Cygun Kpyroecras A.B.,!eno No 33 - 5851t1

,tf1cYEe

1

t . . '

t'

, .yEEEHA n KonnErn, ":$i,if^t

i,fril,iF"^, BEpxoBHoroPECNYEJIhKI4 KOMh

B coc-TaFe npeAceAarenbcrBytoulero CeMenqraHofi fl .A.cy4efr Kopenee oir lA.B., Apxapoeori JI.8.nph ceKperape MaxnNneq T.B.

paccMorpeB e cy4e6rorvr saceAa*Vu 31 0rrr6pa 2011 ro*a rpa*aHc*oe Aeno noxaccaquonuori xano6e ooo <Korr,rnanuR <<f rogruocrcoensrri 40rrir> - Bopxyra> Ha peu,eH,eBopxyrrucxoro ropoAcKofo cy4a pecny6nra;?;;; or_19 ceHra6p a 2011 roga,KoropbrM14c*oBbre rpe60eanun pernoriansgofi o6qecraeuHOri opraHn3aLlh14 <L]eHrp 3au.'4Tblnorpe6lrreneti> B 3alq ry npaB U 3aKOHHblx r4HTepecoB cr,rsoea Banepur r4eaHoeuqaYAoBnerBopeH qacrrlqHo; eqr 'evvD1

B3brcKaHo c OOO <Kovnanur <fl0g.ocrcoexsrz 4-O-,V> - Bopryra) B nonb3y cr4goeaBanepnr l4eaHoeu.ra 30000 py6neri ";;;r;;"pyi,e

1371oor 16.06.2010, HeycrorrKa saHapyrueHue cpoKoB B'nonHeHhq ycnyr r fi.*epe rzooo pvaien,-'np'oq""ro, ,unon b3oBaH he ey>K'Mvt A::""T:lyi "p"

i"r ra* B pa3M epe 1 842,50 py6n eri v H AeKcaLJ''B pa3Mepe 2066,39 pylneil, KoMneHcaq e MopaflbHoro BpeAa B pa3Mepe 3000 py6nefi;^^...-'-

yAOBnerBopeH4 0cranunofi 9acr4 r4cK.Bblx rpe60eauufi peruonansuoraooqecreexuorz opra+u3aquu <L[enrp 3au].4rbr norpe6rrenefi> B 3ar4firy npaB u3aKOHHblx l4HTepecoB cusoea Banepraa vlaanoenqa o B3brcKaHUr4 yourrroe B pa3Mepe84600 py6ne,, neycrorirra 3a HapyueHre cpoKoB Bbrno.nHeHfie ycfiyr B pa3Mepe 7gsog4py6neil, vlH*eKcaLlv,1 AeHexHbtx cyt\4M c npuMeHeHueM uHAeKcoB pocranorpebntenucKl4x 4eH, ycraHoBneHHbrx a pecny6nrre Kou-r, oa ra4qurri nonHb*i Mec'qnp. ocpo.f Kr4 C g xra5pa 2010 foAa no uon6pu 2o1o ro*a, *orn"r"u,i'r'-." -non".oru"r"

:.yll:I-l"r"*HbrMr4 cpeAcrBaMu 3a nepro' c zs.iz:boio ,;;;;; *dio,"""""r"cy'iqeoHofo peueH e or cyMMbr g4600 'py6neri,

KoMneHcaqh uopansnoro BpeAa Bpa3Mepe 7000 py6nefi orKa3aHo:B3btcKaHa c OOO <Korranauur <floguocrognsrfi Aona> _ Bopxyra) rocyAapcrBeHHasnouli Ha. e.6rcj1Ner MyHr4tlrnanbHoro o6pasoeaxue fopo.qcKoro orcpyra <Bopxyra> epa3Mepe 1777,27 pylneilB3btcKaH c OOO <Korvnanrr < flogvocroensrrZ 4ouu>. _ Bopryra> u.rrpa$ e pa3Mepe12227 '22 py6nerz B nonb3y pe'aonansr-rorz oo,.,r""ir"r"ot opteH*satruu <Llenrp 3ar4,rbrnorpeOhTenel4);

- B3btcKaH c OOO <KonrnaH r << [-lon nannv^o rrl,;12227,22pt6"";;;";":y?H;9,:"#I,?ffi #nf ,"Jluorrii,lff ;ilHXt_:.:Til",1;<Bopxyra> B pa3Mepe 1777,27 pylneiliB y'.BrerBopeurr rpe60e auuh ooo <KoMnaHraq <r-ro,wocroensrri 40w> _

ffSff1,;;t""j:KaH u pacxoAoB Ha onrary ycnyr npeAcraBurene B pacvere 20000

3acnyu:ae AoKnaA cygsu Kopeueeofr vi.B., cy4e6xan Korinerh.H,

Y C T A H O B 1 4 I I A :

^"-^::j1:.rTuran o6u.{ecrBeHHa, opraH 3aqu, <l_{enrp 3aulurbt norpe6nrenefi>ooparuflacb B cyA c l4cKoM B 3ar4rry npaB fi 3aKOHHbrx l/HTepecoB cr/soea B.14. r< ooo<Kovnasus < flo4rrrocroenurri ,4ov>' 'B;p;y*;

; B3brcKaH k croLlMoc'4 ycfiyf noAoroBopy Ns 13710 06 0rasasrr yc' lyf or'16.06.2010 r pr.rupu aao00'py6neri,Heycrol4Kr4 3a HapyuJeHhe cpo*o" e"rnonHeHhe ycnyr B pa3Mepe 4g7 44g py6neit,vHAeKCaUVU HeBbtnnaqeHHbtx no AofoBopy cyMM c npnMeHeHr4eM fiHAeKCOB pocTanorpe6urenrcKl4x qeH, ycraHoBneHHbrx no eicnyOnrrKe K.MU, Sa ra44urfr norHb*4 MecnqnpocpoqKr4, HaLl4HaF c oxu6pr 2010 roga no AeHb BblHeceHh.F peueHue cy1a,KoMneHcatlur4 3a nofib3oBaH e qyxfiMr4 AeHexHbtMl4 cpeAcrBaM , HaqhHas c 17.0g.2010

ro.a no 24.12.2010 ro*a , v sa nep oA c 25.12.2010 ro'a no AeHb BbrHeceHh' ocyAa, KoMneHcaqhn MopanbHoro Bpe,qa B pa3Mepe ,lOOOO pyOnef , ,rpr+" . "fna-iu4ecart4 npoqeHroB or nprcyxgqenHorZ B nonb3y -C

soea 'a.H.

"1nepeqrclieHLteM neruAecflru npolleHToB cyMMbr ororo Lurpa$a e nonsey pOd3atl]hrbt norpeoureneri>.

--'--r - " )

_ B nocne4yrcqeM creq yroqHun 3asBfleHHbre rpe6oeaHrr npocr4Jr B3lyburrxu B pa3Mepe 11a6000_!y6nefi; Heycrorixy 3a HapyueHue cpoKoB Bbtno,ycnyr B pa3Mepe 807084 py6neil, r4HAercaq rc HeBbrnflaLteHHbtx no AoroBopynpNMeHeHueM UHAeKCOB pOCra norpe6urefibcKr4x qeH, ycraHoBJleHHUrX no per;y,,,Av^wvD p.,vrd I rr.r I peuyr I eJ rbcKytx qeH, ycraHoBJleHuutx no pecnlKon,'u, sa rax<4s1fi nonnsrr7 Mecsq npocpoqKl4, HaqfiHaF c orrrOpa 2010 ro4a ncBbrH_eceHl4g pelueH F CyAa, KOMneHCat] ro 3a nonb3oBaHue qyxr4M ,qeHe)]cpegcrBaMfi 3a nep oA c 25.12.2010 roAa no AeHb BbtHeceHue peueHfiflKoMneHcaqhp MopanbHoro Bpe4a B pa3Mepe 10000 py6nerZ, ,rp"S, , p,naTuqecarn npotleHToB or npracp44ennofi e nonssy Cr,rsoea' B.H. cyMnepeq cfieHueM nernAecll4 npoqeHroB cyMMbt orofo r_urpa$a e nontsy pOO <

B cyge6norvr 3ace1aHlr4 t4creq 3asBneHHsre rpe6oeaHrF noA4epxan.flpe4craeureneM orBerqhKa ucK He nph3HaH.PeruoHansnaq odqecreeunar optaHu3a\uA <Llenrp saulfiTbt norpe6urryqacruF e cyge6uou oace1aHlu He np Hsfia.Cyg nprannn np BeAeHHoe BbtuJe peueHue.B rcaccaquonHori xano6e npeAcraB Tenb orBerqllKa npoct4T peuleH eorMeH Tb, KaK He3aKoHHoe u geo6ocnoeanuoe.flpoeepre 3aKoHHocrb fi o6ocHoeaHHocrb peueHh A cy1a, o6cy4re 4oarKaccaq oHHofi xano6sr, cy4e6uar Korifier e ocHosaH fi gn" 6u ygornlrLop"H^

3aulrirbr norpeOurenefi >.

roAa.

05 anpenr 201e ropa Cllsoey B.lz.l., xax yqacrHllKy noAnporpaMMbt <BblrocyAapcrBeHHstx o6qsarentcre no o6ecne.reHfilo xl4fibeM Xareropuftyctanoaneunsx Qe,qepansHurrvr saKoHoAarelbcrBoM> Se4epansxoftnporpaMMbr <Xunuule> na 2002_2010 roAbt, 3a cqer cpeAcrB

'eegepanunoro

BbrAaH xhn u_lnurrZ ceprr$r,lKar Ha cyvtuy 1411200 py6ner,t' ' c yqeroM

Conoeseaofi M.A.

_ 16 rrrtous 2010 ro4a rrlre44y Cnaosurrv B.14. (3arasvrar) r,r OOO <Korvne< flo4rvlocroeHurfi 4ou> - Bopryra> (lzlcnonHurens) sarnrcven goroBop Ne 13710\/cn.ltrlro r\r r/.\'r/\ 7r^r^yc;foBl4tM Koroporo cno.nHureflb coBepuaer 4ehcrenn, HanpaBneHHbte Ha no$opvneHre e co6crgeFrHocrb 3aKa3q Ka u (nnvr) yKa3aHHbrx ^* ,i4HeABUXT4MOCTT4 e Mocree nnu Mocrcoecrori o1nactu c ucnonb3.BaNrocy4apcrBeHHoro xuJl4t{Horo ceprr$nxara, a raKxe ycnyru, HanpaBJieHnocneAyorleM Ha no cK npuo6perarens ooterra opraHr3all ro o$oprvrneur,rnno orqp{qeHu}o 3aKa3quKoM eur6pauuoro o6uexra c nocneAy}ouluM nepeq ccpeAcrB B pa3Mepe 1326600 pybneri ua pacverHsrfi cqer 3aKa3qMKa B re.-reHue6auroacrux 4r.tefi c uoruenra nepevrcnenra"

"p"A"r, no AoroBopy orvp44enur o6reCrouuocru pa6or u ycnyr cocraBJiser g4600 pv6nerl.

17 cewn5pa 2010 ro4a OOO <Korrananur <flo4vocxoensnz AoM> _npnoopereno e co6creeHuocrs c soea B.t4. il conoeseeofi M.A. xrrnoe nor,aApecy: Mocroecxas o6nacru, r.Opexoea_3yeso, yn.Mocroscxan, g.5 *r.OO,

"iorr,23'13630 py6nerZ, npaeo co6creeHHoc'4 na xsiprr.,rpy 3aper crp,poBauo 22.0g

09 Hon6pa 2010 roaa OOO <Korritnaxnr <Flo4uocroeHutfi .qou> _ BopKyKa3aHHOe XUnOe noMerJ.{eune 6srno npoAaHo ,leuuceuro B.H. 14nrepecsr cusoea B.Conoeueeofi M.A. no AoBepeHHocrt4 npeAcraBnsJra Hoe roea A.A. B cooreercrailycnoBuaMu AoroBopa Kynnu-npo4axu onnara crot4Mocrr4 KBaprhpbt B pa3Mep 231ipy6nefi npo 3BOA[4TCg 3a cqeT cpeAcTB Segepansuoro 6rc4xera e ellAe cy6cuBbrgeneeMoti no rocygapcrBeHHoMy xhnut4HoMy cepru$urcary, cneAyrcUhMcyMMy B pa3Mepe 1296600 py6neri nepeqrc.nrer Opexoeo_3veecKoe

/.{;;

1556/01s50 no nopyqeHrrc BnaAenbqa ceprrlcpuKara na pacverrurfi cqer c aoea {3.ia cyMMa B pa3Mepe 1017030 py6nefi nepeqr4crieerce Ha pacqerHuri cqernpeAcraBrreflg npoAaBqoB Hoeuroeofi A.A. ne no3AHee cneAyrcujero AHr nocJre3aq cneHhg cpeAcrB se4epansHoro 6rcgxera Ha orlenbHbtri oaHroecrutz cqerrocyAapcrBeHHoro xrnrlr.t1Hofo cepru$llxara BnaAe.nbqa cepru$urara.

24 gexalpa 2010 roqa AeHexHbte cpeAcrBa B pa3Mepe j2g66o0 py6nei,nepeLrucneHbt Ha fitaL{eBoi cqer Cugoga B.[4., ,{ro noATBepx(Aaercs estnr4croli l4onrqeBoro clrera Crsoea 8.t4. Cygoft, ycraHoBneHo He ocnap Baercs cropoHaMr, qroorBerquK no AoroBopy Ne 13710 or 16.06.2010 roAa He Aonrar lr cusoev B.i l . 30000py6neri.

Paopeluar cnop no cyulecrBy, cyA nepeofi tlHcralLlun, pyKoBoAcrByncbnofloxeH FMr4 crarer,r 308, 309 TnK PO npuLuen r o60cHoeaHHoMy BbrBoAy o B3btcKaHhhcoorBerq Ka cyrurvrtl e pa3Mepe 30000 py6nei, nocKonbKy orBerL 4KoM O6ssarenucreano AoroBopy B ycraHoBneHHurrl cpox rcnonHeHbl He B nonHoM o6reue.

flpuuuuan Bo BHuMaH e, qro orBerqhKoM AonyqeHo cytlecrBeHHoe HapyueHhecpoKoB nepeAat{ AeHexHbtx cpeAcrB Cuaoey B.lzl., euraog cy4a o B3btcKaavn ueycrofixurBnrercr BepHbtM, np oroM cy4 o6ocnoeaHHo npuulefi K BbtBoAy o Heo6xo4uuocrucHuxeHur pa3Mepa esurcr eaervtofi Heycroftrn B coorBercrBt4rz co craruefi 333 TnK po,TaK KaK CyMMa HeyCTOfiKr4 9BHO HeCOpa3MepHa nocfleAcrBr4sM HapyujeH s o6qsarenscraOTBETLI14KOM.

BsurcxaFtue B norib3y l4crqa KoMneHcaqh MopanbHoro BpeAa orBeqaerrpe6osaurnv craruu 15 3axona "O aaqrare npae norpe6urenerZ".

Pasrvrep KoMneHcaquu MopanbHoro BpeAa onpeAefieH c yqeroM o6cronrenscreAena, orBeLraer rpe6oeanun v pa3yMHocl.4 rl cnpaBeAn nBocl4.

Y4oanereoprr hcKoBbte rpeboaaHrr B Ltacr B3btcKaH F npoqeHToB 3anoflb3oBaHue Ltyxl4 Mt4 AeHexHbtM14 cpeAcrBaM B cyMMe 1842,50 py6nefi, cygpyKoBogcreoBancs craruefi 395 l-K PO, cornacno roropofi 3a nolb3oBaHr4e vyxhMl4AeHexHbrMl4 cpeAcTBaM BcneAcTBfie ux HenpaBoMepHoro yAepxaHhF, yKnoHeHfig oT l4xBo3Bpara, unoi npocpovKt4 B t4x ynnare nr6o HeocHoBarenbHoro nonygeHufl vvjuc6epexenur 3a cqer Apyroro fi qa noAnexar ynnare npoqeHrbt Ha cyMMy 3rNX cpeAcrB.

Bureog cyga e yrasauuofi qacrr nBnrercfl oruh6oqHblM.B cooreercreun co craruefi 395 l-K PO n cnyvae HenpaBoMepHoro yAepxaHht

AeHexHbrx cpeAcrB, yKnoHeH q or x Bo3Bpara, t4Hoil npocporlr04 Bo3Bpara noAnexaTynnaTe npoqeHTbt 3a nonb3oBaH e 'lyxr4 Ml4 AeHexHbtMl4 cpeAcrBaMh.

B cnny nyxrra 6 nocraHoBfleHhn flneHyua Bepxoenoro Cy4a PocoaicroriOeAepaLlilr4 r Flneuyraor,l Bsrculero Ap6nrpaxHoro Cy4a Poco,rficKofi OeAepaq u Bnyuxre 6 f locraHogneHrn N 13/14 or 08.10.98 "O npaxrrxe npuMeHeH e nonoxenufil-pa4qaucroro KoAeKca Poccnficxofi Oe4epaqrara o npolleHrax 3a norib3oBaHue qy)c4MtlAeHexHbrMl4 cpe4creaur" npaeo eur6opa npeAbgBneH e rpe6osanur o B3btcKaHh,qoroBopHoi ueycrofiru (nenefr) nu6o npoqeuroB, B cny.qae HapyueHhff orBerqriKoMAeHexHbrx oGqgarenscre, npeAocraBfieHo Hcrqy. O4naxo cyA npil BbtHeceHUr.t pelxeH FnpuMeHufl ABe Mepbr orBercrBeHHocr 3a HeHaAnexaulee hcnofiHeH e o6qaatenucrea.

B ceqe c qeM peueHae cyAa B qacru B3brcKaH e npoqeHroB 3a nonb3oBaHheqyxuMr4 AeHexHbtMr4 cpeAcrBaMr't B pa3Mepe 1845,50 py6neft, noAnexr4r orMeHe.

B qennx cnpaBneHun cy4ebnofi oLunbxu, 4onyqeuHofr np paccMorpeH 14 AenacygoM nepBot !4HcraHq h np np MeHeHuh HopM MarepuaflbHoro npaBa, cyEe1HaAKorner q nonaraer neo6xognuurnir npnHFTb no Aeny HoBoe peueHne o6 orKaee ey4oBnerBopeH u 3aFB.neHHbtx rpe6oBaHufi e yrasanuori vacrr.

C yverou r4srioxeHHoro, npvluMa+ Bo BHfiMaHue, qro cyMMa noAnexaulaqB3bfcKaHuo B nonb3y Cheoea B.lz1. yrrlensuunacb Lt cocraBfleer 47066,39 py6neil,cy4e6xar Kornerrr nonaraer ueobxognuulrvr cHr43t4Tb cyrr,r rvry LurpaQa, c ylreroMnonoxeHfifi nynxra 6 crarsn 13 3arosa <O saulfiTe npae norpe6urenefr> onpe4enurspaBHoi 23513,20 py6neri, ns uux 11756,6 py6neil noAnexur B3blcKaH lo e 6rc4xer MOl-O <Bopxyra>, 11756,60 py6neri - B nonb3y POO <Llenrp 3ar4r1rbr norpe6nreneti>.

P--_"l"V crarefi 98, 103 fnK pO c orBerqrKa?^oflexur_ B3btcKaH/procyAapcrBeHHas nounuHa B pa3Mepe 1722 pyOnerl (200 py6neri l"'r^

;;XH#"#HFY:3;?ff;,i.""s, 1522 pvorierr -;; ,;'v',;;'"1,ffi 1J""f""J",,,1,r'36o4>1er MO l-O <Bopxyra>.

-B ocransxori va_cira per_ueHrae cyAa noAflexfiT ocraBJrrrrr4oHHbrx xaro6 He cnr ne,o.r L,.\"ro'hr

eH rc 6es u3MeHeHug' AoeohrtKaccaq oHHblx xano6 se cer4erenuCrevoi'o ""nujl'

vco vr'trucHeH4g' /{oeotr1rtnpolleccyanbHoro npaBa.

BrAerenbcrBylor o HapylleHN cyAoM HopM n'arepraansHor4 r,1

r "r "tot"ffi Xnl?J,ii" "-H3; Jt

t,ca a H c Ko ro n p o qe ccvan b H o ro KoAe Kca p occu fi crori

Pyroeo4creyrcs 361 l-flK pO, cyge6nan Koflrerh.H

otrPEflEIthflA:

LXffiT""3?ly,:::::":':B:ff:f__.yAe or 1e ceursopa 2011roAa, B qacrr;:ffiX['?r:?3i:ixrn:'!:i:"-:-:'l_;i;"';;;;#J"i''""#X;?;'ff#i:*jJ:TEt::(;?.,0^:1,::l::l1';;#";J".;il#il3l'ffi:,,"',':J"Tllffi 'liff ffs,""J"'"fi f f ::":::g1y:a::T,-ilJ;';;#:5il?I;"":r:'ff TJ;yAoBnerBopeHwu tpe6oeaunfi e yrasnori vacrra.

Bopxyra>o6

. .__Bsurcxars c OOO <KonrnaHrar < Flognaocxoeuurri 4ou>11756,60 py6neia B nonbsy p"rros"nr-Jo._,i "Od";;J*ro,norpe6urelei>.

- Bopryra> u.rrpa$ e pa3MepeopraHtrcaqun <l_lenrp 3aulnrbt

Bsurcxars c OOO <Konlrnay11f:_Aro*oeuuri.qov> _ Bopryra> Lurpag e pa3MepelAli?;?3,i*"eti

e nonusv 6ro4xera MvHuq nanbHoro o6paooeauue ropoAcKoio o*pyra<<Kounanrs < flo4locrosusrrZ aou> _B nonb3y 6ro4xera uyuuqunan"toro

B ocranuHorZ qacrh pelueHhe Bopxyrnncroro ropoAcKoro cyAa or?fl 11 ̂, :j:" ::,11^11"_ ^6_:: -'rs M_eHe H hF' *"".",q^r ryro xanooy oo(< flo4rr,rocxoeHurfi goru- Bopxyra>_ 6". y4orn"r"oGrr".

Basrcrars c OOOpa3Mepe 1222 py6nehorpyra <Bopxyra>.

f'lpe4ce4arenscreyrc r.qra fi -

pguje!-{ME, mP*4rOE0P

gtnewe A.-/P4/avecr ?'ils r'tE/Zez+-r/-z n-r> As--ilx'roec* ----n6ar1t

cb -

nOCTAH08rlEHtlE)