1. 2 behavioral health and criminal justice: challenges and opportunities pamela s. hyde, j.d....
TRANSCRIPT
1
2
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE: CHALLENGES AND
OPPORTUNITIES
Pamela S. Hyde, J.D.SAMHSA Administrator
American Correctional AssociationDenver, CO • July 21, 2012
3
INTERSECTION:BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
1/2 of Incarcerated People Have MH Problems
60 Percent Have SUDs
1/3 Have Both
4
CORRECTIONAL BEHAVIORAL HEALTH IS COMMUNITY HEALTH
~ ⅔ of People in Prison Meet Criteria for SUDs, Yet < 15 Percent Receive Treatment After Admission
24 Percent of Individuals in State Prisons Have Recent History of MI, Yet Only 34 Percent Receive Treatment After Admission
~ 700,000 Federal and State Prisoners Released to Communities in U.S. Every Year
5
BEHAVIORAL HEALTHIMPACT ON PHYSICAL HEALTH
6
PREVALENCE OF BH CO-MORBIDITIES(MEDICAID-ONLY BENEFICIARIES W/DISABILITIES)
6Boyd, C., Clark, R., Leff, B., Richards, T., Weiss, C., Wolff, J. (2011, August). Clarifying Multimorbidity for Medicaid Programs to Improve Targeting and Delivering Clinical Services. Presented to SAMHSA, Rockville, MD.
7
PREMATURE DEATH AND DISABILITY
People with M/SUDs are nearly 2x as likely as general population to die prematurely, (8.2 years younger) often of preventable or treatable causes (95.4% medical causes)
More deaths from M/SUDs than HIV, traffic accidents , and breast cancer combined
More deaths from suicide than from HIV or homicides
Half the deaths from tobacco use are among persons with M/SUDs
CDC, National Vital Statistics Report
8
HEALTH REFORM: THE JUSTICE POPULATION
9
2014 – MORE AMERICANS WILL HAVE HEALTH COVERAGE OPPORTUNITIES
Currently, 37.9 million are uninsured <400% FPL*
• 18.0 M – Medicaid expansion eligible • 19.9 M – ACA exchange eligible**• 11.019 M (29%) – Have BH condition(s)
* Source: 2010 NSDUH**Eligible for premium tax credits and not eligible for Medicaid
10
ESSENTIAL HEALTH BENEFITS (EHB) 10 BENEFIT CATEGORIES
1) Ambulatory patient services
2) Emergency services3) Hospitalization4) Maternity and newborn
care5)5) Mental health and Mental health and
substance use disorder substance use disorder services, including services, including behavioral health behavioral health treatmenttreatment
6) Prescription drugs7) Rehabilitative and
habilitative services and devices
8) Laboratory services9) Preventive and wellness
services and chronic disease management
10) Pediatric services, including oral and vision care
11
ACA & JUSTICE INVOLVED POPULATIONS ①
Coverage expansion means individuals in/after jails and prisons (generally w/o health insurance) will now have more opportunity for coverage – exchanges while in; Medicaid expansion upon re-entry
CJ population w/ comparatively high rates of M/SUDs = opportunity to coordinate new health coverage w/other efforts to ↑ successful transitions
Addressing BH needs can ↓ recidivism and ↓ expenditures in CJ system while ↑ public health and safety outcomes
SAMHSA and partners working to develop standards and improve coordination around coverage expansions
12
FOCUS: ENROLLMENT ACTIVITIES
Consumer Enrollment Assistance (thru BRSS TACS)• Outreach/public education• Enrollment/re-determination assistance• Plan comparison and selection• Grievance procedures• Eligibility/enrollment communication materials
Enrollment Assistance Best Practices TA – Toolkits
Communication Strategy – Message Testing, Outreach to Stakeholder Groups, Webinars/Training Opportunities
SOAR Changes to Address New Environment
Data Work with ASPE and CMS
13
TRAUMA-INFORMED SYSTEMS
14
UNDERSTANDING TRAUMA
Event(s)• Exposure to violence, victimization including sexual, physical
abuse, severe neglect, loss, domestic violence, witnessing of violence, disasters
Experience• Intense fear of/ threat to physical or psychological safety and
integrity, helplessness; intense emotional pain and distress
Effects• Stress that overwhelms capacity to cope and manifests in
physical, psychological, and neuro-physiological responses
15
PREVALENCE OF TRAUMA IN JUSTICE-INVOLVED POPULATIONS
About ¼ of State Prisoners (27 Percent) and Jail Inmates (24 Percent) w/ MH Problems Reported Past Physical or Sexual Abuse
Youth in Residential Treatment – 70 Percent Have Past Traumatic Experience With 30 Percent Physical and/or Sexual Abuse (OJJDP)
43-80 Percent of Individuals in Psychiatric Hospitals Have Experienced Physical or Sexual Abuse
51-90 Percent Public MH Clients Exposed to Trauma⅔ Adults in SUD Treatment Report Child Abuse/Neglect
16
TRAUMA-INFORMED SERVICES IN THE JUSTICE SYSTEM (GAINS Center)
Align Opportunities for Change at Each of 5-Intercept Points:
1. Law Enforcement (Crisis intervention training, avoid re-traumatizing, e.g., de-escalation; strip searches)
2. Initial Detention/Court Hearings (screen for trauma; gather trauma histories; what happened to you?)
3. Jails/Courts (avoid re-traumatizing behaviors; demeaning, disempowering; personnel training on trauma; provide trauma-specific tx )
4. Reentry (ensure trauma-informed peer support, transition planning with trauma interventions)
5. Community Corrections (trauma training for parole and probation officers; link with community trauma services/supports)
17
PREVENTION
18
YOUTH, JUVENILE JUSTICE AND BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
~2 million Youth Arrested Each Year600,000 Through Juvenile Detention Centers; more
than 93,000 Put in Secure Juvenile Correction FacilitiesMajority Have M/SUDsPrevalence Rates as High as 66 Percent w/ 95 Percent
Experiencing Functional Impairment56 Percent of Boys and 40 Percent of Girls Tested
Positive for Drug Use at Time of Arrest (NIDA)
19
EARLY INTERVENTION REDUCES IMPACT
½ of All Lifetime Cases of Mental Illness Begin by Age 14; ¾ by Age 24
On Average, > 6 Years from Onset of Symptoms of M/Suds to Treatment
Effective Multi-Sectoral Interventions & Treatments Exist
Need Treatment and Support Earlier• Screening• Brief interventions• Coordinated referrals
20
SAMHSA PREVENTION PRIORITIES
SA Prevention & Emotional Health Development
Suicide
Underage Drinking
Prescription Drug Abuse
21
DIVERSION
22
JAIL DIVERSION: GETTING RESULTS
Jail Diversion Works – Those Diverted: • Use less alcohol and drugs (last 30 days)
• Any alcohol use: baseline 59 percent vs. 6 months 28 percent • Alcohol to intoxication: baseline 38 percent vs. 6 months 13 percent • Illegal drug use: baseline 58 percent vs. 6 months 17 percent
• Fewer arrests after diversion compared to 12 months before (2.4 v 1.3)• Fewer jail days (52 vs 41)• Improved quality of life with fewer symptoms
¾ Jail Diversion Programs Keep Operating After Federal $Courts = Post-Arrest or Post-Conviction Diversion
• ~ 2400 Drug Cts, 300 MH Cts, 80 Veterans Cts
23
GETTING UPSTREAM: PRE-BOOKING DIVERSION
Identified for Diversion by Police; Before Formal Charges
Occurs at Point of Contact w/ Law Enforcement Officers
Relies Heavily on Effective Interactions Between Police and Community MH/SA Services
Characterized by Specialized Training for Police Officers and a 24-hour Crisis Drop-off Center with No-refusal Policy
Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) Model
Collaboration Between Police and Specially-trained MH Providers Who Co-Respond to Calls Involving a Potential MH Health Crisis
24
EXAMPLE: PRE-BOOKING DIVERSION PROGRAM
25
ACCOLADES: BEXAR COUNTY JAIL DIVERSION PROGRAM IN SAN ANTONIO, TX (2002)
Received SAMHSA TCE Jail Diversion grant and Jail Diversion and Trauma Recovery Program – Priority to Veterans Grant
Replication and/or Consultation Underway in All 50 States and in China, Mexico, Australia, England, and Canada
Received Gold Achievement Award for Community-Based Programs from American Psychiatric Association
Received Program for Service Excellence Award from National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare
A SAMHSA National Model Program
26
BEXAR COUNTY PARTNERS
Consumers and families City, State and County Government County Hospital District University, Local and Private Hospitals Criminal /Civil Courts, including Probation Departments Advocacy – NAMI San Antonio State Hospital Mental Health Partners Adult Protective Services Child Protective Services Military Entities EMS System
27
TOOLKITgainscenter.samhsa.gov
Blueprint for Success: The Bexar County Model
How to set up a jail diversion program in your community
• Impacts/Influences CJ/MH System at 46 Intervention Points – “No Wrong Door”
• Trains Practitioners; Educates Policy Makers, Defense Attorneys Community
• Shares Resources – 34 Different Partners
Judges, County Sheriffs Office, Police Department, Health Care Providers, Adult Detention Centers, and Community Stakeholders
28
HIGHLIGHTS: BEXAR COUNTY MODEL
Tools/Resources• Crisis Intervention Team Training (CIT); >50 percent of law
enforcement officers currently trained• Deputy Mobile Outreach Team (DMOT) - one MH professional
and two deputy sheriffs • Crisis Care Center (MH services)• Restoration Center (SA services)
Services – Booking to Court Appearance to Probation, Jail/Prison to Release
At Release, Coordinated Care – Genesis House Program• Intensive Case Management, Psychiatric Services and
Rehabilitation for Offenders on Parole/Probation
29
HIGHLIGHTS: OUTCOMES AND COSTS
~ 13,200 Individuals Diverted (from Jails/Prisons, ERs and Homeless Shelters) Annually
Cost Savings• Jails: ~ $65 M Annually• Cost Savings Emergency Rooms: ~ $52 M Annually
2003 Texas Jail Standards Commission Advised Bexar County Jail Would Need 1,000 New Beds; Today the Jail Currently Has 900 Empty Beds w/o Expansion
30
REENTRY
31
REENTRY CHALLENGES
9 Million Individuals Cycle Through Jails Each Year
> 700,000 Prison Offenders Reenter Communities Annually
2/3 State Prisoners Rearrested Within 3 Years Of Release
Reentering Offenders Represent:• ¼ of general population living with HIV/AIDS• Almost 1/3 of those with Hep C• Almost 40 percent of people with TB
32
REENTRY: KEY ISSUES
Employment: Incarceration decreases annual employment by > 2 months and yearly earnings by 40 percent
Homelessness: Direct relationship between incarceration and homelessness; challenges in securing housing upon reentry
Education: > 40 percent of prison and jail inmates lack a high school diploma or GED compared w/ 18 percent general population
Social Connection & Treatment: Uncertainty about Parole, Housing Arrangements, Employment, Family Reunification, Health/BH Care as Well as How to Function on Outside Can Elevate Stress and Trigger/Exasperate M/SUD Conditions
33
ATTORNEY GENERAL’S REENTRY COUNCIL
Cabinet-Level Council Led by AG Identify Research And EBP To Advance Reentry And Community
Safety Identify Federal Policy Opportunities and Barriers to Improving
OutcomesPromote Federal Policy and Practice Change to Improve Well-
being of Formerly Incarcerated Individuals and Their FamiliesSupport Initiatives in Education, Employment, Housing, Health ,
Faith, BH TreatmentCoordinate Messaging and Communications Re Prisoner ReentryRemoving Barriers to Employment, Access to Benefits Such As
TANF, Food Assistance, Health Care, Etc.
34
CHANGING THE CONVERSATION
35
A BOLDER VISION?
Can We Imagine:• A generation without one new case of trauma-
related mental or substance use disorder?• A generation without a death by suicide?• A generation without one person being jailed or
living without a home because they have an addiction or mental illness?
• A generation without one youth being bullied or rejected because they are LGBT?
• A generation in which no one in recovery struggles to find a job?
36
SAMHSA’S VISION
A Nation that Acts on the Knowledge that:• Behavioral health is essential to health• Prevention works• Treatment is effective• People recover
A nation/community free of substance abuse and mental illness and fully capable of addressing
behavioral health issues that arise from events or physical conditions