- lla het, tfl'0 bbl. kem jkopec meoeeoee
TRANSCRIPT
- XOTeJJU 3aMeHUTb ezo MolflpoM
- lla HeT tfl0 Bbl KeM yroJHO HO He MOllaPOM OH BeJl ce6Jl
no-xaMCKH Ero HeHaBHlleJIH Bee MOllap YgtKe TOrWi BbICTaBJlJlJl Hashy
nOKa3 CBOR aHTHeeMllTH3M
OKOHtlaHHe B CJle~lOWeM HOMepe
lIepeeoo EJICU BeKKepa
JKopec Meoeeoee
rOP5AlIEB
BHYTPEHIDUI DOJIHTHKA
TIepBbIH rOA nOCJIe npHXOWi fop6aQeBa K BJlaCTH 6bIJl OTMeshy
lIeH 6ecnpeueueHTHO KpynHblMH H3MeHeHHJlMH B TIOJlHT6IOPO H npashy
BHTeJlbCme H 6bICTPbIM onpeUeJIeHHeM 3KOHOMHtleCKHX ueneH
H MeTOUOB 3KOHOMHtJeCKoro Pa3BHTHJl Ha 6nHgtKaHwHe 15 JleT
0JHaK0 BO Beex npormx OTHOWeHHJlX H3MeHeHHJl BO BuyTpeHHeR
nOJIHTHKe 6bIJIH tlHCTO KOCMeTHqeCKHMH TIOJlHTHtJeCKHe aKUHH
nyqwe npenoJHOCHJIHCb CTHlIb CTan 60nee coBpeMeHHhIM HO no
cyIUecmy Mano qTQ H3MeHHlIOCb DpHrmHa 3TOMy He B KpaTKOCTH
nepHoWi H He B cocpeUOTOqeHHOcrn Ha 3KOHOMHtJeCKHX 3auatJllx
YCJIOBHJl AJIJI onpeueneHHJl HOBOH BuyTpeHHeH nOJlHTHKH 6bIJIH Ocashy
6eHHO 6naronpHJlTHbIMH B 1985 roAY Torua pa3pa6aTbmanHCb
HOBbie nporpaMMhI H YCTaB napTHH UOJlrocpOIHbIe 3KOHOMHtleCshy
KHe npOrpaMMhI npeUOCTaBJlJlJlH xopoIIIHe B03MO)KHOCTH H 6bIJlO
npoBeueHo MHoro MegtKAYHapoJHbIX BCTpeq B CBJl3H C KOTOPbIMH
ny6nHKOBaJIHCb 33JlBJleHHJl KaCaIOIUHeCJl BuyTpeHHeH nOJlHTHKH
DPH npeAbIAYIIIHX cMeHax PYKoBoAcma HOBbIH BO)KAb BbIHygtKmiddot
ueH 6bIJl nou lJaBJleHHeM 06CTOJlTeJlbCTB npeAfiPHHHMaTb ueHCmHJl
tJpeBaTbIe cepre3HbIMH HlleOJlorHlleCKHMH H MegtKAYHapoAHbIMH
OTKJIHKaMH HanpHMep XpYIUeB CMeCTHlI BepHJl H 06bJlBHJl 0 CTashy
JIHHCKHX npecyYnJleHHJlX tfl06bl npeUOTBpaTHTb K83Hb BbIAaIOIUHXCJl
OTphIBKH H3 KHHrH Zhores A Medvedev Gorbachev WW Norshyton amp Company New York-London 1986 CTP 208-242
200 201
BpaCJeH OCYKAeHHbIX H npHlOBopeHHIgtIX B ljIeBpane 1953 rona B o6JIaCTH BHeIIIHeH nOJIHTHKH 6bIJIO HaCTOHTenlgtHO He06xo~0 3aKOHlIHTh BOHHy B Kopee TIPH IipegtmeBe 61gtIDO MeHlgtWe Me)l(llyshyaapollHhlX KPH3HCOB Tpe60BaBIIIHX HeMenrreHHoro pa3peweHUH HO OH Hero KonnerH 3HeprWlHO oeHCTBOBaJIH B KOHcepBaTHBHOM CTHshyne tfr061gtI H3MeHHIIgt nH6epanIgtHIgtIe TeHJJemum B HAeOnorHH H BayrshypeHHeH nOJIHTHKe B03HHKII1He npH XpymeBe 3anperuaH ny6JIHKashyDHIO KHHf BblnyCK ltpHnIgtMOB H T 0 fop6atfeB npUJJli K BnaCTU BUshyoen caMYIO HeomogtmyIO 3auaQY He B KaKHX-TO oeHCTBHHX a B COCshyTaBneHHH oOKyMeHTOB npegtKJJe Bcero nporpaMMIgtI napTHH roe cooep)K3JlHCb 6bI peKOMeHJJaDHu 0 6yuyruei BHYTpeHHeH nOJIHTHKe H nonmKeHHH CCCP B MHpe OKOHlfaTenlgtHIgtm BapHaHT 3THX oOKyshyMeHTOB nOKaaan tfrO HOBoe PYKOBOoCTBO erue He rOTOBO K oeicTshyBeHHIgtIM HAeOnOfHCIeCKHM H nOnHTHlfeCKHM HHHUHaTHBaM
MHorHe 06rueCTBeHHhle H npoljlecCHOHanlgtHIgtIe rpynnbI BbmashyIIIHBaJIH aaue)KlJbI tfrO HOBoe PYKOBOoCTBO pa3peIIIHT HaKannHBaBshyIIIHeCH rooaMH a TO H oeCHTHneTHHMH 3auallH UeHTpanlgtHIgtIH KOMHshyTeT llpe3HAHM BepxoBHoro COBeTa H peuaKTopbI BeAlURx ra3eT Bceroa nonyqanu MHoro nuceM a nocne CMeHlgtI PYKOBooCTBa OHH nOKaTHnHCIgt naBHHoH 3TH nucbMa a He BIgtI60PbI B BepXOBHIgtm COshyBeT OTpIDKaIOT 06rueCTBeHHOe MHeHHe B HatJane 60-x rooOB MashyBecmH co06ruanu tfrO nOJlYlJaIOT 00 2000 OUceM B oeHlgt a TIPaBshyua MO)KeT 61gtITIgt nonyqana erue 6onlgtwe TIOtfrH K~IH rpa)KJJashyHUH CCCP XOTh pa3 B )KH3HH Hanucan nuCbMO HaIfHHaIOUJeeCH 06shyparueHHeM YBa)KaeMbm TOBapuw H aupeCOBan ero KpaTKO MocKBa KpeMnb Teneplgt Korua 3THM TOBapHIUeM CTan 3HepshymClHhlii fop6atfeB OH HaBepHOe nonylfHn HeCKOnlgtKO MHJIJIHOHOB nuceM cooep)KaBWUX He TOnlgtKO n03opaBneHUH HO npeMO)KeHUH npOOKTbI npoClgt6bI )Kan06hl Tpe60BaHHH cnpaBenrrHBOCTH 06paweshyHUH no nOBOoy 3aKnIOCJeHHbIX (ux B CCCP 60nee 2 MllH tfenOBeK) OT nOnHTHtfeCKUX 3aKnIOtfeHHbIX H OT HHaKOMblCOHIUHX BCHKOro poua (nOtfrH Bee UaBeCTHIgtIe COBeTCKHe HHaKOMbICOHUJHe HaIfaJIH CBOIO 06ruecTBeHHYIO oeHTenbHOCTIgt C OUCIgtMa B UK HJ1H TIOnHT6IOshypo) 3TH nuCIgtMa - Ba)KHbm acneKT coBeTcKoii nOnHTHCJeCKoH )(H3HH OHH nooruPHIOTCH KOHCTHyYDHeH CTaThH 49 KOTOPOi rnashyCHT
K~H rpa)KJJaHHH CCCP HMeeT npaBo BHOCHTh B rocyuapshyCTBeHHble opraHlgtl H 06rueCTBeHHbIe OpraHH3aDHH npeMO)KeHHH 06
yrryqweHHH ux oeHTenbHOCTH KpuTHKOBaTIgt HeoOCTaTKH B pa60Te )lon)KHOCTHhle mrua OM3aHhl B YCTaHOBneHHble aaKOHOM CPOKH paccMaTpHBaTIgt npenrrO)KeHHH U 3aHBneHHH rpa)KJJaH oaBaTb Ha HUX OTBeThI H npHHHMaTh He06xoJJHMble Mephl TIpecoeooBaHHe 3a KpHshyTHKyaanperuaeTcHl
3Ta Ba)KHaH CTaThH cOBeTcKoH KOHCTHTyDHH 03HatfaeT tfrO ecnH nocnaHO cooTBeTCTBYIOruee nuCbMO B TIonHT6IOpo unH B UK ua)Ke caMaH paJJHKanlgtHaH nOnHTHlfeCKaH KpHTHKa He oon)KHa HCTonshyKOBblBaThCH KaK aHTHCOBeTCKaH nponaraaua EcnH TaKHe OUCIgtMa He 61gt1JlH npeuaHhl IIIHPOKOH rnaCHOCTH He pacnpoCTpaHHnHCIgt B CaMH3oare H He OmpaBnHnHCb 3a rpaHJmy aBTOp HJ1H aBTOPbI He oOngtmlgtl npHBneKaThCH K cyoy ECTeCTBeHHO OUCbMa TaKOrO poua MOryT nOnaCTIgt B CaMH3uaT HJ1H 3a rpamwy He no Bone aBTOPOB Ho oljlHDHanlgtHble JIHua paCCMaTpHBaIOT 3T0 KaK nperrnor AllH npeo1gtHBneHHH 06BUHeHHH B HapymeHHH 3aKOHa
TIOXO)Ke fop6aleB nOHHn Ba)KHOCTIgt 3THX nueeM KaK 6aposhyMeTpa 06rueCTBeHHoro MHeHHH OH HeOllHOKpaTHO UHTHpOBan UX B peqax no nOBOoy 3KOHOMHtfeCKHX npo6JIeM (B UenHHOrpaue HanshypHMep OH DHTHpOBan OUCbMa npoCTblX nIOoei KOTOplgtle npeMarashynH nO)JHHYIgt ueHY Ha xne6 tfr06bl ero He CKapMllHBanH CKOTY) OpshyraHH3auHH OTBeTOB Ha 3TH DHCbMa 61gtIDa npeoMeTOM ero nepBOH BHYTpeHHeH nepeCTpoHKH B UeHTpanbHOM KOMHTeTe lJuCJIeHHOCTh 3THX nueeM Teneplgt TaKOBa tfrO 6onbwoH OToen co 150 COIp)llHHKashyMH He CDpaBnHnCH COTBeTaMH Ha HHX nOCKonbKY 3aKOH YCTaHaBnHshyBan O)JHOMeCHlfHbm CPOK AllH OTBeTOB Ha DHCbMa IihlDO peweHO paCnyCTHTIgt OToen H pacnpeoemlTlgt notfrY no coomeTCTBYIOIUHM OTshyoenaM UK 3TO 6bIDO 3opaBoe peweHUe TaK KaK MHome nuClgtMa 6bIDH CJIHWKOM cneDHanIgtHIgtI tfr06hl Ha HHX MornH OTBeTHTh COIPYoshyHHKH oTJJena DHceM
OllHaKO nepBbIM HJJeonOmleCKHM HCnbITaHHeM AllH HOBoro PYKoBOJJCTBa OKa3anCH TaK )Ke KaK H)JlIH npe)JlUeCTBeHHHKoB fopshy6atfeBa Bonpoc 0 CTanHHe B MapTe nmH HHTeHCHBHhle npuroIoBneshyHUH K npa3nHOBaHHIO COPOKOBOi rooOBruHHbl )lHH no6e)JbI TIepeo CMepTbIO qepHeHKo 6bIDO 061gtHBneHO 0 BhlnycKe IjIHnbMa TI06eua CHJlTbm B 1983-1984 roJJax IjIHnbM npeocTaBnHn CTanuaa MyoPbIM repoeM a qepllHJIJIH H TpYM3Ha oTpuuaTenbHIgtIMH nepCOHIDKaMH ManO CJJeJIaBIIIHMH tfr06bI nOMO yCunHHM CCCP B BoHHe HY)KHO 61gtIDO peIIIHTb BhlDycKaTIgt nH 3TOT IjIHnbM Ha 3KpaHlgtl I1MeJIHCb
202 203
rpynnhI B lIaCIHOCm BeTepaHOB BoiHhI KOTOphIe HaCTaHB3nH Ha
pea6~ CTamma BOJIrOrpanCKHH rOpCOBet H 06IueCTBo
BeTepaHOB 06paTHlIHCb C neT~eil 0 BOSBpameHHH ropoA) Ha3BaHIVI
CT3nHHrpaP H rOBOpHlIH lITO lIepHeHKo 6blJI rOTOB nOPnHCSTb
COOTBeTCmyrouum YK33 fOp6atIeB nOWeJI Ha KOMIIpoMHCC cIlHJIbM
nOftBHlICJI Ha SKpaHaX HO BOJIrorpan OCT3nCJI BonrorpaPOM MHoshy
me HHTenneKty3nhI 6hIJDI ycnoKoeHhI STHM peweHHeM
PetIb fop6atIeBa B KaHYH )lHJI no6eAhI 8 MaJI He 6hDIa HHTeshy
peCRoi llO-BHpHMOMy petIb 6blJIa HanHcaHa ARJI Hero TaK lJIO STO
6hDI OtIeHh OltP~hHhIH H CpePKaRHbIH aHalIHS OAHaKO fop6atIeB
npH3H3n H8JIHlHe olIDl60K H npoCtIeTOB B HatIane BoiHhI npepweCTshy
BOBaBlIDIX no6epe H ynoMJIHYn HMB CTanHHa TonbKO oAHH pas
EcnH H cyweCTBOB3nO HaMepeHHe pea6HJIHmpoBaTh CTanKHa OT Heshy
ro OtIeBHAHhIM 06P330M OTKa33nHCb C ppyroi CIOPOHhI TpaAHshy
UHOHHaJI 106HlIeiHaJI aMHHCTHJI 6blJIa p330llapoBaHHeM YKas 06
aMHHCTHH npHHJIThIH llpeSHAHYMOM BepxoBHoro COBeTa B KOmte
anpemI 6hDI OtIeHh Hs6HpaTenbHhIM ftBHhIM 06paSOM HCKnlOlIaBwHH
CIaThH yronoBHoro KopeKca HCIIonbsyeMhIe npoTHB nOnHTHqeCKHX
33KnlOtIeHHhIX WCKnlOtIanHCh pajKe Te KTO nonyqHJI MeHee Tpex
neT no CTaThe 1911 YK2 TaKHe nOnHTSaKJIlOtIeHHhIe KaK IOpHi Opshy
nOB H Cepreil KOB3neB yxce oT6hmlIDle ceMHJIemee SaKnlOtIeHHe B
narepe H HaxOAHBlIDIeCH B WlTHlIeTHei CChDIKe TO)J(e He nonanK
nop aMHHCmlO 3TO 6blJIO 6esoWH60tIHhIM npHSHaKOM lJIO HOBhm
PYKOBOAHTeJIh He JlBJIJletCJI nH6epanOM
3TO 6hDI He nepBhm npH3HaK HO HHTenneKty3nhI npopOJI)J(ashy
JIB HapeJIThCJI lITO nocne BCIynneHHJI fop6atIeBa B pomKHOCTh npoHshy
soiAYT KaKHe-TO HSMeHeHHJI EBpeH-OTK33HHKH HapeJIJIHCb lJIO
SMHrpaURJl ltp3KmtIeCKH npeKpaTHBWaJlCJI npH lIepHeHKo 6ypet
o6nertIeHa llOHatIllJIy CHTY3UHJI K333JIaCh 06Hape)l(lBalOweil B Mapshy
Te nOJIytIHlIH paspeweHHe SMHrpHpoBaTh 98 tIenOBeK3 B anpene
ewe 166 tIenOBeK npH6hIJIH B BeHy cpeAH HHX 6hDIH nlOAH HS MOCKshy
BhI H neHHHIp3A3 OTKYua paHee 6hDIO TpYAHee Bcero SMHrpHposhy
BaTh4 OAH3KO noprOTOBHTenhHhIe onepaUHH KOTophIe HaARe)J(HT
npopenaTh ARJI SMHrpaUHH T3K cnO)J(HhI lJIO SallBneHHJI Tex KTO
yeS)J(3nH B anpene POmKHhl 6hIJIH paCCMaTpHBaTbCH MHoro paRee
neTOM lJHcno P33peWeHHHH Ha SMHrpaUHlO CT3nO YMeHhUIaThCH
H K aBrycry ynano AO 3040 B MeCJIll (B STO tIHcno He BXOpJIT HeMshy
I(bI llOBOn)J(bJl 0 KOTOphIX H3BecTHbI TOJIhKO AaHHbIe sa BeCh roP)
3T0 MHoro HH)J(e cpeAHero YPOBHJI 1983 roua Korua e)J(eMeCJltHO
OKono 100 eBpeeB nOJIytIllJIH paspewellHe (B pasrape SMHrPaUHH
B 1979 r 1IHcneHHOCTb SMHrpaHTOB Bospocna AO 51 330 HOBaJI
xonopH3JI BoiHa YMeHhWHlIa HX tIHcno AO 9 447 B 1881 r H 2 692 B 1982 r)
naHHhIe 06 SMHrpaUHH npHHJITO pacCMaTpHBaTb KaK cyWeCTshy
BeHHhm nOKasaTenb OTHoweHHJI COBeTCKHX BJIactei K npo6neMe
npaB tIenOBeKa WSBecmo lJIO npHMepHO 100 ThIC COBetCKHX rpa)J(
AaH nopanH sallBneHHJI H )J(A)T p33peWeHHJI yexaTamp a 1IHcneHHOCTh
OTK33HHKOB COCTaBJIJleT OKono 30 ThIC tIenOBeK 3m AaHHhIe
xapaKTepHsyroT H 06IUHii ypoBeHamp peMOKpaTHH BHyTpH CIpaHbl
H Me)J(A)HapoAHYlO CHtyaUHlO B OKTJl6pe 3m UHltPPhI CROBa Hecshy
KonhKO BOSPOCJ1H B CBJlSH C BHSHTOM fop6atIeBa BO cJ)pamtH1O
H npHrOTOBJIeHHJIMH K BCIpetIe C npe3HpeHTOM PeiraHOM B OKTJl6shy
pe 124 eBpeJi nOKHHYJIO COBeTcKHH Com B TOM 1IHcne 44 HS
MOCKBampI H 1 H3 neHHHrpauas B HOJl6pe 3MHrpHpoB3nO 128 tIeJIoshyBeK
B HHTepBblO ltPpamty3CKOMy TeneBHAeHHIO 30 ceHTJl6pJl fop6ashy
tIeB npopon)J(3n ymep)J(p3Tb lJIO SMHrpaUHlO HapO paccMatpHBaTh
TonhKO KaK BOCCOeAHHellHe ceMei 3TO SHatIHT lJIO AJlJI COBetcshy
KHX eBpeeB HeMtteB rpeKOB H ppymx HaUHOHanhHampIX MeHhWHHCTB
He CyWeCTByeT eCIeCTBeHHoro npaBa nOKHHYTamp CTpaHY no peJIHmos
HhlM HaUHOH3nbHhIM H KYJIamptypHhlM MOTHBaM B TOM )J(e HHtepBamp1O
fop6atIeB nOK333n lJIO OH HMeeT OlJeHh cna60e npepCIaBJIeHHe
o cyweCTBe eBpeHCKoi npo6neMhl B CCCP OH ymep)J(IJaJl lITO
nonO)J(eHHe eBpeeB B CCCP nyqwe lJeM rpe 6hI TO HH 6blJIO B MHpe
EBpeicKoe HaceneHHe COCIaBJIJIlOwee 069 HaceneHHJI CTpaHbI
B nOJIHTHtIeCKoi H KYJIamptypHOil )J(H3HH npepCTaBJIeHO B KOJlHteCTshy
Be OT 10 po 206 OR 6hIJI npaB B OTHOWeHHH ypeJIhHOrO Becs
eBpeeB B tIHCneHHOCTH HaceneHKJI CCCP HO OtIeHamp tpYAHO H3MepHTamp
HaCKOJIampKO OHH npepcTaBneHbI B cOBeTCKoi KYJIhtypHOil )J(H3HH
llOMHMO Bcero npotIero )TO BOnpOC He TOJIampKO npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHoil
nOJIHTHKH HO T3K)J(e Bonpoc CBJlSaRHhIi C HHAHBHAYanampHhIMH YCHshy
JIHJlMH H CKnOHHOCTJlMH W CK33aTh tITO eBpeH npepCIaBneHhI
B COBeTCKoi nOJIHTHtIecKoi )J(H3HH B npepenax OT 10 po 20 JlBJIJletCJI oqeBHAHhIM a6cYPPoM B npaBHTeJIhCTBe eCTh TOJIampKO
OAHH eBpeil (BeHHaMHH ampIMWHIQ a no MeHee 1 llponopUHSl
eBpeeB B KOMMyHHcTHtIeCKOi napTHH 6hIJIa paBHa 1A B 1983 r
204
205
H TOmKO Owm eBpeH (Be3AecymHH llblMIlIHrO cpenu 311 lJJ1eHOB
IIK Co BpeMeHH nepBoro BRlHTa B COBeTcKHH COI03 rpynnhl
aMepHKaHCKHX ceHaTopoB H KOHfpeccMeHoB B anpene rop6aqeB
nonyIRlI MHoro nHlHhiX oGplllQeHHH no nOBooy nOJIHTHleCKHX laKshy
nIOqeHHhIX H oTKa3HHKoB Ero orneT GhlJI 06hIlHbIM llOlBomTe
HaM caMHM pewaTb HaIIIH BHYTpeHHHe npo6JIeMbl7 OH TaK)Ke
npoAOJIJK3J1 ~ep)l(AaTb ITO nOJIHTHqeCKHX pHcCHAeHTOB cyMT
TonbKO TOrAa KorAa OHH HapywaIOT JaKOH XOTJI OH AOJI)KeH lHaTb
ITO COBeTCKHH 3aKOH 06paIIJaeT HHaKOMhICnHe B npeCTYIIJIeHHe TeM
He MeHee nepeA )KeHeBCKOH BCTpeqeH Ha BblCUleM ypoBHe 6bIJI CAeshy
naH )KeCT AOGpoH BOJIH B HOJlGpe EneHe EOHHJp )KeHe COenaHHOrO
AlmpeJl CaxapoBa 6h1Jlo pa3peUleHo BhlexaTb 3a rpaHHQY Ha caMOM
Aene CaxapoB HaIaJI CBOIO TpeTbIO ronoAoBKY no 3TOMY nOBOOY
B OKTJlGpe TpeGYJI lT06hI ero )KeHe GhlJIO pa3peUleHO BblexaTb
JJl1J1 neqeHHJI Y Hero cna60e 3AopoBbe eMY 6hlJIO 64 rOAa OH GhlJI
OqeHb ena6 noene npe)I(HHx ronoAoBoK laKOHIHBIlIHXCJI B 6onbHHshy
ne npHHYAHTenhHbIM KOpMJIeHHeM Ero )KH3Hb GhlJIa nOA yrpo30H
ECJlH 6hI OH yMep B HOJIGpe HerOAOBaHHe B CIlIA GhlJIO 6bl CJlHIJlshy
KOM CHJIhHblM lT06bI rop6atIeB Mor paCCIHTblBaTlo Ha KaKOH-TO
ycnex B JKeHeBe CTaBKH GhIJIH CJlHIJlI(OM BhlooKH H B KOHne OKTJI~ pJl EneHe EOHHlP COOGIIJHJlH ITO OHa MO)l(eT BblexaTb la rpaHHQY
HeMeJJl1eHHO CaxaPOB GhlJI KpynHeHUleH npo6JIeMoH JJl1J1 rop6aqeshy
Ba B o6JIacTH npas qenOBeKa OH GhIJl BhlenaHB rOpbKHHB 1980 r Ge3 CYAa H cYAeGHoro pa36HpaTemcma 3TO 6h1Jlo CAenaHO KrE
nOA nO)l(HhIM npeJJl10rOM ITO CaxapoB pacnOJIaraeT rocYAaPCrneHshy
HLIMH ceKpeTaMH (nO)l(HhIM nOTOMY ITO CaxaPOB GlolJI YSOJIeR
H3 HHCTHTYTa aTOMHOH 3HepTHH B 1968 r ABeRaAnaTbIO roAaMH
paHee R He npHHHMaJI yttaCTHJI B OpHeHTHpoBaHHLIX Ha BoeHHhle
HY)l(Abl HCeneAOBaHHJlX C 1964 r) OT npaB03aIIJHTHLIX rpynn B CCCP OC06eHHO OT tfJIeROB
MOCKOBCKOH XenlocHHKcKOH rpynnhl H lMHfpaHTOB - GblBIJlHX noshy
JIHT3aKJIIOtIeHHloIX npoAOJI)I(aJla nocrynaTb RHqoPManRJI 06 apeCTax
HHaKOMbICJlJlIIJHX H aKTHBHLIX npasOJaIIJHTHHKOB H CYAJI no
e)KeHeAemHLIM COO6IIJeHHJIM 0 HapYUleHHJlX npas 1IenOBeKa H3Aashy
BaeMloIX KpoHHAOM nI06apcKHM BO BTOPOH nonOBRHe 1985 r He
6hlJI0 3aMemo CYIIJeCTBeHHhIX H3MeHeHHH CHTYanHH8 MOCKOBCKHH
Me)l(AyHapo)lHloIH qeCTHBaJIh MonOAe)KH npoxoAHJl nOA 00060
YCHJleHHOH OXpaHOH MHJlHUHH - cnyqanOClo ITO MHJlHIUlORepOB OKashy
3bmaJIOClo 6onloUle qeM rOCTeH llpe~ qeCTHBaJIh MOnOAe)KH
B 1957 r l 6loIJI paAOCTHLIM H CBo60AHLIM Cbe3AOM IOHOUleH H AeBYshy
UleK Ha nOT pal aTMoccpepa GhlJIa OOBceM RHOH rOCTJlM BhIAaJIH
nponycKa C HX cpoTorpaltPHJlMH KOTopble OHH AOJI)l(HhI 6loIJIH HOeHTb
nOCTOJIRHObull llHCKYCCHH npoBoAHJlHcb fJIaBHLIM 06pa30M Ha nOJIHTHshy
1IeCKRe TeMb C IIBHOH aHTH3anaAHoH HanpasneHHoCTbIO
llOnO)l(eHHe B COI03e nHcaTeneH R Apyrnx ooI03ax TBopllecshy
KOH HHTeJIJIHfeHnHH (~PHaJIHCTOB KOMll03HTOPOB KHHeMaTorpashy
CPRCTOB H T A) OGloIIHO MO)KeT enYJKHTb XOpoUlHM nOKa3aTeneM
BHyTpeRHero nOJIHTHqeCKorO KJlHMaTa BeerAa RMeIOTCJI AeCJITI(H
nOBeCTeH qHJlhMOB nbeC H T A npeACTaBJIeHHhIX )JlIJI Ony6JIHKoshy
BaHHJI HJlH )JlIJI pa3peUleHHJI nOCTaHOBKH Ha cueHe RJIH JKpaHe
Bee nbeCbl R CPRJIbMbl AOJI)I(HbI nOnyqHTb pa3peUleRHe cnenuaJIbHOrO
KOMHTeTa B03fJIaBJIJleMOrO oooTBeTcmyroIIJHM neH3opoM (Ha o~
naCTHOM ypoBHe eCJlH meca npeACTaBneHa npoBHHUHaJIbHOMY
TeaTpy) 3HaIIHTenloHaJI 1IaCTlo lTHX pa60T 6hlJIa oTBepfHYTa RJIH
OTJIO)KeHa AO BHeeeHRJI H3MeHeHHii ABToPhl peLaKTophI H pe)KHcshy
eepbl (cpepH HHX OqeHL R3BecTHble) HeHJGe)I(HO OGplllQaJIHCb K Hoshy
BOMY PYKOBOpHTenIO JJl1J1 pa3peUleHHJI HX TpYAHOCTeH C neH30paMR
B anpene nORBRJIHClo 06HaAe)I(HBaIOIIJHe npR3HaKH TOro ITO RlMeshy
HeHRJI HOCJITCJI B B03JJYXe rOp6alleB OTKa3aJICJI YSHAeTbCJI C AByMR
H8H60nee KOHeepsaTHBHblMH PYKOBOAHTeJIJlMH COI03a nHcaTeshy
neH - r MapKoBblM npeAeeAaTeneM H A qaKOBCKRM peLaKToshy
poM nmepaTYpHOH raJeTbl EMY nonaraJIOCb BCTpeTHTbCJI C HHMH
lTOGbl HaJIaAHTb xopoIlIHe OTHOUleHHJI C JTHMH orneTCrneHHloIMH
pa60THHKaMH (AlmponOB BHAeJICJI C HHMH B AeKaGpe 1982 r
H Bhlpa3RJI RM CBoe AOBepHe) HO RM 6blJlO CKa3aHO ITO ropGaqeB
enHIJll(OM 3aHJIT CTaJIO HJBeCTHO TaK)Ke lITO lleTp lleMHleB (MRshy
HHCTp KynbTYPbl KaHIlHAaT B lDIeHbl llOJIHTGIOPO H 6blBumii rnaBa
oTAena nponaraHAbI IIK) R ero AOn)I(HOCTHLle mwa CTaJIH Gonee
Be)l(llHBbl C nOeeTHTenJlMH C ApyrOH CTOPOHbl llPR6hITKOB owm HJ
fJIaBHLIX nOMOIIJHHKOB qepHeHKo GlolJI Ha3HaqeH 38MeCTHTeneM
KOMHTeTa no oXpaHe rOCYAapcmeHHLIX eeKpeTOB B nettaTH (OcpHshy
nuaJIbHOe Ha3BaHHe OOBeTCKOH neH3yphI) llnJl llpHGbITKOBa 3T0
GlolJIO nOHH)KeHHeM H Re cynHJlO HHlero xopoUlero B o6JIaCTH neH3Yshy
pbl EhlJIH CJIyXR ITO rOp6a1leB H MHXaHJl 3HMJIHHH BTOPOH eeKpeshy
Tapb HAeOJIOfHleCKOrO OTAena IIK BTOPOH qeJIOBeK noene Cyenoshy
206 207
Ba BbDIonwmIIIHii ry )l(e ponb npH JlHraqeBe He nonlAJfJlH Ho noshy
BHARMOMy- HHKatltHX HOBbIX HHCTpYKIHii He 6bmo H CHrylI(HII He
ynyqunmaCb HrreonOrHtJeCKHe 3allBneHIDI rop6aqeBa 6bIllH W3ycshy
MbIcneHHbI H He o6HapYgtKHBaJIH HOBOro no)Uona llOXOgtKe 6bmo tJTO
rop6alleB IIel1HKOM nopYtJHJ1 HpeonOrHlO JlHralleBY H CKOHIIeHTpHshy
POBaJI CBoe BHHMaHHe Ha 3KOHOMHKe
B aBryCTe EBremm EBrymeHKo H3BecmlilH n03T H nOllHTHshy
IeCKH npoTHBopetJIfBaJI cpurypa HanHcaJI rop6alleBY nHCbMO 0 nnashy
IeBHOM COCTOIIHHH COBeTCKOH llHTeparypbI H llpe3MepHOH CTporocshy
TH IIeH3ypHbIX OrpaHHlleHHH B more B llpaBpe 9 ceHTII6pll
6bIJ1a ony6mnltoBaHa ero KOPOTKaJI n03Ma B KOTOPOH noppepgtKHBashy
naCb 3KOHOMHlJeCKaJI nOllHTHKa rop6alleBa COpep)l(aJlHCb HanllAKH
Ha 61OPOKpaTOB 6oIIIIIHxcII HOBoBBepeHHH H npoTHBJDInlxCII HM
H BOCXBaJIIIJ1C11 WeCTHMeCIIIIHbm COBeTCKuH MopaTopuH Ha Mepshy
HbIe HcnhITaHHJI KaK 6ecnpeIIepeHTHOH cMenocm nOW3Hr BO HMII
MHpa9 ll03Ma copepgtKaJla TatltgtKe CKpbIryIO KpHTHKy KOJ1J1eKTHBHshy
3lIIHH H OTKPhITYlO KpHTHKy JIhIceHKo CBII3bIBlll HblHeWHHe Cel1hCshy
Kox03JriiCTBeHHble TpyDHOCTH C 6mpoKpaTmleCKHMH nperpanaMH
Ho H3 n03MbI IICHO cnepOBano tJTO He napTHII a 61OpoKpaThI omeTshy
CTBeHHbI 31 Bce 3TO B TOMgtKe MeCIIIIe rop6alleB Ha3HatJHJ1 AlleKcaHApa HKOBneBa
rnaDOH OTpel1a nponaraHAhI UK CMeCTHB CryKaJIHHa Ha3HalleHHOrO
nocnOM B BeurpHIO 3r0 paCCMaTpHBaJIOCb KaK XOPOWUH 3HaK
OTpen nponaraHJ]hl IIBJ111eTCII KlllOIIeBhIM 3BeHOM l1HIalleBCKOro
H1leonOrHtJeCKOrO ceKpeTapHaTa lloxo)l(e Ha3HaleHHe 3TO 6bIJ10
npoH3BepeHO B cneWKe (Katlt H Ha3HaqeHHe Pa3YMOBCKoro rnaBOH
OpraHH3lI(HOHHoro OTpel1a) Tatlt Katlt 06blIIH0 rnaBa OTpena nponashy
raHIJbl IIBJ1IIeTCII IJl1eHOM HJ1H KaHlJH)JaTOM B IJl1eHhI UK a HKOBlleB
TatltOBbIM He 6bIJ1 OH 6bIJ1 3aMecmTeneM 3aDe)lylOIIero Omel10M
nponaraHAbI HO 6bIJ1 CMeIIeH CycnOBhIM B 1970 r (OqeBHARo 31
ny6mnclI(H1O B nOllHTHtJeCKHX H llHTepaTypHbIX lKYPHaJIax CTaTeH C KpHTHKOH HeOCTaJIHHHCTCKHX H pycOcpHllbCKHX TeHAeHIHii) H HaJHashy
qeH nocnoM B KaHaJJY B nOM KaleCme OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6aqeshy
Ba BO BpeMII ero BH3Hta B KaHaJJy H MegtKAY HHMH YCTaHOBHllHCb
xopowue OTHOWeHIDI HKOBneB 6hIll B03BplIIeH B MOCKBY H Ha3shy
HaleH ARpeKTOPOM HHcmryra MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKH H MegtKAYHapopshy
HbIX OTHowemm OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6alleBa BO BpeMII ero BH3HTa
B BeJIHK06PHTaHHIO B 1984 r CllHTaeTCII tJTO HKOBneB He 1C0Hcepshy
BaTOp HO OH nonytJHT BnHllHHe TonhlCO ecnH 6ypeT H36paH B UK HOBbIe Ha3HaqeHIDI B HAeonOrHtJeCICOM OTpene BbIrnIIAIIT
BeChMa o6eIIalOIIHMH rpy60 rOBOpll COBeTCICHe HAeonorHtJeCKHe
pa60THHICH penIITcII Ha W3e rpynnhI 1C0HCepBaTHBH)IO 0PTOAQICshy
CaJ1hH)IO 1C0TOPym nOppepgtKHBaJIH CycnOB H neMHIIeB H 60nee
clCnoHaym IC pecpopMaM YMepeHHO nporpecCHBH)IO )lHpeICTOP
HHcmryTa CIlIA H KaHaAhI reopruH Ap6aTOB 6bIBWuH peAaKTOP
llpaBAhI a Teneph ARpelCTOP HHCTHtyTa COIIHOnOrHH AllelCceH
Py-MIIHIIeB CTapWUH COTPYAHHK MegtKAYHapoDHoro OTpena UK H nnopOBHThIH nHcaTenb no BonpocaM COIIHaJIH3Ma H KOMMfHH3Ma
r InaXHaJapoB AlleICcaHAP BOBHR H cIgtepop BypnallKHH 06a H3shy
BeCTHhIe gtKypHallHCTbl - OTHOCllTCII KO BTOPOH rpynne CKllOHaym IC
peCPOPMaM rpynny TOIIHee Ha3BaTh nporpeCCHBHOH qeM nH6epanhshy
HOH Y 3TOH rpynnhI YCTaHOBHllHCh xopowue OTHoweHIDI C AHAposhynOBbIM 1C0rna OH po 1967 r 6hm celCpeTapeM UK llocne HeKoToposhy
ro cnlna BnHIIHHII OHH nOXO)l(e BHOBh BhICTynuJIH Ha CIIeHy nocne
CMepTH Bpe)f(leBa rop6aQeB He HMeBWHH co6CTBeHHoro HHTennelCshy
ryaJIhHOro OICpy)l(eHIDI BHAHMO Ha6Hpan COBeTHHICOB nOMoIUHHshy
ICOB H ppyrux pOn)f(lOCTHbIX llHII H3 3TOH rpynnhI Ho nelaJIhHO
H3BecmhIe CBOHM lCoHcepBaTH3MOM 3HMIIHHH rnaDa OTllena lCynhshy
ryPhI UK Inaypo H peAaKTOP gtKypHaJIa BonpoChI 3KOHOMHKH
H ARpelCTOP HHCTHryTa 3KOHOMHKH XatJaTypoB COXpaHHllH BllHllHHe
H B03MO)f(lO HMelOT nyqwue IIeM nporpeCCHCThl OTHOmeHHJI C
JlHraqeBbIM
TpeTbll rpynna - IIeHTpHCTClCaII B Hee BX0AIIT penaICTOp
llpaBAhI ACPaHaCbeB H pepaKTOP TeopemlleCKOrO napmHHoro
gtKYpHaJIa KOMMyHHCT PHtJapp KOCOnaDOB llOCKonhlCY COBeTCKuH
COlO3 IIBJ111eTCII HpeOnOrHtJeCICHM rocypapcmOM nyooHKlIIHU B
napTHHHbIX oprauax netJarn 06bIIIH0 6hIBalOT HaH60nee 3HatJHMhlMH
nOKaJaTenllMH TeKYIIHX nonHTHtJeCICHX H HAeonOrHtJeCKHX TeHAeHshy
IIUHmiddot MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M IIBJ1IIeTCII CYIIeCTBeHHbIM CBII3ymIIIHM
3BeHOM MegtKAY pa3J1HllHhIMH rocynapcmeHHhIMH yqpegtKAeHIDIMH
H neranH3yeT BepxoBHym BnaCTh napTHH H ee reHepanbHoro ceKpeshy
tapll HpeonorHtJeCKHe CBII3H MelKA) pa3HbIMH qaCTIIMH rocypapshy
CTBeHHOH MaWHHbI COXpaHIIT CBOIO npOlJHOCTb ecnH COXPaHHTshy
CII IIeMeHTHpymmaH ponh HAeonorHH 3Ta ponh IIBHO YMeHhIlIHshy
209208
JIaCb BO BpeMeHa Bpe)lQeBa HO 3TO fibIJlO BbI3BaHO He CTPYKrypshy
HblMH H3MeHeHHHMH a CBoero POIJ8 HlJeOJIOrlflleCKHM CKJIeposhy
30M BepXH napTHH fiblJIH He cnocofiHbI C031J8Tb Ifl1eOJIorlfllecshy
KHH COJHaJIbHbIH IDIH nOJIHTlflleCKHH JOKyMem K KOTOPOMY
Ofipa30BaHHbIe KpyrH MornH fibI OTHeCTHCb eepbe3HO B 1970-x H
1980-x roJaX nytflIIee qyO MOrJIa npeJJIO)lOTb napTHH JJIS BJOXHoshy
BeHHS HapolJ8 fibIJIH TPyruI Bpe)lQeBa - BOcnOMHHaHHS 0 roJax
BOHHbI 0 ueJIHHe H T JJ npHMHTHBHO H y60ro HanHCaHHbIe 3a Hero
JpymMH H nopolJHBIillIe 6eCqCJIeHHbIe aHeKJorbI
CaM rOpfialJeB TO)(e He H36e)(aJI HeKOTopoH npHtJaCTHOCTH
K npHMHTHBHbIM H 6ecCMbICJIeHHbIM HJeOJIOrlflleCKHM MaTepHanaM
Toro nepHolJ8 B peq Ha KOHlgtepeHUHli no BonpocaM HJeOJIOrHH B
CTaBponOJIbCKOM Kpae B Mae 1978 r KorJa OH eII(e fibIJI eeKpeTashy
peM rOpKOMa ropfiaqeB CKa3aJI
reHepanbHbIH ceKpeTapb UK KnCC npeJceJareJIb
IIpe3HJHyMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP JI H Bpe)(HeB shy
raJIaHTJIHBbrH PYKoBOJHTeJIb JIeHHHCKOro THna Ero THTashy
HHlJecKas nOBceJHeBHas pafioTa HanpaBJIeHa Ha YKpeIIJIeHHe
MOII(H CTpaHbI nOBbJIIIeHHe 6narocoCToSHHS rpyJlIIUHXCS
Ha ynpoqeHHe MHpa H fie30naCHOCTH HapoJoB
HeJaBHO MbI paCKPbIJIH CTpaHHJbI 3aMelJaTeJIbHOH KHHrH
TOBapHII(a J1 H Bpe)lQeBa bull Manu 3eMJIS rJe 3OJIOTbIMH
fiYKBaMH 3aJIelJaTJIeHbI noprpeTbI JIereHlJ8pHbIX repoeB
60es 3a CeBepHbrH WKaJ HeMHoro BpeMeHH npoIIIJIo co
JHI[ ny6nHKauHH KHHrO HO BOCnOMHHaHHH BbI3BanH
BceofiII(Hii nOJJIHHHO BceHapoJHbrH HHTepec qTofibI YJOBshy
JIeTBopHTb 6ecqCJIeHHbIe 3anpocbI TpKeHHKoB CTaBposhy
nOJIbIUHHbI B lgteBpane 3TH BOCnOMHHaHHH fiyJJYT nepeneshy
lJaTaHbI H3 YpHana HOBbrH MHP B HallIHX KpaeBblX
raJeTax CTaBponOJIbCKas npaBJa H KaBKa3CKas 3JpaBshy
HHua
B KHHre bullManas 3eMJIS He TaK MHoro crpaHHJ HO no
rnyfiHHe HJeOJIOrHlJeCKOrO coJep)(aHHH no IillIpoTe 0606shy
II(eHHH 0 MbICJIeH aBTOpa OHa CTana 60JIbIilllM COfibITHeM
OfiII(eCTBeHHOH )(H3HH OHa BbI3Bana rop~ OTKJIHK B
eepJJax COBeTCKDX mOJeH 0 BOCX8II(eHHble OT3b1BbI COJIshy
IJ8T-IgtPOHTOBHKOB Ha qTaTeJIbCKDX KOHlgtepeHUHSX H B nelJaTH
KOMMYHHCTbI H Bce TpKeHHKH CTaBpOnOJIbIUHHbI 6ecshy
KOHelJHO 6narOJapHbI JIeoHHJy HnbHlfY Bpe)(HeBY 3a ero
nOJJIHHHO BJOXHOBJIeHHYIO napTHeH JIHTeparyPHYlO pa60TY
B KOTOPOH HCTOlfHHKH BeJIHKOro nOJBHra HallIeH repoHlJecshy
KOH CTpaHbI ee JJYXOBHOH H HpaBCTBeHHOH CHJIbI ee CIOHshy
KOCTH H MKeCTBa BCKPblTbI C IgtHJIOCOIgtCKOH rnyfiHHoH
(OfipaTHbrH nepeBOJ C aHrn - PeJ) 10
~ras 3TO HeYMepeHHoe BOCXBaneHHe nOBepXHOCTHoro H noeshy
peJCTBeHHoro COlJHHeHHH Bpe)lQeBa HeJIb3S He nOqyBCTBOBaTb qro
ero oJeOJIOrHqeCKOe B03JeHCTBHe SBJISeTCS ofipaTHblM KpoMe Bceshy
ro npoqero H3JIO)(eHHe Bpe)(HeBa HCKa)(aeT HCTOpHIO H CaM fibIJI
B 1943 r COJIJaTOM TaMaHcKoro IgtpoHTa H Manas 3eMJIS fibIJIa
Beero JImllb ero He60JIbIilllM 6eperoBblM aBaHnOCTOM B03HHKIillIM
BO BpeMH HaYlJ8lJHOro HacTyIlJIeHHH Ha HOBOPOCCHHCK B anpeJIe
H 3aTeM B Mae 1943 r IIoKa Bpe)(HeB 30 JIer CnyCTS He H30fipaJHJI
cofiblTHS TaM KaK OCHOBHYIO fiHTBY OHH fibIJIH He3HalJHTeJIbHbIM
BoeHHbIM 3JIH30JOM Bpe)(HeB fibIJI TorJa nOJIHTKOMHccaPOM
H TOJIbKO OJH~I noJIYqJIJI nOBb1lIIeHHe B lJHHe B 1941 r OH fibIJI
nOJIKOBHHKOM a K 1945 r CTan reHepan-MaH0poM Ho B 1978 r
olgtHUHanbHas npecca CTMa nucaTb 0 HeM TaK KaK fiYJTO OH fibIJI
60JIee BblJalOII(HMCS BoeHHbIM repoeM qeM MapUIan )KYKOB
MHorHe napTHHHbIe lJHHbI nOBa)(Hee ropfiaqeBa B 1978 r
paCTOlJanO HeofibIlJaHHbIe nOXBanbI fipe)(HeBCKOMY JIHTeparypHOMY
onycy 3TO CBHJeTeJIbCTByeT 0 nyCToTe JerpaJaUHH 0 pa3JIO)(eHHH
oJeOJIOrHH JIerKo nOHHTb KynbT BO BpeMeHa CranHHa KorJa
JOJI)(HOCTHble JI8Ja onacanHCb 3a CBOO )(H3HH Ho B 1978 r OHH
pHcKoBanH TOJIbKO 3aJep)(KOH B npoJBH)(eHHH no JOJI)(HOCTH
IDIO YTpaTOH KaKOH-TO npHBIDIerHH
TaKOM OfiPaJOM B 1985 r KorJa ropfiaqeB cran reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKperapeM HeofixoJHMOCTb HOBbIX HJeH 0 HHHUHarHB B 06shy
JIaCTH HJeOJIOrHH CTana BeCbMa HaCrOSTeJIbHoH BbIJIO OqeBOJHO
qyO ropfiaqeB He cofiHpancs caM yJOBJIerBopHTb 3ry HeofixoJHshy
MOCTb pa3Be TOJIbKO B pOJIO PYKOBOJHreJIS HJeOJIorulJeCKOrO
fiaHKa HJeH HalJHHaBUIerO B03HHKan OrJeJIbHbrH fiaHK HJeH
CTan lgtopMHpoBarbCS BOKpyr JIuraqeBa 3ro C03JaBanO B03MO)(shy
HOCTb fiyJJYIUHX npOTHBopelfHil Me)(Jy rreBblM H IIpaBbIM Hanshy
paBJIeHHIMH HO HeJIb3S fibIJIO Cpa3Y onpeJeJIHTb HX reHJeHIQiH
211210
HoeaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii
nporpaMMlgtI no)]roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII CDe3)Jy napTHH 3a)Jashy
lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX BnyTpeHHHX
H Me)l()JyHapolJHblX npo6rreM H Bbl)JBIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX
pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTHshy
IIeCKHH MaHHltpeCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xoIWMa
TaK KaK npeJKlU[a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1961 r Ha 6rrH)l(aiiume 20 JIeT
Dna HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe)]eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor)]a He 6blshy
JIH )]OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03)J3BaTIgt Tpy)]shy
HOCTH H CHH)fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HYKlfll H )IJla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii (TaK KaK
CYlUecmyeT npoue)Jypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIOshy
IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii) H )IJla ny)l()J Me)I()JyHashy
PO)JHoii nOJIHTHKH - nporpaMMa KIICC CIIYflliT Mo)]eJIbIO nporshy
paMM )]PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii
HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii napshy
THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa ltPOPMaJlbHas
nporpaMMa Beer)Ja 6blJIa H3H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me)I()JyHapo)]shy
Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO )JBH)KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrapeshy
BaJla B TelIeHHe )JByx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTyshy
nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre)JHHe napshy
THiiHble )]OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas oltPHUHaJlhHas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II Cbe3)]e napTHH B BplOcceshy
JIe H 3aTeM B llOH)JOHe r)]e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me)K)Jy 6oJIbllleBHshy
KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii
CB060)Jb1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npoltpshy
C01030B11 CJIe)Jyronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM
H TpoIUltHM H 0)]06peua VIII napTCbe3)]oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa)KaJla
yCJIOBHH rpa)l()JaHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3shy
Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa)JHKaJlbHOii oua oTpa)KaJla Ha)Je)K)Jy
na HeH3OO)KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras
oTMeny )]eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH)JOK
XOT9 noerre BBe)]eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII
HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO )]0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH
npaBHlI KaK )JHKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTemHO YMeHblllHlIaCh
oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM
TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO)JfOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C 1954 r no 1961 r
H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua XXII Cbe3)Je KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo-
BaJla 003 ltpOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMlgtI MHorne rO)JbI B npaBJIeHHe CTashy
JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY)KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa OleHb ny)KHa Ero KpHTHshy
KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H )]pyrHe PYKOBOIWTeJIH KaK peshy
BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny)l()JaJlca B )]OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl
ero H)JeH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMHshy
IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c)]eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo)]eJIhlO AllII )]pyrHX CTpaH C
KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha)JemlC9 TaKHM nyreM
npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me)l()JyHapo)JHOM KOMMyshy
HHCTHIeCKOM )JBIDKeHHH (H KHraii H IOroerraBHH npe)JlIO)KHJIH
aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO)JeJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe
KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe
ltpPaKUHH) TaKHM 06pa30M na Me)l()JyHapo)JHoii apeHe TpeTha napshy
THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa )Ja)Ke B)KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii B HTOshy
re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH
H npHTa3aHHs B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko)]eKc
33HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH (HfHopHpyeMbIH cashy
MHMH PyKOBOIWTeJI9MH) onpe)]eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCTshy
BeHHble ueJIH ua 70-e H 8O-e rO)JbI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepeashy
JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK)Ke HeHa)Je)KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl
nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a)JMHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla
1JT0 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo)]CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9IOTC9
C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 1970 r H npeB30ii)JyT HX K
1980 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y)]eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIOIW
6y)JyT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo)JHMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9M COBeTcshy
KHii COlO3 )]OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3BoIWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy)Ja B MHshy
pe Ka)K)Ja9 eeMb9 6y)]eT HMeTh oT)]eJIbHblii )]OM HlIH KBapTHpy
KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoDBeralOIUHMH H )]OXO)JHbIMH a UHTashy
HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y)]eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax
HHIero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO )]OCTHfHyrO B nporpaMMe YKa3blBashy
JIOCh1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm )]OXO)] B 1980 r 6y)]eT B 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM
B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y)]eT npoH3BOIWTh 2700 MJIP)]
KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro)] (Ha )]eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT noshy
KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP)]) 700 MJIH T Heltpm (B 1980 r 6bIJIO)]0shy
6bITO 603 MJIH T) 300 MJIH T lepHa (ypo)fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T) H 30 MJIH T Maca (npOH3Bo)]CTBO M9ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO
15 MJIH T) 12 He 6bIJIa )]oCTHrnyra HH 0)JHa H3 HaMeleHHblX UHltPP
(JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B
1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T)
213 212
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
BpaCJeH OCYKAeHHbIX H npHlOBopeHHIgtIX B ljIeBpane 1953 rona B o6JIaCTH BHeIIIHeH nOJIHTHKH 6bIJIO HaCTOHTenlgtHO He06xo~0 3aKOHlIHTh BOHHy B Kopee TIPH IipegtmeBe 61gtIDO MeHlgtWe Me)l(llyshyaapollHhlX KPH3HCOB Tpe60BaBIIIHX HeMenrreHHoro pa3peweHUH HO OH Hero KonnerH 3HeprWlHO oeHCTBOBaJIH B KOHcepBaTHBHOM CTHshyne tfr061gtI H3MeHHIIgt nH6epanIgtHIgtIe TeHJJemum B HAeOnorHH H BayrshypeHHeH nOJIHTHKe B03HHKII1He npH XpymeBe 3anperuaH ny6JIHKashyDHIO KHHf BblnyCK ltpHnIgtMOB H T 0 fop6atfeB npUJJli K BnaCTU BUshyoen caMYIO HeomogtmyIO 3auaQY He B KaKHX-TO oeHCTBHHX a B COCshyTaBneHHH oOKyMeHTOB npegtKJJe Bcero nporpaMMIgtI napTHH roe cooep)K3JlHCb 6bI peKOMeHJJaDHu 0 6yuyruei BHYTpeHHeH nOJIHTHKe H nonmKeHHH CCCP B MHpe OKOHlfaTenlgtHIgtm BapHaHT 3THX oOKyshyMeHTOB nOKaaan tfrO HOBoe PYKOBOoCTBO erue He rOTOBO K oeicTshyBeHHIgtIM HAeOnOfHCIeCKHM H nOnHTHlfeCKHM HHHUHaTHBaM
MHorHe 06rueCTBeHHhle H npoljlecCHOHanlgtHIgtIe rpynnbI BbmashyIIIHBaJIH aaue)KlJbI tfrO HOBoe PYKOBOoCTBO pa3peIIIHT HaKannHBaBshyIIIHeCH rooaMH a TO H oeCHTHneTHHMH 3auallH UeHTpanlgtHIgtIH KOMHshyTeT llpe3HAHM BepxoBHoro COBeTa H peuaKTopbI BeAlURx ra3eT Bceroa nonyqanu MHoro nuceM a nocne CMeHlgtI PYKOBooCTBa OHH nOKaTHnHCIgt naBHHoH 3TH nucbMa a He BIgtI60PbI B BepXOBHIgtm COshyBeT OTpIDKaIOT 06rueCTBeHHOe MHeHHe B HatJane 60-x rooOB MashyBecmH co06ruanu tfrO nOJlYlJaIOT 00 2000 OUceM B oeHlgt a TIPaBshyua MO)KeT 61gtITIgt nonyqana erue 6onlgtwe TIOtfrH K~IH rpa)KJJashyHUH CCCP XOTh pa3 B )KH3HH Hanucan nuCbMO HaIfHHaIOUJeeCH 06shyparueHHeM YBa)KaeMbm TOBapuw H aupeCOBan ero KpaTKO MocKBa KpeMnb Teneplgt Korua 3THM TOBapHIUeM CTan 3HepshymClHhlii fop6atfeB OH HaBepHOe nonylfHn HeCKOnlgtKO MHJIJIHOHOB nuceM cooep)KaBWUX He TOnlgtKO n03opaBneHUH HO npeMO)KeHUH npOOKTbI npoClgt6bI )Kan06hl Tpe60BaHHH cnpaBenrrHBOCTH 06paweshyHUH no nOBOoy 3aKnIOCJeHHbIX (ux B CCCP 60nee 2 MllH tfenOBeK) OT nOnHTHtfeCKUX 3aKnIOtfeHHbIX H OT HHaKOMblCOHIUHX BCHKOro poua (nOtfrH Bee UaBeCTHIgtIe COBeTCKHe HHaKOMbICOHUJHe HaIfaJIH CBOIO 06ruecTBeHHYIO oeHTenbHOCTIgt C OUCIgtMa B UK HJ1H TIOnHT6IOshypo) 3TH nuCIgtMa - Ba)KHbm acneKT coBeTcKoii nOnHTHCJeCKoH )(H3HH OHH nooruPHIOTCH KOHCTHyYDHeH CTaThH 49 KOTOPOi rnashyCHT
K~H rpa)KJJaHHH CCCP HMeeT npaBo BHOCHTh B rocyuapshyCTBeHHble opraHlgtl H 06rueCTBeHHbIe OpraHH3aDHH npeMO)KeHHH 06
yrryqweHHH ux oeHTenbHOCTH KpuTHKOBaTIgt HeoOCTaTKH B pa60Te )lon)KHOCTHhle mrua OM3aHhl B YCTaHOBneHHble aaKOHOM CPOKH paccMaTpHBaTIgt npenrrO)KeHHH U 3aHBneHHH rpa)KJJaH oaBaTb Ha HUX OTBeThI H npHHHMaTh He06xoJJHMble Mephl TIpecoeooBaHHe 3a KpHshyTHKyaanperuaeTcHl
3Ta Ba)KHaH CTaThH cOBeTcKoH KOHCTHTyDHH 03HatfaeT tfrO ecnH nocnaHO cooTBeTCTBYIOruee nuCbMO B TIonHT6IOpo unH B UK ua)Ke caMaH paJJHKanlgtHaH nOnHTHlfeCKaH KpHTHKa He oon)KHa HCTonshyKOBblBaThCH KaK aHTHCOBeTCKaH nponaraaua EcnH TaKHe OUCIgtMa He 61gt1JlH npeuaHhl IIIHPOKOH rnaCHOCTH He pacnpoCTpaHHnHCIgt B CaMH3oare H He OmpaBnHnHCb 3a rpaHJmy aBTOp HJ1H aBTOPbI He oOngtmlgtl npHBneKaThCH K cyoy ECTeCTBeHHO OUCbMa TaKOrO poua MOryT nOnaCTIgt B CaMH3uaT HJ1H 3a rpamwy He no Bone aBTOPOB Ho oljlHDHanlgtHble JIHua paCCMaTpHBaIOT 3T0 KaK nperrnor AllH npeo1gtHBneHHH 06BUHeHHH B HapymeHHH 3aKOHa
TIOXO)Ke fop6aleB nOHHn Ba)KHOCTIgt 3THX nueeM KaK 6aposhyMeTpa 06rueCTBeHHoro MHeHHH OH HeOllHOKpaTHO UHTHpOBan UX B peqax no nOBOoy 3KOHOMHtfeCKHX npo6JIeM (B UenHHOrpaue HanshypHMep OH DHTHpOBan OUCbMa npoCTblX nIOoei KOTOplgtle npeMarashynH nO)JHHYIgt ueHY Ha xne6 tfr06bl ero He CKapMllHBanH CKOTY) OpshyraHH3auHH OTBeTOB Ha 3TH DHCbMa 61gtIDa npeoMeTOM ero nepBOH BHYTpeHHeH nepeCTpoHKH B UeHTpanbHOM KOMHTeTe lJuCJIeHHOCTh 3THX nueeM Teneplgt TaKOBa tfrO 6onbwoH OToen co 150 COIp)llHHKashyMH He CDpaBnHnCH COTBeTaMH Ha HHX nOCKonbKY 3aKOH YCTaHaBnHshyBan O)JHOMeCHlfHbm CPOK AllH OTBeTOB Ha DHCbMa IihlDO peweHO paCnyCTHTIgt OToen H pacnpeoemlTlgt notfrY no coomeTCTBYIOIUHM OTshyoenaM UK 3TO 6bIDO 3opaBoe peweHUe TaK KaK MHome nuClgtMa 6bIDH CJIHWKOM cneDHanIgtHIgtI tfr06hl Ha HHX MornH OTBeTHTh COIPYoshyHHKH oTJJena DHceM
OllHaKO nepBbIM HJJeonOmleCKHM HCnbITaHHeM AllH HOBoro PYKoBOJJCTBa OKa3anCH TaK )Ke KaK H)JlIH npe)JlUeCTBeHHHKoB fopshy6atfeBa Bonpoc 0 CTanHHe B MapTe nmH HHTeHCHBHhle npuroIoBneshyHUH K npa3nHOBaHHIO COPOKOBOi rooOBruHHbl )lHH no6e)JbI TIepeo CMepTbIO qepHeHKo 6bIDO 061gtHBneHO 0 BhlnycKe IjIHnbMa TI06eua CHJlTbm B 1983-1984 roJJax IjIHnbM npeocTaBnHn CTanuaa MyoPbIM repoeM a qepllHJIJIH H TpYM3Ha oTpuuaTenbHIgtIMH nepCOHIDKaMH ManO CJJeJIaBIIIHMH tfr06bI nOMO yCunHHM CCCP B BoHHe HY)KHO 61gtIDO peIIIHTb BhlDycKaTIgt nH 3TOT IjIHnbM Ha 3KpaHlgtl I1MeJIHCb
202 203
rpynnhI B lIaCIHOCm BeTepaHOB BoiHhI KOTOphIe HaCTaHB3nH Ha
pea6~ CTamma BOJIrOrpanCKHH rOpCOBet H 06IueCTBo
BeTepaHOB 06paTHlIHCb C neT~eil 0 BOSBpameHHH ropoA) Ha3BaHIVI
CT3nHHrpaP H rOBOpHlIH lITO lIepHeHKo 6blJI rOTOB nOPnHCSTb
COOTBeTCmyrouum YK33 fOp6atIeB nOWeJI Ha KOMIIpoMHCC cIlHJIbM
nOftBHlICJI Ha SKpaHaX HO BOJIrorpan OCT3nCJI BonrorpaPOM MHoshy
me HHTenneKty3nhI 6hIJDI ycnoKoeHhI STHM peweHHeM
PetIb fop6atIeBa B KaHYH )lHJI no6eAhI 8 MaJI He 6hDIa HHTeshy
peCRoi llO-BHpHMOMy petIb 6blJIa HanHcaHa ARJI Hero TaK lJIO STO
6hDI OtIeHh OltP~hHhIH H CpePKaRHbIH aHalIHS OAHaKO fop6atIeB
npH3H3n H8JIHlHe olIDl60K H npoCtIeTOB B HatIane BoiHhI npepweCTshy
BOBaBlIDIX no6epe H ynoMJIHYn HMB CTanHHa TonbKO oAHH pas
EcnH H cyweCTBOB3nO HaMepeHHe pea6HJIHmpoBaTh CTanKHa OT Heshy
ro OtIeBHAHhIM 06P330M OTKa33nHCb C ppyroi CIOPOHhI TpaAHshy
UHOHHaJI 106HlIeiHaJI aMHHCTHJI 6blJIa p330llapoBaHHeM YKas 06
aMHHCTHH npHHJIThIH llpeSHAHYMOM BepxoBHoro COBeTa B KOmte
anpemI 6hDI OtIeHh Hs6HpaTenbHhIM ftBHhIM 06paSOM HCKnlOlIaBwHH
CIaThH yronoBHoro KopeKca HCIIonbsyeMhIe npoTHB nOnHTHqeCKHX
33KnlOtIeHHhIX WCKnlOtIanHCh pajKe Te KTO nonyqHJI MeHee Tpex
neT no CTaThe 1911 YK2 TaKHe nOnHTSaKJIlOtIeHHhIe KaK IOpHi Opshy
nOB H Cepreil KOB3neB yxce oT6hmlIDle ceMHJIemee SaKnlOtIeHHe B
narepe H HaxOAHBlIDIeCH B WlTHlIeTHei CChDIKe TO)J(e He nonanK
nop aMHHCmlO 3TO 6blJIO 6esoWH60tIHhIM npHSHaKOM lJIO HOBhm
PYKOBOAHTeJIh He JlBJIJletCJI nH6epanOM
3TO 6hDI He nepBhm npH3HaK HO HHTenneKty3nhI npopOJI)J(ashy
JIB HapeJIThCJI lITO nocne BCIynneHHJI fop6atIeBa B pomKHOCTh npoHshy
soiAYT KaKHe-TO HSMeHeHHJI EBpeH-OTK33HHKH HapeJIJIHCb lJIO
SMHrpaURJl ltp3KmtIeCKH npeKpaTHBWaJlCJI npH lIepHeHKo 6ypet
o6nertIeHa llOHatIllJIy CHTY3UHJI K333JIaCh 06Hape)l(lBalOweil B Mapshy
Te nOJIytIHlIH paspeweHHe SMHrpHpoBaTh 98 tIenOBeK3 B anpene
ewe 166 tIenOBeK npH6hIJIH B BeHy cpeAH HHX 6hDIH nlOAH HS MOCKshy
BhI H neHHHIp3A3 OTKYua paHee 6hDIO TpYAHee Bcero SMHrpHposhy
BaTh4 OAH3KO noprOTOBHTenhHhIe onepaUHH KOTophIe HaARe)J(HT
npopenaTh ARJI SMHrpaUHH T3K cnO)J(HhI lJIO SallBneHHJI Tex KTO
yeS)J(3nH B anpene POmKHhl 6hIJIH paCCMaTpHBaTbCH MHoro paRee
neTOM lJHcno P33peWeHHHH Ha SMHrpaUHlO CT3nO YMeHhUIaThCH
H K aBrycry ynano AO 3040 B MeCJIll (B STO tIHcno He BXOpJIT HeMshy
I(bI llOBOn)J(bJl 0 KOTOphIX H3BecTHbI TOJIhKO AaHHbIe sa BeCh roP)
3T0 MHoro HH)J(e cpeAHero YPOBHJI 1983 roua Korua e)J(eMeCJltHO
OKono 100 eBpeeB nOJIytIllJIH paspewellHe (B pasrape SMHrPaUHH
B 1979 r 1IHcneHHOCTb SMHrpaHTOB Bospocna AO 51 330 HOBaJI
xonopH3JI BoiHa YMeHhWHlIa HX tIHcno AO 9 447 B 1881 r H 2 692 B 1982 r)
naHHhIe 06 SMHrpaUHH npHHJITO pacCMaTpHBaTb KaK cyWeCTshy
BeHHhm nOKasaTenb OTHoweHHJI COBeTCKHX BJIactei K npo6neMe
npaB tIenOBeKa WSBecmo lJIO npHMepHO 100 ThIC COBetCKHX rpa)J(
AaH nopanH sallBneHHJI H )J(A)T p33peWeHHJI yexaTamp a 1IHcneHHOCTh
OTK33HHKOB COCTaBJIJleT OKono 30 ThIC tIenOBeK 3m AaHHhIe
xapaKTepHsyroT H 06IUHii ypoBeHamp peMOKpaTHH BHyTpH CIpaHbl
H Me)J(A)HapoAHYlO CHtyaUHlO B OKTJl6pe 3m UHltPPhI CROBa Hecshy
KonhKO BOSPOCJ1H B CBJlSH C BHSHTOM fop6atIeBa BO cJ)pamtH1O
H npHrOTOBJIeHHJIMH K BCIpetIe C npe3HpeHTOM PeiraHOM B OKTJl6shy
pe 124 eBpeJi nOKHHYJIO COBeTcKHH Com B TOM 1IHcne 44 HS
MOCKBampI H 1 H3 neHHHrpauas B HOJl6pe 3MHrpHpoB3nO 128 tIeJIoshyBeK
B HHTepBblO ltPpamty3CKOMy TeneBHAeHHIO 30 ceHTJl6pJl fop6ashy
tIeB npopon)J(3n ymep)J(p3Tb lJIO SMHrpaUHlO HapO paccMatpHBaTh
TonhKO KaK BOCCOeAHHellHe ceMei 3TO SHatIHT lJIO AJlJI COBetcshy
KHX eBpeeB HeMtteB rpeKOB H ppymx HaUHOHanhHampIX MeHhWHHCTB
He CyWeCTByeT eCIeCTBeHHoro npaBa nOKHHYTamp CTpaHY no peJIHmos
HhlM HaUHOH3nbHhIM H KYJIamptypHhlM MOTHBaM B TOM )J(e HHtepBamp1O
fop6atIeB nOK333n lJIO OH HMeeT OlJeHh cna60e npepCIaBJIeHHe
o cyweCTBe eBpeHCKoi npo6neMhl B CCCP OH ymep)J(IJaJl lITO
nonO)J(eHHe eBpeeB B CCCP nyqwe lJeM rpe 6hI TO HH 6blJIO B MHpe
EBpeicKoe HaceneHHe COCIaBJIJIlOwee 069 HaceneHHJI CTpaHbI
B nOJIHTHtIeCKoi H KYJIamptypHOil )J(H3HH npepCTaBJIeHO B KOJlHteCTshy
Be OT 10 po 206 OR 6hIJI npaB B OTHOWeHHH ypeJIhHOrO Becs
eBpeeB B tIHCneHHOCTH HaceneHKJI CCCP HO OtIeHamp tpYAHO H3MepHTamp
HaCKOJIampKO OHH npepcTaBneHbI B cOBeTCKoi KYJIhtypHOil )J(H3HH
llOMHMO Bcero npotIero )TO BOnpOC He TOJIampKO npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHoil
nOJIHTHKH HO T3K)J(e Bonpoc CBJlSaRHhIi C HHAHBHAYanampHhIMH YCHshy
JIHJlMH H CKnOHHOCTJlMH W CK33aTh tITO eBpeH npepCIaBneHhI
B COBeTCKoi nOJIHTHtIecKoi )J(H3HH B npepenax OT 10 po 20 JlBJIJletCJI oqeBHAHhIM a6cYPPoM B npaBHTeJIhCTBe eCTh TOJIampKO
OAHH eBpeil (BeHHaMHH ampIMWHIQ a no MeHee 1 llponopUHSl
eBpeeB B KOMMyHHcTHtIeCKOi napTHH 6hIJIa paBHa 1A B 1983 r
204
205
H TOmKO Owm eBpeH (Be3AecymHH llblMIlIHrO cpenu 311 lJJ1eHOB
IIK Co BpeMeHH nepBoro BRlHTa B COBeTcKHH COI03 rpynnhl
aMepHKaHCKHX ceHaTopoB H KOHfpeccMeHoB B anpene rop6aqeB
nonyIRlI MHoro nHlHhiX oGplllQeHHH no nOBooy nOJIHTHleCKHX laKshy
nIOqeHHhIX H oTKa3HHKoB Ero orneT GhlJI 06hIlHbIM llOlBomTe
HaM caMHM pewaTb HaIIIH BHYTpeHHHe npo6JIeMbl7 OH TaK)Ke
npoAOJIJK3J1 ~ep)l(AaTb ITO nOJIHTHqeCKHX pHcCHAeHTOB cyMT
TonbKO TOrAa KorAa OHH HapywaIOT JaKOH XOTJI OH AOJI)KeH lHaTb
ITO COBeTCKHH 3aKOH 06paIIJaeT HHaKOMhICnHe B npeCTYIIJIeHHe TeM
He MeHee nepeA )KeHeBCKOH BCTpeqeH Ha BblCUleM ypoBHe 6bIJI CAeshy
naH )KeCT AOGpoH BOJIH B HOJlGpe EneHe EOHHJp )KeHe COenaHHOrO
AlmpeJl CaxapoBa 6h1Jlo pa3peUleHo BhlexaTb 3a rpaHHQY Ha caMOM
Aene CaxapoB HaIaJI CBOIO TpeTbIO ronoAoBKY no 3TOMY nOBOOY
B OKTJlGpe TpeGYJI lT06hI ero )KeHe GhlJIO pa3peUleHO BblexaTb
JJl1J1 neqeHHJI Y Hero cna60e 3AopoBbe eMY 6hlJIO 64 rOAa OH GhlJI
OqeHb ena6 noene npe)I(HHx ronoAoBoK laKOHIHBIlIHXCJI B 6onbHHshy
ne npHHYAHTenhHbIM KOpMJIeHHeM Ero )KH3Hb GhlJIa nOA yrpo30H
ECJlH 6hI OH yMep B HOJIGpe HerOAOBaHHe B CIlIA GhlJIO 6bl CJlHIJlshy
KOM CHJIhHblM lT06bI rop6atIeB Mor paCCIHTblBaTlo Ha KaKOH-TO
ycnex B JKeHeBe CTaBKH GhIJIH CJlHIJlI(OM BhlooKH H B KOHne OKTJI~ pJl EneHe EOHHlP COOGIIJHJlH ITO OHa MO)l(eT BblexaTb la rpaHHQY
HeMeJJl1eHHO CaxaPOB GhlJI KpynHeHUleH npo6JIeMoH JJl1J1 rop6aqeshy
Ba B o6JIacTH npas qenOBeKa OH GhIJl BhlenaHB rOpbKHHB 1980 r Ge3 CYAa H cYAeGHoro pa36HpaTemcma 3TO 6h1Jlo CAenaHO KrE
nOA nO)l(HhIM npeJJl10rOM ITO CaxapoB pacnOJIaraeT rocYAaPCrneHshy
HLIMH ceKpeTaMH (nO)l(HhIM nOTOMY ITO CaxaPOB GlolJI YSOJIeR
H3 HHCTHTYTa aTOMHOH 3HepTHH B 1968 r ABeRaAnaTbIO roAaMH
paHee R He npHHHMaJI yttaCTHJI B OpHeHTHpoBaHHLIX Ha BoeHHhle
HY)l(Abl HCeneAOBaHHJlX C 1964 r) OT npaB03aIIJHTHLIX rpynn B CCCP OC06eHHO OT tfJIeROB
MOCKOBCKOH XenlocHHKcKOH rpynnhl H lMHfpaHTOB - GblBIJlHX noshy
JIHT3aKJIIOtIeHHloIX npoAOJI)I(aJla nocrynaTb RHqoPManRJI 06 apeCTax
HHaKOMbICJlJlIIJHX H aKTHBHLIX npasOJaIIJHTHHKOB H CYAJI no
e)KeHeAemHLIM COO6IIJeHHJIM 0 HapYUleHHJlX npas 1IenOBeKa H3Aashy
BaeMloIX KpoHHAOM nI06apcKHM BO BTOPOH nonOBRHe 1985 r He
6hlJI0 3aMemo CYIIJeCTBeHHhIX H3MeHeHHH CHTYanHH8 MOCKOBCKHH
Me)l(AyHapo)lHloIH qeCTHBaJIh MonOAe)KH npoxoAHJl nOA 00060
YCHJleHHOH OXpaHOH MHJlHUHH - cnyqanOClo ITO MHJlHIUlORepOB OKashy
3bmaJIOClo 6onloUle qeM rOCTeH llpe~ qeCTHBaJIh MOnOAe)KH
B 1957 r l 6loIJI paAOCTHLIM H CBo60AHLIM Cbe3AOM IOHOUleH H AeBYshy
UleK Ha nOT pal aTMoccpepa GhlJIa OOBceM RHOH rOCTJlM BhIAaJIH
nponycKa C HX cpoTorpaltPHJlMH KOTopble OHH AOJI)l(HhI 6loIJIH HOeHTb
nOCTOJIRHObull llHCKYCCHH npoBoAHJlHcb fJIaBHLIM 06pa30M Ha nOJIHTHshy
1IeCKRe TeMb C IIBHOH aHTH3anaAHoH HanpasneHHoCTbIO
llOnO)l(eHHe B COI03e nHcaTeneH R Apyrnx ooI03ax TBopllecshy
KOH HHTeJIJIHfeHnHH (~PHaJIHCTOB KOMll03HTOPOB KHHeMaTorpashy
CPRCTOB H T A) OGloIIHO MO)KeT enYJKHTb XOpoUlHM nOKa3aTeneM
BHyTpeRHero nOJIHTHqeCKorO KJlHMaTa BeerAa RMeIOTCJI AeCJITI(H
nOBeCTeH qHJlhMOB nbeC H T A npeACTaBJIeHHhIX )JlIJI Ony6JIHKoshy
BaHHJI HJlH )JlIJI pa3peUleHHJI nOCTaHOBKH Ha cueHe RJIH JKpaHe
Bee nbeCbl R CPRJIbMbl AOJI)I(HbI nOnyqHTb pa3peUleRHe cnenuaJIbHOrO
KOMHTeTa B03fJIaBJIJleMOrO oooTBeTcmyroIIJHM neH3opoM (Ha o~
naCTHOM ypoBHe eCJlH meca npeACTaBneHa npoBHHUHaJIbHOMY
TeaTpy) 3HaIIHTenloHaJI 1IaCTlo lTHX pa60T 6hlJIa oTBepfHYTa RJIH
OTJIO)KeHa AO BHeeeHRJI H3MeHeHHii ABToPhl peLaKTophI H pe)KHcshy
eepbl (cpepH HHX OqeHL R3BecTHble) HeHJGe)I(HO OGplllQaJIHCb K Hoshy
BOMY PYKOBOpHTenIO JJl1J1 pa3peUleHHJI HX TpYAHOCTeH C neH30paMR
B anpene nORBRJIHClo 06HaAe)I(HBaIOIIJHe npR3HaKH TOro ITO RlMeshy
HeHRJI HOCJITCJI B B03JJYXe rOp6alleB OTKa3aJICJI YSHAeTbCJI C AByMR
H8H60nee KOHeepsaTHBHblMH PYKOBOAHTeJIJlMH COI03a nHcaTeshy
neH - r MapKoBblM npeAeeAaTeneM H A qaKOBCKRM peLaKToshy
poM nmepaTYpHOH raJeTbl EMY nonaraJIOCb BCTpeTHTbCJI C HHMH
lTOGbl HaJIaAHTb xopoIlIHe OTHOUleHHJI C JTHMH orneTCrneHHloIMH
pa60THHKaMH (AlmponOB BHAeJICJI C HHMH B AeKaGpe 1982 r
H Bhlpa3RJI RM CBoe AOBepHe) HO RM 6blJlO CKa3aHO ITO ropGaqeB
enHIJll(OM 3aHJIT CTaJIO HJBeCTHO TaK)Ke lITO lleTp lleMHleB (MRshy
HHCTp KynbTYPbl KaHIlHAaT B lDIeHbl llOJIHTGIOPO H 6blBumii rnaBa
oTAena nponaraHAbI IIK) R ero AOn)I(HOCTHLle mwa CTaJIH Gonee
Be)l(llHBbl C nOeeTHTenJlMH C ApyrOH CTOPOHbl llPR6hITKOB owm HJ
fJIaBHLIX nOMOIIJHHKOB qepHeHKo GlolJI Ha3HaqeH 38MeCTHTeneM
KOMHTeTa no oXpaHe rOCYAapcmeHHLIX eeKpeTOB B nettaTH (OcpHshy
nuaJIbHOe Ha3BaHHe OOBeTCKOH neH3yphI) llnJl llpHGbITKOBa 3T0
GlolJIO nOHH)KeHHeM H Re cynHJlO HHlero xopoUlero B o6JIaCTH neH3Yshy
pbl EhlJIH CJIyXR ITO rOp6a1leB H MHXaHJl 3HMJIHHH BTOPOH eeKpeshy
Tapb HAeOJIOfHleCKOrO OTAena IIK BTOPOH qeJIOBeK noene Cyenoshy
206 207
Ba BbDIonwmIIIHii ry )l(e ponb npH JlHraqeBe He nonlAJfJlH Ho noshy
BHARMOMy- HHKatltHX HOBbIX HHCTpYKIHii He 6bmo H CHrylI(HII He
ynyqunmaCb HrreonOrHtJeCKHe 3allBneHIDI rop6aqeBa 6bIllH W3ycshy
MbIcneHHbI H He o6HapYgtKHBaJIH HOBOro no)Uona llOXOgtKe 6bmo tJTO
rop6alleB IIel1HKOM nopYtJHJ1 HpeonOrHlO JlHralleBY H CKOHIIeHTpHshy
POBaJI CBoe BHHMaHHe Ha 3KOHOMHKe
B aBryCTe EBremm EBrymeHKo H3BecmlilH n03T H nOllHTHshy
IeCKH npoTHBopetJIfBaJI cpurypa HanHcaJI rop6alleBY nHCbMO 0 nnashy
IeBHOM COCTOIIHHH COBeTCKOH llHTeparypbI H llpe3MepHOH CTporocshy
TH IIeH3ypHbIX OrpaHHlleHHH B more B llpaBpe 9 ceHTII6pll
6bIJ1a ony6mnltoBaHa ero KOPOTKaJI n03Ma B KOTOPOH noppepgtKHBashy
naCb 3KOHOMHlJeCKaJI nOllHTHKa rop6alleBa COpep)l(aJlHCb HanllAKH
Ha 61OPOKpaTOB 6oIIIIIHxcII HOBoBBepeHHH H npoTHBJDInlxCII HM
H BOCXBaJIIIJ1C11 WeCTHMeCIIIIHbm COBeTCKuH MopaTopuH Ha Mepshy
HbIe HcnhITaHHJI KaK 6ecnpeIIepeHTHOH cMenocm nOW3Hr BO HMII
MHpa9 ll03Ma copepgtKaJla TatltgtKe CKpbIryIO KpHTHKy KOJ1J1eKTHBHshy
3lIIHH H OTKPhITYlO KpHTHKy JIhIceHKo CBII3bIBlll HblHeWHHe Cel1hCshy
Kox03JriiCTBeHHble TpyDHOCTH C 6mpoKpaTmleCKHMH nperpanaMH
Ho H3 n03MbI IICHO cnepOBano tJTO He napTHII a 61OpoKpaThI omeTshy
CTBeHHbI 31 Bce 3TO B TOMgtKe MeCIIIIe rop6alleB Ha3HatJHJ1 AlleKcaHApa HKOBneBa
rnaDOH OTpel1a nponaraHAhI UK CMeCTHB CryKaJIHHa Ha3HalleHHOrO
nocnOM B BeurpHIO 3r0 paCCMaTpHBaJIOCb KaK XOPOWUH 3HaK
OTpen nponaraHJ]hl IIBJ111eTCII KlllOIIeBhIM 3BeHOM l1HIalleBCKOro
H1leonOrHtJeCKOrO ceKpeTapHaTa lloxo)l(e Ha3HaleHHe 3TO 6bIJ10
npoH3BepeHO B cneWKe (Katlt H Ha3HaqeHHe Pa3YMOBCKoro rnaBOH
OpraHH3lI(HOHHoro OTpel1a) Tatlt Katlt 06blIIH0 rnaBa OTpena nponashy
raHIJbl IIBJ1IIeTCII IJl1eHOM HJ1H KaHlJH)JaTOM B IJl1eHhI UK a HKOBlleB
TatltOBbIM He 6bIJ1 OH 6bIJ1 3aMecmTeneM 3aDe)lylOIIero Omel10M
nponaraHAbI HO 6bIJ1 CMeIIeH CycnOBhIM B 1970 r (OqeBHARo 31
ny6mnclI(H1O B nOllHTHtJeCKHX H llHTepaTypHbIX lKYPHaJIax CTaTeH C KpHTHKOH HeOCTaJIHHHCTCKHX H pycOcpHllbCKHX TeHAeHIHii) H HaJHashy
qeH nocnoM B KaHaJJY B nOM KaleCme OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6aqeshy
Ba BO BpeMII ero BH3Hta B KaHaJJy H MegtKAY HHMH YCTaHOBHllHCb
xopowue OTHOWeHIDI HKOBneB 6hIll B03BplIIeH B MOCKBY H Ha3shy
HaleH ARpeKTOPOM HHcmryra MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKH H MegtKAYHapopshy
HbIX OTHowemm OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6alleBa BO BpeMII ero BH3HTa
B BeJIHK06PHTaHHIO B 1984 r CllHTaeTCII tJTO HKOBneB He 1C0Hcepshy
BaTOp HO OH nonytJHT BnHllHHe TonhlCO ecnH 6ypeT H36paH B UK HOBbIe Ha3HaqeHIDI B HAeonOrHtJeCICOM OTpene BbIrnIIAIIT
BeChMa o6eIIalOIIHMH rpy60 rOBOpll COBeTCICHe HAeonorHtJeCKHe
pa60THHICH penIITcII Ha W3e rpynnhI 1C0HCepBaTHBH)IO 0PTOAQICshy
CaJ1hH)IO 1C0TOPym nOppepgtKHBaJIH CycnOB H neMHIIeB H 60nee
clCnoHaym IC pecpopMaM YMepeHHO nporpecCHBH)IO )lHpeICTOP
HHcmryTa CIlIA H KaHaAhI reopruH Ap6aTOB 6bIBWuH peAaKTOP
llpaBAhI a Teneph ARpelCTOP HHCTHtyTa COIIHOnOrHH AllelCceH
Py-MIIHIIeB CTapWUH COTPYAHHK MegtKAYHapoDHoro OTpena UK H nnopOBHThIH nHcaTenb no BonpocaM COIIHaJIH3Ma H KOMMfHH3Ma
r InaXHaJapoB AlleICcaHAP BOBHR H cIgtepop BypnallKHH 06a H3shy
BeCTHhIe gtKypHallHCTbl - OTHOCllTCII KO BTOPOH rpynne CKllOHaym IC
peCPOPMaM rpynny TOIIHee Ha3BaTh nporpeCCHBHOH qeM nH6epanhshy
HOH Y 3TOH rpynnhI YCTaHOBHllHCh xopowue OTHoweHIDI C AHAposhynOBbIM 1C0rna OH po 1967 r 6hm celCpeTapeM UK llocne HeKoToposhy
ro cnlna BnHIIHHII OHH nOXO)l(e BHOBh BhICTynuJIH Ha CIIeHy nocne
CMepTH Bpe)f(leBa rop6aQeB He HMeBWHH co6CTBeHHoro HHTennelCshy
ryaJIhHOro OICpy)l(eHIDI BHAHMO Ha6Hpan COBeTHHICOB nOMoIUHHshy
ICOB H ppyrux pOn)f(lOCTHbIX llHII H3 3TOH rpynnhI Ho nelaJIhHO
H3BecmhIe CBOHM lCoHcepBaTH3MOM 3HMIIHHH rnaDa OTllena lCynhshy
ryPhI UK Inaypo H peAaKTOP gtKypHaJIa BonpoChI 3KOHOMHKH
H ARpelCTOP HHCTHryTa 3KOHOMHKH XatJaTypoB COXpaHHllH BllHllHHe
H B03MO)f(lO HMelOT nyqwue IIeM nporpeCCHCThl OTHOmeHHJI C
JlHraqeBbIM
TpeTbll rpynna - IIeHTpHCTClCaII B Hee BX0AIIT penaICTOp
llpaBAhI ACPaHaCbeB H pepaKTOP TeopemlleCKOrO napmHHoro
gtKYpHaJIa KOMMyHHCT PHtJapp KOCOnaDOB llOCKonhlCY COBeTCKuH
COlO3 IIBJ111eTCII HpeOnOrHtJeCICHM rocypapcmOM nyooHKlIIHU B
napTHHHbIX oprauax netJarn 06bIIIH0 6hIBalOT HaH60nee 3HatJHMhlMH
nOKaJaTenllMH TeKYIIHX nonHTHtJeCICHX H HAeonOrHtJeCKHX TeHAeHshy
IIUHmiddot MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M IIBJ1IIeTCII CYIIeCTBeHHbIM CBII3ymIIIHM
3BeHOM MegtKAY pa3J1HllHhIMH rocynapcmeHHhIMH yqpegtKAeHIDIMH
H neranH3yeT BepxoBHym BnaCTh napTHH H ee reHepanbHoro ceKpeshy
tapll HpeonorHtJeCKHe CBII3H MelKA) pa3HbIMH qaCTIIMH rocypapshy
CTBeHHOH MaWHHbI COXpaHIIT CBOIO npOlJHOCTb ecnH COXPaHHTshy
CII IIeMeHTHpymmaH ponh HAeonorHH 3Ta ponh IIBHO YMeHhIlIHshy
209208
JIaCb BO BpeMeHa Bpe)lQeBa HO 3TO fibIJlO BbI3BaHO He CTPYKrypshy
HblMH H3MeHeHHHMH a CBoero POIJ8 HlJeOJIOrlflleCKHM CKJIeposhy
30M BepXH napTHH fiblJIH He cnocofiHbI C031J8Tb Ifl1eOJIorlfllecshy
KHH COJHaJIbHbIH IDIH nOJIHTlflleCKHH JOKyMem K KOTOPOMY
Ofipa30BaHHbIe KpyrH MornH fibI OTHeCTHCb eepbe3HO B 1970-x H
1980-x roJaX nytflIIee qyO MOrJIa npeJJIO)lOTb napTHH JJIS BJOXHoshy
BeHHS HapolJ8 fibIJIH TPyruI Bpe)lQeBa - BOcnOMHHaHHS 0 roJax
BOHHbI 0 ueJIHHe H T JJ npHMHTHBHO H y60ro HanHCaHHbIe 3a Hero
JpymMH H nopolJHBIillIe 6eCqCJIeHHbIe aHeKJorbI
CaM rOpfialJeB TO)(e He H36e)(aJI HeKOTopoH npHtJaCTHOCTH
K npHMHTHBHbIM H 6ecCMbICJIeHHbIM HJeOJIOrlflleCKHM MaTepHanaM
Toro nepHolJ8 B peq Ha KOHlgtepeHUHli no BonpocaM HJeOJIOrHH B
CTaBponOJIbCKOM Kpae B Mae 1978 r KorJa OH eII(e fibIJI eeKpeTashy
peM rOpKOMa ropfiaqeB CKa3aJI
reHepanbHbIH ceKpeTapb UK KnCC npeJceJareJIb
IIpe3HJHyMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP JI H Bpe)(HeB shy
raJIaHTJIHBbrH PYKoBOJHTeJIb JIeHHHCKOro THna Ero THTashy
HHlJecKas nOBceJHeBHas pafioTa HanpaBJIeHa Ha YKpeIIJIeHHe
MOII(H CTpaHbI nOBbJIIIeHHe 6narocoCToSHHS rpyJlIIUHXCS
Ha ynpoqeHHe MHpa H fie30naCHOCTH HapoJoB
HeJaBHO MbI paCKPbIJIH CTpaHHJbI 3aMelJaTeJIbHOH KHHrH
TOBapHII(a J1 H Bpe)lQeBa bull Manu 3eMJIS rJe 3OJIOTbIMH
fiYKBaMH 3aJIelJaTJIeHbI noprpeTbI JIereHlJ8pHbIX repoeB
60es 3a CeBepHbrH WKaJ HeMHoro BpeMeHH npoIIIJIo co
JHI[ ny6nHKauHH KHHrO HO BOCnOMHHaHHH BbI3BanH
BceofiII(Hii nOJJIHHHO BceHapoJHbrH HHTepec qTofibI YJOBshy
JIeTBopHTb 6ecqCJIeHHbIe 3anpocbI TpKeHHKoB CTaBposhy
nOJIbIUHHbI B lgteBpane 3TH BOCnOMHHaHHH fiyJJYT nepeneshy
lJaTaHbI H3 YpHana HOBbrH MHP B HallIHX KpaeBblX
raJeTax CTaBponOJIbCKas npaBJa H KaBKa3CKas 3JpaBshy
HHua
B KHHre bullManas 3eMJIS He TaK MHoro crpaHHJ HO no
rnyfiHHe HJeOJIOrHlJeCKOrO coJep)(aHHH no IillIpoTe 0606shy
II(eHHH 0 MbICJIeH aBTOpa OHa CTana 60JIbIilllM COfibITHeM
OfiII(eCTBeHHOH )(H3HH OHa BbI3Bana rop~ OTKJIHK B
eepJJax COBeTCKDX mOJeH 0 BOCX8II(eHHble OT3b1BbI COJIshy
IJ8T-IgtPOHTOBHKOB Ha qTaTeJIbCKDX KOHlgtepeHUHSX H B nelJaTH
KOMMYHHCTbI H Bce TpKeHHKH CTaBpOnOJIbIUHHbI 6ecshy
KOHelJHO 6narOJapHbI JIeoHHJy HnbHlfY Bpe)(HeBY 3a ero
nOJJIHHHO BJOXHOBJIeHHYIO napTHeH JIHTeparyPHYlO pa60TY
B KOTOPOH HCTOlfHHKH BeJIHKOro nOJBHra HallIeH repoHlJecshy
KOH CTpaHbI ee JJYXOBHOH H HpaBCTBeHHOH CHJIbI ee CIOHshy
KOCTH H MKeCTBa BCKPblTbI C IgtHJIOCOIgtCKOH rnyfiHHoH
(OfipaTHbrH nepeBOJ C aHrn - PeJ) 10
~ras 3TO HeYMepeHHoe BOCXBaneHHe nOBepXHOCTHoro H noeshy
peJCTBeHHoro COlJHHeHHH Bpe)lQeBa HeJIb3S He nOqyBCTBOBaTb qro
ero oJeOJIOrHqeCKOe B03JeHCTBHe SBJISeTCS ofipaTHblM KpoMe Bceshy
ro npoqero H3JIO)(eHHe Bpe)(HeBa HCKa)(aeT HCTOpHIO H CaM fibIJI
B 1943 r COJIJaTOM TaMaHcKoro IgtpoHTa H Manas 3eMJIS fibIJIa
Beero JImllb ero He60JIbIilllM 6eperoBblM aBaHnOCTOM B03HHKIillIM
BO BpeMH HaYlJ8lJHOro HacTyIlJIeHHH Ha HOBOPOCCHHCK B anpeJIe
H 3aTeM B Mae 1943 r IIoKa Bpe)(HeB 30 JIer CnyCTS He H30fipaJHJI
cofiblTHS TaM KaK OCHOBHYIO fiHTBY OHH fibIJIH He3HalJHTeJIbHbIM
BoeHHbIM 3JIH30JOM Bpe)(HeB fibIJI TorJa nOJIHTKOMHccaPOM
H TOJIbKO OJH~I noJIYqJIJI nOBb1lIIeHHe B lJHHe B 1941 r OH fibIJI
nOJIKOBHHKOM a K 1945 r CTan reHepan-MaH0poM Ho B 1978 r
olgtHUHanbHas npecca CTMa nucaTb 0 HeM TaK KaK fiYJTO OH fibIJI
60JIee BblJalOII(HMCS BoeHHbIM repoeM qeM MapUIan )KYKOB
MHorHe napTHHHbIe lJHHbI nOBa)(Hee ropfiaqeBa B 1978 r
paCTOlJanO HeofibIlJaHHbIe nOXBanbI fipe)(HeBCKOMY JIHTeparypHOMY
onycy 3TO CBHJeTeJIbCTByeT 0 nyCToTe JerpaJaUHH 0 pa3JIO)(eHHH
oJeOJIOrHH JIerKo nOHHTb KynbT BO BpeMeHa CranHHa KorJa
JOJI)(HOCTHble JI8Ja onacanHCb 3a CBOO )(H3HH Ho B 1978 r OHH
pHcKoBanH TOJIbKO 3aJep)(KOH B npoJBH)(eHHH no JOJI)(HOCTH
IDIO YTpaTOH KaKOH-TO npHBIDIerHH
TaKOM OfiPaJOM B 1985 r KorJa ropfiaqeB cran reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKperapeM HeofixoJHMOCTb HOBbIX HJeH 0 HHHUHarHB B 06shy
JIaCTH HJeOJIOrHH CTana BeCbMa HaCrOSTeJIbHoH BbIJIO OqeBOJHO
qyO ropfiaqeB He cofiHpancs caM yJOBJIerBopHTb 3ry HeofixoJHshy
MOCTb pa3Be TOJIbKO B pOJIO PYKOBOJHreJIS HJeOJIorulJeCKOrO
fiaHKa HJeH HalJHHaBUIerO B03HHKan OrJeJIbHbrH fiaHK HJeH
CTan lgtopMHpoBarbCS BOKpyr JIuraqeBa 3ro C03JaBanO B03MO)(shy
HOCTb fiyJJYIUHX npOTHBopelfHil Me)(Jy rreBblM H IIpaBbIM Hanshy
paBJIeHHIMH HO HeJIb3S fibIJIO Cpa3Y onpeJeJIHTb HX reHJeHIQiH
211210
HoeaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii
nporpaMMlgtI no)]roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII CDe3)Jy napTHH 3a)Jashy
lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX BnyTpeHHHX
H Me)l()JyHapolJHblX npo6rreM H Bbl)JBIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX
pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTHshy
IIeCKHH MaHHltpeCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xoIWMa
TaK KaK npeJKlU[a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1961 r Ha 6rrH)l(aiiume 20 JIeT
Dna HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe)]eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor)]a He 6blshy
JIH )]OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03)J3BaTIgt Tpy)]shy
HOCTH H CHH)fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HYKlfll H )IJla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii (TaK KaK
CYlUecmyeT npoue)Jypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIOshy
IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii) H )IJla ny)l()J Me)I()JyHashy
PO)JHoii nOJIHTHKH - nporpaMMa KIICC CIIYflliT Mo)]eJIbIO nporshy
paMM )]PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii
HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii napshy
THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa ltPOPMaJlbHas
nporpaMMa Beer)Ja 6blJIa H3H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me)I()JyHapo)]shy
Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO )JBH)KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrapeshy
BaJla B TelIeHHe )JByx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTyshy
nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre)JHHe napshy
THiiHble )]OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas oltPHUHaJlhHas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II Cbe3)]e napTHH B BplOcceshy
JIe H 3aTeM B llOH)JOHe r)]e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me)K)Jy 6oJIbllleBHshy
KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii
CB060)Jb1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npoltpshy
C01030B11 CJIe)Jyronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM
H TpoIUltHM H 0)]06peua VIII napTCbe3)]oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa)KaJla
yCJIOBHH rpa)l()JaHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3shy
Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa)JHKaJlbHOii oua oTpa)KaJla Ha)Je)K)Jy
na HeH3OO)KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras
oTMeny )]eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH)JOK
XOT9 noerre BBe)]eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII
HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO )]0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH
npaBHlI KaK )JHKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTemHO YMeHblllHlIaCh
oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM
TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO)JfOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C 1954 r no 1961 r
H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua XXII Cbe3)Je KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo-
BaJla 003 ltpOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMlgtI MHorne rO)JbI B npaBJIeHHe CTashy
JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY)KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa OleHb ny)KHa Ero KpHTHshy
KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H )]pyrHe PYKOBOIWTeJIH KaK peshy
BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny)l()JaJlca B )]OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl
ero H)JeH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMHshy
IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c)]eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo)]eJIhlO AllII )]pyrHX CTpaH C
KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha)JemlC9 TaKHM nyreM
npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me)l()JyHapo)JHOM KOMMyshy
HHCTHIeCKOM )JBIDKeHHH (H KHraii H IOroerraBHH npe)JlIO)KHJIH
aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO)JeJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe
KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe
ltpPaKUHH) TaKHM 06pa30M na Me)l()JyHapo)JHoii apeHe TpeTha napshy
THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa )Ja)Ke B)KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii B HTOshy
re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH
H npHTa3aHHs B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko)]eKc
33HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH (HfHopHpyeMbIH cashy
MHMH PyKOBOIWTeJI9MH) onpe)]eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCTshy
BeHHble ueJIH ua 70-e H 8O-e rO)JbI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepeashy
JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK)Ke HeHa)Je)KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl
nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a)JMHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla
1JT0 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo)]CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9IOTC9
C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 1970 r H npeB30ii)JyT HX K
1980 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y)]eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIOIW
6y)JyT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo)JHMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9M COBeTcshy
KHii COlO3 )]OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3BoIWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy)Ja B MHshy
pe Ka)K)Ja9 eeMb9 6y)]eT HMeTh oT)]eJIbHblii )]OM HlIH KBapTHpy
KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoDBeralOIUHMH H )]OXO)JHbIMH a UHTashy
HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y)]eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax
HHIero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO )]OCTHfHyrO B nporpaMMe YKa3blBashy
JIOCh1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm )]OXO)] B 1980 r 6y)]eT B 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM
B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y)]eT npoH3BOIWTh 2700 MJIP)]
KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro)] (Ha )]eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT noshy
KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP)]) 700 MJIH T Heltpm (B 1980 r 6bIJIO)]0shy
6bITO 603 MJIH T) 300 MJIH T lepHa (ypo)fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T) H 30 MJIH T Maca (npOH3Bo)]CTBO M9ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO
15 MJIH T) 12 He 6bIJIa )]oCTHrnyra HH 0)JHa H3 HaMeleHHblX UHltPP
(JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B
1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T)
213 212
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
rpynnhI B lIaCIHOCm BeTepaHOB BoiHhI KOTOphIe HaCTaHB3nH Ha
pea6~ CTamma BOJIrOrpanCKHH rOpCOBet H 06IueCTBo
BeTepaHOB 06paTHlIHCb C neT~eil 0 BOSBpameHHH ropoA) Ha3BaHIVI
CT3nHHrpaP H rOBOpHlIH lITO lIepHeHKo 6blJI rOTOB nOPnHCSTb
COOTBeTCmyrouum YK33 fOp6atIeB nOWeJI Ha KOMIIpoMHCC cIlHJIbM
nOftBHlICJI Ha SKpaHaX HO BOJIrorpan OCT3nCJI BonrorpaPOM MHoshy
me HHTenneKty3nhI 6hIJDI ycnoKoeHhI STHM peweHHeM
PetIb fop6atIeBa B KaHYH )lHJI no6eAhI 8 MaJI He 6hDIa HHTeshy
peCRoi llO-BHpHMOMy petIb 6blJIa HanHcaHa ARJI Hero TaK lJIO STO
6hDI OtIeHh OltP~hHhIH H CpePKaRHbIH aHalIHS OAHaKO fop6atIeB
npH3H3n H8JIHlHe olIDl60K H npoCtIeTOB B HatIane BoiHhI npepweCTshy
BOBaBlIDIX no6epe H ynoMJIHYn HMB CTanHHa TonbKO oAHH pas
EcnH H cyweCTBOB3nO HaMepeHHe pea6HJIHmpoBaTh CTanKHa OT Heshy
ro OtIeBHAHhIM 06P330M OTKa33nHCb C ppyroi CIOPOHhI TpaAHshy
UHOHHaJI 106HlIeiHaJI aMHHCTHJI 6blJIa p330llapoBaHHeM YKas 06
aMHHCTHH npHHJIThIH llpeSHAHYMOM BepxoBHoro COBeTa B KOmte
anpemI 6hDI OtIeHh Hs6HpaTenbHhIM ftBHhIM 06paSOM HCKnlOlIaBwHH
CIaThH yronoBHoro KopeKca HCIIonbsyeMhIe npoTHB nOnHTHqeCKHX
33KnlOtIeHHhIX WCKnlOtIanHCh pajKe Te KTO nonyqHJI MeHee Tpex
neT no CTaThe 1911 YK2 TaKHe nOnHTSaKJIlOtIeHHhIe KaK IOpHi Opshy
nOB H Cepreil KOB3neB yxce oT6hmlIDle ceMHJIemee SaKnlOtIeHHe B
narepe H HaxOAHBlIDIeCH B WlTHlIeTHei CChDIKe TO)J(e He nonanK
nop aMHHCmlO 3TO 6blJIO 6esoWH60tIHhIM npHSHaKOM lJIO HOBhm
PYKOBOAHTeJIh He JlBJIJletCJI nH6epanOM
3TO 6hDI He nepBhm npH3HaK HO HHTenneKty3nhI npopOJI)J(ashy
JIB HapeJIThCJI lITO nocne BCIynneHHJI fop6atIeBa B pomKHOCTh npoHshy
soiAYT KaKHe-TO HSMeHeHHJI EBpeH-OTK33HHKH HapeJIJIHCb lJIO
SMHrpaURJl ltp3KmtIeCKH npeKpaTHBWaJlCJI npH lIepHeHKo 6ypet
o6nertIeHa llOHatIllJIy CHTY3UHJI K333JIaCh 06Hape)l(lBalOweil B Mapshy
Te nOJIytIHlIH paspeweHHe SMHrpHpoBaTh 98 tIenOBeK3 B anpene
ewe 166 tIenOBeK npH6hIJIH B BeHy cpeAH HHX 6hDIH nlOAH HS MOCKshy
BhI H neHHHIp3A3 OTKYua paHee 6hDIO TpYAHee Bcero SMHrpHposhy
BaTh4 OAH3KO noprOTOBHTenhHhIe onepaUHH KOTophIe HaARe)J(HT
npopenaTh ARJI SMHrpaUHH T3K cnO)J(HhI lJIO SallBneHHJI Tex KTO
yeS)J(3nH B anpene POmKHhl 6hIJIH paCCMaTpHBaTbCH MHoro paRee
neTOM lJHcno P33peWeHHHH Ha SMHrpaUHlO CT3nO YMeHhUIaThCH
H K aBrycry ynano AO 3040 B MeCJIll (B STO tIHcno He BXOpJIT HeMshy
I(bI llOBOn)J(bJl 0 KOTOphIX H3BecTHbI TOJIhKO AaHHbIe sa BeCh roP)
3T0 MHoro HH)J(e cpeAHero YPOBHJI 1983 roua Korua e)J(eMeCJltHO
OKono 100 eBpeeB nOJIytIllJIH paspewellHe (B pasrape SMHrPaUHH
B 1979 r 1IHcneHHOCTb SMHrpaHTOB Bospocna AO 51 330 HOBaJI
xonopH3JI BoiHa YMeHhWHlIa HX tIHcno AO 9 447 B 1881 r H 2 692 B 1982 r)
naHHhIe 06 SMHrpaUHH npHHJITO pacCMaTpHBaTb KaK cyWeCTshy
BeHHhm nOKasaTenb OTHoweHHJI COBeTCKHX BJIactei K npo6neMe
npaB tIenOBeKa WSBecmo lJIO npHMepHO 100 ThIC COBetCKHX rpa)J(
AaH nopanH sallBneHHJI H )J(A)T p33peWeHHJI yexaTamp a 1IHcneHHOCTh
OTK33HHKOB COCTaBJIJleT OKono 30 ThIC tIenOBeK 3m AaHHhIe
xapaKTepHsyroT H 06IUHii ypoBeHamp peMOKpaTHH BHyTpH CIpaHbl
H Me)J(A)HapoAHYlO CHtyaUHlO B OKTJl6pe 3m UHltPPhI CROBa Hecshy
KonhKO BOSPOCJ1H B CBJlSH C BHSHTOM fop6atIeBa BO cJ)pamtH1O
H npHrOTOBJIeHHJIMH K BCIpetIe C npe3HpeHTOM PeiraHOM B OKTJl6shy
pe 124 eBpeJi nOKHHYJIO COBeTcKHH Com B TOM 1IHcne 44 HS
MOCKBampI H 1 H3 neHHHrpauas B HOJl6pe 3MHrpHpoB3nO 128 tIeJIoshyBeK
B HHTepBblO ltPpamty3CKOMy TeneBHAeHHIO 30 ceHTJl6pJl fop6ashy
tIeB npopon)J(3n ymep)J(p3Tb lJIO SMHrpaUHlO HapO paccMatpHBaTh
TonhKO KaK BOCCOeAHHellHe ceMei 3TO SHatIHT lJIO AJlJI COBetcshy
KHX eBpeeB HeMtteB rpeKOB H ppymx HaUHOHanhHampIX MeHhWHHCTB
He CyWeCTByeT eCIeCTBeHHoro npaBa nOKHHYTamp CTpaHY no peJIHmos
HhlM HaUHOH3nbHhIM H KYJIamptypHhlM MOTHBaM B TOM )J(e HHtepBamp1O
fop6atIeB nOK333n lJIO OH HMeeT OlJeHh cna60e npepCIaBJIeHHe
o cyweCTBe eBpeHCKoi npo6neMhl B CCCP OH ymep)J(IJaJl lITO
nonO)J(eHHe eBpeeB B CCCP nyqwe lJeM rpe 6hI TO HH 6blJIO B MHpe
EBpeicKoe HaceneHHe COCIaBJIJIlOwee 069 HaceneHHJI CTpaHbI
B nOJIHTHtIeCKoi H KYJIamptypHOil )J(H3HH npepCTaBJIeHO B KOJlHteCTshy
Be OT 10 po 206 OR 6hIJI npaB B OTHOWeHHH ypeJIhHOrO Becs
eBpeeB B tIHCneHHOCTH HaceneHKJI CCCP HO OtIeHamp tpYAHO H3MepHTamp
HaCKOJIampKO OHH npepcTaBneHbI B cOBeTCKoi KYJIhtypHOil )J(H3HH
llOMHMO Bcero npotIero )TO BOnpOC He TOJIampKO npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHoil
nOJIHTHKH HO T3K)J(e Bonpoc CBJlSaRHhIi C HHAHBHAYanampHhIMH YCHshy
JIHJlMH H CKnOHHOCTJlMH W CK33aTh tITO eBpeH npepCIaBneHhI
B COBeTCKoi nOJIHTHtIecKoi )J(H3HH B npepenax OT 10 po 20 JlBJIJletCJI oqeBHAHhIM a6cYPPoM B npaBHTeJIhCTBe eCTh TOJIampKO
OAHH eBpeil (BeHHaMHH ampIMWHIQ a no MeHee 1 llponopUHSl
eBpeeB B KOMMyHHcTHtIeCKOi napTHH 6hIJIa paBHa 1A B 1983 r
204
205
H TOmKO Owm eBpeH (Be3AecymHH llblMIlIHrO cpenu 311 lJJ1eHOB
IIK Co BpeMeHH nepBoro BRlHTa B COBeTcKHH COI03 rpynnhl
aMepHKaHCKHX ceHaTopoB H KOHfpeccMeHoB B anpene rop6aqeB
nonyIRlI MHoro nHlHhiX oGplllQeHHH no nOBooy nOJIHTHleCKHX laKshy
nIOqeHHhIX H oTKa3HHKoB Ero orneT GhlJI 06hIlHbIM llOlBomTe
HaM caMHM pewaTb HaIIIH BHYTpeHHHe npo6JIeMbl7 OH TaK)Ke
npoAOJIJK3J1 ~ep)l(AaTb ITO nOJIHTHqeCKHX pHcCHAeHTOB cyMT
TonbKO TOrAa KorAa OHH HapywaIOT JaKOH XOTJI OH AOJI)KeH lHaTb
ITO COBeTCKHH 3aKOH 06paIIJaeT HHaKOMhICnHe B npeCTYIIJIeHHe TeM
He MeHee nepeA )KeHeBCKOH BCTpeqeH Ha BblCUleM ypoBHe 6bIJI CAeshy
naH )KeCT AOGpoH BOJIH B HOJlGpe EneHe EOHHJp )KeHe COenaHHOrO
AlmpeJl CaxapoBa 6h1Jlo pa3peUleHo BhlexaTb 3a rpaHHQY Ha caMOM
Aene CaxapoB HaIaJI CBOIO TpeTbIO ronoAoBKY no 3TOMY nOBOOY
B OKTJlGpe TpeGYJI lT06hI ero )KeHe GhlJIO pa3peUleHO BblexaTb
JJl1J1 neqeHHJI Y Hero cna60e 3AopoBbe eMY 6hlJIO 64 rOAa OH GhlJI
OqeHb ena6 noene npe)I(HHx ronoAoBoK laKOHIHBIlIHXCJI B 6onbHHshy
ne npHHYAHTenhHbIM KOpMJIeHHeM Ero )KH3Hb GhlJIa nOA yrpo30H
ECJlH 6hI OH yMep B HOJIGpe HerOAOBaHHe B CIlIA GhlJIO 6bl CJlHIJlshy
KOM CHJIhHblM lT06bI rop6atIeB Mor paCCIHTblBaTlo Ha KaKOH-TO
ycnex B JKeHeBe CTaBKH GhIJIH CJlHIJlI(OM BhlooKH H B KOHne OKTJI~ pJl EneHe EOHHlP COOGIIJHJlH ITO OHa MO)l(eT BblexaTb la rpaHHQY
HeMeJJl1eHHO CaxaPOB GhlJI KpynHeHUleH npo6JIeMoH JJl1J1 rop6aqeshy
Ba B o6JIacTH npas qenOBeKa OH GhIJl BhlenaHB rOpbKHHB 1980 r Ge3 CYAa H cYAeGHoro pa36HpaTemcma 3TO 6h1Jlo CAenaHO KrE
nOA nO)l(HhIM npeJJl10rOM ITO CaxapoB pacnOJIaraeT rocYAaPCrneHshy
HLIMH ceKpeTaMH (nO)l(HhIM nOTOMY ITO CaxaPOB GlolJI YSOJIeR
H3 HHCTHTYTa aTOMHOH 3HepTHH B 1968 r ABeRaAnaTbIO roAaMH
paHee R He npHHHMaJI yttaCTHJI B OpHeHTHpoBaHHLIX Ha BoeHHhle
HY)l(Abl HCeneAOBaHHJlX C 1964 r) OT npaB03aIIJHTHLIX rpynn B CCCP OC06eHHO OT tfJIeROB
MOCKOBCKOH XenlocHHKcKOH rpynnhl H lMHfpaHTOB - GblBIJlHX noshy
JIHT3aKJIIOtIeHHloIX npoAOJI)I(aJla nocrynaTb RHqoPManRJI 06 apeCTax
HHaKOMbICJlJlIIJHX H aKTHBHLIX npasOJaIIJHTHHKOB H CYAJI no
e)KeHeAemHLIM COO6IIJeHHJIM 0 HapYUleHHJlX npas 1IenOBeKa H3Aashy
BaeMloIX KpoHHAOM nI06apcKHM BO BTOPOH nonOBRHe 1985 r He
6hlJI0 3aMemo CYIIJeCTBeHHhIX H3MeHeHHH CHTYanHH8 MOCKOBCKHH
Me)l(AyHapo)lHloIH qeCTHBaJIh MonOAe)KH npoxoAHJl nOA 00060
YCHJleHHOH OXpaHOH MHJlHUHH - cnyqanOClo ITO MHJlHIUlORepOB OKashy
3bmaJIOClo 6onloUle qeM rOCTeH llpe~ qeCTHBaJIh MOnOAe)KH
B 1957 r l 6loIJI paAOCTHLIM H CBo60AHLIM Cbe3AOM IOHOUleH H AeBYshy
UleK Ha nOT pal aTMoccpepa GhlJIa OOBceM RHOH rOCTJlM BhIAaJIH
nponycKa C HX cpoTorpaltPHJlMH KOTopble OHH AOJI)l(HhI 6loIJIH HOeHTb
nOCTOJIRHObull llHCKYCCHH npoBoAHJlHcb fJIaBHLIM 06pa30M Ha nOJIHTHshy
1IeCKRe TeMb C IIBHOH aHTH3anaAHoH HanpasneHHoCTbIO
llOnO)l(eHHe B COI03e nHcaTeneH R Apyrnx ooI03ax TBopllecshy
KOH HHTeJIJIHfeHnHH (~PHaJIHCTOB KOMll03HTOPOB KHHeMaTorpashy
CPRCTOB H T A) OGloIIHO MO)KeT enYJKHTb XOpoUlHM nOKa3aTeneM
BHyTpeRHero nOJIHTHqeCKorO KJlHMaTa BeerAa RMeIOTCJI AeCJITI(H
nOBeCTeH qHJlhMOB nbeC H T A npeACTaBJIeHHhIX )JlIJI Ony6JIHKoshy
BaHHJI HJlH )JlIJI pa3peUleHHJI nOCTaHOBKH Ha cueHe RJIH JKpaHe
Bee nbeCbl R CPRJIbMbl AOJI)I(HbI nOnyqHTb pa3peUleRHe cnenuaJIbHOrO
KOMHTeTa B03fJIaBJIJleMOrO oooTBeTcmyroIIJHM neH3opoM (Ha o~
naCTHOM ypoBHe eCJlH meca npeACTaBneHa npoBHHUHaJIbHOMY
TeaTpy) 3HaIIHTenloHaJI 1IaCTlo lTHX pa60T 6hlJIa oTBepfHYTa RJIH
OTJIO)KeHa AO BHeeeHRJI H3MeHeHHii ABToPhl peLaKTophI H pe)KHcshy
eepbl (cpepH HHX OqeHL R3BecTHble) HeHJGe)I(HO OGplllQaJIHCb K Hoshy
BOMY PYKOBOpHTenIO JJl1J1 pa3peUleHHJI HX TpYAHOCTeH C neH30paMR
B anpene nORBRJIHClo 06HaAe)I(HBaIOIIJHe npR3HaKH TOro ITO RlMeshy
HeHRJI HOCJITCJI B B03JJYXe rOp6alleB OTKa3aJICJI YSHAeTbCJI C AByMR
H8H60nee KOHeepsaTHBHblMH PYKOBOAHTeJIJlMH COI03a nHcaTeshy
neH - r MapKoBblM npeAeeAaTeneM H A qaKOBCKRM peLaKToshy
poM nmepaTYpHOH raJeTbl EMY nonaraJIOCb BCTpeTHTbCJI C HHMH
lTOGbl HaJIaAHTb xopoIlIHe OTHOUleHHJI C JTHMH orneTCrneHHloIMH
pa60THHKaMH (AlmponOB BHAeJICJI C HHMH B AeKaGpe 1982 r
H Bhlpa3RJI RM CBoe AOBepHe) HO RM 6blJlO CKa3aHO ITO ropGaqeB
enHIJll(OM 3aHJIT CTaJIO HJBeCTHO TaK)Ke lITO lleTp lleMHleB (MRshy
HHCTp KynbTYPbl KaHIlHAaT B lDIeHbl llOJIHTGIOPO H 6blBumii rnaBa
oTAena nponaraHAbI IIK) R ero AOn)I(HOCTHLle mwa CTaJIH Gonee
Be)l(llHBbl C nOeeTHTenJlMH C ApyrOH CTOPOHbl llPR6hITKOB owm HJ
fJIaBHLIX nOMOIIJHHKOB qepHeHKo GlolJI Ha3HaqeH 38MeCTHTeneM
KOMHTeTa no oXpaHe rOCYAapcmeHHLIX eeKpeTOB B nettaTH (OcpHshy
nuaJIbHOe Ha3BaHHe OOBeTCKOH neH3yphI) llnJl llpHGbITKOBa 3T0
GlolJIO nOHH)KeHHeM H Re cynHJlO HHlero xopoUlero B o6JIaCTH neH3Yshy
pbl EhlJIH CJIyXR ITO rOp6a1leB H MHXaHJl 3HMJIHHH BTOPOH eeKpeshy
Tapb HAeOJIOfHleCKOrO OTAena IIK BTOPOH qeJIOBeK noene Cyenoshy
206 207
Ba BbDIonwmIIIHii ry )l(e ponb npH JlHraqeBe He nonlAJfJlH Ho noshy
BHARMOMy- HHKatltHX HOBbIX HHCTpYKIHii He 6bmo H CHrylI(HII He
ynyqunmaCb HrreonOrHtJeCKHe 3allBneHIDI rop6aqeBa 6bIllH W3ycshy
MbIcneHHbI H He o6HapYgtKHBaJIH HOBOro no)Uona llOXOgtKe 6bmo tJTO
rop6alleB IIel1HKOM nopYtJHJ1 HpeonOrHlO JlHralleBY H CKOHIIeHTpHshy
POBaJI CBoe BHHMaHHe Ha 3KOHOMHKe
B aBryCTe EBremm EBrymeHKo H3BecmlilH n03T H nOllHTHshy
IeCKH npoTHBopetJIfBaJI cpurypa HanHcaJI rop6alleBY nHCbMO 0 nnashy
IeBHOM COCTOIIHHH COBeTCKOH llHTeparypbI H llpe3MepHOH CTporocshy
TH IIeH3ypHbIX OrpaHHlleHHH B more B llpaBpe 9 ceHTII6pll
6bIJ1a ony6mnltoBaHa ero KOPOTKaJI n03Ma B KOTOPOH noppepgtKHBashy
naCb 3KOHOMHlJeCKaJI nOllHTHKa rop6alleBa COpep)l(aJlHCb HanllAKH
Ha 61OPOKpaTOB 6oIIIIIHxcII HOBoBBepeHHH H npoTHBJDInlxCII HM
H BOCXBaJIIIJ1C11 WeCTHMeCIIIIHbm COBeTCKuH MopaTopuH Ha Mepshy
HbIe HcnhITaHHJI KaK 6ecnpeIIepeHTHOH cMenocm nOW3Hr BO HMII
MHpa9 ll03Ma copepgtKaJla TatltgtKe CKpbIryIO KpHTHKy KOJ1J1eKTHBHshy
3lIIHH H OTKPhITYlO KpHTHKy JIhIceHKo CBII3bIBlll HblHeWHHe Cel1hCshy
Kox03JriiCTBeHHble TpyDHOCTH C 6mpoKpaTmleCKHMH nperpanaMH
Ho H3 n03MbI IICHO cnepOBano tJTO He napTHII a 61OpoKpaThI omeTshy
CTBeHHbI 31 Bce 3TO B TOMgtKe MeCIIIIe rop6alleB Ha3HatJHJ1 AlleKcaHApa HKOBneBa
rnaDOH OTpel1a nponaraHAhI UK CMeCTHB CryKaJIHHa Ha3HalleHHOrO
nocnOM B BeurpHIO 3r0 paCCMaTpHBaJIOCb KaK XOPOWUH 3HaK
OTpen nponaraHJ]hl IIBJ111eTCII KlllOIIeBhIM 3BeHOM l1HIalleBCKOro
H1leonOrHtJeCKOrO ceKpeTapHaTa lloxo)l(e Ha3HaleHHe 3TO 6bIJ10
npoH3BepeHO B cneWKe (Katlt H Ha3HaqeHHe Pa3YMOBCKoro rnaBOH
OpraHH3lI(HOHHoro OTpel1a) Tatlt Katlt 06blIIH0 rnaBa OTpena nponashy
raHIJbl IIBJ1IIeTCII IJl1eHOM HJ1H KaHlJH)JaTOM B IJl1eHhI UK a HKOBlleB
TatltOBbIM He 6bIJ1 OH 6bIJ1 3aMecmTeneM 3aDe)lylOIIero Omel10M
nponaraHAbI HO 6bIJ1 CMeIIeH CycnOBhIM B 1970 r (OqeBHARo 31
ny6mnclI(H1O B nOllHTHtJeCKHX H llHTepaTypHbIX lKYPHaJIax CTaTeH C KpHTHKOH HeOCTaJIHHHCTCKHX H pycOcpHllbCKHX TeHAeHIHii) H HaJHashy
qeH nocnoM B KaHaJJY B nOM KaleCme OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6aqeshy
Ba BO BpeMII ero BH3Hta B KaHaJJy H MegtKAY HHMH YCTaHOBHllHCb
xopowue OTHOWeHIDI HKOBneB 6hIll B03BplIIeH B MOCKBY H Ha3shy
HaleH ARpeKTOPOM HHcmryra MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKH H MegtKAYHapopshy
HbIX OTHowemm OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6alleBa BO BpeMII ero BH3HTa
B BeJIHK06PHTaHHIO B 1984 r CllHTaeTCII tJTO HKOBneB He 1C0Hcepshy
BaTOp HO OH nonytJHT BnHllHHe TonhlCO ecnH 6ypeT H36paH B UK HOBbIe Ha3HaqeHIDI B HAeonOrHtJeCICOM OTpene BbIrnIIAIIT
BeChMa o6eIIalOIIHMH rpy60 rOBOpll COBeTCICHe HAeonorHtJeCKHe
pa60THHICH penIITcII Ha W3e rpynnhI 1C0HCepBaTHBH)IO 0PTOAQICshy
CaJ1hH)IO 1C0TOPym nOppepgtKHBaJIH CycnOB H neMHIIeB H 60nee
clCnoHaym IC pecpopMaM YMepeHHO nporpecCHBH)IO )lHpeICTOP
HHcmryTa CIlIA H KaHaAhI reopruH Ap6aTOB 6bIBWuH peAaKTOP
llpaBAhI a Teneph ARpelCTOP HHCTHtyTa COIIHOnOrHH AllelCceH
Py-MIIHIIeB CTapWUH COTPYAHHK MegtKAYHapoDHoro OTpena UK H nnopOBHThIH nHcaTenb no BonpocaM COIIHaJIH3Ma H KOMMfHH3Ma
r InaXHaJapoB AlleICcaHAP BOBHR H cIgtepop BypnallKHH 06a H3shy
BeCTHhIe gtKypHallHCTbl - OTHOCllTCII KO BTOPOH rpynne CKllOHaym IC
peCPOPMaM rpynny TOIIHee Ha3BaTh nporpeCCHBHOH qeM nH6epanhshy
HOH Y 3TOH rpynnhI YCTaHOBHllHCh xopowue OTHoweHIDI C AHAposhynOBbIM 1C0rna OH po 1967 r 6hm celCpeTapeM UK llocne HeKoToposhy
ro cnlna BnHIIHHII OHH nOXO)l(e BHOBh BhICTynuJIH Ha CIIeHy nocne
CMepTH Bpe)f(leBa rop6aQeB He HMeBWHH co6CTBeHHoro HHTennelCshy
ryaJIhHOro OICpy)l(eHIDI BHAHMO Ha6Hpan COBeTHHICOB nOMoIUHHshy
ICOB H ppyrux pOn)f(lOCTHbIX llHII H3 3TOH rpynnhI Ho nelaJIhHO
H3BecmhIe CBOHM lCoHcepBaTH3MOM 3HMIIHHH rnaDa OTllena lCynhshy
ryPhI UK Inaypo H peAaKTOP gtKypHaJIa BonpoChI 3KOHOMHKH
H ARpelCTOP HHCTHryTa 3KOHOMHKH XatJaTypoB COXpaHHllH BllHllHHe
H B03MO)f(lO HMelOT nyqwue IIeM nporpeCCHCThl OTHOmeHHJI C
JlHraqeBbIM
TpeTbll rpynna - IIeHTpHCTClCaII B Hee BX0AIIT penaICTOp
llpaBAhI ACPaHaCbeB H pepaKTOP TeopemlleCKOrO napmHHoro
gtKYpHaJIa KOMMyHHCT PHtJapp KOCOnaDOB llOCKonhlCY COBeTCKuH
COlO3 IIBJ111eTCII HpeOnOrHtJeCICHM rocypapcmOM nyooHKlIIHU B
napTHHHbIX oprauax netJarn 06bIIIH0 6hIBalOT HaH60nee 3HatJHMhlMH
nOKaJaTenllMH TeKYIIHX nonHTHtJeCICHX H HAeonOrHtJeCKHX TeHAeHshy
IIUHmiddot MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M IIBJ1IIeTCII CYIIeCTBeHHbIM CBII3ymIIIHM
3BeHOM MegtKAY pa3J1HllHhIMH rocynapcmeHHhIMH yqpegtKAeHIDIMH
H neranH3yeT BepxoBHym BnaCTh napTHH H ee reHepanbHoro ceKpeshy
tapll HpeonorHtJeCKHe CBII3H MelKA) pa3HbIMH qaCTIIMH rocypapshy
CTBeHHOH MaWHHbI COXpaHIIT CBOIO npOlJHOCTb ecnH COXPaHHTshy
CII IIeMeHTHpymmaH ponh HAeonorHH 3Ta ponh IIBHO YMeHhIlIHshy
209208
JIaCb BO BpeMeHa Bpe)lQeBa HO 3TO fibIJlO BbI3BaHO He CTPYKrypshy
HblMH H3MeHeHHHMH a CBoero POIJ8 HlJeOJIOrlflleCKHM CKJIeposhy
30M BepXH napTHH fiblJIH He cnocofiHbI C031J8Tb Ifl1eOJIorlfllecshy
KHH COJHaJIbHbIH IDIH nOJIHTlflleCKHH JOKyMem K KOTOPOMY
Ofipa30BaHHbIe KpyrH MornH fibI OTHeCTHCb eepbe3HO B 1970-x H
1980-x roJaX nytflIIee qyO MOrJIa npeJJIO)lOTb napTHH JJIS BJOXHoshy
BeHHS HapolJ8 fibIJIH TPyruI Bpe)lQeBa - BOcnOMHHaHHS 0 roJax
BOHHbI 0 ueJIHHe H T JJ npHMHTHBHO H y60ro HanHCaHHbIe 3a Hero
JpymMH H nopolJHBIillIe 6eCqCJIeHHbIe aHeKJorbI
CaM rOpfialJeB TO)(e He H36e)(aJI HeKOTopoH npHtJaCTHOCTH
K npHMHTHBHbIM H 6ecCMbICJIeHHbIM HJeOJIOrlflleCKHM MaTepHanaM
Toro nepHolJ8 B peq Ha KOHlgtepeHUHli no BonpocaM HJeOJIOrHH B
CTaBponOJIbCKOM Kpae B Mae 1978 r KorJa OH eII(e fibIJI eeKpeTashy
peM rOpKOMa ropfiaqeB CKa3aJI
reHepanbHbIH ceKpeTapb UK KnCC npeJceJareJIb
IIpe3HJHyMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP JI H Bpe)(HeB shy
raJIaHTJIHBbrH PYKoBOJHTeJIb JIeHHHCKOro THna Ero THTashy
HHlJecKas nOBceJHeBHas pafioTa HanpaBJIeHa Ha YKpeIIJIeHHe
MOII(H CTpaHbI nOBbJIIIeHHe 6narocoCToSHHS rpyJlIIUHXCS
Ha ynpoqeHHe MHpa H fie30naCHOCTH HapoJoB
HeJaBHO MbI paCKPbIJIH CTpaHHJbI 3aMelJaTeJIbHOH KHHrH
TOBapHII(a J1 H Bpe)lQeBa bull Manu 3eMJIS rJe 3OJIOTbIMH
fiYKBaMH 3aJIelJaTJIeHbI noprpeTbI JIereHlJ8pHbIX repoeB
60es 3a CeBepHbrH WKaJ HeMHoro BpeMeHH npoIIIJIo co
JHI[ ny6nHKauHH KHHrO HO BOCnOMHHaHHH BbI3BanH
BceofiII(Hii nOJJIHHHO BceHapoJHbrH HHTepec qTofibI YJOBshy
JIeTBopHTb 6ecqCJIeHHbIe 3anpocbI TpKeHHKoB CTaBposhy
nOJIbIUHHbI B lgteBpane 3TH BOCnOMHHaHHH fiyJJYT nepeneshy
lJaTaHbI H3 YpHana HOBbrH MHP B HallIHX KpaeBblX
raJeTax CTaBponOJIbCKas npaBJa H KaBKa3CKas 3JpaBshy
HHua
B KHHre bullManas 3eMJIS He TaK MHoro crpaHHJ HO no
rnyfiHHe HJeOJIOrHlJeCKOrO coJep)(aHHH no IillIpoTe 0606shy
II(eHHH 0 MbICJIeH aBTOpa OHa CTana 60JIbIilllM COfibITHeM
OfiII(eCTBeHHOH )(H3HH OHa BbI3Bana rop~ OTKJIHK B
eepJJax COBeTCKDX mOJeH 0 BOCX8II(eHHble OT3b1BbI COJIshy
IJ8T-IgtPOHTOBHKOB Ha qTaTeJIbCKDX KOHlgtepeHUHSX H B nelJaTH
KOMMYHHCTbI H Bce TpKeHHKH CTaBpOnOJIbIUHHbI 6ecshy
KOHelJHO 6narOJapHbI JIeoHHJy HnbHlfY Bpe)(HeBY 3a ero
nOJJIHHHO BJOXHOBJIeHHYIO napTHeH JIHTeparyPHYlO pa60TY
B KOTOPOH HCTOlfHHKH BeJIHKOro nOJBHra HallIeH repoHlJecshy
KOH CTpaHbI ee JJYXOBHOH H HpaBCTBeHHOH CHJIbI ee CIOHshy
KOCTH H MKeCTBa BCKPblTbI C IgtHJIOCOIgtCKOH rnyfiHHoH
(OfipaTHbrH nepeBOJ C aHrn - PeJ) 10
~ras 3TO HeYMepeHHoe BOCXBaneHHe nOBepXHOCTHoro H noeshy
peJCTBeHHoro COlJHHeHHH Bpe)lQeBa HeJIb3S He nOqyBCTBOBaTb qro
ero oJeOJIOrHqeCKOe B03JeHCTBHe SBJISeTCS ofipaTHblM KpoMe Bceshy
ro npoqero H3JIO)(eHHe Bpe)(HeBa HCKa)(aeT HCTOpHIO H CaM fibIJI
B 1943 r COJIJaTOM TaMaHcKoro IgtpoHTa H Manas 3eMJIS fibIJIa
Beero JImllb ero He60JIbIilllM 6eperoBblM aBaHnOCTOM B03HHKIillIM
BO BpeMH HaYlJ8lJHOro HacTyIlJIeHHH Ha HOBOPOCCHHCK B anpeJIe
H 3aTeM B Mae 1943 r IIoKa Bpe)(HeB 30 JIer CnyCTS He H30fipaJHJI
cofiblTHS TaM KaK OCHOBHYIO fiHTBY OHH fibIJIH He3HalJHTeJIbHbIM
BoeHHbIM 3JIH30JOM Bpe)(HeB fibIJI TorJa nOJIHTKOMHccaPOM
H TOJIbKO OJH~I noJIYqJIJI nOBb1lIIeHHe B lJHHe B 1941 r OH fibIJI
nOJIKOBHHKOM a K 1945 r CTan reHepan-MaH0poM Ho B 1978 r
olgtHUHanbHas npecca CTMa nucaTb 0 HeM TaK KaK fiYJTO OH fibIJI
60JIee BblJalOII(HMCS BoeHHbIM repoeM qeM MapUIan )KYKOB
MHorHe napTHHHbIe lJHHbI nOBa)(Hee ropfiaqeBa B 1978 r
paCTOlJanO HeofibIlJaHHbIe nOXBanbI fipe)(HeBCKOMY JIHTeparypHOMY
onycy 3TO CBHJeTeJIbCTByeT 0 nyCToTe JerpaJaUHH 0 pa3JIO)(eHHH
oJeOJIOrHH JIerKo nOHHTb KynbT BO BpeMeHa CranHHa KorJa
JOJI)(HOCTHble JI8Ja onacanHCb 3a CBOO )(H3HH Ho B 1978 r OHH
pHcKoBanH TOJIbKO 3aJep)(KOH B npoJBH)(eHHH no JOJI)(HOCTH
IDIO YTpaTOH KaKOH-TO npHBIDIerHH
TaKOM OfiPaJOM B 1985 r KorJa ropfiaqeB cran reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKperapeM HeofixoJHMOCTb HOBbIX HJeH 0 HHHUHarHB B 06shy
JIaCTH HJeOJIOrHH CTana BeCbMa HaCrOSTeJIbHoH BbIJIO OqeBOJHO
qyO ropfiaqeB He cofiHpancs caM yJOBJIerBopHTb 3ry HeofixoJHshy
MOCTb pa3Be TOJIbKO B pOJIO PYKOBOJHreJIS HJeOJIorulJeCKOrO
fiaHKa HJeH HalJHHaBUIerO B03HHKan OrJeJIbHbrH fiaHK HJeH
CTan lgtopMHpoBarbCS BOKpyr JIuraqeBa 3ro C03JaBanO B03MO)(shy
HOCTb fiyJJYIUHX npOTHBopelfHil Me)(Jy rreBblM H IIpaBbIM Hanshy
paBJIeHHIMH HO HeJIb3S fibIJIO Cpa3Y onpeJeJIHTb HX reHJeHIQiH
211210
HoeaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii
nporpaMMlgtI no)]roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII CDe3)Jy napTHH 3a)Jashy
lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX BnyTpeHHHX
H Me)l()JyHapolJHblX npo6rreM H Bbl)JBIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX
pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTHshy
IIeCKHH MaHHltpeCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xoIWMa
TaK KaK npeJKlU[a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1961 r Ha 6rrH)l(aiiume 20 JIeT
Dna HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe)]eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor)]a He 6blshy
JIH )]OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03)J3BaTIgt Tpy)]shy
HOCTH H CHH)fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HYKlfll H )IJla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii (TaK KaK
CYlUecmyeT npoue)Jypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIOshy
IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii) H )IJla ny)l()J Me)I()JyHashy
PO)JHoii nOJIHTHKH - nporpaMMa KIICC CIIYflliT Mo)]eJIbIO nporshy
paMM )]PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii
HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii napshy
THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa ltPOPMaJlbHas
nporpaMMa Beer)Ja 6blJIa H3H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me)I()JyHapo)]shy
Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO )JBH)KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrapeshy
BaJla B TelIeHHe )JByx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTyshy
nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre)JHHe napshy
THiiHble )]OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas oltPHUHaJlhHas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II Cbe3)]e napTHH B BplOcceshy
JIe H 3aTeM B llOH)JOHe r)]e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me)K)Jy 6oJIbllleBHshy
KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii
CB060)Jb1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npoltpshy
C01030B11 CJIe)Jyronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM
H TpoIUltHM H 0)]06peua VIII napTCbe3)]oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa)KaJla
yCJIOBHH rpa)l()JaHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3shy
Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa)JHKaJlbHOii oua oTpa)KaJla Ha)Je)K)Jy
na HeH3OO)KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras
oTMeny )]eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH)JOK
XOT9 noerre BBe)]eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII
HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO )]0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH
npaBHlI KaK )JHKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTemHO YMeHblllHlIaCh
oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM
TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO)JfOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C 1954 r no 1961 r
H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua XXII Cbe3)Je KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo-
BaJla 003 ltpOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMlgtI MHorne rO)JbI B npaBJIeHHe CTashy
JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY)KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa OleHb ny)KHa Ero KpHTHshy
KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H )]pyrHe PYKOBOIWTeJIH KaK peshy
BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny)l()JaJlca B )]OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl
ero H)JeH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMHshy
IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c)]eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo)]eJIhlO AllII )]pyrHX CTpaH C
KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha)JemlC9 TaKHM nyreM
npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me)l()JyHapo)JHOM KOMMyshy
HHCTHIeCKOM )JBIDKeHHH (H KHraii H IOroerraBHH npe)JlIO)KHJIH
aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO)JeJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe
KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe
ltpPaKUHH) TaKHM 06pa30M na Me)l()JyHapo)JHoii apeHe TpeTha napshy
THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa )Ja)Ke B)KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii B HTOshy
re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH
H npHTa3aHHs B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko)]eKc
33HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH (HfHopHpyeMbIH cashy
MHMH PyKOBOIWTeJI9MH) onpe)]eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCTshy
BeHHble ueJIH ua 70-e H 8O-e rO)JbI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepeashy
JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK)Ke HeHa)Je)KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl
nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a)JMHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla
1JT0 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo)]CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9IOTC9
C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 1970 r H npeB30ii)JyT HX K
1980 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y)]eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIOIW
6y)JyT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo)JHMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9M COBeTcshy
KHii COlO3 )]OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3BoIWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy)Ja B MHshy
pe Ka)K)Ja9 eeMb9 6y)]eT HMeTh oT)]eJIbHblii )]OM HlIH KBapTHpy
KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoDBeralOIUHMH H )]OXO)JHbIMH a UHTashy
HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y)]eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax
HHIero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO )]OCTHfHyrO B nporpaMMe YKa3blBashy
JIOCh1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm )]OXO)] B 1980 r 6y)]eT B 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM
B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y)]eT npoH3BOIWTh 2700 MJIP)]
KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro)] (Ha )]eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT noshy
KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP)]) 700 MJIH T Heltpm (B 1980 r 6bIJIO)]0shy
6bITO 603 MJIH T) 300 MJIH T lepHa (ypo)fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T) H 30 MJIH T Maca (npOH3Bo)]CTBO M9ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO
15 MJIH T) 12 He 6bIJIa )]oCTHrnyra HH 0)JHa H3 HaMeleHHblX UHltPP
(JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B
1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T)
213 212
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
H TOmKO Owm eBpeH (Be3AecymHH llblMIlIHrO cpenu 311 lJJ1eHOB
IIK Co BpeMeHH nepBoro BRlHTa B COBeTcKHH COI03 rpynnhl
aMepHKaHCKHX ceHaTopoB H KOHfpeccMeHoB B anpene rop6aqeB
nonyIRlI MHoro nHlHhiX oGplllQeHHH no nOBooy nOJIHTHleCKHX laKshy
nIOqeHHhIX H oTKa3HHKoB Ero orneT GhlJI 06hIlHbIM llOlBomTe
HaM caMHM pewaTb HaIIIH BHYTpeHHHe npo6JIeMbl7 OH TaK)Ke
npoAOJIJK3J1 ~ep)l(AaTb ITO nOJIHTHqeCKHX pHcCHAeHTOB cyMT
TonbKO TOrAa KorAa OHH HapywaIOT JaKOH XOTJI OH AOJI)KeH lHaTb
ITO COBeTCKHH 3aKOH 06paIIJaeT HHaKOMhICnHe B npeCTYIIJIeHHe TeM
He MeHee nepeA )KeHeBCKOH BCTpeqeH Ha BblCUleM ypoBHe 6bIJI CAeshy
naH )KeCT AOGpoH BOJIH B HOJlGpe EneHe EOHHJp )KeHe COenaHHOrO
AlmpeJl CaxapoBa 6h1Jlo pa3peUleHo BhlexaTb 3a rpaHHQY Ha caMOM
Aene CaxapoB HaIaJI CBOIO TpeTbIO ronoAoBKY no 3TOMY nOBOOY
B OKTJlGpe TpeGYJI lT06hI ero )KeHe GhlJIO pa3peUleHO BblexaTb
JJl1J1 neqeHHJI Y Hero cna60e 3AopoBbe eMY 6hlJIO 64 rOAa OH GhlJI
OqeHb ena6 noene npe)I(HHx ronoAoBoK laKOHIHBIlIHXCJI B 6onbHHshy
ne npHHYAHTenhHbIM KOpMJIeHHeM Ero )KH3Hb GhlJIa nOA yrpo30H
ECJlH 6hI OH yMep B HOJIGpe HerOAOBaHHe B CIlIA GhlJIO 6bl CJlHIJlshy
KOM CHJIhHblM lT06bI rop6atIeB Mor paCCIHTblBaTlo Ha KaKOH-TO
ycnex B JKeHeBe CTaBKH GhIJIH CJlHIJlI(OM BhlooKH H B KOHne OKTJI~ pJl EneHe EOHHlP COOGIIJHJlH ITO OHa MO)l(eT BblexaTb la rpaHHQY
HeMeJJl1eHHO CaxaPOB GhlJI KpynHeHUleH npo6JIeMoH JJl1J1 rop6aqeshy
Ba B o6JIacTH npas qenOBeKa OH GhIJl BhlenaHB rOpbKHHB 1980 r Ge3 CYAa H cYAeGHoro pa36HpaTemcma 3TO 6h1Jlo CAenaHO KrE
nOA nO)l(HhIM npeJJl10rOM ITO CaxapoB pacnOJIaraeT rocYAaPCrneHshy
HLIMH ceKpeTaMH (nO)l(HhIM nOTOMY ITO CaxaPOB GlolJI YSOJIeR
H3 HHCTHTYTa aTOMHOH 3HepTHH B 1968 r ABeRaAnaTbIO roAaMH
paHee R He npHHHMaJI yttaCTHJI B OpHeHTHpoBaHHLIX Ha BoeHHhle
HY)l(Abl HCeneAOBaHHJlX C 1964 r) OT npaB03aIIJHTHLIX rpynn B CCCP OC06eHHO OT tfJIeROB
MOCKOBCKOH XenlocHHKcKOH rpynnhl H lMHfpaHTOB - GblBIJlHX noshy
JIHT3aKJIIOtIeHHloIX npoAOJI)I(aJla nocrynaTb RHqoPManRJI 06 apeCTax
HHaKOMbICJlJlIIJHX H aKTHBHLIX npasOJaIIJHTHHKOB H CYAJI no
e)KeHeAemHLIM COO6IIJeHHJIM 0 HapYUleHHJlX npas 1IenOBeKa H3Aashy
BaeMloIX KpoHHAOM nI06apcKHM BO BTOPOH nonOBRHe 1985 r He
6hlJI0 3aMemo CYIIJeCTBeHHhIX H3MeHeHHH CHTYanHH8 MOCKOBCKHH
Me)l(AyHapo)lHloIH qeCTHBaJIh MonOAe)KH npoxoAHJl nOA 00060
YCHJleHHOH OXpaHOH MHJlHUHH - cnyqanOClo ITO MHJlHIUlORepOB OKashy
3bmaJIOClo 6onloUle qeM rOCTeH llpe~ qeCTHBaJIh MOnOAe)KH
B 1957 r l 6loIJI paAOCTHLIM H CBo60AHLIM Cbe3AOM IOHOUleH H AeBYshy
UleK Ha nOT pal aTMoccpepa GhlJIa OOBceM RHOH rOCTJlM BhIAaJIH
nponycKa C HX cpoTorpaltPHJlMH KOTopble OHH AOJI)l(HhI 6loIJIH HOeHTb
nOCTOJIRHObull llHCKYCCHH npoBoAHJlHcb fJIaBHLIM 06pa30M Ha nOJIHTHshy
1IeCKRe TeMb C IIBHOH aHTH3anaAHoH HanpasneHHoCTbIO
llOnO)l(eHHe B COI03e nHcaTeneH R Apyrnx ooI03ax TBopllecshy
KOH HHTeJIJIHfeHnHH (~PHaJIHCTOB KOMll03HTOPOB KHHeMaTorpashy
CPRCTOB H T A) OGloIIHO MO)KeT enYJKHTb XOpoUlHM nOKa3aTeneM
BHyTpeRHero nOJIHTHqeCKorO KJlHMaTa BeerAa RMeIOTCJI AeCJITI(H
nOBeCTeH qHJlhMOB nbeC H T A npeACTaBJIeHHhIX )JlIJI Ony6JIHKoshy
BaHHJI HJlH )JlIJI pa3peUleHHJI nOCTaHOBKH Ha cueHe RJIH JKpaHe
Bee nbeCbl R CPRJIbMbl AOJI)I(HbI nOnyqHTb pa3peUleRHe cnenuaJIbHOrO
KOMHTeTa B03fJIaBJIJleMOrO oooTBeTcmyroIIJHM neH3opoM (Ha o~
naCTHOM ypoBHe eCJlH meca npeACTaBneHa npoBHHUHaJIbHOMY
TeaTpy) 3HaIIHTenloHaJI 1IaCTlo lTHX pa60T 6hlJIa oTBepfHYTa RJIH
OTJIO)KeHa AO BHeeeHRJI H3MeHeHHii ABToPhl peLaKTophI H pe)KHcshy
eepbl (cpepH HHX OqeHL R3BecTHble) HeHJGe)I(HO OGplllQaJIHCb K Hoshy
BOMY PYKOBOpHTenIO JJl1J1 pa3peUleHHJI HX TpYAHOCTeH C neH30paMR
B anpene nORBRJIHClo 06HaAe)I(HBaIOIIJHe npR3HaKH TOro ITO RlMeshy
HeHRJI HOCJITCJI B B03JJYXe rOp6alleB OTKa3aJICJI YSHAeTbCJI C AByMR
H8H60nee KOHeepsaTHBHblMH PYKOBOAHTeJIJlMH COI03a nHcaTeshy
neH - r MapKoBblM npeAeeAaTeneM H A qaKOBCKRM peLaKToshy
poM nmepaTYpHOH raJeTbl EMY nonaraJIOCb BCTpeTHTbCJI C HHMH
lTOGbl HaJIaAHTb xopoIlIHe OTHOUleHHJI C JTHMH orneTCrneHHloIMH
pa60THHKaMH (AlmponOB BHAeJICJI C HHMH B AeKaGpe 1982 r
H Bhlpa3RJI RM CBoe AOBepHe) HO RM 6blJlO CKa3aHO ITO ropGaqeB
enHIJll(OM 3aHJIT CTaJIO HJBeCTHO TaK)Ke lITO lleTp lleMHleB (MRshy
HHCTp KynbTYPbl KaHIlHAaT B lDIeHbl llOJIHTGIOPO H 6blBumii rnaBa
oTAena nponaraHAbI IIK) R ero AOn)I(HOCTHLle mwa CTaJIH Gonee
Be)l(llHBbl C nOeeTHTenJlMH C ApyrOH CTOPOHbl llPR6hITKOB owm HJ
fJIaBHLIX nOMOIIJHHKOB qepHeHKo GlolJI Ha3HaqeH 38MeCTHTeneM
KOMHTeTa no oXpaHe rOCYAapcmeHHLIX eeKpeTOB B nettaTH (OcpHshy
nuaJIbHOe Ha3BaHHe OOBeTCKOH neH3yphI) llnJl llpHGbITKOBa 3T0
GlolJIO nOHH)KeHHeM H Re cynHJlO HHlero xopoUlero B o6JIaCTH neH3Yshy
pbl EhlJIH CJIyXR ITO rOp6a1leB H MHXaHJl 3HMJIHHH BTOPOH eeKpeshy
Tapb HAeOJIOfHleCKOrO OTAena IIK BTOPOH qeJIOBeK noene Cyenoshy
206 207
Ba BbDIonwmIIIHii ry )l(e ponb npH JlHraqeBe He nonlAJfJlH Ho noshy
BHARMOMy- HHKatltHX HOBbIX HHCTpYKIHii He 6bmo H CHrylI(HII He
ynyqunmaCb HrreonOrHtJeCKHe 3allBneHIDI rop6aqeBa 6bIllH W3ycshy
MbIcneHHbI H He o6HapYgtKHBaJIH HOBOro no)Uona llOXOgtKe 6bmo tJTO
rop6alleB IIel1HKOM nopYtJHJ1 HpeonOrHlO JlHralleBY H CKOHIIeHTpHshy
POBaJI CBoe BHHMaHHe Ha 3KOHOMHKe
B aBryCTe EBremm EBrymeHKo H3BecmlilH n03T H nOllHTHshy
IeCKH npoTHBopetJIfBaJI cpurypa HanHcaJI rop6alleBY nHCbMO 0 nnashy
IeBHOM COCTOIIHHH COBeTCKOH llHTeparypbI H llpe3MepHOH CTporocshy
TH IIeH3ypHbIX OrpaHHlleHHH B more B llpaBpe 9 ceHTII6pll
6bIJ1a ony6mnltoBaHa ero KOPOTKaJI n03Ma B KOTOPOH noppepgtKHBashy
naCb 3KOHOMHlJeCKaJI nOllHTHKa rop6alleBa COpep)l(aJlHCb HanllAKH
Ha 61OPOKpaTOB 6oIIIIIHxcII HOBoBBepeHHH H npoTHBJDInlxCII HM
H BOCXBaJIIIJ1C11 WeCTHMeCIIIIHbm COBeTCKuH MopaTopuH Ha Mepshy
HbIe HcnhITaHHJI KaK 6ecnpeIIepeHTHOH cMenocm nOW3Hr BO HMII
MHpa9 ll03Ma copepgtKaJla TatltgtKe CKpbIryIO KpHTHKy KOJ1J1eKTHBHshy
3lIIHH H OTKPhITYlO KpHTHKy JIhIceHKo CBII3bIBlll HblHeWHHe Cel1hCshy
Kox03JriiCTBeHHble TpyDHOCTH C 6mpoKpaTmleCKHMH nperpanaMH
Ho H3 n03MbI IICHO cnepOBano tJTO He napTHII a 61OpoKpaThI omeTshy
CTBeHHbI 31 Bce 3TO B TOMgtKe MeCIIIIe rop6alleB Ha3HatJHJ1 AlleKcaHApa HKOBneBa
rnaDOH OTpel1a nponaraHAhI UK CMeCTHB CryKaJIHHa Ha3HalleHHOrO
nocnOM B BeurpHIO 3r0 paCCMaTpHBaJIOCb KaK XOPOWUH 3HaK
OTpen nponaraHJ]hl IIBJ111eTCII KlllOIIeBhIM 3BeHOM l1HIalleBCKOro
H1leonOrHtJeCKOrO ceKpeTapHaTa lloxo)l(e Ha3HaleHHe 3TO 6bIJ10
npoH3BepeHO B cneWKe (Katlt H Ha3HaqeHHe Pa3YMOBCKoro rnaBOH
OpraHH3lI(HOHHoro OTpel1a) Tatlt Katlt 06blIIH0 rnaBa OTpena nponashy
raHIJbl IIBJ1IIeTCII IJl1eHOM HJ1H KaHlJH)JaTOM B IJl1eHhI UK a HKOBlleB
TatltOBbIM He 6bIJ1 OH 6bIJ1 3aMecmTeneM 3aDe)lylOIIero Omel10M
nponaraHAbI HO 6bIJ1 CMeIIeH CycnOBhIM B 1970 r (OqeBHARo 31
ny6mnclI(H1O B nOllHTHtJeCKHX H llHTepaTypHbIX lKYPHaJIax CTaTeH C KpHTHKOH HeOCTaJIHHHCTCKHX H pycOcpHllbCKHX TeHAeHIHii) H HaJHashy
qeH nocnoM B KaHaJJY B nOM KaleCme OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6aqeshy
Ba BO BpeMII ero BH3Hta B KaHaJJy H MegtKAY HHMH YCTaHOBHllHCb
xopowue OTHOWeHIDI HKOBneB 6hIll B03BplIIeH B MOCKBY H Ha3shy
HaleH ARpeKTOPOM HHcmryra MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKH H MegtKAYHapopshy
HbIX OTHowemm OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6alleBa BO BpeMII ero BH3HTa
B BeJIHK06PHTaHHIO B 1984 r CllHTaeTCII tJTO HKOBneB He 1C0Hcepshy
BaTOp HO OH nonytJHT BnHllHHe TonhlCO ecnH 6ypeT H36paH B UK HOBbIe Ha3HaqeHIDI B HAeonOrHtJeCICOM OTpene BbIrnIIAIIT
BeChMa o6eIIalOIIHMH rpy60 rOBOpll COBeTCICHe HAeonorHtJeCKHe
pa60THHICH penIITcII Ha W3e rpynnhI 1C0HCepBaTHBH)IO 0PTOAQICshy
CaJ1hH)IO 1C0TOPym nOppepgtKHBaJIH CycnOB H neMHIIeB H 60nee
clCnoHaym IC pecpopMaM YMepeHHO nporpecCHBH)IO )lHpeICTOP
HHcmryTa CIlIA H KaHaAhI reopruH Ap6aTOB 6bIBWuH peAaKTOP
llpaBAhI a Teneph ARpelCTOP HHCTHtyTa COIIHOnOrHH AllelCceH
Py-MIIHIIeB CTapWUH COTPYAHHK MegtKAYHapoDHoro OTpena UK H nnopOBHThIH nHcaTenb no BonpocaM COIIHaJIH3Ma H KOMMfHH3Ma
r InaXHaJapoB AlleICcaHAP BOBHR H cIgtepop BypnallKHH 06a H3shy
BeCTHhIe gtKypHallHCTbl - OTHOCllTCII KO BTOPOH rpynne CKllOHaym IC
peCPOPMaM rpynny TOIIHee Ha3BaTh nporpeCCHBHOH qeM nH6epanhshy
HOH Y 3TOH rpynnhI YCTaHOBHllHCh xopowue OTHoweHIDI C AHAposhynOBbIM 1C0rna OH po 1967 r 6hm celCpeTapeM UK llocne HeKoToposhy
ro cnlna BnHIIHHII OHH nOXO)l(e BHOBh BhICTynuJIH Ha CIIeHy nocne
CMepTH Bpe)f(leBa rop6aQeB He HMeBWHH co6CTBeHHoro HHTennelCshy
ryaJIhHOro OICpy)l(eHIDI BHAHMO Ha6Hpan COBeTHHICOB nOMoIUHHshy
ICOB H ppyrux pOn)f(lOCTHbIX llHII H3 3TOH rpynnhI Ho nelaJIhHO
H3BecmhIe CBOHM lCoHcepBaTH3MOM 3HMIIHHH rnaDa OTllena lCynhshy
ryPhI UK Inaypo H peAaKTOP gtKypHaJIa BonpoChI 3KOHOMHKH
H ARpelCTOP HHCTHryTa 3KOHOMHKH XatJaTypoB COXpaHHllH BllHllHHe
H B03MO)f(lO HMelOT nyqwue IIeM nporpeCCHCThl OTHOmeHHJI C
JlHraqeBbIM
TpeTbll rpynna - IIeHTpHCTClCaII B Hee BX0AIIT penaICTOp
llpaBAhI ACPaHaCbeB H pepaKTOP TeopemlleCKOrO napmHHoro
gtKYpHaJIa KOMMyHHCT PHtJapp KOCOnaDOB llOCKonhlCY COBeTCKuH
COlO3 IIBJ111eTCII HpeOnOrHtJeCICHM rocypapcmOM nyooHKlIIHU B
napTHHHbIX oprauax netJarn 06bIIIH0 6hIBalOT HaH60nee 3HatJHMhlMH
nOKaJaTenllMH TeKYIIHX nonHTHtJeCICHX H HAeonOrHtJeCKHX TeHAeHshy
IIUHmiddot MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M IIBJ1IIeTCII CYIIeCTBeHHbIM CBII3ymIIIHM
3BeHOM MegtKAY pa3J1HllHhIMH rocynapcmeHHhIMH yqpegtKAeHIDIMH
H neranH3yeT BepxoBHym BnaCTh napTHH H ee reHepanbHoro ceKpeshy
tapll HpeonorHtJeCKHe CBII3H MelKA) pa3HbIMH qaCTIIMH rocypapshy
CTBeHHOH MaWHHbI COXpaHIIT CBOIO npOlJHOCTb ecnH COXPaHHTshy
CII IIeMeHTHpymmaH ponh HAeonorHH 3Ta ponh IIBHO YMeHhIlIHshy
209208
JIaCb BO BpeMeHa Bpe)lQeBa HO 3TO fibIJlO BbI3BaHO He CTPYKrypshy
HblMH H3MeHeHHHMH a CBoero POIJ8 HlJeOJIOrlflleCKHM CKJIeposhy
30M BepXH napTHH fiblJIH He cnocofiHbI C031J8Tb Ifl1eOJIorlfllecshy
KHH COJHaJIbHbIH IDIH nOJIHTlflleCKHH JOKyMem K KOTOPOMY
Ofipa30BaHHbIe KpyrH MornH fibI OTHeCTHCb eepbe3HO B 1970-x H
1980-x roJaX nytflIIee qyO MOrJIa npeJJIO)lOTb napTHH JJIS BJOXHoshy
BeHHS HapolJ8 fibIJIH TPyruI Bpe)lQeBa - BOcnOMHHaHHS 0 roJax
BOHHbI 0 ueJIHHe H T JJ npHMHTHBHO H y60ro HanHCaHHbIe 3a Hero
JpymMH H nopolJHBIillIe 6eCqCJIeHHbIe aHeKJorbI
CaM rOpfialJeB TO)(e He H36e)(aJI HeKOTopoH npHtJaCTHOCTH
K npHMHTHBHbIM H 6ecCMbICJIeHHbIM HJeOJIOrlflleCKHM MaTepHanaM
Toro nepHolJ8 B peq Ha KOHlgtepeHUHli no BonpocaM HJeOJIOrHH B
CTaBponOJIbCKOM Kpae B Mae 1978 r KorJa OH eII(e fibIJI eeKpeTashy
peM rOpKOMa ropfiaqeB CKa3aJI
reHepanbHbIH ceKpeTapb UK KnCC npeJceJareJIb
IIpe3HJHyMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP JI H Bpe)(HeB shy
raJIaHTJIHBbrH PYKoBOJHTeJIb JIeHHHCKOro THna Ero THTashy
HHlJecKas nOBceJHeBHas pafioTa HanpaBJIeHa Ha YKpeIIJIeHHe
MOII(H CTpaHbI nOBbJIIIeHHe 6narocoCToSHHS rpyJlIIUHXCS
Ha ynpoqeHHe MHpa H fie30naCHOCTH HapoJoB
HeJaBHO MbI paCKPbIJIH CTpaHHJbI 3aMelJaTeJIbHOH KHHrH
TOBapHII(a J1 H Bpe)lQeBa bull Manu 3eMJIS rJe 3OJIOTbIMH
fiYKBaMH 3aJIelJaTJIeHbI noprpeTbI JIereHlJ8pHbIX repoeB
60es 3a CeBepHbrH WKaJ HeMHoro BpeMeHH npoIIIJIo co
JHI[ ny6nHKauHH KHHrO HO BOCnOMHHaHHH BbI3BanH
BceofiII(Hii nOJJIHHHO BceHapoJHbrH HHTepec qTofibI YJOBshy
JIeTBopHTb 6ecqCJIeHHbIe 3anpocbI TpKeHHKoB CTaBposhy
nOJIbIUHHbI B lgteBpane 3TH BOCnOMHHaHHH fiyJJYT nepeneshy
lJaTaHbI H3 YpHana HOBbrH MHP B HallIHX KpaeBblX
raJeTax CTaBponOJIbCKas npaBJa H KaBKa3CKas 3JpaBshy
HHua
B KHHre bullManas 3eMJIS He TaK MHoro crpaHHJ HO no
rnyfiHHe HJeOJIOrHlJeCKOrO coJep)(aHHH no IillIpoTe 0606shy
II(eHHH 0 MbICJIeH aBTOpa OHa CTana 60JIbIilllM COfibITHeM
OfiII(eCTBeHHOH )(H3HH OHa BbI3Bana rop~ OTKJIHK B
eepJJax COBeTCKDX mOJeH 0 BOCX8II(eHHble OT3b1BbI COJIshy
IJ8T-IgtPOHTOBHKOB Ha qTaTeJIbCKDX KOHlgtepeHUHSX H B nelJaTH
KOMMYHHCTbI H Bce TpKeHHKH CTaBpOnOJIbIUHHbI 6ecshy
KOHelJHO 6narOJapHbI JIeoHHJy HnbHlfY Bpe)(HeBY 3a ero
nOJJIHHHO BJOXHOBJIeHHYIO napTHeH JIHTeparyPHYlO pa60TY
B KOTOPOH HCTOlfHHKH BeJIHKOro nOJBHra HallIeH repoHlJecshy
KOH CTpaHbI ee JJYXOBHOH H HpaBCTBeHHOH CHJIbI ee CIOHshy
KOCTH H MKeCTBa BCKPblTbI C IgtHJIOCOIgtCKOH rnyfiHHoH
(OfipaTHbrH nepeBOJ C aHrn - PeJ) 10
~ras 3TO HeYMepeHHoe BOCXBaneHHe nOBepXHOCTHoro H noeshy
peJCTBeHHoro COlJHHeHHH Bpe)lQeBa HeJIb3S He nOqyBCTBOBaTb qro
ero oJeOJIOrHqeCKOe B03JeHCTBHe SBJISeTCS ofipaTHblM KpoMe Bceshy
ro npoqero H3JIO)(eHHe Bpe)(HeBa HCKa)(aeT HCTOpHIO H CaM fibIJI
B 1943 r COJIJaTOM TaMaHcKoro IgtpoHTa H Manas 3eMJIS fibIJIa
Beero JImllb ero He60JIbIilllM 6eperoBblM aBaHnOCTOM B03HHKIillIM
BO BpeMH HaYlJ8lJHOro HacTyIlJIeHHH Ha HOBOPOCCHHCK B anpeJIe
H 3aTeM B Mae 1943 r IIoKa Bpe)(HeB 30 JIer CnyCTS He H30fipaJHJI
cofiblTHS TaM KaK OCHOBHYIO fiHTBY OHH fibIJIH He3HalJHTeJIbHbIM
BoeHHbIM 3JIH30JOM Bpe)(HeB fibIJI TorJa nOJIHTKOMHccaPOM
H TOJIbKO OJH~I noJIYqJIJI nOBb1lIIeHHe B lJHHe B 1941 r OH fibIJI
nOJIKOBHHKOM a K 1945 r CTan reHepan-MaH0poM Ho B 1978 r
olgtHUHanbHas npecca CTMa nucaTb 0 HeM TaK KaK fiYJTO OH fibIJI
60JIee BblJalOII(HMCS BoeHHbIM repoeM qeM MapUIan )KYKOB
MHorHe napTHHHbIe lJHHbI nOBa)(Hee ropfiaqeBa B 1978 r
paCTOlJanO HeofibIlJaHHbIe nOXBanbI fipe)(HeBCKOMY JIHTeparypHOMY
onycy 3TO CBHJeTeJIbCTByeT 0 nyCToTe JerpaJaUHH 0 pa3JIO)(eHHH
oJeOJIOrHH JIerKo nOHHTb KynbT BO BpeMeHa CranHHa KorJa
JOJI)(HOCTHble JI8Ja onacanHCb 3a CBOO )(H3HH Ho B 1978 r OHH
pHcKoBanH TOJIbKO 3aJep)(KOH B npoJBH)(eHHH no JOJI)(HOCTH
IDIO YTpaTOH KaKOH-TO npHBIDIerHH
TaKOM OfiPaJOM B 1985 r KorJa ropfiaqeB cran reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKperapeM HeofixoJHMOCTb HOBbIX HJeH 0 HHHUHarHB B 06shy
JIaCTH HJeOJIOrHH CTana BeCbMa HaCrOSTeJIbHoH BbIJIO OqeBOJHO
qyO ropfiaqeB He cofiHpancs caM yJOBJIerBopHTb 3ry HeofixoJHshy
MOCTb pa3Be TOJIbKO B pOJIO PYKOBOJHreJIS HJeOJIorulJeCKOrO
fiaHKa HJeH HalJHHaBUIerO B03HHKan OrJeJIbHbrH fiaHK HJeH
CTan lgtopMHpoBarbCS BOKpyr JIuraqeBa 3ro C03JaBanO B03MO)(shy
HOCTb fiyJJYIUHX npOTHBopelfHil Me)(Jy rreBblM H IIpaBbIM Hanshy
paBJIeHHIMH HO HeJIb3S fibIJIO Cpa3Y onpeJeJIHTb HX reHJeHIQiH
211210
HoeaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii
nporpaMMlgtI no)]roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII CDe3)Jy napTHH 3a)Jashy
lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX BnyTpeHHHX
H Me)l()JyHapolJHblX npo6rreM H Bbl)JBIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX
pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTHshy
IIeCKHH MaHHltpeCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xoIWMa
TaK KaK npeJKlU[a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1961 r Ha 6rrH)l(aiiume 20 JIeT
Dna HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe)]eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor)]a He 6blshy
JIH )]OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03)J3BaTIgt Tpy)]shy
HOCTH H CHH)fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HYKlfll H )IJla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii (TaK KaK
CYlUecmyeT npoue)Jypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIOshy
IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii) H )IJla ny)l()J Me)I()JyHashy
PO)JHoii nOJIHTHKH - nporpaMMa KIICC CIIYflliT Mo)]eJIbIO nporshy
paMM )]PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii
HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii napshy
THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa ltPOPMaJlbHas
nporpaMMa Beer)Ja 6blJIa H3H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me)I()JyHapo)]shy
Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO )JBH)KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrapeshy
BaJla B TelIeHHe )JByx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTyshy
nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre)JHHe napshy
THiiHble )]OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas oltPHUHaJlhHas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II Cbe3)]e napTHH B BplOcceshy
JIe H 3aTeM B llOH)JOHe r)]e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me)K)Jy 6oJIbllleBHshy
KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii
CB060)Jb1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npoltpshy
C01030B11 CJIe)Jyronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM
H TpoIUltHM H 0)]06peua VIII napTCbe3)]oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa)KaJla
yCJIOBHH rpa)l()JaHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3shy
Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa)JHKaJlbHOii oua oTpa)KaJla Ha)Je)K)Jy
na HeH3OO)KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras
oTMeny )]eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH)JOK
XOT9 noerre BBe)]eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII
HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO )]0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH
npaBHlI KaK )JHKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTemHO YMeHblllHlIaCh
oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM
TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO)JfOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C 1954 r no 1961 r
H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua XXII Cbe3)Je KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo-
BaJla 003 ltpOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMlgtI MHorne rO)JbI B npaBJIeHHe CTashy
JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY)KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa OleHb ny)KHa Ero KpHTHshy
KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H )]pyrHe PYKOBOIWTeJIH KaK peshy
BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny)l()JaJlca B )]OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl
ero H)JeH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMHshy
IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c)]eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo)]eJIhlO AllII )]pyrHX CTpaH C
KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha)JemlC9 TaKHM nyreM
npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me)l()JyHapo)JHOM KOMMyshy
HHCTHIeCKOM )JBIDKeHHH (H KHraii H IOroerraBHH npe)JlIO)KHJIH
aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO)JeJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe
KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe
ltpPaKUHH) TaKHM 06pa30M na Me)l()JyHapo)JHoii apeHe TpeTha napshy
THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa )Ja)Ke B)KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii B HTOshy
re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH
H npHTa3aHHs B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko)]eKc
33HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH (HfHopHpyeMbIH cashy
MHMH PyKOBOIWTeJI9MH) onpe)]eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCTshy
BeHHble ueJIH ua 70-e H 8O-e rO)JbI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepeashy
JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK)Ke HeHa)Je)KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl
nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a)JMHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla
1JT0 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo)]CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9IOTC9
C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 1970 r H npeB30ii)JyT HX K
1980 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y)]eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIOIW
6y)JyT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo)JHMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9M COBeTcshy
KHii COlO3 )]OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3BoIWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy)Ja B MHshy
pe Ka)K)Ja9 eeMb9 6y)]eT HMeTh oT)]eJIbHblii )]OM HlIH KBapTHpy
KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoDBeralOIUHMH H )]OXO)JHbIMH a UHTashy
HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y)]eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax
HHIero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO )]OCTHfHyrO B nporpaMMe YKa3blBashy
JIOCh1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm )]OXO)] B 1980 r 6y)]eT B 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM
B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y)]eT npoH3BOIWTh 2700 MJIP)]
KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro)] (Ha )]eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT noshy
KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP)]) 700 MJIH T Heltpm (B 1980 r 6bIJIO)]0shy
6bITO 603 MJIH T) 300 MJIH T lepHa (ypo)fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T) H 30 MJIH T Maca (npOH3Bo)]CTBO M9ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO
15 MJIH T) 12 He 6bIJIa )]oCTHrnyra HH 0)JHa H3 HaMeleHHblX UHltPP
(JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B
1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T)
213 212
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
Ba BbDIonwmIIIHii ry )l(e ponb npH JlHraqeBe He nonlAJfJlH Ho noshy
BHARMOMy- HHKatltHX HOBbIX HHCTpYKIHii He 6bmo H CHrylI(HII He
ynyqunmaCb HrreonOrHtJeCKHe 3allBneHIDI rop6aqeBa 6bIllH W3ycshy
MbIcneHHbI H He o6HapYgtKHBaJIH HOBOro no)Uona llOXOgtKe 6bmo tJTO
rop6alleB IIel1HKOM nopYtJHJ1 HpeonOrHlO JlHralleBY H CKOHIIeHTpHshy
POBaJI CBoe BHHMaHHe Ha 3KOHOMHKe
B aBryCTe EBremm EBrymeHKo H3BecmlilH n03T H nOllHTHshy
IeCKH npoTHBopetJIfBaJI cpurypa HanHcaJI rop6alleBY nHCbMO 0 nnashy
IeBHOM COCTOIIHHH COBeTCKOH llHTeparypbI H llpe3MepHOH CTporocshy
TH IIeH3ypHbIX OrpaHHlleHHH B more B llpaBpe 9 ceHTII6pll
6bIJ1a ony6mnltoBaHa ero KOPOTKaJI n03Ma B KOTOPOH noppepgtKHBashy
naCb 3KOHOMHlJeCKaJI nOllHTHKa rop6alleBa COpep)l(aJlHCb HanllAKH
Ha 61OPOKpaTOB 6oIIIIIHxcII HOBoBBepeHHH H npoTHBJDInlxCII HM
H BOCXBaJIIIJ1C11 WeCTHMeCIIIIHbm COBeTCKuH MopaTopuH Ha Mepshy
HbIe HcnhITaHHJI KaK 6ecnpeIIepeHTHOH cMenocm nOW3Hr BO HMII
MHpa9 ll03Ma copepgtKaJla TatltgtKe CKpbIryIO KpHTHKy KOJ1J1eKTHBHshy
3lIIHH H OTKPhITYlO KpHTHKy JIhIceHKo CBII3bIBlll HblHeWHHe Cel1hCshy
Kox03JriiCTBeHHble TpyDHOCTH C 6mpoKpaTmleCKHMH nperpanaMH
Ho H3 n03MbI IICHO cnepOBano tJTO He napTHII a 61OpoKpaThI omeTshy
CTBeHHbI 31 Bce 3TO B TOMgtKe MeCIIIIe rop6alleB Ha3HatJHJ1 AlleKcaHApa HKOBneBa
rnaDOH OTpel1a nponaraHAhI UK CMeCTHB CryKaJIHHa Ha3HalleHHOrO
nocnOM B BeurpHIO 3r0 paCCMaTpHBaJIOCb KaK XOPOWUH 3HaK
OTpen nponaraHJ]hl IIBJ111eTCII KlllOIIeBhIM 3BeHOM l1HIalleBCKOro
H1leonOrHtJeCKOrO ceKpeTapHaTa lloxo)l(e Ha3HaleHHe 3TO 6bIJ10
npoH3BepeHO B cneWKe (Katlt H Ha3HaqeHHe Pa3YMOBCKoro rnaBOH
OpraHH3lI(HOHHoro OTpel1a) Tatlt Katlt 06blIIH0 rnaBa OTpena nponashy
raHIJbl IIBJ1IIeTCII IJl1eHOM HJ1H KaHlJH)JaTOM B IJl1eHhI UK a HKOBlleB
TatltOBbIM He 6bIJ1 OH 6bIJ1 3aMecmTeneM 3aDe)lylOIIero Omel10M
nponaraHAbI HO 6bIJ1 CMeIIeH CycnOBhIM B 1970 r (OqeBHARo 31
ny6mnclI(H1O B nOllHTHtJeCKHX H llHTepaTypHbIX lKYPHaJIax CTaTeH C KpHTHKOH HeOCTaJIHHHCTCKHX H pycOcpHllbCKHX TeHAeHIHii) H HaJHashy
qeH nocnoM B KaHaJJY B nOM KaleCme OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6aqeshy
Ba BO BpeMII ero BH3Hta B KaHaJJy H MegtKAY HHMH YCTaHOBHllHCb
xopowue OTHOWeHIDI HKOBneB 6hIll B03BplIIeH B MOCKBY H Ha3shy
HaleH ARpeKTOPOM HHcmryra MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKH H MegtKAYHapopshy
HbIX OTHowemm OH conpoBOgtKnaJl rop6alleBa BO BpeMII ero BH3HTa
B BeJIHK06PHTaHHIO B 1984 r CllHTaeTCII tJTO HKOBneB He 1C0Hcepshy
BaTOp HO OH nonytJHT BnHllHHe TonhlCO ecnH 6ypeT H36paH B UK HOBbIe Ha3HaqeHIDI B HAeonOrHtJeCICOM OTpene BbIrnIIAIIT
BeChMa o6eIIalOIIHMH rpy60 rOBOpll COBeTCICHe HAeonorHtJeCKHe
pa60THHICH penIITcII Ha W3e rpynnhI 1C0HCepBaTHBH)IO 0PTOAQICshy
CaJ1hH)IO 1C0TOPym nOppepgtKHBaJIH CycnOB H neMHIIeB H 60nee
clCnoHaym IC pecpopMaM YMepeHHO nporpecCHBH)IO )lHpeICTOP
HHcmryTa CIlIA H KaHaAhI reopruH Ap6aTOB 6bIBWuH peAaKTOP
llpaBAhI a Teneph ARpelCTOP HHCTHtyTa COIIHOnOrHH AllelCceH
Py-MIIHIIeB CTapWUH COTPYAHHK MegtKAYHapoDHoro OTpena UK H nnopOBHThIH nHcaTenb no BonpocaM COIIHaJIH3Ma H KOMMfHH3Ma
r InaXHaJapoB AlleICcaHAP BOBHR H cIgtepop BypnallKHH 06a H3shy
BeCTHhIe gtKypHallHCTbl - OTHOCllTCII KO BTOPOH rpynne CKllOHaym IC
peCPOPMaM rpynny TOIIHee Ha3BaTh nporpeCCHBHOH qeM nH6epanhshy
HOH Y 3TOH rpynnhI YCTaHOBHllHCh xopowue OTHoweHIDI C AHAposhynOBbIM 1C0rna OH po 1967 r 6hm celCpeTapeM UK llocne HeKoToposhy
ro cnlna BnHIIHHII OHH nOXO)l(e BHOBh BhICTynuJIH Ha CIIeHy nocne
CMepTH Bpe)f(leBa rop6aQeB He HMeBWHH co6CTBeHHoro HHTennelCshy
ryaJIhHOro OICpy)l(eHIDI BHAHMO Ha6Hpan COBeTHHICOB nOMoIUHHshy
ICOB H ppyrux pOn)f(lOCTHbIX llHII H3 3TOH rpynnhI Ho nelaJIhHO
H3BecmhIe CBOHM lCoHcepBaTH3MOM 3HMIIHHH rnaDa OTllena lCynhshy
ryPhI UK Inaypo H peAaKTOP gtKypHaJIa BonpoChI 3KOHOMHKH
H ARpelCTOP HHCTHryTa 3KOHOMHKH XatJaTypoB COXpaHHllH BllHllHHe
H B03MO)f(lO HMelOT nyqwue IIeM nporpeCCHCThl OTHOmeHHJI C
JlHraqeBbIM
TpeTbll rpynna - IIeHTpHCTClCaII B Hee BX0AIIT penaICTOp
llpaBAhI ACPaHaCbeB H pepaKTOP TeopemlleCKOrO napmHHoro
gtKYpHaJIa KOMMyHHCT PHtJapp KOCOnaDOB llOCKonhlCY COBeTCKuH
COlO3 IIBJ111eTCII HpeOnOrHtJeCICHM rocypapcmOM nyooHKlIIHU B
napTHHHbIX oprauax netJarn 06bIIIH0 6hIBalOT HaH60nee 3HatJHMhlMH
nOKaJaTenllMH TeKYIIHX nonHTHtJeCICHX H HAeonOrHtJeCKHX TeHAeHshy
IIUHmiddot MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M IIBJ1IIeTCII CYIIeCTBeHHbIM CBII3ymIIIHM
3BeHOM MegtKAY pa3J1HllHhIMH rocynapcmeHHhIMH yqpegtKAeHIDIMH
H neranH3yeT BepxoBHym BnaCTh napTHH H ee reHepanbHoro ceKpeshy
tapll HpeonorHtJeCKHe CBII3H MelKA) pa3HbIMH qaCTIIMH rocypapshy
CTBeHHOH MaWHHbI COXpaHIIT CBOIO npOlJHOCTb ecnH COXPaHHTshy
CII IIeMeHTHpymmaH ponh HAeonorHH 3Ta ponh IIBHO YMeHhIlIHshy
209208
JIaCb BO BpeMeHa Bpe)lQeBa HO 3TO fibIJlO BbI3BaHO He CTPYKrypshy
HblMH H3MeHeHHHMH a CBoero POIJ8 HlJeOJIOrlflleCKHM CKJIeposhy
30M BepXH napTHH fiblJIH He cnocofiHbI C031J8Tb Ifl1eOJIorlfllecshy
KHH COJHaJIbHbIH IDIH nOJIHTlflleCKHH JOKyMem K KOTOPOMY
Ofipa30BaHHbIe KpyrH MornH fibI OTHeCTHCb eepbe3HO B 1970-x H
1980-x roJaX nytflIIee qyO MOrJIa npeJJIO)lOTb napTHH JJIS BJOXHoshy
BeHHS HapolJ8 fibIJIH TPyruI Bpe)lQeBa - BOcnOMHHaHHS 0 roJax
BOHHbI 0 ueJIHHe H T JJ npHMHTHBHO H y60ro HanHCaHHbIe 3a Hero
JpymMH H nopolJHBIillIe 6eCqCJIeHHbIe aHeKJorbI
CaM rOpfialJeB TO)(e He H36e)(aJI HeKOTopoH npHtJaCTHOCTH
K npHMHTHBHbIM H 6ecCMbICJIeHHbIM HJeOJIOrlflleCKHM MaTepHanaM
Toro nepHolJ8 B peq Ha KOHlgtepeHUHli no BonpocaM HJeOJIOrHH B
CTaBponOJIbCKOM Kpae B Mae 1978 r KorJa OH eII(e fibIJI eeKpeTashy
peM rOpKOMa ropfiaqeB CKa3aJI
reHepanbHbIH ceKpeTapb UK KnCC npeJceJareJIb
IIpe3HJHyMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP JI H Bpe)(HeB shy
raJIaHTJIHBbrH PYKoBOJHTeJIb JIeHHHCKOro THna Ero THTashy
HHlJecKas nOBceJHeBHas pafioTa HanpaBJIeHa Ha YKpeIIJIeHHe
MOII(H CTpaHbI nOBbJIIIeHHe 6narocoCToSHHS rpyJlIIUHXCS
Ha ynpoqeHHe MHpa H fie30naCHOCTH HapoJoB
HeJaBHO MbI paCKPbIJIH CTpaHHJbI 3aMelJaTeJIbHOH KHHrH
TOBapHII(a J1 H Bpe)lQeBa bull Manu 3eMJIS rJe 3OJIOTbIMH
fiYKBaMH 3aJIelJaTJIeHbI noprpeTbI JIereHlJ8pHbIX repoeB
60es 3a CeBepHbrH WKaJ HeMHoro BpeMeHH npoIIIJIo co
JHI[ ny6nHKauHH KHHrO HO BOCnOMHHaHHH BbI3BanH
BceofiII(Hii nOJJIHHHO BceHapoJHbrH HHTepec qTofibI YJOBshy
JIeTBopHTb 6ecqCJIeHHbIe 3anpocbI TpKeHHKoB CTaBposhy
nOJIbIUHHbI B lgteBpane 3TH BOCnOMHHaHHH fiyJJYT nepeneshy
lJaTaHbI H3 YpHana HOBbrH MHP B HallIHX KpaeBblX
raJeTax CTaBponOJIbCKas npaBJa H KaBKa3CKas 3JpaBshy
HHua
B KHHre bullManas 3eMJIS He TaK MHoro crpaHHJ HO no
rnyfiHHe HJeOJIOrHlJeCKOrO coJep)(aHHH no IillIpoTe 0606shy
II(eHHH 0 MbICJIeH aBTOpa OHa CTana 60JIbIilllM COfibITHeM
OfiII(eCTBeHHOH )(H3HH OHa BbI3Bana rop~ OTKJIHK B
eepJJax COBeTCKDX mOJeH 0 BOCX8II(eHHble OT3b1BbI COJIshy
IJ8T-IgtPOHTOBHKOB Ha qTaTeJIbCKDX KOHlgtepeHUHSX H B nelJaTH
KOMMYHHCTbI H Bce TpKeHHKH CTaBpOnOJIbIUHHbI 6ecshy
KOHelJHO 6narOJapHbI JIeoHHJy HnbHlfY Bpe)(HeBY 3a ero
nOJJIHHHO BJOXHOBJIeHHYIO napTHeH JIHTeparyPHYlO pa60TY
B KOTOPOH HCTOlfHHKH BeJIHKOro nOJBHra HallIeH repoHlJecshy
KOH CTpaHbI ee JJYXOBHOH H HpaBCTBeHHOH CHJIbI ee CIOHshy
KOCTH H MKeCTBa BCKPblTbI C IgtHJIOCOIgtCKOH rnyfiHHoH
(OfipaTHbrH nepeBOJ C aHrn - PeJ) 10
~ras 3TO HeYMepeHHoe BOCXBaneHHe nOBepXHOCTHoro H noeshy
peJCTBeHHoro COlJHHeHHH Bpe)lQeBa HeJIb3S He nOqyBCTBOBaTb qro
ero oJeOJIOrHqeCKOe B03JeHCTBHe SBJISeTCS ofipaTHblM KpoMe Bceshy
ro npoqero H3JIO)(eHHe Bpe)(HeBa HCKa)(aeT HCTOpHIO H CaM fibIJI
B 1943 r COJIJaTOM TaMaHcKoro IgtpoHTa H Manas 3eMJIS fibIJIa
Beero JImllb ero He60JIbIilllM 6eperoBblM aBaHnOCTOM B03HHKIillIM
BO BpeMH HaYlJ8lJHOro HacTyIlJIeHHH Ha HOBOPOCCHHCK B anpeJIe
H 3aTeM B Mae 1943 r IIoKa Bpe)(HeB 30 JIer CnyCTS He H30fipaJHJI
cofiblTHS TaM KaK OCHOBHYIO fiHTBY OHH fibIJIH He3HalJHTeJIbHbIM
BoeHHbIM 3JIH30JOM Bpe)(HeB fibIJI TorJa nOJIHTKOMHccaPOM
H TOJIbKO OJH~I noJIYqJIJI nOBb1lIIeHHe B lJHHe B 1941 r OH fibIJI
nOJIKOBHHKOM a K 1945 r CTan reHepan-MaH0poM Ho B 1978 r
olgtHUHanbHas npecca CTMa nucaTb 0 HeM TaK KaK fiYJTO OH fibIJI
60JIee BblJalOII(HMCS BoeHHbIM repoeM qeM MapUIan )KYKOB
MHorHe napTHHHbIe lJHHbI nOBa)(Hee ropfiaqeBa B 1978 r
paCTOlJanO HeofibIlJaHHbIe nOXBanbI fipe)(HeBCKOMY JIHTeparypHOMY
onycy 3TO CBHJeTeJIbCTByeT 0 nyCToTe JerpaJaUHH 0 pa3JIO)(eHHH
oJeOJIOrHH JIerKo nOHHTb KynbT BO BpeMeHa CranHHa KorJa
JOJI)(HOCTHble JI8Ja onacanHCb 3a CBOO )(H3HH Ho B 1978 r OHH
pHcKoBanH TOJIbKO 3aJep)(KOH B npoJBH)(eHHH no JOJI)(HOCTH
IDIO YTpaTOH KaKOH-TO npHBIDIerHH
TaKOM OfiPaJOM B 1985 r KorJa ropfiaqeB cran reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKperapeM HeofixoJHMOCTb HOBbIX HJeH 0 HHHUHarHB B 06shy
JIaCTH HJeOJIOrHH CTana BeCbMa HaCrOSTeJIbHoH BbIJIO OqeBOJHO
qyO ropfiaqeB He cofiHpancs caM yJOBJIerBopHTb 3ry HeofixoJHshy
MOCTb pa3Be TOJIbKO B pOJIO PYKOBOJHreJIS HJeOJIorulJeCKOrO
fiaHKa HJeH HalJHHaBUIerO B03HHKan OrJeJIbHbrH fiaHK HJeH
CTan lgtopMHpoBarbCS BOKpyr JIuraqeBa 3ro C03JaBanO B03MO)(shy
HOCTb fiyJJYIUHX npOTHBopelfHil Me)(Jy rreBblM H IIpaBbIM Hanshy
paBJIeHHIMH HO HeJIb3S fibIJIO Cpa3Y onpeJeJIHTb HX reHJeHIQiH
211210
HoeaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii
nporpaMMlgtI no)]roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII CDe3)Jy napTHH 3a)Jashy
lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX BnyTpeHHHX
H Me)l()JyHapolJHblX npo6rreM H Bbl)JBIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX
pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTHshy
IIeCKHH MaHHltpeCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xoIWMa
TaK KaK npeJKlU[a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1961 r Ha 6rrH)l(aiiume 20 JIeT
Dna HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe)]eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor)]a He 6blshy
JIH )]OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03)J3BaTIgt Tpy)]shy
HOCTH H CHH)fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HYKlfll H )IJla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii (TaK KaK
CYlUecmyeT npoue)Jypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIOshy
IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii) H )IJla ny)l()J Me)I()JyHashy
PO)JHoii nOJIHTHKH - nporpaMMa KIICC CIIYflliT Mo)]eJIbIO nporshy
paMM )]PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii
HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii napshy
THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa ltPOPMaJlbHas
nporpaMMa Beer)Ja 6blJIa H3H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me)I()JyHapo)]shy
Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO )JBH)KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrapeshy
BaJla B TelIeHHe )JByx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTyshy
nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre)JHHe napshy
THiiHble )]OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas oltPHUHaJlhHas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II Cbe3)]e napTHH B BplOcceshy
JIe H 3aTeM B llOH)JOHe r)]e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me)K)Jy 6oJIbllleBHshy
KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii
CB060)Jb1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npoltpshy
C01030B11 CJIe)Jyronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM
H TpoIUltHM H 0)]06peua VIII napTCbe3)]oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa)KaJla
yCJIOBHH rpa)l()JaHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3shy
Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa)JHKaJlbHOii oua oTpa)KaJla Ha)Je)K)Jy
na HeH3OO)KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras
oTMeny )]eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH)JOK
XOT9 noerre BBe)]eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII
HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO )]0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH
npaBHlI KaK )JHKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTemHO YMeHblllHlIaCh
oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM
TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO)JfOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C 1954 r no 1961 r
H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua XXII Cbe3)Je KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo-
BaJla 003 ltpOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMlgtI MHorne rO)JbI B npaBJIeHHe CTashy
JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY)KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa OleHb ny)KHa Ero KpHTHshy
KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H )]pyrHe PYKOBOIWTeJIH KaK peshy
BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny)l()JaJlca B )]OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl
ero H)JeH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMHshy
IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c)]eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo)]eJIhlO AllII )]pyrHX CTpaH C
KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha)JemlC9 TaKHM nyreM
npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me)l()JyHapo)JHOM KOMMyshy
HHCTHIeCKOM )JBIDKeHHH (H KHraii H IOroerraBHH npe)JlIO)KHJIH
aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO)JeJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe
KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe
ltpPaKUHH) TaKHM 06pa30M na Me)l()JyHapo)JHoii apeHe TpeTha napshy
THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa )Ja)Ke B)KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii B HTOshy
re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH
H npHTa3aHHs B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko)]eKc
33HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH (HfHopHpyeMbIH cashy
MHMH PyKOBOIWTeJI9MH) onpe)]eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCTshy
BeHHble ueJIH ua 70-e H 8O-e rO)JbI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepeashy
JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK)Ke HeHa)Je)KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl
nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a)JMHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla
1JT0 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo)]CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9IOTC9
C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 1970 r H npeB30ii)JyT HX K
1980 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y)]eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIOIW
6y)JyT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo)JHMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9M COBeTcshy
KHii COlO3 )]OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3BoIWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy)Ja B MHshy
pe Ka)K)Ja9 eeMb9 6y)]eT HMeTh oT)]eJIbHblii )]OM HlIH KBapTHpy
KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoDBeralOIUHMH H )]OXO)JHbIMH a UHTashy
HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y)]eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax
HHIero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO )]OCTHfHyrO B nporpaMMe YKa3blBashy
JIOCh1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm )]OXO)] B 1980 r 6y)]eT B 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM
B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y)]eT npoH3BOIWTh 2700 MJIP)]
KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro)] (Ha )]eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT noshy
KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP)]) 700 MJIH T Heltpm (B 1980 r 6bIJIO)]0shy
6bITO 603 MJIH T) 300 MJIH T lepHa (ypo)fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T) H 30 MJIH T Maca (npOH3Bo)]CTBO M9ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO
15 MJIH T) 12 He 6bIJIa )]oCTHrnyra HH 0)JHa H3 HaMeleHHblX UHltPP
(JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B
1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T)
213 212
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
JIaCb BO BpeMeHa Bpe)lQeBa HO 3TO fibIJlO BbI3BaHO He CTPYKrypshy
HblMH H3MeHeHHHMH a CBoero POIJ8 HlJeOJIOrlflleCKHM CKJIeposhy
30M BepXH napTHH fiblJIH He cnocofiHbI C031J8Tb Ifl1eOJIorlfllecshy
KHH COJHaJIbHbIH IDIH nOJIHTlflleCKHH JOKyMem K KOTOPOMY
Ofipa30BaHHbIe KpyrH MornH fibI OTHeCTHCb eepbe3HO B 1970-x H
1980-x roJaX nytflIIee qyO MOrJIa npeJJIO)lOTb napTHH JJIS BJOXHoshy
BeHHS HapolJ8 fibIJIH TPyruI Bpe)lQeBa - BOcnOMHHaHHS 0 roJax
BOHHbI 0 ueJIHHe H T JJ npHMHTHBHO H y60ro HanHCaHHbIe 3a Hero
JpymMH H nopolJHBIillIe 6eCqCJIeHHbIe aHeKJorbI
CaM rOpfialJeB TO)(e He H36e)(aJI HeKOTopoH npHtJaCTHOCTH
K npHMHTHBHbIM H 6ecCMbICJIeHHbIM HJeOJIOrlflleCKHM MaTepHanaM
Toro nepHolJ8 B peq Ha KOHlgtepeHUHli no BonpocaM HJeOJIOrHH B
CTaBponOJIbCKOM Kpae B Mae 1978 r KorJa OH eII(e fibIJI eeKpeTashy
peM rOpKOMa ropfiaqeB CKa3aJI
reHepanbHbIH ceKpeTapb UK KnCC npeJceJareJIb
IIpe3HJHyMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP JI H Bpe)(HeB shy
raJIaHTJIHBbrH PYKoBOJHTeJIb JIeHHHCKOro THna Ero THTashy
HHlJecKas nOBceJHeBHas pafioTa HanpaBJIeHa Ha YKpeIIJIeHHe
MOII(H CTpaHbI nOBbJIIIeHHe 6narocoCToSHHS rpyJlIIUHXCS
Ha ynpoqeHHe MHpa H fie30naCHOCTH HapoJoB
HeJaBHO MbI paCKPbIJIH CTpaHHJbI 3aMelJaTeJIbHOH KHHrH
TOBapHII(a J1 H Bpe)lQeBa bull Manu 3eMJIS rJe 3OJIOTbIMH
fiYKBaMH 3aJIelJaTJIeHbI noprpeTbI JIereHlJ8pHbIX repoeB
60es 3a CeBepHbrH WKaJ HeMHoro BpeMeHH npoIIIJIo co
JHI[ ny6nHKauHH KHHrO HO BOCnOMHHaHHH BbI3BanH
BceofiII(Hii nOJJIHHHO BceHapoJHbrH HHTepec qTofibI YJOBshy
JIeTBopHTb 6ecqCJIeHHbIe 3anpocbI TpKeHHKoB CTaBposhy
nOJIbIUHHbI B lgteBpane 3TH BOCnOMHHaHHH fiyJJYT nepeneshy
lJaTaHbI H3 YpHana HOBbrH MHP B HallIHX KpaeBblX
raJeTax CTaBponOJIbCKas npaBJa H KaBKa3CKas 3JpaBshy
HHua
B KHHre bullManas 3eMJIS He TaK MHoro crpaHHJ HO no
rnyfiHHe HJeOJIOrHlJeCKOrO coJep)(aHHH no IillIpoTe 0606shy
II(eHHH 0 MbICJIeH aBTOpa OHa CTana 60JIbIilllM COfibITHeM
OfiII(eCTBeHHOH )(H3HH OHa BbI3Bana rop~ OTKJIHK B
eepJJax COBeTCKDX mOJeH 0 BOCX8II(eHHble OT3b1BbI COJIshy
IJ8T-IgtPOHTOBHKOB Ha qTaTeJIbCKDX KOHlgtepeHUHSX H B nelJaTH
KOMMYHHCTbI H Bce TpKeHHKH CTaBpOnOJIbIUHHbI 6ecshy
KOHelJHO 6narOJapHbI JIeoHHJy HnbHlfY Bpe)(HeBY 3a ero
nOJJIHHHO BJOXHOBJIeHHYIO napTHeH JIHTeparyPHYlO pa60TY
B KOTOPOH HCTOlfHHKH BeJIHKOro nOJBHra HallIeH repoHlJecshy
KOH CTpaHbI ee JJYXOBHOH H HpaBCTBeHHOH CHJIbI ee CIOHshy
KOCTH H MKeCTBa BCKPblTbI C IgtHJIOCOIgtCKOH rnyfiHHoH
(OfipaTHbrH nepeBOJ C aHrn - PeJ) 10
~ras 3TO HeYMepeHHoe BOCXBaneHHe nOBepXHOCTHoro H noeshy
peJCTBeHHoro COlJHHeHHH Bpe)lQeBa HeJIb3S He nOqyBCTBOBaTb qro
ero oJeOJIOrHqeCKOe B03JeHCTBHe SBJISeTCS ofipaTHblM KpoMe Bceshy
ro npoqero H3JIO)(eHHe Bpe)(HeBa HCKa)(aeT HCTOpHIO H CaM fibIJI
B 1943 r COJIJaTOM TaMaHcKoro IgtpoHTa H Manas 3eMJIS fibIJIa
Beero JImllb ero He60JIbIilllM 6eperoBblM aBaHnOCTOM B03HHKIillIM
BO BpeMH HaYlJ8lJHOro HacTyIlJIeHHH Ha HOBOPOCCHHCK B anpeJIe
H 3aTeM B Mae 1943 r IIoKa Bpe)(HeB 30 JIer CnyCTS He H30fipaJHJI
cofiblTHS TaM KaK OCHOBHYIO fiHTBY OHH fibIJIH He3HalJHTeJIbHbIM
BoeHHbIM 3JIH30JOM Bpe)(HeB fibIJI TorJa nOJIHTKOMHccaPOM
H TOJIbKO OJH~I noJIYqJIJI nOBb1lIIeHHe B lJHHe B 1941 r OH fibIJI
nOJIKOBHHKOM a K 1945 r CTan reHepan-MaH0poM Ho B 1978 r
olgtHUHanbHas npecca CTMa nucaTb 0 HeM TaK KaK fiYJTO OH fibIJI
60JIee BblJalOII(HMCS BoeHHbIM repoeM qeM MapUIan )KYKOB
MHorHe napTHHHbIe lJHHbI nOBa)(Hee ropfiaqeBa B 1978 r
paCTOlJanO HeofibIlJaHHbIe nOXBanbI fipe)(HeBCKOMY JIHTeparypHOMY
onycy 3TO CBHJeTeJIbCTByeT 0 nyCToTe JerpaJaUHH 0 pa3JIO)(eHHH
oJeOJIOrHH JIerKo nOHHTb KynbT BO BpeMeHa CranHHa KorJa
JOJI)(HOCTHble JI8Ja onacanHCb 3a CBOO )(H3HH Ho B 1978 r OHH
pHcKoBanH TOJIbKO 3aJep)(KOH B npoJBH)(eHHH no JOJI)(HOCTH
IDIO YTpaTOH KaKOH-TO npHBIDIerHH
TaKOM OfiPaJOM B 1985 r KorJa ropfiaqeB cran reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKperapeM HeofixoJHMOCTb HOBbIX HJeH 0 HHHUHarHB B 06shy
JIaCTH HJeOJIOrHH CTana BeCbMa HaCrOSTeJIbHoH BbIJIO OqeBOJHO
qyO ropfiaqeB He cofiHpancs caM yJOBJIerBopHTb 3ry HeofixoJHshy
MOCTb pa3Be TOJIbKO B pOJIO PYKOBOJHreJIS HJeOJIorulJeCKOrO
fiaHKa HJeH HalJHHaBUIerO B03HHKan OrJeJIbHbrH fiaHK HJeH
CTan lgtopMHpoBarbCS BOKpyr JIuraqeBa 3ro C03JaBanO B03MO)(shy
HOCTb fiyJJYIUHX npOTHBopelfHil Me)(Jy rreBblM H IIpaBbIM Hanshy
paBJIeHHIMH HO HeJIb3S fibIJIO Cpa3Y onpeJeJIHTb HX reHJeHIQiH
211210
HoeaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii
nporpaMMlgtI no)]roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII CDe3)Jy napTHH 3a)Jashy
lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX BnyTpeHHHX
H Me)l()JyHapolJHblX npo6rreM H Bbl)JBIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX
pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTHshy
IIeCKHH MaHHltpeCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xoIWMa
TaK KaK npeJKlU[a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1961 r Ha 6rrH)l(aiiume 20 JIeT
Dna HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe)]eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor)]a He 6blshy
JIH )]OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03)J3BaTIgt Tpy)]shy
HOCTH H CHH)fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HYKlfll H )IJla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii (TaK KaK
CYlUecmyeT npoue)Jypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIOshy
IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii) H )IJla ny)l()J Me)I()JyHashy
PO)JHoii nOJIHTHKH - nporpaMMa KIICC CIIYflliT Mo)]eJIbIO nporshy
paMM )]PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii
HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii napshy
THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa ltPOPMaJlbHas
nporpaMMa Beer)Ja 6blJIa H3H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me)I()JyHapo)]shy
Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO )JBH)KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrapeshy
BaJla B TelIeHHe )JByx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTyshy
nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre)JHHe napshy
THiiHble )]OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas oltPHUHaJlhHas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II Cbe3)]e napTHH B BplOcceshy
JIe H 3aTeM B llOH)JOHe r)]e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me)K)Jy 6oJIbllleBHshy
KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii
CB060)Jb1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npoltpshy
C01030B11 CJIe)Jyronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM
H TpoIUltHM H 0)]06peua VIII napTCbe3)]oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa)KaJla
yCJIOBHH rpa)l()JaHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3shy
Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa)JHKaJlbHOii oua oTpa)KaJla Ha)Je)K)Jy
na HeH3OO)KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras
oTMeny )]eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH)JOK
XOT9 noerre BBe)]eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII
HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO )]0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH
npaBHlI KaK )JHKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTemHO YMeHblllHlIaCh
oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM
TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO)JfOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C 1954 r no 1961 r
H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua XXII Cbe3)Je KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo-
BaJla 003 ltpOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMlgtI MHorne rO)JbI B npaBJIeHHe CTashy
JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY)KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa OleHb ny)KHa Ero KpHTHshy
KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H )]pyrHe PYKOBOIWTeJIH KaK peshy
BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny)l()JaJlca B )]OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl
ero H)JeH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMHshy
IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c)]eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo)]eJIhlO AllII )]pyrHX CTpaH C
KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha)JemlC9 TaKHM nyreM
npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me)l()JyHapo)JHOM KOMMyshy
HHCTHIeCKOM )JBIDKeHHH (H KHraii H IOroerraBHH npe)JlIO)KHJIH
aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO)JeJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe
KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe
ltpPaKUHH) TaKHM 06pa30M na Me)l()JyHapo)JHoii apeHe TpeTha napshy
THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa )Ja)Ke B)KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii B HTOshy
re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH
H npHTa3aHHs B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko)]eKc
33HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH (HfHopHpyeMbIH cashy
MHMH PyKOBOIWTeJI9MH) onpe)]eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCTshy
BeHHble ueJIH ua 70-e H 8O-e rO)JbI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepeashy
JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK)Ke HeHa)Je)KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl
nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a)JMHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla
1JT0 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo)]CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9IOTC9
C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 1970 r H npeB30ii)JyT HX K
1980 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y)]eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIOIW
6y)JyT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo)JHMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9M COBeTcshy
KHii COlO3 )]OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3BoIWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy)Ja B MHshy
pe Ka)K)Ja9 eeMb9 6y)]eT HMeTh oT)]eJIbHblii )]OM HlIH KBapTHpy
KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoDBeralOIUHMH H )]OXO)JHbIMH a UHTashy
HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y)]eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax
HHIero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO )]OCTHfHyrO B nporpaMMe YKa3blBashy
JIOCh1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm )]OXO)] B 1980 r 6y)]eT B 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM
B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y)]eT npoH3BOIWTh 2700 MJIP)]
KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro)] (Ha )]eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT noshy
KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP)]) 700 MJIH T Heltpm (B 1980 r 6bIJIO)]0shy
6bITO 603 MJIH T) 300 MJIH T lepHa (ypo)fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T) H 30 MJIH T Maca (npOH3Bo)]CTBO M9ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO
15 MJIH T) 12 He 6bIJIa )]oCTHrnyra HH 0)JHa H3 HaMeleHHblX UHltPP
(JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B
1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T)
213 212
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
HoeaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii
nporpaMMlgtI no)]roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII CDe3)Jy napTHH 3a)Jashy
lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX BnyTpeHHHX
H Me)l()JyHapolJHblX npo6rreM H Bbl)JBIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX
pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTHshy
IIeCKHH MaHHltpeCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xoIWMa
TaK KaK npeJKlU[a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1961 r Ha 6rrH)l(aiiume 20 JIeT
Dna HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe)]eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor)]a He 6blshy
JIH )]OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03)J3BaTIgt Tpy)]shy
HOCTH H CHH)fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HYKlfll H )IJla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii (TaK KaK
CYlUecmyeT npoue)Jypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIOshy
IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii) H )IJla ny)l()J Me)I()JyHashy
PO)JHoii nOJIHTHKH - nporpaMMa KIICC CIIYflliT Mo)]eJIbIO nporshy
paMM )]PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii
HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii napshy
THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa ltPOPMaJlbHas
nporpaMMa Beer)Ja 6blJIa H3H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me)I()JyHapo)]shy
Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO )JBH)KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrapeshy
BaJla B TelIeHHe )JByx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTyshy
nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre)JHHe napshy
THiiHble )]OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas oltPHUHaJlhHas
nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II Cbe3)]e napTHH B BplOcceshy
JIe H 3aTeM B llOH)JOHe r)]e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me)K)Jy 6oJIbllleBHshy
KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii
CB060)Jb1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npoltpshy
C01030B11 CJIe)Jyronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM
H TpoIUltHM H 0)]06peua VIII napTCbe3)]oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa)KaJla
yCJIOBHH rpa)l()JaHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3shy
Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa)JHKaJlbHOii oua oTpa)KaJla Ha)Je)K)Jy
na HeH3OO)KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras
oTMeny )]eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH)JOK
XOT9 noerre BBe)]eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII
HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO )]0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH
npaBHlI KaK )JHKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTemHO YMeHblllHlIaCh
oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM
TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO)JfOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C 1954 r no 1961 r
H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua XXII Cbe3)Je KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo-
BaJla 003 ltpOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMlgtI MHorne rO)JbI B npaBJIeHHe CTashy
JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY)KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa OleHb ny)KHa Ero KpHTHshy
KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H )]pyrHe PYKOBOIWTeJIH KaK peshy
BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny)l()JaJlca B )]OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl
ero H)JeH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMHshy
IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c)]eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo)]eJIhlO AllII )]pyrHX CTpaH C
KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha)JemlC9 TaKHM nyreM
npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me)l()JyHapo)JHOM KOMMyshy
HHCTHIeCKOM )JBIDKeHHH (H KHraii H IOroerraBHH npe)JlIO)KHJIH
aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO)JeJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe
KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe
ltpPaKUHH) TaKHM 06pa30M na Me)l()JyHapo)JHoii apeHe TpeTha napshy
THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa )Ja)Ke B)KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii B HTOshy
re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH
H npHTa3aHHs B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko)]eKc
33HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH (HfHopHpyeMbIH cashy
MHMH PyKOBOIWTeJI9MH) onpe)]eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCTshy
BeHHble ueJIH ua 70-e H 8O-e rO)JbI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepeashy
JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK)Ke HeHa)Je)KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl
nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a)JMHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla
1JT0 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo)]CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9IOTC9
C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 1970 r H npeB30ii)JyT HX K
1980 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y)]eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIOIW
6y)JyT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo)JHMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9M COBeTcshy
KHii COlO3 )]OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3BoIWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy)Ja B MHshy
pe Ka)K)Ja9 eeMb9 6y)]eT HMeTh oT)]eJIbHblii )]OM HlIH KBapTHpy
KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoDBeralOIUHMH H )]OXO)JHbIMH a UHTashy
HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y)]eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax
HHIero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO )]OCTHfHyrO B nporpaMMe YKa3blBashy
JIOCh1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm )]OXO)] B 1980 r 6y)]eT B 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM
B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y)]eT npoH3BOIWTh 2700 MJIP)]
KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro)] (Ha )]eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT noshy
KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP)]) 700 MJIH T Heltpm (B 1980 r 6bIJIO)]0shy
6bITO 603 MJIH T) 300 MJIH T lepHa (ypo)fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T) H 30 MJIH T Maca (npOH3Bo)]CTBO M9ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO
15 MJIH T) 12 He 6bIJIa )]oCTHrnyra HH 0)JHa H3 HaMeleHHblX UHltPP
(JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B
1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T)
213 212
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npegtKHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06bHCshy
HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT
nporpaMMhI nOJIOTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3~ COCTOBshy
IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe)(lleHa KOMHCCHH no noprOTOBKe
npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npepeeASTeJIbCTBOM Bpe)f(HeBa 3TY
pOJI)f(HOCTb YHaCJIepOBan AHDponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT
nOCJIepOBaTeJIbHO OTpa)KllJI MHeHHH olepe)JHoro reHepanbHoro eeKshy
peTapH Ho He TaK Ba)f(HO ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOHlaTeJIbshy
H)IO peASKUHIO pOKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY)(lleHHH
B OKTH6pe 1985 r13 Op06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6aleB
H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa
XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpaxlteHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK
H HMelOTCH pa3JIHlHH B pa3peJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTpeshy
JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIHlHOCTb fopGaleBa OKOHllashy
TeJIbHOe 0p06peHHe Ka)(llOrO pa3peJIa npHHa)JJIe)KllJIO eMY H n03TOshy
MY OKOHlaTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B neJIOM JIe)fQfI
Ha HeM
IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTHshy
lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Meshy
TOADI H B03MO)f(HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya nporshy
paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyweBcKoi H Kypa MeHee DBeTHCTa OHa
HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6yshy
pymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM)HH3M a
TOJIbKO 3peJIhIii CODHanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM
6yuymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma KanHTanH3M BbJ)KllBeT YaK KaK
BblH))(lleH COUHaJIH3MOM HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOpy MHorHe HCTOshy
pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKUlteHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCTshy
ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTOshy
pbIe HepOCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei (KYJIbT JIHlHOCTH CTaJIHHa
BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO XpyweBa Refgtshy
JIarOnpOHTHble TeH)JeHQHH H TpYAHOcrn C03paHHbIe Bpe)l(leBbIM)
HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO
npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTOIHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHeshy
HHeM 3TOX nOCJIepCTBoi14
MelK)JyHapOAHbIH OTpeJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble
MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accODHHshy
pyeT C COQHaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me)KAYHapo)JHoe nOJIO)Keshy
HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y HepOCTaeT 06beKTHB-
HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 opeT BO rnamiddot
Be MHpoBoro H TeXHHleCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBashy
JIeHTHO YaK lT06bl CpeJIaTb B03MO)f(HbIMH pa3DHlHble TOJIKOBaHHH
IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyweCTBYlOmaH peMOKpashy
THH CBoGopa HHIPOpMaUHO KaK Pocryn KO BceM HCTOlHHKaM
3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaDHH K KOTOphIM
Y COBeTCKOX rpa~ HeT pocryna onpepeJIHIOTCH KaK ReH))l(loe
3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H))(Il a 0 npaBax IeJIOBeKa CKashy
3aH0 ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO peiCTBHTeJIbHO )1(13HeHHO BIDKshy
HbIM copep)KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S3aHHOCTHMH
B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTpeJIa nOCB8IDeHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03sHCTshy
BY (B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOlsHCTBa paccMaTshy
pHBanocb) 0 He 06CjiK)JaIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI peMOrpalPHH
H OKp)KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH)BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B palshy
BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C ppyroi CTOPOHbI
MeHee BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe
06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX
06CY)(llalOTCH peTanbHO 06mee BnelaTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi
nporpaMMbI TaKOBO ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOmleCKOe KpbIDO
npopOJI)KaeT POMHHHPOBaTb B UK BOT O)JHO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH
ITO neHbl POJI)I(IbI OTpa)KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOPCTBO npopyKTa
CJIepyeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb neHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl neshy
Hbl TOIHee OTp8)KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aTshy
paT a TaK)Ke KaleCTBO npopyKDHH 0 YCJIyrlS Ho nporpaMMa
TaK)Ke CYJIHT yseJIHlHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH ITO
03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ECJIH neHbI OTshy
pa)KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOPCTBO neHbI Ha npopyKThI DHTaHHs
pOJI)f(Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBSshy
3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM)HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH
COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano ITO npoH3BOpCTBO nposhy
pyKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6ypeT yseJIHshy
lIHBaTbCH 0 ITO ypoBeHb )KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTHleCKOi
TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleCshy
KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOpyKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOpshy
CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH)KaH npoHlshy
BopCTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH)KeHOe neH HAes npOCTa
HO Ha peJIe npopyKTHBHOCTb npoH3BopCTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTeneshy
214 215
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
HH MellleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO
B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlHshy
HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO noshy
AOpBaHa
COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAHshy
pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym (xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy
OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06weCTBeHHbIii TpaHCshy
nopT neHCHH COIJHaJIbHble 6JIara H T A) 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX
CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb
OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHomeshy
HHe Me~ npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAHshy
PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH (OT Keshy
POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX
npoAYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno) HO
H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJy BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH
KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTHIeCKHe H XYAO)l(eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy
H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror
H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI
He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO
B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30shy
40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH ycshy
nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180middot190 MJIH
qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM
ny-reM npoAOJI)I(8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXoshy
AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopIIHH Ha neHbl
pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH)I(eHbI HeKOshy
Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH (oAe)l(shy
AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl
KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne) B
pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa
HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB lllJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He
nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJHH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK
npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOTshy
pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa ~e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI
nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy
XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAHshy
pyeMoro ceKTopa (HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY
nJlTOpbI) H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOHshy
IJbI C KOHUaMH (HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI
BOHRbl H BAOBbI) Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3middot
OO)I(HO
npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r16 OCHOBshy
Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeHshy
TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJHe BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe)I(HHe napshy
THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI)l(eH H36HpaTbCJI
reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opramiddot
HH38IJHOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH
napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii
H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT
noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro
ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe)I(HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Meshy
Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30shy
BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJHaJIbHOrO JIHAepa
napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyweCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJIshy
napaTa npeAhJAYIIIHe yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemoshy
H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJHcpHIJHpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHKshy
IJHH annapaTa o6CJI~alOwero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M
MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO
cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop
He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO
HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB
napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba)I(Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH
npeAhIAywHX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO)I(H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH
B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm
3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJHeii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm
tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqHshy
nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJHH HJIH
HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO)l(aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK
MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM
yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO)l(eHa PemeHHe
napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii oprashy
HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS (qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He
HCKJIlOtfaJICJI) Ho 3TO nOJIO)l(eHHe B TO )I(e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb
KrB H MB)J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH
3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY
B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIbshy
216
217
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
HhIii eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ewe 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb
AHmKOpp~OHHaJl KaMIIaHWI npolr~OJ[)KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa
MecTHhlX napnmHbIX llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX tJlleHOB UK HaIIpHshy
Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06shy
BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyweHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO
AJIJI coopY)lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHHIbHX yroAHH H T A17 Ha AeJIe
npHBHJIernH tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb
OXOTHHttbH yrOiJbJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe)ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa
AOJI)lCHO 6bIJIO noen~b npeIJYRpe)KlJeHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpetashy
pHM 06KOMOB
B 06weM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06wecmeHHo H nOJIHshy
TH1IeCKH 3HaIHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJa
npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4gtecshy
CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOwero litO JIH6epashy
JIH3aIIIDl H AeMOKpaTH3aIIIDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI
a mK~ HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJbI rAe HH llHraqeB
HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI)lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero )lCenaHHJI CAeshy
JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb
CBo60iJbI ilJlJI HecornaCHblX He06xo)1HMa B HiJeOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIacshy
TH litO TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4gtOPMOH Onn03HIJHH
npasmnaH napmJl MO)ICeT H36e~Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJeOJIornqeCKOrO
3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJHOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHHshy
UHIlOB OTKJIaiJbmaHHe ocyweCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX uaIIHHaHHH
B 06wecmeHHoH H nOJIHTHIeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI
rOp6aqeBa B AOJI)lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM meshy
MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cywecmyeT npoTHBopeIHe
Me)lCily nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH ueJIJlMH
H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH)lCeHWI MOAepHH3auHeH Hero nORbITKOH
AOCTHttb 3THX ueJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee ry )l(e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO
H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO)I(H0 rOp6atteB ewe He
OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xoJHMOCTb nOMep)ICKH 60JIee nporshy
peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJlshy
HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb
BCTb iJBe B03MO)I(HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX
3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xoJHMO ocyweCTBHTb IIepshy
BaH - 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aUHJI H nORbITKa nOJIyIHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO
BceuapoiJHyIO nOMep)ICKY BropaH - 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBashy
THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIHIHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe-
HHH IC CO)ICaJIeHHIO nOXO)ICe litO eeiittac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho
BeB03MO)I(HOCTb 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro
nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO)ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Koshy
tOpbIH nOKa ewe Ka)lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI
06rIaiJaHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uattashy
JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO
HJIH XYAmyIO - nOKa)lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH
y COBeTCKoro 06wecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o)JHa B03MO)ICHOCTb - Hamiddot
AeJITbCJI
HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR )ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE
HeKOTopble 3aIIa)JHble iJHllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJaIOT litO ueJIH coshy
BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPOshy
BOH BOHHbI HJIH ~ co BpeMeH peBOJIIOIJHH litO 3T0 BeeriJa 0iJHa
ueJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O)JHH y6e)KlJeHbI liTO
3KCRaHCHH npHcywa HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJeOJIOfHH H HiJee
MHpoBOH peBOJIIOIJHH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e)1HTeJIbo
HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeilIIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe)ICHMy
ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH HaIIHHaH
C XV B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIHIHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X
npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJeOJIOfHH 18 HeYilHBHTeJIbHO lfrO
000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHIJaIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPHshy
KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOIJHOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK
06lgteiJHHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOIJHOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK
He06xoiJHMOCTb 3alIJHTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJa npe)KlJe Beero
OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp)ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH
3a HHM BoiiHe (1941-1945 rr) AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO
OOJIHTHIecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb
Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcywa MHOrHM Hashy
IJHJIM ua npoTJI)lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO HauHH 3aMeshy
HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4gtoPMaMH - 3KOHOshy
MH1IeCKOH H HlJeOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aashy
HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcrshy
BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHilyCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTHIeCshy
KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHHlecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKyshy
peHIJHH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOwHble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI
(HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH) CTaJIH JIHiJHpyIOlIJHMH
218 219
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H)JeOJIOr8trecKOH (rum nOJIHTHleCKOH)
3KCIIaHCHR 06bIIH0 nO)JBepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe)f(HBlIIHe BuyrpeHshy
HHH nOJlHTHleCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo)JaJl(HOH He3qqeKTHBHOH
aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMlgtl Pa3BarI rum peBOmOshy
IJlUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT )JBIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHCIH1IeCK8e
H)JeH CTarIH npHBneKaTenIgtHbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO pJIJI CTpaH
1I06e)JHee )JllII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa)JHaJI H)JeJl CB060)JHoro MHpa elI(e
60nee yTOJIHIIHB leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H)JeJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo
HOMHKR 8 crrpaBepJIHBOrO pacnpe)JeneHBJI6nar
EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO nonHTHKY no
3THM ynpolI(eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe)JCTaBnJleTCJI IaCTHlHO cne)Jshy
CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO)JJllI(ero B MHpe a laCTHlHO HTorOM BHYTpeHshy
HHX HYK)l 8 Tpa1HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX ropshy
6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa)l(eHHeM
B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H)JeonornleCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP
B 6YI1JUeM )Jonxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM ITO 06elI(arI8
IIpe)JbI)JyIUHe lIporpaMMbI O)JHH 83 pa3)JenOB HOBOH nporpaMM1gtI
1I0CBJlllJeH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me)fC)JY CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml
B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTCshy
KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH
MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTOlHHKOM Booro peaKUHOHshy
HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co)JepllOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl
C peaKUHOHHlgtIMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E)J1IHCTBeHHoe
SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY)JHHleCTBe
C COUHaJtHCTHleCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1gtIrO)JH0ii OCHOBe pashy
)J1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH
R o6be)JHHeHBJI YcnnHH )J1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a)Jal HCTOPHshy
leCKoii 3HalHMOCTH - B1gtIXO)Jy Ha nepe)JOB1gtIe py6e)I(H HaYK8 8 Texshy
HHKH19 Cy)JH no nporpaMMe XO)J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma
C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H)Jashy
renbHOH )JeJITenbHOCTH KaJI()JOH CTpaHbl20 IIporpaMMa TaK)lCe 06eshy
lI(aeT C01lH)lllpHOCTh C He)JaBHO OCBo60l1HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COTshy21
pY)JHHleCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI(b
K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO)JCTBO OC03HaJIO ITO oc060e
nonO)ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX)Jep)l(aBhI 8 ~e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI
H)JeonorHleCKaJI H 1I0nuTHleCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT OleHb BhICOshy
KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO)JbI Bpe)I(HeBCshy
Koe PYKOBO)JCTBO rop)JHnOCb CB08MH Me)IC)JyHapOl1HlgtlMH ycnexaMB
TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa)l(eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTHshy
leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3qHOlIHH 8 HHshy
TeHcuqHKa1HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX )JB8)1(eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe
Ho nocne KaJI()JOii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTHleCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh
B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMHleCKoii nOMOllUl
8 He Morna HHlerO npepJIO)ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP
OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI(h ronO)JalOlI(eii 3qHOlIH8 (COBeTCKaJI
nelaTb He co061I(aJIa 0 rono)Je 60nee ro)Ja a Kor)Ja coo61I(eHHJI
06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8)I(eHHbIMH) HaRTH nonHTHtreCshy
Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aqraHCKOrO KOHqnHKTa CBH)JeTenhCTshy
ByeT 06 orpaHHleHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMHleCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro
MOfYIIIeCTBa 3HepreTHleCKuH Kp838C B BoCTOlHOii EBpone B
1984-1985 rr 6bIn cne)JylOllUIM TpeBO)lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CUshy
MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTHleCKHX CTpaH 3ana)Ja B 06naCT8 pa3B8shy
THJl nepe)JoBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO
MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO)l(e ChIrparIa
pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe
B03paCTalOII(aJI cnO)I(HOCTb BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro
C0103a ynpaBneHHe BHelllHeii nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX
()JHIInOMaTHleCKOM 3KOHOMHleCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be)JbIBaTenbshy
HOM nonuTHleCKOM) OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe)JCTBeHHO rum
lepe3 nocpe)JHHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP)JHHauHH Me)fC)JY 3THMH ypOBBJIshy
MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT)JenOB ceKpeTHOCshy
TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03)JaJI8 K KOnuy 6pe)I(HeBcKoii 3pbI cnryashy
UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e
IInaTHTb npe)lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY)JapCTB-KnueHTOB
OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro)JbI - cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI
pa3pJI)JKH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop~eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM
nocne)JCTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8uaeT ITO 8HTepshy
BeHUIDl B AqraHHCTaH B 1979 r 8 nonuTHleCKHH KpH38C B IIonIgtme
B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 61gt1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXYl1illeshy
HHlO nono)l(eHHJI
rop6aleB nyqme npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmHleCKOH
)JeJITenbHOCTH leM ero npel1illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpeshy
Mft ero nOcelI(eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor)Ja OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM
3aIIa)JHOH npeccbI KaK nOn8THleCKHH )JeJlTenb OH npo83Ben BnelaTshy
neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIleH HMeBIIIHX B03MO)ICHOCTb
6ece)JoBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1gtICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHqepeHUIDlx
221 220
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
~BaJI nOrlAHbIe (XOTH He Bcer~ TOllHble) OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT
OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor~ cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy)l(ll3Tb WHpOshy
KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl0 ]]0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH
BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn ]]OBonbHO orpaHHleHHbIM Ho HHor~ OH
fibmaeT lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTCl peWHTb npofineMbl KOshy
TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHUY3CKHMH KoppecnOH]JeHTaMH
Henocpe]]CTBeHHO nepe]] CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tlgtPaH~lO OH C]Jenan
nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl0 COBeTCKHe ]]OCTIDKeHHl B ofinaCTH
npaB lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb oueHeHbI no lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX
cpe]JH ]]enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTCl
60nbwe npe]]CTaBHTeneH pa60lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeHshy
Tax pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTHleCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe B3HTblX2 2
Ha caMOM )l(e 11ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO]JBepraeTCH KpHTHKe
la npeo6JI~HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX
H rOCY]JapCTBeHHblX lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7 ]]enyTaToB
ObIJIH pa60lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO]]0 11 B 1962 r H ]JO 18
B 1974 r (coBMeCTHaJI ]]0JIl napTHHHblxHrocy]]apCTBeHHblXolOpoKshy
paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36)23 3TO nOKalanO lfl0
rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl0 Ha 3anaAe Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta
3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTCl
HHleM ]]pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmune JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH
K ]JHJIJIOMaTHH HHor]Ja npOlBJIlnHCb JIHWb BCJIe]]CTBHH cnaOOCTH
onnOHeHTOB rop6aleBa
PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqeshy
BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO)I(HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe
HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH]]eHHIO
COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH]JeJIH HHtJero nO]]OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpymiddot
weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec ]Ja)I(e OObllHO anOJIHTHlHOH COBeTCKOH
MOJIo]]e)I(H 06aHHne rop6aleBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa
OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e]JHTeJIbHbIe ]]OBO]JbI H He OqeHb tJaCToe
oopaweHHe K ]]eMarOrHH B]]pyr BBeJIH JIHlHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B nposhy
THBOCTOlHHe BOCTOKa H 3an~ 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano
YMeHbweHHIO HanpH)I(eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo]JHJI Ita qeJIOBemiddot
Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3anauHbIe
CTpaHbI H]JepHble 6oMObI
B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH
COlO3 H HMenH leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI OHHJI
CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA BpylHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H]JeHTa
PeHraHa C npe)JllO)l(eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe OHHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH
rop6aleBbIM H WHPOKO ~HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl0
rop6aleB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl(OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI]JlllOWHMCH a]JBOshy
KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCshy
Koro HCKYCCTBa24 AMepHKaHCKHe ~HaJIHCTbl TO)l(e JIHcaJIH
o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH]Jepe C npeKpaCHbIMH
MaHepaMH 3HeprHlHOM TBep]]OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero
npolero o6JI~lOweM ]JHC~HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM25 Ho OHH He
laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTHleCKOH nHHHH
3aJIBneHHl rop6aleBa co]]ep~H ure )l(e 3JIeMeHThI )l(eCTKOH
COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO]JHOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObllHOM ne]JaHTHlshy
HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl0 rop6aleB B03HeCCH
Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro~pH COleTaHHlO H]JeoJIOrHleCKOrO ]]OrMashy
TH3Ma y6e)l(]JeHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTHleCKHM
MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nHlHOCTH
Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHHlX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana ]JHJIJIOMaTHshy
tJeCKOH CTonHueH MHpa IIonHTHlecKHe JIH]Jepbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb
B olepe]Jb Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl0 HeKoTopble ero
)l(eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI (oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIashy
HHl npoTHB nbHHCTBa) Bpl]J nH C03]Ja]JyT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb ITO
JIpo]]OJI)I(3lOWaJICH KaMJIaHHl npoTHB KOPpynuHH H CMeWeHHe
]]on)I(HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B ueHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax
MO)l(eT BbI3Ban HacTopo)l(eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO )l(e BpeMH
Me)l(]JYHapO]JHaJI apeHa ]JaBaJIa eMy H]JeaJIbHylO B03MO)I(HOCTh
npe]]CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI]JaIOWerOCH nH]Jepa MHoro c]]eJIaBwero
)JlIl CBoeH CTpaHbl H ]J1IH coxpaHeHHl MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanbshy
HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHUOM B IIOJIHT6IOPO
OH Bee ewe ~Cl B nOMep)I(Ke ero OCTanbHblX Il1eHOB Bee
Ba)l(Hble peweHHJl npe]]cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlIHH
UK H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono)l(eHHe B eenbCKOM X03lHCTBe
H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbCl MrHOBeHHO bull Drra 3Toro Hy)I(Hbl
6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe ITO
Booowe ITO-TO BblHneT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe ]JaHHble PYKOBO]JHTeJIl He
MornH o6ecnelHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO]]CTBa 3epHOBblX HO
CHJIbHble ClOPOHbI ero JIHlHOCTH H nOJIHTHleCIltoe MaCTepCTBO MornH
npHHeClH 60raTbIH ]JHJIJIOMaTHleCKHH ypo)l(aH OH ]]OJI)I(eH ObIn
lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03~Tb
ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIHlHOCTH K TOMY )l(e BO BHeWHeH
222 223
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO)JlJepIKKe BHyrPH
erpamI He TOJIbKO no H)JeOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHHshy
HOH JJHCnmmHHampI MHome COBeTCKHe rpa)l(llaHe HaOllIO~IOT 3a ero
BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me)J(lJyHllpopHOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor
POJIb HanHOHMbHaJI rop)]ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaKlKe TOT pe3KHH
Kompacr KOTOPhIH npoIBmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOaIeBa co
CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHOll3hIII1lgtIM BpelKHeBbIM
Bo BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoaIeBY HeoOXOJJHM OhIJI KOHKpeTshy
HhIH ycuex H 3HaIHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIlb TOJIbKO YJIyIWeHHe
OTHomem C 3anapHOH EBponOH H ITO eme BalKHee - C ChIAo
KJIIOIeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopYlKem XOTJI OHa H He Heshy
epmmaJIa CJIOlKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem MelK)ly BoCTOKOM
H 3anaoOM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa
HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa
3aTJIHyJIacamp (OHa YlKe IlIlHTCJI HaMHoro )]OJIhwe IeM BeJIHKaJI OTeshy
IecmeHHaJI BORHa) H KO~ He BH)JHO STO C03)]aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIeeshy
KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpypHeHHJI BbDlH H )]pyme npo6JIeMhI - KmaH
lfH)lwI IIaKHeraH BJIHlKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa
IOlKHaJI AqpHKa BberHaM H KaMnyIHJI BORHa B IIepcH)JcKoM 3ashy
JIHBe - HO HH O)lHa H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIOlKHOH ECJlH
rOpOOIeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMHIeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3ashy
uaIeH ero )lHIIJlOMaTHH )]OJIlKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar
Ha ~I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH ITO 03HaIaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpashy
~eHHe BoopYlKem
CTpaTerHIO ropoaIeBa OhIJIO HeTpypHO npe)]CK83aTb B HaIaJIe
anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H)JeHT ChIA PHtJap)] HHKCOH c)]eJIaJI TaKoe
npe)]CKa3aHHe
rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOaIeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa
B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana)] CHJIeH H OH HylKIlaeTCJI B HameH nOMomH
EMY HYlKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerOIHOH EBpone H )]pyrnx CIpaHax
BXO)lJIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO Jho6aJI IltOJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro
COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO)JlJepIKKH27
rOpOaIeB c)]eJIaJI nepBhtH XO)])laB TpaJJHDHOHHoe HHTepBhlO
HeHa3BaHHOMY pe~KTOpy bullrrpaB)lhI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO
8 anpeJIJl OH HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH)laPTHyIO q0PMYJIHPOBKY ITO
MelK)lyHapopHhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe)]eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM )lByx
pa3JIHIHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem
JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma
IIpo)]oJIlKeHHe npo3ByIaJI0 KaK TOplKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe
)]OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO)]CTBa
H C 3Toro )lHJI - xoqy nO)]IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3
BBO)lHT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpepHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe )]PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep2 8
0)lHaIlt0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM ITO COeJJHHeHHhle hImThI )]OJIlKHhI
CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe)lHeH )lIIJllgtshy
HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH )]OJIlKeH )lJlHrbCJI )]0 HOJIoshy
pJI (Ha CaMOM )]eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03pHee) PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO
KOHeIHO 60JIee nonynJIPHO B BOCTOIHOH EBpone (r)]e )]OJIlKHhI ObIshy
JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI) eM B ChIAo r)]e CIHTaJIH
ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha ylKe
HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MOlKHO ObIJIO
npe)lBH)JeTb ChIA omeprJIH npellllOlKeHHe 0 3aMOpalKHBaHHH Ha TOM
OCHOBaHHH ITO )TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H ITO npe)]shy
JIOlKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH MelK)ly ChIA H HX eBposhy
neHCKHMH COI03HHIltaMH B tmCTHOCTH CIHraJIOCh ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT
Ha peweHHe rOJIJIaH)lCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe
)]OJIlKHO ObIJIO O~Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe 48 KphIJIashy
TbIX paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH)]epJIaH)lOB (peweHHe npHHIIToe
n03lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Memeshy
HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI )]pymx BH)JOB
BOOpylKeHHJI) bull
BeceHHee )lHIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoaIeBa He OhIJlO
HeOlKH)JaHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO)lIIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0
npolllleHHH BapwascKoro )]OrOBOpa eme Ha 20 JIer H yqacmOBaJI
raM B HanpJIlKeHHOM oOcy)l(lleHHH npoIHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX
B OpraHH3anH1O BapWaBCKOrO )]OrOBOpa erpaHlImI MHorHX BOCTOqshy
HoeBponeHcKHx JIH)JepOB )TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MOlKHOCThlO YBH)]en
ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH)lHH
Pa)l)KHB raH)lH HaHeC oltPHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOashy
IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO)]hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpashy
HHueH HH)lHJI ObIJIa BalKHhIM )]pylKecmeHHhIM rocy~pcmoM B IOlKshy
HOH AlHH H COJIH)JHhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO
o60pY)]OBaHHJI H BOOpylKeHHH Ho HHJJHJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oashy
JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H HylK)laJIaCb B nepHO)lHshy
eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO)lIIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koroshy
phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca ODHaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe)]oeshy
224 225
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
TaBJIemm HHlJHH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB
(B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJtIHOrO - AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPHshy
HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTCJI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bepshy
XOBHoro COBeTa)
OCHOBHhle )JHnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITHJI ro)Ja HaMelaJIHCh Ha
oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO ltDpaHllHIO
B HalaJIe OKTJI6pJI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJe Toro xre MeCJIml AOJI)I(Ha
6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH ylaCTHHshy
KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HOJI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM
ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B )l(eHeBe BHHM3HHe Beero MHpa
6h1JIO cocpeAOTOleHO Ha nOCJle)JHeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB
AOJIlKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH)Jy no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHshy
Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO
nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT
MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap)JHa)l3e COBepIlleHshy
HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapAshy
Ha)J3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO)JHa eCJlH HaMelaJIHCh
H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHHJI Ha PYKoshy
BOAJInme AOJI)I(]OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIashy
TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH (33HHMaBIllHH 3TOT
noCT C 1958 r) 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM
COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHHshy
MaeTCJI npeH~eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH
CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI
OT03BaH B ~OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee)JaTeJIeM fOcY)JapCTBeHHoro
KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMHleCKHM CBJI3J1M KOTOPhIii 33HHshy
MaeTCJI TOprOBJIeH C COuHaJIHCTHleCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB
6bIJI BH)JHOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM UK B 1972-1977 rr
3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee)JaTeM COBeTa MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM
npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMHleCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero
CqHTaJIH B03MOlKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce)JaTeshy
M COBera ~HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDICJI nOCTa MelK)JyHapO)JHOH 3Hashy
lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r
IIpa3)JHOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIlUlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii
B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO)l(]OCTh CAeJIaTh
JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B HalaJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerauHii C06paJIHCb
B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJe Ha TpeX)JHeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJHH HeH36elKH0
AOJIlKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY)K)JaThcJI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa )l(eCT Peiishy
raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX CneuHaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBOshy
BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3HHJIX B HeBa)le fop6aleB OTBepr 3Ty
MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O)JHOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeCJIlHhIii MopaTopHii
Ha Bee JI)JepHhIe HcnhITaHHH HalHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy
pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO
xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-lIO
npennOlKHTh
XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe)JycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle
peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopMluHeH lIHlTo He npoTIIBoshy
pelHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJHJIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlleshy
HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJKOH BOJIHbI
H nOA06HhIX HM pa)JHOCTaHIJHH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX
JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO)JHMoe Hecshy
KOJIhKHMH ThICHlaMH cneuHaJIhHO nnJI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaTshy
lHKOB 06XO)JHTCJI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY
AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTCJI
nOCKOJIhKY IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe)JalH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJIshy
Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH (HanpHMep C 1954 r AO
BTOplKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B
1960 r H B nepHO)JbI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIpJI)KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rOrTPI)
OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJgtcpeKTIIBHhIM B 80ble roshy
rTPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJIJlJIa HAeaJIhshy
HYIO B03MO)l(]OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH
nopolKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6aleB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO)I(HOCIb
H HHKTO Hi 3ana)le He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT
AYX XeJIbCHHKH
BCTpelH fopGaqeBa C 3ana)JHhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIhshy
KHX MeCJIIJeB ero npe6hIB3HHJI B AOJIlKHOCTH He )JaJIH HH MaJIeHweshy
ro YKalaHHJI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH
CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npennOlKeHHH 0 pa30pYlKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK
TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3Ashy
HhIX BoiiH (IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeCshy
KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI) lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0
MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MOlKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH
)JHnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM coshy
BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH)Ja YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3shy
HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpHshy
CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH )JIIBH3HH (120 TbIC qeJIOshy
226 227
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
BeK) 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1HKe BOPbGa TaM
mrreHCHltpHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHHshy
IlKaTHBbI H npennO)KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJIshy
Jl(8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTashy
TOIIHOlllIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3ltPltpeKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH
6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH
CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAigtIX 60HUOB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta
BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH
6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb
elDe CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38KpbIshy
tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Haceshy
neHHoro AltpraHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH
COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH (no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM
BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r) He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHlgtIM
TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH
YJlCe eeiilac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM
ITO rOpGaleB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaBshy
WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTHIecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep
B 1978 r ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAHshy
TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH
H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHODeHHOCTH OHH
MOryr nOBepHTb B TO IeM XBacralOT (H) MOryr BCJIeACTBHe
3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee29
HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B~eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero
KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH
ero pea6HJlHTaDHH OJICHAaJIOCb ITO ero Ha3HalaT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlOshy
IDHM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO
ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGaleBa 06bIllHO reHepanbshy
HlgtIii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIHllHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa
He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHeshy
pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa
co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeHIeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIeshy
re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH
nOCJIe OKOHlaHHH BOHHbI CTaB HalaJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBCshy
Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana
OleBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH
Heo~O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOIDaAH Y BpeJICHeBa
6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero-
BOPbI no orpaHHleHHIO CTpaTefHleCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY
HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Monorwx BOeHHlgtlX COBeTHHlCOB lTOGbI
HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe
OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlDHHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMeshy
lDeHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHlgtIM KaHAHA3TOM IllIH ltp0PMHshy
poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI
B03MOJl(HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH
yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B AltpraHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH
uenblO BpeJICHeBa B AltpraHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne
KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaDHH B TeleHHe rom HJlH )lByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb OleHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH
B 1968 r Ho B AltpraHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHCshy
KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlDeHHe H MHJl1IHOHlgtI 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH
MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryIDeCTBeHHoro
oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - KXAIl altpraHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHocshy
TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3Dy KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamuIe
oT60pHble norpaHHlHbIe laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX
areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb
rpynRbI KXAIl A3JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI lT06bl
BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H noposhy
AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B uensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX
CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HHltpHJlbTpaDHH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3oshy
BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlDHX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A
B npouecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO
HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03shy
A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH altpraHCKOH apMHeH
TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX
apMHH HaAeH1IHCb ITO MHJIHUeHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM
cnocoGHbIM altpraHH3HpoBaTb KOHltpJIHKT
rOp6aleB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM
ltPpoHTax BHOBb C03A3HHOe B altpraHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTepshy
CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfleHHH KOHltpJIlnltta
MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl
CTapeiiUIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH
paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH
MHHHpoBaTb norpaHHllHble AoporH H 06b1IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAHshy
HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC
YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH
228 229
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
OP))KWI rpymJaM conponmneHHfJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOPshy
nHpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH
6omme DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMemashy
TenbCTBO (CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep)(lJaJIa trIO
TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06poshy
BonbueB nepeoAenlx aqraHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqaeshy
THe B 6oHx)31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy
Hcnonb3YH nOA1gteM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl
B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD)laTaX rOTOBbIX noxltepTshy
BOBaTb co60H 3a PO)lHy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH)leHHlO
HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeueIleHTshy
HbIM32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepXltAan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTHshy
qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxoxlte trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO
33KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBHshy
nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI
C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me~ CCCP H KHTaeM
HOH IfPaHOM If306paXlteHHe BOHHbI B AqraHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oeshy
BbIX nO)lBHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAlOTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCHshy
neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eXltOM B TeqeHHe
neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOXltHO 06)lyMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA
COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060)lHTb cpeACTBalJJIH BHyTpemmx
peqoPM33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI
Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJJIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a
nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHHfJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopashy
xlteHHe lJJIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJJIH AHAponOBa
H qepHeHKO E)lHHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJJIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTHshy
qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq
raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTeshy
KHX BOHCK B AqraHHCTaHe BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO)JHllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B
1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06yshy
IJeHHe 6oHuoB aqraHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opYshy
XltHeM34 qacTb BoopyXlteHHfJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO
DapTH3aH OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHHmiddot BpaXltAYIOIUHM
Me~ co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBuaM
HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKashy
MH ODHYMa H repoHHa (rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana)]) DIHPOKaH
norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeXltAY ITaKHCTaHOM H AqraHHCTaHOM CTana
nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro
naKHCTaHCKaH apMHH He MoxlteT 34gtqeKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb
H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HObshy
HOCTH B AqraHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblrshy
pan lJJIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B
AqraHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH oooeKnmshy
HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe
C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeXltAYHapoAHylO
nO)lAep)l(l(y (npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro) lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonbshy
30BanHCb ClJIA B 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B AqraHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH
COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO
BeCTH npoAOOXltHTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO C nOMOlUblO
HOB06pauueB B WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD)laTbI-Aonroshy
CPOllHHKH apMIDI nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT qPOHTOBOH ORbIT
H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oqHUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOHshy
qaHHf[ BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHHshy
HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO)lbl MoxlteT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpashy
HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIlpoB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroTshy
CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa ClIyXlt6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe
Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH)lUeB
If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe
PYKOBOACTBO OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoXltHoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll
B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoqeccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06yshy
qeHHblX lJJIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaXlteHHii He06xonHMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb
uenHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO)lXOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH)lOBashy
HHfJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHDeB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Aeshy
naeTCfI Bee 60nee npoqeCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb
HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAlOTOBneHbI K
TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT
Bce 60nee H 60nee enOXltHoe opYXltHe H orpaHHlJHBalOTCfI HanalleHHflshy
MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKoshy
MY BoeHHoMY KOMaH)lOBaHHIO CTaHOBHTCfI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO
napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH qYHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro
TpYAHee qeM OHH OXltHAanH
KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03)lan CDeDHanbHylO KOMHCCHIO
COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnXltHa AOKna)lbIBaTb
IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOXltH0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnHflHHe sa
231 230
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm AqraHHCTaHa Ho B03MO)fCH0 TaK)((e lITO reshy
HepanbI H OqHllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B AqraHHCTaHe 6YAYT
npo~HHyTbI B 1987 r Korna BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH
npHCTynHT K oMonO)l(eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaHllOBaHHJI
Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTOampl1H H3 oqHllepoB YllaCTshy
BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapHshy
IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Korna HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl AqraHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeHshy
Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxoo 6yoeT B03MO)((eH TOIIbKO nocshy
lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJHH 3TO He npe~emaeT HHlIero xopomero B coshy
BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33JIBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03shy
MO)fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQraHCKoii npo6JteMbI06MaHshy
lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c~Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no
TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COeeoHHMB HenaMCKHMB
CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e)fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBOo COBeTCKHX
BoiicK a aqraHH3aIJHH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex
TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJHH AqraHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBeshy
IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npeOCTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlTshy
HbIM pemeHHeM
He 6bmo HHlIero Heo~oro B 3anaouoii nonHTHKe fop6ashy
tJeBa OH HaoeMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep)I(KY 3anaouoii EBpoRbI B KaMshy
namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JIoepHOe paaopY)l(eHHe OH XOTen TaK)I(e
lff06bI CTpaHbI 3anaouoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii
H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii MooepHHshy
3llUHH H HaoeMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii
H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX goepHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK
eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epashy
IIH~ BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO coeIIan XpymeB 00 H noene
BTOp)l(elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe)fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pgoshy
KH 6bI1Ia npoOOII)I(eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO)l(e 6bI1Ia CBJl3ashy
Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJn1eii ooMa (npe)l(Je Beero C pa3shy
pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM He~ rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBrshy
pHpoBaTb) Ho B 1985 r Korna B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKOshy
RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Korna npoOOII)I(anaCb BOHRa B AqraHHCTaHe
3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33Mopo)l(eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH
C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQshy
melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3anaouoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Haoe)l(JbI Ha
ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha ~yx qaKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX
TpyoHOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THue B 3anaouOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJIshy
HHH HOBoro PYKoBOIJHTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe nonashy
Ban Hoew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpYoHHlIeCTBa qeM ero npeoshy
meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3anaouaJI EBpona OOCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl
MO)fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm
TIOe3oKa fop6aQeBa BO Cl)paHuHW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii
peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0)(HllaHHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex
fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpaxlteHHW
3anaoHblX CpeoCfB HHqOPM3IJHH He oana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMHshy
lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npooeMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTHshy
QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM qopMaM 06meCTshy
BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT
TPaoHDHOHHbIX COBeTCKHX ueneii OR HH B KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha
Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBeoeHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP
B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HDHJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee oeHCTBM
COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no
He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3anaouoii EBpone CTHIIb
XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMooshy
BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He oHII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH oeiiCTBHTenhHO Bell
HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTCshy
KHH COW3 He Beerna 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB Bo06aBOK
K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro
rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3opaxltancJI
rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBOoy 3MHrp3IJHH H HeBepshy
HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl)paHumf uaoeJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha
eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JIoepHbIX BoopY)l(eHHJlX
B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHHampl1 yqacme B ~YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH
BapIIlaBCKOrO oorOBOpa B COqHH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryWlHshy
KOBaHO oqHllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe roe nOBTopampl1HCb Bee Te )l(e
3ae3)1(eHHhle oeKIIapauHH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi
Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIeshy
HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBoomeIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl
06cy)I(JaIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO
He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBOIJHTeIIH He nonyqHshy
IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep)I(KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH
a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH ~epbMB TIollTH OlleBHoHO
lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY)I(JaIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH
232 233
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbCfI BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBercshyKOH Heltpm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36elKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH Heltpm BocroqshyHOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e~aTb H B HOfl6pe neHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe
BepHBWHCb H3 COltpHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbCfI K OCHOBshyHOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B )leHeBe COBerCKaH n03HDHfI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax YlKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B ColtHH OlKHAashynoCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK (Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH) - coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe IIpe)JycshyMarpHBano lITO Ka)K)J8fl eropoHa MOlKer HMerb no 6000 6oeronoshyBOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO )llIfI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITOlKeHHfI HO Ha 50 MeHbwe lIeM npe)JycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeHshyHbIe rnrarbI B npHHDHIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me)K)Jy cBepxnepshylKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCHfl no nOBOA pacnpeAeneHllJl npe)llIDshygtKeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpameshyHlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHHfI (rnaBHaH lJaCTb coshyBerCKoro MepHoro apceHana) Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaHshyBan Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIbshyHoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raKlKe Ha 06CylKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 (cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa)JHOH EBponbI) Ha orAerrbHOM COBe~ashyHHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX AeranfIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBDshyPHTbCfI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeMfl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHDHne coBercKoe npe)llIOlKeHHe 6bIJIO peashyJIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03)JaBanO nOllBY )llIfI 06cylKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CBfI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOHfITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb ~HT 3~IllawJItHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMOlKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llaxlte eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or HeogtKH)J8HshyHoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6arraHc JloroshyBOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO)JIIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman KalKAOH cBepxneplKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW
CRCTeMY )llIfI 3amHrbI HacerreHHbIX neHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeHshyraMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHHfI fIBJIflWrCfI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro)Japfl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06peshyrawr BeAYIllYw ponb
CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa (20-30 MnpAmiddot AorrrrapoB) HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa (xorfl )llIfI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHHfI) CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pagtKaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHDaeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03palKeHHfI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnonoshylKeHHH aMepHKaHneB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrCfl BnepeA B pa3pashy60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAercfI 3aMeHflTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pYgtKHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaroshyIllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKalKeTCfI COBepmeHHO HeHygtKHbIM H HalIHerCfI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeCshyKOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopYlKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03palKeshyHHfI 3anauaoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA COM CrnA npeAshynOgtKHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3HITH rorOBshyHoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHHfI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bIshyJIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHHfI H BenHK06pHraHHfl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbCfI K pa60raM COBercshyKOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO MelKAHapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe~~x HccneAOBaHHfI B nOH o6JIacm
COBeTcKHe YTBepgtKAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCTshypoHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBnflWTCfI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHHfI ECJIH IllHT MOlKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MOgtKHO 6YAeT Hcnonampshy30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux neneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBeshyPOflTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyrolKe CHereMY lJaCTHlHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH (aMepHKaHDbI npe)llIaraIQT nOAenHTbCfI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrCfI) CCCP AOnlKeH 3amHshymaTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH ~T He 3aIDHTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera )llIfI AOCrH)KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BCfIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonDshy)KHT KOHen fI)JepHbIM BoopYlKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTOfl~H 3TaII fOSKH BoopYlKeHHH
234 235
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B )KeHeBe cOCpeoOTOllllT BHHMaHHe
Ha oOBOoax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6yoeT npooOJIshy
lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l~HIUaTb ce6fI H nOB TOshy
pfITb 06emaHHfl nooeJIHTbCfI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O)i(HJ3JIOCb
BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY JHfl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI
npeJJBapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO)Kshy
HOCTb oOCTIDKeHHfl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHHfl
B Boopy)KeHHflx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxyoshy
lllHT OTHOWeHHfl MelKJy CBepxoeplKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocyoapcTB
6yoyT OpaTb opyr Ha opyra lla)l(e OnTHMHCTbI He O)i(HJ3JIH HHKaKHX
HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCTshy
Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He oYMaJIH lITO nOflBHTCfI
COBMecTHoe laflBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka)KJbIH H3 pyKOBOJHTeJIeH
BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt(KOH lpeHHfl opyroro B 6ecKOHet(HbIX
JJHCKYCCHflX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBHJJeHHIO
H paJJH0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXOJHJIHCb Ha TOM lITO
BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTCfI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB eneooBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX
COBeTHHKOB (HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnHflTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK
WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTenfI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX
oeJI) BCTpeqa oOJI)KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbCfI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH
4aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIHflTb Ha ee HCXOo TonbKO la CqeT JIHt(HbIX
KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO
ycnellIHoH XOTfI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cymecrneHHhlX pelyJIbshy
TaTOB
Ba)KHbIM 4aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha
KOTOpoii JIHt(Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH
JHfl YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem MelKoy maBaMH CBepxoepshy
lKaB laTpYJHHJIO BnoeneoCTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbInaJhl C 000HX CTOpoH
06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH (H BOlMO)KHO 06c~H no B
palrOBopax MelKoy C060H) t(T0 opyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTHshy
KH-fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka)KJOMY npeoCTOflJIO HMeTb oerro no
B03B~eHHH oOMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHHfl npeoCTaBHTb
BCTpeqy KaK ycnex
3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe COB MeCTHOe laflBJIeHHe HelHallHTeJIbHhle
COmameHHfI 0 KyJIbl)PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO noposhy
CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba)KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6shy
JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa)KJe6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHHfl HcnopTHTb
penyrauHIO opyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa)KeHHe Ho
lTO xpynKoe oOCTH)KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me)KJJyHapoJHbIH KPH3HC
Bceroa B03MO)KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4PO~ MO)l(eT palBfIJaTb
Bpa)KJe6uylO nponaraHoy IIOe3JJKa fop6aqeBa B CrnA B 1986 r H PeHraHa B CCCP B 1987 r eenH OHH COCTOflTCfI KaK 6bInO yenoBshy
JIeHO npooOJI)KaT npouecc yrryqweHHfl oTHowem MelKoy cBepxshy
oep)l(aBaMH
IIo B03BpameHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB coeJIaJI oeTaJIbHbIH
oOKJIaJJ 0 BCTpeQe B )KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP3S
OH 6bIJI coeplKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaueshy
KOii n03HuHH (HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKauueB arpeccopashy
MH XOTb H yrnep)KJaJI no-npe)KHeMY lITO OHH XOTflT o06HTbCJI
npeBocxoocrna) MelKoyHapoJHbIe OTHOWeHHfl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToHshy
lIHBbIMH HO BcenflJIH 60JIbwe HaJJe)KJ qeM B HemmHee BpeMJI
Me)KJy TeM cymecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Kyoa 60JIee npoCTbIe
qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npOflBHTb 3oPaBbIH
CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me)KJJyHapo)JHy1O cHTYauulO 4 HOfI6pfI Ha npeceshy
KOH4epeHuHH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH )lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrIDltaj
weM 6yoymeM OTKpbITb JJBepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJaTb B03shy
MO)KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIOJflM cBo60ouo npHe3DTb Ha 3anao a
nlOJJIM C 3anaoa npHe3lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI03136 fop6aqeB
He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpeoeJIeHHO He HaMepeH
OTKpbITb JJBepH COBeTCKHM rpa)KJaHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIOoeii Ha 3ashy
naoe OHH MorYT npHe3)1(aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t(T0 HX nOe3JJKH
He 6yoyr CBfIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHHfl B nOJIHTuqecshy
KHX npoBOKaUUOHHbIX ueJIfIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJIflTb aTMoc4epy
BMeWHBaTbCfI BO BuyrpeHHHe oerra37 lIruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI
o rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3JJKy no
Bonre OH nO-BHJJHMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe
rpa)KJaHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIleshy
CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH COUUashy
JIHCTHqeCKOH oeMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM oeJIa MHpa
fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO coenaTb
TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBHflTbCfI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbCfI C03oaTb
nporpaMMY 3Be3JHbIX BoHH 3TO oeweBJIe H npome CopeBHOBamiddot
HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJIflpHbIM B 000n
CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO)KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO)l(eshy
HHfl Koroa COBeTCKoe PYKOBOoCTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa)KJashy
HaM H npeoOCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO)KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa
236 237
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
H CBo60tngtI moIJH B npyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH
COBeTCKoro PYKOBOnCma
IIPHMEIAHHR
1 KOHCTHTyuwI COI03a COBeTCKHX CO~HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK
IIpaB~ 4 HIOIDI 1917 r
2 YKal IIpe3HllHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH BCBIl3H C
40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTeleCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTHll 28 anpeJIll1985 r
3 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4
4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 21985 p 4
5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 71985 p 4
6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman
1985 p 253
7 TaM lKe CTp 252
8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH
9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bIIeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHTIll5pll 1985 r
10 CraBpOnomcKaIl npaBAIl 6 MaIl 1978 r
11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union (2 edl lonshydon Allen amp Unwin 1970
12 IIpoIpaMMa KIICC 1961 r
13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTlll5pll 1985 r
14 TaM lKe
15 TaM lKe
16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB~a 2 HOllOpll 1985 r
17 IIpaBAIl 14 HIOlLIl 1985 r
18 Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79
19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaBIJa 26 OKTIlIlpll 1985 r
20 TaMlKe
21 TaM lKe
22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252
23 JF Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Cambshyridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364
24 Time April 22 1985 p 7
25 Time September 9 1985 p 4
26 TaM lKe CTp 5
238 239
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241
27 Time April 22 1985 p8
28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1
29 Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld amp Nicolshy
son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141
30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 P 16
31 B KPOTKOB llymMIHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 113BeCTHlI
6 Hog6pg 19851
32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International
Herald Tribune November 13 1985
33 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26
34 TimeDecember 9 1985 p 10
35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851
36 H3BeclllJl6 OKTg6pg 19851
37 TaM )ICe
240
HAIII APXHB
H3 DHCLMA B PEIlAKIUOO
BaUlUHZTOH 5 iJeKaDpR 19862
B 1952-1953 22 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJoftbUlOU cnpa80rmou DU(j
ftUOTeKOU nocOftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJTaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8
nOpROoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1M KHU2U 11 HaUlert 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJopshy
HUKa U30aHH020 8 1919 2 (JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MUshy
pa (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) 8 KOTOPOM 8 nemiddot
pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK DblrtU HanelaTaHbl OeKrtapaltWl He3a8UCUshy
MOCTU CTaTbU KOHrJeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJrashy
T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra (3TOT CfJoPHUK
11 nocblrtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU)
HeT COMHeHWl lTO lJe8partbCKaR pe8OrtlOltWl nocnvJICUl(l
UMnVftbCOM iJrtJI U30aHWl (JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl
PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM lTODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80ftlOltUoshy
Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJlMU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOHlaHWl nepe80iJa
U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa noftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK
OCH080nOrta2alOUUX iJoKVMeHT08 f1MepUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a noshy
nail ryiJa cnUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMarushy
leCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble
iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02ftU CTaTb 8KftaiJoM 8 iJe(faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU
H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a
PulapiJ T o38UC
IIocoll COellHHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr
241