5i (D

2

~ 0 ~

()

~

c

-

n 3

7 Q

r ~

~ ji

-s

I

~ ~

n g

i tT1

-

oi

[

M0

Vl

--

VH

Il

EH

TH

EH

IUIT

IS

~

~

CQlI

lpli

catl

onwl

Sd

eltlW

heni

w

sugg

este

dth

tTro

janM

iOY

n

(an

dtl

un

frc

pre

su

bly

Gre

ok

Min

)n

wel

l)oo

uldb

eot

nooh

ave

anccst

rYinlhJatteepartoftbEIYBron~AgltinlhR3ionUth

and

ft

he S

eao

fb

rmr

a T

he

oonc

lull

on 1

0 be

dra

wn

from

thi

s w

bullbull b

tp

roo

-Gce

e1p

eak

ersh

d e

nter

ed A

nato

b

rlie

rn

theE

uly

B

ron

u A

ge

hd

sta

yed

he

flt

gtro

m

time

n

d h

d l

hen

=d

by

oo

ccn

IIl

IGre

ea

th

ebeg

inn

ing

of

hef

oU

oi

ng

pen

od

I

inl

so

meOf

lh

nn

mber

tode

CIo

Plhe

CUII

UO

fTro

yvl

Mo

e rlaquo

en

rch

hO

we

ver

eem

I

nd

ioat

eh

atbo

lh t

hes

Ihoriarbuedonfal~prem

M

lny

anp

on

ery

blS

no

wb

en

fo

und

in ~

moo

t no

tabl

y al

Ler

na

lh

e A

rgot

ld

in E

H I

II

XIS

T

hc

an

hee

xpl

ined

WL

Y b

y cw

mm

g

ha

so

t pr

oto-

Grc

d o

peak

e

had

cro

ed

from

An

alO

lia

li

rth

ano

lhe

Bu

hi

i

con

tro

dk

ted

by

su

die

swh

ich

ug

ges

tth

ath

EH

lIlc

ulr

ure

who

le i

h

e e

sult

no

ofi

mm

igra

cion

fem

n A

nato

lia b

ut o

f p

lO

d o

f in

diglt

nou

d

dopm

ent

in c

entr

ol G

reec

e pr

eced

d b

y tn

fIue

nces

w

hicl

t ca

me

ultim

atel

y fr

om t

he B

de n

cul

tu

ofA

uotr

io-H

unga

ry

culturewhicltlnturncanhehnkedthhespreadofKl1la~f

tu

in

occ

ntr

oIE

uro

pe

F

w-m

ero

nal

ysi

ofA

na

oIi

anM

ny

ana

loo

sU

ha

t th

e re

sem

bbnc

es b

etw

en

it a

nd G

e

k M

iny

n or

e lo

rgel

y il

luso

ry a

nd

ha

the

two

hav

e di

ffer

ent

orig

in bullbull

nd d

ilfe

rent

d

velo

pmn

So

he

ori

th

at

h

w

ere

Gre

eks

in n

orth

-wes

A

nII

)i

duri

ng th

e M

iddl

e an

d La

B

ronz

e A

ge

em

0 b

e w

itbo

nt

fgun

dri

on Y

etac

ott

oin

amo

on

ofd

oub

tm

n

A1t

houg

bdet

aile

d ex

omin

io

no

fth

tw

ltgt

yp

eo

fpo

tter

yh

o

h

ath

red

shap

esw

OK

al

mos

tnon

-i

sten

t h

lI

m

ili

y t

napp

eara

ncbullbull

nd

n f

abri

c an

be

feJt

to b

e tn

o cl

oe

0 b

eoc

iden

tal

And

wh

n in

he

li

t m

ilJe

nniu

mth

enor

th_w

este

mer

gos

in

wri

lten

nJS

tory

iti

ptt

rtof

rne

Gre

tkw

orl

do

ccu

pie

db

y G

reek

p

eakm

gp

I

B

uh

earr

ivaI

of

hes

e A

eoli

c G

reeb

frO

lmG

reec

e u

nlik

e h

at o

f h

e Io

nlO

nf

urrh

er

su

hc

ann

oy

lt1

ber

oco

gn

ized

wih

Olu

t do

ubt

in

her

clta

eolo

gica

l =

rd

fo

r fi

rst_

mill

eoni

um p

oIe

ry i

n t

he

1iee

IIt

lO h

e d~rly

deoc

end

edfr

omh

otO

lftb

osec

ondm

ilim

nium

ra

hert

hlll

lint

rodu

ccd

from

llll

you

Llt

iel

Our

lte

Nor

cant

hbullbull

caht

yfO

luru

iai

onie

geod

liof

the

Ae

hc

lem

eni

nspi

regr

eatc

onli

denc

cint

heir

hist

oeic

alc

cy

Onl

yfun

bee

Jtca

Vll

rion

nd

e

rc

hca

n

how

whe

ther

h

A

li

c G

nek

w

e

in

fct

im

mig

from

C

ngtSl

i th

e A

eg

0

th

e de

ocen

dant

sofG

reek

p

eali

ngno

tl

o

fthbullbulle

con

dm

ilie

nn

ium

h

Tro

in

o

f h

e H

omor

io p

oem

s

Lu

wia

ns

in G

reo

oe

Ao

orn

etb

eory

wlu

chu

gg

d

l

i

i

cco

nn

ecti

on

bet

wee

n

Anatoliand~ecentreSnhemanyplace-nunesendingin

nt

bo

n

dm

iltt

r fo

rm

whi

ch u

to

be fo

und

ou e

ithe

r sid

e o

f th

e A

ejIl

lII

Thc

se e

ndin

g c

on p

lau

ibl

be

exp

wn

d a

s L

uwi

n

nd

hei

tdis

rib

ui

on

u

gg

ch

atL

uw

ian

orc

ah

erm

lin

gu

itl

c n

ceo

r W

lo

m

tlm

sp

oker

ov

er l

arg

e

ofb

otb

w bullbullt

ltm

Ana

toli

an

d G

=cel

t hI

S blt

ensu

ggbullbull

ted

lha

it

00

L

u

in

(ntt

her

than

Gre

eks)

h

oam

ved

inG

rco

ce

tth

ebeg

inru

ng

oft

h

Mkl

dIoH

eJbd

icpe

rind

(I

J00

Bc)

ore

ven

hatt

heya

rriv

ed

I

heS

hlf

Cin

v ep

erio

dlaquo

6

Cgt

ClI

IQB

uu

p

oin

ted

ou

Jo

ns

go

th

ibullbull r

emtt

rkab

lecO

linc

idn

ceb

twee

nthe

dist

dbuc

iono

fpJa

ccshy

nm

es

of

this

y

pe

nd

th

at

of

site

s w

ith

Ear

ly

Hel

ladl

C

II

con

n

u

T

h

ori

gm

ofn

um

ero

ur

et

u

ft

he

Aeg

eanE

rly

B

ro=

Ag

eh

av

bbullbull

nse

en i

n w

nA

nm

l

Th

bullbullbull

may

wel

l be

e

plic

able

in

tetm

o

f tr

adin

g co

ntac

ts

Bu

tin

ce

ooe

ptin

g h

e r

gu

men

tsp

rese

ne

db

obullbull

A

nato

li w

ar

r

dy

a th

at r

im

pro

o-L

uwia

n in

p

eech

th

ere

i so

met

hmg

0

b

said

fO

l bull

cont

empo

rary

h

gu

isti

c p

rltad

to

h

e G

reek

m

ainl

and

O

n th

is

hypo

the

G

reek

was

no

tth

e6m

lnd

o-E

uro

pea

nJa

ng

ug

eutG

reec

e

bU

pr

elted

eltli

nhbullbull

b

YI

pro

o-L

u_

nl

rng

ui

kele

men

w

hk

hw

lSw

idcs

pte

add

uri

ng

bee

arli

erp

aro

fh

ltE

dy

Bro

nu

Ag

e

Con

clus

ions

Ish

theJ

n

nw

erto

theq

onp

oeed

inth

eti

lef

tbiamp

clta

per

T

oso

mo

nta

tlea

stth

e

ib

uti

tmu

stti

r5b

eem

ph

ie

dth

atw

ca

nooo

deJ

ine

the

Hlt

ti

or

any

of t

heir

con

m

poca

ries

in

term

of

thei

r ph

ysic

oJ

ppe

arn

ce

Th

e

I

hi

that

ca

n be

la

belle

d un

ique

lyH

itl

n

hes

bope

ofh

eir

IruJ

Is

tb

ocol

ouro

rthe

Hk

in

eyes

Oe

h

in

pol

iica

] an

d cl

gtron

olog

ical

er

msd

eJin

ioon

is

muc

h

e

r T

he

Him

tes

h

A

czaw

an

and

othe

r pe

ltlFl

es w

ho h

ave

been

m

eno

ned

abo

e oc

cupi

ed n

elgh

boue

ing

area

s of

o

ond-

mil

lenn

ium

no

oli

n

d t

hei

rhi

tocy

n

d m

oy

bullbullp

eclS

ofth

eiel

tf

wiU

be

the

sub

j

ofs

ub

soq

un

lclt

ape

Bu

tto

lim

i

d

din

itio

nin

tlti

sway

is

mig

no

no

avcc

ym

po

rran

tpan

ofw

luw

ekn

ow

lbo

ult

heH

itli

IltI

dth

itco

ntem

poro

ri

-th

eit

angu

agt

U

stn

gh

isas

]wo

an

det

ine

Hit

it

som

eone

wblt

gtus

edth

eHi

tie

lang

uago

anA

noW

ito

a

spea

ker(

or w

rl

r)o

fLu

wll

lnt

hl

ang

uag

cofA

rzaw

aan

do

on

T

h

op

enu

pm

uch

wid

of

nq

uir

yf

oti

can

men

bes

een

that

m

uclt

ofe

cond

_mU

nru

um A

nato

Iia

occu

piod

by

spea

kers

of

lang

ulge

w

hich

wO

ee d

osel

y re

late

ltl

oo

aclt

od

terl

nd

wh

ich

mo

c

impo

nant

lyh

ve

bei

ron

gin

in

the

Ind

o-E

urop

e

fam

ily o

f w

hich

lu

ge

num

bers

of

mod

em I

ngu

ages

D

elud

ing

ou

ow

n

al

me

mbe

Lt

llul

Sic

vid

~con

tSO

ttt

exte

nb

lin1

edoo

the

evid

eru

ofa

rclt

aeO

lIl

IYr

ul i

n tl

i

Wly

wo

can

hope

to

trac

e th

e hi

Slor

y of

tho

Hil

tl

llII

d A

w

llIlS

(ie

sp

ltallte

rs o

f H

itti

e a

nd

LUW

lon

or

fIh

er t

heit

im

med

iate

nce

smr

per

ha

bet

ter

fer

rcd

to

pr

oto-

An

touc

)bc

kint

oear

lier

miH

enni

lo

ngbe

f e

the

tl

eno

e O

lfan

ywri

ttn

docu

men

tai

onO

lfh

iato

nce

Wec

anl

snre

cogn

i

th

epo

ibil

itr

hat

speL

krs

ofa

do

sely

rel

elt

lI

gu

gew

eret

ob

fo

und

tnlh

lld-

mil

ienn

ium

Gr=

bullbullnd

the

Aeg

ean

andt

here

i bullbullt

leos

h

ing

to

he

d

ro

he

theo

ry t

hat

norr

h-w

An

Olb

a w

as

OCC

UPI

ed b

y p

elko

rs o

fan

bull

ly fo

rm

fGre

ek (a

loo

Irul

o-E

urop

ean

buhelongingtoadifferentbranchOlfthefamily)InHa~wohve

id

ence

f

l

o

n

of

he

lang

uage

o sp

olt

I

I c

ntra

lAna

toli

a b

efo

n

hea

rri

lo

fth

eln

dn

-Eu

rop

ean

pealte-Thuinotu~

for

he

otig

ios

Olf

the

Hit

ri

an

d th

eirn

igh

oour

s th

e

iden

ceof

la

ng

uag

oen

ob

ksu

oto

go

bac

kf

beyo

rul

th b

ound

arie

s im

pose

d by

an

yh

ito

rica

lmat

eru

lco

ni

nedi

nSW

Vtv

ingt

t

--

VH

Il

EH

TH

EH

IUIT

IS

~

~

CQlI

lpli

catl

onwl

Sd

eltlW

heni

w

sugg

este

dth

tTro

janM

iOY

n

(an

dtl

un

frc

pre

su

bly

Gre

ok

Min

)n

wel

l)oo

uldb

eot

nooh

ave

anccst

rYinlhJatteepartoftbEIYBron~AgltinlhR3ionUth

and

ft

he S

eao

fb

rmr

a T

he

oonc

lull

on 1

0 be

dra

wn

from

thi

s w

bullbull b

tp

roo

-Gce

e1p

eak

ersh

d e

nter

ed A

nato

b

rlie

rn

theE

uly

B

ron

u A

ge

hd

sta

yed

he

flt

gtro

m

time

n

d h

d l

hen

=d

by

oo

ccn

IIl

IGre

ea

th

ebeg

inn

ing

of

hef

oU

oi

ng

pen

od

I

inl

so

meOf

lh

nn

mber

tode

CIo

Plhe

CUII

UO

fTro

yvl

Mo

e rlaquo

en

rch

hO

we

ver

eem

I

nd

ioat

eh

atbo

lh t

hes

Ihoriarbuedonfal~prem

M

lny

anp

on

ery

blS

no

wb

en

fo

und

in ~

moo

t no

tabl

y al

Ler

na

lh

e A

rgot

ld

in E

H I

II

XIS

T

hc

an

hee

xpl

ined

WL

Y b

y cw

mm

g

ha

so

t pr

oto-

Grc

d o

peak

e

had

cro

ed

from

An

alO

lia

li

rth

ano

lhe

Bu

hi

i

con

tro

dk

ted

by

su

die

swh

ich

ug

ges

tth

ath

EH

lIlc

ulr

ure

who

le i

h

e e

sult

no

ofi

mm

igra

cion

fem

n A

nato

lia b

ut o

f p

lO

d o

f in

diglt

nou

d

dopm

ent

in c

entr

ol G

reec

e pr

eced

d b

y tn

fIue

nces

w

hicl

t ca

me

ultim

atel

y fr

om t

he B

de n

cul

tu

ofA

uotr

io-H

unga

ry

culturewhicltlnturncanhehnkedthhespreadofKl1la~f

tu

in

occ

ntr

oIE

uro

pe

F

w-m

ero

nal

ysi

ofA

na

oIi

anM

ny

ana

loo

sU

ha

t th

e re

sem

bbnc

es b

etw

en

it a

nd G

e

k M

iny

n or

e lo

rgel

y il

luso

ry a

nd

ha

the

two

hav

e di

ffer

ent

orig

in bullbull

nd d

ilfe

rent

d

velo

pmn

So

he

ori

th

at

h

w

ere

Gre

eks

in n

orth

-wes

A

nII

)i

duri

ng th

e M

iddl

e an

d La

B

ronz

e A

ge

em

0 b

e w

itbo

nt

fgun

dri

on Y

etac

ott

oin

amo

on

ofd

oub

tm

n

A1t

houg

bdet

aile

d ex

omin

io

no

fth

tw

ltgt

yp

eo

fpo

tter

yh

o

h

ath

red

shap

esw

OK

al

mos

tnon

-i

sten

t h

lI

m

ili

y t

napp

eara

ncbullbull

nd

n f

abri

c an

be

feJt

to b

e tn

o cl

oe

0 b

eoc

iden

tal

And

wh

n in

he

li

t m

ilJe

nniu

mth

enor

th_w

este

mer

gos

in

wri

lten

nJS

tory

iti

ptt

rtof

rne

Gre

tkw

orl

do

ccu

pie

db

y G

reek

p

eakm

gp

I

B

uh

earr

ivaI

of

hes

e A

eoli

c G

reeb

frO

lmG

reec

e u

nlik

e h

at o

f h

e Io

nlO

nf

urrh

er

su

hc

ann

oy

lt1

ber

oco

gn

ized

wih

Olu

t do

ubt

in

her

clta

eolo

gica

l =

rd

fo

r fi

rst_

mill

eoni

um p

oIe

ry i

n t

he

1iee

IIt

lO h

e d~rly

deoc

end

edfr

omh

otO

lftb

osec

ondm

ilim

nium

ra

hert

hlll

lint

rodu

ccd

from

llll

you

Llt

iel

Our

lte

Nor

cant

hbullbull

caht

yfO

luru

iai

onie

geod

liof

the

Ae

hc

lem

eni

nspi

regr

eatc

onli

denc

cint

heir

hist

oeic

alc

cy

Onl

yfun

bee

Jtca

Vll

rion

nd

e

rc

hca

n

how

whe

ther

h

A

li

c G

nek

w

e

in

fct

im

mig

from

C

ngtSl

i th

e A

eg

0

th

e de

ocen

dant

sofG

reek

p

eali

ngno

tl

o

fthbullbulle

con

dm

ilie

nn

ium

h

Tro

in

o

f h

e H

omor

io p

oem

s

Lu

wia

ns

in G

reo

oe

Ao

orn

etb

eory

wlu

chu

gg

d

l

i

i

cco

nn

ecti

on

bet

wee

n

Anatoliand~ecentreSnhemanyplace-nunesendingin

nt

bo

n

dm

iltt

r fo

rm

whi

ch u

to

be fo

und

ou e

ithe

r sid

e o

f th

e A

ejIl

lII

Thc

se e

ndin

g c

on p

lau

ibl

be

exp

wn

d a

s L

uwi

n

nd

hei

tdis

rib

ui

on

u

gg

ch

atL

uw

ian

orc

ah

erm

lin

gu

itl

c n

ceo

r W

lo

m

tlm

sp

oker

ov

er l

arg

e

ofb

otb

w bullbullt

ltm

Ana

toli

an

d G

=cel

t hI

S blt

ensu

ggbullbull

ted

lha

it

00

L

u

in

(ntt

her

than

Gre

eks)

h

oam

ved

inG

rco

ce

tth

ebeg

inru

ng

oft

h

Mkl

dIoH

eJbd

icpe

rind

(I

J00

Bc)

ore

ven

hatt

heya

rriv

ed

I

heS

hlf

Cin

v ep

erio

dlaquo

6

Cgt

ClI

IQB

uu

p

oin

ted

ou

Jo

ns

go

th

ibullbull r

emtt

rkab

lecO

linc

idn

ceb

twee

nthe

dist

dbuc

iono

fpJa

ccshy

nm

es

of

this

y

pe

nd

th

at

of

site

s w

ith

Ear

ly

Hel

ladl

C

II

con

n

u

T

h

ori

gm

ofn

um

ero

ur

et

u

ft

he

Aeg

eanE

rly

B

ro=

Ag

eh

av

bbullbull

nse

en i

n w

nA

nm

l

Th

bullbullbull

may

wel

l be

e

plic

able

in

tetm

o

f tr

adin

g co

ntac

ts

Bu

tin

ce

ooe

ptin

g h

e r

gu

men

tsp

rese

ne

db

obullbull

A

nato

li w

ar

r

dy

a th

at r

im

pro

o-L

uwia

n in

p

eech

th

ere

i so

met

hmg

0

b

said

fO

l bull

cont

empo

rary

h

gu

isti

c p

rltad

to

h

e G

reek

m

ainl

and

O

n th

is

hypo

the

G

reek

was

no

tth

e6m

lnd

o-E

uro

pea

nJa

ng

ug

eutG

reec

e

bU

pr

elted

eltli

nhbullbull

b

YI

pro

o-L

u_

nl

rng

ui

kele

men

w

hk

hw

lSw

idcs

pte

add

uri

ng

bee

arli

erp

aro

fh

ltE

dy

Bro

nu

Ag

e

Con

clus

ions

Ish

theJ

n

nw

erto

theq

onp

oeed

inth

eti

lef

tbiamp

clta

per

T

oso

mo

nta

tlea

stth

e

ib

uti

tmu

stti

r5b

eem

ph

ie

dth

atw

ca

nooo

deJ

ine

the

Hlt

ti

or

any

of t

heir

con

m

poca

ries

in

term

of

thei

r ph

ysic

oJ

ppe

arn

ce

Th

e

I

hi

that

ca

n be

la

belle

d un

ique

lyH

itl

n

hes

bope

ofh

eir

IruJ

Is

tb

ocol

ouro

rthe

Hk

in

eyes

Oe

h

in

pol

iica

] an

d cl

gtron

olog

ical

er

msd

eJin

ioon

is

muc

h

e

r T

he

Him

tes

h

A

czaw

an

and

othe

r pe

ltlFl

es w

ho h

ave

been

m

eno

ned

abo

e oc

cupi

ed n

elgh

boue

ing

area

s of

o

ond-

mil

lenn

ium

no

oli

n

d t

hei

rhi

tocy

n

d m

oy

bullbullp

eclS

ofth

eiel

tf

wiU

be

the

sub

j

ofs

ub

soq

un

lclt

ape

Bu

tto

lim

i

d

din

itio

nin

tlti

sway

is

mig

no

no

avcc

ym

po

rran

tpan

ofw

luw

ekn

ow

lbo

ult

heH

itli

IltI

dth

itco

ntem

poro

ri

-th

eit

angu

agt

U

stn

gh

isas

]wo

an

det

ine

Hit

it

som

eone

wblt

gtus

edth

eHi

tie

lang

uago

anA

noW

ito

a

spea

ker(

or w

rl

r)o

fLu

wll

lnt

hl

ang

uag

cofA

rzaw

aan

do

on

T

h

op

enu

pm

uch

wid

of

nq

uir

yf

oti

can

men

bes

een

that

m

uclt

ofe

cond

_mU

nru

um A

nato

Iia

occu

piod

by

spea

kers

of

lang

ulge

w

hich

wO

ee d

osel

y re

late

ltl

oo

aclt

od

terl

nd

wh

ich

mo

c

impo

nant

lyh

ve

bei

ron

gin

in

the

Ind

o-E

urop

e

fam

ily o

f w

hich

lu

ge

num

bers

of

mod

em I

ngu

ages

D

elud

ing

ou

ow

n

al

me

mbe

Lt

llul

Sic

vid

~con

tSO

ttt

exte

nb

lin1

edoo

the

evid

eru

ofa

rclt

aeO

lIl

IYr

ul i

n tl

i

Wly

wo

can

hope

to

trac

e th

e hi

Slor

y of

tho

Hil

tl

llII

d A

w

llIlS

(ie

sp

ltallte

rs o

f H

itti

e a

nd

LUW

lon

or

fIh

er t

heit

im

med

iate

nce

smr

per

ha

bet

ter

fer

rcd

to

pr

oto-

An

touc

)bc

kint

oear

lier

miH

enni

lo

ngbe

f e

the

tl

eno

e O

lfan

ywri

ttn

docu

men

tai

onO

lfh

iato

nce

Wec

anl

snre

cogn

i

th

epo

ibil

itr

hat

speL

krs

ofa

do

sely

rel

elt

lI

gu

gew

eret

ob

fo

und

tnlh

lld-

mil

ienn

ium

Gr=

bullbullnd

the

Aeg

ean

andt

here

i bullbullt

leos

h

ing

to

he

d

ro

he

theo

ry t

hat

norr

h-w

An

Olb

a w

as

OCC

UPI

ed b

y p

elko

rs o

fan

bull

ly fo

rm

fGre

ek (a

loo

Irul

o-E

urop

ean

buhelongingtoadifferentbranchOlfthefamily)InHa~wohve

id

ence

f

l

o

n

of

he

lang

uage

o sp

olt

I

I c

ntra

lAna

toli

a b

efo

n

hea

rri

lo

fth

eln

dn

-Eu

rop

ean

pealte-Thuinotu~

for

he

otig

ios

Olf

the

Hit

ri

an

d th

eirn

igh

oour

s th

e

iden

ceof

la

ng

uag

oen

ob

ksu

oto

go

bac

kf

beyo

rul

th b

ound

arie

s im

pose

d by

an

yh

ito

rica

lmat

eru

lco

ni

nedi

nSW

Vtv

ingt

t

W

T

~ z ~ ~ a f ~

~

T is c Ul

Med

ller

ra

on

th

atth

eco

nt3

t

hen

iris

mo

de

isO

llu

sth

i

me

n

d a

t ju

s

tho

pi

whe

o

ne

mig

ht o

xpelt

t It

on

d h

at

he

reoe

mbl

anclt

ofn

lle

s be

twec

n th

e A

ch

a_

an

d t

he A

hhly

awan

s is

m

O

lhan

form

ito

u

Anl

i-M

ycen

aeo

l

legc

that

orch

ocoJ

ogJC

ally

th

i

slit

tle

vid

ence

forc

on

t3ct

th

th

ere

n

oth

ing

nth

et

rutlt

gt

sugg

est

that

Ahh

iyaw

a is

oull

iide

An

tltgt

li

nd t

hat

thee

qur

ion

oft

he

Ila

III

S isphllologiC31imposib~ity

Iac

on

Oic

toft

his

lUlt

ure

on

ehao

tota

ke

ides

n

dth

eu

tho

rmu

st

lm

il alt

onc

e th

arl

lhou

gh h

e w

ould

lik

e tlt

gtlaquo

Pt

Ihe

eqno

1on

wit

h M

ycc

nae

ns

ho

stil

lfee

isth

ott

bb

aln

ceo

fey

iden

i

qi

ust

itT

his

ewis

bao

edm

oin

lyo

nlh

ewld

rq

ut

iono

fAn

toli

ange

ogra

phy

r

Ahh

iyaw

bullbull

nd M

Ulo

won

da a

tal

cit

y un

der

Ahh

iy

an

inf

luen

clt

c

kgtse

y li

nked

wlt

h

uch

th $

ehR

iyO

T L

and

whi

chalt

if

on

middotmiddot

Pll

itha

IAno

w

oclt

upi

edth

ecen

tral

Aeg

lta

ntoa

ot

d

that

lhe

sout

h-w

est

was

virt

uU

y un

oltcu

pied

to

bel

oca

td

in

th

nort

hshy

trn

cor

ner

ofA

no

lia T

heM

yce

ne

an h

eory

is I

orge

ly b

ased

on

the

qu

ti

ofM

illo

w

d

it

hM

ilt

u

whe

re t

here

is

know

n M

ycen

=

tIem

nt

Att

ralt

t

h

ou

gh

lhia

cqu

aun

iil

ltr

eate

S

l

pro

bl

hi

cb

iIl

hav

eto

be

l

ved

bef

i

en

gi

n

univ

enal

ce

ptan

c bull

ltis

fori

nst

anco

har

dw

bullbull

ho

MiH

awan

d

ifi

isM

ilo

tus

en

be

fute

din

toth

epmof~Anatoliantawithoulplacmgome

oft

hem

in

du

dn

gA

ruw

m

thep

rob

lem

aric

alo

uth

w

tern

ar

nd

ven

ifo

nea

min

terp

rett

heg

mg

rap

hic

alev

iden

cein

wsy

wh

ich

ke

ep

Ar

wa

in L

yd

i

it is

equa

lly d

illi

cuit

to

how

reJ

allo

n

betw

en

theH

ittU

e

and

Ml

law

anda

jAhh

iya

w

heth

er f

rien

dly

or

oh

erw

ise

cou

ldb

aveb

een

mi

nta

ined

attt

mes

wh

mah

ost

ileA

ru

a

Iy

belw

n

he

wo

It

al

so n

ec

ry

tO

Uil

ume

from

h

e le

Xu

l

~d~~~~~

o~tr~r~~~lou~i~~

evld

nce

-a1t

houg

h it

can

of c

ourS

e be

roa

sona

bly

cbim

ed t

hal

ueh

ro

idm

gpar

ti

o

uld

beu

nli

kel

ytn

l

yre

cogn

i2ab

leph

ysic

ol

tr

o

f th

eir

prc

ene

gt7

Th

eo t

he

is t

he bull

d

ce

of

tra

ty d

raw

n u

pab

ou

ta3

ob

etw

_b

Hit

til

andth~landofAmutruonthe

Lbullbull

bullnti

ne=

rln

this

t

ryt

heru

lo

fAm

urru

isfo

rbid

dnt

oall

ow

hip

ofA

hh

y

aro

lrad

lu

ou

gh

tbep

ort

sofA

mu

fJU

Wlt

hA

yr

ia

t

hat

rim

e H

itti

m

) ~ow i

itr

uetb

(h

ere

isb

un

d

ev

iden

ce o

fMy

=

lrad

e m

th

LeY

ltnt

and

evid

cnce

too

of

that

o

rade

g

tlyd

ecli

ning

lt J~So-JOampotitisimpot1ntorembor

thai

Myo

ena

n r

raamp

wo

spu

rcy

taIm

ch

cte

r T

here

evid

at1

1 of

Myc

enae

n g

ood

pn

etra

tmg

far

inla

nd

nd

pas

sing

Ih

roug

hLev

anti

n t

ernt

ory

to b

e re

cel

d i

n A

ssy

ia

If t

he t

rade

w

as o

fu

ffid

ent

Impo

rtan

ce f

or

Hi

ute

kin

g ro

try

to

put bullbullr

op

ro i

t o

n

mig

ht e

pec

to

me

ign

o

f M

yceJ

3C

an p

otte

ry e

of

the

Eup

hrat

es

Nev

rth

I

th

eAh

biy

awaj

M=

oea

n G

rtk

qu

n

has

ov

erth

e y

b

een

tro

nl

y a

nd p

ersu

asiv

ely

argu

ed

and

i

il w

ith s

ome

hesi

tati

onlh

ltth

bullbulll

temariv~viewismainroindher

bull l

thao

nh

een

d

w b

bullbull

dmitt

erl

thah

eev

idn

i

bull

pre

snt

in

uffi

cien

t to

off

conc

lusi

pro

off

nre

ih

erca

se

Wha

t w

e re

ally

nee

d be

fore

we

can

pt o

ne

de

IX

the

othe

r IS

som

elthi

ng r

athe

r m

oe

u

re t

han

dedu

lttio

D8

mad

fr

om t

he H

omr

ic p

o

O

D w

ha

un

)th

ing

th

M

yce1

13ea

nca

1led

them

selv

bullbull E

yld

enc

cfro

mu

nea

rSte

nu

ldb

in

lu

bJe

wou

ld

infO

J1Jt

t1on

frO

Jn

som

e

sid

e so

uc

e_o

ay

lIg

arit

-on

wha

t M

ylte

neO

Jul

reca

lld

by

tbei

rcon

tcm

pora

ries

Jo

On

edy

uch

bull

dl9

lco

may

bf

ou

nd

bu

ttb

atd

aYlS

lgtO

lty

ctl

inti

ln

com

oo

neh

asto

tak

eup

thep

osi

io

nw

hic

bse

to

bt

h

mO

li p

robl

bl

in t

erllt

5 oflh~ e

vide

nce

tber

e i

A

ocor

dng

Iy

ho

hi

tori

ltal_

tro

cli

on

wh

ilth

foll

nw

tn

thi

bo

ok

ib

ase

d

the

lSS

umpt

that

Mil

lw

anda

loy

on

he

shor

es o

fthe

Sea

of M

orm

n

dth

atA

hh

iyaw

ato

o

iu

ate

d

ll

in

pu

1i

nl1

Olt

h_

w

t A

nOlo

Iia

nd

vcry

pro

bbl

y in

clud

ed

rri

ory

t

heE

uro

n

sh

ofl

h

Sea

of

Mar

mor

bullbull

well

H

owev

er

an a

lter

nny

e m

ap

providedwihMillwandaM~otubullbulln

dA

rza

in

the

uth

and

thoo

c w

hod

sogr

ee w

th t

h

relt

onst

ruo

ion

can

6Ilo

w h

eir

own

~p

~~

ro

u~~

~~~~t

i~~

~g~~~

~

n~mentofa

ug

gest

edab

ovei

scc

epe

dth

~oe

rall

pic

tue

o

fAn

ao

Jian

geo

gra

ph

yn

dh

isto

rym

akbullbull

E

f

itn

toa

gn

eral

pat

tern

ofe

con

Olt

1le

nec

essi

tya

nd

hee

lfu

rtso

fth

var

io

t

ales

am

be

I b

e di

rect

ed t

owar

ds

thin

g m

ore

perm

anen

t th

an t

h

arbi

tror

yom

biio

nsof

indi

VK

Iual

oove

reis

n

The

pro

ble

m o

f ti

n a

uppl

iBS

nt

tem

pti

ng

loju

srif

yth

v

iew

wem

ayn

ow

retn

mo

Ho

ttu

Oil

isan

d

hi

cam

paig

n ag

Uos

t A

rz

I

up

p

oslt

iu

nm

ow

n

He

may

ha~

be

en a

trac

kedf

rom

heh

ind

he

n hi

bullbull

tte

ntro

nwo

dir

ecte

d ro

the

out

h

b

utc

qu

ally

h

ep

edio

on

my

bel

ink

edw

ub

on

e

crb

ed

ro

Lab

mas

in

a la

ter

bullbullty

III

th~ltou~ofwhib

bo

thA

ru

a an

d W

lIu

w

OTec

on

q

ere

dl

fe

no

was

kw

hat

hi

mp

ort

a nlt

eofW

ilus

w

asa

glan

ee a

t h

e m

ap W

Jll

ho

wu

sfo

rWil

u

by

trid

eth

b

och

o

ftn

eno

r(h

enr

ou

lep

rcv

Wu

sly

men

tio

ned

wln

che

dfr

t

hL

and

of

Hot

tilo

nonh

-wlt

mem

n

atoJ

ioan

dfro

mth

mac

ross

thes

t

tsin

to

Eu

ope

Was

ih

on

ro

d

wh

ich

pro

vo

ked

Hit

ri

n

esti

nth

ro

ute

ashadeconomicftorinlhsoutb-estalooAodifoowh~tartid

otm

are

rial

cam

eto

Ha

usa

salo

ng

tbr

ou

W

cn

on

lyg

ues

sfo

r n

o H

Itti

te m

onar

ch

ver

gIv

es

any

hint

o

f

ie m

i

es i

n

atto

ckin

gm

akin

g a

tr

y w

ilh

oo

ther

wi

se

ok

ing

0 in

flue

nce

ooot

herc

oun

ry

It h

a b

een

51tg

ges

d t

ha

thi

tOU

le to

o w

ti

n-r

ou

te

Id

ing

thro

ugh

the

Su

u

and

eve

ntua

llyr

o h

tic

h

u

rces

ofB

oh

i

a

An

dll

utt

lead

on

sdlr

eltt

lyto

th

vxe

d qu

esrio

n o

f th

e so

urce

or

oo

uro e

so

fth

eti

h

ichW

28W

idl

yuse

dint

hm

anuf

tu

rcof

bron

IU

n o

rui

eotA

naro

lio I

nc

ide

ng

rhiq

uest

ion

drlt

ady

touc

hed

on in

dt

opt

o

nem

ust

tak

ein

toac

cou

nle

vid

ence

fro

mth

oE

arly

aru

l M

iddl

e B

ran

A

ges

wel

l bullbull

the

Hit

tite

p

cd

It i

s d

ut

for

inSt

ance

th

at

in

the

dnn

m

Uen

nium

BC

h

pe

nen

tage

ofc

oppe

r_]

sed

ar

tifO

Cts

con t

slni

ngm

cret

han)

iYep

erce

ntl

lnis

rou

chh

igh

rin

no

nh

shyw

este

rnan

dcet

ttra

l A

o o

Jia(

nd

lso

nonh

-wes

tern

Ira

n) th

an i

t ii

n

nelg

hbou

ing

ar

uc

h

es

opot

ami

Syr

i

Egy

ptn

d C

ret bull

Th

e o

bv

iou

co

nc

usi

on

lob

dra

wn

fro

mth

isis

thal

ther

e

tin-s

ourlt

e

I

Med

ller

ra

on

th

atth

eco

nt3

t

hen

iris

mo

de

isO

llu

sth

i

me

n

d a

t ju

s

tho

pi

whe

o

ne

mig

ht o

xpelt

t It

on

d h

at

he

reoe

mbl

anclt

ofn

lle

s be

twec

n th

e A

ch

a_

an

d t

he A

hhly

awan

s is

m

O

lhan

form

ito

u

Anl

i-M

ycen

aeo

l

legc

that

orch

ocoJ

ogJC

ally

th

i

slit

tle

vid

ence

forc

on

t3ct

th

th

ere

n

oth

ing

nth

et

rutlt

gt

sugg

est

that

Ahh

iyaw

a is

oull

iide

An

tltgt

li

nd t

hat

thee

qur

ion

oft

he

Ila

III

S isphllologiC31imposib~ity

Iac

on

Oic

toft

his

lUlt

ure

on

ehao

tota

ke

ides

n

dth

eu

tho

rmu

st

lm

il alt

onc

e th

arl

lhou

gh h

e w

ould

lik

e tlt

gtlaquo

Pt

Ihe

eqno

1on

wit

h M

ycc

nae

ns

ho

stil

lfee

isth

ott

bb

aln

ceo

fey

iden

i

qi

ust

itT

his

ewis

bao

edm

oin

lyo

nlh

ewld

rq

ut

iono

fAn

toli

ange

ogra

phy

r

Ahh

iyaw

bullbull

nd M

Ulo

won

da a

tal

cit

y un

der

Ahh

iy

an

inf

luen

clt

c

kgtse

y li

nked

wlt

h

uch

th $

ehR

iyO

T L

and

whi

chalt

if

on

middotmiddot

Pll

itha

IAno

w

oclt

upi

edth

ecen

tral

Aeg

lta

ntoa

ot

d

that

lhe

sout

h-w

est

was

virt

uU

y un

oltcu

pied

to

bel

oca

td

in

th

nort

hshy

trn

cor

ner

ofA

no

lia T

heM

yce

ne

an h

eory

is I

orge

ly b

ased

on

the

qu

ti

ofM

illo

w

d

it

hM

ilt

u

whe

re t

here

is

know

n M

ycen

=

tIem

nt

Att

ralt

t

h

ou

gh

lhia

cqu

aun

iil

ltr

eate

S

l

pro

bl

hi

cb

iIl

hav

eto

be

l

ved

bef

i

en

gi

n

univ

enal

ce

ptan

c bull

ltis

fori

nst

anco

har

dw

bullbull

ho

MiH

awan

d

ifi

isM

ilo

tus

en

be

fute

din

toth

epmof~Anatoliantawithoulplacmgome

oft

hem

in

du

dn

gA

ruw

m

thep

rob

lem

aric

alo

uth

w

tern

ar

nd

ven

ifo

nea

min

terp

rett

heg

mg

rap

hic

alev

iden

cein

wsy

wh

ich

ke

ep

Ar

wa

in L

yd

i

it is

equa

lly d

illi

cuit

to

how

reJ

allo

n

betw

en

theH

ittU

e

and

Ml

law

anda

jAhh

iya

w

heth

er f

rien

dly

or

oh

erw

ise

cou

ldb

aveb

een

mi

nta

ined

attt

mes

wh

mah

ost

ileA

ru

a

Iy

belw

n

he

wo

It

al

so n

ec

ry

tO

Uil

ume

from

h

e le

Xu

l

~d~~~~~

o~tr~r~~~lou~i~~

evld

nce

-a1t

houg

h it

can

of c

ourS

e be

roa

sona

bly

cbim

ed t

hal

ueh

ro

idm

gpar

ti

o

uld

beu

nli

kel

ytn

l

yre

cogn

i2ab

leph

ysic

ol

tr

o

f th

eir

prc

ene

gt7

Th

eo t

he

is t

he bull

d

ce

of

tra

ty d

raw

n u

pab

ou

ta3

ob

etw

_b

Hit

til

andth~landofAmutruonthe

Lbullbull

bullnti

ne=

rln

this

t

ryt

heru

lo

fAm

urru

isfo

rbid

dnt

oall

ow

hip

ofA

hh

y

aro

lrad

lu

ou

gh

tbep

ort

sofA

mu

fJU

Wlt

hA

yr

ia

t

hat

rim

e H

itti

m

) ~ow i

itr

uetb

(h

ere

isb

un

d

ev

iden

ce o

fMy

=

lrad

e m

th

LeY

ltnt

and

evid

cnce

too

of

that

o

rade

g

tlyd

ecli

ning

lt J~So-JOampotitisimpot1ntorembor

thai

Myo

ena

n r

raamp

wo

spu

rcy

taIm

ch

cte

r T

here

evid

at1

1 of

Myc

enae

n g

ood

pn

etra

tmg

far

inla

nd

nd

pas

sing

Ih

roug

hLev

anti

n t

ernt

ory

to b

e re

cel

d i

n A

ssy

ia

If t

he t

rade

w

as o

fu

ffid

ent

Impo

rtan

ce f

or

Hi

ute

kin

g ro

try

to

put bullbullr

op

ro i

t o

n

mig

ht e

pec

to

me

ign

o

f M

yceJ

3C

an p

otte

ry e

of

the

Eup

hrat

es

Nev

rth

I

th

eAh

biy

awaj

M=

oea

n G

rtk

qu

n

has

ov

erth

e y

b

een

tro

nl

y a

nd p

ersu

asiv

ely

argu

ed

and

i

il w

ith s

ome

hesi

tati

onlh

ltth

bullbulll

temariv~viewismainroindher

bull l

thao

nh

een

d

w b

bullbull

dmitt

erl

thah

eev

idn

i

bull

pre

snt

in

uffi

cien

t to

off

conc

lusi

pro

off

nre

ih

erca

se

Wha

t w

e re

ally

nee

d be

fore

we

can

pt o

ne

de

IX

the

othe

r IS

som

elthi

ng r

athe

r m

oe

u

re t

han

dedu

lttio

D8

mad

fr

om t

he H

omr

ic p

o

O

D w

ha

un

)th

ing

th

M

yce1

13ea

nca

1led

them

selv

bullbull E

yld

enc

cfro

mu

nea

rSte

nu

ldb

in

lu

bJe

wou

ld

infO

J1Jt

t1on

frO

Jn

som

e

sid

e so

uc

e_o

ay

lIg

arit

-on

wha

t M

ylte

neO

Jul

reca

lld

by

tbei

rcon

tcm

pora

ries

Jo

On

edy

uch

bull

dl9

lco

may

bf

ou

nd

bu

ttb

atd

aYlS

lgtO

lty

ctl

inti

ln

com

oo

neh

asto

tak

eup

thep

osi

io

nw

hic

bse

to

bt

h

mO

li p

robl

bl

in t

erllt

5 oflh~ e

vide

nce

tber

e i

A

ocor

dng

Iy

ho

hi

tori

ltal_

tro

cli

on

wh

ilth

foll

nw

tn

thi

bo

ok

ib

ase

d

the

lSS

umpt

that

Mil

lw

anda

loy

on

he

shor

es o

fthe

Sea

of M

orm

n

dth

atA

hh

iyaw

ato

o

iu

ate

d

ll

in

pu

1i

nl1

Olt

h_

w

t A

nOlo

Iia

nd

vcry

pro

bbl

y in

clud

ed

rri

ory

t

heE

uro

n

sh

ofl

h

Sea

of

Mar

mor

bullbull

well

H

owev

er

an a

lter

nny

e m

ap

providedwihMillwandaM~otubullbulln

dA

rza

in

the

uth

and

thoo

c w

hod

sogr

ee w

th t

h

relt

onst

ruo

ion

can

6Ilo

w h

eir

own

~p

~~

ro

u~~

~~~~t

i~~

~g~~~

~

n~mentofa

ug

gest

edab

ovei

scc

epe

dth

~oe

rall

pic

tue

o

fAn

ao

Jian

geo

gra

ph

yn

dh

isto

rym

akbullbull

E

f

itn

toa

gn

eral

pat

tern

ofe

con

Olt

1le

nec

essi

tya

nd

hee

lfu

rtso

fth

var

io

t

ales

am

be

I b

e di

rect

ed t

owar

ds

thin

g m

ore

perm

anen

t th

an t

h

arbi

tror

yom

biio

nsof

indi

VK

Iual

oove

reis

n

The

pro

ble

m o

f ti

n a

uppl

iBS

nt

tem

pti

ng

loju

srif

yth

v

iew

wem

ayn

ow

retn

mo

Ho

ttu

Oil

isan

d

hi

cam

paig

n ag

Uos

t A

rz

I

up

p

oslt

iu

nm

ow

n

He

may

ha~

be

en a

trac

kedf

rom

heh

ind

he

n hi

bullbull

tte

ntro

nwo

dir

ecte

d ro

the

out

h

b

utc

qu

ally

h

ep

edio

on

my

bel

ink

edw

ub

on

e

crb

ed

ro

Lab

mas

in

a la

ter

bullbullty

III

th~ltou~ofwhib

bo

thA

ru

a an

d W

lIu

w

OTec

on

q

ere

dl

fe

no

was

kw

hat

hi

mp

ort

a nlt

eofW

ilus

w

asa

glan

ee a

t h

e m

ap W

Jll

ho

wu

sfo

rWil

u

by

trid

eth

b

och

o

ftn

eno

r(h

enr

ou

lep

rcv

Wu

sly

men

tio

ned

wln

che

dfr

t

hL

and

of

Hot

tilo

nonh

-wlt

mem

n

atoJ

ioan

dfro

mth

mac

ross

thes

t

tsin

to

Eu

ope

Was

ih

on

ro

d

wh

ich

pro

vo

ked

Hit

ri

n

esti

nth

ro

ute

ashadeconomicftorinlhsoutb-estalooAodifoowh~tartid

otm

are

rial

cam

eto

Ha

usa

salo

ng

tbr

ou

W

cn

on

lyg

ues

sfo

r n

o H

Itti

te m

onar

ch

ver

gIv

es

any

hint

o

f

ie m

i

es i

n

atto

ckin

gm

akin

g a

tr

y w

ilh

oo

ther

wi

se

ok

ing

0 in

flue

nce

ooot

herc

oun

ry

It h

a b

een

51tg

ges

d t

ha

thi

tOU

le to

o w

ti

n-r

ou

te

Id

ing

thro

ugh

the

Su

u

and

eve

ntua

llyr

o h

tic

h

u

rces

ofB

oh

i

a

An

dll

utt

lead

on

sdlr

eltt

lyto

th

vxe

d qu

esrio

n o

f th

e so

urce

or

oo

uro e

so

fth

eti

h

ichW

28W

idl

yuse

dint

hm

anuf

tu

rcof

bron

IU

n o

rui

eotA

naro

lio I

nc

ide

ng

rhiq

uest

ion

drlt

ady

touc

hed

on in

dt

opt

o

nem

ust

tak

ein

toac

cou

nle

vid

ence

fro

mth

oE

arly

aru

l M

iddl

e B

ran

A

ges

wel

l bullbull

the

Hit

tite

p

cd

It i

s d

ut

for

inSt

ance

th

at

in

the

dnn

m

Uen

nium

BC

h

pe

nen

tage

ofc

oppe

r_]

sed

ar

tifO

Cts

con t

slni

ngm

cret

han)

iYep

erce

ntl

lnis

rou

chh

igh

rin

no

nh

shyw

este

rnan

dcet

ttra

l A

o o

Jia(

nd

lso

nonh

-wes

tern

Ira

n) th

an i

t ii

n

nelg

hbou

ing

ar

uc

h

es

opot

ami

Syr

i

Egy

ptn

d C

ret bull

Th

e o

bv

iou

co

nc

usi

on

lob

dra

wn

fro

mth

isis

thal

ther

e

tin-s

ourlt

e

I

~ ~ iil ~

s Q

Q ~ s

ojgt

CD