030314 aereo solicitor general

Upload: sam-gustin

Post on 03-Jun-2018

224 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    1/40

    !"# %&'()%

    !" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. $%& /"0$&1 '$2$&3

    "#$%&'"( )%*"+'",-&(. '*#/"(&$,0&('10$- "210/$-&-&*($%,

    !"

    "$%$*0&('1034" )"#)**# 2"),0&('1

    #$ &'() #* +,')(#'-'(

    )# )., /$(),0 1)-),1 +#/') #* -22,-31

    *#' )., 1,+#$0 +('+/()

    *+,-. ./+ 01- 2!,0-3 4050-454 56,724 72+,5- 4288/+0,!9 8-0,0,/!-+4

    5"'67$2&($ '1'8"%2$,9*%-84565789 +:;6?89 -@!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    2/40

    ? '@ABCDE>F "GF @H IJKL0 IK 71,1'1 IMI 5A

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    3/40

    ? 7ODF?S ,FNF?P 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 I

    ,FNF?Y?OF 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 b,RYYNCB @H NCERY?OF 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 II

    "CERY?OF 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 I\&1 %?PA@OS?OF A?CH@CYP G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP ARZUDGUB

    DO TD@UNFD@O @H IK 71,1'1 IML

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    4/40

    &:

    'NP?Ph'@OFDOR?S_ /NE?

    *:Z )595!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    5/40

    :

    ,FNFRF?Ph'@OFDOR?S_ /NE?

    IK 71,1'1 IML

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    6/40

    :&

    #DPG?UUNO?@RPh'@OFDOR?S_ /NE?

    /?F?C #?UU i -DY@F>B .CNOG?0 (NFD@ONU &OPF1 @H

    ,FNOSNCSP i -?G>10 71,1 +?A]F @H '@YY?CG?01=5N

    >?89 2;Y" `HHNOJI0 )B5 $(1) 05E?6?A?:6 :E +9:;@+:K=;A?6DFFA_jjGPCG1ODPF1E@TjARZUDGNFD@OPj

    ODPFARZPjeMMgI\fj,/eMMgI\f1ASH 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111 cI

    %?EDPF?C @H '@ABCDE>FP018A599?A5 .:K5 _?5X57 ,ZN

    A56

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    7/40

    F "GF]P ARZUDGgA?CH@CYNOG? CDE>F DO F>? G@OgF?WF @H O@T?U F?G>O@U@ED?P H@C FCNOPYDFFDOE NOS TD?QDOEG@ABCDE>F?S NRSD@TDPRNU Q@CVP RPDOE F>? &OF?CO?F1->? 7ODF?S ,FNF?P '@ABCDE>F *HHDG? DP C?PA@OPDZU? H@CNSYDODPF?CDOE F>? C?EDPFCNFD@O @H GC?NFDT? Q@CVP NOSH@C NSTDPDOE '@OEC?PP0 H?S?CNU NE?OGD?P0 F>? G@RCFP0NOS F>? ARZUDG @O G@ABCDE>F UNQ NOS A@UDGB1 IK 71,1'1KMI1 ->DP GNP? NUP@ DYAUDGNF?P YNFF?CP @H G@OG?CO F@@F>?C H?S?CNU NE?OGD?P G>NCE?S QDF> NSYDODPF?CDOEH?S?CNU UNQP E@T?CODOE DOF?UU?GFRNU AC@A?CFB0 F>? F?U?g

    TDPD@O DOSRPFCB0 NOS F>? &OF?CO?F1 ->? 7ODF?S ,FNF?PF>?C?H@C? >NP N PRZPFNOFDNU DOF?C?PF DO F>? '@RCF]PSDPA@PDFD@O @H F>DP GNP?1

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    8/40

    b

    4050-6-!0

    I1 ->? '@ABCDE>F "GF @H IJKL0 IK 71,1'1 IMI 5A ?'@ABCDE>F "GF @H IJMJ ECNOF?S NO ?WGURPDT? CDE>F F@A?CH@CY G?CFNDO G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP XARZUDGUB[ @C XDOARZUDG1[ IK 71,1'1 I

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    9/40

    c

    PRZPGCDZ?CP DO O?NCZB G@YYRODFD?P1 (@" NF cJIgcJb1->? '@RCF >?US F>NF F>@P? PBPF?YP SDS O@F XA?CH@CY[F>? G@ABCDE>F?S F?U?TDPD@O AC@ECNYP F>?B C?FCNOPYDFgF?S Z?GNRP? F>?B SDS XO@ Y@C? F>NO ?O>NOG?`a F>?

    TD?Q?C]P GNANGDFB F@ C?G?DT? F>? ZC@NSGNPF?C]P PDEONUP[ZB XAC@TDS`DOEa N Q?UUgU@GNF?S NOF?OON QDF> NO ?HHDgGD?OF G@OO?GFD@O F@ F>? TD?Q?C]P F?U?TDPD@O P?F1[ (@1 NFcJegcJJ1

    ,RZP?^R?OFUB0 DO )595=7:K=A57 +:7=" T1 +P1F (6>10\If 71,1 cJ\ ? '@RCF >?US F>NF GNZU? F?U?TDgPD@O PBPF?YP SDS O@F XA?CH@CY[ G@ABCDE>F?S AC@ECNYP?T?O Q>?O F>?B NUU@Q?S PRZPGCDZ?CP F@ TD?Q AC@gECNYYDOE @CDEDONUUB ZC@NSGNPF DO SDPFNOF GDFD?P1 ->?'@RCF C?NP@O?S F>NF XC?G?AFD@O NOS C?G>NOO?UDOE @H

    `ZC@NSGNPFa PDEONUP H@C PDYRUFNO?@RP TD?QDOE DP ?PP?OgFDNUUB N TD?Q?C HROGFD@O0 DCC?PA?GFDT? @H F>? SDPFNOG?Z?FQ??O F>? ZC@NSGNPFDOE PFNFD@O NOS F>? RUFDYNF?

    TD?Q?C1[ (@1 NF \Me13DONUUB0 DO )X56A?5AB +56A;7C \; +:7=1 T1 -?N

    W560 \bb 71,1 IfI ? '@RCF >?US F>NF N C?PFNRgCNOF @QO?C SDS O@F XA?CH@CY[ G@ABCDE>F?S YRPDGNU

    Q@CVP AUNB?S @T?C N CNSD@ DO >DP ?PFNZUDP>Y?OF1 ->?'@RCF ?WAUNDO?S F>NF *:7A6?DBA9C NOS )595=7:K=A57X?WAUDGDFUB SDPNT@Q?S F>? TD?Q F>NF F>? C?G?AFD@O @H NO?U?GFC@ODG ZC@NSGNPF GNO G@OPFDFRF? N A?CH@CYNOG?0[

    ?T?O DH F>? A?CP@O Q>@ C?G?DT?P F>? ZC@NSGNPF F>?OYNV?P DFP G@OF?OFP NTNDUNZU? F@ Y?YZ?CP @H F>? ARZUDG1

    (@"NF ILI1Z1 &O F>? '@ABCDE>F "GF @H IJKL0 '@OEC?PP C?g

    PA@OS?S F@ F>@P? S?GDPD@OP ZB NS@AFDOE ?WANOPDT?S?HDODFD@OP @H XA?CH@CY[ NOS XARZUDGUB1[ ->? "GFPFNF?P F>NF F@ XA?CH@CY[ NO NRSD@TDPRNU Q@CV Y?NOPXF@ P>@Q DFP DYNE?P DO NOB P?^R?OG? @C F@ YNV? F>?P@ROSP NGG@YANOBDOE DF NRSDZU?1[ IK 71,1'1 IMI1 ->?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    10/40

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    11/40

    f

    "UF>@RE> XA?CH@CY[ DP S?HDO?S ZC@NSUB ?O@RE> F@DOGURS? ?T?O F>? NGF @H FRCODOE @O N F?U?TDPD@O0 O@F>DOEDO F>? IJKL "GF C?PFCDGFP ACDTNF? A?CH@CYNOG?P @H G@AgBCDE>F?S Q@CVP1 ,?? IK 71,1'1 IML@US?C F>? ?WGURPDT? CDE>F XF@ A?CH@CY F>?G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CV =;Y9?>9C[

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    12/40

    L

    @H F>?DC Q@CVP F@ ANBDOE PRZPGCDZ?CP0 Q>DU? NUP@ AC@gY@FDOE F>? PAC?NS @H O?Q NOS RP?HRU Y?G>NODPYP H@CG@YYRODGNFDOE ZC@NSGNPF F?U?TDPD@O AC@ECNYYDOE F@F>? ARZUDG1

    b1 %?PA@OS?OF G>NCE?P G@OPRY?CP N Y@OF>UB PRZgPGCDAFD@O H?? F@ QNFG> ZC@NSGNPF F?U?TDPD@O AC@ECNYP@T?C F>? &OF?CO?F1 /?F1 "AA1 cN1 9>?O N PRZPGCDZ?C

    TDPDFP C?PA@OS?OF]P Q?ZPDF?0 P>? DP XAC?P?OF?S QDF> NAC@ECNYYDOE ERDS?[ F>NF UDPFP AC@ECNYP NDCDOE @T?CZC@NSGNPF PFNFD@OP DO >?C U@GNU NC?N1 (Y?@ 1 I &H P>?G>@@P?P F@ X9NFG>[ N AC@ECNY F>NF DP GRCC?OFUB NDCDOE0F>? AC@ECNY Z?EDOP AUNBDOE @O >?C G@YARF?C @C @F>?C&OF?CO?FgG@OO?GF?S S?TDG?1 (@" NF cNg\N1 &H F>? PRZgPGCDZ?C DOPF?NS G>@@P?P F@ X%?G@CS[ N AC@ECNY0 C?g

    PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y GC?NF?P NOS PF@C?P N SDEDFNU G@ABF>NF F>? PRZPGCDZ?C GNO TD?Q @T?C F>? &OF?CO?F NF NFDY? @H >?C G>@@PDOE1 (@"NF \NgfN1

    %?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y C?UD?P @O XF>@RPNOSP @H DOSDgTDSRNU NOF?OONP0[ ?NG> NZ@RF F>? PDm? @H N SDY?0 NCgCNOE?S @O XUNCE? NOF?OON Z@NCSP[ NF C?PA@OS?OF]PG?OFCNU HNGDUDFB1 /?F1 "AA1 LN1 9>?O N PRZPGCDZ?CP?U?GFP N F?U?TDPD@O AC@ECNY0 N G?OFCNUDm?S P?CT?CF?YA@CNCDUB XNPPDEOP @O? @H F>? DOSDTDSRNU NOF?OONP[F@ F>NF RP?C NOS FRO?P F>? NPPDEO?S NOF?OON F@ F>?NAAC@ACDNF? G>NOO?U1 (Y?@1 ->? NOF?OON C?G?DT?P F>?

    AC@ECNY0 Q>DG> DP XPNT?S F@ N UNCE? >NCS SCDT?[ NFC?PA@OS?OF]P HNGDUDFB DO N XSDC?GF@CB C?P?CT?S H@C[ F>?RP?C Q>@ C?^R?PF?S DF1 (@1 NF KN1 &H F>? RP?C G>@@P?PF@ C?G@CS F>? AC@ECNY0 F>? PBPF?Y XGC?NF?`Pa N G@YgAU?F? G@AB @H F>? AC@ECNY[ DO F>? RP?C]P SDC?GF@CB1

    (Y?@ 1 &H F>? RP?C G>@@P?P F@ QNFG> F>? AC@ECNY UDT?0

    I %?PA@OS?OF]P P?CTDG? QNP NTNDUNZU? @OUB DO (?Q ;@CV 'DFBQ>?O F>DP NGFD@O QNP ZC@RE>F0 ZRF DF >NP O@Q ?WANOS?S F@ NSSDFD@Og

    NU YNCV?FP1 /?F1 "AA1 cNl /?F1 ccgc\1

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    13/40

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    14/40

    e

    "AA1 fJN1 &F DP ROSDPARF?S F>NF A?FDFD@O?CP] G@ABCDE>Fg?S Q@CVP NC? FCNOPYDFF?S F@ C?PA@OS?OF]P PRZPGCDZ?CP@T?C C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y0 NOS F>NF C?PA@OS?OF S@?PO@F >NT? N UDG?OP? F@ A?CH@CY F>? G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVPARZUDGUB1 (@"NF cN1

    &O #NCG> bMIb0 A?FDFD@O?CP ZC@RE>F F>DP PRDF H@CG@ABCDE>F DOHCDOE?Y?OF DO F>? 7ODF?S ,FNF?P +DPFCDGF'@RCF H@C F>? ,@RF>?CO +DPFCDGF @H (?Q ;@CV1 /?F1

    "AA1 LMN1 /?FDFD@O?CP P@RE>F N AC?UDYDONCB DOdROGFD@OZNCCDOE C?PA@OS?OF HC@Y C?FCNOPYDFFDOE F>?DC G@ABgCDE>F?S F?U?TDPD@O AC@ECNYP Q>DU? F>@P? AC@ECNYP

    Q?C? Z?DOE ZC@NSGNPF @T?C F>? NDC1 (@" NF LMNgLIN1/?FDFD@O?CP G@OF?OS?S F>NF F>@P? G@OF?YA@CNO?@RPC?FCNOPYDPPD@OP G@OPFDFRF?S RONRF>@CDm?S ARZUDG A?Cg

    H@CYNOG?P DO TD@UNFD@O @H IK 71,1'1 IML? SDPgFCDGF G@RCF S?GUDO?S F@ ?OF?C NO DOdROGFD@O0 HDOSDOE F>NFA?FDFD@O?CP] GUNDY QNP H@C?GU@P?S ZB F>? ,?G@OS 'DCgGRDF]P S?GDPD@O DO +87A::6 $5AX:7W 32F 3332 T1 +1+

    .:9@?6D"0 fcL 31cS IbI

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    15/40

    J

    VO@QO NP N X k%?Y@F? ,F@CNE?] +DEDFNU :DS?@ %?G@CSg?C[

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    16/40

    IM

    TDSRNU FCNOPYDPPD@O1[ (Y?@" X&H F>NF FCNOPYDPPD@O DPkGNANZU? @H Z?DOE C?G?DT?S ZB F>? ARZUDG] F>? FCNOPYDPgPD@O DP N ARZUDG A?CH@CYNOG?l DH F>? A@F?OFDNU NRSD?OG?@H F>? FCNOPYDPPD@O DP @OUB @O? PRZPGCDZ?C0 F>? FCNOPgYDPPD@O DP O@F N ARZUDG A?CH@CYNOG?1[ (Y?@" ,?G@OS0NOS C?UNF?SUB0 XACDTNF? FCNOPYDPPD@OP n n n P>@RUSO@F Z? NEEC?ENF?S0[ NOS DF DP F>?C?H@C? XDCC?U?TNOF F@F>? -CNOPYDF 'UNRP? NONUBPDP Q>?F>?C F>? ARZUDG DPGNANZU? @H C?G?DTDOE F>? PNY? ROS?CUBDOE Q@CV @C@CDEDONU A?CH@CYNOG? @H F>? Q@CV ZB Y?NOP @H YNOBFCNOPYDPPD@OP1[ (Y?@" 3DONUUB0 XF>?C? DP NO ?WG?AFD@OF@ F>DP O@gNEEC?ENFD@O CRU? Q>?O ACDTNF? FCNOPYDPgPD@OP NC? E?O?CNF?S HC@Y F>? PNY? G@AB @H F>? Q@CV[lPRG> FCNOPYDPPD@OP X?B X?ONZU? F>? ARZUDG F@ TD?Q F>NF G@AB0 F>? FCNOPgYDPPD@OP NC? ARZUDG A?CH@CYNOG?P1[ (Y?@"\"AAUBDOE F>DP DOF?CAC?FNFD@O @H F>? -CNOPYDF

    'UNRP?0 F>? G@RCF @H NAA?NUP NEC??S QDF> F>? SDPFCDGFG@RCF F>NF C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y DP YNF?CDNUUB DOSDPFDOgERDP>NZU? HC@Y F>? %,g+:% PBPF?Y H@ROS F@ Z? O@OgDOHCDOEDOE DO +8Y95!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    17/40

    II

    PBPF?Y O@ODOHCDOEDOE ROS?C +8Y95!??NCDOE ?O ZNOG1 (@" NFIbeNgIffN1 &O NSSDFD@O F@ C?DF?CNFDOE F>? NCERY?OFPYNS? DO >DP ANO?U SDPP?OF0 5RSE? '>DO NCER?S F>NF+8Y95!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    18/40

    Ib

    F>@CP] CDE>F F@ Z? G@YA?OPNF?S H@C F>? ?WAU@DFNFD@O @HF>? HCRDFP @H F>?DC UNZ@CP1 7OS?C F>? IJKL "GF0 N G@YgANOB F>NF C?FCNOPYDFP G@ABCDE>F?S ZC@NSGNPF F?U?TDgPD@O AC@ECNYP YRPF @ZFNDO N UDG?OP?0 F>@RE> ^RNUDHBgDOE C?FCNOPYDPPD@O P?CTDG?P YNB NTNDU F>?YP?UT?P @HF>? S?FNDU?S PFNFRF@CB UDG?OPDOE PG>?Y?P ?PFNZUDP>?SZB '@OEC?PP1 %?PA@OS?OF]P RONRF>@CDm?S &OF?CO?FC?FCNOPYDPPD@OP TD@UNF? F>?P? PFNFRF@CB C?^RDC?Y?OFPNOS DOHCDOE? A?FDFD@O?CP] ARZUDGgA?CH@CYNOG? CDE>FPROS?C IK 71,1'1 IML? dRSEY?OF Z?U@Q O??S O@F GNUU DOF@ ^R?PFD@O F>?U?EDFDYNGB @H DOO@TNFDT? F?G>O@U@ED?P F>NF NUU@Q G@OgPRY?CP F@ RP? F>? &OF?CO?F F@ PF@C?0 >?NC0 NOS TD?Q

    F>?DC @QO UNQHRUUB NG^RDC?S G@AD?P @H G@ABCDE>F?SQ@CVP1&1 %?PA@OS?OF FCNOPYDFP G@ABCDE>F?S ZC@NSGNPF

    AC@ECNYP F@ F>? ARZUDG0 QDF>@RF F>? NRF>@CDmNFD@O @HF>? G@ABCDE>F >@US?CP0 NOS DP F>?C?H@C? UDNZU? H@C DOgHCDOE?Y?OF1

    "1 %?PA@OS?OF XA?CH@CYP[ G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP1%?PA@OS?OF NCER?P F>NF0 Z?GNRP? NO DOSDTDSRNU PRZgPGCDZ?C S?F?CYDO?P Q>NF G@OF?OF P>? QDUU C?G?DT? NOS

    Q>?O0 DF DP F>? PRZPGCDZ?C CNF>?C F>NO C?PA@OS?OFDFP?UH F>NF XFCNOPYDFP[ F>? ZC@NSGNPF AC@ECNYYDOE1 &O

    N TNCD?FB @H GDCGRYPFNOG?P0 >@Q?T?C0 G@YY?CGDNU NGgF@CP XFCNOPYDF[ @C @F>?CQDP? XA?CH@CY[ G@ABCDE>F?S

    Q@CVP0 ?T?O F>@RE> F>?B S@ P@ NF F>? Z?>?PF @H DOSDgTDSRNU GRPF@Y?CP1

    %?PA@OS?OF Z@F> @QOP NOS NGFDT?UB G@OFC@UP F>? DOgSDTDSRNU NOF?OONP0 G?OFCNUDm?S P?CT?CP0 NOS P@HFQNC?F>NF @A?CNF? F@E?F>?C F@ C?G?DT? ZC@NSGNPF PDEONUP NOSFCNOPYDF G@ABCDE>F?S G@OF?OF F@ F>? ARZUDG1 ->? HROGgFD@ODOE @H F>NF DOF?ECNF?S PBPF?Y S?A?OSP PRZPFNOFDNUg

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    19/40

    Ic

    UB @O A>BPDGNU ?^RDAY?OF F>NF DP RP?S DO G@YY@O ZBC?PA@OS?OF]P PRZPGCDZ?CP1 %?PA@OS?OF @ZP?CT?P F>NF0HC@Y F>? PRZPGCDZ?C]P A?CPA?GFDT?0 C?PA@OS?OF]P P?Cg

    TDG? AC@TDS?P PRZPFNOFDNUUB F>? PNY? HROGFD@ONUDFB F>NFG@OPRY?CP G@RUS @ZFNDO ZB ARCG>NPDOE ?^RDAY?OF H@CF>?DC >@Y?P1 &O ?ONGFDOE F>? IJKL '@ABCDE>F "GFNY?OSY?OFP0 >@Q?T?C0 '@OEC?PP @T?CC@S? S?GDPD@OP@H F>DP '@RCF F>NF SC?Q @O F>? PNY? NONU@EB1 &O NAgAUBDOE F>? '@ABCDE>F "GF DO DFP GRCC?OF H@CY0 F>? Y@C?DYA@CFNOF HROGFD@ONU ?^RDTNU?OG? DP Z?FQ??O C?PA@OSg?OF NOS F>? GNZU? PBPF?YP F>NF F>? IJKL '@OEC?PPZC@RE>F QDF>DO F>? '@ABCDE>F "GF]P ARCTD?Q1

    )1 %?PA@OS?OF FCNOPYDFP A?CH@CYNOG?P @H G@ABgCDE>F?S ZC@NSGNPF AC@ECNYYDOE XF@ F>? ARZUDG1[ 3@C

    F>?P? ARCA@P?P0 F>? F?CY XA?CH@CYNOG?[ ?OG@YANPP?PY:ABF>? NUU?E?SUB DOHCDOEDOE FCNOPYDPPD@OP F>?YP?UT?P86@ NOB ROS?CUBDOE A?CH@CYNOG?P0 PRG> NP F>? O?Fg

    Q@CV ZC@NSGNPF1 )?GNRP? C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y FCNOPgYDFP F>? PNY? ROS?CUBDOE A?CH@CYNOG?P F@ ORY?C@RPPRZPGCDZ?CP0 F>? PBPF?Y DP GU?NCUB DOHCDOEDOE1 &O NOB?T?OF0 ?T?O DH C?PA@OS?OF Q?C? G@CC?GF F>NF DFP @QOFCNOPYDPPD@OP NC? F>? @OUB C?U?TNOF XA?CH@CYNOG?P0[F>@P? FCNOPYDPPD@OP F>?YP?UT?P NC? YNS? XF@ F>?ARZUDG[ QDF>DO F>? Y?NODOE @H F>? -CNOPYDF 'UNRP?1

    "UF>@RE> ?NG> FCNOPYDPPD@O DP RUFDYNF?UB P?OF @OUB F@

    N PDOEU? DOSDTDSRNU0 F>@P? FCNOPYDPPD@OP NC? 8!8?98Y95F@ NOB Y?YZ?C @H F>? ARZUDG Q>@ DP QDUUDOE F@ ANB F>?Y@OF>UB H??1

    '@OFCNCB F@ F>? G@RCF @H NAA?NUP] PREE?PFD@O0 FC?NFgDOE C?PA@OS?OF NP NO DOHCDOE?C Q@RUS O@F GNUU DOF@^R?PFD@O F>? U?ENUDFB @H ARC?UB ACDTNF? A?CH@CYNOG?P0PRG> NP NO DOSDTDSRNU]P FCNOPYDPPD@O @H N UNQHRUUBgNG^RDC?S G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CV F@ >DYP?UH

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    20/40

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    21/40

    If

    AC@Y@FDOE DOO@TNFD@O DO O?Q G@YYRODGNFD@O F?G>O@U@gED?P ZB UDYDFDOE F>? DOGDS?OG? @H UDNZDUDFB H@C G@ABCDE>FDOHCDOE?Y?OF1[ \5A7:N4:9@XC6N\8C57 1A;@?:< (6>" T147:W? ARZUDG1 %?PA@OS?OF0 ZB G@OFCNPF0 S?PGCDZ?PDFP?UH O@F NP N C?FCNOPYDFF?C0 ZRF NP N AC@TDS?C @H A>BPgDGNU ?^RDAY?OF F>C@RE> Q>DG> DFP PRZPGCDZ?CP NG^RDC?

    ZC@NSGNPF AC@ECNYYDOE NOS FCNOPYDF DF F@ F>?YP?UT?P@T?C F>? &OF?CO?F1

    ->? AC@A?C C?P@URFD@O @H F>DP SDPARF? DP PFCNDE>FgH@CQNCS1 7OUDV? N ARCT?B@C @H >@Y? NOF?OONP0 @C F>?U?PP@C @H >DUUF@A PANG? @O Q>DG> DOSDTDSRNU G@OPRY?CPYNB ?C?GF F>?DC @QO NOF?OONP ?C AC@A?CFB F>NF HNGDUDFNF?P GRPF@Y?CP] C?G?AFD@O@H ZC@NSGNPF PDEONUP1 %NF>?C0 C?PA@OS?OF @A?CNF?P NO

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    22/40

    IL

    DOF?ECNF?S NC?S RP? @HG@YY@O HNGDUDFD?P1 ->? HNGF F>NF NP ANCF @H F>NF PBPF?YC?PA@OS?OF RP?P ROD^R? G@AD?P NOS YNOB DOSDTDSRNUFCNOPYDPPD@OP S@?P O@F NUF?C F>? G@OGURPD@O F>NF DF DPC?FCNOPYDFFDOE ZC@NSGNPF G@OF?OF XF@ F>? ARZUDG1[2DV? DFP G@YA?FDF@CP0 C?PA@OS?OF F>?C?H@C? YRPF @ZgFNDO UDG?OP?P F@ A?CH@CY F>? G@ABCDE>F?S G@OF?OF @O

    Q>DG> DFP ZRPDO?PP C?UD?P1 ->NF G@OGURPD@O0 >@Q?T?C0P>@RUS O@F GNUU DOF@ ^R?PFD@O F>? U?EDFDYNGB @H ZRPDgO?PP?P F>NF RP? F>? &OF?CO?F F@ AC@TDS? O?Q QNBP H@CG@OPRY?CP F@ PF@C?0 >?NC0 NOS TD?Q F>?DC @QO UNQHRUUBNG^RDC?S G@AD?P @H G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP1

    ,# +-48/!3-!0 8-+./+64 7/84

    82*;,7;< ,! ?,/;50,/! /. %@ 2#4#7# %A)B(C

    %?PA@OS?OF S@?P O@F SDPARF? F>NF F>? FCNOPYDPgPD@OP @H ZC@NSGNPF AC@ECNYYDOE HC@Y DFP G?OFCNU HNGDUgDFB F@ PRZPGCDZ?CP G@OPFDFRF? A?CH@CYNOG?P QDF>DO F>?Y?NODOE @H F>? '@ABCDE>F "GF1 &OPF?NS0 C?PA@OS?OFS?OD?P F>NF ?A FCNOPYDFP F>? G@ABCDE>F?S YNF?CDNU1 *OC?PA@OS?OF]P TD?Q0 DF PDYAUB AC@TDS?P PRZPGCDZ?CP QDF>NGG?PP F@ A>BPDGNU ?^RDAY?OF0 Q>DG> F>? PRZPGCDZ?CPRP? F@ GNAFRC? ZC@NSGNPF PDEONUP NOS F@ FCNOPYDF F>?G@ABCDE>F?S G@OF?OF F@ F>?YP?UT?P1

    "UF>@RE> F>? G@RCF @H NAA?NUP CRU?S DO C?PA@OS?OF]PHNT@C0 DF SDS O@F S?GDS? F>? GNP? @O F>NF F>?@CB1 -@ F>?G@OFCNCB0 F>? G@RCF S?GDS?S F>? GNP? @O F>? NPPRYAgFD@O F>NF X`C?PA@OS?OFa FCNOPYDFP F@ DFP PRZPGCDZ?CPZC@NSGNPF F?U?TDPD@O AC@ECNYP @T?C F>? DOF?CO?F H@C NY@OF>UB PRZPGCDAFD@O H??1[ /?F1 "AA1 cN1f ->? G@RCF

    f 2DV? F>? G@RCF @H NAA?NUP0 F>? SDPFCDGF G@RCF SDS O@F NSSC?PPC?PA@OS?OF]P NCERY?OF F>NF XDF DP kF>? G@OPRY?C0 O@F `C?PA@OS?OFa0

    Q>@ YNV?P F>? FCNOPYDPPD@OP] [ NF DPPR? >?C?1 /?F1 "AA1 IMKN1

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    23/40

    IK

    O?T?CF>?U?PP >?US F>NF C?PA@OS?OF SDS O@F DOHCDOE?A?FDFD@O?CP] ARZUDGgA?CH@CYNOG? CDE>FP Z?GNRP? F>?G@RCF TD?Q?S ?NG> @H C?PA@OS?OF]P FCNOPYDPPD@OP NP NP?ANCNF? ACDTNF? A?CH@CYNOG?1

    )@F> @H F>@P? CNFD@ONU?P UNGV Y?CDF1 2DV? F>? GNZU?F?U?TDPD@O PBPF?YP NF DPPR? DO *:7A6?DBA9C +:7=" T1/6?A5@ -7A?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    24/40

    Ie

    F>NF F>? IJKL '@OEC?PP P@RE>F F@ ZCDOE QDF>DO F>?'@ABCDE>F "GF]P ARCTD?Q0 C?PA@OS?OF DP U?ENUUB C?gPA@OPDZU? H@C FCNOPYDFFDOE F>? G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP DFPP?CT?CP P?OS F@ PRZPGCDZ?CP1

    I1 %?PA@OS?OF ?YA>NPDm?P F>NF DOSDTDSRNU PRZgPGCDZ?CP G@OFC@U Q>?O DFP NOF?OONP NC? NGFDT?0 P?U?GFF>? PA?GDHDG G>NOO?UP F>? NOF?OONP C?G?DT?0 NOS SDGFNF?

    Q>?O F>? PBPF?Y FCNOPYDFP A?CH@CYNOG?P @H F?U?TDPD@OAC@ECNYP F@ PRZPGCDZ?CP1 %?PA1 )C1 IKgIe1 %?PA@OSg?OF G@OF?OSP @O F>NF ZNPDP F>NF DF DP F>? DOSDTDSRNUPRZPGCDZ?C0 CNF>?C F>NO C?PA@OS?OF0 XQ>@ ?YAU@BP`C?PA@OS?OF]Pa PBPF?Y F@ FCNOPYDF ZC@NSGNPF AC@gECNYYDOE F@ >?CP?UH1[ (@1 NF IKl P?? ?@1 NF I\

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    25/40

    IJ

    NTNDUNZU? @O S?YNOS @T?C F>? &OF?CO?F1 /?F1 "AA1 ffNO1f1 "UU @H F>?P? P?CTDG?P DOT@UT? F>? FCNOPYDPPD@O @HG@OF?OF @OUB @O F>? G@YYNOS @H F>? DOSDTDSRNU RP?C0

    Q>@ G>@@P?P Q>DG> G@OF?OF F@ AUNB NOS Q>?O F@ Z?EDOAUNBDOE DF1 &F DP O?T?CF>?U?PP F>?P? ZRPDO?PP?P0 CNF>?CF>NO F>?DC GRPF@Y?CP0 F>NF XFCNOPYDF[ NOS F>?C?ZBXA?CH@CY[ F>? C?U?TNOF G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP1 ,??&87657 P7:NF `N PFC?NYDOE P?CTDG?]Pa GRPF@Y?CPDODFDNF? F>? FCNOPYDPPD@O ZB FRCODOE @O F>?DC G@YARFg?CP NOS G>@@PDOE `F>? G@OF?OFa F>?B QDP> F@ TD?Q DPDYYNF?CDNU[ F@ F>? DOHCDOE?Y?OF NONUBPDP=1 L "GG@CSgDOEUB0 F>? Y?C? HNGF F>NF C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y C?g

    PA@OSP NRF@YNFDGNUUB F@ RP?C G@YYNOSP GNOO@F ?Wg?YAF C?PA@OS?OF HC@Y SDC?GF UDNZDUDFB H@C FCNOPYDFFDOEG@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP1

    b1 *O F>? @F>?C >NOS0 @QO?CP>DA @H F>? A>BPDGNU?^RDAY?OF ZB Q>DG> N A?CH@CYNOG? DP NGG@YAUDP>?SS@?P O@F NUQNBP S?F?CYDO? Q>@ A?CH@CYP N G@ABCDE>Fg?S Q@CV1 9>?O NO DOSDTDSRNU AUNBP >DP @QO '+ @HG@ABCDE>F?S YRPDG @O F>? P@ROS PBPF?Y @H N C?OF?SGNC0 F>NF DOSDTDSRNU0 CNF>?C F>NO F>? C?OFNU G@YANOB0A?CH@CYP F>? G@ABCDE>F?S P@OEP1 )B F>? PNY? F@V?O0XF>? @QO?C @H N FCNSDFD@ONU G@ABDOE YNG>DO? Q>@P?

    GRPF@Y?CP ANB N HDW?S NY@ROF A?C G@AB NOS @A?CNF?F>? YNG>DO? F>?YP?UT?P[ DP O@F SDC?GFUB UDNZU? H@CDOHCDOEDOE F>? C?AC@SRGFD@O CDE>F Q>?O N GRPF@Y?CSRAUDGNF?P N G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CV1 +:1A87 47="F (6>" T1

    L ,DYDUNCUB0 DH N Y@TD? F>?NF?C]P A@UDGB DP F@ P>@Q N HDUY @OUB Q>?O

    N GRPF@Y?C DP AC?P?OF0 NOS N PDOEU? ANFC@O ARCG>NP?P N FDGV?F0 F>?

    HDUY ANFC@O S@?P O@F F>?C?ZB XA?CH@CY[ F>? HDUY1 %NF>?C0 F>?F>?NF?C A?CH@CYP F>? HDUY ZB P>@QDOE F>? DYNE?P @H F>? HDUY NOS

    YNVDOE DFP P@ROSP NRSDZU?1 ,??IK 71,1'1 IMI

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    26/40

    bM

    3::=$5AF (6>" 0 cKc 31cS f\\0 ffM 'DC1 bMM\=1 %?gPA@OS?OF]P @QO?CP>DA @H F>? NOF?OONP NOS @F>?C A>BPgDGNU ?^RDAY?OF U@GNF?S NF DFP G?OFCNU HNGDUDFB F>?C?H@C?S@?P O@F0 ZB DFP?UH0 G@YA?U F>? G@OGURPD@O F>NF C?gPA@OS?OF ?C F>NO DFP GRPF@Y?CP= FCNOPYDFP0 NOSF>?C?ZB A?CH@CYP0 F>? G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP1

    c1 %?PA@OS?OF0 >@Q?T?C0 O@F @OUB @QOP0 ZRF NGFDT?gUB G@OFC@UP0 F>? PBPF?Y @H NOF?OONP0 G?OFCNUDm?S P?CTg?CP0 NOS P@HFQNC? F>NF C?G?DT?P ZC@NSGNPF PDEONUP NOSFCNOPYDFP G@OF?OF F@ F>? RP?C1 ->? SDPFCDGF G@RCFH@ROS F>NF C?PA@OS?OF]P XNOF?OONP HROGFD@O DOS?gA?OS?OFUB0[ DO F>? P?OP? F>NF X?NG> NOF?OON P?ANCNF?UB75>5?!5? DOG@YDOE ZC@NSGNPF PDEONU0 CNF>?C F>NOHROGFD@ODOE G@UU?GFDT?UB QDF> F>? @F>?C NOF?OONP @C

    QDF> F>? NPPDPFNOG? @H F>? P>NC?S Y?FNU PRZPFCRGFRC?1[/?F1 "AA1 KcN

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    27/40

    bI

    YNOG?P @H G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP DO N QNB F>NF Y?C??^RDAY?OF PRAAUD?CP GU?NCUB S@ O@F1

    $T?O DH C?PA@OS?OF]P NOF?OONP Q?C? TD?Q?S DO DP@gUNFD@O HC@Y F>? @F>?C G?OFCNUDm?S ?^RDAY?OF RP?S DOF>? FCNOPYDFFDOE AC@G?PP0 NOB NONU@EB F@ ARCT?B@CP @H>@Y? NOF?OONP Q@RUS Z? DONAF1 &F DP FCR? F>NF0 NF NOBY@Y?OF DO FDY?0 ?NG> PRZPGCDZ?C Q>@ DP U@EE?S DOF@F>? PBPF?Y DP NPPDEO?S N SDPGC?F? NOF?OON1 ->NFROD^R? NPPDEOY?OF @GGRCP0 >@Q?T?C0 @OUB NHF?C F>?PRZPGCDZ?C >NP U@EE?S DO NOS >NP C?^R?PF?S N FCNOPgYDPPD@O @H N ANCFDGRUNC G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CV1 ,?? /?F1

    "AA1 cN0 LN1 "OS Q>?O F>NF PRZPGCDZ?C DP O@ U@OE?CG@OO?GF?S F@ C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y ?CPRZPGCDAFD@O=0 C?PA@OS?OF]P G@YARF?CDm?S P?CT?C YNB

    C?NPPDEO F>? PNY? NOF?OON F@ N SDHH?C?OF PRZPGCDZ?ChF>NF DP0 N SDHH?C?OF ANBDOE PFCNOE?C1 (@"NF eN O1Kl ?@"NF \\N ?ZC@NS S?HDODFD@OP @H XA?CH@CY[ NOS XFCNOPYDF[ DO F>?IJKL "GF F@ @T?CFRCO F>? C?PRUFP @H F>DP '@RCF]P S?GDg

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    28/40

    bb

    PD@OP NAAUBDOE F>? PNY? U@EDG @O Q>DG> C?PA@OS?OFO@Q C?UD?P1

    &O *:7A6?DBA9C0 F>? '@RCF O@F?S F>NF GNZU? PBPF?YPXC?G?DT?`Sa AC@ECNYP F>NF >N`Sa Z??O C?U?NP?S F@ F>?ARZUDG[ ZB ZC@NSGNPF NOS Y?C?UB X?O>NOG?`Sa F>?

    TD?Q?C]P GNANGDFB F@ C?G?DT? F>? ZC@NSGNPF?C]P PDEONUP[ZB AC@TDSDOE XN Q?UUgU@GNF?S NOF?OON QDF> NO ?HHDGD?OFG@OO?GFD@O F@ F>? TD?Q?C]P F?U?TDPD@O P?F1[ cJb 71,1 NFcJJg\MM1 &O )595=7:K=A570 F>? '@RCF C?NP@O?S F>NFX`Qa>?O N F?U?TDPD@O ZC@NSGNPF?C FCNOPYDFP N AC@ECNY0DF >NP YNS? ARZUDG H@C PDYRUFNO?@RP TD?QDOE NOS >?NCgDOE F>? G@OF?OFP @H F>NF AC@ECNY1[ \If 71,1 NF \Me1->? '@RCF G@OGURS?S F>NF X`Fa>? ACDTDU?E? @H C?G?DTDOEF>? ZC@NSGNPF ?U?GFC@ODG PDEONUP NOS @H G@OT?CFDOE

    F>?Y DOF@ F>? PDE>FP NOS P@ROSP @H F>? AC@ECNY DOg>?C?P DO NUU Y?YZ?CP @H F>? ARZUDG Q>@ >NT? F>? Y?NOP@H S@DOE P@1[ (Y?@1

    ->? IJKL "GF @T?CFRCO?S F>@P? S?GDPD@OP0 YNVDOEGU?NC F>NF N G@YANOB GNO XA?CH@CY[ G@ABCDE>F?S

    Q@CVP QDF>DO F>? Y?NODOE @H F>? '@ABCDE>F "GF ?T?OQ>?O DF PDYAUB C?FCNOPYDFP ZC@NSGNPF PDEONUP F@ G@OgPRY?CP Q>@ G@RUS >NT? NG^RDC?S F>?Y H@C HC?? @T?CF>? NDCQNT?P1 ,?? *:Z )595!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    29/40

    bc

    @F>?C Y?NOP0 C?PA@OS?OF F>?C?H@C? DP XA?CH@CYDOE[F>? ZC@NSGNPF AC@ECNYP QDF>DO F>? Y?NODOE @H F>?'@ABCDE>F "GF1

    *# +DEF"GHDGI 0KTGEMPIE 8DKL"KMTGUDE /L 7"FOKPQRIDH*K"THUTEI 8K"QKTMMPGQ J0" 0RD 8VWXPUN

    I1 7OS?C F>? -CNOPYDF 'UNRP?0 N G@YANOB XA?CgH@CY`Pa @C SDPAUNB`Pa[ N Q@CV XARZUDGUB[ DH DF

    FCNOPYDF`Pa @C @F>?CQDP? G@YYRODGNF?`Pa N A?CH@CgYNOG? @C SDPAUNB @H F>? Q@CV n n n F@ F>? ARZgUDG0 ZB Y?NOP @H NOB S?TDG? @C AC@G?PP0 Q>?F>?C F>?Y?YZ?CP @H F>? ARZUDG GNANZU? @H C?G?DTDOE F>? A?CgH@CYNOG? @C SDPAUNB C?G?DT? DF DO F>? PNY? AUNG? @CDO P?ANCNF? AUNG?P NOS NF F>? PNY? FDY? @C NF SDHg

    H?C?OF FDY?P1IK 71,1'1 IMI1 7OS?C F>NF S?HDODFD@O0 F>? F?CY XA?CgH@CYNOG?[ ?OG@YANPP?P Y:AB F>? FCNOPYDPPD@O @CG@YYRODGNFD@O F@ F>? ?T?OFRNU TD?Q?C @C UDPF?O?C 86@NOB ROS?CUBDOE A?CH@CYNOG? F>NF DP FCNOPYDFF?S @CG@YYRODGNF?S1 *F>?C '@ABCDE>F "GF AC@TDPD@OP G@OgHDCY F>DP DOF?CAC?FNFD@O1 3@C ?WNYAU?0 IK 71,1'1 III0

    Q>DG> C?ERUNF?P F>? C?FCNOPYDPPD@O @H ZC@NSGNPF PDEgONUP0 C?A?NF?SUB C?H?CP F@ X`Fa>? P?G@OSNCB FCNOPYDPgPD@O :E 8 =57E:7K86>5 :7 @?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    30/40

    b\

    Q>?O?T?C >? @C P>? n n n G@YYRODGNF?P F>?A?CH@CYNOG? ZB FRCODOE @O N C?G?DTDOE P?F1

    IJKL 8@RP? %?A@CF Lc1 ->RP0 Q>?O N GNZU? G@YANOB

    C?FCNOPYDFP N U@GNU ZC@NSGNPF PDEONU ROS?C F>? GDCGRYgPFNOG?P S?PGCDZ?S DO F>? NZ@T?g^R@F?S ANPPNE?0 F>?PFNFRF@CB F?CY XA?CH@CYNOG?[ ?OG@YANPP?P F>? GNZU?G@YANOB]P @QO C?FCNOPYDPPD@O0 NP Q?UU NP F>? ROS?CUBgDOE A?CH@CYNOG?P ?YZ@SD?S DO F>? U@GNU ZC@NSGNPF NOSF>? PDOE?C]P @CDEDONU C?OSDFD@O1

    "P P?T?CNU G@RCFP @RFPDS? F>? ,?G@OS 'DCGRDF >NT?G@OGURS?S0 C?PA@OS?OF NOS AC@TDS?CP @H PDYDUNC P?Cg

    TDG?P NC? AUNDOUB ?OENE?S DO ARZUDG A?CH@CYNOG?P QDF>gDO F>? Y?NODOE @H ,?GFD@O IMI1 ,?? +:KK;6?AC )595N!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    31/40

    bf

    TDG?[=1 "OS0 ROS?C F>? AUNDO F?CYP @H ,?GFD@O IMI0 F>?HNGF F>NF C?PA@OS?OF]P PRZPGCDZ?CP C?G?DT? F>? A?CH@CgYNOG? XDO P?ANCNF? AUNG?P[ NOS XNF SDHH?C?OF FDY?P[S@?P O@F NUF?C F>? ARZUDG G>NCNGF?C @H C?PA@OS?OF]PA?CH@CYNOG?P1

    ->? ZC@NS PFNFRF@CB S?HDODFD@O @H XFCNOPYDF[ HRCgF>?C G@OHDCYP F>DP G@OGURPD@O1 X-@ kFCNOPYDF] N A?CgH@CYNOG? @C SDPAUNB DP F@ G@YYRODGNF? DF ZB NOB S?TDG?@C AC@G?PP Q>?C?ZB DYNE?P @C P@ROSP NC? C?G?DT?SZ?B@OS F>? AUNG? HC@Y Q>DG> F>?B NC? P?OF1[ IK 71,1'1IMI1 "OS N XS?TDG?[ @C XAC@G?PP[ DP S?HDO?S F@ DOGURS?X@O? O@Q VO@QO @C UNF?C S?T?U@A?S1[ (Y?@" ->?P?S?HDODFD@OP NC? XZC@NS ?O@RE> F@ DOGURS? NUU G@OG?DTNgZU? H@CYP NOS G@YZDONFD@OP @H QDC?S @C QDC?U?PP G@Yg

    YRODGNFD@OP Y?SDN0 DOGURSDOE ZRF ZB O@ Y?NOP UDYDF?SF@ CNSD@ NOS F?U?TDPD@O ZC@NSGNPFDOE NP Q? VO@QF>?Y1[ IJKL 8@RP? %?A@CF L\1 '@OEC?PP YNB O@F>NT? ?OTDPD@O?S F>? S?FNDUP @H C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y @HYDODNFRC? NOF?OONP0 UNCE? >NCS SCDT?P0 NOS &OF?CO?FPFC?NYDOE Q>?O DF ?ONGF?S F>? PFNFRF? DO IJKL1 ->?'@ABCDE>F "GF]P ZC@NS0 F?G>O@U@EBgO?RFCNU S?HDODFD@OPYNV? GU?NC0 >@Q?T?C0 F>NF C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y @HDOSDTDSRNUDm?S SDEDFNU FCNOPYDPPD@OP G@OPFDFRF?P N XS?g

    TDG? @C AC@G?PP[ H@C G@YYRODGNFDOE F>? A?CH@CYNOG?P?YZ@SD?S DO F?U?TDPD@O ZC@NSGNPFP F@ F>? ARZUDG1 "P

    5RSE? '>DO ?WAUNDO?S0 @O? XGNO kFCNOPYDF][ QDF>DO F>?Y?NODOE @H F>? PFNFRF? XZB P?OSDOE @O? FCNOPYDPPD@O@C YRUFDAU? FCNOPYDPPD@OP1[ /?F1 "AA1 I\KNgI\eN1

    b1 ->? G@RCF @H NAA?NUP C?NG>?S N G@OFCNCB C?PRUFZNP?S @O +8Y95!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    32/40

    bL

    UBDOE Q@CV Z?DOE FCNOPYDFF?S ZRF CNF>?C F@ F>? FCNOPgYDPPD@O DFP?UH0 PDOG? F>? kFCNOPYDPPD@O @H N A?CH@CgYNOG? DP DFP?UH N A?CH@CYNOG?1] [ /?F1 "AA1 IeN

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    33/40

    bK

    EU? C?OSDFD@O @H N G@ABCDE>F?S P?U?GFD@O HC@Y C?PRUFDOEDO Y@C? F>NO @O? ARZUDG A?CH@CYNOG?[=1 ->NF DP ROg^R?PFD@ONZUB FCR? @H C?PA@OS?OF]P FCNOPYDPPD@OP0 ?NG>@H Q>DG> G@OFNDOP F>? ACD@C A?CH@CYNOG? ZB F>? U@GNUZC@NSGNPF?C ? G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVPARZUDGUB0 ?T?O F>@RE> ?NG> @H C?PA@OS?OF]P FCNOPYDPgPD@OP E@?P F@ N PDOEU? PRZPGCDZ?C1

    ->? G@RCF @H NAA?NUP] DOF?CAC?FNFD@O SDPC?ENCSP F>?ROS?CUBDOE A?CH@CYNOG?P NOS DOPF?NS FC?NFP F>? A?CgH@CYNOG? GC?NF?S ZB F>? NGF @H FCNOPYDPPD@O NP F>?:69C XA?CH@CYNOG?[ ?OG@YANPP?S ZB F>? -CNOPYDF'UNRP?1 ->? C?U?TNOF S?HDODFD@ONU AC@TDPD@O PA?GDHD?P0

    >@Q?T?C0 F>NF N G@YANOB A?CH@CYP N G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVARZUDGUB Q>?O?T?C DF XFCNOPYDF`Pa @C @F>?CQDP? G@YgYRODGNF?`Pa 8 A?CH@CYNOG? @C SDPAUNB @H F>? Q@CV[ F@F>? ARZUDG1 IK 71,1'1 IMI

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    34/40

    be

    F>?O FCNOPYDFP F>NF C?G@CSDOE F@ N F?U?TDPD@O DO NO@F>g?C C@@Y0 >? Q@RUS Z? ARZUDGUB A?CH@CYDOE F>? Q@CVZ?GNRP? P@Y? @F>?C ANCFB0 ONY?UB F>? @CDEDONU ZC@NSgGNPF?C0 >NS @OG? FCNOPYDFF?S F>? PNY? A?CH@CYNOG? F@F>? ARZUDG1[ (Y?@" %?PA@OS?OF ?G>@?P F>? PNY? @Zd?GgFD@O1 %?PA1 )C1 IcgI\1 )RF F>DP G@OG?CO C?PFP @O NYDPROS?CPFNOSDOE @H F>? PFNFRF?1 "UF>@RE> F>? -CNOPgYDF 'UNRP? ?OG@YANPP?P F>? FCNOPYDPPD@O @C G@YYRgODGNFD@O @H NO ROS?CUBDOE A?CH@CYNOG?0 DF DYA@P?PUDNZDUDFB @OUB @O ANCFD?P Q>@ XFCNOPYDF @C @F>?CQDP?G@YYRODGNF?[ F>NF A?CH@CYNOG? XF@ F>? ARZUDG1[ IK71,1'1 IMIl P?? IK 71,1'1 IML

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    35/40

    bJ

    f1 &H F>?C? Q?C? NOB S@RZF NZ@RF F>? AC@A?C NAAUDgGNFD@O @H F>? PFNFRF@CB F?WF F@ C?PA@OS?OF]P PBPF?Y0 DFP>@RUS Z? C?P@UT?S ZB F>? G@OF?WF NOS YNODH?PF ARCgA@P? @H F>? C?U?TNOF AC@TDPD@OP @H F>? IJKL "GF1 '@OgEC?PP G@OGURS?S F>NF XGNZU? PBPF?YP NC? G@YY?CGDNU?OF?CACDP?P Q>@P? ZNPDG C?FCNOPYDPPD@O @A?CNFD@OP NC?ZNP?S @O F>? GNCCDNE? @H G@ABCDE>F?S AC@ECNY YNF?CDgNU0[ NOS F>NF XG@ABCDE>F C@BNUFD?P P>@RUS Z? ANDS ZBGNZU? @A?CNF@CP F@ F>? GC?NF@CP @H PRG> AC@ECNYP1[IJKL 8@RP? %?A@CF eJ1 &H C?PA@OS?OF RP?S N PDOEU?YNPF?C NOF?OON F@ FCNOPYDF F?U?TDPD@O AC@ECNYYDOE F@F>@RPNOSP @H PRZPGCDZ?CP0 DF GU?NCUB Q@RUS HROGFD@O NP NC?FCNOPYDPPD@O PBPF?Y PRZd?GF F@ UDNZDUDFB ROS?C F>?'@ABCDE>F "GF1 %?PA@OS?OF P??VP F@ NGG@YAUDP> F>?

    PNY? C?PRUF ZB YNDOFNDODOE F>@RPNOSP @H DOSDTDSRNUNOF?OONP DOPF?NS @H @O?1 )RF ?T?O DH F>? PFNFRF@CBUNOERNE? G@RUS Z?NC N G@OPFCRGFD@O ROS?C Q>DG> F>NFF?G>ODGNU S?FNDU ?W?YAF?S C?PA@OS?OF HC@Y F>? "GF]PG@T?CNE?0 F>NF PRC?UB DP O@F F>? ONFRCNU C?NSDOEhNOSC?PA@OS?OF DS?OFDHD?P O@ C?NP@O Q>B '@OEC?PP Q@RUS>NT? QNOF?S F@ G@ROF?ONOG? PRG> N U@@A>@U?1 -@ F>?G@OFCNCB0 F>NF C?PRUF Q@RUS NHH@CS FNUDPYNODG PDEODHDgGNOG? F@ AC?GDP?UB F>? P@CF @H F?G>O@U@EDGNU YDORFDN?F>NF '@OEC?PP DOF?OS?S F@ FC?NF NP DCC?U?TNOF DO GCNHFgDOE F>? IJKL "GF1

    ->? ORNOG?S PG>?Y? F>NF '@OEC?PP >NP GC?NF?S F@E@T?CO F>? C?FCNOPYDPPD@O @H G@ABCDE>F?S Q@CVP DO,?GFD@OP IIM NOS III @H F>? '@ABCDE>F "GFhDOGURSDOES?FNDU?S ?WG?AFD@OP NOS N C?FDGRUNF?S PFNFRF@CB UDG?OPgDOE PG>?Y? QDF> N GNC?HRUUB GNUDZCNF?S PBPF?Y @H C@BgNUFD?PhHRCF>?C Z?UD?P NOB G@OF?OFD@O F>NF '@OEC?PP

    Q@RUS >NT? C?ENCS?S C?PA@OS?OF]P G@YY?CGDNU A?CgH@CYNOG?P NP @RFPDS? F>? '@ABCDE>F "GF]P ARCTD?Q1'@OEC?PP YNS? GU?NC F>NF FCNOPYDFFDOE XN A?CH@Cg

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    36/40

    cM

    YNOG? @C SDPAUNB @H N Q@CV[ F@ XPRZPGCDZDOE Y?YZ?CP@H F>? ARZUDG Q>@ ANB H@C PRG> P?CTDG?[ DOHCDOE?P F>?ARZUDGgA?CH@CYNOG? CDE>F0 ?WG?AF DO ONCC@Q NOS PA?GDHgDGNUUB DS?OFDHD?S GDCGRYPFNOG?P1 IK 71,1'1 III

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    37/40

    cI

    ,,# +-?-+45; /. 01- Y2396-!0 *-;/= !--3 !/0

    01+-50-! 7;/23 7/6820,!9

    "P F>? G@RCF @H NAA?NUP @ZP?CT?S0 NSTNOG?P DO

    G@YYRODGNFD@OP F?G>O@U@EB >NT? U?S YNOB RP?CP F@P>DHF HC@Y U@GNU F@ O?FQ@CVgZNP?S Y?F>@SP H@C PF@CDOENOS TD?QDOE G@ABCDE>F?S NRSD@ NOS TDS?@ G@OF?OF1 /?F1

    "AA1 cfNgcLN O1IJ1 ->? %,g+:% PBPF?Y NF DPPR? DO+8Y95!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    38/40

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    39/40

    cc

    YDPPD@O NP F>? @OUB C?U?TNOF A?CH@CYNOG? H@C ARCA@P?P@H F>? DOHCDOE?Y?OF NONUBPDP0 C?HU?GF?S NO ?CC@O?@RPDOF?CAC?FNFD@O @H F>? -CNOPYDF 'UNRP?1 ,?? AA1 bcgbe0@Q?T?C0 F>NF F>? G@RCF DO+8Y95!?

  • 8/12/2019 030314 Aereo Solicitor General

    40/40

    c\

    %,g+:% PBPF?Y k?WDPF`?Sa @OUB F@ AC@SRG? N G@AB] @HYNF?CDNU F>NF DF NUC?NSB >NS N UDG?OP? F@ C?FCNOPYDF F@DFP PRZPGCDZ?CP1[ /?F1 "AA1 fIN