2016-02-24 plaintiff surreply (flores decl) (flores v doj)(15-cv-2627)(jg)(rlm)(stampted)
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
1/57
! # !
!"#$%& ($)$%( ($*#+$ +,!*$
%)($%*" ($*#+$ ,- "%. /,*0
%&'() *%&+,)-
!"#$%&$''-
./
'0(1,2 )131,) 2,43+15,01 &*
6')1(7,-
()')%*#%&/
#8!79!:;:< =6>?=+%5?
&%+1)*)$#," ,- 1,!#( -1,*%(
(- %&'() *%&+,)- @AB+,- /) 4CDEF@EGG- HBICDJB DK GLCCLMK N
#/ ( DO D PLQJFDCEK@ DFH DF [email protected]@/ ( RQSCEKA @AB LFCEFB FBMK TBS KE@B-
4JLUJBKK VQBBFK/ ( DCKL ODEF@DEF DFH LMF KB.BJDC RLCE@EIDC DFH [email protected]@ SCLUK LF @AB
(F@BJFB@/ ( GECBH @AB *EJK@ *&(3 +BWQBK@- DK HBGEFBH EF @AB DIILORDFXEFU RCBDHEFUK- LF YZ
3RJEC :Z#Y- ME@A @AB 2BGBFHDF@ 'FE@BH )@D@BK 2BRDJ@OBF@ LG 6QK@EIB =@AB [2&6\?/ ( GECBH
@AB )BILFH *&(3 +BWQBK@ ME@A @AB 7E.EC +EUA@K 2E.EKELF LG @AB 2&6 LF :Z &I@LSBJ :Z#8 EF
DF BGGLJ@ @L [ICLKB @AB CLLR\ LF @AB JBILJHK SBEFU JBWQBK@BH GJLO @AB 2&6/
:/
( JD@EGX DK GDI@K DCC LG @AB K@D@BOBF@K ODHB SX 4CDEF@EGG EF @AB 3OBFHBH
7LORCDEF@- RDJ@EIQCDJCX- SQ@ ME@ALQ@ B]ICQKE.E@X- DCC LG @AB K@D@BOBF@K RBJ@DEFEFU @L
4CDEF@EGG^K BGGLJ@K @L FBUL@ED@B ME@A @AB 2&6 GLJ @AB JBCBDKB LG JBILJHK JBKRLFKE.B @L @AB
*EJK@ *&(3 +BWQBK@/ =2_@/ 0L/ #8?/
Y/
,]IBR@ GLJ OEFLJ DFH JBDKLFDSCB DCCLMDFIBK GLJ @XRLUJDRAEIDC BJJLJK- (
JD@EGX DK GDI@K DCC LG @AB K@D@BOBF@K ODHB SX 4CDEF@EGG EF DCC LG @AB HLIQOBF@K GECBH SX
4CDEF@EGG EF @AB HLI_B@ ME@A @AEK 7LQJ@- DFH ( D@@BK@ @L DCC HLIQOBF@K GECBH SX 4CDEF@EGG EF
@AB HLI_B@ ME@A @AEK 7LQJ@ DK @JQB DFH ILJJBI@ ILREBK LG KQIA HLIQOBF@K/
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 1 of 57 PageID #: 1699
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
2/57
! : !
`/
1AEK HBICDJD@ELF DFH @AB B]AESE@K DFFB]BH ABJB@L KQSOE@@BH EF KQRRLJ@
LG 4CDEF@EGG^K LRRLKE@ELF OL@ELF DFH 4CDEF@EGG^K IJLKK!OL@ELF GLJ KDFI@ELFK DJB @JQB ILREBK
LG @AB HLIQOBF@K EF RLKKBKKELF LG 4CDEF@EGG/
5/
3@@DIABH ABJB@L DK ,]AESE@ 5 EK D @JQB DFH ILJJBI@ ILRX LG N,]IBJR@ GJLO :Z#8!#Z!#; 7LFGBJBFIB 7DCC SB@MBBF 4CDEF@EGG %LQEK *CLJBK DFH
2BGBFKB 7LQFKBC +Q_AKDFDA )EFUA- ,KW/
0/
3@@DIABH ABJB@L DK ,]AESE@ 0 EK D @JQB DFH ILJJBI@ ILRX LG N
1AB GEJK@ CLFU!GLJO DJ@EICB ( AD.B MJE@@BF- SDKBH LF @AB GBM JBKRLFKE.B
HLIQOBF@K RJLHQIBH EF @AB )BILFH *&(3 +BKRLFKB- B.EHBFIEFU @AB GDI@ @AD@ @AB
>L.BJFOBF@ EK FL@ SBEFU @JDFKRDJBF@ DSLQ@ @AB UQEHBCEFBK E@ GLCCLMK EF @AB
RJLKBIQ@ELF LG [email protected]@K/ 1AEK RJBKK JBRLJ@ EK D.DECDSCB LFCEFB/ 0)) %LQEK *CLJBK-
1)*),#" 23$*)"$%)/ '-, &4) +,-/)53&$-% -' #5&$6$/&/ #++)#, &- ,)5-%/&,35& # ")2#"
',#7)8-,9 "-/& 3%*), &4) 07$&4 :5&- 4JLUJBKK VQBBFK =#Y *BSJQDJX :Z#;?-
A@@RNaaMMM/RJLUJBKKWQBBFK/ILOaFBMKa:Z#;a:a#YaGBHBJDC!UQEHBCEFBK!GLJ!
@AB!RJLKBIQ@[email protected]@K!DRRBDJ!@L!JBILFK@JQI@!D!CBUDC!GJDOBMLJ_!CLK@!QFHBJ! @AB!KOE@A!DI@/
(F DIILJHDFIB ME@A :b '/)/7/ c #
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
3/57
EXHIBIT M
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 3 of 57 PageID #: 1701
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
4/57
"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /
Page M-1
0#123* 45 678 9:;
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
5/57
"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /
Page M-2
012#$3$'%4&5 '-1 613*4& 7-4 24&892'18 '-1 *1$32- 634:%818 '-1 1,$2'
#$&;9$;1 4( ?@ A1B91*' $&8 C $&8 #1')* *11 -1315 %' *$J)* 4< 7%##%&; '4 %&8%2$'1 '-$' &4 312438* 7131
(49&85 .12$9*1 '-$')* E%&8 4( '74 8%((131&' '-%&;*G
AM N1##5 ? '-%&E 7-$' '-1 012#$3$'%4&* *$< %* '-$' &4 312438* 7131 (49&8G O-1
'-%&; 7%'- 7-1'-13 &4 8429F1&'* 1,%*' 9&813 =>?@ #$75 '-131 F$< .1
8429F1&'* 49' '-131 %& '-1 743#8 '-$' 71 749#8 &4' .1 $7$31 4(5 $&8 $* #4&;
$* 71 84 $ 8%#%;1&' *1$32-5 '-1& 71 -$:1 (9#(%##18 493 4.#%;$'%4&* 9&813 =>?@G
M45 ? 84&)' 312$## '-1 J98;1 *612%(%2$##< $*E%&; $' '-1 K4&(131&21 7-1'-13 &4
8429F1&'* 1,%*'5 7-4#1*$#15 43 7-1'-13 &4 312438* 7131 (49&8G P9'5 &4
312438* 7131 (49&8G ? 2$& '1##
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
6/57
"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /
Page M-3
!"# %&' ()*'+,-.'/ 01+2*'31,)4*5 6'-'4+'
01 2#*34 #335%&6 $' '-7 1892 :7;7=7 67&7=$# =7;$%' (3= '-7
/$6%*'=$'7 D7 H 9 E3&)' '-%&5 '-7 /$6%*'=$'7 D
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
7/57
"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /
Page M-4
!""# %&' ()* +,', -&' (.,/0'-.12304 5'6'3,' -1 70'3-' )89:,/3-.12
01 23435 .6' 78%&7 .$9: '8 '-; %**6; 8( '-$' (%
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
8/57
"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /
Page M-5
01 2 3&456*'$&4 '-$' 78%&'9 :-$' 2); '5##%&< =83 %* '-$' >5 $65 &8' 3*%&< '-5
?%*@65'%8&$6= 05#5$*5 %& 7#$@5 8( '-5 AB2C 05*78&*59 D-5 AB2C 05*78&*5
>$* '-$' '-565 >565 &8 65@864* #8@$'54 (8##8>%&< '-5 *5$6@-9 C&4 '-5& '-5
?%*@65'%8&$6= 05#5$*5 >$* 768E%454F .5@$3*5 =836 65G35*' 65#$'54 '8 '-5
H-8% 768*5@3'%8&F $&4 >5 '-83-$' 2 65G35*'54 $' '-5 4$'5 8( '-5 2&%'%$#
H8&(565&@59 2 4%4 $*J '-5 /$%'- -569
EF P?J'9 Q89 RST9
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 8 of 57 PageID #: 1706
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
9/57
"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /
Page M-6
!"# %&' ()* +, !-./0+.- 1&' 2'34',1 5/0 6'.'078 64+9'8+.', :/0
1&' ;0/,'7D37*' %* '-$' '-%* %* 6A $.63' 0'H
O$&%7# ' 7 B0+C+.78 (+>+,+/.
01 27*%:7* '-7 +BQNC '-$' =6J7;* '-7 OH
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
10/57
"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /
Page M-7
01 2 3& '-4 #4''45 (567 #$*' &%8-' 9
:; 3& 2 3 '-%&< %')* '=6 2 '-454)* $ (>## 1?3@ A6&'$A' #%*'B $&C %' %'47%*4* '-4
C%((454&' C4D$5'74&'*E F>' '-4 G5%7%&$# H%I%*%6& %* '-4 C%I%*%6&B =-%A- =6>#C
-$I4 %&(657$'%6& 54#$'4C '6 '-4 D56*4A>'%6& 6( $A'%I%*'*E
01 @&C %* '-$' '-4 6((%A4 >&C45 '-4 @**%*'$&' 2 %* '-$' >&C45 '-4 ?((%A4 6( '-4
@**%*'$&' @''65&4J K4&45$# 9
:; L4*B *6 '-4 ?((%A4 6( '-4 @**%*'$&' @''65&4J K4&45$# %* 4**4&'%$##J '-4 -4$C
D6#%AJ $&C 4&(65A474&' *4A'%6& 6( '-4 G5%7%&$# H%I%*%6&E M-4 D6#%A%4*
65%8%&$'4 (567 '-$' 6((%A4E M-$')* =-J '-$' 6((%A4 =$* *4$5A-4CE
1>## 54A65C%&8 A$& .4 -4$5C 6%&4 N !""#$%&&'(()'*&+,-./0
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 10 of 57 PageID #: 1708
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
11/57
EXHIBIT N
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 11 of 57 PageID #: 1709
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
12/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 1ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-ts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
PROGR SS QU NS
T R N S P R E N C Y I N P O L I T I C S
H O M E N E W S E D I T O R I A L C A L E N D AR S P E C I A L R E P O R T S N O T I C I A S V O T E T W I T T E R
C O N TA C T A D V E R T I S E D O N A T E
Federal guidelines for the
prosecution of activists appear
to reconstruct a legal
framework lost under the
Smith Act!"#$%&$' )*+ ,-).
A special investigation
SHARE ON TWITTER AND GOOGLE
Tweet
!
TUMBLR
/&0" 1%$" 23 45152 &67 #3308&$0 3%$ 9%8#:$
;3$ 562"$"1256< 56;3$8&2536+ 56=:%756< :5601 23
6">1 &$25=:"1 632 ?%#:51@"7 #' A$3
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
13/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 2ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-ts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
! #$%&'$()'*+!, -.'#/!*+%0 !%1 +%()*&2)%&
')*&'+#&+$%* 3+,, &/!&4 +5 -!**)1 36 &/) %)7 6$'8 *&!&)
!**)23,64 7+,, 0$ 3)5$') 0$(9 !"#$%& ()*+*:1;%)7
6$'8< :$55+#+!, -/$&$0'!-/=%)7 6$'8 *&!&)=-.3,+#
1$2!+%< 5$' /+* #$%*+1)'!&+$%9 &/) -'$-$*)1 3+,,
7$.,1 )2-$7)' %)7 6$'8 *&!&) $55+#) $5 0)%)'!,
)'(+#)* #$22+**+$%)' $*!"" #%,-.-*:%$& -+#&.')1* $55+#)=-.3,+# 1$2!+%< 7$.,1 3)$'#)1 &$ #$%*.,& &/) ,+*& !%1 3!% !%6 *&!&)
%()*&2)%& !#&+(+&+)* 7+&/ *.#/ +%1+(+1.!,*4
#$'-$'!&+$%*4 !%1 0'$.-*9 +5 /.2!% '+0/&* !#&+(+*&*
!') +1)%&+5+)1 $% *.#/ ! ,+*&4 &/)+' !1($#!#6 #!'))'*
#$.,1 3) &!'%+*/)1 36 ! *&!&);*-$%*$')1 )55$'& &$
')&!,+!&) !0!+%*& !#&+(+*&* 3!*)1 $% &/)+' !#&+(+*29
&/)') +* %$ +%5$'2!&+$% !3$.& /$7 $0* #$22+**+$%)'
1)*&+&$ 7+,, #$2-+,) *.#/ ! ,+*&4 3.& !#&+(+*&* /!()
#$2-,!+%)1 &/!& &/) )?+*&)%#) $5 *.#/ ! ,+*& 2!6 ,)!1
&$ ! 2$1)'%;1!6 2##!'&/6+&) 7+/ /.%& $5 /.2!%
'+0/&* !#&+(+*&*9 $%) $5 &/) ,)!1 *-$%*$'* $5 &/) *&!&)
)%!&) 3+,, 7!* *&!&) *)%9 ,.+(/! 2%1#%$:1;3'$$8,6%( (8.( "2 '&( . 1&5%,#(# .'9 .11>4.(#
#%4#2#'(.("&' &* (8# "5%.1( &* (8# %4&%&2#9 F#$ G&4H
I(.(# ,"2( &* -&/1&B .1("!"2(23 .11&49"'< (& 4#1&492 &-(."'#9
4&5 (8# MNO: PQ"2("'< R#9#4., ,.$ 1(2 (8#
NTI 7&55"22"&'#4 (& '&("*/ (8# .1("!"2(2 (8.( (8# .1("!"2(2
8.!# -##' "9#'("U#9 .'9 %,.1#9 &' (8# %>418.2#
#2(4"1("&'2 ,"2( (& ("&' *&4 $8.( 1&>,9 -# (8# 2.5# &4 2"5",.4
.1("!"25: F&( &',/ "2 (8#4# . ,.1H &* . R#9#4., '&("U1.("&'
&4 4#2%&'2# 4#V>"4#5#'(23 ->( R#9#4., "'!#2("9"'< "'!&,!"'< (8#
LINK LIST
+(,.'("1 G.492W?.1"U1 ?.4H X#%&4(
7,#.' K% O.5."1.3 @>##'2 F&$
P(8"12 +"'Y( ?4#B/
F#$ G&4H 7"(/ 7&>'1", S.(18
A8# ?#' "2 6"4 #5.", .994#22\
I>-214"-#
M#,"!#4#9 -/ R##9L>4'#4
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 17 of 57 PageID #: 1715
https://feedburner.google.com/http://www.willetspoint.org/http://www.welcome2thebronx.com/wordpress/http://www.savenyc.nyc/http://robertreich.org/http://queenscrap.blogspot.com/http://sullio.blogspot.com/http://citycouncilwatch.net/http://ethicsaintpretty.blogspot.com/https://cleanupjamaicaqueens.wordpress.com/http://atlanticyardsreport.blogspot.com/ -
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
18/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 7ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-ts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"# %& '#(#)*+ ,-.#"/,0*/,%-"1 2),-3,2*++4 3%-(!3/#( 54 /6#
!"#"$%& ()$"%) *+ ,-."/012%01*-1 %) '781 *3/,-0 /%
#2)#"#-/ '#(#)*+ ,-/#)#"/" ,- /6# 2)%/#3/,%- %& /6#
2)%2#)/4 %& &%)#,0- 0%.#)-9#-/": ;-( /6," '78
-.%+.#9#-/ 3*- /*+#( 54 /6# 2!5+,"6#) %& A)%0)#"" O!##-"1 -%) 6*"
6# PRQ *-"=#)#( S!#"/,%-" &%++%=,-0 * (!# (,+,0#-3#
#.,#= %& /6# = )#"2%-",.# )#3%)(" 2)%(!3#( 54 /6#
T%.#)-9#-/: U#.#)/6#+#""1 *33%)(,-0 /% /6# ,-&%)9*/,%-
2)%.,(#( /6!" &*)1 /6# &%++%=,-0 *-*+4"," %& )#3%)(" *-(
-&%)9*/,%- 3*- 5# 9*(#:
'%++%=,-0 *- #V2+,3*/,%- %& /6# /6)## "#3/,%-" &)%9 /6#
JK;N:
USAM 9-65.880 : DEMONSTRATIONS
@6# *22+,3*5+# '#(#)*+ +#0*+ "/*/!/# /6*/ 0%.#)-" +*=
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 18 of 57 PageID #: 1716
http://www.justice.gov/usam/united-states-attorneys-manual -
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
19/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 8ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-ts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&!'!"( *"+!,(*-.(*$", ."/ 0%$,!&1(*$", *, 23 4565
7$/! 8 9:;< =>*&> "$'*".??@ &$/*A!, (>! 0%$(!&(*$" $#
0%$0!%(@ $&&10*!/ B@ #$%!*-" -$+!%"'!"(,5 C" ?$$D*"- .(
3 4565 7$/! 8 9:;< (>! E!/!%.? 0%$,!&1($%, #%$' (>! !"#"
$%&'()*+, ./0)< $% 46FG< "$%'.??@ ?$$D .( +*$?.(*$",
$&&1%%*"- /1%*"- /!'$",(%.(*$", $# ,*H.B?! "1'B!%, $#0!$0?! (>.( '.@ *"+$?+! (>! 0%$0!%(@ $# #$%!*-"
-$+!%"'!"(,< ?*D! .( !'B.,,*!, $% '*,,*$",5 C" ,1&>
",(."&!,< (>! 46FG .??$=, ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(, ($
'.*"(.*" $%/!% ."/ ($ '.D! .%%!,(,< *# "!&!,,.%@5 C( &." B!
.*/ (>.( (>! 46FG -*+!, *(, *'0?*&*( .00%$+.? #$% 0$?*&*"-
."/ .%%!,(, B@ .??$=*"- ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(, ($ (.D!
>! ?!./5 I+!" ,$< (>! 46FG *, "$( %!?*!+!/ $# *(,
!,0$",*B*?*(*!, =>!" *( .??$=, ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(, ($
.D! (>! ?!./ *" 0$?*&*"- ."/ (>! '.D*"- $# .%%!,(,< *#
"!&!,,.%@5 J>! 46FGK, %!,0$",*B*?*(*!, &$''!"&! B@
0.%(*&*0.(*"- *" &$$%/*".(!/ *"(!??*-!"&! ,>.%*"- $"
L0$(!"(*.? /*,(1%B."&!, ?*D!?@ ($ .M!&( . #$%!*-" #.&*?*(@
."/ .%%."-!'!"(, #$% "!!/!/ ?.= !"#$%&!'!"( %!,0$",!5N
J>1,< !+!" *# (>! 46FG .??$=, ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(,
$ (.D! (>! ?!./ $" 0$?*&*"- $# /!'$",(%.(*$", .M!&(*"-
$%!*-" #.&*?*(*!, $% #$%!*-" 0%$0!%(*!,< (>! 46FG '1,(
.O!"/ ($ (>! !P&>."-! $# *"(!??*-!"&! ."/ (>! .%%."-!'!"(
$# ?.= !"#$%&!'!"( %!,0$",!5
J>! 46FG 0%!Q0?.", #$% ." $,,1,23(2 !"#" $%&'()*< $%
F46F< ($ B! .,,*-"!/ ($ '$"*($% (>! /!'$",(%.(*$"5 E$%
1&> /!'$",(%.(*$",< (>! ERC< /*,0.(&>!, $B,!%+!%, ($ (>!
&!"!< ."/ (>! ERC $B,!%+!%, 0%$+*/! ,0$( %!0$%(, ($ (>!
F46F5 C# (>! 46FG /$!, "$( 0%!Q0?." #$% ." F46F ($ B!
.,,*-"!/ ($ . /!'$",(%.(*$"< (>!"< 10$" "$(*A&.(*$" $# .
/!'$",(%.(*$" ?*D!?@ ($ %!,1?( *" . /*,(1%B."&!< (>!" (>!
46FG ,>$1?/ .,,*-" ." F46F ($ '$"*($% (>!
/!'$",(%.(*$"5 S$(! (>.( (>! 46FG "$%'.??@ &$",*/!%,
/!'$",(%.(*$", 1"/!% (>! .00?*&.B?! ?.= ($ *"+$?+!
*H.B?! "1'B!%, $# 0!$0?!5 J>!%!#$%!< *( &." 0%$B.B?@ B!
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 19 of 57 PageID #: 1717
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/970 -
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
20/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 9ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-ts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
"#$ &'"& "(( $)*+,!&-"+,! +. !/0' !#1) 2+/($ 3) (#4)(5 &+
)!/(& #, " $#!&/-3",0) +. !+*) 4#,$6 !/0' "! "7)0,8
&-))& &-"90 +- &') /!) +. !#$)2"(4!6 )&0: ;')-).+-)6 &')
2+-$#,8 #, &') ? )@#!&! &+ &-#88)- &') "!!#8,#,8 +. ",
> ",$ &') $#!A"&0' +. BCD +3!)-E)-! .+- "(( ("-8)
$)*+,!&-"+,! &'"& *"5 3) ')($ "& .+-)#8, ."0#(#)! +-,E+(E) .+-)#8, A-+A)-)!6 (#4) )*3"!!#)! +- *#!!#+,!6 .+-
)@"*A():
;') 2+-$#,8 #, &') ? 0"!& E#+("+,! +. &') ("2
A-+&)0,8 .+-)#8, ."0#(#)! +- .+-)#8, A-+A)-)! &+ 3) ",
)@&),!#+, +. E#+("+,! +. (+0"( ("26 ",$ &') 2+-$#,8 #, &')
? '#8'(#8'&! ", )@A)0&"+, &'"& (+0"( A+(#0)
$)A"-&*),&! 2#(( *"4) "--)!&! .+- &'+!) E#+("+,! +. &')
+0"( ("2: D, #,!&",0)! 2')-) &')-) #! ,+ (+0"( ("2 &'"&
+/($ 3) /!)$ .+- E#+("+,! +. &') .)$)-"( ("2 A-+&)0,8
+-)#8, ."0#(#)! +- .+-)#8, A-+A)-)!6 &'), &') ?
"/&'+-#!)! "--)!&! /,$)- &') .)$)-"( ("2 2#&'+/& ("2
),.+-0)*),& '"E#,8 &+ +3&"#, ",5 A-#+- "/&'+-#!"+, .-+*
') !"#$#%&' )#*#+#,%+. &') FGH: >00+-$#,8 &+
,.+-*"+, +3&"#,)$ 35 I-+8-)!! J/)),! $/-#,8
,)8+"+,! 2#&' &') FGH6 A+(#05 +. &') K-#*#,"( F#E#!#+,
! !)& 35 &') -./0 ,1 230 4++#+2&%2 45,"%06 70%0"&':
>(&'+/8' MN
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
21/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 10ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&'()! &+ !),+-#&.%&"+-# &+ +/&%"- #$+& .)$+. %.)
-+& "- 1-"2+.,3 4(1#0 &()5 %'& %# +/#).6).# "- 7$8%"-9
8+&()#3: ;''+.!"-< &+ &() ? +/#).6).# A+.)1-"2+.,#0 &() "!)-&"B'%&"+- +2 &()". )C$8"'"& $.)#)-')
A+18! '.)%&) .)#"#&%-') &+ &()". A+.@3 ?- )C')$&"+-%8
".'1,#&%-')#0 8"@) % ,),/). +2 % 2+.)"?
+/#).6). +. +/#).6).# A+18! /) )C$)'&)! &+ &%@)
$.+&)'&"6) ,)%#1.)# 2+. $.+&)'&)! 2+.)"
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
22/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 11ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$% '( ) *'++$,-" .$'-)%$'/0 )#" 1'23!"/%"1 $/ %4" 5678+
"*'#% '( %4" 1"!'/+%#)%$'/9
:4"+" ;3$1"-$/"+ )#" +$-"/% ),'3% 1"!'/+%#)%$'/+ %4)% 1'
/'% $/.'-." +$+9
USAM 9-65.881 : DEMONSTRATIONS
PROCEDURES
:4" B'#1$/; $/ %4$+ +"2%$'/ '( %4" ?@=C $+ 2'!*-"D0 )/1
% B)+ *#',),-> 1'/" $/%"/%$'/)-->9
E/2" %4" 567 #"2"$."+ $/('#!)%$'/ $/1$2)%$/; ) .$'-)%$'/ '#
*'%"/%$)- .$'-)%$'/ '( %4" ("1"#)- -)B *#'%"2%$/; ('#"$;/
)2$-$%$"+ '# ('#"$;/ *#'*"#%$"+0 %4" 567 B$-- /'%$(> %4" !"#"
$%&'()*%+) -. #)')%)/1 B$-- 2'/+3-% B$%4 %4" )**#'*#$)%"
?9@9 =A'#/">9 = 1"!'/+%#)%$'/ $+ 2'1"1 %' ," ) .$'-)%$'/
'# *'%"/%$)- .$'-)%$'/ '( %4" ("1"#)- -)B *#'%"2%$/; ('#"$;/
)2$-$%$"+ '# ('#"$;/ *#'*"#%$"+9 =22'#1$/; %' %4";3$1"-$/"+0 %4" 567 B$-- $/$%$)%" )/ $/."+%$;)%$'/ F)+ $+
1""!"1 /"2"++)#> $( $% $+ 1"%"#!$/"1 %4)% 5"1"#)- *#"+"/2"
+ B)##)/%"10G B$%4'3% H3)-$(>$/; 4'B %4)% $+ 1"%"#!$/"19
:4" 2'/%)2% B$%4 %4" I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%" $+ /'!$/)-->
1"+2#$,"1 )+ F/'%$J2)%$'/0G 4'B"."#0 $( %4" I"*)#%!"/% '(
@%)%" 1$1 /'% #"H3$#" )/ $/."+%$;)%$'/0 %4" %$!" %4)% %4"
I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%" B'3-1 !)K" %4)% K/'B/ B'3-1 ,"
B4"/ %4" 567 /'%$J"1 %4" I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%" '( ).$'-)%$'/ '# *'%"/%$)- .$'-)%$'/ '( %4" 5"1"#)- -)B9 7/1""10
B4"/ %4" ?9@9 =A'#/"> $+ /'% 2"#%)$/ )+ %' B4"%4"# F%4"
/2$1"/% B$-- )1."#+"-> )L"2% %4" ('#"$;/ #"-)%$'/+ '( %4"
?/$%"1 @%)%"+0G %4" ?9@9 =A'#/"> $+ *#'.$1"1 ) 4'%-$/" %'
4" I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%"0 %4)% B$-- 2'//"2% %4" ?9@9
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 22 of 57 PageID #: 1720
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
23/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 12ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&' )*+, +,& -..$#.$*-+& /&.-$+0&%+ #1 2+-+& #34*-5
)*+, ),#0 +# 4#%675+8 9&$&: +,& 4#;& )#$; 1#$
;&0#%6+$-+*#% 6,*1+6 1$#0 #1 ?&;&$-5 5-) .$#+&4+*%@ 1#$&*@% 1-4*5*+*&6 #$
#$&*@% .$#.&$+*&6: +# -% +,-+
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
24/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 13ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#"$%& #()*+)(,(+-./ 0&,1+231 ,1" 4%**$+*$(%," 5-(,"#
6,%,") %2,1+$(,(")/ (- -+, )*"&&"# +2, 1"$"7 *$")28%9&: ,1()
++*) 9%;< 2* ,+ ,1" =$(8(-%& >(?()(+- +@ ,1" >AB7 ,1"
")*";,(?" 5.6. 0C+$-": (-?+&?"# (- ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+-7 ,1"
5.6. 6";$", 6"$?(;"7 %-# ,1" >"*%$,8"-, +@ 6,%," 4D(,1+2,
#"&%:./
E1"- 4,1" +F"-)"/ () +@ % -%,2$" ,1%, 8"$(,) !"#"$%&
*$+)";2,(+-7 ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+- )1+2 9" ;+-#2;,"#
D(,1+2, $"3%$# @+$ D1",1"$ 4,1" *"$,(-"-, @+$"(3- +G;(%&)
D(&& %3$"" ,+ %**"%$ %) D(,-"))") %, %- "-)2(-3 ,$(%&./
H"$"7 ,1" ;+#" @+$ % #"8+-),$%,(+- 1%) )1(@,"# ,+ 4,1"
+F"-)"./ A-;" ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+- 1%) (#"-,(I"# % )29J";,7
%-# +-;" ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+- 1%) %;;282&%,"# )2G;("-,
"?(#"-;" 4,+ @+$8 ,1" 9%)() @+$ !"#"$%& ;1%$3")7/
-?"),(3%,+$) )1+2 8%
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
25/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 14ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&'(#"$ *%+%" (,% ("-./0 #+ &".1./23 &,2"0%$ (# 3#&23
!"#$%&'(#"$4 (,%"% &2/ 5% $2.* (# 5% 2/ .1!3.&.( 2*1.$$.#/
,2( (,% 2'(#12(.& (".00%"./0 #+ 6%*%"23 #7%"$.0,( #7%"
2&(.7.$($ %/020./0 ./ 3#&23 *%1#/$("2(.#/$ 12- 5%
%/$/2"./0 2&(.7.$($ +#" !#(%/(.23 6%*%"23 $&"'(./-4 %7%/
,#'0, *%1#/$("2(.#/$ 12- /%7%" "%$'3( ./ (,% 5"./0./0 #+6%*%"23 &,2"0%$89
:#(;.(,$(2/*./0 (,% *%+%""23 5- 6%*%"23 !"#$%&'(#"$ #+
".1./23 &,2"0%$ (# 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#"$4 (,% ?
0'.*%3./%$ 0.7%$ @A$ (,% *.$&"%(.#/ (# ./$'"% (,2( (,%
6BC ;.33 1#/.(#" (,% !"#0"%$$ #+ (,% 3#&23 !"#$%&'(.#/4
0.7./0 (,% 6BC D'2$.E#7%"$.0,( #7%" 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#"$8 C/
/$(2/&%$ ;,%"% (,% 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#" $,#'3* *"#! &".1./23
,2"0%$ 202./$( 2/ 2&(.7.$(4 (,% @ $,#'3* "%F723'2(%
,% 12G%"4 2/* H2 /%; !"#$%&'(.7% *%(%"1./2(.#/ $,#'3*
5% "%/*%"%*4I 1%2/./0 (,2(4 %7%/ .+ 2/ 2&(.7.$( ,2* 5%%/
&"'(./.$%* 5- 6%*%"23 !"#$%&'(#"$4 5'( (,% 12G%" ;2$
*%+%""%* (# 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#"$4 5%+#"% (,% 2&(.7.$( &2/ 5%
#1!3%(%3- &3%2"%* #+ 2/- &,2"0%$ *"#!!%* 5- 3#&23
!"#$%&'(#"$4 (,% 6%*%"23 !"#$%&'(#"$ 2( (,% @ 2"%
0.7%/ 2/ #!!#"('/.(- (# /$.*%" (,% 5"././0 #+ 6%*%"23
".1./23 &,2"0%$ 202./$( (,% 2&(.7.$( 2/%;8
:#/% #+ (,% !"#&%*'"%$ /#(%* ./ J KELM8NNO 2"% /#(%* ./ J
KELM8NNP8
USAM 9-65.882 : DEMONSTRATIONS
NVESTIGATIVE DECISIONS BY U.S. ATTORNEYS
Q#&23 !#3.&% *%!2"(1%/($ ,27% "%D'."%1%/($ +#" 2/* 0.7%/$("'&(.#/$ ./ "%$!%&( #+ *%1#/$("2(.#/$ 5- 2&(.7.$($8
6'"(,%"1#"%4 (,% ? 0'.*%3./%$ ./*.&2(% (,2( 6BC
20%/($ ;.33 %R!32./ 6%*%"23 32;$ (# 2&(.7.$($8 6%*%"23 32;
%/+#"&%1%/( #S&.23$ %R!%&( (,2( 2&(.7.$($ ;.33 2G%1!( (#
#1!3- ;.(, (,% "%D'."%1%/($4 (,% ./$("'&(.#/$4 2/* (,%
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 25 of 57 PageID #: 1723
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
26/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 15ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&%'()& )+ ,!-!.%$ $%/01 23!& % -!4)&0'.%'()& 56
%7'(8(0'0 (0 -!!4!- ') 5! 97$!%.$6 )5:!7'()&%5$!; 56
&8!0'(7'(&< %& !&'.%&7! ') %
5>($-(&
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
27/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 16ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&'$&() +$!,%-.$// "0 (1$ 2'3,.,&4$ 3$(5$$&
,4(6,.2(7 "0 ,&7 8"($&(2,. '2&"% #2".,(2"&/ "0 ."4,. .,5/ "%
"%-2&,&4$/ ,&- , 8$%4$8(2"& (1,( (1$/$ #2".,(2"&/ ',7
"'$1"5 2'8,4( 9):) 0"%$2!& %$.,(2"&/; (1$ 9:&"5.$-!$ (1,( ."4,. 8".24$
-$8,%('$&(/ 52.. $&0"%4$ (1$ ."4,. .,5/ "% "%-2&,&4$/)?1$ 9):)
(,(6("%7 ,6(1"%2(7 (" 3%2&! 41,%!$/ ,!,2&/( ,4(2#2/(/) B&
641 4,/$/; "% 51$%$ C$-$%,. ,4(2"& 2/ -$$'$- &$4$//,%7;
1$ 9):)
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
28/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 17ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"# %&'( #)*"#%+ %&) *#)(( ",-) ."# %&) /010 23"#4)56(
7,-) ."# 8)9 :"#;6( ("4 '4='->%'"4 %&>% *)#&>*( %&) H7I
C>5 4"% .B@) %" -#'C'4>@ *#"()-4 '4%)#D')9 ."# %&'( #)*"#%0
G&)#) '( >4"%&)#+ C#?)#+ ?#>5 >#)> 9&)4 >-%'D'(C
&>% '4-@5 B) -"4('=)#)= B5
!)=)#>@ @>9 )4."#-)C)4% ",-'>@( %" -"4(%'%( %)##"#'(% ?#"-%'D'(% C>5 >@#)>=5 B) (
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
29/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 18ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%$&'% $' $'#"%)$*+)&!, *-$."/$'"% +00/$1+2/" )&
)3" 4"."!+/ 2-!"+- &4 $'#"%)$*+)$&'5 &! 42$6 )3"%"
'#"%)$*+)&!, *-$."/$'"% 7"!" 0!&8-/*+)". 2, )3"
&44$1" &4 )3" -6%6 +))&!'", *"'"!+/6 $' 9::95 4&!8"!
+))&!'", *"'"!+/ !"#$%&' !)*%+&,;'&) 0$1)-!".5 4&!8"! +))&!'", *"'"!+/ -.$/ %+$#0.12
&44$1$+/ 03&)&*!+03?-%.&@?7$A$0".$+?0-2/$1 .&8+$'"9;- 6"++,.;@ *%$1($ A+"'$
6";,(,*1; -,+*"',(3 (3$& M(1($
M$&1("% L.1'17 L(3$% 1*(,#,+(+ 31- .$$& A1*(,#$ ,& ;1."%
9&,"&+/0 >3,*3 31- +966"%($- M(1($ M$&1("% L.1'1N+
6";,(,*1; %,+$/ (3$ 1%(,*;$ &"($-7 O$(/ (3$ %$6"%( ,& 23$
P1+3,&!("& 5"+( ,'6%".1.;@ %1,+$- (3$ Q9$+(,"& 1."9(
>3$(3$% 5%$+,-$&( L.1'1 >1+ $#$& 1>1%$ "< (3$ 6%".$ ""9;- 31#$ %$Q9,%$-
6";,(,*1; *;$1%1&*$ "< +"'$ +"%(7 R9%,&! (3$ ($%' "<
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
35/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 24ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%$&' )*+ &,-."+ &!$/ #*!#0 1+2+.!3340 $2 &-"*
2%+$1!#$,2&0 #*+ 567 ",2/-"#& #*+ $2%+$1!#$,2&0 !2/
5+/+.!3 8.,&+"-#,.& 9$#* #*+ :';' ?@"+&
9,-3/ A,33,9 #*+ B!2-!3 $2 .+&8+"# ,A #*+ "!&+& !1!$2
*+ !"#$%$&' 5+/+.!3 8.,&+"-#,.& 9,-3/ /+#+.B$2+
9*+#*+. #*.+&*,3/& 9+.+ B+# $2 .+1!./ #, 8.,&+"-#$,2&!2/ $2%+$1!#$,2&0 &!4$21 ,A 5+/+.!3 8.,&+"-#,.&0 C)*+4
!.+ #*+ ,2+&0 9*, /+"$/+'D
2 .+&8,2&+ #, ! .+E-+ A,. !2 $2#+.%$+90 ! &,-."+ 9$#* #*+
567 F+3/ ,@"+ $2 G$22+!8,3$& &!$/0 C7>B 2,# !# 3$H+.#4 #,
/$&"-&& #*,&+ I$2/& ,A $2%+$1!#$,2&'D
2,.#*+.2 /$.$"# !2/ A,. #*+
G$22+&,#! /$.$"# 9+.+ -2&-""+&&A-3'
A never-ending encroachment by
Federal law enforcement on the
political activities of activists
J,2+ ,A #*+ KL 8+!"+ !"#$%$& $2 733$2,$&0 G$22+&,#!0 ,.
G$"*$1!20 9*, 9*$"* 9+.+ +2&2!.+/ $2 #*+ KMNM 567
8.,H+0 *!%+ #+$F+/ H+A,.+ ! 1.!2/ O-.40 /+&8$#+ *!%$21
H++2 &+.%+/ 9$#* &-H8,+2!& ",B8+33$21 #*+B #, /, &,'
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
36/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 25ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&'()#*$ ,#'-. /01% !"#2)$%. (/% 0&()1)$($3 4)"$(
52%*.2%*( ")6/($7
8/% "%".$ "%1)%,%. 9: 8/% 5$$#&)0(%. ;"%$$ $/#,%.
/0( (/% -("0(% .)$$).%*( !#-)()&0- 6"#'!$?@ 0..)*6 (/0( (/%
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
37/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 26ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
"#$%&$'($)*+&*, $'- +&.-/$* $')$ $'- /'-/0&*, #1 2-)+(
#. $'- 3#($ 3&*&3)2 $45- #1 &*6-($&,)$* 7- 3)+-
5.#35$248 &$ &( *#$ 0*#%* &1 $'-.- -9&($-+ $'-*8 #. -9&($
*#%8 )*4 .-($.&/$*( #* :-+-.)2 5.#(-/;$#.( %&$' $'-
6).( = ?@#.*-4(A BC/-( ).#;*+ $'- *)$* $#
-)(#*)724 $-.3&*)$- +-)+D-*+ &*6-($&,)$*( #*/- $'-4')6- 7--* 7-,;*=
"#. &( &$ 0*#%* &1 $'-.- ).- )*4 :&.($ ?3-*+3-*$D(5-/&E/
5#2&/&-( )552&/)72- $# :-+-.)2 5.#(-/;$#.( $')$ /#;2+ 7-
#35).)72- $# $'- :&.($ ?3-*+3-*$D(5-/&E/ 5#2&/&-(
)552&/)72- $# $'- :FG8 1#. -9)352-= H'- 2)%(;&$ E2-+ 74
'- 5;72&('-. #1 I.#,.-(( J;--*( &* F.##024* :-+-.)2
#;.$ ')( (#;,'$ $# #7$)&* .-/#.+( )7#;$ '#% :-+-.)2
5.#(-/;$#.( 7)2)*/- $'- :&.($ ?3-*+3-*$8 /&6&2 .&,'$(8
&6&2 2&7-.$&-(8 )*+ #$'-. /&6&2 .&,'$( #1 )/$&6&($( &* /)(-( $')$
'- K#6-.*3-*$ 3)4 7.&*, ),)&*($ )/$&6&($( #6-. $'-&.
)/$&6&(3= G* +&(5#(&$&6- 3#$* 5.)/$&/- E2&*,( %&$' $'-
= L&($.&/$ M#;.$ 1#. "-% N#.0A( -)($-.* +&($.&/$ 3)+- 74
?((&($)*$ = ?@#.*-4 !"#$%&'&$ )*'+$8 $'-
K#6-.*3-*$ .-O-/$-+ )//;()$*( $')$ $'- LBP %)(
%&$''#2+&*, (;/' .-/#.+( 7-/);(-8 QH'-.- /)* 7- *#
%&$''#2+&*, %'-*8 )( &* $'&( /)(-8 *# .-(5#*(&6- .-/#.+(
-9&($=R H# *# (;.5.&(-8 ?? >&*,' )*+ #$'-.(8 &*/2;+&*,
?((&($)*$ = ?@#.*-4 ,'+-.& /-01+-8 ')6-
;..-5$&$(24 )/$-+ $# $'%).$ $'- .-2-)(- #1 (;/' .-/#.+(=
?? K-#.,- &( ) :-+-.)2 5.#(-/;$#.8 %'# $.&-+ SKFH
&6&2 .&,'$( )/$&6&($ S$= 2&'*-. 3$0*1#. '&( )/$&6&(3 $')$
).,-24 /#*$.&7;$-+ $# $'- #6-.D$;.*&*, #1 $'-
K#6-.*3-*$A( 1#.3-.24 +&(/.&3&*)$#.4 5#2&/4 ),)&*($
#5-* ,)4( )*+ 2-(7&)*( 1.#3 (-.6&*, &* $'- = 3&2&$).48
0*#%* )( QL#*A$ ?(08 L#*A$ H-22=R G* #55#(&$*
52-)+&*,(8 I.#,.-(( J;--*( ')( +-3#*($.)$-+ $')$ .-/#.+(
&0-24 -9&($ )*+ ')( 3)+- ) +-3)*+ 1#. $'#(- .-/#.+(=
$ &( *#$ 5.-/&(-24 0*#%* )$ %')$ $45- #1 &*6-($&,)$* $'-
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 37 of 57 PageID #: 1735
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
38/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 27ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"# %&%'%(')* %& +),-).' /0 '1) %&0/+2('%/& %', 3&*)+./4)+
&0/+2(&' 1(* +).)%4)* %& '1) .(,) /0 '1) 56 7%*8),'
-)(.) (.'%4%,',9 ").(3,) '1) -/:%.%), (&* -+/.)*3+), (::/8
/+ ;(,%. %& /&.) '1) !"# 1(* ./2-:)')* )&/3=1 /0 81(')4)+
?-) /0 %&4),'%=('%/&, '1)? ./22)&.)*> 8)+) 1(&*)* 3-
/ '1) K9L9 FU/+&)?,S IV.), %& )(.1 /0 Q1%.(=/ (&*
7%&&)(-/:%,9 #' 8(, ,1/8& '1(' !)*)+(: -+/,).3'/+, 8)+)
))W%&= %&0/+2('%/& 0+/2 '1) )A).3'%/& /0 '1) ,)(+.1
8(++(&', (;/3' +)./+*, ,1/8%&= 81)'1)+ '1) (.'%4%,', 1(*
-+/4%*)* O2(')+%(: (%*P '/ =+/3-, %*)&'%J)* ;? '1) K9L9
L).+)'(+? /0 L'(') '/ ;) 0/+)%=& ')++/+%,' /+=(&%M('%/&,>
&.:3*%&= '1) E/-3:(+ !+/&' 0/+ '1) X%;)+('%/& /0 E(:),'%&)9
G8/ 7%&&)(-/:%,B;(,)* (.'%4%,', 8)+) 2)2;)+, /0 (
=+/3- W&/8& (, '1) *+,,-./ $.0- 1.(20324)
&+506270)2.6> ( =+/3- '1('> (../+*%&= '/ G1) F,,/.%(')*
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 38 of 57 PageID #: 1736
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/06/21/AR2010062101811_pf.htmlhttp://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-1498.pdf -
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
39/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 28ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$$% '() *##+ ,-#+ (*,./ 0/$ 1("20$3 -'04,$,-'5% (+)
3#3*#"$ ,6 7"##),3 8,() '() *##+% 0+ /."+% $.--,"/09#
,6 (+,/'#" :",.-% /'# !"#$%&'($)*+, .+/"0 1$+2"3 $4
5$%&/6(*% ( :",.- "#6#""#) /, 0+ /'(/ +(/0,+ *5 /'#
(;",+53% 7 ?'# @,9#"+3#+/ 3()# 6(+/($/0;(4
(;;.$(/0,+$ (:(0+$/ ,+# ,6 /'# 3#3*#"$ ,6 7"##),3 8,()%4(030+: /'(/ 7"##),3 8,()% )#$-0/# +,/ '(90+: #+,.:'
3#3*#"$ (+) +,/ *#0+: A/'#"# 5#/%B '() ( -4(+ /, $#0C#
,;(/0,+$ ($ -("/ ,6 ("3#) "#9,4./0,+> ?'# @,9#"+3#+/
(4$, ;4(03#) /'(/ 7"##),3 8,() '() .$#) (;/090$3 /,
/##" 3,+#5 /, /'# 7$8&%*+ 1+$)' 4$+ '9" :(6"+*'($) $4
7*%"3'()"> D,/' 7J>
K#-("/3#+/ ,6 J/(/# *5 6,"3#" J#;"#/("5 ,6 J/(/#
;*0"%()" .%6+(%() !$$3"#"%''() ( )$?3'+(>" 8$%(2,E0/' $,3#
=,33.+0$/$ .+0,+ (;/090$/$ 0+ ,")#" /, :.("(+/## $/#()5
+).$/"0(4 -",).;/0,+ 6",3 ?'# 0)#($
,6 $,;0(4 (+) #;,+,30; -",/#;/0,+$ 6,"
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
40/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 29ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"# %&' &()& #')*'' +, -'"%*!. /+0'*"1'"% 2.!""(") +,
&' '-+"+13 %&!% &'.2'# 4)&% %&' !"#$% '#("#))*+,
5')!" %+ 5' 6"7+6"#8 !"# !-%(0(9%9 7(%& ! *'0+.6%(+"!*3
5'"% 5'-!1' %&' %!*)'% +, :-;!*%&3(91 ' -+*2+*!%(+"9>
:!"3 &61!" *()&%9 !-%(0(9%9 &!0' .+") +5@'-%'# %+ %&'
.!99(4-!%(+" +, 9+1' )*+629 !9 %'**+*(9% +*)!"(A!%(+"9>
:(""'!2+.(9 !-%(0(9%9 %!*)'%'# 53 %&' /+0'*"1'"% ,+*
"0'9%()!%(+"8 ,+* 'B!12.'8 +5@'-%'# %+ %&' C'2!*%1'"% +,
?%!%' -.!99(,3(") DEF; !"# %&' G+26.!* D*+"% !9 %'**+*(9%
+*)!"(A!%(+"9> ?'2!*!%'.38 &61!" *()&%9 !-%(0(9%9 +22+9'#
+ %&' (..')!. H9*!'.( +--62!%(+" +, %&' I'9% J!"K !"# %&'
/!A! 9%*(2 &!0' (",+*1'# G*+)*'99 L6''"9 %&!% 7&'" %&'
C'2!*%1'"% +, ?%!%' -.!99(4'9 -'*%!(" )*+629 !9 %'**+*(9%
+*)!"(A!%(+"98 %&' ="(%'# ?%!%'9 (9 2*+.+")(") &61!"
()&%9 0(+.!%(+"9 (" %&' ,+*'()" -+6"%*('9 7&'*' %&+9'
)*+629 +2'*!%'8 .(K' (" H9*!'.> H9*!'.8 ,+* 'B!12.'8 &!9 5''"
+6"# %+ 5' (" 0(+.!%(+" +, D+6*%& /'"'0! ;+"0'"%(+"8 !
*'!%3 7&(-& 5!*9 ! "!%(+" ,*+1 %*!"9,'**(") (%9 +7"
2+26.!%(+" ,*+1 7(%&(" (%9 +7" 5+*#'*9 ("%+ +--62('#
'**(%+*('9> C'92(%' %&' &61!" *()&%9 0(+.!%(+"98
'-+)"(A'# 53 %&' ="(%'# M!%(+"98 %&' ="(%'# ?%!%'9 &!9
'99'"%(!..3 1!#' (% (..')!. ,+* !-%(0(9%9 %+ !#0+-!%' +"
5'&!., +, 9+1' &61!" *()&%9 )*+629 7(%&(" H9*!'.>
"%'*9'-%(") 7(%& D'#'*!. )6(#'.("'9 ,+* %&' 2*+9'-6%(+" +,
!-%(0(9%9 (9 %&' "'78 2*+2+9'# M'7 N+*K ?%!%' .!78 7&(-&
+6.# 2+%'"%(!..3 )(0' D'#'*!. !6%&+*(%('9 ! .(9% +, &61!"
()&%9 !-%(0(9%9 !#0+-!%(") ,+* '-+"+1(- 9!"-%(+"9 !)!("9%
9*!'.8 7&(-& -+6.# -+"-'(0!5.3 5' ("%'*2*'%'# 53 D'#'*!.
2*+9'-6%+*9 %+ .'!# %+ ! #(1("(9&1'"% +, %&' 2*+2'*%3 +, !
+*'()" )+0'*"1'"%> :+*'0'*8 !9 +"' +, %&' !O+*"'39 ,+*
&' PQ :(#7'9% 2'!-' !-%(0(9%9 7!*"'#8 %&' /+0'*"1'"%
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 40 of 57 PageID #: 1738
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
41/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 30ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"# %&&' #&&()'* +,- .#& &/)0&'1& -2 3-4),)1"4 "1,)/),5
-33-#&0 ,- 6787 2-9&)*' 3-4)15 "# 39--2 -2 19):)'"4 )',&',7;
?-9( 8,",& 4">@ )',&9'",)-'"4 !.:"'
)*!,# "1,)/)#, !"#$%&' !")*,-40 A9-*9# B.&&'# ,!",
,",& 4&*)#4",-9# >&9& 19&",)'* " %"1(0--9 >"5 ,- 3.')#!
9&& #3&&1! %5 %"'')'* "1,)/)#,# 29-: 1-',9"1,)'* >),!
=&> ?-9( 8,",&@ "00)'* ,!", ,!)# ":-.',&0 ,- "
.9,")4:&', -2 1)/)4 4)%&9,) "'0 9)*!,# -2 )'0)/)0."4# "'0
-9*"')C",)-'# ,- "0/-1",& )' ,!& 3.%4)1 #3!&9&7
D- #-:& !.:"' 9)*!,# "1,)/)#,#@ ,!& E-/&9':&',F# &G-9,#
- ,"9*&, "1,)/)#,# )' 9&1, -2 0&:-'#,9",)-'#@ )'14.0)'*
"0/-1",)'* 2-9 %-51-H# "'0 &1-'-:)1 #"'1,)-'# -2 2-9&)*'
*-/&9':&',#@ 1-'/&')&',45 -/&94--( ,!& "0/-1"15 -2 -,!&9
*9-.3# ,!", #&',)"445 >"', ,- :")',")' " #,",.# I.- -2
!.:"' 9)*!,# /)-4",)-'#7 J!&9&"# ,!& 6'),&0 =",)-'# !"#
0&14"9&0 ,!", K#9"&4 )# /)-4",)'* !.:"' 9)*!,# -2 ),#
),)C&'#@ ,!& 6'),&0 8,", )# #)0,&33)'* "'5
-'#)%)4),5 ,- "1, ,- 39#.9& K#9"&4 ,- 1-:345 >),!
',&9'",)-'"4 !.:"' 9)*!,# 4">#7 K'#,&"0@ ,!& E-/&9':&',
!"# %&&' ,"9*&,)'* !.:"' 9)*!,# "1,)/)#,#@ "'0 #-:&
"1,)/)#,# ,-40 A9-*9# B.&&'# ,!", ,!& E-/&9':&',F#
"1,)-'# :"5 !"/& #-:&,!)'* ,- 0- >),! ,!& )'L.&'1& -2
-/&9#&"# *9-.3# "0/-1",)'* " #,",.# I.-7 K2 ), >&9& ,9.&
!", ,!& 6787 *-/&9':&', !"# %&&' :-9& 1-'1&9'&0 >),!
3-4),)1"4 )'L.&'1&@ +)',&9'",)-'"4 )' #1-3& >),! #.%/&9#)/&
-/&9,-'@; ,!&' ,!& 6787 !"# %&&' %&)'* 0.34)1),-.# "%-.,
!& &I."4 "334)1",)-' -2 ),# ->' 4&*"4 #,"'0"90@ &G&1,)/&45
"44->)'* 3-4),)1"4 %)"# ,- 0&,&9:)'& >!)1! )',&9'",)-'"4
'L.&'1& ,- ,9&", "# #.%/&9#)/&7
83&"()'* -2 ,!& =&> ?-9( 8,",& 8&'",-9#@ >!- /-,&0 ,-
3"## ,!& 3.91!"#)'* "'0 )'/,:&', 9,9)1,)-'# %)44@ M#7
A"9( #")0@ +D!&5 "9& "29")0 -2 NO8@ %&1".#& ),F# *")')'*
9"1,)-'@; 9&2&99)'* ,- ,!& )',&9'",)-'"4 %-51-H@ 0)/)#)-'@
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 41 of 57 PageID #: 1739
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
42/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 31ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"# %!"&'()"% *)+,*,"' !-!("%' '., /'!', )0 1%2!,34 56.)
7")8% 8.!' '., !&'9!3 (*:!&' )0 '., ;(33 8(33 ;,%4 ?!27
!##,#< 5;9' (' 8(33 .!+, ! &.(33("- ,@,&' A)" %:,,&.B4=
6.,2,!% '., 0)&9% )0 %)*, !&'(+(%'% *!C ;, )" '.,
,&."(&!3('(,% )0 '., :2):)%,# D,8 E)27 /'!', 3!8J5 %2# *;%!*$ *& *;#$!$( - ;+#4!,!$-+'
$L0!+'. -$ -0%2*+!%' %2-% 2-" #K!/%#" 0$"#+ %2# ABBA DE
E0!"#4!$#/6 5% :-/ -,!"/% %2# 4**/#$!$( -$" %2#
!(2%#$!$( *& >#"#+-4 !$8#/%!(-%!*$ (0!"#4!$#/ %2-% %2#
E*8#+$,#$% :-/ -
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
46/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 35ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%$&' )$* +,-./,-.# *$01#&2
. #1- %$-4 56 &5,- !"#$%$&7 #1- 85%-*.,-.# 4!& .5# &5
,9"1 #!*0-#$.0 #1- !"#$%$& !& ,9"1 !& #1- 85%-*.,-.#
4!& 65"9&$.0 5. #15&- &9::5*#$.0 )+;< !./ #1- =5:9>!*
)*5.#7 #1- #45 0*59:& #1!# #1- ?-:!*#,-.# 56 @#!#- 1!/
>!&&$A-/ !& #-**5*$&, 5*0!.$B!#$5.&2
@:-!C$.0 !D59# 1-* 5D&-*%!#$5.& !D59# #1- 85%-*.,-.#'&
!&- !& ! >!4E-* 65* &5,- 56 #1- !"#$%$&7 !$, 1!/ D--. >-0$#$,!#-7L J&2 =54-*
!$/7 *-6-**$.0 #5 #1- 85%-*.,-.#'& !""9&!#$5. #1!# #1-
!"#$%$& 4-*- !"#$.0 4$#1 !. $.#-.# #5 1!*,7 #1-. K$#
459>/ .5# 1!%- D--. ! )$* +,-./,-.# %$5>!#$5.2L
@$."- #1- 85%-*.,-.# /$/ .5# -!D>$&1 ! :*-/$"!#- 65* !.
.#-.# #5 1!*,7 #1!# >-!%-& 5:-. 65* $.#-*:*-#!#$5. 41-#1-*
1- .-# -M-"# 56 #1- 85%-*.,-.#'& $.#*9&$5. 5. #1-
:5>$#$"!> !"#$%$#$-& 56 #1- !"#$%$& !./ #1- ,$&"!$.0 56 #1-
-:9#!#$5.& 56 #1- !"#$%$& !& &9&:-"#& $. #-**5*$&,
.%-$0!#$5.& ,!E 1!%- %$5>!#-/ #1- HNNH +8 89$/->$.-&
. *-&:-"# 56 #1- 9&- 56 $.%-$0!#$%- #-"1.$O9-& /9*$.0
:*->$,$.!*E !./ 69>> $.%-$0!#$5.& 65* $.%-$0!#$5.& #1!#
5,,-."-/ $. #1- #$,- >-!/$.0 9: #5 #1- HNNP ;Q/ =*50*-&& G9--.& #1!# $6 #1- 85%-*.,-.#
1!/ D--. $.#-./$.0 #5 /$&*9:# #1- 6*-- &:--"1 56 !"#$%$&7
415 &9::5*#-/ 19,!. *$01#& $. 9,D$! !./ $. 3&*!->7
1-. #1- 85%-*.,-.#'& "!&- !0!$. #1- HI J$/4- :-!"-
!"#$%$& D!"CA*-/2
R1- 85%-*.,-.# /$/ .5# 1!%- #1- *-&:5.&- #1!# #1-E
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 46 of 57 PageID #: 1744
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
47/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 36ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%&' $)% *+,%-#.%#$ &/& #+$ 0)/11 $)% 2/-3$
4.%#&.%#$ -/5)$3 +6 "0$/,/3$3' "#& 78%+81% !%-% 3+ ."&9
)"$ $)%: +-5"#/;%& " 0".8"/5# $+ 8 +6 $)% H+../I%% $+ J$+8 2KG
L%8-%33/+#)"3 0+#$/##+!1%&5%"=1% "#& 0+
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
48/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 37ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#" %&'()*+ !"#$%&' )%*+,$"-., -.' )' /')0*( .'/12 3.*
4'23, -52 5) 544'6)3** '7 8(*261*)3 /,0$+, 12 3456" !"#"
%&'()*+ 96:0*(5/1 -52 )*;*( 6) =5) (60.32542 3.53
'44'2* '44(*226;* (*06=*2 6) 3.*6( (*24*3 3.*
!)63*1 #353*2 35A*2 )' 54 7'(=*(/+ ,, -52 236// ') 3.* !"#"
0';*()=*)3S2 3*(('(62= -53
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
49/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 38ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
!"#$%$# '($)* +,- !".$!$/' 01'$* '($ 2344$2213% $5"*'2
(0' 04').)2'2 32$# )/ '($ #).$2'!$/' !".$!$/' 060)/2'
-"3'( 71*)40 '(0' $.$/'30%%8 9*$223*$# '($ -"3'( 71*)40/
6".$*/!$/' '" $/# 090*'($)#: ;/#$$#< '($ =*2' 2'$9 '(0'
($ /0')"/ "1 -"3'( 71*)40 '""> '" $/# 090*'($)# ?02 '"
"*!0%%8 *$4"6/)@$'($ 71*)40/ A0')"/0% B"/6*$22 0/#"'($* 0/')C090*'($)# 6*"392 02 %$6)')!0'$ 9"%)')40%
"*60/)@0')"/2: D%')!0'$%8< '($ D:-: 1"%%"?$# 23)'< E3' )'
?02 #$40#$2 %0'$*:
F" !0/8 (3!0/ *)6('2 "*60/)@0')"/2< '(0' '($ D/)'$#
-'0'$2 ?02 ?*"/6 '" 4%022)18 '($ 71*)40/ A0')"/0%
B"/6*$22 02 0 '$**"*)2' "*60/)@0')"/ 0/# )'2 2%"? *$29"/2$
" "G4)0%%8 *$4"6/)@$ '($ 6*"392H ?"*> 1"* )'2 %$6)')!0'$
9"%)')40% 93*9"2$2 9")/'2 '" '($ I".$*/!$/'H2 10%%)E)%)'8 )/
($ *$0%! "1 6%"E0% (3!0/ *)6('2 ?"*>: F" 2"!$ (3!0/
)6('2 04').)2'2< 2399"*')/6 '($ ?"*> "1 6*"392 $/606$# )/
($ 2'*366%$ '" $/# 090*'($)# )/ ;2*0$%< "*< 0%'$*/0').$%8< '"
399"*' 0 E"84"J "1 ;2*0$% 3/')% ;2*0$% $/#2 )'2 *$6)!$ "1
090*'($)#< )2 4"!90*0E%$ '" ?($/ (3!0/ *)6('2 04').)2'2
399"*'$# '($ ?"*> "1 '($ 71*)40/ A0')"/0% B"/6*$22 '"
$/# 090*'($)# )/ -"3'( 71*)40 #$40#$2 06"< "*
0%'$*/0').$%8< '" (0.$ 2399"*'$# 0 E"84"J "1 -"3'( 71*)40
3/')% -"3'( 71*)40 $/#$# )'2 *$6)!$ "1 090*'($)#: F($
"6)4 "1 '($ I".$*/!$/' '" %0E$% 6*"392 %)>$ '($ 71*)40/
A0')"/0% B"/6*$22 02 0 '$**"*)2' "*60/)@0')"/ !$0/2 '(0'& #/0'& "!'&' !' 3&$*.
!30,# #/& 32&!?$*. 0; 5&-&2!+ +!
1&01+& #0 '&2%& !' $*;027!*#' #0 $*A+#2!#& %&.!*
.!#/&2$*.' $* 02-&2 ;02 #/& $*;027!*#' #0 L2,3 '/0,+-&2'
6"# /!- 3&&* .,T&- 34 W8J8 J,12&7& I0,2# -&"$'$0*'(
*"+,-$*. #/& X!#&' "!'&( #/& C0%&2*7&*#
!11+$"!3+& #0 #/& 5QB #0 !11!2&*#+4 #!2. !"#$%$'#' ;02 #/&$2
-&0+0.48 N/&'& .,$-&+$*&' !2& '&+;S1207,+.!#&- 34 #/&
W8J8 6T02*&4 C&*&2!+8
H0 7!T&2
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
55/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 44ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
"#$% $'#()(*+ ",-# !.%/#' .0 #10!+2 3%(1 !"# 45 0#,6#
,6!$-$7!7 $/ !"# 8$'9#7!: !( !"# ,/!$;9,% ,6!$-$7!7 $/
.%*: !( ,6!$-$7! 1#1>#%7 (? ##/ ,>)# !( 0%(-# $! #7!,>)$7"#' !"# 0%#'$6,!#7 !(
(11#/6# (% 6(/!$/.# $/-#7!$*,!$(/7 !",! 9#%# >,7$6,))+
(./'#' (/ ,6!$-$7!7D $'#()(*+ ,/' ,00,%#/!)+ /(!"$/*#)7#2 E? !"# 4FGF EHC I#0(%!: !"# J(.%/,)$7!!"#$%&
'()%"K)#' , %#0(%!?(% !"# %&'()&*+: 6(/6).'$/* !",!: LA"#
4FM;0,*# %#0(%!: 7$*/#' >+ H/70#6!(% C#/#%,) C)#// B2
3$/#: 6(/6).'#' !",! 9"$)# /(/# (? !"# *%(.07 9#%#
,%*#!#' >+ !"# 3NH ?(% !"#$% -$#97 ,)(/# ;; (/# (? !"# O#+
,))#*,!$(/7 1,'# >+ 6%$!$67 (? !"# 7.%-#$)),/6# ;; !"#
N.%#,. /#-#%!"#)#77 #/*,*#' $/ !,6!$67 ,/' 7!%,!#*$#7
(9,%' !"(7# *%(.07 ,/' !"#$% 1#1>#%7 !",! 9#%#
/,00%(0%$,!#: 1$7)#,'$/*: ,/' $/ 7(1# 6,7#7
(./!#%0%('.6!$-#2P
A"# C(-#%/1#/! ,00#,%7 !( ># ?(6.7#' (/ %#*,$/$/* !"#
0(9#% !( $/-#7!$*,!# ,/' 0%(7#6.!# ,6!$-$7!7 7()#)+ ?(%
"#$% $'#()(*+: ,7 9,7 !"# 6,7# >#!9##/ !"# !$1# ,?!#% !"#
Q1$!" B6! 9,7 #/,6!#' >.! >#?(%# !"# Q1$!" B6! 9,7
*.=#' >+ R2Q2 Q.0%#1# S(.%! '#6$7$(/72 T$!"$/ 3#'#%,)
,9 #/?(%6#1#/! ,*#/6$#7: !"#%# 1.7! 7!$)) %./ , LI#'
6,%#P;)$O# 0,%,/($, ,>(.! !"# %#?(%1 #U(%!7 (? *%,77%((!7
*%(.07 !",! ",7 /(9 !%,/76#/'#' 9(%%$#7 ,>(.! !"#
0%#,' (? S(11./$71: >.! /(9 $/6).'#7 6%$!$67 (? R2Q2
(%#$*/ 0()$6+ ,/': #-#/: ,/$1,) %$*"!7 ,6!$-$7!72
A"# 4FGF EHC I#0(%! )((O#' >,6O ,! 6,7#7 !",! !"# 3NH
/-#7!$*,!#' '.%$/* !"# ,'1$/$7!%,!$(/ (? ?(%1#%
-
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
56/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
Page 45ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act
COMMENTS (0) "#$%&'($) *(+ ),-+(.
! LAW FIRM REPRESENTING MANHATTAN FEDERAL JUDGE
/%0 123)'4 25) 26 78) +92'5):% 62' 78) ;< /(=3)%7 >)+&)
+&7(*(%7%4 %+(= 78+74 ?@7A% 527 + B)-2&'+7 2' C)>#$.(&+5
%%#)0 @7A% 78) 5+7#') 26 78) %7+7)0 @7 3(.. =2 38+7 (7 5))=%4
2 >')%)'*) (7%).60D
EFGHICFB
E)=)'+. J#(=).(5)%2' 78) >'2%)(25
26+&7(*(%7% +>>)+' 72)&25%7'#&7 + .)J+.'+-)32'K .2%7
#5=)' 78) "-(78 G&7
1'))7 L8+'+'+ %#)%M.)5322=/+5+J)-)574+..)J(5J 6+(' 82#%(5J+&&)%%($(.(7:*(2.+7(25%
N)3 O2'K $(.. 25$2:&29% -+: 8+*)&'(-(5+. (->.(&+7(25%62' 8#-+5 '(J87%+&7(*(%7% PQ2'')&7)=R
# Louis Flores$ Comment
FOIA, Civil Rights, Unions
& Eric Holder, Barrack Obama, U.S. Department Of Justice, PATRIOT Act, Smith
ct, Communism, Marxism, Leninism, Political Ideology, Human Rights, Civil
ights, First Amendment, Civil Liberties, Activism, Activists, Freedom Of
nformation Act, Indictment, Selective Prosecution, Lt. Daniel Choi, Aaron Swartz,
Melinda Power, Pauline Park, Israel, Palestine, Preet Bharara, Silk Road, Freedom
oad Socialist Organization, Revolutionary Armed Forces Of Columbia, Popular
ront For The Liberation Of Palestine, African National Congress, Nelson
Mandela, Joseph McCarthy, RoAnn Destito
0 Likes Share
N)3)%7 E('%7
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 56 of 57 PageID #: 1754
http://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=RoAnn+Destitohttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Joseph+McCarthyhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Nelson+Mandelahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=African+National+Congresshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Popular+Front+for+the+Liberation+of+Palestinehttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Revolutionary+Armed+Forces+of+Columbiahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Freedom+Road+Socialist+Organizationhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Silk+Roadhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Preet+Bhararahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Palestinehttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Israelhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Pauline+Parkhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Melinda+Powerhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Aaron+Swartzhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Lt.+Daniel+Choihttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=selective+prosecutionhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=indictmenthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Freedom+of+Information+Acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=activistshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=activismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=civil+libertieshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=First+Amendmenthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=civil+rightshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=human+rightshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=political+ideologyhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Leninismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Marxismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Communismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Smith+Acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=PATRIOT+Acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=U.S.+Department+of+Justicehttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Barrack+Obamahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Eric+Holderhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?category=Unionshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?category=Civil+Rightshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?category=FOIAhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-the-prosecution-of-activists-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act#commentinghttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?author=54174acee4b0294e676e7581http://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/2/new-york-bill-on-boycotts-may-have-criminal-implications-for-human-rights-activistshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/4/preet-bharara-sues-glenwood-management-alleging-fair-housing-accessibility-violationshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-the-prosecution-of-activists-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/2/new-york-bill-on-boycotts-may-have-criminal-implications-for-human-rights-activistshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/4/preet-bharara-sues-glenwood-management-alleging-fair-housing-accessibility-violationshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-the-prosecution-of-activists-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-arm -
7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)
57/57
24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens
!"#$%#& Post Comment
Copyright 2015 by Progress Queens, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 57 of 57 PageID #: 1755