BRODY & BRANCH LLPAttorneys at Law

205 Lexington Avenua 4th FloorNew York, New York 10016

. Tel No.: (212) 879-7007 RECElVED. Fax No.: (212) 679-7123

DEC zc2010

December 26 2018 SUP COURT APP. DIV.

FIRST DEPT.

Hon. Suzanna Molina Rojas

Clerk of the Court

Appellate Division: Supreme Court

First Judicial Department

27 Madison Avenue

New York, New York 10010

Re: Francesco Bellucia v. CF 620 Owner LLC et al.

Index No. 150207/2011 as consolidated with

Index No. 651472 and related appeals

Orally Argued on December 4, 2018 ..

Dear Ms. Rojas

I am appellate counsel to Brody & Branch, LLP attorneys for defendants-respondents

appellants Henegan Construction Co., Inc. ("Henegan") and Building Service 32 BJ Health Fund

("32BJ") in the above referencedappeals.'

As this matter was fully settled as to these parties, we circulated a stipulation on or about

November 14, 2018 to withdraw the appeals of Henegan and 32BJ as evideñced by the numerous

e-mails annexed hereto. However, we have not yet to receive a fully executed stipulation.

Nonetheless, we submit the partially executed stipulation and formally inform the court that the

issues as Heñegañ and 32BJ have been fully resolved and it is the intent of these defendants to

withdraw their appeals.

Sincerely yours,

Mary Ellen O'Brien

Encls: E-mails

1M=cg= accepted the tender of32BJ after the appeals were perfected.

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

1 of 23

F

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORKAPPELLATE DIVISION: FIRST DEPARTMENT---------- --------------------------X

FRANCESCO BELLUCIA,

Plaintiff-Respondent,

- against - Index No.: 150207/2011

(as consolidated with

Index No.: 651472/2014)CF 620 OWNER, LLC; CF 620 OWNER ONE, LLC;

CF 620 OWNER TWO, LLC; CF 620 OWNER THREE,

LLC; BONJOUR 620 I, LLC, BONJOUR 620 II, LLC; STIPULATION TOand YL 620 SIXTH, LLC; WITHDRAW APPEAL

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.

Defendants-Respondents-Appellants, c 2 8 201B

d SUP COURT APP. DIV.-ªU -

FIRST DEPT.

ROBINSON ELEVATOR LLC, ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP,MJR ELEVATOR CONSULTING GROUP LLC, SCHINDLER

ELEVATOR CORPORATION, SERVICE EMPLOYEES

INTERNATIONAL UNION 32BJ; PRINCIPAL FACILITY

MANAGEMENT, LLC; NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK GLOBAL

MANAGEMENT SERVICES and NEWMARK & COMPANYREAL ESTATE, INC.

Defendants-Respondents.

----- ---------------------- -----X

JESUS RIVERA, DIANE ACEVEDO, BRENDAN GIANNINI,

EDWARD QUIMBY, NAOMI QUIMBY, WILLIAM CLIFTON,

LINDA CLIFTON, DAVID JENNE, CHRISTOPHER FRANZONE

and MARIE FRANZONE,

Plaintiffs-Respondents,

- against - FormerlyIndex No. 306448/2011

CF 620 OWNER ONE LLC, CF OWNER TWO, LLC,

CF620 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I, LLC,

I

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

2 of 23

BONJOUR 620 II, LLC, and YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendants-Respondents-Appellants,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC, ROBINSON

ELEVATOR LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR CORPORATION

and SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION 32BJ,

Defendants-Respondents,

-and-

SCHIMENTI CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, LLC and

SCHIMENTI CONSTRUCTION COMPANY OF

NEW YORK, INC.,

Defendants..________________________ ____. ------X

BRIAN CHRISTIAN,

Plaintiff-Respondent-Appellant,

- against - FormerlyIndex No.: 14993/2011

CF 620 OWNER ONE LLC, CF 620 OWNER TWO,

LLC, CF 620 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I,

LLC, BONJOUR 620 II, LLC, YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendants-Respondents-Appellants,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR

CORPORATION, PRINCIPAL BUILDING SERVICES, LLC,

NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK GLOBAL MANAGEMENT

SERVICES, LLC, SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL

UNION 32BJ, ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC,

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

3 of 23

MJR CONSULTING, LLC, MJR CONSULTING, INC.,

MJR ELEVATOR CONSULTING GROUP, PRINCIPAL

FAClLITY MANAGEMENT, LLC, NEWMARK KNIGHT

FRANK, NEWMARK & COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

and NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK d/b/a NEWMARK &COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

Defendants-Respondents.---------------- ------------------------------------X

EFRAIN HERNANDEZ,

Plaintiff-Respondent-Appellant,

-against - Formerly

Index No.: 14995/2011

CF 620 OWNER ONE LLC, CF 620 OWNER TWO,

LLC, CF 620 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I,

LLC, BONJOUR 620 II, LLC, YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondêñts,

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendants-Respondei1ts-Appellants,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR

CORPORATION, PRINCIPAL BUILDING SERVICES, LLC,

NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK GLOBAL MANAGEMENT

SERVICES, LLC, SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL

UNION 32BJ, ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC,

MJR CONSULTING, LLC, MJR CONSULTING, INC.,

MJR ELEVATOR CONSULTING GROUP, PRINCIPAL

FACILITY MANAGEMENT, LLC, NEWMARK KNIGHT

FRANK, NEWMARK & COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

and NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK d/b/a NEWMARK &COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

Defendants-Respondents.

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

4 of 23

X

PHILLIP NICHOLAS and SUSAN NICHOLAS,

Plaintiff-Respondents-Appellant,

- against -FormerlyIndex No.: 14994/2011

CF 620 OWNER ONE LLC, CF 620 OWNER TWO, LLC,

CF 620 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I, LLC,

BONJOUR 620 II, LLC, YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendants-Respondents-Appellants,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR

CORPORATION, PRINCIPAL BUILDING SERVICES, LLC,

NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK GLOBAL MANAGEMENT

SERVICES, LLC, SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL

UNION 32BJ, ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC,

MJR CONSULTING, LLC, MJR CONSULTING, INC.,

MJR ELEVATOR CONSULTING GROUP, PRINCIPAL

FACILITY MANAGEMENT, LLC, NEWMARK KNIGHT

FRANK, NEWMARK & COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

and NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK d/b/a NEWMARK &COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

Defendants-Respondents.-- -------------------- -------------X

GLEN GERISCH,

Plaintiff-Respondents-Appellant,

-against- Formerly

Index No.: 152768/2014

CF 620 OWNER ONE LLC, CF 620 OWNER TWO,

LLC, CF 620 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I,

LLC, BONJOUR 620 II, LLC, YL 620SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

5 of 23

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendants-Respondents-Appellants,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR

CORPORATION, PRINCIPAL BUILDING SERVICES, LLC,

NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK GLOBAL MANAGEMENT

SERVICES, LLC, SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL

UNION 32BJ, ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC,

MJR CONSULTING, LLC, MJR CONSULTING, INC.,

MJR ELEVATOR CONSULTING GROUP, PRINCIPAL

FACILITY MANAGEMENT, LLC, NEWMARK KNIGHT

FRANK, NEWMARK & COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

and NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK d/b/a NEWMARK &COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

Defendants-Respondents.________ ____------------------X

JOSEPH MARANDOLA and ANTONELLA MARANDOLA,

Plaintiff-Respondents-Appellant,

-against- Formerly

Index No.: 154546/2012

CF 620 OWNER ONE LLC, CF 620 OWNER TWO, LLC,

CF 620 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I, LLC,

BONJOUR-620 II, LLC, YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendants-Respondents-Appellants,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR

CORPORATION, PRINCIPAL BUILDING SERVICES, LLC,

NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK GLOBAL MANAGEMENT

SERVICES, LLC, SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL

UNION 32BJ, ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC,

MJR CONSULTING, LLC, MJR CONSULTING, INC.,

MJR ELEVATOR CONSULTING GROUP, PRINCIPAL

FACILITY MANAGEMENT, LLC, NEWMARK KNIGHT

FRANK, NEWMARK & COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

and NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK d/b/a NEWMARK &COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

6 of 23

Defendants-Respondents.

---X

DAVID KWARTA,

Plaintiff-Respondents-Appellant,

-against- Formerly:

Index No.: 155764/2012

CF 620 OWNER ONE LLC, CF 620 OWNER TWO,

LLC, CF 620 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I,

LLC, BONJOUR 620 II, LLC, YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

BUILDING SERVICE 32BJ HEALTH FUND and

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendants-Respondents-Appellants,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR

CORPORATION, PRINCIPAL BUILDING SERVICES, LLC,

NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK GLOBAL MANAGEMENT

SERVICES, LLC, SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL

UNION 32BJ, ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC,

MJR CONSULTING, LLC, MJR CONSULTING, INC.,

MJR ELEVATOR CONSULTING GROUP, PRINCIPAL

FACILITY MANAGEMENT, LLC, NEWMARK KNIGHT

FRANK, NEWMARK & COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

and NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK d/b/a NEWMARK &COMPANY REAL ESTATE, INC.,

Defendants-Respondents._____________________ _____- ------------------X

JOSEPH DESIMONE,

Plaintiff-Respondents-Appellant,

-against- FormerlyIndex No.: 154231/2014

BONJOUR 620 I, LLC, BONJOUR 620 II, LLC,

CF 620 OWNER LLC, CF 620 OWNER THREE, LLC,

CF 620 OWNER TWO, LLC and YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

7 of 23

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

NEWMARK KNIGHT GLOBAL MANAGEMENT SERVICES,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR, LLC, RXR 620 OWNER II LLC,

SCHINDLER ELEVATOR CORPORATION, PRINCIPAL

BUILDING SERVICES, LLC and SERVICE EMPLOYEES

INTERNATIONAL UNION 32BJ,

Defendants-Respondents,

-and-

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendant-Respondent-Appellant.

-- ---------------------------------------X

JOSE MOLINA and RACHEL MOLINA,

Plaintiffs-Respondents,

-against- FormerlyIndex No.: 155973/2013

CF 620 OWNER ONE, LLC, CF 620 OWNER TWO, LLC,

CF 62 OWNER THREE, LLC, BONJOUR 620 I, LLC,

BONJOUR 620 II, LLC and YL 620 SIXTH, LLC,

Defendants-Appellants-Respondents,

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.,

Defendant-Respondent-Appellant,

-and-

ROBINSON ELEVATOR GROUP, LLC,

ROBINSON ELEVATOR, LLC, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR

CORPORATION, NEWMARK KNIGHT GLOBAL

SERVICES, LLC and SERVICE EMPLOYEES

INTERNATIONAL UNION 32BJ,

Defendants-Respondents.

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

8 of 23

IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED by and between the attorneys for the

respective parties herein that an appeal having been noticed by defendant, HENEGAN

CONSTRUCTION, CO, INC., in the above-captioned matter on July 10, 2017 from an Order of

the Supreme Court, County of New York (Hon. Carol R. Edmcad, J.S.C), the Notice of Appeal is

Withdrawn on consent.

A facsimilciscarJêlectronic/e-mail copy of signatures of this Stipulation shall serve with

the same force and effect as the original.

Dated: New York, New York

November 14, 2018

BRODY & BRANCH LLP SHAUB, AHMUTY, CITRIN & SPRATT LLP

By: By: .,

Attorneys for Defendant-Respondent-Appellant Ap e Cdunsel to:

HENEGAN CONSTRUCTION CO., INC. LEWIS BRISBOIS BISGAARD &205 Lexington Avenue,

4* Floor SMITH LLP

New York, New York 10016 Attorneys for Defendants-Appellants-

(212).679-1007 Respondents CF 620 Owner, LLC,inobrienSbroifybi·anch.cóm CF 620 Owner One, LLC, CF 620 Owner

Two, LLC, CF 620 Owner Three, LLC,Bonjour 620 I, LLC, Bonjour 620 II, LLC

and YL 620 Sixth, LLC, and Defendants-

Respondents Newmark Frank Global

Management Services, LLC, Newmark

Knight Frank, Newmark & CompanyReal Estate, Inc. and Newmark Knight

Frank d/b/a Newmark & Company Real

Estate, Inc.

1983 Marcus Avenue

Lake Success, New York 11042

(516) 488-3300teapowskiGsacslaw.comgrathra)sacilaw.com.okaneØsacslawicom

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

9 of 23

EUSTACE, MARQUEZ, PSTEIN, PREZIOSO GOTTLIEB, SIEGEL & SCHWARTZ, LLP

& YAPCHANYK

By: By:

Attorneys for Defendant-RespGñdcñt- Attorneys for Defendants-Respondents

Appellant Building Service 32BJ Health Fund Robinson Elevator LLC, Robinson Elevator

and Defendant-Respondent Service Group LLC, MJR Consulting, LLC, MJR

Employees International Union 32BJ Consulting, Inc., and MJR Elevator Consulting55 WaterStreet, 29th Floor GroupNew York, New York 10041 207 East 94th Stn:et, Mezzanine Level(212) 612-4200 New York, New York 10128mpeknic@eustacelaw.com

(646) 449-8141

michaelditesslawlip.com

daniel@esslawllo.com

SACKS AND SACKS LLP SULLIVAN PAPAIN BLOCK MCGRATH& CANNAVO P.C.

Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents- gy.

Appe!!ants Brian Christian, Efrain Hernandez, Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents-Glen Gerisch, Phillip Nicholas and Susan

Appellants Joseph Marandola andNicholas

Antonella Marandola150 Bmadway, 4th Floor

120 Broadway, 18th FloorNew York, New York 10038

New York, New York 10271(212) 96405570

(212) 732-9000scott@sacks-sacks.com bshoot@triallaw l.com

FRIEDMAN, LEVY, GOLDFARB FIORE LAW GROUP& GREEN P.C.

By: scs By:

Attorneys forPlaint^

-Respond Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents

David Kwarta Jose Molina and Rachel Molina

250 West 57th Street, Suite 1619 320 Carleton Avenue, Suite 6800

New York, New York 10107 Central Islip, New York 1 1722

(212) 307-5800 (631) 861-3000

cgreen@fried-sñ!evy.com fiorelawatnupdilemail.com

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

10 of 23

EUSTACE, MARQUEZ, PSTElN, PREZlOSO GOTTLIEB, SIEGEL & SCHWARTZ, LLP

& YAPCHANY K

By: ... . ... By: ...

Attsneys for Defendant-Respondent- Attorneys for Defendants-Respondents

Appellant Building Service 32BJ Health Fund Robinson Elevator LLC, Robinson Elevator

and Defendant-Respondent Service Group LLC, MJR Consulting, LLC, MJR

Employees International Union 32BJ Consulting, Inc., and MJR Elevator Consulting

55 Water Street, 29th Floor GroupNew York, New York 10041 207 East 94th Street, Mezzanine Level

(212) 612-4200 . New York, New York 10128nipeknic eusracclaw.com

.(646) 449-8141michael(fãesslawilp.com.

danicl@ussiawllo.com

SACKS.AN SACKS I P SULLIVAN PAPAIN BLOCK MCGRATH

& CANNAVO P.C.

By:

Attorneys for Plaintiffs ndents-By: .

Appellants Brian Christian Efrain Hernandez, Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents-Glen Gerisch, Phillip Nicholas and Susan

Appê|lãñts Joseph Marandola andNicholas Antonella Marandola150 Broadway, 4th Floor

120 Broadway, 18th FloorNew York, New York 10038 New York, New York 10271(212) 96405570

(212) 732-9000scott@sacks-sacks.com bshoot@triallawl com

FRIEDMAN, LEVY, GOLDFARB F1ORE LAW GROUP

& GREEN, P.C.

By: .. . By:

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents

David Kwarta Jose Molina and Rachel Molina

250 West 57th Street, Suite 1619 320 Carleton Avenue, Suite 6800

New York, New York 10107 Central 1slip, New York 11722

(212) 307-5800 (631) 861-3000

cereen@fi'iedmñnlcvy.com florelawgroupffligmail.com

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

11 of 23

EUSTACE, MARQUEZ, PSTEIN, PREZIOSO GOTTLIEB, SlEGEL & SCHWARTZ, LLP

& YAPCHANYK

By: By:

Atterneys for Defendant-Respêñdêñt- Attorneys for Defendants-Respondents

Appe!!ant Bui!ding Service 32BJ Health Fund Robinson Elevator LLC, Robinson Elevator

and Defendant-Respondent Service Group LLC, MJR Consulting, LLC, MJREmployees International Union 32BJ Consulting, Inc., and MJR Elevator Consulting

55 Water Street, 29th Floor GroupNew York, New York 10041 207 East 94th Street, Mezzanine Level(212) 612-4200 New York, New York 10128mpeknuc@custacelaw.com

(646) 449-8141

michael@p,sslawlip.com

daniel@gsslawilp.com

SACKS AND SACKS LLP SULLIVAN PAPAIN BLOCK MCGRATH

& CANNAVO P.C.

By:

Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents-By:

Appellants Brian Christian, Efrain Herñañdez' Attorneys for Pfai dffs-Respoñdêñts-Glen Gerisch, Phillip Nicholas and Susan

Appellants Joseph Marandola andNicholas

Antonella Marandola150 Broadway, 4th Floor

120 Broadway, 18th FloorNew York, New York 10038 New York, New York 10271(212) 96405570

(212) 732-9000scon(i4sacks-sacks.com bshoot@triallawl.com

FRIEDMAN, LEVY, GOLDFARB FlORE LAW GROUP

& GREEN, P.C.

By: By:

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents

David Kwarta Jose Molina and Rachel Molina

250 West 57th Street, Suite 1619 320 Carleton Avenue, Suite 6800

New York, New York 10107 Central islip, New York I 1722

(212) 307-5800 (631) 861-3000

careen@friedmanlevy.com florelawgroup@email.com

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

12 of 23

.

EUSTACE, MARQUEZ, PSTE1N, PREZIOSO GOTTLIEB, S LEGEL & SCHWARTZ, LLP& YAPCHANYK

By: By:

Attorneys for Defendant-Respondent- Attorneys for Defendants-Respondents

Appellant Building Service 32BJ Health Fund Robinson Elevator LLC, Robinson Elevator

and Defendant-Respondent Service Group LLC, MJR Consulting, LLC, MJREmployees International Union 32BJ Consulting, Inc., and MJR Elevator Consulting

55 Water Street, 29th Floor GroupNew York, New York 10041 207 East 94th Street, Mezzanine Level(212) 612-4200 New York, New York 10128mpeknic(Seustacelâw.com

(646) 449-8141

michael@gsslawilp.com

daniel@esslawllp.com

SACKS AND SACKS LLP SULLIVAN PAPAIN BLOCK MCGRATH& CANNAVO P.C.

By:

Attomeys for Plaintiffs-Respondents-By:

Appellants Brian Christian, Efrain Hemandez, Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents-Glen Gerisch, Phillip Nicholas and Susan

Appellants Joseph Marandola andNicholas

Antonella Marandola150 Broadway, 4th Floor

120 Broadway, 18th FloorNew York, New York 10038 New York, New York 10271(212) 96405570

(212) 732-9000scott@sacks-sacks.com bshoot@triallawl.com

FRIEDMAN, LEVY, GOLDFARB FIORE LAW GRO.

& GREEN, P.C. --

By: By: .

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Respondcat Attorneýhórfl)l int -R spondents

David Kwarta Jose Molina n Rachel Molina

250 West 57th Street, Suite 1619 320 Carleto ·venue, Suite 6800

New York, New York 10107 Central Islipl ew York 1 1722

(212) 307-5800 (631) 861-3000

careen@friedmâñlevy.com florelawgroup@gmail.com

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

13 of 23

CREEDON & GILL P.C. SABATB41 & ASSOCIATES

.

By-By:

Attorneys for PhMW-Respondent Atto endant-Respondent

Prancesco Bellucia Schindler Elevator Corporation24 Woodbine Avenue, Suite 8 237 West 35th Street, Suite 1502

Northport, New York 11768 New York, New York 10001

(631) 656-9220 (212) 239-5900

peter(dcreedongill.com ris@sabatini-law.com

kirdi)sabatini-law.co

Ido dsabatini-law m

COZEN O'CONNOR NEIL G & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

By: BAttomeys for Defendant-Respondent ys r Plaintiffs-Respondents Jesus

Principal Facility Management, LLC i/s/h/a Rivera, Diane Acevedo, Brendan Giannini,Principal Building Services, LLC Edward Quimby, Naomi Quimby, William

45 Broadway, 16th Floor Clifton, Linda Clifton, David Jenne,New York, New York 10006 Christopher Franzone and Maria Franzone

(212) 509-9400 4242 Merrick Road

wkirrane doozen.com Massapequa, New York 11758

(5t6) 228-5100

instin'dnhalaw,eom

pseenbera@nhalaw.com

POLLACK, POLLACK, ISAAC &DECICCO, LLP

By:

225 Broadway, 3rd Floor

New York, New York 10007

(212) 233-8100

bli decid.com

Appeuate Counsel to:

SUBIN ASSOCIATES, LLP

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Respondent

Joseph DeSimone

150 BmadwayNew York, New 10038

hsgitsubinlaw-com

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

14 of 23

CREEDON & GILL P.C. SABATINI & ASSOCIATES

By: __ By:

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys for Defendant-Respondent

Francesco Bellucia Schindler Elevator Corporation

24 WOGdbiiie Avenue, Suite 8 237 West 35th Street, Suite 1502

Northport, New York 11768 New York, New York 10001

(631) 656-9220 (212) 239-5900

peter@creedoneill.com risGsabatini-law.com

klr@sabatini-law.com

Ido@.sabatini-law.com

COZEN O'CONNOR NEIL GREENBERG & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

By: By:

Attorneys for Defendant-Respandent Attorneys for Plaintiffs-Respondents JesusPrincipal Facility Management, LLC i/s/h/a Rivera, Diane Acevedo, Brendan C-iaenini,Principal Bei:din;; Services, LLC Edward Quimby, Naomi Quimby, Williani

45 Broadway, 16th Floor Clifton, Linda Clifton, David Jenne,New York, New York 10006 Christopher Franzone and Maria Franzone

(212) 509-9400 4242 Merrick Road

wki rrane@cozen.com Massapequa, New York 11758

(516) 228-5100

justin(shnhglaw.com

ngreenberg@nhalaw.com

POLLACK, POLLACK, ISAAC &DECICCO, LLP

By:

225 Broadway, 3rd Floor

New York, New York 10007

(212) 233-8100

bii@ppid.com

Appellate Counsel to:

SUBIN ASSOCIATES, LLP

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Respondent

Joseph DeSimone

150 BroadwayNew York, New 10038

hs@subinlaw.com

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

15 of 23

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

16 of 23

Millie Sanchez

From: Millie SanchezSent: Thursday, November 15, 2018 3:35 PMTo: 'tcapewsk?@sacslaw.com'; 'grath@sacslaw.com';

'ckane@sacslaw.com'

'mpskñic@eustace!sw.com'; 'michaei@ÿssiawllp.com'; 'danis|@ges!aw!lp.com'; 'scott@sacks-

sacks.com'; 'bshoot@triallaw1.com'; 'cgissñ@friedmanlevy.com'; 'fiors|âwgicup@gmail.com';'peter@crssdcagill.com'; 'rjs@sabatini-law.com'; 'k:r@sabatini-law.com'; 'idp@sabatini-

law.com'; 'wkirrañê@cozen.com'; 'justin@nhglaw.com'; 'ñgisêñberg@nhglaw.com';'bji@ppid.com';

'hs@subiniaw.com'

Cc: obrienmeattorney@aol.comSubject: Francesco Bellucia, et al / Our Insured: Héñéÿãñ Construction Co., Inc.Attachments: Stipulation to Withdraw Appeal.pdf

Counselors:

On behalf of our insured, Henegan Construction Co., Inc. in the above-referenced matters, attached please find

a Stipulation to Withdraw our Appeal. Kindly sign and return for filing with the Court. Thank you.

Sincerely,

Milagros Sanchez

Senior Assistant to Neil Brody, Esq.,

Steven R. Perkel, Esq., Mary Ellen O'Brien and Nicola Duffy, Esq.

BRODY & BRANCH LLP

205 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor

New York, New York 10016

Tel: (212) 679-7007

Fax: (212) 679-7123

msanchez@brodybranch.com

1

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

17 of 23

Millie Sanchez

From: Millie SanchezSent: Wednesday, November 21, 2018 2:10 PMTo: 'tcapowski@sacslaw.com'; 'grath@sacslaw.com'; 'ckane@sacslaw.com';

'mpekñic@êustacelaw.com'; 'michâê|@ÿéé;ew!!p.com'; 'dañiê| gss!awllp.com'; 'scott@sacks-

sacks.com'; 'bshcct@tria"aw1.com'; 'cgreen@friedmanlevy.com'; 'fiorelawgroup@gmail.com';'peter@cissdongill.com'; 'rjs@sabatini-law.com'; 'klr@sabatini-law.com'; 'Idp@sabatini-

law.com'; 'wkirrane@cozen.com'; 'justin@nhglaw.com'; 'ngreenberg@nhglaw.com';'bli@ppid.com';

'hs@subinlaw.com'

Cc: obrienmeattorney@aol.comSubject: RE: Francesco Bellucia, et al / Our Insured: Hêñêgañ Construction Co., Inc.Attachments: Stipulation to Withdraw Appeal.pdf

Counselors:

On behalf of our insured, Henegan Construction Co., Inc. in the above-refereñced matters, attached please find

the"corrected"

Stipulation to Withdraw our Appeal. Kindly sign and return for filing with the Court. Thank

you.

Sincerely,

Milagros Sanchez

Senior Assistant to Neil Brody, Esq.,

Steven R. Perkel, Esq. and Nicola Duffy, Esq.

BRODY & BRANCH LLP

205 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor

New York, New York 10016

Tel: (212) 679-7007

Fax: (212) 679-7123

msanchez@brodybranch.com

-----Original Message-----

From: Millie Sanchez

Sent: Thursday, November 15, 2018 3:35 PMTo:

'tcapowski@sacslaw.com'<tcapowski@sacslaw.com>;

'grath@sacslaw.com'<grath@sacslaw.com>;

'ckane@sacslaw.com'<ckane@sacslaw.com>;

'mpeknic@eustacclaw.com'<mpeknic@eustacelaw.com>;

'michael@gsslawllp.com'<michael@gsslawllp.com>;

'daniel@gsslawllp.com'<daniel@gsslawllp.com>;

'scott@sacks-sacks.com'<scott@sacks-sacks.com>;

'bshoot@triallawl.com'<bshoot@triallawl.com>;

'cgreen@friedmanlevy.com'<cgreen@friedmanlevy.com>;

'fiorelawgroup@gmail.com'

<fiorelâwgroup@gmail.com>;'peter@creedongill.com'

<peter@crcedongill.com>;'rjs@sabatini-law.com'

<rjs@sabatini-law.com>;'kir@sabatini-law.com'

<kir@sabatini-law.com>;'ldp@sabatini-law.com'

<ldp@sabatini-law.com>;'wkirrane@cozen.com'

<wkirrane@cozen.com>;'justin@nhglaw.com'

<justin@nhglaw.com>;'ngreenberg@nhglaw.com'

<ñgreenberg@nhglaw.com>;'bji@ppid.com'

<bji@ppid.com>;'hs@subinlaw.com' <hs@subinlaw.com>

Cc: obrienmeattorney@aol.com

Subject: Francesco Bellucia, et al / Our Insured: Henegan Construction Co., Inc.

1

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

18 of 23

Counselors: . • •• •

On behalf of our insured, Heilegaii Construction Co., Inc. in the above-referenced matters, attached please find

a Stipulation to Withdraw our Appeal. Kindly sign and return for filing with the Court. Thank you.

Sincerely,

Milagros Sanchez

Senior Assistant to Neil Brody, Esq.,

Steven R. Perkel, Esq., Mary Ellen O'Brien and Nicola Duffy, Esq.

BRODY & BRANCH LLP

205 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor

New York, New York 10016

Tel: (212) 679-7007

Fax: (212) 679-7123

msanchez@brodybranch.com

2

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

19 of 23

Millie Sanchez

From: Millie SanchezSent: Wednesday, November 28, 2018 11:07 AMTo: 'tcapowski@sacslaw.com'; 'grath@sacsiew.com';

'ckane@sacslaw.com'

'mpeknic@eustacelaw.com'; 'michaei@gss!ew!!p.com'; 'dañie|@gss!ew!!p.com'; 'scott@sacks-

sacks.com'; 'bshoot@triallaw1.com'; 'cgreen@friedmañ|évy.com'; 'fiorelawgroup@gmail.com';'peter@creedcagill.com'; 'rjs@sabatini-faw.com'; 'kir@sabatini-law.com'; 'Idp@sabatini-

law.com'; 'wkirrane@cozen.com'; 'justin@nhglaw.com'; 'ngreenberg@nhglaw.com';'bji@ppid.com';

'hs@subinlaw.com'

Cc: obrienmeattomey@aol.comSubject: RE: Francesco Bellucia, et al / Our Insured: Heñêÿañ Construction Co., Inc.Attachments: Stipulation to Withdraw Appeal.pdf

Good morning counselors:

I am writing to inquire the status of signing the attached Stipulation withdrawing the appeal on behalf of our

insured, Henegan Construction. Kindly signed the attached Stipulation and return to my attention. Thank you.

Millie Sanchez

Sincerely,

Milagros Sanchez

Senior Assistant to Neil Brody, Esq.,Steven R. Perkel, Esq., Nicola Duffy, Esq.

and Mary Ellen O'Brien, Esq.

BRODY & BRANCH LLP .

205 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor

New York, New York 10016

Tel: (212) 679-7007 .... ...

Fax: (212) 679-7123

msanchez@brodybranch.com

-----Original Message-----

From: Millie Sanchez

Sent: Wednesday, November 21, 2018 2:10 PMTo:

'tcapowski@sacslaw.com'<tcapowski@sacslaw.com>;

'grath@sacslaw.com'<grath@sacslaw.com>;

'ckane@sacslaw.com'<ckane@sacslaw.com>;

'mpeknic@eustacclaw.com'<mpeknic@eustacelaw.com>;

'michael@gsslawilp.com'<michael@gsslawilp.com>;

'daniel@gsslawllp.com'<daniel@gsslawllp.com>;

'scott@sacks-sacks.com'<scott@sacks-sacks.com>;

'bshoot@triallawl.com'<bshoo . allawl.com>;

'cgreen@friedmanlevy.com'<cgreen@friedmanlevy.com>; 'florelawgroup@gñiall.

' . .,<fiorelawgroup@gmail.com>;

'peter@creedongill.com'<peter@creedon 111zom s@

äbatini-law.com'

<rjs@sabatini-law.com>;'klr@sabatini-law.com'

<klr@sabatini-law.copi>; 'ldpbati(idaw.com'

<ldp@sabatini-law.com>;'wkirrane@cozen.com'

<wkirrane@cozen.côm>;'justin@nhglaw.com'

<justin@nhglaw.com>;'ngreenberg@ñhglaw.com'

<ngreenberg@nhglaw.com>;'bji@ppid.com'

<bji@ppid.com>;'hs@subinlaw.com' <hs@subinlaw.com> 7

Cc: obrienmeattorney@aol.com

Subject: RE: Francesco Bellucia, et al / Our Insured: Hêñêgeui Cóñstruction Co., Inc.

1

i

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

20 of 23

Counselors:

On behalf of our insured, Henegan Construction Co., Inc. in the above-referenced matters, attached please find

the"corrected" Stipulation to Withdraw our Appeal. Kindly sign and return for filing with the Court. Thank

you.

Sincerely,

Milagros Sanchez

Senior Assistant to Neil Brody, Esq.,

Steven R. Perkel, Esq. and Nicola Duffy, Esq.

BRODY & BRANCH LLP

205 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor

New York, New York 10016

Tel: (212) 679-7007

Fax: (212) 679-7123

msanchez@brodybranch.com

-----Original Message-----

From: Millie Sanchez

Sent: Thursday, November 15, 2018 3:35 PMTo:

'tcapowski@sacslaw.com'<tcapewski@sacslaw.com>;

'grath@sacslaw.com'<grath@sacslaw.com>;

'ckane@sacslaw.com'<ckane@sacslaw.com>;

'mpeknlc@eüstacelaw.com'<mpeknic@eustacelaw.com>;

'michael@gsslawllp.com'<michael@gsslawllp.com>;

'dañiel@gsslawilp.com'<daniel@gsslawllp.com>;

'scott@sacks-sacks.com'<scott@sacks-sacks.com>;

'bshoot@triallawl.com'<bshoot@triallawl.com>;

'cgreen@friedmanlevy.com'<cgreen@friedmañlevy.com>;

'fiorelawgroup@gmailcom'

<fiorelawgroup@gmail.com>;'peter@creedongill.com'

<peter@creedongill.com>;'rjs@sabatini-law.com'

<rjs@sabatini-law.com>;'klr@sabatini-law.com'

<kir@sabatini-law.com>;'ldp@sabatini-law.com'

<ldp@sabatini-law.com>;'wkirrane@cozen.com'

<wkirrane@cczen.com>;'justin@nhglaw.com'

<justin@ñhglaw.com>;'ñgreêñberg@nhglaw.com'

<ñgreenberg@nhglaw.com>;'bji@ppid.com'

<bji@ppid.com>;'hs@subinlaw.com' <hs@subinlaw.com>

Cc: obrienmeattorney@aol.com

Subject: Francesco Bellucia, et al / Our Insured: Henegan Construction Co., Inc.

Counselors:

On behalf of our insured, Henegan Construction Co., Inc. in the above-referenced matters, attached please find

a Stipulation to Withdraw our Appeal. Kindly sign and return for filing with the Court. Thank you.

Sincerely,

Milagros Sanchez

Senior Assistant to Neil Brody, Esq.,Steven R. Perkel, Esq., Mary Ellen O'Brien and Nicola Duffy, Esq.

BRODY & BRANCH LLP

2

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

21 of 23

205 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor

New York, New York 10016

Tel: (212) 679-7007

Fax: (212) 679-7123

msanchez@brodybranch.com

3

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

22 of 23

Millie Sanchez

From: Millie SanchezSent: Friday, December 14, 2018 11:13 AMTo: mpeknic@eusEé|ëw.com; peter@creedongill.com; Kirrane, William; justin@ñhg:âw.com;

ngreenberg@nhgiaw.com; Rosa@nhglaw.com; bji@ppid.comCc: obrienmeattorney@aol.comSubject: Francesco Bellucia, et al / Our Insured: Hêñêgañ Construction Co., Inc.Attachments: 20181214102801752.pdf

Good morning counselors:

I am writing to inquire the status of signing the anached Stipulation withdrawing the appeal on behalf of our

insured, Henegan Construction. Kindly sign the sitsched Stipulation and return to my attention as soon as

possible.

Thank you for your cooperation.

Millie Sanchez

Sincerely,

Milagros Sanchez

Senior Assistant to Neil Brody, Esq.,

Steven R. Perkel, Esq., Nicola Duffy, Esq.

and Mary Ellen O'Brien, Esq.

BRODY & BRANCH LLP

205 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor

New York, New York 10016

Tel: (212) 679-7007

Fax: (212) 679-7123

msanchez@brodybranch.com

1

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/21/2019 11:45 AM INDEX NO. 150207/2011

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1182 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/21/2019

23 of 23