psruetheses.psru.ac.th/.../files/site/default/thesis/ch4_151.pdf · 2015. 9. 11. · 2....
TRANSCRIPT
. ' 9
w'n~snszuaums~i9awuia'iiai - x S.D.
i.&iunis8~ana
2. &;7¶dfll5<Fl
3. ~iunis8ibaunds:m~
4.81un1swinaiu8uw'uisz~ii9~~d51
~uarmlar ranzardn6u~ani atdar5ua'aq
5. hunisiiuaa
6. ~ i u m r knsadi~m~donaiuwuiu4~~a
7. ~iuntnnuftmiiuoin4~~a
8.~1uniswuinsti P)
9. i iunisihnuu~2iu
lo. ~iumsCiinunu'uiu~~~nl~G~nis
1 1 . ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ 1 ~ F l b 6 ~ Z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a b b d ~
12. 81unisw~lao.1
1 3 . 8 1 ~ m ~ ~ n ? l ~ ~ l n ~ b b a ~ a 9 ~ 8 d ~ d
saoliiasadu
%auaz s:&~naiua41%~
1.66
1.37 ~ Oa9I ~ 1.25
2.02
O e g 5
: 1" 2.1
1.54
I.*" 1.6
1.6
I 9.61
55.37
45.80
45.66
41.67
67.42
42.56
48.62
54.68
73.28
52.07
43.97
55.30
53.65
53.00
0.92
0.75
0.63
0.83
0.94
0.72
0.87
0.99
0.99
0.87
0.80
1.06
0.93
6.22
diunaiq
diunai9
diuna19 1
diunni9 I
@ diuna1.a I
I
=diunni9
d iuna i~
flq
d1unai.a
dlodf1a19
diunai9
di1anai9 1 I
diunaiq I
- x S.D.
0.3 1 0.49
2.19 0.84
2.35 0.92
2.37 0.8 1
2.36 0.93
a i n ~ 1 5 i 9 9 wuii naiul;ilo8iu3ni3~19 wuimnfii uo~rinbuunu lumwrauodlu
sr~uqs'~inrlUdo~o~TruirSu~~u$nw'ui~ n1~5itw ~ t i ~ o q n f l l ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ f l l 3 ~ ~ ) ~ 0 ~ l ~ ~ ~ f l l 3 6 ~ ~ v i 6 q n ierni.rG4nuaZ~iu o~'lusz6uq-r daurn36 r l u m u o u n ~ ~ o a ~ ~ r n n ~ ~ u 3 z ~ u ~ i a i n
8 . 6 1 u n i s ~ u i n s d Y
9. ~ l u n l s ~ d m u ~ ~ l u
lo. &urns h n ~ R ~ ~ i ¶ ~ A ~ d d ~ s J " ~ n i ~
-
S.D.
0.89
0.75
0.69
0.82
0.97
0.69
0.89
0.98
1.02
0.88
m131.r is riita&~ didaut6u.riuuui~sliu~iaz4e,unz otn-iiuu uo.r?lmmi.r?nui~id
uoecnd uuw Gc I
diunais
L f l BlVl U w ' n ~ z m z u a u n i ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ i 8 ( i a ~ ; 1 ~ t- value Sig
8. Ziuniswuinsd P)
9 . ~ 1 u n i ~ ~ a s m r ~ w ' ~ i u 4 014
lo. ~iurn3iiinua~uiuiDad~'t)wni~
t- value
0.819
-0.862
-1.760
-1.515
1.071
0.129
-0.533
diw"uun195nuiainai ~ i g
0.413
0.389
0.079
0.130
0.285
0.898
0.594
~wantfjs - x
W~BYIU
1. Gswcqwn
2. Gnaiuouinfouin~iiu
3. Znaiu'len5is d w sd 9 d
4. w ~ ~ d ~ n n i 9 n ~ o a s n n a 8 ~ ~
5. i n a i ' ~ 4 0 ~ ~ 1 6 ~ ~ n ~ e ~ ~ u n a i q
6. i a i ~ m i o k j i s ~ o u n o u i o u n i ~
6 d ~ % e
s a u i i m i u
S.D. - x
2.26
1.99
2.42
2.10
1.40
1.9 1
12.08
S.Cl.
0.89
0.89
0.87
0.97
0.96
1.01
3.87
1.92
2.27
1.97
1.49
1.92
11.89
Os9! 1.0
1-02
0.97
0.93
1.06
3.94
oinms1.r 21 wuii ts~GuuFiuqlnnFinu1n11 i j ~ a 1 ~ ~ 4 1 l a
~iu52ni~rn.t?nuiaiami ldow'o1ra1i3uriu8~wui1 mrf?inun
n~zuaums~i~aanin?-id
wi~5wuiaia~i
1. %n~swiGwu~a~ami
2. Gn~~znszuaunis wi~5nuiaiami
3. fiiGeruwi-r5wu1a1ami
saufii~aiu
LM ~ C I ~ I ~ J
x 1 9.57
19.72
11.89
41.15
iwaw{s
s.13.
2.79
6.46
3.94
11.37
t- value
-2.777*
0.342
-0.533
-0.656
- x
10.21
19.52
12.08
41.81
Sig
0.006
0.732
0.594
0.512
S.D.
2.22
6.03
3.87
10.58
tw mi u
1.89 0.89 1.76 0.58 0.969 0.336
1.60 0.70 1.17 0.66 2.897* 0.005
0.98 0.71 1.07 0.46 -0.805 0.423
1.34 O.EO 1.66 0.86 -1 302 0.074
2.58 0.66 1.97 1.05 2.960* 0.005
0.86 0.44 -0.31 1 0.757
1.45 0. 6 1.45 0.73 0.035 0.972
O-"
o", 1.68 1 . 2 1.83 1.17 -0.642 0.522
2.50 0.82 2.69 0.66 ,-1.134 0.259
1.88 0.74 1.83 0.71 0.302 0.763
1.59 0.77 1.34 0.81 1.475 0.143
1 1.89 1.06 1.79 0.77 0.438 0.662
1 1.79 0.95 1.14 0.95 1.880 0.063
22.01 5.06 20.83 4.59 1.117 0.266
. x S.C
nawi$ t- value -
x Sig
S.D.
-
61Guumiq9m uiaiani t- value Sig
rwff %IU M"n~zns:uaunis wiGwuiaiarni t- value
1. 8iunisiYann
2. &iuflisTn
3. &;iunis9iriunnJszmw
4. ~iunis~imaiu3uw"uis~wii~
arrnJarn"unanla. ira:nadnn"uiani
aranlarn"u:ng
5. 81un1s~1uam
6. 6iunis~nns:fiiira:de,nai%~~uiu
C y a
7. ~iua.maiunP~i~~in40ya
8. 81ufliswu1ns& Y
9.&iunis64auu~3iu n w n lo. 8ium~Ainunu'siur~~dgu~nis
11. 6iunis61~u~arn:~auqu6a~anls
12.6iuniswna0s
13. 81urn~~nai%~nlnuua:a~4~ar~sJ
s a w i i m i u
Sig
~ ~ L U ~ U ~ ~ L L R ~ W I R " J I ¶ . J $ in amu bw aw ds t- value
-2.035*
-1.1 16
-1.663
-1.797
- x
11.29
23.85
14.34
49.48
- wis1wuiaiani x S.D. Sig
0.049
0.272
0.099
0.08 1
S.D. ---- 1.23
3.98
2.30
5.29
I. Gnisw~a1wu1mn~ii 2. Gnnransru~launi5wi91~~1~1inni
~ . ~ I G u u w I ~ ? V ~ U I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
YJU~I~Q&J
10.61
22.57
13.43
46.61
1.64.
5 . 6 ~
3.10
7.90
Aiu"uuwit?wuiainfii t- value Sig
94 aanisn19?wuiaiami t- value Sig
1.6iunisZanol
2. 41unisTm
3.4iunisIir~unnlszmw
4. 8 1 u n i s ~ i ~ a i u ~ u w " u 9 " s ~ ~ i i ~
n~dnlnhmdnln 1~n:nidn6viani
n~dnlnfh'hq
5. 8iunis4iuam
6. &iunis~mnszsjji~~a:8nwaiu~uiu
Cqa 7. eiiun~naiu~m~iiu~in6v'nqa
8. ~ l ~ f l l ~ ~ ~ l f l ~ d Y
9. eiiunisitnuuZ~iu
lo. 41ums Aiwu~iiviu~D~d~Gtnis
1 I. humsiii~uann%na~~u6ab~ds
12. ~ 1 ~ ~ 1 3 ~ R ~ 8 9
13. 8iunis~naiu~uiubbazat4on~d
~ I ~ U ~ J W I ~ ? W U I ~ I T I ~ ~
1. Zmqwn
2. i j n a i ~ ~ ~ n $ ~ l n ~ i i u
3. inaiuIon319 a 4 O1 4dp
4. ~ojb4otvnn19wsoksananw~
5. i j n a i u ~ o ~ a ~ i ~ n z 1 ~ ~ ~ u n n i 9
6. % Q I ~ ~ I ~ ~ I ~ ~ Q Y ~ ~ P I ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~
~%Gw%Q saudirraih
~ ~ ~ l m t l
x
2.66
2.17
2.69
2.71
1.88
2.51
14.63
bW flp149
S.D.
0.59
0.89
0.63
0.67
0.76
0.66
2.24
t- value
-0.262
2.243*
0.182
1.056
0.212
0.317
-1.697
- x
2.70
1.60
2.65
2.45
1.85
2.45
13.70
Sig
0.795
0.029
0.857
0.300
0.851
0.752
0.209
S.D.
0.57
0.94
0.81
0.99
0.49
0.83
3.16
ns~~aums~ma~mnaiu$
wi.Gwuiainni
1.3niswi.aSnuiainsl i
2. ~ n ~ ~ n s ~ u a u n i s w i ~ S w u i ~ i n m f
3. t4iGuuwi~Swuiainni
s a u i i m i u
t- value
-4.094*
-1.927
1.270
-1.697
Sig
0.000
0.059
0.209
0.096
LW 8 9~1u i w a ~ i $ - x
9.74
23.17
14.63
47.54
- x
11.90
25.40
13.70
51.00
S.D.
2.841
4.56
2.24
8.09
S.D.
0.97
3.20
3.16
5.52
t- value
1.007
0.214
1.453
-2.347*
-1.555
. Sig
0.328
0.832
0.169
0.024
0.142
4d
asni%n19Swuiainor1i
1 . n i r ~ i ~ u ~ u ~ n r r w o r 1 w ~ ~ ~ ~ w i sr
iwa~ds
-1.425 '0.177
- x
0.09
2.26
2.74
2.58
2.45
10.13
2. nis~~nuol?giu
3. m=innnoq imr m=iiiiubo%n
4. ~ 1 5 ~ 1 f l 5 1 ~ w " r u * 0 ~ ~
5. nisn3dera
sauiimiu
S.D.
0.30
0.68
0.44
0.62
0.62
1.34
iw B-%IU
- x
0.23
S.C
0.44
2.31 2.23
2.00
1.85
8.62
O S 7 1 1.2
l.CO
1.34
3d3
1. &iunisJsinm
2. 6iunisTn
3. %iiunisGiriundszmw
4. %;7unist11naiu~u~uBdSzt1iis
ardaharidar rm~nrelan'flrani
arrdaiYpIT~q
5.61unisAiuanr
6. 6 i u n i s ~ n n r ~ i i r r n z d ~ ~ a i ~ ~ w ~ ~ i u
4oyn
7. Aiunsmaiu5~ti/uoin+
8.4iunis~uinsoJd Y
9. &iunisisnuuSqiu
lo. Kiunis h w u ~ ~ u i u i % s d ~ ~ % n i s
11. ~iunis6iwu~ranzaapIqu~aaads
12.8iuniswnn0s
13. ~iunirlnaiuwlnuainznsBu*~ar~d
Sig
~i~uuniq?nuiaiawi
1. imqwn
2. ~ ~ ~ I U ~ U I ~ I $ D ~ J I ~ L ~
3. i ~ a i u l s n f i q 4 d ., sds ed
4. W~4o1rnmqwsoaqflnaan~j
5. i ~ a i u ~ o d w ~ d i i a ~ ~ a ~ ~ u f l ~ i ~
6. ~ ~ 1 3 6 ~ 1 0 ~ 1 9 3 ~ ¶ J ~ ~ P I ti~pdfllf
in?u%e
sau61iradu
awawt$a iWfl%IU t- value
1.921
-2.755*
-2.694*
-1.908
-0.330
0.124
-1.563
- x
1.77
2.39
2.48
1.90
1.16
1.35
11.06
x
2.23
1.54
1.30
1.30
1.08
1.38
8.85
Sig
0.062
0.015
0.017
0.063
0.776
0.902
0.139
S.D.
0.67
0.56
0.77
0.87
0.69
0.66
2.46
S.D.
0.83
1.05
1.49
1.11
0.45
0.87
4. 6
*PC .05
sinais1.r 40 wuii ~ $ 9 IssdaudiunQos in~ iu~41%0Xiu
~ s ~ Y ~ u ~ s L L ~ ~ ~ H I ~ ~ I ~ ~
ni~%nuiainf i i
1. %niswi~~wuiainvti
2. ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ Y ? ~ ~ l ~ ~ l 9 ~ ~ ~ l f f l ~ ~ <
3. ~ 7 i h . ~ ~ i 9 5 ~ ~ 1 f f i n a <
3 ' 2 ~ 6 7 L ~ i t J
L I ~ H H ~ ~ mer'111u
96
asnisnifiwuierinvt;
1. n l 3 ~ l M ~ ~ ( u D ~ L ( u f i ( u 0 9 ~ ~ ~ 7 Y
2. nir~anuuGjiu
3. m3nnno.r i~n-nis~~uGoya
4. rnsimsizvi4otn
5. nisn.gnl~n
t- value
-1.425
0.591
-1.563
-0.802
x
10.13
14.97
11.06
36.16
- x
8.62
15.85
8.85
33.31
sao~dll~du 6.78 1179 8.41 2.12 -2.117* 0.040
aw eraiu - s
0.22
1.78
1.67
1.67
1.44 -
S.D.
0.44
0.83
1.12
0.50
OJ88
Sig
0.177
0.557
0.139
0.437
S.D.
1.34
3.58
2.46
4.24
s.11.
3.73
6.22
4.86
12-53
twer~6.r t- value
-0.228
-0.639
-1.081
-2.405*
-0.867
- x
0.26
1.97
2.09
2.35
1.73 ----
Sig
0.821
0.526
0.306
0.021
0.391
S.D.
0.51
0.79
0.67
0.81
0.89
Sig
1. hunisir'sinol
2.41unisTn
3. ~lunls~liiund~z~~w
4. & C 7 ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ 7 ~ 8 U ~ ~ m " ~ ~ M ~ 1 9
aidnhnidn irnznidafi~iaai
nidnn'fl5~q
5. %;iunisdiiuam
6. ~ i u n i s ~ n n s z i i i i a z i S a n a i ~ ~ ~ ~ i u
Goqa
7. &iun.raailmPniiiu~in4ayn
8. &unis~uinsd Y
9. &iunis~~noJnr~qiu
lo. Kiunia hnunu'uio~Bad~3Snis
11. Ciiurn~inu~imzaa~q0~W"aiids
12. #iuniswmna9
~ ~ . # I u ~ S ~ ~ ~ ? I X I M X I I U H ~ Z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
*P< .05
a i n ~ i s i ~ 43 w u i i J n B u u ~ i u t t n z SnBu 1s.rBuuynaSusi.a 8na iu i $ i l o# iu
diGuun1~9~uiainmi luniwsaulojarolnBi19n'u Gnaia~lon419 99d ianBiiariuoli i -r i jJua~i~~~i~anm6s~~u .os
t- value
-0.447
- 1.052
2.784*
0.600
-0.027
1.505
0.640
i iGuun is?nu ia iami
1. Gmqwn
2. Gnaiuouinfauinri iu
3. Gnaiulonfi ls rr 4 QI ed
4 . l d r ~ o % m n 1 9 n s 0 ~ 4 f l n f i m
5. ~naiu$o~~Blbrrnz~or~unni~
6. Goi~sldiodissounop16ounis
~ ? u $ o
saudiiraiu
.
1
Sig
0.657
0.299
0.009
0.552
0.978
0.140
0.526
rwflr iu rwanifjs
x
1.33
1.33
2.56
1.56
0.67
1.67
9.1 I
- x
1.50
1.74
1.82
1.32
0.68
1.18
8.24
S.1:
1.00
1.03
0.53
0.88
1.12
0.
2.89
S.D.
0.99
1.02
1.14
1.07
0.91
0.90
3.81
nszuau rn3~ ina .1~ iaa iu f
w i ~ % w u i a i n m i
1 . 3 n i s ~ i q 4 w u i a i n n i
2. Gn~zns:nraunis~i~~wuiaia~1i
3. 6 1 G u u ~ i G w u i a i n ~ i
s a u d m &
t- value
-2.117*
0.556
0.640
0.049
Sig
0.040
0.581
0.526
0.961
mawis
t- valuc
-0.409
-0.829
-1.868
-0.063
-1.689
-1.736
a‘S
a s n i s w i . a % ~ o i a i a ~ ~
1. ~ 1 ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ 6 U D ~ i ~ ~ ~ 8 9 ~ ~ ~ 1 Y
2. ni=ihanrnrZziu
3. mmslno.a irtlzmriiiu4n%n
4. nis%msizwd4o~n
5. n i~nqdern
saudirw$u
- x
8.41
13.65
8.24
30.29
iaamu
Sig
0.685
0.419
0.070
0.950
0.100
0.092
S.D.
0.51
1.09
lJol
0.89
0,98
2-60
iwa.lriu - s
0.38
1.77
1.77
2.15
1.84
7.92
S.D.
2.12
4.48
3-81
8.50
- x
6.78
14.56
9.11
30.44
S.D.
1.79
3.81
2.89
6.21
twaw6-a - x
0.48
2.04
2.30
2.17
2.35
9.35
S.D.
0.73
0.64
0.70
0.94
0.78
2.23
Sig
di~uuwid?wuiainmi
1. iimtyn
2. inaiuouinfouiniiiu
3. inaiulon51s rr d w ads ed
4.lii4o1vnais~3oad~nnnnm
5. ~na iu~o~nu"uar~o i f lunn i~
6. W4~i~~iee i i~~ounopI f iouni~
~ @ ~ u % Q
saudim6u
iwa~{s
5
t- value
-1.217
-1.095
-3.110*
-4.475*
-0.674
-2.436*
-4.195*
- x
1.91
2.04
2.52
2.39
1.52
1.96
12.35
LW RTIU Sig
0.232
0.291
0.007
0.000
0.505
0.020
0.000
S.D.
0.67
0.64
0.67
0.94
0.95
0.88
2.55
- s
1.62
1.61
1.31
0.92
1.31
1.15
7.92
S.D.
0.78
1.33
1.32
0.55
0.d6
1.
3.77
n ~ ~ u a u m ~ ~ i a a ~ m ~ a i u f
wisSwuiaiawi
I . %ni3widSiuiaiawi
2. ~ n u z n ~ z u a ~ l n i 3 w i ~ ~ w u i a i a w i
3. i~Guuw~qSwu~a~awi
3 3 ~ f i i k ~ &
iw BVI u - x
7.92
1 3 . 6
7.92
29.31
iwands
S.D.
2.60
5.36
3.77
9.93
t- value
-1.736
-2.541*
-4.195*
-3.468*
- x
9.35
17.35
12.35
39.04
Sig
0.092
0.016
0.000
0.001
S.D.
2.23
3.79
2.55
6.89
2 2 a@ a@
a a
8 6 a t
a s uzz aa 7 9 -3
-s 8 3 3 5 -E c c '" 5 c -.
g E E
3 g - z s g2 c
TI76 ag 9 bg 6; C -G - 7 5 ,- aco -F lr. F aa c lr. G
%@ x2 I. a g F a
"5
acD 7 9 8
G
I]m c aco 3 s 5 a P
2
C C -P -p 3 J J ag
g -& 0, a? c 9 9 5 r lr. s z G GI C F C 3 C, % -0s r 5
v a g a@
!? 0 ? "3 -e
*P< .05
I ainnsw 51 wuii n a i u d i l ~ ~ i u % n i ~ ~ i . r ~ ~ u i ~ i n a i ludauuoqmsi.rnuu%iu
r:nii.rnoiu;lnln wuii T3.rduuw"uqTanQn inudnaiui~~npii~n'uF3~duuw"~lqFan4nui
~s~$uuasiiuua'qnn~dnaiui~an~i~n'u~~.rduu~p~ Tnn4nln b.rSuuyna3usi.a aaazTs.ri3uu
wq-r31gf I.r~Suu~uqTan8nuidrnaiu~~ansii.r~ Ir~duuprnns~si~5nuiGu imzh.rduu
d1unfo.r 1~.rduupmn.rolnv4~ui~u~rnaiu~i~ di.rfiuT~.r8uuqns~u~ia i~a:ls.rSuu
wqaiugi Tnulinduu13.rduuw"uqFanw"nuin iaaiui#il~uinniiinduuF~~duuw"uqFan
Rnw ~ ~ d ~ ~ b ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 Q ~ ~ 6 ~ a ' ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ b ( u ' i ~ ~ ~ l niirinduuh~duuw"uq1an8nui insou
Ts-aduuyna$u.na ~mzinAuuTs.rliuuw~~~iugi rin8uulmduu diunf~.rdnaiui#ile
uinnii~3qduuw"~qlan8nui Gnn$uul3qduup i nsasi.a~nuihdnaiub#i~~uinn~iw'n~uu
F~.ri?uuw"~qlon4nui linSuul3cduuqna$u3iv 1 I a~induul~.r$uuwq.rsiugi
PssGuu
w"uqlanw"nu1nu (2.34)
ma"o~%a'~fld (2.50)
w'uqFan8nui ( I .8s)
~winsa3iv~wuia'u
(2.46)
diwn+os (2.27)
V~WB$~~I'% (1.93)
wqtsiupi ( 1.94)
p m n ~ ~
3 IT
3wu1;u
(2.64)
-0.29
-0.13
3 % ~ - Fan
80~ l l
(1.88)
0.46*
0 * T - o . 7 , *
diunfo~
(2.27)
0.06
0.23
-0.39*
0.36
Guy-
Fan
w"wu1nu
(2.34)
m5u
u5q
an:
(2.50)
-0.16
yn63u
ma
(1.93)
0.4 I
0.57*
-0.04
0.70*
0.34
~q . r siupi
(1.94)
0.40
0.56*
-0.06
0.69*
0.33
0.0 1
1.34 ;flu
w"Mq%anGwuiau (2.66)
t~aa"4~~%yfln? (2.74)
gmnrtu
3 11
%'Vlulc~
(2.49)
0.17
0.25
w"uq-
l a n
w"'?le)lR¶J
(2.66)
diunfo'o.1
(2.59)
0.06
0.15
-0.39 -0.49
-0.10
w'uqlnnilnln (2.09)
pmnsmsiv3wui~u
(2.49)
<lpdflf89 (2.59)
yn ~Gusiv (2.00)
wqssiugi (2.1 1)
6 ~ a a " ~
va'q
dm?
(2.74)
-0.08
Gu~q-
Ian
8 ~ 1
(2.09)
0.56*
yns5u
s i r
(2.00)
0.66*
0.43*
-
wqc siuaf
(2.1 1)
0.48
0.63*
0.09
0.49
0.59*
O a T . I
0.0 1
0.38
0.48
-0.1 1
pmnm
s IY
?WUI;U
(2.33)
0.19
0.52*
-0.05
Oss ;flu
w"k~qFanw"wuinu (2.5 1)
ma"u%a'~flfl: (2.85)
w"erqbanfin~1 (2.27)
gwinsmsiv?wu15u
(2.33)
d i t d n t ~ c (2.41)
v p m ~ ~ 3 1 ~ (2.2 1 )
wsl.rsiu~i (2.17)
diunfoc
(2.41)
0.10
0.44
-0.13
-0.08
4k1-q-
Fan
W " W U I ~ ~ ~ J (2.51)
-
q n a h
I
(2.21)
0.30
0.64*
0.06
0.1 1
0.20
wqc
S I Y ~ ~
(2.1 7)
0.3 5
0.68*
0.1 1
0.16
0.24
0.04
ian'u
a '
(2.85)
-034
%try-
Tan
df1kI1
(2.27)
0.24
0.57*
Cs9Guu
w'wy tnnw'merinu (2.60)
rniiuu5qjnd (2.76)
w'uqInn8nui (2.04)
~mnsmsi~~muin"u
(2.65)
diunfaq (2.27)
q~n3u3iq (1.67)
H ~ - I ~ I M Q + (2.17)
w'uq-
Ian
W4muinu
(2.60)
-
pmn.ra
~ I Y
?muitYu
(2.65)
-0.05
0.1 1
-0.62*
aaiiu
ua"q BR?
(2.76)
-0.16
-
diunfas
(2.27)
0.33
0.49
-0.23*
0.38
Guy-
Ian
anwi
(2.04)
0.55*
0.72*
-
qma5u
~ I Y
(1.67)
0.92*
1.09*
0.37
0.98*
0.59
wqq 3 1 u ~ i
(2.17)
0.43
0.59*
-0.13
0.49
0.1 I
-0.49
9
5 "g i c i i % m o o F 6 o 5 1; + QC c 9 P ? - w m rc)
I- -9 I" 2 2 b, -.I g - -
cb3sduu
w'~syl'bnnw'm~inxl(1.86)
b ~ ~ s l % T q p d (2.10)
w'uq%anAnui (1.04)
jmn~msi~?woia"e,
( 1.98)
i iun%'~s ( 1.59)
%p&hmlf ( 1 .oo)
wq931upQ ( 1 33 )
d1unf0-r
(1.59)
0.27
0.5 1
-0.55
0.39
w'uq-
%an
w'muinu
(1.86)
-
ymaSu
31%
(1.00)
0.86*
1. lo*
-0.03
0.98*
0.59
iruq-
'ban
I
(1.04)
0.82*
1.06*
-
-
miiu
o?qj
.am5 (2.10)
-0.23
wq9
5 1 u ~ i
(1.33)
0.53
0.76*
-0.29
0,65*
0.26
-0.33
prnnrol
~ I Y
3muia'er
(1.98)
-0.12
0.12
-0.94*
Tssduu
w4nrsylIanGwuinu (1.49)
sniiu6ua"qnm$ ( L ,691
w4~lsylInn3np11 (1.00)
gmnsorsi%4wu18u
( 1.60)
d ~ u n f m (1.32)
Iy~'6%d11% (0.84)
wq.rsiupi (1.14)
finr q -
Ian
Gwennu
(1.48)
-
aaiiu
~ a ' q j
ar.G (1.69)
-0.10
-
-
Gnrq-
Inn
dnnri
( 1.00)
0.49*
0.69*
gr*msor
31%
%wia"u
(1.60)
-0.1 I
0.09
-o.60*
d iun f~s
( 1.32)
1.77
0.37
-0.32*
0.36
-
ywaSu
31%
(0.84)
0.65*
0.85*
0.16
0.70*
0.28
w4.a finrgi
(1.14)
0.35
0.55*
-0.14
0.69*
0.46
-0.30
-
*P-= .05
~ in~r1is iq 59 nu<i naiui~1%~&i7u~nuznsz~auniswis4wuiai~~i I u i a u u o s m s ~ i
naiuPiuGui3z~ii~ntdnn"un~fln n t d n h t m i nillntiva'mga szn iwnoiu i fnu i nuii
I~sbuu%uqInn~wuiwu~naiu1~~1nBii~n"uFs~duudiunf~~ T ~ a M ' n G u u I s ~ S u u G ~ q I n n
W"wui~u~naiub~i'7%~uinniiod'nb"suu~~~duudiunfo~
Isst?uu
GuqInnGwui~u (1.42)
t~a"u%a"~tIW~ (1.35)
GuqInnAnui (1.22)
pmnsa3iq"aui6u
( 1 . 4 )
diunJss (0.86)
qYlw'6?~3131 (0.91)
w q s s i u ~ i ( 1.08)
pmnrtu
31%
SwuiiYu
(1.40)
0.02
-0.05
-0.18
Guy-
Inn
Gwuinu
(1.42)
-
diunf~c
(0.86)
0.56*
0.49
0.36
0.54
iaau
wa'y n
(1 -35)
0.07
-
-
y n a S u
41%
(0.9 1)
0.5 1
0.44
0.3 1
0.49
-0.05
Guy-
Inn
inui
(1.22)
0.20
0.13
wq.a 5iugi
(1.08)
0.34
0.27
0.14
0.32
-0.22
-0.17
Fssduu
w"ut-qIanw"wuinu (2.43)
~ Q ~ ~ J % < ~ H F I ; (2.58)
4~q Ian3nui (1.25)
pmnstusi~3w uiG'u
(2.09)
diunfoq ( 1.86)
~ W S G U ~ I V ( 1.33)
wq.rsiugi ( 1.50)
pmnrcu
51%
3muiG'u
(2.09)
0.34
0.49*
-0.84*
%uq-
Fan
w"wuinu
(2.43)
-
diun3'o.r
(1.86)
0.56*
0.72*
-0.6 I *
0.23
iaiiu
u5t-g H
(2.58)
-0.15
Guy-
I a n
8nui
(1.25)
1.18*
1.33*
y n a h
51%
( 1.33)
I . ~ o *
1.25*
-0.08
0.76*
0.53
wq-r ~ I Y Q ~
(1.50)
0.93*
1.08*
-0.25
0.59*
0.36
-0.17
T J S ~ U U
w'~sy%anw"nuinu(2.55)
awa"uarTqam? (2.71)
w'uqTan3nui (1.82)
gmnsmsiv?wuia"u
(2.62)
diunfos (1.41)
~ w ' ~ G u ~ I % ( 1.44)
W ~ J S I U Q ~ (1.50)
pmmrol
31%
5nuii7u
(2.62)
-0.07
0.09
-0.80*
Guq-
t a n
w'wuinu
(2.55)
diunf0'o.r
(1.41)
1.14*
1.30*
-0.4 1
1.21*
ian'u
ar%y
am?
(2.71)
-0.16
H'uq-
tan
8nui
(1.82)
0.73*
0.89*
-
ynatu
sia
(1.44)
1.11*
1.27*
0.37
1.18*
-0.03
-
wqq
siugi
(1.50)
1.05*
1.21*
0.32
1.12*
-0.09
-0.06
*P< .05
oinn-1~19 65 wuii nai~l~G~%~~iuM"nuzn~zuauni~ni~~~ui~iprorf %udauduosni~ 4 w e
fii~.sun~uiudsdppilni~ ~ ~ w ~ i 9 ~ n i u i n u i W Y ~ I l~~Wuu4uq%mG~uinuGnaiu1bmnBii~n"~
bsduuw'~qlani9nw T3-rBuuiiunfot frcZuuynaSu31a imzls-rduuwqsnugf ls;rZuu
mdubvaln/prs l~~nai~~i i~n~i~n'u*b~~duu~uq~an~n~~ t3.rduudiun#oc 'Is.18uuqnaGu.ri.a
bmzh%uwqa3 wgf bs~uupmnscuria~wu1a"u~na~uibsln~i9n"~ T~~duuw'uqlan8nui
Tstiiuuiiunfo.r l3~duuqnaSu3ir imzTrslivuwq.rnugf TnuhBuuhsiiuuw'uqlan
w'wuiwuina1uah%ox11nniiJnduul~~duu4uqlan4n'~11 u'nduu%.jsduuiiun~o~ Jnduu
TscGuuynaSu3i.a imz~nduuT~tduuwqq~i '~l~~ rinGuuT~.rduuiaiiawa"~~~~~naiuibu'iI~
uinniiinGuul~cduuw'uqlan8nui GnBuuT~~iiuudiunfo rinSuuTr.r8uuyna3u~ia
i i az lh~uuT~- r l f iuu~~~~ iug f ~ n ~ u u b ~ ~ u u j m n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ u i a " u ~ n a i u ~ ( u * ~ % ~ a i n n ~ i ~ n d u u
FssGeruw'u~Fan4n~11 Jnduubsduuiiun3'o~ u'na"suu~~sduuqna3u~ia iiazinduu
Tssduuwq.rs~upf
TssGuu
w"~+nGwuinu (2.1 1)
awSuara"ynm? (2.14)
GpIq%,,8fl~l (1.53)
qp.~ins~siclr?wuia"uu
( 1.96)
diun3'os (2.14)
I~W'~$U~I% ( 1.65)
wr)snugf (1.89)
Gyq-
Fan
8nv1
(1.53)
0.58*
0.6 1 *
Guy-
Fan
Gwuinu
(2.1 1)
1md75m
51%
~wuit=Yu
(1.96)
0.15
0.18
-0.44
sw5u
va'y n ?
(2.14)
-0.03
-
H Q ~
51vq9d
(1.89)
0.22
0.25
-0.36
0.07
0.25
-0.24
i i u n f ~ q
(2.14)
-0.03
0.00
-0.6 1
-0.17
-
qwdu
TIT
(1.65)
0.46
0.49
-0.12
0.3 1
0.49
Fs9duu
W ~ M ~ % ~ ~ ~ I W " W U I ~ ~ U (2.47)
i~%J%?~fiFl? (2.62)
GnrqIan8n~i (2.01)
qmnsmsia3wuin'u
(2.67)
~ l p d f l f 8 9 (2.14)
Y~IM~?UJIY ( 1.98)
wqsriugi (2.08)
qmnssla
TIY
?wui;u
(2.67)
-0.20
-0.05
-0.66*
-
4 '~1q-
Fan
~ " W C I I R ~ I
(2.47)
-
-
-
diunfoa
(2.14)
0.33
0.48
-0.12
0.54
rwn'u
u?q
nm?
(2.62)
-0.15
4uq-
Fnn
3 n ~ i
(2.01)
0.46
0.6 1 *
q w ~ % u
n a
(1.98)
0.49
0.64*
0.03
0.69*
0.16
wq9
siupi
(2.08)
0.39
0.54
-0.07
0.59
0.06
-0.10
*P< .05
0in~11si.a 73 wvii na1ui41%o~iud1u'uu~ia?mui~1in0;1i 1wdau9~aa10ji~sf%naian~o w 4% d
dannnnns s~wii.moiu8nln wuii Isaduuw'~a(Innw'nuinuinaiuunn4ian'uIs.afiuu
4uqlnniloln im:ls.aduuyma~un.a lsaduuiwa'ubva'qnp9?inaiuii~1n~i.an'uls~duu
w'uqlnnilnln 13.rduudiun%o.a nnrr3.riseurlns)un.a1sduuymusi lraduupmnsm.n~?~uia'uGnaiu
aandi.ah%saduuw'uq~an~nui baduudiunfoa lsaduuu]na;usir imzls~duu~qasiugi
lnurinBuuls~duuw'uqlan~mu1~u~~aiuibu'ifouinniiGnduu~s~duu~~1q~an~nui nnz
Gnduu%s.afiuugma~usiv ~nfiuu~sa~uui~~u9~a"qn99?~~aiu~(u'i~ou1nnil~nduu%saduu
4uqlan8nui Gnduu%saduudiunfoa ian~Gnduu%ssduuu]w~hsiv Gnduu%s.aduu
gms~~iv?muib~na~uibu'i"b~u~nni~Gnduul~aBuuw"uq~an~nuiGnduu%saduu~iun~~.a
rinBuu%saduuqmabm amzrinduu~s.advuwqasiP1~i
*PC .05
oinmisis 74 wuii n a i u ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ i u ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ w i . r ~ ~ u ~ m ~ m i 1uiauu~.rinaiu4~~~6bba~
Iat?Iu sznii.rnmuilnui wuii Ts~Buutj~qlnnw'nuinuGnaiu~~wnBii.r~~1ls~duu~mnsa
si~?nuia'u ~ssduud~unfas~~aiu~~mnsi~.rn'u~s.rduub~a"u~a't$dm? bba%%ssduujmnsasibtl 4
awuia'u Ts.rduuynm$usi.lr~na~u~~mnsii~n'u~s.rduu~~~syl~nn~w~~~u lssduubwa"uua'tgtm?
Is.rduuw'utyTnn8nln ls.rduujmnsasiv3wuia'u 1m~1s.rduur]na5usia Tnulinduu
~~~duuw'uq~nnw'n~~nu~na~u~~i~ouinn~iod'nd~u~s.rduu~mnsdsiv~~uia '~ ~mrod'nduu
ls~Suuywa5usi.a rinduuh.rduu~~a"uua'tgdm?~naiu1bu'i"b~uinn41od'nduu~s9duudiunf~~
1mrlio8uu'ls.rdeuynaGusi.lr l i n d u u l s . r d u u w ' u q 1 a n i l n u i i m a i ~ u u
1r.rduugnaGusi.a Gn~uuls~duupmnsasi~?wu~a'u~naiu~4iIouinn4~od'nduuTs~duu
d1unfa.r ~m:Gnduulr~duuyw~Gusi~
13sduu
w"~q%anw"nuinu
( 1 0.43)
ara5u~:qnG (1 1.12)
w"~cylIan8n~1 (8.61)
gmn5msi~?muia'u
(10.53)
d ~ u n f ~ s (9.68)
~ W B G U ~ I Y (8.07)
wqasiu8i (8.83)
pmnsol
4 1% 4
amuia'u
(10.53)
-0. 10
0.60
- 1.92*
Guq-
Ian
w"mu1nu
(10.43)
-
diunios
(9.68)
0.75
1.41
-1.08
0.85
-
rra5.u
(11.12)
-0.70
-
-
Guy-
Ian
8nu1
(8.61)
1.82*
2.52*
ymah
31%
(8.07)
2.36*
3.05*
0.54
2.46*
1.61
wqa 3 1 u ~ i
(8.83)
1.59'
2.29*
-0.23
I .69
0.85
-0.76
baBu
u5y .am;
(14.12)
- 1.32
Guq-
Inn
8nu1
(9.45)
3.35*
4.67*
IssEuu
Gyq FanGnu~mu
(12.79)
b~%J%a'ytlfl? (14.12)
4uqlnnlnln (9.45)
pmnsms1~5wu15u
( 14.29)
i1unf8.a (10.41)
~ Y W ~ % U S I ? ~ (8.42)
~ ~ 4 3 1 ~ ~ 9 ' ( 10.75)
w'uq-
Fan
w'wu~nu
(12.79)
pmnsm
~ I V a awu~a"u
(14.29)
- 1.50
-0.18
-4.84*
diunfo'o~
(10.41)
2.39*
3.71*
-0.96
3.88*
yn1i5u
~ I V
(8.42)
4.38*
5.70*
1.03
5.87*
I .99
wqq s ~ u ~ i
(10.75)
2.04
3.37*
- 1.30
3.54*
-0.34
-2.33