대한소화기학회지대한소화기학회지Medline Medline 등재경험등재경험

경희의대 소화기내과경희의대 소화기내과

김 병 호김 병 호

MedlineMedline

Online counter part of Index Medicus

Bibliographic citation database of NLM to provide acce

ss to the world’s biomedical journal literature

Decision to Index a Journal TitleDecision to Index a Journal Title

Director of the NLMDirector of the NLM

LSTRC (LSTRC (literature selection technical review committee)literature selection technical review committee)

– 3 times/year: late spring (June), fall, winter 3 times/year: late spring (June), fall, winter

– about 140 titles at each meeting about 140 titles at each meeting

25-30% of the titles reviewed25-30% of the titles reviewed

Reference SitesReference Sites

www.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/factsheets/jsel.htmlwww.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/factsheets/jsel.html

– Journal Selection for Index Medicus/MedlineJournal Selection for Index Medicus/Medline®®

www.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/factsheets/j_sel_faq.htmlwww.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/factsheets/j_sel_faq.html

– FAQ about Journal Selection for Indexing

http://www.kamje.or.kr ( 의편협 web site)

Critical Elements for IndexingCritical Elements for Indexing

1.1. Core biomedicalCore biomedical subjects subjects

2.2. Scientific meritScientific merit: primary consideration: primary consideration

3.3. Quality of editorial workQuality of editorial work: objectivity, creditability and quality: objectivity, creditability and quality

– explicit processexplicit process of external peer review of external peer review

– aims and scope of the journal, instruction to authorsaims and scope of the journal, instruction to authors

4.4. Production qualityProduction quality

– uniform requirement for manuscripts by ICMJE (www.icmje.org) uniform requirement for manuscripts by ICMJE (www.icmje.org)

5.5. Foreign language journals: Foreign language journals: English-language abstractsEnglish-language abstracts

6.6. Geographical coverage: broad international coverageGeographical coverage: broad international coverage

FAQFAQ

How do I get a journal title reviewed?How do I get a journal title reviewed?

1)1) a letter of requestinga letter of requesting

2)2) the most recent published issuesthe most recent published issues

– 4 recent issues & a complementary subscription4 recent issues & a complementary subscription

(2/year: 3 recent issues, 1/year: 2 recent issues)(2/year: 3 recent issues, 1/year: 2 recent issues)

Reviewed by a Reviewed by a subject or language specialistsubject or language specialist??

– impossible because the LSTRC consists of 12 impossible because the LSTRC consists of 12 members serving 4-year termsmembers serving 4-year terms

FAQFAQ

Select score Select score (range 0–5)(range 0–5)

– 4.0 or greater:4.0 or greater: selected for indexing selected for indexing

– 2.0-3.99:2.0-3.99: reexamined after a minimum of 2 years reexamined after a minimum of 2 years

– lower scores:lower scores: reexamined after 4 years reexamined after 4 years

How are titles How are titles deselected deselected ??

– Extremely late publication patternExtremely late publication pattern

– Major changes in the scientific quality or editorial processMajor changes in the scientific quality or editorial process

등재 사전 작업등재 사전 작업 학회지 형식학회지 형식

– 편집위원회 명단편집위원회 명단 : : 국문 및 영문 소속국문 및 영문 소속

– 학회지 개요학회지 개요 (aims & scope): (aims & scope): 국문 및 영문국문 및 영문

– 투고규정투고규정 : : 국문 및 영문국문 및 영문

– 영문약어 목록영문약어 목록

– 원고 점검 사항원고 점검 사항 (checklist): (checklist): 국문 및 영문국문 및 영문

– 저작권 동의서저작권 동의서 : : 국문 및 영문국문 및 영문

Peer review: Peer review: 2424 인의 편집위원 및 인의 편집위원 및 5454 인의 심사위원인의 심사위원

Title page: Title page: 영문제목영문제목 , , 영문소속영문소속 , , 영문초록영문초록 (( 권권 ,, 호호 ,, 쪽쪽 ), ), 교신저자 교신저자 영문주소영문주소

출판 흐름도출판 흐름도게재결정 논문1 차 교정쇄

편집위원 copyediting ( 참고문헌 100% 확인 )

1 차 국문교정( 전문 교정자 )

영문교정 (1 차 )(native speaker)

2 차 국문교정 ( 전문 편집위원 )

순서 , 도표 , 그림 , 참고문헌

영문교정 (2 차 )( 전문 편집위원 )

저자 교정

편집이사최종 교정

출판사 ( 매달 20 일 이전 )

2 차 교정쇄

3 차 교정쇄

②

학회지명학회지명 : : 영문 영문 vs. vs. 국문국문• 대한소화기학회지

– Taehan Sohwagibyong Hakhoe Chapchi

– Korean J Gastroenterol

• 학회지명 결정– 앞표지 도안으로 결정 .

– 학술지 논문 사용 언어와는 관계 없음 .

한국 한국 ISSNISSN 미국 미국 ISSNISSN NLMNLM

Medline Medline 등재신청 전 등재등재신청 전 등재

• 의편협 학술지 등재– http://www.kamje.or.kr

– 국내 의학학술지 평가기준

• 한국학술진흥재단– http://www.krf.or.kr

– 사업안내

– 국내 학술지 평가

Application Letter Application Letter (( 회의록 참조회의록 참조 ))

Aims or purposeAims or purpose of the journal & the kinds of paper of the journal & the kinds of paper

The importanceThe importance of the journal throughout the world of the journal throughout the world

The composition and role of The composition and role of the editorial boardthe editorial board

The journal’s The journal’s target audience(s)target audience(s)

Detailed information about Detailed information about the peer review processthe peer review process

학회지의 특성학회지의 특성 (unique)(unique) 과 강점과 강점 (( 자국에서의 위치자국에서의 위치 ))