. , . ,-,,- Nationalist ideology has often enabled ruling groups to mobilize the people for military adventures and wars from which they had nothing to gain. Irving Zeitlin 1. - genocide, caedere . , , 1920 , ,1, , , Ahmed Mithad Bay and others, Bahaeddin Sakir Bey and others -MehmedAliBayandothers2., , , 3. 1.Cassese,A.,InternationalCriminalLaw.2ndEdition.(Oxford:OxfordUniversity Press, 2008), 131. 2. . Case of Ahmed Mithad Bey and others, Trial of the Regional Party Secretaries, Ottoman Empire, Extraordinary Court Martial, 8 January 1920, 147-154, Case of MehmedAliBeyandothers,TrabzonDeportationsandMassacresTrial,OttomanEmpire, ExtraordinaryCourt Martial, 22 May1919, 177-184CaseofBahaeddinSakirBey andothers,HarputTrial,OttomanEmpire,ExtraordinaryCourtMartial,13January1920, 103, 188.3.Andreopoulos,G.,Genocide:ConceptualandHistoricalDimensions.(Philadelphia: UniversityofPennsylvaniaPress,1994),Sarkissian,R.,TheArmenianGenocide:ACon-textual View of the Crimeand Policies of Denial, in The Criminal Law of Genocide. Inter- 238 16 (2005-2014) RaphaelLem-kin, 1944 AxisRuleinOccupiedEurope:LawofOccupation.AnalysisofGover-nment.ProposalsforRedress4,, 5. ,..96/46, 6. .6(),- -,Goringandothers7, -8., 9 ,Hoess10 1947, -national,ComparativeandContextualAspects,edit.Henham,R.,Behrens,P.(Hampshire, Burlington: Ashgate, 2007), 3-16.4 .Lemkin,R.,AxisRuleinOccupiedEurope:LawofOccupation.Analysisof Government.ProposalsforRedress.(Washington:CarnegieEndowmentforWorldPeace, 1944), 79-90.5. . Shaw, M., What is Genocide? (Malden, MA: Polity Press, 2007).6.ConventiononthePreventionandPunishmentoftheCrimeofGenocide,G.A.Res. 260(III),9December1948..Simon,W.T.,DefiningGenocide,Wisconsin InternationalLawJournal15(1996):243,Schabas,W.A.,ProblemsConfrontingInternat-ionalLawandPolicyonWarCrimesandCrimesAgainstHumanity:WarCrimes,Crimes against Humanity and the Death Penalty, Albany Law Review 60 (1997): 741-742.7..Prosecutorv.Goringandothers,InternationalMilitaryTribunal, Judgment and Sentence, 01 October 1946, 247-255. 8. Prosecutor v. Martin Gottfried Weiss and 39 others, General Military Court of the US Zone, Germany, 15 November-13 December 1945, 16 UNWCC Law Reports 5, 12-13.9.Abrams,J.,UniversalJurisdiction:Myths,RealitiesandProspects:TheAtrocitiesin CambodiaandKosovo:ObservationsontheCodificationofGenocide,NewEnglandLaw Review35(2001):303-305,Schabas,W.A.,AnIntroductiontotheInternationalCriminal Court.(Cambridge,CambridgeUniversityPress,2001),30,Ludi,R.,ReparationsforNazi Victims in Post War Europe. (Cambridge: Cambridge UniversityPress, 2012), 95-105, Som-mer,R.,ForcedSexLabourinNaziConcentrationCamps,inBrutalityandDesire:War and Sexuality in Europes Twentieth Century, edit. Herzog, D. (New York: Palgrave McMil-lan, 2009), 168-173. 10. Prosecutorv.RudolfFranzFerdinandHoess, Supreme National Tribunal of Poland, March 1947, 12-18. . 239 Greifelt and others11 1948. , , , , -. Altstotter and others12 Josef Kramer and others (Bel-sen Trial)13 Luneburg, - . , 14. , 1992, -,- 15. 2., , -, 1948 , . 4(2) , . 2(2) .6, 16. 11.Prosecutorv.Greifeltandothers,UnitedStatesMilitaryTribunalsittingatNurem-berg, 10 March 1948, 2-36.12. Prosecutor v. Altstotter and others, United States Military Tribunal sitting at Nurem-berg, 4 December 1947, 1156. 13.Prosecutorv.JosefCramerandothers(TheBelsenTrial),BritishMilitaryTribunal sitting at Luneburg, 17 November 1945, 117-121.14.Kittichaisaree,K.,InternationalCriminalLaw.(Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress, 2001), 22, Lerner, N., Ethnic Cleansing, Israel Yearbook on Human Rights 24 (1995): 103-117, Bell-Fialkoff, A., A Brief History of Ethnic Cleansing, Foreign Affairs 72 (1993): 120-122,Bell-Fialkoff,A.,EthnicCleansing.(London:MacMillan,1996),Sokolovic,D.,How toConceptualizetheTragedyofBosnia:Civil,Ethnic,ReligiousWaror?,WarCrimes, Genocide and Crimes against Humanity 1(1) (2005): 115-130. 15. . U.N. Doc. E/1992/22, E.CN.4/1992/84/Add.1 (1992).16. Cassese, A., International Criminal Law, in International Law, Second Edition, edit. Evans, D.M. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006), 740. 240 16 (2005-2014) , , jus cogens, - : () ()- () () () . . 96()/46 , , . -1948 , , , 17. ,,, , , , 18, - . 1 19. 17. . Browning, R.C., The Origins of the Final Solution: The Evolution ofNaziJewishPolicy,September1939-March1942.(JerusalemandLincoln:YadVashem and University of Nebraska Press, 2004). 18.ReservationstotheConventiononthePreventionandPunishmentoftheCrimeof Genocide, Advisory Opinion, ICJ Rep. 1951, 15, 23. . , ., ., .Scripta.(-: . . , 2003), 116. 19. . 1 . 1 :1.,: . 241 , , 20, , ()21.,-, -22, -., , , ,,-(dolusspecialis), , 23. 24. , -, , - . 2. . ,.,..(-: , 2013), 5. 20.,.., . -. . (-: . . , 2001), 77. 21. , .., : , (-: , 2013), 416. 22. Leaute, J., . (: , 1991), 34. 23.Bauman,Z.,LifeinFragments.(Oxford:Blackwell,1995),203,Behrens,P.,A Moment of Kindness? Consistency and Genocidal Intent, in The Criminal Law of Genocide. International,ComparativeandContextualAspects,edit.Henham,R.,Behrens,P.(Ham-pshire: Burlington, 2007), 124-140.24.Moghalu,K.C.,InternationalHumanitarianLawfromNurembergtoRome:The WeightyPrecedentsoftheInternationalCriminalTribunalforRwanda,PaceInternational LawReview14(2002):273-305,Lewis,F.L.,Sexuality,RaceandEthnicity,inSexand Sexuality. Volume I. Sexuality Today: Trends and Controversies, edit. McAnulty, D.A., Bur-nette, M. M. (Westport, Connecticut, London: Praeger, 2006), 229-260. 242 16 (2005-2014) , 25 , -,, , . , , 26, -- . ..47/80 , 27., Sikirica, Dosen and Kolundzija ( ). - , 28, ,-, . , , 29. 25. El-Bushra, J., Mukarubuga, C., Women, War and Transition, Gender and Develop-ment 3(3) (1995): 17-19. 26. Schabas, W.A., Hate Speech in Rwanda: The Rode to Genocide, McGill Law Jour-nal46(2000):144-145,May,L.,IdentifyingGroupsinGenocideCases,inInternational Criminal Law and Philosophy, edit. May, L., Hoskins, Z. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010), 91-107.27. . Damrosch, L. F., Genocide and Ethnic Conflict, in International LawandEthnicConflict,edit.Wippman,D.(Ithaca,NewYork:CornellUniversityPress, 1998), 256-279.28.Prosecutorv.DuskoSikirica,DamirDosenandDraganKolundzija,Prosecutors Second Revised Pre-Trial Brief, Case No. IT-95-8-PT, 13 October 2000.29.Ladd,J.,IdeologicalComponentsoftheConceptsofCollectiveViolence,Human Rights and Solidarity, in Human Rights in the 21th Century: A Global Challenge, edit. Mah-oney, K.E., Mahoney, K.P. (Martinus Nihjoff Publishers, Dordrecht, 1993), 230. . 243 , Jelisic30 -Nikolic31, , ,,- . ,Krstic , , , , 32.,, -, ,-33.,- , , - 196334. 35. ,- -, 30. Prosecutor v. Goran Jelisic, Judgment, Case No. IT-95-10-T, 14 December 1999, 70. 31. Prosecutor v. Dragan Nikolic, Sentencing Judgment, Case No. IT-94-2-S, 18 Decem-ber 2003, 27. 32. Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic, Judgment, Case No. IT-98-33-T, 2 August 2001, 590. 33. Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic, Judgment, Case No. IT-98-33-T, 2 August 2001, 589. 34. Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic, Judgment, Case No. IT-98-33-T, 02 August 2001, 557. 35. . Wing, A.K., Merchan, S., Rape, Ethnicity and Culture: Spirit In-juryfromBosniatoBlackAmerica,ColumbiaHumanRightsLawReview25(1)(1993), Dana,S.,Genocide,ReconciliationandSentencingintheJurisprudenceoftheICTY,in TheCriminalLawofGenocide.International,ComparativeandContextualAspects,edit. Henham,R.,Behrens,P.(Hampshire,Burlington:Ashgate,2007),259-273,,.., , . ,.-,.,..,,.(-:..,1994),393-434. 244 16 (2005-2014) 36, - , 37. , - ,, -, . , , 38 Krstic39 . , ,- 40.,, Vuckovic41 Jorgic42 . 36.U.N.CommissiononHumanRights,SituationofHumanRightsintheRepublicof BosniaandHerzegovina,theRepublicofCroatiaandtheFederalRepublicofYugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro), Res. 1995/89, U.N. Doc. E/CN.4/RES1995/89, March 8, 1995.37.GeneralAssembly,TheSituationinBosniaHerzegovina,G.A.Res.47/121,U.N. Doc.A/RES/47/121,December181992,GeneralAssembly,RapeandAbuseofWomenin theAreasofArmedConflictintheFormerYugoslavia,G.A.Res.50/192,U.N.Doc. A/RES/50/1992, February 23, 1996, Koenig, D.M., Women and Rape in Ethnic Conflict and War, Hastings Womens Law Journal 5 (1994): 129-130. 38. International Court of Justice, Case Concerning the Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Serbia and Montenegro), 26/02/2007, para. 190.39.Prosecutorv.RadislavKrstic, TrialChamber,CaseNo.IT-98-33-T,2August2001, 562. 40.Lyman,B.L.,Beyondthe1948Convention.EmergingPrinciplesofGenocidein Customary International Law, Maryland Journal of International Law and Trade 17 (1993): 193,MacKinnon,C.A.,Rape,GenocideandWomensHumanRights,HarvardWomens Law Journal 17 (1994): 12 Zabeida, N., Not Making Excuses: Functions of Rape as a Tool of Ethno-Nationalist Wars, in Women, War and Violence. Personal Perspectives and Global Activism, edit. Chandler, M.R., Wang, L., Fuller, K.L. (New York: Palgrave McMillan, 2010), 17-30.41.VuckovicCase,FederalRepublicofYugoslavia(SerbiaandMontenegro),Supreme Court of Kosovo, 31 August 2001, 135.42.JorgicCase,Germany,HigherStateCourt(Oberlandsgericht)ofDusseldorf,Jud-gment of 26 September 1997, 132-135. . 245 , ,-43, . , , ,44 45. ,-,-, , , -.,- , - , -46. 43. Niarchos, C.N., Women, War and Rape: Challenges Facing the International Tribun-al for the Former Yugoslavia, Human Rights Quarterly 17 (1995): 682, Kesic, O., Women andGenderImageryinBosnia:Amazons,Sluts,Victims,WitchesandWombs,inGender andPoliticsintheWesternBalkans:WomenandSocietyinYugoslaviaandtheYugoslav Successor States, edit. Ramet, S.P. (University Park: Penn State University Press, 1999), 194-197.44. De Ruiter, D., Sexual Offences in International Criminal Law: Cases and Documents. (The Hague: International Courts Association, 2011), 24. 45. Salzman, T.A., Rape Camps as a Means of Ethnic Cleansing: Religious, Cultural and EthnicResponsestoRapeVictimsintheFormerYugoslavia,HumanRightsQuarterly20 (1998):355-356,Chinkin,C.,RapeandSexualAbuseofWomeninInternationalLaw, European Journal of International Law 5 (1994): 333-334.46. Dinstein, Y., International Criminal Law, Israel Law Review 20 (1985): 221-222. 246 16 (2005-2014) , , 47. 3. ,--, adhoc.-,,, 48 , ,-- . , , -49. , ,-,,- 50. , -47. Bassiouni, M.C., Manikas, P., The Law of the International Criminal Tribunal for the FormerYugoslavia.(IrvingtononHudson:TransnationalPublishers,1996),53,Schabas, W.A.,ProblemsConfrontingInternationalLawandPolicyonWarCrimesandCrimes AgainstHumanity:Warcrimes,CrimesAgainstHumanityandtheDeathPenalty,Albany LawReview60(1997):741-743,Petrovic,R.,EthnicCleansing:AnAttemptatMethodo-logy, European Journal of International Law 5 (1994): 342-344. 48.Askin,K.D.,WarCrimesagainstWomen:ProsecutioninInternationalWarCrimes Tribunals. (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, The Hague, 1997), 262-273.49.Jamieson,R.,GenocideandtheSocialProductionofImmorality,Theoretical Criminology (1999): 139. 50.Copelon,R.,SurfacingGender:ReconceptualisingCrimesagainstWomeninTime of War, in The Women and War Reader, edit. Lorentzen, L.A., Turpin, J. (New York: New York University Press, 1998), 64-66. . 247 ,,, Kunarac, Kovac and Vukovic, (instrumentofterror)- 51. , 2000, Bassiouni, ,80% ., - , , ,- 52. ,- -,,-, 53. ,-, , 54., 51. Kuo, P., Prosecuting Crimes of Sexual Violence in an International Tribunal, Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law 34 (2002): 318-319. 52.UnitedStatesCommissionontheSecurityandCo-operationin Europe,Genocidein Bosnia-Herzegovina: A Hearing before the U.S. OSCE. Washington D.C. 2000. . Stern, B., Fouchard, P.M., Sexual Violence as Genocide: The Important Role Played by the Bassiouni Commission in the Recent Development of International Criminal Law, in The Theory and Practice of International Criminal Law. Essays in Honor of M. Cherif Bassiouni, edit. Sadat, L.N., Scharf, P.M. (Leiden, Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2008), 285-308. 53.Gardam,J.,GenderandNon-CombatantImmunity,TransnationalLawandCon-temporary Problems 3 (1993): 363-364. 54.Filice,I.,Vincent,C.,WomenRefugeesfromBosnia-Herzegovina:Developinga Culturally Sensitive Counseling Framework, International Journal of Refugee Law 6 (1994): 248 16 (2005-2014) , , 55. , - ., KaradzicandMladic,-,,, , 56.,Krstic ,,-Srebrenica,,-,, -57. , , , 58. , , Stakic. , - , -,,,-210-212,Miller,L.S., VictimsasOffenders:TheParadoxofWomensViolenceinRelation-ships. (New Brunswick, New Jersey, London: Rutgers University Press, 2005), 113-129.55. El Bushra, J., Mukarubuga, C., Women, War and Transition, Gender and Develop-ment 3(3) (1995): 17-18. 56.Prosecutorv. RadovanKaradzicandRatkoMladic,Transcripts,CaseNo.IT-95-18-R61 & IT-95-5-R61, 02 July1996, 60-82. 57. Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic, Judgment, Case No. IT-98-33-T, 02 August 2001, 513. 58.Prosecutorv.MilomirStakic,Judgment,CaseNo.IT-97-24-T,31July2003,635. ,.Prosecutorv.RadislavBrdanin,Judgment,Case No. -99-36-, 01 September 2004, 690, Prosecutor v. Vidoje Blagojevic and Dragan Jokic, Transcripts,IT-02-60-,17January2005,646,Prosecutorv.MomciloKrajisnik and Biljana Plavsic, Amended Consolidated Indictment, Case No. IT-00-39-T, 27 September 2006, 862. . 249 , 59. , . , . , -.,, ., , . , - , , . , , ,-,-60, , , ,, . 59. . Prosecutor v. Milomir Stakic, Judgment, Case No. IT-97-24-T, 31 July 2003, 516, Prosecutor v. Radovan Karadzic, Amendment Indictment, Case No. IT-95-5/18-I, 28 June 2000, 93. 60. Olson, R.K., Children in the Grey Spaces between War and Peace, in Children and Youth on the Front Line, edit. Boyden, J., De Berry, J. (New York: Berghann Books, 2007), 154-155. 250 16 (2005-2014) KaradzicandMladic-, , ,- -, , 61. , , , , -. , - , , , . -,, 62.,- ,Karadzic&Mladic,Tadic, Mucicetal.,Stakic,Cesic,Furundzija,Kunaracetal.,Krstic,Todorovic, Simic et al. , -,,- , ,.-, , ,- , , , 61.Prosecutorv. RadovanKaradzicandRatkoMladic,Transcripts,CaseNo.IT-95-18-R61 and Case No. IT-95-5-R61, 02 July 1996, 400. 62. Seifert, R., War and Rape: A Preliminary Analysis, in Mass Rape: The War against Womenin Bosnia-Herzegovina, edit.Stiglmayer,A.(Lincoln:UniversityofNebraskaPress, 1994), 59. . 251 -63. , , -,Keraterm,TrnopoljeOmarska, , 64. , , , , -, ,65 66.,- , 67. 63. Wood, J.E., Sexual Violence during War: Toward an Understanding of Variation, in Order,ConflictandViolence,edit.Shapiro,I.,Kalyvas,S.,Masoud,T.(Cambridge:Cam-bridgeUniversityPress,2008),327-329,ViseurSellers,P.,EmergingJurisprudenceon Crimes of Sexual Violence, American University International Law Review 13 (1998): 1523, 1529. 64. Viseur Sellers, P., Okuizumi, K., Prosecuting International Crimes: An Inside View: International Prosecution of Sexual Assaults, Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems 7(1) (1997): 45, 51. 65. OBrien, W., The Rule of Law in Small Wars, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 541 (1995): 42-43, Lewis, A.D., Unrecognized Victims: Sexual Violence against Men in Conflict Settings under International Law, Wisconsin International Law Journal 27(1) (2009): 2-51, Sivakumaran, S., Prosecuting Sexual Violence against Men and Boys, in Sexual Violence as an International Crime: Interdisciplinary Approaches, edit. De Brouwer, A.M., Ku, C., Romkens, R., Van den Herik, L. (Antwerpen, Oxford: Intersentia, 2013), 80-82. 66. Jasinski, J.L., Theoretical Explanations for Violence against Women, in Sourcebook on Violence against Women, edit. Renzetti, C.M., Edleson, J.L., Bergen, R.K. (London: Sage Books,2001),12-13,Bielefeldt,H.,MuslimVoicesintheHumanRightsDebate,Human Rights Quarterly 17 (1995): 598-599. 67. Lindner, E.G., Gendercide and Humiliation in Honor and Human Rights Societies, JournalofGenocideResearch4(1)(2002):137-155,Warren,M.A.,Gendercide:TheIm-plications of Sex Selection. (Ottawa, New Jersey: Rowman and Allanheld, 1985), 198-201. 252 16 (2005-2014) , 1948,adhoc . -, .- , . , . . ,, , . ,, , , 68. ,, , 69, 68. Russell-Brown, S.L., Rape as an Act of Genocide, Berkeley Journal of International Law 21 (2003): 363-365, MacKinnon, C.A., Rape, Genocide and Womens Human Rights, Harvard Womens Law Journal 17 (1994): 9-11. 69.Sharlach,L.,RapeasGenocide:Bangladesh,the FormerYugoslaviaandRwanda, NewPoliticalScience22(1)(2000):89-102,Short,J.M.H.,SexualViolenceasGenocide: TheDevelopingLawoftheInternationalCriminalTribunalsandtheInternationalCriminal Court, Michigan Journal of Race and Law 8 (2003): 503-527. . 253 70. 70.MacKinnon,C.A.,Essay:CrimesofWar,CrimesofPeace,UCLAWomensLaw Journal4(1993):64-67,Scales,A.,Militarism,MaleDominanceandLaw:Feminist Jurisprudence as Oxymoron, Harvard Womens Law Journal 12 (1989): 40-41, Patel, K.R., RecognizingtheRapeofBosnianWomenasGender-BasedPersecution,BrooklynLaw Review60(1994):958-959,Mazur,D.H.,TheBeginningoftheEndforWomeninthe Military, Florida Law Review 48 (1996): 471, Collier, R., Masculinities, Law and Personal Life:TowardsaNewFrameworkforUnderstandingMen,LawandGender,Harvard Journal of Law and Gender 33 (2010): 433-471.