35th street better block follow-up design charrette: results
DESCRIPTION
ÂTRANSCRIPT
1
35th Street Better BlockFollow-Up Design Charrette: ResultsOctober 8, 2015
©2015 Work Program Architects
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page 3 Process Overview
Page 4 35th Street Corridor Context
Page 6 Strengths of 35th Street
Page 10 Weaknesses of 35th Street
Page 14 Aspirations for 35th Street
Page 15 Emerging Themes
Page 16 Strategies & Infrastructure Options
Page 17 Charrette Plan & Intersection Plans
Page 18 Three Street Section Options
Page 19 Better Block & Norfolk First Program
Page 20 Next Steps
Page 21 Proposed Streetscape Sketches
Prepared for the City of Norfolk by Work Program Architects
Raymond L. Gindroz
2
3
Process OverviewThe Planning Process was initiated by the City to obtain input for determining the best use of a $200,000 budget from the Neighborhood and Commercial District Capital Program. It also included finding ways of coordinating this work with other programs, such as the Better Block Grant Program and other economic incentives. A public charrette was held to gather community input and begin to identify a strategy for the most effective use of the $200,000.
April 25, 2015Understanding and Evaluation20 Participants identified the strengths and weaknesses of the area as well as sharing their aspirations for the future. The WPA and City team presented some ideas in response to the input from the community, including modifications to the street pattern, pedestrian improvements and landscape recommendations. These were then evaluated by participants.
Next Steps include proceeding with more detailed design and addressing some of the longer term concerns of the community.
4
RHODE ISLAND AVENUE
E 39TH STREET
E 40TH STREET
ETHEL AVENUE
47TH STREET
W 40TH STREET
W 39TH STREET
48TH STREET
45TH STREET
W 41ST STREET
W 42ND STREET
NEW YORK AVENUE
CONNECTICUT AVENUE
MAYFLOWER ROAD
NEW JERSEY AVENUE
PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE44TH STREET
MARYLAND AVENUE43RD STREET
VIRGINIA AVENUE
GEORGIA AVENUEMICHIGAN AVENUE
46TH STREET
38TH STREET
DELAWARE AVENUE
E 42ND STREET
LUCILE AVENUE
CAROLINA AVENUE
OM
OH
UN
DR
O A
VE
NU
E
LAVALETTE AVENUE
E 41ST STREET
CO
LUM
BU
S A
VE
NU
E
HOLLY AVENUE
GO
SN
OLD
AV
EN
UE
36TH STREET
NE
WP
OR
T AV
EN
UE
34TH STREET
LAMBERTS POINT ROAD
MU
NS
ON
STR
EE
T
W 31ST STREETW 29TH STREET
W 28TH STREET W 30TH STREET
33RD STREET
35TH STREET
37TH STREET DE
BR
EE
AV
EN
UE
E 30TH STREET
CH
UR
CH
STR
EE
W 32ND STREET
BROADWAY STREET
W 27TH STREET
W 26TH STREET
KIL
LAM
AV
EN
UE
MO
RTO
N A
VE
NU
E
W 25TH STREET
W 24TH STREET
SHUM
ADIN
E ST
REET
LEO
STR
EE
T
DRUID CIRCLE
EAST 30TH STREET
GA
ZEL S
TRE
ET
HA
MP
TON
BO
ULE
VAR
D
W 21ST STREETW 23RD STREET
WOODROW AVENUE
AZALEA COURT
HARRINGTON AVENUE
SPOTSWOOD AVENUE
LEIG
H S
TREE
T
WASHINGTON PARK
CO
RE
AVEN
UE
MO
NTI
CE
LLO
AVE
NU
E
ARM
ISTE
AD A
VEN
UE
E 29TH STREET
E 28TH STREET
E 25TH STREET
E 24TH STREET
E 26TH STREET
E 27TH STREET
FAW
N S
TRE
ET
E 23RD STREET
MAN
TEO
STR
EET
MO
NA
RC
H W
AY
W 20TH STREET
W 22ND STREET
E 22ND STREET
SHIRLEY AVENUE
GATES AVENUE
BRANDON AVENUE
SH
UM
AD
INE
RO
AD
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS, NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong), swisstopo, MapmyIndia, ©OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 200 400 600 800100Feet
0 ¼ ½Miles
1 inch = 200 feet35th STREET CORRIDOR CONTEXT
NORFOLK, VA
LAFAYETTE PARK
MONROE ELEMENTARYSCHOOL
PARK PLACE LIBRARY
[
Pre-Charrette StudyThe North-South connections throughout Norfolk are particularly strong. Unfortunately, in the case of the 35th Street Corridor, this means that most traffic travels past it, rather than through it.
The 35th Street Corridor must provide an easily identified and compelling reason for traffic to divert from the North-South routes to the commercial concentration between Colonial Avenue and Gosnold Avenue.
Commercial Property
Residential Property
35th Street Corridor
5
6
Strengths of 35th StreetEach participant placed three green dots on the three best places in the focus area and the overall context area. These results are sum-marized on the following pages. They then produced written lists to identify the strengths of the corridor on which a revitalizing effort could be built, including:
• Collection of small retail• Age of buildings• Potential• Location of neighborhood (close to Downtown, Zoo, Universities,
Colley Ave.)• The Venue-bright colors• Desire to bring the neighborhood back• Neighborhood Village (potential)• Connections – woven into the fabric• Bookends• Potential to attract specialty shops• Park Place School• Proximity to Riverview, Colonial Place, Larchmont—could be the
central hub• Potential for theater to be like Woolworth’s in Asheville or Chelsea
Market in NYC• Opportunity for unique specialty shops• Younger people now frequent the Venue• Active Civic League• Neighborhood Mix/diversity (buildings, demographics)• Walkability in the neighborhood• Good bones • Newport Sign• History—feels like is was a little downtown• Two anchors for retail – Rosna Theater and Newport Theater• YMCA
GO
SN
OLD
CO
LON
IAL
31ST
NEW
POR
T
DE
BR
EE
33RD32ND
28TH
29TH
36TH
35TH
34TH
LAMBERTS POINT
31ST
30TH
LAMBERTS POINT
NE
WP
OR
T
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 100 200 300 40050Feet
1 inch = 200 feet
35th STREET FOCUS AREA - STRENGTHSNORFOLK, VA
[
35th Street AssetsParticipants listed the existing assets of the 35th Street Corridor which could best anchor the future improvements, including:• Presence of quality residential• Croaker Spot (will also need to reach outside area)• Parking available at the school and the community center• Historic buildings• Scale of buildings• The Venue at 35th• Granny’s• YMCA/New School• Handsome Biscuit & Toast• New Apartments (market-rate) on 35th
7
GO
SN
OLD
CO
LON
IAL
31ST
NEW
POR
T
DE
BR
EE
33RD32ND
28TH
29TH
36TH
35TH
34TH
LAMBERTS POINT
31ST
30TH
LAMBERTS POINT
NE
WP
OR
T
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 100 200 300 40050Feet
1 inch = 200 feet
35th STREET FOCUS AREA - STRENGTHSNORFOLK, VA
[
2
3
1
6
45
8
710
9
11
12
1. Commercial Corridor2. Granny’s3. The Venue on 35th
4. Mosque5. Croaker Spot6. Public Parking
7. Renovated Commercial8. Historical Buildings9. Public Art
10. Quality Residential11. Open Space12. Available Parking
8
CO
LON
IAL
GO
SN
OLD
MARYLAND
MAY
FLO
WE
R
32ND
NEW
POR
T
LLE
WE
LLY
N
NE
WP
OR
T
OM
OH
UN
DR
O
DE
BR
EE
28TH
PENNSYLVANIA
38TH
BROADWAY
33RD
NE
WP
OR
T
31ST
34TH
40TH
35TH
36TH
VIRGINIA
LAVALETTE
37TH
29TH
41ST
MAY
FLO
WE
R
39TH
30TH
MICHIGAN
39TH
31ST
GEORGIA
27TH
CAROLINA
CAROLINA
LAMBERTS POINT
CO
LLE
YC
OLL
EY
GR
AN
BY
CO
LLE
Y
GR
AN
BY
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 200 400 600 800100Feet
1 inch = 400 feet
35th STREET CONTEXT AREA - STRENGTHSNORFOLK, VA
[
Strengths of 35th StreetResults of community input session
9
CO
LON
IAL
GO
SN
OLD
MARYLAND
MAY
FLO
WE
R
32ND
NEW
POR
T
LLE
WE
LLY
N
NE
WP
OR
T
OM
OH
UN
DR
O
DE
BR
EE
28TH
PENNSYLVANIA
38TH
BROADWAY
33RD
NE
WP
OR
T
31ST
34TH
40TH
35TH
36TH
VIRGINIA
LAVALETTE
37TH
29TH
41ST
MAY
FLO
WE
R
39TH
30TH
MICHIGAN
39TH
31ST
GEORGIA
27TH
CAROLINA
CAROLINA
LAMBERTS POINT
CO
LLE
YC
OLL
EY
GR
AN
BY
CO
LLE
Y
GR
AN
BY
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 200 400 600 800100Feet
1 inch = 400 feet
35th STREET CONTEXT AREA - STRENGTHSNORFOLK, VA
[
Strengths of 35th StreetInterpretation of community input session
2 1
3 4
5
6
7
1. Commercial Corridor2. Hardware Store3. Available Parking
4. Open Space5. Open Space6. Redeveloped Area
7. Lafayette Park/Virginia Zoo
10
Weaknesses of 35th StreetEach participant placed three red dots on the three worst places in the focus area and the overall context area. These results are summarized on the following pages. They then produced written lists of the key problems and weaknesses of the area that needed to be corrected in order to revitalize the area, including:
• Apartments behind the school at Omohundro Avenue• Boys & Girls Club at 26th Street needs a tenant• Perception affects the brand• The Virginian Pilot always identifies crimes as taking place in • “Park Place” (starting to use street names instead)• “Crossing the tracks”• Not many people supporting businesses on 35th Street• Traffic – N & S routes not travelled• Chinese restaurant at Colley and 35th Street• Old Rite-Aid• Codes not being enforced• Exposed AC units in the windows• Old chain link fences• Graffiti (especially on the façade of the Chinese restaurant)• Negative perception/exaggeration of negativity• Lack of branding/identity• Not a core group of patrons actively supporting the businesses• Not enough businesses focused on daily needs• Zoning restrictions• Speeding traffic (high traffic counts are desired as well as a
walkable environment)• Pawn shop and churches at the corner of Colonial and 35th
GO
SN
OLD
CO
LON
IAL
31ST
NEW
POR
T
DE
BR
EE
33RD32ND
28TH
29TH
36TH
35TH
34TH
LAMBERTS POINT
31ST
30TH
LAMBERTS POINT
NE
WP
OR
T
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 100 200 300 40050Feet
1 inch = 200 feet
35th STREET FOCUS AREA - WEAKNESSESNORFOLK, VA
[
35th Street AssetsParticipants listed the key obstacles encountered in the area that needed to be corrected in order to revitalize the area, including:• Sidewalks are not wide enough for outdoor dining• Funding• Not yet perceived as a welcoming neighborhood; curb appeal• Solutions should have a dual purpose: solve a problem & provide
an aesthetically pleasing object, place, etc. • Connected to main streets• Perception• Wide/hostile road• Lack of activity or evidence of activity• Nothing makes you want to stop• Distance/visibility from main arteries (does not look commercial)• Lack of neighborhood-servicing businesses• Businesses have not been updated• Heavy institutional uses• Lack of focus on the 35th Street corridor• Money (the grant is a start)• Aesthetics/appeal/walkability issue• Needs the image of a neighborhood that is a whole place
11
GO
SN
OLD
CO
LON
IAL
31ST
NEW
POR
T
DE
BR
EE
33RD32ND
28TH
29TH
36TH
35TH
34TH
LAMBERTS POINT
31ST
30TH
LAMBERTS POINT
NE
WP
OR
T
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 100 200 300 40050Feet
1 inch = 200 feet
35th STREET FOCUS AREA - WEAKNESSESNORFOLK, VA
[
12 3 64
5
7
1. Vacant Building2. Vacant Building3. Problems with some tenants
4. Land Use questioned by participants5. Vacant Building6. Problems with some tenants
7. Problems with some tenants
12
CO
LON
IAL
GO
SN
OLD
MARYLAND
MAY
FLO
WE
R
32ND
NEW
POR
T
LLE
WE
LLY
N
NE
WP
OR
T
OM
OH
UN
DR
O
DE
BR
EE
28TH
PENNSYLVANIA
38TH
BROADWAY
33RD
NE
WP
OR
T
31ST
34TH
40TH
35TH
36TH
VIRGINIA
LAVALETTE
37TH
29TH
41ST
MAY
FLO
WE
R
39TH
30TH
MICHIGAN
39TH
31ST
GEORGIA
27TH
CAROLINA
CAROLINA
LAMBERTS POINT
CO
LLE
YC
OLL
EY
GR
AN
BY
CO
LLE
Y
GR
AN
BY
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 200 400 600 800100Feet
1 inch = 400 feet
35th STREET CONTEXT AREA - WEAKNESSESNORFOLK, VA
[
Weaknesses of 35th StreetResults of community input session
13
CO
LON
IAL
GO
SN
OLD
MARYLAND
MAY
FLO
WE
R
32ND
NEW
POR
T
LLE
WE
LLY
N
NE
WP
OR
T
OM
OH
UN
DR
O
DE
BR
EE
28TH
PENNSYLVANIA
38TH
BROADWAY
33RD
NE
WP
OR
T
31ST
34TH
40TH
35TH
36TH
VIRGINIA
LAVALETTE
37TH
29TH
41ST
MAY
FLO
WE
R
39TH
30TH
MICHIGAN
39TH
31ST
GEORGIA
27TH
CAROLINA
CAROLINA
LAMBERTS POINT
CO
LLE
YC
OLL
EY
GR
AN
BY
CO
LLE
Y
GR
AN
BY
Sources: Esri, HERE, DeLorme, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS,NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong),swisstopo, MapmyIndia, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community
0 200 400 600 800100Feet
1 inch = 400 feet
35th STREET CONTEXT AREA - WEAKNESSESNORFOLK, VA
[
Weaknesses of 35th StreetInterpretation of community input session
1
2
3
8
6
5
4
7
1. Dilapidated Restaurant2. Vacant Rosna Theater3. Vacant Retail
4. Vacant Building & Lot5. Land Use questioned by some participants6. Problems with some tenants
7. Problems with some tenants8. Problems with some tenants
14
Aspirations for 35th StreetParticipants listed the aspirations for the area toward which future ef-forts should be directed, including:
• 35th Street to become like a mini U Street corridor in D.C. • Historic Warehouse District• Both a destination and a community market place• Eateries with outdoor seating• Reduce the number of storefront churches• Decorative signs and lighting• Keep parking in mind – solve in a smart way that does not incur a
large city cost• Visually pleasing• People & Patrons• Activate the green dot areas• Economic diversity• A positive image• Realize its potential as a draw• Food/entertainment district• Moratorium on additional subsidized housing• Restore the historical churches
15
Emerging ThemesFrom these lists, a set of common themes emerged:
1. Branding and Implementation Branding the street as a destination as well as a neighborhood is very important to the community. Establishing 35th Street as the business and cultural hub of Park Place is the first step towards being acknowledged as a regional treasure. Calling attention to, and further developing, the musical, culinary, artistic, and cultural identities of the existing and forthcoming businesses within the 35th Street Corridor will be necessary in order to draw visitors off of the nearby North-South routes and into the local establishments.
Frequently mentioned ideas for achieving this were: “Live on 35th Street” Brand Flags Painting the street Gateways Markers (Wayfinding) on sign tops
2. Traffic Calming The wide cartway of 35th Street is more effective as a shortcut between Granby Street and Colley Avenue than as a thriving business street. It encourages high traffic speeds which cause drivers to pay less attention to businesses that they’re passing by as well as making the street uncomfortable for pedestrians. Calming traffic is critical to reinventing the 35th Street Corridor as a pedestrian-friendly business and cultural center for the Park Place neighborhood and the Hampton Roads region. Potential Traffic Calming measures include: Gateways Crosswalks Bump-outs Parklets Bike Racks Table-top crosswalk Custom decorative concrete planter boxes
16
Infrastructure OptionsParticipants listed structural and infrastructural options that they felt would meet their needs and help achieve their collective aspirations for the corridor, including:
• Gateways and Markers (double-duty as traffic calming)• Middle turn lane• Bike Lanes – where should they be placed?• Traffic calming – coordination with other road projects in the city• Parking bump-outs• Rosna Theater has 700 seats -- will need a parking solution if
renovated• Cooperative parking agreements• Church parking is conflicting with business parking
parklet seatingPhoto by Colleen McHugh100resilientcities.org
existing sidewalk landscapingPhoto by Work Program Architects
intersection medallionImage by Park Place Business Association
bike lanePhoto by NYDOT
StrategiesBy applying the lists of Strengths, Weaknesses, and Aspirations to the list of Emerging Themes, a set of Strategies were developed to best counter the negative aspects of the corridor while enhancing the existing positive aspects, including:
IDENTITY• Gateways to connect to arteries – create image of the place, let people
know they have arrived, lead people to the commercial district -Two scales: 1) Gateways - Colley & 35th and Granby and 35th At intersection or the middle of the block 2) Markers – Granby, Llewellyn, Colonial, Colley, Hampton)• Flags on houses and businesses along the street, flowers, front yard
improvements -Atlanta example along the beltway (everyone has neighborhood flags; competition between neighborhoods)
TRAFFIC CALMING• Bike Lane replacing central turning lane• Angled Parking in center of street• Look at perpendicular parking solution• Parklets on North side of 35th Street for café seating (for Croaker Spot
and other eateries)• Primary Focus areas: -Start just East of Colonial Avenue -Finish just West of Gosnold Avenue• Don’t make 35th street a detour street for other roadway work
ACCESS• Use both 35th Street and surrounding blocks for parking• Community Center – program change from being a social services
location to a neighborhood anchor for all citizens with parking
17
35th Street Charrette PlanDuring the Charrette, a conceptual plan was sketched to illustrate a possible set of moves which satisfy the goals and intent of the previously identified strategies.
35th & GosnoldA) Gateways, B) bump-outs,
C) bike lane
35th & Gosnold
35th & Newport
Mid-Block crossing
Lambert’s Point & Newport
35th & NewportA) Landscaping, B) parklets, C)bike lane, D) bump-outs, E) intersection medallion
Mid-Block crossingA) Flags and banners,
B) pedestrian crossings, C) bike lane
Lambert’s Point & NewportA) Gateways, B) landscaping,
C) additional parking
A A AA
B BC
C
B
C
D
E
A
B
BC
18
Street Section 3: protected bike lane in center
Street Section 1: bike lane on one side
Street Section 2: perpendicular parking in center; bike lane to one side
35th Street Central Bike/Ped Lane:
The City of Norfolk Department of Public Works has completed engineered drawings for a central bicycle and pedestrian lane on 35th street. It includes some narrowing of the vehicular travel lanes at intersections in order to calm traffic and to create better safety islands.
NE
WP
OR
T AV
EN
UE
35th STREET 8.0'
4" SOLID YELLOW
R10-15L (MODIFIED)WITH HELMETEDBICYCLE RIDERSYMBOL (TYP. @INTERSECTIONS
R10-15L
4" YELLOW3'-9' MINI-SKIP(CENTERLINE)
4" YELLOW3'-9' MINI-SKIP(CENTERLINE)
6" YELLOW2'-6' MINI-SKIP
2.0'
6.0'
20.0' 20.0'4" SOLID YELLOW
6" SOLID YELLOW
10.0' Ø
6" SOLID YELLOW
4" SOLID YELLOW
11.0'
1.5'
10' Ø YELLOWFLEX POSTS (TYP.)
2.5'
Street SectionsDuring the Charrette, three options for street sections were sketched to illustrate various methods for incorporating community amenities with a desirable streetscape and traffic calming measures.
19
Better BlockThis process was preceded by a Better Block Workshop during the spring. That process tested a series of ideas for improving the area including streetscapes, pop up shops and programmed activities. Participants generally felt that the Better Block Event was successful and helped the community visualize a future for the area.
35th Street Better Block Plan
Norfolk First Program:The Department of Economic Development has initiated a program that will be used to help start and grow Norfolk businesses.
Better Block Grant:The first Better Block Grant will be awarded to a business for improvements to a building.
20
Participant’s Responses and Next Steps
1. Design of the Crosswalks: The Park Place Business Association has proposed a series of art projects including painting graphic images on the pavement to support the “Brand”. These should be designed by a graphic artists on the WPA team in order to be correctly coordinated with the other elements.
2. Design of Planters: The planters are intended to carry shrubs that match the existing ones on Newport. How deep do they need to be? How will irrigation be handled? A logo or marketing image should be imprinted on the ends and sides of the planters to further reinforce the Brand.
3. Bike Lane: The lane itself is straight forward, but how will crosswalks and turning movements across it be handled? What devices can be used to protect the bike lane and indicate the location of crosswalks?
4. Markers and Gateways: This is a specialized design that needs to be created before they can be fabricated.
“Live on 35th” gateway sign
Colley Ave. GatewayPhoto by Google
Granby St. GatewayPhoto by Google
21
Sketch Ideas for gateways, bike racks, benches, planters
Music note flag/bike racks Music note and saxaphone public art gateway