1

ArnoJamesChristianKaterina

Feedback2

2

Introduction to afternoon break out groups

The Work Packages3

3

Objectives:

1. Introduction to the afternoon breakout groups

2. Overview of Work-Package plans

Product and Waste Characterisation – Patrick and

Susanne

Stocks and Flows – Jaco

End User Requirements – David

Information Network - Sarah

Table of Contents

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 641999.

Product Characterisation WP2Waste Characterisation WP4

23rd April 2015BrusselsPatrick WagerSusanne Rotter

5

WP5

Knowledge Base (BRGM)

WP3Stocks and flowsCharacterisation(UNU)

WP1 Project management (WF)

WP6

Exploitation (WF)

ProSUMProspecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes

WP2ProductCharacterisation(Empa)

Information Network

ComponentsCRM POM

ProductsCRM Stocks

FractionsCRM in Waste

WP4WasteCharacterisation(TUB)

6

1. Identify existing CRM data sources on a. products put on the market b. end of life (EoL) products c. residues from waste treatment d. mining waste

2. Assess and validate data

3. Evaluate and test sampling, sample preparation

and chemical analysis methods for CRM

quantification

4. Data protocols

Objectives and tasks

7

Task

Identify and assess existing CRM

data sources

Deliverables

1. Reports on available data (M12)

2. Report on data assessment (M24)

Identify existing CRM data sources

a. products put on the market b. end of life (EoL) products c. residues from waste

treatment d. mining waste

8

Identify existing CRM data sources on

Raw materials considered by ProSUMIa

Ib013Al 014Si 015P 016S

IIa

IIIb IVb Vb

2(L)

3Li

011Na 012Mg

4Be

3(M) IIb

IIIa IVa Va VIIa

005B 006C 007N 008O 009F

VIb

VIIIa

1(K)

001H 002He

017Cl 018Ar

010Ne

VIIb VIII

VIa

4(N)

019K 020Ca 21Sc 022Ti 023V 024Cr 025Mn 026Fe 27Co 028Ni 29Cu 030Zn 31Ga 32Ge 33As 034Se 035Br 036Kr

5(O)

37Rb 038Sr 39Y 040Zr 41Nb 42Mo 043Tc 44Ru 45Rh 46Pd 47Ag 48Cd 49In 50Sn 51Sb 52Te 053I 054Xe

79Au6(P)

55Cs 056Ba 57La 72Hf 73Ta 81Tl 82Pb 83Bi 84Po 085At74W 75Re 76Os 77Ir 78Pt 086Rn80Hg

58Ce 59Pr 60Nd 61Pm 62Sm 63Eu 64Gd 65Tb 66Dy 67Ho 70Yb 71Lu68Er 69Tm

+ glass, plastics

not addressed by EC 2014

Critical according to EC 2014

not critical according to EC 2014, but considered relevant

consideration in discussion

10

Identify existing data sources

Data maps• Track information flows• Map data “holders” & “producers”• Indicate data availability• Show data granularity

11

Sampling, sample preparation & chemical analysis

Task

Evaluate and test sampling, sample preparation

and chemical analysis methods for CRM

quantification

Deliverables

1. Recommendations for sampling and analysis

of products, components and wastes (M30)

12

WP2 3 "particularly interesting" products and components (POM /EoL)

- sensors- LED- photovoltaic applications

WP4 4-6 "particularly interesting" waste fractions

- printed wiring boards scrap - thermal battery treatment fractions - ...

Sampling, sample preparation & chemical analysis

• Criteria for "particularly interesting" products / components / waste fractions:- include different types of matrices (alloys, silica based,

…)- cover the three product groups considered in ProSUM

(batteries, EEE, vehicles) with expected growing market share + mining waste

- little data on CRM composition available - etc.

Prelimina

ry

13

Your views on …

• major challenges in acquiring data related to CRM and other relevant raw materials;

• your role in data acquisition• standardisation and harmonisation needs

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 641999.

Stocks and Flows – WP3

23rd April 2015BrusselsJaco Huisman

15

WP5

Knowledge Base (BRGM)

WP3Stocks and flowsCharacterisation(UNU)

WP1 Project management (WF)

WP6

Exploitation (WF)

ProSUMProspecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes

WP2ProductCharacterisation(Empa)

Information Network

ComponentsCRM POM

ProductsCRM Stocks

FractionsCRM in Waste

WP4WasteCharacterisation(TUB)

16

Objectives and Tasks WP3

• Describe, compile and harmonize available data on the stocks and flows of CRM containing products

• Assess disposal trends and complementary flows

• Stock - flow model development• Analysis and data handling framework for WP5• Data quality tests and recommendations for

maintenance and updating

17

Key challenges

• From products stocks and flows to CRM

stocks and flows

• Trends over time / rapid technology

changes affecting disposal

• Data on product flows for Batteries and ELV

Stocks and Flows – WP3

18

Your views on …

• Types and definitions of complementary flows• Challenges in acquiring comprehensive data• Your needs related to stock and flows

information• Inventory existing studies and activitiesIf time allows:• Harmonisation and standardisation needs• How to update information

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 641999.

Knowledge Base– WP5

23rd April 2015BrusselsDavid Gardner

20

WP5

Knowledge Base (BRGM)

WP3Stocks and flowsCharacterisation(UNU)

WP1 Project management (WF)

WP6

Exploitation (WF)

ProSUMProspecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes

WP2ProductCharacterisation(Empa)

Information Network

ComponentsCRM POM

ProductsCRM Stocks

FractionsCRM in Waste

WP4WasteCharacterisation(TUB)

21

Examples of material and product flows

Data needed to map flows

Seeking your input

1

2

3

Contents

22

Generic product flow

23

DATA:-Quantity-Value-CRM?

DATA:-Quantity-Value-CRM?

-Quantity-Value-Purity-CRM?-PriceCode list:

COMPOUND

Code list:COMMODITY

Code list:PART

Code list:COMPONENT

Code list:PRODUCT

ID, depending on the CATEGORY:

ATTACHED DATA:Code list:

Facilities

DATA:-Quantity-Value-CRM?

DATA:-Quantity-Value-CRM?

-Legal Name-Organisation type-Location-Capacity

ID:

ATTACHED DATA:

Code list:Facilities

DATA:-Quantity-Value-CRM?

DATA:-Quantity-Value-CRM?

-Legal Name-Organisation type-Location-Capacity

ID:

ATTACHED DATA:

MATERIAL FLOW

Source: ID

Geographic region

Destination: ID Geograpic

region

ATTACHED TAGS:

MATERIAL FLOW

Geographic region

24

Your views on ….

• What tangible/ factual outputs would you expect to see? Map of Europe with layers, material flow data in tables, other types of infographics

• The basic flow diagram – what are the boundaries?

• Specific questions like the detail by region / country / Europe, etc.

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 641999.

The Information Network –WP6Information Network Launch

23rd April 2015BrusselsSarah Downes

26

WP5

Knowledge Base (BRGM)

WP3Stocks and flowsCharacterisation(UNU)

WP1 Project management (WF)

WP6

Exploitation (WF)

ProSUMProspecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes

WP2ProductCharacterisation(Empa)

Information Network

ComponentsCRM POM

ProductsCRM Stocks

FractionsCRM in Waste

WP4WasteCharacterisation(TUB)

27

Improved coordination and support

• Improve the knowledge base • Enable coordination and collaborative

work to enhance data gathering• Raise awareness and share best practice• Facilitate standardisation• Support policy dialogue• Support further research

28

Membership

• Researchers• Recycling industry – pre-processors, recyclers and

smelters• Producers and their component suppliers• Producer Responsibility Organisations and

Associations• Public authorities –policy makers, national statistics

offices, national and regional government• Geological surveys• Waste industry• Other EU projects e.g. KIC on Raw Materials

29

Objectives

• Allow partners to identify the knowledge and data requirements to support on-going and future data collection and dissemination

• Identify data and information needs by industry and policy makers including the granularity and format

• Coordinate harmonised data collection in standard formats

• Engage in communication and dissemination along the value chain to improve the knowledge base

• Provide recommendations and standards

30

Operation Strategy

• Interface between project and stakeholders• Share best practice and knowledge• Showcase advances and opportunities in

data gathering and exchange• Create opportunities and cooperation on

data pooling• Agree a Terms of Reference for members• Develop a Business Plan for life beyond the

project

31

Operation Tactics

• Annual Network Meetings• Special Interest Groups• Identify end user requirements and test

EU-UMKDP• Website Platform

• Discussion groups• MOOCs

• Data Sharing Agreements – protection of data

32

Your views on …

• Provide useful data and intelligence for stakeholders• Engage a wide range of end users • Identify opportunities and overcome barriers to

gathering data• Act as a vehicle to disseminate project findings and

results to raise awareness• Improve the coordination and cooperation of data

owners and improve the interoperability and harmonisation of data

• Assist in improving the knowledge base on the availability of secondary raw materials, particularly critical raw materials

33

Afternoon Breakouts

1. Product and Waste Characterisation• Forum A• Patrick and Susanne

2. Stocks and Flows• Forum B• Jaco

3. End User Requirements• Consilium A• David

4. Information Network• Consilium B• Pascal

34

Lunch at OO!