.. .

5

..

1.

, , . , , - , , , . , . 1) , .. -, (, -, ) , - - . 2) -, , . , - 1, - 1 .: Mejer J. berlieferung der Philoso-

phie im Altertum. Eine Einfhrung. Copenhagen, 2000. S. 91194.

6

, , ( , , , . placita).

: 1) -, 2) , 3) () 4) - (), , , 2. - , - : , - . , -, (DK 68 A 33), , - . , (D. L. IV 13), (fr. 22, 4041) . IV . . . , , , , , - . , , , (fr. 22), , - (D. L. IV 13) - (fr. 39). - : (fr. 191196 Rose) , ( - ), (fr. 198205 Rose) - . 2 .: Ueberweg F., Praechter K. Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie. I. Teil:

Die Philosophie des Altertums. 11. Aufl. Berlin, 1920. S. 13f.; Mejer J. Diogenes Laertius and his Hellenistic background. Wiesbaden, 1978. P. 60ff.; Mejer J. ber-lieferung der Philosophie im Altertum. S. 28ff.; Mansfeld J. Sources // Algra K. et al. (edd.). The Cambridge history of Hellenistic philosophy. Cambridge, 1999. P. 16f.; : Runia D. What is doxography? // Van der Eijk P. (ed.). Ancient his-tories of medicine. Essays in medical doxography and historiography in classical Antiquity. Leiden, 1999. P. 33ff.

.. .

7

- , , - . , , - , - , -. , -: ( , , ) ( , , D. L. V 25), (, , , , , -, ) (137 2740 FHSG). , , , - , , - - . ( -), - , (137 3940 FHSG), , (137 2930 FHSG), , ; . (fr. 245 FHSG). , ; , , . -, (. fr. 235 FHSG), - ( ), - (. ). , - .

- , - ( ) . ( . FGrHist 10081111.) - , , - . (fr. 1125, 2632, 4750) , , . , ,

8

-, , - (fr. 52, 62, 67). ( , fr. 2546) , , - . ( , ) - (fr. 22), (D. L. V 42 = fr. 436 Nr. 16 FHSG), (fr. 3031), (fr. 3762) (fr. 136). , III . . . .

- . - , - , , , , , , , . , , - ( ), - . - , , , ( ) , (. Aristox. fr. 50). , , - , . , - , .

- , - . - , , II . . . -3. ( ) - . - 3 .: Wehrli F. (ed.). Sotion. Basel, 1978 [Die Schule des Aristoteles, Supplbd. II].

.. .

9

: , - ; , ; , - ( ), . , , , , , - . , , : , , ; . -, , - . - , (. ; , - ); - (fr. 3031). - 4 , - , , 5.

- , -, 6. . , ; , , - . - 7, 8, , 4 .: Giannattasio Andria R. I frammenti delle Successioni dei filosofi. Napoli, 1989. 5 Mejer J. Diogenes Laertius. P. 64f. 6 .: Gigante M. Frammenti di Ippoboto // Mastrocinque A. (ed.). Omaggio a Piero

Treves. Padova, 1984. P. 151193. 7 : Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. Berlin, 1879. S. 447ff. 8 FGrHist 1058 F 1; Staden H. von. Rupture and continuity: Hellenistic reflections on

the history of medicine // Van der Eijk P. (ed.). Ancient histories of medicine.

10

, 9, -. , . 1) - -, , , . , , - , . 2) -, , -, . - , (, , ), .

2.

, ( ) . - , , Doxographi Graeci . (1879). - (1903), , , . -, , . ( 10) - . , -, , , : 1) -

Essays in medical doxography and historiography in classical Antiquity. Leiden, 1999. P. 143187.

9 Wyss B. Doxographie // Reallexikon fr Antike und Christentum. Bd. 4. 1959. Sp. 199; Mejer J. berlieferung der Philosophie im Altertum. S. 31f.

10 C.: Runia D. What is doxography? P. 34.

.. .

11

, - , 2) 3) , - , , - .

, , - 11 12. 80- . XX . - ; - 13. - 8090 . XX . : 1) - , , - 14; 2) 15 -16; 3) 17 - 11 Wendland P. Eine doxographische Quelle Philos // Sitzungsberichte der Preussi-

schen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin. 1897. S. 10741079; Pasquali G. Doxographica aus Basiliusscholien // Nachrichten der Gttingen Wiss. Gesellschaft 1910. S. 194228.

12 Stratton G.M. Theophrastus and the Greek physiological psychology before Aristo-tle. London, 1917; McDiarmid J.B. Theophrastus on Presocratic causes // Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 61. 1953. P. 85156; Kienle W. von. Die Berichte ber die Sukzessionen der Philosophen in der hellenistischen und sptantiken Literatur. Diss. Berlin, 1961; Gigon O. Die der Vorsokratiker bei Theophrast und Aristoteles // Dring I. (ed.). Naturphilosophie bei Aristoteles und Theophrast. Heidelberg, 1969. S. 114123.

13 Steinmetz P. Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos. Berlin, 1964. 14 Berti E. Sul carattere dialettico della storiografia filosofica di Aristotele //

Cambiano G. (ed.). Storiografia e dossografia nella filosofia antica. Torino, 1986. P. 101125; Patzer A. Der Sophist Hippias als Philosophiehistoriker. Freiburg, 1986; Mansfeld J. Aristotle, Plato, and the Preplatonic doxography and chronogra-phy // Cambiano G. (ed.). Storiografia e dossografia nella filosofia antica. P. 159.

15 Baltussen H. Theophrastus against the Presocratics and Plato: Peripatetic dialectic in the De sensibus. Leiden, 2000; Mansfeld J. Aristote et la structure du De sensibus de Thophraste // Phronesis 41. 1996. P. 158188; Sharples R.W. Theophrastus of Eresus. Commentary, 3.1. Sources on physics. Leiden, 1998.

16 Daiber H. Aetius Arabus. Die Vorsokratiker in arabischer berlieferung. Wiesba-den, 1980.

17 Lebedev A. : Neglected fragments of Democritus and Metrodorus of Chios // Proceedings of the 1st intern. Congress on Democritus. Xanthi, 1984. P. 1318;

12

18; . - . , - , 19. - , , - .

, - (II, 2425) (II, 2023): , . , , De inundatione Nili (IV, 1). , -: , - ( ), -. , , , . - , -

Lebedev A. Did the doxographer Aetius ever exist? // Philosophie et Culture. Actes du 18e Congrs mondial de philosophie, 3. Montral, 1988. P. 813817.

18 Kingsley P. Empedocles and his interpreters: The four-element doxography // Phronesis 39. 1994. P. 235254; Bremmer J. Atius, Arius Didymus and the trans-mission of doxography // Mnemosyne 51. 1998. P. 154160; Baltussen H. Plato in the Placita (Atius bk. IV): A Dielsian blind spot // Philologus 144. 2000. S. 227238.

19 C., .: Mansfeld J. Doxography and dialectic: The Sitz im Leben of the Placita // Aufstieg und Niedergang der rmischen Welt, II 36.4. 1990. S. 30573231; Mans-feld J. Physikai doxai and Problmata physica from Aristotle to Atius (and beyond) // Fortenbaugh W., Gutas D. (edd.). Theophrastus of Eresus: His psychological, doxographical and scientific writings. New Brunswick, 1992. P. 63111; Mans- feld J. Heresiography in context (1992); Runia D. Xenophanes or Theophrastus? An Atian doxographicum on the sun // Fortenbaugh W., Gutas D. (edd.). Theophrastus of Eresus. P. 112140; Runia D. What is doxography? (1999); Mansfeld J., Ru- nia D. Atiana: The method and intellectual context of a doxographer. Vol. I. The sources. Leiden, 1997; .: . . : // - - 2002. ., 2003. . 534; .: Mansfeld J. Deconstructing doxography // Philo-logus 146. 2002. S. 277286.

.. .

13

. ( , .), , - . -, (De Caelo 294b79): , - , , - ( - . 20). , , , , - (Ps.-Arist. MXG 5, 979a1418, . 980a18), : 1) , 2) , 3) 21. - (13) , , , , ( ), . , , - , , , , (Mem. I, 1, 1314). - V ., -: , , - , , (De nat. hom. 1). , , - : , -, , , , , , , , , , (Antid. 268). (. Hel. 3), , , 22. 20 Cherniss H. Aristotles criticism of Presocratic philosophy. Baltimore, 1935. P. 349. 21 Mansfeld J. Aristotle, Plato, and the Preplatonic doxography and chronography.

P. 59ff. 22 (Mansfeld J. Aristotle, Plato, and the Preplatonic

doxography and chronography. P. 61), (Patzer A. Der Sophist Hippias als Philosophiehistoriker. S. 90).

14

, , , () , , -, , (DK 86 4). - , , - , , .23 , , - , - 24.

, , - , ( -, , ) , - . : 1) - 2) , - ( , - ..) (., , ). , -, , .

- , -25, . - , , , , . - , , , - . , , . , , 23 Patzer A. Der Sophist Hippias als Philosophiehistoriker; Mansfeld J. Aristotle, Pla-

to, and the Preplatonic doxography and chronography. 24 .. . ., 2002. . 193. 25 Mansfeld J. Aristotle, Plato, and the Preplatonic doxography and chronography.

.. .

15

- , , 26. - , , , , , - 27. , - , 28. -, , (, , ..) - , ( ) (EN 1098a23ff.; Poet. 1449a15; Pol. 1252a26ff., 1264a3; Met. 993a15ff.). , , , , (Met. 993a1517; fr. 53 Rose). , , -, VIV . , 29. , -, , -, , . - , - ( ), - - , 26 Gigon O. Die Geschichtlichkeit der Philosophie bei Aristoteles // Archivio di fi-

losofia 23. 1954. S. 129150; Owen G.E.L. Tithenai ta Phainomena (1961) // Owen G.E.L. Logic, science and dialectic. Ithaca, 1986. P. 239251.

27 Gigon O. Die Geschichtlichkeit der Philosophie bei Aristoteles. P. 134. 28 Jaeger W. Aristoteles. Grundlegung einer Geschichte seiner Entwicklung. Berlin,

1923. S. 3. 29 .: Cherniss H. Aristotles criticism of Presocratic philosophy; McDiarmid J.B.

Theophrastus on Presocratic causes.

16

. , , - , . , - (, -), (), (), (), () (), ( ), - 30.

, , , , - , , -- , -, - - , 31. , - , . I, 2 - , - (): , ; - , , ; , (, , . .), -; , , -. (, , ), , - , - (. GC I 12, ). De an. I, 2 - 15 , 30 Fritz K. von. Die Bedeutung des Aristoteles fr die Geschichtsschreibung // Entreti-

ens Fondation Hardt IV. 1956. P. 83128; .. . . 196.

31 .: Cherniss H. Aristotles criticism of Presocratic philosophy; Jaeger W.: Rec.: H. Cherniss: Aristotles cri- ticism of Presocratic philosophy // American Journal of Philology 63. 1937. P. 350356; Guthrie W.K.C. Aristotle as a historian of philosophy: Some prelimi-naries // Journal of Helleni Studies 77. 1954. P. 3441.

.. .

17

( ) -. , , (), , .

- Met. 37. - ( , . .), - , - . : , , . , , , , , . , , - . -, ; , (, ) - ; -. , : , . , - , , ( ), , , .

, - - . , , - . - ( - , , , , ). - ( ..); ( -). (, , , ), ( , ) ( -

18

). , - (, , , ).

3.

- -. . , - . - . , , , ( ) / , - . , , (fr. 224230 FHSG), , - , . - / - 13 17 -. , , Met. A, ( , , , , ), , -, ( , -, , ). : , , (fr. 225, 226, 228a FHSG). , . - , - , , . , , ( . ), , -

.. .

19

, - .

- , , , . - , - ; - (., , , DK 32 A 27). - , - - , ( ) -. , , , , . De sensibus, 32. - , , 33; - 34, - . (fr. 233, 241a FHSG), , De sensibus, . , , , - . - -, , , (-: . Arist. Met. 984a3 38 A 34, 10, 1314) - (: . Arist. EE 1225a30 44 A 9, 1623; -: Theophr. fr. 240 FHSG). , , - , - 32 Stratton G.M. Theophrastus and the Greek physiological psychology before Aristo-

tle (1917); Baltussen H. Theophrastus against the Presocratics and Plato (2000). 33 Usener H. Analecta Theophrastea. Bonn, 1858. S. 27; Diels H. Doxographi Graeci.

P. 114; Baltussen H. Theophrastus against the Presocratics and Plato. P. 245. 34 Regenbogen O. Theophrastos von Eresos // Paulys Real-Encyclopdie, Suppl. 7.

1940. S. 1400; Steinmetz P. Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 338.

20

. , - (At. II, 4). , , - .

, , , , , , - . , , (At. II, 20), (II, 29), (III, 9) (IV, 1), . , -, - . , , , (At. III, 28), , - 35, - . -, - (geschichtliche Ergnzung zur eigenen Physik36), - , - . , - , a huge collection of materials to be used in dialectical and/or scientific discussion37.

De inundatione Nili - , , 35 Daiber H. The Meteorology of Theophrastus in Syriac and Arabic translation //

Fortenbaugh W., Gutas D. (edd.). Theophrastus of Eresus. P. 166293. 36 Gigon O. Die der Vorsokratiker bei Theophrast und Aristoteles. S. 117. 37 Mansfeld J. Physikai doxai and Problmata physica from Aristotle to Atius. P. 67;

Mansfeld J. Doxographical studies, Quellenforschung, tabular presentation and oth-er varieties of comparativism // Burkert W. et al. (ed.). Fragmentsammlungen phi-losophischer Texte der Antike. Gttingen, 1998. S. 22, 26; . : Runia D. What is doxography? P. 45f.

.. .

21

38. (. 330327) , , (At. IV,1). Terminus ante quem , . 311 . 306 . . .39 - , , - , , - , 2- , - .

- (Met. 1026a619) -, ( ). , , -. - (, , , , , .), , , .. , - . - - 40 Vetusta placita I . . . , , , , , ( ), ( ). , - , (Theophr. Met. 9a315, 9b2010a4, . At. V,14. 1922. 26 ), , -, , - .

: 38 Partsch J. Des Aristoteles Buch ber das Steigen des Nil // Abhandlungen der

Schsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften 27. 1909. S. 553600. 39 Sedley D. Theophrastus and Epicurean physics // Van Ophuijsen J. M., Van Raal-

te M. (edd.): Theophrastus: Reappraising the sources. New Brunswick; London, 1998. P. 331354.

40 Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 181f.

22

, -, , . , , , ( - ), . (, , - .) - , , , - 41. , (fr. 150); - 42. , , , , (At. I, 7). - (fr. 133141I) - (fr. 142) . , , , , , ., , - , (Arist. Mete. 342b29; Met. 1043a19; Eud. fr. 60, 65). , (Phys. 193b2236) -, -, -. , (fr. 143149) , , , , -, . , - ( ) - , , (De sens. 436a17ff.; De vit. 480b21ff.), , -. , , - 41 Zhmud L. Historiographic project of the Lyceum: The peripatetic history of science,

philosophy, and medicine // Antike Naturwissenschaft und ihre Rezeption 13. 2003. S. 113130; .. . . 181.

42 Zhmud L. Eudemos aus Rhodos, Menon // Flashar H. (ed.). Grundriss der Geschich-te der Philosophie: Die Philosophie der Antike, 3. 2. Aufl. Bern, 2004. S. 562f.

.. .

23

, , 43. , -, , , - 44.

-, , (D. L. V 48), ( )45, ( )46. () ( , ) (Phys. 187a27; Met. 1062b21, 25) 47, - ( ) (Elem. harm. p. 7.3 Da Rios), - , 48. ( -) (137 6b = fr. 241A FHSG) . - () , - 18 (137 4 a-b FHSG)49, (fr. 227C FHSG; . 137 7a). (D. L. V 46, 48) (16 18), . , 50 51, : 43 Zhmud L. Eudemos aus Rhodos, Menon. S. 564f. 44 Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 232; Runia D. The Placita ascribed to doctors in A-

tius doxography. P. 233f.; . Mansfeld J. Physikai doxai and Problmata physica from Aristotle to Atius. P. 65f.; Mansfeld J. Doxographical studies. P. 22.

45 Usener H. Analecta Theophrastea (1858); Diels H. Doxographi Graeci (1879); Re-genbogen O. Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 1395.

46 Mansfeld J. Doxography and dialectic: The Sitz im Leben of the Placita. P. 3057 n. 1; Mansfeld J. Physikai doxai and Problmata physica from Aristotle to Atius (1992); Runia D. Xenophanes or Theophrastus? P. 116 n. 9; Sharples R.W. Theophrastus of Eresus. Commentary, 3.1. Sources on physics. P. 10; Mejer J. berlieferung der Philosophie im Altertum. S. 27.

47 Zhmud L. Revising doxography: Hermann Diels and his critics // Philologus 145. 2001. S. 228, Anm. 45; . : .. : . 2003.

48 .: Mansfeld J. Deconstructing doxography. . 279f. 49 . : Usener H. Analecta Theophrastea. S. 27; Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 102; Regenbogen O. Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 1395.

50 Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 103. 51 Regenbogen O. Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 1536.

24

(137 7a, FHSG; Sharples R.W. Theophrastus of Eresus. 1998. P. 12f).

(fr. 226B, 228B, 234 FHSG; fr. 234 ); , (fr. 241A FHSG). , , , - 52, 53. ( ) ( ) (fr. 140, 148), -. 54 , () 55. , 18 , , 56. , , 57, 58, -59. - , (fr. 143, 144b, 146, 149, 153a, 153c, 176, 238, 279, 298a FHSG). ( Naturalis historia Naturalis auditus: no. 137 1b, 5b FHSG.) , , : , 52 Ibid. S. 1536; Steinmetz P. Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 341. 53 . Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. P. 112f. 54 Zeller E. ber die Bentzung der aristotelischen Metaphysik in den Schriften der l-

teren Peripatetiker (1877) // Zeller E. Kleine Schriften. Bd. I. Berlin, 1910. S. 197. 55 Steinmetz P. Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 334ff. 56 .: Gottschalk H. Rez.: Steinmetz P.

Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos // Gnomon 39. 1967. S. 1726. 57 Mansfeld J. Gibt es Spuren von Theophrasts Phys. Op. bei Cicero? // Fortenbaugh W.,

Steinmetz P. (edd.). Ciceros knowledge of the Peripatos. New Brunswick, 1989. P. 148; Mansfeld J. Sources. P. 26.

58 Runia D. Xenophanes or Theophrastus? P. 117f.; Runia D.T. A difficult chapter in Aetius Book II on cosmology // Brancacci A. (ed.). Philosophy and doxography in the Imperial age. Firenze, 2005. P. 12.

59 Baltussen H. Theophrastus against the Presocratics and Plato. P. 241.

.. .

25

fr. 238 FHSG (), . , , , - 60, (fr. 232 FHSG). - , - (IX, 22 = fr. 227D FHSG) : , IX, 21. , .

Met. 3761, - Phys. I, 2 , - . , , . , , , ( ), , , , . , (In Phys., 22.20 sq.) (Ibid., 28.30 sq. = fr. 229 FHSG), , , 62. , , - 63. - , . , , , - , , -, (fr. 229 FHSG). , - ( ) - 60 Runia D. Xenophanes or Theophrastus? (1992). 61 Zeller E. ber die Bentzung der aristotelischen Metaphysik. S. 197ff. 62 McDiarmid J.B. Theophrastus on Presocratic causes. P. 88f.; Kienle W. von. Die

Berichte ber die Sukzessionen der Philosophen. S. 58ff.; Steinmetz P. Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 346f.; .. . . 229230; .: Mansfeld J. Gibt es Spuren von Theophrasts Phys. Op. bei Cicero? P. 147.

63 Regenbogen O. Theophrastos von Eresos. S. 1536.

26

, -, , : - , - , - (?) 64. , / , , ( - : fr. 226a FHSG), : -, (fr. 227d FHSG). , , . - Vetusta placita (Cic. Luc. 118) (I, 3.16 1217).

, , , . - , - , , - 65. , De sensibus , , , ( 1). - , ( 324), - 66, - , ( 2558), : , , - , 67. , - , 68. 64 Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 103f.; McDiarmid J.B. Theophrastus on Presocratic

causes. P. 88f.; Kienle W. von. Die Berichte ber die Sukzessionen der Philosophen. S. 61f.; .. . . 233.

65 Diels H. ber die Excerpte von Menons Iatrika in dem Londoner Papyrus 137 // Hermes 28. 1893. S. 415.

66 Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 105. 67 .: Mansfeld J. Aristote et la structure du De sensibus de Thophraste (1996);

Baltussen H. Theophrastus against the Presocratics and Plato. P. 15. 68 .. . . 235236; .: Manet-

ti D. Aristotle and the role of doxography in the Anonymus Londinensis // Van der Eijk P. (ed.). Ancient histories of medicine. P. 102. 118f.

.. .

27

4. : Vetusta placita

, , 1874 . -: -, - , -. . , , , 69. Historia philosopha - (V .), , 70, - (. 150 . .). Doxographi Graeci , 31- , 71, , - . Graecarum affectionum curatio (. 430 .), , - , Placita philosophorum - Eclogae physicae (. 420 .), 5 - (. 100 . .). - -, , , , . ( ) , , , -, . - ( V .), - aliorum ex Aetio excerpta. , . -, , , : - 69 Usener H. Analecta Theophrastea (1858). 70 Diels H. De Galeni Historia philosopha. Diss. Bonn, 1870. 71 .: Mansfeld J., Runia D. Atiana. I (1997).

28

(II .) - (III .), (III .), (. 260340) (. 380440), (VI .); - , . - testimonia Plutarchi. , , - , , , Epitome - (I . . .) Vita Homeri.

, , , - 72. , - (- Placita -- ) -73 -. - Vetusta placita , - 74.

Vetusta placita , - , . (Tusc. I, 9); . De pietate (I . . .), (. 200), (II .) (. 200), I . . . , (III .), (I . . .). 75 De somniis (. 40). I . . ., Vetusta placita , , II 1- . I . . . - 72 Mansfeld J., Runia D. Atiana. I (1997). 73 Burkert W. Diels Vorsokratiker. Rckschau und Ausblick // Calder W.M. III,

Mansfeld J. (edd.). Hermann Diels (18481922) et la science de lantiquit. Vanduvres; Genve, 1998. P. 165 ( ); .: Frede M. Atiana // Phronesis 44. 1999. P. 135149.

74 Pasquali G. Doxographica aus Basiliusscholien. S. 221 Anm. 1. 75 Wendland P. Eine doxographische Quelle Philos (1897).

.. .

29

, Vetusta placita I . . ., , 76, .

Vetusta placita - . (6 18 ) , , , ( ) , - , . - , - , 77. - - , (fr. 4849, 137, 222 E.-K.), - (fr. 7, 2627 E.-K.); ; mathmata - (fr. 18, 90 E.-K.). Vetusta placita , , , (At. V, 1; .: Diels H. Dox-ographi Graeci. . 224), (V, 2930), (IV, 12), . , - - : 1) (e.g. At. I, 6); 2) , .. (, , .), (, .), ( - . fr. 111112 E.-K.); 3) (, , ) (, , -). Vetusta placita 78, 79. - , Vetusta placita , Vetustissima placita80, - . - 76 Diels H. ber das physikalische System des Straton // Sitzungsberichte der Preussi-

schen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin. 1893. S. 102. 77 Zhmud L. The origin of the history of science in classical Antiquity. Berlin, 2006. . 288ff.

78 Diels H. ber das physikalische System des Straton. S. 102. 79 Staden H. von. Rupture and continuity. P. 166f. 80 Mansfeld J. Chrysippus and the placita // Phronesis 34. 1989. P. 311342; Mans-

feld J. Doxography and dialectic. P. 3167f.

30

(III . . .) hegemonikon , ( ), , 81 ( -). Vetustissima placita III . . ., .

Vetusta placita , . , De sensibus , , Vetusta placita - . , , , ; - . ( , ) , - ; 10 (At. IV, 9.1). . , (I,2, I,3.34, I,5.3, I,7.7), , 82.

Vetusta placita, , . (I, 10, 1718, 20, 2526, 29; II, 23; III, 10, 16; IV, 12; V, 14, 24, 30), - . (II, 21, 26), , (. IV, 3 ), . - , , - . ( ) - : (I, 5, . II, 1), (II, 34), (II, 8), 81 Runia D. The Placita ascribed to doctors in Atius doxography on physics. P. 233. 82 Diels H. Doxographi Geaci. . 180f.; .: Mansfeld J. Physikai doxai and Problma-

ta physica from Aristotle to Atius. P. 109f.

.. .

31

(IV, 20) (V, 4), etc. - , - , (V, 1 = Cic. De div. III, 5). , , - -- , 83. - (.. - -), () , , , . - - ; , . 84, Phys. I, 2 , . Vetusta placita, , -, . , - 85.

, , , , () () , . , -, 86, -. , - 87, , , , 83 Mansfeld J. Physikai doxai and Problmata physica from Aristotle to Atius.

P. 68ff.; Mansfeld J. Aristote et la structure du De sensibus de Thophraste (1996); Mansfeld J. Doxographical studies. P. 22f.; Runia D.T. A difficult chapter in Aetius Book II. P. 122.

84 .: Mansfeld J. Chrysippus and the placita. P. 311342; Mansfeld J. Doxographical studies. . 22f.

85 Laks A. Du tmoignage comme fragment // Most G.W. (ed.). Collecting fragments = Fragmente sammeln. Gttingen, 1997. P. 257f.

86 Wyss B. Doxographie. Sp. 197210; Mansfeld J., Runia D. Atiana I (1997). 87 .: Mansfeld J. Gibt es Spuren von Theophrasts Phys. Op. bei Cicero? (1989) .

32

Phys. I, 2 . , -, - , - (In Phys., 20.12, 28.31, 179.28, 204.27, 404.21, etc.). , (. . 235), ( , ), (IIIII .?), (IV .), , , , .. -, , , - . , - , .

5.

, II . - , -: 1) 18 ( 16) , 2) 2- , 3) Vetusta placita 6 , 4) 5 5) 5 , -. , , , - , .. Vetusta placita, -. .

( ) , - . , , -, . , -, , , -, - , . . - 88. , , - , - 88 Burnet J. Early Greek philosophy. 4th ed. London, 1930. P. 34f.

.. .

33

. , 89 - , , . , , , -, , -: (), , .. , - , , ; . doxai - ( ) ; 90, - : , , , 91. , - : , , .., - . , 92. - : , .

I - Refutatio 93, . (I, 14: , , , ) , , . (I, 616) , - , : -, , .. , , 94. 89 Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 579ff.; 651ff. 90 Ibid. . 587f. 91 . : Ibid. . 588.18. 92 Ibid. . 156f. 93 Ibid. . 553f. 94 Kienle W. von. Die Berichte ber die Sukzessionen der Philosophen. S. 23f.; Mejer

J. Diogenes Laertius and his Hellenistic background. P. 83f.; Mansfeld J. Heresiog-raphy in context (1992).

34

, , , , , , ; - - 95. , , -, (. At. I 3,1. 3,9). , - (I, 13.1, 14.1), . , , , haireseis96.

, - . , - , De Platone et eius dogmate . , - (1- . III .) 10 , : , - . , , , . - , -. - , . , , . , - -. , , -. -. 97, : , , , - , . - , . 95 Mejer J. Diogenes Laertius and his Hellenistic background. P. 66; 91 n. 60. 96 Mansfeld J. Heresiography in context. P. 18ff. 97 Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. . 161ff.

.. .

35

1. Daiber H. Aetius Arabus. Die Vorsokratiker in arabischer berlieferung. Wiesbaden, 1980. - -.

2. Daiber H. The Meteorology of Theophrastus in Syriac and Arabic trans-lation // Fortenbaugh W., Gutas D. (edd.). Theophrastus of Eresus: His psy-chological, doxographical and scientific writings. New Brunswick, 1992. P. 166293.

3. Diels H. Doxographi Graeci. Berlin, 1879 (repr. Berlin, 1965). 4. Fortenbaugh W. W., Huby P. M., Sharples R. W., Gutas D. (edd.). The-

ophrastus of Eresus: Sources for his life, writings, thought, and influence. Pt. 12. Leiden, 1992. , - (fr. 224241a).

5. Giannattasio Andria R. I frammenti delle Successioni dei filosofi. Napoli, 1989.

6. Gigante M. Frammenti di Ippoboto // Mastrocinque A. (ed.). Omaggio a Piero Treves. Padova, 1984. P. 151193.

7. Usener H. Analecta Theophrastea. Bonn, 1858 (repr: Usener H. Kleine Schriften, I. Leipzig, 1912; Osnabrck, 1965). P. 5087: .

8. Wehrli F. (ed.). Sotion. Basel, 1978 [Die Schule des Aristoteles, Sup- plbd. II].

9. Baltussen H. Theophrastus against the Presocratics and Plato: Peripatet-

ic dialectic in the De sensibus. Leiden, 2000. 1-e .: Theophrastus on theories of perception: Argument and purpose in the De sensibus. Diss. Utrecht, 1993.

10. Baltussen H. Plato in the Placita (Atius bk. IV): A Dielsian blind spot // Philologus 144. 2000. . 227238.

11. Berti E. Sul carattere dialettico della storiografia filosofica di Aristotele // Cambiano G. (ed.). Storiografia e dossografia nella filosofia antica. Torino, 1986. P. 101125.

12. Bremmer J. Atius, Arius Didymus and the transmission of doxog-raphy // Mnemosyne 51. 1998. P. 154160.

13. Burkert W. Diels Vorsokratiker. Rckschau und Ausblick // Cal- der W.M. III, Mansfeld J. (edd.). Hermann Diels (18481922) et la science de lantiquit. Vanduvres; Genve, 1998. P. 169197.

14. Burnet J. Early Greek philosophy. 4th ed. London, 1930.

36

15. Cherniss H. Aristotles criticism of Presocratic philosophy. Baltimo- re, 1935.

16. Diels H. De Galeni Historia philosopha. Diss. Bonn, 1870. 17. Diels H. ber die Excerpte von Menons Iatrika in dem Londoner Pa-

pyrus 137 // Hermes 28. 1893. S. 407434. 18. Diels H. ber das physikalische System des Straton // Sitzungsberichte

der Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin. 1893. S. 101127 (repr.: Diels H. Kleine Schriften zur Geschichte der antiken Philosophie. Darmstadt, 1969. S. 239265).

19. Frede M. Atiana // Phronesis 44. 1999. P. 135149. . : Mans-feld J., Runia D. Atiana: The method and intellectual context of a doxogra-pher. Vol. 1. The sources. Leiden, 1997.

20. Fritz K. von. Die Bedeutung des Aristoteles fr die Geschichtsschrei-bung // Entretiens Fondation Hardt IV. 1956. S. 83128.

21. Gigon O. Die Geschichtlichkeit der Philosophie bei Aristoteles // Ar-chivio di filosofia 23. 1954. S. 129150.

22. Gigon O. Die der Vorsokratiker bei Theophrast und Aristote- les // Dring I. (ed.). Naturphilosophie bei Aristoteles und Theophrast. Hei-delberg, 1969. S. 114123.

23. Gottschalk H. Rez.: Steinmetz P. Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos // Gnomon 39. 1967. S. 1726.

24. Guthrie W.K.C. Aristotle as a historian of philosophy: Some prelimi-naries // Journal of Helleni Studies 77. 1954. P. 3441.

25. Jaeger W. Aristoteles. Grundlegung einer Geschichte seiner Entwick-lung. Berlin, 1923.

26. Jaeger W.: Rec.: H. Cherniss: Aristotles criticism of Presocratic phi-losophy // American Journal of Philology 63. 1937. P. 350356.

27. Kienle W. von. Die Berichte ber die Sukzessionen der Philosophen in der hellenistischen und sptantiken Literatur. Diss. Berlin. 1961.

28. Kingsley P. Empedocles and his interpreters: The four-element doxo-graphy // Phronesis 39. 1994. P. 235254.

29. Laks A. Du tmoignage comme fragment // Most G.W. (ed.). Collecting fragments = Fragmente sammeln. Gttingen, 1997. P. 237276.

30. Lebedev A. : Neglected fragments of Democritus and Metrodorus of Chios // Proceedings of the 1st intern. Congress on Democritus. Xanthi, 1984. P. 1318.

31. Lebedev A. Did the doxographer Aetius ever exist? // Philosophie et Culture. Actes du 18e Congrs mondial de philosophie, 3. Montral, 1988. P. 813817.

32. Manetti D. Aristotle and the role of doxography in the Anonymus Londinensis // Van der Eijk P. (ed.): Ancient histories of medicine. Essays in medical doxography and historiography in classical Antiquity. Leiden, 1999. P. 95141.

.. .

37

33. Mansfeld J. Aristotle, Plato, and the Preplatonic doxography and chronography // Cambiano G. (ed.). Storiografia e dossografia nella filosofia antica. Torino, 1986. P. 159 (repr.: Mansfeld J. Studies in the historiography of Greek philosophy. Assen, 1990. P. 2283).

34. Mansfeld J. Chrysippus and the placita // Phronesis 34. 1989. P. 311342. 35. Mansfeld J. Gibt es Spuren von Theophrasts Phys. Op. bei Cicero? //

Fortenbaugh W., Steinmetz P. (edd.). Ciceros knowledge of the Peripatos. New Brunswick, 1989. P. 133168 (repr: Mansfeld J. Studies in the historio- graphy of Greek philosophy. Assen, 1990. P. 238263).

36. Mansfeld J. Doxography and dialectic: The Sitz im Leben of the Placita // Aufstieg und Niedergang der rmischen Welt, II 36.4. 1990. S. 30573231.

37. Mansfeld J. Physikai doxai and Problmata physica from Aristotle to Atius (and beyond) // Fortenbaugh W., Gutas D. (edd.): Theophrastus of Ere-sus: His psychological, doxographical and scientific writings. New Bruns-wick, 1992. P. 63111.

38. Mansfeld J. Heresiography in context. Hippolytus Elenchos as a source for Greek philosophy. Leiden, 1992.

39. Mansfeld J. Aristote et la structure du De sensibus de Thophraste // Phronesis 41. 1996. P. 158188.

40. Mansfeld J. Doxographical studies, Quellenforschung, tabular presenta-tion and other varieties of comparativism // Burkert W. et al. (ed.). Fragment-sammlungen philosophischer Texte der Antike. Gttingen, 1998. P. 1640.

41. Mansfeld J. Doxographi Graeci // Calder W. M. III, Mansfeld J. (edd.). Hermann Diels (18481922) et la science de lantiquit. Vanduvres; Genve, 1998. P. 143164.

42. Mansfeld J. Sources // Long A.A. (ed.). The Cambridge companion to early Greek philosophy. Cambridge, 1999. P. 2244.

43. Mansfeld J. Sources // Algra K. et al. (edd.). The Cambridge history of Hellenistic philosophy. Cambridge, 1999. P. 330.

44. Mansfeld J. Cosmic distances: Aetius 2. 31 Diels and some related texts // Canto-Sperber M., Pellegrin P. (ed.). Le style de la pense. Recueil de textes en hommage J. Brunschwig. Paris, 2002. P. 429463.

45. Mansfeld J. Deconstructing doxography // Philologus 146. 2002. P. 277286.

46. Mansfeld J. Plato, Pythagoras, Aristotle, the Peripatetics, the Stoics, and Thales and his followers On causes // Brancacci A. (ed.). Antichi e moderni nella filosofia det imperiale. Napoli, 2002. P. 1768.

47. Mansfeld J., Runia D. Atiana: The method and intellectual context of a doxographer, 1. The sources. Leiden, 1997; 2. The Compendium (2 vols). Leiden, 2009; 3. Studies in the doxographical traditions of ancient philo- sophy. Leiden, 2009. 19892009 ., -.

38

48. McDiarmid J.B. Theophrastus on Presocratic causes // Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 61. 1953. P. 85156.

49. Mejer J. Diogenes Laertius and his Hellenistic background. Wiesba-den, 1978.

50. Mejer J. berlieferung der Philosophie im Altertum. Eine Einfhrung. Copenhagen, 2000. -.

51. Owen G.E.L. Tithenai ta Phainomena (1961) // Owen G.E.L. Logic, science and dialectic. Ithaca, 1986. P. 239251.

52. Partsch J. Des Aristoteles Buch ber das Steigen des Nil // Ab-handlungen der Schsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften 27. 1909. S. 553600.

53. Pasquali G. Doxographica aus Basiliusscholien // Nachrichten der Gttingen Wiss. Gesellschaft 1910. S. 194228.

54. Patzer A. Der Sophist Hippias als Philosophiehistoriker. Freiburg, 1986.

55. Regenbogen O. Theophrastos von Eresos // Paulys Real-Encyclopdie, Suppl. 7. 1940. S. 13541562.

56. Runia D. Xenophanes or Theophrastus? An Atian doxographicum on the sun // Fortenbaugh W., Gutas D. (edd.). Theophrastus of Eresus: His psy-chological, doxographical and scientific writings. New Brunswick, 1992. P. 112140.

57. Runia D. What is doxography? // Van der Eijk P. (ed.): Ancient histo-ries of medicine. Essays in medical doxography and historiography in classi-cal Antiquity. Leiden, 1999. P. 3355.

58. Runia D. The Placita ascribed to doctors in Atius doxography on physics // Van der Eijk P. (ed.). Ancient histories of medicine. Essays in me- dical doxography and historiography in classical Antiquity. Leiden, 1999. P. 189250.

59. Runia D.T. A difficult chapter in Aetius Book II on cosmology // Brancacci A. (ed.). Philosophy and doxography in the Imperial age. Firenze, 2005. P. 122.

60. Sedley D. Theophrastus and Epicurean physics // Van Ophuijsen J. M., Van Raalte M. (edd.). Theophrastus: reappraising the sources. New Bruns-wick; London, 1998. P. 331354.

61. Sharples R.W. Theophrastus of Eresus. Commentary, 3.1. Sources on physics. Leiden, 1998.

62. Staden H. von. Rupture and continuity: Hellenistic reflections on the history of medicine // Van der Eijk P. (ed.). Ancient histories of medicine. Essays in medical doxography and historiography in classical Antiquity. Lei-den, 1999. P. 143187.

63. Steinmetz P. Die Physik des Theophrastos von Eresos. Berlin, 1964.

.. .

39

64. Stratton G.M. Theophrastus and the Greek physiological psychology before Aristotle. London, 1917 (repr: Amsterdam, 1965). De sensibus - . .

65. Ueberweg F., Praechter K. Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie. I. Teil: Die Philosophie des Altertums. 11. Aufl. Berlin, 1920.

66. Wendland P. Eine doxographische Quelle Philos // Sitzungsberichte der Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin. 1897. S. 10741079.

67. Wyss B. Doxographie // Reallexikon fr Antike und Christentum. Bd. 4. Stuttgart, 1959. Sp. 197210.

68. Zeller E. ber die Bentzung der aristotelischen Metaphysik in den Schriften der lteren Peripatetiker (1877) // Zeller E. Kleine Schriften I. Ber-lin, 1910. S. 191214.

69. Zhmud L. Revising doxography: Hermann Diels and his critics // Philologus 145. 2001. P. 219243, . .: .. - : (2003).

70. Zhmud L. Historiographic project of the Lyceum: The peripatetic his-tory of science, philosophy, and medicine // Antike Naturwissenschaft und ihre Rezeption 13. 2003. S. 113130.

71. Zhmud L. Eudemos aus Rhodos, Menon // Flashar H. (ed.). Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie: Die Philosophie der Antike, 3. 2. Aufl. Bern, 2004. S. 558565.

72. .. . ., 2002. . .: Zhmud L. The origin of the history of science in classical Antiquity. Berlin, 2006.

73. .. : // - 2002. .: , 2003. . 534.

40

.. :

(

O )

- , : , . . ( Parva Naturalia), , : (453b1124)1, (464b1618)2. - , . . , - 3. 1 , ; , ; -, , , - , - , , , , . , , , , , , . , -, , , - , [ -] , , , - ( 453b1124).

2 , , , - , ( 464b1618).

3 , - , , (453b24454a11).

.. .

41

, - .

(. , . De divinatione per somnum)4 - , , - , , - . - : ? ? , ? , - , , , . , , - . , , . , , ?

, , , , - , . -, - , . - , , . , , , , , : - , ( 462b1314). 4 :

Aristotelis. De somno et vigilia, De insomniis et De divinatione per somnium / Rec. G. A. Becker. Leipzig: Teubner, 1923; Aristotelis. De insomniis et De divinatione per somnium / A new Edition of the Greek text with the Latin translation by H. J. Drossaart Lulofs. Vol. 12. Leiden: Brill, 1947; : Aristoteles. ber Trame, ber Weissagung im Schlaf / bersetzt und erlautert von Ph. J. Van der Eijk // Aristoteles. Werke in deutscher bersetzung / Hrsg. von E. Grumach, H. Flashar. Bd. 14, Teil III. Berlin, 1994; Aristote. La vrit des songes, De la divination dans le sommeil / Traduit du grec et prsent par J. Pi- geaud. Paris, 1995.

42

, , .

, - . . , - , , , . - , ( ), , - .

, , . . , - ( )5. , : , . , : - , . - , - , , .

? - , ? (, ) , , , . , ( ), , - -, , . - (), , , , . , : , - , . 5 ., .: . 277d10; 158b6; 382e11, 476c4 . , ( (453b18), (463b12), . .: (9578). II 1, 335b8 - : , .

.. .

43

, , , - . , , . , , (. 464b516). , - , - , , : , , : ; 6.

, , . , ( : XIV 495), , . . , , ( , , , )7, , , , 8. - ., - , -, , , 9.

(.: 463b13: ... ). : , - 6 . XIX 555556 / . . . 7 .: I 63 ( ); II 5 .; X 496; IV 796 .

(); XIX 604 () .; VII 138 (, , , ( Eustath. Ad Odyss (ad loc.)) ( Scholia in Homeri Odyss. (ad loc.)).

8 .: XIX 559568, - , : .

9 .. . .; ., 2000. . 114.

44

, , - , . , : , , , , - , . - , , - . : , [] , -, (462b2022). : , , (463b15). , , , , , , , , - (462b2425).

- , . , - 10. , - - , , - .

, . . - 10 .: . VII 1220: , ( ) , , , , . , - , (VII 1218). , , -. , - , , , - (. VII 19).

.. .

45

- (2- . II . . .). , -, , , -, (Cic. De divin. I 20; II 70; D. L. II 46; Tertull. De an. 46), (D. L. V 59; Tertull. De an. 46), (Cic. De divin. I 39 = SVF II 1199; II 134 = SVF II 134; Artemid. IV 65) (Artemid. II 66). (. I, 2029).

- ( ), (-, , , II 46, ). , , , (. DK 87 A 8; B 7881).

. (44b) , , ( ) , : -! . (60) , , , - , -, , , .

- ; 420 . . . . ; - . - , -. , , - , , .

46

- , , - - :

, , , ; , - ( X, 910a26).

-: , .

V . .. . - , . - - : , -, , - . , IV . - . - , - , . : , , -, ?

(460370 . . .) - , . - , .

, - , . (). , - . (, - , , ), , - .

.. .

47

, , . , , , ( , ) ( 4641215). , , . - , - . , . : , - , 11. , -, (. . ) -, . , , , , , (4642224). , - 12.

IV . . , , . (7172) , , . , - , - - . , 11 , , -, , . , , - . , - - , . , , , ( , , ) , .

12 . : .. . , 1970. . 322 (. 472).

48

.

, - , , - . . - , . - , , , - . - () (), ( 7167). , - , . , , , - . , , , , -, , - . , , , , . , , , - (71d). , , , . , , , - , .

, : , , , . - , - , , , .

- , , .

.. .

49

IV, 2, 676b22: -, , , .

, . , , .

, . - , , . , , - , - . : , . , -, , . , , , .

, - . , , , . , , . , , . . , ( VIII 7). - : , , , . (. 10 Rose = . 21). , . - .

- , -

50

, . , , , - 13, - . , . - : , ( , ). . , , - (). - (-, ). , , , - , . , - .

, , - : , ( 455b22). - , , , -, (454b). - .

, , , . , , - ( 463b12). , - , , . , , , , , , , . - , [ ] ( 13 .: . IX, 572a .

.. .

51

IV 10, 536b2730, . .. ). , , , 14. , . . .

- , . , , . , . . , , , - : , , 15. , , , . - . -, - , , . . , .

, - , . - , , - . , , , . - [-] , [] 14 . III 3, 428a2324: - (), () . - , -, , - , (42868); , . , -, : -, , , (911).

15 : , - ; : - , - ; : - (. 462b28 .).

52

( 463a47). - , - .

-, , : - , , : (463a811).

-, . : , -, , , , , - , - (463b). , - . ( , , , ), .. , , -. - , - , - 16.

, VIII, 124840, - , -, (). , , , .

-, , , , . - - , - , -, - 16 .: Aristoteles. Problemata 30, 9541238: 1) (), (45319); 2) , , (4572733) 3) (4612123), -, - . , 4) - (463b17) 5) (4643233).

.. .

53

, , - , (46323.). , -, : , (- VII 16). - , : , , , . - , . , - : , , - ( , - , , ).

. , . , - , -, , , ( 4643032). , , - .

, -, - , -: , , , -, , , - . , , (46312.). , , - , -: .

, . , - , ,

54

(. 464b14). , , .

, - . , , . , , , . -, , , -, , ( ) , - ( ) ( 463b28 .). 9- -: , , , , . , -, . ( , , ), , - , - .

* * *

, , ( - IV . . .), - , XIX . -17. .

, , - . , -, , . 17 . . .: . / . .. // . -. . 2. .: , 1944.

.. .

55

(= IV) , - . - , -, , , :

, , - , - : , , , , ; , - . , , , - . , -, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ( IV, p. 86, 213 Littr).

, , (-) . , , . - , . - , , .

-. , , , , - , : , , , , , - (p. 87, 1012 Littr).

- , . - () : , , , - , , - , . : , , ,

56

. - , .

, , ( . .). : , ; - , - ; , , , , , , - - .

-, , - . - , , . - , , , - . -, , , , . , , . , - , .

-, . , , - , - (), - (464b24). , , - , - .

.. .

57

Aristoteles. De insomniis et De divinatione per somnium / A new Edi- tion of the Greek text with the Latin translation by H. J. Drossaart Lulofs. Vol. 12. Leiden: Brill, 1947.

Aristoteles. De somno et vigilia, De insomniis et De divinatione per somnium / Rec. G.A. Becker. Leipzig: Teubner, 1923.

Aristoteles. Fragmenta varia / Ed. V. Rose // Aristotelis qui ferebantur librorum fragmenta. Leipzig: Teubner, 1886 (repr. Stuttgart: 1967). P. 23104 (Dialogi).

Aristoteles. ber Trame, ber Weissagung im Schlaf / bersetzt und erlautert von Ph.J. van der Eijk // Aristoteles. Werke in deutscher berset- zung / Hrsg. von E. Grumach, H. Flashar. Bd. 14, Teil III. Berlin, 1994.

Aristote. La vrit des songes, De la divination dans le sommeil / Traduit du grec et prsent par J. Pigeaud. Padris, 1995.

Aristotle. On Sleep and Dreams / A Text and Translation with Introduction, Notes and Glossary by David Gallop. Warminster, 1996.

Aristotle. On the Soul. Parva Naturalia. On Breath / With an Eng- lish Translation by W.S. Hett. Cambridge (Mass.): Harvard University Press, 1957 (repr. 2000). P. 374385.

Hippocrates. De diaeta i-iv // uvres compltes d'Hippocrate / Traduction nouvelle avec le texte grec en regard, par . Littr. In 10 vols. Vol. 6. Paris: Baillire, 1849 (repr. Amsteram: Hakkert, 1962). P. 466662.

Michaelis Ephesii. In Parva naturalia commentaria / Ed. P. Wend- land. Berlin: Reimer, 1903 [Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca XXII. 1]. P. 7786.

Themistii (Sophoniae). In Parva naturalia commentarium / Ed. P. Wend- land. Berlin: Reimer, 1903 [Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca V. 6]. P. 144.

. .: 4 . .: , 19761984. . / . .. . .: , 1996. . / . . .. -

// / . . .. . .: , 2010. . 169175.

. / . . . // . . . 6. .: , 2005. . 423432.

. . IV / . .. , .. , .. , .. . . .. - // . 1989. 4. 1990. 24; 1991. 13.

58

. / . . .. . .: , 1972; .: , 1993.

. / . .. // . . . 2 .: , 1944.

: . . / . . .. . : , 1970.

. / . . .. .. . .: , 1977.

. . .: 4 . .: , 19901994. . / . .. // -

. .: 2 . . 1. .: , 1975.

Bouche-Leclercq A. Histoire de la divination dans lantiquite. T. IIV. Paris, 18791882.

Holowchak M.A. Aristotle on Dreaming: What Goes On in Sleep When the Big Fire Goes Out // Ancient Philosophy. Vol. 16. 2. 1996. P. 405424.

Kany-Turpin J., Pellegrin P. Cicero and the Aristotelian Theory of Divination by Dreams // Fortenbaugh W.W., Steinmetz P. (eds.). Ciceros Knowledge of the Peripatos. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1989.

Wijsenbeek-Wijler H. Aristotles Concept of Soul, Sleep and Dreams. Amsterdam: Hakkert, 1978.

.. (1951) / . . .. -. .; .: , 2000.

.. // . 1927. . 1051 .

.. ( ) // - / . . .. . .: , 2010. . 176228.

.. : oneiros chora // . ., 2001. . 340360.

.. .

59

..

() . - , . , , , , 1, . , ( , , ), 2, . , - ( , , , ). . (, : , ).

- : , 1 Sext. Adv. math. VII 159. 2

(Luc. 40, 83), Adv. math. VII 154; 160164. , .

60

, 3, , , - . , - , 4. , , , 5. - . , ad hominem, . , 3 (Cic.

Luc. 28, Sext. Pyrrh. I 226, 234). Pyrrh. I, 23 . , - . , .. , ( .. . ., 1976. C. 497), , : , ( . . 501). , -, . : 2030 (Cicero. On Academic Scepticism / Translated, with introd. and notes, by Charles Brittain. Indianapolis; Cambridge, 2006. P. viii). . : Striker G. Sceptical strategies // Striker G. Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology and Ethics. Cambridge, 1996. P. 92.

4 Cic. Ac. 1, 45: , , , , . Luc. 28: , .

5 Brittain C. Philo of Larissa: The Last of the Academic Sceptics. Oxford, 2001. P. 4: , , , , , , , . - , ( , p. 130), ( , ) - , (for the purpose of the argument).

.. .

61

.

, , , - , (/- ).

, -. - - , 6. 6 (). 10- , , (602c603b). - (264b12) , () -, , (). , , - () , . . - . De An. III 3, (), (), () (). , -, . - (), - (). , , , -, . -, ( , , ), , - , . , - , . , , , . , , . : , (De An. III 3, 427b18). , , - (De An. III 3, 428a 12). (. Sext. Adv. math. VII 203 ., 8, 63; Epic. Ad Hdt. 50), - . , , .

62

() . , 7 8. 9, . - , - , 10. , -, - , (). , , . 11, ()12.

, - . - ()13. - 14, 15, . , - 16.

, /, - , - . - , - . - . : 7 SVF II 54: . [ . ..]. 8 SVF II 53: . 9 Sext. Adv. math. VII 228231. 10 , . 478 (), Plat. Theaet. 191c ., Arist. De An. 424a 17 . 11 De An. II 5. 12 De An. 429a3 . , - , , , - , .

13 , .: Plat. Rep. 382a, Phdr. 81d, Soph. 266b.

14 D.L. VII 50 = SVF II 55. 15 Aetius 4, 12, 4 = SVF II 54. 16 .: D.L. VII 46.

.. .

63

[ ] , , 17. , [. . . ..] , , 18 ( ), - . 19, , , . , ( )20.

: , -

[ . ..]21.

, : 1) , 2) . , , , - , .

- - . ? , . -, - 17 , : - (. ).

18 , . , . , , , , , - .

19 , . 20 D.L. VII 46. 21 Sext. Adv. math. VII 248.

64

. , - -. -, , - 22. ( ) - . - - , , , . , , , , -, 23. , - , . , , , , - 24.

-, . - . - 25, , , 26. : - 22 .: D.L. VII 46: , -. , , - (, ) (, -, ).

23 Cic. Luc. 52: , , , -, .

24 .: Sext. Adv. math. VII 252. 25 , , , - , . , -, - ( - ), - . , -, , , - . , , - , .

26 Cic. Ac. 1, 40.

.. .

65

, , , / (). , - 27. , .

28 . 1) , . 2) . , , , , , . 3) , , , 29, , , . 4) 27 SVF I 68. 28 Cic. Ac. 1, 42: [. . . ..] - , [ Ac. 1, 41. ..]. , , , . , , , , , (facta sensibus), , . , , , , [. -, cadere. ..] . [. . , - . ..] (norma scientiae) (principium sui), - , (principia), .

29 ., .: Cic. Ac. 1, 41 (= SVF I 60): -, . - Sext. Adv. math. VII 151: = (. . , ). : , , - (Ibid. VII 154).

66

. , .

, , : 30 31. , , . .

Luc. 7982 , . : , ?32 , Luc. 83 - , . . -, 33 , , , - . -, . , , . - , - . , . , , , modus tollens , - . 30 Sext. Adv. math. VII 153154. , , -.

31 Ibid. VII 154155. . , , , - , . - .

32 Luc. 79: Quid ergo est quod percipi possit, si ne sensus quidem vera nuntiant? 33 Cic. Luc. 19: , .

.. .

67

, . , , , , , , , , . , , , - , , ( ) 34. : , : , , , 35 .

, , - , , Luc. 83. 36.

37, - , . , : . , , , . , .

[ 138]. . , 39. 34 Sext. Adv. math. VII 163. 35 Ibid. VII 164. 36Cicero. On Academic Scepticism / Transl. by C. Brittain. Indianapolis; Cambr.,

2006. P. xxii : core Academic argument. . 2. 37 Cic. Luc. 83: , , , , .

38 , , .

39 Cic. Luc. 7982.

68

, , . - , .

[ 2]. . , , , [ 2] .

[ 3]. , (inter quae visa nihil intersit), -, . , - ( ) - ( , , -). , inter quae visa nihil intersit Luc. 83. ( , . . ). - , , . . . , - , , , - , . - [ 3], , , , : .

[ 4]. , , -, , - [].

. , - . , -. , . - , , , [ 4], - . Luc. 84, -

.. .

69

. , - , - 40, 41, , , (-) . , , , 42. -, , ( ), , -, 43.

, , , , , [ 4] , - .

[]. - , . [] , [ 4].

[]. , , .. -.

44. , . , - , - , . - - -? Luc. 103 , , , , 40 Luc. 84: , - .

41 . Luc. 84. 42 Luc. 40. 43 . Luc. 84: , -.

44 Cic. Luc. 3336, 58, 69, 84, 101, 103, . Sext. Adv. math. VII 160164.

70

45. Luc. 101 , - , , . Luc. 36 , - , - - .

, , , . , , ( , - 46), - . - , -, , 47. , . -. () (), , - 48.

, , , , , - .

, , , , [] [], - , [ 4] . , 45 , .

46 - : Brittain C. Philo of Larissa. P. 73128.

47 .: Luc. 34. Adv. math. VII 143, .

48 Sext. Adv. math. VII 203.

.. .

71

, [] [] [ 4]. , , , - [ 4]. .

- [ 3] [ 4]:

[C]. , - . ( ) , . , . , , - , -. , - . , , - (, , ) . -, ( , ), -- , - . - - , . - , - , -.

[]. . , . , , . , , - . - . , , 49 - 49 Frede M. The Sceptics Two Kinds of Assent and the Question of the Possibility of

knowledge // Frede M. Essays in Ancient Philosophy. Oxford, 1987. P. 201222.

72

, (having a view) , (making a claim), - - . : , - - , . , , - 50. , ( having a view making a claim ). , , .

[ 4] - . , - ( , - ) . , - . , 51. , - 52. - . , , , , , , , . -, Luc. 84, ( , , , , ), , . - . , , , 50 . 6. 51 Sext. Adv. math. VII 252. 52 .: Cic. Luc. 84.

.. .

73

-53. , 54, , - !

, . , - , , . , - , - . . , - , - , . - 55.

, (, , )56, . - . , - : -57, . 53 .: Cic. Luc. 85. 54 Plut. De comm. not. 1077 c. 55 , -, . - , . , , . , , ,

56 , [] - .

57 Sext. Adv. math. VII 402408, Cic. Luc. 8790. 23- , , , .

74

, (vis) , (integritas)58 - . , 59, , , -. -, . , , -, , - . , 60.

, , , . , -- , . , , , , . - , , , , . , - . - , , -, , , , -, - . , . , , 58 Cic. Luc. 52. 59 Sext. Adv. math. VII 403; 405. 60 , , , , , . , - . - , - ( / . .. . 3- . .: -, 2008. C. 240).

.. .

75

-.

, , . , - , , , . , - , , , , - -. , .

, , ,

, . . , -, , , - . , - : , , .

. -, - , . , , , 61. -, , 62. -, - , -63. , , , , , 61 Cic. Luc. 73. 62 .: Luc. 68. 63 .: Luc. 101.

76

, 64. - , -, .

, - : -, - - - . , , - . - 65, . , , . , , - , , .

- , -? , . - , 66, - ( , 67, - ). , , , . Luc. 99, -68. ? - 64 Luc. 77. 65 , . : Allen J. Academic Probabilism and Stoic Epistemology // Classical Quarterly. 1994. 44. P. 85113.

66 Ac. 1, 45. 67 . Sext. Pyrrh. I 234. 68 Cic. Luc. 99: , (etenim contra naturam esset, si probabile nihil esset).

.. .

77

, -, . - - , -. , , - . , , .

- , - , - . , . -, -. , , , - , , . , 69, , , , , , , , . , (temeritatem) , , . , - 70. , - , . . , (ut feram et immanem belluam)71. - .

-, , , . , : -, - 69 Cic. Luc. 66. 70 Cic. Ac. 1, 45. 71 Cic. Luc. 108.

78

, , , ; -, - , - , , , ; -, -, , . , , , , , , , - . . , , , -, , , , , - (Evidenz) . - (philosophy of perception). - XX . -72, qualia73, 74.

. [4] 72 Sense-data , , ; .

73 Qualia , - , qualia - , .

74 , , , . (beliefs theories) 1960- ., , - .

.. .

79

. [4] . , - . , - . , ( ), - , - . - , - , . , , - . - . , -, , ( - , - ). , , -.

, , , , . - - , , - , - , . , , , - , , - , -. , - . , - , - . - . , , - .

80

. con- fessio ignorationis - 75. , - - - -. - 76, . - , 77, , - . - , - .

. Cic. Ac. 1 (Academica posteriora), Luc. (Lucullus) (Academica priora).

1. Cicero. On Academic Scepticism / Transl., with introduction and notes,

by Charles Brittain. Indianapolis; Cambridge, 2006. 2. M Tulli Ciceronis Academica / Ed. by J. Reid. London, 1885. 3. Plutarque. Oevres morales. Trait 72. Sur les notiones communes,

contre les Stociens. Paris : Belles Lettres, 2002. 4. Sexti Empirici Opera. Vol. 12 / Ed. by H. Mutschmann. Leipzig,

19121914.

1. Brittain C. Philo of Larissa. The Last of the Academic Sceptics. Oxford:

Oxford University Press, 2001. 2. The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Scepticism / Ed. by R. Bett.

Cambridge, 2010. 75 Ac. 1, 44. 76 Luc. 99105. 77 Luc. 78, . Luc. 148.

.. .

81

3. Frede M. The Sceptics Two Kinds of Assent and the Question of the Possibility of knowledge // Frede M. Essays in Ancient Philosophy. Oxford, 1987. P. 201222.

4. Frede M. Stoic Epistemology //The Cambridge History of Hellenistic Philosophy / Ed. by K. Algra, J. Barnes, J. Mansfeld, M. Schofield. Cambridge, 1999. P. 295322.

5. Perin C. Academic Arguments for the Indiscernibility Thesis // Pacific Philosophical Quarterly. 2005. Vol. 86. P. 493517.

6. Schofield M. Academic Epistemology // The Cambridge History of Hellenistic Philosophy / Ed. by K. Algra, J. Barnes, J. Mansfeld, M. Schofield. Cambridge, 1999. P. 323351.

7. Striker G. // Striker G. Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology and Ethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996. P. 2276.

8. Striker G. Sceptical Strategies // Doubt and Dogmatism: Studies in Hellenistic Epistemology / Ed. by M. Schofield, M. Burnyeat and J. Barnes. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1980. P. 5483.

9. Tarrant H. Scepticism or Platonism? The Philosophy of the Fourth Academy. Cambridge, 1985.

82

..

,

(129210/217 . . .) - , - - 1500 . 100 : - , , , , -, , , , ; , , , - -. , (, ). , , - , . , - , .

. 129 . . . , - 1. , , , (Aff. dig. V 40 = SM1 31, 912). , (Libr. prop. XIX 58 = SM2 88, 715). - , , , - (Aff. dig. V 4142 = SM2 88, 715). 1 .: Hankinson R.J. The man and his work //

The Cambridge Companion to Galen / Ed. by R.J. Hankinson. Cambridge, 2008. P. 133; : Singer P. Galen: Selected Works. Oxford, 1997.

.. .

83

, , . (Libr. prop. XIX 5759 = SM2 87, 819; 88, 1317). 149 . , - , (Ibid. XIX 1617 = SM2 97, 623) (Ibid. XIX 1617 = SM2 97, 698). , (De anat. adm. II 217218). 157 . , - , - . 161 . , - , , , , .

, - , , - . , , , - (Loc. aff. VIII 361366). , (XIV 606607 = 74, 1776, 8). , -, (XIV 611612 = 80, 1525). , , - (XIV 614615 = 84, 110) , (XIV 617628 = 86, 730). , - (XIV 612 = 80, 2527), - . , - . - . (De natomicis dministra-tionibus)

84

. - , - , . , - (Praen. XIV 627). , - (XIV 612 = 80, 2527). 6 (De placitis Hippocratis et Platonis) - , I - (De usu partium), , .

166 . , - . - . , , 168169 ., . , - (Libr. prop. XIX 18 = SM2, 98, 2399, 3).

169 . , - . , , - , , 7 . - . -, , , , (Praen. XIV 665 = 134, 38). - , - , -, . - . - , , -, , , ., -

.. .

85

, , , , - , . , - , (Puls. VIII 462477). , , 6 .

180 . , 192 . , , - . - , . 192 . , . - , (Hipp. Epid. VI comm. VIII = CMG V 10, 2, 2, 495, 212). . , III . 2. , (Ars medica) , - , , - , . , , , , , - .

. , , 1819 1833 .3, - , 4. , , 2 Hankinson R.J. The man and his work. P. 22; Nutton V. Ancient Medicine. London,

2004. Ch. 15. 3 Galeni Opera Omnia / Rec. C.G. Khn. T. 120. Leipzig, 18191833. 4 Hankinson R. J. Preface // The Cambridge Companion to Galen. P. XVI.

86

XX . XIX . 1884 1893 . Galeni Scripta Minora5 (SM). XIX , - Corpus Medicorum Graecorum (CMG), , - . 70- . XX . , , - - , - , , , , Loeb Classical Library6 Bud Collection7.

, . , , - : - , , , : , (Khn XIX, 37). , - .

. , . - - - , 5 Galeni Pergameni Scripta Minora / Edd. J. Marquardt, J. Mller, G. Helmreich.

T. 13. Leipzig: Teubner, 18841893. 6 Galen. Method of Medicine / Ed. and transl. I. Johnston, G.H.R. Horsley. Vol. IIII.

Cambridge, 2011. 7 2002 . Belles lettres - . VI (IIV, VII, VIII), , Protrepticus Ars medica (II), De libris propriis De ordine librorum propriorum (I) .

.. .

87

, 8, 180 192 .9 , , , .

. , - , - : , (III, 8). , , , . - II , - . , , , - , .

, - , , - , - , - , (I, 1). . 14 . - . - , , , - , - : (2), (3), (4), - (5), (6), (7). 8 , .: Flemming R. Commentary // The Cambridge Companion to Galen. P. 349; Ga-lens Commentary on the Treatise Airs, Waters, Places in the Hebrew Translation of Solomon ha-Meati / Ed., trans. and comm. A. Wasserstein. Jerusalem, 1982.

9 .: Galien. Introduction gnrale; Sur lordre de ses Propres Livres; Sur ses Pro-pres Livres; Que lExcellent Mdecin est aussi Philosophe. T. 1 / Texte tabli, trad. et annot par V. Boudon-Millot. Paris, 2007. P. 238239.

88

, (II.1). , (2), (3), (4), , , (5), (6). , , - (7) (8) - (9).

, - , - (III). , , (1). , , (2) (3). , - (4). , - (5), (6) (7). - , (8). , , (9), (10). , , - (11), , (12).

. -, (IV.1), (2), , , , (3), . , , - , , - (4).

, , - -. , -

.. .

89

10; - 11 12. , , , Protrepticus Ars medica13.

. - , - , , , - , - () , II 14. - , - 10 Barigazzi A. Un manifesto di Galeno ai medici // Prometeus 18. 1992. P. 127138. 11 Jouanna J. La lecture de lthique hippocratique chez Galien // Mdicine et morale

dans l Antiquit, Genve-Vanduvres, 1997. P. 211253; Pigeaud J. La figure du mdecin: Galien philosophe // Loraux N., Miralles C. Figures de lintellectuel en Grce ancienne. Paris, 1988. P. 295331; Desideri P. Galeno come intellettuale // Manetti D. Studi su Galeno: scienza, filosofia, retorica e filologia. Firenze, 2000. P. 1329.

12 Vegetti M. Limmagine del medico e lo statuto epistemologico della medicina in Ga-leno // ANRW II. Bd. 37, 2. 1994. P. 16721717.

13 Galien. Introduction gnrale. P. 250251. 14 , :

1) , , 2) - - , 3) , 4) - , 5) - , - , 6) . .: Bowersock G. Greek Sophists in the Roman Empire. Oxford, 1969; Anderson G. The Second So-phistic: a cultural phenomenon in the Roman Empire. London, 1993; Swain S. Hel-lenism and Empire. Oxford, 1996; Perceptions of the Second Sophistic and its Times Regards sur la Seconde Sophistique et son poque / Ed. T. Schmidt, P. Fleury. Toronto, 2010; Staden H. von. Galen and the Second Sophistic // So-rabji R. Aristotle and After. Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies. London, 1997. P. 3355.

90

. - , , . . - (II, 23), figura etymologica (III.1 ), (I, 6; II, 3; II, 7 ) (I, 6 , II,5) (III,12 ). , - - (IV, 1), (III, 7), (I.3 , , I, 5) (II, 7 ). , (I, 12), (II, 6), . - (I, 1) (IV, 2).

(. . .. , , 1971) . .. -. .. . -, , - - , .

Galeni. Opera Omnia / Rec. C.G. Khn. T. 120. Leipzig, 18191833 (repr. Hildesheim, 1965).

Galeni Pergameni Scripta Minora / Edd. J. Marquardt, J. Mller, G. Helm-reich. T. 13. Leipzig, 18841893 (= SM).

Galien. Introduction gnrale; Sur lordre de ses Propres Livres; Sur ses Propres Livres; Que lExcellent Mdecin est aussi Philosophe. T. 1 / Texte tabli, trad. et annot par V. Boudon-Millot. Paris: Belles lettres, 2007.

Galien. Exhortation ltude de la mdicine. Art mdical. T. 2 / Texte tabli, trad. et annot par V. Boudon-Millot. Paris: Belles lettres, 2002.

Galeni. In Hippocratis de Natura Hominis / Ed. J. Mewaldt // Corpus Med-icorum Graecorum (= CMG) V 9, 1. Berlin, 1914.

.. .

91

Galen. On the Elements according to Hippocrates / Ed., trans. and comm. P. H. De Lacy // CMG V 1, 2. Berlin, 1996.

Galen. On the Doctrines of Hippocrates and Plato. Vols. III / Ed., trans. and comm. P.H. De Lacy // CMG V 4, 1, 2. Berlin, 19781984.

Galen. Method of Medicine / Ed. and transl. I. Johnston, G.H.R. Horsley. Vols. IIII. Cambridge, 2011 (LCL 516, 517, 518).

Galeni de Constitutione Artis Medicae ad Patrophilum / Ed., trans. S. For-tuna // CMG V 1, 3. Berlin, 1997.

Galens Commentary on the Treatise Airs, Waters, Places in the Hebrew Translation of Solomon ha-Meati / Ed., trans. and comm. A. Wasserstein. Jerusalem, 1982.

Oeuvres compltes dHippocrate / Par . Littr. Vol. 110. Paris, 18391861 (repr. Amsterdam, 19611973).

. / . .. - . .: , 1971.

. / . .. . .: , 1936 (1994).

. . . 23. .: , 19411944.

,

Galeni. Opera Omnia. Quod Optimus Medicus sit quoque Philosophus / Rec. C.G. Khn. T. 1, 5363. Leipzig, 1819 (repr. Hildesheim, 1965).

Galeni Pergameni. Scripta Minora / Ed. J. Marquardt. Bd. I. Leipzig, 1884 (= SM1).

Galeni Pergameni. Scripta Minora / Ed. J. Mller. Bd. II. Leipzig, 1891 (= SM2).

Galien. Introduction gnrale; Sur lordre de ses Propres Livres; Sur ses Propres Livres; Que lExcellent Mdecin est aussi Philosophe. T. 1 / Texte tabli, trad. et annot par V. Boudon-Millot. Paris: Belles lettres, 2007.

Galen. Selected Works / Transl., introd. and notes by P.N. Singer. Oxford, 1997. P. 3034.

Lth P., Knapp W. Der beste Arzt ist Wissenschaftler: Galen von Perga-mon // Die Medizinische Welt 33. 1965. S. 21852187.

Garofalo I., Vegetti M. Opere scelte di Galeno. Torino, 1978. P. 91101.

.-. (). .: , 1998 (. .).

.. // : . .: -, 2008. C. 245251.

92

Anderson G. The Second Sophistic: a cultural phenomenon in the Roman Empire. London, 1993.

Barigazzi A. Un manifesto di Galeno ai medici // Prometeus 18, 1992. P. 127138.

Bowersock G. Greek Sophists in the Roman Empire. Oxford, 1969. Desideri P. Galeno come intellettuale // Manetti D. Studi su Galeno:

scienza, filosofia, retorica e filologia. Firenze, 2000. P. 1329. Grant M. Galen on Food and Diet. London; New York, 2000. Hankinson R.J. (ed.). The Cambridge Companion to Galen. Cambrid-

ge, 2008. Jouanna J. La lecture de lthique hippocratique chez Galien // Mdicine

et morale dans l Antiquit, Genve-Vanduvres, 1997. P. 211253. Nutton V. Ancient Medicine. London, 2004. Perceptions of the Second Sophistic and its Times Regards sur la Se-

conde Sophistique et son poque / Ed. T. Schmidt, P. Fleury. Toronto, 2010. Pigeaud J. La figure du mdecin: Galien philosophe // Loraux N., Miral-

les C. Figures de lintellectuel en Grce ancienne. Paris, 1988. P. 295331. Singer P. Galen: Selected Works. Oxford, 1997. Staden H. von. Galen and the Second Sophistic // Sorabji R. Aristotle and

After. Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies. London, 1997. P. 3355. Swain S. Hellenism and Empire. Oxford, 1996. Vegetti M. Limmagine del medico e lo statuto epistemologico della me-

dicina in Galeno // ANRW II, 37, 2, 1994. S. 16721717.

. ,

93

, *

I.1. , - , , , , - c , . 2. , , , -1. , - . 3. , , , - 2. , [], , -, , . 4. , , - , , , - . * , (. , . Quod optimus medicus sit quoque philosophus) Galien. Sur lordre de ses Propres Livres; Sur ses Propres Livres; Que lExcellent Mdecin est aussi Philosophe / Texte tabli, trad. et annot par V. Boudon-Millot. Paris: Belles lettres, 2007 (= Khn C.G. Galeni. Opera Omnia I, 53; Mller I. SM2, 1). - -, .

1 .: . , II, 3 (Littr II, 16), , , , - , : , - .

2 , - . ., ., II (Littr VI, 278): - , . : I, 2 (Littr VI, 468), XX, 3 (Littr I, 622).

94

, -. 5. , , - , - , 3. , , , 4. 6. , , , 5. 7. , , ? , , , ; , , , 6.

II.1. , , , , , , , , , , , . 2. , - . , 7. 3. , 3 , - , . 1 (Littr II, 110): , - ( ) , , , , , , - .

4 , - , - ( Khn XIV, 599 = CMG V, 8, 1, 1979, p. 68, 67).

5 .: . I, 311, 89 (Littr IV, 464): - , -. , (. .. ).

6 -. , - , . , - 48 , - , , - . (Galen. Libr. propr. XX).

7 , : -

. ,

95

, , , , , - , ? 4. , , - , , , , , ? 5. [], -, -, , , , , , - , , - , . 6. [], 8, , , - , -, , 9. 7. , , , . , , - , , .

8 , , , . , , , , , .: .-. (). .: , 1998. . 201. .: Grant M. Galen on Food and Diet. London; New York, 2000. , , , , , .

9 , , - - : , . . (Jouanna J. La lecture de lthique hippocratique chez Galien // Mdicine et morale dans l Antiquit, Genve-Vanduvres, 1997. P. 250) , - (311 b-c), , . - .

96

10, - . 8. , , , - , , . , - . , , . 9. , - , - , ? -, , , - , ?

III. 1. , , , 11, , , , , , . , , , 12 , , 10 , - . ., ., De methodo medendi IX, 4 (Khn X, 609): , -, , , - , , , .

11 (Soranus. Vita Hippocratis 8, 3; Plut. Cato Major 23, 4; Stob. Anthologium III, 13, 51) (464424) - , , , . - , , , . II, - (Soranus. Vita Hippocratis 5, 1, Suda. Lexicon, ) , , . , -, .

12 , . , , .

. ,

97

- . 2. , - , [-], - , , , 13, , 14, , , 15. 3. , - , 16, - , , , , 13 .: . , I, 3 (Littr II, 12): , , , - , , , , - , , , , , , .

14 .: . , I, 5 (Littr II, 12): , , , , .

15 ( ) , - . . , - IX.1 (Littr II, 36): - , , -. () : -, , , , , , , , , , , , , , . , - , ( , VII. 36, Littr II, 2830). (), , , , - (Ibid. VIII, 2, Littr II, 32). ( ) , , , , , , - , , - , , - (Ibid. VII, 2, Littr II, 26). , - : , , (Ibid. XXIV, 16, Littr II, 88).

16 ., .: . , VII. 9 (Littr II, 30); IX. 2 (II, 38): () ( ), , () ( - ).

98

, . 4. , [] , - , 17. , -, , , , , , -, . , . 5. , - 18, , 19. 6. , , , , -, , , , , -, 20. 7. -, , , 17 , , De ordine librorum propriorum IV, 3: , .

18 (Khn X, 11021) , - . (Khn X, 15): , , , , , , , .

19 , - () . .: Staden H. von. Galen and the Second Sophistic // Sorabji R. Aristotle and After. Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies. London, 1997. P. 39; Galen. Method of Medicine / Ed. and transl. I.Johnston, G.H.R. Horsley. Vol. I. Cambridge, 2011. P. XCII.

20 (Khn I, 415 = De Lacy, CMG, V 1, 2, 1996, p. 58, 5) (Khn VI, 841) . - ( , , , , , ) - ( , , , , , , ., . . - II, 648a6655b27), , , ( , .).

. ,

99

. 8. -, , -, ? , , , - , , , 21. 9. , - . -, , . 10. . , - , , -22. 11. , - , , - , , 23. 12. , , -, , , , - .

IV.1. , - , , , 21 , , . , , , (D. L. VII 39). , , - De methodo medendi, - ; , , (. . 22); -, .

22 .: De placitis Hipp. et Plat. IV, 7 (Khn V, 181805 = De Lacy, CMG V 4, 1, 2, 1978, p. 286, 57), : , .

23 (Littr IX, 232) : - . - , - , , , .

100

, , -, , , , - , ? , , -24? 2. , , , , , - 25, . 3. , - 26 - , - -, , , - , ! 4. , 27 , , , , - , , , - , , .

..

24 , , . - , (, - , .) , , , -. , , , ( , , , -), , . - , , , , .

25 , , , , (Khn I, 10), - .

26 , , , , , - . , , , (Khn I, 39), , . (Khn I, 230 = Fortuna, CMG V 1I, 3, 1997, p. 59, 1920), .

27 ( ), .

.. .

101

..

( )

, , - , . - : - , , - . , - , . ? , . - ? . : ( ) : , .

, - -- ( ) . - . - , , -, , - : - , . , - , 1. 1 Nygren A. Eros und Agape. Gestaltwandlungen der christlichen Liebe. Berlin, 1955.

S. 445.

102

, , , . . - , - , - . , , , , , .

, , , , . - - , . , - , -, : , - . , , , - , -.

I.

- , - , -.