201505 peer review-early-adopter-paglione
TRANSCRIPT
orcid.org
early adopter program peer review
2015 may laura paglione
technical director, ORCID [email protected]
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-3188-6273
goals of this program ● provide working use case examples for peer
review with ORCID iDs ● enable immediate utility to researchers upon ORCID release of peer review functionality ● highlight and promote our early adopters and supporters
orcid.org
Early Adopter Program: Peer Review
ORCID and peer review
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
peer review working group • established february 2014
• recommendations published april 2014 • http://casrai.org/standards/subject-groups/peer-review-service
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
data model & citation standard • PERSON: person who performed review & being
recognized for review activity. • REVIEW: review itself. For blind or unshared reviews, may
be left blank. • SUBJECT: subject of the review, i.e., the paper, grant, etc.
For blind or unshared reviews, may be left blank. • ORGANIZATION: organization recognizing the person
for review activity, such as a publisher, association or funder.
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
rich review citation • PERSON: Laura AD Paglione; http://orcid.org/
0000-0003-3188-6273; ROLE: reviewer • REVIEW: TYPE: review; DOI: 20934/28.293; REVIEW
DATE: 2015-04; http://URLofReview.com • SUBJECT: Title of Item Reviewed; Nature; journal article;
DOI: 20934/230.38920; http://URLofItemReviewed.com • ORGANIZATION: Nature Publishing Group; publisher ;
RINGGOLD ID: 53264
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
sparse review citation • PERSON: Laura AD Paglione; http://orcid.org/
0000-0003-3188-6273; ROLE: reviewer** • REVIEW: TYPE: review** • SUBJECT: Nature**; journal article* • ORGANIZATION: Nature Publishing Group; publisher ;
RINGGOLD ID: 53264
* optional information ** optional, but recommended
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
on orcid.org – the fields (api only)
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
on orcid.org – the user interface
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
process flow – from your site
orcid.org
TO: [email protected] FROM: Grateful Journal Thank you for reviewing this article. Would you like to be recognized on your ORCID Record?
Your Site
</> determine reviewer
format API call
your site sends review activity to the ORCID record
your site asks for permission
ORCID sends info (and the user) to your site
process flow – from ORCID wizard
orcid.org
Your Site
</> determine reviewer
format API call
your site sends review activity to the ORCID record
ORCID initiates permission request
ORCID sends info (and the user) to your site
LINK PEER REVIEW Grateful Journal Grateful Journal recognizes peer reviewers on ORCID records... Other Journal Add your review activity to your record
process flow – already have permission
orcid.org
Your Site
</> determine reviewer format API call
if so, your site sends review activity to the ORCID record
check if you already have stored permission
?
have permission?
communications
orcid.org PHOTO: suessian megaphone www.flickr.com/photos/theparadigmshifter/470341923
communications – what we will do • joint news release deployed to our media contact list • social marketing (Twitter, Facebook and, shortly, LinkedIn):
we will @ mention you
• blog post on ORCID.org (include quotes from someone from your organization if desired)
• promotion at conferences we attend / speak at
orcid.org PHOTO: suessian megaphone www.flickr.com/photos/theparadigmshifter/470341923
communications – what you can do • keep us updated on your progress / coordinate peer
review launch date with ours • provide feedback on the peer review API and UI to the
ORCID team • share example workflows, code libraries, end-user
communications for peer review with the community • liaise re marketing efforts • share endorsements / feedback from your stakeholders
orcid.org PHOTO: suessian megaphone www.flickr.com/photos/theparadigmshifter/470341923
next steps • join & participate in the peer review early adopters forum
• respond to forum question–expected launch date? • respond to forum question–planned early application?
• review the tech “getting started” document for links to the API and example workflows
• respond to Alice’s requests for more information about your communication plans
orcid.org PHOTO: Peer Review, https://flic.kr/p/bgepei Source: Research to Action www.researchtoaction.org/reviewing-peer-review
