6,#+.(#$**(''$+(#4/&%+#/1#N&1(#VR)#PUUUW#$''(8518#251$145$'#4/1"+%$51+"#-5+./&+#"./-518#Y"&6"+$1+5$'#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#H&'("Z#/%#0(3/1"+%$+518#$#-5''5181(""#+/#$650(#6,#+.(#fHg&'("#6,#*/"+518#$#*$%+5$'#6/109Z##I.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#b&("+5/1(0#+.(#4/3*&+$+5/1#/2#+.(#3/1(+$%,#$-$%0 #!# 6$"5"#/2#+.(#4/3*&+$+5/1#/2#+.(#$3/&1+#/2#$**($'#6/10#050#1/+#(;4&"(#5+#2%/3# #*/"+518#$#6/10#51#$#%($"/1$6'(#$3/&1+#/%#-.$+#5+#6('5(7(0#+/#6(#+.(#4/%%(4+#$3/&1+9##>I[D#[DHFI!ED#[CID@#M!AF@!#79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#HJ]FAC#B9#H!hCA#FF)#!A:#FLM!D@#B9#\F@@!)#E9H9#A/"9###PRT`QRXQU)#L(*+(36(%#S)#VTTUW

• '#()*+($(*

H("*/10(1+#3$,#.$7(#$#*/51+# 51#$""(%+518#+.$+# 51#+.5"#4$"(#$#H&'(#_a#*(+5+5/1# 5"#$#-%/18#3/0(#/2 #$**($') #$"# # 510((0#+.(#-%5+ #/2#4(%+5/%$%5#5"#$1#(;+%$/%051$%,#%(3(0,)#$10#4(%+5/%$%5#<&%5"054+5/1#5"#1/+#+/#6(#(b&$+(0#-5+.#$**(''$+(#<&%5"054+5/19# #A(7(%+.('("")# #5+#5"#"(++'(0)#$"#$#8(1(%$'#*%/*/"5+5/1) #+.$+#+.(#$7$5'$65'5+,#/2#$1#$**($'#0/("#1/+#2/%(4'/"( # %(4/&%"(# +/# +.(#(;+%$/%051$%, #%(3(05(") #"&4.#$" ##$%&'(%)%'*$10#*%/.565+5/1) #-.(%(#$**($'# 5" #1/+#$0(b&$+(#/% #(b&$'',#6(1(2545$')#"*((0,#$10#"&22545(1+) # #$"#-.(%(# +.(#/%0(%" #/2 # +.(# +%5$' #4/&%+ #-(%(#5""&(0#51#(;4(""#/2#/%#-5+./&+#<&%5"054+5/1)#/%#+.(%(#5"#1((0#+/#*%/3*+',#%('5(7(#+.(#$88%5(7(0#*$%+,#2%/3#+.(#51<&%5/&"#(22(4+"#/2#+.(#$4+"#/2#$1#512(%5/%#4/&%+#/%#+%56&1$')#$+,9)#+.(#4/&%+#.$"#$&+./%5i(0#(;(4&+5/1#/2#+.(#<&083(1+9 # # # I.5" # B/&%+ # .$" # (7(1 # %(4/815i(0 # +.$+ # # $ # %(4/&%"( # +/#4(%+5/%$%5 # 5" # *%/*(% # 1/+ # /1', #-.(%( # +.(%( # 5" # $ # 4'($% # 0(*%57$+5/1 # /2#*(+5+5/1(%e"#2&10$3(1+$'#%58.+#+/#0&(#*%/4("")##6&+#"/#$'"/#-.(%(#/+.(%#"*(45$' # 45%4&3"+$14(" # -$%%$1+ # 533(05$+( # $10 #3/%( # 05%(4+ # $4+5/19#>GDCG@DeL # ^HC!:B!LIFAE>^CM^C # H!:KC # G[F@L9) # FAB9W # 7"9 # #I[D#LDBHDI!HK#C]#I[D #:DG!HIMDAI#C]#@!^CH#!A:#DMG@CKMDAI)#I[D#HDEFCA!@#:FHDBICH)#:C@D#HDEFCA#\FF)#$10#N!A:D@DCA#NJDO!A)#E9H9#A/9#PQU_aV)#M$,#R)#VTTUW

• ,)(*-)&!""%*-$)*+.&+/&)0#&12%#3

"

Page 3: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

!"#+/#+.(#/+.(%#8%/&10#45+(0#6,#*%57$+(#%("*/10(1+"e #4/&1"(')#"&2254(#5+#+/#"$,#+.$+#5+#-$"#$#6$%(#$''(8$+5/1#&1"&6"+$1+5$+(0#6,#$1,#*%//2#/%#$2250$75+#/2#3(%5+9#^("50(")#+.(,#4/&'0#.$7(#25'(0#+.(#*(+5+5/1#/1#+53(#-5+.#$#3/+5/1#+/#6(#$''/-(0#+/#'5+58$+( #'-*.(%/)*0)10$%'29#c.5'(#"/45$'#<&"+54(#%(b&5%("#+.$+#+.(#'$-#'//=#+(10(%',#/1#+.(#05"$07$1+$8(0#"(4+/%" # /2 # "/45(+,) # 1(5+.(% # +.( # %54. # 1/% # +.( # *//% # .$" # $ # '54(1"( # +/#05"%(8$%0#%&'("#/2#*%/4(0&%(9#I.(#2&10$3(1+$'#%&'(#/2#.&3$1#%('$+5/1"#(1</51" # (7(%,/1() # %(8$%0'("" # /2 # "+$10518 # 51 # '52() # +/ # 0&', # /6"(%7(#*%/4(0&%$'#%&'("#$"#$1#$"*(4+#/2#$4+518#-5+.#<&"+54()#857518#(7(%,/1(#.5"#0&( # $10 # /6"(%7518 # ./1("+, # $10 # 8//0 # 2$5+.9 # ]/% # 510((0) # -.5'(#+(4.154$'5+5("#"./&'0#1/+#&10&',#.$3*(%#/&%#b&("+#2/%#<&"+54()#/%0(%',#*%/4(0&%(#5"#(""(1+5$'#+/#+.(#"&44(""#/2#+.$+#b&("+#+/#-.54.#$''#4/&%+"#$%(#0(7/+(09#>@!EJA!#MDIIL#BCHGCH!IFCA#79#!HFDL#B9#B!!@!M#$10#EDH!@:FAD#DLEJDHH!)#E9H9#A/9#PRaVVT)#N&',#VQ)#VTTUW

• 4$)#&+/&5*%*.6

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e"#1/+54(#/2#$**($'#/1#V_#](6%&$%,#VTTP)#+.(#$**($'#-$"#4'($%',#25'(0#/&+#/2#+53(9##G(+5+5/1(%#.$0#+.&"#'/"+#5+"#%58.+#+/#$**($' # 2%/3#+.(#0(45"5/1#/2 #+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(% #$10#+.(#A@HB#"./&'0#.$7( # 05"35""(0 # 5+" # 1/+54( # /2 # $**($'9 # >B[!HIDH # B[DMFB!@ # !A:#BC!IFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA#7"9#[DH^DHI#I!A#$10#!M!@F!##LCALFAE)#E9H9#A/9#P_SRUP)#M$,#VP)#VTTUW##

• 4#%$7#8&5*%*.6&

c(#$8%((#-5+.#+.(#B/&%+#/2#!**($'"#+.$+#"514(#1/#51+(1+#+/#0('$,#+.(#$03515"+%$+5/1#/2#<&"+54(#4/&'0#6(#$++%56&+(0#+/#E&513$*$18)#$#/1(#0$,#0('$,#0/("#1/+#<&"+52,#+.(#$**($'e"#0(15$'9# #M/%(#53*/%+$1+',)#+.(#B/&%+ # /2 # !**($'" # 0(4'$%(0 # +.$+ #E&513$*$18e" # $**($') # /1 # 5+" # 2$4()#$**($%"#+/#6(#53*%(""(0#-5+.#3(%5+9 # #I.(#4/1"+5+&+5/1$' #3$10$+(#+/#$44/%0#2&''#*%/+(4+5/1#+/#'$6/%#$10#+/#"$2(8&$%0#+.(#(3*'/,((e"#3($1"#/2#'57('5.//0#"./&'0#6(#857(1#*%/*(%#$++(1+5/1#$10#"$14+5/19##!#8%($+(%#51<&"+54(#3$,#/44&%#52#"$50#$**($'#5"#1/+#857(1#0&(#4/&%"(#+.$1#52#+.(#%(8'(3(1+$%,#*(%5/0#+/#$**($'#-(%(#"+%54+',#2/''/-(09##F1#+.5"#4$"()#-(#$%(#514'51(0#+/#(;4&"(#+.(#/1(#0$,#0('$,#51#/%0(%#+/#2&'',#"(++'(#+.(#3(%5+"#/2#+.(#4$"(9# #I.5"# 5" # 51# '51(#-5+.#/&%#*/'54,#+/#(14/&%$8(#2&''#

#

Page 4: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

$0<&054$+5/1 # /2 # +.( # 3(%5+" # /2 # $1 # $**($'9# >HDGJ^@FB # BDMDAI#BCHGCH!IFCA#79#GDIDH#F9#EJFAM!G!AE)#E9H9#A/9#P_RUPT)#!&8&"+#V`)#VTTUW#

• !""#$%&9+.8

!+#+.(#+53(#/2#+.(#25'518#/2#+.(#"&%(+,#6/10#6,#GNF #/1# N$1&$%,#V)#VTTS)#GG!B#-$"#"+5''#$1#$44%(05+(0#6/10518#4/3*$1,9#I.&")#5+#-$"#6&+#*%/*(%#+/#./1/%#+.(#$**($'#6/10#5""&(0#6,#$#6/10518#4/3*$1,#0&', # $44%(05+(0 #6, # +.5" #B/&%+ #$+ # +.( # +53( #/2 # 5+" # 5""&$14(9 # # I.(#"&6"(b&(1+ # %(7/4$+5/1 # /2 # +.( # $&+./%5+, # /2 # $ # 6/10518 # 4/3*$1,#"./&'0 # 1/+ # *%(<&054( # *$%+5(" # -./ # %('5(0 # /1 # 5+" # $&+./%5+,9 # # I.(#%(7/4$+5/1 #/2 # $&+./%5+, #/2 # $ #6/10518 #4/3*$1, # 5" #*%/"*(4+57( # 51#$**'54$+5/19#>BDL!HFC#@9#:D@#HCL!HFC#79#G[F@FGGFAD#NCJHA!@FLIL)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#PRPaP_)#!&8&"+#PU)#VTTUW

c.5'(#+.(#6/10#3$,#6(#%(0&4(0#&*/1#3/+5/1#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(%)#+.5"#5"#"&6<(4+#+/#+.(#4/105+5/1"#+.$+#>PW#+.(#3/+5/1#+/#%(0&4(#+.(#6/10#".$'' # 6( # 6$"(0 # /1 #:#(*)+(*+23 & 6(+2.83j # $10 # >VW # $ #(#$3+.$;%#&$:+2.)#51#%('$+5/1#+/#+.(#3/1(+$%,#$-$%0#5"#*/"+(0#6,#+.(#$**(''$1+)#/+.(%-5"(#+.(#25'518#/2#+.(#3/+5/1#+/#%(0&4(#6/10#".$'' #1/+#"+/*#+.(#%&11518#/2#+.(#*(%5/0#+/#*(%2(4+#$1#$**($'9##I.(#b&$'5254$+5/1#(22(4+57(',#%(b&5%("#+.$+#&1'(""#+.(#A@HB#8%$1+"#+.(#%(0&4+5/1#/2#+.(#4$".#6/10#-5+.51 # +.( # PT # 0$, # %(8'(3(1+$%, # *(%5/0) #)0# & #:"%+7#( & *3 & 3)*%%&#<"#-)#8 & )+ &"+3) & )0# &-$30 &+( &32(#)7 &;+.8 &3#-2(*.6 &)0# &!"##$$:+2.) & =*)0*. & )0# & 3$*8 & >?@8$7 & "#(*+89## F2 # +.( # A@HB # 0/("#(7(1+&$'', # 8%$1+ # +.( # 3/+5/1 # 2/% # %(0&4+5/1 # $2+(% # +.( # %(8'(3(1+$%,#*(%5/0#.$"#('$*"(0)#+.(#4/%%(4+#%('5(2#-/&'0#6(#+/#%(0&4(#+.(#4$".#/%#"&%(+,#6/10#$'%($0,#*/"+(0#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(%#-5+.51#+.(#PTX0$,#*(%5/09#>!A:HDc#N!MDL#MB^JHAFD#79#DJ@!@FC#E!AOCA)#DEFXM!A!EDHL)FAB9#$10#D9#E!AOCA)#FAB9#E9H9#A/"9#PQRTS`#d#PQRPPQ)#E9H9#A/"9#PR_UR`XRa)#L(*+(36(%#PR)#VTTUW

F1#$005+5/1)#-.5'(#+.(#6/10#%(b&5%(3(1+#/1#$**($'"#517/'7518#$#3/1(+$%,#$-$%0#.$"#6((1#%('$;(0#51#4(%+$51#4$"(")#+.5"#4$1#/1',#6(#0/1(#-.(%(#+.(%(#-$"#"&6"+$1+5$'#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#H&'("j#/%#-.(%(#+.( # $**(''$1+") # $+ # +.( # 7(%, # '($"+) # (;.565+(0 # -5''5181("" # +/ # *$, # 6,#*/"+518#$#*$%+5$'#6/109#>#@C@FI!#!9#@CGDO)#DI9#$'9)#7"9# # #kJDOCA#BFIK#LGCHIL#B@J^)#FAB9)E9H9#A/9##P_`TSV)#N$1&$%,#PU)#VTTUW

I.(#0(45"5/1")#$-$%0"#/%#/%0(%"#/2#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#$%(#251$'#$10#(;(4&+/%,#&1'(""#$**($'(0#+/#+.(#A@HB#6,#$1,#*$%+5("#-5+.51#+(1#>PTW#4$'(10$% # 0$," # 2%/3 # %(4(5*+ # +.(%(/2) # -5+. # *%//2 # /2 # *$,3(1+ # /2 # +.(#%(b&5%(0#$**($'#2((#$44/3*$15(0#6,#$#3(3/%$10&3#/2#$**($'9# #!10#-.(%() #$" #.(%() # +.( #<&083(1+# 517/'7("# 3/1(+$%,# $-$%0) #$1 #$**($'#

$

Page 5: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+.(%(2%/3#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(%#3$,#6(#Y*(%2(4+(0#/1',#&*/1#+.(#*/"+518#/2#$# 4$".# /%# "&%(+,# 6/109Z# #!#3(%(#1/+54(#/2#$**($'#-5+./&+#4/3*',518#-5+.#+.(#/+.(%#%(b&5"5+("#3(1+5/1(0#0/("#1/+#"+/*#+.(#%&11518#/2#+.(#*(%5/0#2/%#*(%2(4+518#$1#$**($'#$"#51#2$4+# #1/#3/+5/1#2/%#(;+(1"5/1#/2#"$50 # *(%5/0 # 5" # $''/-(09 # >c!@@DM # M!HFIFMD # LDH\FBDL) # FAB9 # $10#LB!A:FB#L[FGM!A!EDMDAI#@FMFID:#79# DHF^DHIC#L9#^J@IHCA)# E9H9#A/9#PRaV_P)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

I.(#*&%*/"(#/2#$1#$**($'#6/10#5"#+/#(1"&%()#0&%518#+.(#*(%5/0#/2#$**($')#$8$51"+#$1,#/44&%%(14(#+.$+#-/&'0#0(2($+#/%#053515".#%(4/7(%,#6, # +.( # $88%5(7(0 # (3*'/,((" # &10(% # +.( # <&083(1+ # 52 # "&6"(b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e"##-5''5181(""#+/#*$,#+.(#<&083(1+#$3/&1+9# #>GDCG@DeL#^HC!:B!LIFAE>^CM^C#H!:KC#G[F@L9)#FAB9W # 7"9 # #I[D # LDBHDI!HK # C] # I[D #:DG!HIMDAI #C] # @!^CH # !A:#DMG@CKMDAI) # I[D # HDEFCA!@ # :FHDBICH) # :C@D # HDEFCA # \FF) # $10#N!A:D@DCA#NJDO!A)#E9H9#A/9#PQU_aV)#M$,#R)#VTTUW########################!))+(.#7A3&5##3

]51$'',)#+.(#B/&%+#/7(%%&'("#+.(#0('(+5/1#6,#+.(#A@HB#/2#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%e"#$-$%0#2/%#$++/%1(,e"#2(("#+/#*(+5+5/1(%9##G(+5+5/1(%#5"#(750(1+',#(1+5+'(0 # +/ # $++/%1(,e" # 2((") # "514( # .S( #-$" # 4/3*(''(0 # +/ # '5+58$+( # +/#*%/+(4+#.5"#51+(%("+#6,#%($"/1#/2#&1<&"+525(0#$10#&1'$-2&'#+(%351$+5/1#/2#.5"#(3*'/,3(1+#6,#%("*/10(1+"#BB^G#$10#I$8&56$/9#>DHcFA#[9#HDKDL#79 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA) # E9H9 # A/9 # PRTaaP)#](6%&$%,#PT)#VTTUW

B/1"50(%518#+.$+#!++,9#E/#"&44(""2&'',#%(*%("(1+(0#.5"#4'5(1+)#5+#5"#/1', #*%/*(% # +.$+ # .( # "./&'0 # %(4(57( #$0(b&$+( # 4/3*(1"$+5/1 # 2/% # .5"#(22/%+"9#D7(1#$"#-(#$8%((#-5+.#+.(#%(0&4+5/1#/2#+.(#$-$%0#/2#$++/%1(,l"#2((" # 6, # +.( # B!) # +.( # 2$4+ # +.$+ # $ # '$-,(% # *'$," # $ # 75+$' # %/'( # 51 # +.(#$03515"+%$+5/1 #/2 # <&"+54( #(3*.$"5i(" # +.( #1((0#+/ #"(4&%( # +/ #.53#.5"#./1/%$%5&3#'$-2&'',#($%1(0#$"#$#3($1"#+/#*%("(%7(#+.(#0(4/%&3#$10#%("*(4+$65'5+,#/2#+.(#'(8$'#*%/2(""5/19#!#'$-,(%#5"#$"#3&4.#(1+5+'(0#+/#<&0545$'#*%/+(4+5/1#$8$51"+#51<&"+54(#/%#53*/"5+5/1#/2#2%$&0#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#

%

Page 6: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

.5"#4'5(1+#$"#+.(#4'5(1+#5"#$8$51"+#$6&"(#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#.5"#4/&1"('9#I.(#0&+,#/2#+.(#4/&%+#5"#1/+#$'/1(#+/#(1"&%(#+.$+#$#'$-,(%#$4+"#51#$#*%/*(%#$10#'$-2&'#3$11(%)#6&+#$'"/#+/#"((#+.$+#$#'$-,(%#5"#*$50#.5"#<&"+#2(("9#c5+.#.5"#4$*5+$'#4/1"5"+518#/2#.5"#6%$51"#$10#-5+.#.5"#"=5''#$4b&5%(0#$+#+%(3(10/&"#4/"+#1/+#/1',# 51#3/1(,#6&+# 51#(;*(105+&%(#/2 #+53(#$10#(1(%8,)#.(#5"#(1+5+'(0#+/#+.(#*%/+(4+5/1#/2#$1,#<&0545$'#+%56&1$'#$8$51"+#$1,#$++(3*+#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#.5"#4'5(1+#+/#("4$*(#*$,3(1+#/2#.5"# <&"+#4/3*(1"$+5/19#F+#-/&'0#6(#5%/154#52#$2+(%#*&++518#2/%+.#+.(#6("+#51#.53#+/#"(4&%( # <&"+54( # 2/% # .5" # 4'5(1+) # .( # .53"('2 # -/&'0 # 1/+ # 8(+ # .5" # 0&(9#>D\!AED@FA!#M!LMJ:#>$"#"&6"+5+&+(#4/3*'$51$1+# 2/% #!@Dm!A:DH#N9#M!LMJ:W # 79 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA) # E9H9 # A/9#PRSSRa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTUW

M/%(/7(%)#51#4$"("#2/%#%(4/7(%,#/2#-$8(")#+.(#$-$%0#/2#$++/%1(,l"#2(("#5"#*%/*(%#$10#+.(%(#1((0#1/+#6(#$1,#"./-518#+.$+#+.(#(3*'/,(%#$4+(0#3$'545/&"',#/%# 51#6$0#2$5+.#-.(1#5+ #-5+..('0#+.(#-$8("9#I.(%(#1((0 # /1', # 6( # $ # "./-518 # +.$+ # +.( # '$-2&' # -$8(" # -(%( # 1/+ # *$50#$44/%0518',9#>^!HCA#HDGJ^@FB#I[D!IHFB!@#\9#ACHMFI!#G9#GDH!@I!#(+#$')#E9H9#A/9#PQTaVa)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

F1 # +.( # 4$"( # $+ # 6$%) # -( # 2510 # +.$+ # +.( # 2'58.+ # $++(10$1+" # -(%(#%(*%("(1+(0#6,#%("*/10(1+#&15/1#-.54.)#51#+&%1)#(18$8(0#+.(#"(%754("#/2 # 5+" #/-1#4/&1"('9 # #I.(# 2'58.+ #$++(10$1+" #.$0#$ #4/33/1#4$&"(#/2#$4+5/19##c.5'(#+.(#-/%=#*(%2/%3(0#6,#%("*/10(1+e"#4/&1"('#-$"#6,#1/#3($1"#"53*'()#"((518#$"#5+#"*$11(0#+.(#-./'(#'5+58$+5/1#2%/3#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(% # "+$8( # $'' # +.( # -$, # +/ # +.5" # B/&%+) # 1(7(%+.('("") # +.( # 5""&("#517/'7(0#51#+.5"#4$"(#$%(#"53*'()#$10#+.(#'(8$'#"+%$+(85(")#+.(/%5("#$10#$%8&3(1+"#$07$14(0#-(%(#4/33/1#2/%#$''#+.(#$22(4+(0#4%(-#3(36(%"9#[(14()# 5+ #3$,#1/+ #6(#%($"/1$6'(#+/#$-$%0#"$50#4/&1"(' #$1#$3/&1+#(b&57$'(1+ # +/ #PTn#/2 #$'' #3/1(+$%, #$-$%0" # +/ #6( # %(4(57(0 #6, #($4.#5105750&$'#2'58.+#$++(10$1+9##^$"(0#/1#+.(#'(18+.#/2#+53(#+.$+#+.5"#4$"(#.$"#6((1#'5+58$+(0)#./-(7(%)#-(#2510#+.$+#+.(#$3/&1+#/2#GV)TTT)TTT9TT#5" # %($"/1$6'( # $" # $++/%1(,e" # 2(("9 # # I.5" # $3/&1+ # "./&'0 # 514'&0( # $''#(;*(1"("#/2#'5+58$+5/1#+.$+#-(%(#514&%%(0#6,#%("*/10(1+#&15/19#>]@FE[I#!IIDA:!AIL # !A: # LIDc!H:L # !LLCBF!IFCA # C] # I[D # G[F@FGGFADL#>]!L!GW)#79 #G[F@FGGFAD#!FH@FADL)#FAB9)G!IHF!#B[FCAE#$10#BCJHI#C]#!GGD!@L)E9H9#A/9#PQRTRS)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

I.(#4'$53#2/%#$++/%1(,e"#2(("#5"#8%$1+(0#2/''/-518#!%+54'(#VVTR#/2#+.(#A(-#B575'#B/0(#-.54.#$''/-"#5+"#%(4/7(%,#51#$4+5/1"#2/%#%(4/7(%,#/2#-$8(" # /2 # '$6/%(%" # $10 # $4+5/1" # 2/% # 510(315+, # &10(% # +.( # (3*'/,(%l"#'5$65'5+, # '$-"9 # # I.( # "$3( # 2((" # $%( # $'"/ # %(4/7(%$6'( # -.(1 # +.(#0(2(10$1+l" # $4+ # /% # /35""5/1 # .$" # 4/3*(''(0 # +.( # *'$51+522 # +/ # 514&%#(;*(1"("#+/#*%/+(4+#.5"#51+(%("+# $"#51#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"(#2/''/-518#+.(#%(2&"$' # 6, # %("*/10(1+ # +/ # "(++'( # .5" # 4'$53"9 # # G&%"&$1+ # +/ # *%(7$5'518#<&%5"*%&0(14()#*(+5+5/1(%#5"#(1+5+'(0#+/#$++/%1(,e"#2(("#/2#+(1#*(%4(1+#

&

Page 7: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

>PTnW #/2 # +.( #3/1(+$%, #$-$%09# >@DCGC@:C#!^!AID# #79 #?NEL#]@DDI#M!A!EDMDAI#M!AF@!#E9H9#A/9#PRV`ST)#:(4(36(%#`)#VTTUW

9$-B=$6#3

C1(#/2#+.(#1$+&%$'#4/1"(b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e" # 5''(8$' #05"35""$' #&*#+/# +.(#+53(#/2 #$4+&$' # %(51"+$+(3(1+9#I.(%(#4$1#6(#1/#8$*#/%#51+(%%&*+5/1)#'("+#-(#0(2($+#+.(#7(%,#%($"/1#/2#+.(#'$-#51#8%$1+518#+.(#"$3(9##I.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#050#1/+#533(05$+(',#25'(#.5"#B/3*'$51+#"./&'0#1/+#$22(4+#/%#053515".#.5"#%58.+#+/#6$4=-$8(")#2/%#5+#5"#$#%58.+#4'($%',#8%$1+(0#+/#.53#6,#'$-#XX#"./&'0#.(#6(#2/&10#+/#.$7(#6((1#5''(8$'',#05"35""(0#XX#$10#2/%#$"#'/18#$"#.5"#4$&"(#/2#$4+5/1#.$"#1/+#6((1#6$%%(0#6, #*%("4%5*+5/19 # >DHcFA#[9 #HDKDL#79 #A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PRTaaP)#](6%&$%,#PT)#VTTUW

[(#1(7(%#6/+.(%(0#+/#%(0((3#.5"#'54(1"(#$+#+.(#"//1("+#*/""56'(#+53(#-.(1#+.(%(#-$"#1/#"./-518#+.$+#.(#-$"#&1'$-2&'',#*%(7(1+(0#6,#%("*/10(1+#2%/3#0/518#"/9#I.&")#*(+5+5/1(%#"./&'0#1/+#6(#*$50#2/%#+.(#+53(#.(#-$"#1/+#-/%=5189#I.(#B/&%+#.$"#.('0#+.$+#-.(%(#+.(#2$5'&%(#/2#(3*'/,(("#+/#-/%=#-$"#1/+#0&(#+/#+.(#(3*'/,(%l"#2$&'+)#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#(4/1/354#'/""#"&22(%(0#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(("#"./&'0#1/+#6(#".52+(0#+/#+.(#(3*'/,(%9 #D$4.#*$%+,#3&"+#6($%#.5"#/-1#'/""9# F+ #-/&'0#6(#&12$5%# +/#$''/-#*(+5+5/1(%#+/#%(4/7(%#"/3(+.518#.(#.$"#1/+#($%1(0#$10#4/&'0#1/+#.$7(#($%1(0)#"514(#.(#4/&'0#1/+#05"4.$%8(#.5"#-/%=#$"#$#0%57(%#-5+./&+#.5"#0%57(%l"#'54(1"(9#H("*/10(1+#"./&'0#6(#(;(3*+(0#2%/3#+.(#6&%0(1#/2 #*$,518#6$4=-$8("9 #>^DHA!H:FAC#\9 #A!\!HHC#79 #G9\9 #G!N!HF@@C#@FADH)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_`_RP)#!*%5'#V`)#VTTUW

92(8#.&+/&C(++/

F1#+(%351$+5/1#4$"(")#+.(#(3*'/,(%#6($%"#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%/7518#+.$+#+.(#05"35""$'#/2#+.(#(3*'/,((#5"#2/%#$#<&"+#/%#$1#$&+./%5i(0#4$&"(9#]$5'&%(#+/#05"*/"(#/2#+.(#6&%0(1#-/&'0#53*',#+.$+#+.(#05"35""$'#5"#1/+#'$-2&')#$10#+.$+#+.(#(3*'/,((#5"#(1+5+'(0#+/#%(51"+$+(3(1+)#6$4=#-$8("#$10 # $44%&518 # 6(1(25+"9 # # M/%(/7(%) # 05"35""(0 # (3*'/,((" # $%( # 1/+#%(b&5%(0 # +/ # *%/7( # +.(5% # 511/4(14( # /2 # +.( # (3*'/,(%e" # $44&"$+5/1"#$8$51"+ # +.(39 # >L!A # MFEJD@ # BCHGCH!IFCA # 7"9 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH#HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA # !A: # cF@@F!M # @9 # ]HFDA:) # NH9)# E9H9 # A/9#PaSURS)#M$,#V_)#VTTUW

'

Page 8: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

!"#$#8(1(%$'#%&'()#/1(#-./#*'($0"#*$,3(1+#.$"#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%/7518 # 5+9 #D7(1#-.(%( # +.( #(3*'/,(( #3&"+ #$''(8(#1/1*$,3(1+) # +.(#8(1(%$' # %&'( # 5" # +.$+ # +.( # 6&%0(1 # %("+" # /1 # +.( # (3*'/,(% # +/ # *%/7(#*$,3(1+) # %$+.(% # +.$1 #/1 # +.( #(3*'/,(( # +/ #*%/7( #1/1*$,3(1+9 # I.(#%($"/1 # 2/% # +.( # %&'( # 5" # +.$+ # +.( # *(%+51(1+ # *(%"/11(' # 25'(") # *$,%/''")#%(4/%0")#%(35++$14("#$10#/+.(%#"535'$%#0/4&3(1+"#o#-.54.#-5''#"./-#+.$+#/7(%+53()#0522(%(1+5$'")#"(%754(#514(1+57(#'($7(#$10#/+.(%#4'$53"#/2#-/%=(%"#.$7(#6((1#*$50#o#$%(#1/+#51#+.(#*/""(""5/1#/2#+.(#(3*'/,((#6&+#51#+.(#4&"+/0,#$10#$6"/'&+(#4/1+%/'#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%9#L514(#51#+.(#4$"(#$+#6$%#*(+5+5/1(%#4/3*$1,#.$"#1/+#"./-1#$1,#*%//2#/2#*$,3(1+#/2#+.( #4/%%(4+ #$3/&1+ #/2 # "$'$%,) #./'50$, #*$,#$10 #PS+.# 3/1+. #*$,) #-(#$225%3#+.(#$-$%0#/2 #M$0%5$8$e"#3/1(+$%,#4'$53"9#>M!AI@D#IH!:FAE#LDH\FBDL)#FABCHGCH!ID:#!A:pCH#^C^^K#:D@#HCL!HFC#79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH #HD@!IFCAL #BCMMFLLFCA # $10 # G!^@C # L9 #M!:HF!E!)E9H9 #A/9#P__QTa)N&',#VR)VTTUW

H("*(4+518#+.(#5""&(#/2#5''(8$'#05"35""$')#+.(#B/&%+#$**%(45$+("#1/ # (750(14( # +.$+ # *(+5+5/1(% #-$" # 05"35""(09 # #c.$+ # 5+ # 2510" # 5" # +.$+#*(+5+5/1(% # &15'$+(%$'', # "+/**(0 # %(*/%+518 # 2/% # -/%= # 6(2/%( # 25'518 # $#4/3*'$51+#2/%#5''(8$'#05"35""$')#6$"(0#/1#.5"#6('5(2#+.$+#E&5''(%3/#$10#^(%8/15$#.$0#"*%($0#%&3/%"#+.$+#.5"#+%$1"$4+5/1"#/1#6(.$'2#/2#^!KDH#-/&'0#1/#'/18(%#6(#./1/%(0#$"#/2#!*%5'#ST)#VTTV9##I.5"#6('5(2#%(3$51"#<&"+#+.$+#q#5+#5"#&1"&6"+$1+5$+(09##c.5'(#51#4$"("#/2#5''(8$'#05"35""$')#+.(#(3*'/,(%#6($%"#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%/7518#+.$+#+.(#05"35""$'#5"#2/%#$#7$'50#/%#$&+./%5i(0#4$&"()#+.(#(3*'/,((#3&"+#25%"+#("+$6'5".#6,#"&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14( # +.( # 2$4+ # /2 # 05"35""$'9 # # # #>H!MK # E!@@DEC # 79 # ^!KDH#G[F@FGGFADL)#FAB9)#:!AGFA#EJF@@DHMC)#GHC:JBI#FM!ED#M!H?DIFAE)#FAB9)#$10#D:E!H:C#^DHECAF!)#E9H9#A/9#PQURTQ)#N&',#SP)#VTTUW

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`#1(-#(3*'/,(("#$""581(0#51#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%l"#"+/%("#'/4$+(0#51#+.(#0522(%(1+#*'$4("#/2#+.(#4/&1+%,9##>DMBCH#FABCHGCH!ID:#79#M!9#@CJH:DL#:9#LFDADL)#E9H9#A/9#PaVPTP)#L(*+(36(%#R)#VTTUW

# F+#5"#-(''X"(++'(0#+.$+#51#+(%351$+5/1#4$"(")#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%//2#%("+"#&*/1#+.(#(3*'/,(%#+/#"./-#+.$+#+.(#05"35""$'#-$"#2/%#$#<&"+#$10#7$'50#4$&"(#$10#2$5'&%(#+/#05"4.$%8(#+.(#"$3(#-/&'0#3($1#+.$+#+.(#05"35""$'#5"#1/+#<&"+525(0#$10#+.(%(2/%(#5''(8$'9# #[(14()#51#$%8&518#+.$+#L$6&'$/#$6$10/1(0#.5"#-/%=)#5+#5"#514&36(1+#&*/1#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%"#+/#*%/7(r # >PW # +.$+ # +.(#(3*'/,((#2$5'(0#+/# %(*/%+ # 2/% #-/%=#/% #.$0#6((1#

(

Page 9: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

$6"(1+#-5+./&+#7$'50#/%#<&"+525$6'(#%($"/1j#$10#>VW#+.$+#+.(%(#3&"+#.$7(#6((1#$#4'($%#51+(1+5/1#+/#"(7(%#+.(#(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*#$"#3$152("+(0#6,#"/3(#/7(%+#$4+"9# #B'($%',)# <&%5"*%&0(14(#054+$+("#+.$+#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%//2#+/#"./-#+.$+#+.(%(#-$"#&1<&"+525(0#%(2&"$'#+/#8/#6$4=#+/#-/%=#%("+"#/1#+.(#(3*'/,(%9#>I!B@C^!A#]!H#D!LI#M!H?DIFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA # $10 # ]H!ABFLBC # K9 # HCMJ!@:DO # 79 # I[D # BCJHI # C]#!GGD!@L)#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PRVSVT)#L(*+(36(%#PP)#VTTUW

'$23#&+/&!-)*+.

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cCH?DHL#JAFCAXGIEcC#@CB!@#B[!GIDH#A/9#RSV)#E9H9#A/9#P_Q`V_)#N$1&$%,#PV)#VTTUW'*(-2:D#.)*+.&+/&)0#&E$=&

A/+$6',) # *%57$+( # %("*/10(1+e" # *&%*/%+(0 # (3*'/,3(1+ # -5+.#M!AHD:#4/33(14(0#/1',# 51#PUU_) #-$,#$2+(%#".(#-$"#.5%(0#6,#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%#$"#(;+%$#6(7(%$8(#$++(10$1+#/1#!*%5'#V`)#PUUa9#I.(%(#5"#+.&"#3&4. # 4%(0(14( # 51 # +.( # *%57$+( # %("*/10(1+e" # 4'$53 # +.$+ # +.( # "(%754(#$8%((3(1+#(;(4&+(0#6(+-((1#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%#$10#M!AHD:#5"#$#3(%(#*'/,#+/#45%4&37(1+#+.(#'$-#/1#(3*'/,3(1+) # 51#*$%+54&'$%#+.$+#-.54.#*(%+$51"#/1#%(8&'$%5i$+5/19 #>M!H!A!c#[CID@L#!A:#HDLCHI#BCHG#7"#BCJHI # C] # !GGD!@L) # L[DHK@ # C!^D@ # !A: # M!AF@! # HDLCJHBD#:D\D@CGMDAI#BCHG9)#E9H9#A/9#P`U__T)#N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

'+%%#-)*D#&9$(6$*.*.6&!6(##:#.)&F'9!G

F2 # +.(#+(%3"#/2 #$#B^!#$%(#4'($% #$10#.$7(#1/#0/&6+ #&*/1#+.(#51+(1+5/1 # /2 # +.( # 4/1+%$4+518 # *$%+5(") # $" # 51 # +.( # .(%(51 # b&("+5/1(0#*%/75"5/1)#+.(#'5+(%$'#3($1518#+.(%(/2#".$''#*%(7$5'9##I.$+#5"#"(++'(09##!"#"&4.)#+.(#0$5',X*$50#(3*'/,(("#3&"+#6(#*$50#+.(5%#%(8&'$%#"$'$%5("#/1#

)

Page 10: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+.( # ./'50$," # -.54. # $%( # "/ # 0(4'$%(0 # 6, # +.( # 1$+5/1$' # 8/7(%13(1+)#%(8$%0'(""#/2#-.(+.(%#+.(,#2$''#/1#%("+#0$,"9##

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c!AE # GFA!E?!FL!XH]M # >?!MGFXA!]@JX?MJW#$10#L!A:FE!A#!I#JEA!K!A#AE#M!AEE!E!c!AE#GFA!E?!FL!XL]F#>LJM!GFXA!]@JX?MJW)#E9H9#A/9#P_VSV`)#](6%&$%,#`)#VTTUW

'+:"$.7&C+%*-7

!" # %("*/10(1+" # 4%(05+$6', # (;*'$51(0) # $10 # $" # $035++(0 # 6,#*(+5+5/1(% # .(%"('2) # %("*/10(1+" # .$7( # "+$10518 # */'545(" # +.$+ # $1#(3*'/,(( #3&"+ #6( #"518'( #$+ # +.( # +53(#/2 #(3*'/,3(1+ #$10#3&"+ #6(#-5''518 # +/ # 6( # $""581(0 # +/ # $1, # /2 # 5+" # 6%$14.(" # 51 # +.( # 4/&1+%,9##G(+5+5/1(%e"#4/1+(1+5/1#+.$+#&*/1#8(++518#3$%%5(0)#".(#1/#'/18(%#6/&10#.(%"('2#+/#6(#$""581(0#+/#$1,#/2#%("*/10(1+"e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e" # +%$1"*/%+$+5/1 # $10 # '/08518#(;*(1"("9 # G(+5+5/1(% # 1(7(% # 05"*&+(0 # +.("( # 3$++(%"9## I.(%( # 5" # 1/#"./-518 # (5+.(% # +.$+ # *(+5+5/1(%e" # +%$1"2(% # -$" # /1', # 6(518 # &"(0 # 6,#%("*/10(1+"#+/#4$3/&2'$8(#$#"515"+(%#"4.(3(#/2#3$1$8(3(1+#+/#%50#5+"('2#/2#$1#&10("5%$6'(#-/%=(%#51#+.(#*(%"/1#/2#*(+5+5/1(%9 #>!F@DDA#E9#[DHF:! # 79 # ] # d # B # G!cAL[CG # $10 # NDcD@HK # LICHDpM!HBD@FAC#]@CHDID)#NH9)#E9H9#A/9#PQV_TP)#!*%5'#P_)#VTTUW

'+:"2)$)*+.&+/&!=$(8

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

!*

Page 11: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

>VW#,($%"#2%/3#+.(#251$'5+,#/2#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%e"#0(45"5/1) #+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#4/%%(4+',#514'&0(0#+.$+#51#5+"#/%0(%#/2#(;(4&+5/19#I.&")#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%e"#/%0(%#/2#(;(4&+5/1#"53*',#4/7(%(0#+.(#4/%%(4+#4/3*&+$+5/1#/2#-$8("#$10#/+.(%#*$,3(1+"#(1</,(0#6,#*(+5+5/1(%e"#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,(("9#>G[F@FGGFAD#@CAE#:FLI!ABD#ID@DG[CAD#BCMG!AK#79#HFO!@FA!#H!JI)#@DF@!#DMA!BD#$10#EFA!#B!GFLIH!AC)#E9H9#A/9#PQ`VTU)# # #!&8&"+#Va)#VTTUW

I.5"#B/&%+#1/+("#+.$+#+.(#A@HB#$-$%0(0#6$4=-$8(")#PS+.#3/1+.#*$,)#$10#"(%754(#514(1+57(#'($7(#*$,#2%/3#N&',#PT)#VTTa#+/#N$1&$%,#VS)#VTTQ#/1',9##F+#5"#(750(1+#+.$+#+.("(#"./&'0#1/+#6(#'535+(0#+/#"$50#*(%5/09#I.("(#"./&'0#6(#4/3*&+(0#2%/3#+.(#0$+(#/2#.(%#5''(8$'#05"35""$'#&1+5'#+.5" # 0(45"5/1 # $++$51" # 251$'5+,9 # # I./&8. # ^/'$1/" # 050 # 1/+ # $**($' # +.(#4/3*&+$+5/1#/2#+.(#A@HBe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b&(14(#/2#+.(#2510518#+.$+#%("*/10(1+#-$"#5''(8$'',#05"35""(0#6,#*(+5+5/1(%"9#>[DA@FA#G!A!K#BCMG!AK##79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#)#E9H9#A/9#PRTQPR)#C4+/6(%#VS)#VTTUW

'+.-%23*D#.#33&+/&H286:#.)

89'%79# #I.(#3$++(%#/2#(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*#.$"#6((1#%("/'7(0#-5+.#251$'5+,#6,#+.(#L(4%(+$%,#/2#@$6/%#$10#D3*'/,3(1+#51#+.(#H("/'&+5/1#0$+(0#:(4(36(%#VQ)#VTTV9##L514(#*(+5+5/1(%#050#1/+#$**($'#+.5"#2$4+&$'#2510518)#+.(1)#5+#3$,#6(#4/1"50(%(0#$"#+.(#251$'#%("/'&+5/1#/2#"&4.#5""&(9# #I/#%(5+(%$+()#Y4/14'&"57(1(""#/2#<&083(1+Z#.$"#+.(#(22(4+#/2 # *%(4'&"5/1 # /2 # 5""&("9# >B[HFL #E!HMDAIL #BCHGCH!IFCA # 7" #[CA9#G!IHFBF! #!9 # LIC9 # ICM!L #$10 #B[HFL #E!HMDAIL #cCH?DHL #JAFCAXGIEcC#@CB!@#B[!GIDH#A/9#RSV)#E9H9#A/9#P_Q`V_)#N$1&$%,#PV)#VTTUW

'+.)*.6#.)&5##

B/1+518(1+#2((#4/1+%$4+"#$%(#"&6<(4+#+/#+.(#"&*(%75"5/1#$10#4'/"(#"4%&+51,#/2#+.(#4/&%+#51#/%0(%#+.$+#4'5(1+"#3$,#6(#*%/+(4+(0#2%/3#&1<&"+#4.$%8("9#I.(#$3/&1+#/2#4/1+518(1+#2(("#$8%((0#&*/1#6,#+.(#*$%+5("#5"#"&6<(4+#+/#+.(#"+5*&'$+5/1#+.$+#4/&1"('#-5''#6(#*$50#2/%#.5"#

!!

Page 12: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

'(8$'#"(%754("#/1',#52#+.(#"&5+#/%#'5+58$+5/1#*%/"*(%"9#!#3&4.#.58.(%#4/3*(1"$+5/1#5"#$''/-(0#$"#4/1+518(1+#2(("#6(4$&"(#/2#+.(#%5"=#+.$+#+.(#'$-,(%#3$,#8(+#1/+.518#52#+.(#"&5+#2$5'"9#I.(#B/&%+#2510"#1/+.518#5''(8$' # 51 # +.( # 4/1+518(1+ # 2(( # 4/1+%$4+ # 6(+-((1 # !++,9 # E/ # $10#D7$18('51$e"#.&"6$109#I.(#B!#4/335++(0#1/#(%%/%#/2#'$-#-.(1#5+#$-$%0(0#+.(#$++/%1(,e"#2(("#/2#!++,9#E/#$10#$''/-(0#.53#+/#%(4(57(#$1 # (b&57$'(1+ # /2 # SUn # /2 # +.( # 3/1(+$%, # $-$%09 # >D\!AED@FA!#M!LMJ:#>$"#"&6"+5+&+(#4/3*'$51$1+#2/%#!@Dm!A:DH#N9#M!LMJ:W#79#A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA) # E9H9 # A/9 # PRSSRa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTUW

'+.)($-)&+/&!80#3*+.

F1#$005+5/1)#+.(#(3*'/,3(1+#$8%((3(1+#3$,#6(#'5=(1(0#51+/#$#4/1+%$4+#/2#$0.("5/1#4/1"50(%518#+.$+#5+#5"#*(+5+5/1(%#-./#51"5"+"#+.$+#+.(%( #(;5"+(0 #$1 #(;*%("" #*(%5/0 #/2 #/1( #,($% # 2%/3#!*%5' #P) #VTTV # +/#M$%4.#SP)#VTTS)#&"518#$"#*%//2#5+"#/-1#4/*,#/2#+.(#$8%((3(1+9##c.5'(#4/1+%$4+"#/2#$0.("5/1#$%(#7$'50#$10#6510518)#51#4$"("#/2#0/&6+#-.54.#-5''#4$&"(#$#8%($+#536$'$14(#/2#%58.+"#$8$51"+#/1(#/2#+.(#*$%+5(")#+.(#4/1+%$4+#".$''#6(#4/1"+%&(0#$8$51"+#+.(#*$%+,#-./#0%$2+(0#+.(#"$3(9#[(14()#51#+.5"#4$"()#-.(%(#+.(#7(%,#(3*'/,3(1+#/2#%("*/10(1+#5"#$+#"+$=()#+.(#0/&6+#$"#+/#+.(#*(%5/0#/2#(3*'/,3(1+#3&"+#6(#4/1"+%&(0#51#.(% # 2$7/%9 # >M!EFL#KCJAE#!B[FD\DHLe #@D!HAFAE#BDAIDH#$10 #MHL9#\FC@DI!#I9#B!HFhC#79#!:D@!F:!#9#M!A!@C)#E9H9#A/9#PQRRSa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTUW

'+.)($-)&+/&I:"%+7:#.)

L514(#%("*/10(1+#-$"#$'%($0,#$#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,((#3/1+."#6(2/%(#+.( #(;(4&+5/1 #/2 # +.( #D3*'/,3(1+ #-5+. # $ # ]5;(0 #G(%5/0 # 4/1+%$4+) # 5+"#(;(4&+5/1#-$"#3(%(',#$#*'/,#/1#LMBe"#*$%+#+/#0(*%57(#%("*/10(1+#/2#.5"#+(1&%5$'#"(4&%5+,9#[(14()#1/#7$'50#25;(0X+(%3#4/1+%$4+#-$"#(;(4&+(09#I.(#(3*'/,3(1+#"+$+&"#/2#$#*(%"/1#5"#0(251(0#$10#*%("4%56(0#6,#'$-#$10#1/+ #6,#-.$+# +.(#*$%+5("#"$,# 5+ #"./&'0#6(9 #Db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

'+("+($)#&1#0$;*%*)$)*+.

########## E57(1 # +.("( # *%(35"(") # 5+ # 5" # 1/+ # 052254&'+ # +/ # &10(%"+$10 #-.,#$4+5/1"#2/%#4'$53"#$8$51"+#+.(#$5'518#(1+(%*%5"(#.$7(#+/#6(#"&"*(10(09#

!"

Page 13: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

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b&$"5X<&0545$'#+%56&1$'")#"514(#"&4.#-%5+"#(3$1$+(#2%/3#Y$4+5/1"#2/%#4'$53")Z#3&"+)#'5=(-5"()#6(#"&"*(10(09#>M!@!K!A#FALJH!ABD#BCMG!AK)#FAB9#79#\FBICHF!L#MF@@FAE#BCMG!AK)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_QQ_R)#!*%5'#PQ)#VTTUW

4$:$6#3

G(+5+5/1(%l" # %('5$14( # /1 #:'$%-$2 * ;+ * <)&'(-)3 * =)4(% * >$3)&'(-2*?(//'22'(- *+/ # "&**/%+ # 5+" # 4'$53 # 2/% # +.( # %(0&4+5/1 #/2 # +.( #$-$%0 #/2#1/351$' # 0$3$8(" # 5" # 35"*'$4(09 # # I.( # 2$4+&$' # 45%4&3"+$14(" # $%(#0522(%(1+9 #:'$%-$2# 5" # $1 # 5''(8$' # 05"35""$' # 4$"() # "514( # +.(%( # -$" # 1/#$&+./%5i(0#4$&"(#2/%#+.(#05"35""$'#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(("j#$10#+.(#(3*'/,(%#-$" # /%0(%(0 # +/ # *$, # 6$4=-$8(" # 514'&"57( # /2 # $''/-$14(" # $10 # /+.(%#6(1(25+")#4/3*&+(0#2%/3#+.(#+53(#+.(#4/3*(1"$+5/1#-$"#-5+..('0#&*#+/#+.(#$4+&$'#%(51"+$+(3(1+9#F1#$005+5/1)#"514(#+.(#05"35""$'#-$"#0/1(#-5+./&+ # 0&( # *%/4("") # +.( # 1/351$' # 0$3$8(" # $-$%0(0 # -$" # /1',#GV)aUT9TT #(b&57$'(1+ # +/ #/1(X3/1+. # "$'$%, #/2 # +.( #(3*'/,((9 # F1 # +.5"#4$"()#+.(#05"35""$'#-$"#7$'50)#$"#5+#-$"#0&(#+/#$1#$&+./%5i(0#4$&"()#6&+#-5+./&+#+.(#/6"(%7$14(#/2#*%/4(0&%$'#0&(#*%/4("")#$10#+.(#/1',#$-$%0#857(1#-$"#1/351$'#0$3$8("9# >BD@D^DL#N!G!A#]CC:L#BCHGCH!IFCA#\9#LJL!A#KDHMC#E9H9#A/9#PQaRaa#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

F1 # *%(75/&" # 4$"(" #-.(%( #3/%$' # 0$3$8(" # $10 # $++/%1(,e" # 2(("#-(%(#$-$%0(0)#+.(#3$11(%#/2#+(%351$+5/1#-$"#0/1(#51#$#.&35'5$+518#$10#51"&'+518#3$11(%) #"&4.#$"# 51#+.(#4$"(#/2 #9$%$7$.&'+%%#6#3&DJ&K$)*+.$%&E$;+(&1#%$)*+.3&'+::*33*+.&-.(%(#+.(#(3*'/,(%#*/"+(0#4/*5("#/2# 5+"# '(++(%"#/2#+(%351$+5/1#+/#+.(#+($4.(%"# 51"50(#+.(#"4.//'#4$3*&"#$10# 5+ #$'"/# 2&%15".(0#4/*5(" # +/ # +.(# +/-1#3$,/% #$10#G$%5".#G%5("+#/2#+.(5%#4/33&15+,#2/%#+.(#*&%*/"(#/2#3$'581518#+.(#+($4.(%"e#%(*&+$+5/19#L/#$'"/#51#+.(#4$"(#/2#'0*$.6&L$*&,0#B&,-0++%&DJ&'+2()&+/&!""#$%3)#+.5"#B/&%+#$-$%0(0#3/%$'#0$3$8("#+/#$#+($4.(%#-./#-$"#2'$+',) # $10 #-5+./&+ #-$%1518 # /% # $ # 2/%3$' # 1/+54() # +/'0 # +.$+ # ".( #-$"#05"35""(09#>Msc#O!A:DH#G[F@FGGFADL)#FAB9#$10#HC@]#cF@ILB[D?##79#IHFAF:!:#M9#DAHFkJDO)#E9H9#A/9#P_UPQS)#N&1(#a)#VTTUW#

4*3$;*%*)7&9#.#/*)3

J10(%#*$%$8%$*.#VT9P9a#/2#+.(#*$%+5("e#B^!)#5+#5"#"+5*&'$+(0#+.$+#Yf$g#"($2$%(%#-./"(#05"$65'5+,#5"#$""(""(0#$+ #aTn&/%&3/%(# &10(%#+.(#

!#

Page 14: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

GCD!#D3*'/,3(1+#B/1+%$4+#".$'' #;#;#; #6(# %(8$%0(0# $"# *(%3$1(1+',#&125+# 2/%# 2&%+.(%# "($# "(%754(# 51# $1,# 4$*$45+,# $10# (1+5+'(0# +/# PTTn#4/3*(1"$+5/1) #'+$+) # # ; # ; # ; #JLt_T)TTT9TT# 2/% # %$+518"9Z # # G(+5+5/1(%e"#05"$65'5+, # %$+518 # 6(518 # _R9__n) # .( # 5" # (1+5+'(0 # +/ # $ # PTTn # 05"$65'5+,#4/3*(1"$+5/1#/2#JLt_T)TTT)#$"#4/%%(4+',#2/&10#6,#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#$10 # +.( # A@HB9 # # L/ #@9'3'/)%$A * B-#+CD)%3(6 * <);',)&'(- * ?(+A * =&7+ * ;+*!1,)-(4)#(1'58.+(1")#+.&"r

E0%(0(2# +.( # $**%/*%5$+( # 05"$65'5+, # 6(1(25+" # +.$+#%("*/10(1+#5"#(1+5+'(0#+/)#-(#2510#+.$+#L&8$1/6#5"#(1+5+'(0#+/#E%$0(#P#05"$65'5+, #6(1(25+" #-.54.#4/%%("*/10"#+/#+/+$'#$10#*(%3$1(1+#05"$65'5+,9#9#9#

; # ; # ; #M+ & ;# & #.)*)%#8 & )+ & N($8# & > & 8*3$;*%*)7&;#.#/*)3O&)0#&#:"%+7##A3&8*3$;*%*)7&:23)&.+)&+.%7&;#&)+)$%&;2)&$%3+&"#(:$.#.)9

C#(:$.#.)&8*3$;*%*)7&*3&)0#&*.$;*%*)7&+/&$&=+(B#(&)+ & "#(/+(: & 0*3 & P+; & /+( & :+(# & )0$. & >Q? & 8$73O&(#6$(8%#33&+/&=0#)0#(&+(&.+)&0#&%+3#3&)0#&23#&+/&$.7&+/&0*3&;+879# #B'($%',)#L&8$1/6e"#05"$65'5+,#5" #"#(:$.#.)&"514( # .( # -$" # &1$6'( # +/ # -/%= # 2%/3 # +.( # +53( # .( # -$"#3(054$'', # %(*$+%5$+(0 #/1 #L(*+(36(% #PQ) #VTTP #&* # +/ # +.(#+53(#+.(#4/3*'$51+#-$"#25'(0#/1#!*%5' #Va) #VTTV) #/%#3/%(#+.$1#Q#3/1+."9##M/%(/7(%)#52#51#2$4+#L&8$1/6#5"#4'($%#$10#25+#+/#-/%=#/1#C4+/6(%#VU)#VTTP)#.(#-/&'0#.$7(#6((1#+$=(1#6$4=#6,#*(+5+5/1(%"#+/#4/1+51&(#.5"#-/%=#$"#$#B.5(2#B//=)#6&+ # .( # -$" # 1/+9 # #R*3 & 8*3$;*%*)7 & *3 & 2.8+2;)#8%7&"#(:$.#.)9

M+)$% &8*3$;*%*)7O &+.&)0# &+)0#( &0$.8O &8+#3 &.+)&:#$. & $;3+%2)# & 0#%"%#33.#33J# F1 # 05"$65'5+,#4/3*(1"$+5/1)# 5+ # 5" #1/+#+.(#51<&%,#-.54.#5"#4/3*(1"$+(0)#6&+ # %$+.(% # +.( # 514$*$45+, # +/ # -/%= # %("&'+518 # 51 # +.(#53*$5%3(1+#/2#/1(e"#($%1518#4$*$45+,9#I/+$'#05"$65'5+,#0/("#1/+#%(b&5%(#+.$+#+.(#(3*'/,((#6(#$6"/'&+(',#05"$6'(0)#/%#+/+$'',#*$%$',i(09##S0$)&*3&.#-#33$(7&*3&)0$)&)0#&*.P2(7&:23)&;#&32-0&)0$)&)0#&#:"%+7##&-$..+)&"2(32#&0*3&232$% &=+(B &$.8 &#$(. & )0#(#/(+:9 # ^/+. # +.( # 4/3*$1,X0("581$+(0#*.,"545$1#$10#L&8$1/6e"#*.,"545$1#2/&10#+.$+#L&8$1/6 # 5" #2./*) & )+ & -+.)*.2# &0*3 &82)*#3 &$3 &$ &'0*#/&'++B&3*.-#&0*3&*%%.#33&"(#D#.)#8&0*:&/(+:&-+.)*.2*.6&0*3&82)*#3&$3&32-09# #:&(#+/#.5"#5''1("")#.(#4$1#1/#'/18(%#*(%2/%3#-/%= #-.54. # 5" #*$%+ #/2 #.5" #0$5', # %/&+51( #$" #B.5(2#B//=# '5=(# '52+518#.($7,# '/$0"#/2 # 2%/i(1#3($+) # 25".) #-$+(%)#(+49#-.(1#*%(*$%518#3($'"#2/%#+.(#4%(-#3(36(%"9##R#.-#O&,26$.+;A3&8*3$;*%*)7&*3&$%3+&)+)$%9##>D3*.$"5"#"&**'5(0W#

!$

Page 15: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

>NCD@LCA # C9 # F@CHDI! # 79 #G[F@FGGFAD # IH!ALM!HFAD#B!HHFDHL)#FAB9)#E9H9#AC9#PRSUTR)#:(4(36(%#`)#VTTUW

&!"#-5+.#$''#/+.(%#=510"#/2#-/%=(%)#+.(#+(%3"#$10#4/105+5/1"#/2#$#"($2$%(%e"#(3*'/,3(1+#5"#8/7(%1(0#6,#+.(#*%/75"5/1"#/2#+.(#4/1+%$4+#.(#"581"#$+#+.(#+53(#.(#5"#.5%(09# #^&+#&1'5=(#+.$+#/2#/+.(%")#0((3(0#-%5++(1#51#+.(#"($2$%(%e"#4/1+%$4+#5"#$#"(+#/2#"+$10$%0#*%/75"5/1"#"(+#$10#53*'(3(1+(0#6,#+.(#GCD!)#4$''(0#+.(#!&)-7)%7*8$%/2*)-7*?(-7'&'(-2*F(;$%-'-,*&9$*G/03("/$-&*(.*H'3'0'-(*!$).)%$%2*(-*I()%7*J#$)-KF('-,*:$22$32) # -.54. # $%( # 4/1"50(%(0 # +/ # 6( # +.( # 35153&3 # %(b&5%(3(1+"#$44(*+$6'(#+/#+.(#8/7(%13(1+#2/%#+.(#(3*'/,3(1+#/2#]5'5*51/#"($2$%(%"#/1 #6/$%0 # 2/%(581 #/4($1X8/518 #7(""('"+# # I.&") # +.( # 5""&( #/2 #-.(+.(%#*(+5+5/1(%#A5"0$#4$1#'(8$'',#0(3$10#$10#4'$53#05"$65'5+,#6(1(25+"#2%/3#%("*/10(1+" # L($ # L(%7( # $10 # !:!ML # 2/% # $1 # 5''1("" # "&22(%(0 # 5" # 6("+#$00%(""(0#6,#+.(#*%/75"5/1"#/2#.5"#GCD!XLDB)#-.54.#514/%*/%$+(0#+.(#!&)-7)%7*8$%/2*)-7*?(-7'&'(-2*F(;$%-'-,*&9$*G/03("/$-&*(.*H'3'0'-(*!$).)%$%2*(-*I()%7*J#$)-KF('-,*:$22$329# #c.(1#*(+5+5/1(%#A5"0$#-$"#(3*'/,(0 # /1 # Q #!&8&"+ # VTTP) # 5+ #-$" # +.( #LMMM *E/$-7$7 *!&)-7)%7*8$%/2*)-7*?(-7'&'(-2*F(;$%-'-,*&9$*G/03("/$-&*(.*H'3'0'-(*!$).)%$%2*(- * I()%7 * J#$)-KF('-, * :$22$32 *>.(%(51$2+(% # %(2(%%(0 # +/ # "53*', # $"#E/$-7$7*!&)-7)%7*8$%/2*)-7*?(-7'&'(-2#2/%#6%(75+,W#+.$+#$**'5(0#$10#-(%(#0((3(0#-%5++(1# 51 #/% #$**(10(0#+/#.5" #GCD!XLDB9 #>B!H@CL#A9#AFL:!#79 #LD!#LDH\D#M!HFIFMD#!EDABK#$10#?[!@F]!#!9 #!@ECL!F^F#:F\FAE#!A:#M!HFAD#LDH\FBDL)#E9#H9#A/9#PQUPQQ)#N&',#VS)#VTTUW

E57(1#$#"($2$%(%e"#(1+5+'(3(1+#+/#*(%3$1(1+#05"$65'5+,#6(1(25+"#-.(1#.(#5"#&1$6'(#+/#-/%=#2/%#3/%(#+.$1#PVT#0$,")#+.(#2$5'&%(#/2#+.(#4/3*$1,X0("581$+(0 # *.,"545$1 # +/ # *%/1/&14( # *(+5+5/1(% # 25+ # +/ # -/%=#-5+.51 # +.(#PVTX0$,#*(%5/0#(1+5+'(" #.53#+/#*(%3$1(1+ # +/+$' #05"$65'5+,#6(1(25+#51#+.(#$3/&1+#/2#JLt_T)TTT9TT9# >@DCGC@:C#!^!AID# #79#?NEL#]@DDI#M!A!EDMDAI#M!AF@!#E9H9#A/9#PRV`ST)#:(4(36(%#`)#VTTUW

4*3:*33$%&

F1#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"()#-(#"5815254$1+',#1/+(#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%) #$2+(%#25'518#.(%#(;*'$1$+5/1#51#%("*/1"(#+/#+.(#(3*'/,(%e"#N&',#P)#PUUQ#3(3/)#1(7(% # $"=(0 # 2/% # $1, # 4'$%5254$+/%, # .($%518 # 0&%518 # +.( # *'$1+X'(7('#*%/4((0518"9#L.(#$'"/#.$0##$3*'(#/**/%+&15+,#+/#(;*'$51#.(%#"50(#;'2KNK;'2#+.(#*%5145*$'#4.$%8(#$8$51"+#.(%#o#.(%#517/'7(3(1+#51#+.(#51450(1+#/2#N&1(#ST)#PUUQ#9## F+#5"#$#3$++(%#/2#%(4/%0#+.$+#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%#'/"+#1/#+53(#51#"&635++518#+.(#%(b&5%(0#(;*'$1$+5/1)#$"#".(#"&635++(0#5+#/1#+.(#7(%,#"$3(#0$,#+.$+#+.(#3(3/#-$"#"(%7(0#/1#.(%9#I.(#(;*'$1$+5/1)#51#]5'5*51/) # 1$%%$+(0 # $3/18 # /+.(%" # +.( # 510522(%(1+ # $10 # 05"4%5351$+/%,#+%($+3(1+ #".(#.$0 #6((1# %(4(57518 # 2%/3# +.( #8%/&* #/2 #A5'/ #D4.$7(i)#-.54.#".(#$'"/#+/'0#.(%#.&"6$10#-./#8/+#3$09## I$=(1#+/8(+.(%#-5+.#+.(#+("+53/15("#/2#/+.(%#-5+1(""("#-./#8$7(#+.(5%#"+$+(3(1+"#/1#./-#

!%

Page 16: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+.(#*(+5+5/1(%#(14/&%$8(0#.(%#.&"6$10#+/#$++$4=#D4.$7(i#>$''#/2#-.54.#-(%(#0&',#$10#"($"/1$6',#05"4'/"(0W)#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%#4$11/+#4'$53#+.$+#+.( # %("*/10(1+ #4/3*$1,#050 #1/+ #857( #.(% #$3*'( #/**/%+&15+, # +/ #6(#.($%09##!''#+/'0)#-(#$%(#4/17514(0#+.$+#+.(#%("*/10(1+#4/3*$1,#$4+(0#6$"(0 # /1 # $ # 7$'50 # 4$&"( # 2/% # 05"35""$' # $10 # /6"(%7(0 # +.( # %(b&5%(0#*%/4(0&%("#51#"/#$4+5189##>HCL!HFC#!9#E!IJL#79#kJ!@FIK#[CJLD)#FAB9#$10##B[HFLICG[DH##B[J!)##E9H9#A/9#Pa_Q__)#!*%5'#P_)#VTTUW

• '+.3)(2-)*D#&4*3:*33$%

B$"(#'$-#./'0"#+.$+#4/1"+%&4+57(#05"35""$'#/44&%"#-.(1#+.(%(#5"#4(""$+5/1 # /2 # -/%= # 6(4$&"( # 4/1+51&(0 # (3*'/,3(1+ # 5" # %(10(%(0#53*/""56'()#&1%($"/1$6'(#/%#&1'5=(',j#-.(1#+.(%(#5"#$#0(3/+5/1#51#%$1=#/% # 05351&+5/1 # 51 # *$, # /% # 6/+.j # /% # -.(1 # $ # 4'($% # 05"4%5351$+5/1)#51"(1"565'5+,) #/% #05"0$51#6,#$1#(3*'/,(% #6(4/3("#&16($%$6'(# +/# +.(#(3*'/,((9###H("*/10(1+e"#"&00(1)#$%65+%$%,#$10#&12/&10(0#$0/*+5/1#/2#+.(#+-/X0$,#-/%=#"4.(3(#-.54.#8%($+',#%(0&4(0#*(+5+5/1(%"e#"$'$%5("#%(10(%" # 5+ # '5$6'( # 2/% # 4/1"+%&4+57( #05"35""$'9 #>]D # @! #HCL! #(+9 # $'9) # 79#!M^!LL!:CH#[CID@)E9H9#A/9#PQQTaU)#M$%4.#PS)#VTTUW

c.$+#+.&"#"&%2$4("#5"#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#-$"#4/1"+%&4+57(',#05"35""(09#A/#$4+&$'#05"35""$'#358.+#.$7(#/44&%%(0#51#+.(#"(1"(#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#-$"#1/+ #"(%7(0#-5+.#$#1/+54(#/2 # +(%351$+5/1) #6&+# +.(%(#-$"#4/1"+%&4+57(#05"35""$')#*(+5+5/1(%#.$7518#6((1#*'$4(0#51#$#*/"5+5/1#-.(%(#4/1+51&(0#(3*'/,3(1+ # -$" # %(10(%(0 # 53*/""56'( # $10 # &1%($"/1$6'( # 6, # +.(#45%4&3"+$14(" # 51054$+(0 #$6/7(9 #>C:F@CA #@9 #M!HIFADO #79 #^d^#]FL[#^HC?DHpACH^DHIC#M9#@JBFA!HFC) #E9H9 #A/9#PQUURa)# L(*+(36(%#PR)#VTTUW#

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e" # +%$1"2(% # 5" # +$1+$3/&1+ # +/ # &1'$-2&'#4/1"+%&4+57(#05"35""$'9 # >MDHB?#L[!HG#!A:#:C[MD#>G[F@FGGFADLW #79#NCA!H#G9#HC^@DL)#(+#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#PQ_aT_)#A/7(36(%#Va)#VTTUW

I.("(#05"4%5351$+/%,#$4+"#-(%(#4$'4&'$+(0#+/#3$=(#*(+5+5/1(%#2(('#+.$+#.(#5"#1/#'/18(%#-('4/3(#1/%#1((0(0#51#%("*/10(1+#4/3*$1,#u#"./%+#/2#"(10518#.53#$1#$4+&$'#1/+54(#/2#+(%351$+5/19#c()#+.(%(2/%()#./'0 # +.$+ # %("*/10(1+ # 4/1"+%&4+57(', # 05"35""(0 # *(+5+5/1(% # 2%/3 # +.(#"(%754(9 # >H!MCA # ^9 # ]CHM!AIDL # 79 # :JAB!A # G[!HM!BDJIFB!@L)#G[F@L9)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#PQT__P)#:(4(36(%#`)#VTTUW

!&

Page 17: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

F1 # +.( # *%("(1+ # 4$"() # +.( # *(+5+5/1(%" # 4($"(0 # 7(%6$'',#4/33&154$+518#-5+.#+.(#%("*/10(1+#$10#857518#.53#-/%=#$""5813(1+#$2+(% # "&"*(4+518 # +.$+ #.( #.$0 # 2/%8(0 #*&%4.$"( # %(4(5*+"9 # #J10(% # +.5"#"5+&$+5/1) # +.( # %("*/10(1+ # -$" # 2/%4(0 # +/ # '($7( # +.( # *(+5+5/1(%"e#4/3*/&10#-5+.#.5"#2$35',#$10#+/#+%$1"2(%#+/#$#1($%6,#*'$4(9###I.&")#+.(#%("*/10(1+e"#$4+#/2#'($7518#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%"e#*%(35"("#-$"#51#%($'5+,#1/+#.5"#4./54(#6&+#$#"5+&$+5/1#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%"#4%($+(09#>BHB#!EHFBJ@IJH!@#IH!:FAE#$10#HC@!A:C#^9#B!IFA:FE##79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9##PQQ__`)#:(4(36(%#VS)#VTTUW

• 4*3:*33$%&+/&T$.$6#(*$%&I:"%+7##3

F1 # 75(- # /2 # +.( # '$4= # /2 # *%/*(% # 517("+58$+5/1 # 51+/ # +.( # 4.$%8("#$8$51"+#%("*/10(1+) #*(+5+5/1(%"# 2$5'(0#+/#"./-#+.$+#+.(,#.$7(#$# <&"+#4$&"( # 2/% # +(%351$+518 # .5" # (3*'/,3(1+9 # # H("*/10(1+"e # $''(8(0#512%$4+5/1" # $3/&1+ # +/ # 1/+.518 # 3/%( # +.$1 # 6$%( # $44&"$+5/1" # $10#&15'$+(%$' # 4/14'&"5/1" # +.$+ # 0/ #1/+ # *%/750( # '(8$' # <&"+5254$+5/1 # 2/% # .5"#+(%351$+5/1 # 2%/3 # (3*'/,3(1+9 # # !'+./&8. # *(+5+5/1(%" # .$7( # -50(%#'$+5+&0(#/2#05"4%(+5/1#51#+(%351$+518#%("*/10(1+)#-./#-$"#$#3$1$8(%5$'#(3*'/,(()# 5+ # 5" #1/1(+.('(""#"(++'(0#+.$+#4/1250(1+5$' #$10#3$1$8(%5$'#(3*'/,(("#4$11/+#6(#$%65+%$%5', #05"35""(0#$+#$1,#+53()#$10#-5+./&+#4$&"(#)2*%$)2(-)43"*$2&)43'29$7*'-*)-*)00%(0%')&$*'-;$2&',)&'(-9#L&4.#(3*'/,((") # +//) #$%(#(1+5+'(0#+/#"(4&%5+, #/2 # +(1&%() # 2$5% #"+$10$%0"#/2#(3*'/,3(1+#$10#+.(#*%/+(4+5/1#/2#'$6/%#'$-"9##M$1$8(%5$'#(3*'/,((")#1/#'(""#+.$1#%$1=X$10X25'(#'$6/%(%"#$%(#(1+5+'(0#+/#0&(#*%/4(""9###>B!L!#BD^J!A!#FABCHGCH!:!#$10#!AED@!#]FEJDHC!#G!J@FA#79#FHDADC#G9#@DJIDHFC)#E9H9#A/9#PQ_T`T)#L(*+(36(%#`)#VTTUW

• 4*3:*33$%&82#&)+&U.*+.&,#-2(*)7&'%$23#3

A/1(+.('("") #-.5'( #c( # &*./'0 # 05"35""$' # *&%"&$1+ # +/ # $ # &15/1#"(4&%5+,#4'$&"()#+.(#"$3(#5"#1/+#-5+./&+#$#4/105+5/1#/%#%("+%54+5/19###]/%#+/ # $''/- # 5+" # &1+%$33('(0 # (12/%4(3(1+ # -/&'0 # (14/&%$8( # $%65+%$%,#05"35""$' # $10 # $6&"( # 6, # +.( # (3*'/,(%) # +/ # +.( # 0(+%53(1+ # /2 # +.(#(3*'/,(("9###I.&")#+/#"$2(8&$%0#+.(#%58.+"#/2#+.(#(3*'/,((")#c(#.$7(#"$50#+53(#$10#$8$51#+.$+#05"35""$'"#*&%"&$1+#+/#&15/1#"(4&%5+,#4'$&"("#$%(#7$'50#$10#'(8$') #"&6<(4+#/1',#+/#+.(#%(b&5%(3(1+#/2#0&(#*%/4("")#+.$+ # 5") # 1/+54( # $10 # .($%518 # *%5/% # +/ # 05"35""$'9 # F1 # '5=( #3$11(%) #c(#(3*.$"5i(0 # +.$+ # +.( # (12/%4(3(1+ # /2 # &15/1 # "(4&%5+, # 4'$&"(" # 5"#$&+./%5i(0#6,#'$-)#*%/750(0#"&4.#(12/%4(3(1+#5"#1/+#4.$%$4+(%5i(0#6,#$%65+%$%51("")#$10#$'-$,"#-5+.#0&(#*%/4(""9# >[(%351585'0/#F18&5''/#$10#O(1$50$ # ^(%8$1+( # 79 #]5%"+ # G.5'5**51( # L4$'(") # F149 # $10p/% # !3*$%/#G/'54$%*5/)#M$1$8(%)#E9H9#A/9#P_a`TQ)#N&1(#a)#VTTUW#

• 4*3:*33$%&+/&U.*+.&V//*-#(

!'

Page 18: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

A/+( # +.$+ # +.( # 7(%6 # Y*$%+545*$+("Z # 5" # *%(4(0(0 #6, # +.( # $07(%6#Y=1/-518',9Z # I.5" # %(2'(4+" # +.( # 51+(1+ # /2 # +.( # '(85"'$+&%( # +/ # %(b&5%(#Y=1/-'(08(Z#$"#$#4/105+5/1#2'-$*O1)*-(-#6(2/%(#$#&15/1#/2254(%#4$1#6(#05"35""(0#2%/3#(3*'/,3(1+#2/%#*$%+545*$+518#51#$1#5''(8$'#"+%5=(9#I.(#*%/75"5/1 # 5" #-/%0(0 # 51 # "&4. #$ #-$, #$" # +/ #3$=( # 5+ # 7(%, #052254&'+ # 2/%#(3*'/,(%"#+/#45%4&37(1+#+.(#'$-#6,#$%65+%$%5',#05"35""518#(3*'/,(("#51#+.( # 8&5"( # /2 # (;(%45"518 #3$1$8(3(1+ # *%(%/8$+57(9 # I.5" # 5" # 6&+ # /1(#$"*(4+#/2#+.(#L+$+(e"#4/1"+5+&+5/1$'#$10#"+$+&+/%,#3$10$+(#+/#*%/+(4+#+.(#%58.+" #/2 #(3*'/,(("#+/#"('2X/%8$15i$+5/19 #####>B@J^#]F@FGFAC) # FAB9#$10###!IIK9#HC^DHIC#]9#:D#@DCA#79#6(1<$351#6$&+5"+$)#(+9#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#P_R`T_)#N&',#PS)#VTTUW

• W%%#6$%&4*3:*33$%

c5+.#+.(#2510518#+.$+#F1+(%"(%7(#-$"#(18$8(0#51#*%/.565+(0#'$6/%X/1', # 4/1+%$4+518) # *(+5+5/1(% # ".$'' # 6( # 0((3(0 # +.( # +%&( # (3*'/,(% # /2#%("*/10(1+"9# #!"#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,(("#/2#*(+5+5/1(%)#%("*/10(1+"#4$11/+#6(#05"35""(0#(;4(*+#2/%#<&"+#/%#$&+./%5i(0#4$&"(")#1/1(#/2#-.54.#-(%(#$''(8(0#/%#*%/7(1#+/#(;5"+#51#+.5"#4$"()#+.(#/1',#0(2(1"(#/2#*(+5+5/1(%#$8$51"+#+.(#4.$%8(#/2#5''(8$'#05"35""$'#6(518#+.$+#%("*/10(1+"#-(%(#1/+#5+" #(3*'/,(("9# #H(4/%0"#$'"/#2$5'(0#+/#"./-#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#$22/%0(0#%("*/10(1+" # +.( # +-51 # %(b&5%(3(1+" # /2 # *%/4(0&%$' # 0&( #*%/4("") #'+$+)#1/+54( #$10#.($%518) #*%5/% # +/# +.(5% #05"35""$'9 # #H("*/10(1+" #-(%(#1/+#"(%7(0#1/+54("# 512/%3518#+.(3#/2#+.(#*$%+54&'$% #$4+"# 2/%#-.54.#+.(5%#05"35""$' # -$" # "/&8.+9 # # A/% #-(%( # +.(, # %(b&5%(0 # +/ # 857( # +.(5% # "50(#%(8$%0518#+.(#4.$%8("#3$0(#$8$51"+#+.(39##B(%+$51',)#+.(#%("*/10(1+"e#05"35""$'#-$"#1/+#4$%%5(0#/&+#51#$44/%0$14(#-5+.#'$-#$10)#+.(%(2/%()#5''(8$'9#>BCB!XBC@!#^CII@DHL#G[F@L9)#FAB# #79 #!@!A#M9#!EFIC)#(+#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#PQUa`_)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTUW

!"#+.(#(3*'/,(%)#*(+5+5/1(%#.$"#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%/7518#+.$+#+.(#05"35""$'#/2#*(+5+5/1(%#-$"#2/%#$#4$&"(#$''/-(0#&10(%#+.(#'$-#$10#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(% #-$"#$22/%0(0#*%/4(0&%$' #0&(#*%/4(""9## G(+5+5/1(% # 2$5'(0# +/#05"4.$%8(#+.5"#6&%0(19##F10((0)#5+#2$5'(0#+/#"./-#$1,#7$'50#/%#$&+./%5i(0#4$&"(#&10(%#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(#-.54.#$''/-(0#5+#+/#+(%351$+(#+.(#"(%754("#/2#5105750&$'#%("*/10(1+"9##A(5+.(%#050#*(+5+5/1(%#"./-#+.$+#5105750&$'#%("*/10(1+"#-(%(#857(1#$3*'(#/**/%+&15+,#+/#4/1+("+#+.(#'(8$'5+,#/2#+.(5% #05"35""$'9### A/#1/+54(#/2 #"&4.# 53*(10518#+(%351$+5/1#-$"#(7(%#857(1 # +/ # +.(39## F105750&$' # %("*/10(1+" #-(%( # 0(2515+(', # 0(15(0 # 0&(#*%/4(""9##[$7518#2$5'(0#+/#("+$6'5".#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#%(b&5%(3(1+"#/1#+(%351$+5/1#/2#(3*'/,3(1+#&10(%#+.(#@$6/%#B/0()#+.(#05"35""$'#/2#5105750&$' # %("*/10(1+" #-$" # +$51+(0 #-5+. # 5''(8$'5+,9& >F@FE!A # BDMDAI#BCHGCH!IFCA # 79 # F@F!LBCH # DMG@CKDDL # !A: # cCH?DHL # JAFCA # q#LCJI[DHA#G[F@FGGFADL#]D:DH!IFCA#C]#@!^CH#>FDcJXLG]@W)#!A:#FIL#C]]FBDHL#!A:#MDM^DHL)#(+9#$')#E9H9#A/9#PaRUa_)#!*%5'#V`)#VTTUW#

!(

Page 19: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

F1#+.5"#4$"()#-(#2510#1/#/7(%+#$4+#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#*(+5+5/1(%#+.$+#.(#-$"#%($0,#+/#"(7(%#.5"#(3*'/,3(1+#+5("9##I.(#$''(8(0#%("581$+5/1#-$"#$4+&$'',#*%(35"(0#6,#%("*/10(1+"#/1',#/1#+.(#25'518#/2#+.(#4/3*'$51+#2/%#"(*$%$+5/1 #*$,) #6&+ # +.5" #$'/1(# 5" #1/+ #"&22545(1+ #*%//2 # +.$+ #*(+5+5/1(%#51+(10(0#+/#%("581#2%/3#+.(#4/3*$1,9#c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p #CH!I!#IH!:FAE#$10#]@CH:D@FO!#@DE!LGF)#E9H9#A/9#PQaS`a)#!&8&"+#PU)#VTTUW

I.(%(2/%()#+.5"#B/&%+#2510"#1/#%($"/1#+/#05"+&%6#5+"#2510518#+.$+#+.(#%(+%(14.3(1+#/2#+.(#2'58.+#$++(10$1+"#-$"#5''(8$'',#(;(4&+(09# #!"#.('0#51#+.(#:(45"5/1#"/&8.+#+/#6(#%(4/1"50(%(0)#G!@#2$5'(0#+/#/6"(%7(#+.(#*%/4(0&%(#$10#%(b&5%(3(1+"#2/%#$#7$'50#%(+%(14.3(1+9# #!""&3518#+.$+ # G!@ #-$" # 510((0 # "&22(%518 # 251$145$' # '/""(") # +.( # %(b&5"5+( # *%//2#+.(%(2/% #-$" #1/+ #*%("(1+(0#6(2/%( # +.( #A@HB#-.54. #-$" # +.( #*%/*(%#2/%&39##M/%(#53*/%+$1+',)#+.(#3$11(%#/2#+.(#%(+%(14.3(1+#-$"#1/+#51#$44/%0$14( # -5+. # +.( # *%/4(0&%( # %(b&5%(0 # 6, # '$-9 # # [(14() # +.(#%(+%(14.3(1+#/2 # +.(# 2'58.+ #$++(10$1+" #$3/&1+(0#+/# 5''(8$' #05"35""$'9#B/1"(b&(1+',)#+.(#2'58.+#$++(10$1+"#$22(4+(0#$%(#(1+5+'(0#+/#+.(#%('5(2"#*%/750(0 # 6, # '$-) # -.54. # 514'&0( # 6$4=-$8(" # $10 # %(51"+$+(3(1+ # /%#"(*$%$+5/1 # *$,) # $" # +.( # 4$"( #3$, # 6(9 # # >]@FE[I # !IIDA:!AIL # !A:#LIDc!H:L#!LLCBF!IFCA#C]#I[D#G[F@FGGFADL#>]!L!GW)#79 #G[F@FGGFAD#!FH@FADL) # FAB9)G!IHF! # B[FCAE # $10 # BCJHI # C] # !GGD!@L)E9H9 # A/9#PQRTRS)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

B'($%',)#^/'$1/"e"#4$"(#5"#/1(#/2#5''(8$'#05"35""$'9##]5%"+)#+.(%(#5"#1/ # <&"+ # /% # $&+./%5i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

!)

Page 20: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

F1 # 251() # $" # *(+5+5/1(%" # 2$5'(0 # +/ # 510&65+$6', # *%/7( # +.$+#%("*/10(1+"#-(%(#8&5'+,#/2#0%&8#&"(#51#4/1+%$7(1+5/1#/2#5+"#0%&8X2%((#-/%=*'$4( #*/'54, #$3/&1+518#+/#"(%5/&" #35"4/10&4+) # %("*/10(1+" #$%(#0((3(0#+/#.$7(#6((1#5''(8$'',#05"35""(09# >G@!AI!IFCA#^!K#HDLCHI#$10#LG!#79#HCMD@#L9#:J^HFBC)#(+#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#PRVVP_) #:(4(36(%#`)#VTTUW

4+-B#)&5##3

!1(1+#*(+5+5/1(%l"#4'$53#%(8$%0518#%("*/10(1+l"#2$5'&%(#+/#*$,#+.(#2&''#$3/&1+#/2#0/4=(+#2(("#$+#+.(#+53(#/2##+.(#25'518#/2##+.(#*(+5+5/1#-5+.#+.(#B!)##-(#2510#+.$+#5+#5"#("+/**(0#2%/3#b&("+5/1518#+.(#<&%5"054+5/1#/2#+.(#B!#/1#+.5"#8%/&10)#6(4$&"(#"&4.#5""&(#.$0#1(7(%#6((1#%$5"(0#51#$1,#/2 #+.(#*'($0518"#25'(0#6(2/%(#+.(#B!9# #A/+$6',)#+.(#B!# 5""&(0#$#351&+(#%("/'&+5/1#0$+(0#N&1(#Q)#PUUU#%(b&5%518#%("*/10(1+#+/#%(35+#+.(#$3/&1+ # /2 # GaPT9TT # +/ # 4/3*'(+( # +.( # 0/4=(+ # $10 # /+.(% # 2(("9#H("*/10(1+#4/3*'5(0)#6&+#0&(#+/#51$07(%+(14()#+.(#$3/&1+#%(35++(0#'$4=(0 # +.( # $3/&1+ # /2 # GPT9TT) # +.&") # +.( #B! # 51 # $ # H("/'&+5/1 # 0$+(0#A/7(36(% #VV) #PUUU) #4/1"50(%(0 # +.( #$**($' #$6$10/1(0#*&%"&$1+ # +/#L(4+5/1# #P>4W)#H&'(#aT#/2#+.(#PUUQ#H&'("#/2#B/&%+9#J*/1#%("*/10(1+l"#3/+5/1#2/%#%(4/1"50(%$+5/1)#+.(#$**($'#-$"#%(51"+$+(0#/1#](6%&$%,#VV)#VTTT9# #G(+5+5/1(%#-$"#4/*,X2&%15".(0#$''#+.(#%("/'&+5/1"#5""&(0#6,#+.(#B!) #6&+ #*(+5+5/1(% #1(7(%# %$5"(0#+.(# 5""&(#/2 # 514/3*'(+( #*$,3(1+#/2#0/4=(+#2(("9##F1#2$4+)#"&4.#5""&(#-$"#/1',#%$5"(0#2/%#+.(#25%"+#+53(#51#5+"#H(*', # 25'(0 # -5+. # &"9 # >DMBCH # FABCHGCH!ID: # 79 # M!9 # @CJH:DL # :9#LFDADL)#E9H9#A/9#PaVPTP)#L(*+(36(%#R)#VTTUW

4+-)(*.#&+/&,)($*.#8&1#%$)*+.30*"

I/ # *%/+(4+ # +.( # (3*'/,((e" # "(4&%5+, # /2 # +(1&%() # +.( # B/&%+ # .$"#(3*.$"5i(0#+.$+#+.(#0/4+%51(#/2#Y"+%$51(0#%('$+5/1"Z#"./&'0#6(#"+%54+',#$**'5(0#"/#$"#1/+#+/#0(*%57(#$1#5''(8$'',#05"35""(0#(3*'/,((#/2#.5"#%58.+#+/ # %(51"+$+(3(1+9 # # D7(%, # '$6/% # 05"*&+( # $'3/"+ # $'-$," # %("&'+" # 51#Y"+%$51(0#%('$+5/1")Z#$10#+.(#*.%$"(#4$11/+#6(#857(1#$1#/7(%$%4.518#51+(%*%(+$+5/1j#/+.(%-5"() #$1#&1<&"+',#05"35""(0#(3*'/,((#4$1#1(7(%#6( # %(51"+$+(09 # # I.( # $""&3*+5/1 # /2 # "+%$51(0 # %('$+5/1" # -$" # $'%($0,#0(6&1=(0#6,#+.(#2$4+#+.$+#$"#($%',#$"#M$%4.#VTT_#*(+5+5/1(%#%(+&%1(0#+/#-/%=# 2/% # %("*/10(1+ #BB^G) #-5+./&+ #$1,#$1+$8/15"3#.$7518#6((1#%(*/%+(0#+.&"#2$%#6,#$1,#/2#+.(#*$%+5("9# #A(5+.(%#4$1#-(#"&"+$51#+.(#A@HBe"#4/14'&"5/1#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%e"#*/"5+5/1# 5"#4/1250(1+5$' # 51#1$+&%(9#H(4(5*+#/2#*%/4((0"#2%/3#"$'("#/2#%("*/10(1+#BB^Ge"#*%/0&4+"#0/("#1/+#3$=(#*(+5+5/1(%#$#4/1250(1+5$'#(3*'/,((9#!#4/1250(1+5$'#(3*'/,((#5"#/1(#-./#>PW#$""5"+"#/%#$4+"#51#$#4/1250(1+5$'#4$*$45+,)#51#%(8$%0#+/#>VW#

"*

Page 21: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

*(%"/1" # -./ # 2/%3&'$+() # 0(+(%351() # $10 # (22(4+&$+( # 3$1$8(3(1+#*/'545("#"*(45254$'',#51#+.(#25('0#/2#'$6/%#%('$+5/1"9# #\(%5',)#*(+5+5/1(%e"#</6 #$" #$ #"$'("3$1#0/(" #1/+ # 2$'' #&10(% # +.5" #b&$'5254$+5/19 # >DHcFA#[9#HDKDL#79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PRTaaP)#](6%&$%,#PT)#VTTUW

F1#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"()#%(51"+$+(3(1+#5"#1/#'/18(%#2($"56'(#6(4$&"(#/2#+.(#"+%$51(0#%('$+5/1"#6(+-((1#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%"#$10#+.(#%("*/10(1+9#I53( # $10 # $8$51) # +.5" # B/&%+ # .$" # %(4/815i(0 # +.$+ # "+%$51(0 # %('$+5/1"#6(+-((1 # +.( # (3*'/,(% # $10 # (3*'/,(( # 5" # $1 # (;4(*+5/1 # +/ # +.( # %&'(#%(b&5%518#$4+&$'#%(51"+$+(3(1+#2/%#5''(8$'',#05"35""(0#(3*'/,(("#2/%#+.(#*%$4+54$'#%($"/1#+.$+#+.(#$'%($0,#(;5"+518#$1+$8/15"3#-5''#/1',#2("+(%#$10#0(+(%5/%$+()#$10#-5''#/1',#-/%"(1#-5+.#*/""56'(#$07(%"(#(22(4+"#/1#+.(#*$%+5(")#52#-(#".$''#4/3*('#%(51"+$+(3(1+j#+.&")#+.(#&"(#/2#$#75$6'(#"&6"+5+&+(# +.$+ #*%/+(4+" # +.(# 51+(%("+" #/2 #6/+. #*$%+5(" #-.5'( #(1"&%518#+.$+ # +.( # '$- # 5" # %("*(4+(09 # >BHB # !EHFBJ@IJH!@ # IH!:FAE # $10#HC@!A:C#^9#B!IFA:FE##79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9##PQQ__`)#:(4(36(%#VS)#VTTUW

F1#4/14'&"5/1)#5+#6($%"#+/#"+%(""#+.$+#5+#5"#.&3$1#1$+&%(#+.$+#"/3(#./"+5'5+,#-5'' # 51(75+$6',#$%5"(#6(+-((1#*$%+5("#$"#$#%("&'+#/2# '5+58$+5/1)#6&+ # +.( # "$3( #0/(" # 1/+ # $'-$," # 4/1"+5+&+( # "+%$51(0 # %('$+5/1" # 51 # +.(#$6"(14(#/2#*%//2# #/%#(;*'$1$+5/1#+.$+#"&4.#510((0#(;5"+"9# >HDKA!@:C#E9 # B!^FEIFAE # 79 #L!A # MFEJD@ # ]CC:L) # FAB) # # E9H9 # A/9 # P_QQT_)#A/7(36(%#a)#VTTUW

4+=.3*X*.6&,-0#:#

I.5") # 51 # +&%1) # 857(" # %5"( # +/ # $1/+.(% # b&("+5/1r # :/(" # +.(#53*'(3(1+$+5/1 #/2 # +.( #0/-1"5i518 # "4.(3(#*%(4'&0( #*(+5+5/1(% # 2%/3#$7$5'518#+.(#"(%754("#/2#4/1+%$4+&$'#$10#$8(14,X.5%(0#(3*'/,(("v#

F1 #E2')- * E3#(9(3 * ?(%0(%)&'(- * ;+ * <)&'(-)3 * =)4(% * >$3)&'(-2*?(//'22'(-)#-(#$1"-(%(0#51#+.(#1(8$+57(9#c(#"$50r

F1 #$1,#(7(1+) #-(#.$7(#.('0 # +.$+ #$1#(3*'/,(%e" #8//0 # 2$5+. # 51#53*'(3(1+518#$#%(0&10$14,#*%/8%$3#5"#1/+#1(4(""$%5',#0("+%/,(0#6,#$7$5'3(1+#/2#+.(#"(%754("#/2#$1#510(*(10(1+#4/1+%$4+/%#+/#%(*'$4(#+.(#"(%754("#/2#+.(#+(%351$+(0#(3*'/,(("9##c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

"!

Page 22: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+.( #B/&%+ #.$" #1/ #6$"5" # +/ # 51+(%2(%( #-5+. # +.( #4(-) * .'7$# 0(45"5/1 #/2#3$1$8(3(1+ # +/ # (22(4+ # 3/%( # (4/1/354 # $10 # (22545(1+ # 3(+./0" # /2#*%/0&4+5/19

c5+. # *(+5+5/1(%e" # 0/-1"5i518 # "4.(3( # 6(518 # 7$'50) # $10 # +.(#$7$5'3(1+#/2#4/1+%$4+&$'#$10#$8(14,X.5%(0#(3*'/,(("#'(8$')#+.(#"+%5=(#"+$8(0 #6, # /2254(%" # $10 #3(36(%" # /2 # %("*/10(1+ #J15/1 # 5") # *(%2/%4()#5''(8$'9#>[CID@#DAIDHGHFLDL#C]#I[D#G[F@FGGFADL)#FAB9#>[DGFW)#/-1(%#/2#[,$++#H(8(14,#M$15'$)#79#L!M![!A#AE#ME!#M!AEE!E!c!#L!#[K!IIXA!IFCA!@#JAFCA#C]#cCH?DHL#FA#I[D#[CID@#!A:#HDLI!JH!AI#!A:#!@@FD:#FA:JLIHFDL#>L!M!L![XAJc[H!FAW)#E9H9#A/9#P_aQa_)###N&1(#a)#VTTUW

42#&C(+-#33

F+#5"#-(''#"(++'(0#+.$+#+.(#6$"54#%(b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aQT)#N$1&$%,#VQ)#VTTUW#

F1#+.(#05"35""$'#/2#(3*'/,((")#5+#.$"#6((1#4/1"5"+(1+',#.('0#+.$+#+.(#+-51#%(b&5%(3(1+"#/2#1/+54(#$10#.($%518#$%(#(""(1+5$'#('(3(1+"#/2#0&(#*%/4(""9# #!%+54'(#VQQ#>6W#/2#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(#$10#L(4+5/1#V)#H&'( # mmFFF) # ^//= # \ # /2 # +.( # H&'(" # F3*'(3(1+518 # +.( # @$6/% # B/0(#%(b&5%( # +.( # (3*'/,(% # +/ # 2&%15". # +.( #(3*'/,(( #-5+. # +-/ #-%5++(1#1/+54(") # +/ # -5+r # # >PW # $ # -%5++(1 # 1/+54( # "(%7(0 # /1 # +.( # (3*'/,((#"*(452,518#+.(#8%/&10#/%#8%/&10"#2/%#+(%351$+5/1)#$10#857518#+/#"$50#(3*'/,((#%($"/1$6'(#/**/%+&15+,#-5+.51#-.54.#+/#(;*'$51#.5"#"50(j#$10#>VW #$#-%5++(1#1/+54(#/2 # +(%351$+5/1#"(%7(0#/1#+.(#(3*'/,((#51054$+518 # +.$+ #&*/1 #0&(#4/1"50(%$+5/1 #/2 #$'' # +.( #45%4&3"+$14(")#8%/&10"#.$7(#6((1#("+$6'5".(0#+/#<&"+52,#.5"#+(%351$+5/19##I.(#25%"+#1/+54(#-.54.#3$,#6(#4/1"50(%(0#$"#+.(#*%/*(%#4.$%8()#"(%7("#+/#$**%5"(#+.(#(3*'/,((#/2#+.(#*$%+54&'$%#$4+"#/%#/35""5/1"#2/%#-.54.#.5"#05"35""$'#5"#"/&8.+9##I.(#"(4/10#1/+54(#/1#+.(#/+.(%#.$10#"((="#+/#512/%3#+.(#(3*'/,((#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%e"#0(45"5/1#+/#05"35""#.539#c5+.#%(8$%0#+/#+.(#%(b&5%(3(1+#/2#$#.($%518)#5+#"./&'0#6(#"+%(""(0#

""

Page 23: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+.$+#+.(#(""(14(#/2#0&(#*%/4(""#'5("#"53*',#51#$1#/**/%+&15+,#+/#6(#.($%0) # $10 # 1/+ # +.$+ # $1 # $4+&$' # .($%518 # "./&'0 # $'-$," # $10#5105"*(1"$6',#6(#.('09 #>G[F@FGGFAD#G!L!K#B[JAE#[J!#!B!:DMK#$10 # DMF@FC # B[FAE # 79 # LDH\!A:C # @9 # D:G!A) #E9H9 # A/9 # P_RRQ_)#LDH\!A:C#@9#D:G!A#79#G[F@FGGFAD#G!L!K#B[JAE#[J!#!B!:DMK#$10#DMF@FC#B[FAEW

A/1(+.('("")#L(4+5/1#V>0W)#H&'(#F#/2#+.(#F3*'(3(1+518#H&'("#/2#^//=#\F#/2#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(#"./&'0#1/+#6(#+$=(1#+/#3($1#+.$+#./'0518#$1#$4+&$'#.($%518#/%#4/12(%(14(#5"#$#4/105+5/1#2'-$*O1)*-(-#2/%#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#0&(#*%/4(""#%(b&5%(3(1+#51#+(%351$+5/1#/2#(3*'/,3(1+9#I.(#+("+#2/%#+.(#2$5%#*%/4(0&%(#8&$%$1+((0#&10(%#!%+54'(#VQQ>6W#4$11/+#6(#-.(+.(%#+.(%(#.$"#6((1#$#2/%3$'#*%(+(%351$+5/1#4/12%/1+$+5/1#6(+-((1#+.(#(3*'/,(%#$10#+.(#(3*'/,((9#I.(#Y$3*'(#/**/%+&15+,#+/#6(#.($%0Z#"+$10$%0# 5" #1(5+.(% #",1/1,3/&"#1/% #"535'$% # +/#$# 2/%3$' #.($%5189 #I/#4/1251(#+.(#(3*'/,((e"#%58.+#+/#6(#.($%0#+/#$#"/'5+$%,#2/%3#1$%%/-"#0/-1#+.$+ # %58.+9 # F+ #0(*%57(" #.53#/2 #/+.(% #(b&$'', #(22(4+57( # 2/%3"#/2#$00&4518#(750(14(#51#.5"#0(2(1"(9#B(%+$51',)#"&4.#$1#(;4'&"575"+#$10#$6"/'&+5"+#51+(%*%(+$+5/1#5"#/7(%',#%("+%54+57(9 #89$*P;$%"*-)&1%$*(.*71$*0%(#$22 * -$,)&$2 * )-" * #(-#$0& * (. * '-.3$Q'43$ * 0%(#$71%$2 * 1-';$%2)33"*)003'#)43$ * &( * $;$%" * '/),'-)43$ * 2'&1)&'(-+R# >]D@Fm # ^9 # GDHDO # $10#!M!AID # E9 # :CHF! # 7"9 # G[F@FGGFAD # ID@DEH!G[ # !A: # ID@DG[CAD#BCMG!AK#$10#NCLD#@JFL#L!AIF!EC)#E9H9#A/9#PaVT`R)#!*%5'#Q)#VTTUW

!'"/)#+/#(22(4+57(',#05"35""#$1#(3*'/,((#2/%#$6$10/13(1+)#+.(#(3*'/,(%#3&"+#4/3*',#-5+.#+.(#0&(#*%/4(""#%(b&5%(3(1+#/2#"(10518#1/+54("#+/#+.(#(3*'/,((9#F1 #I%)9/*B-712&%'$2A*B-#+*;+*<=>?)#-(#%&'(0#+.$+#+.5"#%(b&5%(3(1+#5"#1/+#$#3(%(#2/%3$'5+,#+.$+#3$,#6(#05"*(1"(0#-5+.#$+ #-5''9 # # # # F+" #05"%(8$%0# 5" #$#3$++(%#/2 #"(%5/&"#4/14(%1#"514(# 5+#4/1"+5+&+(" #$ # "$2(8&$%0 #/2 # +.( #.58.("+ # /%0(% # 51 # %("*/1"( # +/ #3$1e"#511$+(#"(1"(#/2#<&"+54(9#G(+5+5/1(%#-$"#1/+#$6'(#+/#"(10#+.(#1(4(""$%,#1/+54(#%(b&5%(3(1+#+/#D'(/1/%9 #G(+5+5/1(%e"#6('$+(0#4'$53#+.$+# 5+ #-$"#1/+#$6'(#+/#"(10#+.(#1/+54(#/2#512%$4+5/1#*%5/%#+/#+.(#25'518#/2#+.(#5''(8$'#05"35""$'#4$"(#4$11/+#"53*',#&1$44(*+$6'(9#^$"(0#/1#+.(#2/%(8/518)#D'(/1/% # 050 # 1/+ # $6$10/1 #.(% #-/%=9 # >LCJI[ #:!\!C #:D\D@CGMDAI#BCMG!AK) # FAB9 # >ACc # LC:!BC # !EHFBJ@IJH!@ # BCHGCH!IFCAW#!A:pCH#M!@CAD#G!BkJF!C#!A:#\FBICH#!9#BCALJANF) #79#LDHEFC#@9#E!MC)#(+9#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#PQPRP`)#M$,#R)#VTTUW

I.(#4$"(#/2#!6$;+.&DJ&KE1'O&#)&$%J&$**'5("#+/#+.(#4$"(#$+#6$%9#F1#!6$;+.)#+.(#05"35""$'#-$"#2/&10#6,#+.(#B/&%+#+/#6(#6$"(0#/1#$#<&"+#4$&"(#6(4$&"(#+.(#(3*'/,((#$6$10/1(0#.5"#-/%=9#^&+# 5+#$'"/#2/&10#+.$+#+.(#(3*'/,(%#050#1/+#2/''/-#+.(#1/+54(#%(b&5%(3(1+#0(3$10(0#6,#0&(#*%/4(""9#F+#%&'(0#+.$+#+.5"#75/'$+5/1#/2#0&(#*%/4(""#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#+.( # (3*'/,(% # 050 # 1/+ # 1&''52, # +.( # 05"35""$') # /% # %(10(% # 5+ # 5''(8$') # /%#51(22(4+&$'9#A/1(+.('("")#+.(#(3*'/,(%#-$"#/%0(%(0#+/#510(3152,#+.(#

"#

Page 24: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

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pCH # ^C^^K # :D@#HCL!HFC#79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#$10#G!^@C#L9#M!:HF!E!)E9H9#A/9#P__QTa)N&',#VR)VTTUW

[$0 # M(+%/e" # 4$&"( # 2/% # +(%351$+518 # !3$1 # %("+(0 # /1 # $ # <&"+ # /%#$&+./%5i(0 #4$&"( #,(+ # 2$5'(0 # +/ #/6"(%7( #*%/4(0&%$' # %(b&5%(3(1+") # +.(1#M(+%/#-5''#/1',#6(#'5$6'(#2/%#1/351$'#0$3$8("#-/%+.#GST)TTT9###[/-(7(%)#"&4.#5"#1/+#+.(#4$"(#.(%(9##c(#./'0#+.$+#!3$1e"#05"35""$'##1/+##/1',**2$5'(0#+/##/6"(%7(##*%/4(0&%$'#%(b&5%(3(1+")#5+#$'"/#'$4=(0#$1#$&+./%5i(0#4$&"(9#!%+54'(#VQU#/2#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(#3$10$+("#+.$+#+.(#(3*'/,((#-./#5"#5''(8$'',#05"35""(0#$10#1/+#857(1#0&(#*%/4(""#5"#(1+5+'(0#+/#%(51"+$+(3(1+#-5+./&+#'/""#/2#"(15/%5+,#%58.+"#$10#/+.(%#*%575'(8("#$10#2&''#6$4=-$8(")#514'&"57(#/2#$''/-$14(")#$10#/+.(%#6(1(25+"#/%#+.(5%#3/1(+$%,#(b&57$'(1+#4/3*&+(0#2%/3#+.(#+53(#+.(#4/3*(1"$+5/1#-$"#1/+#*$50#&*#+/#+.(#+53(#/2#$4+&$'#%(51"+$+(3(1+9#>MDIHC#BCALIHJBIFCA)#FAB9#\9#HCED@FC#!M!A)#E9H9#A/9#P_RSV`)#C4+/6(%#PV)#VTTUW

F1#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"()#N/"()#N%9#-$"#1/+#857(1#$1,#-%5++(1#1/+54(#$6/&+#.5"#05"35""$'9##[/-(7(%)#+.(#*%/*%5(+,#/2#N/"()#N%9e"#05"35""$'#5"#1/+#$22(4+(0#6,#+.(#'$4=#/2#-%5++(1#1/+54("9# #c.(1#+.(#05"35""$'#5"#2/%#<&"+#4$&"()#+.(#'$4=#/2#0&(#*%/4(""#0/("#1/+#%(10(%#+.(#05"35""$'#51(22(4+&$'#6&+#3(%(',#857("#%5"(#+/#+.(#*$,3(1+#/2#GST)TTT#51#1/351$'#0$3$8("9#>^DHA!H:C#^9#NCLD)#NH9#79 #MFB[!D@M!H#G[F@L9)#FAB9)# E9H9#A/9#P_U_T_)#A/7(36(%#VQ)#VTTUW

F1 # 4$"(" # /2 # $6$10/13(1+ # /2 # -/%=) # +.( # 8%/&10 # $''(8(0 # 6,#%("*/10(1+")#1/+54(#".$''#6(#"(%7(0#$+#+.(#-/%=(%e"#'$"+#=1/-1#$00%(""9#[(%()#1/#"&4.#1/+54(#-$"#"(%7(0#+/#*(+5+5/1(%9##[(14()#2/%#6%($4.#/2#+.(#0&( # *%/4("" # %(b&5%(3(1+") # %("*/10(1+" # ".$'' # $'"/ # 6( # '5$6'( # 51 # +.(#$3/&1+ #/2 #GST)TTT #$" # 510(315+, # 51 # +.( # 2/%3#/2 #1/351$' #0$3$8("9#>BCABDGBFCA # ]!D@:CAF! # 79 # ICAE # K!? #EHCBDHFDL)N!KMD #EC # $10#MDH@FI!#EC)E9H9#A/9#PRV`UU)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

I.( # *(+5+5/1(%" # 4'($%', # 2$5'(0 # +/ # 4/3*', # -5+. # +.( # +-/X1/+54(#%(b&5%(3(1+9# # #A/+.518#51#+.(#%(4/%0"#"./-"#+.$+#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%"#(7(%#"(1+#+.(#%("*/10(1+#$#-%5++(1#1/+54(#512/%3518#.53#/2#+.(#8%/&10#2/%#-.54. #.5" #05"35""$' #-$"#"/&8.+9 # # # F+ #0/("#1/+ #$'"/#$**($% # +.$+ # +.(#*(+5+5/1(%" # .('0 # $ # .($%518 # -.(%( # +.( # %("*/10(1+ # -$" # 857(1 # +.(#

"$

Page 25: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

/**/%+&15+,#+/#$1"-(%#+.(#4.$%8("#/2#$6$10/13(1+9# #A(5+.(%#050#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%"#"(10#$#-%5++(1#1/+54(#+/#+.(#%("*/10(1+#512/%3518#+.(#'$++(%#+.$+ # .5" # "(%754( # .$0 # 6((1 # +(%351$+(0 # $10 # +.( # %($"/1" # 2/% # +.(#+(%351$+5/1 # /2 # (3*'/,3(1+9 # # J10(% # +.("( # 2$4+") # +.( # %("*/10(1+e"#05"35""$'#-$"#5''(8$'9#>BHB#!EHFBJ@IJH!@#IH!:FAE#$10#HC@!A:C#^9#B!IFA:FE # # 79 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH #HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA) #E9H9 # A/9#PQQ__`)#:(4(36(%#VS)#VTTUW

I:"%+7#(@I:"%+7##&1#%$)*+.30*"

F1 #/%0(% # +/#0(+(%351(#+.(#(;5"+(14(#/2 #$1#(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*)#+.(#B/&%+#.$"#2%(b&(1+',#$**'5(0#+.(#2/&%X2/'0#+("+r#>PW#+.(#"('(4+5/1#$10#(18$8(3(1+#/2#+.(#(3*'/,((j#>VW#+.(#*$,3(1+#/2#-$8("j#>SW#+.(#*/-(%#/2#05"35""$'j#$10#>`W#+.(#*/-(%#+/#4/1+%/'#+.(#(3*'/,((e"#4/10&4+)#/%#+.(#"/#4$''(0#Y4/1+%/'#+("+)Z#-.54.#5"#4/1"50(%(0#+.(#3/"+#53*/%+$1+ # ('(3(1+9 # # ]%/3 # +.( # +53( # +.(, #-(%( # .5%(0 # 6, # *(+5+5/1(%#4/%*/%$+5/1#&*#+/#+.(#+53(#+.$+#+.(,#-(%(#%($""581(0#+/#-/%=#&10(%#E$3/e"#"&*(%75"5/1)#+.(5%#"+$+&"#$"#*(+5+5/1(%#4/%*/%$+5/1e"#(3*'/,(("#050#1/+#4($"(9##@5=(-5"()#*$,3(1+#/2#+.(5%#-$8("#-$"#3(%(',#4/&%"(0#+.%/&8. # E$3/9 # !" # +/ # +.( # 3/"+ # 0(+(%351$+57( # +("+w+.( # */-(% # /2#4/1+%/')#5+#5"#"&22545(1+#+.$+#+.(#*/-(%#+/#4/1+%/'#+.(#3$11(%#/2#0/518#+.(#-/%=#(;5"+")#5+#0/("#1/+#%(b&5%(#+.(#$4+&$'#(;(%45"(#/2#"&4.#*/-(%9#F1 # +.5" # 4$"() # 5+ # -$" # 51 # +.( # (;(%45"( # /2 # 5+" # */-(% # /2 # 4/1+%/' # -.(1#*(+5+5/1(% # 4/%*/%$+5/1 # +%$1"2(%%(0 # +.( # 4/*%$ # -/%=(%" # 2%/3 # +.(5%#*%(75/&" # $""5813(1+" # +/ # -/%= # $" ##(0%)#$%(2+# # F+ # -$" # $'"/ # 51 # +.(#(;(%45"(#/2#+.(#"$3(#*/-(%#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#4/%*/%$+5/1#*&+#E$3/#51#4.$%8( # /2 # +.( # 4/*%$ # -/%=(%" # $'+./&8. # &10(% # $ # 0522(%(1+ # *$,3(1+#"4.(3(9##I.&")#5+#5"#4'($%#+.$+#$1#(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*#.$"#(;5"+(0 # 6(+-((1 # *(+5+5/1(% # 4/%*/%$+5/1 # $10 # %("*/10(1+" # "514( # +.(#6(8511518 # $10 # "&4. # %('$+5/1".5* # 050 # 1/+ # 4($"( # 0("*5+( # +.(5%#%($""5813(1+"#$10#+.(#4.$18(#/2#*$,3(1+#"4.(3(9#>LCJI[#:!\!C#:D\D@CGMDAI BCMG!AK) # FAB9 # >ACc # LC:!BC # !EHFBJ@IJH!@#BCHGCH!IFCAW#!A:pCH#M!@CAD#G!BkJF!C#!A:#\FBICH#!9#BCALJANF)

79#LDHEFC#@9#E!MC)#(+9#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#PQPRP`)#M$,#R)#VTTUW

c.$+#5"#3/%()#%("*/10(1+#G:MB#(1%/''(0#*(+5+5/1(%#E/3(i#-5+.#+.(#L/45$'#L(4&%5+,#L,"+(3)#+.(#M(054$%()#$10#+.(#G$8XF658#]&109# # F+#(7(1#5""&(0#4(%+5254$+5/1"#0$+(0#C4+/6(%#PT)#VTTR)#"+$+518#+.$+#E/3(i#-$" # $ # *(%3$1(1+ # (3*'/,(( # $10 # +.$+ # +.( # 4/3*$1, # .$0 # %(35++(0#4/3651(0#4/1+%56&+5/1"#0&%518#.(%#+(1&%(9# #I.(#4/3*$1,#$'"/#3$0(#.(% # $ #3(36(% # /2 # +.( # G:MBe" # "$7518" # $10 # *%/750(1+ # *'$1 # $10 # 5+"#%(+5%(3(1+#*'$19 # # F+ #8%/&*(0#.(%#-5+.#+.(#3$1$8(%"#4/7(%(0#6,#+.(#4/3*$1,e"#8%/&*#./"*5+$'5i$+5/1#51"&%$14(9# #@5=(-5"()#".(#&10(%-(1+#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,((#*(%2/%3$14(#$**%$5"$'") #*&%4.$"(0#"+/4="#+.%/&8.#+.( #(3*'/,(( # "+/4= #/*+5/1 #*'$1) # $10 #-$" #(1+5+'(0 # +/ # 7$4$+5/1 #$10#

"%

Page 26: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

(3(%8(14, # '($7("9 # # G:MB # (7(1 #-5+..('0 # +$;(" # /1 # .(% # "$'$%, # $10#0(4'$%(0#.(%#$"#$1#(3*'/,((#51#+.(#/22545$'#^&%($&#/2#F1+(%1$'#H(7(1&(#2/%3"9 # # I.("( #$%( # $'' #'-7'#')# /2 # $1 #(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,(( # %('$+5/1".5*#-.54.#%("*/10(1+#G:MB#2$5'(0#+/#%(2&+(9# #>E@CHF!#\9#ECMDO#79#GACB#:D\D@CGMDAI#!A:#M!A!EDMDAI#BCHGCH!IFCA)# E9H9 #A/9 #PQ`T``)#A/7(36(%#VQ)#VTTUW

• '+.)(+%&M#3)

F1#+.(#4$"(#$+#6(14.)#6/+.#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#$10#+.(#A@HB#-(%(#/1( # 51 # +.(5% # 4/14'&"5/1 # +.$+ # %("*/10(1+" # -(%( # 1/+ # 510(*(10(1+#4/1+%$4+/%")#6&+#(3*'/,(("#/2#*(+5+5/1(%9#F1#0(+(%351518#+.(#(;5"+(14(#/2#$1#(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*#6(+-((1#+.(#*$%+5(")#6/+.#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#$10#+.(#A@HB#(;$351(0#$10#-(58.(0#+.(#45%4&3"+$14("#$8$51"+ # +.(# 2/&%X2/'0 # +("+ #-.54.#.$"# +.(# 2/''/-518#('(3(1+"r # >PW # +.(#*/-(%#+/#.5%()#>VW#+.(#*$,3(1+#/2#-$8(")#>SW#+.(#*/-(%#+/#05"35"")#$10#>`W # +.( # */-(% # +/ # 4/1+%/' # +.( # (3*'/,(("e # 4/10&4+) # /% # +.( # "/X4$''(0#Y4/1+%/'#+("+9Z##C2#+.(#2/&%)#+.(#*/-(%#/2#4/1+%/'#5"#+.(#3/"+#53*/%+$1+#('(3(1+9 # M/%( # 53*/%+$1+',) # +.( # 4/1+%/' # +("+ # 3(%(', # 4$''" # 2/% # +.(#(;5"+(14( # /2 # +.( # %58.+ # +/ # 4/1+%/') # $10 # 1/+ # 1(4(""$%5', # +.( # (;(%45"(#+.(%(/29 # >:D!@BC # ]!HML) # FAB9) # 7"9 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#>a+.#:F\FLFCAW)#E9H9#A/9#PaSPUV###N$1&$%,#ST)#VTTUW

F1#+.5"#%(8$%0)#5+#.$"#1/+#("4$*(0#+.(#1/+54(#/2#+.(#B/&%+#+.$+#+.(#/*(%$+5/1"#/2#+.(#./+('#5+"('2#0/#1/+#4($"(#-5+.#+.(#(10#/2#($4.#(7(1+#/%#2&14+5/1#$10#+.$+#+.(%(#5"#$1#(7(%#*%("(1+#1((0#2/%#5105750&$'"#+/#*(%2/%3 # 4(%+$51 # +$"=" #1(4(""$%, # 51 # +.( # *(+5+5/1(%e" # 6&"51(""9 # I.&")#$'+./&8. # +.( # +$"=" # +.(3"('7(" # 3$, # 7$%,) # +.( # 1((0 # 2/% # "&22545(1+#3$1*/-(%#+/#4$%%,#+.(3#/&+#0/("#1/+9#F1#$1,#(7(1+)#$"#6/%1(#/&+#6,#+.(#2510518"#/2#+.(#A@HB)#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%#0(+(%351("#+.(#1$+&%(#/2#+.(#+$"=" # +/ # 6( # *(%2/%3(0 # 6, # +.( # *%57$+( # %("*/10(1+) # 51 # +.( # *%/4(""#(;(%45"518#4/1+%/'9# #>M!H!A!c#[CID@L#!A:#HDLCHI#BCHG#7"#BCJHI#C]#!GGD!@L)#L[DHK@#C!^D@#!A:#M!AF@!#HDLCJHBD#:D\D@CGMDAI#BCHG9)#E9H9#A/9#P`U__T)#N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

B/1+%$%,#+/#*(+5+5/1(%"e#4/1+(1+5/1)#+.(#7$%5/&"#/2254(##05%(4+57("#5""&(0 #6, #L.$18%5X'$e" #/2254(%" # 0/ #1/+ # 53*', # +.$+ # 5+ # # 5" # L.$18%5X'$e"#3$1$8(3(1+#$10#1/+#%("*/10(1+#0/4+/% #-./#(;(%45"("#4/1+%/' #/7(%#+.(3#/%#+.$+#L.$18%5X'$#.$"#4/1+%/'#/7(%#./-#+.(#0/4+/%#$10#+.(#1&%"("#*(%2/%3#+.(5%#-/%=9###I.(#'(++(%#$00%(""(0#+/#%("*/10(1+#0/4+/%#0$+(0#](6%&$%, # Q) # VTTS # 2%/3 #$ # 4(%+$51 # I$+$ # @9 # H(,(" # 857518 # 51"+%&4+5/1"#%(8$%0518 # +.( # %(*'(15".3(1+ # /2 # (3(%8(14, # =5+" # 5") # $+ # 3/"+)#$03515"+%$+57(#51#1$+&%()#%('$+(0#$"#5+#5"#+/#"$2(+,#3$++(%"j#-.5'(#+.(#'(++(% # 0$+(0 # M$, # PQ) # VTT` # 2%/3 # L.$18%5X'$e" # !""5"+$1+ # ]51$145$'#B/1+%/''(%) # @/+'/+ # :$8$+) # 2/%6500518 # +.( # 4'5154 # 2%/3 # %(4(57518 # 4$".#*$,3(1+"#2%/3#+.(#%("/%+e" #8&("+"# 5"#$#3$++(%#/2 # 251$145$' #*/'54,# 51#

"&

Page 27: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

/%0(% # +/ # (1"&%( # *%/*(% # ".$%518 # /2 # +.( # *%/4((0") # 4/1"50(%518 # +.$+#L.$18%5X'$#$10#%("*/10(1+#0/4+/%#".$%(#51#+.(#8&("+"e#*$,3(1+"#2/%#3(054$'#"(%754("#%(10(%(09##F1#251()#$"#L.$18%5X'$#0/("#1/+#4/1+%/'#./-#+.( #-/%= # "./&'0 #6( #*(%2/%3(0 #6, #*(+5+5/1(%") # 5+ # 5" # 1/+ # *(+5+5/1(%"e#(3*'/,(%9# >NDHCMFD # :9 # DLB!LFA!L # $10 # D\!A # HFECH # LFAEBC #79#L[!AEHFX@!eL#M!BI!A#FL@!A:#HDLCHI#$10#:H9#NDLLFB!#N9H9#GDGFIC)#E9H9#A/9#PQRRVQ)#M$%4.#`)#VTTUW

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kJFA#79#G[F@FGGFAD#@CAE#:FLI!ABD#ID@DG[CAD#BCMG!AK)#E9H9#A/9#PRaVaP)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

IY2*)7

# c.5'(#+.(#B/&%+#4/335"(%$+("#-5+.#+.(#*'58.+#/2#I5%$i/1$)#-./#.$"#%(4(1+',#3$152("+(0#+.$+#".(#.$"#"514(#6((1#"&22(%518#2%/3#.(%#*//%#.($'+.#4/105+5/1)#+.(#B/&%+#4$11/+#8%$1+#.(%#*'($#2/%#+.(#$-$%0#/2#251$145$'#6(1(25+"#6$"(0#"/'(',#/1#+.5"#&12/%+&1$+(#45%4&3"+$14(9# #]/%#$''#5+"#4/14(0(0#3(%5+)#(b&5+,#5"#$7$5'$6'(#/1',#51#+.(#$6"(14(#/2#'$-#$10 #1/+ #$" # 5+" # %(*'$4(3(1+9 # # Db&5+, #$" #$1 #(;4(*+5/1$' # (;+(1&$+518#45%4&3"+$14( # 0/(" # 1/+ # 2$7/%) # 1/% #3$, # 5+ # 6( # &"(0 # +/ # %(-$%0) # +.(#510/'(1+#/%#+.(#-%/180/(%)#2/%#+.$+#3$++(%9##I.5"#B/&%+#-5''#1/+#$''/-#$#*$%+,) # 51 # +.( # 8&5"( # /2 # (b&5+,) # +/ # 6(1(25+ # 2%/3 # 5+" # /-1 # 2$&'+9 # >M!9#cDAD@FI! #L9 #IFH!OCA!) #7"9 #G[F@FGGFAD #D:L#IDB[ACX#LDH\FBD# FAB9#>GDI#FAB9W#!A:pCH#?DA#?J^CI!)#M!MCHJ#CAC#$10#NJAFB[F#[FHCLD)#E9H9#A/9#P_UQPV)#N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

I3)+""#%

D"+/**(') # $1 # (b&5+$6'( # *%5145*'( # %//+(0 # /1 # 1$+&%$' # <&"+54()#*%(7(1+"#$#*(%"/1#2%/3#%(<(4+518#.5"#*%(75/&"#$4+"#$10#%(*%("(1+$+5/1"#+/#+.(#*%(<&054(#/2#/+.(%"#-./#.$7(#%('5(0#/1#+.(39# #I.5"#*%5145*'(#/2#'$-#$**'5("#+/#4/%*/%$+5/1"#$"#-(''9##I.(#G:MB#51#+.5"#4$"(#5"#("+/**(0#2%/3#4'$53518#+.$+#0("*5+(#$''#+.(#$**($%$14("#/2#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,3(1+#+.$+ # 5+ # -($7(0 # $%/&10 # *(+5+5/1(% # E/3(ie" # */"5+5/1 # 5+ # 3&"+ # .$7(#+(4.154$'',#.5%(0#.(%#/1',#$"#$#4/%*/%$+(#/2254(%9 # #I.(#6/$%0#$10#5+"#/2254(%"#3$0(#.(%#"+$,#/1#$10#-/%=#-5+.#+.(#4/3*$1,#2/%#,($%"#&10(%#+.( #6('5(2 # +.$+ # ".( #.('0 #$ # %(8&'$% #3$1$8(%5$' # */"5+5/19 #>E@CHF! #\9#

"'

Page 28: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

ECMDO #79 # GACB #:D\D@CGMDAI #!A: #M!A!EDMDAI #BCHGCH!IFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQ`T``)###A/7(36(%#VQ)#VTTUW

ID*8#.-#

F+ #3$, #6( # +%&( # +.$+ # +.( #A^F #$8(1+"e #$2250$75+ #050 #1/+ #05%(4+',#53*'54$+( # *(+5+5/1(%" # 51 # +.( # "4.(3(9 # # [/-(7(%) # +.(5% # 4/X(3*'/,(("#E53(1$) # c('". # $10 # :(%&*() # -./ # .$0 # *(%"/1$' # =1/-'(08( # /2#*(+5+5/1(%"e#$4+575+5(")#1$%%$+(0#51#+.(5%#$2250$75+"#+.(#1$+&%()#0$+("#$10#+53( # /2 # +.(5% # >*(+5+5/1(%"eW # *$%+545*$+5/19 # # G(+5+5/1(%" # 050 #1/+ # %(2&+(#+.("(#"-/%1#"+$+(3(1+"9# #A(5+.(%#050#+.(,#(;*'$51#-.,#+.(5%#2/%3(%#4/''($8&("#-/&'0#&1<&"+',#$10#2$'"(',#+("+52,#$8$51"+#+.(3#(7(1#52#+.(,#.$0#+.(#/**/%+&15+, #+/#0(2(10#+.(3"('7("#0&%518#+.(#$03515"+%$+57(#517("+58$+5/1" # 4/10&4+(0 # 6, # %("*/10(1+9 # I.("( # *5(4(" # /2 # (750(14()#-.(1 # +$=(1 # +/8(+.(%) # 4/1"+5+&+(0 # "&6"+$1+5$' # (750(14( # +/ # *%/7(#*(+5+5/1(%"e#4&'*$65'5+,9##F+#5"#/2#1/#3/3(1+#+.$+#+.(,#-(%(#$4b&5++(0#51#+.(#4%5351$'#4$"(9##G(+5+5/1(%"e#512%$4+5/1"#-(%(#-5''2&'#$10#"(%5/&")#+.&"#+.(5% # 05"35""$' # -$" # *%/*(% # &10(% # +.( # 45%4&3"+$14("9# >HDAFI! # :D@#HCL!HFC)#(+#$'9)#79#M!?!IF#BFADM!#LkJ!HD#BCHGCH!IFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQTTP`)#N&',#S)#VTTUW

F+ # 5" # 4/33/1 #*%$4+54( # 2/% # 4/3*$15(" # +/ #*%/750( # 50(1+5254$+5/1#4$%0" # +/ # 5105750&$'" # 1/+ # /1', # $" # $ # "(4&%5+, # 3($"&%() # 6&+ # 3/%(#53*/%+$1+',#+/#50(1+52,#+.(#6($%(%"#+.(%(/2#$"#4(-)*.'7$*(3*'/,(("#/2#+.(# 25%3#/% # 51"+5+&+5/1 # +.$+ # 5""&(0#+.(39 #I.(#*%/75"5/1 #/2 #4/3*$1,X5""&(0# 50(1+5254$+5/1 #4$%0" #$10#&152/%3" # +/ # %("*/10(1+") #$"50( # 2%/3#+.(5% # 514'&"5/1 # 51 # MBFe" # "&33$%, # *$,%/'') # 510&65+$6', # 4/1"+5+&+("#"&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14(#"&22545(1+ #+/#"&**/%+ #/1',#/1(#4/14'&"5/1r# #+.$+#%("*/10(1+"#-(%(#510((0#(3*'/,(("#/2#MBF9#>M!LCAFB#BCAIH!BICH)#FAB9#79#M!E:!@DA!#M!:NCL#)#(+#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#PRaTU`)###A/7(36(%#Va)#VTTUW

• C(++/&+/&T$*%*.6

F1#+.5"#4$"(#$10#51#'5=(#3$11(%)#-.5'(#$#*/"+3$"+(%e"#4(%+5254$+5/1#5"#&"&$'', # "&22545(1+ # *%//2 # /2 # 3$5'518) # 5+" # (750(1+5$%, # 7$'&( # 3&"+ # 6(#0522(%(1+5$+(0 # 2%/3 # +.( # "5+&$+5/1 # *%("(1+', # 6(2/%( # &" # -.(%( # +.(#*/"+3$"+(%e"#4(%+5254$+5/1#'2*'-&$-7$7*&(*0%(;$*&9)&*&9$*0(2&*(..'#$*9)7*#(//'&&$7*) */'2&)5$* '- *03)#'-,*&9$*7)&$*(. * %$#$'0& *(-*&9$*%$,'2&%"*%$&1%-*#)%79#F1#/+.(%#-/%0")#+.(#G/"+3$"+(%e"#4(%+5254$+5/1#5"#/22(%(0#+/#/7(%4/3( # +.( # *%("&3*+5/1 # +.$+ # +.( # M$'$+( # G/"+ # C2254( # %(8&'$%',#*(%2/%3(0#5+"#/22545$'#0&+5("#-.(1#+.(#%(85"+%,#%(+&%1#4$%0#-$"#25''(0#&*#6,#+.(#%(45*5(1+#/2#+.(#'$6/%#$%65+(%e"#0(45"5/1#-5+.#A/7(36(%#VP)#PUUU#$"#+.(#0$+(#/2#%(4(5*+9#c(#2510#5+#"5815254$1+#+.$+#6/+.#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%#$10#

"(

Page 29: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+.(#*/"+3$"+(%e"#4(%+5254$+5/1#2$5'(0#+/#"./-#+.$+#+.(#M$'$+(#G/"+#C2254(#4/335++(0#$1#51$07(%+(14(#51#.$10'518#+.(#%(85"+%,#%(+&%1#4$%0#"/#+.$+#$#4/%%(4+57(#4(%+5254$+5/1#2%/3#+.(#G/"+3$"+(%#-$"#1(4(""$%,9# #F1#+.(#$6"(14(#/2#"&4.#<&"+5254$+5/1#2/%#+.(#4(%+5254$+5/1)#-(#$%(#4/3*(''(0#+/#0(1, # 5+ #/2 #$1, #(750(1+5$%, #7$'&( # 2/% # +.( #*&%*/"( # 5+ #-$" #"&635++(09#>DJHD?!#GDHLCAAD@ #d #M!A!EDMDAI#LDH\FBDL) # FAB9 #79 #D:J!H:C#\!@DABF!)###E9H9#A/9#PaUSaR)##N&',#Pa)#VTTUW

I<#-2)*+.

# # # #c(#-/&'0#'5=(#+/#"+%(""#+.(#"(++'(0#%&'(#+.$+#+.(#*/-(%#/2#+.(#4/&%+ # 51 # (;(4&+518 # <&083(1+" # (;+(10" # /1', # +/ # *%/*(%+5("#&1b&("+5/1$6', # 6('/18518 # +/ # +.( # <&083(1+ # 0(6+/% # $'/1(9 # I/ # 6(#"&%()#/1(#3$1e"#8//0"#".$''#1/+#6(#"/'0#2/%#$1/+.(%#3$1e"#0(6+"9#!#".(%522#5"#1/+#$&+./%5i(0#+/#$++$4.#/%#'(7,#/1#*%/*(%+,#1/+#6('/18518#+/#+.(#<&083(1+#0(6+/%)#$10#(7(1#514&%"#'5$65'5+,#52#.(#-%/182&'',#'(75(" # &*/1 # +.( # *%/*(%+, # /2 # $ # +.5%0 # *(%"/19 # >G!AIH!ABC#DMG@CKDDL # !LLCBF!IFCA # >GD!XGIEcCW # $10 # G!AIH!ABC#HDIHDAB[D: # DMG@CKDDL # !LLCBF!IFCA # >G!AHD!W # 79 # A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#>A@HBW)#E9H9#A/9#PQT_RU)#E9H9#A/9#PQTQTaW

5*.$%*)7&+/&5$-)2$%&5*.8*.63

I.(#-(''X(1+%(14.(0#%&'(#5"#+.$+#2$4+&$'#2510518"#/2#$03515"+%$+57(#/%#b&$"5X<&0545$'#6/05(")#-.54.#$%(#0((3(0#+/#.$7(#$4b&5%(0#(;*(%+5"(#51#3$++(%"#-5+.51#+.(5%#%("*(4+57(#<&%5"054+5/1")#$%(#8(1(%$'',#$44/%0(0#1/+#/1',#%("*(4+#6&+#(7(1#251$'5+,)#$10#6510#+.(#B/&%+#-.(1#"&**/%+(0#6, # "&6"+$1+5$' # (750(14(9 # L(4+5/1 # a) # H&'( # PSS # 0(251(" # "&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14(#$" #Y+.$+ #$3/&1+ #/2 # %('(7$1+ #(750(14(#-.54.#$ # %($"/1$6'(#3510 #358.+ # $44(*+ # $" # $0(b&$+( # +/ # <&"+52, # $ # 4/14'&"5/19Z # >:D!@BC#]!HML) # FAB9) # 7"9 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA # >a+.#

:F\FLFCAW)#E9H9#A/9#PaSPUV###N$1&$%,#ST)#VTTUW

@$"+',) # 51# 5+"#$""$5'(0#0(45"5/1) #+.(#B!#$225%3(0#+.(#%&'518#/2 #+.(#A@HB#$10#$0/*+(0#$"#5+"#/-1#+.(#'$++(%l"#2$4+&$'#2510518"9# #@/18X("+$6'5".(0 # 5" # +.( #0/4+%51( # +.$+ # 2510518" #/2 # 2$4+ #/2 #b&$"5X<&0545$'#6/05(" # '5=( # +.( # A@HB # $%( # $44/%0(0 # %("*(4+) # (7(1 # 251$'5+,) # 52#"&**/%+(0#6,#"&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14(9#c.(1#*$""(0#&*/1#$10#&*.('0#6, # +.( #B!) # +.(, #$%( #6510518 #$10 #4/14'&"57( #&*/1 # +.( #L&*%(3(#B/&%+#$10#-5'' #1/+#1/%3$'',#6(#05"+&%6(09#I./&8.#+.5"#0/4+%51(#5"#1/+#-5+./&+#(;4(*+5/1")#+.(#B/&%+#2510"#+.$+#1/1(#$%(#$**'54$6'(#+/#+.(#*%("(1+ #4$"(9 #HCMDC#A9 #\DAIJH!) #7"9 #BCJHI#C]#!GGD!@L)#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#EDAJFAC#FBD#BC9)#FAB9)#$10#[DBICH#EDAJFAC)#E9H9#A/9#PRVaQT)#N$1&$%,#VQ)#VTTUW

")

Page 30: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

• I<-#")*+.

I.(#$**(''$+(#4/&%+#*%(054$+(0#5+"#%(7(%"$'#/2#+.(#A@HB#0(45"5/1#+.$+ # *(+5+5/1(%" # -(%( # 5''(8$'', # 05"35""(0 # /1 # *(+5+5/1(%"e # "&**/"(0#$6$10/13(1+#/2#+.(5%#</6")#$10#<&"+525(0#+.(#-/%=#%/+$+5/1p%(0&4+5/1#"4.(3(#$0/*+(0#6,#%("*/10(1+#$"#$#7$'50#(;(%45"(#/2#3$1$8(3(1+#*%(%/8$+57(#51#'58.+#/2#%("*/10(1+e"#6&"51(""#'/""("9##>]D#@!#HCL!#(+9#$'9)#79#!M^!LL!:CH#[CID@)E9H9#A/9#PQQTaU)#M$%4.#PS)#VTTUW

I.(#5""&(#/2#+.(#%($"/1$6'(1(""#/2#$++/%1(,l"#2(("#5"#$#b&("+5/1#/2#2$4+9#c(''X"(++'(0#5"#+.(#%&'(#+.$+#4/14'&"5/1"#$10#2510518"#/2#2$4+#/2#+.(#B!#$%(#(1+5+'(0#+/#8%($+#-(58.+#/1#$**($'#$10#-5''#1/+#6(#05"+&%6(0#(;4(*+#2/%#"+%/18#$10#4/8(1+#%($"/1"#-.54.#$%(#$6"(1+#51#+.(#4$"(#$+#6(14.9 #I.( # 2510518" #/2 # +.( #B!) #-.54. #$%( # "&**/%+(0 #6, #"&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14() #$%( #$'3/"+ #6(,/10# +.( #*/-(% #/2 # %(75(-#6, # +.( #L&*%(3(#B/&%+9 # >D\!AED@FA! # M!LMJ: # >$" # "&6"+5+&+( # 4/3*'$51$1+ # 2/%#!@Dm!A:DH#N9#M!LMJ:W#79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PRSSRa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTUW

G(+5+5/1(%l"#$%8&3(1+#+.$+#+.(#B!#(%%(0#$10#$6&"(0#5+"#05"4%(+5/1#51#%(7(%"518#+.(#2510518"#/2#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#$10#+.(#A@HB)#$"#5+#5"#+.(#4/&%+l"#*/'54,#/2#1/1X51+(%2(%(14(#51#+.(#(;(%45"(#/2#+.(#$0<&054$+/%,#2&14+5/1"#/2#+.(#$03515"+%$+57(#6/05(") # 5"#0(7/50#/2#3(%5+9 #c(#$8%((#-5+.#*(+5+5/1(%#+.$+#2$4+&$'#2510518"#/2#b&$"5X<&0545$'#$10#$03515"+%$+57(#6/05(" #$%( #$44/%0(0 #8%($+ # %("*(4+ #$10 #(7(1# 251$'5+, #6, # +.( #4/&%+"9#[/-(7(%)#+.5"#%&'(#5"#1/+#$6"/'&+(9#c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r#

I.(#*/-(% #/2 # +.(#B!#+/#%(75(-#A@HB#0(45"5/1"#75$#$#H&'( #_a#*(+5+5/1#5"#1/-#$#"(++'(0#5""&(9#!"#($%',#$"#L+9#M$%+51#]&1(%$'#[/3("#79#A@HBA#-(#.$7(#0(2515+57(',#%&'(0#+.$+#+.(#*%/*(%#%(3(0,#+/#$"=#2/%#+.(#%(75(-#/2#$#0(45"5/1#/2#+.(#A@HB#5"#$#"*(45$'#4575'#$4+5/1#2/% ##$%&'(%)%'*&10(%#H&'(#_a#/2#+.(#H&'("#/2#B/&%+)#$10#+.$+#"&4.#*(+5+5/1#"./&'0#6(#25'(0#-5+.#+.(#B!#51#"+%54+#/6"(%7$14(#/2#+.(#0/4+%51(#/1#+.(#.5(%$%4.,#/2#4/&%+"9#M/%(/7(%)#5+#.$"#$'%($0,#6((1#(;*'$51(0#+.$+#&10(%#L(4+5/1#U#/2#^$+$"#G$36$1"$#>^GW#PVU)#$"#$3(10(0#6,#H(*&6'54#!4+#QUTV)#+.(#B!#q#*&%"&$1+#+/#+.(#(;(%45"(#/2#5+"#/%5851$'#<&%5"054+5/1#/7(%#*(+5+5/1"#2/% ##$%&'(%)%'# q #-$" # "*(45254$'', # 857(1 # +.( # */-(% # +/ # *$"" # &*/1 # +.(#(750(14() # 52 # $10 #-.(1 #1(4(""$%,) # +/ # %("/'7( # 2$4+&$' # 5""&("9>DMBCH#

#*

Page 31: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

FABCHGCH!ID: # 79 # M!9 # @CJH:DL # :9 # LFDADL) # E9H9 # A/9 # PaVPTP)#L(*+(36(%#R)#VTTUW

5+(2:&,0+""*.6

C1#+.(#*$%+#/2#M%9#E&3$%$18)#=1/-518#2&'',#-(''#+.$+#.(#-$"#1/#'/18(%#+.(#%(*%("(1+$+57(#/2#+.(#ABID!)#-.,#050#.(#1/+#512/%3#6/+.#+.(#B/&%+#/2#!**($'"#$10#+.(#L&*%(3(#B/&%+#/2#"&4.#2$4+#-.(1#.(#25'(0#+.(#*(+5+5/1"v # # F1"+($0) # .( # 4'$53(0 # +/ # 6( # +.( # 0&', # $&+./%5i(0#%(*%("(1+$+57( #/2 # +.( #ABID! #-.54. #.( #-$" #1/+9 # #[5" #/35""5/1 #$10#35"%(*%("(1+$+5/1#$%(#4'($%#51054$+5/1"#/2#6$0#2$5+.#/2#-.54.#+.5"#B/&%+#0/("#1/+#$**%/7(9##[(#"./&'0#.$7(#=1/-1#+.$+#6,#514'&0518#ABID!#$"#*(+5+5/1(%#$10#"581518#$"#5+"#%(*%("(1+$+57()#.(#"./&'0#.$7(#.$0#+.(#$&+./%5+,#+/#0/#"/9##I.5")#.(#050#1/+#*/""(""9##c.(1#.(#$'/1(#"581(0#/1#.5"#6(.$'2 #$10#+.$+#/2# +.(#ABID!)#1/+#/14(#6&+#+-54() #.(#2'$8%$1+',#75/'$+(0#+.(#%&'(#/1#+.(#25'518#/2#$#4(%+5254$+(#/2#1/1X2/%&3#"./**5189#>ACHI[D!LIDHA#BC@@DED#ID!B[DHL#!A:#DMG@CKDDL#!LLCBF!IFCA#7"9 # ACHI[D!LIDHA # BC@@DED) # FAB9) # E9H9 # A/9 # PaVUVS) # N$1&$%, # PU)#VTTUW

c5+./&+#+.(#%(b&5%(0#$&+./%5+,#2%/3#+.(#ABID!)#M%9#E&3$%$18#4$11/+#%(*%("(1+#+.(#ABID!9##!"#(;*'$51(0#$6/7()#52#+.(%(#$%(#"(7(%$'#*(+5+5/1(%") # +.( # 2$5'&%( # /2 # /1( # +/ # "581 # +.( # 4(%+5254$+( # /2 # 1/1X2/%&3#"./**518# 5" #$#0(2545(14,#-.54.# 5" #$#8%/&10# 2/% # +.(#05"35""$' #/2 # +.(#*(+5+5/19# #F1#+.(#4$"(#6(2/%(#&") #+.(%(#6(518#+-/#*(+5+5/1(%"#q#ABID!#$10#M%9#E&3$%$18#q#6/+.#/2#+.(3#"./&'0#"581#+.(#4(%+5254$+(#$8$51"+#2/%&3#"./**5189##L514(#+.(%(#-$"#/1',#/1(#"581$+/%,)#+.(#%(b&5%(3(1+#/1#+.(#25'518#/2#+.(#4(%+5254$+(#$8$51"+#2/%&3#"./**518#.$"#1/+#6((1#4/3*'5(0#-5+.9 # #!"# 51# +.(#B/&%+ #/2 #!**($'")#M%9 #E&3$%$18#2$5'(0#+/#"./-#-.,#+.(#0&',#$&+./%5i(0#%(*%("(1+$+57(#/2#+.(#ABID!#-$"#&1$6'(#+/#"581#+.(#4(%+5254$+5/1)#$10#+/#4/17514(#+.5"#B/&%+#+.$+#+.(#/&+%58.+#05"35""$' #/2 # +.( #*(+5+5/1 #-/&'0 #0(2($+ # +.( #$03515"+%$+5/1 #/2 # <&"+54(9#>ACHI[D!LIDHA#BC@@DED#ID!B[DHL#!A:#DMG@CKDDL#!LLCBF!IFCA#7"9 # ACHI[D!LIDHA # BC@@DED) # FAB9) # E9H9 # A/9 # PaVUVS) # N$1&$%, # PU)#VTTUW

H1$-&$4$33)*)-7*>(33'-, *T'332 *D$/(%')3 *@)%5*;+ *?)2&%(A# #/1#+.(#

%(b&5%(3(1+#/2#$#4(%+5254$+5/1#$8$51"+#2/%&3#"./**518)#(;*'$51"r

I.(#%($"/1#2/%#+.5"#5"#+.$+#+.(#*%5145*$'#*$%+,#.$"#$4+&$'#=1/-'(08(#-.(+.(%#$#*(+5+5/1#.$"#*%(75/&"',#6((1#25'(0#517/'7518#+.(#"$3(#4$"(#/%#"&6"+$1+5$'',#+.(#"$3(#5""&("9##F2)#2/%#$1,#%($"/1)#+.(#*%5145*$'#*$%+,#4$11/+#"581#+.(#*(+5+5/1) # +.(#/1(#"581518#/1#.5" #6(.$'2 #3&"+ #.$7(#6((1#0&',#$&+./%5i(09#

#!

Page 32: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

9 # 9 # 9 # #c.(%( # +.( #*(+5+5/1(% # 5" #$ #4/%*/%$+5/1) # +.(#4(%+5254$+5/1#$8$51"+#2/%&3#"./**518#"./&'0#6(#"581(0#6,#5+"#0&',#$&+./%5i(0#05%(4+/%#/%#%(*%("(1+$+57(#xfFg2 # +.(#%($'#*$%+,X51X51+(%("+# 5" #$#4/%*/%$+(#6/0,)#$1#/2254(% #/2#+.(#4/%*/%$+5/1#4$1#"581#+.(#4(%+5254$+5/1#$8$51"+#2/%&3#"./**518 #$"#'/18#$"#.(#5"#$&+./%5i(0#6,#$#%("/'&+5/1#/2#5+"#6/$%0#/2#05%(4+/%"9#

#;#;#;#;

!#4(%+5254$+5/1 ## #6'&9(1&*&9$*0%(0$%*)1&9(%'U)&'(- *# #5"# ##0(2(4+57(#$10#4/1"+5+&+("#$#7$'50#4$&"(#2/%#+.(#05"35""$'#/2#+.(#*(+5+5/19##>B5+$+5/1"#/35++(0j#(3*.$"5")#5+$'54"##$10#&10(%"4/%518#"&**'5(0W

G(+5+5/1(%e" # 05"4/&%"( # /1 # %('$;$+5/1 # /2 # +(4.154$' # %&'(" # /2#*%/4(0&%( # 51 # +.( # 51+(%("+ #/2 #"&6"+$1+5$' # <&"+54(#0/("#1/+ # 53*%(""9#c.5'( # +.(%( #.$7(#6((1# 51"+$14(" #-.(1# +.( #B/&%+ #05"*(1"(0#-5+.#+(4.154$'5+5(" #/1#+.(#6$"5" #/2 #"*(45$' #45%4&3"+$14("#/% #4/3*(''518#%($"/1")#+.(%(#5"#1/#"&4.#45%4&3"+$14(#/%#%($"/1#51#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"(#-.54.#-$%%$1+"#+.(#'56(%$'#$**'54$+5/1#/2#+(4.154$'#%&'("9# # #>D!E@D#LI!H#LDBJHFIK#LDH\FBDL)#FAB9##79#^CAF]!BFC#@9#MFH!A:C)#E9H9#A/9#PQUaPV)#N&',#ST)#VTTUW

N($D#&!;23#&+/&4*3-(#)*+.

I.(#H(85/1$'#:5%(4+/%#2&'',#%('5(0#/1#+.(#"('2X"(%7518#$''(8$+5/1"#/2 # %("*/10(1+ # $10 # 35"51+(%*%(+(0 # +.( # 0/4&3(1+" # *%("(1+(0 # $"#(750(14( # 6, # %("*/10(1+9 # I/ # 3$=( # 3$++(%" # -/%"() # :C@D # 0(15(0#*(+5+5/1(%e"#$**($'##6$"(0#"/'(',#/1##*(+5+5/1(%e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

#"

Page 33: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

("+$6'5".(0#+.$+#+.(#+%56&1$'#.$0#$4+(0#4$*%545/&"',#$10#-.53"54$'',#51#+/+$' # 05"%(8$%0 # /2 # (750(14( # 3$+(%5$' # +/ # /% # (7(1 # 0(45"57( # /2 # +.(#4/1+%/7(%",9 # >GDCG@DeL#^HC!:B!LIFAE>^CM^C#H!:KC#G[F@L9) # FAB9W#7"9 # #I[D # LDBHDI!HK # C] # I[D #:DG!HIMDAI # C] # @!^CH # !A:#DMG@CKMDAI) # I[D # HDEFCA!@ # :FHDBICH) # :C@D # HDEFCA # \FF) # $10#N!A:D@DCA#NJDO!A)#E9H9#A/9#PQU_aV)#M$,#R)#VTTUW#

R#$(*.6

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e" # %58.+ # +/ # 6( # .($%09#>]D@Fm#^9#GDHDO#$10#!M!AID#E9#:CHF!#7"9#G[F@FGGFAD#ID@DEH!G[#!A:#ID@DG[CAD#BCMG!AK#$10#NCLD#@JFL#L!AIF!EC)#E9H9#A/9#PaVT`R)#!*%5'#Q)#VTTUW

• 4*$%+62#&.+)&M$.)$:+2.)&)+&R#$(*.6##G/'54$%*5/l"#$''(8$+5/1"#$%(#"('2X"(%75189###D;4(*+#2/%#.(%#4'$53#$"#

"+$+(0#51#+.(#%("*/10(1+l"#G/"5+5/1#G$*(%)#1/-.(%(#2%/3#+.(#%(4/%0"#4$1#c(#2510#+.$+#^(%8$1+(#$10#F18&5''/#-(%(#$44/%0(0#+.(#/**/%+&15+,#+/#*%("(1+#(750(14(# 51 #"&**/%+ #/2 # +.(5% #0(2(1"("9 # # #G/'54$%*5/#%('5(0#.($75',#/1#+.(#YG(+5",/1Z#/2# #]GLF@J9# # #L.(#2$5'(0#+/#4/17514(#J"#+.$+#0&%518 # +.( # 05$'/8&() # ".( #-$" # $6'( # +/ # $"4(%+$51 # +.( # 7$'505+, # /2 # +.(#4.$%8("#3(1+5/1(0#51#+.(#YG(+5",/19Z# # #F1#.(%#2&+5'(#$++(3*+#+/#*%/7(#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#*%/4(0&%$'#%(b&5%(3(1+)#".(#%(5+(%$+(0#+.$+#+.(#/6<(4+57( # /2 # +.( # 05$'/8&( # -$" # +/ # *%/750( # +.( # (3*'/,((" # Y+.(#/**/%+&15+, # +/ # %(4(57( # +.( #$4+ #/2 #8%$4( #/2 #]GLF #6, #857518 # +.(3#$1#$3/&1+#(b&57$'(1+#+/#/1(X.$'2#>yW#3/1+.#/2#+.(5%#"$'$%,#2/%#(7(%,#,($%#/2#"(%754(9Z# # #c(#$%(#1/+#4/17514(09# # #c(#4$11/+#(7(1#4/1"50(%#+.(#0(3$10#$10#4/&1+(%X/22(% # 2/% # +.(#*$,3(1+#/2 #+.(#(3*'/,(("#$"#$1#$354$6'(#"(++'(3(1+#6(+-((1#+.(#*$%+5("#6(4$&"(#-.$+#+//=#*'$4(#-$"#3(%(', # $ # 05"4&""5/1 # /1', # /2 # +.( # $3/&1+ #-.54. # +.( # (3*'/,((" # $%(#-5''518#+/#$44(*+#$10#+.(#$3/&1+#-.54.#+.(#%("*/10(1+"#$%(#-5''518#+/#857(9 # # #L&4. #1/1X4/3*'5$14( # 5" #$'"/ #4/%%/6/%$+(0 #6, #^(%8$1+( #$10#F18&5''/#51#+.(5%#*'($0518"#0(1/&14518#+.(5%#&1<&"+525(0#05"35""$'9# # #F1#251()#c(#./'0#+.$+#+.(#05$'/8&(#5"#1/+#+$1+$3/&1+#+/#+.(#.($%518#/%#4/12(%(14(#*%("4%56(0#6,#'$-9### # # # #>[(%351585'0/#F18&5''/#$10#O(1$50$#

##

Page 34: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

^(%8$1+( # 79 #]5%"+ # G.5'5**51( # L4$'(") # F149 # $10p/% # !3*$%/ # G/'54$%*5/)#M$1$8(%)#E9H9#A/9#P_a`TQ)#N&1(#a)#VTTU

W.-0+$)#&1*60)

!8$51) # +.( # 4/1+(1+5/1 # 5" # 6(%(2+ # /2 #3(%5+9 # #c.5'( # GA^ # .$" # $1#$**$%(1+ # 51+(%("+ # 51 #M(8$ #G%53(e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cCW # $10#G!AIH!ABC # HDIHDAB[D: # DMG@CKDDL # !LLCBF!IFCA # >G!AHD!W # 79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#>A@HBW)# E9H9#A/9#PQT_RU)#E9H9#A/9#PQTQTaW

W.8#"#.8#.)&'+.)($-)+(

I.( # (;5"+(14( # /2 # $1 # 510(*(10(1+ # $10 # *(%35""56'( # 4/1+%$4+/%#%('$+5/1".5* # 5" # 8(1(%$'', # ("+$6'5".(0 # 6, # 4/1"50(%518 # +.( # 2/''/-518#0(+(%351$1+"r# #-.(+.(%#+.(#4/1+%$4+/%#5"#4$%%,518#/1#$1#510(*(10(1+#6&"51(""j #+.(#1$+&%(#$10#(;+(1+#/2 # +.(#-/%=j #+.(#"=5'' # %(b&5%(0j #+.(#+(%3 # $10 # 0&%$+5/1 # /2 # +.( # %('$+5/1".5*j # +.( # %58.+ # +/ # $""581 # +.(#*(%2/%3$14(#/2#$#"*(4525(0#*5(4(#/2#-/%=j#+.(#4/1+%/'#$10#"&*(%75"5/1#/2 # +.( #-/%= # +/ # $1/+.(%j # +.( # (3*'/,(%l" # */-(% #-5+. # %("*(4+ # +/ # +.(#.5%518)#25%518#$10#*$,3(1+#/2#+.(#4/1+%$4+/%l"#-/%=(%"j#+.(#4/1+%/'#/2#+.( # *%(35"("j # +.( # 0&+, # +/ # "&**', # +.( # *%(35"(") # +//'") # $**'5$14(")#3$+(%5$'"#$10# '$6/%j #$10#+.(#3/0()#3$11(%#$10#+(%3"#/2 #*$,3(1+9#>NDHCMFD#:9#DLB!LFA!L#$10#D\!A#HFECH#LFAEBC#79#L[!AEHFX@!eL

F1 # "&3) # +.(%( # (;5"+(0 # 1/ # (3*'/,(%X(3*'/,(( # %('$+5/1".5*#6(+-((1#+.(#*$%+5("9##:(#H$(0+#5"#$1#510(*(10(1+#4/1+%$4+/%)#-./#-$"#(18$8(0#6,#LE\#+/#%(10(%#"(%754("#+/#LE\e"#4'5(1+#IMF)#$10#&'+53$+(',#+/ #:! #/1 # +.( #BDB!G #*%/<(4+) # %(8$%0518 #3$++(%" # 51 # +.( # 25('0 #/2 #.(%#"*(45$'#=1/-'(08(#$10#+%$51518#2/%#$#"*(45254#*(%5/0#/2#+53(9##J1'5=(#$1#/%051$%,#(3*'/,(()#:(#H$(0+#%(4(57(0#%(+$51(%#2(("#$10#6(1(25+"#"&4.#$"#./&"518#$10#"&6"5"+(14(#$''/-$14("#$10#3(054$' # 51"&%$14(9 # #:(#H$(0+e"#"(%754("#4/&'0#6(#+(%351$+(0#/1#+.(#8%/&10#/2#(10#/2#4/1+%$4+#6(+-((1 # +.( # :! # $10 # IMF) # $10 # 1/+ # /1 # 8%/&10" # &10(% # '$6/% # '$-"9#I./&8.#+.(#(10#/2#+.(#4/1+%$4+#6(+-((1#+.(#:!#$10#IMF#-$"#1/+#+.(#

#$

Page 35: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

8%/&10#2/%#+.(#-5+.0%$-$'#/2#:(#H$(0+#2%/3#+.(#BDB!G)#:(#H$(0+#-$"#05"(18$8(0#2%/3#+.(#*%/<(4+#&*/1#+.(#51"+%&4+5/1#/2#LE\e"#4'5(1+)#IMF9#M/"+#53*/%+$1+#/2#$'')#LE\#050#1/+#(;(%45"(#4/1+%/'#/7(%#+.(#3($1"#$10#3(+./0"#6,#-.54.#:(#H$(0+#*(%2/%3(0#.(%#0&+5("#$"#L/45/'/85"+9##LE\#050# 53*/"(#%&'("#/1#:(#H$(0+) #6&+#+.("(#-(%(#1(4(""$%,#+/#(1"&%(#LE\e"#2$5+.2&'#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#+(%3"#$10#4/105+5/1"#/2#+.(#L&6XB/1"&'+$14, # !8%((3(1+ # 5+ # (1+(%(0 # 51+/ #-5+. # IMF9# >LKBFG) # ECHHDL)#\D@!KC#d#BCMG!AK)#79#B!HC@#:D#H!D:I)#E9H9#A/9#P_PS__)#N&1(#P_)#VTTUW

W.32;+(8*.$)*+.

!"50(#2%/3#+.(#2510518"#/2#"(;&$'#$6&"()#*(+5+5/1(%#5"#$'"/#8&5'+,#/2 # 51"&6/%051$+5/19 # H(4/%0" # "./- # +.$+ # $2+(% # 25'518 # $ # 4$"( # 2/%#4/1"+%&4+57( # 05"35""$' # /1 # !*%5' # PS) # PUU` # $8$51"+ # +.( # %("*/10(1+)#*(+5+5/1(% # 4/1+51&(0 #-/%=518 #$10 #*(%2/%3518 #.5" # 2&14+5/1" #-5+. # +.(#%("*/10(1+#4/3*$1,#&1+5'#.5"#+(%351$+5/1#/1#M$,#PU)#PUU`9#[/-(7(%)#0("*5+(#%(4(5*+#/2 #+.(#7$%5/&"#1/+54("#"(1+#6,#%("*/10(1+#+/#.53#+/#%(*/%+#+/#+.(#/2254(#$10#+/#"&635+#-%5++(1#(;*'$1$+5/1"#%('$+57(#+/#.5"#2$5'&%( # +/ # 2/''/- # 51"+%&4+5/1") # +.( # %(4/%0" #/2 # +.( # 4$"( #$%( #6(%(2+ # /2#"./-518#+.$+#.(#25'(0#$1,#-%5++(1#(;*'$1$+5/1#+/#$1,#/2#+.("(#1/+54("9#[5" # 4/1+51&(0 # 2$5'&%( # +/ # 4$%%, # /&+ # +.( # %($"/1$6'( # /%$' # /% # -%5++(1#51"+%&4+5/1"#/2#.5"#"&*(%75"/%#5"#*&15".$6'(##6,#51"&6/%051$+5/1)#-.54.#5"#*%/750(0#&10(%#H&'(# F\9a9$#/2 # +.(#C*(%$+5/1$' # F1"+%&4+5/1#CFX!X!GVa)#c/%= # H&'("9 # c.5'( # *(+5+5/1(% # 4$11/+ # 6( # 2$&'+(0 # 51 # 6('5(7518 # +.$+#%("*/10(1+ # 4/1"+%&4+57(', # 05"35""(0 # .53 # 2%/3 # -/%=) # .( # -$" # "+5'')#"+%54+',#"*($=518)#%("*/10(1+l"#(3*'/,((#-.(1#.(#%(4(57(0#+.(#-%5++(1#1/+54("9#!"#$1#(3*'/,(()#.(#"./&'0#.$7(#$+#'($"+#%("*/10(0#+.(%(+/)#$"#51"+%&4+(09#>H!MCA#^9#]CHM!AIDL#79#:JAB!A#G[!HM!BDJIFB!@L)#G[F@L9)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#PQT__P)#:(4(36(%#`)#VTTUW

W.)#("(#)$)*+.&+/&4+2;)&

c(#%(<(4+ #*(+5+5/1(%e" #"('2X"(%7518#4/1+(1+5/19 #[$7518# 2$5'(0 # +/#"&6"+$1+5$+(#5+"#$''(8$+5/1#/1#+.(#%('$+5/1".5*#6(+-((1#+.(#*$%+5(")#-(#"+54=#+/# +.(#"(++'(0#%&'(# 51#4/1+%/7(%"5(" #6(+-((1#$# '$6/%(% #$10#.5"#3$"+(% # +.$+ #0/&6+"# %($"/1$6',#$%5"518#2%/3#+.(#(750(14(#"./&'0 #6(#%("/'7(0#51#+.(#2/%3(%e"#2$7/%9#I.(#*/'54,#5"#%(2'(4+(0#51#1/#'(""#+.$1#+.(#B/1"+5+&+5/1)#@$6/%#B/0(#$10#B575'#B/0(9#>:D!@BC#]!HML)#FAB9)#7"9#A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH #HD@!IFCAL #BCMMFLLFCA # >a+.# :F\FLFCAW) # E9H9 # A/9#PaSPUV###N$1&$%,#ST)#VTTUW

I.(#%('$+5/1"#6(+-((1#4$*5+$'#$10#'$6/%#$%(#"/#53*%(""(0#-5+.#*&6'54#51+(%("+)#$10#1(5+.(%#".$''#$4+#/**%(""57(',#$8$51"+#+.(#/+.(%)#/%#53*$5%#+.(#51+(%("+#/%#4/17(15(14(#/2#+.(#*&6'549## F1#4$"(#/2#0/&6+)#$''#

#%

Page 36: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

'$6/%#'(85"'$+5/1#$10#$''#'$6/%#4/1+%$4+"#".$''#6(#4/1"+%&(0#51#2$7/%#/2#+.( # "$2(+, # $10 # 0(4(1+ # '57518 # 2/% # +.( # '$6/%(%9 # >^DBMDA # LDH\FBD#DmGCHIDH #79 # LGCJLDL #LFMG@FBFC #$10 #MF@! #BJ!HDLM!# >2/% # $10 # 51#6(.$'2 # /2+.(5% # 0$&8.+(%) #N$"351# E9 #B&$%("3$W) # c[FID # ]!@BCA#LDH\FBDL)#FAB9#$10#N!FMD#CHIFO#>G%("50(1+)c.5+(#]$'4/1#L(%754(")#F149W#!A: # GHCMCIFCA) # FAB9)E9H9 # A/"9 # PRVUQRXQU) # E9H9 # A/"9 # PR`VURXUU)#!*%5'#Q)#VTTUW

H+;&-+.)($-)*.6&+(&,2;-+.)($-)*.6

G(%35""56'( # </6 # 4/1+%$4+518 # /% # "&64/1+%$4+518 # %(2(%" # +/ # $1#$%%$18(3(1+#-.(%(6,#$#*%5145*$'#$8%(("#+/#2$%3#/&+#-5+.#$#4/1+%$4+/%#/%#"&64/1+%$4+/%#+.(#*(%2/%3$14(#/2#$#"*(45254#</6)#-/%=)#/%#"(%754(#-5+.51#$#0(2515+(#/%#*%(0(+(%351(0#*(%5/0)#%(8$%0'(""#/2#-.(+.(%#"&4.#</6) # -/%= # /%) # "(%754( # 5" # +/ # 6( # *(%2/%3(0 # /% # 4/3*'(+(0 #-5+.51 # /%#/&+"50(#+.(#*%(35"("#/2#+.(#*%5145*$'9# # #J10(%#+.5"#$%%$18(3(1+)#+.(#2/''/-518#4/105+5/1" #3&"+#6(#3(+r # # >$W # +.(#4/1+%$4+/% #4$%%5("#/1#$#05"+514+#$10#510(*(10(1+#6&"51(""#$10#&10(%+$=("#+.(#4/1+%$4+#-/%=#/1 #.5" #$44/&1+ #&10(% #.5" # /-1 # %("*/1"565'5+, #$44/%0518 # +/ #.5" #/-1#3$11(% # $10 #3(+./0) # 2%(( # 2%/3 # +.( # 4/1+%/' # $10 # 05%(4+5/1 # /2 # .5"#(3*'/,(%#/%#*%5145*$'#51#$''#3$++(%"#4/11(4+(0#-5+.#+.(#*(%2/%3$14(#/2##.5"##-/%=##(;4(*+#$"#+/#+.(#%("&'+"#+.(%(/2j#>6W#+.(#4/1+%$4+/%#.$"#"&6"+$1+5$'##4$*5+$'##/%##517("+3(1+j#$10#>4W##+.(#$8%((3(1+#6(+-((1#+.(#*%5145*$'#$10#4/1+%$4+/%#/%#"&64/1+%$4+/%#$""&%("#+.(#4/1+%$4+&$'#(3*'/,(("e # (1+5+'(3(1+ # +/ # $'' # '$6/% # $10 # /44&*$+5/1$' # "$2(+, # $10#.($'+. # "+$10$%0") # 2%(( # (;(%45"( # /2 # +.( # %58.+ # +/ # "('2X/%8$15i$+5/1)#"(4&%5+, #/2 # +(1&%() #$10#"/45$' #-('2$%(#6(1(25+"9 #>H!MK#E!@@DEC#79#^!KDH # G[F@FGGFADL) # FAB9) # :!AGFA # EJF@@DHMC) # GHC:JBI # FM!ED#M!H?DIFAE)# FAB9) #$10#D:E!H:C#^DHECAF!)#E9H9 #A/9#PQURTQ) #N&',#SP)#VTTUW

H+*.)&Z#.)2(#

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hC) # (+ # $' # 79 # ^C^CAECA # ^!A!A! # EHCcDHL#

#&

Page 37: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

MJ@IFXGJHGCLD#BCCGDH!IF\D)#IFMCE#!EHFBJ@IJH!@#BCHGCH!IFCA)#:F!MCA:#]!HML)#FAB9)#$10#:C@D#!LF!#G[F@FGGFADL)#E9H9#A/9##P_`VTa)#L(*+(36(%#S)#VTTUW

H286:#.)

c( # 05"2$7/% # 0('$, # 51 # +.( # (12/%4(3(1+ # /2 # +.( # '$6/% # $%65+(%e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a)#VTTUW

H2(*38*-)*+.

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cCH@:#FAIDHA!IFCA!@)#^D[!\FCH#MC:F]FB!IFCAL)# FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_TP`_)#:(4(36(%#PP)#VTTUW

"# $%&'( $)*+#$ ,*+ $ -./01 $.1/2,+1 $3104++5+5$)2,* $ ,*+$40#%0-25.,+5$4.%+%$5+%32,+$,*+$678$%&%3+#%20#$015+1($*+$+94++5+5$*2%$:&12%524,20#$,0$*+.1$.#5$5+425+$2--+;.-$52%'2%%.-$4.%+%$.#5$,*+$8<$4011+4,-=$1+>+1%+5$*2%$?&#+$@A( $ BCCD $ 015+1E $ FG"H< $ IE $ J"<HG8K( $ $ +, $ .-( $ >E $ LH"M"N7 $ 6<O76$M<P7QKL67$8OLR($"H8E($GEPE$H0E$@ASATU($N+4+'/+1$@D($BCCTV

W.)($@'+("+($)#&4*3"2)#&

!++,9#E$%45$#+%5("#+/#0(1,#.(#5"#$1#/2254(%#/2#DIGF9## A/+#6(518#$#4/%*/%$+(#/2254(%)#.(#$%8&("#+.$+#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#.$"#<&%5"054+5/1#/7(%#+.(#4$"(9##C1(#/2#+.(#4/%*/%$+(#/2254(%"#*%/750(0#2/%#51#+.(#6,X'$-"#/2#DIGF # 5" # +.( #\54(XG%("50(1+9## F+ # 4$1 # 6( # 8$+.(%(0 # 2%/3 #!++,9 #E$%45$e"#4/3*'$51+X$2250$75+ # +.$+ #.( #-$" #\54( #G%("50(1+ # 2/% #^&"51("" #L&**/%+#L(%754(" # $10 # [&3$1 # H("/&%4( # :(*$%+3(1+" # /2 # DIGF # -.(1 # .5"#

#'

Page 38: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

(3*'/,3(1+#-$"#+(%351$+(0#(22(4+57(#P_#!*%5'#VTTT#9## F+#5"#+.(%(2/%(#4'($% # 2%/3 # +.( #6,X'$-" #$10 # 2%/3#!++,9 #E$%45$ #.53"('2 # +.$+ # .( # 5" # $#4/%*/%$+(#/2254(%9##C1(#-./#5"#514'&0(0#51#+.(#6,X'$-"#/2#$#4/%*/%$+5/1#51#5+"#%/"+(%#/2#4/%*/%$+(#/2254(%"#5"#$1#/2254(%#/2#"$50#4/%*/%$+5/1#$10#1/+ # $ # 3(%( # (3*'/,((9## ^(518 # $ # 4/%*/%$+( # /2254(%) # .5" # %(3/7$' # 5"#0((3(0#+/#6(#$1#51+%$X4/%*/%$+(#05"*&+(#4/815i$6'(#6,#+.(#LDB#$10#1/+ # 6, # +.( # @$6/% # !%65+(%9 # >!IIK9 # \FHEF@FC # H9 # E!HBF! # 79#D!LIDHA#ID@DBCMMJAFB!IFCAL # G[F@FGGFADL) # FAB9 # $10 # !IIK9 # L!@\!:CH # B9#[FOCA) # E9H9 # A/9 # PQSPPa)# D!LIDHA # ID@DBCMMJAFB!IFCAL#G[F@FGGFADL)#FAB9#$10#!IIK9#L!@\!:CH#B9#[FOCA#79#!IIK9#\FHEF@FC#H9#E!HBF!)#E9H9#A/"9#PQSP_SX_`)#!*%5'#P_)#VTTUW

• 4#:$(-$)*+.&%*.#&9#)=##.&4VEIA3&C(#(+6$)*D#&&&&&&&$.8&KE1'A3&H2(*38*-)*+.

F+#4$1#6(#$""&3(0#+.$+#+.(#:C@D#51#+.(#(;(%45"(#/2#5+"#75"5+/%5$'#$10#(12/%4(3(1+#*/-(%#"/3(./-#.$"#+/#3$=(#$#0(+(%351$+5/1#/2#+.(#(;5"+(14(#/2 #$1 #(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,(( # %('$+5/1".5*9 # #L&4. #*%(%/8$+57$'#0(+(%351$+5/1)#./-(7(%)#4$11/+#6(#4/(;+(1"57(#-5+.#+.(#75"5+/%5$'#$10#(12/%4(3(1+ # */-(% # 5+"('29 # # F10((0) # "&4. # 0(+(%351$+5/1 # 5" # 3(%(',#*%('5351$%,)#51450(1+$'#$10#4/''$+(%$'#+/#+.(#:C@De"#*%53$%,#2&14+5/1#/2#(12/%4518 # '$6/% # "+$10$%0" # *%/75"5/1"9 # # # # I.( # 0(+(%351$+5/1 # /2 # +.(#(;5"+(14(#/2 #(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*# 5" #"+5'' #*%53$%5', # '/08(0#-5+.#+.(#A@HB9#I.5"#5"#+.(#3($1518#/2#+.(#4'$&"(#Y51#4$"("#-.(%(#+.(#%('$+5/1".5* # /2 # (3*'/,(%X(3*'/,(( # "+5'' # (;5"+"Z # 51 # !%+9 # PVR>6W9#>GDCG@DeL # ^HC!:B!LIFAE>^CM^C # H!:KC # G[F@L9) # FAB9W # 7"9 # # I[D#LDBHDI!HK#C]#I[D#:DG!HIMDAI#C]#@!^CH#!A:#DMG@CKMDAI)#I[D#HDEFCA!@#:FHDBICH)#:C@D#HDEFCA#\FF)#$10#N!A:D@DCA#NJDO!A)#E9H9#A/9#PQU_aV)#M$,#R)#VTTUW

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a)###N&',#PS)#VTTUW

E$;+(@+.%7&'+.)($-)+(

#(

Page 39: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

F1#"&3)#F1+(%"(%7(#050#1/+#.$7(#"&6"+$1+5$'#4$*5+$'#/%#517("+3(1+#51#+.(#2/%3#/2#+//'")#(b&5*3(1+)#3$4.51(%5(")#$10#-/%=#*%(35"("j#$10#%("*/10(1+") # 5+" # "&**/"(0 # (3*'/,((") # *(%2/%3(0 # -/%= # -.54. # -$"#05%(4+', # %('$+(0 # +/ # +.( #*%5145*$' # 6&"51("" #/2 # *(+5+5/1(%9 # # F+ # 5") # +.&")#(750(1+ # +.$+ # F1+(%"(%7( # 2$''" # &10(% # +.( # 0(2515+5/1 # /2 # $ # Y'$6/%X/1',Z#4/1+%$4+/%)#&10(%#!%+54'(#PT_#/2#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(j#$"#-(''#$"#L(4+5/1#a>5W#/2 # +.( #H&'(" # F3*'(3(1+518 #!%+54'(" #PT_XPTU #/2 # +.( # @$6/% #B/0() # $"#$3(10(09# #>BCB!XBC@!#^CII@DHL#G[F@L9)#FAB# #79 #!@!A#M9#!EFIC)#(+#$'9)##E9H9#A/9#PQUa`_)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTUW

F1#$#'$6/%X/1',#4/1+%$4+)#+.(%(#$%(#+.%((#*$%+5("#517/'7(0r## >PW#+.(#Y'$6/%X/1',Z#4/1+%$4+/%j#>VW#+.(#(3*'/,((#-./#5"#/"+(1"56',#&10(%#+.(#(3*'/, #/2 # +.( # Y'$6/%X/1',Z # 4/1+%$4+/%j #$10 # >SW # +.( #*%5145*$' #-./# 5"#0((3(0 # +.( # %($' # (3*'/,(%9## J10(% # +.5" # "4.(3() #)0# &[%$;+(@+.%7\&-+.)($-)+(&*3&)0#&$6#.)&+/&)0#&"(*.-*"$%+##[(%()#\(0$'5#5"#+.(#Y'$6/%X/1',Z # 4/1+%$4+/%j # 5105750&$' # %("*/10(1+" # $%( # +.( # (3*'/,((" # $10#*(+5+5/1(%#5"#+.(#*%5145*$'9##I.(#'$-#3$=("#+.(#*%5145*$'#%("*/1"56'(#+/#+.(#(3*'/,(("#/2#+.(#Y'$6/%X/1',#4/1+%$4+/%Z#$"#52#+.(#*%5145*$'#5+"('2#05%(4+', # .5%(0 # /% # (3*'/,(0 # +.( # (3*'/,(("9& FF@FE!A # BDMDAI#BCHGCH!IFCA # 79 # F@F!LBCH # DMG@CKDDL # !A: # cCH?DHL # JAFCA # q#LCJI[DHA#G[F@FGGFADL#]D:DH!IFCA#C]#@!^CH#>FDcJXLG]@W)#!A:#FIL#C]]FBDHL#!A:#MDM^DHL)#(+9#$')#E9H9#A/9#PaRUa_)#!*%5'#V`)#VTTUW

E#.6)0&+/&,#(D*-#

!'+./&8.#.5"#1($%',#+-/#0(4$0("#/2#"(%754(#358.+#8(1(%$'',#6(#

4/1"50(%(0#2/%#"/3(#2/%3#/2#251$145$'#$""5"+$14(#+/#".5('0#.53#2%/3#+.(#

(22(4+"#/2#.5"#+(%351$+5/1)#I/3$0$e"#$4+"#%(2'(4+#$#%(8%(++$6'(#'$4=#/2#

4/14(%1#2/%#.5"#(3*'/,(%9##F2#'(18+.#/2#"(%754(#<&"+525("#+.(#35+58$+5/1#/2#

+.(#*(1$'+,#/2#05"35""$')#+.(1#+.5"#B/&%+#-/&'0#6(#$-$%0518#05"'/,$'+,)#

05"+/%+518#51#+.(#*%/4(""#+.(#3($1518#/2#"/45$'#<&"+54(#$10#&10(%351518#

+.(#(22/%+"#/2#'$6/%#+/#4'($1"(#5+"#%$1="#/2#&10("5%$6'("9#>D:J!H:C#M9#ICM!:!) #LH9 # 79 # #H]M #BCHGCH!IFCAX^!?DHK # ]@CJH #:F\FLFCA #$10#NCLD#M!HF!#BCABDGBFCA#FFF)#E9H9#A/9#P_SVQT)#L(*+(36(%#PP)#VTTUW

E*$;*%*)7&+/&'+("+($)#&V//*-#(3

[/-(7(%) #!%+54'( # VPV>(W #/2 # +.( #@$6/% #B/0() #6, # 5+"('2) # 0/(" #1/+#3$=( # $ # 4/%*/%$+( # /2254(% # *(%"/1$'', # '5$6'( # 2/% # +.( # 0(6+" # /2 # +.(#4/%*/%$+5/1 #6(4$&"(#L(4+5/1 #SP#/2 # +.(#B/%*/%$+5/1 #B/0(# 5" #"+5'' # +.(#8/7(%1518 # '$- #/1 #*(%"/1$' # '5$65'5+, # /2 # /2254(%" # 2/% # +.( #0(6+" # /2 # +.(#4/%*/%$+5/19##L(4+5/1#SP#/2#+.(#B/%*/%$+5/1#B/0(#*%/750("r

#)

Page 40: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

=')4'3'&" *(. *7'%$#&(%2A * &%12&$$2 *(% *(..'#$%2+# o# #:5%(4+/%" #/%#+%&"+((" #-./ #-5''2&'', # $10 # =1/-518', # 7/+( # 2/% # /% # $""(1+ # +/#*$+(1+',#&1'$-2&'#$4+"#/2#+.(#4/%*/%$+5/1#/%#-./#$%(#8&5'+,#/2#8%/""#1(8'58(14(#/%#6$0#2$5+.# 51#05%(4+518#+.(#$22$5%"#/2 #+.(#4/%*/%$+5/1#/%#$4b&5%(#$1,#*(%"/1$'#/%#*(4&15$%,#51+(%("+#51#4/12'54+#-5+.#+.(5%#0&+,#$"#"&4.#05%(4+/%")#/%#+%&"+(("#".$''#6(#'5$6'(#</51+',#$10#"(7(%$'',#2/%#$''#0$3$8("#%("&'+518#+.(%(2%/3#"&22(%(0#6,#+.(#4/%*/%$+5/1)#5+"#"+/4=./'0(%"#/%#3(36(%"#$10#/+.(%#*(%"/1"9#;#;#;

I.(%(#-$"#1/#"./-518#/2#:$750#-5''518',#$10#=1/-518',#7/+518#2/%#/%#$""(1+518#+/#*$+(1+',#&1'$-2&'#$4+"#/2#+.(#4/%*/%$+5/1)#/%#+.$+#:$750#-$" #8&5'+, # /2 # 8%/"" #1(8'58(14( #/% #6$0 # 2$5+.9 # # >!HM!A:C#:!\F: #79#A!IFCA!@ # ]D:DH!IFCA #C] # @!^CH #JAFCA #$10 #M!HF\D@DL #!GG!HD@#BCHGCH!IFCA)#E9H9#A/"9#P`RV_S#$10#P`RVQPXQV)#!*%5'#VP)#VTTUW

E*$;*%*)7&+/&N#.#($%&T$.$6#(

@$"+',) # -( # 4/3( # +/ # +.( # 5""&( # /2 # -.(+.(% #c5'+"4.(=) # $" # +.(#E(1(%$' # M$1$8(%) # "./&'0 # 6( # *(%"/1$'', # '5$6'( # +/8(+.(% # -5+. # Msc#O$10(%9 # #c( # $8%(( #-5+. # *(+5+5/1(%" # +.$+ # .( # "./&'0 # 1/+ # 6( #3$0(#*(%"/1$'',#'5$6'(9#I.(#8(1(%$'#3$1$8(%#/2#$#4/%*/%$+5/1#"./&'0#1/+#6(#3$0(#*(%"/1$'',#$1"-(%$6'(#2/%#+.(#*$,3(1+#/2#$1#5''(8$'',#05"35""(0#(3*'/,((l"#3/1(+$%,#4'$53"#$%5"518#2%/3#+.(#05"35""$'#&1'(""#.(#.$0#$4+(0#3$'545/&"', #/% # 51 #6$0# 2$5+. # 51 # +(%351$+518# +.( #"(%754(" #/2 # +.(#(3*'/,((+# I.( # (3*'/,(% # 4/%*/%$+5/1 # .$" # $ # "(*$%$+( # $10 # 05"+514+#*(%"/1$'5+, # 2%/3 # 5+" # /2254(%" #-./ #3(%(', # $4+ # $" # 5+" # $8(1+"9# >Msc#O!A:DH # G[F@FGGFADL) # FAB9 # $10 # HC@] #cF@ILB[D? # # 79 # IHFAF:!: #M9#DAHFkJDO)#E9H9#A/9#P_UPQS)#N&1(#a)#VTTUW

E*$;*%*)7&+/&1#-(2*):#.)&!6#.-*#3&$.8&5+(#*6.@9$3#8&I:"%+7#(

G%57$+(#(3*'/,3(1+#$8(145("#$%(#.('0#</51+',#$10#"(7(%$'',#'5$6'(#-5+.#+.(#2/%(581X6$"(0#(3*'/,(%#2/%#$1,#75/'$+5/1#/2#+.(#%(4%&5+3(1+#$8%((3(1+#/%#4/1+%$4+#/2#(3*'/,3(1+9##I.5"#</51+#$10#"/'50$%,#'5$65'5+,#53*/"(0#6,#'$-#$8$51"+#%(4%&5+3(1+#$8(145("#$10#2/%(581#(3*'/,(%"#5"#3($1+ # +/ #$""&%( # +.( #$88%5(7(0 #-/%=(% #/2 # 533(05$+( #$10 # "&22545(1+#*$,3(1+#/2#-.$+#5"#0&(#.539#F2#+.(#%(4%&5+3(1+p*'$4(3(1+#$8(14,#5"#$#<&%5054$'#6(518)#+.(#4/%*/%$+(#/2254(%"#$10#05%(4+/%"#$10#*$%+1(%"#$"#+.(#4$"(#3$,#6()#".$''#+.(3"('7("#6(#</51+',#$10#"/'50$%5',# '5$6'(#-5+.#+.(#4/%*/%$+5/1 # /% # *$%+1(%".5* # 2/% # +.( # $2/%("$50 # 4'$53" # $10 # 0$3$8("9#>^DBMDA # LDH\FBD # DmGCHIDH # 79 # LGCJLDL # LFMG@FBFC # $10 # MF@!#BJ!HDLM!#>2/%#$10#51#6(.$'2#/2+.(5%#0$&8.+(%) #N$"351#E9 #B&$%("3$W)#

$*

Page 41: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

c[FID # ]!@BCA # LDH\FBDL) # FAB9 # $10 # N!FMD # CHIFO # >G%("50(1+)c.5+(#]$'4/1#L(%754(")#F149W#!A:#GHCMCIFCA)#FAB9)E9H9#A/"9#PRVUQRXQU)#E9H9#A/"9#PR`VURXUU)#!*%5'#Q)#VTTUW#

T$.$6#:#.)&C(#(+6$)*D#

!"#$*+',#45+(0#6,#+.(#B!r

I.(#8(1(%$'#%&'(#5"#+.$+#+.(#4.$%$4+(%5i$+5/1#6,#$1#(3*'/,(%#/2#$1#(3*'/,((e"#"(%754("#$"#1/# '/18(%#1(4(""$%,#/%#"&"+$51$6'(# 5" #$1#(;(%45"( # /2 # 6&"51("" # <&083(1+ # /1 # +.( # *$%+ # /2 # +.( # (3*'/,(%9 # I.(#-5"0/3#/%#"/&101(""#/2#"&4.#$#4.$%$4+(%5i$+5/1#/%#0(45"5/1#5"#1/+)#$"#$#8(1(%$'#%&'()#"&6<(4+#+/#05"4%(+5/1$%,#%(75(-#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%)#+.(#A@HB#$10#+.(#B!9#L&4.#4.$%$4+(%5i$+5/1#3$,)#./-(7(%)#6(#%(<(4+(0#52#+.(#"$3(#5"#2/&10#+/#6(#51#75/'$+5/1#/2#+.(#'$-#/%#5"#$%65+%$%,#/%#3$'545/&"9

c(#2510#1/#75/'$+5/1"#/2#'$-#51#+.(#%("*/10(1+e"#$4+5/1"#$8$51"+#+.( # *(+5+5/1(%) # 1/% # -$" # +.( # %("*/10(1+ # $%65+%$%, # /% # 512'&(14(0 # 6,#3$'54(#51#+(%351$+518#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%e"#(3*'/,3(1+#2/%#%(0&10$14,9#I.5"#8%/&10 # 2/% # +(%351$+5/1 # 5" # $ # '(85+53$+( # (;(%45"( # /2 # 3$1$8(3(1+#*%(%/8$+57( #&1'("" #$++(10(0# +/ #6,#$%65+%$%51("" #/% #6, # +.( # 2$5'&%( # +/#2/''/-#"+$+&+/%,#%(b&5%(3(1+"9#A/#$%65+%$%51(""#/%#$1,#75/'$+5/1"#+//=#*'$4(#51#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"(9#>MFHF!M#^9#D@@DBBFCA#\:!9#:D#@DBBFCADL#79#A!IFCA!@##@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)###AA!#G[F@FGGFADL#BC9)#FAB9#$10#ML9#?FMF#?FMJH#!)#E9H9#A/9#PR`QSa)####L(*+(36(%#PQ)#VTTUW

• M($.3/#(

F1#+.5"#4$"()#-(#2510#1/#%($"/1#+/#05"+&%6#+.(#4/14'&"5/1#/2#+.(#B/&%+ # /2 # !**($'" # +.$+ # +.(%( # -$" # 1/ # 4/1"+%&4+57( # 05"35""$'9#H($""5813(1+" # 3$0( # 6, # 3$1$8(3(1+ # *(10518 # 517("+58$+5/1 # /2#75/'$+5/1"#/2#4/3*$1,#*/'545("#$10#*%/4(0&%("#$''(8(0',#4/335++(0#6,#$1#(3*'/,((#2$''#-5+.51#+.(#$365+#/2#3$1$8(3(1+#*%(%/8$+57(9# #I.(#0(45"5/1#/2 #k&$1+&3#]//0"#+/# +%$1"2(% #D1054/#*(10518# 517("+58$+5/1#-$" # $ # 7$'50 # (;(%45"( # /2 #3$1$8(3(1+ # *%(%/8$+57( # +/ # 05"45*'51( # 5+"#(3*'/,(("9 # # # I.( # +%$1"2(%) #-.5'( # 51450(1+$' # +/ # +.( # 4.$%8(" #$8$51"+#D1054/) # -$" # 1/+ #3($1+ # $" # $ # *(1$'+,) # 6&+ # %$+.(% # $" # $ # *%(7(1+57(#3($"&%(#+/#$7/50#2&%+.(%#'/""#/2#"$'("#$10#+.(#0("+%&4+5/1#/2#k&$1+&3#]//0"e#53$8(#$10#8//0-5''9##F+#-$"#1/+#0("581(0#+/#6(#+.(#4&'351$+5/1#/2 # +.( # +.(1 # /1X8/518 # $03515"+%$+57( # 517("+58$+5/1 # $8$51"+ # D1054/9#>!HAJ@]C#C9 #DA:FBC#7"9 #kJ!AIJM#]CC:L#:FLIHF^JIFCA#BDAIDH)#E9H9#A/9#P_P_Pa)#N$1&$%,#ST)#VTTUW

!IFe"#+%$1"2(%#/2#^5"3$%=#F\e"#6$"(#2%/3#M$15'$#+/#^$+$$1#-$")#4/1+%$%, # +/ # !8&$1i$e" # $""(%+5/1") # $ # 7$'50 # (;(%45"( # /2 #3$1$8(3(1+#

$!

Page 42: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

*%(%/8$+57(9# #I.(#+%$1"2(%#/2#(3*'/,(("#.$"#6((1#+%$05+5/1$'',#$3/18#+.( # $4+" # 50(1+525(0 # $" # $ #3$1$8(3(1+ # *%(%/8$+57( # "&6<(4+ # /1', # +/#'535+$+5/1"#2/&10#51#'$-)#4/''(4+57(#6$%8$51518#$8%((3(1+)#$10#8(1(%$'#*%5145*'("#/2#2$5%#*'$,#$10#<&"+54(9# #D7(1#$"#+.(#'$-#5"#"/'545+/&"#/2#+.(#-('2$%(#/2#(3*'/,((")#5+#3&"+#$'"/#*%/+(4+#+.(#%58.+#/2#$1#(3*'/,(%#+/#(;(%45"(#-.$+#$%(#4'($%',#3$1$8(3(1+#*%(%/8$+57("9#I.(#2%((#-5'' #/2#3$1$8(3(1+#+/#4/10&4+#5+"#/-1#6&"51(""#$22$5%"#+/#$4.5(7(#5+"#*&%*/"(#4$11/+#6(#0(15(09#>EJ!@^DHIC#!EJ!AO!#79#!LF!A#IDHMFA!@)# FAB9)#?DFI[##N!MDL)#HFB[!H:#^!HB@!K)#$10#!IIK9#HC:C@]C#BCH\FID)#E9H9#A/9#P_SaTa)#!&8&"+#P`)#VTTUW

T+.#7&'%$*:3

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pCH # ^C^^K # :D@#HCL!HFC#79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#$10#G!^@C#L9#M!:HF!E!)E9H9#A/9#P__QTa)N&',#VR)VTTUW

T+)*+.&/+(&1#-+.3*8#($)*+.

F1 # +.5" # 4$"() # +.( # :(45"5/1 # 0$+(0 # N$1&$%, # PR) # VTTa # /2 # +.(#L(4%(+$%, # /2 # @$6/% #$10 #D3*'/,3(1+ #-$" # %(4(57(0 #6, #*(+5+5/1(% #/1#N$1&$%, # Va) # VTTa9 # # F+ # -/&'0 # .$7( # 6(4/3( # 251$' # $10 # (;(4&+/%, # /1#](6%&$%, # `) # VTTa) # +.( # +(1+. # 0$, # 2%/3 # *(+5+5/1(%e" # %(4(5*+ # /2 # +.(#0(45"5/19 # #[/-(7(%) #*(+5+5/1(% # 25'(0 #$#*(+5+5/1 # 2/% #4(%+5/%$%5 #-5+.# +.(#B/&%+#/2#!**($'"#/1#(7(1#0$+(9##B'($%',)#*(+5+5/1(%#$7$5'(0#/2#+.(#*%/*(%#%(3(0,#"514(#:(*$%+3(1+#C%0(%#A/9#`TXTS#(;*'545+',#*%/.565+"#+.(#25'518#/2 #$#3/+5/1#2/% #%(4/1"50(%$+5/19 # #L&4.#3/+5/1#6(4/3("#05"*(1"$6'(#$10#1/+#$+#$''#1(4(""$%,9# >B[HFL#E!HMDAIL#BCHGCH!IFCA#7" #[CA9#G!IHFBF! #!9 # LIC9 # ICM!L #$10 #B[HFL #E!HMDAIL #cCH?DHL #JAFCAXGIEcC#@CB!@#B[!GIDH#A/9#RSV)#E9H9#A/9#P_Q`V_)#N$1&$%,#PV)#VTTUW

KE1'&12%#3&+/&C(+-#82(#

• 1#*.3)$)#:#.)&'+:"%*$.-#&1#"+()&

I.(#1(-#A@HB#H&'("#/2#G%/4(0&%()#-.54.#+//=#(22(4+#/1#N$1&$%,#Q)#VTT_)#1/-#%(b&5%(#+.(#(3*'/,(%#+/#"&635+#$ #%(*/%+#/2#4/3*'5$14(#

$"

Page 43: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

-5+.51#PT#4$'(10$%#0$,"#2%/3#%(4(5*+# /2#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%e"#0(45"5/1)#05"/6(05(14( # +/ #-.54. # 4'($%', # 0(1/+(" # $ # %(2&"$' # +/ # %(51"+$+(9 # # I.(#(3*'/,(( # 1((0 # 1/+ # 25'( # $ #3/+5/1 # 2/% # +.( # 5""&$14( # /2 # +.( # -%5+ # /2#(;(4&+5/1#"514(#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(% #".$''# +.(%($2+(%*/(&1*0%(0%'(# 5""&(#+.(#-%5+9# #c5+.#+.(#1(-#%&'("#51#*'$4()#+.(%(#5"#.$%0',#$1,#052254&'+,#51#0(+(%351518 # +.( #(3*'/,(%e" # 51+%$1"58(14(# 51 # 533(05$+(', #4/3*',518#-5+. # +.( # /%0(%9 #>NJ!AFIC # !9 #E!HBF! # $10 # !@^DHIC # N9 # :JM!EC # 7"9#G[F@FGGFAD#!FH@FADL)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_`Ra_)###N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

• E*;#($%&!""%*-$)*+.&+/&)0#&12%#3&+/&C(+-#82(#

I.( #B/&%+ # 5" #&153*%(""(09 # #I.( #8%$75+, #/2 #M$%$'5+e" # 512%$4+5/1#0(3$10"# +.(#%('$;$+5/1 #/2 #"+%54+ # %&'(" #/2 #*%/4(0&%(9 # #L+%54+ # %&'(" #/2#*%/4(0&%( #3$, # 6( # "(+ # $"50( # +/ # "(%7( # +.( # 0(3$10" # /2 # "&6"+$1+5$'#<&"+54(9##@$6/%#4$"("#3&"+#6(#0(450(0#$44/%0518#+/#<&"+54()#(b&5+,)#$10#+.(#"&6"+$1+5$' #3(%5+" #/2 # +.(#4/1+%/7(%",9 # # F1 #EU13 *;+ *I)-#(*H'3'0'-(*!);'-,2*)-7*D(%&,),$*I)-5)#+.(#B/&%+#.('0r

I.(#"(%5/&"1(""#/2#*(+5+5/1(%e"#512%$4+5/1#0(3$10(0#+.(#"(++518#$"50(#/2#"+%54+#%&'("#/2#*%/4(0&%(#$"#+/#$''/-#+.(#0(+(%351$+5/1#/1#+.(#3(%5+"#/2#-.(+.(%#.(#-$"#'$-2&'',#05"35""(09##!"#.('0#6,#+.(#B/&%+)#+.(#$**'54$+5/1#/2#+(4.154$'#%&'("#/2#*%/4(0&%(#3$,#6(#%('$;(0#+/#"(%7(#+.(#0(3$10" #/2 # "&6"+$1+5$' # <&"+54() #*$%+54&'$%', # 51 # '$6/% #4$"(") #6(4$&"(#+.(, # 3&"+ # 6( # 0(450(0 # $44/%0518 # +/ # <&"+54( # $10 # (b&5+, # $10 # +.(#"&6"+$1+5$'#3(%5+"#/2#+.(#4/1+%/7(%",9

# I.(%( # 5" # "&6"+$1+5$' # (750(14( # "./-518 # +.$+ # +.(%( #-$" # 7$'50#4$&"(#2/%#+.(#6$1=#+/#05"35""#*(+5+5/1(%e"#(3*'/,3(1+#2/%#'/""#/2#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(9##G(+5+5/1(%#-$"#$#6$1=#$44/&1+$1+)#-.54.#5"#$#*/"5+5/1#/2 #+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(9# #I.(#$3/&1+# 517/'7(0# 5"#"5815254$1+) #$'3/"+#G`9a#35''5/19# #>DLIDH#^9#M!H!@FI#79 #G[F@FGGFAD#A!IFCA!@#^!A?)#E9H9#A/9#P_SQRR)#!&8&"+#V`)#VTTUW

K+)*-#&+/&'0$.6#&+/&!88(#33

G!@e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

$#

Page 44: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

*&%*/"( #/2 # +.( # %&'(" #/1 #4/3*'(+(1("" #/2 #"(%754( #$10 # +.( #1/+54( #/2#4.$18(#/2#$00%("")#-.54.#5"#+/#*'$4(#+.(#0$+(#/2#%(4(5*+#/2#*'($0518")#<&083(1+"#$10#*%/4(""("#6(,/10#+.(#*/-(%#/2#+.(#*$%+,#6(518#"(%7(0#+/#0(+(%351(#$+#.5"#*'($"&%(9# >G[F@FGGFAD#!FH@FADL)#FAB9#79 #[DFHL#C]#^DHA!H:FA#N9#O!MCH!)#E9H9#A/9#P_`V_Q)#E9H9#A/9#P__UU_W

VD#(3#$3&I:"%+7:#.)&'+.)($-)3&

H("*/10(1+e"#"(%754(#$-$%0#2/%#+.(#"5;+.#4/1+%$4+#5"#(b&57$'(1+#/1', # +/ # .$'2X3/1+.e" # *$, # *'&" # +.( # *%/*/%+5/1$+( # $3/&1+ # 2/% # +.(#$005+5/1$' # 151( # 0$," # /2 # "(%754( # .( # %(10(%(0 # $2+(% # /1( # ,($%9#H("*/10(1+e" # (3*'/,3(1+ # 4/1+%$4+" # (;*%(""', # "+$+(0 # +.$+ # .5"#(3*'/,3(1+ # (10(0 # &*/1 # .5" # 0(*$%+&%( # 2%/3 # -/%=9 # D$4. # ,($% # .(#0(*$%+(0# 2%/3#-/%= #$10#"&44(""57(', #1(-#4/1+%$4+" #-(%( #(;(4&+(0#6(2/%( #.( #%(*/%+(0 # 2/% #-/%= #$1(-9 #[5" #"(%754( #-$"#1/+ #4&3&'$+57(9#G(%+51(1+',)#51#I%$-&*!#9((3A*B-#+*;+*W)/(%))#-(#"$50#+.$+#Y$#25;(0#+(%3#5" #$1 #(""(1+5$' #$10#1$+&%$' #$**&%+(1$14(Z #/2 #/7(%"($" #(3*'/,3(1+#4/1+%$4+") # $" # 51 # +.5" # 4$"(9## c( # $'"/ # "$50 # 51 # +.$+ # 4$"( # +.$+ # &10(%#!3(%54$1#'$-)#Yf-g.(%(#$#4/1+%$4+#"*(4525("#+.(#*(%5/0#/2#5+"#0&%$+5/1)#5+#+(%351$+("#/1#+.(#(;*5%$+5/1#/2#"&4.#*(%5/09##!#4/1+%$4+#/2#(3*'/,3(1+#2/%#$#0(2515+(#*(%5/0#+(%351$+("#6,#5+"#/-1#+(%3"#$+#+.(#(10#/2#"&4.#*(%5/09Z## !"#5+#5")#!%+54'(#QV#/2#+.(#L$&05#@$6/%#@$-#5"#$'"/#/2#"535'$%#53*/%+9##F+#%($0"r

!#'$6/%#4/1+%$4+#4/14'&0(0#2/%#$#"*(4525(0#*(%5/0#".$''#+(%351$+(#&*/1#+.(#(;*5%,#/2#5+"#+(%39#F2#6/+.#*$%+5("#4/1+51&(#+/ # (12/%4( # +.( # 4/1+%$4+) # +.(%($2+(%) # 5+ # ".$'' # 6( # 4/1"50(%(0#%(1(-(0 # 2/% # $1 # &1"*(4525(0 # *(%5/09# >@c\ # BCALIHJBIFCA#BCHGCH!IFCA#79 #M!HBD@C#^9#:JGC)* F+>+ *<(+*XYLZ[LA# N&',#PS)#VTTU

F1 #@3)#$6$33 * B-&$%-)&'(-)3 *!$%;'#$2 *?(%0(%)&'(- *;+ *?)/(&$) #-(#.('0#+.$+#+.(#"&6"(b&(1+',#(;(4&+(0#"50(#$8%((3(1+#/2#$1#/7(%"($"#4/1+%$4+#-/%=(%#-5+.#+.(#2/%(581#(3*'/,(%#5"#7/50)#"53*',#6(4$&"(#5+#5"#$8$51"+#/&%#(;5"+518#'$-")#3/%$'"#$10#*&6'54#*/'54,9# #I.(#"&6"(b&(1+#$8%((3(1+#4$11/+#"&*(%"(0(#+.(#+(%3"#/2#+.(#"+$10$%0#(3*'/,3(1+#4/1+%$4+#$**%/7(0#6,#+.(#GCD!9 # #H(*&6'54 #!4+#A/9#RT`V) #4/33/1',#=1/-1#$" # +.(#M58%$1+ #c/%=(%" #!4+ #/2 #PUUa) #(;*%(""', #*%/.565+" # +.(#"&6"+5+&+5/1 # /% # $'+(%$+5/1) # +/ # +.( # *%(<&054( # /2 # +.( # -/%=(%) # /2#(3*'/,3(1+ # 4/1+%$4+" # $'%($0, # $**%/7(0 # $10 # 7(%525(0 # 6, # +.(#:(*$%+3(1+#/2 #@$6/%#$10#D3*'/,3(1+# >:C@DW# 2%/3#+.(#+53(#/2 #+.(#$4+&$'#"581518#+.(%(/2#6,#+.(#*$%+5("#&*#+/#$10#514'&0518#+.(#*(%5/0#/2#+.(#(;*5%$+5/1#/2#+.(#"$3()#-5+./&+#+.(#$**%/7$'#/2#:C@D9# #L514(#+.(#"(4/10#(3*'/,3(1+#4/1+%$4+#*(+5+5/1(%#A5"0$#"581(0#-5+.#%("*/10(1+#!:!ML#-$"#7/50#2/%#1/+#.$7518#6((1#"$14+5/1(0#6,#+.(#GCD!)#+.(1#*(+5+5/1(% # A5"0$e" # (3*'/,3(1+ # -5+. # %("*/10(1+ # !:!ML # -$" # "+5''#

$$

Page 45: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

8/7(%1(0#6,#.5"#GCD!XLDB#&1+5'#.5"#%(*$+%5$+5/1#+/#+.(#G.5'5**51("#/1#PQ#N&',#VTTV9##>B!H@CL#A9#AFL:!#79#LD!#LDH\D#M!HFIFMD#!EDABK#$10#?[!@F]! # !9 # !@ECL!F^F # :F\FAE # !A: # M!HFAD # LDH\FBDL) #E9 # H9 # A/9#PQUPQQ)#N&',#VS)#VTTUW

C$7:#.)&+/&S$6#3&C#.8*.6&!""#$%

F1#/+.(%#-/%0")#$#05"35""(0#(3*'/,((#-./"(#4$"(#-$"#2$7/%$6',#0(450(0 #6, # +.( # @$6/% #!%65+(% # 5" # (1+5+'(0 # +/ # %(4(57( #-$8(" #*(10518#$**($'#&*/1#%(51"+$+(3(1+)#-.54.#5"# 533(05$+(',#(;(4&+/%,9# #J1'(""#+.(%(#5"#$#%("+%$51518#/%0(%)#5+#5"#3515"+(%5$'#&*/1#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#+/#53*'(3(1+ # +.( # /%0(% # /2 # %(51"+$+(3(1+ # $10 # 5+ # 5" #3$10$+/%, # /1 # +.(#(3*'/,(%# +/#4/3*',#+.(%(-5+.9# >NJ!AFIC#!9#E!HBF!#$10#!@^DHIC#N9#:JM!EC#7"9#G[F@FGGFAD#!FH@FADL)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_`Ra_)###N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

C(#3-(*")*D#&C#(*+8&/+(&W%%#6$%&4*3:*33$%

* # I.(#'$-#25;("#+.(#*(%5/0#/2#+53(#-5+.51#-.54.#*(+5+5/1(%#4/&'0#"((=#%(3(0,#2/%#.5"# 5''(8$'#05"35""$'#$10#2/%#$"# '/18#$"#.(#25'(0#.5"#B/3*'$51+#-5+.51#+.(#*%("4%5*+57(#*(%5/0)#.(#".$''#6(#(1+5+'(0#+/#+.(#2&''#*%/+(4+5/1#/2#.5"#%58.+#+/#6$4=-$8("9# # F1# 5''(8$' #05"35""$'#4$"(")#+.(#(3*'/,((#4/14(%1(0#5"#857(1#$#*(%5/0#/2#2/&%#,($%"#2%/3#+.(#+53(#/2#.5" # 5''(8$' #05"35""$' #-5+.51#-.54.#+/# 51"+5+&+(#+.(#4/3*'$51+9 # #I.5" # 5"#6$"(0#/1#!%+54'(#PP`_#/2#+.(#A(-#B575'#B/0(#-.54.#"+$+("#+.$+#$4+5/1"#6$"(0#&*/1#$1# 51<&%, # +/#+.(#%58.+" #/2 # +.(#*'$51+522 #3&"+ #6(#6%/&8.+#-5+.51#2/&%#,($%"9##I.(#2/&%X,($%#*%("4%5*+57(#*(%5/0#".$''#4/33(14(#+/#%&1#/1',#&*/1#+.(#$44%&$'#/2#$#4$&"(#/2#$4+5/1#/2#+.(#-/%=(%9# #[(%()#*(+5+5/1(%#-$"#05"35""(0#2%/3#"(%754(#/1#Pa#L(*+(36(%#VTTP9##[(#25'(0#.5"#4/3*'$51+#2/%#5''(8$'#05"35""$'#/1#P`#N&1(#VTT`9# #B'($%',)#+.(1)#+.(#51"+$1+#4$"(#-$"#25'(0#-5+.51#+.(#*%("4%5*+57(#*(%5/09#>DHcFA#[9#HDKDL#79 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA) # E9H9 # A/9 # PRTaaP)#](6%&$%,#PT)#VTTUW

C(#3-(*")*D#&C#(*+8&/+(&T+.#7&'%$*:3

F1#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"()#+.(#($%'5("+#51450(1+#4/7(%(0#6,#!%+54'(#PPaa#5"#+.(#(;+%$<&0545$'#0(3$10#-.54.#4$3(#/1#N$1&$%,#Q)#PUUa#9#!"#+.(#B!#4/%%(4+', # 4/3*&+(0) # +.( # *(%5/0 # 2/% # *%("4%5*+5/1 # "+$%+(0 # +/ # %&1 # /1#N$1&$%,#Pa)#PUUS#)#$10#-$"#51+(%%&*+(0#/1#N$1&$%,#Q)#PUUa#9##JAF@!^#/1',#$1"-(%(0#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%e"#N$1&$%,#Q)#PUUa#'(++(%#/1#](6%&$%,#V_)#PUU_#)#-5+.#$#4$+(8/%54$'#0(15$'#/2#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%e"#0(3$10j#+.(#%&11518#/2 # +.(#*%("4%5*+5/1 #*(%5/0#%(X"+$%+(0#/1#+.(#0$+(#/2 # +.5" #0(15$') #6&+#$8$51#"+/**(0#$8$51#/1#!&8&"+#U)#PUU_#)#-.(1#+.(#4/3*'$51+#6(2/%(#+.(#A@HB#-$"#25'(09##!00518#$''#+.(#%&11518#*(%5/0"#,5('0"#$#+/+$'#/2#'(""#

$%

Page 46: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+.$1 # +.%(( # >SW # ,($%"j # .(14() # +.( # *(+5+5/1(% # "($"/1$6', # 25'(0 # .(%#3/1(+$%, # 4'$53 # -.(1 # ".( # 25'(0 # .(% # 4/3*'$51+ # 6(2/%( # +.( # A@HB9##>N!AJ!HF!#!9#HF\DH!#79#JAFID:#@!^CH!ICHFDL)#FAB9)E9H9#A/9##Paa_SU#!*%5'#VV)#VTTUW

• T+.#7&'%$*:3&@&V5S3

F1 #?)7)3'- * ;+ * @JGE\2 * E7/'-'2&%)&(%) # -( # .('0 # +.$+ # !%+54'( # VUP#4/7(%"#$''#3/1(,#4'$53"#2%/3#(3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*#$10#5"#6%/$0(% # 51 # "4/*( # +.$1#4'$53" #$%5"518 # 2%/3#$ #"*(45254 # '$-9 ##F+ # 5" #1/+#'535+(0#+/#3/1(,#4'$53"#%(4/7(%$6'(#&10(%#+.(#@$6/%#B/0()#6&+#$**'5("#$'"/#+/#4'$53"#/2 #/7(%"($"#4/1+%$4+#-/%=(%"9## I.(#2/''/-518#%&'518# 51#?)7)3'-#;+*@JGE\2*E7/'-'2&%)&(%#5"#51"+%&4+57(r

]5%"+ #+/#6(#0(+(%351(0#5"#-.(+.(%# 5+ # 5" #+.(#^$.%$51#'$-#/1#*%("4%5*+5/1#/2#$4+5/1#6$"(0#/1#+.(#!35%5#:(4%((#A/9#VS#/2#PUQ_#/%#$#G.5'5**51(#'$-#/1#*%("4%5*+5/1#+.$+#".$''#6(#+.(#8/7(%1518#'$-9

!%+54'( # Pa_ # /2 # +.( # !35%5 # :(4%(( # A/9 # VS # /2 # PUQ_#*%/750("r

Y! # 4'$53 #$%5"518 #/&+ # /2 # $ # 4/1+%$4+ # /2 # (3*'/,3(1+#".$''#1/+#6(#$4+5/1$6'(#$2+(%#+.(#'$*"(#/2#/1(#,($%#2%/3#+.(#0$+(#/2#+.(#(;*5%,#/2#+.(#4/1+%$4+Z#;#;#;9

!"#$#8(1(%$'#%&'()#$#2/%(581#*%/4(0&%$'#'$-#-5''#1/+#6(#$**'5(0#51#+.(#2/%&39##G%/4(0&%$'#3$++(%")#"&4.#$"#"(%754(#/2 # *%/4("") # </510(% # /2 # $4+5/1") # *(%5/0 #$10 # %(b&5"5+(" # 2/%#$**($') # $10 # "/ # 2/%+.) # $%( # 8/7(%1(0 #6, # +.( # '$-" # /2 # +.(#2/%&39## I.5" # 5" # +%&( #(7(1 # 52 # +.( #$4+5/1 # 5" #6$"(0 #&*/1 #$#2/%(581 # "&6"+$1+57( # '$- # >H("+$+(3(1+ # /2 # +.( # B/12'54+ # /2#@$-") # L(49 # _Raj # L$'/18$) # G%57$+( # F1+(%1$+5/1$' # @$-) #PSP#fPUQUgW9#

! # '$- # /1 # *%("4%5*+5/1 # /2 # $4+5/1" # 5" #21' * ,$-$%'2 *51#B/12'54+#/2#@$-"#51#+.(#"(1"(#+.$+#5+#3$,#6(#75(-(0#(5+.(%#$" # *%/4(0&%$' # /% # "&6"+$1+57() # 0(*(10518 # /1 # +.(#4.$%$4+(%5i$+5/1#857(1#"&4.#$#'$-9

;#;#;#;

[/-(7(%) # +.( # 4.$%$4+(%5i$+5/1 # /2 # $ # "+$+&+( # 51+/ # $#*%/4(0&%$'#/%#"&6"+$1+57(#'$-#6(4/3("#5%%('(7$1+#-.(1#+.(#4/&1+%, # /2 # +.( # 2/%&3 # .$" # $ # Y6/%%/-518 # "+$+&+(9Z## L$50#"+$+&+( # .$" # +.( # *%$4+54$' # (22(4+ # /2 # +%($+518 # +.( # 2/%(581#

$&

Page 47: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

"+$+&+(#/2#'535+$+5/1#$"#/1(#/2#"&6"+$14(#>E//0%54.)#B/12'54+#/2 #@$-")#PaVXPaS#fPUSRgW9## !#Y6/%%/-518#"+$+&+(Z#05%(4+"#+.( # "+$+( # /2 # +.( # 2/%&3 # +/ # $**', # +.( # 2/%(581 # "+$+&+( # /2#'535+$+5/1"#+/#+.(#*(10518#4'$53"#6$"(0#/1#$#2/%(581#'$-#>L5(8(') # B/12'54+") # PRS # fPUQagW9## c.5'( # +.(%( # $%( # "(7(%$'#=510"#/2#Y6/%%/-518#"+$+&+(")Z#/1(#2/%3#*%/750("#+.$+#$1#$4+5/1#6$%%(0#6,#+.(#'$-"#/2#+.(#*'$4(#-.(%(#5+#$44%&(0)#-5'' #1/+#6(#(12/%4(0# 51#+.(#2/%&3#(7(1#+./&8.#+.(# '/4$'#"+$+&+(#.$"#1/+#%&1#$8$51"+#5+#>E//0%54.#$10#L4/'(")#B/12'54+#/2#@$-")#PaVXPaS#fPUSRgW9##L(4+5/1#`R#/2#/&%#B/0(#/2#B575'#G%/4(0&%(#5"#/2#+.5"#=5109##L$50#L(4+5/1#*%/750("r

YF2 #6, # +.( # '$-" #/2 # +.( #"+$+( #/% # 4/&1+%, #-.(%( # +.(#4$&"(#/2#$4+5/1#$%/"()#+.(#$4+5/1#5"#6$%%(0)#5+#5"#$'"/#6$%%(0#51#+.(#G.5'5**51(#F"'$10"9Z

L(4+5/1#`R#.$"#1/+#6((1#%(*($'(0#/%#$3(10(0#6,#+.(#B575' #B/0( #/2 # +.( #G.5'5**51("9## !%+54'( #VVQT #/2 #"$50 #B/0(#%(*($'(0 # /1', # +./"( # *%/75"5/1" # /2 # +.( # B/0( # /2 # B575'#G%/4(0&%(#$"#+/#-.54.#-(%(#514/1"5"+(1+#-5+.#5+9## I.(%(#5"#1/#*%/75"5/1#51#+.(#B575'#B/0(#/2#+.(#G.5'5**51(")#-.54.#5"#514/1"5"+(1+#-5+.#/%#4/1+%$054+/%,#+/#L(4+5/1#`R#/2#+.(#B/0(#/2#B575'#G%/4(0&%(#>G$%$")#G.5'5**51(#B/12'54+#/2#@$-")#PT`#fQ+.#(09gW9

F1 # +.( # '58.+ # /2 # +.( # PURQ # B/1"+5+&+5/1) # ./-(7(%)#L(4+5/1 # `R # f/2 # +.( # B/0( # /2 # B575' # G%/4(0&%(g # 4$11/+ # 6(#(12/%4(0 #$Q * 0%(0%'( * ;',(%$# 51"/2$% # $" # 5+ # /%0$51" # +.(#$**'54$+5/1#51#+.5"#<&%5"054+5/1#/2#f!%+54'(g#Pa_#/2#+.(#!35%5#:(4%((#A/9#VS#/2#PUQ_9

I.(#4/&%+"#/2#+.(#2/%&3#-5''#1/+#(12/%4(#$1,#2/%(581#4'$53 # /61/;5/&" # +/ # +.( # 2/%&3e" # *&6'54 # */'54, # ; # ; # ;9 # I/#(12/%4(#+.(#/1(X,($%#*%("4%5*+57(#*(%5/0#/2#+.(#!35%5#:(4%((#A/9 #VS#/2 #PUQ_#$" # %(8$%0"# +.( #4'$53"# 51 #b&("+5/1 #-/&'0#4/1+%$7(1(#+.(#*&6'54#*/'54,#/1#+.(#*%/+(4+5/1#+/#'$6/%9

<&<&<&<I.&") # 51#/&% #4/1"50(%(0#75(-) #%("*/10(1+e" #4/3*'$51+ #-$"#25'(0#-(''#

-5+.51#+.(#+.%((X,($%#*%("4%5*+57(#*(%5/0#&10(%#!%+54'(#VUP#/2#/&%#@$6/%#B/0(9##I.5"#*/51+)#./-(7(%)#.$"#$'%($0,#6((1#3//+(0#6,#/&%#2510518#+.$+#%("*/10(1+e"#"(%754(#$-$%0#.$0#6((1#*$50)#$'6(5+#+.(#*$,%/'' # +(%3(0 # "&4. # *$,3(1+ # $" # "(7(%$14( # *$,9# >@c\#BCALIHJBIFCA #BCHGCH!IFCA #79 #M!HBD@C #^9 #:JGC)# E9H9 #A/9#PQVS`V)#N&',#PS)#VTTUW

C(+;$)*+.$(7&I:"%+7##

$'

Page 48: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

!#*%/6$+5/1$%,#(3*'/,((#/%#*%/6$+5/1(%#5"#/1(#-./#5"#/1#+%5$'#2/%#$1#(3*'/,(%)#0&%518#-.54.#+.(#'$++(%#0(+(%351("#-.(+.(%#/%#1/+#.(#5"#b&$'525(0#2/%#*(%3$1(1+#(3*'/,3(1+9##I.(#*%/6$+5/1$%,#(3*'/,3(1+#5"#51+(10(0#+/#$22/%0#+.(#(3*'/,(%#$1#/**/%+&15+,#+/#/6"(%7(#+.(#25+1(""#/2#$#*%/6$+5/1$%,#(3*'/,((#-.5'(#$+#-/%=)#$10#+/#$"4(%+$51#-.(+.(%#.(#-5''#6(4/3(#$1#(22545(1+#$10#*%/0&4+57(#(3*'/,((9##c.5'(#+.(#(3*'/,(%#/6"(%7(" # +.( # 25+1("") # *%/*%5(+, # $10 # (22545(14, # /2 # $ # *%/6$+5/1(% # +/#$"4(%+$51 # -.(+.(% # .( # 5" # b&$'525(0 # 2/% # *(%3$1(1+ # (3*'/,3(1+) # +.(#*%/6$+5/1(%)#/1#+.(#/+.(%#.$10)#"((="#+/#*%/7(#+/#+.(#(3*'/,(%#+.$+#.(#.$"#+.(#b&$'5254$+5/1"#+/#3((+#+.(#%($"/1$6'(#"+$10$%0"#2/%#*(%3$1(1+#(3*'/,3(1+9 #I.&") # +.( #-/%0 #0%(4)&'(-)%") # $" #&"(0# +/ #0("4%56( # +.(#*(%5/0#/2#(3*'/,3(1+)#53*'5("#+.(#*&%*/"(#/2#+.(#+(%3#/%#*(%5/0)#1/+#5+" # '(18+.9 #>M!EFL#KCJAE#!B[FD\DHLe #@D!HAFAE#BDAIDH#$10 #MHL9#\FC@DI!#I9#B!HFhC#79#!:D@!F:!#9#M!A!@C)#E9H9#A/9#PQRRSa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTU#W

• C(+;$)*+.$(7&I:"%+7:#.)&/+(&!-$8#:*-&C#(3+..#%

]/% # Y$4$0(354 # *(%"/11('Z # 51 # *%57$+( # "4.//'") # 4/''(8(" # $10#&157(%"5+5(") #*%/6$+5/1$%,#(3*'/,3(1+# 5" #8/7(%1(0#6,#L(4+5/1#UV#/2#+.(#PUUV#M$1&$'#/2 #H(8&'$+5/1"#2/% #G%57$+(#L4.//'" #>M$1&$'W) #-.54.#%($0"r#

####### L(4+5/1 # UV+ * * @%(4)&'(-)%" * @$%'(7+ *q* L&6<(4+ # 51 # $''#51"+$14("#+/#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#:(*$%+3(1+#$10#"4.//'#%(b&5%(3(1+") # +.( # *%/6$+5/1$%, # *(%5/0 # 2/% # $4$0(354#*(%"/11(' # ".$'' # 1/+ #6( #3/%( # +.$1 # +.%(( # >SW # 4/1"(4&+57(#,($%"#/2 #"$+5"2$4+/%,#"(%754(#2/% #+./"(# 51 #+.(#('(3(1+$%,#$10 # "(4/10$%, # '(7('") # "5; # >_W # 4/1"(4&+57( # %(8&'$%#"(3("+(%"#/2#"$+5"2$4+/%,#"(%754(#2/%#+./"(#51#+.(#+(%+5$%,#'(7(')#$10#151(# #>UW#4/1"(4&+57(#+%53("+(%"#/2#"$+5"2$4+/%,#"(%754( # 2/% # +./"( # 51 # +.( # +(%+5$%, # '(7(' # -.(%( # 4/''(85$+(#4/&%"("#$%(#/22(%(0#/1#$#+%53("+(%#6$"5"9

>M!EFL#KCJAE#!B[FD\DHLe#@D!HAFAE#BDAIDH#$10 #MHL9#\FC@DI!#I9#B!HFhC#79#!:D@!F:!#9#M!A!@C)#E9H9#A/9#PQRRSa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTU#W

• ,#-2(*)7&+/&M#.2(#&+/&C(+;$)*+.$(7&I:"%+7##3

!"#$6/7(#05"4&""(0) #*%/6$+5/1$%,#(3*'/,(("#(1</,#"(4&%5+, #/2#+(1&%(#0&%518#+.(#+(%3#/2# +.(5% #*%/6$+5/1$%, #(3*'/,3(1+#"&4.#+.$+#+.(,#3$,#/1',#6(#+(%351$+(0#2/%#4$&"(#$"#*%/750(0#2/%#6,#'$-)#/%#52#$+#+.(#(10#/2#+.(#*%/6$+5/1$%,#*(%5/0)#+.(#(3*'/,((#2$5'(0#+/#3((+#+.(#

$(

Page 49: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

%($"/1$6'( # "+$10$%0" # "(+ # 6, # +.( # (3*'/,(% # $+ # +.( # +53( # /2 # +.(#(3*'/,((e" # (18$8(3(1+9 # # J10(15$6',) # %("*/10(1+ # -$" # .5%(0 # $" # $#*%/6$+5/1$%,#+($4.(%#$10)#$"#"&4.)#5+#-$"#514&36(1+#&*/1#*(+5+5/1(%#+/#"./-#6,#4/3*(+(1+#(750(14(#+.$+#".(#050#1/+#3((+#+.(#"+$10$%0"#"(+#6,#+.(#"4.//'9 # #I.5"#%(b&5%(3(1+) #*(+5+5/1(%# 2$5'(0#+/#05"4.$%8(9# #I/#1/+()#+.(#+(%351$+5/1#/2#%("*/10(1+#-$"#(22(4+(0#6,#+.$+#'(++(%#"+$+518#+.$+ # ".( #-$" #6(518 # %('5(7(0 # 2%/3 #(3*'/,3(1+ # 6(4$&"( # +.( # "4.//'#$&+./%5+5(" # $''(8(0', # 0(450(0) # $" # $ # 4/"+X4&++518 #3($"&%() # +.$+ # +.(#*/"5+5/1#/2#YG%5145*$'Z#-$"#+/#6(#$6/'5".(09##A/-.(%(#51#+.$+#'(++(%#-$"#%("*/10(1+# 512/%3(0#+.$+#.(%#*(%2/%3$14(#$"#$#"4.//' #+($4.(%#-$"#'(""#+.$1#"$+5"2$4+/%,9#>M!EFL#KCJAE#!B[FD\DHLe#@D!HAFAE#BDAIDH#$10#MHL9#\FC@DI!#I9#B!HFhC#79#!:D@!F:!#9#M!A!@C)#E9H9#A/9#PQRRSa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTU#W

• M#(:*.$)*+.&+/&C(+;$)*+.$(7&I:"%+7##

J10(%#!%+54'(#VRP#/2#+.(#@$6/%#B/0()#$#*%/6$+5/1$%,#(3*'/,((#4$1#6(#'(8$'',#05"35""(0#(5+.(%r#>PW#2/%#$#<&"+#4$&"(j#/%#>VW#-.(1#.(#2$5'"#+/#b&$'52,#$"#$#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,((#51#$44/%0$14(#-5+.#+.(#%($"/1$6'(#"+$10$%0"#3$0(#=1/-1#+/ #.53#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(% #$+ # +.(#"+$%+ #/2 # +.(#(3*'/,3(1+9##A/1(+.('("")#+.(#*/-(%#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%#+/#+(%351$+(#+.(#"(%754("#/2#$1#(3*'/,((#/1#*%/6$+5/1#5"#1/+#-5+./&+#'535+$+5/1"9##]5%"+)#+.5" # */-(% # 3&"+ # 6( # (;(%45"(0 # 51 # $44/%0$14( # -5+. # +.( # "*(45254#%(b&5%(3(1+"#/2#+.(#4/1+%$4+9##L(4/10)#+.(#05""$+5"2$4+5/1#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%#3&"+#6(#%($'#$10#51#8//0#2$5+.)#1/+#2(581(0#"/#$"#+/#45%4&37(1+#+.(#4/1+%$4+#/%#+.(#'$-9##I.5%0)#+.(%(#3&"+#6(#1/#&1'$-2&'#05"4%5351$+5/1 # 51 #+.(#05"35""$'9## F1 # +(%351$+5/1#4$"(") #+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%/7518#<&"+#/%#7$'50#4$&"(#2/%#05"35""518#$1#(3*'/,((#%("+"#/1#+.(#(3*'/,(%9 # >:!\!C # BCAIH!BICHL # :D\D@CGMDAI # BCCGDH!IF\D#>:!BC:DBCW#79##M!HF@KA#!9#G!L!c!)E9H9#A/9#PQVPQ`)N&',#U)#VTTUW

C(+P#-)&I:"%+7##

c.5'( # %("*/10(1+ # *(%2/%3(0 # +$"=" # +.$+ # -(%( # 4'($%', # 75+$')#1(4(""$%,#$10#5105"*(1"$6'(#+/#+.(#&"&$'#6&"51(""#/%#+%$0(#/2#!'4$+(')#%("*/10(1+#-$"#1/+#4/1+51&/&"',#%(.5%(0#6,#!'4$+('#$2+(%#+.(#4(""$+5/1#/2#(7(%,#*%/<(4+9# #H(4/%0"#"./-#+.$+#%("*/10(1+#-$"#.5%(0#6,#!'4$+('#2%/3#PURR#+/#PUUa#2/%#+.%((#*%/<(4+")#1$3(',#+.(#G@:I#mXa#*%/<(4+)#+.(#G@:I#mX`#FCI#*%/<(4+#$10#+.(#G@:I#PS`V#*%/<(4+9# #C1#ST#!*%5'#PURR)#&*/1 # +.( #(;*5%$+5/1 #/2 # %("*/10(1+e" # 4/1+%$4+ # 2/% # +.( #G@:I #mX` # FCI#*%/<(4+) # #!'4$+('#050#1/+#%(.5%(#%("*/10(1+#&1+5'#P#](6%&$%,#PUUP) #+(&$/)#(&$&%$"3#&+/&]]&:+.)03)#2/%#+.(#G@:I#PS`V#*%/<(4+9# # #!'4$+('e"#4/1+51&/&"#%(.5%518#/2#%("*/10(1+#51#7$%5/&"#4$*$45+5("#2%/3#](6%&$%,#PUUP#+/#:(4(36(%#PUUa#-$"#0/1(#(1+5%(',#-5+.51#+.(#2%$3(-/%=#/2#/1(#$10#+.(#"$3(#*%/<(4+#w# #+.(#G@:I#PS`V#*%/<(4+9# #I.5"#050#1/+#3$=(#%("*/10(1+ # $ # %(8&'$% # (3*'/,(( # /2 # !'4$+(' # $" # %("*/10(1+ # -$" # 1/+#

$)

Page 50: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

4/1+51&/&"', # %(.5%(0 # $2+(% # +.( # 4(""$+5/1 # /2 # $ # *%/<(4+9 # # H("*/10(1+#%(3$51(0#$ #*%/<(4+ #(3*'/,(( #/2 #!'4$+(' #-/%=518 #/1 # +.( #G@:I#PS`V#*%/<(4+9 # >!@B!ID@ # G[F@FGGFADL) # FAB9) # 79 #HDAD # H9 # HD@CL)# E9H9 # A/9#P_`SPa)#N&',#S)#VTTUW#

C(+)#-)*+.&)+&E$;+(

c.(+.(%#(3*'/,(0#'/4$'',#/%#/7(%"($")#$''#]5'5*51/#-/%=(%"#(1</,#+.(#*%/+(4+57(#3$1+'(#/2#G.5'5**51(#'$6/%#$10#"/45$'#'(85"'$+5/1)#4/1+%$4+#"+5*&'$+5/1"#+/#+.(#4/1+%$%,#1/+-5+."+$105189##I.5"#*%/1/&14(3(1+#5"#51#=((*518#-5+.#+.(#6$"54#*&6'54#*/'54,#/2#+.(#L+$+(#+/#$22/%0#*%/+(4+5/1#+/#'$6/%) # *%/3/+( # 2&'' # (3*'/,3(1+) # (1"&%( # (b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mGCHIDH # 79 # LGCJLDL # LFMG@FBFC # $10 # MF@!#BJ!HDLM!#>2/%#$10#51#6(.$'2#/2+.(5%#0$&8.+(%)#H$3:*.#E9#'2$(#3:$W)#c[FID # ]!@BCA # LDH\FBDL) # FAB9 # $10 # N!FMD # CHIFO # >G%("50(1+)c.5+(#]$'4/1#L(%754(")#F149W#!A:#GHCMCIFCA)#FAB9)E9H9#A/"9#PRVUQRXQU)#E9H9#A/"9#PR`VURXUU)#!*%5'#Q)#VTTUW#

I.&") # $" #.('0 # 51 # +.$+ # 4$"() # z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z# >[DHMFAFEF@:C # FAEJF@@C # !A: # ODA!F:!#^DHE!AID # \9 #]FHLI # G[F@FGGFAD # LB!@DL) # FAB9 #$10p/% #!MG!HC#GC@FB!HGFC)#M!A!EDH)#E9H9#A/9#P_a`TQ)#N&1(#a)#VTTUW#

^2#3)*+.&+/&E$=&_&5$-)

I.(%(#5"#$#b&("+5/1#/2#'$-#52#+.(#5""&(#%$5"(0#5"#4$*$6'(#/2#6(518#%("/'7(0 # -5+./&+ # 1((0 # /2 # %(75(-518 # +.( # *%/6$+57( # 7$'&( # /2 # +.(#(750(14(9##I.(#%("/'&+5/1#/2#+.(#5""&(#3&"+#%("+#"/'(',#/1#-.$+#+.(#'$-#*%/750("#/1#$#857(1#"(+#/2#45%4&3"+$14("9# #C14(#5+ # 5" #4'($%#+.$+#+.(#5""&(#5175+("#$#%(75(-#/2#+.(#(750(14(#*%("(1+(0)#+.(#b&("+5/1#*/"(0#5"#/1(#/2#2$4+9# #F2#+.(#b&(%,#%(b&5%("#$#%(X(7$'&$+5/1#/2#+.(#4%(0565'5+,#/2#-5+1(""(")#/%#+.(#(;5"+(14(#/%#%('(7$14(#/2#"&%%/&10518#45%4&3"+$14("#$10#+.(5%#%('$+5/1#+/#/1(#$1/+.(%)#+.(#5""&(#51#+.$+#b&(%,# 5"#2$4+&$'9#

%*

Page 51: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

>EDADH!@#L!AICL#BCB!XBC@!#G@!AI#]HDD#cCH?DHL#JAFCAXIJG!L#7"9#BCB!XBC@!#^CII@DHL#G[F@L9)#FAB9#>EDADH!@#L!AICL#BFIKW)#I[D#BCJHI # C] # !GGD!@L # $10 # I[D # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQR_`QW

^2*)-%$*:

[/-(7(%)#-5+.#%("*(4+#+/#+.(#"(4/10#6$+4.#/2#b&5+4'$53"#"581(0#6,#Ra#/2#+.(#%(3$51518#P_T#(3*'/,(("#-./#-(%(#+(%351$+(0#2/''/-518#[,$++e"#*(%3$1(1+#4'/"&%()#-(#./'0#+.$+#+.("(#$%(#7$'50#$10#6510518#&10(%+$=518"9#I.(#"$50#0/4&3(1+"#51054$+(#+.$+#+.(#$3/&1+#%(4(57(0#6,#($4.#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(("#%(*%("(1+"#$#%($"/1$6'(#"(++'(3(1+#/2#+.(5%#3/1(+$%, # 4'$53" # $8$51"+ # *(+5+5/1(% # $10 # -(%( # (7(1 # "581(0 # 51 # +.(#*%("(14( # /2 # $ # :C@D # %(*%("(1+$+57(9 # ! # b&5+4'$53) # -5+. # 4'($% # $10#&1$3658&/&"#4/1+(1+"#$10#(;(4&+(0#2/%#$#7$'50#4/1"50(%$+5/1#%(4(57(0#51 # 2&'' # 6, # +.( # (3*'/,(( # -./ # "581(0 # +.( # "$3() # 4$11/+ # 6( # '$+(%#517$'50$+(0#6(4$&"(# 5+" #"581$+/%,#4'$53"#+.$+ #.(#-$"#*%(""&%(0# 51+/#"581518#5+#/1#$44/&1+#/2#.5"#05%(#251$145$'#1((09#c.(1#5+#5"#"./-1#+.$+#+.( # *(%"/1 # (;(4&+518 # +.( # -$57(% # 050 # "/ # 7/'&1+$%5',) # -5+. # 2&''#&10(%"+$10518#/2 #-.$+ #.(#-$"#0/518) #$10#+.(#4/1"50(%$+5/1# 2/% # +.(#b&5+4'$53 # 5" # 4%(056'( # $10 # %($"/1$6'() # +.( # +%$1"$4+5/1 # 3&"+ # 6(#%(4/815i(0#$"#$#7$'50#$10#6510518#&10(%+$=5189& F[CID@#DAIDHGHFLDL#C]#I[D#G[F@FGGFADL)#FAB9#>[DGFW) #/-1(%#/2#[,$++#H(8(14,#M$15'$)#79#L!M![!A #AE #ME! #M!AEE!E!c! #L! #[K!IIXA!IFCA!@ #JAFCA #C]#cCH?DHL#FA#I[D#[CID@#!A:#HDLI!JH!AI#!A:#!@@FD:#FA:JLIHFDL#>L!M!L![XAJc[H!FAW)#E9H9#A/9#P_aQa_)###N&1(#a)#VTTUW#

I/ #(;4&"( #*(+5+5/1(%" # 2%/3#4/3*',518 #-5+. # +.( # +(%3" #/2 # +.(5%#-$57(%") # +.(, #3&"+ # '/4$+( # +.(5% # 4$"( # -5+.51 # $1, # /2 # +.%(( # 1$%%/-#8%/&10"r # >PW # +.( # (3*'/,(% # &"(0 # 2%$&0 # /% # 0(4(5+ # 51 # /6+$51518 # +.(#-$57(%"j # >VW # +.(* 4/1"50(%$+5/1 # +.( # (3*'/,(% # *$50 # 5" # 514%(056'( # $10#&1%($"/1$6'(j#/%#>SW#+.(#+(%3"#/2#+.(#-$57(%#$%(#4/1+%$%,#+/#'$-)#*&6'54#/%0(%)#*&6'54#*/'54,)#3/%$'"#/%#8//0#4&"+/3"#/%#*%(<&0545$'#+/#$#+.5%0#*(%"/1#-5+.#$#%58.+#%(4/815i(0#6,#'$-9#I.(#*%(4(0518#05"4&""5/1#/1#+.(#7/'&1+$%51("" # /2 # *(+5+5/1(%"e # %(+5%(3(1+ # 2%/3 # "(%754( # (22(4+57(',#%(3/7(" # +.("( # 8%/&10" # 6(,/10 # *(+5+5/1(%"e # $%8&3(1+$+57( # %($4.9#!44/%0518',)#*(+5+5/1(%")#6,#+.(#+(%3"#/2#+.(5%#-$57(%")#$%(#6$%%(0#2%/3#25'518#+.5"#"&5+9 # >!HLDAFC#]9#kJD\D:C)#(+#$'9) #79 #^DAEJDI#D@DBIHFB#BCCGDH!IF\D)FABCHGCH!ID:#>^DADBCW#$10#EDH!H:C#G9#\DHOCL!)#E9H9#A/9#P_RUVQ)#L(*+(36(%#PP)#VTTUW

• W.D$%*8&^2*)-%$*:3

L5815254$1+',)#+.(#M$152("+$+5/1"#25'(0#6,#*(+5+5/1(%#-5+.#%("*(4+#+/#+.(#b&5+4'$53"#(;(4&+(0#6,#3(36(%"#/2#%("*/10(1+#J15/1#"+$+(#+.$+#S`#/2#+.(#`R#(3*'/,(("#+(%351$+(0#/1#$44/&1+#/2#+.(#0/-1"5i518#*%/8%$3#

%!

Page 52: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

.$7(#$'%($0,#(;(4&+(0#b&5+4'$53"#/1#7$%5/&"#0$+("9#c()#./-(7(%)#+$=(#<&0545$' # 1/+54( # +.$+ # SS # /2 # +.("( # b&5+4'$53" # 2$5'(0 # +/ # 51054$+( # +.(#$3/&1+" # %(4(57(0 # 6, # +.( # +(%351$+(0 # (3*'/,(("9 # ^(4$&"( # /2 # +.5")#*(+5+5/1(%# '($7("#&"#1/#4./54(#6&+#+/# 517$'50$+(#$10#"(+#$"50(#+.("(#b&5+4'$53"9 #[/-(7(%) # +.(#$4+&$' #$3/&1+ # %(4(57(0#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(("#&*/1 #"581518 # +.( #"$50 #0/4&3(1+" #".$'' #6( #0(0&4+(0 # 2%/3#-.$+(7(%#%(3$51518#$3/&1+#5"#0&(#+.(3#+/#$7/50#0/&6'(#%(4/7(%,#/2#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#$10#/+.(%#3/1(+$%,#6(1(25+"9#c(#.(%(6,#/%0(%#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#+/#(22(4+#+.(#1(4(""$%,#4/3*&+$+5/1#/1#+.5"#3$++(%9&F[CID@#DAIDHGHFLDL#C]#I[D#G[F@FGGFADL)#FAB9#>[DGFW) #/-1(%#/2#[,$++#H(8(14,#M$15'$)#79#L!M![!A #AE #ME! #M!AEE!E!c! #L! #[K!IIXA!IFCA!@ #JAFCA #C]#cCH?DHL#FA#I[D#[CID@#!A:#HDLI!JH!AI#!A:#!@@FD:#FA:JLIHFDL#>L!M!L![XAJc[H!FAW)#E9H9#A/9#P_aQa_)###N&1(#a)#VTTUW

!'"/) # LMB # 4$11/+ # +$=( # %(2&8( # 51 # +.( # H(4(5*+ # $10 # H('($"(#0/4&3(1+ # "581(0 # 6, # +.( # %("*/10(1+9 # E(1(%$'',) # 0((0" # /2 # %('($"()#-$57(%")#/%#b&5+4'$53"#4$11/+#6$%#(3*'/,(("#2%/3#0(3$10518#6(1(25+"#+/#-.54.#+.(,#$%(#'(8$'',#(1+5+'(0#/%#2%/3#4/1+("+518#+.(#'(8$'5+,#/2#+.(5%#05"35""$') # "514( # b&5+4'$53" # $%( # '//=(0 # &*/1 #-5+. # 05"2$7/% # $10 # $%(#2%/-1(0#&*/1#$"#4/1+%$%,#+/#*&6'54#*/'54,9#c.(%()#./-(7(%)#+.(#*(%"/1#3$=518#+.(#-$57(%#.$"#0/1(#"/#7/'&1+$%5',)#-5+.#$#2&''#&10(%"+$10518#+.(%(/2) # $10 # +.( # 4/1"50(%$+5/1 # 2/% # +.( # b&5+4'$53 # 5" # 4%(056'( # $10#%($"/1$6'()#+.(#+%$1"$4+5/1#3&"+#6(#%(4/815i(0#$"#$#7$'50#$10#6510518#&10(%+$=5189# #I.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%/7518#+.$+#+.(#b&5+4'$53#/%#-$57(%#-$"#7/'&1+$%5', # (1+(%(0 # 51+/ # %("+" # /1 # +.( # (3*'/,(%9& >L!A # MFEJD@#BCHGCH!IFCA#79#D:J!H:C#@9#IDC:CLFC)#E9H9#A/9#P_STSS)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

1#$%&C$()7&*.&W.)#(#3)

I/#b&$'52,#$#*(%"/1#+/#6(#$#%($'#*$%+,#51#51+(%("+#51#-./"(#1$3(#$1#$4+5/1#3&"+#6(#*%/"(4&+(0)#.(#3&"+#$**($%#+/#6(#+.(#*%("(1+#%($'#./'0(% # /2 # +.( # %58.+ # "/&8.+ # +/ # 6( # (12/%4(09 # # YF1+(%("+Z # -5+.51 # +.(#3($1518#/2#+.(#%&'(#3($1"#3$+(%5$'#51+(%("+)#$1#51+(%("+#51#(""(14(#+/#6(#$22(4+(0#6,#+.(#<&083(1+#$"#05"+518&5".(0#2%/3#3(%(#51+(%("+#51#+.(#b&("+5/1#517/'7(0) #/%#$#3(%(# 51450(1+$'# 51+(%("+9 # #^,#%($' # 51+(%("+# 5"#3($1+ #$ #*%("(1+ #"&6"+$1+5$' # 51+(%("+) #$" #05"+518&5".(0 # 2%/3#$#3(%(#(;*(1+$14, # /% # $ # 2&+&%() # 4/1+518(1+) # "&6/%051$+( # /% # 4/1"(b&(1+5$'#51+(%("+9 # #>ACHI[D!LIDHA # BC@@DED # ID!B[DHL # !A: # DMG@CKDDL#!LLCBF!IFCA #7"9 #ACHI[D!LIDHA#BC@@DED) # FAB9) #E9H9 #A/9 #PaVUVS)#N$1&$%,#PU)#VTTUW

F+#.$"#6((1#%(*($+(0',#"+$+(0#+.$+#+.(#G$1+%$14/#*%/*(%+5("#-.54.#-(%(#+.(#"&6<(4+#/2#(;(4&+5/1#"$'(#-(%(#/-1(0#6,#M$4%5"#$10#'$+(%)#+.( # GA^XM$0(4/%9 # # I.(, # -(%( # 1(7(% # /-1(0 # 6, # GADF # /% # GA^9#]/''/-518#/&%#($%'5(%#05"4&""5/1#/1#+.(#"(*$%$+(#*(%"/1$'5+5("#/2#+.(#

%"

Page 53: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

0522(%(1+#4/%*/%$+5/1"#517/'7(0#51#+.(#51"+$1+#4$"()#+.(#/1',#(1+5+,#-.54.#.$"#+.(#%58.+#$10#51+(%("+#+/#b&("+5/1#+.(#(;(4&+5/1#"$'(#$10#+.(#(7(1+&$'#%58.+#+/#$11&'#+.(#"$3()#52#$1,)#5"#GA^XM$0(4/%#/%#5+"#"&44(""/%X51X51+(%("+9#L(++'(0#5"#+.(#%&'(#+.$+#*%/4((0518"#51#4/&%+#3&"+ # 6( # 51"+5+&+(0 # 6, # +.( # %($' # *$%+, # 51 # 51+(%("+9 # >G!AIH!ABC#DMG@CKDDL # !LLCBF!IFCA # >GD!XGIEcCW # $10 # G!AIH!ABC#HDIHDAB[D: # DMG@CKDDL # !LLCBF!IFCA # >G!AHD!W # 79 # A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#>A@HBW)#E9H9#A/9#PQT_RU)#E9H9#A/9#PQTQTaW

1#@-+:"2)$)*+.&+/&!=$(83

]&%+.(%3/%()#+.(#B!#"&22545(1+',#(;*'$51(0#+.(#1((0#+/#514%($"(#+.(#$-$%0#/2#PS+.#3/1+.#*$,#$10#LF@#*$,9#F+#3/0525(0#+.(#$-$%0#$2+(%#2510518#+.$+#+.(#4/3*&+$+5/1#/2#+.(#$3/&1+#857(1#6,#+.(#A@HB#51#5+"#:(45"5/1 #0$+(0#M$%4.#Va) #VTTV#0/(" #1/+ #4/12/%3#+/ # +.( #05"35""(0#(3*'/,(("e#(3*'/,3(1+#.5"+/%,9#I.(#B!#$*+',#(;*'$51(0)#;'U+r

! # 4&%"/%, # %($0518 # /2 # +.( # $""$5'(0 #:(45"5/1 # /2 # +.(#A@HB#0$+(0#M$%4.#Va)#VTTV#%($05',#%(7($'"#+.$+#+.(#'$6/%#+%56&1$' # $-$%0(0 # *%57$+( # %("*/10(1+" # +.(5% # &1*$50 # PS+.#

M/1+.#G$,#$10#L(%754(#F14(1+57(#@($7(#>LF@W#G$,#-5+./&+#%(8$%0 # +/ # +.(5% # (3*'/,3(1+ # .5"+/%, #-5+. # +.( # *(+5+5/1(%9#I.(%(#-$"#(7(1#1/#(;*'$1$+5/1#/% #$0(b&$+(#"./-518#/1#+.(#2$4(#/2#+.(#b&("+5/1(0#<&083(1+#-.,#+.(#$-$%0#/2#+.(#&1*$50 #PS+.# M/1+. #$10 #LF@ #G$, #0522(%" # 2%/3#/1( #*%57$+(#%("*/10(1+ # +/ # $1/+.(%9 # # I.5" # B/&%+) # +.(%(2/%() # $2+(%#0(+(%351518 # +.$+ # 510((0# +.( #*(+5+5/1(% #.$0#1/+ #*$50 # +.(#*%57$+(#%("*/10(1+" # +.("(#"*(45$' #6(1(25+" # 2/% # +.(#-./'(#*(%5/0#/2#+.(5%#(3*'/,3(1+#+.(%(-5+.)#3/0525(0#+.(#$-$%0#6, # *$51"+$=518', # 6$"518 # 5+ # +/ # ($4. # /2 # +.( # 05"35""(0#(3*'/,((e"#(3*'/,3(1+#.5"+/%,#-5+.#*(+5+5/1(%9

;#;#;#;

I.(#*%/4(0&%$'#'$*"(#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#+.(#A@HB#51#+.5"#4$"(#51#2$5'518#+/#+$=(#51+/#$44/&1+#+.(#1&36(%#/2 #,($%"#-.(1# +.( #*%57$+( # %("*/10(1+" #050 #1/+ # %(4(57( # +.(5% #PS+.#

M/1+. #$10 # LF@ # G$, # 4$11/+ # 0(2($+ # +.(5% # %58.+ # +/ # %(4(57(#+.("( # 6(1(25+" # $" # 8%$1+(0 # &10(% # "&6"+$1+57( # '$-9 # I.5"#B/&%+#"53*',#4/&'0#1/+#&*./'0#$1#(%%/1(/&"#4/3*&+$+5/1#/2#+.(#"$50#&1*$50#6(1(25+"9#[(14()#5+#.$0#+/#%(X4/3*&+()#$10#$"#$#4/1"(b&(14()#514%($"(0#5+9

%#

Page 54: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

>!?@!A #BC@@DED) # FAB9 # 7"9# GDHGDIJC #DADHC) #!H@KA #B!LIFE!:CH)#AJDA!#LDHMCA#$10#NCBD@KA#OC@FA!)#E9H9#A/9#PQRSTU) #N$1&$%,#VQ)#VTTUW

1#-(2*):#.)&!6#.-7

!" # +.( # B/&%+ # *%(75/&"', # /6"(%7(0) # +.( # B/1+%$4+ # /2 # L(%754("#6(+-((1#F1+(%"(%7(#$10#*(+5+5/1(%#050#1/+#50(1+52,#+.(#-/%=#1((0(0#+/#6( # *(%2/%3(0 # $10 # +.( # 251$' # %("&'+ # %(b&5%(0 # +/ # 6( # $44/3*'5".(09#F1"+($0) # +.(#B/1+%$4+ #"*(4525(0 #+.(# +,*(#/2 #-/%=(%" # F1+(%"(%7(#3&"+#*%/750( # *(+5+5/1(% # >YH/&+( # [('*(%") # L$'("3(1) # :%57(%") # B'(%54$'")#D14/0(%"#d#G:ZW#$10#+.(5%#b&$'5254$+5/1"#>+(4.154$'p7/4$+5/1$'#4/&%"(#8%$0&$+(")#*.,"54$'',#25+)#/2#8//0#3/%$'#4.$%$4+(%)#$10#.$7(#1/+#6((1#4/1754+(0#/2#$1,#4%53(W9# #I.(#B/1+%$4+#$'"/#"+$+("#+.$+)#Y+/#4$%%,#/&+#+.(#&10(%+$=518"#"*(4525(0 # 51 # +.(# 533(05$+(', #*%(4(0518#*$%$8%$*.)#+.( # BCAIH!BICH # ".$'' # (3*'/, # +.( # 1(4(""$%, # *(%"/11(')Z # +.&")#$4=1/-'(08518 # +.$+ # F1+(%"(%7( # 050 # 1/+ # ,(+ # .$7( # 51 # 5+" # (3*'/, # +.(#*(%"/11('#1((0(0#6,#*(+5+5/1(%#$10#-/&'0#"+5''#*54=#/&+#"&4.#*(%"/11('#6$"(0#/1#+.(#4%5+(%5$#*%/750(0#6,#*(+5+5/1(%9##F1#/+.(%#-/%0")#F1+(%"(%7(#050#1/+#/6'58$+(#5+"('2#+/#*(%2/%3#$1#50(1+525$6'(#</6)#-/%=)#/%#"(%754(#2/%#*(+5+5/1(%)#6&+#3(%(',#6/&10#5+"('2#+/#*%/750(#+.(#'$++(%#-5+.#"*(45254#+,*("#/2#(3*'/,(("9# #I.("(#4/1+%$4+&$'#*%/75"5/1"#"+%/18',#51054$+(0#+.$+ # F1+(%"(%7( # -$" # 3(%(', # $ # %(4%&5+518 # $10 # 3$1*/-(% # $8(14,#*%/750518#*(+5+5/1(%#-5+.#-/%=(%"#*(%2/%3518#+$"="#05%(4+',#%('$+(0#+/#+.(#'$++(%e"#*%5145*$'#6&"51(""9##>BCB!XBC@!#^CII@DHL#G[F@L9)#FAB##79#!@!A#M9#!EFIC)#(+#$'9)##E9H9#A/9#PQUa`_)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTUW

1#/23$%&)+&1#)2(.&)+&S+(B

I.(%(2/%()#+.(#4/3*'$51+#2/%#5''(8$'#05"35""$'#25'(0#6,#%("*/10(1+"#-$" #*%(3$+&%() # "514( #(7(1 #$2+(% # +.( #(;*5%$+5/1 #/2 # +.(5% # "&"*(1"5/1#*(%5/0)#+.(,#%(2&"(0)#0("*5+(#0&(#1/+54()#+/#%(*/%+#+/#-/%=9##F1#2$4+)#51#+.(5%#M(3/%$10&3#/2#!**($')#%("*/10(1+"#$035++(0#.$7518#%(4(57(0#*(+5+5/1(%"e # %(+&%1X+/X-/%= # 3(3/%$10&3 # -.54.) # ./-(7(%) # 6(4$3(#2&+5'( # 6(4$&"( # +.(, #.$"+5', # 25'(0 # +.( # 4/3*'$51+ # 2/% # 5''(8$' # 05"35""$'9#>FA:JLIHF!@#d#IH!ALGCHI#DkJFGMDAI)#FAB9# #H!KMCA:#N!HFA!)#7"9#ICM!L#IJE!:D#$10#BHDLDABFC#IJE!:D)#E9H9 #A/9#PaRaSU)# N$1&$%,#Pa)#VTTUW

1#62%$(&I:"%+7:#.)

J10/&6+(0',)#%("*/10(1+"#-(%(#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,(("#/2#*(+5+5/1(%#-5+. #%("*(4+ # +/ # +.(#("4/%+ #/% #Y4/36/,Z#$4+575+, # 2/% #-.54. #+.(,#.$0#

%$

Page 55: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

6((1#(18$8(0#"514(#PUUS#$10#PUU`)#%("*(4+57(',)#-5+./&+#%(8$%0#+/#4/1+51&5+, #/% # 6%/=(11("" # /2 # +.( # "(%754(9 # >:D!@BC#]!HML) # FAB9) # 7"9#A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH #HD@!IFCAL #BCMMFLLFCA # >a+.# :F\FLFCAW) # E9H9 # A/9#PaSPUV###N$1&$%,#ST)#VTTUW!

I.&") # +.(%( #$%( # +-/ # =510" # /2 # %(8&'$% # (3*'/,((") # 1$3(',r # >PW#+./"( # -./ # $%( # (18$8(0 # +/ # *(%2/%3 # $4+575+5(" # -.54. # $%( # &"&$'',#1(4(""$%,#/%#0("5%$6'(#51#+.(#&"&$'#6&"51(""#/%#+%$0(#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%j#$10#>VW#+./"(#-./#.$7(#%(10(%(0#$+#'($"+#/1(#,($%#/2#"(%754()#-.(+.(%#4/1+51&/&"#/%#6%/=(1)#-5+.#%("*(4+#+/#+.(#$4+575+,#51#-.54.#+.(,#$%(#(3*'/,(09 # #L53*', #"+$+(0) # %(8&'$% #(3*'/,(("#$%( #4'$""525(0 # 51+/ # >PW#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,(("#X#6,#1$+&%(#/2#-/%=#$10#>VW#%(8&'$%#(3*'/,(("#X#6,#,($%"#/2#"(%754(9##I.(#2/%3(%#%(2(%"#+/#+./"(#(3*'/,(("#-./#*(%2/%3#$#*$%+54&'$%#$4+575+,#-.54.#5"#1(4(""$%,#/%#0("5%$6'(#51#+.(#&"&$'#6&"51(""#/%#+%$0(#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%)#%(8$%0'(""#/2#+.(5%#'(18+.#/2#"(%754(j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

1#*.3)$)#:#.)

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

!2+(%#+.(#'$6/%#$%65+(%e"#0(45"5/1#5"#%(7(%"(0#6,#$#.58.(%#+%56&1$')#+.(#(3*'/,((#3$,#6(#6$%%(0#2%/3#4/''(4+518#+.(#$44%&(0#-$8(")#52#5+#5"#"./-1#+.$+#+.(#0('$,#51#(12/%4518#+.(#%(51"+$+(3(1+#*(10518#$**($'#-$"#-5+./&+#2$&'+#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%9#>NJ!AFIC#!9#E!HBF!#$10#!@^DHIC#N9#:JM!EC#7"9#G[F@FGGFAD#!FH@FADL)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_`Ra_)#N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

• 1#*.3)$)#:#.)&82(*.6&'+("+($)#&1#0$;*%*)$)*+.

%%

Page 56: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

B$"(#'$-#%(4/815i("#+.$+#&1'(""#+.(%(#5"#$#%("+%$51518#/%0(%)#+.(#53*'(3(1+$+5/1 # /2 # +.( # /%0(% # /2 # %(51"+$+(3(1+ # 5" # 3515"+(%5$' # $10#3$10$+/%,9# #I.5"#51<&14+5/1#/%#"&"*(1"5/1#/2#4'$53"#6,#'(85"'$+57(#25$+#*$%+$=("#/2#+.(#1$+&%(#/2#$#%("+%$51518#/%0(%#+.$+#4/1"+5+&+("#$#'(8$'#<&"+5254$+5/1 # 2/% # %("*/10(1+e" #1/1X4/3*'5$14(#-5+. # +.(# %(51"+$+(3(1+#/%0(%9 # # H("*/10(1+e" # 2$5'&%( # +/ # (;(%45"( # +.( # $'+(%1$+57( # /*+5/1" # /2#$4+&$' # %(51"+$+(3(1+ # $10 # *$,%/'' # %(51"+$+(3(1+ # -$" # +.&" # <&"+525(09#L&4. # 6(518 # +.( # 4$"() # %("*/10(1+e" # /6'58$+5/1 # +/ # *$, # +.( # "$'$%5("#*(10518 # $**($') # $" # +.( # 1/%3$' # (22(4+ # /2 # +.( # 1/1X(;(%45"( # /2 # +.(#/*+5/1")#050#1/+#$++$4.9#>NJ!AFIC#!9#E!HBF!#$10#!@^DHIC#N9#:JM!EC#7"9#G[F@FGGFAD#!FH@FADL)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_`Ra_)###N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

1#"2;%*-&!-)&K+J&`?aQ&

• 5*/)0&C$($6($"0&+/&,#-)*+.&>?b&U.-+.3)*)2)*+.$%

I.(#$%8&3(1+#/2#+.(#L/'545+/%#E(1(%$')#+.$+#+.(#$4+&$'#*&%*/"(#/2#+.(#"&6<(4+#4'$&"(#/2#'535+518#+.(#(1+5+'(3(1+#/2#C]c"#+/#+.(5%#+.%((X3/1+. # "$'$%, # 51 # 4$"( #/2 # 5''(8$' #05"35""$') # 5" # +/ #857( # +.(3#$ #6(++(%#4.$14(#/2#8(++518#.5%(0#6,#2/%(581#(3*'/,(%"9##I.5"#5"#*'$51#"*(4&'$+5/19#!" #($%'5(% #05"4&""(0) # +.(%( # 5" #1/+.518 # 51 # +.( # +(;+ #/2 # +.(# '$-#/% # +.(#%(4/%0"#/2#+.(#0('56(%$+5/1"#'($0518#+/#5+"#(1$4+3(1+#/%#+.(#*'($0518"#/2 # %("*/10(1+ # +.$+ # -/&'0 # 51054$+( # +.$+ # +.(%( # 5" # $1 # (;5"+518#8/7(%13(1+$'#*&%*/"(#2/%#+.(#"&6<(4+#4'$&"()#/%#(7(1#<&"+#$#*%(+(;+#/2#/1(9#

I.( # "&6<(4+ # 4'$&"( # 0/(" # 1/+ # "+$+( # /% # 53*', # $1, # 0(2515+57(#8/7(%13(1+$'#*&%*/"(j#$10#5+#5"#2/%#+.$+#*%(45"(#%($"/1#+.$+#+.(#4'$&"(#75/'$+("#1/+#<&"+#*(+5+5/1(%l"#%58.+#+/#(b&$'#*%/+(4+5/1)#6&+#$'"/#.(%#%58.+#+/ # "&6"+$1+57(0&( # *%/4("" #&10(% # L(4+5/1 # P) # # !%+54'( # FFF # /2 # +.(#B/1"+5+&+5/19 #>!AICAFC # M9 # LDHH!AC # 79 # # E!@@!AI # M!HFIFMD#LDH\FBDL)FAB9#$10#M!H@Cc#A!\FE!IFCA#BC9)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#P_Q_P`)#M$%4.#V`)#VTTUW

1#)*(#:#.)&'+D#($6#

!#+-5"+#51#H57(%$e"#4$"(#5"#+.$+#".(#4/1+51&(0#-/%=518#6(,/10#+.(#4/3*&'"/%,#"(*$%$+5/1#2%/3#"(%754(#+.$+#%("&'+(0#2%/3#.(%#%(+5%(3(1+9#c.(+.(%#".(#4/&'0#/%#4/&'0#1/+#%("&3(#-/%=518#-5+.#+.(#4/3*$1,#5")#$"#$#%&'()#$#4/1"(1"&$'#3$++(%#2/%#+.(#*$%+5("#+/#$8%((#&*/1)#'535+(0#/1',#6,#4/3*$1,#*/'545("#$10#+.(#$**'54$6'(#+(%3"#/2#+.(#%(+5%(3(1+#

%&

Page 57: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

*'$19## I/#6(#"&%()#+.(%(#5"#1/#'535+$+5/1#6,#'$-#+.$+#6$%%(0#.(%#2%/3#4/1+51&518 # .(% # -/%= # -5+. # JAF@!^j # (7(1 # +.( # $6/7(Xb&/+(0#F3*'(3(1+518#H&'(")#51#"(++518#+.(#%(+5%(3(1+#$8(#$+#_T)#0(2(%%(0#+/#+.( #*$%+5("e #$8%((3(1+9 #[(% #(3*'/,3(1+ # +(%3"#&10(% # +.5" # %(1(-(0#(3*'/,3(1+#$%(#6$"(0#/1#-.$+#".(#$10#+.(#4/3*$1,#$8%((0#&*/19##c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aa_SU # !*%5' # VV)#VTTUW#

,#$/$(#(

• 4#$)0&9#.#/*)3

I.(#8(1(%$'#%&'(#5"#+.$+#+.(#(3*'/,(%#5"#'5$6'(#+/#*$,#+.(#.(5%"#/2#+.(#0(4($"(0#"($2$%(%#2/%#0($+.#6(1(25+"#/14(#5+#5"#("+$6'5".(0#+.$+#.(#05(0#0&%518#+.(#(22(4+575+,#/2#.5"#(3*'/,3(1+#4/1+%$4+9# #[/-(7(%)#+.(#(3*'/,(%#3$,#6(#(;(3*+(0#2%/3#'5$65'5+,#52#.(#4$1#"&44(""2&'',#*%/7(#+.$+#+.(#"($2$%(%e"#0($+.#-$"#4$&"(0#6,#$1#51<&%,#05%(4+',#$++%56&+$6'(#+/#.5"#0('56(%$+(#/%#-5''2&'#$4+9##F1#"&3)#%("*/10(1+"e#(1+5+'(3(1+#+/#$1,#0($+.#6(1(25+" #0(*(10" #/1#-.(+.(% # +.( #(750(14(#/2 # +.(#*(+5+5/1(%"#"&2254("#+/#*%/7(#+.$+#+.(#0(4($"(0#4/335++(0#"&5450(j#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%//2#%("+"#/1#.5"#(3*'/,(%9 #>EHD!I#LCJI[DHA#M!HFIFMD #LDH\FBDL#BCHG9 # $10 # FMB # L[FGGFAE # BC9) # GID9 # @I:9 # 79# @DCAF@! # LJHFE!C # 2/%#[(%"('2#$10#F1#^(.$'2#/2#[(%#M51/%#B.5'0%(1)A$3(',#?!KD#!AED@F#$10#MFHF!M)^/+.#L&%1$3(0#LJHFE!C#E9H9#A/9#PRS_`_W

• C+3)@I:"%+7:#.)&T#8*-$%&I<$:*.$)*+.

^&+#(7(1#$""&3518#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#-$"#%(*$+%5$+(0#2/%#3(054$'#%($"/1")#.(#2$5'(0#+/#"&635+#.53"('2#+/#+.(#4/3*$1,X0("581$+(0#0/4+/%#51 # $44/%0$14( # -5+. # +.( # */"+X(3*'/,3(1+ # 3(054$' # (;$351$+5/1#%(b&5%(3(1+#&10(%#+.(#$6/7(Xb&/+(0#*$%$8%$*.#S#/2#L(4+5/1#VT>^W#/2#+.(#GCD!#L+$10$%0#D3*'/,3(1+#B/1+%$4+9##]$5'&%(#+/#4/3*',#-5+.#+.5"#%(b&5%(3(1+ #-.54. # 5" # $ #2'-$ * O1) * -(- *6$%" # +.( # 25'518 # /2 # 4'$53 # 2/%#05"$65'5+, #6(1(25+"9# >:FCAFLFC # #M9 # #MJLAFI# # 79 #LD! #LI!H #L[FGGFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA#)#E9H9#A/9#PRV_VS)#:(4(36(%#`)#VTTUW

%'

Page 58: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

,#-2(*)7&N2$(8

[M#:"+($(7&+//c8#)$*%\

C#)*)*+.#(A3 & -*)$)*+. & +/ & !()*-%# & Q`d & +/ & )0# & E$;+( & '+8#&

(#$8*.6e

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j#&10(%"4/%518#"&**'5(0W

5" # 35"*'$4(09 # # # #@9'3'00'-$ * B-712&%')3 * !$#1%'&" * E,$-#" * ;+ * _)0'&(-*

+($4.("r

c(#"+%("" # +.$+ #!%+54'( #VR_#$**'5(" #/1', #-.(1#+.(%( # 5" #$#4(-).'7$ * 2120$-2'(- * (. * &9$ * $/03("$%\2 * (0$%)&'(- * (. * )*412'-$22*(%*1-7$%&)5'-,*.(%*)*0$%'(7*-(&*$Q#$$7'-,*2'Q*`ab*/(-&92+ * *F1 # "&4. # $ # 4$"() # +.(%( # 5" # 1/ # +(%351$+5/1 # /2#(3*'/,3(1+ # 6&+ # /1', # $ # +(3*/%$%, # 05"*'$4(3(1+ # /2#(3*'/,((")#$'6(5+#+.(#05"*'$4(3(1+#"./&'0#1/+#(;4((0#"5;#>_W#3/1+."9# #I.(#*$%$3/&1+#4/1"50(%$+5/1#"./&'0#6(#+.(#05%(#(;58(14,#/2#+.(#6&"51(""#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%#+.$+#4/3*('"#5+#+/#*&+#"/3(#/2#5+"#(3*'/,(("#+(3*/%$%5',#/&+#/2#-/%=9##F1#"(4&%5+, # "(%754(") # +.( # +(3*/%$%, # Y/22X0(+$5'Z # /2 # 8&$%0"#+$=("#*'$4(#-.(1#+.(#"(4&%5+,#$8(14,e"#4'5(1+"#0(450(#1/+#+/#%(1(-#+.(5%#4/1+%$4+"#-5+.#+.(#"(4&%5+,#$8(14,)#%("&'+518#51#$#"5+&$+5/1#-.(%(#+.(#$7$5'$6'(#*/"+"#&10(%#5+"#(;5"+518#4/1+%$4+"#$%(#'(""#+.$1#+.(#1&36(%#/2#8&$%0"#51#5+"#%/"+(%9#>J10(%"4/%518#"&**'5(0W

F1#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"()#+.(%(#5"#1/#"./-518#+.$+#+.(%(#-$"#'$4=#/2#$7$5'$6'( #*/"+"#$+ #*(+5+5/1(%e" #4'5(1+"#/% #+.$+#+.(%(#-$"#$#%(b&("+#2%/3#+.(#4'5(1+X6$1=)#-.(%(#%("*/10(1+#-$"#'$"+#*/"+(0#$10#-.54.#

%(

Page 59: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

4/1+51&(0#+/#.5%(#*(+5+5/1(%e"#"(%754(")#+/#%(*'$4(#%("*/10(1+#-5+.#$1/+.(%9# #G(+5+5/1(%#"&00(1',#*%(7(1+(0#.53#2%/3#%(*/%+518#/1#.5"#+/&% # /2 # 0&+, # $+ # +.( # 6$1= # /1 # :(4(36(% # Pa) # VTTP # $10 # .$0 # 1/+#+.(%($2+(% # $"=(0 #.53 # +/ # %(*/%+ # 2/% # 0&+,9# >D!E@D #LI!H #LDBJHFIK#LDH\FBDL)#FAB9##79#^CAF]!BFC#@9#MFH!A:C)#E9H9#A/9#PQUaPV)#N&',#ST)#VTTUW

,#"$($)#&'+("+($)#&C#(3+.$%*)7

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e" # "(*$%$+( # (;5"+(14(#".$'' #6(#%("*(4+(0)#$10#+.(# '5$65'5+,#/2 #+.(#*$%(1+#4/%*/%$+5/1#$"#-('' # $" # +.( #"&6"505$%, #-5'' # 6( # 4/1251(0 # +/ # +./"( #$%5"518 # 51 # +.(5%#%("*(4+57( # 6&"51(""("9 # >G!AIH!ABC # DMG@CKDDL # !LLCBF!IFCA#>GD!XGIEcCW # $10 # G!AIH!ABC # HDIHDAB[D: # DMG@CKDDL#!LLCBF!IFCA # >G!AHD!W # 79 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#>A@HBW)#E9H9#A/9#PQT_RU)#E9H9#A/9#PQTQTaW

,#"$($)*+.&C$7

L514(#*(+5+5/1(%#-$"#1/+#2$&'+'(""#51#%(8$%0#+/#+.(#/22(1"("#53*&+(0#$8$51"+#.(%)#-(#./'0#+.$+#+.(#$-$%0#/2#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#/1',)#-5+./&+#6$4=-$8(") # 5" # *%/*(%9 #>D@FO!^DI[ # :9 # G!@IDAE # 79 #JAFID:#BCBCAJI#G@!AIDHL#^!A?)*E9H9#A/9#PQVPUU)#](6%&$%,#VQ)#VTTUW

c( # +.&" # 2510 # +.( # 05"35""$' # +/ # 6( # 5''(8$'9 # B/1"(b&(1+',)#%("*/10(1+#5"#(1+5+'(0#+/#%(51"+$+(3(1+#-5+./&+#'/""#/2#"(15/%5+,#%58.+"#$10#/+.(%#*%575'(8(") #$10#+/#2&'' #6$4=-$8(")# 514'&"57(#/2 #$''/-$14(")#$10#/+.(%#6(1(25+"#/%#+.(5%#3/1(+$%,#(b&57$'(1+)#4/3*&+(0#2%/3#+.(#+53(#/2#+.(#-5+../'0518#/2#+.(#(3*'/,((l"#4/3*(1"$+5/1#&*#+/#+.(#+53(#/2 #$4+&$' # %(51"+$+(3(1+9 # F2 # %(51"+$+(3(1+# 5" #1/+ #*/""56'( #0&(# +/ # +.(#"+%$51(0#%('$+5/1"#6(+-((1#+.(#(3*'/,(%#$10#+.(#(3*'/,(()#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#"./&'0 # 51"+($0#6(#*$50 # +.( #(3*'/,((#(b&57$'(1+ # +/ #/1(#3/1+.#"$'$%, # 2/% # (7(%, # ,($% # /2 # "(%754() # 4/3*&+(0 # 2%/3 # +.( # +53( # /2#(18$8(3(1+ # &* # +/ # +.( # 251$'5+, # /2 # +.5" # 0(45"5/19 # >Msc # O!A:DH#G[F@FGGFADL)# FAB9#$10#HC@]#cF@ILB[D?# #79#IHFAF:!:#M9#DAHFkJDO)#E9H9#A/9#P_UPQS)#N&1(#a)#VTTUW

%)

Page 60: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

!%+54'(#VQU#/2#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(#*%/750("#+.$+#Yf$g1#(3*'/,((#-./#5" # &1<&"+', # 05"35""(0 # 2%/3 #-/%= # ".$'' # 6( # (1+5+'(0 # +/ # %(51"+$+(3(1+#-5+./&+ # '/"" # /2 # "(15/%5+, # %58.+" # $10 #/+.(% # *%575'(8(" #$10 # +/ #.5" # 2&''#6$4=-$8(")#514'&"57(#/2#$''/-$14(")#$10#+/#.5"#/+.(%#6(1(25+"#/%#+.(5%#3/1(+$%,#(b&57$'(1+#4/3*&+(0#2%/3#+.(#+53(#.5"#4/3*(1"$+5/1#-$"#-5+..('0#2%/3#.53#&*#+/#+.(#+53(#/2#.5"#$4+&$'#%(51"+$+(3(1+9Z##L514()#51#+.(#*%("(1+#4$"()#%(51"+$+(3(1+#5"#1/#'/18(%#*%$4+54$6'(#/%#2($"56'()#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#3$,#6(#$-$%0(0#51#'5(&#/2#%(51"+$+(3(1+9# #M/%(/7(%)#+.( # $-$%0" # /2 # "(*$%$+5/1 # *$, # $10 # 6$4=-$8(" # $%( # 1/+ # 3&+&$'',#(;4'&"57(#$10#6/+.#3$,#6(#857(1#+/#I$8&'$/#$10#L(%%$1/9

I.( #1/%3$' #4/1"(b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o%(51"+$+(3(1+ # $10 # *$,3(1+ # /2#6$4=-$8("#o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j # "(*$%$+5/1 # *$,) # 51 # 4/1+%$"+) # 5" # /%5(1+(0 # +/-$%0" # +.(#533(05$+(#2&+&%()#+.(#+%$1"5+5/1$'#*(%5/0#+.(#05"35""(0#(3*'/,((#3&"+#&10(%8/ # 6(2/%( # '/4$+518 # $ # %(*'$4(3(1+ # </69# ; # ; # ; #I.( # 8%$1+ # /2#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#-$"#$#*%/*(%#"&6"+5+&+(#/1',#2/%#%(51"+$+(3(1+j#5+#4/&'0#1/+ # 6( # $1 # $0(b&$+( # "&6"+5+&+( # 6/+. # 2/% # %(51"+$+(3(1+ # $10 # 2/%#

&*

Page 61: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

6$4=-$8("9# # >D3*.$"5" #$00(0W# >AFLL!A#ACHI[#D:L!#^!@FAI!c!?)#kJDOCA#BFIK#79#!AED@FIC#LDHH!AC)#NH9#$10#D:cFA#I!EJ@!C)#E9H9#A/9#P_VaSR)#N&1(#`)#VTTUW

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e"#0(3$10#$+#+.$+#51"+$14(#$10#/%0(%(0#.(%#+/#%(+&%1#+/#-/%=#.$0#5+#1/+#6((1#+.(5%#51+(1+5/1#+/#"(7(%#*(+5+5/1(%#2%/3#+.(5%#(3*'/,9##[(14()#-(#2510#+.(#$''(8$+5/1#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#*%("(1+(0#.(%"('2#2/%#-/%=#6&+#-$"#%(2&"(0#6,#%("*/10(1+"#3/%( # 4%(056'(9 # #>BCABDGBFCA # ]!D@:CAF! # 79 # ICAE # K!?#EHCBDHFDL)N!KMD#EC#$10#MDH@FI!#EC)E9H9#A/9#PRV`UU)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

L514( #:&"5+ #[/+(' # 5" # (;*'545+', #3$10$+(0 # 6, # +.( # $2/%(Xb&/+(0#"+$+&+/%, # *%/75"5/1 # +/ # *$, # 5+" # (3*'/,((" # $10 # 3$1$8(3(1+ # +.(5%#%("*(4+57(#".$%("# 51#+.(#"(%754(#4.$%8("#4/''(4+(0)#+.(#./+(' #4$11/+#4'$53#+.$+#*$,3(1+#+.(%(/2#+/#5+"#RV#(3*'/,(("#4/1"+5+&+(#"&6"+$1+5$'#4/3*'5$14(#-5+.#+.(#*$,3(1+#/2#DBC@!#&10(%#cC#A/9#U9##J10/&6+(0',)#+.( # ./+(' # (3*'/,(("e # %58.+ # +/ # +.(5% # ".$%(" # 51 # +.( # "(%754( # 4.$%8("#4/''(4+(0#6,#:&"5+ #[/+(' # 5" #05"+514+ #$10#"(*$%$+(# 2%/3#+.(5% # %58.+ # +/#DBC@!j # 8%$+5254$+5/1 # 6, # +.( # ./+(' # /2 # /1( # 0/(" # 1/+ # %("&'+ # 51 # +.(#"$+5"2$4+5/1#/2#+.(#/+.(%9# #>G[F@FGGFAD#[CID@FDHL)#FAB9)#:JLFI#[CID@#AF??CXM!AF@! # 79 # A!IFCA!@ # JAFCA # C] # cCH?DHL # FA # [CID@)#HDLI!JH!AI) # !A: #!@@FD: # FA:JLIHFDL # >AJc[H!FAX!G@XFJ]WX #:JLFI#[CID@#AF??C#B[!GIDH)#E9H9#A/9#PRPUQV)#!&8&"+#Va)#VTTUW######

,+-*$%&H23)*-#

I.( #B/&%+ # 5" # 1/+ # &135102&' # /2 # +.( #(b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l" #4/14(%1#2/% # +.(#-/%=5183$19 # # I.(%( # 5") # 51 # $005+5/1) # .5" # 2$35', # +/ # 4/1"50(%9#J1(3*'/,3(1+ # 6%518" # &1+/'0 # .$%0".5*" # $10 # "/%%/-" # /1 # +./"(#

&!

Page 62: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

0(*(10(1+ # &*/1 # +.( # -$8(X($%1(%9 #>!^D@!H:C # G9 # !^D@ # 79 # G[F@Dm#MFAFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQRUQ_)#N&',#SP)#VTTUW

c.5'(#+.(#B/&%+#4/335"(%$+("#-5+.#*(+5+5/1(%"#/1#+.(5%# '/""#/2#(3*'/,3(1+)#("*(45$'',#1/-#+.$+#+.(#B//*(%$+57(#5"#1/#'/18(%#$#8/518#4/14(%1) # 5+ # 4$11/+ # "53*',) # 6, # 0(2$&'+) # ./'0 # +.( # B//*(%$+57(e" # 4/X%("*/10(1+" # '5$6'( # 2/% # +.(5% # 4'$53" # -5+./&+ # $1, # 2$4+&$' # $10 # '(8$'#<&"+5254$+5/1#+.(%(2/%9 # #I.(#"/45$'# <&"+54(#*/'54,#/2# '$6/%#'$-"#$10#+.(#B/1"+5+&+5/1#5"#1/+#3($1+#+/#6(#/**%(""57(#/2#4$*5+$'9# # #>C@:!HFBC#L9#IH!\DhC) # (+ # $' # 79 # ^C^CAECA #^!A!A! #EHCcDHL #MJ@IFXGJHGCLD#BCCGDH!IF\D) # IFMCE # !EHFBJ@IJH!@ # BCHGCH!IFCA) # :F!MCA:#]!HML) # FAB9) # $10 # :C@D # !LF! # G[F@FGGFADL) # E9H9 # A/9 # # P_`VTa)#L(*+(36(%#S)#VTTUW

F1 # +.(#*%("(1+ #4$"() # %("*/10(1+ #.$0#6((1#(3*'/,(0#-5+. # +.(#*(+5+5/1(% # 2/% # $'3/"+ # +-('7( # >PVW # ,($%"9 #C1 # ](6%&$%, # PS) # PUU_) # .(#"&22(%(0 # 2%/3#$ #Y2%$4+&%(0 # '(2+ # +%$1"7(%"( #*%/4("" #/2 # 2/&%+. # '&36$%#7(%+(6%$)Z#-.5'(#+.(5%#7(""('#-$"#$+#+.(#*/%+#/2#K/=/.$3$)#N$*$19#!2+(%#4/1"&'+518#$#0/4+/%)#.(#-$"#%(b&5%(0#+/#%("+#2/%#$#3/1+.9#c.(1#.(#-$"#%(*$+%5$+(0 # +/ #M$15'$ #$10 #(;$351(0 #6, #$ #4/3*$1, #0/4+/%) #.( #-$"#0(4'$%(0#25+#+/#4/1+51&(#.5"#-/%=9#c.(1#.(#%(*/%+(0#2/%#-/%=)#*(+5+5/1(%#%(2&"(0#+/#(3*'/,#.53#0("*5+(#+.(#$""&%$14(#/2#5+"#*(%"/11('#3$1$8(%9#H("*/10(1+#*$+5(1+',#-$5+(0#2/%#3/%(#+.$1#/1(#,($%#+/#(36$%=#/1#+.(#7(""('#$"#V%0#D1851((%)#6&+#+.(#*/"5+5/1#-$"#1/+#857(1#+/#.53)#$"#5+#-$"#/44&*5(0 # 6, # $1/+.(% # *(%"/1 # =1/-1 # +/ # /1( # /2 # +.( # "+/4=./'0(%"9#B/1"(b&(1+',)#2/%#.$7518#6((1#0(*%57(0#/2#4/1+51&(0#(3*'/,3(1+#-5+.#*(+5+5/1(%l"#7(""(')#%("*/10(1+#/*+(0#+/#$**',#2/%#/*+5/1$'#%(+5%(3(1+9#F1 #$005+5/1) #%(4/%0" #"./-#+.$+# %("*/10(1+l" #"($3$1l"#6//=) #$"#0&',#1/+(0 #$10 # "581(0 #6, # +.( # 4$*+$51 # /2 # +.( # 7(""(' #-$" #3$%=(0 #P:$%"*F((7AR# $10 #P%$#(//$-7$7 * .(% *9'%$+R# M/%(/7(%) # %("*/10(1+ #.$0 #1/#0(%/8$+/%, # %(4/%0 # /1 # 25'( # /7(% # .5" # '/18 # ,($%" # /2 # "(%754( # -5+. # +.(#*(+5+5/1(%9

B/1"50(%518#$''#/2#+.(#2/%(8/518#$10#51#'51(#-5+.#G)2&$%-)*+.(#(10"#/2#"/45$'#$10#4/3*$""5/1$+(#<&"+54(#-/&'0#6(#"(%7(0#6("+#52#%("*/10(1+#-5''#6(#857(1#"/3(#(b&5+$6'(#%('5(29#I.&")#+.(#$-$%0#/2#GPTT)TTT9TT#+/#%("*/10(1+ # $" # 251$145$' # $""5"+$14( # 5" # 0((3(0 # (b&5+$6'( # &10(% # +.(#45%4&3"+$14("9>#D!LIDHA#L[FGGFAE#@FADL)#FAB#\9#]DHHDH#:9#!AICAFC#E9H9#A/9#PQPaRQ)#C4+/6(%#PS)#VTTUW

G(+5+5/1(%"e#6$%(#517/4$+5/1#/2#Y+.(#51+(%("+#/2#"&6"+$1+5$'#<&"+54(Z#0/(" # 1/+ # '5(9Z # # C1', # &10(% # (;4(*+5/1$'', #3(%5+/%5/&" # 4$"(" #3$, # $#%('$;$+5/1#2%/3#$1#/+.(%-5"(#"+%518(1+#%&'(#6(#$''/-(0#Y+/#%('5(7(#$#'5+58$1+ # /2 # $1 # 51<&"+54( # 1/+ # 4/33(1"&%$+( # -5+. # +.( # 0(8%(( # /2#+./&8.+'(""1(""#51#1/+#4/3*',518#-5+.#+.(#*%/4(0&%(#*%("4%56(0Zq#+.(#(;5"+(14( # /2 # -.54. # *(+5+5/1(%" # 2$5'(0 # +/ # 0(3/1"+%$+(9 # >c!@@DM#

&"

Page 63: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

M!HFIFMD#LDH\FBDL)#FAB9#$10#LB!A:FB#L[FGM!A!EDMDAI#@FMFID:#79#DHF^DHIC#L9#^J@IHCA)#E9H9#A/9#PRaV_P)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

,)(*B#

• W%%#6$%&,)(*B#

I.(#&"(#/2#&1'$-2&'#3($1"#51#+.(#4/&%"(#/2#$#"+%5=(#%(10(%"#"&4.#"+%5=(#5''(8$'9#I.(%(2/%()#*&%"&$1+#+/#+.(#*%5145*'(#/2#4/14'&"57(1(""#/2#<&083(1+)#+.(#M$%4.#U)#PUUR#"+%5=(#-$"#'02(*.)#&(*5''(8$'+*I.(#25'518#/2#$#*(+5+5/1#+/#0(4'$%(#+.(#"+%5=(#5''(8$'#-$"#+.&"#&11(4(""$%,9# >N!B?^F@I#FA:JLIHFDL) FAB979#N!B?^F@I#DMG@CKDDLcCH?DHL#JAFCAXA!]@JX?MJ)E9H9#A/"9#PQP_PRXPU)#M$%4.#VT)#VTTUW

• 4*.+"+%&$.8&E23)(*$&4#-*3*+.

I.(%( # 5" # 1/ # 4/12'54+ # 6(+-((1 # +.( #_'-(0(3# $10 # +.( #=12&%')*0(45"5/1"9 # c.5'( # 6/+. # %&'518" # 517/'7( # +.( # "$3( # *$%+5(" # $10 # "$3(#5""&(") # +.(%( # 5" # $ # 05"+514+5/1 #6(+-((1 # +.( # %(3(05(" # "/&8.+ #6, # +.(#*$%+5("#51#+.("(#+-/#4$"("9##F1#+.(#_'-(0(3#0(45"5/1)#5+#-$"#kBLB#-.54.#25'(0#$#*(+5+5/1#+/#0(4'$%(#+.(#5''(8$'5+,#/2#+.(#PV#!&8&"+#PUUQ#"+%5=(#6,#+.(#&15/19#I.(#4/1"(b&(14(#/2#+.(#0(4'$%$+5/1#/2#$1#5''(8$'#"+%5=(# 5"#+(%351$+5/1#2%/3#(3*'/,3(1+)#-.54.#+.(#@$6/%#!%65+(%#050#"/#%&'(#51#"$50#4$"(9##[/-(7(%)#1/+#$''#&15/1#3(36(%"#-(%(#+(%351$+(09##F1#2$4+)#/1', #$#2(-#&15/1#/2254(%"#-(%(#7$'50', #05"35""(0# 51#$44/%0$14(#-5+.#!%+54'(#V_`#/2#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(9# #B/%/''$%5',)#+.(#/+.(%#&15/1#3(36(%"#-./#.$0#3(%(',#*$%+545*$+(0#51#+.(#"+%5=(#6&+#.$0#1/+#4/335++(0#$1,#5''(8$'#$4+"#-(%(#1/+#05"35""(0#2%/3#(3*'/,3(1+9# #[(14()#+.(#A@HB#(%%(0#51#0(4'$%518#+.(#(3*'/,3(1+#"+$+&"#/2#$''#(3*'/,(("#$"#.$7518#6((1#'/"+#/%#2/%2(5+(0#6,#75%+&(#/2#+.(#_'-(0(3*0(45"5/19#

C1#+.(#/+.(%#.$10)#+.(#=12&%')#0(45"5/1#517/'7(0#+.(#&12$5%#'$6/%#*%$4+54("#$''(8(0#6,#+.(#&15/1#-5+.#*$%+54&'$%5+,9# #F1#"$50#4$"()#@$6/%#!%65+(% #@&"+%5$ #"50(0#-5+.#+.(#J15/1#$10#2/&10#kBLB#8&5'+, #/2 #"&4.#*%$4+54("9# #!"#$#4/1"(b&(14()#+.(# #$22(4+(0#(3*'/,(("#-(%(#8%$1+(0#6$4=-$8(" # $10 # "(*$%$+5/1 # *$,9 # I.( # 8%$1+ # /2 # 6$4=-$8(" # $10#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#./-(7(%#-$"#1/+#*%(35"(0#/1#+.(#0(4'$%$+5/1#/2#+.(#5''(8$'5+,#/2#+.(#"+%5=(#6&+#/1#+.(#2510518#+.$+#+.("(#$22(4+(0#(3*'/,(("#-(%(#4/1"+%&4+57(',#05"35""(0#2%/3#-/%=)#$"#(750(14(0#6,#+.(#'$,/22"#(22(4+(0#6,#+.(#4/3*$1,9##!"#(;*'$51(0#51#+.(#=12&%')#0(45"5/1r#

B/1"50(%518 # +.$+ # +.( # +(3*/%$%, # '$,X/22 # /2 # '5"+(0#(3*'/,(("#(22(4+(0#6,#+.(#%("*/10(1+"#/1#P_#!&8&"+#PUUQ#-$" # -5+./&+ # 0/4&3(1+$%, # (750(14( # +/ # 0(+(%351( # 5+"#7$'505+,)#5+#5"#/&%#4/1"50(%(0#75(-#$10#-(#"/#./'0#+.$+#"$50#(3*'/,(("#-(%(#4/1"+%&4+57(', #05"35""(0#-5+./&+ # <&"+ #/%#

&#

Page 64: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

$&+./%5i(0 # 4$&"( # $10 # /6"(%7$14( # /2 # 0&( # *%/4(""9 # I.5"#/*515/1 # 2510" # "&**/%+ # 2%/3 # +.( # .$%0 # $10 # 4/'0 # 2$4+ # /2#$6"(14(#/2#*%5/%#1/+54()#%(*/%+#-5+.#+.(#%(85/1$'#/2254(#/2#+.( # :(*$%+3(1+ # /2 # @$6/% # $10 # D3*'/,3(1+ # .$7518#<&%5"054+5/1 #/7(% # +.( #$%($ #$10# +.(,# %(3$51 #&10(% # '$,X/22#"+$+&"#/2#(3*'/,3(1+9# #F1#4/14'&"5/1)#+.(,#$%(#(1+5+'(0#+/#6$4=-$8("#$10#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#51#'5(&#/2#%(51"+$+(3(1+#$"#*%$,(09

B'($%',)#+.(%(#$%(#+-/#"(*$%$+(#0(45"5/1"#5""&(0#6,#+-/#0522(%(1+#'$6/%#$%65+(%"#517/'7518#+.(#"$3(#*$%+5("#$10#51+(%("+"9# #B/1"50(%518#+.$+#+.(#%(3(05("#"/&8.+#6,#+.(#*$%+5("#51#($4.#4$"(#0522(%)#+.("(#+-/#%&'518" #3$,#4/X(;5"+9 # >@C@FI!#!9 #@CGDO) #DI9 #$'9) #7"9 # # #kJDOCA#BFIK#LGCHIL#B@J^)#FAB9)E9H9#A/9##P_`TSV)#N$1&$%,#PU)#VTTUW

,2;3)*)2)*+.&+/&C$()*#3

]51$'',)#$"#+/#+.(#*%$,(%#/2#+.(#4/&1"('#/2#M%9#E&3$%$18#+/#$''/-#+.(#'$++(%#+/#6(#"&6"+5+&+(0#6,#.5"#-52()#$10#6,#.5"#2/%3(%#4/X(3*'/,(("#-./3#.(#.$0#$''(8(0', # %(*%("(1+(0#6(2/%( # +.(#H(85/1$' #!%65+%$+5/1#^%$14. # /2 # +.( # A@HB) # -( # 8%$1+ # +.( # "$3( # 51"/2$% # $" # +.( # -52( # 5"#4/14(%1(0)#".(#6(518#.5"#.(5%)#6&+#1/+#$"#+/#+.(#/+.(%#4/X(3*'/,(("9#c(#4$11/+#$''/-#*(+5+5/1(%#E&3$%$18e"#4/X(3*'/,(("#+/#+$=(#.5"#*'$4(#6(4$&"()#52#-(#0/)#-(#-/&'0#6(#$''/-518#+.(3#+/#6(4/3(#*$%+5("#+/#+.(#51"+$1+#*(+5+5/1#-.(1#+.(,#$%(#1/+9##F+#-/&'0#.$7(#6((1#0522(%(1+#52#+.(,#*%("(1+(0#(750(14(#"./-518#+.$+#+.(,#.$0#$&+./%5i(0#M%9#E&3$%$18#+/#25'(#+.(#*(+5+5/1#/1#+.(5%#6(.$'2#6(2/%(#+.5"#B/&%+#$10#(7(1#6(2/%(#+.(#B/&%+ # /2 # !**($'"9 # # I.5") # +.(, # .$0 # 1/+ # 0/1(9 # # # #>ACHI[D!LIDHA#BC@@DED # ID!B[DHL # !A: # DMG@CKDDL # !LLCBF!IFCA # 7"9#ACHI[D!LIDHA#BC@@DED)#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9#PaVUVS)#N$1&$%,#PU)#VTTUW

,23"#.3*+.

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aU_RQ)#!*%5'#V`)#VTTUW

&$

Page 65: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

M#$-0#(3

• I:"%+7:#.)&,)$)23&

I.(#4/33/1#*%$4+54(# 5" # 2/% # +.(#(3*'/,(% #$10# +.( # +($4.(% # +/#(1+(%#51+/#$#4/1+%$4+)#(22(4+57(#2/%#/1(#"4.//'#,($%9##!+#+.(#(10#/2#+.(#"4.//'#,($%)#+.(#(3*'/,(%#.$"#+.(#/*+5/1#1/+#+/#%(1(-#+.(#4/1+%$4+)#*$%+54&'$%',#4/1"50(%518#+.(#+($4.(%e"#*(%2/%3$14(9# #F2#+.(#4/1+%$4+#5"#1/+#%(1(-(0)#+.(#(3*'/,3(1+#%('$+5/1".5*#+(%351$+("9##F2#+.(#4/1+%$4+#5" # %(1(-(0) # &"&$'', # 2/% # $1/+.(% # "4.//' # ,($%) # +.( # *%/6$+5/1$%,#(3*'/,3(1+#4/1+51&("9# #!8$51)#$+#+.(#(10#/2#+.$+#*(%5/0)#+.(#*$%+5("#3$,#/*+#+/#%(1(-#/%#1/+#+/#%(1(-#+.(#4/1+%$4+9##F2#%(1(-(0)#+.5"#"(4/10#%(1(-$'#/2#+.(#4/1+%$4+#2/%#$1/+.(%#"4.//'#,($%#-/&'0#+.(1#6(#+.(#'$"+#,($% # q # "514( # 5+ # -/&'0 # 6( # +.( # +.5%0 # "4.//' # ,($% # q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e # @D!HAFAE # BDAIDH # $10 #MHL9 # \FC@DI! # I9 # B!HFhC #79#!:D@!F:!##M!A!@C)#E9H9#A/9#PQRRSa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTU#W

• C(+;$)*+.$(7&C#(*+8&/+(&M#$-0#(3

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e # @D!HAFAE # BDAIDH # $10 #MHL9 # \FC@DI! # I9 # B!HFhC #79#!:D@!F:!#9#M!A!@C)#E9H9#A/9#PQRRSa)#](6%&$%,#PS)#VTTU#W

M#(:*.$)*+.&+/&I:"%+7:#.)

&%

Page 66: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

H23)&'$23#3

• K#6%#-)&+/&42)7_!;$.8+.:#.)

[(14()#-(#2510#5+#.$%0#+/#6('5(7(#+.$+#.(#-5''#<&"+#$6$10/1#.5"#</6#$2+(%#*(+5+5/1(%"#8$7(#.53#$#4.$14(#+/#4/1+51&(#-/%=518#2/%#+.(39##c(#&*./'0#+.(#2/''/-518#2510518"#/2#+.(#B/&%+#/2#!**($'"#+.$+#%("*/10(1+#050#1/+#$6$10/1#.5"#</6r###

F1 # +.( #4$"( #$+ #6$%) # +.( #4.$%8(#/2 #$6$10/13(1+ # 5"#6('5(0 # 6, # +.( # 2/''/-518 # 45%4&3"+$14("r #H'%2&A *+.( # .58.#53*%/6$65'5+, # /2 # *%57$+( # %("*/10(1+ # +/ # 51+(1+5/1$'',#$6$10/1#.5"#-/%=#4/1"50(%518#+.$+#.(#.$0#$'%($0,#"(%7(0#$#*(1$'+,#/2#"&"*(1"5/1#2/%#.5"#512%$4+5/1"#$10#75/'$+5/1"#$"#-(''#$"#+.(#*(+5+5/1(%e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m\F) # ^//= # \) # H&'(" # $10 # %(8&'$+5/1"#53*'(3(1+518#+.(#@$6/%#B/0(#*%/750("#+.$+#$1,#(3*'/,(%#-./#"((="#+/#05"35""#$#-/%=(%#".$''#2&%15".#.53#$#-%5++(1#1/+54( #"+$+518# +.( #*$%+54&'$% #$4+ #/% #/35""5/1 #4/1"+5+&+518#+.(#8%/&10#2/%#.5"#05"35""$'9# #F1#4$"("#/2#$6$10/13(1+#/2#-/%=)#+.(#1/+54(#".$''#6(#"(%7(0#$+#+.(#-/%=(%e"#'$"+#=1/-1#$00%(""#>B#)6)&*;2+*<)&'(-)3*=)4(%*>$3)&'(-2*?(//'22'(-A*SS` # LBH! # Qa) # RP # fVTTTgW9 # # ]/% # +.5" # %($"/1) # c( # $%(#4/1"+%$51(0 # +/ # 857( # 4%(0(14( # +/ # *%57$+( # %("*/10(1+e"#$""(%+5/1#+.$+#.(#$++(3*+(0#+/#%(*/%+#6$4=#+/#-/%=#6&+#.(#-$"#<&"+#$"=(0#+/#'($7(#$"#.(#-$"#4/1"50(%(0#+(%351$+(09#E-7*3)2&3"A **%57$+(#%("*/10(1+e"#25'518#/2#$#4$"(#2/%#5''(8$'#05"35""$'#-5+.#+.(#'$6/%#$%65+(%#1(8$+("#$6$10/13(1+9##!"#.('0#6,#+.(#L&*%(3(#B/&%+)#$#4.$%8(#/2#$6$10/13(1+#5"#+/+$'',#514/1"5"+(1+#-5+.#+.(#533(05$+(#25'518#/2#$#4/3*'$51+#2/%#5''(8$'#05"35""$')#3/%(#"/#-.(1#5+#514'&0("#$#*%$,(%#2/%#%(51"+$+(3(1+#>F3(4$*8$3$#(/A*B-#+*;2*H3(%$-7(KH3(%$2)#SUT#LBH! # VTP) # VTTVf"54gXVTS # fVTTVgW9 # >^B # B!^@D # M!LIDH#LKLIDM#!A:pCH#D\D@KA#BFADALD##7"9#M!HBF!@#^!@JKCI)#E9H9#A/9#PQV_QT)N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

######

&&

Page 67: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

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b&$%(#-5+.#+.(#2$4+#+.$+#$#-((=#$2+(%#%("*/10(1+e"#$''(8(0#05"35""$')##.(#25'(0#$#4/3*'$51+#-5+.#+.(#A@HB9#>[!H^CH\FDc#HDLI!JH!AI#79#HDKA!@:C#@!^HC)#E9H9#A/9###P_RVQS)#!*%5'#ST)#VTTUW#

I/ # 4/1"+5+&+( # $6$10/13(1+) # +.(%( # 3&"+ # 6( # 4'($% # *%//2 # /2#0('56(%$+( # $10 # &1<&"+525(0 # 51+(1+ # +/ # "(7(% # +.( # (3*'/,(%X(3*'/,((#%('$+5/1".5*9#B'($%',)#+.(#/*(%$+57(#$4+#5"#"+5''#+.(#(3*'/,((e"#&'+53$+(#$4+#/2#*&++518#$1#(10#+/#.5"#(3*'/,3(1+9#[/-(7(%)#$1#(3*'/,((#-./#+$=("#"+(*"#+/#*%/+("+#.(%#'$,/22#4$11/+#6(#"$50#+/#.$7(#$6$10/1(0#.(%#-/%=#6(4$&"(#$#4.$%8(#/2#$6$10/13(1+#5"#+/+$'',#514/1"5"+(1+#-5+.#+.(#533(05$+(#25'518#/2#$#4/3*'$51+#2/%#5''(8$'#05"35""$')#3/%(#"/#-.(1#5+#514'&0(" #$ #*%$,(% # 2/% # %(51"+$+(3(1+9 #c.(1 #D'(/1/% # 25'(0 # +.( # 5''(8$'#05"35""$' # 4/3*'$51+) # 5+ # +/+$'', # 1(8$+(0 # *(+5+5/1(%e" # +.(/%, # /2#$6$10/13(1+9 # >LCJI[#:!\!C#:D\D@CGMDAI#BCMG!AK) # FAB9 # >ACc#LC:!BC#!EHFBJ@IJH!@#BCHGCH!IFCAW#!A:pCH#M!@CAD#G!BkJF!C#!A:#\FBICH#!9#BCALJANF)#79#LDHEFC#@9#E!MC)#(+9#$'9)#E9H9#A/9#PQPRP`)#M$,#R)#VTTUW

F1#*(+5+5/1(%"e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`UU)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW#

&'

Page 68: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

]&%+.(%3/%() # +.( # B/&%+ # $8%((" # -5+. # %("*/10(1+" # -.(1 # +.(,#$%8&(0#51#+.(5%#*(+5+5/1#25'(0#-5+.#+.(#B!#+.$+#52#$1#(3*'/,((l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l#+.(/%,#+.$+#!8&5'$%#$6$10/1(0 # .5" # </69# >^!HCA #HDGJ^@FB # I[D!IHFB!@ # \9 # ACHMFI! # G9#GDH!@I!#(+#$')#E9H9#A/9#PQTaVa)#C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

• N(+33&K#6%*6#.-#

!1#(3*'/,(%#4$11/+#'(8$'',#6(#4/3*(''(0#+/#4/1+51&(#-5+.#+.(#(3*'/,3(1+#/2#$#*(%"/1#$035++(0',#8&5'+,#/2#8%/""#1(8'58(14(#51#+.(#*(%2/%3$14(#/2#.5"#0&+5("9#I.5"#./'0"#+%&(#"*(45$'',#52#+.(#(3*'/,((e"#4/1+51&(0#+(1&%(#5"#*$+(1+',#515354$'#+/#+.(#(3*'/,(%e"#51+(%("+9#c.$+#.$**(1(0 # -$" # 1/+ # $ # "53*'( # 4$"( # /2 # /7(%"58.+ # $10 # 4/&'0 # 1/+ # 6(#$++%56&+(0#+/#$#"53*'(#'$*"(#/2#<&083(1+9#A/#$3/&1+#/2#8//0#51+(1+)#/%#*%(75/&"#4/1"45(1+5/&"#*(%2/%3$14(#/2#0&+,)#4$1#$""&$8(#+.(#0$3$8(#M$+(/#4$&"(0#@^B#-.(1#.(#2$5'(0#+/#(;(%45"(#+.(#%(b&5"5+(#0(8%((#/2#05'58(14(#%(b&5%(0#/2 #.53#&10(%#+.(#45%4&3"+$14("9># @^B#DmGHDLL#q#MDIHC#M!AF@!)#FAB9#$10#@CHDAOC#!9#AFhC#79#N!MDL#M!IDC)#E9H9#A/9#P_RVPa)#N&1(#U)#VTTUW

I/ #-$%%$1+ # %(3/7$' # 2%/3 # "(%754() # +.( # 1(8'58(14( # "./&'0 # 1/+#3(%(',#6(#8%/""#6&+#$'"/#.$65+&$'9##E%/""#1(8'58(14(#53*'5("#$#-$1+#/%#$6"(14(#/2#/%#2$5'&%(#+/#(;(%45"(#(7(1#"'58.+#4$%(#/%#05'58(14()#/%#+.(#(1+5%( # $6"(14( # /2 # 4$%(9 # # F+ # (7514(" # $ # +./&8.+'("" # 05"%(8$%0 # /2#4/1"(b&(14(" #-5+./&+ #(;(%+518 #$1, #(22/%+ # +/ #$7/50 # +.(39 # #[$65+&$'#1(8'(4+#53*'5("#%(*($+(0#2$5'&%(#+/#*(%2/%3#/1(l"#0&+5("#2/%#$#*(%5/0#/2#+53()#0(*(10518#&*/1#+.(#45%4&3"+$14("9#I.(#"518'(#/%#5"/'$+(0#$4+#/2#1(8'58(14(#0/("#1/+#4/1"+5+&+(#$# <&"+#4$&"(#2/%#+.(#05"35""$'#/2#+.(#(3*'/,((9#>!^D@!H:C#G9#!^D@#79#G[F@Dm#MFAFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQRUQ_)#N&',#SP)#VTTUW

• ,#(*+23&T*3-+.82-)

GA^#3$,#%58.+2&'',#+(%351$+(#M$%$'5+e"#"(%754("#2/%#$#<&"+#4$&"()#514'&0518#"(%5/&"#35"4/10&4+9##L(%5/&"#35"4/10&4+#5"#53*%/*(%#4/10&4+)#$ # +%$1"8%(""5/1 # /2 # "/3( #("+$6'5".(0 # $10 # 0(2515+( # %&'( # /2 # $4+5/1) # $#2/%6500(1#$4+)#/%#$#0(%('54+5/1#/2#0&+,9# #[$7518#6((1#05"35""(0#2/%#$#<&"+#4$&"()#M$%$'5+#5"#1/+#(1+5+'(0#+/#.(%#%(+5%(3(1+#6(1(25+"9#>DLIDH#^9#

&(

Page 69: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

M!H!@FI#79 #G[F@FGGFAD#A!IFCA!@#^!A?)#E9H9#A/9#P_SQRR)#!&8&"+#V`)#VTTUW

^,#"'((*518#/1#+.(#</6#$10#'($7518#.5"#-/%=#$%($#-5+./&+#*%5/%#$&+./%5i$+5/1) # I/3$0$ # 050 # 1/+ # 3(%(', # 05"%(8$%0 # 4/3*$1, # %&'("9#I/3$0$)#51#(22(4+)#5""&(0#$1#/*(1#5175+$+5/1#2/%#/+.(%"#+/#75/'$+(#+./"(#"$3(#4/3*$1,#%&'("9##F10((0)#4/1"50(%518#+.(#*%("(14(#/2#+%$51(("#51#+.( # 6&5'0518 # $10 # I/3$0$e" # $4+") # I/3$0$ # 2$5'(0 # +/ # '57( # &* # +/ # .5"#4/3*$1,e" # %($"/1$6'( # (;*(4+$+5/1"9 # # I/3$0$e" # /22(1"(" # 4$11/+ # 6(#(;4&"(0#&*/1#$#*'($#/2#6(518#$#Y25%"+#/22(1"()Z#/%#.$7(#1/+#%("&'+(0#51#*%(<&054(#+/#+.(#4/3*$1,#51#$1,#-$,9#A/#(3*'/,(%#3$,#%$+5/1$'',#6(#(;*(4+(0#+/#4/1+51&(#51#(3*'/,3(1+#$#*(%"/1#-./"(#'$4=#/2#3/%$'")#%("*(4+#$10#'/,$'+,#+/#.5"#(3*'/,(%)#%(8$%0#2/%#.5"#(3*'/,(%e"#%&'(")#$10#$**%(45$+5/1#/2#+.(#05815+,#$10#%("*/1"565'5+,#/2#.5"#/2254()#.$"#"/#*'$51', # $10 # 4/3*'(+(', # 6((1 #6$%(09 #>D:J!H:C #M9 # ICM!:!) #LH9 # 79#H]M # BCHGCH!IFCAX^!?DHK # ]@CJH # :F\FLFCA # $10 # NCLD # M!HF!#BCABDGBFCA#FFF)#E9H9#A/9#P_SVQT)#L(*+(36(%#PP)#VTTUW

M/%(/7(%)#+.(#*(4&'5$%#1$+&%(#/2#D"*$0(%/e"#*/"5+5/1#$88%$7$+("#.(%#35"4/10&4+9#M5"4/10&4+#.$"#6((1#0(251(0#$"# 53*%/*(%#/%#-%/18#4/10&4+j # +.( # +%$1"8%(""5/1 # /2 # "/3( # ("+$6'5".(0 # /% # 0(2515+( # %&'( # /2#$4+5/1)#$#2/%6500(1#$4+)#$#0(%('54+5/1#/2#0&+,)#-5''2&'#51#4.$%$4+(%)#$10#53*'5(" # -%/182&' # 51+(1+ # $10 # 1/+ # 3(%( # (%%/% # 51 # <&083(1+9 # I.(#35"4/10&4+)#+/#6(#"(%5/&")#3&"+#6(#/2#"&4.#$#8%$7(#4.$%$4+(%#$10#1/+#3(%(',#+%575$'#/%#&153*/%+$1+9#I/#4/1"+5+&+(#<&"+#4$&"(#2/%#+(%351$+5/1)#5+#3&"+#6(#51#4/11(4+5/1#-5+.#+.(#(3*'/,((e"#-/%=9#c5+.#+.(#0(8%((#/2#+%&"+#(;*(4+(0#/2#D"*$0(%/)#"&4.#512%$4+5/1#4$1#.$%0',#6(#4'$""525(0#$"#/1(#+.$+#5"#+%575$'#/%#&153*/%+$1+9#[(%#2$5'&%(#+/#*%/3*+',#%(*/%+#+.(#51450(1+#%(2'(4+"#$#4$7$'5(%#%(8$%0#2/%#+.(#%("*/1"565'5+,#%(b&5%(0#/2#.(%#51#+.(#05"4.$%8(#/2#+.(#0&+5("#/2#.(%#*/"5+5/19 # #>D!ILXBDIDH!#]CC:#LDH\FBDL#CJI@DI#$10p/%#LDH!]FA#H!MFHDO#79#MKHA!#^9#@DIH!A#$10#M!HK#EH!BD#DLG!:DHC)#E9H9#A/9#PQUaTQ)###C4+/6(%#V)#VTTUW

!1 # (3*'/,(( #-./ # 2$5'" # +/ # $44/&1+ # 2/% # $10 # 0('57(% # +.( # 2&10"#(1+%&"+(0 # +/ # .53 # 5" # '5$6'( # 2/% # 35"$**%/*%5$+518 # +.( # "$3( # $10 # 5"#4/1"(b&(1+',#8&5'+,#/2#"(%5/&"#35"4/10&4+9#G(+5+5/1(%#+.(%(2/%(#7$'50',#05"35""(0#%("*/10(1+9>#LJGDH@FADL#IH!ALGCHI!IFCA#BCMG!AK)#FAB9#79#D:J!H:C#GFADH!#E9H9#A/9#PRRQ`V)#C4+/6(%#PS)#VTTUW

! ,*:"%#&T*3-+.82-)

^$"(0#/1#+.(#2/%(8/518)#-(#4/1"50(%#%("*/10(1+e"#/22(1"(#+/#6(#$ # "53*'( # 35"4/10&4+ # -.54. # 0/(" # 1/+ # 3(%5+ # +(%351$+5/1 # /2 # .5"#(3*'/,3(1+9 # I.( # *(1$'+, # /2 # 05"35""$' # 2%/3 # "(%754( # 5" # 1/+#4/33(1"&%$+( # +/ # %("*/10(1+e" #/22(1"(9 # #!'+./&8. #*(+5+5/1(%) #$" #$1#

&)

Page 70: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

(3*'/,(%)#.$"#+.(#%58.+#+/#05"45*'51(#5+"#(%%518#(3*'/,((")#(;(%45"(#/2#"&4.#%58.+#"./&'0#6(#+(3*(%(0#-5+.#4/3*$""5/1#$10#&10(%"+$105189#I.(#3$815+&0(#/2#+.(#512%$4+5/1#4/335++(0#6,#$1#(3*'/,((#3&"+#6(#-(58.(0 # $10 # (b&$+(0 # -5+. # +.( # *(1$'+, # *%("4%56(0 # $10 # 3&"+ # 6(#4/33(1"&%$+( # +.(%(+/) # 51 # 75(- # /2 # +.( # 8%$75+, # /2 # +.( # *(1$'+, # /2#05"35""$'#/%#+(%351$+5/1#2%/3#+.(#"(%754(9#I.(#(3*'/,(%#"./&'0#6($%#51#3510 # +.$+ # 51 # +(%351$+5/1 # 4$"(") #-.$+ # 5" #$+ # "+$=( # 5" #1/+ # "53*', # +.(#(3*'/,((e"#</6#/%#*/"5+5/1#6&+#.5"#7(%,#'57('5.//09&FCRWEWCCWKI&EVKN&4W,M!K'I&MIEICRVKI&'VTC!Kf&DJ & WKV'IK'WV&9J &9I19!KVO&H1JO&NJ1J&K+J&>dg>hhO#A/7(36(%#VQ)#VTTUW

• E+33&+/&M(23)&$.8&'+./*8#.-#

G(+5+5/1(%)#51#.5"#G/"5+5/1#G$*(%#25'(0#6(2/%(#+.(#@!#$10#51#.5"#!),(&*-)*!'-1/0))-,*!)3)"2)"A# $7(%%(0#+.$+#"/3(+53(#51#!&8&"+#VTT`)#!'50/ # 512/%3(0 # .53 # /2 # +.( # 5''(8$' # $4+575+5(" # 51 # +.( # 4/3*$1,#*%(35"("9##^&+#+.5"#2$4+#-$"#1/+#%(2'(4+(0#51#.5"#G$%+5$'#!&05+#H(*/%+j#51"+($0) #*(+5+5/1(% #3$0(# 5+ #$**($% # +.(%(51 # +.$+ # 5+ #-$" #&*/1# +.(#515+5$+57(#/2#@(</"#+.$+#.(#05"4/7(%(0#+.(#5''(8$'#$4+575+5("#/1',#/1#C4+/6(%#VR)#VTT`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q#$ # 4'($% # 6%($4. # /2 # +.( # +%&"+ # $10 # 4/1250(14( # +.( # 4/3*$1, # .$0#%(*/"(0# 51#.53#$"#/1(#/2 # 5+" #!&05+/%"9> #HCMDC#A9#\DAIJH!)#7"9#BCJHI#C] #!GGD!@L) #A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#EDAJFAC#FBD#BC9)#FAB9)#$10#[DBICH#EDAJFAC)#E9H9#A/9#PRVaQT)#N$1&$%,#VQ)#VTTU

F10((0) # 6, # /6+$51518 # $1 # $'+(%(0 # */'54( # %(*/%+ # $10 # 3(054$'#4(%+5254$+()#*(+5+5/1(%"#0('56(%$+(',#$++(3*+(0#+/#4/7(%#&*#+.(#2$4+#+.$+#L$'("#-$"#&10(%#+.(#512'&(14(#/2#'5b&/%#$+#+.(#+53(#+.(#$4450(1+#+//=#*'$4(9 # # F1 # "/ # 0/518) # +.(, # 4/335++(0 # $4+" # 515354$' # +/ # %("*/10(1+e"#51+(%("+"9# #I.(,#+.&"#4/335++(0#$#-/%=X%('$+(0#-5''2&''#6%($4.#/2#+.(#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(#%(*/"(0#51#+.(39#>DHFB#:D@!#BHJO#$10#H!J@#M9#@!BJ!I!#79#BCB!XBC@!#^CII@DHL#G[F@L9#FAB9)#E9H9#A/9####PRT`_a)#N&',#SP)#VTTUW

I.(#$3/&1+#35"$**%/*%5$+(0#6,#*(+5+5/1(%#M$1'54'54#5"#5%%('(7$1+9#M/%(#+.$1#+.(#%("&'+518#3$+(%5$'#0$3$8(#/%#*%(<&054()#5+#5"#*(+5+5/1(%#M$1'54'54e"#7(%,#$4+#/2#35"$**%/*%5$+5/1#+.$+#5"#/22(1"57(#+/#%("*/10(1+#GD@BC#F9# #F2#+$;("#$%(#+.(#'52(6'//0#/2#+.(#"+$+()#+.(1)#6,#$1$'/8,)#+.(#

'*

Page 71: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

*$,3(1+#4/''(4+5/1#5"#+.(#'52(6'//0#/2#+.(#4//*(%$+57(9# #I.(#4/''(4+5/1#*%/750("#%("*/10(1+#GD@BC#F#-5+.#+.(#251$145$'#%("/&%4("#+/#4/1+51&(#5+"#/*(%$+5/1"9# #H("*/10(1+#GD@BC#F#4$11/+#$22/%0#+/#4/1+51&(#51#5+"#(3*'/,#05"./1("+#65''#4/''(4+/%"9

^,#.5"#/-1#$035""5/1)#*(+5+5/1(%#M$1'54'54#4/335++(0#$#6%($4.#/2#+.(#+%&"+#%(*/"(0#51#.53#6,#.5"#(3*'/,(%)#%("*/10(1+#GD@BC#F9# #I.5"#4/1"+5+&+("#7$'50#4$&"(#2/%#.5"#05"35""$'#2%/3#"(%754(9#>B[CA!#DLI!BFC#$10 #@DCGC@:C#M!A@FB@FB #79 #G!MG!AE!# F #D@DBIHFB #BCCGDH!IF\D)#FAB9)#$10#@C@F!AC#D9#!@@!L)#E9H9#A/9#PRSPU_)#!&8&"+#PU)#VTTUW

c( #$%( # 1/+ # &135102&' # /2 # +.( # (3*'/,(%e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e"#$%65+%$%51("")#-.53")#4$*%54("#/%#"&"*545/1j#/+.(%-5"()#+.(#(3*'/,((#-/&'0#(+(%1$'',#%(3$51#$+#+.(#3(%4,#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(%9##F+#"./&'0#6(#8(1&51(#$10#1/+#"53&'$+(0j#1/%#"./&'0#5+#$**($%#$"#$#3(%(#$2+(%+./&8.+#+/#<&"+52,#$1#($%'5(%#$4+5/1#+$=(1# 51#6$0#2$5+.#/%#$"#$#"&6+(%2&8(#2/%#4$&"("#+.$+#$%(# 53*%/*(%)#5''(8$'#/%#&1<&"+525(09##F+#.$"#1(7(%#6((1#51+(10(0#+/#$22/%0#$1#/44$"5/1#2/%#$6&"(#6(4$&"(#/2#5+"#"&6<(4+57(#1$+&%(9##I.(%(#3&"+)#+.(%(2/%()#6(#$1#$4+&$'#6%($4.#/2#0&+,#4/335++(0#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(()#-.54.#3&"+#6(#("+$6'5".(0#6,#"&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14(9# #F1#+.5"#4$"()#L@MB#&++(%',#2$5'(0#+/#("+$6'5".#+.(#%(b&5%(3(1+"#*%("4%56(0#6,#'$-#$10#<&%5"*%&0(14(#2/%#$#7$'50#05"35""$'#/1#+.(#8%/&10#/2#6%($4.#/2#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(9##>LI9#@J?DeL # MD:FB!@ # BDAIDH) # FABCHGCH!ID: # 79 # NDAAF]DH # @KAAD # B9#]!:HFEC)#E9H9#A/9#PRaUSS)###A/7(36(%#Va)#VTTUW

\(%5',) # +.(#$4+5/1"#/2#I5%$i/1$#%(2'(4+(0#$1#/60&%$+(#4.$%$4+(%#+.$+# 5" #$%%/8$1+) #&14/3*%/35"518) #$10#./"+5'(9 # #^,# 533(05$+(',#$10#&1%($"/1$6',#$0/*+518#$1#$07(%"(#"+$14(#$8$51"+#GDI)#".(#"/&8.+#+/#53*/"(#.(%#-5''#/1#+.(#4/3*$1,#$10#*'$4(0#.(%#/-1#51+(%("+"#$6/7(#+./"(#/2#.(%#(3*'/,(%9##[(%#3/+57(#2/%#.(%#$4+5/1"#-$"#%(10(%(0#(7(1#3/%( # b&("+5/1$6'( # 6, # .(% # (;/%65+$1+ # $10 # $%65+%$%, # 0(3$10 # 2/%#GV)TTT)TTT9TT#*$,$6'(#-5+.51# 257(#0$,"# 2%/3#0(3$109# #[(%#$++5+&0(#+/-$%0"#.(%#(3*'/,(%#-$"#4'($%',#514/1"5"+(1+#-5+.#.(%#*/"5+5/1#/2#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(9##[(%#*//%#4.$%$4+(%#6(4$3(#(7(1#3/%(#(750(1+#-.(1#".(#%($0#-.$+#-$"#"&**/"(0#+/#6(#$#4/1250(1+5$'# '(++(%#/2#+.(#'(8$'#4/&1"('#/2#GDI#+/#GDI#/2254(%"p05%(4+/%"#(;*%(""518#.5"#'(8$'#/*515/1#/1#I5%$i/1$e"#$03515"+%$+57(#4$"(9# #GDI#-$") #+.(%(2/%() # 2&'',# <&"+525(0# 51#+(%351$+518#I5%$i/1$e"#(3*'/,3(1+#2/%# '/""#/2 #+%&"+ #$10#4/1250(14(9#

'!

Page 72: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

>M!9#cDAD@FI!#L9 #IFH!OCA!)#7"9 #G[F@FGGFAD#D:L#IDB[ACX#LDH\FBD#FAB9 # >GDI # FAB9W # !A:pCH # ?DA # ?J^CI!) #M!MCHJ #CAC # $10 # NJAFB[F#[FHCLD)#E9H9#A/9#P_UQPV)#N$1&$%,#VT)#VTTUW

I/#%(4$*5+&'$+()#+.(#%58.+#/2#$1#(3*'/,(%#+/#05"35""#$1#(3*'/,((#/1 #$44/&1+ # /2 # '/"" # /2 # +%&"+ # $10 # 4/1250(14( #3&"+ # 1/+ # 6( #(;(%45"(0#-.53"54$'',9##I/#4/&1+(1$14(#$1#$%65+%$%,#(;(%45"(#/2#+.$+#*%(%/8$+57(#5"#+/#1(8$+(#+.(#(3*'/,((e"#4/1"+5+&+5/1$'#%58.+#+/#"(4&%5+,#/2#+(1&%(9#F1#/+.(%#-/%0")#+.(#(3*'/,(%#3&"+#4'($%',#$10#4/17514518',#*%/7(#6,#"&6"+$1+5$' # (750(14( # +.( # 2$4+" # $10 # 51450(1+" # &*/1 # -.54. # '/"" # /2#4/1250(14(#51#+.(#(3*'/,((#3$,#6(#2$5%',#3$0(#+/#%("+j#/+.(%-5"()#+.(#'$++(%e"#05"35""$'#-5''#6(#%(10(%(0#5''(8$'9###>L!A#MFEJD@#BCHGCH!IFCA#7"9 # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL # BCMMFLLFCA # !A: # cF@@F!M # @9#]HFDA:)#NH9)#E9H9#A/9#PaSURS)#M$,#V_)#VTTUW

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a`)#!*%5'#P_)#VTTUW#

B/1"50(%518#+.(#2/%(8/518)#-(#2510#+.$+#%("*/10(1+"#!*/"+/'#$10#C*&'(145$ #-(%( #05"35""(0 #6, #IFGF # 2/% #$ #7$'50 #$10 # <&"+ #4$&"(9 # # I.(#%('$+5/1".5*#/2#(3*'/,(%#$10#(3*'/,(()#"*(45$'',#-.(%(#+.(#(3*'/,((#.$"#$44(""#+/#+.(#(3*'/,(%e"#*%/*(%+,)#1(4(""$%5',#517/'7("#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(9#c.(%(#+.(#%&'("#'$50#0/-1#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(%#+/#*%/+(4+#5+"#*%/*(%+, # $%( # 75/'$+(0 #6, # +.( # 7(%, # (3*'/,(( #-./ # 5" # (1+%&"+(0 # $10#(;*(4+(0#+/ # 2/''/-#$10# 53*'(3(1+ # +.(#%&'(") # +.(#(3*'/,((#3$,#6(#7$'50', # 05"35""(0 # 2%/3 # "(%754(9 # #>IHFJMG[ # FAIDHA!IFCA!@>G[F@L9W)#FAB9]FHLI #:F\FLFCA#79 #H!MCA#@9 #!GCLIC@ #$10#^DA#M9 #CGJ@DABF!)#E9H9#A/9#P_``VS)#N&1(#P_)#VTTUW#

!" # !5%*/%+ # M$1$8(%) # %("*/10(1+ # /44&*5(" # $ # */"5+5/1 # /2 # "&4.#(;+%(3(#"(1"5+575+, # +.$+ # +.( #(;5"+(14( #/2 # "/3(#6$"5" #/% # %($"/1$6'(#8%/&10#2/%#.5"#517/'7(3(1+#51#$1,#5%%(8&'$%5+,#5"#(1/&8.#+/#0("+%/,#+.(#+%&"+ #$10 #4/1250(14( #-.54. #*(+5+5/1(% #E&'2 #!5% #.$0 # %(*/"(0 # 51 #.539#[/-(7(%)#5+#5"#"(++'(0#+.$+#2/%#6%($4.#/2#+%&"+#+/#4/1"+5+&+(#$#7$'50#4$&"(#2/%#05"35""$')#+.(#"$3(#3&"+#6(#-5''2&'9#C%051$%,#6%($4.#/2#+%&"+#-5''#1/+#

'"

Page 73: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

"&2254(9#>EJ@]#!FH)#N!LLFM#[FA:HF#!^:J@@![#$10#HDLIK#!HD\!@C##79#A!IFCA!@#@!^CH#HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#$10#HC^DHIC#N9B9#HDKDL)#E9H9#A/9#PaU_RQ)#!*%5'#V`)#VTTUW

I.(#"(4/10#%(b&5"5+(# 5" # +.$+# +.(%(#3&"+#6(#$1#$4+ #+.$+#-/&'0#<&"+52,#+.(#'/""#/2#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(9#@/""#/2#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14()#+/#6(#$#7$'50#4$&"(#2/%#05"35""$')#3&"+#6(#6$"(0#/1#$#-5''2&' #6%($4.#/2#+%&"+ # $10 # 2/&10(0 # /1 # 4'($%', # ("+$6'5".(0 # 2$4+"9 # I.( # 6$"5" # 2/% # +.(#05"35""$' # 3&"+ # 6( # 4'($%', # $10 # 4/17514518', # ("+$6'5".(0 # 6&+ # *%//2#6(,/10#%($"/1$6'( #0/&6+ # 5" #1/+ #1(4(""$%,9 # #H("*/10(1+e" #(750(14(#$8$51"+#*(+5+5/1(%#2$5'"#+/#3((+#+.5"#"+$10$%09##F+"#'/1(#-5+1("")#@&*(8$)#050 # 1/+ # "&**/%+ # .5" # $2250$75+ # $10 # +("+53/1, # 0&%518 # +.( # 4/3*$1,#517("+58$+5/1#-5+.#$1,#*5(4(#/2 #(750(14(#$+#$''9 # #A/#/+.(%#(3*'/,((#-/%=518#$+#%("*/10(1+e"#351(#"5+(#$++("+(0#+/#+.(#+%&+.#/2#$1,#/2#.5"#"+$+(3(1+"9##L+$10518#$'/1()#@&*(8$e"#$44/&1+#/2#+.(#"&6"50(14(#$%($#$1/3$',#4/&'0#.$%0',#6(#4/1"50(%(0#"&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14(9# #!10#-.5'(#+.(%(#5"#1/#4/14%(+(#"./-518#/2#$1,#5''#3/+57(#/1#+.(#*$%+#/2#@&*(8$#+/#2$'"(',#$44&"(#*(+5+5/1(%)#+.$+#@&*(8$#.53"('2#-$"#&10(%#517("+58$+5/1#-.(1#.(#53*'54$+(0#*(+5+5/1(%#51#+.(#"&6"50(14(#$%($#$1/3$',#3$=("#.5" # &14/%%/6/%$+(0 # 7(%"5/1 # "&"*(4+9# >!^D@!H:C #G9 # !^D@ # 79 # G[F@Dm#MFAFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQRUQ_)#N&',#SP)#VTTUW

! !""%*-$)*+. & +/ & )0# & 4+-)(*.# & +/ & E+33 & +/ & M(23) & $.8&

'+./*8#.-#

H(4(1+ #0(45"5/1" #/2 # +.5" #B/&%+ #.$7( #05"+518&5".(0 # +.( # +%($+3(1+ #/2#3$1$8(%5$'#(3*'/,(("#2%/3#+.$+#/2#+.(#%$1=X$10X25'(#*(%"/11(')#51"/2$%#$"#+.(#$**'54$+5/1 #/2 # +.(#0/4+%51(#/2 # '/""#/2 #+%&"+ #$10#4/1250(14(# 5"#4/14(%1(09#I.&")#-5+.#%("*(4+#+/#%$1=X$10X25'(#*(%"/11(')#'/""#/2#+%&"+#$10 # 4/1250(14() # $" # 8%/&10 # 2/% # 7$'50 # 05"35""$') # %(b&5%(" # *%//2 # /2#517/'7(3(1+ # 51 # +.( # $''(8(0 # (7(1+" # 51 # b&("+5/1) # $10 # +.$+ # 3(%(#&14/%%/6/%$+(0#$""(%+5/1"#$10#$44&"$+5/1"#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(%#-5''#1/+#6(#"&22545(1+9#^&+#$"#%(8$%0"#$#3$1$8(%5$'#(3*'/,(()#+.(#3(%(#(;5"+(14(#/2#$#6$"5"#2/%#6('5(7518#+.$+#"&4.#(3*'/,((#.$"#6%($4.(0#+.(#+%&"+#/2#.5" #(3*'/,(% #-/&'0 #"&2254(# 2/% #.5" #05"35""$'9 ##[(14()# 51 # +.(#4$"(#/2#3$1$8(%5$'#(3*'/,((")#*%//2#6(,/10#%($"/1$6'(#0/&6+#5"#1/+#%(b&5%(09#F+#5"#"&22545(1+#+.$+#+.(%(#5"#"/3(#6$"5"#2/%#+.(#(3*'/,(%e"#'/""#/2#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14()#"&4.#$"#-.(1#+.(#(3*'/,(%#.$"#%($"/1$6'(#8%/&10#+/#6('5(7(#+.$+#+.(#(3*'/,((#4/14(%1(0#5"#%("*/1"56'(#2/%#+.(#*&%*/%+(0#35"4/10&4+) #$10#+.(#1$+&%(#/2 #.5" #*$%+545*$+5/1 #+.(%(51#%(10(%"#.53#&1-/%+., # /2 # +.( # +%&"+ # $10 # 4/1250(14( # 0(3$10(0 # /2 # .5" # */"5+5/19#A/1(+.('("") # +.( # (750(14( #3&"+ # 6( # "&6"+$1+5$' # $10 #3&"+ # ("+$6'5".#4'($%',#$10#4/17514518',#+.(#2$4+"#/1#-.54.#+.(#'/""#/2#4/1250(14(#%("+"#$10 # 1/+ # /1 # +.( # (3*'/,(%e" # $%65+%$%51("") # -.53") # $10 # 4$*%54(" # /%#"&"*545/19# >IHFJMG[ # FAIDHA!IFCA!@>G[F@L9W) # FAB9]FHLI #:F\FLFCA # 79#

'#

Page 74: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

H!MCA#@9#!GCLIC@#$10#^DA#M9#CGJ@DABF!)#E9H9#A/9#P_``VS)#N&1(#P_)#VTTUW

! C+3*)*+.3&+/&M(23)

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m#MFAFAE#BCHGCH!IFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQRUQ_)#N&',#SP)#VTTUW

!2)0+(*X#8&'$23#3

• 1#)(#.-0:#.)

I.(#*%/*(%#75(-)#+.(%(2/%()#5"#+.$+#+.(#L(49#P#4%5+(%5$#b&$'52,#+.(#2$4+/%"#/2#Y"(15/%5+,#$10#1((0"#/2#+.(#4/3*$1,Z#51#L(49#a>4W9#L+$+(0#$#65+ #0522(%(1+',) #L(49#a>4W#"./&'0#6(#&10(%"+//0#51#+.(#'58.+#/2 #L(49#P#-.54.) # +/ # "+%("") # *%/750(" # "(15/%5+,) # (22545(14, # $10 # $++5+&0() # </6#=1/-'(08(#$10#*/+(1+5$')#$10#$++(10$14(#$"#$3/18#+.(#2$4+/%"#+.$+#"./&'0#8&50(#+.(#4/3*$1,#51#4.//"518#+.(#(3*'/,(("#+/#6(#'$50X/22#/%#=(*+9#!''#/+.(%#+.518"#6(518#(b&$')#$#4/3*$1,#-/&'0#1(4(""$%5',#1((0#+/#%(+$51#+./"(#-./#.$0#%(10(%(0#0(054$+(0#$10#.58.',#(22545(1+#"(%754(#$10#-./"(#=1/-'(08()#$++(10$14()#$10#*/+(1+5$'#.(-#-5+.#4/3*$1,#"+$10$%0"9 # !1, # /+.(% #3($"&%( #-/&'0 # 6( # "(1"('("" # 51 # +.( # 6&"51(""#75(-*/51+9##!44/%0518',)#+.(#3(%5+#%$+518#&"(0#6,#MMGB#6$"(0#/1#L(49#a#51#4/1<&14+5/1#-5+.#$10#$"#b&$'525(0#6,#+.(#2$4+/%"#*%/750(0#&10(%#L(49 # P # 5" # 2$5% # $10 # %($"/1$6'() # $10) # +/ # 6( # "&%() # -('' # -5+.51 # +.(#4/1+(3*'$+5/1 # /2 # +.( # *$%+5("e # B^!9 # # F1 # 2$4+) # !'2%(0/) # "./%1 # /2 # +.(#4/1+(1+5/1#+.$+#+.(#3(%5+#%$+518#5"#$8$51"+#+.(#B^!)#.$"#1/+#"./-1#$1,#$%65+%$%51("" #/1# +.( #*$%+ #/2 #MMGB# 51 # +.( #(7$'&$+5/1) #"('(4+5/1) #$10#%(+%(14.3(1+#/2#(3*'/,(("9#>!@]HD:C#!9#MDA:HCL)#NH#79##MFILJ^FL[F#MCICHL#G[F@L9#BCHGCH!IFCA#>MMGBW)#E9H9#A/9#P_UQRT)#](6%&$%,#P_)#VTTUW

#H(4/%0"#0/#1/+#"./-#$1,#4%5+(%5/1#$0/*+(0#/%#&"(0#6,#*(+5+5/1(%#51 # 05"35""518 # %("*/10(1+9 # H("*/10(1+ # -$" # +(%351$+(0 # -5+./&+#4/1"50(%518 # .(% # "(15/%5+,9 # H(+%(14.3(1+ # "4.(3( # -5+./&+ # +$=518#"(15/%5+, # 51+/ # $44/&1+ # %(10(%(0 # +.( # %(+%(14.3(1+ # 517$'509 # c.5'(#%("*/10(1+ # -$" # +.( # +.5%0 # 3/"+ # "(15/% # (3*'/,(( # $3/18 # +.( # Q#(3*'/,(("#51#*(+5+5/1(%l"#*(%"/11('#0(*$%+3(1+)#".(#-$"#%(+%(14.(0#

'$

Page 75: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

-.5'(#.(%#/+.(%#4/X(3*'/,(("#<&15/%#+.$1#.(%#-(%(#(5+.(%#%(+$51(0#51#+.(#G(%"/11('#:(*$%+3(1+#/%#-(%(#+%$1"2(%%(0#+/#/+.(%#*/"5+5/1"#51#+.(#4/3*$1,9#I.(%(#-$"#1/#"./-518#+.$+#%("*/10(1+#-$"#/22(%(0#+/#6(#+%$1"2(%%(0#+/#/+.(%#*/"5+5/1"9>DMBCH#FABCHGCH!ID:#79#M!9#@CJH:DL#:9#LFDADL)#E9H9#A/9#PaVPTP)#L(*+(36(%#R)#VTTUW

!+ # $'' # (7(1+") # (7(1 # 52 # +.( # 4/3*$%$+57( # %(*/%+ # -(%( # +/ # 6(#4/1"50(%(0)#+.(#B/&%+#5"#1/+#*(%"&$0(0#/1#+.(#1(4(""5+,#/2#%("/%+518#+/#%(+%(14.3(1+ # +/ # *%(7(1+ # /% #351535i( # $4+&$' # /% # 53351(1+ # 6&"51(""#'/""(" #/1 # +.( #*$%+ # /2 #*(+5+5/1(%9 # # ]/% # %(+%(14.3(1+ # "./&'0 #/1', #6(#%("/%+(0#+/#-.(1#/+.(%#'(""#0%$"+54#3($1"#.$7(#6((1#+%5(0#$10#2/&10#+/#6(#51$0(b&$+(9##L/#@(3"/)%&*@)0$%*B-712&%'$2A*B-#+*;+*<=>?#51"+%&4+"r

9#9#9#fDg7(1#52#6&"51(""#'/""("#-(%(#510((0#"&22545(1+',#*%/7(1)#+.(#(3*'/,(% #:23)&3)*%% &"(+D#&)0$)&(#)(#.-0:#.)&=$3&(#3+()#8&)+&+.%7&$/)#(& %#33&8($3)*-&:#$32(#3# "&4.#$"#+.( # %(0&4+5/1 # /2 # 6/+. # 3$1$8(3(1+ # $10 # %$1=X$10X25'(#6/1&"(" # $10 # "$'$%5(") # 8/518 # /1 # %(0&4(0 # +53() # 53*%/7518#3$1&2$4+&%518 # (22545(14,) # %(0&4+5/1 # /2 # 3$%=(+518 # $10#$07(%+5"518 # 4/"+") # 2$"+(% # 4/''(4+5/1 # /2 # 4&"+/3(% # $44/&1+")#%(0&4+5/1 # /2 # %$- #3$+(%5$'" # 517("+3(1+ # $10 # /+.(%") #0$D#&;##.&)(*#8&$.8&/+2.8&=$.)*.69##>D3*.$"5"#"&**'5(0W

F1#+.(#4$"(#$+#6$%)#*(+5+5/1(%#050#1/+#$00&4(#(750(14(#+/#*%/7(#+.$+ # %(+%(14.3(1+ # -$" # %("/%+(0 # +/ # 6(4$&"( # /+.(% #3($"&%(" # -(%(#&10(%+$=(1#+/#$6$+(#$4+&$'#/%#2&+&%(#6&"51(""#'/""("#6&+#+.&"#2$5'(09#>^FC#kJDLI#M!H?DIFAE#FAB9#$10p/%#NCLD#@9#BC#79#D:MJA:#HDK)#E9H9#A/9#PRPaTSOL(*+(36(%#PR)#VTTUW

• 1#Y2*(#:#.)&/+(&1#)(#.-0:#.)

]/% # $ # 7$'50 # +(%351$+5/1 # 0&( # +/ # %(+%(14.3(1+) # +.( # '$- # $'"/#%(b&5%("#+.$+#-%5++(1#1/+54("#/2#+.(#51+(10(0#%(+%(14.3(1+#6(#"(%7(0#6,#+.(#(3*'/,(%#/1#+.(#-/%=(%#$10#/1#+.(#:C@D#$+#'($"+ #/1(#3/1+.#6(2/%( # +.( # $4+&$' # 0$+(# /2 # +.( # %(+%(14.3(1+9 # # I.( # *&%*/"( # /2 # +.5"#%(b&5%(3(1+#5"#+/#857(#(3*'/,(("#+53(#+/#*%(*$%(#2/%#+.(#(7(1+&$'#'/""#/2#+.(5%#</6")#$"#-(''#$"#+/#857(#:C@D#+.(#/**/%+&15+,#+/#$"4(%+$51#+.(#7(%$45+,#/2#+.(#$''(8(0#4$&"(#/2#+(%351$+5/19# #F1#+.5"#4$"()#*(+5+5/1(%#51"5"+"#+.$+#+.(#*$,3(1+#/2#ST#0$,"#"$'$%,#+/#%("*/10(1+"#51#*'$4(#/2#1/+54( #-$" # "&22545(1+ # 4/3*'5$14( #-5+. # +.( #STX0$, # 1/+54( # %&'(9 # #c(#4$11/+ # $8%((9 # # A/+.518 # 51 # +.( # '$- # 857(" # *(+5+5/1(% # +.( # /*+5/1 # +/#"&6"+5+&+(#+.(#%(b&5%(0#*%5/%#-%5++(1#1/+54(#-5+.#*$,3(1+#/2#ST#0$,"#

'%

Page 76: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

"$'$%,9##F10((0)#$#</6#5"#3/%(#+.$1#+.(#"$'$%,#5+#4$%%5("9##G$,3(1+#/2#ST#0$," # "$'$%, # 4$11/+ # 4/3*(1"$+( # 2/% # +.( #*",4./'/854$' # (22(4+ # /% # +.(#"+583$#/2#533(05$+(',#2510518#/1(e"#"('2#'$50#/22#2%/3#-/%=9# #F+#4$11/+#6( # $ # 2&'', # (22(4+57( # "&6"+5+&+( # 2/% # +.( # ST # 0$,"e # -%5++(1 # 1/+54(#%(b&5%(3(1+#6,#'$-)#("*(45$'',#-.(1)#$"# 51#+.5"#4$"()#1/#1/+54(#-$"#857(1#+/#+.(#:C@D9##D7(1#$"#+.(#'(++(%"#/2#7/'&1+$%,#$44(*+$14(#-(%(#0$+(0#N&',#Va)#PUUR)#+.(#1/+54("#/2#+(%351$+5/1#857(1#/1#N&',#VS)#PUUR#-(%(#(22(4+57(#+.(#2/''/-518#0$,9##F1#(""(14()#%("*/10(1+"#.$0#$'%($0,#6((1#05"35""(0#6(2/%(#+.(,#"581(0#+.(#'(++(%"#/2#7/'&1+$%,#$44(*+$14(9#B'($%',)#*(+5+5/1(%#0(*%57(0#%("*/10(1+"#/2#+.(5%#%58.+#+/#"+$+&+/%,#0&(#*%/4(""9# #]/%#+.5") #-(#$225%3#+.(#$**(''$+(#4/&%+e"#$-$%0#/2 #1/351$'#0$3$8("#+/#%("*/10(1+"9##^&+)#4/1"5"+(1+#-5+.#/&%#%&'518#51#E,)4(-*;+*<)&'(-)3*=)4(%*>$3)&'(-2*?(//'22'(-)*+.(#$3/&1+#/2#1/351$'#0$3$8("#"./&'0#6(#GST)TTT9##c(#$'"/#"&"+$51#+.(#$-$%0#/2#$++/%1(,e"#2(("#$"#5+#5"#"$14+5/1(0#6,#'$-9#>MC^F@F!#GHC:JBIL)#FAB9#79#!@!A#E9#:DMDBF@@C)#(+#$'9)*E9H9#A/9#PQT__U)#](6%&$%,#`)#VTTUW

• E+33#3

89'%7)#5+#6($%"#+/#"+$+(#+.$+#+.(#$2/%(b&/+(0#!%+9#VRS#/2#+.(#B/0(#&"(" # +.( # *.%$"( # Y%(+%(14.3(1+ # +/ # *%(7(1+ # '/""("9Z # I.( # *.%$"(#1(4(""$%5', # 53*'5(" # +.$+ # %(+%(14.3(1+ #3$,#6(#(22(4+(0#(7(1# 51 # +.(#(7(1+#/1',#/2#53351(1+)#53*(10518)#/%#(;*(4+(0#'/""("9#I.(#(3*'/,(%#1((0#1/+#-$5+# 2/%#"&6"+$1+5$' # '/""("#+/#3$+(%5$'5i(#6(2/%(#(;(%45"518#&'+53$+( #$10 #0%$"+54 # /*+5/1 # +/ #*%(7(1+ # "&4. # '/""("9 # F1 # +.( # 4$"( #$+#6(14.) # MMGB # -$" # $'%($0, # 251$145$'', # .(3/%%.$8518 # 6(2/%( # 251$'',#%("/%+518#+/#%(+%(14.3(1+9# >!@]HD:C#!9#MDA:HCL)#NH#79# #MFILJ^FL[F#MCICHL#G[F@L9#BCHGCH!IFCA#>MMGBW)#E9H9#A/9#P_UQRT)#](6%&$%,#P_)#VTTUW

[/-(7(%) # $*$%+ # 2%/3 # *(+5+5/1(%e" # 6$%( # $""(%+5/1 # /2 # %(0&4(0#/%0(%"#2%/3#N$*$1)#+.(#/1',#(750(14(#5+#*%("(1+(0#-(%(#+.(#'(++(%"#/2#7/'&1+$%, # $44(*+$14( # /2 # %(+%(14.3(1+) # $10 #-$57(%" # $10 # b&5+4'$53"#"581(0#6,#%("*/10(1+"9# #I/#/&%#3510)#+.("(#-(%(#51"&22545(1+#+/#"./-#+.$+ # *(+5+5/1(% # 510((0 # "&22(%(0 # 6&"51("" # '/""(" # "/ # "(%5/&" # $" # +/#1(4(""5+$+(#+.(#%(0&4+5/1#/2#*(%"/11('9##c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`)#VTTUW

'&

Page 77: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

U./$*(&E$;+(&C($-)*-#

• M+)$%*)7&+/&)0#&'+.82-)&4+-)(*.#&

I.(1 #4$3(# +.( #=12&%')# 0(45"5/1) # 5""&(0 # +-/ # >VW #3/1+." # '$+(%)#2510518#+.$+#kBLB#.$0#4/335++(0#&12$5% # '$6/% #*%$4+54(" #$8$51"+# +.(#&15/1#$10#$44/%0518',#8%$1+518#6$4=-$8("#$10#"(*$%$+5/1#*$,#51#2$7/%#/2#PPV#(3*'/,(("9##I.(#=12&%')#0(45"5/1#(3$1$+(0#2%/3#$#4/3*'$51+#2/%#&12$5%#'$6/%#*%$4+54(#$8$51"+#kBLB9##B&''(0#2%/3#+.(#&15/1e"#*'($0518"#-(%(#+.(#"*(45254#$4+"#4/335++(0#6,#kBLB)#"&4.#$"r#

P9F1"&'+518 #/2 # +.(#J15/1#G%("50(1+ #$"#(750(14(0#6,#+.(#L$'$,"$,#/2#M$9#B(45'5$#G$18$1j

V9B&00'518 # $10 # +%($+518 # +.( # 351/%5+, # &15/1 # -5+.#2$7/%)#"&4.#$"#*$,518#+.(5%#"$'$%5("p-$8("#2&'',#$10#$.($0#/2#+.(#514&36(1+#&15/1#$10#$"#52#5+#-(%(#+.(#514&36(1+#6$%8$51518#$8(1+"j

S9:5"4/&%$8518#+.(#3(36(%"#/2#+.(#514&36(1+#&15/1#2%/3 # 4/1+51&518 # +.(5% # 3(36(%".5* # -5+. # +.(#514&36(1+#&15/1#$"#(750(14(0#6,#+.(#G51$8"$3$18#L$'$,"$,#/2#H$35%/#D"*51/"$#$10#H/1$'0/#k9#@53j

`9^%56518#&15/1#3(36(%#$10#*%/35"518#*%/3/+5/1#52#.( #-5'' # 1/+ # </51 # +.( # "+%5=( # $" # (750(14(0 # 6, # +.(#L$'$,"$,#/2#^(%1$%0#:('+$j

a9I%$1"2(%%518 # &15/1 # 3(36(%" # +/ # $1/+.(% # </6#0("4%5*+5/1j

_9H(*'$4518 # +.(3#-5+. #3(36(%" #/2 #351/%5+, #&15/1#(750(14(0#6,#@("'5(#I$3$,/e"#L$'$,"$,j

Q9L&6<(4+518 # /1( # &15/1 # 3(36(% # +/ # $ # 7(%, # +(1"(#4/12%/1+$+5/1#51#+.(#E(1(%$'#M$1$8(%e"#C2254(#$2+(%#".(#4/33(1+(0#0&%518#+.(#ABM^#4/12(%(14(#+.$+#+.(#VTP#25'(#/2#+.(#(3*'/,(("#$%(#51+$4+)#%("&'+518#+/ # .(% # 6(518 # +$=(1 # +/ # +.( # ./"*5+$' # 2/% # 1(%7/&"#6%($=0/-1j#$10#

R9H(b&5%518 # +.( #&15/1 #3(36(%" # +/ # "&635+ #$1/+.(%#512/%3$+5/1#".((+)#$10#2$5'&%(#+/#0/#"/#-/&'0#3($1#1/#*$,3(1+#/2#+.(5%#N&1(#P_XST)#PUUQ#"$'$%,9

!**',518 # +.( # +/+$'5+, # /2 # +.( # 4/10&4+ # 0/4+%51() # @$6/% # !%65+(%#@&"+%5$#.('0#+.$+#kBLB#.$0#4/335++(0#&12$5%#'$6/%#*%$4+54("9#>@C@FI!#!9 #@CGDO) #DI9 # $'9) # 7"9 # # #kJDOCA#BFIK #LGCHIL #B@J^) # FAB9)E9H9 #A/9#P_`TSV)#N$1&$%,#PU)#VTTUW

J12$5% # '$6/% #*%$4+54( # %(2(%" # +/ # Y$4+" # +.$+ # 75/'$+( # +.( #-/%=(%"e#%58.+#+/#/%8$15i(9Z#I.(#*%/.565+(0#$4+"#$%(#%('$+(0#+/#+.(#-/%=(%"e#%58.+#

''

Page 78: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

+/ #"('2X/%8$15i$+5/1 #$10# +/ # +.( #/6"(%7$14(#/2 #$ #B^!9 # #c5+./&+ # +.$+#('(3(1+) # +.( # $4+") # (7(1 # 52 # &12$5%) # $%( # 1/+ # &12$5% # '$6/% # *%$4+54("9#>EDADH!@#L!AICL#BCB!XBC@!#G@!AI#]HDD#cCH?DHL#JAFCAXIJG!L#7"9#BCB!XBC@!#^CII@DHL#G[F@L9)#FAB9#>EDADH!@#L!AICL#BFIKW)#I[D#BCJHI # C] # !GGD!@L # $10 # I[D # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA)#E9H9#A/9#PQR_`QW

[(%()#%("*/10(1+#J15/1#-(1+#/1#"+%5=(#51#+.(#./1("+#6('5(2#+.$+#*(+5+5/1(%#-$"#4/335++518#J@G#$2+(%#+.(#'$++(%#0(450(0#+/#0/-1"5i(#5+"#-/%=2/%4(#4/1+%$%,#+/#+.(#"+$22518p3$11518#"+$10$%0"#$0/*+(0#6,#6/+.#*$%+5(" #&10(% #$ #B^!# 2/%8(0 #/1', # 2/&% # >`W # "./%+ #3/1+."#($%'5(%9 #I.(#6('5(2 #-$" # 6/'"+(%(0 #-.(1 # +.( #3$1$8(3(1+ # .5%(0 # PTT # 4/1+%$4+&$'#-/%=(%"#+/#%(*'$4(#+.(#`R#+(%351$+(0#%(8&'$%#%$1=X$10X25'(#(3*'/,(("#-./#-(%( #$'' #J15/1 #3(36(%"9 # F10((0) # +./"( #45%4&3"+$14(" #"./-(0#0%'/)*.)#'$# +.$+# +.(#./+(' #4/335++(0#J@G9 #I.&") #(7(1# 52 # +(4.154$'',#+.(%(#-$"#1/#'(8$'#8%/&10#+/#"+$8(#$#"+%5=(#6$"(0#/1#J@G)#"514(#+.(#$++(10$1+ # 45%4&3"+$14(" # "&**/%+ # +.( # 6('5(2 # 51 # 8//0 # 2$5+. # +.$+#*(+5+5/1(%e" # %(+%(14.3(1+ # "4.(3( # -$" # "+%&4+&%(0 # +/ # -($=(1 # +.(#6$%8$51518 # */-(% # /2 # +.( # J15/1) # +.( # "+%5=() # 6, # (;4(*+5/1) #3$, # 6(#4/1"50(%(0 # '(8$'9 #F[CID@ # DAIDHGHFLDL # C] # I[D # G[F@FGGFADL) # FAB9#>[DGFW) # /-1(% # /2 # [,$++ # H(8(14, # M$15'$) # 79 # L!M![!A # AE # ME!#M!AEE!E!c! # L! # [K!IIXA!IFCA!@ # JAFCA # C] # cCH?DHL # FA # I[D#[CID@ # !A: # HDLI!JH!AI # !A: # !@@FD: # FA:JLIHFDL # >L!M!L![XAJc[H!FAW)#E9H9#A/9#P_aQa_)###N&1(#a)#VTTUW

G(+5+5/1(%" #1(7(% # "&6"+$1+5$+(0 # +.(5% # $''(8$+5/1"9 # # F1 #$ # "535'$%#4$"()#!#9$%'-,*G/03("$$2*=)4(%*c-'(-*`!G=cb*$&*)3+*;+*!#9$%'-,*@3(1,9*?(%0(%)&'(-) # *(+5+5/1(% # L(%(1(/) # +.( # *%("50(1+ # /2 # LD@J) # 4.$%8(0#%("*/10(1+ #-5+. #J@G #$10 # 5''(8$' # 05"35""$' # 6(4$&"( # ".( #-$" # 51 # +.(#*%/4("" # /2 # %(1(8/+5$+518 # +.( # B^! # -5+. # %("*/10(1+ # -.(1 # ".( # -$"#05"35""(0#/1#+.(#8%/&10#/2#'/""#/2#+%&"+#$10#4/1250(14(9##c(#"$50r

G(+5+5/1(%"l#$44&"$+5/1#/2#&15/1#6&"+518#5"#6(%(2+#/2#$1,#*%//29#c(#"4$11(0#+.(#%(4/%0"#7(%,#4$%(2&'',#$10#2$5'(0#+/#05"4(%1#$1,#(750(14(#+/#"&"+$51#"&4.#4.$%8(9

F1#8'1*;2+*<=>?)#-(#.('0r

9#9#9#9#F+#5"#+.(#&15/1)#+.(%(2/%()#-./#.$0#+.(#6&%0(1#/2#*%//2#+/#*%("(1+#"&6"+$1+5$'#(750(14(#+/#"&**/%+#5+"#$''(8$+5/1"#>/2#&12$5%#'$6/%#*%$4+54("#4/335++(0#6,#3$1$8(3(1+W9

;;;####################;;;####################;;;9

'(

Page 79: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

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kJ!HD # BCHGCH!IFCA) # E9H9 # A/9 # PQTTP`) #N&', # S)#VTTUW&Z+%2.)$(7&1#3*6.$)*+.

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e"#Yf.g5"+/%,#/2#.,*(%+(1"5/1#2/%#S#,($%"9Z## M/%(/7(%) # +.( # ?/%($1 # *.,"545$1 # 050 # 1/+ # 3$=( # $1,#%(4/33(10$+5/1 #$" # +/ # %("*/10(1+e" #65'' # /2 #.($'+. # 2/% #*(+5+5/1(%" # +/#$""&3(#+.$+#.(#-$"#25+#2/%#%(*$+%5$+5/19######

WK&5WKI)#%("*/10(1+e"#$4+5/1"#"./-#+.$+#.(#7/'&1+$%5',#%("581(09#>\FHEDA # L[FGGFAE # BCHGCH!IFCA) # B!GI9 # HDA!IC # MCHDAID # d#C:KLLDK # M!HFIFMD # GID9# @I:9) # A!IFCA!@ # @!^CH # HD@!IFCAL#BCMMFLLFCA#79#NDLJL#^9#^!HH!kJFC)#E9H9#A/9#PQRPVQ)#!*%5'#P_)#VTTUW

S+(B@(#%$)#8&4*3#$3#

F2 # -( # 2/&10 # 51 #!$),133 * !9'0/)-),$/$-&# +.$+ # +.( # 0522(%(1+#4'53$+("#$10#&1*%(054+$6'(#-($+.(%)#$"#-(''#$"#+.(#"+%(""#/2#+.(#</6)#.$0#$#4/%%('$+5/1#-5+.#+.(#.($%+ #05"($"(#/2#$#"($2$%(%#-/%=518#$"#$#%$05/3$1 # /1 # $ # 7(""(') # +.(1 #-.$+ #3/%( # 51 # +.( # .($%+ # 05"($"( # /2 # $#"($2$%(%#"(%7518#$"#$#".5*#3$"+(%)#$#*/"5+5/1#517/'7518#3/%(#"+%$51#$10#*%(""&%(v##!#I&8#>6/$+W#M$"+(%#5"#*%53$%5',#+$"=(0#+/#/*(%$+(#+&8#6/$+")#$#*/-(%2&'#3$%51(#7(""('#+.$+#3((+"#'$%8(#".5*"#/&+#$+#"($#$10#$++$4.#$#'51(#+/#8&50(p"+((%#+.(#"$3(#51+/#$10#/&+#/2#6(%+."9##F1#/*(%$+518#"&4.#$ # */-(%2&' # 7(""(') # $ # I&8 # M$"+(% # %(b&5%(" # 1/+ # <&"+ # $ # +./%/&8.#=1/-'(08(#/2#+.(#*/%+#(175%/13(1+#51#-.54.#.(#5"#/*(%$+518)#6&+#$#.58.#'(7('#/2#"=5''#$"#-(''9# #F1#2$4+)#51#+.(#4$"(#$+#6$%)#%("*/10(1+#!:!ML#%(4/815i(0 # ./- # 8%&('518 # *(+5+5/1(% # A5"0$e" # </6 #-$") # $44/%0518 # +.(#'$++(%#$#3/1+.#/2#*$50#7$4$+5/1#(7(%,#+.%((#3/1+."#/2#"+%$58.+#"(%754(9#I.&") # 3/%( # +.$1 # $ # %($"/1$6'( # 4/11(4+5/1 # 6(+-((1 # +.( # 1$+&%( # /2#*(+5+5/1(% # A5"0$e" # </6 # $10 # .5" # B/%/1$%, # !%+(%, # :5"($"( # .$" # 6((1#

')

Page 80: 37136624-2009-LABOR-Case-Digest

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

(*