10

/:

))Nelson Mandela(())OUA. ((*

:

112001.

.

.

))en Somalie(())en Bosnie((

))au Kosovo(())au

Rwanda. (())((

11

.

.

.

))OTAN(())au Kosovo((1999

.

))OTAN((.))KOFI ANANE((

19992000

))((1.

)) :

))au Rwanda(())en Bosnie((

. ((2

12

))Westphalie((1648

))THE REPONSIBILITY TO PROTECT(())R2P((

.

....

:

:

:

:

13

.

:

....

.3

.

.

14

.

.4

:1

.

.2

Perroux

5.

15

.

6.

.

7.

16

Scelle)) :

8. ((

.

))Westphalie((91648.

.

17

:

10.

.

.

.

18

11.

)()(12.

.:

.

19

Tanke )()) :

.

:13.((

14.

)) :

20

.

––

((15.

:

)). ((16

.

.

21

.

.

.

.

.17

..

:

.

:.

.

22

..

.:

18

19

.20

.

.

.

23

.

..

.21

:

))ICISS((2001

))(())((

.

1948.

24

.

1866187719021860

1860.22

))ROUGIER: ((

((.........23.

.:

11919:

1919..

.

25

281919.

227

))GUILLAUME II((.

228

24.

.25

1920895.

26

1907))MARTENS((:

((27.

26

))MARTENS((

.28

))MARTENS((

.

1915.))((1920

1923))LAUSANNE((

29.

.1917

27

))BOSPHORE(())DARDANELLES((

.30

2:227228

227

227.

.227

)) :))GUILLAUME II((

.

28

..((31

.227

227.1921

228

))LEIPZIG((228.32

3))LEIPZIG((1923:

227228))LEIPZIG. ((

458951919.

1919

29

.111919

))LEIPZIG((231921.1923

.

.33

:

))MOSCOU(())CHURCHILL(())ROOSVELT(())STALINE((1943

))STALINE(())HITLER((.

.

30

.

.

.

:.

.3481945))NUREMBERG. ((191946

))TOKYO. (())NUREMBERG(())TOKYO((

.

31

.35

..36

))NUREMBERG((.37

.

.38

32

:1948

.

)) :

...:

((39.

)) :

((40.

.

.41

33

:

.

:195519931955

.1958.

.

...

..

:

.

34

42.

..

181543.

.

1954196119651956

19501968......

1985

.1986

35

.....

.

.:

.

))OUA((.

))UA((

))OUA((

.

2005

))UA((2000

:))

. ((44

45

36

.

.....

:))ICISS((::

1994.

..

.

.46

37

1999

.))BELGRADE((

))((

47

1995

.

.

1992/1993

38

.

.

.

..

.

..

.

.))KOFI ANANE((

1999))((

39

.....

.:))...........

48

2000

))ICISS((.

.

.

.

40

2000))OTTAWA((

.

.

.

.))OTTAWA((

))PARIS(())BEIJING(())GENEVE(())SAINT PETERSBOURG((

))SANTIAGO(())LE CAIRE(())LONDON(())MABUTU(())NEWDELHI((

))NEW YORK(())WASHINGTON((..

41

..49

))((

......:

1::

:.

:

.

2::

:.:24

.:

.

42

:.3::

:

50.

:

.

:

.

4:::

.

51.

43

:

.))((:

.

.

.

..

.

.

52.

44

.......:

.))...((532/7))((.

))((

))((.54

55

.

.

45

.

.))((

))((

.

.

..

.

46

))((.56

.

:

.

.

47

.57

.

.

.

:

:

48

:

:

:

:

.58

:2005

184.

.....

....

49

59

2005:

..

.

.

.

.

50

.

.

. ((60

.

.

.

.

.61

51

.

.

..

.

.

.

52

.

.

.62

.

.

.

53

.

.

.

.

:

.

.:

.

54

.

.

.63

.

.

.64

.

55

.

.

:138139

2005:

65.

.

.

.

.

.66

56

.

.

.

2005.

2005.

.2005

138139

:676869

.

57

:

.

.

..

....

.

.

.

58

.

.

.

.

.

.

59

.

:

.70

..

60

:-)(01.*-81998:

.-.1-/A/57/((303)) .2-/A/57/((303)) ..3-/

200676.4-)(

19793..-)BERTRAND BADI(

.Un Monde Sans Souveraineté – Fayard –Paris – 1999 – p 19,20

-.-.

5-198664.

6-))((2821998194.

7-19781012.

61

8-))((331982

213.9-

141274.10-1978

911-1978

27.12-36

402199717.13-))((

331982214215.

14-19863940.

15-1111993

11.16-2/7.17-51.18-1/1.19-.20-.21-A/57/((303)) – p 30,31 .

62

22-/))((

141248.-23 A ROUGIER – La Théorie De L’intervention D’humanité –

RGDIP – 1910 – p 468 .24-/

1975225))((1997

63.25-

200212.-26 1919 Commission Report, Supra Note 09 .

FIODOR MATENS.

-27 Hague Convention, Supra 1907 – 10 Note 14 ,Preamble((Emphasis added)) .

28-200214

-29 Treaty With Turkey And Other Instruments,july 24,1923 ( treaty oflausanne), reprinted in 18 AJIL 1 (supp 1924) .

30-200215.

-31 TREATY OF VERSAILLES, SUPRA NOTE 6 , AT136(EMPHASUS ADDED)

32-200217.

33-2002.

34-200225.

63

35-2001.

36-1978173.

37-199852.

38-200846.

39-.40-.41-2/7.42-/3.43-

141234.44-.45-.46-A/57/303 – p 16 .

-))OTAN. ((47-/A/57/303 – p 16 ..48-/A/57/303 – p 17 .

-))))(())((2000

))ICISS((

......

64

''''.

/A/63/PV.96-101.49-/A/57/303 – p 18 .50-A/57/303 – p 12 .51-/A/57/303 – p 13 .52-A/59/56553-.54-A/59/56555-

.56-A/59/56557-A/59/56558-A/59/56559-2005

.-2004

.

:

65

.60-:A/RES/60/1 – P 41 .61-/A/57/303 – p 34 .62-A/57/303 – p 3563-36-A/57/303 – p64-A/57/30365-))A/RES/60/1. ((

-2005.

66-–A/63/PV.96-101.67-6A/CONF.183/968-7A/CONF.183/969-8A/CONF.183/9

-:....70-28 , 29 .A/57/((303)) – p

66

/-1

:

...

.. ..

)1(

.

.

67

.....

.

...

)2(03/09)3()4(

.

68

03/09

.:

:

:

:

:1(:

...

)5(.

69

.

-)6(.)7(

-

:––.-

.

..

»

...«.

70

)1987(»

)8(«.03/09

3/7»«.

90/266)9(

)10(

89-0271989

)2(::

:)11(

.

71

.

3/109/03»

«.

:1(

.2(

.

:3(

.

72

.

.....

.

.

.

:

:»«)12(

73

.

..

3(:

.09/03

:

3/209/03»

«

3/17»«.

74

03/09

..

:3/1009/03

)13(

)14(.

)15(.

75

)16(

.

:3/1709/03»

«

.

09/03

::

.

76

)17(

.

:

1(:

...

)3/410(09/03.

77

2(:

)3/4(.

)18(17-1809/03.

3(:

)19(

)20(.

78

.

4(

(:

:

:

.

79

)21(

68.

.

:

......

)22(

.

80

5(

.

)23(

09/03)3-17-18(

)24(

:

)25(

81

)26(

)27(

.

86.

1(

)28(

.

82

)29(

09/03)30(

)31(

2(

.

83

(:

.

...)32(

.

84

09/0317-18

(

)33(110)34(

.09/03

)35(

09/03

)36(.

85

.

::09/03

:

379)37(.

)38(379

09/03.

379

09/03

86

)39(

)40(.

2(

.

)41(

.

.

.

87

.

1(:

.

.

2(:

.

)42(

88

.

.

)43(

.

09/03

.

:

.

89

.

1(:

)44(

1761401.

2(:

379

138

.

138/1

90

138

176.

3(

.

176

91

)45(.

09/0303/11...»:/

/«1316

...

.

92

.

)46(.

)(

)(09/03

)47(.

93

138352-37909/03

.

:

.

09/03.

94

)(

...)3/4-17-1809/03....

.

.

.

95

09/03)3-17-18(

)3/19-1316(09/03.

379

.

96

)379()138(

)176.(

.

09/03)3/13-13-16.(

97

:

109/03.

2-:09/03.

3-:09/0326/02/20091508/03/2009.

89/0207/02/1989.

4-:)01()03(.

:)04()24(.

/)252152(.

/)53/85(

/)8695.(

5)5678(.

::–4

990/26615/09/199040.

1089/02)/

.

98

/(

11//2

12

.

:../.

2-3-4.

1303/1103/0937903/1903/09.

1403/09.

1503/12-1310-11-12:03/09.

164-5-6-7-803/09

173/41003/09

18///364.

19/361.

201996

21-22

99

2159-60.

22/433.

2321-22.

24

:03/09.

25:8191.

26352.

27379.

2886.

29131720:03/09.

30:3-17-18:03/09

313/191316:03/09.

32/372.

21.

33

.

100

)110(:03/0919.

.....

.

34110""

""

35212803/09.

36253403/09.

37/

02/201041.

38/.40.

391303/09.

406003/09.

41/470.

42352-379.43/

2041996

237.

101

44/483.

45/484.

46

1982101.

47

.

:244.

102

1(/

.

2(1996.

3(–1982

:

1(..

2(/20-

041996.

3(/-02

/2010

:103/09262009

15082009

103

289/020719896081989

3755826

19757830/09/197507-05132007.

490/26615/199004