133 ss morality

Download 133 SS Morality

Post on 10-Mar-2015

878 views

Category:

Documents

0 download

Embed Size (px)

TRANSCRIPT

DDI SS6/26/2011

MoralityCarlotti

MoralityMorality....................................................................................................................................................................1 Meta Information.....................................................................................................................................................2 Utilitarianism Good Frontline..................................................................................................................................4 Utilitarianism Good Frontline..................................................................................................................................5 Utilitarianism Good Frontline..................................................................................................................................6 EXT Schell 2NC...................................................................................................................................................7 EXT Extinction Mandates Util.............................................................................................................................8 EXT Extinction Mandates Util.............................................................................................................................9 EXT Nye 2NC.....................................................................................................................................................10 EXT Deontology Flawed....................................................................................................................................11 EXT Goodin 2NC...............................................................................................................................................12 EXT Util K2 Policymaking................................................................................................................................13 EXT Harsanyi 2NC.............................................................................................................................................14 EXT Mulholland 2NC.........................................................................................................................................15 EXT Conflicting Morals.....................................................................................................................................16 Util Good Deterrence..........................................................................................................................................17 Util Good Deterrence..........................................................................................................................................18 Util Good Rights.................................................................................................................................................19 Util Good Life Outweighs Rights.......................................................................................................................20 AT: UtilRights Violations..................................................................................................................................21 AT: No Ontological Foundation............................................................................................................................22 AT: UtilEvil (Santos).........................................................................................................................................23 AT: UtilEvil (Santos).........................................................................................................................................24 AT: UtilDehumanization...................................................................................................................................25 AT: Util is Selfish.................................................................................................................................................26 AT: Cultural Relativism.........................................................................................................................................27 AT: Justifies GENOCIDE!!!..................................................................................................................................28 Deontology Bad Foreign Policy..........................................................................................................................29 Deontology Bad Foreign Policy..........................................................................................................................30 AT: Calculation Bad (Dillon)................................................................................................................................31 AT: Calculation Bad (Dillon)................................................................................................................................32 AT: Calculation Bad (Dillon)................................................................................................................................33 AT: Calculation Bad (Dillon)................................................................................................................................34 AT: Economic Evaluation Bad..............................................................................................................................35 AT: Economic Evaluation Bad..............................................................................................................................36 AT: No War (Mendelbaum)...................................................................................................................................37 AT: The Other (Levinas).......................................................................................................................................38 AT: The Other (Levinas).......................................................................................................................................39 AT: The Other (Levinas).......................................................................................................................................40 AT: Rescher...........................................................................................................................................................41 AT: Callahan..........................................................................................................................................................42 AT: Gewirth...........................................................................................................................................................43

1

DDI SS6/26/2011

MoralityCarlotti

AT: Gewirth...........................................................................................................................................................44 Utopianism Turn....................................................................................................................................................45 Deontology Good Frontline...................................................................................................................................46 Deontology Good Frontline...................................................................................................................................47 Deontology Good Frontline...................................................................................................................................48 No War (Mandelbaum)..........................................................................................................................................49 No War (Mandelbaum)..........................................................................................................................................50 No War (Nye)........................................................................................................................................................51 Probability Outweighs (Rescher)...........................................................................................................................52 EXT Callahan 2AC/1AR....................................................................................................................................53 EXT Rights Outweigh.........................................................................................................................................54 AT: Extinction Outweighs.....................................................................................................................................55 EXT Rights Solve Extinction..............................................................................................................................56 AT: Util Solves Rights...........................................................................................................................................57 AT: Rights Calculation Requires Util....................................................................................................................58 AT: Deontology Utopian.......................................................................................................................................59 Utilitarianism Bad..................................................................................................................................................60 Util Bad Dont Fear the Reaper..........................................................................................................................61 Consequentialism Bad...........................................................................................................................................62 Consequentialism Good Frontline.............................................