10 improving decision making and managing knowledge

134
_ KLMNOPQRS)TUVQWQOR) \RO]^U[SU) XYZQRS)YR[ )XYRYSQRS) a b c d e f g ! " # $ $ # # %" & '()*+,-.,/0.- +0.12330/04-.- 5607.83.109272847:.,41.+8 ;.1807.-+0. 10927284<=,>24?.6/8907.;8 />@ A()B8;.18.CD72407.24-0E2? 0490.,41.CD72407.,4,E5- 297.7D668/-. 10927284.=,>24?@ F(B8;.18.2438/=,-284.757- 0=7.+0E6.6086E0.;8/ >24?.24.,.?/8D6.

Upload: irawandedy

Post on 18-Feb-2016

223 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

management

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

_KLMNOPQRS)TUVQWQOR)

\RO]^U[SU)XYZQRS)YR[)XYRYSQRS)

a b c d e f g

! " # $ $ # # %" &

'()*+,-.,/0.-+0.12330/04-.-5607.83.109272847:.,41.+8;.1807.-+0.

10927284<=,>24?.6/8907.;8/>@

A()B8;.18.CD72407.24-0E2?0490.,41.CD72407.,4,E5-297.7D668/-.

10927284.=,>24?@

F(B8;.18.2438/=,-284.757-0=7.+0E6.6086E0.;8/>24?.24.,.?/8D6.

=,>0.109272847.=8/0.03329204-E5@

G()*+,-.,/0.-+0.CD72407.C04032-7.83.D724?.24-0E2?04-.-09+42HD07.

24.10927284.=,>24?.,41.>48;E01?0.=,4,?0=04-@

I(*+,-.-5607.83.757-0=7.,/0.D701.38/.04-0/6/270<;210.>48;E01?0.

Page 2: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

=,4,?0=04-.,41.>48;E01?0.;8/>:.,41.+8;.18.-+05.6/8J210. J,ED0.38/.CD7240707@

FFh

Page 3: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!" "# $%&' !" ()*+% "# , !)-%' ./0 " % 1!"!

2342 5 6 7 8 9 : ; <7 = 7 >? = 234@ AB ; C 6 D 234E ; C >? = <7 5 6 7 >B 7 234F >? = <7 8 G 7HC : AB I 7JC =

>7CK LMN-! *N/ O*" PQ/*N%// RN"%&*-%N+%

STUVWVXWYZ[[\WSTUVW]^_`ZWVXW`TU^aZ\WUYbWVTZWcUVUdefghi J H ? 7 : 67B 7 ?7B =7 67< > JB69 j ;< ?7B C K 8 k ?7B 67BC: B 7B C? : 9 BJH ? :7H 7H 7 A 779C? 4 l C m 7 23 6 6 ?7B J7 77:k 6 <n C : C 6 7< C =7 7B : 6 9 4 AB =B< B 23 6 =7 B 7H 8 JC o Ck : C I 9 IC 6 p7 67 q24r3 7 = H ?7B C K 4

> JB69 7 7< = ? C B 7 6 : 7< H 7 C?s t 7 J? 7 : = J? =t 7H : = : 7 : 7 6 6 4 u 6B 7= H C 7 ? <7 6 = : : K ? =B6 7 J7 77: 7 K 7 7< 67B ? H ? C K 4 > 7 6 C76 7 H C 7 ? =7 4

v 5B p : : B 7 6 k 6 C? B 6 : J? u C k C 7 :

Page 4: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

:wB 6 4 >7< H C?s C <7B : 7< HJ7 J J 7 6 K 7 H 7::C k 7 67= ? H JC 7 6 7 : <7 HJ7 < H 7B C7 C 4 v 6 x <7 = 7

y z{|}~�€�‚ƒz„…††ƒz}‡ �|ˆ‰Š‹| �|zŒŠ�

Page 5: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

! " #"$ % #"$ " %&' ()*+*,- . % ", !"+ *",/ 0#"(( ) # 1' , 2 % ") , ) 34 # 0 ) ,% 5 6*,- ", 78 ,' ( 9: + , ") ;") ."6 "; <! , 6 ,% =: + , ") ;") ." ! "; > ( "? @ * "! # , +' " ) *, A )! /

@' *, , ! *+ "; $ ) '+# # ' % . 1' , 2 % (*+ ! , ! B

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

0"')+ N CG?3:: H!"$ ) /+" O' " ) O",, + *", @!"" $* # 070 @' *, 7, ! *+ ID # (NP$$$/ /+" I ++ % 7()*! GQI 9:GGR 7,, < % I C>)*+ ?>"*, >"!* *+ ID STUVWXYZZXV[\]Y^TUI _'! 9`I 9:G:R 0 8 5"#)I C7 1 a6(!" *", 2 E 2 *!*,-ID STUVWXYZZXV[\]Y^TUI _'! 93I 9:G:/

b# 6( )* ,+ "; 0 ).'+E I 1' , 2 % I ,% G?3::?H!"$ ) ) ("$ );'! *!' ) *", "; #"$ *,;") *", * ()"8 % +* *", E*,-/ c , - ) # ) *! +# *, $ ) ', .! " E -""% % +* *", ."' $# ()*+ " +# )- " * ()"8 ()";* .*!* ,% $# * " ! " 6* *B ! %*; ) , !"+ *", ,% %*; ) , * ( )*"% / K# # % ++ " +' " ) (')+# % I .' # $ ) ', .! " , ! B *!*", "; (* + "; % ", # *) "$,/ @ % % +* *", ."' #"$ '+#

Page 6: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

" +# )- ,% #"$ " "+E ") !"$ ) % ! ) 8 ,' ,% () 8 , % # +" ( ,* ;)" ) (",%*,- L'*+E! " +' " ) , % /

K# +# ( )?"( ,*,- %* -) + ! , *", " * (") , ("*, ) * % . #* +

,% #* +# ( )/ 0 ).'+E I 1' , 2 % I ,% G?3::?H!"$ ) ) % ' *,- .' *, *, !*- ,+ "; $ ) I $#*+# * .! " ;*,% ( ), ,% ) ,% *, *8 L' , * * "; % / J,;") *", ;)" # .' *, *, !*- ,+ # !( , - ) # +" ( ,* E . ) % +* *", ."' ()*+*,-I # !;? "+E*,-/ ,% ()"%'+ "; )*,- / K# ) .! " $# ) # + , +# )- #*-# ) ()*+ ") $# ) # ' !"$ ) ()*+ " 6* *B ! ) 8 ,' I $ ! $# * " "+E ,% $# , " +# ,- # *) )+# ,%* *6/ @ ) % +* *", E*,- ' *,- .' *, *, !*- ,+ # % ! "; # +" ( ,* ") ()";* .! /

Page 7: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

VW1,XY11 Z[\WY ]^ ,'_`]ZY Ya,1,]X '[b,Xcd:<96F75B6=96;5< 4 6 9 7 6 9 : 5 6 @ A B =45B 6 9 7 6 @ 5 6 < @ J 5 6 9 7 6 ;<G56< 6 @ 5 95?6F5>=B=74Q6d:<96=B69:56;7459<?C6E< J A 5 6 9 7 69 : 5 6 @ A B =45B 6 7 8 6 @ 5 95?I6=;D?7E5F6F5>=B=746;<G=4HQ6M< @ J 5 6 e f K e 6 <95;D9B6976;5<BA?569:56;7459<?C6E<JA56786=;D?7E5F6F5>=B=746;<G=4H687?6<6B;<J6gKhK6;<4A8<>9A?=4H68=?;6N=9:6 ijkf6;=J=746=46<44A<J6?5E54A56<4F6elf65;DJ7C55BK6M:568=?;6:<B6=F549=8=5F6<64A; @ 5 ?6786G5C6F5>=B=74B6N:5?5645N6BCB95;6=4E5B9;549B6;=H:96=;D?7E569:56mA<J=9C6786F5>=B=746;<G=4HK6M:569< @ J 5 6 D ?

Page 8: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

7E=F5B6B5J5>95F65B9=;<95B6786<44A<J6E<JA56n=469:5687?;6786>7B96B<E=4HB67?6=4>?5<B5F6?5E54A5o68?7;6=;D?7E5F6F5>=B=746;<G=4H6=46B5J5>95F6<?5< B 6 7 8 6 9 : 5 6 @ A B =45BKd56><46B5568?7;6M< @ J 5 6 e f K e 6 9 : <96F5>=B=74B6<?56;<F56<96<J6J5E5JB67869:568=?;I6<4F69:<96B7;56

7869:5B56F5>=B=74B6<?56>7;;74I6?7A9=45I6<4F64A;5?7ABK6pJ9:7AH:69:56E<JA56786=;D?7E=4H6<4C6B=4HJ56F5>=B=746;< C 6 @ 5 6 B ;<JI6=;D?7E=4H6:A4F?5FB67869:7AB<4FB6786qB;<Jr6F5>=B=74B6<FFB6AD6976<6J<?H56<44A<J6E<JA5687? 6 9 : 5 6 @ A B =45BK

st_Y1 ]^ Ya,1,]X1u:<D95?6j6B:7N5F69:<969:5?56<?56F=85?5496J5E5JB6=46<467?H<4=S<9=74K6v<>:67869:5B56J5E5JB6:<B6F=85?5496=487?;<9=746?5mA=?5;549B687?6F5>=B=746BADD7?96<4F6?5BD74B=@=J=9C687?6F=85?54969CD5B6786F5>=B=74B6nB556w=HA?56efKeoK6L5>=B=74B6<?56>J<B=8=5F6<B6B9?A>9A?5FI6B5;=B9?A>9A?5FI6<4F6A4B9?A>9A?5FKxyz{|}~{}| �€�€ �~‚z‚ƒyz6<?569:7B56=46N:=>:69:56F5>=B=746;<G5?6;AB96D?7E=F56„AFH;549I6

5E<JA<9=74I6<4F6=4B=H:96976B7JE569:56D? 7 @ J 5 ;K6v<>:67869:5B56F5>=B=74B6=B647E5JI6=;D7?9<49I6<4F6474?7A9=45I6<4F69:5?56=B6476N5JOA4F5?B977F67?6<H?55FO746D?7>5FA?5687?6;<G=4H69:5;K

s[V\Y …†‡ˆ‰Š‡‡‹ŒŽ†Š‹ ��‹‘‰’ �‰“Š”‹•Š“ˆ‡ˆ�‰‹–�—ˆ‰˜‹

Page 9: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

Y™(/š›! !

!"#$#%&

Xœ/ �!. %-

Y$0#/(0!+ Z(›œ! 0% [&&

œ(Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦§¨©©¡ª¤¦¤

Ÿ¢¢¡¨¯¤§¦«£¯£°¥ª

±² ³±´´µ´´´

³±µ²´´µ´´´

¶ª¥·¸¢¤¦¢£ ¦¢¥¯¤

º£ ¦º¥¯¤¥ª¦«£¯£

» ±¼´µ´´´

½´´µ´´´

¾¥¢¸·¥¦©£ª¤§¦¸¯¥¯¤

¿¯¥¯¤¡ª¹¦«£¯£°¥ª

À½¼ ¼µ´´´¦ ±µÁ²¼µ´´´

¿·¥¯¤¸Â¹¦¢¡«©¥¤¸¤¸-

Ä¥¯¸¡ª¦«£¯£°¥«¥¯¤

± ²µ´´´µ´´´

²µ´´´µ´´´

Ģť·¨ ¥¦©ª¡·¨¢¤¸¡¯¦¤

Ç£¯¨Â£¢¤¨ª¸¯°¦«£¯£°¥ª

±¼´ ±´µ´´´ ±µ¼´´µ´´´

Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦ £®¡ª¦¤¡¦

¶ª¡·¨¢¤¸¡¯¦È¦

±´´ »µ´´´ »´´µ´´´

Page 10: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

VWXYZ[\]^_]\`abcdefghcai jklmhdkekagnicbi okpiqkrhnhcas tfuhaviwdcmxnihaifi yhdez{|}~ �€ �‚|‚ƒ{ �„…€�}††‡{€ �‚|‚ƒ{�„…€~ˆ{�‚‰}~|‚‡€ �‚|‚ƒ{�„…€‚|†€{�ˆ‡~Š{{„€ �‚‹{€†}Œ{ �{|‰€‰Šˆ{„€~Œ€†{ �}Ž„}~|„€‚|†€}|Œ~ ��‚‰}~|€�{��} �{�{|‰„‘

! "#"$%#&'()'*+,-./0-&'/.1'.121-3-341'/,5'.+6-3,1&'/,5'-71)'3,4+841'/'5193:,3-1'2.+*156.1'9+.'7/,583,;'-71<'0+'-7/-'-71)'5+',+-'7/41'-+'(1'-.1/-15'1/*7'-3<1'/0'39'-71)'=1.1',1=>'?/,)'51*303+,0'7/41'181<1,-0'+9'(+-7'-)210'/,5'/.1'# @"# ! "#"$%#&'=71.1'+,8)'2/.-'+9'-71'2.+(81<'7/0'/'*81/.:*6-'/,0=1.'2.+43515'()'/,'/**12-15'2.+*156.1>' A,';1,1./8&'0-.6*-6.15'51*303+,0'/.1'<+.1'2.14/81,-'/-'8+=1.'+.

Page 11: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

;/,3B/-3+,/8'814180&'=71.1/0'6,0-.6*-6.15'2.+(81<0'/.1'<+.1'*+<<+,'/-'73;71.'814180'+9'-71'93.<>

C1,3+.'1D1*6-3410'9/*1'</,)'6,0-.6*-6.15'51*303+,'03-6/-3+,0&'06*7'/0'10-/(83073,;'-71'

93.<E0'F:'+.'GH:)1/.';+/80'+.'51*353,;',1='</.I1-0'-+'1,-1.>'J,0=1.3,;'-71'K610-3+,'LC7+685'=1'1,-1.'/',1='</.I1-MN'=+685'.1K63.1'/**10'-+',1=0&';+41.,<1,-'.12+.-0&'/,5'3,560-.)'431=0&'/0'=18'/0'73;7:81418'06<</.310'+9'93.<'21.9+.</,*1>'O+=141.&'-71'/,0=1.'=+685'/80+'.1K63.1'01,3+.'</,/;1.0'-+'601'-713.'+=,'(10-'P65;<1,-'/,5'2+8'+-71.'</,/;1.0'9+.'-713.'+23,3+,0>?35581'</,/;1<1,-'9/*10'<+.1'0-.6*-6.15'51*303+,'0*1,/.3+0&'(6-'-713.'51*303+,0'</)'

3,*8651'6,0-.6*-6.15'*+<2+,1,-0>'J'-)23*/8'<35581:81418'</,/;1<1,-'51*303+,'<3;7-'(1' LQ7)'30'-71'.12+.-15'+.51.'968938<1,-'07+=3,;'/'51*83,1'+41.'-71'2/0-'03D'<+,-70'/-'/''530-.3(6-3+,'*1,-1.'3,'?3,,1/2+830MN'R730'<35581'</,/;1.'*+685'+(-/3,'/'.12+.-'9.+<'-71'

Page 12: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

93.<E0'1,-1.2.301'0)0-1<'+.'530-.3(6-3+,'</,/;1<1,-'0)0-1<'+,'+.51.'/*-343-)'/,5'+21./-3+,/8'193*31,*)'/-'-71'?3,,1/2+830'530-.3(6-3+,'*1,-1.>'R730'30'-71'0-.6*-6.15'2/.-'+9'-71'51*303+,>' S6-'(19+.1'/.343,;'/-'/,'/,0=1.&'-730'<35581'</,/;1.'=38'7/41'-+'3,-1.431='1<28+)110'/,5';/-71.'<+.1'6,0-.6*-6.15'3,9+.</-3+,'9.+<'1D-1.,/8'0+6.*10'/(+6-'8+*/8'1*+,+<3*''*+,53-3+,0'+.'0/810'-.1,50>T21./-3+,/8'</,/;1<1,-'/,5'./,I:/,5:9381'1<28+)110'-1,5'-+'</I1'<+.1'0-.6*-6.15'

51*303+,0>'U+.'1D/<281&'/'0621.430+.'+,'/,'/01<(8)'83,1'7/0'-+'51*351'=71-71.'/,'7+6.8)'2/35'=+.I1.'30'1,-3-815'-+'+41.-3<1'2/)>'A9'-71'1<28+)11'=+.I15'<+.1'-7/,'13;7-'7+6.0'+,'/'2/.-3*68/.'5/)&'-71'0621.430+.'=+685'.+6-3,18)';./,-'+41.-3<1'2/)'9+.'/,)'-3<1'(1)+,5'13;7-'7+6.0'-7/-'=/0'*8+*I15'+,'-7/-'5/)>J'0/810'/**+6,-'.12.101,-/-341'+9-1,'7/0'-+'</I1'51*303+,0'/(+6-'1D-1,53,;'*.153-'-+'

*60-+<1.0'()'*+,068-3,;'-71'93.<E0'*60-+<1.'5/-/(/01'-

Page 13: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

7/-'*+,-/3,0'*.153-'3,9+.</-3+,>'A9'-71'*60-+<1.'<1-'-71'93.<E0'2.1021*39315'*.3-1.3/'9+.';./,-3,;'*.153-&'-71'/**+6,-'.12.101,:-/-341'=+685';./,-'-7/-'*60-+<1.'*.153-'-+'</I1'/'26.*7/01>'A,'(+-7'3,0-/,*10&'-71'51*303+,0'/.1'73;78)'0-.6*-6.15'/,5'/.1'.+6-3,18)'</51'-7+60/,50'+9'-3<10'1/*7'5/)'3,'<+0-'8/.;1'93.<0>'R71'/,0=1.'7/0'(11,'2.12.+;./<<15'3,-+'-71'93.<E0'2/).+8'/,5'/**+6,-0'.1*134/(81'0)0-1<0>

Page 14: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

! "#$#%&'()*#&+ ,-%" $$./01234/4567181924184/4:;<=18=6>4>?9768 @ 4 A 1 : 9 2 4 B C D E F G 4 5 6 8 7 ?1H654I9;?451I6?62=48=/3684124567181924:/0123J412=6<136276K4568132K47L9176K4/2541:><6:62=/=1924B8664M13;? 6 4 C F @ N G @ 4 O L 6 8 6 4 8=/368479?68>9254=94=L64I9;?48=6>84124>?9H<6:P89<Q1234;8654=L?9;3L9;=4=L184H990@

RSTUVWXUSYU4792818=849I451879Q6?123K41562=1IZ123K4/254;256?8=/251234=L64>?9H<6:84

4977;?1234124=L649?3/21[/=192\]LZ4=L64>?9H<6:46^18=8K4]L6?6K4/254]L/=46I67=841=4184L/Q1234924=L64I1? : @ 4 _ U `WXS412Q9<Q6841562=1IZ1234/2546^><9?1234Q/?19;8489<;=19284=94=L64>?9H< 6 : @ 4 abcWYU4792818=849I47L9981234/:923489<;=1924/<=6?2/= 1 Q 6 8 @ 4 R d e V U d U S T f T W c S 4 1 2 Q 9 <Q684:/01234=L647L98624/<=6?2/=1Q64]9?04/254792=12;1234=94:921=9?4L9]4]6<4=L6489<;=1924184]9?0123@gL/=4L/>>62841I4=L6489<;=1924Z9;4L/Q647L986245968429=4]9?0h4M13;? 6 4 C F @ N 4 8 L 9 ]84=L/=4Z9;4

7/24?6=;?24=94/246/?<16?48=/364124=L6456718192P:/01234>?97684/254?6>6/=41=K41I426768/? Z @ 4 M 9 ?4128=/276K4124=L64I/7649I4567<1212348/<68K4/48/<684:/2/36:62=4=6/:4:/Z45671564=94>/Z4=L648/<684I9?764/4L13L6?479::181924I9?4:/01234:9?648/<684=948>;?4924=L648/<6846I9?= @ 4 i I 4 =L1845968429=4

Page 15: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

127?6/8648/<68K4:/2/36?84]9;<5426654=9412Q68=13/=64]L6=L6?4=L64>?9H<6:48=6:84I?9:4>99?4>?95;7=4568132K412/56j;/=647;8=9:6?48;>>9?=K49?4/4L98=49I49=L6?47/;8684=L/=47/<4I9?4/451I6?P62=489<;=192@kWXblmUVcYWTnlopTcdfTUql_UYW`WcSlrfsWSXlO95/ZK4:/2Z45671819284:/564HZ49?3/21[/P=19284/?6429=4:/564HZ4:/2/36?849?4/2Z4L;:/ 2 8 @ 4 M 9 ?4128=/276K4]L624Z9;462=6?4/4j;6?Z412=94 t993<6u8486/?7L4623126K4t993<6u8479:>;=6?48Z8=6:4L/84=945671564]L17L4vwx84=94518></Z4124/H9;=4L/<I4/48679254924/Q6?/364ByFF4:1< 1 8 6 7 92 5 8 G @ 4 z 1 3 L P I ?6j;627Z4=?/51234>?93?/:84/=46<67=?921748=97046^7L/23684124=L64v21=654A=/=6846^67;=64=L61?4=?/5684124;256?4{F4:1<1867P92 5 8 @ 4 z ;:/284/?646<1:12/=654I?9:4=L645671819247L/124H67/;864=L6Z4/?64=9948<9]@

|}~�€ � ‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ

‰Š‹Œ�ŽŒ �Š ��‹ �‘ŽŒ’ˆ“�Ž‰

”•–—˜–™š›šœ �žŸ ¡š �¢—£¤œ™–››—™  �—¥–—¥

¤œ¡–�—˜œ¦ �—š �§œ—¨œ©¤—›§ 

¢–›ª

Page 16: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!" # $ % &' ()& % % *! !( + ! ,!" * + % !" + * (!* + & % !)$, #) & !( $&- (. % *! !( #)&/! " $-(* &- *&$ '- % 01 *()$' - &,"(-! ) & $- *! ,1 % .! $ ( 0 .(,(2 % ( $-(%'* & % *! !( 3 4 $ ($, 2 ( 2-( (. 2&- !% !.! % $-(0, )+ % !" % & ) (% .(- .! %! " & (,' !( + % .! % & -& " (. &** $ &0, (,' !( + & % !)$, ) % (,' !( 3 ! '& !( + (-"& !5& !( &- )&/! " % *! !( .& - & 2 & )& &" - *& )( ! (- (- *( -(,+ & % "- & *&- % ( 0 &/ ( '- $-($ - ($ -& !( (. 1 ) ( $- 6 !" !.!*& &-)3

789:;<=>?@>ABC;D;?ED>9EA>ABC;D;?E>F9G;EHI(2 *& 1(' , !. & % *! !( & 0 *() J0 -K (- % *! !( #)&/! " $-(* J!)$-(6 %KL M**'-&*1 ! ( !)$(- & %!) !( (. N'&,! 1O " -&,+ 2 ! / % *! !( &- J0 -K !. 1 &**'-& ,1 - ., * - &,#2(-,% %& &3 P$ % ! & ( - %!) !( O Q % ( ! / & % *! !( #)&/! " $-(* (',% 0 .!*! + 6 $ %13 R(- ! & * + 2 1(' &$$,1 .(- *&- ! '-& * + 1(' 2& ! '-& * .!-) ( )&/

Page 17: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

& .& & % &**'-& % *! !( 3 S' - &- )& 1 ( - %!) !( (. N'&,! 1 ! % *! !( & % % *! !( #)&/! " $-(* ( *( !% -3 Q !* ! !)$(- & .(- 1(' 2!, % $ % ( 0' ! .!-) 2 - 1(' 2(-/+ 6&-!(' $&- ! ! 6(,6 % ! % *! !( + & % 1('- (2 $ - ( &, 6&,' 3 4&0, TU3V % *-!0 () N'&,! 1 %!) !( .(- % *! !( )&/! "3 Q 2 % *-!0 (2 1 ) J!)$-(6 % *! !( & % % *! !( #)&/! " $-(* K ! ! * &$ -+ 2 &- - . -# *! " %!) !( ! ! &0, 3

WXYZ>[\]^_`]]>;_a`b^c`_d`>^_>ae`>B_a`fgf^]`h &$ - V ! -(%'* % 1(' ( %!. - /! % (. 1 ) .(- '$$(- ! " , 6 , & % 1$ (. % *! !( 2 &6 i' % *-!0 %3 4 .(' %& !( .(- &, (. 1 ) ! & 0' ! ! ,!" * & % 0' ! & &,1 !* ! .-& -'* '- & '$$,! %& & & % & &,1 !* ((, .(- '$$(- ! " % *! !( )&/! "3

jk9<>;D>[8D;EBDD>;E<B::;HBECBlJS' ! ! ,!" * K mS n ! & -) ' % 01 &-%2&- & % (. 2&- 6 %(- & % ! .(-)& !( * (,("1 *( ', & ( % *-!0 ! .-& -'* '-

Page 18: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

.(- 2&- (' ! "+ ! "-& #! "+ - $(- ! " & % & &,15! " %& & & *() .-() 0' ! 6!-( ) 3 4 .(' %& !( ! .-& -'* '- *(, * + (- + *, & + & % )&/ &6&!,&0, - , 6& %& & ( )& &" - 3 4 ! / %& &0& + %& & 2&- (' + & % %& & )&- % *-!0 % ! h &$ - o3 pS' ! & &,1 !* p

qrstuvuwxyz{y|w}uxuz~xy s~ �yv€wy|w}uxuz~ �‚sƒu~„y…†z}wxxy

7\‡b^aˆ>A^‰`_]^Š_ A`]df^ga^Š_>

‹ŒŒ �Ž �Œ � ‘’Œ“”“•–—Ž’˜—’Œ™”—Ž’ �š“™�

›•œ �Ž’ž’–”“Ÿ’–’”” ‘’Œ“”“•–—Ž’˜—’Œ™”—�—  �š—Œ•–”“¡’Ž �™“•–—• —™ž’— �Œ™”—�–¡—Œ“ŽŒ �œ”™�–Œ’”

¢�“Ž–’”” ‘’Œ“”“•–—  �“™ž  �š �—Ž’˜—’Œ™”—™ž’—Œ•–Œ’Ž–”—�–¡—“–™’Ž’”™”—• —� ’Œ™’¡—

��Ž™“’”

£�’’¡—¤’ ¥—Œ“’–Œ �¦ ‘’Œ“”“•–—œ �§“–¨—“”—’ ¥—Œ“’–™—©“™ž—Ž’” �’Œ™—™•—™“œ’—�–¡—•™ž’Ž—Ž’”•�ŽŒ’”ª— “–Œš �¡“–¨—™ž’—™“œ’—�–¡—Ž’”•�ŽŒ’”—• —� ’Œ™’¡—��Ž™“’”ª—” �Œž—�”— Œ �”™•œ’Ž”

›•ž’Ž’–Œ’ ‘’Œ“”“•–—Ž’˜—’Œ™”—�—Ž �™“•–�

Page 19: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

š—�Ž•Œ’””—™ž �™—Œ �–—«’—’¬ �š �“–’¡—™•—•™ž’Ž”—�–¡—

œ�¡’—�–¡’Ž”™�–¡�«š’

‘ �’—�Ž•Œ’”” ‘’Œ“”“•–—“”—™ž’—Ž’” �š™—• —�—§–•©–—�Ž•Œ’””—�–¡—Œ �–—«’—���’ �š’¡—™•—�—

ž“¨ž’Ž—��™ž•Ž“™�

Page 20: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"#!$%#&!$!'()*&+,*(-")(*!.(+/!.0$.!-&12#(#!/&+(!&)!.&&%#!$)*!.(10)"32(#!-&+!$)$%45")6!$)*!2)*(+#.$)*")6!*$.$7!80")9!:; <=!#.$."#."1#=!/&*(%#=!$)*!*$.$!/")")6=!>0"10!>(!$%#&! ").+&*21(*!")!?0$@.(+!A7! 2#")(#!").(%"6()1(!$)*!$)$%4."1#!$+(!(#()."$%4!$B&2.!").(6+$.")6!$%!.0(!")-&+/$."&)!

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

C.!"#!"/ @ & + . $ ).!.&!+(/(/B(+!.0$.!B2#")(#!").(%"6()1(!$)*!$)$%4."1#!$+( !

Page 21: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

NOPQRSTUVPTTQUVNPWWUXPVYPQPVZU[\V]PVND"62+(!IE7^!6"'(#!$)!&'(+'"(>!&-!$!B2#")(#!").(%"6()1(!()'"+&)/().=!0"60%"60.")6!.0(!9")*#!&-!0$+*>$+(=!#&-.>$+(=!$)*!/$)$6(/(). ! 1$ @ $ B "%"."(#!.0$.!.0(!/$_&+!'()*&+#!&-(+!$)*!.0$.!-"+/#!*('( % & @ ! & '(+!."/(7!80(+(!$+(!#"K!(%(/().#!")!.0"#!B2#")(#!").(%"6()1(!()'"+&)/().`!abcbdefghdcijdklmnojmmdjopnfgohjocq! 2#")(#(#!/2#.!*($%!>".0!B&.0!#.+21.2+(*!$)*!2)#.+21.2+(*!*$.$!-+&/!/$)4!*"-(+().!#&2+1(#=!")1%2*")6!/&B"%(!*('"1(#!$)*!.0(!C).(+)(.7!80(!*$.$!)((*!.&!B(!").(6+$.(*!$)*!&+6$)"5(*!#&!.0$.!.0(4!1$)!B(!$)$%45(*!$)*!2#(*!B4!

Page 22: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

02/$)!*(1"#"&)!/$9(+#7rlmnojmdnocjsntjoujdnoefbmcfluclfjq!80(!2)*(+%4")6!-&2)*$."&)!&-!B2#")(#!").(%"6()1(! " # ! $ ! @ & >(+-2%!*$.$B$#(!#4#.(/[email protected]+(#!$%!.0(!+(%('$).!*$.$!.&!&@(+$.(!.0(!B2#")(#7!80(!*$.$!/$4!B(!#.&+(*!")!.+$)#$1."&)$%!*$.$B$#(#!&+!1&/B")(*!$)*!").(6+$.(*!").&!$)!().( + @ + "#(,*$.$!>$+(0&2#(!&+!#(+"(#!&-!").(+(%$.(*!*$.$!/$+.#7!

vwxyz{Q|}~�Q€�‚ƒ„…‚‚†

‡„ˆ…‰ƒŠ…„‹…†Œ„ �† Ž„Œ‰�ˆƒ‹‚†�‘’† “…‹ƒ‚ƒ‘„†” �••‘’ˆ†

–—˜™š›˜˜œ™š �›ž™Ÿ›š ›œ

¡š¢œ¡š¡ž£ �™ ˜œ¤›¥—™¤›˜œ¡œ

˜�¤¦šŸœ¢¡�¡§¡˜›œ¨¦—š¢¡©�™¦šªœ¡œ˜› �œ¦¨œ¡š¡ž£�

™ œ�¦¦ž˜ªœ¡š

¢œ¡šœ™š«¦ž«›¢œ¬¡š¡Ÿ›¬›š �œ�›¡¬œ �¡�œ

Page 23: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

 ¡šœ¡˜®œ™š �›ž™Ÿ›š �œ¥—›˜©

�™¦š˜œ¡š¢œ¡š¡ž£¯›œ¢¡ �¡°

Page 24: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

! !"#$ % $&&" $'()(*+,(-.(*-.,/01+(,--2*(01+(3*+4(,-(050267+(40,0(054(81-439+(1+8-1,*:(1+*8-54(,-(;3+*,<-5*(8-*+4(=6(>050?+1*:(054(,109@(,A+(81-?1+*(-.(,A+(=3*<5+*(3*<5?( @ + 6 (<54<90,-1*(-.(8+1.-1>059+B(C! !D E !" E ! F G $H&F '(I3*<5+*(<5,+2<?+59+(A014/01+(054(*-.,/01+(01+(-526(0*(<5,+2<?+5,(0*(,A+(A3>05(=+<5?*(/A-(3*+(,A+>B(J050?+1*(<>8-*+(-14+1(-5(,A+(05026*<*(-.(40,0(3*<5?(0(K01<+,6(-.(>050?+1<02(>+,A-4*(,A0,(4+.<5+(*,10,+?<9(=3*<5+*(?-02*(054(*8+9<.6( A-/(81-?1+**(/<2(=+(>+0*31+4B(LA+*+(<59234+(=3*<5+**(8+1.-1>059+(>050?+>+5,(054( (=02059+4(*9-1+9014(0881-09A+*(,A0,(.-93*(-5( @ + 6 (8+1.-1>059+(<54<90,-1*:(/<,A(*8+9<02(0,+5M,<-5(,-(9->8+,<,-1*B(N " O E# P"!$Q&EGRCSTU NTTU VTT'(LA+(1+*32,*(.1->(=3*<5+*(<5,+2<?+59+(054(05026,<9*(

Page 25: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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`(4+*@,-8(-1(>-=<2+(820,.-1>*B(a E S $ EQ!% '(I3*<5+*(8+-82+(01+(5-(2-5?+1(,<+4(,-(,A+<1( 4 + * @ * (054(4+*@,-8*B(LA+6(-.,+5(2+015(;3< 9 @ + 1 (.1->(0(K<*302(1+81+*+5,0,<-5(-.(40,0(,A05(.1->(0(416(1+8-1,(/<,A(9-23>5*(054(1-/*(-.(<5.-1>0,<-5B(L-406b*(=3*<5+*(05026,<9*(*-.,/01+(*3<,+*(+>8A0*<7+(K<*302(,+9A5<;3+*(*39A(0*(40*A=-014*(054(*9-1+9014*B(LA+6(02*-(01+(0=2+(,-(4+2<K+1(1+8-1,*(-5( I 2 0 9 @ I + 16*:(

Page 26: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

<cA-5+*:(054(-,A+1(>-=<2+(A054A+24*(0*(/+2(0*(-5(,A+(.<1>b*(d+=(8-1,02B(I)(*-.,/01+(<*(044<5?(9080=<2<,<+*(,-(8-*,(<5.-1>0,<-5(-5(L/<,+1:(e09+= - - @ : (-1(<5,+1502(*-9<02(>+4<0(,-(*388-1,(4+9<*<-5(>0@<5?(<5(05(-52<5+:(?1-38(*+,<5?(10,A+1(,A05(<5(0(.09+M,-M.09+(>++,<5?B(

fghijkhhlijmknniokjpklqjrlqjqnsmiphlpqtqfinimikhI3*<5+*(<5,+2<?+59+(054(05026,<9*(81-><*+(,-(4+2<K+1(9-1+9,:(5+0126(1+02M,<>+(<5.-1>0,<-5(,-(4+9<*<-5(> 0 @ + 1 * : (054(,A+(05026,<9(,--2*(A+28(,A+>(;3< 9 @ 2 6 (354+1*,054(,A+(<5.-1>0,<-5(054(, 0 @ + (09,<-5B(LA+1+(01+(.<K+(05026,<9(.359,<-502<,<+*(,A0,(IX(*6*,+>*(4+2<K+1(,-(09A<+K+(,A+*+(+54*uvE&F %$ & E P&E$ '(LA+*+(01+(81+M4+.<5+4(1+8-1,*(=0*+4(-5(<543*,16M*8+9<.<9(1+;3<1+>+5,*(w*++(L0=2+(xyBz{B(

mqfnkl|}~ �

€�

‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ‰Šˆ‹Œ‡�Ž†‡‡ˆ�Ž �†…�‘†Ž’†ˆ“”†•–†Š �Ž†—ˆ“”‰—Œ’��‰Žˆ

Page 27: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

˜†„‰”�‡ f™š›œ�ššlž™œŸ ›

¡œ¢£lq¤ �¢ t¤¡¥™Ÿ ›¡œl¦ �§¡¤ šl

¨©ª«¬®¯°«±©¬²¬³-¬©ª«¬²«©´µ«°®¯°´©¶±«³±°¯¬¬-¬«ª·¶¸³¬©ª«¬¨©ª«¬ ±¹±ª«²·´«¬

¨«°º·±«»¼©ª¼«¶²«° ¼½¬²¯´«°¬©²·¬®©±²·¯¶³-¬«°º·±«±¯¬²³°«¬¯ª½²·¯¶-°©²«¬³±¾½°¶°©²«¬

¿©°À«²·¶¸ ¼©´µ©·¸¶-«®«±²·º«¶«¬¬³-ª¯¹©ª²¹©¶Á-©²°·²·¯¶³´©°À«²-©¬À«²©¶©ª¹¬·¬

𯱽°«´«¶²-©¶Á-¨½µµ¯°²

Ä·°«±²©¶Á-·¶Á·°«±²-¬µ«¶Á·¶¸³-¯®Å±¯¶²°©±²-µ½°±¾©¬«¬³-¬½µµª·«°µ«°®¯°´©¶±«

¨½µµª¹¼¾©·¶ Æ©±Àª¯¸³®½ªÇª´«¶²¬²©²½¬³-¯°Á«°±¹±ª«²·´«³-·ª¯®´©²«°·©ª¬©¶©ª¹¬·¬

È·¶©¶±·©ª¬ É«¶«°©ªª«Á¸«°³©±±¯½¶²¬°«±«·º©Âª«-©¶Áµ©¹©Âª«³±©¬¾-ʯ˳µ°¯Ç²©Â·ª·²¹

̽´©¶-Í«¬¯½°±«¬

䵪¯¹««-µ°¯Á½±²·º·²¹³±¯´µ«¶¬©²·¯¶³-˯°À®¯°±«-Á«´¯¸°©µ¾·±¬³°«²«¶²·¯¶

Page 28: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"! #$!%& !'( ")*+,-./-+.01./+-.2./34+53/36.1./-+3-+70+3+57281+1394.+18+:741./+;313+30;+7-8431.+7653<1-+8:+53/36.1./-=+>8/+70-130<.? + @ 8 A + 6 7 B C 1 + D 3 0 1 + 1 8 + . 0 1 ./+/.B780+30;+176.+8:+; 3 @ + 18+A0;./-130;+C8D+-34.-+8:+3+5/8;A<1+23/ @ + 9 @ + /.B780+30;+176.= + E : + @ 8 A + D ./.+F13/9A<G-? + @ 8 A + 67BC1+:70;+1C31+<A-186./-+70+1C.+.3-1./0+,071.;+F131. - + 9 A @ + 6 8 - 1 + 8 : + 1 C . 7 /+<8:..+70+1C.+68/0H70B?+DC./.3-+70+1C.+08/1CD.-1+<A-186./ - + 9 A @ + <8:..+1C/8ABC8A1+1C.+;3@=+IC7-+:70;70B+67BC1+4.3;+18+;7:./.01+63/G.170B+30;+3;+<36537B0-+70+.3<C+/.B780=+JF..+1C.+;7-<A-780+8:+57281+1394.-+431./+70+1C7-+-.<1780=KL )MN( %)OPQ( !Q %)*+IC.-.+3/.+27-A34+1884-+:8/+5/.-.0170B+5./:8/630<.+;313+;.:70.;+9 @ + A - ./-=R%&M(Q&ST! UO)! QMO& !'( "&Q ! "#(V*+IC.-.+348D+A-./-+18+</.31.+1C.7/+8D0+/.58/1-+93-.;+80+WA./7.-+30;+-.3/<C.-=L #X&%(YV*+IC7-+7-+1C. + 3 9 7 4 7 1 @ + 1 8 + 6 82 . + : /86+3+C7BC+4.2.4+-A663/ @ + 1 8 + 3 + 6 8 /.+;.1374.;+27.D= Z( !Q )")[&)Q!V #()[& (%!X)*+IC.-.+70<4A;.+<353974717.-+:8/+470.3/+:8/.<3-170B?+\DC31+7:]+-<.03/ 7 8 + 3 0 3 4 @ - 7 - ?+30; + 3 0 3 4 @ ̂ 7 0 B + ;313+A-70B+-130;3/;+-1317-17<34+1884-=

_`abcdefaghijka`el

Page 29: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

IC.+68-1+D7;. 4 @ + A - .;+8A15A1+8:+3+mE+-A71.+8:+1884-+7-+5/.H53<G3B.;+5/8;A<1780+/.58/1-=+ I394.+no=p+74A-1/31.-+-86.+<86680+5/.H;.:70.;+/.58/1-+:/86+q/3<4.r-+mE+-A71.+8:+1884-=+

_`jbfdefsjhtguvwefdlx/.;7<172. + 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <-?+DC7<C+D.+701/8;A<.;+70+yC351./+z?+3/.+9.70B+9A741+7018+9A-70.--++701.47B.0<.+35547<31780-+:8/+-34.-?+63/G.170B?+:7030<.?+:/3A;+;.1.<1780?+30;+C.341C+<3/.=+x/.;7<172. + 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <-+A-.+-1317-17< 3 4 + 3 0 3 4 @ - 7 - + 3 0 ;+81C./+1.<C07WA.-+18+.{1/3<1+70:8/631780+:/86+;313+30;+A-.+71+18+5/.;7<1+:A1A/.+1/.0;-+30;+9.C3278/+531./0-=+q0.+8:+1C.+68-1+.-13947-C.;+9A-70.-+35547<31780-+8:+5/.;7<172. + 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <-+7-+5/.;7<170B+/.-580-.+18+;7/.<1+63/G.170B+<36537B0-= + m @ + 7 ;. 0 17 : @ 7 0 B + <A-186./-+4.-+47G. 4 @ + 1 8 + /.-580;?+<865307.-+3/.+394.+18+48D./+1C.7/+63/G.170B+30;+-34.-+< 8 - 1 - + 9 @ + 9 @ 5 3 -70B+1C7-+B/8A5+30;+:8<A-70B+1C.7/+/.-8A/<.-+80+<A-186./-+DC8+C32.+9..0+7;.017:7.;+3-+68/.+5/867-70B=+>8/+.{3654.?+y357134+q0.+<80;A<1-+68/.+1C30+po?ooo+.{5./76.01-+.3<[email protected]/+A-70B+;7:./.01+701./.-1+/31.-?+70<.0172.-?+;7/.<1+6374+53<G3B70B?+30;+81C./+23/7394.-+18+7;. 0 17 : @ + 1 C . + 9 . - 1 +

Page 30: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

581.01734+<A-186./-+:8/+13/B.170B+71-+</.;71+<3/;+8:./-=+IC.-.+5.854.+3/.+68-1+47G. 4 @ + 1 8 + -7B0+A5+:8/+</.;71+<3/;-+30; + 1 8 + 5 3 @ + 9 3 <G+y357134+q0.+:8/+1C.+93430<.-+1C. @ + /70B+A5+70+1C.7/+</.;71+<3/;+3<<8A01-=+x/.;7<172. + 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <-+C32.+34-8+C.45.;+</.;71+<3/;+<865307.-+7;. 0 17 : @ + +<A-186./-+DC8+3/.+31+/7-G+:8/+4.3270B?+30;+<CA/0+68;.470B+7-+3081C./+585A43/+5/.;7<172.+3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <-+35547<31780=x/.;7<172. + 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <-+3/.+C.4570B+<865307.-+A0;./-130;+81C./+<A-186./H/.431.;+9.C3278/-=+

>.;|{+7-+A-70B+F}F+E0-171A1.~-+|01./5/7-.+�70./+30;+5/.;7<172. + 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <+1884-+18+;.2.485+68;.4-+1C31+5/.;7<1+C8D+<A-186./-+D74+/.-580;+18+5/7<.+<C30B.-+30;+0.D+-./27<.-?+DC7<C+<A-186./-+3/.+68-1+31+/7-G+8:+-D71<C70B+18+<865.1718/-?+30;+C8D+6A<C+/.2.0A.+D74+9.++B.0./31.; + 9 @ + 0 . D + - 1 8 /.:/801+8/+;/85H98{+48<31780-=+IC.+3<<A/3< @ + /31.+8:+1C.+5/.;7<172.++ 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 < - + - @ - 1 . 6 + /30B.-+:/86+€z+18+�o+5./<.01=+>.;|{+7-+08D+-13/170B+18+A-.+5/.;7<172.+303H4 @ 1 7 <-+70+<34+<.01./-+18+C.45+<A-186./+-./27<.+/.5/.-.013172.-+7;. 0 17 : @ + <A-186./-+D71C+1C.+ C7BC.-1+4.2.4-+8:+;7-317-:3<1780+30;+13G.+1C.+0.<.-3/ @ + - 1 . 5 - + 1 8 + 6 3 G . + 1 C . 6 + C 3 5 5 @=

Page 31: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

‚ueuhƒflcuvf„uefag…hƒflcuvhtguvwefdl…hugbh†ja‡`ukˆfdh‰gŠa`‹uefaghŒwlej‹lm @ + 5 /.-.0170B+;313+70+27-A34+:8/6?+% " &#)T X#$ "#(V+30; + 2 7 - A 3 4 + 3 0 3 4 @ 1 7 <-+1884-+C.45+A-./-+-..+531./0-+30;+/.431780-C75-+70+43/B.+368A01-+8:+;313+1C31+D8A4;+9.+;7:7<A41+18+;7-<./0+7:+1C.+;313+D./.+5/.-.01.;+3-+1/3;7178034+47-1-+8:+1.{1+8/+0A69./-=+Ž313+3/.+5/.-.01.;+70+1C.+:8/6+8:+/7<C+B/35C-?+<C3/1-?+;3-C983/;-?+30;+635-=+x.854.+9.<86.+68/.+.0B3B.;+DC.0+1C. @ + <30+:741./+70:8/631780+1C31+7-+5/.-.01.;+27-A34 @ + 3 0 ;+;.2.485+70-7BC1-+80+1C.7/+8D0=+�!( 'M#Q&#V‘( "#(V&)U)"! )&’“P”+3/.+3+-5.<734+<31.B8/ @ + 8 : + 1 8 8 4 - + : 8 /+C.4570B+

+;.<7-780+63G./-+27-A347^.+5/894.6-+/.WA7/70B+G08D4.;B.+398A1+1C.+B.8B/35C7<+;7-1/79A1780+8:+5.854.+8/+81C./+/.-8A/<.-=+IC.7/+-8:1D3/.+17.-+48<31780+;313+18+58701-?+470.-?+30;+3/.3-+80+3+635=+F86.+•EF+C32.+68;.470B+<353974717.-+:8/+<C30B70B+1C.+;313+30;+3A186317<34 @ + +/.27-70B+9A-70.-+-<.03/78-=+•EF+67BC1+9.+A-.;+18+C.45+-131.+30;+48<34+B82./06.01-+<34<A431.+

Page 32: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

koqlr}lzqr|pƒotr�€lp€q„qot{q€plup�uzqrlsz �„qp vl{{�u…p†q‡ˆ‡lmq€p‰yŠp‡lmq€ptup‹ŠŒyp mtwz}lrq‚p�lzlpnmq€p�up z~ �mp{rt…rlvprq{rqmquzp„lr �tnmpz �{qmptwpslompwtrp{to �sqpmqr„ �sq|pmns~plmp lrvq€prt‡‡qr�|plmmlnoz|p€rn…pslom|psr�v �ulop v�ms~ �qw|plu€p}ql{tump„�tolz�tum‚pŽ~qpm�mzqvp{rt„�

€qmp �uwtrvlz �tupz~lzp~qo{mpol}pquwtrsqvquzp{qrmtuuqop{�u{t �uzplrqlmp twpsr�vqplsz �„�z �‚

Page 33: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"#$ !" ! %"& %'!(# % " !% (! ") ! $ * +# ! !" !) ' !,% - !#( "#./!") !, "!' +%"# !. !# "%'# *! 0!, % +) ! !123!" $# %' 45 ! 6%$ ' 7!8 '&$,#%7!9 &")!8% '# %:,% (!5# "!8#"#; !<%

-!& !=>9! ."0% !. $!3% > . !" !( " $# !0)#+)!$% - " !" !. +& ! !. ! "%# # *!+& " $ !% (!0)#+)! " !. +& ! !. !%+?&# # *! 0!+& " $ 4!3% > . !%' !' " !") !,% -!( #'!( 0 !# " !( "%#' !%"!") !# ( # @ # (&%'!, % +)!' @ '!% (!# ( # @ # (&%'#; !* %' !. ! %+)!, % +)4!A%+)!, % +)!# !%,' ! " ! !0) ") !") !* %" "! @ & ! "& #"# !% !. $!$# # *!#" !(%"%,% ! .! 6# "# *!+& " $ ! !. $!.# (# *! 0!+& " $ 4!

BCDEFGDDHEFIGJJEKGFLGHCDGMD5#*& !NO4P! ) 0 !")%"! @ !QO! + "! .!") !%&(# + !. !<>!+ # " ! .!+% &%'!& 4!9 # ! 6 +&"#@ !" (!& !<>!" !$ #" !.# $!%+" # @ # "# !& # * ! @ # &%'!# " .%+ !'#- !(% ), % ( !% (! + +% ( 4!3#((' !$% %* !% (!% %'/ " !% !$&+)!$ !'#- '/!" !, !#$$ (!# !") !(%"%!% (! ."0% 7! " # *!?& # !% (! '#+# *!% (!(#+# *!") !(%"%!%' *!(#. "!(#$ # 4! R %"# %'! $ ' / !0#'7!%' *!0#")!+& " $ !% (! & '# 7!, !' -# *!$ "'/!%"!! : %+-%* (! " 4!

Page 34: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

STUVWXHYZ[\H]^_`ab cdaebf`gbahbci_bj_ klmnlopnmqrmplrqp stumnvqrmptwpxyptnz{nz|p}~ �oqp�uzqumqp{t}qrp nmqrmplrqpz~qp{rt€nsqrmp twprq{trzm|puq}plulo �mqm|p vt€qom|plu€pwtrqslmzm‚

Page 35: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

@ 1 8 .>6:<501<C1= @ 6 5 @ H 1 M?>I1>I61.G?D?>01><1@=44<5> 1 @ 6 B ?@>5=8>=56;1;68?@?</1B.9?/:E QAA156D01B<561I6.N?D01</1B<;6D?/:1>I./1-3AH1=@?/:1B.>I6B.>?8.D1<51./.D0>?8.D1B<;7

6 D @ 1 ><1465C<5B1MI.>7?C1<51<>I6519?/; @ 1 <C1./.D0@? @ E 1 F I .>7?C1./.D0@? @ H 1 M <59?/:1C<5M.5;1C5<B19/<M/1<51.@=B6;18</;?>?</ @ H 1 .D< M @ 1 >I61= @ 6 5 1 ><1N.501865>.?/1N.D= 6 @ 1 ><1>6@>156@=D> @ 1 ><1456;?8>1<=>8< B 6 @ 1 ?C18I./: 6 @ 1 <88=51?/1>I< @ 6 1 N . D = 6 @ E 1 F I .>1I.446/ @ 1 ?C1M615.? @ 6 1 4 5 <;=8>145?

Page 36: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

8 6 @ 1 G 0 1 T 1 46586/>1<51?/856. @ 6 1 >I61.;N65>?@?/:1G=;:6>1G01UV1B?D?</W1XYZ[\]\^\]_`aZab_[\[1B<; 6 D @ 1 . @ 9 1 MI.>7?C1c=6@>?</ @ 1 5 6 4 6 .>6;D01><1456;?8>1.15./:61<C1<=>8< B 6 @ 1 M I 6 /1</61<51B<561N.5?. G D 6 @ 1 . 5 6 1 8I./:6;1B=D>?4D61>? B 6 @ 1 R @ 6 6 1 d ?:=561VeETSE12.89M.5; 1 @ 6 /@?>?N?>01./.D0@? @ 1 I 6 D 4 @ 1 ;68?@?</1B.976 5 @ 1 M ?>I1:<. D 1 @ 6 6 9 ?/:f13C131M./>1>< 1 @ 6 D1V1B?D?</145<;=8>1=/?> @ 1 /6g>106.5H1I<M1B=8I1B=@>13156;=861>I6145?861<C1>I6145<;=8>W JI.4>651T1; 6 @ 8 5 ?G6;1B=D>?;?B6/@?</.D1;.>.1./.D0@? @ 1 ./;1hijk1. @ 1 </61<C1>I619601

1G=@?/6@ 1 ?/>6D?:6/861>68I/<D<:? 6 @ E 1 A 4 5 6 .; @ I 6 6 > @ 1 I . N 6 1 . 1 @?B?D.51C6.>=561C<51B=D>?;?B6/@?</.D1./.D0@? @ 1 8 .D6;1.1l\^m]`]anbYH1MI?8I1O@=4651= @ 6 5 P 1 B ./. : 6 5 @ 1 ./;1./.D0@> @ 1 6 B 4 D <01><1?;6/7>?C01./;1=/;65@>./;14.>65/ @ 1 ?/1G=@?/6@ 1 ?/C<5B.>?</1>I.>1B.01G61= @ 6 C =D1C< 5 1 @ 6 B ?@>5=8>=56;11;68?@?</1B.9?/:E1d?:=561VeEo1?D=@>5.> 6 @ 1 . 1 - ?85<@<C>1pg86D14?N<>1>.GD61>I.>16g.B?/ 6 @ 1 . 1 D . 5 : 6 1 D ?@>1<C1<5;651

>5./@.8>?</ @ 1 C <51.18<B4./ 0 1 @ 6 D?/:1</D?/61B./.:6B6/>1>5.?/?/:1N?;6< @ 1 ./;1G<< 9 @ E 1 3 >1 @ I < M @ 1 >I6156D.>?</ @ I ?41G6>M66/1>M<1;?B6/@?</ @ f 1 >I61@. D 6 @ 1 5 6 : ?</1./;1>I61@<=5861<C18</>.8>1RF6G1

Page 37: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

G.//651.;1<5167B.?DS1C<516.8I18=@><B651<5;65E13>1./ @ M 6 5 @ 1 >I61c=6@>?</f1;< 6 @ 1 >I61@<=5861<C1>I618=@><B651B.961.1;?C656/861?/1.;;?>?</1><156:?</W1qI614?N<>1>.GD61?/1>I? @ 1 C ?:= 5 6 1 @ I < M @ 1 >I.>1B<@>18=@>< B 6 5 @ 1 8 <B61C5<B1>I61F6@>1./;1>I.>1G.//651.;N65>?@?/:145<;= 8 6 @ 1 B <@>1<C1>I618=@>< B 6 5 @ 1 ?/1.D1>I6156:?</ @ E h/61<C1>I61L./; @ 7 </1-3A145<r68> @ 1 C <51>I? @ 1 8 I . 4 >651. @ 9 @ 1 0 <=1><1= @ 6 1 . 1 4 ?N<>1>.GD61><1C?/;1./ @ M 6 5 @ 1 ><1.1/=BG651<C1<>I651c=6@>?</ @ 1 =@?/:1>[email protected]?@>1<C1>5./@.8>?</ @ 1 C <51>I61</D?/61>5.?/?/:18<B4./01. @ 1 M 6 1 = @ 6 ;1?/1>I? @ 1 ;? @ 8 =@?</E1qI618<B4D6>61pg86D1C?D61C<51> I 6 @ 6 1 >5./@.87>?</ @ 1 ? @ 1 . N .?D.GD61?/1-0-3Ai.GE1F61I.N61.1i6.5/?/:1q5.891</1856.>?/:14?N<>1>. G D 6 @ 1 =@?/:1 pg86DE13/1>I614.@>H1B=8I1<C1>I? @ 1 B <;6D?/:1M. @ 1 ;</61M?> I 1 @ 4 5 6 .; @ I 6 6 > @ 1 ./; 1 @ B .D1@>./;7.D</61;.>.G. @ 6 @ E 1 q <;.01> I 6 @ 6 1 8 . 4 . G ?D?>? 6 @ 1 . 5 6 1 ?/8<54<5.>6;1?/><1D.5:616/>6545? @ 6 1 2 3 1 @ 0 @> 6 B @ H 1 ./;1>I601.561.GD61><1./.D0s61;.>.1C5<B1D.5:618<54<5.>61;.>.G. @ 6 @ E 1 2 3 1 ./.D0>? 8 @ 1? /8D=;61><< D @ 1 C <51?/>6/@?N61B<;6D?/:H1@<B61<C1MI?8I1M61; 6 @ 8 5 ?G6;16.5D?65E1A=8I18.4.G?D?>? 6 @ 1 I 6 D 4 1 k 5 <:56@?N613/@=5./861?;6/>?C01>I61G6@>18=@>< B 6 5 @ 1 C <51?> @ 1 4 5 <;=8> @ E 1 t @?/:1M?;6D01.N.?D.GD61?/@=5./861?/;=@>501;.>.H1k5<:56@?N61;6C?/ 6 @ 1 @ B .D1:5<= 4 @ 1 <C18=@>< B 6 5 @ H 1

Page 38: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

<51O86D @ H P 1 @=8I1. @ 1 B <><5808D615?; 6 5 @ 1 . : 6 ;1ue1<51.G<N61M?>I18<D6:616;=8.>?</ @ H 1 8 5 6 ;?> 1 @ 8 < 5 6 @ 1 <N651.1865>.?/1D6N6DH1./;1/<1

v'w !%#xyz{#|}~�€ �€‚€�ƒ„…~†‡ƒ�€

ˆ‰Š‹Œ�Ž ��‘Œ’Š‹“ �Ž”‹

Œ�‰‘Œ•‘‹–��‹Œ—˜ŒŽŒ‹‘™‹Š�ŠšŠ�”Œ Ž™Ž �”‹Š‹Œ—˜Œ�‰‘Œ‘˜‘› �Œ

—˜Œ›‰Ž™œŠ

™œŒ�

‰‘Œ‹Ž �‘‹Œ

“•Š›‘Œ

—˜ŒŽŒ™‘› ��

Š‘ŒŽ™’Œ

�‰‘Œ›

Page 39: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

—‹ �Œ“‘•Œ–™Š�Œ—™Œ�‰‘Œ “•—’–› �ž‹Œ�•‘Ž �Ÿ‘š‘™Œ “—Š™� Œ¡�ŒŽ™‹¢‘•‹Œ �‰‘Œ

£–‘‹ �Š—™¤Œ¥¦‰Ž�Œ‰Ž““‘™‹Œ

�—Œ�‰‘Œ�•‘Ž �Ÿ‘š‘™Œ“—Š™�Œ Š˜Œ�‰‘Œ‹Ž �‘‹Œ“•Š›‘ŒŽ™’Œ�‰‘Œ›—‹ �Œ �—Œ§Ž �‘Œ‘Ž›

Page 40: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

‰Œ–™Š�Œ Š™›•‘Ž‹‘Œ—•Œ’‘›•‘Ž‹‘¨©

Page 41: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

„ @ M F H >D…†‡ˆD‰Š‹Œ �Ž �Š �‘’“”Š �•‘ �Š–—‘˜Œ™”šŠ›œš �Ž˜” �Šž”ŸŒŽ™‘“Š Œš ��Œ’œ�ŒŽ™Š‘™¡Š‰¡ �” ��ŒšŒ™ŸŠ¢Žœ �£”Š¤¥¦§¨©ª¦«©¬§¦§®¯°±²¦³±¦®´±¦®¯°±¦§¦±µ®¶©¥±¦³¨±´±¦®¥¦¥°©¥±¦§´®©¥©¥·¦¸¶«®¥¹ºª¦¸»ª§¶±´ª¦¸¶±¦¼´¶¦©¥¦§±´¶ª¦¼¦´±·©¥¦®¥½¦®½¬±´§©ª©¥·¦ª»´¸±¾

!"#$%&'$ ($) *+,$-'&.' " / $0 '1&'2"$ $' .' " & $ *3" "$!&$ ! 13$1 !&'"$2&"!$ *&" *3$ &' * ! $4 !($!( $ "5' $*&" "$!( !$ ' $!30 *$1&'$!( "$.'&50#$6!$!( $" !"$0' "$1&'$ ($ *+$ $5" "$" 25* ! & $"&1!4 ' $!&$! "!$4( !( '$!( "$0' .$ ' . 2 !$4 *$ 7* $!( $ &20 3$!&$2 8 $ $0'&1 !#$9( " $ *3! $! ( :5 "$2 8 $ !$0&" 7* $1&'$-'&.' " / $!&$0'&1 ! 7*3$ "5' $ 5"!&2 '"$ $!' ! & *3$( .(;' "8$ ! .&' "$!( !$&!( '$ "5' '"$4&5* $( / $' < ! #

Page 42: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

=>? @ A @ B C D E F GG B H I D J B H D E > C @ B H D K L C L M >N>CIODPQ>DRLSLC?>TDE?BH>?LHTDLCTD UCI> H G H @ A >DV>HJBHNLC?>DKLCLM>N>CIDW5" "$ ! * . $ * / ' $ $!( $1&'2$&1$ X 5! / $"500&'!$"3"! 2"$YZ[[\$( *0"$" &'$ X 5! / "$1& 5"$& $!( $' *3$ 20&'! !$0 '1&'2 $ 1&'2 ! & $!( !$ 1 !"$!( $&/ ' *$0'&1 ! 7 * !3$ $"5 "$&1$!( $1 '2#$]5' !*3+$!( $* .$2 !(& &*&.3$1&'$5 '"! ; .$!( $2&"!$ 20&'! !$ 1&'2 ! & $ $73$ $1 '2^"$ X 5! / "$ "$ * $!( $_`a`bcdef fgchidc`iefjdklhe$Ym 0* $ $n&'!& +$oppqr$m 0* $ $n&'!& +$stto\#$9( $7 * $ " &' $ ' $ "$ $1' 2 4&'8$1&'$&0 ' ! & * u .$ $1 '2^"$"!' ! . $0* $73$1& 5" .$& $$2 "5' 7* $&5! &2 "$& $1&5'$ 2 " & "$&1$1 '2$0 '1&'2 v$1 *+$75" "$0'& "+$ 5"!&2 '+$ $* ' .$ $.'&4!($Y" $% .5' $sp#w\#$- '1&'2 $& $ ($ 2 " & $ "$2 "5' $5" .$xdyfzdi{hij`bcdf|be|c`khigf}~ �€g �+$

4( ($ ' $!( $2 "5' "$0'&0&" $73$" &'$2 . 2 !$1&'$5 '"! .$(&4$4 *$!( $1 '2$ "$0 '1&'2 .$ *& .$ 3$. / $ 2 " & #$%&'$ "! +$& $8 3$ !&'$&1$(&4$4 *$ $& * $' ! *$1 '2$ "$2 ! .$ !"$ 5"!&2 '$0 '1&'2 $&7< ! /

Page 43: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

"$ "$!( $ / ' . $* .!($&1$! 2 $' :5 ' $!&$ * / '$ $0 8 . $!&$ $ & "52 '#$61$3&5'$1 '2$ "$ $7 8+$& $m-6$&1$75" "$0'& "$0 '1&'2 $ "$!( $* .!($&1$! 2 $' :5 ' $!&$0 '1&'2$ $7 " $15 ! & $* 8 $ ' ! .$ $ 4$ 5"!&2 '$ &5 !#$9( $7 * $" &' ' $1' 2 4&'8$ "$!(&5.(!$!&$7 $)7 * ,$7 5" $ !$ 5" "$

$2 . '"$!&$1& 5"$& $2&' $!( $<5"!$1 *$0 '1&'2 #$6 $!( "$/ 4+$1 *$$0 '1&'2 $ "$0 "!$( "!&'3‚!( $' "5*!$&1$0 "!$ ! & "‚ $2 . '"$"(&5* $1& 5"$& $!( $!( ."$!( 3$ ' $ 7* $!&$ 1*5 $!& 3+$"5 ($ "$75" "$0'& "$ 1 3+$ 5"!&2 '$$" ! "1 ! & +$ $ 20*&3 $!' .#$ƒ $ $" &' ' $ "$ / *&0 $73$ & "5*! !"$ $" &'$

Page 44: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

}~�€ �‚nƒ„…†n‡ˆ‰Š‹Œ�ŒŽ �‰�Š

‘�’“‰�Œ“ �Š”“Œ•‰–’“—Š˜™š›œ�šžŸ Ÿ™¡�¢š£¡¤¥ �¦

¡Ÿ¥¢š§¥Ÿ �̈©¤¥ª«š›œ�š§¬¥¨£š£›¥Ÿ› �®¬¡š¤ž �̄¡¦

›¬°�£šŸ¥�š¤±�¥Ÿ›¬¤™Ÿ ¬² �¢šŸ ¤™®š§¤³¥š¢¬¨�™£¬¤™£´š§¬™Ÿ™¡¬Ÿ «šž³£¬™�££š

±¥¤¡ �££«š¡³£›¤¨�¥«šŸ™¢š  �Ÿ¥™¬™®šŸ™¢š®¥¤©›œµš

¶Ÿ¡œš¢¬ �̈™£¬¤™š¬£š¨�Ÿ£³¥ �¢š³£¬™®š£�°�¥Ÿ š

·¸˜£µ

!"# $%&!' &( !&$! )&"$&* !+,*!"(-&*&./+0&+.&"(.+1,*!"+(&!+& !"# $&*(2&+!' 1&,*(*-3 1$&.+1& * '&+.&!' &4 5&) 1.+1,*( &"(2" *!+1$6&7(+!' 1& /+$ /5&1 /*! 2&,*(*- , (!&, !'+2+/+-5&"$&89:;<=::>?= @ A B @ C D <E=>

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

Page 45: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

,*!"+(&21*0(&.1+,&!' &."1,Y$& (! 1)1"$ &2*!*N*$ &$5$! ,$6&RVTW&[+14"(-&\1+ )%&OPPQX6&]+1)+1*! &2*!*&.+1& +(! ,)+1*15&^SS&*1 &$ ))/" 2&N5&!' &."1,Y$& "$!"(-& (! 1)1"$ &

&*))/" *!"+($&R (! 1)1"$ &1 $+ 1 &)/*(("(-%&$ ))/5& '*"(&,*(*- , (!%&*(2& $!+, 1&&1 /*!"+($'")&,*(*- , (!X6&^SS&*/$+&)1+#"2 &* $&!+&( 0$&$ 1#" $%&."(*( "*/&,*14 !&2*!*3N*$ $%& +(+," &"(.+1,*!"+(%&*(2&0'*! # 1&+!' 1& ! 1(*/&2*!*&$ ("+1& !"# $&1 _ "1 6&^SS&'*# &$"-("." *(!

&`@;ab`Bc<& *)*N"/"!" $&".&,*(*- 1$&( 2&,+1 &2 !*"/ 2&#" 0$&+.&2*!*6& [ /32 $"-( 2&^SS&' /)&$ ("+1& !"# $&,+("!+1&+1-*("d*!"+(*/&) 1.+1,*( %&!1* 4&

* !"#"!" $&+.& +,) !"!+1$%&1 +-("d & '*(-"(-&,*14 !& +(2"!"+($%&*(2&"2 (!".5&)1+N/ ,$&*(2&+))+1! ("!" $6&^,)/+5 $&/+0 1&2+0(&"(&!' & +1)+1*! &'" 1*1 '5&*/$+& $ &!' $ &$5$! ,$&!+&,+("!+1&*(2&, *$ 1 &N $"( $&) 1.+1,*( &"(&!' "1&*1 *$&+.&1 $)+($"N"/"!56&e+1&!' $ &*(2&+!' 1&N $"( $&"(! /"- ( &$5$! ,$&!+&N &!1 /5& $ . /%&!' &"(.+1,*!"+(&, $!&N &f* !"+(3*N/ gh"!&, $!&N &1 *2"/5&*#*"/*N/ &*(2&*/$+& *$5&!+& $ &0' (&,*4"(-&2 "$"+($6&U.& $ 1$&'*# &2"." /!5&"2 (!".5"(-& 1"!" */&, !1" $&0"!'"(&!' &1 )+1!$&!' 5&1 "# %& ,)/+5 &)1+2 3!"#"!5&*(2&N $"( $&) 1.+1,*( &0"/&$ . 16&Z' &U(! 1* !"# &S $"+(&+(&T +)/ &$'+0$&'+0&

Page 46: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

]+/-*! 3T*/,+/"# &*221 $ 2&!'"$&)1+N/ ,&*(2&' /) 2&"!$&,*(*- 1$&,*4 &,+1 &2*!*321"# (%&* !"+(*N/ &2 "$"+($6

ijklmnopqrsrktuslmmkjvnswsvpxsZ' &$5$! ,$&0 &'*# &y $!&2 $ 1"N 2&.+ $&)1",*1"/5&+(&' /)"(-&5+ &,*4 &*&2 "$"+(&* !"(-&*/+( 6&V !&0'*!&".&5+ &*1 &)*1!&+.&*&! *,&*(2&( 2&!+&,*4 &*&2 "$"+(&*$&*&-1+ )z&{+ &0+ /2& $ &*&$) "*/& *! -+15&+.&$5$! ,$& */ 2&-1+ )&2 "$"+(3$ ))+1!&$5$! ,$&R\|SSX&.+1&!'"$&) 1)+$ 6

Page 47: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

! " # ## $ % & $&' !()*+,-.&+)/()01- 2-34 5+6+*-74 #/0)06* 80,9 :-;<,01- =+49>(+7?4@ A B C D E F G H D B I A B J K F L @ A I M D N O L J P L E Q F L P F R AN S L L B D T C F P E L LRANPUIFTLMTASUREPLRAIMDNOLJNLEQFLVATBSWLDNSLJEPL MTASUREPLDTFLIDTXFEFSLJNLAKFTLYZZLRAUNETJFPLDNSL LEFTJEATJFP[L\QFLRAIMDNOLQDSL]^WZZZLFIMBAOFFPL VATBSVJSFLDNSL_`aLbJBJANLJNLDNNUDBLTFKFNUFLJNLYZ`Z[L@ A B C D E F L Q D P L b F F N L X F F M J N C L M F A M B F L P I J B J N C L D N S L R B F D N L DTAUNSLEQFLVATBSWLVJEQLIATFLEQDNLEQTFFGcUDTEFTPLAdLJEPL PDBFPLJNLTFRFNELOFDTPLRAIJNCLdTAILAUEPJSFLEQFLeNJEFSL fEDEFP[ L @ A B C D E F g P L b T D N S P L J N L A T D B L M T A S U R E P W L P A D M W L D N S L M F E L d A A S W L D T F L C B A b D B L N D I F P W L J N R B U S J N C L @ A B C D E F W L H D B I A B J K F W L hFNNFNWLfAdEPADMWLiTJPQLfMTJNCWLfATJPAWLjABONAPWL kBIFlWL\AIgPLAdLhDJNFWLmnDlWLmlJANWLoDbUBAPAWL fAUMBJNFWLDNSLfUDKJEFBWLDPLVFBLDPLpJBgPLfRJFNRFLqJFEL DNSLpJBgPLHTFPRTJMEJANLqJFE[\

QFLPFRTFELEALRANEJNUFSLCTAVEQLDNSLPEDbJBJEOLdATL E Q F L M D P E L E V A L S F R D S F P L Q D P L b F F N L @ A B C D E F g P L D b J B J E O L E A L IAKFLJEPLbTDNSPLAdPQATFLEALrDEJNLmIFTJRDWLkUTAMFL DNSLmPJD[ L i N L E Q F L M D P E W L @ A B C D E F L S J K J S F S L E Q F L V A T B S L J N E A L CFACTDMQJRLTFCJANPsLrD

EJNLmIFTJRDNWLkUTAMFWLmPJDWL DNSLtATEQLmIFTJRD[LkDRQLTFCJANLQDSLJEPLAVNLJNdATG IDEJANLPOPEFIP[LmPLBANCLDPLEQFLTFCJANPLSJSLNAELNFFSL EALPQDTFLTFPAUTRFPLATLJNdATIDEJANWLEQJPLMDERQVATXL LPOPEFILVATXFSWLIATFLATLBFPP[L\QJPLDBLRQDNCFSLDPL CBAbDBLAMFTDEJANPLbFRDIFLIATFLJNEFCTDEFSLDNSLPFNJATL LIDNDCFIFNELNFFSFSLEALAKFTPFFLDNSLRAATSJNDEFLEQFPFL AMFTDEJANPLIATFLRBAPFBO[L

@ A B C D E F L Q D S L b F F N L D L C B A b D B L f m H L U P F T L P J N R F L E Q F L F D T B O L

`^^ZPWLbUELJELVDPLTUNNJNCLdJKFLPFMDTDEFLkuHLPOPEFIPLEAL PFTKFLJEPLSJdFTFNELCFACTDMQJRLTFCJANP[LvKFTLDLMFTJASLAdL EJIFWLSJPMDTJEJFPLJNLEQFLSDEDLSFKFBAMFSLbFEVFFNLSJdFTFNEL CFACTDMQJRLTFCJANPWLDNSLbFEVFFNLEQFLSDEDLUPFSLDELEQFL RATMATDEFLBFKFBLDNSLEQFLSDEDLUPFSLbOLDNLJNSJKJSUDBLTFCJANL ATLbUPJNFPLUNJE[L\QFLSDEDLVFTFLRANPEDNEBOLRQDNCJNC[LoATL FlDIMBFWLFKFTOLEJIFLDLPDBFPLTFMATELVDPLTUNWLJELPQAVFSL SJdFTFNELNUIbFTPLdATLATSFTPLDNSLPQJMIFNEP[ L @ A B C D E F L VDNEFSLIATFLUPDbBFLSDEDLEALSTJKFLbUPJNFPLSFRJPJANPL DNSLDBLAdLJEPLIDNDCFTP

Page 48: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

LDNSLbUPJNFPLUNJEPLVATBSVJSFL EALVATXLVJEQLEQFLPDIFLKFTPJANLAdLEQFLSDED[

@ A B C D E F L R Q A P F L E A L P A B K F L E Q J P L M T A b B F I L b O L R T F D E J N C L DLPJNCBFLCBAbDBLSDEDLTFMAPJEATOLUPJNCLfmHLtFEwFDKFTL xUPJNFPPLwDTFQAUPFWLfmHgPLDNDBOEJRDBWLTFMATEJNCL DNSLSDEDLVDTFQAUPJNCLPABUEJAN[ L @ A B C D E F g P L T F C J AN D B L kuHLPOPEFIPLdFFSLEQFJTLSDEDLEALEQFLVDTFQAUPFWLVQFTFL EQFLSDEDLDTFLPEDNSDTSJyFSLDNSLdATIDEFSLdATLFNEFTG MTJPFGVJSFLTFMATEJNCLDNSLDNDBOPJP[L\QJPLFBJIJNDEFPL LSJdFTFNRFPLJNLSDEDLDRTAPLEQFLFNEFTMTJPF[L

vNFLAdLEQFLAUEMUEPLAdLEQFLVDTFQAUPFLdATLPFNJATL IDNDCFTPLJPLDLSDJBOLp\hrLEDbBFLPQAVJNCLDLPFTJFPL AdLdJNDNRJDBLDNSLAMFTDEJANDBLIFETJRPLdATLEQFLSDOL LRAIMDTFSLEALEQFLMTFKJAUPLIANEQLDNSLcUDTEFT[L\QFLSDEDL EQFLFlFRUEJKFPLPFFLDTFLFlDREBOLEQFLPDIFLDPLVQDELEQFJTL MFFTPLJNLDB L @ A B C D E F L T F C J A N P L D N S L b U P J N F PLUNJEPLPFF[L

pAVFKFTWLEQFLSDEDLVFTFLNAELbFJNCLUPFSLbOLFNAUCQL FIMBAOFFPLJNLEQFJTLSFRJPJANLIDXJNCLEALQDKFLDNLJIMDREL ANLbUPJNFPPLbFNFdJEP[ L @ A B C D E F g P L M A V F T L U P F T P L Q D S L NALETAUbBFLUPJNCLEQFLTFMATEJNCLDNSLDNDBOEJRDBLEAABPL LMTAKJSFSLbOLEQFLVDTFQAUPFWLDNSLEQFOLVFTFLPDEJPdJFSL VJEQLEQFLIDETJlLTFMATEPLdTAILEQFLPOPEFI[ L @ A B C D E F g P L PFNJATLIDNDCFTPLDNSLAEQFTLRDPUDBLUPFTPWLANLEQFLAEQFTL QDNSWLSJSLNAELdFFBLRAIdATEDbBFLTUNNJNCLDSLQARLTFMATEPL ATLSTJBJNCLSAVNLJNEALEQFLBDOFTPLAdLSDEDLEALDNPVFTL LcUFPEJANPLEQFLSDEDLbTAUCQELEALBJCQE[L\QFOLSJSLNAEL QDKFLIURQLEJIFLEALPMFNSLSFKFBAMJNCLTFMATEPWLDNSLEQFL LPEDNSDTSLTFMATEPLMTASURFSLdATLEQFILbOLEQFLVDTFQAUPFL BDRXFSLNDKJCDEJANLDNSLSTJBGSAVNLRDMDbJBJEJFP[L\DbBFPL QDSLNALRABATLRASJNCWLPALUPFTPLRAUBSLANBOLJNEFTMTFELEQFL SDEDLbOLPRTUEJNJyJNCLEQFLNUIbFTPLJNLEQFLEDbBF[L

kKFNEUDB O L @ A B C D E F g P L P F N J A T L I D N D C F T P L D N S L A E Q F T L RDPUDBLUPFTPLbFCDNLTFcUFPEJNCLSFFMFTLDRRFPLEALEQFL VDTFQAUPFLSDEDLJNLDLIATFLEJIFBOLDNSLUPFTGdTJFNSBOL dATIDE[L\QFOLVDNEFSLTFMATEPLEQDELVFTFLFDPJFTLEALTUNL VQFTFLEQFLSDEDLRAUBSLbFLJNEFTMTFEFSLdDPEFT[LfFNJATL LIDNDCFIFNELTFcUFPEFSL

Page 49: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

RUPEAIJyDbBFWLTFDBGEJIFL LSDPQbADTSPLEQDELRAUBSLbFLIATFLFDPJBOLUPFSLEALSTJKFL MFTdATIDNRFLJIMTAKFIFNE[L

@ A B C D E F g P L J N d A T I D E J A N L P O P E F I P L P M F R J D B J P E P L E Q F N L JIMBFIFNEFSLfmHLtFEwFDKFTLxwLmRRFBFTDEATLEAL PMFFSLUMLSDEDLBADSPLDNSLJIMTAKFLUPFTLMFTRFMEJANL DNSLDSAMEJANWLDNSLEQFOLJIMBFIFNEFSLfmHLxUPJNFPPL vbnFREPLwFbLiNEFBJCFNRFLEALbUJBSLRUPEAIJyFSLTFMATEP[L fmHLxUPJNFPPLvbnFREPLwFbLiNEFBJCFNRFLMTAKJSFPLDL MAVFTdUBWLJNEUJEJKFLJNEFTdDRFLEQDELFNDbBFPLbUPJNFPLDNDG BOPEPLDNSLNANGEFRQNJRDBLbUPJNFPLMTAdFPJANDBPLEALDPXL PMANEDNFAUPLcUFPEJANPLDbAUELEQFJTLSDED[ L @ D P U D B L b U P J G NFPLUPFTPLRDNLUPFLPJIMBFLSTDCGDNSGSTAMLEFRQNJcUFPL EALDRRFPLSDEDLPAUTRFPLDNSLRTFDEFLJNEFTDREJKFLTFMATEPL EQDELSTJBWLPBJRFWLDNSLdATIDELJNdATIDEJANLbDPFSLANLEQFJTL NFFSP[L\AABPLdATLRUEJNCGFSCFLKJPUDBJyDEJANLDBAVLFNSL UPFTPLEALKJFVLEVAGLDNSLEQTFFGSJIFNPJANDBLRQDTEPLDNSL QANFLJNLANLPMFRJdJRLDTFDPLAdLdARUP[

@ A B C D E F L P E D T E F S L U P J N C L f m H g P L x U P J N F PLvbnFREPLEAABPL EALbUJBSLUPFTGdTJFNSBOLSDPQbADTSPWLDNSLcUJRXBOLRTFDEFSL SDPQbADTSLMTAEAEOMFPLdATLIDNDCFIFNELEALTFKJFV[L ePJNCLSTAMGSAVNLIFNUPWLPBJSFTPWLDNSLFSJEDbBFLB

DbFBPL DNSLRABATPWLEQFLJNdATIDEJANLPOPEFIPLPEDdLVDPLDbBFLEAL RTFDEFLRUPEAIJyFSLSDPQbADTSPLEQDELPJIMBJdJFSLEQFLMTFG PFNEDEJANLAdLRAIMBFlLbUPJNFPPLSDEDLEALPUJELSJdFTFNEL EOMFPLAdLFIMBAOFFP[LvNRFLIDNDCFIFNELDMMTAKFSLEQFL SDPQbADTSLSFPJCNWLEQFLSDPQbADTSPLVFTFLMAMUBDEFSLVJEQL MTASUREJANLSDED[ L t A V L @ A B C D E F g P L P F N J A T L I D N D C F T P L D T F L TUNNJNCLEQFLSDPQbADTSPLEALIANJEATLEQFLbUPJNFPLdTAIL DLQJCQLBFKFB[L

kIMBAOFFLETDJNJNCLVDPLFPFNEJDBLEALEQFLSDPQbADTSPgL PURRFPP[ L h F I b F T P L A d L @ A B C D E F g P L C B A b D B L L J N d A T I D E J A N L

Page 50: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"# $"%"&'(#")! !"*# +,"*!"$ +- !'#./"$ +'-, " 0', 1'&2*!"3 45 6- .)" .)!"&.2")+" "7(",! *)$ ,*) !8" +&* ,''# !,*.).)29 :8" !,*.).)2 .$")!.0."$ ("'(&" ;8' +'-&$ 6" - "$ * ," '-,+" 0', $"%"&'(<.)2 !8" ,"(',!.)2 !''& 9 =8") ;',$ (,"*$ *6'-! !8" $* 86'*,$ 3 +*(*6.&.!." > 1'&2*!"3 (';", - ", .2)"$ -( 0', !8" +&* " * ;"&9

?', 1'&2*!"> 6"!", ,"(',!.)2 !''& !8*! +*) -((',!

$.0",")! @.)$ '0 - ", 8*%" 2,"*!& "7(*)$"$ !8" - " '0 6- .)" .)!"&.2")+" !8,'-28'-! !8" +'#(*) 9 1-,")!& > *6'-! A>BBB - ", .)!",*+! ;.!8 1'&2*!"3 CDE !"# $*.& > 6-! !8. )-#6", . "7("+!"$ !' "7(*)$ !' F5>BBB ', GB>BBB - ", .) !8" 0-!-,"9 E"'(&" ;8' *," *++- !'#"$ !' "".)2 ,"(',! !-0"$ ;.!8

)-#6", *," 0.)$.)2 !8*! !8" +*) - " !8" .)0',#*<!.') (," ")!"$ .) $* 86'*,$ !' #*@" 0* !", $"+.< .') 9 ?', "7*#(&"> #*)*2", +*) $"!",#.)" (' .!.%" ', )"2*!.%" 0.)*)+.*& +')$.!.') 6 .#(& &''@.)2 0', ;8"," $* 86'*,$ ,"(',! - " !8" +'&', 2,"")> ;8.+8 ,"0&"+! .#(,'%"#")! .) 1'&2*!"3 0.)*)+.*& (' .!.')9 H7"+-!.%" ;8' 0',#",& ,"&."$ ') '!8", ("'(&" !' '6!*.) !8"., +- !'# ,"(',! *)$ $*!* *," *6&" !' *++" !8" .)0',#*!.') ') !8"., ';)9 :8" +*) "" ,"*& $*!* 0,'# !8" !"# #-+8 #'," "* .& *)$ I-. +@& 9

C'-,+" J K*%.$ L*))')> M1'&2*!"<E*&#'&.%" H#(';", C").', N"*$", ;.!8 H7"+-!.%" K* 86'*,$ >O CDE P) .$",EQR?PNHC> D(,.&<S-)" GBFFT MC"" U'-, V- .)" 1&"*,& >O CDE> GBFBT *)$ ME&*+.)2 Q"&"%*)! V- .)" 1')!")! ;.!8.) V- .)" W ", Q"*+8>O CDE> GBFF9

abcdecfghiejgdcfklmce enkcekmebafklmXYZK" +,.6" !8" $.0",")! ! (" '0 6- .)"

.)!"&.2")+" - ", *! 1'&2*!"<E*&#'&.%"9

Page 51: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

[YZK" +,.6" !8"

M("'(&"O . -" !8*! ;"," *0"+!.)2

1'&2*!"3 *6.&.! !' - " 6- .)" .)!"&.2")+"9 \YZ=8*! ("'(&"> ',2*)./*!.')> *)$ !"+8)'&'2 0*+!', 8*$ !' 6" *$$," "$ .) (,'%.$.)2 6- .)" .)!"&.2")+" +*(*6.&.!." 0', "*+8 ! (" '0 - ",]

^YZ=8*! @.)$ '0 $"+. .') $'" 1'&2*!"3 )"; 6- .)" .)!"&.2")+" +*(*6.&.! -((',!] _.%" !8,"" "7*#(&" 9 =8*! . !8"., ('!")!.*& 6- .)" .#(*+!]

`. .! 1'&2*!"<E*&#'&.%"3 ="6 .!" !' *++" .! *))-*& ,"(',!9 V* "$ ') !8. ,"(',!> $" +,.6" !;' ', !8,"" $* 86'*,$ !8*! #.28! 6" *((,'(,.*!" 0', ").', #*)*2"#")!9

D opqrsZtuvwxwqyzxrssqp{Zx|x{u} ~ �€��‚ . *) .)!",*+!.%" +'#(-!",<6* "$ !"#

0', 0*+.&.!*!.)2 !8" '&-!.') '0 -) !,-+!-,"$ (,'6&"# 6 * "! '0 $"+. .') #*@", ;',@.)2 !'2"!8", * * 2,'-( .) !8" *#" &'+*!.') ', .) $.0",")! &'+*!.') 9 _,'-(;*," *)$ ="6<6* "$ !''& 0', %.$"'+')0",")+.)2 *)$ "&"+!,').+ #""!.)2 $" +,.6"$ "*,&.", .) !8. !"7! -((',! '#" 2,'-( $"+. .') (,'+" " > 6-! !8"., 0'+- . (,.#*,.& ') +'##-).<+*!.')9 _KCC> 8';"%",> (,'%.$" !''& *)$ !"+8)'&'2." 2"*,"$ "7(&.+.!& !';*,$ 2,'-( $"+. .') #*@.)29

_KCC<2-.$"$ #""!.)2 !*@" (&*+" .) +')0",")+" ,''# ;.!8 ("+.*& 8*,$;*," *)$

'0!;*," !''& !' 0*+.&.!*!" 2,'-( $"+. .') #*@.)29 :8" 8*,$;*," .)+&-$" +'#(-!", *)$ )"!;',@.)2 "I-.(#")!> '%",8"*$

Page 52: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

(,'ƒ"+!', > *)$ $. (&* +,"") 9 C("+.*& "&"+!,').+ #""!.)2 '0!;*," +'&"+! > $'+-#")! > ,*)@ > "$.! > *)$ !'," !8" .$"* '0","$ .) * $"+. .')<#*@.)2 #""!.)29 :8" #'," "&*6',*!" _KCC - " * (,'0" .')*& 0*+.&.!*!', *)$ -((',! !*09 :8" 0*+.&.!*!', "&"+! !8" '0!;*," !''& *)$ 8"&( ',2*)./" *)$ ,-) !8" #""!.)29

D '(8. !.+*!"$ _KCC (,'%.$" "*+8 *!")$"" ;.!8 * $"$.+*!"$ $" @!'( +'#(-!", -)$",

!8*! (", ')3 .)$.%.$-*& +')!,'&9 „' ')" ;.& 6" *6&" !' "" ;8*! .)$.%.$-*& $' ') !8"., +'#(-!", -)!.& !8' " (*,!.+.(*)! *," ,"*$ !' 8*," .)0',#*!.')9 :8"., .)(-! . !,*) #.!<!"$ '%", * )"!;',@ !' * +")!,*& ",%", !8*! !'," .)0',#*!.') 2")",*!"$ 6 !8" #""!.)2 *)$ #*@" .! *%*.&*6&" !' *& ') !8" #""!.)2 )"!;',@9 K*!* +*) *& ' 6" (,'ƒ"+!"$ ') * &*,2" +,"") .) !8" #""!.)2 ,''#9

Page 53: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

<=>? @ A B C D E F G D B C @ H I J C D K J @ L M N @ O D P F J F M B @ HQ RR M N C "+#'#&* !#*- #' )'& "*0 *+"1 (4 #*$")#-"*$ $"+0*#S2"' *1 !*&/)"1-" * -" "*$ '4'$" '5 TUVWXYZWUV[VW\]UY^_W`[+&*'#'$ &8 "a%",$ '4'$"

Page 54: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

': + '"b( '"1 ," '&*#*-: -"*"$#+ )-&,#$0 ': *"2, ) *"$/&,!': 82..4 )&-#+: *1 #*$")#-"*$ -"*$'5 ;0"'" $"+0*#S2"' ," ( '"1 &* cdVYeY\YcX[YUVWXYZWU\W[fgTh $"+0*&)&-4: /0#+0 +&*'#'$' &8 +& %2$",b( '"1 '4'$" ' i(&$0 0 ,1/ ," *1 '&8$/ ,"j $0 $ $" %$ $& " 2) $" 02 * ("0 3#&, *1 $0&2-0$ % $",*'5 k*$")#-"*$ $"+0*#S2"' #1 1"+#'#&* !",' (4 + %$2,#*- #*1#3#12 ) *1 +&)"+$#3" !*&/)"1-": 1#'+&3",#*- % $",*' *1 ("0 3#&,' #* 3",4 ) ,-" S2 *$#$#"' &8 1 $ : *1 -"*", $#*- '&)2$#&*' $& %,&()" ' $0 $ ," $&& ) ,-" *1 +& %)"a 8&, 02 * ("#*-' $& '&)3" &* $0"#, &/*5 l*&/)"1-" * -" "*$ '4'$" ': /0#+0 /" #*$,&12+"1 #* m0 %$", n: *1 !*&/)"1-" /&,! '4'$" ' %,&3#1" $&&)' 8&, !*&/)"1-" 1#'+&3",4: +& 2*#+ $#&*: *1 +&) (&, $#&* $0 $ !" !*&/)"1-" &," " '#)4 3 #) ()" $& 1"+#'#&* !",' *1 #*$"-, $" #$ #*$& $0" (2'#*"' %,&+"'"' &8 $0" 8#, 5

o p q o r s @ H t H s o u H

Page 55: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

v0 $ #8 " %)&4""' #* 4&2, 8#, 0 1 $& !" 1"+#'#&*' $0 $ ,"S2#,"1 '& " '%"+# ) !*&/)"1-": '2+0 ' 0&/ $& 8&, 2) $" 8 '$b1,4#*- '" )#*- +& %&2*1 &, 0&/ $& 1# -*&'" *1 ,"% #, )82*+$#&*#*- 1#"'") "*-#*": (2$ ) $0" %"&%)" /#$0 $0 $ "a%",$#'" 0 1 )"8$ $0" 8#, w xa%",$ '4'$" ' ," &*" $4%" &8 1"+#'#&*b !#*- #1 $0 $ +&2)1 0")% 4&2 &2$5 6* WyzWdV[`{`VW| + %$2,"' 02 * "a%",$#'" #* )# #$"1 1& #* &8 !*&/)"1-" ' '"$ &8 ,2)"' #* '&8$/ ," '4'$" $0 $ + * (" 2'"1 (4 &$0",' #* $0" &,- *#. $#&*5 ;0"'" '4'$" ' $4%#+ )4 %",8&, )# #$"1 *2 (", &8 $ '!' $0 $ + * (" %",8&, "1 (4 %,&8"'#&* )' #* 8"/ #*2$"' &, 0&2,': '2+0 ' 1# -*&'#*- )82*+$#&*#*- +0#*" &, 1"$", #*#*- /0"$0", $& -, *$ +,"1#$ 8&, )& *5 ;0"4 ," 2'"82) #* 1"+#'#&*b !#*- '#$2 $#&*' /0"," "a%",$#'" #' "a%"*'#3" &, #* '0&,$ '2%%)45

} M ~ @ o � R D N C @ H I J C D K J@€MN �‚2 * !*&/)"1-" 2'$ (" &1")"1 &, ,"%,"'"*$"1 #* 8&, $0 $ +& %2$", + * %,&+"'5 xa%",$ '4'$" ' &1") 02 * !*&/)"1-" ' '"$ &8 ,2)"' $0 $ +&)"+$#3")4 ," + )"1 $0" ƒU„…XW†ZW[‡c`W5 xa%",$ '4'$" ' + * 0 3"

Page 56: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

8,& nˆˆ $& ' *4 ' ‰ˆ:ˆˆˆ &8 $0"'" ,2)"': 1"%"*1#*- &* $0" +& %)"a#$4 &8 $0" 1"+#'#&*b !#*- %,&()" 5 ;0"'" ,2)"' ," 2+0 &," #*$",+&**"+$"1 *1 *"'$"1 $0 * #* $, 1#$#&* ) '&8$/ ," %,&-, i'"" Š#-2," ‰ˆ5‹j5;0" '$, $"-4 2'"1 $& '" ,+0 $0,&2-0 $0" +&)"+$#&* &8 ,2)"' *1 8&, 2) $" +&*+)2'#&*' #'

+ )"1 $0" YUeWdWU\W[WUZYUW5 ;0" #*8","*+" "*-#*" /&,!' (4 '" ,+0#*- $0,&2-0 $0" ,2)"' *1 Œ8#,#*- $0&'" ,2)"' $0 $ ," $,#--","1 (4 8 +$' - $0","1 *1 "*$","1 (4 $0" 2'",5xa%",$ '4'$" ' %,&3#1" (2'#*"''"' /#$0 * , 4 &8 ("*"8#$': #*+)21#*- # %,&3"1 1"+#'#&*': ,"12+"1 ",&,': ,"12+"1 +&'$': ,"12+"1 $, #*#*- $# ": *1 # %,&3"1 S2 )#$4 *1 '",3#+"5 Š&, "a %)": m&*bv 4 ;, *'%&,$ $#&* (2#)$ * "a%",$ '4'$" + )"1 Ž#*"b0 2) $& 2$& $" *1 &%$# #." %) **#*- &8 &3",*#-0$ '0#% "*$ ,&2$"' 8&, #$' * $#&*/#1" 8,"#-0$b$,2+!#*- (2'#*"''5 ;0" "a%",$ '4'$" + %$2,"' $0" (2'#*"'' ,2)"' $0 $ 1#'% $+0b",' 8&)&/ /0"* '#-*#*- 1,#3",': $,2+!': *1 $, #)",' $& $, *'%&,$ ˆ:ˆˆˆ '0#% "*$' &8 0" 34 8,"#-0$ " +0 *#-0$ +,&' n 5 5 '$ $"' *1 m * 1 *1 /0"* %)&$#*- $0"#, ,&2$"'5

Page 57: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

YZ[\]^S_`abS cdefghijhkjhlmnfophqrgpfs tuvwxywz{v|}|{w~v �€u{�‚u|v �v|w{v€ƒvz„…w|v{€v†wvƒ€…€‡wˆv‡‰wuv„|wˆŠv‹‰wvz„…w|v�zwv‚u{wz�€uuw �{wˆŒv{‰wvu„~†wzv€ƒv€„{ �€~w|v‚|v�u€‡uv‚uv �ˆŽ�u �wv�uˆv‚|v…‚~‚{wˆŒv{‰wzwv �zwv~„…{‚y…wvy�{‰|v{€v{‰wv| �~wv€„{ �€~wŒv �uˆv{‰wv|}|{w~v��uv �€u|‚ˆwzv~„…{‚y…wvz„…w|v �{v �v|‚u �…wv{‚~wŠv‹‰wvz„…w|v‚…„|{z �{wˆv�zwvƒ€zv �v|‚~y…wv �zwˆ‚{��z �u{‚u �vwxywz{v|}|{w~Š

!"#$%&'(% )'* '$'+% ',&$-.*(/'$ 0'%)!)'0$-$'* '0$ &1'2%)-*/!(')# ,/! -'(!3%!)-)4'$5$ &$6&!'0( 5!()4'-(%27)4'-($ &!('),$2!4'$ 0'8! 9#-')-*(!0' '$ ':($2&!'0$-$6$)!;'<#!'!=,!(-')1)-!/'%)!)'-#*%)$ 0)'*.'(%&!)'$ 0'>??4???'& !)'*.',(*9($/'2*0!'8( -! ' ' @ A A '-*'2(% 2#'-#!' %/6!()'$ 0'2(!$-!'*,- /%/'(*%- 9',&$

Page 58: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

)'.*('BC',!(2! -'*.'0$ &1'.(! 9#-')# ,/! -);' @ * "D$1'0 ),$-2#!()'-8!$7'-#!'(*%- 9',&$ ',(*5 0!0'61'-#!'!=,!(-')1)-!/'$ 0'(!&$1'. $&'(*%- 9'),!2 . 2$- * )'-*'. !&0',!()* !&'(!),* ) 6&!'.*(',$27 9'-#!'-($ &"!()'.*('-#! (' 9#- /!'(% );' @ * "D$1'(!2*%,!0' -)'EF'/ & * ' 5!)-/! -' '-#!')1)-!/'8 -# '-8*'1!$()'61'(!0%2 9'-#!' %/6!('*.'0( 5!()4',$27 9'/*(!'.(! 9#-',!('-($ &!(4'$ 0' (!0%2 9'0$/$9!'.(*/'(!#$ 0& 9;'<#!')1)-!/'$&)*'(!0%2!)'0 ),$-2#!()G'$(0%*%)' 9#-&1'-$)7);

H&-#*%9#'!=,!(-')1)-!/)'&$27'-#!'(*6%)-'$ 0'9! !($&' -!& 9! 2!'*.'#%/$ '6! 9)4'-#!1'2$ ',(*5 0!'6! !. -)'-*'*(9$ I$- * )' .'-#! ('& / -$- * )'$(!'8!&'% 0!()-**0;': &1'2!(-$ '2&$)!)'*.',(*6&!/)'2$ '6!')*&5!0'%) 9'!=,!(-')1)-!/);'J (-%$&1'$&')%22!).%&'!=,!(-')1)-!/)'0!$&'8 -#',(*6&!/)'*.'2&$)) . 2$- * ' '8# 2#'-#!(!'$(!'(!&$- 5!&1'.!8''$&-!( $- 5!'*%-2*/!)'$ 0' '8# 2#'-#!)!',*)) 6&!'*%-2*/!)'$(!'$&'7 *8 ' '$05$ 2!;' K=,!(-')1)-!/)'$(!'/%2#'&!))'%)!.%&'.*('0!$& 9'8 -#'% )-(%2-%(!0',(*6&!/)'-1, 2$&1'! 2*% -!(!0'61'/$ $9!();

LMNOPQMNORSTOMNUVWVXK=,!(-')1)-!/)',( /$( &1'2$,-%(!'-#!'7 *8&!09!'*.'

Page 59: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

0 5 0%$&'!=,!(-)4'6%-'*(9$ I$- * )'$&)*'#$5!'2*&!2- 5!'7 *8&!09!'$ 0'!=,!(- )!'-#$-'-#!1'#$5!'6% &-'%,'*5!('-#!'1!$();'<# )'

Page 60: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

Q ,R$ E! ( ) -'.* -'( ' - ! ! (! -#!) -J-#'G- ! G'(!)! ' ),-# G' -,++ #

&F' ' ,-' - ) '# !'H' + -# ) -'- &F -' )F )#' !-#!)- ' -!G!$ # #F' '& ) -'/ IF' -J-#'G -, '-#- - $,#! (! -!- * -'( #F' *'-#.G #)F! '# !'H'( ) -'/

STUUVWXYZ[\W]V]^_`]a -# +' +$' ( # #F! % ! #' G- E # (!#! $ 0M.Ibcd ,$'- + ')!-' ,G*' -/ b,G - #' ( # ) #' !"' #F! - !G+ ')!-'$JC ,-! ,$'- E G %! (')!-!

Page 61: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

- #F # G J F H' G J -F ('- E G' ! / M 'D G+$'C G & G G J *' efghij kiflmkjlif/ n ) G+ J G J *' mogjlpqrlsktrC erom ! -!"'/ I'G+' #, ' G J *' uhfC vhmsC vhhmC wogr/ IF'-' ) #' !'- '+ '-' # ' E H $,'-/xyzz{8|:=<1 !- ,$'.* -'( #')F $ J #F # '+ '-' #- -,)F !G+ ')!-! *J ) ' #! ,$'- #F # ,-' ++ D!G #' -,*}')#!H' H $,'-/ 0# ('-) !*'- + #!),$ +F' G' + )'- $! ,!-#!) $J ( #F' '+ '-' #- #F # ('-) !+#! ! -G $ ,G*' E E$'D!*$' ,$'-/~'#R- $ % # #F' & J E,""J $ !) & ,$( '+ '-' # H ! ,- #'G+' #, '- ! ) G+,#' ++$!) #! # ) # $ G #'G+' #, ' ,# G #!) $J/ IF' #' G- >% & - rlr �lgeuk€q

S �‚ƒ„…W†‡ˆ‰WŠ‹Œ �Ž ��‘’“ ��‘” �•‘��‹–—–˜�™‹š› �œ �žŸ ¡�žŸ¢£¤Ÿ �ž¥¦§¦¨£¤Ÿ©¤ŸžŸ¦ªž£«¦¥¬Ÿ¢¨Ÿ£�ž£�£¢�ª �¡�žŸ£¥®£©�žª£¯ �žŸž£�¦¢£ª°Ÿ§¤£ž¥±ª§¥¦ž²£³°Ÿ£ž´žªŸµ£±žŸž£ �£ž§¶ žªŸ©£©¤¥¯Ÿžž£ª¥£¨Ÿ¦Ÿ¤ �ªŸ£ž¥±ª§¥¦ž£ª¥£¦Ÿ¬££©¤¥¡Ÿµž£Ÿ¦¯¥±¦ªŸ¤Ÿ¢£¡´£ª°Ÿ£±žŸ¤²

Page 62: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

Page 63: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

(48'V*42(+W/'/< @ A (1'/1/6*,'</*/'3<PP1'05;+.'.546)50/'65'(..*0*)(6*'/5'/,556701'67(6'/6(42+4;'-(/*4;*)/'4**2'456'7502'54?':<PP1'05;+.'(05A/'+4.)*,*46(0'.7(4;*/'+4'+4-<6/'65'-)52<.*'/,5567'.7(4;*/'+4'5<6-<6/'+4/6*(2'53'2+/.546+4<5</'54*/8',(X+4;'+6'</*3<0'35)'.54/<,*)'*0*.6)54+./'(42'*4;+4**)+4;'(--0+.(6+54/?

YZ[\]^_YZ`ab\cdefghijklfmnohpq'()*'</*2'35)'/50H+4;'.5,-0*98'-55)01'<42*)/6552'-) 5 @ 0 * ,/'35)'A7+.7'0();*'(,5<46/'53'2(6('7(H*' @ * * 4 '.50*.6*2?'L7*1'3+42'-(6*)4/'(42')*0(6+54/7+-/'+4',(/+H*' (,5<46/'53'2(6('67(6'A5<02' @ * '655'.5,-0+.(6*2'(42'2+3+.<06'35)'('7<,(4' @ * + 4 ;'65'(4(01P*?' F*<)(0'4*6A5)X/'2+/.5H*)'67+/'X45A0*2;*' @ 1 '</+4;'7()2A()*'(42'/536A()*'67(6'-()(0*0'67*'-)5.*/+4;'-(6*)4/'53'67*' @ + 5 0 5 ;+.(0'5)'7<,(4'@)(+4?'F*<)(0'4*6A5)X/'M0*()4O'-(6*)4/'3)5,'0();*'Q<(46+6+*/'53'2(6(' @ 1 '/

Page 64: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

+36+4;'67)5<;7'2(6(8'/*().7+4;'35)')*0(6+54/7+-/8'@<+02+4;',52*0/8' (42'.5)*.6+4;'5H*)'(42'5H*)'(;(+4'67*',52*0W/'5A4',+/6(X*/?r'4*<)(0'4*6A5)X'7(/'('0();*'4<, @ *)'53'/*4/+4;'(42'-)5.*/+4;'452*/'67(6'.546+4<5</01'

+46*)(.6'A+67'*(.7'567*)?':+;<)*'=>?==')*-)*/*46/'54*'61-*'53'4*<)(0'4*6A5)X'.5,-)+/+4;' (4'+4-<6'0(1*)8'('7+22*4'-)5.*/+4;'0(1*)8'(42'(4'5<6-<6'0(1*)?'S<,(4/'M6)(+4O'67*'4*6A5)X'@ 1 '3**2+4;'+6'('/*6'53'6)(+4+4;'2(6('35)'A7+.7'67*'+4-<6/'-)52<.*'('X45A4'/*6'53'5<6-<6/'5)''.54.0</+54/?'L7+/'7*0-/'67*'.5,-<6*)'0*()4'67*'.5)*.6'/50<6+54' @ 1 '*9(,-0*?'r/'67*'.5,-<6*)'+/'3*2',5)*'2(6(8'*(.7'.(/*'+/'.5,-()*2'A+67'67*'X45A4'5<6.5,*?'N3'+6'2+3*)/8'('.5)*.6+54'+/'.(0.<0(6*2'(42'(--0+*2'65'67*'452*/'+4'67*'7+22*4'-)5.*/+4;'0(1*)?'L7*/*'/6*-/'()*')*-*(6*2'<46+0'('.542+6+548'/<.7'(/'.5)*.6+54/' @ * + 4 ;'0*/'67(4'('.*)6(+4'(,5<468'+/')*(.7*2?'L7*''4*<)(0'4*6A5)X'+4':+;<)*'=>?=='7(/'0*()4*2'75A'65'+2*46+31'('3)(<2<0*46'.)*2+6'.()2'-

Page 65: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

<).7(/*?'

stuvwx_yz{yz_|}~~ �€�‚ƒ„…€†‚‡€ˆ‰Š‹‰‡Œ�}‡‰€Ž‚ ��‡‚�‘’“”•“•–“—˜’™š”›œ�žŸ™  �˜”› —”Ÿ’“”™�šœŸ”ž¡¢“£”¤Ÿ“•š“—¡Ÿœ—“¥”¡—“”™ �”Ÿ’“”¢ ¦™ž” ›”Ÿ’“”Ÿ’“—• ˜Ÿ¡Ÿ”Ÿ ”ž  �Ÿ— ¢”Ÿ’“”—  •”Ÿ“•š“—¡Ÿœ—“§”¨“•–“—˜’™š”›œ�žŸ™  �˜”’“¢š”Ÿ—¡�˜¢¡Ÿ“”¢™�¦œ™˜Ÿ™ž”“©š—“˜˜™  �˜ª”˜œž’”¡˜”«¡—•ª”™ �Ÿ ”�œ•–“—˜”Ÿ’¡Ÿ”Ÿ’“”ž •šœŸ“—”ž¡ �”•¡�™šœ¢¡Ÿ“§

Page 66: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

defghiFjkljjF mnopqprstuqvp rswonuxpynuxz{|}~ �€ �‚|}~ƒ„…€†| �‡~‡|€ �‚~‡|ˆƒ|‰‚~ �€}‡Š|‹€…Œ|��ƒ~€}‡|ˆ}|Ž�ƒ�|ƒ…|�…}‡ƒ€ ��ƒ| �| �ˆŽŽ~}|‚ �‘~€|…‹|‚…’ˆ�“|” �~| �ˆŽŽ~}|‚ �‘~€|ƒ�~}| �€…�~‡‡~‡|ˆ} ��ƒ‡•|�‚ �‡‡ˆ‹‘ˆ}’|ƒ�~Œ|– �‡~Ž|…}|ƒ�~|~—�~€ˆ~}�~|…‹|ƒ�~| Œ…Ž~‚“|˜}|ƒ�ˆ‡|~—�Œ �‚~•| ƒ�~|}~ �€ �‚|}~ƒ„…€†| ��‡|–~~}|ƒ€ �ˆ}~Ž|ƒ…|Žˆ‡ƒˆ}™’ �ˆ‡�|–~ƒ„~~}|š �‚ˆŽ| �}Ž|‹€ ��Ž�‚~}ƒ| �€~Žˆƒ| ��€Ž|��€ ���‡~‡“

! "# $%&'()('% '!*$& '!+, $- .&' /! +$&('!0 /1 !23 ('% +4!5 + &$%! &5 *'+ " 0&+& &'0 & ,('% +4!5 + 0( . 6!$ +4! 3&+!$' &'0 $! &+( ' 4(3 (' +4! 0&+&784!$!& !23!$+ 1 +!5 !!- + !5* &+! $ 5

Page 67: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

Page 68: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

/*1('% 3&+!$' " .&$04 0!$ 7<4!$! &$! 5&'1 3*)) ('% & 3!.+ " '!*$& '!+, $- 7 ?' (-! !23!$+ 1 +!5 ,4(.4 +13(.& 1 3$ 6(0! !23 &'&+( ' " $ +4!($ *+( ' '!*$& '!+, $- .&'' + & ,&1 !23 &(' ,41 +4!1 &$(6!0 &+ & 3&$+(.* &$ *+( '7 <4!1 5&1 ' + 3!$" $5 ,! (" +4!($ +$&('('% . 6!$ + (+ ! $ + 5*.4 0&+&7 :' 5 + .*$!'+ &33 (.&+( ' '!*$& '!+, $- &$! /! + * !0 & &(0 + 4*5&' 0!.( ( ' 5&-!$ (' +!&0 " */ +(+*+! " $ +4!57

@ A B A C D E F G H @ I J D C K L M NOPOQRSTUVWXYRQZ[\ &$! * !"* " $ "('0('% +4! 3+(5& *+( ' " $ & 3!.("(. 3$ / !5 /1 !2&5('('% & 6!$1 &$%! '*5/!$ " & +!$'&+(6! *+( ' " $ +4&+ 3$ / !57 <4!1 &$! /& !0 ' +!.4'(=*! (' 3($!0 /1 !6 *+( '&$1 /( %1 *.4 & ('4!$(+&'.! 5*+&+( ' ! !.+( ' &'0 .$ 6!$ ]$!. 5/('&+( '^7 %!'!+(. & % $(+45 , $- /1 $!3$! !'+('% & *+( ' & & +$('% " _ &'0 ` 7 <4! %!'!+(.

& % $(+45 !&$.4! & 3 3* &+( ' " $&'0 5 1 %!'!$&+!0 +$('% " /('&$1 0(%(+ + (0!'+("1 +4! $(%4+ +$('% $!3$! !'+('% +4! /! + 3 (/ ! *+( ' " $ +4! 3$ / !57 *+( ' & +!$ &'0 . 5/('! +4! , $ + '! &$! 0( .&$0!0 &'0 +4! /!+!$ '! *$6(6! + % ' + 3$ 0*.! !6!' /!+!$ *+( ' 7

Page 69: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

:' a(%*$! `_7`b !&.4 +$('% . $! 3 '0 + '! " +4! 6&$(&/ ! (' +4! 3$ / !57 c'!

&33 (! & +! + " $ "(+'! $&'-('% +4! +$('% (' +4! 3 3* &+( ' &.. $0('% + +4!($ !6! " 0! ($&/( (+1 & 3 (/ ! *+( ' 7 "+!$ +4! ('(+(& 3 3* &+( ' ( !6& *&+!0 " $ "(+'! +4! & % $(+45 +4!' 3$ 0*.! +4! '!2+ %!'!$&+( ' " +$('% . ' ( +('% " +$('% +4&+ *$6(6!0 +4! "(+'! +! + 3 * " 3$('% +$('% 3$ 0*.!0 "$ 5 5&+('% 3&($ " +$('% &'0 +! + +4!($ "(+'! 7 <4! 3$ .! . '+('*! *'+( & *+( ' ( $!&.4!07

Page 70: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

abcdefHghigjHklmnopqrpsmstunpvnwnxmsmtyzn{|}p~ytlq�€�‚ƒ„…†‡ˆ‰„ƒ �‰Š‚‹Œ†‹„‚ƒ†�ƒ ���‹ �†‰ƒˆŽˆŠ‰†‹ �Ž �ƒŽƒ� �‘€ŒŽ‡Ž‚Ž‡„‚’“ƒ„†‘€ƒŒ„ˆŒ„‚„�‹ ��”ƒ†ƒ• ��„Œ„ �‹ƒ‚Ž‰Š–‹ �Ž �—ƒ�€„ƒ”„ �„‹ �‘ƒ†‰”ŽŒ �‹€‡ƒŠ‚„‚ƒ†�ƒ �‹„Œ†‹ �˜„ƒˆŒŽ‘„‚‚ƒ‹ŽƒŒ„ ���„ƒ‹€„ƒ ���‹ �†‰ƒ‚Ž‰Š‹ �Ž �‚ƒ‚Žƒ‹€†‹ƒ‹€„ƒ™„‹„ŒƒŽ �„‚’ƒ‹€Ž‚„ƒš �‹€ƒ‹€„ƒ€ �”€„Œƒ� �‹ �„‚‚’ƒ†Œ„ƒ‡ŽŒ„ƒ‰�›„‰œƒ‹Žƒ„‡„Œ”„ƒ†‚ƒ‹€„ƒ™„‚‹ƒ‚Ž‰Š‹ �Ž �—

!"#$%&'(! )*+#$( #,+ -# '#+'%. #"'*/% 0#/('1% *+# )$ #$( #. (2#-2 $*!"#$ -#"'*/% 03#! .'%.! &#), -( -+#'(# )',+$ -+#'4#.$(!$1% +#'(#4'(*,%$+5#6) #/('1% *#*,+ #1 #' #7) ( # ) # ($ & #'4#/'+!1% #+'%, !' +#"$ #1 #( /( + -#& !"$%2#$ -#"(! (!$#"$ #1 # + $1%!+) -#4'(# .$%,$ ! &#4! +5# !"#$%&'(! )*+# 0/ -! # ) #+'%, !' #1 "$,+ # ) 2#"$ #

Page 71: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

Page 72: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

! &#=, 9# A*$!%3#+") -,%! &#$//'! * +3#'(#4! -! &# ) #") $/ + #$!(4$( # '#W$%!4'( !$56) ( #$( #*$ 2#! %!& #$& #$//%!"$ !' +# '-$2#! #'/ ($ ! &#+2+ *+3#$//%!"$ !' #

+'4 7$( 3# A*$!%#+2+ *+3#*'1!% #"'*/, ! &#+'4 7$( 3#$ -# 7'(9# ''%+5#X4#+/ "!$%#! ( + # '#1,+! +#$( #! %!& #$& +# )$ #+ $(")#4'(#! 4'(*$ !' #' # ) #K ( 5#W)$/ (#Y#- +"(!1 +#)'7#+)'//! &#1' +#) %/#"' +,* (+#4! -#/('-," +# ) 2#7$ #$ -#$+!+ +# ) *#! # "'*/$(! &#/(!" +#$ -#' ) (#4 $ ,( +5

Z('" (#[# $*1% #\Z[ ]#,+ -#! %!& #$& # ") '%'&2# '#*$9 #! +#+,//%2#")$! #

*'( # 4!"! #\+ #:!&,( #>?5>^]5#K #*'- % -#$#"'*/% 0#+,//%2#")$! #$+#$#&(',/#'4#+ *!$,A ' '*',+#_$& +`#( /( + ! &#! -!.!-,$%#+,//%2#")$! #"'*/' +3#+,")#$+# (,"9+3#/('A-," !' #4$"!%! ! +3#-!+ (!1, '(+3#$ -#( $!%#+ '( +5#6) #1 )$.!'(#'4# $")#$& #!+#/('&($** -# '#4'%'7#(,% +# )$ #*!*!"#$" ,$%#1 )$.!'(3#+,")#$+#_'(- (#$ #! *#7) #! #!+#', #'4#+ '"95`#

Page 73: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

sa`t\XSOPQOuvwxyz{|ywx}~|ywx �}{w}€�‚ƒ�}„…††z‡}ˆ‰Š{w}‹yxŒ �Ž ��‘’“”•–“‘’—˜–“‘’™—˜š“—›“”œ•‘–—�šžŸ’“š— —¡˜¢£”“—™›žš’“‘—’›“—š“œ”“‘•™›¢“‘’—Ÿ¤Ÿ”“™—¥žš—œšž¦§Ÿ’™¨—™§Ÿ›—˜™—˜—£ž©—ž¥—ª•¦“«

! "#$% $ #&%!'(% &(#!$%(# ) (%!'(%*" + #,%!"%+(-."- %/' !0 .% # ,$($%"#% #1(#!"-,% (1( $2% #0$!"-(%$!"*3" !$2% #4%!- #$+"-! ! "#%*"$!$56$ #&% #!( &(#!% &(#!% "4( $2%789%4 $*"1(-(4%!' !%!- *3$%$'" 4%".!(#%)(%4 $+ !*'(4%)(."-(%)( #&%. ,% " 4(45%: !'" &'%!- #$+"-! ! "#%*"$!$%/" 4%)(%' &'(-% $ #&%+ -! ,% " 4(4%!- *3$2%!'(%$ ! "#%$'"/(4%!' !%-(! %$!"-(%$!"*3" !$%/" 4%"** -% ($%".!(#2%!' $%

Page 74: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

-(4 * #&%!'(% " #!%".% "$!%$ ($2%/' *'%/" 4% "-(%!' #% 3(% +%."-%!'(%' &'(-%4 $!- ) 0! "#%*"$!$5%:&(#!0) $(4% "4( #&%' $%$ 1(4%789%;<==% "#% ## ,%"#% #% #1($! (#!%".% ($%!' #%>%+(-*(#!%".%!' !% " #!5: !'" &'% -! . * % #!( &(#*(%!(*'#" "&,%+ ,$% #% +"-! #!%-" (% #%*"#!( +"- -,%

3#"/ (4&(% # &( (#!2% !%$! %4"($%#"!%(?' ) !%!'(%)-( 4!'2%*" + (? !,2% #4%"- & # !,%".%' #% #!( &(#*(5%@" + !(-%$* (#! $!$% #4%#( -" "& $!$% 3(%' 1(%*" (%!"%-( A(%'"/%$"+' $! * !(4%" -%)- #$% *! ,% -(2% #4%'"/%*" + * !(4%*(-! #%! $3$% 3(%-(*"&# A #&% #& &(2% 4(#! ., #&%")B(*!$2% #4% 3 #&% #."- (4%4(* $ "#$%* #%)(%."-%*" + !(-$5 " 1 #&%/' !C$%3#"/#%

$%!'(%D7 - $%E !"#%+-") ( FG4(!(- # #&%/'(!'(-%!'(%+'- $(% D7 - $%E !"#F%-(.(-$%!"%!'(%*( ()- !,%$"* !(%"-% %'"!( % #%7 - $G' $%)((#%"#(%".%!'(%%!" &'($!%+-") ( $%."-%4(1( "+(-$%".%:H%$,$!( $5%E #%)( #&$%$" 1(% ) & ! ($% 3(%!' $% $ #&%*"#!(?!2%) !%*" + !(-$%4"#C!%' 1(%!' !%"+! "#5%I'(%H#!(- *! 1(% ($ "#%"#%I(*'#" "&,%$'"/$%'"/%HJK%$* (#! $!$% "1(4%* "$(-%!"% %$" ! "#%/ !'% %*" + !(-

Page 75: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

%# (4%L !$"#%) !%!"%+ ,%!'(%+"+ -%& (%$'"/%M("+ -4,N%

OPQRSTUVWXYVSZ[\S]^_^`a_`Sb_[cdXe`X ,$!( $%."-%3#"/ (4&(% # &( (#!% +-"1(%!'(%f !,% #4% ! A ! "#%".%3#"/ (4&(% $(4% #%!'(%4(* $ "#0 3 #&%+-"*($5%ghijklmnlopqhqnlplhr%-(.(-$%!"%!'(%$(!%".%) $ #($$%+-"*($$($%4(1( "+(4% #% #%"-& # A ! "#%!"%*-( !(2%$!"-(2%!- #$.(-2% #4% ++ ,%3#"/ (4&(5%

Page 76: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"#$ %! &!&& ' ( !$) '*'+, -./0 123045( $25 $467839:0 "97;2<9 )86250=>? @ A B C D E F D G @ H I J J K @ F ?@> L M @ N O P Q E R B D @? F P B S @ T F R U O ?@ R O O V @ O ? @ R W B @ R X O @ P O U R Y S B N O D F R B S @ N W F P Q Z O ? U @ O [ @ R W B @\ F P B @ U W O X @] B OQ F D S G K @ ̂ B ?@]B??Z?\ U @ F ? S @ L D F S @ _ E RBD`@ TFRUO? K @ X W Z N W @ X F U @? F P B S @ F [RBD@>LMaU@[OE?SBDK@ bWOPFU@] ̀ @ T F R U O ? K @ X O ? @ W F ?SZcG`

TFRUO? a U @ F N W Z B d B P B ? R @ D B Q D B U B ? R U @ F @ P Z c B U R O ? B @ Z ? @ R W B @ F C Z c Z R G @ O [ @ N O P Q E R B D U @ R O @ Q D O N B U @ F ? S @ Z ? R B D Q D B R @ W E P F ?@ cF?\EF\B ̀ @ b W B @\ O F c @ O [ @ R W B @> L M @ R B F P K @ F @\ D O E Q @ O [ @ H e @ D B U B F D N W B D U @ c B S @ C G @ f D ̀ @ f F d Z S @ A B D E N N Z K @ X F U @ R O @ S B d B c O Q @ F @ P O D B @ B [ B N R Z d B @ U B R @ O [ @ R B N W ? Z g E B U @ R W F R @ N O P Q E R B D U @ N F ?@ E U B @ R O @ Q D O N B U U @ h ? F R E D F c @ c F ?\EF\BijcF?\EF\ B @ R W F R @ WEPF? @ C B Z ?\ U @ Z ?URZ? N R Z d B c G @ E U B K @? O R @ c F ?\EF\ B @ U Q B N Z F cG@@[ODPFR B S @ R O @ C B @ E ? S B D U R O O S @ C G @ N O P Q E R B D U ̀ @ T F R U O ? @ W F S @ RO@\O@[ F D @ C B G O ? S @ D B U Q O ?SZ?\ @ R O @ U Z P Q c B @ N O P P F ?SUK@ O D @ D B N B Z d Z ?\ @ O ? c G @ U Q B N Z [ Z N K @ Q D B Y S B [Z? B S @ Z ?QERU`@]BOQFDSG@gEBURZO? U@FDB@DB?OX?BS@[OD@RWBZD@XODSQc

FGK@@ W Z SS B ? @ P B F ?Z?\ U K @ F ? S @ R D Z N V G @ Q E ? U K @ F ? S @ N F ? @ S B F c @ XZRW@ Q D F N R Z N F c G @ F ? G @ U E C k B N R @ P F RBD ̀ @ A O D @ N O P Q E R B D U K @@ c F ?\EF\

B @ Q D O N B UZ?\ @ S O B U ?aR@\ B R @ P E N W @ W F D S B D ` TFRUO? a U @ Q B D [ODPF? N B @ O ? @ R W B @ U W O X @ X F U @[FD@[DOP@

QBD[BNR ̀ @ b W B @ N O P Q E R B D @ C c E ? S B D B S @ O ? @ F @ A Z ?Fc@]BOQFDSG@ gEBURZO? @ X Z R W @ R W B @ N F R B \ O D G @ h l `m ̀ @ n Z R Z B U K i @ X W B D B @ Z R @ U B c B N R B S @ b O D O ? R O @ F U @ Z R U @ D B U Q O ?UB ̀ @ m O P B R Z P B U K @ R W B @ F? U X B D U @ Z ? @ F @ N F R B \ O D G @ S O @? O R @ S Z D B N R c G @ N O DBUQO? S @ X Z R W @ R W B @ R Z R c B @ O [ @ R W B @ N F R B \ O D G K @ U O @ T F R U O ? @ S Z S ? a R @ F U E P B K @ F U @ R W B @ WEPF? @ Q c F G B D U @ S Z S K @ R W F R @ R W B @ F ? U X B D @ W F S @ R O @ C B @ F @ N Z R G @ Z ?@ R W B @ l ? Z R B S @ m R F R B U ̀ @ o B d B D R W B c B U K @ T F R U O ? @ O d B D N F P B @ R W F R @ [ c E C @ R O @ X Z ? @ N O ?dZ?NZ?\cGK@[Z?ZUWZ?\ @ X Z R W @ O d B D @ p q q K II I @ R O @ F C O E R @ p H I K II I @ F Q Z B N B @[ O D @ Z R U @ W E P F ? @ O Q Q O ?B?RU`

b W B @ W F D S X F D B @ D B g E Z D B S @[ O D @ T F R U O ? @ R O @ X O D V @ U O @ g E Z N V c G @ F ?

Page 77: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

S @ F N N E D F R B c G @ X F U @ U R F \\BDZ?\ c G @ Q O X B D [Ec`@ TFRUO? @ N O ? U Z U R U @ O [ @ J I @ D F N V U @ O [@> L M @ r s T t _ @ q e I @ U B D d B D U @ DE??Z?\ @ u Z ? E v K @ E U B U @ J e @ R B D F C G R B U @ O [ @ _ w M @ F ? S @ H K x x I @ QDONBU O D @ N O D B U @ y B g E Z d F c B ? R @ R O @ z K II I @ R O Q Y B ? S @ W O P B @ N O P Y QERBDU{ K @ F ? S @ O Q B D F R B U @ F R @ x I @ R B D F[cOQU ̀ @ T F R U O ?@? B B S B S @ R W Z U @ FPOE? R @ O [ @ Q O X B D @ R O @ g E Z N V c G @ U N F ? @ Z R U @ B ? O D P O E U @ S F R F C F U B @ O[ @ Z ?[ODPFRZO? K @ Z ?NcESZ?\@ Z ?[ODPFRZO?@[ D O P @ R W B @>?RBD?BR`@ b W B @ R B F P @ S O X ? c O F S B S @ O d B D @ J I @ P Z cZO? @ S O N E P B ?RUK@ Z?NcESZ?\ @ B ? N G N c O Q B S Z F U @ F ? S @ T Z V Z Q B S Z F K @ R W B @>?RBD?BR@ M O d Z B @ f F R F C F U B @ y >MfL{ K @ F ? S @ R W B @ B ? R Z D B @ F D N W Z d B @ O [ @ R W B @|}~�€ �‚ƒ�„…†}‡ ̀ @ w c @ O [ @ R W B @ S F R F @ U F R @ Z ? @ T F R U O ? a U @ Q D Z P F D G @ P B P O D G K @ F U @ O Q Q O U B S @ R O @ F @ P E N W @ U c O X B D @ W F D S @ S D Z d B K @ U O @ R W F R @ T F R U O ? @ N O E c S @[Z? S @ R W B @ S F R F @ Z R @? BB S B S @ X Z R W Z ? @ R W D B B @ UBNO?SU ̀ @ b W B @ T F R U O ? @ Q D O k B N R @ R O O V @ H I @> L M @ B ?\Z?BBDU@ R W D B B @ G B F D U @ R O @ C E Z c S @ F R @ F ? @ p J x @ P Z cZO? @ c F C O D @ N O U R K @ F ? S @ F ?@ B U R Z P F R B S @ p J @ P Z cZO? @ Z ? @ B g E Z Q P B ?R`@

TFRUO? @ Z U @ F C c B @ R O @ c B F D ?@[ D O P @ Z R U @ P Z U R F V B U @ F U @ X B c@ F U @ Z R U @ U E NN B UBU ̀ @ b O @ U O c d B @ F @ R G Q Z N F c @ Q D O C c B P K @ T F R U O ?@ R D Z B U @ P F ?

G @ O [ @ R W B @ R W O E U F ? S U @ O [ @ F c \ O D Z R W P U @ R W F R @ R W B @ R B F P @ W F U @ Q D O \ D F P P B S @ Z R @ R O @ E U B ̀ @ b W B @ F c \ O D Z R W P U @ B d F c E Y F R B @ R W B @ c F ?\EF\ B @ E U B S @ Z ? @ B F N W @ N c E B K @\ F R W B D @ Z ?[ODPFRZO?@ F C O E R @ R W B @ Z P Q O D R F ? R @ Q B O Q c B @ F ? S @ Q c F N B U @ P B ?RZO? B S @ Z ?@

Page 78: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

R W B @ N c E B K @ F ?S@\B? B D F R B @ W E ? S D B S U @ O [ @ U O c E R Z O ?U`@ˆEPF?@ CBZ?\ U @ S O ?aR@? BB S @ R O @ R F V B @ U E N W @ F @[ O D P F c @ F QQ D O F N W @ RO@\B? B D F R B @ R W B @ U O c E R Z O ? U @ R W F R @[ Z R @ F @ g E B U R Z O ? @ C B U R K @ C E R @ TFRUO?@ N O P Q B ?UFRBU@[ O D @ R W Z U @ X Z R W @ U E Q B D Z O D @ N O P Q E R Z ?\@ Q O X B D @ F ? S @ U Q B B S `@>[ @ F @ N B D R F Z ? @ F c \ O D Z R W P @ X O D V U @ R O @ U O c d B @ F @ Q D O C c B P K @ T F R U O ? @ D B P B P C B D U @ X W F R @ R G Q B @ O [ @ g E B U R Z O ? @ Z R @ X F U @ F ? S @ R W B @ F c \ O D Z R W P @ Z R @ E U B S @ R O @\ B R @ R W B @ D Z \ W R @ F ?UXBD`@>? @ R W Z U @ X F G K @ T F R U O ? @ Z P Q D O d B U @ F R @ F ?UXBDZ?\ @ g E B U R Z O ?U@ O d B D @ R Z P B ̀ @ T F R U O ? @ F c U O @ c B F D ? U @ F ? O R W B D @ X F G j R W B @ R B F P @\ F d B @ T F R U O ? @ R W O E U F ? S U @ O [ @ O c S @] B OQ F D S G @ g E B U R Z O ? U @ R O @ QDONBU ̀ @ T F R U O ? @ F ?FcG‰ B S @ C O R W @ g E B U R Z O ? U @ F ? S @ F ?UXBDU@ R O @ S B R B D P Z ? B @ Q F RBD? U @ O D @ U Z P Z c F D Z R Z B U @ C B R X B B ? @ N c E B U K @ F? S @ E U Z ?\ @ R W B U B @ Q F RBD? U K @ Z R @ F UZ\? U @ d F D G Z ?\ @ S B \ D B B U @ O [@ NO?[ZSB? N B @ R O @ R W B @ F ? U X B D U @ Z R @\ZdBU`

TFRUO? @ X F U @ F C c B @ R O @ N O D B N R c G @ F ? U X B D @ O ? c G @ F @ UPFc@[DFNRZO? @ O [ @ R W B @ g E B U R Z O ? U @ Z R @ X F U @\ZdB? @ F R @[ZDURK@ C E R @ P F N W Z ? B @ c B F D ?Z?\ @ F c O X B S @ T F R U O ? @ R O @ N O ?RZ?EB@@ Z P Q D O d Z ?\K@[ZDUR@\DOXZ?\ @ N c O U B D @ R O @] B O Q F D S G @ N O?RBURF?R@ c B d B c K @ F ? S @ R W B ?@[Z?Fc G @ D B F N W Z ?\

@ R W B @] B O Q F D S G @ N W F P Q Z O?@ c B d B c @ O [@]B??Z?\ U @ F ? S @ _ E RBD ̀ @ m Z P Z c F D @ P F N W Z ? B @ c B F D ?Z?\@ RBNW? Z g E B U @ F D B @ E U B S @ Z ? @ N O P Q E R B D @ P O S B c U @ R W F R @ Q D B S Z N R @ X B F R W B D K @ c Z V B U @ F ? S @ S Z U c Z V B U @[ D O P @ O ?cZ? B @ D B R F Z c B D U @ c Z V B @ wPF‰O? ̀ N O P K @ F ? S @ U Q B B N W @ D B N O \?ZRZO? @ R O @ S B d B c O Q @ P O D B @ F N N E D F R B @ Q D B S Z N R Z O ? U K @ D B N O P P B ?SFRZO? U K @ F ? S @ U Q BB N W @ QDONBUZ?\`

>LM@CBcZBdBU@[ERED B@FQQcZNFRZO?U@[OD@TFRUO?@FDB@

? E P B D O E U @ F ? S @ X Z S B Y D F ?\Z?\ @ Z ? @ P B S Z N Z ?BK@[Z?F?NZFc@ U B D d Z N B U K @ O D @ F ? G @ Z ? S E U R D G @ X W B D B @ U Z [RZ?\ @ R W D O E \ W @ c F D \B@ FPOE? R U @ O [ @ S F R F @ R O @ F ? U X B D @ g E B U R Z O ? U @ Z U @ Z P Q O D R F ?R`@>?@ m B Q R B P C B D @ H I J J K @ W B F c R W @ Z ? U E D B D @ T B crOZ?R@>?N ̀ K @ X Z R W @ Š‹ ̀ H @ P Z cZO? @ P B P C B D U K @ B ? c Z U R B S @ T F R U O ? @ R O @ W B c Q @ Z R @ N W O O U B @ F P O ?\ @ R D B F R P B ? R @ OQ R Z O ? U @ F ? S @ P B S Z N Z ?BU ̀ @ b W B @ TBcrOZ? R @ F Q Q c Z N F R Z O ? @ X Z c @ N O P C Z ? B @ S F R F @[ D O P @ R W D B B @ U O E D N B U Œ @ F @ Q F R Z B ? R a U @ N W F D R @ F ? S @ B c B N R D O ? Z N @ D B N O D S U @ P F Z ?Y RFZ? B S @ C G @ F @ Q W G U Z N Z F ? @ O D @ W O U Q Z R F c K @ R W B @ Z ?UEDF? N B @ N O P Q F Y ? G a U @ W Z U R O D G @ O [ @ P B S Z N Z ? B U @ F ? S @ R D B F R P B ?

Page 79: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

R U K @ F ? S @ T F R U O ?aU@ WE\ B @ c Z C D F D G @ O [ @ R B v R C O O V U @ F ? S @ P B S Z N F c @ k O E D ?FcU ̀ @ T F R U O ?@ U W O E c S @ C B @ F C c B @ R O @ Q D O N B U @ F c @ O [ @ R W B @ S F R F @ F ? S @ F ?UXBD@ F @ g E B U R Z O ? @ Z ? @ P O P B ? R U K @ Q D O d Z S Z ?\ @ U B d B D F c @ Q O U U Z C c B @@ S Z F \? O U B U @ O D @ R D B F R P B ? R U K @ D F ? V B S @ Z ? @ O D S B D @ O [ @ R W B @ N O P Y QERBDaU@ N O ?[ZSB? N B K @ F c O ?\ @ X Z R W @ R W B @ C F U Z U @[ O D @ Z R U @ F ?UXBD`@

> R a U @ E ? N c B F D @ W O X @ B [ B N R Z d B @ T F R U O ? @ X Z c @ F N R E F cG@ C B @ Z ? @ R W Z U @[ Z B c S K @ X W B D B @ R W B @ Z ?[ODPFRZO? @ F d F Z c F C c B @ Z ?@ P B S Z N F c @ k O E D ? F c U @ F ? S @ O R W B D @ U O E D N B U @ Z U @ W Z \ W c G @ S Z U O D Y \F?Z‰ B S K @ O [RB? @ N O ? R D F S Z N R O D G K @ F ? S @ c Z R B D B S @ X Z R W @ R G Q O U @ F?S@ Z ?NO?UZURB?R@?FPZ?\ @ N O ?dB?RZO?U ̀ @ T W B ? @ W E P F ?@@ S O N R O D U @ F Q Q c G @ R W B Z D @ E?SBDURF?SZ?\ @ O [ @ S Z U B F U B @ R O @ O E D @ C O S Z B U K @ Z R @ Z U @ C F U B S @ O ? @ V ?OXcBS\ B @ O [ @ R W B @ c Z R B D F R E D B K @ C E R @ F c U O @ C F U B S @ O ? @ Q D Z O D @ B v Q B D Z B ? N B @ F ?S@\OOS@\EBUBU`@ bWBDBaU@?O@\EFDF? R B B @ R W F R @ T F R U O ? @ N F ? @ O d B D N O P B @ R W B U B @ O C U R F N c B U K @ C E R @ Z [ @ Z R @ N F ? K @ Z R @ N O E c S @ S D F P F R Z N F c G @ Z ?NDBFUB@ B[ZNZB? N G @ F ? S @ F N N E D F N G @ O [ @ P B S Z N F c @ S Z F \?OUBU`@

Page 80: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

*+,) -<)!+1('(,4!, !"$ 0#))!-+,&$+'!'+-3&+3#!

+' )!(,!, !"#$% $8!8+-4!J 1)!$#7&($(-3!%+0,&+'!>- '#63#!+-6!#E"#$,()#5!I 1)!,2+,!(-? '?#!+-) #$(-3!7&#),( -)! $!0 -6&0,(-3!,$+-)+0,( -)! -!,2#!,#'#"2 -#!+$#!'(>#'4!0+-6(6+,#)!% $!$#"'+0#8#-,5!*2('#!2&-6$#6)! %!,2 &)+-6)! %!"# "'#! 2 !"#$% $8!,2#)#!J 1)!0 &'6!1#!&-#8"' 4#6K!8+-4!1&)(-#)#)!0 &'6!&)#!*+,) -<)!,#02- ' 34!, !(-0$#+)#!#%(0(#-04!+-6!(8"$ ?#!,2#($!1 , 8!'(-#)5!

B&,!6 #)!*+,) -!$#+'4!&-6#$),+-6!'+-3&+3#! $!,2#!+-) #$)!(,<)!3(?(-3.!L>#",(0)! %!+$,(%(0(+'!(-,#'(M3#-0#!(-)(),!,2+,!(,!6 #)-<,5!G2#!ABC!

$#)#+$02#$)! 2 !6#)(3-#6!,2#!)4),#8!6 -<,!6()+3$##5!B&,!, !,2#!ABC!,#+8K!,2+,<)!'#)!(8" $,+-,!,2+-!,2#!%+0,!,2+,!*+,) -!0+-!#?#-!+-) #$!7&#),( -)!0 $#0,'4!+)!%$#7&#-,'4!+)!(,!6 #)5!

Page 81: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

N#,<)!+)>!*+,) -H!G+>#!+!),+1!+,!"$#6(0,(-3!4 &$!

%&,&$#!(8"+0,O!*+,) -!()!)('#-,! -!,2()!+-6! ,2#$!!, "(0)5!P)!(,!,&$-)! &,K!*+,) -! +)!- ,!"$ 3$+88#6!, !' >!(-, !,2#!%&,&$#K! $!, !2+?#!(-,#-,( -)K! 1J#0,(?#)K! $!%##'(-3)!+1 &,!,2#!#E"#$(#-0#! %!1#(-3!*+,) -5!

L &$0#)H!P--+!*('6#!C+,2# )K!:*#'" (-,<)!Q# ! ($#5!*2+,!A)!*+,) -.;!RSTU VWXYYWUZ[\X]STK!L#",#81#$!^_K!_`^^a!I 2-!C+$> %K!:P!b(32,!, !*(-!,2#!b&,&$#H! c 8"&,#$)!?)5!

&8+-)K;!dYeUf[XgUhijYkK!b#1$&+$4!^lK!_`^^a!I 2-!C+$> %K!:c 8"&,#$!*(-)! -!mI# "+$64O<H!G$(?(+'K!A,<)!Q ,K;!dYeUf[XgUhijYkK!b#1$&+$4!^nK!_`^^a!:ABC<)!*+,) -! #+6)!b$ 8!mI# "+$64O<!G !c '&81(+!o-(?#$)(,4! C#6(0+'!c#-,#$K;!cBLQ# p $>50 8K!b#1$&+$4!^qK!_`^^a!L,+-'#4!b()2K!:*2+,!/(6!*+,) -!,2#!c 8"&,#$!/ .;!dYeUf[XgUhijYkK!b#1$&+$4!_^K!_`^^a!c2+$'#)! B+10 0>K!:*+,) -<)!I# "+$64!*(-!+!F(0, $4!b $!C+->(-6K;!A-% $8+,( -*##>K! b#1$&+$4!_lK!_`^^a!r$#3!N(-6)+4K:c2+-3(-3!G2#!r+8#H!m !A!B#+,!*+,) -!+-6!c+8#!s&,!+!/(%#$#-,!t'+4#$;!+-6!L,#"2#-!B+>#$K!:G2#!t$ 3$+88#$<)!/('#88+H!B&('6(-3!+!I# "+$64O!c2+8"( -K;!C0u(-)#4!v&+$,#$'4K!b#1$&+$4!_`^^5

wxyz{y|}~ �{€}zy| �‚ƒy{ {„�y{ �ƒ{xw| �‚ƒ !" #$%&'!()!*+,) -.!/#)0$(1#!(,)!,#02- ' 345!*24!6 #)!(,!$#7&($#!) !8&02!" #$%&'!2+$6 +$#.

9 !:(-,#'(3#-,;!()!*+,) -.!*2+,!0+-!(,!6 .!*2+,!0+-<,!(,!6 .

= *2+,!>(-6)! %!"$ 1'#8)!()!*+,) -!

Page 82: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

+1'#!, !) '?#.@ / !4 &!,2(->!*+,) -! ('!1#!+)!&)#%&'!(-! ,2#$!6()0("'(-#)!+)!ABC!2 "#).!*('!(,!1#!1#-#%(0(+'!, !#?#$4 -#.!DE"'+(-!4 &$!+-) #$5!

F()(,!,2#!ABC!*#1!)(,#!+-6!)#+$02!% $!(-% $8+,( -! -!*+,) -5!G2#-!+-) #$!,2#!% ' (-3!7&#),( -)H *2(02!(-6&),$(#)! $!6()0("'(-#)!()!ABC!,+$3#,(-3! (,2!*+,) -.

9 *2+,!(8"$ ?#8#-,)!()!ABC!2 "(-3!, !8+>#!(-!*+,) -<)!1+)(0!%&-0,( -+'(,4.

= G$4!, !%(-6!?(6# ! %!*+,) -!"'+4(-3!I# "+$645!*2+,!>(-6)! %!7&#),( -)!6 #)!(,!3#,! $ -3.

u- '#63#!8+-+3#8#-,!(-0$#+)#)!,2#!+1('(,4! %!,2#! $3+-(…+,( -!, !'#+$-!%$ 8!(,)!#-?($ -M8#-,!+-6!, !(-0 $" $+,#!>- '#63#!(-, !(,)!1&)(-#)!"$ 0#)#)!+-6!6#0()( -!8+>(-35u- '#63#!,2+,!()!- ,!)2+$#6!+-6!+""'(#6!, !,2#!"$ 1'#8)!%+0(-3!%($8)!+-6!8+-+3#$)!

6 #)!- ,!+66!+-4!?+'&#!, !,2#!1&)(-#)5!u- (-3!2 !, !6 !,2(-3)!#%#0,(?#'4!+-6!#%(0(#-,'4! (-!

Page 83: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

+4)!,2+,! ,2#$! $3+-(…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

†‡ˆ†‰Š‰‹Œ†�Ž‹ �†�‘‡’Ž“†�”†�•–‡–”†•†‡ˆ�Œ—Œˆ†•Œb($8)!8&),!6#+'! (,2!+,!'#+),!,2$##!>(-6)! %!>- '#63#5!L 8#!>- '#63#!#E(),)! (,2(-!

Page 84: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

,2#!%($8!(-!,2#!% $8! %!),$&0,&$#6!,#E,!6 0&8#-,)!˜$#" $,)!+-6!"$#)#-,+,( -)™5!/#0()( -!8+>#$)!+') !-##6!>- '#63#!,2+,!()!)#8(),$&0,&$#6K!)&02!+)!#M8+('K!? (0#!8+('K!02+,!$ 8!#E02+-3#)K!?(6# )K!6(3(,+'!"(0,&$#)K!1$ 02&$#)K! $!1&'#,(-!1 +$6!" ),(-3)5!A-!),('! ,2#$!0+)#)K!,2#$#!()!- !% $8+'! $!6(3(,+'!(-% $8+,( -! %!+-4!>(-6K!+-6!,2#!>- '#63#!$#)(6#)!(-!,2#!2#+6)! %!#8"' 4##)5!C&02! %!,2()!>- '#63#!()!š›œš žŸ ¡¢£¤¥£!+-6!()!$+$#'4! $(,#-!6 -5

Page 85: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"!#$ %&#' () *&+ ', (-. ., - ($/$ -$012340567803407892207:;2<0=>0

0?@= 5 4 2 1 A 2 B 0 C @ 7 2 9 ;96<2D56120?@= 5 4 2 1 A 2 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 E 2 @ 7 0 <:<72E< 0 3 9 2 0 A 2 @ 2 9 3 4 D ;F9;=<2G0>69E56120<:<72E<078370H=42H7G0<7=92G016< 7 9 6 I F 7 2 G 0 3 @ 1 0 3 ;;4:016A67340H= @ 7 2 @ 7 0 3 @ 1 0 ?@=5421A2B0J82<20<:<D72E< 0 6 @ H 4 F 1 2 0 H 3 ;3I646762<0>=90< 2 3 9 H 8 6 @ A 0 >=906@>=9E376= @ G 0 <7= 9 6 @ A 0 I =780< 7 9 F H 7 F 9 2 1 0 3 @ 1 0 F @<79FHD7 F 9 2 1 0 1 3 7 3 G 0 3 @ 1 0 4 = H 3 76 @ A 0 2 E ;4=:2202K;2976< 2 0 5 6 7 8 6 @ 0 7 8 2 0 >69EB0J82:034<= 0 6 @ H 4 F 1 2 0 <F;;= 9 76 @ A 0 72H8@=4=A62<0<FH803<0;=9734<G0< 2 3 9 H 8 0 2 @ A 6 @ 2 <G0H=43I=9376= @ 0 7 ==4< G 0 3 @ 1 0 4 2 3 9 @ 6 @ A 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 E 2 @ 7 0 <:<72E<B

LMNOPQPRSOTUVMNOMNTWXMXYOZOMNT[\SNOZS]F< 6 @ 2 <2<07=1 3 : 0 @ 2 2 1 0 7 =0= 9 A 3 @ 6 ̂ 2 0 3 @ 1 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 0 I =780< 7 9 F H 7 F 9 2 1 0 3 @ 1 0 <2E6<79FH7F9210?@=5421A203<27<B0_ !`a `! '() *&+ ', 06<02K;46H670?@=5421A20783702K6<7< 0 6 @ 0 >=9E3401= H F E 2 @ 7 <G03<052403< 0 6 @ 0 >=9E3409F42<078370= 9 A 3 @ 6 ̂ 3 7 6 =@<01296b20I:0=I< 2 9 b 6 @ A 0 2 K ;297< 0 3 @ 1 0 7 8 2 6 9 0 1 2 H 6 <6= @ D E 3 ? 6 @ A 0 I283b6=9<B0]F7G03HH= 9 1 6 @ A 0 7 =02K;297<G0370423<70cd0; 2 9 H 2 @ 7 0 =>03@0= 9 A 3 @ 6 ̂ 3 7 6 = @ e <0IF< 6 @ 2 <0H= @ 7 2 @ 7 0 6<0<2E6<79FH7F9210=90F@<79FH7F921f6@>=9E376= @ 0 6 @ 0 >=4129<G0E2<3A2<G0E2E=<G0;9=;=<34<G02DE364<G0A93;86H<G0242H79= @ 6 H 0<46120;92< 2 @ 7 3 7 6 =@< G 0 3 @ 1 0 2 b 2 @ 0 b 6 1 2 =< 0 H 9 23 7 2 1 0 6 @ 0 1 6 > 2 9 2 @ 7 0>=9E37<03 @ 1 0 <7= 9 2 1 0 6 @ 0 E 3 @ : 0 4 =H376=@<B !"!#$ (a* (-. ., - ($/$ -$0824;0= 9 A 3 @ 6 ̂ 3 7 6 =@< 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 0 I =7807:;2<0=>0

6@>=9E376= @ B 0 J 8 2 : 0 8 3 b 2 0 H 3 ;3I64

Page 86: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

6762<0>=90?@=5421A20H3;7F92G0<7=93A2G0927962b34G016<796IF76= @ G 0 3 @ 1 0 ;92<29b376= @ 0 7 =0824;0>69E<06E;9=b20782690IF< 6 @ 2 <0;9=H2<2< 0 3 @ 1 0 1 2 H 6 <6=@<B0gFH80<:<72E<06 @ H 4 F1 2 0 H =9;=9372092;=<67=962<0=>01= H F E 2 @ 7 <G092;=97<G0;92< 2 @ 7 3 7 6 =@< G 0 3 @ 1 0 I 2 <70;93H76H2<G03<052403<0H3;3I646762<0>=90H=4 2 H 76 @ A 0 3 @ 1 0 = 9 A 3 @ 6 ̂ 6 @ A 0 <2E6<79FH7F9210?@=5421A20<FH803<02DE3640 h<220i6AF920jdBjklB0m3n= 9 0 2 @ 7 2 9 ;96<20H= @ 7 2 @ 7 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 E 2 @ 7 0 <:<72E<034<= 0 2 @ 3 I 4 2 0 F <29<07=03HH2<02 K 7 2 9 @ 3 4 0 <=F9H2<0=>06@>=9E376= @ G 0 <FH803< 0 @ 2 5 <0>221< 0 3 @ 1 0 9 2 < 2 3 9 H 8 G 0 3 @ 1 0 7 =0H= E E F @ 6 H 3 7 2 0 b 6 3 0 2DE364G0H837o6@< 7 3 @ 7 0 E 2 < 3 A 6 @ A G 0 1 6 <HF<6= @ 0 A 9 =F;< G 0 3 @ 1 0 b 6 1 2 =H=@> 2 9 2 @ H 6 @ A B p0?2:0;9= I 4 2 E 0 6 @ 0 E 3 @ 3 A 6 @ A 0 ?@=5421A206<07820H92376= @ 0 => 0 3 @ 0 3 ;;9=;963720H43<6>6H3D

76= @ 0 <H82E207=0= 9 A 3 @ 6 ̂ 2 0 6 @>=9E376= @ 0 6 @ 7 = 0 E 2 3 @ 6 @ A >F40H372A=962< B 0 q @ H 2 0 7 8 2 0 H 3 7 2 A =962<0>=900H43<6> : 6 @ A 0 ?@= 5 4 2 1 A 2 0 8 3 b 2 0 I 2 2 @ 0 H 9 23 7 2 1 G 0 23 H 8 0 ?@=5421A20= I n 2 H 7 0 @ 2 2 1 <07=0I20r73AA21Gs0=90H43<6>621G0<= 0 7 8 3 7 0 6 7 0 H 3 @ 0 I 2 0 2 3 < 6 4 : 0 9 2 7 9 6 2 b 2 1 B 0 C @ 7 2 9 ;96<20H= @ 7 2 @ 7 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 E 2 @ 7 0 <:<72E<083b20H3;3I646762<0>= 9 0 7 3 A A 6 @ A G 0 6 @ 7 2 9 > 3 H 6 @ A 0 5 6 7 8 0 H =9;=937201373I3<2<058292078201= H F E 2 @ 7 <03920<7= 9 2 1 G 0 3 @ 1 0 H 9 23 76 @ A 0 3 @ 0 2 @ 7 2 9 ;96<20;= 9 7 3 40 2 @ b 6 9 = @ E 2 @ 70 >=902E;4=:22<07=0F<20582@0< 2 3 9 H 8 6 @ A 0 >=90H=9;=93720?@=5421A2B0q; 2 @ 0 J 2 K 7 G 0 C m t 0 u = H F E 2 @ 7 F E G 0 v ] m G 0 3 @ 1 0 q 9 3 H 4 2 0 3 9 2 0 4 2 3 1 6 @ A 0 0 b 2 @ 1 =9<0=>0 2 @ 7 2 9 ;96<20H= @ 7 2 @ 7 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 E 2 @ 7 0 <=>75392B

Page 87: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

]396H?0w=41G078205=941e< 0 4 23 1 6 @ A 0 A= 410;9=1FH29G0F<2<0q; 2 @ 0 J 2 K 7 0 x 6 b 2 x 6 @? 0 C @ 7 2 9 ;96<20 t= @ 7 2 @ 7 0 m 3 @ 3 A 2 E 2 @ 7 0 7 ==4<07= 0 E 3 @ 3 A 2 0 7 8 2 0 E 3 <6b203E= F @ 7 <0=>06@>=9E376= @ 0 9 2 y F 6 9 2 1 0 >=90I F 6 4 1 6 @ A 0 E 6 @ 2 <B0J820<:<72E0= 9 A 3 @ 6 ̂ 2 < 0 3 @ 1 0 <7=92<0I=780< 7 9 F H 7 F 9 2 1 0 3 @ 1 0 F @<79FH7F9210H= @ 7 2 @ 7 G 0 6 @ H 4 F 1 6 @ A 0 H =E;F729D36121012< 6 A @ 0 h t p u l 0 1 9 3 5 6 @ A <G0H= @ 7 9 3 H 7 < G 0 2 @ A 6 @ 2 2 9 6 @ A 0 1 3 7 3 G 0 3 @ 1 0 ;9=D1FH76= @ 0 9 2 ;=97<B0v>03@0=;29376= @ 3 4 0 7 2 3 E 0 @ 2 2 1 <07=092>290I3H?07=07820= 9 6 A 6 @ 3 4 0 1 = H F E 2 @ 7 G 0 7 8 3 7 0

zRY{POT|}~|€�‚ƒ�„…†‡†ˆ‰…‚ Š‹ �„…�„‚ Œ���Ž…�…�„‚

�‘‰„…’“”•“–•—˜—

™š•”›œ“–•“–”�ž“žŸ•�•“–”š š–•�”

¡žš”›ž˜ž¢™£™–™•š”¤œ—”›£žš¥

š™¤ ™“Ÿ¦”œ—Ÿž“™§™“Ÿ¦”ž“¨”

�ž“žŸ™“Ÿ”š–—©›–©—•¨”

ž“¨”š• �™š–—©›–©—•¨”ª“œ«£•¨Ÿ•”ž“¨” �žª™“Ÿ”

™–”ž¬ž™£ž¢£•”–¡—œ©Ÿ¡œ©–”–¡•”

•“–•—˜—™š•

Page 88: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"#$%#$!#&#%$!'( # $'$"&(#) * %$" )+#&%# ** % #" #, $!'#% &" ) # - )# ("$*( #%+%." %/#0&)$ 12%# ( ") !$ # !" !"# &!&' !"#%+%" #) %#"3 #& !"# 4#"$ #) 5 $) # " #% &) 3#4 )# !"%6#%3 )" !$!'#*) 7 "#% 3 ( %6#$ *) -$!'#"3 #5 &($"+# 4# $%$ !%6#&! # $!$ $8$!'#) 9 )1#:;* !#< ="6#>?@@ A /

B$) %#$!#* ,($%3$!'6#& - )"$%$!'6#,) & &%"$!'6#&! # !" )"&$! !"#3&- #%* $&(#! %#

4 )#%" )$!'#&! # &!&'$!'# !%") " ) # $'$"&(# &"&#% 3#&%#*3 " ')&*3%6#')&*3$ #$ &' %6#-$ 6#&! #& $ # !" !"/#CDEDFGHIGJJKFILGMGEKLKMFIJNJFKLJ#3 (*#"3 # (&%$4+6#%" ) 6#&! # $%")$, " #"3 % # $'$"&(# ,7 "%/

OPQRSTUVTWXTYRQZ[W\]^YT_^`MabHKcEKIMKFbadeIJNJFKLJ6#&(% #1! 9!#&%#fghfijklfmnopqjkormqrsmtqrquftfrjmlvljftl6#& ) %#"3 #*) ,( #"3&"#&)$% %#93 !#"3 #&**) *)$&" #1! 9( ' #$%#! "#$!#"3 #4 ) # 4#&# $'$"&(# !"#, "#$!%" & #) %$ %#$!#"3 # )+# 4# =* )"#$! $-$ &(%#$!#"3 #4$) /#w! 9( ' #! "9 )1#%+%" %#*) -$ #&!# !($! # $) " )+# 4# )* )&" # =* )"%#$!#9 (. 4$! #1! 9( ' # &$!%#&! # % # !$ &"$ !#" 3! ( '$

Page 89: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

%#" # &1 #$"# &%+#4 )# *( + %#" #4$! #"3 ##&**) *)$&" # =* )"#$!#&# *&!+/#x #1! 9( ' #! "9 )1#%+%" %#' #4 )"3 )#,+#%+%" &"$8$!'# "3 #% ( "$ !%# - ( * #,+# =* )"%#&! #"3 !#%" )$!'#"3 #% ( "$ !%#$!#&#1! 9( ' # &"&,&% #&%#&#, %".*)& "$ %# )#4) 5 !"(+#&%1 #5 %"$ !%#:Byz%A#) * %$" )+#:% #B$' ) #@?/@{A/#|$- $! }%#y%1~ #*) -$ %#%"&! .&( ! #1! 9( ' #! "9 )1$!'# &*&,$($"$ %6#&! #% #1! 9( ' #! ".9 )1$!'# &*&,$($"$ %# &!#, #4 ! #$!#"3 #( & $!'# (&, )&"$ !#% 4"9&) #% $" %/

�QS€ �QZ€Y‚QPWƒQQS^W€PUW„T€ZP‚PVW…€P€VT_TPYW\]^YT_^† #3&- #&() & +# $% %% #"3 #) ( # 4# (&, )&"$ !#" (%#$!#$!4 ) &"$ !#%3&)$!'#&! ##" & 9 )1#$!#‡3&*" )%#>#&! #ˆ/#x $&(#, 1 &)1$!'#&! #( &)!$!'# &!&' !"#%+%" %##4 &" ) #& $"$ !&(# &*&,$($"$ %#4 )#%3&)$!'#&! # &!&'$!'#1! 9( ' /

‰‚VŠZTW‹Œ �‹Ž��‘’ �“”•–•—˜”‘™�š›œ”ž�”‘ Ÿ”“›š• 

Page 90: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

‘¡¢˜“”£¤¥¦§¨©ª«¬«¥§«®©¨¯¦¥°±²§®±²§³¥±¥¬±®±´±³«¥¨µ¥µ²¯°¥«¶·«¯®³¸¥±³¥©«ª¥±³¥±¹¹«·®«¬¥³¨ªº®²¨§³¥®¨¥¦§¨©§¥·¯¨´ª«°³¸¥±§¬¥®»«§¥µ±¹²ª²®±®«³¥®»«¥¹¨°°º§²¹±®²¨§¥´«®©««§¥«°·ª¨¼««³¥ª¨¨¦²§¥µ¨¯¥¦§¨©ª«¬«¥±§¬¥«¶·«¯®³¥©»¨¥»±½«¥®»±®¥¦§¨©ª¾«¬«¿¥À¨ªº®²¨§³¥¹¯«±®«¬¥²§¥®»²³¥¹¨°°º§²¹±®²¨§¥±¯«¥®»«§¥±¬¬«¬¥®¨¥±¥¬±®±´±³«¥¨µ¥³¨ªº®²¨§³¥²§¥®»«¥µ¨¯°¥¨µ¥µ¯«Áº«§®ª¼¥±³¦«¬¥Áº«³®²¨§³¥ÂäijŸ¥´«³®¥·¯±¹®²¹«³¸¥¨¯¥¨®»«¯¥¬¨¹º°«§®³¿

Page 91: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!"#$% &'"(&!)*+,-./0+12+/-01/3+24+0/-356+743+-89+06-3/+18743,-2148+:;+-<4=18>+

?0/30+24+0-@/+26/13+:44.,-3.0+24+A/:+B->/0+48+-+B?:<15+A/:+012/+-89+2->+26/0/+:44.C,-3.0+=126+./;=4390D+E6/0/+2->0+5-8+:/+?0/9+24+43>-81F/+-89+0/-356+743+26/+945?,/820D+ G1020+47+2->0+5-8+:/+06-3/9+=126+426/3+B/4B</+24+6/<B+26/,+7189+18743,-2148+47+182/3/02D+ E6/+?0/3C+53/-2/9+2-H484,1/0+53/-2/9+743+06-3/9+:44.,-3.0+-89+0451-<+2->>18>+-3/+5-</9++I #&J ) '!KJD+L/<1514?0+-89+L1>>+-3/+2=4+B4B?<-3+0451-<+:44.,-3.18>+012/0D M?BB40/N+743+/H-,B</N+26-2+;4?+-3/+48+-+543B43-2/+2/-,+3/0/-35618>+=189+B4=/3D+O7+;4?+919+-+A/:+0/-356+-89+74?89+3/</ @ - 8 2 + A /:+B->/0+48+=189+B4=/3N+;4?+=4?<9+5<15.+48+-+:44.,-3.18>+:?248+48+-+0451-<+:44.,-3.18>+012/+-89+53/-2/+-+2->+19/8217;18>+/-56+A/:+945?,/82+;4?+74?89+24+<18.+12+24+=189+B4=/3D+P;+5<15.18>+48+26/+Q2->0R+:?248+-2+26/+0451-

Page 92: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

<+8/2=43.18>+012/N+;4?+=4?<9+:/+-:</+24+0//+-+<102+47+-<+26/+2->0+;4?+53/-2/9+-89+0/</52+26/+945?,/820+;4?+8//9D

S4,B-81/0+8//9+=-;0+24+.//B+23-5.+47+-89+,-8->/+/,B<4;//+</-3818>+-89+24+182/>3-2/+

12+,43/+7?<;+1824+26/13+.84=</9>/+,-8->/,/82+-89+426/3+543B43-2/+0;02/,0D+T+#K"()!)*$'")"*K'K)U$JVJUK'+WXY Z + B 3 4 @ 1 9 /0+244<0+743+26/+,-8->/,/82N+9/<1@/3;N+23-5.18>N+-89+-0/0,/ 8 2 + 4 7 + @ - 3 1 4? 0+2;B/0+47+/,B<4;//+</-3818>+-89+23-1818>D[43+/H-,B</N+26/+A613<B44<+S43B43-2148+?0/0+S\]E^_O`Ea0+</-3818>+,-8->/,/82+

+0;02/,+24+,-8->/+26/+3/>1023-2148N+056/9?<18>N+3/B43218>N+-89+5482/82+743+120+23-1818>++B34>3-,0+743+bNcdd+0-</0B/4B</D+E6/+0;02/,+6/<B0+A613<B44<+2-1<43+54?30/+5482/82+24+26/+31>62+-?91/85/N+23-5.+26/+B/4B</+=64+244.+54?30/0+-89+26/13+0543/0N+-89+54,B1</+,/23150+48+/,B<4;//+B/

Page 93: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

3743,-85/D

efghijkljmhgnemopoqjroE6/+/82/3B310/C=19/+.84=</9>/+0;02/,0+=/+6-@/+s?02+9/0531:/ 9 + B 3 4 @ 1 9 /+-+=19/+3-8>/+47+5-B-:1<121/0+?0/9+:;+,-8;N+17+842+-<N+26/+=43./30+-89+>34?B0+18+-8+43>-81F-2148D+[13,0+-<04+6-@/+0B/51-<1F/9+0;02/,0+743+.84=</9>/+=43./30+24+6/<B+26/,+53/-2/+8/=+.84=</9>/+743+1, B 3 4 @ 1 8 >+26/+713,a0+:?018/0+B345/0/0+-89+9/510148+,-.18>D+t) u#Kv*K$u (&$JVJUK'J+ Wtw Z$-3/+0B/51-<1F/9+0;02/,0+743+/8>18//30N+051/821020N+-89+426/3+.84=</9>/+=43./30+26-2+-3/+9/01>8/9+24+B34,42/+26/+53/-2148+47+.84=</9>/+-89+24+/80?3/+26-2+8/=+.84=</9>/+-89+2/56815-<+/HB/3210/+-3/+B34B/3<;+182/>3-2/9+1824+26/+:?018/0D

nxyz{|x}x~ �€m�‚me~�ƒ„x…†xmh�|‡moˆ€ �x}€‰84=</9>/+=43.+0;02/,0+>1@/+.84=</

Page 94: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

9>/+=43./30+26/+0B/51-<1F/9+244<0+26/;+8//9N+0?56+-0+B4=/37?<+>3-B6150N+-8-<;215-<+244<0N+-89+54,,?815-21480+-89+945?,/82+,-8->/,/82D+ E6/0/+0;02/,0+3/Š?13/+>3/-2+54,B?218>+B4=/3+24+6-89</+26/+04B610215-2/9+>3-B6150+43+54,B</H+5-<5?<-21480+8/5/00-3;+743+0?56+.84=</9>/+=43./30+-0+051/821715+3/0/-356/30N+ B349?52+9/01>8/30N+-89+718-851-<+-8-<;020D+P/5-?0/+.84=</9>/+=43./30+-3/+04+745?0/9+48+.84=</9>/+18+26/+/H2/38-<+=43<9N+26/0/+0;02/,0+-<04+,?02+>1@/+26/+=43./3+Š?15.+-89+/-0;+-55/00+24+/H2/38-<+9-2-:-0/0D+E6/;+2;B15-<;+7/-2?3/+?0/3C731/89<;+182/37-5/0+26-2+/8-:</+?0/30+24+B/3743,+8//9/9+2-0.0+=1264? 2 + 6 - @ 1 8 >+24+0B/89+-+<42+47+21,/+</-3818>+64=+24+?0/+26/+54,B?2/3D+[1>?3/+‹dD‹Œ+0?,,-31F/0+26/+3/Š?13/,/820+47+.84=</9>/+=43.+0;02/,0D

Page 95: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

‰84=</9>/+=43.02-21480+472/8+-3/+9/01>8/9+-89+4B21,1F/9+743+26/+0B/51715+2-0.0+24+:/+ B/3743,/9D+L/01>8+/8>18//30+8//9+>3-B6150+=126+/84?>6+B4=/3+24+6-89</+263//C91,/80148-<+ STL+0;02/,0D+4=/@/3N+718-851-<+-8-<;020+-3/+,43/+182/3/02/9+18+-55/0+24+-+,;31-9+47+/H2/38-<+9-2-:-0/0+-89+2/5684<4>;+743+/7151/82<;+024318>+-89+-55/018>+,-01@/+-,4?820+47+718-851-<+9-2-D

jŽ�}�„x€m�‚me~ �ƒ„x…†xmh �|‡moˆ€ �x}€‘-s43+.84=</9>/+=43.+-BB<15-21480+185<?9/+STL+0;02/,0+’=6156+=/+182349?5/9+18+ S6-B2/3+b“ N + @ 1 3 2 ?-<+3/-<12;+0;02/,0+743+01,?<-2148+-89+,49/<18>N+-89+718-851-<+=43.02-21480D

S482/,B43-3;+STL+0;02/,0+-3/+5-B-:</+47+>/8/3-218>+3/-<10215C<44.18>+263//C91,/8C

0148-<+>3-B615+9/01>80+26-2+5-8+:/+342-2/ 9 + - 8 9 + @ 1 /=/9+734,+-<+019/0D+E34;+G//+L/01>80N+

Page 96: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

=6156+,-./0+0B4320+6/<,/20N+3/5/82<;+18@/02/9+18+STL+0472=-3/+26-2+54?<9+53/-2/+26/+

Page 97: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

lmnopqrstusvwxyz{|x}x~ �€ �‚ƒ �„~‚…†x‡ˆx�‰‚|Š�‹Œ€�x}€�Ž ��‘’“”’• ��–—•˜™˜š’›˜•–’œ �ž–’•˜š–�Ž”•‘žŽ—˜•š �•’Ÿš’–Ž ‘•—Ž ��‘¡’“”’•¢ ˜’˜•žŽ• ““žšž �Ž•š �•˜£’¤ž ‘ž¥’“•¦ –“� –’• Ž“•˜�§š � –’¨

!"#!$%&'!( ! ) #* *+,!- ."# -! ! /0 !1 2! /#! 2/-" "*#/ ! *- 3!4 ") ! "#5* 5 -! 6 ) "#+!/#!"- /!*#!0/0 23! /#-% * -"#+!/!) /,! *- 3!/#-! "00"#+! ! *- ! *!7 "/#!./) *2" ! *!)2 / !/!0 / ")!02* * ,0 '!82*-9) "*#!" !#*4!/1*9 ! ":! *# !./ 2!/#-!/1*9 !$;!0 2) # !) /0 23!4" !7 "/#!./) *2" !/1 ! *!02*-9) !/#! :/) !2 0 ")/!/. 2!2 ) "5"#+! !-"+" / !- "+#!5"/! % /" !<=/ 1,3!>?@?A'

BCDEFGHIDJGHCEK!LKLEJML!9 !"# 2/) "5 !+2/0 ") ! *. 4/2 ! *!)2 / !)* 09 2%!+ # 2/ -! " 9 / "*# ! / !/2 ! *!) * ! *!2 / " ,! / !9 2 !/ * !1 " 5 ! ,!/2 !0/2 ")"0/ "#+!"#!/!2 / %4*2 -! " 9/ "*#'!N#! /#,!5"2 9/ !2

Page 98: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

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

Page 99: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!<[/#- 2 3!>?@?A'!\F]MJ^EJ_IDJGHCEKI`\ab!" !/!2 / -! ) #* *+,!.*2! # /#)"#+!5" 9/ "c/ "*#'!

7d!02*5"- !/! "5 !-"2 ) !*2!"#-"2 ) !5" 4!*.!/!0 , ")/ !2 / %4*2 -! #5"2*# # !4 * !! # !/2 !/9+ # -!1,!5"2 9/ !)* 09 2%+ # 2/ -!" /+ 2,'!( !9 2!" !+2*9#- -!"#! !2 / !0 , ")/ !4*2 -3!/#-! !5"2 9/ !" /+ !/2 ! 2+ -!4" ! !2 / !5" 4! *!)2 / ! !/9+ # -!-" 0 /,'!( !-"+" / ! ) #* *+,!02*5"- !/--" "*#/ !"#.*2 / "*#! *! # /#) ! !0 2) 0 "*#!*.!2 / " ,3! /6"#+! ! 92*9#-"#+!2 / !4*2 -!*.! !9 2! *2 !"# 2/) "5 !/#-! /#"#+.9 '!( !, *4!."2 %-*4#! /26 2 ! *4#!*#! 5" -!.** 1/ !+/ !/2 ! :/ %0 !*.!/9+ # -!2 / " ,!/ !/2 ! -")/ !02*) -92 ! "6 !" /+ %+9"- -! 92+ 2,3!4 2 !-/ /!/)O9"2 -!.2* !)* 09 2"c -! * *+2/0 ,!<T(A!/#-! /+# ")!2 *#/#) !" /+"#+!<=dNA! )/# !*2!.2* !9 2/ *9#-!" /+"#+!/2 ! 90 2" 0* -!*#! !0/ " # !"#! !*0 2/ "#+!2** '!e 2!"#-9 2" !4 2 !7d! / !)/9+ !*#!"#) 9- ! " " /2,! 2/"#"#+3! #+"# 2"#+!- "+#3!2*1* ") 3!/#-!)*# 9 2!- "+#'f"2 9/ !2 / " ,!/00 ")/ "*# !- 5 *0 -!.*2! !g 1!9 !/! /#-/2-!)/ -!BCDEFGHI

aJGHCEKIhi_JHC^]IjG^]FG]J!`Bahjb'!fd=k!" !/! !*.! 0 )".")/ "*#

Page 100: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!.*2!"# 2/) "5 3!

Page 101: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

!!"#$%!&'$(&)*+%(#!*$&,+(&+ !+-( *#+-$#!+-!.+ ) +( ,)&$/!'+%0* $1*!+%!#$)+ 21!'3+$&4*0#$&,+)&$%) $(&3+$%),!'3+)&#+)0#$(3+ (+10 +0'! '+$&+)+'$%0*) !#+ !)*"5( *#+!&6$ (&"%!& 7+89:;+$'+1*) <( %+$&#!1!&#!& 3+(1! ) !'+(6! +)+#!'= (1+4(%10 ! 3+)&#+ !>0$ !'+*$ *!+.)&#5$# 7

?0@(& 3+ !+-$*%$&, (&3+?!*)5) !3+4 !%$4)*+4(%1)&23+4 !) !#+)+89:;+)11*$4) $(&+

4)*!#+A21! @*)& 3+5 $4 +!&).*!'+0'! '+ (+)44!'+ !!"#$%!&'$(&)*+#) )+(6! + !+B& ! &! +0'$&,+-!.+. (5'! +'(< 5) !7+C&,$&!! '+4)&+,(+ (0, + !!"#$%!&'$(&)*+%(#!*'+)'+$<+ !2+5! !+1 2'$4)*2+5)*=$&,+ (0, +)+1*)& 3+6$!5$&,+(.D!4 '+) +!2!+*!6!*7+E $'+*!6!*+(<+#! )$*+ !#04!'+ !+&0%.! +(<+%$' )=!'+ !2+%)=!+#0 $&,+4(&' 04 $(&+(<+($*+ $,'3+($*+1*)& '3+)&#+ ( ! +' 04 0 !'7

E !+<$&)&4$)*+$&#0' 2+$'+0'$&,+'1!4$)*$/!#+FGHIJKLIGKMNOPQJKRKFOGJ+ (+*!6! ),!+ !+

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

XYZ[\]\^_`[Zabc_E !+<(*(5$&,+;!) &$&,+E

)4='+1 (6$#!+4(& !& + !*!

Page 102: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

e

f

6)& + (+ (1$4'+4(6! !#+$&+ $'+

+4 )1 ! de7+U0$*#$&,+)&#+T'$&, + @ $ 6 ( +E).*!' f7+A(5+)&+CW1! +V2' !%+B&<! !&4!+C&,$&!+-( ='g7+h )*!&,!'+(<+B%1*!%!& $&,+)&#+T'$&,+i&(5*!#,!+:)&),!%!& +V2' !%'j7+U0'$&!'+B& !*$,!&4!

klmnlopqrsstuvxyRKMRPIMKyIMzF{IPIGKMK|}IJMO{MzI~FJFOGJ �MRGzMyONMzOIJMKyIMzI~FJFOG€LRQFG �M M}PO~IJJMNOPQ‚M?!4$'$(&'+%)2+.!+' 04 0 !#3+'!%$' 04 0 !#3+( +0&' 04 0 !#3+5$ +

' 04 0 !#+#!4$'$(&'+4*0' ! $&,+) + !+(1! ) $(&)*+*!6!*+(<+ !+( ,)&$/) $(&+)&#+0&' 04 0 !#+#!4$'$(&'+) + !+' ) !,$4+*!6!*7+?!4$'$(&+%)=$&,+4)&+.!+1! <( %!#+.2+$&#$6$#0)*'+( +, (01'+)&#+$&4*0#!'+!%1*(2!!'+)'+5!*+)'+(1! ) $(&)*3+%$##*!3+)&#+'!&$( +%)&),! '7+E ! !+) !+<(0 +' ),!'+$&+#!4$'$(&+%)=$&,d+$& !*$,!&4!3+#!'$,&3+4 ($4!3+)&#+$%1*!%!& ) $(&7+

ƒONMzOM„…JFGIJJMFGKI†FIG~IMRGzM„…JFGIJJMRGR†|KF~JMJ…}}OPKMzI~FJFOGMLRQFG‚M U0'$&!''+$& !*$,!&4!+)&#+)&)*2 $4'+1 (%$'!+ (+#!*$6! +4( !4 3+&!) *2+ !)*" $%!+

+$&<( %) $(&+ (+#!4$'$(&+%)=! '3+)&#+ !+)&)*2 $4+ ((*'+ !*1+ !%+>0$4=*2+0&#! ' )&#+ !+$&<( %) $(&+)&#+ )=!+)4 $(&7+‡+.0'$&!'+$& !*$,!&4!+!&6$ (&%!& +4(&'$' '+(<+#) )+< (%+ !+.0'$&!'+!&6$ (&%!& 3+ !+UB+$&< )' 04 0 !3+)+U‡+ ((*'! 3+%)&),! $)*+0'! '+)&#+%! (#'3+)+UB+#!*$6! 2+1*) <( %+ˆ:BV3+?VV3+( +CVV‰3+)&#+ !+0'! +$& ! <)4!7+E ! !+) !+'$W+)&)*2 $4+<0&4 $(&)*$ $!'+ ) +UB+'2' !%'+#!

Page 103: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

*$6! + (+)4 $!6!+ !'!+!&#'d+1 !"#!<$&!#+1 (#04 $(&+ !1( '3+1) )%! ! $/!#+ !1( '3+#)' .() #'+)&#+'4( !4) #'3+)#+ (4+>0! $!'+)&#+'!) 4 !'3+ !+).$*$ 2+ (+# $*+#(5&+ (+#! )$*!#+6$!5'+(<+#) )3+)&#+ !+).$*$ 2+ (+%(#!*+'4!&) $('+)&#+4 !) !+<( !4)' '7

Page 104: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

A

\

!"# $%& !#% "'('! '") *+,"-&%./0# "-& - 01 ."-&%./0!#%

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

CDEFGDFHIJDKLMNHDIFOPONQLOFRQSTFTQDTSQFEDKUHIVFHIFMFVKDWTFLMUQFGQXHOHDIOFLDKQF QJHXHQINSPYFZ&%/-". 0#'#% :'/--%&!"'('! '")Z;++,"5 2-"- %-2

" !# "!% !5 &"# " " &%/-" &#< " !". 0#'#% '" %& " $#0# !2(6"Z;++"$ !/& "'- 0# 2"0% $ & 0 "&%% "$ 0#2#!# '"45 & "- &!#0#- !'"0% !&#=/! "!5 #&"#. '"/'# " !4%&1 ."0% -/! &'" ."'%$!4 & "!%%2'"$%&"%& #[# "#. '3" !5 &# "# $%& !#% 3"& 1# " ."' !# "-&#%&#!# '3" .".%0/ !# " !# "' '#% '6

]RMNFMKQFNRQF^WOHIQOOF^QIQJHNOFDJFWOHIVFHINQSHVQINFNQXRIH_WQOFHIFGQXHO

HDIFLMUHIVF MIGFUIDESQGVQFLMIMVQLQINYF@>-

&!"'('! '"0 -!/& "! 0#!"1 %42 . "$&% " "2# #! ."

.% # "%$"5/ " >- &!#' " ." >-& '"!5 !"1 %42 . "# "!5 "$%& "%$"&/2 '6"?5 "'!& ! ("!%"' &05"!5&%/ 5"!5 "1 %42 . "= ' "#'"0 2 ."!5 "# $ & 0 " # 6"` ' := ' ."& '% # "& -& ' !'"%& #[ !#% 2"1 %42 . " '" ". ! = ' "%$"0 ' '"!5 !"0 "= "0% !# / 2(" >- . ." ."& $# .6"

7/[[("2% #0"#'" "'%$!4 & "! 05 %2% ("$%&" >-& '# "1 %42 . "# "!5 "$%&

"%$"&/2 '"!5 !"

Page 105: 10 Improving Decision Making and Managing Knowledge

c

/' " --&%># ! "%&"'/=a 0!#< "< 2/ '6"b /& 2" !4%&1'"0% '#'!"%$"5 &.4 & " ."'%$!4 & "!5 !" ! -!"!%" # #0"!5 "!5%/ 5!"-&%0 ' '"%$"!5 "5/ "=& # 6"b /& 2" !4%&1'" & " %! =2 "$%&"!5 #&" =#2#!("!%"2 & "4#!5%/!"-&% & # " ."!%"& 0% #[ "- ! & '"# " '#< " %/ !'"%$". ! 6

Z !#0" 2 %&#!5 '". < 2%-"'%2/!#% '"!%"- &!#0/2 &"-&%=2 '"/'# " !#0 2("= ' ." "-&%0 ' '3"'/05" '"$#! '3"0&%'%< &3" ." /! !#% 6"* ! 2# !" !'" & "'%$!4 & "-&% & '"4#!5"=/#2!:# "%&"2 & ."1 %42 . "= ' '"!5 !"0 &("%/!"'- 0#$#03"& - !#!#< 3" ."-& .#0! =2 "! '1'"$%&" "# .#<#./ 2"/' &3"=/'# '"-&%0 '3"%&"'%$!4 & " --2#0 !#% 6"

]RMNFNPTQOFDJFOPONQLOFMKQFWOQGFJDKFQINQKTKHOQdEHGQFUIDESQGVQFLMIMVQLQIN

FMIGF UIDESQGVQFEDKUeFMIGFRDEFGDFNRQPFTKDfHGQFfMSWQFJDKF^WOHIQOOQOYF@ ! &-

&#' "0% ! !" !"'('! '"$ !/& ". ! = ' '" ."!%%2'"$%&"%& #[# " ."'!%&# "'!&/0!/& ." ".%0/ !'" ."' #'!&/0!/& ."1 %42 . 3"'/05" '" : #2"%&"&#05" .# 6"g %42 . " !4%&1"'('! '"-&%<#. ".#& 0!%&# '" ."!%%2'"$%&"2%0 !# "$#& " -2%( '"4#!5"'- 0# 2" >- &!#' "45%" & "# -%&! !"'%/&0 '"%$"! 0#!"1 %42 . 6"h$! "!5 ' "'('! '"# 02/. " &%/-"0%2 =%& :!#% "!%%2'3"-%&! 2'"!%"'# -2#$("# $%& !#% " 00 '3"' &05"!%%2'3" ."!%%2'"$%&"02 '#$(# "# $%& !#% "= ' ."% " "! >% % ("!5 !"#'" --&%-&# ! "$%&"!5 "%& #[ !#% 6"i & # " " !"'('! '"-&%<#. "!%%2'"$%&"!5 " !3". 2#< &(3"!& 01# 3" ." ' ' !"%$"< &#%/'"!(- '"%$" -2%( "2 & # " ."!& # # 6

g %42 . "4%&1"'('! '")gj+,"'/--%&!"!5 "0& !#% "%$" 4"1 %42 . " ."#!'" "# ! & !#% "# !%"!5 "%& #[ !#% 6"gj+"& k/#& " '(" 00 '"!%" " >! & 2"1 %42 . "= ' l"-%4 &$/2"0% -/! &"5 &.4 & "!5 !"0 "'/--%&!"'%$!4 & "4#!5"# ! '#< " & -5#0'3" 2('#'3".%0/ !" !3" ."0% / #0 !#% '"0 - =#2#!# 'l" ." "/' &:$&# .2("# ! &$ 0 6