2009 05 vvbad brussel nieuwenhuysen
Upload: vlaamse-vereniging-voor-bibliotheek-archief-documentatie-vzw
Post on 09-May-2015
2.776 views
TRANSCRIPT
1
Federated search engines: een inleiding
Paul.Nieuwenhuysen @ vub.ac.bePrepared to support a presentation at the
1-day conference about “Federated search engines”organized by VVBAD, section School Libraries, in Brussels, Belgium, on May 5, 2009
2
These slides should be available from the WWW sitehttp://www.vub.ac.be/BIBLIO/nieuwenhuysen/presentations/
(note: BIBLIO and not biblio)and also from the WWW site of the organisers of the
conference = VVBAD
3
1. Introduction and definition2. Problem statement3. Federated search engines as a
partial solution4. Meaning and confusion5. Advantages / benefits ☺6. Difficulties / limitations 7. Implementation8. Putting federated searching in
a wider context9. (Some good information
sources about federated searching)
- contents - summary - structure- overview
of thispresentation
4
Federated searching
Introduction and definition
5
Introduction: scattering of sources
• Users want to exploit information sources fast and effectively.
• This is hindered by the fact that digital, electronic information sources that may contain relevant information are created and scattered, distributed on numerous computers all over their intranet or even over the Internet and the WWW.
6
Introduction: scattering of sources
• In other words: integration / aggregation is still far from perfect.
7
Introduction: scattering of sources difficulties
• Various sources »must be used one after the other which requires many
decisions and actions and costs time»offer different user interfaces in the retrieval phase,
which is confusing and time consuming»offer each found information item in various formats»display items in different ways on a computer display
8
Federated searching
Problem statement
9
Introduction: problem statements
Which methods have been developed and applied to cope with this reality?
10
Federated searching
Federated search engines as a partial solution
11
Method 1: Merging = aggregating into a searchable database
Search engine Aggregated database
Database or web site
or…
Database or web site
or…
Database or web site
or…
UserUser UserUser
o
12
Method 1: Merging = aggregating into a searchable database
Search engine Aggregated database
Database or web site
or…
Database or web site
or…
Database or web site
or…
UserUser UserUser
o
13
Method 2: Federated searchingthrough scattered databases
Federated search engine
Database Database Database
UserUser UserUser
Search engineSearch engine Search engine
14
Federated searching: definition
An ideal federated search system1. allows a user to formulate a query, 2. it adapts/transforms this query,
so that it can be sent with a proper syntax to each search engine of a chosen set/group of disparate databases,
3. it broadcasts this query to those databases, 4. it collects results from each database,5. (perhaps: consolidates these results into 1 result set)6. (perhaps: detects and removes duplicate items)7. shows the final results to the user, in a unified format8. allows the user to sort the results by various criteria
☺
15
Federated searching: approach
• This type of computer systems helps to integrate access to distributed databases in one search action, as far as possible.
• The catalogue of local library holdings can be one of the target databases.
16
Federated searching: scheme
informationsourcesportal for
meta-searching= federated searching= cross-database searching
portal formeta-searching
= federated searching= cross-database searching
End user
☺End user
☺
End user
☺End user
☺
17
Federated searchingthrough scattered databases: why?
• Applications:»Finding flights to a particular destination offered by
various airline companies»Finding the availability of rooms in various hotels»Finding information in various databases related to a
particular museum»Finding information in bibliographic databases !
18
Federated searchingthrough scattered databases: why?
The perfect trip:1. A cheap and nice flight2. A cheap and nice hotel3. A visit to a nice museum4. Something nice to read (free via your library)
The perfect trip:1. A cheap and nice flight2. A cheap and nice hotel3. A visit to a nice museum4. Something nice to read (free via your library)
☺
19
Federated searching: application:finding a suitable flight
Example
20
Federated searching: application:finding a hotel room in some city
Example
21
Federated searching: searching in a museum
Example
22
Federated searching: searching in a library
Example
23
Meta-searching systemMeta-searching system
Catalog database(s)
of other libraries
Catalog database(s)
of other libraries
Federated searching: integrating access
Databases(full-text or bibliographic)
Databases(full-text or bibliographic)
PublishersPublishers
JournalsJournals
ArticlesArticlesIntranetIntranet
Local library catalog database(s)
Local library catalog database(s)
WWW search engines
WWW search engines
24
Federated searching: produce - distribute - implement
Producers = developers = creatorsProducers = developers = creators
Implementers = users (for instance a libraryImplementers = users (for instance a library
Intermediate sellers = distributorsIntermediate sellers = distributors
25
Federated searching: examples of commercial software
360 SearchSerials Solutions
Groxis
Vivissimo
MuseSearchMuseGlobal
Distributing / selling company
MetaLibEx Libris
V-SpacesInfor (was GEAC)
MuseGlobal CSA
WebFeatSerials Solutions
Infotrieve
…
Product nameProducing company
26
Federated searching
Meaning and confusion
27
Federated searching: terminology / vocabulary / synonyms
federated searching= meta-searching = metasearching= cross-database searching= multi-database searching= multi-threaded searching= one-stop searching= poly-searching = polysearching= broadcast searching= searching through a portal (but the term “portal” is
used also with other meanings)
28
“Federated searching”meaning and confusion
Here and in many other contexts, the term “federated searching” is used as a synonym for “meta-searching”.
29
“Federated searching”meaning and confusion
However, some use the terms “federated searching” and “meta-searching” with DIFFERENT meanings.»“Federated searching” as searching through a database
that results from merging several databases. So this is certainly NOT equal to “meta-searching”.
»“Federated searching” as meta-searching that is followed by merging (federating) the items retrieved from various databases into only 1 set, ordered in one way or another.
This language problem creates confusion.
30
“Federated searching”meaning and confusion
• Furthermore:A federated search engine as software productis NOT the same asa federated searching system implemented as a servicethat can be available for all on the WWW, to search»public WWW search engines»bookshop databases»library catalogs / holdings»flight databases»hotel databases
31
Federated searching
Advantages / benefits
☺
32
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ The system can help the user to select appropriate sources.
☺
33
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ The system can help in the process of authentication and authorization when this involves not only a simple recognition of IP-address of the user’s client computer, but when it involves user-id’s and passwords.
☺
34
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ The need to know which particular database is suitable for a particular search is reduced, because several ones can be searched in one action.
☺
35
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ The users have to learn only 1 user interface for searching and only 1 search syntax, instead of a user interface and a search syntax for each database!
☺
36
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Saves the users time executing queries to various servers!
☺
37
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Can make users search and exploit databases that they would never use otherwise, that is without federated search system!
☺
38
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Useful, relevant, interesting items/references can be found/uncovered from unexpected, unknown, unfamiliar databases!This is mainly beneficial in the case of interdisciplinary subjects/topics.
☺
39
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Offers a consistent display of results in the output phase, (even though the original sources display results in various ways).
☺
40
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Some systems offer tools to refine display of the results; for instance »to dedupe very similar items in the result set,»to sort the results, »to rank the results, »to search within the result set,»…
☺
41
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Some systems offer interesting links from a retrieval result to various related sources or services (such as the full text or a document delivery service), using a link generator based on the OpenURL standard.
☺
42
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Some systems check for each retrieved bibliographic description if the corresponding full text is immediately available online and indicate this immediately to the user, on the fly.
☺
43
Federated searching: benefits for the users
+ Some systems further process the retrieved results and display them in an interesting way that is not offered by the searched original systems. For instance:
» Clustering of results according to— subject— age— availability of full text
» Displaying the results in a graphical way☺
44
Federated searching: benefits for the users
So far so good !
☺
45
Federated searching
Difficulties / challenges / problems / limitations
46
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Portal software tries to cope with several difficulties/challenges/problems/pitfalls that hinder the application of the “good idea”:The user does not notice most of these problems and shortcomings, because results from various databases are merged by the federated search system.
47
Federated searchingthrough scattered databases
Federated search engine
Database Database Database
UserUser UserUser
Search engineSearch engine Search engine
48
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Searching in a target database may be restricted by the federated search engine to a particular field (for example: a restriction to words occurring in the title, because this is the default way of searching of that system) while this restriction is not present in other target databases.Furthermore, this is perhaps not explained in the user interface.This may lead to a lower recall, which is of course NOT desirable. Even worse, the user is perhaps not aware of this.
49
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- How to deduplicate/dedupe/cluster very similar entries/results/items= near-duplicates, from various target sources? When is similar similar enough? Which entry/result/item to choose/select as the representative of a cluster of similar entries?
50
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- How to provide some useful relevance ranking of search results/entries, even when the target databases can be quite different in type and quality, and even when no index is created in advance, just-in-case, well before the search action, like Google and other Internet search engines do.
51
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Powerful / sophisticated / refined forms of searching may not be applicable in a federated search.Example: limiting to a particular type of document, such as a therapy in medicine.This may cause a LOSS of time, instead of winning time.
52
Federated searchingthrough scattered databases
Federated search engine
Database Database Database
UserUser UserUser
Search engine Search engine Search engine
53
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Differences among target sources in the Internet application protocols that are applied normally, by default, for connection/communication and retrieval, such as»telnet»HTTP»proprietary, non-standard protocols»Z39.50, ISO239.50, SRU, and related protocols that are
developed for federated-searching!
54
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Even when the target is compatible with a suitable set of protocols for standardised retrieval Z39.50, ISO239.50, SRU…,then difficulties can arise due to»poor implementations»incomplete implementations
(the target may lack features supported by the protocol and by the software for federated searching)
»variations in implementations
55
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- When a suitable protocol can NOT be used and simple HTTP must be used for connection to the target source, and when simple HTML is used by the target source to present results,then the capture and analysis of the results by the federating search system is complicated and difficult and can be hindered by changes with time in the method of the presentation of results.
56
Federated searchingthrough scattered databases
Federated search engine
Database Database Database
UserUser UserUser
Search engineSearch engine Search engine
57
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Various search engines may act in different ways!For instance:Is truncation of a word in a search query possible?Is limitation to a particular field possible?
How can a federated search engine take these differences into account?
58
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- A query with several words and without explicit Boolean operators can be interpreted in various ways by the various database retrieval systems.For instance, the retrieval software may apply the Boolean operator AND to combine all the query words, but it may also use OR. In the case that the federated search system does not take care of this well, then this may lead to lower recall and precision.
59
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- When some special, non-standard, dedicated retrieval software is made available by a specific target source databases to offer special features to the user to exploit the database better than with a standard retrieval interface, then the source can probably not be exploited as well by the federated search system.Searches are reduced to the lowest common denominator.
60
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Differences in response time among the target sources.A slow response of a target source can hinder the final analysis and presentation of the results to the user.
61
Federated searchingthrough scattered databases
Federated search engine
Database Database Database
UserUser UserUser
Search engineSearch engine Search engine
62
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Differences among target sources in the formatting/structuring of their database records in fieldshinders - searching limited to a field
(for instance the author field)- displaying selected fields only
(such as the retrieved titles)- sorting of the displayed records on the contents of a
particular selected field (such as author or publication date)
63
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Differences among target sources in the applied metadataschemes in the databases to improve retrieval, such as»classifications»taxonomies»thesaurus systems»ontologies
This hinders the exploitation of the added value of such metadata.
64
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- A user of a federated search system may perhaps incorrectly assume that ALL relevant databases are covered simply in 1 action, or that if a database is not included, then it must not be relevant/important.However, even a federated search system can only search a limited number of databases, so that perhaps somerelevant databases are NOT covered.
65
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Students who rely on a federated search system may perhaps not learn about the important subject-specific databases in their field, so that when they have no access anymore to the same federated search system, they still do not know which database may help them in their research and how to use it well.
66
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Some databases are accessible only by a limited number of concurrent/simultaneous users from one organisation, as agreed in the licence and controlled by the authorization software of the database. When such a database would be included automatically in all or in many federated searches, then some users who really require access to that particular database may perhaps not be able to use that database.
67
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- When a database is accessible by an unlimited number of concurrent/simultaneous users from one organisation, and when such a database would be included automatically in all or in many federated searches, from many organisations (even when the searcher does not have any particular interest in that database), then the retrieval system of that database may be overburdened.This is mainly a concern for information vendors, who must maintain servers with sufficient capacity.
68
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Some databases can NOT be included as a target database in a federated searching engine, because their owners/producers do not allow this.This is an important difficulty, because in this way interesting / valuable databases are perhaps not exploited by users who rely on federated searching.Even worse: one of the databases in this category is one of the biggest and important databases for the discovery of scientific documents AND is freely accessible through the direct, normal user interface: Google Scholar.
69
Federated searchingthrough scattered databases
Federated search engine
Database Database Database
UserUser UserUser
Search engineSearch engine Search engine
70
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- Users may be less impressed by a federated searching system than by the simple, common, familiar, famous Internet / WWW search engines, as response time is in most cases less impressive, due to differences as follows:- The computer hardware used by the systems- Slower distributed searching through several computer
systems, versus faster searching through a more centralised computer database of a priori compiled records
71
Federated searching: difficulties / challenges / problems
- The evaluation of the quality of each search result from a federated search action may be more difficult than when each database is searched separately, because the user may be less aware of the limitations, strengths, selection criteria and aims of the individual, separate databases that offer each result.For instance, peer-reviewed articles from reputable scientific journals may be mixed with more popular and more biased, unscientific texts from trade literature.
72
Federated searching
Implementation
73
Federated searching: local or remote hosting
• The federated searching system can be developed and maintained »on a local computer in-house, or »hosted on a more distant, external, remote computer;
this service is offered by some vendors of software for federated searching; partly outsourcing
74
Federated searching: local hosting: scheme
In-house portal formeta-searching
= federated searching= cross-database searching
In-house portal formeta-searching
= federated searching= cross-database searching
End user
☺End user
☺information
sources
End user
☺End user
☺
75
Federated searching: remote hosting: scheme
Externally hosted portal formeta-searching
= federated searching= cross-database searching
Externally hosted portal formeta-searching
= federated searching= cross-database searching
End user
☺End user
☺information
sources
End user
☺End user
☺
76
Federated searching: local versus remote hosting
• Remote hosting requires perhaps »a smaller initial investment in computer hardware and
skilled personnel»less time investment in installation and maintenance of
equipment and software
77
Federated searching: tasks for the library
Some roles/functions/tasks of the library related to federated searching:»of course providing a computer system for meta-searching»maintaining a list of target information sources that are
appropriate in the framework of the particular library:—subjects covered by the target databases should be
relevant—subscriptions must have been made by the library for
access to the targets
78
Federated searching: tasks for the library
»grouping databases in groups that correspond to subject fields and offer these as pre-selections in the user interface of the federated search system
»showing the system and its features to potential users»…
79
Federated searching in a library WWW site?
- Searching for books - Searching for articles
- Opening hours- Library services- Rules and regulations- Organisation of the
library
80
Federated searching in a library WWW site?
- Searching for books - Catalog of this library- Other catalogs- Other book databases- Electronic books- Federated searching for
books- Searching for articles
- Opening hours- Library services- Rules and regulations- Organisation of the
library
81
Federated searching in a library WWW site?
- Searching for books- Searching for articles
- Databases to find articles- Electronic journals- Collective catalog of
periodicals- Repositories of articles on
the Internet and WWW- Federated searching for
articles
- Opening hours- Library services- Rules and regulations- Organisation of the
library
82
Federated searching in a library WWW site!
- Find the information that you need
- The catalog- Databases- Opening hours- Library services- Rules and regulations- Organisation of the library
To a federated search engine To a federated search engine
83
Federated searching: conclusion
Federated searching - is a continuous challenge
for developers of the sophisticated software and for the implementers in libraries and information centers
- offers benefits for those end-users who are not enthusiastic to work with separate target source databases
- does not eliminate the need for access to individual databases
84
Libraries and information centres
Putting federating searching in a wider context
85
informationsources
informationsources
Federated searching + link generator
appropriatetarget
informationsource
appropriatetarget
informationsource
context-sensitivehyperlink generatorcontext-sensitive
hyperlink generator
database about local situation
“knowledgebase”
database about local situation
“knowledgebase”
federated searchingfederated searching
user
☺user
☺ full-text document !full-text document !
referencereference menumenu
86
Federated search systemand link resolver compared
!-How to bring a user from some information to related information?
-!How to bring a user to many information sourcesin 1 action?
Link resolverFederated search system
Problem to be solved
87
library WWW sitelibrary WWW site
Putting the digital tools togetherin a library system
catalogue(s) of local holdings
catalogue(s) of local holdings
context-sensitivehyperlink generatorcontext-sensitive
hyperlink generator
database about local situation
“knowledgebase”
database about local situation
“knowledgebase”
federated searchingfederated searching
user
☺user
☺
88
Access to information sources: tools / methods / systems
In sequence of priority:
1. Online library catalogue(for hard copy and digital documents)
2. Library web site3. Link generator + “knowledgebase”4. Federated search system
5. …
89
Libraries and information centres
Good information sources about federated searching
90
Some good information sourcesabout federated searching
Baer, WilliamFederated searching: friend or foe?College & Research Libraries News, October 2004, pp. 518-519.
Hofstede, MartenPortals op de pijnbank.Informatie Professional, 2002, No. 10, pp. 34-39.
Jacso, PeterThoughts about federated searching.Information Today, October 2004, pp. 17, 20.
Joint, NicholasManaging the implementation of a federated search tool in an academic library.Library Review, Vol. 58, No. 1, 2009, pp. 11-16.
Linoski, Alexis and Walczyk, TineFederated search 101.Library Journal Netconnect Summer 2008, pp. 2-5.
Lockwood, Charles and Mac Donald, PatriciaImplementation of a federated search system in the academic library: lessons learned.Co-published simultaneously in Internet Reference Service Quarterly, Vol. 12, No. ½, 2007, pp. 73-91 and in Federated search: solution or setback for online library services (edited by Christopher N. Cox) The Haworth Information Press, 2007, pp. 73-91. Available online from: http://irsq.haworthpress.com
McHale, NinaAccidental federated searching: implementing federated searching in the smaller academic library.Co-published simultaneously in Internet Reference Service Quarterly, Vol. 12, No. 1-2, 2007, pp. 93-110 and in Federated search: solution or setback for online library services (edited by Christopher N. Cox) The Haworth Information Press, 2007, pp. 93-110. Available online from: http://irsq.haworthpress.com
Noerr, PeterScaling the digital divide: how interoperable systems are making information more accessible.In proceedings of the International Conference on Digital Libraries 2004: knowledge creation, preservation, access, and management, ICDL 2004, in Habitat Centre, New Delhi, India, 24-27 February 2004, Volume 1, 517 pp. New Delhi : TERI, The Energy and Resources Institute, 2004, ISBN 81-7993-029-7, pp. 66-68.
Reiss, KevinSRU, Open Data and the future of metasearchCo-published simultaneously in Internet Reference Service Quarterly, Vol. 12, No. ½, 2007, pp. 369-386 and in Federated search: solution or setback for online library services (edited by Christopher N. Cox) The Haworth Information Press, 2007, pp. 369-386. Available online from: http://irsq.haworthpress.com
Sadeh, TamarTo Google or not to Google: metasearch design in the quest for the ideal user experience. [online]In: Proceedings of the ELAG 2004 Conference, May 2004. Available from: http://www.elag.org/ [cited 2004]
Sadeh, TamarTransforming the metasearch concept into a friendly user experience.Co-published simultaneously in Internet Reference Service Quarterly, Vol. 12, No. ½, 2007, pp. 1-25 and in Federated search: solution or setback for online library services (edited by Christopher N. Cox) The Haworth Information Press, 2007, pp. 1-25. Available online from: http://irsq.haworthpress.com
Tennant, RoyThe right solution: federated search tools.Library Journal, June 15, 2003, p. 28.
Webster, Peter M.Challenges for federated searching.Co-published simultaneously in Internet Reference Service Quarterly, Vol. 12, No. ½, 2007, pp. 357-368 and in Federated search: solution or setback for online library services (edited by Christopher N. Cox) The Haworth Information Press, 2007, pp. 357-368. Available online from: http://irsq.haworthpress.com
91
• You are free to copy, distribute, display this work under the following conditions:»Attribution:
You must mention the author.»Noncommercial:
You may not use this work for commercial purposes.»No Derivative Works:
You may not change, modify, alter, transform, or build upon this work.
• For any reuse or distribution, you must make clear to others the license terms of this work.