2012 az local government scorecard -- w/ cumulative ...€¦ · tax district type off. type fy 2012...

2012 AZ Local Government Scorecard -- w/ Cumulative Averages for FYs 2008 - 2012 Americans for Prosperity 2011 Arizona Legislative Scorecard

Updated April 2013 -- Scoring Rubric on Pages 22 -24 -- Full Spreadsheet: email [email protected]

Tax District Type Off. Type FY 2012 Official FY

201

2 Sc

ore

FY 2012 Category 2011

2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average CategoryApache County Supervisor Claw, Jim 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 0 2 2 1 Not Bad

Apache County Supervisor Lee, R. John 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 0 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Apache County Supervisor White, Tom M. 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 0 -2 0 0 Needs Improvement

Apache Junction City City Council Barker, Robin 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 1 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Apache Junction City City Council Coleman, Doug 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 3 1 Not Bad

Apache Junction City City Council Dietz, Richard 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 1 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Apache Junction City City Council Smithson, Clark 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Apache Junction City City Council Insalaco, John 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 1 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Apache Junction City City Council Serdy, Jeff 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 1 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Apache Junction City City Council Wilson, Chip 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 1 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Avondale City City Council Buster, Jim 1 Not Bad 5 4 -6 -5 0 Needs Improvement

Avondale City City Council Karlin, Stephanie 1 Not Bad 5 4 -7 1 Not Bad

Avondale City City Council Lopez-Rogers, Marie 1 Not Bad 5 4 -10 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Avondale City City Council McDonald, Jim 1 Not Bad 5 4 -2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Avondale City City Council Scott, Frank 1 Not Bad 5 4 -8 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Avondale City City Council Vierhout, Charles 1 Not Bad 5 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Avondale City City Council Weise, Kenneth 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 5 4 -8 -3 0 Needs Improvement

Benson City City Council Maldonado, Nick 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Benson City City Council Brooks, Ron 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -6 2 -5 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Benson City City Council King, Toney 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -6 2 -5 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Benson City City Council Lambert, David 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -6 2 -1 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Benson City City Council Moncada, Chris 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Benson City City Council McGoffin, Lori 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -6 1 -6 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Benson City City Council Sacco, Al 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -6 2 -5 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Tax District Type Off. Type FY 2012 Official 12 FY 2012 Category 11 10 09 08 Avg

.

Average Category

Bisbee City City Council Budge, Ken 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -6 -4 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Bisbee City City Council Burke, Ransom 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 1 Not Bad

Bisbee City City Council Cline, Anna 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -6 -8 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Bisbee City City Council Giacomino, Luche 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Bisbee City City Council Nicholl, Boyd 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -6 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Bisbee City City Council Porter, Jack 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -6 -8 -3 Friend of Big Government

Bisbee City City Council Scott, Bennie 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 1 Not Bad

Buckeye City City Council Garza, Robert -5 Champion of Big Government -1 1 -7 -4 -3 Friend of Big Government

Buckeye City City Council Heustis, Craig -5 Champion of Big Government -1 -3 Friend of Big Government

Buckeye City City Council May, Elaine 0 Absent -1 1 -7 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Buckeye City City Council McAchran, Brian -5 Champion of Big Government -1 1 -3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Buckeye City City Council Meck, Jackie -5 Champion of Big Government -1 1 -3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Buckeye City City Council Orsborn, Eric -5 Champion of Big Government -1 -3 Friend of Big Government

Buckeye City City Council Strauss, Ray -5 Champion of Big Government -1 -3 Friend of Big Government

Bullhead City City City Council Bruck, Kathy 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 F 4 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Bullhead City City City Council Clark, Mark 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Bullhead City City City Council Duvall, Jerry 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Bullhead City City City Council Hakim, Jack 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 F 4 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Bullhead City City City Council McClure, Mickey 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Bullhead City City City Council Medrano, Sam 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 2 F 4 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Bullhead City City City Council Shutts, Sheila 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Camp Verde City City Council Baker, Jackie -4 Friend of Big Government -6 3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Camp Verde City City Council Burnside, Bob -4 Friend of Big Government -6 3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Camp Verde City City Council George, Bruce -4 -4 Friend of Big Government

Camp Verde City City Council German, Carol -4 Friend of Big Government -6 3 F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Camp Verde City City Council Kovacovich, Bob -4 Friend of Big Government -6 3 F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Camp Verde City City Council Buchanan, Alan -4 -4 Friend of Big Government

Camp Verde City City Council Whatley, Robin -4 Friend of Big Government 0 3 0 Needs Improvement

Carefree City City Council Price, Melissa -1 Needs Much Improvement -1 Needs Much Improvement

Carefree City City Council Farrar, Mike -1 Needs Much Improvement -1 Needs Much Improvement

Carefree City City Council Gimson, Arthur -1 Needs Much Improvement -1 Needs Much Improvement

Carefree City City Council Miller, Glenn -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 4 0 1 1 Not Bad

Carefree City City Council Schwan, David -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 4 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Carefree City City Council Saltzman, Marty -1 Needs Much Improvement -1 Needs Much Improvement

Carefree City City Council Van Allen, Jim -1 Needs Much Improvement -1 Needs Much Improvement


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Casa Grande City City Council Fitzgibbons, Lisa Navarro 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Casa Grande City City Council Herman, Matt 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -7 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Casa Grande City City Council Jackson, Robert 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -7 -8 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Casa Grande City City Council Kortsen, Mary 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -7 -8 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Casa Grande City City Council Miller, Steve 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -7 -8 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Casa Grande City City Council Montoya, Karl 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -7 -8 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Casa Grande City City Council Powell, Dick 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -7 -8 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Cave Creek City City Council Bruce, James 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 1 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Cave Creek City City Council Bunch III, Ernest 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 6 1 -4 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Cave Creek City City Council Esser, Dick 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 6 1 -4 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Cave Creek City City Council Francia, Vincent 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 4 1 -4 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Cave Creek City City Council LaMar, Steven 1 Not Bad 4 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Cave Creek City City Council McGuire, Thomas 1 Not Bad -4 2 0 Needs Improvement

Cave Creek City City Council Anderson, Shelley 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Atkins, Lisa 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 -1 1 1 Not Bad

Central AZ Project Water Director Holway, Jim 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Bray, Timothy 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 -1 1 1 Not Bad

Central AZ Project Water Director Burns, Gayle 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 2 5 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Fairbanks, Frank 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Moulton, Cynthia 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Jacobs IV, L.M. Pat 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Kibler, Terri 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Lewis, Mark 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 1 8 5 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director McGrath, Jean 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 4 8 5 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Megdal, Sharon 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Pickard, Pam 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 5 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Tenney, Warren 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Thom, Janie 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 6 4 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Central AZ Project Water Director Zimmerman, Carol 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 -1 1 1 Not Bad


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Chandler City City Council Caccamo, Bob 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -7 -6 0 Needs Improvement

Chandler City City Council Donovan, Trinity 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -7 -6 0 Needs Improvement

Chandler City City Council Dunn, Boyd 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -7 -6 0 Needs Improvement

Chandler City City Council Heumann, Rick 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Chandler City City Council Orlando, Matt 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -7 -6 0 Needs Improvement

Chandler City City Council Sellers, Jack 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Chandler City City Council Weninger, Jeff 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -7 -6 0 Needs Improvement

Chino Valley City City Council Baker, Joel 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 -6 0 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Chino Valley City City Council Bunker, Jim 4 Friend of the Taxpayer -5 -6 0 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Chino Valley City City Council Echols, Dean 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Chino Valley City City Council Romley, Ron 4 Friend of the Taxpayer -5 -6 0 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Chino Valley City City Council Moore, Gloria 4 Friend of the Taxpayer -5 -6 0 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Chino Valley City City Council Tenney, Carl 4 Friend of the Taxpayer -5 -6 -2 Ally of Big Government

Chino Valley City City Council Hatch, Linda 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Clarkdale City City Council Bohall, Curtis 0 Needs Improvement 2 -10 F 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Clarkdale City City Council Denhart, Richard 0 Needs Improvement 2 -10 F -3 Friend of Big Government / FTP

Clarkdale City City Council Regner, Bill 0 Needs Improvement 2 1 Not Bad

Clarkdale City City Council Von Gausig, Doug 0 Needs Improvement 2 -10 F 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Clarkdale City City Council Williams, Patricia 0 Needs Improvement 2 -10 F 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Cochise County Supervisor Call, Pat 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -3 -2 -7 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Cochise County Supervisor English, Ann 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -3 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Cochise County Supervisor Searle, Richard 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -3 -2 -7 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Coconino County Supervisor Archuleta, Elizabeth -1 Needs Much Improvement -6 -3 -3 -6 -4 Friend of Big Government

Coconino County Supervisor Fowler, Lena -1 Needs Much Improvement -6 -3 -3 Friend of Big Government

Coconino County Supervisor Metzger, Mandy -1 Needs Much Improvement -6 -3 -3 Friend of Big Government

Coconino County Supervisor Ryan, Matt -1 Needs Much Improvement -6 -3 -3 -6 -4 Friend of Big Government

Coconino County Supervisor Taylor, Carl -1 Needs Much Improvement -6 -4 Friend of Big Government

Coolidge City City Council Curry, Les 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -5 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Coolidge City City Council Lister, Richard 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -5 2 2 1 Not Bad

Coolidge City City Council Lopez, Gilbert (Cldg) 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 -5 2 2 0 Needs Improvement

Coolidge City City Council Rotz-Lopez, Judy 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 -5 1 2 0 Needs Improvement

Coolidge City City Council Hudson, Steve 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Coolidge City City Council Shope, Thomas 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 4 -5 2 2 1 Not Bad

Coolidge City City Council Thompson, Jon 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 7 -5 5 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Cottonwood City City Council Elinski, Tim -6 Hero of Big Government -6 -2 -11 -4 -6 Hero of Big Government

Cottonwood City City Council Joens, Diane -6 Hero of Big Government -6 -2 -7 0 -4 Friend of Big Government

Cottonwood City City Council Dowling Jesse -6 Hero of Big Government -6 Hero of Big Government

Cottonwood City City Council Norman, Linda -6 Hero of Big Government -6 -2 -11 -4 -6 Hero of Big Government

Cottonwood City City Council Pfeifer, Karen -6 Hero of Big Government -6 -2 -11 -4 -6 Hero of Big Government

Cottonwood City City Council Pratt, Terence -6 Hero of Big Government -6 -2 -7 0 -4 Friend of Big Government

Cottonwood City City Council Jauregui, Ruben -6 Hero of Big Government -6 Hero of Big Government

Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Hiles, David 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Dewey-Humboldt City City Council McBrady, Mark 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Nolan, Terry 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 3 1 Not Bad

Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Dibble, John 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Rogers, Denise 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 3 -4 0 Needs Improvement

Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Repan, Dennis 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Wright, Nancy 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 3 -4 3 0 Needs Improvement

Douglas City City Council Quinonez, Rudy 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Douglas City City Council Fernandez, Bob 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 3 2 F 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Douglas City City Council Gomez, Michael 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 2 F 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Douglas City City Council Huish, Ivan 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 2 F F 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Douglas City City Council Lindemann, Mitch 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 2 F F 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Douglas City City Council Morales, Margaret 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 2 F 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Douglas City City Council Shelton, Ray 1 Needs Improvement 3 0 F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Duncan City City Council Duncan Council F Failed to Post F Failed to Post

El Mirage City City Council Mook, Lana 1 Not Bad 1 Not Bad

El Mirage City City Council McPhetres, James 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

El Mirage City City Council Delgado, Roy 1 Not Bad -1 -1 -8 1 -2 Ally of Big Government

El Mirage City City Council Palladino, Jack 1 Not Bad 1 Not Bad

El Mirage City City Council Ramirez, Joe 1 Not Bad 1 Not Bad

El Mirage City City Council Shapera, David 1 Not Bad 5 -1 -8 -1 Needs Much Improvement

El Mirage City City Council Selby, Lynn 1 Not Bad 1 Not Bad


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Eloy City City Council Acuña, Frank 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 -2 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Eloy City City Council Rosel, Jesse 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 -2 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Eloy City City Council Amerson, Etta Ruth 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 -2 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Eloy City City Council Belloc, Joel 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 -2 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Eloy City City Council Jackson, Byron 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 -2 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Eloy City City Council Akes, Belinda 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 Not Bad

Eloy City City Council Tidwell, J.W. 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 -2 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Flagstaff City City Council Brewster, Karla -4 Friend of Big Government -1 3 1 0 Needs Improvement

Flagstaff City City Council Evans, Coral -5 Champion of Big Government 1 3 1 0 Needs Improvement

Flagstaff City City Council Haughey, Joe -4 Friend of Big Government -1 3 -3 -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Flagstaff City City Council Overton, Scott -3 Friend of Big Government 1 3 -3 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Flagstaff City City Council Presler, Sara -4 Friend of Big Government -3 3 1 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Flagstaff City City Council Babbott, Art -4 Friend of Big Government -4 Friend of Big Government

Flagstaff City City Council White, Al -4 Friend of Big Government 1 3 -3 -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Florence City City Council Brown, Barbara 0 Needs Improvement -3 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Florence City City Council Celaya, Tom 0 Needs Improvement -3 -4 -4 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Florence City City Council Hawkins, Bill 0 Needs Improvement -3 -4 0 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Florence City City Council Kilvinger, Vicki 0 Needs Improvement -3 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Florence City City Council Raasch, Arnie 0 Absent -3 -4 -4 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Florence City City Council Smith, Tom 0 Needs Improvement -3 -4 -4 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Florence City City Council Woolridge, Vallarie 0 Needs Improvement -3 -4 -4 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Fountain Hills City City Council Brown, Dennis -6 Champion of Big Government 5 -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Fountain Hills City City Council Contino, Dennis -5 Champion of Big Government 5 -5 0 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Fountain Hills City City Council Dickey, Ginny -5 Champion of Big Government 5 -5 -3 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Fountain Hills City City Council Elkie, Tait -5 Champion of Big Government 5 0 Needs Improvement

Fountain Hills City City Council Hansen, Cassie -5 Champion of Big Government 5 -5 0 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Fountain Hills City City Council Leger, Henry -5 Champion of Big Government 5 -5 -3 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Fountain Hills City City Council Schlum, Jay -5 Champion of Big Government 5 -5 -3 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Fredonia City City Council Heaton, Scott F Failed to Post F Failed to Post

Fredonia City City Council Judd, Cody F Failed to Post F Failed to Post

Fredonia City City Council Lukus, Jennifer F Failed to Post F Failed to Post

Fredonia City City Council Mackelprang, Brent F Failed to Post F Failed to Post

Fredonia City City Council Zaccaria, Tony F Failed to Post F Failed to Post


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Gila County Supervisor Dawson, Shirley 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 -5 -2 3 0 Needs Improvement

Gila County Supervisor Martin, Tommie Cline 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 -5 -2 3 0 Needs Improvement

Gila County Supervisor Pastor, Michael A. 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 -5 0 Needs Improvement

Gila Bend City City Council Fernandez, Fernando -1 Needs Much Improvement F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Gila Bend City City Council Gonzales, Armida -1 Needs Much Improvement F F F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Gila Bend City City Council Henry, Ron -1 Needs Much Improvement F F F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Gila Bend City City Council Sikes, Tommy Lee -1 Needs Much Improvement -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Gila Bend City City Council Turner, Chuck 0 Needs Improvement F F F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Gila Bend City City Council Holt, Steve -1 Needs Much Improvement -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Gila Bend City City Council Young, Donny -1 Needs Much Improvement F F F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Gilbert City City Council Abbott, Linda 1 Not Bad 3 3 -3 1 Not Bad

Gilbert City City Council Cooper, Ben 1 Not Bad 3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Gilbert City City Council Crozier, Dave 1 Not Bad 1 3 -5 0 Needs Improvement

Gilbert City City Council Daniels, Jenn 3 Not Bad 3 5 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Gilbert City City Council Lewis, John 1 Not Bad 3 5 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Gilbert City City Council Presmyk, Les 1 Not Bad 3 3 -3 1 Not Bad

Gilbert City City Council Sentz, John 1 Not Bad 3 3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Glendale City City Council Clark, Joyce 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 4 -1 -2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Glendale City City Council Frate, Steven 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 4 -1 -2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Glendale City City Council Alvarez, Norma 0 Needs Improvement 0 Needs Improvement

Glendale City City Council Knaack, Yvonne 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 4 -1 -2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Glendale City City Council Lieberman, Phil 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 4 1 -2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Glendale City City Council Martinez, Manuel 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 4 -1 -2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Glendale City City Council Scruggs, Elaine 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 4 5 2 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Globe City City Council Alderman, Lerry 1 Not Bad 3 0 1 Not Bad

Globe City City Council Baker, Dezi 0 Absent 1 0 0 Needs Improvement

Globe City City Council Casillas, Carmen 1 Not Bad 3 0 F F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Globe City City Council Shipley, Fernando 1 Not Bad 1 0 F F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Globe City City Council Uhl, Mary Ann 1 Not Bad 1 0 1 Not Bad

Globe City City Council Wheeler, Terry 0 Absent 3 0 1 Not Bad

Globe City City Council Wilshire, Thea 1 Not Bad 1 0 1 Not Bad


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Goodyear City City Council Campbell, Wally 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 6 Hero of the Taxpayer

Goodyear City City Council Gelzer, Gary 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 6 Hero of the Taxpayer

Goodyear City City Council Lauritano, Sheri 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 6 6 Hero of the Taxpayer

Goodyear City City Council Lord, Georgia 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 6 0 1 -1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Goodyear City City Council Osborne, Joanne 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 0 1 -1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Goodyear City City Council Pizzillo, Joe 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 6 0 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Goodyear City City Council Stipp, Bill 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Graham County Supervisor Drew, John 1 Not Bad -2 -1 -3 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Graham County Supervisor Herrington, Mark 1 Not Bad -2 -1 -3 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Graham County Supervisor Palmer, Jim 1 Not Bad -2 -1 -3 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Greenlee County Supervisor Gomez, David -3 Friend of Big Government 2 1 0 Needs Improvement

Greenlee County Supervisor Lunt, Richard -3 Friend of Big Government 3 1 -4 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Greenlee County Supervisor Ruedas, Hector -3 Friend of Big Government 2 1 -4 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Guadalupe City City Council Flores, Saturnino -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Guadalupe City City Council Cota, Gloria -2 Ally of Big Government 3 -6 -2 Ally of Big Government

Guadalupe City City Council Perez, Angie -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Guadalupe City City Council Sanchez, Joe -2 Ally of Big Government 3 -6 F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Guadalupe City City Council Solarez, Alma -2 Ally of Big Government 3 -6 -2 Ally of Big Government

Guadalupe City City Council Sanchez, Andres -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Guadalupe City City Council Valencia, Laura -2 Ally of Big Government 3 -6 -2 Ally of Big Government

Hayden City City Council Badillo, Monica F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Hayden City City Council Cooper, Rhonda F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Hayden City City Council Cruz, Kathy F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Hayden City City Council Lagunas, Thomas F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Hayden City City Council Lopez, Enrique F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Hayden City City Council Munoz, Maria F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Hayden City City Council Quesada, Annette F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Holbrook City City Council Carlisle, Wade F Failed to Post 3 2 3 F 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Holbrook City City Council Cobb, Phillip F Failed to Post 3 2 3 F 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Holbrook City City Council Haussmann, Charles F Failed to Post 0 2 3 F 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Holbrook City City Council Hill, Jeff F Failed to Post 3 2 3 F 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Holbrook City City Council Maxwell, Myron F Failed to Post 3 2 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Holbrook City City Council Searles, Matthew F Failed to Post 3 2 3 FOT / Failed to Post

Holbrook City City Council Peterson, Richard F Failed to Post F Failed to Post


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Huachuca City City City Council Johnson, Donna 2 Ally of the Taxpayer F -5 F -3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Huachuca City City City Council McCullough, Gene 2 Ally of the Taxpayer F -5 F -3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Huachuca City City City Council Robertson, Byron 2 Ally of the Taxpayer F -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Huachuca City City City Council Smith, Craig 2 Ally of the Taxpayer F -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Huachuca City City City Council Taylor, Ken 2 Ally of the Taxpayer F -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Huachuca City City City Council Wilkey, Eric 2 Ally of the Taxpayer F -5 F -3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Huachuca City City City Council Woodruff, Pat 2 Ally of the Taxpayer F -5 F -3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Jerome City City Council Jerome Council F Failed to Post F F F Failed to Post





Kearny City City Council Chiquette, Cheryl 0 Needs Improvement F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Kearny City City Council Dalton, Lana 0 Needs Improvement F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Kearny City City Council Gambell, Neil 0 Needs Improvement F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Kearny City City Council Martin, Henry 0 Needs Improvement F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Kearny City City Council Radcliffe, Daniel 0 Needs Improvement F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Kearny City City Council Sommers, Debra 0 Needs Improvement F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Kearny City City Council Stephenson, Sheila 0 Needs Improvement F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Kingman City City Council Anderson, Richard 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Kingman City City Council Gordon, Robin 2 Friend of the Taxpayer -2 -1 3 1 Not Bad

Kingman City City Council Cochran, Erin 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Kingman City City Council Salem, John 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 -1 3 1 Not Bad

Kingman City City Council Walker, Keith 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 -1 3 1 Not Bad

Kingman City City Council Watson, Janet 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 -1 -1 -3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Kingman City City Council Young, Carole 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 -1 3 1 Not Bad

La Paz County Supervisor Drum, John 1 Not Bad 1 -1 0 Needs Improvement

La Paz County Supervisor Irwin, Holly 1 Not Bad 1 -1 0 Needs Improvement

La Paz County Supervisor Pierce, Sandy 1 Not Bad 1 -1 0 Needs Improvement


.

Average Category

Lake Havasu City City City Council Barlow, Dean 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 5 -4 1 Not Bad

Lake Havasu City City City Council Barnes, Lee 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 5 -3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Lake Havasu City City City Council Callahan, Don 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 5 -4 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Lake Havasu City City City Council McAtlin, David 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 5 -4 3 0 1 Not Bad

Lake Havasu City City City Council Nexsen, Mark 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 5 -3 3 0 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Lake Havasu City City City Council Nyberg, Margaret 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 5 -3 -1 0 1 Not Bad

Lake Havasu City City City Council Borrelli, Sonny 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Litchfield Park City City Council Blake, Tim 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Litchfield Park City City Council Faith, Paul 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Litchfield Park City City Council Landis, Diane 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 0 Needs Improvement

Litchfield Park City City Council Mahoney, Peter 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Litchfield Park City City Council Romack, John 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 2 1 Not Bad

Litchfield Park City City Council Schoaf, Tom 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Litchfield Park City City Council Stucky, Paul 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -2 2 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Mammoth City City Council Barcelo, Alvaro F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Mammoth City City Council Goff, Bart F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Mammoth City City Council Koch, Robert F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Mammoth City City Council Ramirez, Larry F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Mammoth City City Council Romo, Rudy F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Mammoth City City Council Wickham, Frances F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Mammoth City City Council Williams, J.C. "Craig" F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Marana City City Council Bowen, Dave 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Marana City City Council Comerford, Patti 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 2 4 -7 -4 0 Needs Improvement

Marana City City Council Honea, Ed 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 2 4 -7 -4 0 Needs Improvement

Marana City City Council Kai, Herb 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 2 4 -7 -4 0 Needs Improvement

Marana City City Council McGorray, Carol 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 2 4 -7 -4 0 Champion of the Taxpayer

Marana City City Council Post, Jon 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 2 4 -3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Marana City City Council Ziegler, Rosemary 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 2 0 -7 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Maricopa City City Council Brown, Marvin 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -9 -5 5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Maricopa City City Council Diedrich, Carl 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -9 -5 5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Maricopa City City Council Gusse, Julia 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Maricopa City City Council Farrell, Edward 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -9 -5 -5 -4 -4 Friend of Big Government

Maricopa City City Council Griffin, Marquisha 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -9 -5 5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Maricopa City City Council Marchione, Alan 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -9 -5 -5 -6 -4 Friend of Big Government

Maricopa City City Council Smith, Anthony 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -9 -5 -1 -3 Friend of Big Government


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Maricopa County Supervisor Brock, Fulton 1 Not Bad 2 0 -2 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Maricopa County Supervisor Kunasek, Andy 1 Not Bad 2 0 -2 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Maricopa County Supervisor Stapley, Don 1 Not Bad 2 0 -2 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Maricopa County Supervisor Wilcox, Mary Rose 1 Not Bad 2 -1 -2 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Maricopa County Supervisor Wilson, Max 1 Not Bad 2 -1 -2 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Maricopa C.C. College Board Member Campbell, Don 3 Ally of the Taxpayer -3 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Maricopa C.C. College Board Member Saar, Dana 3 Ally of the Taxpayer 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Maricopa C.C. College Board Member Lumm, Randolph 3 Ally of the Taxpayer -3 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Maricopa C.C. College Board Member Pearson, Debra 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -2 0 1 Not Bad

Maricopa C.C. College Board Member Burke, Doyle 3 Ally of the Taxpayer 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Bicknell, Elbert 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Bruno, Bil 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 -6 -8 -3 -3 Friend of Big Government

Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Gerard, Susan 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Lara, Alice 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Patterson, Greg 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Mesa City City Council Finter, Alex -1 Needs Much Improvement 0 -2 2 0 Needs Improvement

Mesa City City Council Higgins, Dina -1 Needs Much Improvement 0 -2 2 0 Needs Improvement

Mesa City City Council Jones, Kyle -1 Needs Much Improvement 0 -2 -1 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Mesa City City Council Kavanaugh, Dennis -1 Needs Much Improvement 0 -2 2 0 Needs Improvement

Mesa City City Council Richins, Dave -1 Needs Much Improvement 0 -2 2 0 Needs Improvement

Mesa City City Council Smith, Scott -1 Needs Much Improvement 0 -2 2 0 Needs Improvement

Mesa City City Council Somers, Scott -1 Needs Much Improvement 0 -2 -1 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Miami City City Council Black, Mike F Failed to Post F F F F F Failed to Post

Miami City City Council Canizales, Chuy F Failed to Post F F F F F Failed to Post

Miami City City Council Dalley, Daryl F Failed to Post F F F F F Failed to Post

Miami City City Council Hanson, Susan F Failed to Post F F F F F Failed to Post

Miami City City Council Medina, Jose Angel F Failed to Post F F F F F Failed to Post

Miami City City Council Musgrave, Jerry F Failed to Post F F F F F Failed to Post

Miami City City Council Shaffer, Levi F Failed to Post F F F F F Failed to Post

Mohave County Supervisor Johnson, Buster 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 3 1 6 -1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Mohave County Supervisor Sockwell, Tom 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 3 1 -1 -1 1 Not Bad

Mohave County Supervisor Watson, Gary 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 3 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Navajo County Supervisor Brownlow, Jerry 1 Not Bad -3 0 -6 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Navajo County Supervisor Despain, J.R. 1 Not Bad -3 0 -6 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Navajo County Supervisor Nez, Jonathan 1 Not Bad -3 0 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Navajo County Supervisor Tenney, David 1 Not Bad -3 0 -6 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Navajo County Supervisor Thompson, Jesse 1 Not Bad -3 0 -6 -5 -3 Friend of Big Government

Nogales City City Council Felix, Ramon -6 Hero of Big Government 3 4 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Nogales City City Council Garcia-Von Borstel, Octavio -6 Hero of Big Government 3 4 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Nogales City City Council Garino, Arturo -6 Hero of Big Government 3 4 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Nogales City City Council Hanessian, Nubar -6 Hero of Big Government 3 4 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Nogales City City Council Melendez-Lopez, Esther -6 Hero of Big Government 3 4 0 Needs Improvement

Nogales City City Council Parada, Cesar N. -6 Hero of Big Government 3 4 0 Needs Improvement

Nogales City City Council Valdez, Olga R. -6 Hero of Big Government 3 4 0 Needs Improvement

Oro Valley City City Council Garner, William 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 5 -6 1 Not Bad

Oro Valley City City Council Gillaspie, Barry 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 5 -8 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Oro Valley City City Council Hiremath, Satish 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Oro Valley City City Council Hornat, Joe 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Oro Valley City City Council Snider, Mary 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Oro Valley City City Council Solomon, Steve 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Oro Valley City City Council Waters, Lou 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Page City City Council Cobb, Cecilia 1 Needs Improvement 1 1 0 1 Not Bad

Page City City Council Cook, John 1 Needs Improvement 1 1 -7 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Page City City Council Diak, Bill 1 Needs Improvement 1 1 1 Not Bad

Page City City Council Dimbatt, Lyle 1 Needs Improvement 1 1 -7 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Page City City Council Kocjan, John 1 Needs Improvement 1 1 -7 -4 -2 Ally of Big Government

Page City City Council Makowski, Vida 1 Needs Improvement 1 1 1 Not Bad

Page City City Council Puckett, Tom 1 Needs Improvement 1 1 -4 0 Needs Improvement

Paradise Valley City City Council Trueblood, Lisa -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Paradise Valley City City Council Collins, Michael -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Paradise Valley City City Council Hamway, Mary -2 Ally of Big Government 0 3 -2 0 0 Needs Improvement

Paradise Valley City City Council Kirby, Pam -2 Ally of Big Government 3 3 -2 0 0 Needs Improvement

Paradise Valley City City Council LeMarr, Scott -2 Ally of Big Government 0 3 -2 0 0 Needs Improvement

Paradise Valley City City Council Parker, Vernon -2 Ally of Big Government 1 3 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Paradise Valley City City Council Dembow, Paul -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government


.

Average Category

Parker City City Council Beaver, Dan -5 Champion of Big Government 2 1 F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Parker City City Council Boatwright, Christine -5 Champion of Big Government 2 1 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Parker City City Council Duran, Romana -5 Champion of Big Government 2 1 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Parker City City Council Yackley, Frank -5 Champion of Big Government -5 Champion of Big Government

Parker City City Council Madoneczky, Steve -5 Champion of Big Government 2 1 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Parker City City Council Savino, Frank -5 Champion of Big Government 2 1 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Parker City City Council Shontz, Marion -5 Champion of Big Government 2 1 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Payson City City Council Blair, Ed 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -6 -6 5 1 0 Needs Improvement

Payson City City Council Carpenter, Fred 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -6 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Payson City City Council Connell, Su 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -6 0 5 1 1 Not Bad

Payson City City Council Croy, Rick 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -6 -6 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Payson City City Council Evans, Kenny 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -6 -6 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Payson City City Council Hughes, Michael 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -6 -6 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Payson City City Council Wilson, John 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -6 -6 5 2 0 Needs Improvement

Peoria City City Council Aames, Ron 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -2 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Peoria City City Council Barrett, Bob 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -2 -2 1 Not Bad

Peoria City City Council Carlat, Cathy 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -2 -2 1 Not Bad

Peoria City City Council Evans, Joan 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -2 -2 1 Not Bad

Peoria City City Council Rivero, Tony 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Peoria City City Council Leone, Carlo 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -2 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Peoria City City Council Pearson, Dave 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 5 4 -2 -2 1 Not Bad

Phoenix City City Council DiCiccio, Sal 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 6 1 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Phoenix City City Council Gates, Bill 5 Champion of the Taxpayer 5 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Phoenix City City Council Gordon, Phil 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 1 -6 -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Phoenix City City Council Johnson, Michael 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 -6 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Phoenix City City Council Mattox, Claude 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 -6 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Phoenix City City Council Waring, Jim NA Not Scored NA Not Scored

Phoenix City City Council Nowakowski, Michael 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 -4 0 Needs Improvement

Phoenix City City Council Simplot, Tom 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 -6 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Phoenix City City Council Williams, Thelda 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 1 -4 1 Not Bad

Pima County Supervisor Bronson, Sharon 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -1 -1 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Pima County Supervisor Carroll, Ray 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 7 5 4 Friend of the Taxpayer

Pima County Supervisor Day, Ann 3 Friend of the Taxpayer 2 2 7 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Pima County Supervisor Elias, Richard 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -1 -1 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Pima County Supervisor Valadez, Ramon 3 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 -1 -1 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Pinal County Supervisor Martyn, Brian 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -5 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Pinal County Supervisor Rios, Pete 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -5 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Pinal County Supervisor Snider, David 5 Champion of the Taxpayer -5 -1 -4 -5 -2 Ally of Big Government

Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Hughes, Dennis -3 Friend of Big Government 0 2 0 Needs Improvement

Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Crockett, Rich -3 Friend of Big Government 3 2 3 1 Not Bad

Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Vanesian, Dara -3 Friend of Big Government -3 Friend of Big Government

Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Irwin, Stephanie -3 Friend of Big Government 3 2 1 Not Bad

Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Smith, Luke -3 Friend of Big Government 3 2 2 -1 1 Not Bad

Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Webb, Kim -3 Friend of Big Government 3 2 1 Not Bad

Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Wessel, Leslee -3 Friend of Big Government 0 2 3 1 Not Bad

Prescott City City Council Blair, Steve -2 Ally of Big Government 4 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Prescott City City Council Hanna, John -1 Needs Much Improvement 4 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Prescott City City Council Kuykendll, Marlin -2 Ally of Big Government 4 1 Not Bad

Prescott City City Council Lamerson, Jim -2 Ally of Big Government 4 6 -8 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Prescott City City Council Carlow, Alan -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Prescott City City Council Arnold, Charlie -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Prescott City City Council Kuknyo, Chirs -2 Ally of Big Government -2 Ally of Big Government

Prescott Valley City City Council Anderson, Rick 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 2 1 Not Bad

Prescott Valley City City Council Schmitt, Henry 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Prescott Valley City City Council Lasker, Patty 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 2 1 Not Bad

Prescott Valley City City Council Nye, Lora Lee 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 2 2 -1 1 Not Bad

Prescott Valley City City Council Mallory, Mary 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Prescott Valley City City Council Skoog, Harvey 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 2 2 -1 1 Not Bad

Prescott Valley City City Council Tjiema, Don 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Quartzsite City City Council Foster, Ed 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 3 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Quartzsite City City Council Cowell, Barbara -6 Hero of Big Government 2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Quartzsite City City Council Anderson, Pat -6 Hero of Big Government 2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Quartzsite City City Council Kelley, Bob -6 Hero of Big Government 2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Quartzsite City City Council Lukkasson, Jerry -6 Hero of Big Government 2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Quartzsite City City Council Winslow, Joe -6 Hero of Big Government 2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Quartzsite City City Council Jewitt, Mike -6 Hero of Big Government -6 Hero of Big Government


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Queen Creek City City Council Alston, John 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Queen Creek City City Council Barnes, Craig 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 0 1 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Queen Creek City City Council Barney, Gail 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Queen Creek City City Council Benning, Robin 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Queen Creek City City Council Brown, Jeff 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 0 1 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Queen Creek City City Council Oliphant, Dawn 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Queen Creek City City Council Wheatley, Julia 6 Hero of the Taxpayer 4 5 Champion of the Taxpayer

Safford City City Council Attaway, Jacque -6 Hero of Big Government 3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Safford City City Council Bingham, Mary -6 Hero of Big Government 3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Safford City City Council Gibbs, Wyn "Chris" -6 Hero of Big Government 3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Safford City City Council Kouts, Jason -6 Hero of Big Government 3 3 -6 -2 Ally of Big Government

Safford City City Council Malloque, Kenneth -6 Hero of Big Government 3 3 -6 -2 Ally of Big Government

Safford City City Council Seale, Gene -6 Hero of Big Government 3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Safford City City Council Smith, Danny -6 Hero of Big Government 3 0 -1 0 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Sahuarita City City Council Blumberg, Duane 1 Not Bad 3 3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Sahuarita City City Council Conklin, Phil 1 Not Bad 3 3 -2 1 1 Not Bad

Sahuarita City City Council Downs, Scott 1 Not Bad 3 3 -7 1 0 Needs Improvement

Sahuarita City City Council Egbert, Kara 1 Not Bad 3 4 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Sahuarita City City Council Gabaldon, Rosanna 1 Not Bad 3 3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Sahuarita City City Council Oldham, Charles 1 Not Bad 3 3 -7 1 0 Needs Improvement

Sahuarita City City Council Skelton, Lynne 1 Not Bad 3 3 -7 1 0 Needs Improvement

San Luis City City Council Buchanan, Mario Jr. F Failed to Post -5 3 F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

San Luis City City Council Escamilla, Juan C. F Failed to Post -5 3 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

San Luis City City Council Luna-Carrasco, Africa F Failed to Post -5 -5 Champ. of Big Government / FTP

San Luis City City Council Pinzon, Marco A. F Failed to Post -5 -5 Champ. of Big Government / FTP

San Luis City City Council Sanchez, Gerado F Failed to Post -5 3 F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

San Luis City City Council Suarez, Jose F Failed to Post -5 3 F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

San Luis City City Council Torres, Rafael F Failed to Post -5 3 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Santa Cruz County Supervisor Maynard, John 1 Not Bad 4 -7 2 0 0 Needs Improvement

Santa Cruz County Supervisor Molera, Rudy 1 Not Bad 4 -7 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Santa Cruz County Supervisor Ruiz, Manuel 1 Not Bad 4 -7 2 0 0 Needs Improvement


.

Average Category

Scottsdale City City Council Borowsky, Lisa M. 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -8 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Scottsdale City City Council Milhaven, Linda 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Scottsdale City City Council Klapp, Suzanne 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -8 0 -2 Ally of Big Government

Scottsdale City City Council Lane, Jim 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -8 3 -1 3 0 Needs Improvement

Scottsdale City City Council Littlefield, Robert 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -8 3 -2 2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Scottsdale City City Council McCullagh, Ron 2 Ally of the Taxpayer -8 0 0 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Scottsdale City City Council Robbins, Dennis 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Sedona City City Council Adams, Rob -4 Friend of Big Government 4 3 -1 -3 0 Needs Improvement

Sedona City City Council DiNunzio, Mark -4 Friend of Big Government 4 3 1 Not Bad

Sedona City City Council Hamilton, Cliff -4 Friend of Big Government 4 3 2 1 Not Bad

Sedona City City Council Litrell, Barbara -4 Friend of Big Government 4 0 Needs Improvement

Sedona City City Council McIlroy, Dan -4 Friend of Big Government 4 0 Needs Improvement

Sedona City City Council Rayner, Dennis -4 Friend of Big Government 4 0 Needs Improvement

Sedona City City Council Ward, Mike -4 Friend of Big Government 4 0 Needs Improvement

Showlow City City Council Allsop, Mike -2 Ally of Big Government 3 1 Not Bad

Showlow City City Council Fernau, Rick -2 Ally of Big Government 3 2 -4 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Showlow City City Council Kelley, Gene -2 Ally of Big Government 3 2 -4 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Showlow City City Council Latham, Jack -2 Ally of Big Government 3 2 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Showlow City City Council Leech, John -2 Ally of Big Government 3 1 Not Bad

Showlow City City Council Seymore, Daryl -2 Ally of Big Government 3 2 -2 -2 0 Needs Improvement

Showlow City City Council Whipple, Gerry -2 Ally of Big Government 3 2 -4 -2 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Sierra Vista City City Council Blanchard, Bob -4 Friend of Big Government 3 -1 0 1 0 Needs Improvement

Sierra Vista City City Council Calhoun, Gwen -4 Friend of Big Government 0 -2 Ally of Big Government

Sierra Vista City City Council Dockter, Carol -4 Friend of Big Government 3 -1 0 1 0 Needs Improvement

Sierra Vista City City Council Hampton, Larry -4 Friend of Big Government 3 -1 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Sierra Vista City City Council Crosby, Tom -4 Friend of Big Government -4 Friend of Big Government

Sierra Vista City City Council Reardon, Tom -4 Friend of Big Government 3 -1 -1 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Sierra Vista City City Council Strain, Bob -4 Friend of Big Government 3 -1 0 1 0 Needs Improvement

Snowflake City City Council Ballard, Kerry -5 Champion of Big Government 2 3 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Snowflake City City Council Brimhall, Chris -5 Champion of Big Government 2 3 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Snowflake City City Council Davis, Lorri -5 Champion of Big Government 2 3 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Snowflake City City Council Hendrickson, Charlie -5 Champion of Big Government 2 3 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Snowflake City City Council Porter, Dean -5 Champion of Big Government 2 3 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Snowflake City City Council Tate, Sharon -5 Champion of Big Government 2 3 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Snowflake City City Council Willis, Kelly -5 Champion of Big Government 2 3 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Somerton City City Council Galindo, Luis -1 Needs Much Improvement -3 0 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Somerton City City Council Anaya, Gerardo 1 Not Bad -4 ? F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Somerton City City Council Magana, Arturo 1 Not Bad -4 ? F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Somerton City City Council Porchas, Martin 1 Not Bad -4 0 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Somerton City City Council Ramirez, Laura -1 Needs Much Improvement -4 0 F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Somerton City City Council Villalpando, Miguel 1 Not Bad -3 0 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Somerton City City Council Yepez, Jose 1 Not Bad -3 0 F F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

South Tucson City City Council Eckstrom, Jennifer F Failed to Post 2 3 0 F 2 AOT / Failed to Post

South Tucson City City Council Felix, John F Failed to Post 2 3 3 FOT / Failed to Post

South Tucson City City Council Diaz, Paul F Vacant 0 F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

South Tucson City City Council Romero, Anita F Failed to Post F Failed to Post

South Tucson City City Council Salaz, Carlos G. F Failed to Post 2 3 3 FOT / Failed to Post

South Tucson City City Council Soltero, Mary F Failed to Post 2 3 0 F 2 AOT / Failed to Post

South Tucson City City Council Tadeo, Pete F Failed to Post 2 3 0 F 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Springerville City City Council Baca, Eric -3 Friend of Big Government F F F F Friend of Big Government / FTP

Springerville City City Council Hunt, Connie -3 Friend of Big Government F F Friend of Big Government / FTP

Springerville City City Council Muth, Dan -3 Friend of Big Government F F Friend of Big Government / FTP

Springerville City City Council Silva, Susie 0 Absent F F Absent / Failed to Post

Springerville City City Council Thebeau, Ron -3 Friend of Big Government F F F Friend of Big Government / FTP

St. Johns City City Council Ashton, Ryan 0 Needs Improvement 3 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

St. Johns City City Council Cirivello, Mike 0 Needs Improvement 3 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

St. Johns City City Council Hancock, Pete 0 Needs Improvement 3 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

St. Johns City City Council Hauser, Kay 0 Needs Improvement 3 0 1 Not Bad

St. Johns City City Council Nielson, Fred 0 Needs Improvement 3 -5 -1 Needs Much Improvement

St. Johns City City Council Udall, Spence 0 Needs Improvement 0 Needs Improvement

St. Johns City City Council Patterson, Ryan 0 Needs Improvement 0 Needs Improvement

Superior City City Council Aguilar, Gilbert -2 Ally of Big Government 0 -9 -4 Friend of Big Government

Superior City City Council Gutierrez, Hank -2 Ally of Big Government 0 -9 -4 Friend of Big Government

Superior City City Council Heglie, Lynn -2 Ally of Big Government 0 -9 -4 Friend of Big Government

Superior City City Council Hing, Michael -2 Ally of Big Government 0 -9 -4 Friend of Big Government

Superior City City Council Lopez, Olga -2 Ally of Big Government 0 -3 -2 Ally of Big Government

Superior City City Council Peralta, Soyla -2 Ally of Big Government 0 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government

Superior City City Council Pfohl, David -2 Ally of Big Government 0 -6 -3 Friend of Big Government


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Surprise City City Council Alton, Richard 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 4 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Surprise City City Council Hall, Skip 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 4 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Surprise City City Council Truitt, Lynn 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 4 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Surprise City City Council Villanueva, Roy 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 4 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer

Surprise City City Council Williams, John 0 Needs Improvement 1 4 3 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Surprise City City Council Wolctott, Sharon 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Surprise City City Council Woodard, Mike 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 0 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Tempe City City Council Arredondo, Ben 1 Not Bad 5 -1 -2 -3 0 Needs Improvement

Tempe City City Council Ellis, Shana 1 Not Bad 5 -1 -3 -3 0 Needs Improvement

Tempe City City Council Hallman, Hugh 1 Not Bad 3 -1 2 1 1 Not Bad

Tempe City City Council Mitchell, Mark 1 Not Bad 5 -1 -3 -3 0 Needs Improvement

Tempe City City Council Navarro, Joel 1 Not Bad 5 -1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Tempe City City Council Shekerjian, Onnie 1 Not Bad 5 0 2 1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Tempe City City Council Woods, Corey 1 Not Bad 5 -1 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Thatcher City City Council Griffin, D. Wayne -1 Needs Much Improvement 1 1 0 Needs Improvement

Thatcher City City Council Innes, Donald -2 Ally of Big Government 1 1 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Thatcher City City Council Larson, Ken -2 Ally of Big Government 0 1 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Thatcher City City Council Merriman, Eric -2 Ally of Big Government 1 1 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Thatcher City City Council Morris, Charles -2 Ally of Big Government 1 1 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Thatcher City City Council Mulleneaux, Bill -2 Ally of Big Government 1 1 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Thatcher City City Council Rivera, Bob -2 Ally of Big Government 1 1 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Tolleson City City Council Erives, Clorinda 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 -2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Tolleson City City Council Espinoza, Diego 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 -2 F 0 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Tolleson City City Council Farr, Kathie 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 1 -2 F -1 1 NB / Failed to Post

Tolleson City City Council Gamez, Adolfo 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 0 F -1 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Tolleson City City Council Laborin, Linda 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 -2 F 0 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Tolleson City City Council Mendoza, Albert 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 -2 F 0 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Tolleson City City Council Rodriguez, Juan 4 Friend of the Taxpayer 4 -2 F 0 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Tombstone City City Council Davis, Randy F Failed to Post F F F F Failed to Post

Tombstone City City Council Doherty, James F Failed to Post F F F F Failed to Post

Tombstone City City Council Henderson, Jack F Failed to Post F F F F Failed to Post

Tombstone City City Council Korbeck-Reeder, Stacey F Failed to Post F F F F Failed to Post

Tombstone City City Council Troncale, Steve F Failed to Post F F F F Failed to Post


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Tucson City City Council Cunningham, Paul -3 Friend of Big Government 0 -2 Ally of Big Government

Tucson City City Council Fimbres, Richard -2 Ally of Big Government -2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Tucson City City Council Kozachik, Steve -1 Needs Much Improvement 4 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Tucson City City Council Romero, Regina 0 Needs Improvement -2 -1 2 0 Needs Improvement

Tucson City City Council Scott, Shirley C. -2 Ally of Big Government -2 -1 -1 -2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Tucson City City Council Uhlich, Karin -2 Ally of Big Government -2 -1 -1 -2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Tucson City City Council Walkup, Robert -2 Ally of Big Government -2 -1 -1 -2 -2 Ally of Big Government

Tusayan City City Council Blasi, Bob -6 Hero of Big Government Unincorp. until 2011 -6 Hero of Big Government

Tusayan City City Council Bryan, Greg -6 Hero of Big Government Unincorp. until 2011 -6 Hero of Big Government

Tusayan City City Council Maniaci, Cecily -6 Hero of Big Government Unincorp. until 2011 -6 Hero of Big Government

Tusayan City City Council Montoya, Al -6 Hero of Big Government Unincorp. until 2011 -6 Hero of Big Government

Tusayan City City Council Rueter, John -6 Hero of Big Government Unincorp. until 2011 -6 Hero of Big Government

Wellton City City Council Bejarano, Alejandro F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Wellton City City Council Deermer, James F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Wellton City City Council McCollough, Cecilia F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Wellton City City Council Milam, John F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Wellton City City Council Moser, Emma F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post

Wickenburg City City Council Band, Chris -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 0 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Wickenburg City City Council Blunt, Kelly -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 0 0 Needs Improvement

Wickenburg City City Council Cook, John -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 0 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Wickenburg City City Council Crissman, Sam -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 1 Not Bad

Wickenburg City City Council Madrid, Ruben -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 0 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Wickenburg City City Council Pereira, Rui -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 0 0 Needs Improvement

Wickenburg City City Council Stewart, Scott -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 0 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Willcox City City Council Cronberg, Monika -1 Needs Much Improvement 2 -5 F 3 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Willcox City City Council Donahue, Christopher 1 Not Bad 0 -5 F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Willcox City City Council Holloway, William 1 Not Bad 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Willcox City City Council Irvin, Robert 1 Not Bad 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer

Willcox City City Council Johnson, Elwood -1 Needs Much Improvement -2 7 F 3 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Willcox City City Council Klump, Stephen 1 Not Bad 2 -5 F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP

Willcox City City Council Lindsey, Gerald 1 Not Bad 2 -5 F -1 Needs Much Improvement / FTP


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Williams City City Council Dent, Don 1 Not Bad F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Williams City City Council Heimenz, Bernie 1 Not Bad F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Williams City City Council McNelly, Frank 1 Not Bad F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Williams City City Council Miller, William J. 1 Not Bad F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Williams City City Council Moore, John 1 Not Bad F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Williams City City Council Payne, Lee 0 Not Bad F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Williams City City Council Wurgler, Jim 1 Not Bad F 1 NB / Failed to Post

Winkelman City City Council Winkelman Council F Failed to Post F F Failed to Post





Winslow City City Council Boyd, Robin 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 2 F -5 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Winslow City City Council Cake, Peter 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 0 2 F -5 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Winslow City City Council Chacon Sr., Thomas 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 2 F 2 AOT / Failed to Post

Winslow City City Council Howell, Judy 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 3 F -5 1 NB / Failed to Post

Winslow City City Council Juergens, Marsha 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 2 F -5 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Winslow City City Council Losey, Marshall 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 2 F -5 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Winslow City City Council Soehner, Harold 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 2 F -5 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Yavapai County Supervisor Davis, Chip 4 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 2 -5 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Yavapai County Supervisor Springer, Carol 4 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 2 -5 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Yavapai County Supervisor Thurman, Thomas 4 Friend of the Taxpayer -1 2 -5 -1 0 Needs Improvement

Youngtown City City Council Chittenden, Margaret -5 Champion of Big Government 3 -3 F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Youngtown City City Council Duran, Jacob "Jack" 0 Needs Improvement 3 -3 F F 0 Needs Improvement / FTP

Youngtown City City Council Johnson, Judy -5 Champion of Big Government 3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Youngtown City City Council LeVault, Michael -5 Champion of Big Government 3 -3 F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Youngtown City City Council MacKay, Susan -5 Champion of Big Government 3 -3 F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Youngtown City City Council Mello, Dorena -5 Champion of Big Government 3 -3 F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP

Youngtown City City Council Oglesby, Shirley -5 Champion of Big Government 3 -3 F F -2 Ally of Big Government / FTP


201

2 Sc

ore


2010

2009

2008

Avg

.

Average Category

Yuma City City Council Beeson, Cody -2 Ally of Big Government 1 1 -3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Yuma City City Council Brooks-Gurrola, Bobbi -2 Ally of Big Government -1 -2 Ally of Big Government

Yuma City City Council Johnson, Paul 2 Ally of the Taxpayer 2 1 1 1 1 Not Bad

Yuma City City Council Krieger, Alan -2 Ally of Big Government -1 -2 Ally of Big Government

Yuma City City Council McClendon, Leslie -2 Ally of Big Government -1 1 -3 1 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Yuma City City Council Mendoza, Raul -2 Ally of Big Government -1 1 -3 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Yuma City City Council Stuart, Jerry -2 Ally of Big Government -1 -2 Ally of Big Government

Yuma County Supervisor Ferguson, Greg -1 Needs Much Improvement 1 1 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Yuma County Supervisor McCloud, Russell -1 Needs Much Improvement 1 1 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Yuma County Supervisor Prochaska, Casey -1 Needs Much Improvement 1 1 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Yuma County Supervisor Reyes, Marco "Tony" -1 Needs Much Improvement 1 1 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

Yuma County Supervisor Lorona Stuart, Lenore -1 Needs Much Improvement 1 1 -2 -4 -1 Needs Much Improvement

AFPF-Arizona thanks Rudy F. Richards for contributing to the research for the FY 2012 Scorecard.

AFPF-Arizona Local Government Scorecard -- Scoring Guide

Overall Scoring Key Total Score = Budget Score + Property Tax Score + Sales Tax Score

TotalScore Category

6 Hero of the Taxpayer -1 Needs Much Improvement5 Champion of the Taxpayer -2 Ally of Big Government4 Friend of the Taxpayer -3 Friend of Big Government3 Friend of the Taxpayer -4 Friend of Big Government2 Ally of the Taxpayer -5 Champion of Big Government1 Not Bad -6 Hero of Big Government0 Needs Improvement F Failed to Post Budgets, Levies or Vote Minutes

Budget Scoring Key (AFPF-AZ scores all expenditures, including General Fund & Capital Projects)

Strong Growth Year (FY 2008)

BudgetIncrease Score Notes

< minus 30 6 Heroic Spending Cuts-30 to -15% 5 Major Spending Cuts-15 to -5.0% 4 Significant Spending Cuts-5.0% to Zero 3 Nominal Spending CutsZero to +2.4% 2 Inflation+2.5 to +5.0% 1 Population + Inflation (FiscCon)+5.1 to +7.0% 0 Personal Income Range (FiscMod)+7.1 to +10.5% -1 Above Personal Income+10.6 to +14.0% -2 Well Above Personal Income+14.1 to +20% -3 Double Personal Income> +20% -4 Triple Personal Income

Slow Growth Year


< minus 30 5 Heroic Spending Cuts-30 to -15% 4 Major Spending Cuts-15 to -5.0% 3 Significant Spending Cuts-5.0% to Zero 2 Nominal Spending CutsZero to +2.4% 1 Inflation (FiscCon)+2.5 to +5.0% 0 Pop + Infl/Personal Income (FiscMod)+5.1 to +7.0% -1 Above Personal Income+7.1 to +10.5% -2 Double Personal Income+10.6 to +14.0% -3 Triple Personal Income+14.1 to +20% -4 Quadruple Personal Income> +20% -5 Quintuple Personal Income

Recession Scoring (FYs 2009-2012)


< minus 30 4 Heroic Spending Cuts-30 to -15% 3 Major Spending Cuts-15 to -5.0% 2 Significant Spending Cuts-5.0% to Zero 1 Nominal Spending Cuts (FiscCon)Zero to +2.4% 0 Inflation (FiscMod)+2.5 to +5.0% -1 Population + Inflation (FiscCon)+5.1 to +7.0% -2 Strong Personal Income+7.1 to +10.5% -3 Above Strong Personal Income+10.6 to +14.0% -4 Well Above Strong Personal Income+14.1 to +20% -5 Double Strong Personal Income> +20% -6 Triple Strong Personal Income

Property Tax Scoring Key

Strong Growth Year (FY 2008) Recession/Slow Growth Year (FYs 2009-2012)

Levy Change Score Notes

< -5.0% 2 Substantial Levy ReductionBelow zero 2 Levy Reduction -5.0% to Zero 1 Levy Reduction (FiscCon)Zero to +5.0% 1 Population + Inflation (FiscCon) Zero to +5.0% 0 Strong Population + Inflation (FiscMod)+5.1 to +7.0% 0 Personal Income Range (FiscMod) +5.1 to +7.0% -1 Strong Personal Income Range+7.1% to +14.0% -1 Above Personal Income +7.1% to +14.0% -2 Above Strong Personal Income> +14.1% -2 Double Personal Income > +14.1% -3 Double Strong Personal Income

Sales/Bed Tax Scoring Key

Action Score Permanent Scale

Voted to Cut 1 (Includes ballot referenda)No Vote 0 (Includes ballot referenda)Voted to Raise -1 (Includes ballot referenda)

Boondoggles AFPF-AZ does not have a means of objectively scoring the impact of local-government boondoggles, including corporate welfare handouts and tax abatements awarded to politically-connected developers, except insofar as those boondoggles increase current operations and capital budgets.

Absence If an official is absent for all key votes, such is noted in the "Category" column. Officials who are present for at least one key vote receive a score of zero for missed votes, and receive a total score.

Failed Schedules A & B of the state-required budget reports should be posted on a jurisdiction's website,to Post as well as the minutes for the board/council meetings at which the final budget and final property tax levies

are approved by roll call vote. The Category designates failure to post the documents by October.

Note on When a property tax levy is less than one percent of a district's budget, Property Levies the levy is dropped from the scoring rubric.

2012 az local government scorecard -- w/ cumulative ...€¦ · tax district type off. type fy 2012...

Documents