Αεροπορική Επιθεώρηση τ.89
DESCRIPTION
Περιοδικο - Έκδοση του ΓΕΑTRANSCRIPT
-
/
() ( )
() ( )
.: 210 8192615
&
.. 407/80
- ()
/ .: 210 8079444 - 210 8192040
/
T: 89
2009, : 49
()
.: 210 8192600, FAX: 210 2467682
-
1 ( , ,
) :
* * * * * * :
,
* - , .
* -
' - . .
- , , / ( ASCII ) , , , , sli des, .
. - , .
. .2/76198/0022/ ( 208//11-
02-2008). , , (: 210 8192045) .
1,17 . / , / - - 1010. 2320016 - 5 ( / - . 2108192047).
- 89
-
- 892
15 ()
4
20
34
,
20
() .
48
(French Carrier Strike Group)
(1469-1527)
60
()
74
()
12
-
- 89 3
94
1940-41
()
84
.
110
+
.
120
.
156 ...
() ..
136I 20
152
/
160
-
4 - 89
( (FrenchFrenchCarrier Strike GroupCarrier Strike Group))
-
5 - 89
2009 2010 - (French Carrier Strike Group). PEAN 2009 MEDOR 2010 . - Charles de Gaulle (R91) Cassard, Georges Leygues, La Fayette, Durance - Rubis.
Charles de Gaulle Rafale-M F-3, - Super Etendard - -2 Hawkeye. Mirage-2000/-5, F-16 Blk30/50/52+/52M,F-4 (AUP) ERIEYE/EMB-145H .
[Defensive Counter Air(DCA)] [Combined AirOperations (COMAO)]. SuperEtendard Mirage-2000 332 - -39Exocet- LINK-16 - .
LINK-16 - - F-16 Blk52M 335 ERIEYE/EMB-145H 380 .
-
6 - 89
-
7 - 89
, 335 Rafale F3 Flotille 12, , - , . LINK-16 - .
Super Etendard Mirage-2000 332 - - AM-39 Exocet Blk2.
- -39 Exocet - . , -, , - -.
Exocet , , , , - .
, - -39 Exocet , , - Mirage 2000EGM , - . anti-jamming - .
-
8 - 89
-
9 - 89
- 12 , . , .
2007 332 114 . - .
- - - - .
8.4.2010
-
10 - 89
Charles De Gaulle (R91) La Fayette
Mirage-2000 Rafale-M F3
ERIEYE/EMB-145H
-
11 - 89
Cassard Georges Leygues
Rafale-M () F3 Super Etendard
Rubis Durance
-
12 - 89
, ,
-
13 - 89
. 1940-41
, . -, - . , , - - 1941, . , - , .
, - , 7,5 - .
- 731 - , - - 1941. - - , - . . -, .
: - 2,5 - - - - , .
, . , -, , , - . , - .
. .
. , -.
, . -, - -.
-
14 - 89
, - ( - -) - - .
***
, - , .
1941 - - - , - - .
, , - ( ).
-- , , .
( ),
1941 - - - , - 1943 - 17 -.
() , 614 1942 . , , - . 14 1943 , 86 -, . - . 1 , - . & .
() ( ) -. 1941 . . , . , .. , , - ... 20 1942, Waffen SS. O , 4 1943 . & .
-
15
. -
- - Avro Anson 13 , 23 1941 Marsa Matruh. - Avro 626 Avro 621, - . - 29 Dornier 21 Aboukir . - .
- - - (), . 46 4 - 1941.
***
- Avro, Gauntlet GlosterGladiator, . -
RAF , . - 1944 27 - .
V.
Avro Anson, - - 1941 13 14 - .
Blenheim MK IV 1941, Blenheim MK V, - - 1942 1943. 1943 .
Baltimore MKIII 1943 13 - ( ) - .
- 89
Avro Anson MkI 13 -
Bristol Blenheim
-
16 - 89
1944 1600 - 4550 - 13 .
1944 - - 6 - , 7 , 3 , 4 7 ,, 9 . - 1400 3 8 - - - .
***
7 1941 Agiz 335 8 Hawker Hurricane MK I HawkerHurricane MK Ib c. 265 - .
1942 - - , .
1942 El Daba 17 - .
1942 - . - |-. EL ALAMEIN, 23.10.1942 - , -.
, , 28 1942, 1940. -, - . -
Martin A-30 Baltimore 13
Hawker Hurricane. 335 .
(--)
-
17
.
, - , - .
23 1943 - 8 , 184 30 , - .
1943 Hurricane Spitfire Vb Vc. 335 4.000 10.
***
- - , 336 , 25
1943 - AL MAZA 21Hurricane MK IIc. 335 1 23 1943 5 , , - .
- , . - ( )
, .
, - - 25.3.1944 - , Stalag Luft III - -
- 89
Spitfire
()
-
18 - 89
. 336 4-9, -.
14.11.1943 . - Marsa Matruh 1944.
- . - 1944, .
336, 335 - - - - (sweep).
- - 335 , - , . 336 , - - . .
1944 - , - DC 3.
V. - ,
, -
, - . - , , . , .
2 , , -. , , - - , 2+2 4, 3 3,5 4,5 . .
***
- .
1821, 1940-44.
.
, - - ,
El Adem 1944 336 Spitfire Vc
-
19
-.
, .
, , . - ; -.
.
- 89
, , , - 2004Simon GOODNOUGH, War Maps, New York (Martins press) 1982
-
15 15 **
(..) , , . - . , - , . , -, . , . .. , , , , - , . .. (soft & smart) . , , .. - , - .
, 15 1 , , , - (.. ) Effects Based-Approach on Operations2 ( ).
; , , -
, . , - , , , . , , , . , .3 ;
20 - 89
1 ..2 Effects Based Operations (EBO- ), Comprehensive Approach( . ), Whole-of-Government Approach ( ). , . 3 , , : , / : . , : :Yale Ferguson & Richard Mansbach, /GEOLAB-, :2009. . . , . 24-25:
-
.. , , . 20 - [: ]. , , , . , . , / anom-alies. , . , , , !..........4 ( 2 )5 .6 .7 Joint Forces Air Component Commands8 , , . , 1940, Robert McNamara () , 1943 . , B-29.
, , , , , - . , . , -, , .
. . .
; (1991),
4 . , , -: () ( (/) GPS) 5, , - ( ), 6 ( ), .
; , . , -
, (1991) GPS . (JFACCs7 ) adhoc de facto : - , .8
21 - 89
-
22 - 89
tomahawk, ; - (carpet bombing), .
, , ;
;
1 ; .. ,
( ) (mass to mass). , - .
. . , . Sun Tzu9 , !
(10 ) , - , :, , , ..
, , , .
, 3-4 100, .
, 1-2 , . , , .
, , , -.
; tomahawk , -
, . , . : (System of SystemsTheory), (Complex Adaptive System)
.. .
9 100 100 , . .10 . .
-
23
, , .
. . - .
, , - !
.
; ,
() -, (, TV, , R/T, ) - , ( ) . -, . - , , .11
- 89
11 .
-
24 - 89
EBO;
! ! . - ( ), . -!
: , ++ -, , - ( ), +++. . , ( 1991), - 12 - .
; !!!
13, - , () - , 14 - ( ) .15
, . , ! , , Anders Fogh Rasmussen, Military is no longer the complete answer16.
, , - . 2 (2003) ( ). , , , .
12 . 13 14 Jobbagy Z., Literature Survey on Effects-Based Operations-A Ph.D. study on measuring military effects and effec-tiveness, TNO Physics and Electronics Laboratory (The Hague-The Netherlans), . 11-14. 15 , , .. (capabil-ities) . 16 http://andersfogh.info/2010/03/04/military-is-no-longer-the-complete-answer/
-
25
, -, 17, , - .18
, .
;
, , , - . = = = (- ).
, (post war end state), . , .19
20 , , -, , (as a free country). , - . post waroperations.21
- 89
17 , , . . , , . . Jean-Jacques Roche(Professeur de Science politique lUniversit Panthon-Assas), Le diplomate et le soldat : questions de prsances,Le Figaro, 12 Fvrier 2006. , . .18 , , , : (system of systems). 19 , (hearts and minds). ( ). ; 20 , , (). 21 , (. Mearsheimer J. John, , . -W.W.NORTON & COMPANY, 2007 (.), .XVII, 473-531, 744-764), , - , ( ).
-
26 - 89
;! (2010) ! ,
- . , .
, - , - , , . - , . , - , () .
; , (..)
() , , , - 22
22 .
-
27
, ., ().
(. ) , , ().23,24
.., , . - (lessons learned) . - , , .
, , , ( ). .. ( ), . - , - .
. (effects), - (effects) .
soft .
, , (soft) , , , , , , - .
, (..) () , , -, .
- , 1989, , . , (The great-est strength of America is that people want to live there).25
- 89
23 ( ): Military, OGDs, Allies, IOs,NGOs, PMCs, Media, Indigenous Populations, Multi-National Corporations, Universities / think-tanks, IndividualsOpportunists. 24 , McCrystal - . , .25 . , - , : . A PONZI SCHEME THAT WORKS, The greateststrength of America is that people want to live there, The Economist, page 69-70, December 19th 2009.
-
28 - 89
soft soft ,
. , , . - .
soft , , , - .
26 .27 , - , , , , , - .
..; -
, - (post conflict operations) .
.. ; . , -
: . , , - .
, (,, , soft & ) . , , .28 - .
26 27 , , , .28 Visa - . , . - .
-
29
, . :
, 1974-2010 ( ) 2010-2025 2030. - . (Hellenic Effects Based-Approach29 ) - - , - .30
- 89
29 HelEBA30 (). Effects Based-Approach , - , , -. , (2010) , . , , (MoD) Comprehensive Approach ( ). .
-
30 - 89
. , , , ( ), . , .
, . , -, , - .
, , - upsilondiaeresis , - () . upsilondiaeresis .
.. ( -) , , ( ).31
, , - , : (), , .32
- .
,33 , ( ) , - .
31 (.) . , upsilondiaeresis - , . ( , ), () . . - , upsilondiaeresis, (), , . 32 , (. , , 07, ) , .33 - (.. .
-
31
1. Israel and NATO Between, Membership and Partnership, A Working Paper in Preparationfor the Herzliya Conference 2010, Shlomo Ben AmiJanuary 14, 2010, Oslo, Prof. Shlomo Ben Ami.,Executive Vice President, Toledo International Center for Peace (CITpax). 2. A Multi-Polar Nuclear Middle East How, it Will Operate?, A Working Paper in Preparationfor the Herzliya Conference 2010, Shmuel Bachar, Shmuel Bar, Rachel Machtiger, Former Minister ofForeign Affairs of Israel. 3. , / : . , -: :Yale Ferguson & Richard Mansbach, : /GEOLAB-, :2009,: . . : .4. , . , GEOLAB - , :. - . .5. , . . ,. -. . , . , :GEOLAB - :. . . 6. & - , :. , :Geolab/, :2007, -: . .7. & O : . , : , 1989.8. Turkish Political Islam and its role in the Geopolitical Complex of the Middle East, . . : . , - : , :1991. 9. : :. . , : , :2002. 10. , , , 1997 ( Theorie des Krieges, 1988).11. MEARSHEIMER J. John, , .-W.W.NORTON & COMPANY, 2007 (. ).12. ., & , , 2006. 13. BISCOP Sven & COOLSAET Rik, THE WORLD IS THE STAGE-A GLOBAL SECURITYSTRATEGY FOR THE EUROPEAN UNION, Groupement dEtudes et de Recherches (Pres.JacquesDELORS), Policy papers No 8 , December 2003. 14. VAN EVERA Stephen, , --Cornell University, , 2005.15. Greene Robert, The 33 Strategies of War, A JOOST ELFFERS BOOK, Penguin Books, USA2006. 16. , , , 1997 ( Theorie des Krieges, 1988).17. Effects Based Operations, Strategy, Concepts and Doctrine Air Combat Command, USAF.18. HAIDER Sajjad and Alexander H. Levis, Fellow, IEEE, Effective Courses of action to achievedesired effects.19. DEPTULA David, Effects Based Operations: Change in the nature of warfare, AerospaceEducation Foundation, Defense and Airpower Series, 2001, Virginia.20. DEPTULA David, Fires for Effects, Air Force magazine , April 2001, Vol.84, No4,http://www.afa.org/magazine/April2001/0401effects_print.htm. 21. Rapid Decisive Operations (RDO), US Joint Forces Command. 22. RICHTER Andrew, Lessons from the Revolution: What Recent Military Operations RevealAbout the Revolution in Military Affairs and Future Combat, Journal of Military and Strategic Studies,Sprong 2005, Vol.7, Issue 3. 23. DAVIS Paul, Effects Based Operations-A Grand Challenge for the analytical community,RAND-NDRI and Project Air Force (Prepared for the office of the secretary of defense and the UnitedStates AirForce), 2001.
- 89
-
32 - 89
24. JOBBAGY Z., Literature Survey on Effects-Based Operations-A Ph.D. study on measuringmilitary effects and effectiveness, TNO Physics and Electronics Laboratory (The Hague-TheNetherlans). 25. JOBBAGY Z., Effects-Based Operations and the Problem of Thinking Beyond: A CriticalReflection, Clingendael Center for Strategic Studies, March 2006, The Hague, The Netherlands. 26. JOBBAGY Z., Effects-Based Operations and the Age of Coplexity, Militaire Spectator, JRG175 , 5-2005.27. Air Force Luxury or Necessity?, Clingendael Center for Strategic Studies, February 2006,The Hague, The Netherlands.28. Necessary Choices, Clingendael Center for Strategic Studies, February 2006, The Hague,The Netherlands.29. ZOBBAGY Z., Literature survey on Effects-Based Operations, A PhD study on measuring mil-itary effects and effectiveness, TNO Physics and Electronics Laboratory, 2003.30. CHEEK Gary, Effects-Based Operations:The End of Dominant Maneuver?, US Army WarCollege, Carlisle Barracks, 2002. 31. SEOW Hiang Lee, Center of Gravity or Center of Confusion, Understanding the Mystique, AirCommand and Staff College, Air University, Maxwell AFB, Wright Flyer Paper No10, December 1999.32. WILCOX Greg/Wilson, Gary I., Military Response to fourth generation warfare inAfghanistan.33. WOLFE Frank, Air Force Officials to Emphasize Effects-Based Operations in QDR, DefenseDaily, 18 January 2001.34. WARDEN John A. (Col), The Enemy as a system, Air Power Journal, Spring 1995.35. SENLAUB Michael, Ph.D., The Analytic & Philosophical Imperatives of effects-BasedOperations (EBO), www.mors.org/meetings/ebo/ebo_reads/Senglab.pdf.36. YIN K. Robert, Case Study Research: Design and Methods, London:Sage Publications,2003.37. CORBETTA Piergiorgio, Social Research:Theory, Methods and Techniques, London:SagePublications, 2003.38. MEARSHEIMER J. John, , .-W.W.NORTON & COMPANY, 2007 (. ).39. ., & , , 2006. 40. BISCOP Sven & COOLSAET Rik, THE WORLD IS THE STAGE-A GLOBAL SECURITYSTRATEGY FOR THE EUROPEAN UNION, Groupement dEtudes et de Recherches (Pres.JacquesDELORS), Policy papers No 8 , December 2003. 41. , , (), 2004.42. , , , (6), 1999.
** (.. Universit Paris II-Pantheon Assas-Sorbonne ) - . [email protected]
-
33 - 89
-
34 - 89
(1469-1527) (1469-1527) , 407/80
-
35 - 89
, , . , - .
- 3 | 1469 . 1498 1512 . , - -. , - . , - , , . ( , , , , - , , , ). , - -.
1501 - . - (1503) . . : - , - , , , -. - .
1504 , . 1507 1508 , . 1508-1509 -.
(1512), - . . : - . - , - . 1513 - . , - . , , , .
-
36 - 89
. , - . .
. 1513 . - - , . . - . - . 1514 - , . 1515 1517 - , - , - . 1518 1519 -, 1525. 1520 - . 1521 - Clizia.
- . -. -. .
, , -. , . . - - - , , , , , . , .
- . . , - . - .
-, 1522, , - Orti Oricellari, . . 1525 - . - - .
21 1527, -
-
37
, .
- , - . 1559 . - . 19 .
- ,
- - - -.
, , - , -. , . . -
.
26. . . . .
- : 16 . : , - -, 14 - . , , - , . , - - . - . ,, . , , . - . . .
, . . . -
- 89
-
38 - 89
. (, ,), . . - , .
- -. - - . . - , - - - .
. - - .
- . - . : - . .
, , -
, .
- . . - . , , , . : , .
-. . , - . - . - , , - . -, . : , - .
-
- 89 39
-
40 - 89
- . , . , - , (, , ) , - . -, , -, , -, .
- , - -, - . - -. - . , , , - . - . - . . - , - . . - .
,
16 - - -. - -. - , . , - , . upsilondiaeresis . . , - , . - - .
- - , : . . - - .
-
41
. - . - . - . , .
- - - . - , . - - , , , . - .
- , . : , , , .
- . - , . - - . -
upsilondiaeresis . . - , - , , . , , -, - .
- , - . - . - , - - , -, . : - , - , - . - .
- - . : - .
- 89
-
42 - 89
. : , , , ,, - -. - , . 20 . - status quo, -. - : - , . - : - ; , () . , , - ;
. - . , - - : , , .
. , , - -.
, , , . , - - -. , , , .
- - : , , - .
-
43
- - , , - - . : .
- , , -, .
.
-, - , . - : - - - - - .
- . ,
- , ;
- :1) .2) , .
- . - .
, - - . - , , .
- , , , , , . - :, , -, -. : ) -, ) .
- , ,
- 89
-
44 - 89
- , - -.
, , , - , .
.
- -, .
- , , , .
, . -, - - - .
, . , - -
, - .
-, - - .
. - . - .
- , -.
. . , - , . - -, . , , - -, , - . .
-
45
, , -. . -. , - . , , - , . .
- , -. , , -, , , . . -, , , -. 16 .
- . . . - .
, -
- . . - .
- - . - , .
-. , -, , . - . - - , - .
- - , . - . , - - - , .
- . . - -.
- 89
-
46 - 89
-. - - - , . . - , . , , . - -, - .
- -, -. ( - , ) . - .
Leopoldvon Ranke : . , - , , - , .
- -.
- - . - . .
, - , . - -. , - , , . , , . , , -. , , , . - , - , -, .
-
47
, , . ., . , , 2004 ., , . , , . , 1984
., , , 1995 . , Niccolo Machiavelli, , . -
-, , 2001 , , University studio press, , 2009
Gherel F., La pensee de Machiaveli en France, Paris, 1935
- 89
-
48 - 89
H H 20 20
() .
1898-1908, 1897( ) , , . . . , , .
, 1904-1908. , .
1910 , . . 11 1910 25 1912 , . upsilondiaeresis, , .
-
49 - 89
1912-19131912-1913
1909 . , - , , 12 1910 - . - - - . 1911 - .
1912 - . - (29/3 1912), . - - , - - . , - , . , - ,
, . - . - , - , - . 1911 ( Geshov , - Geshov - ), - 1912 - (16/29 | 1912). - . , , - . -. , - - . - - - . - . -.
5 1912, - , - . - , - , . , , -
-
50 - 89
, , , - 26 1912, . , , 1912. , , , , 22 1913.
, - -, , - ( , ) . , - . - 17/30 |1913, , , . . , . - , -.
16 17 1913, - - , . - -, - , -
. ,
, - . . - , . . (28/7-10/81913) - - -- .
- -, , -.
- - --
1909 -.
, - , - - .
-
51
- . , - .
, -, , - , 1908, | , -. - Bleriot, 30HP. , . - , - - - .
- , - Farman, 50 , . - , - .
., , .
1912 Nieuport, 50 , . -, | . , 8 1912, , . -
.. - , - , - . - () - (12-2-1912) - . -, -
. -
. Bleriot, 50 , 17-7-1912 ( 26/3/1912). 19-8-1912 . , , , - (3.050). -
- 89
Bleriot- & Nieuport -
-
52 - 89
, . 29-8-1912 . , - - , . .
- 1911 , - Eudoux. 1911 - , - Henry Farman, - (, , ), 1912 (, ,).
1912 - , - . , , HenryFarman, 50 HP, , . . 13 | 1912 . ( - ), - -. (14 19 | 1912) - , - , . 27 | 1912 . . ( -
), -.
- -. . - - . 22 1912 Henry Farman .. , - . (24 25 - 1912) . - 110 . .
-
-
53
1912 . - -.
Henry Farman - - . - , - - . , - , - . , -, . - . - , - , .
Farman, , 1500 ,
-, -, . - . -, - -, . , - . - Maurice Farman .
5 1912, - , . - - , . , - ( - 1911, - ).
- 89
- ( )
-
54 - 89
26 1912, . , , 15 , . , Maurice Farman, - .
1912, - Maurice Farman - - - - . - Barres , . - , , Barres . , - , . -, - , - . - , - , - - .
5 1912 . - . . - , , , - -, , . 21 1913 . , -. - . . - , . .
24 1913 - - -, , . . , - 1912 - -, . |, , - . - , - .
-
55
- . , . , - . 180, .
, 16 1913 , - - - .
1913-1916 - , , - () , - (), , - . - ( -
). - - . - - 1917, | , - , 1917.
, , , . -Denatin ( - - 1918) - - .
--
1914 - . 1915 - - -, . - - , , . - , - ( 1915), ,
- 89
- .
-
56 - 89
1916. - , - , - , , . -, 1916, . . 1916-1917 - , - .
, ( 1916), 1 1917, - , - . .
1917 - - 10 - ( - 1916 - ). 1918 - - 1918 . - ( ). - . -
1919 . .
-- , 1916- , 1916-
1918 1918
1916 . - 1917, - . Denain, - . - - - - , -. - ( ) . - , , Denain - . 18 ( 6 50 - 1916 1918 500 40 ), - 11 19 .
1918 , 531
-
57
Nieuport 24 bis Spad 532 533 - - Dorand AR-1 Nieuport, Breguet 14 Sopwith ( ). 531 532 - , 533 . . - 1916 -. 531 532 (16-18/5/1918) - , - (14-21/9/1918) 45 . - , .
- -
. | 16 1916. - 19 . - - 1916, - . 12 1916 . . |.
1917 : - .
- 89
Nieuport 531
Breguet Bre 14 ( 532 & 533)
Dorand (532 533 )
-
58 - 89
, - , , - - (.. Fokker).
31 1917, | Henry Farman , - - , , , . The Fearless Aviator.
- - , 1917, Farman155 Bristol.
1917 1918 , ,
. 4 1917 Farman . - . . , - . 1917.
1918 , - Goeben Breslau, . - , - . , - - . 276 15 .
1918 , 1, 2,3, 4. 10-12 , - . , ,
H2 -
-
59
. ( ).
, 1917-18 - , - - . 17 1918 . - , , .
, 1453.
- - - . , , . , - - ...
- 89
::- , , 1908-1918.- , 1908-1944, . & ., 2000.- 1900-1980, . .- , .
-
60 - 89
, -
1996, . , - , - , . . , -, 1.
, , -, , - . , . , - , . , , upsilondiaeresis .
()
1 , & , & (), . .., , 2002,.596.
-
61 - 89
1.
. James A.Robinson, 62 , , , :There is no theory of crises2 . .
, , , . , , .
, 3. ,
, 4 .
, ( ), , , upsilondiaeresis , (-) , .
, ( ), , , , , , ... , , 1999, 2006, S-300 , .
2 James A. Robinson, An appraisal of concepts and theories, in Charles F. Hermann, ed., International Crises,New York: Free Press, 1972, p.273 , , ,
(), , 2004, . 20.4 , , , ,
& , . . , 2002, , , 11/2001, .35.
-
62 - 89
1.1
, : - . (, , ). ( , , /Cyber-terrorists). / -(Hacking, etwars). (SARS, ). (, |, ). ( 1986).
, - . , , . , , , , . , . , :
. . , . . . upsilondiaeresis (risks). (-).
, .
1.2 (crisismanagement):
, , , , , 5 . : , 6.
5 , , , (), , 2004, . 20.6 , , , ,
& , 38.
-
63
. , 13, 2594/1998 (), () . , 2 . 4 31/2000, , , (). , ,
, , : , , , , , .
. , , ,
- 89
-
64 - 89
2.
J.F.Kennedy, The besttime to repair the roof, is when the sun isshinning7 , ,, upsilondiaeresis , . (, ,, ) ., . , , , , . . .
2.1. -
, upsilondiaeresis
. , .
2.1.1.
, . , (Crisis ManagementTeams) : - , , , , , , , - , (Damage control)
7 J.F. Kennedys Annual Message to the Congress on the State of the Union, Jan 11th, 1962.
-
65
. , ., .
2.1.2.
, . , : ,(.. , , ...). , . , (.. , ...). / FigenAkat 26-12-95 ., . , ,
, (.. , ...) (), . , . , , - .
, , , / . , , / . , .
. . .
- 89
-
66 - 89
2.1.3.
.
1 , , - - - .
, . , , - , , -. -
, . , , , .
2.1.3.1.
: . : -/ , , -
1:
-
67
, , - , , - , , , - , .
2.1.3.2.
: - .
: - , - , , , .
2.1.3.3.
: - - - . - : , , , - (Lessons Learned), , , ...
2.2 - -
.
, - -, - . .
, -, - -. - - ,
- 89
-
68 - 89
, , 8.
1.
8 : , , ., 2003.9 , , 1997, .138-145
.
, (Blackmail) , (the limited, reversible probe) , (the strategy of controlled pressure). , (the fait accompli strategy). . (the attrition strategy).
. (coercive diplomacy). , . (limited escalation) , . (tit-for-tat). " " -. (test of capabilities). . (the strategy of "drawing a line"). -, (conveying commitment and resolve). - , . (buying time)
1: 9
-
69
. (
) - 2:
- 89
2: 10
(negotiation). , - , , , , . .
(mediation). - - . .
(arbitration). .
.
.
10 : , , ., 2003,.29.
-
70 - 89
- . , -, , , -. , -, - . , - . - , - .
, , , - . , - , , .
, - , - -, .
-
71
3.
-
, , , 11.
, . , . , . , . .
, .
, -, . , . , , . , . , , . .
, ,
- 89
11 . ., 1996. , 56, Defencenet,. 2006. . 61-69.12 , & , & (), . , , 2002, .598.
-
72 - 89
12. . (deterrence bydenial). , (deter-rence by punishment).
, , . , , .. (crisis escalation). , .. , . .
... :
, . , . , .
, , (, ,, ,) .
-, . , , statusquo , , /, .. , . , statusquo, , , , .
, , , , .. . , , - .
-
73
, , ( ) .
(, , ) , .
- 89
13 George Alexander: A Provisional Theory of Crisis Management- Avoiding War: Problems of CrisisManagement, 1991, .23.
-
-
1. George Alexander: A Provisional Theory of Crisis Management- Avoiding War:Problems of Crisis Management, 1991
2. , & , & (), . , , 2002.
3. James A. Robinson, An appraisal of concepts and theories, in Charles F.Hermann, ed., International Crises, New York: Free Press, 1972
4. , , - , (), , 2004
5. , , , & , , . ., 2002, , , 11/2001
6. Lebow, Richard N, Between Peace and War: The Nature of International Crisis.1981, ISBN 0-8018-2311-0
7. : , , ., 2003.
8. , , 1997
9. Snyder, Glenn H. and Diesing, Paul, Conflict Among Nations: Bargaining,Decision Making and System Structure in International Crises, 1977, ISBN 0-691-05664-1
1. . ., 1996. , - 56, Defencenet, . 2006
-
74 - 89
, - , -, - . , -, - , , , . , - , - .
- , -. - .
, , - - 1. , , - . , - ( )., 2006 (crisis
management).
1999, - , - . (Conflict Prevention) (Crisis Management). - , , .
*** -
. - -, , . - . , - .
7 - ( , 1949) . 4, 5 7 2. , - - , - --.3
()
-
75 - 89
4 - . : , , -, - 4. - , - , .
, - . - , - , / . - .
- , , -, - (North Atlantic Council) .
, - - : - , . - ,
, - (CrisisResponse Operations). NRF (Nato Response Force) ( ISAF-International Security Assistance Force ..)5. NRF 5 , - , - ( - - ). 5 : , , . , , , 51 , () , , - , - 6.
. 7.
, - , , , , -
-
76 - 89
. , , - . 1997 : - , , , - 8.
, ... , , , .
- - (Military Committee), ( ) - (Crisis Response Operations). -, - , - . , . / - , -
(Status kvo ante).
- - . , , . 1991 .
, , , , , , , - (- ). - - , , - - - OSCE(Organization for Security and Co-opera-tion in Europe). - , PfP.
PfP (Partnership forPeace) - 1994. - . - (NorthAtlantic Cooperation Council) - -
-
77
(Conference for Securityand Cooperation in Europe). (PfP) 27. PfP - , - . - , PfP - , , - 9.
PfP (, -, , ). - , , PfP 10.
***
, -, , -. , (NorthAtlantic Council) - - (DefensePlanning Committee). - - - . - . - . - (, , - ) . ,
, , ( ) , - - (Military Committee, PoliticalCommittee, Senior Civil EmergencyPlanning Committee, Crisis ResponseCommittee). - . , - , - - - . , . - - .
-, . , - (Crisis ResponseOperations), .
- COEC (Council Operations and ExercisesCommittee) -- -. , , - , , NATOSituation Center.
(Crisis Management andOperations Directorate)
- 89
-
78 - 89
(CouncilOperations Section), (peacekeeping staff). , - - NATO Situation Center.
, (Defense PlanningCommittee) -. - - , - , ... 2003 , - .. ( 19 25 2003). .. . . - .11. E.E. (SoftPower) -, - 12. - .. - , 13. .. - .
.. 14.
- (Council Operations Section) - - , -, (Defense Planning Committee), .
(Peacekeeping Section) - -.
(NATO Situation Center), SITCEN, , (NorthAtlantic Council) - (Defense PlanningCommittee), - (Military Committee). -, - (intelli-gence and information) . , - (CommunicationCenter).
- , --. , - (Non NATO Troops ContributingNations) , - -.
/-
-
79
, - , .
, . , -, - . , - (Defense Planning Council) , - - .
- . - , - - - , -. ,, - . , - .
- 5( ) . - -, - . -, , - ,
, -.
. , - , .
, - 15 , - - , - .
-- -
-, - . -- - , - .
, --/ -, , - - -- .
-
- 89
-
80 - 89
, (Comprehensive Approach) 2006. , - -. , - , - (civil-ian) . - ( ) -, , . , - .16
MultinationalExperimental Series ( ), - - , . - , , , - .
, - . - , - . , , , (-), -. State Actors
. , - , , - (NGOs).
(Conflict) , . -.
T
-, - , . , - () - 17.
, - . 2008 , - - -.18
To NATO . , - - -19.
, , . - -
-
81 - 89
1 Handbook, NATO Office of Information and Press, 2001
2 Nato crisis management concept, PfP ADL WG, 2006, . 1-2. http://pfpdev.ethz.ch/SCORMcontent/43272/scos/12/index.pdf
3 Yoram Dinstein, War, Aggression and Set/Defense, Cambridge, 1988, . 238
4 THE AVALON PROJECT Documents in Law, History and Diplomacy, .http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/nato.asp
5 http://www.arrc.nato.int/brc
6 THE AVALON PROJECT Documents in Law, History and Diplomacy, .http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/nato.asp
7 David C. Compert and Stephen Larrabee, America and Europe: A Partnership for a New Era, Cambridge,England: Cambridge University Press, 1997, . 1-18
8 Albright, Statement at the North Atlantic Council, Federation of American Scientists, December 16, 1997, . 6 http://www.fas.org/man/nato/offdocs/us_97/970218.htm
9 John Blasing, The Secretary of Defense and the Partnership for Peace: A Policy for a Safer World, InternationalAffairs University of Colorado, Boulder, 2008, . 3 http://www.colorado.edu/artssciences/defense/John%20Blasing.pdf
10 Website Cooperative Longbow & Lancer 2009, The Partnership for Peace, 17 May 2009.http://cooperative09.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=21&Itemid=33
11 First Joint EU/NATO Crisis Management Exercise (CME/CMX 03) From 19 to 25 November 2003, Brussels, 12November 2003, EU Council Press Office, 14570/03 (Presse 320), . 1-2 https://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cmsUpload/77895%20%20Press%20information%20of%20Nov.%202003.pdf
12 Adriana Craclunescu, The EU-NATO Strategic Partnership, Strategic Planning Directorate, The General Staff,2009, . 1-4http://www.defense.ro/gmr/Engleza/Ultimul_nr/craciunescu-p.44-47.pdf
. ... - - , - , - - -.20
, . , ,
. --, , - 21.
-, , - -, , - - .
-
13 Stephen J. Gomershall, Nato and European Defense, Journal of International Affairs, Vol. 4, No.1, March-May1999, . 1-2http://www.sam.gov.tr/perceptions/Volume4/March-May1999/gomersall.PDF
14 Remarks by Javier Solana, EU High Representative for the Common Foreign and Security Policy following theagreement on the establishment of E.U-NATO permanent arrangements, Brussels, 16 December 2002, . 1-3http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cmsUpload/73803%20%20Solana%20%20Permanent%20arrange-ments%20+%20NATO%20declaration.pdf
15 D. W. Bowett, The Law of International Institutions, 4th Edition, 1984, . 180-185
16 Comprehensive Approaches to International Crisis Management, CSS, Analyses in Security Policy, Vol. 3, No.42, Oct. 2008, .1-3http://www.isn.ethz.ch/isn/DigitalLibrary/Publications/Detail/?ots591=0C54E3B3-1E9C-BE1E-2C24-A6A8C7060233&lng=en&id=93229
17 Robert L. Pfaltzgraff, Crisis Management: Looking Back and Looking Ahead, presented at the CrisisManagement Conference: Athena 2008, July 2, 2008, .1-9http://www.ifpa.org/pdf/athena_08.pdf
18 The International Institute for Strategic Studies, Military Balance 2009 Executive Summary, Europa Publications,2009, .1-4http://www.iiss.org/publications/military-balance/
19 Stanley R. Sloan, CRS Report for Congress, 97-708F, NATOs Evolving Role and Missions, March 13, 1998,.4 http://digital.library.unt.edu/govdocs/crs/permalink/meta-crs-612:1
20 Andrew A. Michta, What Next for NATO?, Orbis, Vol. 51, Issue 1, Winter 2007, .155-164http://www.rhodes.edu/faculty/AndrewMichta/Andrew_Michta/Whats_Next_for_NATO.pdf
21 Samuel Grier, Nato and 21st Century War, Nato Defense College, Research Division, Rome, October 2007,.1-76http://www.nato.int/docu/21-cent/21st_eng.pdf
82 - 89
Albright, Statement at the North Atlantic Council, Federation of American Scientists, December 16,1997. http://www.fas.org/man/nato/offdocs/us_97/970218.htm
Adriana Craclunescu, The EU-NATO Strategic Partnership, Strategic Planning Directorate, TheGeneral Staff, 2009.http://www.defense.ro/gmr/Engleza/Ultimul_nr/craciunescu-p.44-47.pdf
Andrew A. Michta, What Next for NATO?, Orbis, Vol. 51, Issue 1, Winter 2007.http://www.rhodes.edu/faculty/AndrewMichta/Andrew_Michta/Whats_Next_for_NATO.pdf
Comprehensive Approaches to International Crisis Management, CSS, Analyses in Security Policy,Vol. 3, No. 42, Oct. 2008.http://www.isn.ethz.ch/isn/DigitalLibrary/Publications/Detail/?ots591=0C54E3B3-1E9C-BE1E-2C24-A6A8C7060233&lng=en&id=93229
David C. Compert and Stephen Larrabee, America and Europe: A Partnership for a New Era,Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1997, . 1-18
D. W. Bowett, The Law of International Institutions, 4th Edition, 1984.
-
83 - 89
First Joint EU/NATO Crisis Management Exercise (CME/CMX 03) From 19 to 25 November 2003,Brussels, 12 November 2003, EU Council Press Office, 14570/03 (Presse 320).https://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cmsUpload/77895%20%20Press%20information%20of%20Nov.%202003.pdf
THE AVALON PROJECT Documents in Law, History and Diplomacy, .http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/nato.asp
John Blasing, The Secretary of Defense and the Partnership for Peace: A Policy for a Safer World,International Affairs University of Colorado, Boulder, 2008. http://www.colorado.edu/artssciences/defense/John%20Blasing.pdf
Nato crisis management concept, PfP ADL WG, 2006. http://pfpdev.ethz.ch/SCORMcontent/43272/scos/12/index.pdf
Handbook, NATO Office of Information and Press, 2001.
Remarks by Javier Solana, EU High Representative for the Common Foreign and Security Policy fol-lowing the agreement on the establishment of E.U-NATO permanent arrangements, Brussels, 16December 2002.http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cmsUpload/73803%20%20Solana%20%20Permanent%20arrangements%20+%20NATO%20declaration.pdf
Robert L. Pfaltzgraff, Crisis Management: Looking Back and Looking Ahead, presented at the CrisisManagement Conference: Athena 2008, July 2, 2008.http://www.ifpa.org/pdf/athena_08.pdf
Samuel Grier, Nato and 21st Century War, Nato Defense College, Research Division, Rome, October2007.http://www.nato.int/docu/21-cent/21st_eng.pdf
Stanley R. Sloan, CRS Report for Congress, 97-708F, NATOs Evolving Role and Missions, March13, 1998.http://digital.library.unt.edu/govdocs/crs/permalink/meta-crs-612:1
Stephen J. Gomershall, Nato and European Defense, Journal of International Affairs, Vol. 4, No.1,March-May 1999.http://www.sam.gov.tr/perceptions/Volume4/March-May1999/gomersall.PDF
The International Institute for Strategic Studies, Military Balance 2009 Executive Summary, EuropaPublications, 2009.http://www.iiss.org/publications/military-balance/
Website Cooperative Longbow & Lancer 2009, The Partnership for Peace, 17 May 2009http://cooperative09.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=21&Itemid=33
Yoram Dinstein, War, Aggression and Set/Defense, Cambridge, 1988. http://www.arrc.nato.int/brc
-
1940-41 1940-41 ()
84 - 89
3.
-
85 - 89
() 20 - .
30 - -. -. , - , (, - ) . - () -, - . - , . - . , , .
- , - : , . , () , -, - - . - .
, , - . , - -. . -, , , - - .
- - ( - ) , - . - , ( - ) . - . . 4-5 -.
- . - , -
-
86 - 89
, . , -, - -, - . - - , , . , - , - . , . , - - .
, - . - Radar , Radar - , . - - .
1935 4 Bofors 80mm 32 Hotchkiss 13,2mm,
. 2-11-1935 , -. - / , 1937, - . 4 - Bofors 80mm.
1935-1940 -, - ( , - ). - , . 960.631.497 . : - , - . - 13 (52 ) 75mm 83.200 200 20mm 740.000 . 18 150mm , - Siemens . 1937 - :
39 FLAK 18 88mm, 18 6 - , 32600 . 5000 - . 15 . 57 FLAK 36 37mm 131.000 , 2500 5000 ( 154.000 5000 ). 3 - . 56 FLAK 30 20mm -
St. Etienne M1907 8mm
-
87 - 89
(). 52 FLAK 30 20mm - ( - ). 4600 - Bofors 80mm. 500 .
, -
, .
, - (.., , , ,).
. - :
20mm Rheinmetall FLAK 30 -
.
Rheinmetall FLAK36 37mm. -
. FLAK 18 88mm.
-
88 - 89
, - - , - . , , , .
- , - , . , - Radar ( ), 11 , 101 - 595 , , 30.000 - . -, -, , , ,
(, , , ). - -. - , Saint Etien 8mm. 4 , - , , , -, 2 , 2 VIII 1 1 - . 1. - - , . 4 - 88, 80 37mm 6 - 20mm, - 16 . 37mm 20mm - . - , ,
/ Bofors FLAK
80mm 88mm
.
/ 4
/ 4
/ 12
/ 8
2 /
VIII
. 2 .+.
.
2
8
7
15
4 39
"1" -
-
89 - 89
, . 1941
16 3,7in (94mm) 18 Bofors 40mm.
- , .. . - , -, 37mm, 20mm 47mm, .
80mm 88mm - . Radar - (-, -
FLAK FLAK 20mm FLAK 20mm FLAK 20mm HOTSKIS S-ETIEN
37mm . . 13,2mm 150/200 /
8 6 6 6 32
8 6 6 6 6 16
16 6 6 6 6 32 12 4
8 6 6 6 6 16 6 2
8 8 12
2 4 2
4 4 4
16 48
32
44
21
3
57 56 24 28 32 241 18 6
(/)
-
90 - 89
, ...), - , . 37mm 20mm - , , . - , , .
/ /
(), - 1937 - . - - :
FLAK 18: FLAK18 88mm (Flugzeugabwehrkanone ) 88 . , - , - . , , FLAK36/37 (105 128mm). .
Q.F. 3.7 Inch Mk.II: - 94mm FLAK 18 . BOFORS Model 1930: , 80mm - - . - , -. FLAK 36: 37mm , 20mm. BOFORS Mk I 40mm: - 1941 . Bofors, . - . - 20 , -. FLAK 30: - 1, 2 4 , . Rh-202 . Hotchkiss 13,2mm: - 1925 . , - - , . St. Etienne 1907: - ( 2300 ) 1916. -
-
91 - 89
. 241 , ( ) - 16 4-6 - . 3 , - -.
- , 28-10-1940.
. , , , -, . , - , - - - - , .
- . : 4 ( ) 52 , PZL P.24 Bloch MB.151, 28-10-1940. 463 (179 , 225 59 ), . , -, - . .
Hotchkiss 13,2mm -
St. Etienn M1907 - . -
30
Bofors Mk I 40mm
-
92 - 89
RAF 265 , 2 Hurricane. - . . - - 23 28-10-1940 / 5-4-1941. - - , -:
30-10-1940 - S-81 . 2-11-1940 - S-81 202 , . 3-11-1940, CANT Z1007bis . - 4-11-1940 S-81 -. CANTZ1007bis 17-11-1940. Ro-37 - 20-11-1940. 12-1-1941 FIAT CR.42. FIATG.50 28-1-1941. 11-2-1941 Ju-87 Stuka. CANTZ1007bis , 12 . 26-2-1941 .
11 - , - 7 . 13-3-1941.
25 6-4-1941. , ( -). , : 8 -, . - , - - - Jungers Ju-87 Stuka. , - . 6-4-1941 , . - 8-4-1941 .
- - . , - RAF. . - Bf-109 Bf-110, Ju-87 , , -
-
93
. - , - - - . -, -.
. - , - . 50 , 64 ( 23 ) -
, - . , - . - - .
- 89
CANT Z.1007.
-
.
94 - 89
-
95 - 89
, - 1821. - - , .
, - , - , . -1 .2 , , - (1421) .3
- , . , () - () .
- - - - , , - , .
- , . - . () , - - .
-
96 - 89
, , - 1821. () - , - . - - 1821. - -4 - 5 (-, ) - - - -, , .
, , - . - , , . - 18, - . - , ; .
-
97
-
, - -, 18 - - . - - . - 6, -, - , . . 7 : - , , | , , , -, () - - - , - . - -- 8 - ( ), 9, - , - .
, - :
- 89
-
98 - 89
[] -, . , - .
- , - .10
() - - -, , . - 18 , - . - -, - . , 18 - - -11 .
- - -. -- - . -
- , , .12 - , , , -, ...
-- , - - . - 120 - - .
-- , , , . -, -, - - , - - - .
- -
-
99
.13 - - - -.14 - - -.15 - . (), - , - - . - .16
, , .
- , .
- , -- - , - - . -- - - , . -
-
100 - 89
. , - .20 21 - -. - , - - , .22 - - , . . - . 23 - .24 -, , - - :
- , . , - , , . - ,
, - , .25
- , - , . 26 , - -.
- - - , - - - -. 27 , - , - -, . - , (1822) -, :
28
, upsilondiaeresis; . ,
-
101
N.
- - -- - - - . . , , , , -, - - . .
- 89
-
102 - 89
- 1821 -
- - 1821 : , , - . - - - .
, , - . -, .
, , , -.29 - - - , .30 31
- - , . - - , - . - N N 32 , - , , , -.
- : . . - , , , -. -, .
- , : - , , , , , . - .
- .
-
103
- . - , - , - - - -. - -, - .
. - - . 33 - , ( ), - , -, - , .
- . , , .
, - (, , ) (, -
), , - - , -.
.
- 89
-
104 - 89
18 , , - . - 18 , - - .34
- , . , - - , - ( ) - -- , . . -, , - , . , - - 1821.35
- - , -.36
- -,37 , - - . , [] , .38
- - -
-
105
, , - . , , - - . (1461), :
, -
, , , -.- , , , .- , -
. ,
.42
-- , , 43 . Giacomo Soranzo 1576 :
() , [], , - , , , -
-44
GiacomoSoranzo , , , . - - , - , - .
upsilondiaeresis -, -. 45 - - - -.46
- 89
-
106 - 89
-
1. , /, , - , , . , . - , , , . ,. 301-302.2. . . , , , , . ,. 268.3. , . ., . , . 365. . 16 , : , - , , , , , , , arma-tores, , - , . . , . , - (. . 1880, 1996, . 32-33 .4. . . , . 1800-1864, Gutenberg, 1996, . 17-21.5. , . . -, , , 2009, .102-119.6. . . , , , ( ), . , . 417-420. . . , - , 1821-1833, , 1998, . , . 10-18.7. ., . , , , 2009, .138-164.8. , : - : , , -, - . , 1821-1828, . . , 2002, .23.9. . . , , 1821-1833, . ., . , . 414.10. .11. . , . , , 1867, . 179 . . -, , 2, . 111, ... , , - , , , . , . ., . 179. . : , ,/ , ./ [] , ,/ -, ,/ , ,/ , ./ , . . , - , , , 1978, (. . 1859) (), . 14. .Passow, . A. Passow, T , . -. , ( . 1860), . 15, 16, 16,17, . 15-18. ., . , , 1821-1833, . ., . , . 17 1. A. Passow: ;/ . A. Passow, T , . ., . 59, ( ), . 51.12. . , , 1821-1833, . ., . , . 267.13. -
-
107
, .14. . , , 1821-1833, . ., . , . 106.15. , .., . , . 108.16. , .., . , . 109.17. A. Passow, T , . ., .95, ( ), . 78.18. , . ., .124, ( ), . 99.19. , , , 1973, . , . 50. , , , -. . , , , 1999, . , . 360. . , , , 1979, . 30-31.20. - , , . . , - , 1821-1833, .., . , . 41, 44 . 521. . . - . : , , . . , , 1821-1833, . ., . , . 28. . William Leake . , . . , , 1977, , . 2 (1669-1812), . 141, .637. 22. : [ ] [ ] - [ ] , - -- [ ] . . , , 1821-1833, .., . , . 98.23. : [ ] [-] , , , . . , ,1821-1833, . ., . , . 97. -, , : . , . , . , . , . , ., . , . , , , ..24. : : -, , - . () , . . , ,1821-1833, . ., . , . 388 5.25. . . , , 1821-1833, . ., . , . 116-117.26. ( ) ( , ) - , . . . , , 14, . 20, ...27. - . . , , , 1800-
- 89
-
108 - 89
1864, . ., .37-51. . . , , -, 1999, .13-15.28. . A. Passow, T , . ., . 236, ( ), . 176.29. ,. . , , . ., . 215-235.30. : , , , . , -, . . , ,, 2005, . 109. . ., ., , 1893, . 308. , - , , : , , - , .31. : - , . , , , , , , -, .32. . . 3 1824 -, , . . , , ..., 1982, . 50748,. 60.33. (- ) . - . . , , ., . .266-322.34. . , , upsilondiaeresis , , - 2003, . 48. 35. . . , . , , 2004. - . , - , , , 2002, , .128-132. . , -, upsilondiaeresis - , . ., . 29-65. . . - . . , , , 1979, .118, . 16.36. , , , 2003, . 47.37. . , , , 1993, . 65.38. , , , 1981, , . . 39. : , [] [] - . , . - -, . ., . , . 32. : , . . , , . ., . 45. 40. . , , . ., .135.41. . , , . ., . 79, .71. . . , , , ., . 119. . . , - , , 1999, . 223-224, 226. 42. E. Legrand, , 2001, ,(,
-
109
. 1874), . 49, . 76. . :, , -, / , , . . , , , . . -, 1925, . 4-5. . . , ,. ., . , . 372-373.43. : , . . , , -, , 1981, . , .159. . , . , , , 1997, . 93. 44. . , , . ., . , . 376.45. , . 1463 - , 1585, - , . , . . . , , . ., . , . 366 . , - , (. 1869), 1995, . 178.46. : [ ] - , . , - , . ., . 48.
- 89
-
110 - 89
--
.
-
111 - 89
1990 . . - - , , , - .
- 2000. , - - . , , - - . - .
-
112 - 89
TT
Eurostat 1 1998-2007, 1999 2002 .
, .
, : , . 385681 1998 463750 2006 . 2003 441839 , 2004, ( ), 405627 455952 2007 423422 .
. 2598 2006 2895 2007.
2009 .2
49,46%(50.54% ). - 50,87%, 37.57%, 48,36%, 55,13% (98,78%), (95,67%) (90,72%).
2007 .
1 Eurostat, Statistics in focus 36/2009, Crime and Criminal Justice, by C. Tavares, G. Thomas2 ( , . 2009)
-
113 - 89
2007 . ( /)
(%)
195 103 34,56% 415 104 20,03% 114 107 48,85% 131 51 28,02%- 5751 3471 37,63% 69 22 24,17% 648 442 40,55% 70 468 86,98% 147 763 83,84%/ 304 244 44,52% 389 7043 94,88% 1714 449 20,75%
9947 13267 57,15%
- - . . - 57,15%. - , - -, - . ( 7043 389 ), - (468 70) (CD .. 763 147). ., , - - .
To -
-. - . - ( , -) - ( - - -), ( ) ( - ). - .
. . - , - ,
-
114 - 89
- - - . ( ) . - . - - - - . . - - . - . - - : -;. . - . - - , . , , - - . -,
- -.
- , - mea culpa - . - ; - . , - . ( ).
--
- , - 1990. - - , - - , - . - MarcOuimet,3 1991 2001 - - -
3 Marc OUIMET. Oh, Canada!. La baise de la criminalite au Canada et aux Etats-Unis entre 1991 et 2002, RevueChamp penal, mars 2004
-
115
. , - - . .4
- .
- 1960 1970.
- - - .
1990, , - . . - - (, ) .
, -. . - - . , , - () . -
- .
- 1990 : , - - .
- . - - 1995 2001 -. - - - . , , - .
- Marc Ouimet - .
- 89
4 (Blumstein, The Crime Drop in America Wallman, 2000)]
-
116 - 89
1990 1991 2001 - 9% 7% - 10%, 42% - 24%.
- - - - : 1990 - - - . - . 147 1991 ( ) 1/6 . - 83% 1/6 1/3 .
- - -.
- -
- 1990. - 18-35 - . - 20-34 18% 1990 2001 - . , -, - - 30% 1991 2001. - . - 1991 2001. - . 30 - . - - .
H H 5
, - , (, , ) - . -
5 . . , , , , 1999
-
117
. - - - . - - - - , , - . , , - - -, .6
-.
-- - -. - () -.
1985
- - .7
- - - (, ) , .
2003, , - , - - , , . -, , - . , , , , -, - . , , - - - .
- - . - .
- 89
6 . . , .., 20067 Ibid
-
118 - 89
- . - -, - .
. -- - . - - . - , -.
- . - . - - .
- .
, , , -
. . - - , - , - - - .
- -, , - - , -, - (-, ,).
- , , - . 1972.8 - - . , , - .
-
8 IVAC, 2007, Quebec, 2008
-
119
. - . 1972 148 , 2007 4.810. - 87.000 - 894 . .
- -: - - - . - .
- - . - - . - - , , , - -.
- . - , , . - . , - - . - - - .
-, - - , . () . - . - . - , -, - .
- 89
-
120 - 89
++
.
-
121 - 89
(. -. ) , - - , , : ,: 1 . : , - (- 77, 158). ( 360) . , , - , . - upsilondiaeresis . - . . - - .
, , - . 2. , (. ). - , , ( , ). , , , . - - ( ). , , , (1 ..), ( - 2 ..). ( ) : , , !
-
122 - 89
, -
-, . , - , - - -,
( ) . - - , , - , , , - 3 .
, , - - , , - ( 65
)
. , - -. - .
, - . - , , . - . , .
, , - , - - - , - - -. , -
(. 498), - , - . , -
. - (,, )
-
123
- .
: ,, , , -. -, 5 .. . - , , , ( ), , -.
- , 50, . , , , . . . - -. , -,
. . 1000 . -
600. (=) - .
-, . -
(5, 68, 5), - ( 50 ) -. -=, , - . , - .
- . - () -. , -, - . 4. , , . -, .
, , . . 3-4 . , , . , , -. : - - - , -, , , , - ,
- 89
-
124 - 89
5 . , , - (. 103) , , . , - , - 30 40 . .
, . , . . , , ! . - (=). - . , (= ). - ( ), - (=)!
, , - 6.
, - -, , -, -. , , - . 8 ( -). , , , . . ( - )7.
- . ( ) . - , -. , -, 300 - . - - 300 , 300 , , , .
, - - , - (
-
125
) . , - , . , ( - ).
600 ( ) . -. - , - , 8.
- 89
-
126 - 89
( ) ,
,, , - - . - , , ( ) 16.384 . -9 (8.192 ). -, , ( 4.000 - ) . . . .
- ( ) . 16 - 10. : (-)11. ( = , -
). . - 2 . 1,85. - (0,93 .). ( 46 ). - . , , . - .
: . - 16 , - . , , . - , , (), 12. .
-
127
-
(490..). - , ( ), , -, , -: . - (6,11), 13 , (/-). , ( ). - - - -. . -
- 1 4 . - . - ,
, (=-), - .
, . , 6.400 , 192 -.
- . ( 325), . , (2 .. .) . .
, , , (394/5-385) |, , - , - . . - .
, - - , - (386 ..), . , , - . : - . (. , . 426). (371 ..) (362 ..).
, , - , -
- 89
-
128 - 89
- , , , , . U. Wilken, () 15. - , .. . -16. - - - . - , , :
- - , - , - - - . - . , - 17.
- -, Egon Friedell, : ( ) , . 18. . (371 ..), - - ,
( 50, 8 ) . . . , , , , (. . : . , . 428).
-, - , - (362..) - .
-, , - 19. -, . . , /- , , , - . , - - .
-
129
, , , . 15 -, ,, , . ( ), , . - . -. , 19/20 - - - , , . . , , , , - -, () , , , , - 20.
, , , - . , , . . 12 - - . -
, . , , -: , , , 6-7 . . , - . 10 6-7 . - . - . , , .
() 16 . . , 16 , 256 . (512 ) - - . 21, , . 10, 15 ... , - . - , . , . 11 . , ,
- 89
-
130 - 89
-
131 - 89
, - . - 22.
: - . -. :
- -. - , - - 23.
, , , (=), , , ., - . -. - .
(338 ..) , , -, ( , .), 24. - / - , - - .
. - . - - 197 .. 168.. - .
-
132 - 89
^ 25, ,
, . 17 60 ( 45 ). - , , . -, - ().
- (. legio .lego=). - -, . 4.200 (milites) 300 (equites). - 26. 10 10 . 10. - -. (socii). . - , - . , . . - , , -
(, , ..).
, . , - 60 . (centurio). - , -, , , . - - , ( , -, , ..). , , . , , , ..
, , , , ( - ), (dis-ciplina). ,
-
133
-. - .
(156-86 ..) . 6.000 () 10 (cohorts), . - . .
- , , , , ( ) , , , .
- 89
-
134 - 89
1 , , . , , - ( ), - .2 , , . - - - . (..) (= ).3 : , 1998, . 131.4 . : , Cutenberg 2006, . , . 479.5 Victor D. Hanson: . . , 2003, . 92. : . -, 2000 S.N. Snodgrass: . UniversityStudio Press6 .. , .. . , . 482.7 , love , -. :
, ( 2,3), [ , ( ) , , ].
, -:
, - ( 12), [ . , -, . , : . ].8 .. , . . . .
9 10 : !11 . , , . , , : . .. ( ) . , .12 . (10 1821) .13 (508..) , - . - (Cutenberg 2004) (. . 635).14 . . , . ., . . 477.15 U. Wilken: , . , . 275.16 , , , 2003 - . , . , - , 1,5 ., /, - . . , , .17 : . 40.18 Egon Friedell: . , 1994, . 302.19 : , 5, 27.20 : 1983, . 78.21 . . : (Cutenberg 1993, . 18 ..) (Cutenberg 1999, . , . 263-264 ..).22 (
-
135
), . 42.23 . , . ., . 22.24 . , . 22, 3 1983 , .62-74.25 . : . , . 401.26 , (hastati) 1200, , principes ( 1200), - ( 600), triarii. 1200
. . 1937. 35 . . 10 6 . Nemesis . 75 (2 ), (3 ), - (2 ), : (2 ). : (2 ) (4).
- 89
-
20
136 - 89
-
137 - 89
-
1, - 20 .
.., O...2 - - 3. 2 - , .
, - : - / , .
-, () - . , ..., -, , .
/ - , - , .
...
-, . - , ... , - , :
- . , - . ( -), . - - -, - , - .
.. - , , ( ). Genocide Watch4 1951-1998 - (73) , ( , .., - 1993 1994).
, ..., , , - , - 47/135 , 18/12/1992, - - , 5. 47/135, - 21/4/2005 , - , .
... 21, .
-
138 - 89
: - millet -
- Martens6 1899. 1907 ( 1910). - ., - - ; ( )7 20;
21 .
. , . 4 ( - ) - ( N , ). - , - . , , ( ). , , - . -
( , , -, , ). - ( , , ).
7 , ( 12 ), 8.
, - zimmi (= , )9. , , - -, - . (gavur kafir,, ), , . - 19 .
-, , -, , 1463 -, ., zimmi - - . 1514, - - . mil-let (=).
millet (milletbasi .. , - ...).
-
139
, , . [ ALLAH () / ], ( , -). - . (gayrimuslim, -) - . - .
- , , - 10. - (-). - , , -.
6 1827 , -, - , - , - . mil-let .
, , -
Gulhane () 183911
- 28/2/185612. - ( 1878)13.
-
. , . - , - . , , : - . -. . . - , - . - . -. , - -. - .
- 89
-
140 - 89
- , -, ( 1).
, .
, , 1871 - 1880 . . , - . Weltpolitik Wilhelm ( 1888).
- -, , -.
Gulhane 1845. (Vilayet, -)
, - -. , 1862-1865, millet , - -.
- 1876, -
, - . , 50.000 -. - , 1876 46 67 - , 42% 14. - : (- Abdulhamid, ), ( ) Ittihat Terakki (- , ).
- , - - , , , -
1:
__ _ _ 6
-
141
30/10/1895 - (cemmiyet, ) - (Vatan Tehlikede, ). Mesveret(, ).
(1894-1895) 6.437 - .
1896 176 8