1

15th Policy SIG Report

2007.3.2Kenny Huang

Toshiyuki HosakaEugene Li

Chair/co-chair of APNIC Policy SIG

2

APNIC Policy Development Process

3

History• 1st SIG:Korea, Mar. 2000• 2nd SIG:Brisbane, Oct. 2000• 3rd SIG: KL, Mar. 2001• 4th SIG: Taipei, Aug. 2001• 5th SIG: Bangkok, Mar. 2002• 6th SIG: Kita-Kyushu, Sep. 2002• 7th SIG: Taipei, Feb. 2003• 8th SIG: Korea, Aug. 2003• 9th SIG: Kuala Lumpur, Feb. 2004• 10th SIG: Fuji, Sep. 2004• 11th SIG: Kyoto, Feb. 2005• 12th SIG: Hanoi, Sep. 2005• 13th SIG: Perth, Feb. 2006• 14th SIG: Kaohsiung, Sep. 2006• 15th SIG: Bali, Feb. 2007

4

Policy SIG Agenda

• Draft SIG guidelines: Kenny Huang• Chair / co-chair Election• Action items update: Kenny Huang• Global policy update: Nurani Nimpuno, APNIC • prop-042: Proposal to change IPv6 initial allocation criteria: Jordi Palet Martinez,

Consulintel • prop-043: Proposal to remove reference to IPv6 policy document as an "interim" policy

document : Jordi Palet Martinez, Consulintel • prop-044: Proposal to remove requirement to document need for multiple /48s

assigned to a single end site Jordi Palet Martinez, Consulintel • prop-045: Proposal to modify "end site" definition and alllow end sites to receive IPv6

allocations: Jordi Palet Martinez, Consulintel • Large IPv4 address space usage trial for future IPv6 deployment - phase 2 Fukushima

Nao, IPv6 Promotion Council of Japan• Evaluation of GAP algorithm, Mei Wang, CISCO• prop-046: IPv4 countdown policy proposal, Toshiyuki Hosaka, JPNIC • Resource management system WG update, Shin Yamasaki, JPNIC • prop-037: Deprecation of email updates for APNIC Registry and whois data Terry

Manderson, APNIC • prop-047: eGLOP multicast address assignments Marshall Eubanks • Resource transfer and certification Geoff Huston, APNIC

5

Chair / Co-Chair Election

• Nominee for Policy SIG Chair – Toshiyuki Hosaka, JPNIC

• Nominee for Co-Chair – Dong Yang, CNNIC

• Elected Chair : Toshiyuki Hosaka

• Elected Co-Chair : Dong Yang

6

Head count for Policy SIG

• 1st session 85 in room, 2nd session 80 in room

• 9 in jabber chat

7

Content of SIG

• 6 policy proposals

• 7 informational presentations

8

prop-042: Proposal to change IPv6 initial allocation criteria (Jordi Palet Martinez)

• The proposal– Proposed IPv6 policy:

• Be an LIR;• Not an End Site;• Plan to make assignments• Plan to aggregate

• The proposal didn’t reach consensus at the OPM, chair to refer the proposal to mailing list for further discussion

9

prop-043: Proposal to remove reference to IPv6 policy document as an "interim" policy document (Jordi Palet Martinez)

• The proposal– Proposed IPv6 policy

• APNIC-089 : “Interim”• Proposed Modification : remove the statement

• The proposal didn’t reach consensus at the OPM

10

prop-044: Proposal to remove requirement to document need for multiple /48s assigned to a single end site (Jordi Palet Martinez)

• The proposal– Proposed IPv6 Policy

• APNIC-089 : Required• Document nx / 48: Not Required

• The proposal didn’t reach consensus at the OPM

11

prop-045: Proposal to modify "end site" definition and alllow end sites to receive IPv6 allocations (Jordi Palet Martinez)

• The proposal– Proposed IPv6 Policy

• APNIC-089 : Restricted to other organizations• Proposed modefication : Broadened to include end users related to organization

• The proposal didn’t reach consensus at the OPM

12

prop-046: IPv4 countdown policy proposal (Toshiyuki Hosaka)

• The proposal is splited into 4 points– 1 Global synchronization– 2 Some block to be left– 3 Keeping current practices until the last

mement– 4 Separate discussions on recycle issue

• General feeling from the floor support the point 1,3,4. Chair to refer the proposal to mailing list for further discussion.

13

prop-037: Deprecation of email updates for APNIC Registry and whois data (Terry Manderson)

• The proposal– Secretariat to phase out email updates of

registry and whois data in favour of more suitable and responsible methods providing APNIC has bridging mechanism provide migration capability

• The proposal didn’t reach consensus at the OPM

14

Informational Presentations

• Draft SIG guidelines & open action items (Kenny Huang)

• Global policy update (Nurani Nimpuno)• Large IPv4 address space usage trial for future

IPv6 deployment - phase 2 (Fukushima Nao)• Evaluation of GAP Algorithm (Mei Wong)• Resource management system WG update (Shin

Yamasaki)• prop-047: eGLOP multicast address assignments

(Marshall Eubanks)• Resource transfer and certification (Geoff Huston)

15

Action Items

• pol-23-001: Chair to refer prop-042: Proposal to change IPv6 initial allocation criteria to mailing list for further discussion.

• pol-23-002: Chair to refer prop-046: IPv4 countdown policy proposal to mailing list for further discussion. 

• pol-23-003: Chair to refer prop-037: Deprecation of email updates for APNIC Registry and whois data to mailing list for further discussion.

• pol-23-004: Marshall Eubanks to present prop-047: eGLOP multicast address assignments as a formal policy proposal at APNIC 24.

16

THANK YOUTHANK YOU