МЕТОДЫ ОПТИМИЗАЦИИ УПРАВЛЕНИЯ И ПРИНЯТИЯ РЕШЕНИЙ

664

Upload: ivan-stojanov

Post on 08-Aug-2015

954 views

Category:

Documents


7 download

DESCRIPTION

Количественные методы в менеджменте

TRANSCRIPT

2 .., .. 3 4 ...........................................................................................................4 , ......................................................................6 .....................................................................................................................14 ...............................................................................................................20 1..................................................................................................................................23 ...........................23 1. ...............................................................................25 . .............................................................................................25 ...................................................................................................28 .......................................................................86 1.1. .............................................................................86 1.2. .................................................................................................. 112 1.3. ....................................................................................... 120 1.4. ...................................................................................... 128 1.5............................................................................................................. 133 1.6. ...................... 147 ................................................................................................. 147 ..................................................................... 158 2. ; . ........... 164 . ........................................................................................... 164 ................................................................................................. 169 ..................................................................... 242 2.1.......................................................................................................... 242 2.2. ................................................................. 265 3. ........................................................................ 278 . ........................................................................................... 278 . ................................................................................................ 288 ..................................................................... 317 4. ................................................................... 333 ...................................................... 333 . ........................................................................................... 335 . ................................................................................................ 345 ..................................................................... 357 5. .............................................. 367 . ................................................................................................ 367 ..................................................................... 383 2................................................................................................................................ 391 .................................................................................................................................................... 391 6..393 ...................................................... 393 ............................................................................................ 395 ................................................................................................. 415 ..................................................................... 444 6.1. .................... 444 6.2. ................. 457 6.3. ..................................................................................... 464 7. . ................................................................................................. 471 ................................................................ 471 .., .. 5 . ........................................................................................... 472 ................................................................................................. 505 ..................................................................... 519 ....................................................................... 519 .............................................................................................. 534 8. 550 . ........................................................................................... 550 . ................................................................................................ 555 ..................................................................... 562 9. 566 . .............................................................................................. 566 . ................................................................................................ 588 ..................................................................... 608 ....................................................................................................... 624 ...................................................... 625 ......................... 642 ........................................................................................................................ 658 6 ,

...........................................................................................................4 , ......................................................................6 .....................................................................................................................14 ...............................................................................................................20 1..................................................................................................................................23 ...........................23 1. ...............................................................................25 . .............................................................................................25 ...................................................................................................28 1.-1. .......................................................................................................... 28 1.-2. ........................................................................................ 36 1.-3. .............................................................................................. 40 1.-4. . ()............................................................................ 42 1.-5. () ..................................... 56 1.-6. ............................................................................................... 71 1.-7. ..................................................................................................... 79 .......................................................................86 1.1. .............................................................................86 1.1. ........................................................................................................... 86 1.2............................................................................................................................... 86 1.3. ....................................................................................................... 87 1.4. ......................................................................................................... 88 1.5. ................................................................................................... 88 1.6. ................................................................................................... 89 1.7. 3............................................................................................................................ 90 1.8. ...................................................................................................... 90 1.9. ..................................................................................................... 91 1.10. ...................................................................................... 92 1.11. ............................................................................................ 92 1.12. --.............................................................................................. 93 1.13. .................................................................................. 94 1.14. .................................................................................................... 95 1.15. ................................................................... 96 1.16. ......................................................................................... 97 1.17. ................................................................ 98 1.18. .................................................................................................... 99 1.19. ........................................................ 99 1.20. ......................................................................................... 100 1.21. ........................................................................................................... 101 1.22. (-)..................................................... 102 1.23. ............................................................................................... 103 1.24. (-) ......................... 104 1.25. ....................................................................................................... 105 1.26. ............................................................................................................... 106 1.27. ..................................................................................................... 107 1.28. ...................................................................................................... 108 1.29. ................................................................................................... 109 1.30.! ! !!!.......................................................................................... 109 1.31. ................................................................................................. 110 1.32., ..................................................................................... 111 1.2. .................................................................................................. 112 1.33., .................................................................................................... 112 1.34. (-) ........................................................... 112 1.35. ............................................................................................ 113 .., .. 71.36. .................................................................... 114 1.37. ........................................................................ 115 1.38. .......................................................... 116 1.39. (-) .......................................................... 117 1.3. ....................................................................................... 120 1.40. .................................................................................................. 120 1.41. ................................................................................................. 120 1.42. JL ................................................................................................................ 122 1.43. (-) ................................................................. 123 1.44. (-)..................................................... 124 1.45. ......................................................................... 126 1.4. ...................................................................................... 128 1.46. ................................................................................................................ 128 1.47................................................................................................................. 128 1.48. .................................................................................... 128 1.49. ...................................................................................................... 129 1.50.- 4 ........................................................................................................... 129 1.51. ....................................................................................................... 130 1.52. (-)....................................................................... 132 1.5............................................................................................................. 133 1.53. 6 ...................................................................................................... 133 1.54. .............................................................................................. 133 1.55. ......................................................................................... 134 1.56. ........................................................................................ 135 1.57. ............................................................................................... 136 1.58. ................................................................ 137 1.59. 5 .............................................................................................. 138 1.60. ...................................................................................................... 138 1.61. ............................................................................................................. 139 1.62. ............................................................... 140 1.63. ........................................................................ 141 1.64............................................................................................................... 142 1.65. ........................................................................................ 142 1.66. ......................................................................... 143 1.67.- (-) ....................................................................................... 144 1.6. ...................... 147 ................................................................................................. 147 1.-8. ....................................................................................................... 147 1.-9. ............................................................. 152 ..................................................................... 158 1.68. ........................................................................................................... 158 1.69. (-)........................................................................... 159 1.70. AllLink (-)............................................................................. 160 1.71........................................................................................................... 161 1.72. ...................................... 162 1.73. ....................................... 162 2. ; . ........... 164 . ........................................................................................... 164 ................................................................................................. 169 2.-1. .................................................................................................................. 169 2.-2. ............................................................................. 173 2.-3.- ............................................................................................................. 176 2.-4. .................................................................... 182 2.-5. ............................................................................................................. 188 2.-6. ............................................................................................................. 194 2.-7. () ........................................................... 201 2.-8. ()....................................... 210 2.-9. ...................................................................................... 230 ..................................................................... 242 2.1.......................................................................................................... 242 2.1. .................................................................................................... 242 2.2. ............................................................................................. 242 2.3. .................................................................................................... 243 2.4. ............................................................................................................ 244 2.5. ............................................................................................. 244 2.6. ......................................................................... 245 82.7. ............................................................................................... 246 2.8. VIP- (-) .............................................................. 247 2.9........................................................................................................................ 248 2.10. ....................................................................................................... 248 2.11. .................................................................................. 249 2.12. ................................................ 250 2.13. ....................................................................................... 251 2.14. ....................................................................................... 252 2.15. ......................................................................................... 253 2.16. .................................................... 253 2.17. ................................................................................................................... 255 2.18. ....................................................................................................... 256 2.19.- ....................................................................... 257 2.20. (-)................................................................................... 258 2.21. (-).................................................................................... 259 2.22. ................................................................................................. 260 2.23. ......................................................................................... 261 2.24. ................................................................... 262 2.25. . .............................................................................................. 263 2.26. ........................................................................................ 263 2.2. ................................................................. 265 2.27.7 ...................................................................................................................... 265 2.28.8 ................................................................................................ 265 2.29.9 ...................................................................................................................... 266 2.30. .................................................................................................... 267 2.31. ................................................................................................. 267 2.32. ............................................................ 268 2.33. ............................................................................................ 268 2.34. ......................................................................................... 269 2.35. ............................................................................... 269 2.36. ........................................................... 270 2.37. ................................................................................... 271 2.38. ....................................................................................................... 272 2.39. ........................................................................................................ 272 2.40. ....................................................................................................... 273 2.41. .............................................................................. 273 2.42. (-) ................................................................ 275 2.43. ...................................................................................................... 276 2.44. .................................................. 277 3. ........................................................................ 278 . ........................................................................................... 278 . ................................................................................................ 288 3.-1. .......................................... 288 3.-2. ................................................. 296 3.-3. ...................................................................................................... 302 3.-4.- ...................... 309 ..................................................................... 317 3.1. .................................................................................................. 317 3.2. .................................................................................... 318 3.3. . ................................................. 319 3.4. . ............................................................ 320 3.5. 007 ........................................................................................................... 321 3.6. ................................................................................ 322 3.7. ....................................................................................... 322 3.8. - ............................................................................... 323 3.9. ....................................................................................................... 324 3.10. !..................................................................................... 325 3.11. .............................................................................................................. 326 3.12. ........................................................................................ 327 3.13. SHARON CONSTRUCTION ................................................ 329 4. ................................................................... 333 ...................................................... 333 . ........................................................................................... 335 . ................................................................................................ 345 4.-1. .................................................................................................. 345 4.-2. ............................................................................................... 348 .., .. 94.-3. .................................................................................................................. 351 ..................................................................... 357 4.1. ............................................................................................... 357 4.2...................................................................................................................... 357 4.3. ............................................................................................................... 357 4.4. ...................................................................................................... 357 4.5. ......................................................................................... 358 4.6. - ................................................................................................... 358 4.7. ..................................................................................................... 359 4.8. ....................................................................................................... 360 4.9. .......................................................................................... 360 4.10.- (-).......................................................................................... 361 4.11. ........................................................................................................ 362 4.12. -....................................................................................................... 362 4.13.......................................................................................................................... 363 4.14. ...................................................................................................... 363 4.15. .......................................................................... 364 4.16.- (-)...................................................................................... 365 5. .............................................. 367 . ................................................................................................ 367 5.-1. () ............... 367 ..................................................................... 383 5.1. MemoBlink ................................................................................................... 383 5.2. - (-) .............................................................. 383 5.3. ........................................................................................................ 385 5.4. ................................................................................................................ 386 5.5. .......................................................................................... 387 5.6. ........................................................................................... 388 5.7. ........................................................................................ 388 5.8. .......................................................................................................... 389 2................................................................................................................................ 391 .................................................................................................................................................... 391 6..393 ...................................................... 393 ............................................................................................ 395 ................................................................................................. 415 6.-1. ................................................................................................ 415 6.-2. ................................................................................ 422 6.-3. ...................................................................................................... 425 6.-4. .......................................................................................................... 432 6.-5. .................................................................................................. 437 ..................................................................... 444 6.1. .................... 444 6.1.............................................................................................................................. 444 6.2. ............................................................................................. 444 6.3. .............................................................................................. 444 6.4. ................................................................................................................... 445 6.5. ........................................................................................................................ 445 6.6.- .................................................................................................................... 446 6.7. ............................................................................................................ 446 6.8. ..................................................................................................... 447 6.9. ................................................................................. 447 6.10. ........................................................................................................... 448 6.11........................................................................................................................... 448 6.12. ................................................................................................................. 449 6.13. ...................................................................................... 449 6.14. .................................................................................................. 450 6.15. ........................................................................................................ 451 6.16. ........................................................................................................... 451 6.17. ............................................................................................... 452 6.18. ............................................................................................................. 452 6.19. ................................................................................................. 453 106.20. .................................................................................... 453 6.21. ................................................................................................................... 454 6.22. .............................................................................................. 454 6.23. .............................................................................................. 455 6.24. ........................................................................................... 455 6.2. ................. 457 6.25. RC-Computers........................................................................................... 457 6.26.- .............................................................................................................. 457 6.27. ............................................................................................ 457 6.28. .......................................................................................................... 458 6.29. .............................................................................................................. 458 6.30. ..................................................................................... 459 6.31. ............................................................................. 459 6.32. ................................................................................................. 460 6.33.- ............................................................................................................. 460 6.34.- ........................................................................................... 461 6.3. ..................................................................................... 464 6.35..................................................................................................................... 464 6.36. -..................................................................................... 464 6.37. ............................................................................................................. 465 6.38. .................................................................................................... 465 6.39. (-) .................................................................................................. 465 6.40. .......................................................................................................................... 466 6.41. .............................................................................................. 466 6.42. ....................................................................................... 467 6.43. .................................................................... 468 6.44. ........................................................................................................ 468 6.45. ............................................................................................................... 469 6.46. .......................................................................................... 470 7. . ................................................................................................. 471 ................................................................ 471 . ........................................................................................... 472 ................................................................................................. 505 7.-1. ..................................................................................... 505 7.-2. ................................................................................... 513 ..................................................................... 519 ....................................................................... 519 7.1. ........................................................................................... 519 7.2. ..................................................................... 519 7.3. .................................................................................................... 520 7.4.- ................................................................................................................... 520 7.5. ............................................................................................................. 521 7.6. .................................................................................................................... 521 7.7. ............................................................................................. 522 7.8. .................................................................................... 522 7.9. ....................................................................................................... 523 7.10. ................................................................................................................ 523 7.11. ................................................................................................ 524 7.12. ............................................................................................................... 524 7.13.- ................................................................................................................. 525 7.14. ..................................................................................................... 526 7.15. .............................................................................. 527 7.16. ........................................................................................... 528 7.17.......................................................................................................................... 528 7.18. ............................................................................................................. 529 7.19. ........................................................................................................... 529 7.20. ...................................................................................................... 530 7.21. .................................................................................................. 532 .............................................................................................. 534 7.22. CD-........................................................................................ 534 7.23. -............................................................................................... 534 7.24. ............................................................................................ 535 7.25. ..................................................................................................... 535 7.26. (-)................................................................................................. 536 7.27. ..................................................................................... 537 7.28. (-)................................................................ 538 .., .. 117.29. LCD- ..................................................................................... 539 7.30. " " ............................................................................................ 539 7.31. ............................................................................................. 540 7.32. (-) .............................................. 541 7.33........................................................................................................................ 541 7.34. ............................................................................................................. 542 7.35. -.............................................................. 543 7.36. ........................................................................................................ 544 7.37.-.............................................................................................................. 545 7.38. ........................................................................................................... 546 7.39................................................................................................................... 546 7.40. .......................................................................................................... 547 7.41. . ............................................................................... 548 7.42. (-) ............................................................................. 549 8. 550 . ........................................................................................... 550 . ................................................................................................ 555 8.-1. - ....................................................................................... 555 ..................................................................... 562 8.1. ............................................................................................................ 562 8.2. ............................................................................... 562 8.3. ...................................................................................................... 563 9. 566 . .............................................................................................. 566 . ................................................................................................ 588 9.-1................................................................................................................. 588 9.-2. ................................................................................................ 597 9.-3. ................................................................................................... 602 ..................................................................... 608 9.1. ........................................................................... 608 9.2. ...................................................................................................... 608 9.3. ................................................................................................................. 608 9.4....................................................................................................................... 609 9.5. ................................................................................................ 609 9.6. ................................................................................................ 609 9.7. .................................................................................................. 610 9.8. .......................................................................................................................... 610 9.9. (-) ....................................................... 611 9.10.......................................................................................................... 611 9.11. ................................................................................................................. 611 9.12. 95.................................................................................................................. 612 9.13. ...................................................................................................... 612 9.14. . ..................................................................................................... 612 9.15. ......................................................................................................... 613 9.16. .................................................................................................... 613 9.17............................................................................................................................. 613 9.18. .................................................................................... 614 9.19. ............................................................................................... 614 9.20. ................................................................................................................. 614 9.21. ......................................................................................... 615 9.22. ............................................................................................. 615 9.23. ...................................................................................................................... 616 9.24.- ................................................................................................................ 616 9.25. (-)........................................................................................ 617 9.26.-....................................................................................................... 619 9.27. ...................................................................................... 619 9.28. ............................................................................................ 619 9.29. ............................................................................................. 620 9.30...................................................................................................................... 620 9.31. .............................................................................................................................. 620 9.32. ........................................................................................................ 621 9.33. ..................................................................................................... 621 9.34. ............................................................................ 622 9.35. ...................................................................................................... 622 12 ....................................................................................................... 624 ...................................................... 625 ............................................................................................... 625 ; ................................... 633 .......................................................................................... 637 ....................................................................................... 639 ................................................................... 641 ......................... 642 ....................... 642 ................................................................................................................. 647 ...... 652 .................... 653 ........................................................................................................................ 658 .., .. 13 14 , ! ,,.,, , ! , . , , , ,(Operations Research). , . , , ,, ,, . , , , , ,, . ,, , . , . .., .. 15 . . , . . , ,, () .(, ), ., , . , , , , , ., - . ,, ( ). , ,., - , ., , . ,-, (). , .-, ( ,-..). . 161,- ,. MS-Excel . , 8 MBAExecutiveMBA , -, . , . , 300 . . , . , (, ) , , , . ,,., , . , ,, . ,, (, , )., , . 1 ., , ., ( , ). , , , ,. , - ,. ., ,,, , . .., .. 17 (-). 10%., ( ). , ,,,, ., ,, . , . : , : I. 1 2 ; 3 4 5 II. 6 7 8 9 . . , , (), . , . ,MSExcel, ,,, , .MSExcel,, ,MSExcel , , www.ibs-m.ru/books , . ., ,- 18, (,,, , , ..). . , . -, ( ).-, , . ,, , ., - . 1... , (-),,2002,, 2005 (. 2- ). 2...,..,.., , , --, 2001 3..,.,,, , 1997 4. ., , , 1999 5... ,,, ,2002 6...,..,.., , , -, 1998 7... , , , 1988. 8.,...,, , 1997 9. .., , , , 2001 10. ..,.., ,II, , 2001 11. AustinL.M.,P.Ghandforoush,ManagementScienceforDecisionMakers,West Publishing Company, 1993 12. ChaseR.B.,N.J.Aquilano,JacobsF.R.,ProductionandOperationsManagement/ Manufacturing and Services, Irwin- McGrow-Hill, 1995 13. LawrenceJ.A.,B.A.Pasternack,AppliedManagementScience(Computer Integrated Approach for Decision Making), J Willey&Sons, 1998 .., .. 1914. MeredithJ.R.,S.M.Shafer,E.Turban,QuantitativeBusinessModeling,South-Western, Thomson Learning, 2002. 15. HillerF.S.,G.J.Lieberman,IntroductiontoOperationsResearch,McGrow-Hill International Edition, 1995. [1]. ,, MSExcel, . [1], ., [1]. [1], . ,[1], , [2-5]. . [2] , . [3,4] . -,,, ,, . [5] , [1]. ,. 6 7. [6], , . [7]. [8-10] , . [11-15] ,, , , . 20 .. - .. . , . ExecutiveMBA (UAMS) , , , . : (ExecutiveMBA UAMSIBS-M(), -04, 1999 .), (MBA -, 20, 2004 .), (MBA -, 08, 2002 .), (MBA -, 15, 2003 .), (MBA, -10, 2001 .), ( MBA , -06, 2003 .), (MBA, -11, 2001 .), (Executive MBAUAMSIBS-M() , -09, 2002 .), (MBA, -12, 2002 .), (MBA -, 11, 2002 .), (MBA -, 18, 2003 .), .., .. 21(Executive MBAUAMSIBS-M(), -10, 2002 .), (ExecutiveMBA UAMSIBS-M(), -09, 2002 .), (MBA -, 01, 2000 .), (Executive MBAUAMSIBS-M(), -16, 2006 .), (ExecutiveMBA UAMSIBS-M(), -09, 2002 .), (MBA -, 04, 2001 .), (MBA, -04, 2002 .), (Executive MBAUAMSIBS-M() , -11, 2003 .), (MBA, -10, 2001 .), ( Executive MBA UAMSIBS-M(), -11, 2003 .), (MBA, -02, 2001 .), (ExecutiveMBA UAMSIBS-M(), -13, 2004 ), (Executive MBAUAMSIBS-M() , -03, 1999 ), ,, , . MBA Executive MBA , . ,:, , ,, . . , ( , ). , . 22 .., .. 26 2006 1 .., .. 25 1. . , (, ), . . ,,,, ,. , ,. ,, (,, ..),,., , . . , . , , , , , .. , . ,, , . (,- )., . ,. ,,. , . , . -(, , ),-, (, , ), -(, , , ). , , . , , , .. n n 2 2 1 1x c x c x c + . + + ? ,, , ; ,; ,, ., - , , . , 1 1 2 1, / x c x cx , x c ,x cx21 1 2 1 .., . , , .. ,. , . , , ( ) . MSExcel, . . , MS Excel: .., .. 27 ; ,MSExcel, (); , ; , MS Excel .. ,, Windows(,, , , , , .). , , , Windows MS Excel. ,( ,), ,,MS Excel., ,( Solver)., \ ( Add-Ins) .Ok(, MS Office) MS Excel, . , MS Office, MS Excel., , , , . [1]. 1.-1. . . 10 (8 ), 5 ,400. : .400 250150. 3:,. . () () 3015$ 45 3030$ 90 6030$120 a., ? b. ()? , ? c. 280 , 120 100 . . , .6 ,30( ). $15, -$50.,-250 150, , ? d., , ? ? # .., .. 29 . a.,. ,, . , , .P, . , , .3:1- ,23. , , :P = X1*45 + X2*90 + X3*120 ($). MS Excel (. 1): , ,(),.. ,. MS Excel=( ) (SUMPRODUCT()), P., ., 250, 150. . , MS-Excel. , , . t1=X1*30+X2*30+X3*60 (), . 1 12345678A B C D E F () (), $ 30 15 45 0 X1 30 30 90 0 X2 60 30 120 0 X3 =(E3:E5;D3:D5) t2=X1*15+X2*30+X3*30 (), t17%. 2,71. , . 4., .1,8.1. ,16.., 8 36 .. 3,48,87..21 .. 6().1,6.10. 10. 21 . . . 106. , 0,2%(), , .123456789101112131415161718192021A B C D E F G H I . . . 1 2 3 4 5- 18 25 30 15 20min % 5% 5% 5% 7% 7%- Max Min % -/ 1 16 1 6.0% 7.50 4 1 16.002 30 1 8.0% 15.80 23 24 1 5.8% 7.53 64 28 1 5.3% 7.10 85 20 2 7.8% 14.80 1 1 20.006 32 2 6.2% 9.80 67 34 2 7.1% 11.53 5 1 15.008 36 2 6.0% 8.37 4 1 36.009 38 3 5.9% 7.20 910 40 3 5.6% 7.07 6 1 21.00108.0035.003.971038.60 %>7% . 106 -. MSExcel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min % 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.07 0.07 1 2 3 4 5 1 16 0.000 281.605 20 0.750 292.007 15 -0.750 273.008 18 18 0.000 511.2010 9 12 0.000 381.000.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1 739 % 0.0600 0.0586 0.0584 0.0710 0.0780 Max 20 18 16 22 20k 1.5 1.2 1.2 1 1 14.00 14.30 12.77 21.69 17.71 1 672.4 . 107 . ,, .,, ., ., . ,, . , -, , . , - . ,, ,, , .,,, . 3-e: .., .. 225,,,, .,,. , .-,-?- , . , ? 3 . , , , , , . . . ,, ,..107, , 5- maxminmin) 1 ( Ckk kH C = . (, ), , - = 1038,6 + 1738,8 + 1642,7 = $ 4449,8 .

. . 108. 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243A B C D E F G H I . Max Min % / . 1 16 1 0.060 7.5 4 0=G3*C3=G15-100*G32 30 1 0.080 15.8 2 1=G4*C4=G16-100*G43 24 1 0.058 7.53 6 1=G5*C5=G17-100*G54 28 1 0.053 7.1 8 0=G6*C6=G18-100*G65 20 2 0.078 14.8 1 1=G7*C7=G19-100*G76 32 2 0.062 9.8 6 1=G8*C8=G20-100*G87 34 2 0.071 11.53 5 1=G9*C9=G21-100*G98 36 2 0.060 8.37 4 1=G10*C10=G22-100*G109 38 3 0.059 7.2 9 0=G11*C11=G23-100*G1110 40 3 0.056 7.07 6 0=G12*C12=G24-100*G12 1 2 3 4 5 1 - - - - 0.0 - =(B15:F15)-G152 - 21.8 - 8.2 - 30.0 =(B16:F16)-G163 - 3.2 - 6.8 - 10.0 =(B17:F17)-G174 - - - - - 0.0 - =(B18:F18)-G185 - - - - 10.0 10.0 =(B19:F19)-G196 - - 16.0 - 10.0 26.0 =(B20:F20)-G207 18.0 - - - - 18.0 =(B21:F21)-G218 - - 14.0 - - 14.0 =(B22:F22)-G229 0.0 - - - - - =(B23:F23)-G2310 - - 0.0 - - 0.0 =(B24:F24)-G24 18 25 30 15 20 /- =(B15:B24)-B25 =(C15:C24)-C25 =(D15:D24)-D25=(E15:E24)-E25=(F15:F24)-F25=(G15:G24;F3:F12)/(B25:F25)4min % 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 7.00% 7.00% % =(F=(G29;G30;G31). 20 18 16 22 20=(B15:F24;B34:F43)K_% 1.50 1.20 1.20 1.00 1.00=(B31:F31;B25:F25)- =B29*(1-B30*(B28-B27)/B27) =C29*(1-C30*(C28-C27)/C27) =D29*(1-D30*(D28-D27)/D27) =E29*(1-E30*(E28-E27)/E27) =F29*(1-F30*(F28-F27)/F27) =(G15:G24;E3:E12)- - 1 2 3 4 51 24.2 17.6 25.8 24.2 18.8=G28 4 449.8=(H34-G28)/H342 28.8 9.6 11.8 10.2 15.6=G29 1 738.8=(H35-G29)/H353 15 7.8 21.8 8.2 11=G30 1 672.4=(H36-G30)/H364 23.2 17.4 25.4 19.8 26.2=G31 1 038.6=(H37-G31)/H375 23.6 20.2 22.6 20.4 14.66 14.2 8.2 9.4 15.8 8.47 12 16.2 19.2 18.2 198 15.8 19 12.6 24 21.29 11.4 20.2 16.6 25.4 22.210 21.4 20.2 16.6 25.4 22.2- - . - =(B15:B24;$D$3:$D$12)/B25 . 108 50 105-( B15:F24),1010- ( G15:G24), 10 (G3:G12), 1. H3:H12, ,I3:I12, , .., .. 227(H26), 1. H15:H24,, B26:F26,-, %, (B28:F28), 1. ,(, ),L3.(L9) -(L5) 1 . ( L7) ,, , , . 1 ( B31:F31). , . . 109. . 109 . 110.,, , 15%, ,$700. 34%,18%, 23%. , . 4,5,1,2, ., . 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243A B C D E F G H I . Max Min % / . 1 16 1 0.060 7.5 4 0 0 0.02 30 1 0.080 15.8 2 1 1 -70.03 24 1 0.058 7.53 6 1 1 -90.04 28 1 0.053 7.1 8 0 0 0.05 20 2 0.078 14.8 1 1 2 -90.06 32 2 0.062 9.8 6 1 2 -74.07 34 2 0.071 11.53 5 1 2 -82.08 36 2 0.060 8.37 4 1 2 -86.09 38 3 0.059 7.2 9 0 0 0.010 40 3 0.056 7.07 6 0 0 0.0 1 2 3 4 5 1 - - - - 0.0 - 0.002 - 21.8 - 8.2 - 30.0 0.003 - 3.2 - 6.8 - 10.0 0.004 - - - - - 0.0 - 0.005 - - - - 10.0 10.0 0.006 - - 16.0 - 10.0 26.0 0.007 18.0 - - - - 18.0 0.008 - - 14.0 - - 14.0 0.009 0.0 - - - - - 0.0010 - - 0.0 - - 0.0 0.00 18 25 30 15 20 /- 0.00 0 0 0 0 4 4min % 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 7.00% 7.00% % 7.10% 7.72% 6.11% 7.00% 7.00% 3 795.2Max . 20 18 16 22 20 1 146.4K_% 1.50 1.20 1.20 1.00 1.00 1 372.0- 7.40 6.25 11.75 22.00 20.00 1 276.8- - 1 2 3 4 51 24.2 17.6 25.8 24.2 18.8 3 795.2 4 449.8 15%2 28.8 9.6 11.8 10.2 15.6 1 146.4 1 738.8 34%3 15 7.8 21.8 8.2 11 1 372.0 1 672.4 18%4 23.2 17.4 25.4 19.8 26.2 1 276.8 1 038.6 -23%5 23.6 20.2 22.6 20.4 14.66 14.2 8.2 9.4 15.8 8.47 12 16.2 19.2 18.2 198 15.8 19 12.6 24 21.29 11.4 20.2 16.6 25.4 22.210 21.4 20.2 16.6 25.4 22.2- - . - . 110 , . . , . , .., .. 229,.-, . , , ,,.-,, ., , ., , ,, . (. [2-6] 2.1 ). -, , , -.. ..,, ., , , , ? ,, 1. . ,Frontlinesystems1991., StandardSolver,,200 .Premium Solver 2000.Solver,1 .. . -www.solver.com -www.maximalsoftware.com -www.cplex.com-www.ilog.com (.,Interfaces_________,INFORMS2004______________________________)., , ,, , . , , ,, . , (-) . , , , , . -,,, ,, , . ,, . - -. -, .-, , , , . , , ,, . , , ( ). -,, , ,, ., ,-,, . ,, , , -. , -.,,, .,, . 2.-9. 12. ., ,., . , . .., .. 231 .12, , , , 78( ). . , 12345678910 1112 ##58635 913 27 23 19 14 2020 . 15##13537 14 18 28 28 24 19 2125 . 2813##939 7833 17 12 92620 . 3659##40 13 16 32 26 21 17 2526 . 435373940## 32 34 12 37 37 33 1721 . 591471332 ## 428 15 10 52214 . 6131881634 4## 31 10 612514 . 72728333212 28 31 ## 37 36 30 722 . 82328172637 15 10 37 ## 593316 . 91924122137 10 636 5## 63016 . 10141991733 5130 96## 2512 . 112021262517 22 25 733 30 25 ##18 . 122025202621 14 14 22 16 16 12 18## a., , 12 . . . b., 2 . . # . ,, ., , . ! ,, () ,. ,, ,,. . , ! . , ,, . , . - !? ., . , . ,,, . , .1313 ,(12) 13 , , . =(), ,. (. 111). ABCDEFGHIJKLM NOP 1 2012345678910 11 1230##58635913 27 23 19 14 20 20=(C3:O3;C18:O18) 41 15## 1353714 18 28 28 24 19 21 25 0 52 2813 ##9397833 17 12 926 20 0 63 3659##4013 16 32 26 21 17 25 26 0 74 43537 3940##32 34 12 37 37 33 17 21 0 . . 1512 122025 20262114 14 22 16 16 12 18 ## 0 160 17012345678910 11 1218=(C18:O18) 19 10 20 20 21 30 22 40 30 120 31000000000000=(O18:O30) . 111 ., . .., .. 233 . 112 .. - , -->3-> 1-> . : 2 -> 5-> 2, 7 -> 11 -> 7 (. 113 . 112).

0123456789101112 0##586359132723191420205 1 15##1353714182828241921255 2 2813##93978331712926207 3 3659##4013163226211725266 4 435373940##323412373733172121 5 591471332##4281510522147 6 61318816344##31106125141 7 727283332122831##3736307227 8 82328172637151037##5933165 9 91924122137106365##630165 10 10141991733513096##25121 11 11202126251722257333025##187 12 12202520262114142216161218##21 98 0123456789101112 01000000000001 100010000000001 200000100000001 310000000000001 400000000000011 500100000000001 600000000001001 700000000000101 800000000010001 900000000100001 1000000010000001 1100000001000001 1200001000000001 1111111111111 . 113 , . 7 -> 11 -> 7,., C18-O30., , , J29 ( 7 11),N25(117),J29 . , , ., , . ,1. . (.114 ). 109 0123456789101112 00010000000001 110000000000001 200000000010001 301000000000001 400000000000101 500100000000001 600000100000001 700001000000001 800000000000011 900000000100001 1000000010000001 1100000001000001 1200000000001001 1111111111111 . 114 -, , 98 109 . .. . . 115 .., .. 235(.114.115), . , . ( ), 3 . www.HCXL.ru , . , . . ,, Large-ScaleLPSolver. -FrontLineSystem www.solver.com. . . , 1608. MS Excel 200 . ,, , ,, . : . , . . 1 12 , (), .. 12 . . (112)( 112,,), , 144(=12*12). ,, , . , , , . 144 . . . .12 . 12 + 11* 12*12 + 12 = 1608 . , , . , , .,, , 12() 13 . (.116) .D36:O168C169:C180. D36D36:O36, 1. D21:O21D36:O36,R21 =($D$1:$O$1;D21:O21) . .., .. 237ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQR 10123456789101112 20##58635 9 13 27 23 19 14 20 2031 15##13537 14 18 28 28 24 19 21 2542 2813##939 7 8 33 17 12 9 26 20 53 3659##40 13 16 32 26 21 17 25 26 64 435373940## 32 34 12 37 37 33 17 21 , . 75 591471332 ## 4 28 15 10 5 22 1486 6131881634 4 ## 31 10 6 1 25 1497 72728333212 28 31 ## 37 36 30 7 22108 82328172637 15 10 37 ## 5 9 33 16119 91924122137 10 6 36 5 ## 6 30 161210 10141991733 5 1 30 9 6 ## 25 121311 112021262517 22 25 7 33 30 25 ## 181412 122025202621 14 14 22 16 16 12 18 ##15 , . 1655974165162112720118 170=R212000000000=R33 18 19111111111111=(O36:O180) 20 211100000000000111 222001000000000113 233010000000000112 244000010000000110 255000001000000110 266000000000100110 277000000001000110 288000000010000110 299000000000001110 3010000100000000110 3111000000100000110 3212000000000010110 33131110 34 350123456789101112 3601100000000000 = (D36:O36) 37120010000000001 3820000000000000 3930000000000000 48120000000000000 49130000000000000 1571120000000000000 16370000000000101 16812000000000000 = (D168:O168) 1691130=C169 17020=C170 1791111 1801200 =($D$1:$O$1;D21:O21) =(D36:D48)=(D109:D120)=(D36:O36) . 116 D37:O48. F37 , 3 (. ,1,F35). A37. P36:P168. , . , , ,P37:P48 D21:O21.,., (,, )!D22:O22D37:D48 O37:O48,, . .. D22:O22 , . R22=($D$1:$O$1; D22:O22) .D49:O60. P49:P60D22:O22, .13 . ,. 12 : C169:C180. , , , .. . P169:P180 D32:O32, Large-Scale LP Solver. , 1, C19:O19. ,1, .1 Q21:Q33. :1 2,3,412,22,3,412..12., Q21:Q33=1, .,., , ,. C2:O14. C16=($C$2:$O$2;$C36:$O36) .D16:O16 =($C$3:$O$14;$C37:$O48) , .. (Q16),, .., , (. 117) .., .. 239 . 117 , . Options (. 118) . 118 ,1-3, , , : 118 , - (0)132561098124711 (0) , ..119 . . 119 b., ,2. ., , , , . ,MSExcel. . ,, 2. .. ,2. 2,,. ., , . 120. .., .. 241ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQR 10123456789101112 20##50635 913 27 23 19 14 20 2031 15##5537 14 18 28 28 24 19 21 2542 205##635 913 27 23 19 14 20 20 53 3656##40 13 16 32 26 21 17 25 26 64 435373540## 32 34 12 37 37 33 17 20, . 75 591491332 ## 428 15 10 522 1486 61318131634 4## 31 10 6125 1497 72728273212 28 31 ## 37 36 30 722108 82328232637 15 10 37 ## 5933 16119 91924192137 10 636 5## 630 161210 101419141733 5130 96## 25 121311 112021202517 22 25 733 30 25 ## 181412 122025202621 14 14 22 16 16 12 18 ## . 120 , 2,, . Large-Scale LP Solver,:R21=2. ,2 . : (0) 231117412891065 (0) 112 . , ., . , . 2.1. 2.1. 11- . ,

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 11515202325272829303538 21313212319242931272935 31213162326262631333332 41115202419252727323533 1 2 3 4 30755540 ( ) . 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 - 1520152015102510102535 , . # 2.2. W1,W2,W5D1,D2,D101 ., ,D4 W3,D9W1D7 W 5. D1D2D3 D4 D5D6 D7 D8D9D10 .., .. 243W 11465126141411612 W 21310415149816417 W 315131159767146 W 41217412146117912 W 5181211981781189 . D1D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D8 D9D10 -611 11 312 12 83211 W 1W 2W 3W 4W 5 -172310245 a. , .b.? . # 2.3. . ., . - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 1345340360360350355335340 2335360355355345345350355 3350340340345350345350345 4350335350340360360365360 :

- 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 , 2614281713183454 : 1 2 3 4 , 45786362 8, 1 - 4. a. , , . ? b.?, . # 2.4. . ., . - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 1255270255270250265270250 2270270270260265255250260 3260270255245260245255255 4250270245265260260245265 :

- 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 , 3132284246294189 : 1 2 3 4 , 651196369 , , .. 8 , . . a., . ? b. ? c.? . # 2.5. 5. , , (. ). . A B C D E 43450510610470520 44460360380390390 45570420390360550 46600500590640500 47370530440430550 48470460410610390 49470530510560400 - : .., .. 245 A B C D E 45615754179 : 43 44 45 46 47 48 49- 49396469484670 . a. ? b. ?c. ? d. ? . # 2.6. 1, 2, 3 4 . . (1 10). 1 . , . . C1C2C3C4C5C6C7C8C9C10 13.1187.517.69.3149.714.58.114.1 23.86.86.38.317.312.316.35.25.113.9 39.65.6716.88.510.411.28.28.318.9 412.516.26.616.514.93.45.614.211.317.4 , . . C1C2C3 C4 C5 C6 C7 C8 C9 C10-, 2254544123 , . 1234 -4111720 ,- 3 2 3 .. a., . ? b. ? c. ?# 2.7. W1,W2,W5C1,C2,C91 ., ,3 W4 W5. C1C2C3C4C5C6C7C8C9 W1486557576854654949 W2634558755170565275 W3656557466267757243 W4627557666060595557 W5524451774456556048 . C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7 C8C9 -45 36 31 28 19 40 30 3946 W1W2W3W4W5 -5845686339 a., . ? b. ? c. ? d.-3 W4 W5? # .., .. 2472.8. VIP- (-)12 -., , . 9. , (7 .). 1 ( , ). - - - - -- - Cubi5641012915 Mistral10151830321835 Giro67612141116 Maxi58121415820 Veroca2216538 Dany12151117201418 Ondex15101829342028 Srisce86101517720 Metafisika17182333351928 a., , . , CubiGiro, Maxi, -Dany,Veroca,Ondex. (,)? ( ) ? b., . , . ? ? # 12MBA (MBA04)2003.( " "). 2.9. . 1 ., . . - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 - 9 1395310355315315310295295325 2350300360345345275270285300 3320345305380385335320265300 : - 1 - 2 - 3- 4- 5- 6- 7- 8 - 9 , . 9111018121312625 : 1 2 3 , .464447 9, 1 - 3. 2 -> 3 . a.,, . ? b. ? # 2.10. . (. ). A B C D E 16845925900715925 17905685665665720 18710665830800735 19835645785665815 .., .. 249 20825930795715960 21745785935780885 22680715895665710 23655715765865830 - : A B C D E 160186123165135 : 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23- 12810476786011713056 . a. ? b. ? c. ? d.,- 20D. 100.- ? e. ?# 2.11. . .

A 1130701407050 2110801206080 36010010080110 414080100100150

( ):

1 2 3 4 , \ 30482030 :

A ,\ 1827422615 a. , . b. , , . ,, . , . ? c.,,,, ., ,, . ? # 2.12. :,, ,,. , ,. , . . -200-1000100200300400500600-400 -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 50003 . : ,. . .., .. 25110 .3,, 3.3. (),( )( ). 5 . . - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 . . 1 . . 2. 10615760248184179356 11048072167220177343 215331019927711777106 3812368528378109276 414631121137266212367 5228236256114307215243 . . (3 ) - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 . . 1 . . 2 10001200850250015002200750 , . a.,5 . ? b. , , , , . ?# 2.13. 3 1, 3 : X, Y , Z W. : A B. , , . X Y Z W ABABABAB A45 50 40 50 1 B 10090105100 A45 60 55 55 2 B 9585110100 A60 55 40 50 3 B 90858595 A, B. X Y Z W ABABABAB , .1236-1913372950 : 1 2 3 ABABAB , .34472050-45 a. , . , .b. ? # 2.14. 1, 2, 3 : X, Y Z. : A, B, C. , , . X Y Z ABCABCABC A46--64--61-- B-91-91--113- 1 C--214--161--206 A37--63--46-- B-113--104--119- 2 C--116--89--108 A51--58--37-- B-168--168--224- 3 C--183--164--184 A, B, C X Y Z ABCABCABC , .661892- 3090447588 : 1 2 3 ABCABCABC , .-35114593483515473 .., .. 253 a.,. , .b. ? # 2.15. 3 1, 3 : X, Y , Z W. : A B. , , . X Y Z W ABABABAB A40 45 45 35 1 B 80 60 75 65 A40 45 30 40 2 B 60 60 60 70 A40 35 50 45 3 B 85 70 70 85 A, B. X Y Z W ABABABAB , .7312415142810 : 1 2 3 ABABAB , .169185287 a.,. , .b. ? c., Z. ? # 2.16. 6. . - -, . S1S2S3S4243281268179971 D1D2D3D4D5D6 591414443123286 696 D1D2D3D4D5D6 S1121115151414 S211149111215 S391312141611 S412913111612 . ,. , ( - , ,-). , - . W1 W2W3D1D2D3D4D5D6 S1856W1 444766 S2656W2 567768 S3554W3 747746 S4477 . a. . b.-,- -., ( ), . c.-,- -, , , . .., .. 255# 2.17. . , . . 0135 1121 0224 1225 0322 1340 0424 1419 0527 1517 0618 1631 0716 1737 0819 1825 0914 1931 1022 2033 300 , 200 , , . 110. . 1 2 3 4 5 405400465335325 380370340335385 , , , . .

01695605 11 465575 02585510 12 640520 03525560 13 595660 04680575 14 680420 05465465 15 470605 06655635 16 505475 07515620 17 730635 08350595 18 600505 09665650 19 680555 10675505 20 395540 , . 1 2 3 4 5 01758590135110 02906515513075 0390951408085 041601351008580 051151509570130 0695115110115120 07854011511075 081151451609080 09125100359575 1010510514012065 111451456590120 129575858050 13958010075100 14651755011590 15551058050125 1610570130130100 1712575105100125 181258010580100 1914010080115115 2050851406085 , . a., . b. . 50 , . . ,. ?# 2.18. 3:, ., : () (3) 12700 .., .. 25718900 10500 , , . 4., () (3/) ($/) 1205320 21670400 32560360 41340290 . a., , . b., . , ? # 2.19.- -40005 :500,1000,1500,12006003.8 1:- 350,33;1600,13;5.,6.53; 35 ., 6 3; 4 , 6 3; 2500,7.63;250,13;120,0.53.:100,1000,200,200,350,600,500 1300 . : 8,21.5, 51, 275, 110,34.5,92.7USA. : 700, 800, 1300, 700 500 ( ). . a. , . b.,. , ? # 2.20. (-)13 ,, . . () () () - () (USD)* MAN12.52.72.6204000 VOLVO11.12.72.619.53600 IVECO11.52.72.118.53400 , ,.. . . , . , $ () (3) , $ . 110807035.20.08625105 . 152808542.80.09530127.5 .214104.20.24620321 8517.40.101-127.5 .15770.30.15940263.76 124590.13240193.44 68310.06840102 -1243388.51.0122237.4 (15)1951081.07810468 38110.0485059.28 -121180.4710203.28 () ::,(15), 3, 20, 80 15 , ; 13MBA ( 12) 2002 . ( "-") .., .. 259, .110802 15280; (); 90% ; 20% . a., , .b. ? c.-, 6% ( + ). ,( )? ? # 2.21. (-)14 ,,10. . . 30% . ., , : , , , ,, , . , . , USD/ , USD/ 175.1244.28 180.1441.18 182.8746.7 180.0244.63 175.7648.11 14ExecutiveMBA UAMSIBS-M() (EMBA11)2004.( ""). 175.5743.61 175.2743.61 175.9343.61 172.6240.57 172.5940.57 ,, ,. , . 75.54 USD . 1., 0.5 . . 70 . 200.,120. 100 . . , 800., ,35% . ,, 300., - 200 . . a. . ? b. 1 . . 100 . USD? c.. , , , ? . # 2.22. (, , ) . , 1, , . . .. 6 7 8 1 2 3 145032%38%30%300$-700$ 260037%28%35%-400$500$ .., .. 261 : 900,1100 1000 ., , 3035 . . , ,,, . a. . b., ? ?, ? c.,, b? # 2.23. 3 1, 3 : X, Y , Z W. : A B. (- ). 100..1..1. X Y Z W 140454535 240453040 340355045 1.1.0,1. 1 . B 0,2 . , , . A, B. X Y Z W AAAA 7121528 355030%32%38%600$300$200$ 435028%40%32%200$500$- 550039%34%27%--400$ 645034%28%38%500$300$- BBBB 341410 : AB 11619 22515 3287 . # 2.24. A,BC-. ,,,, : () ()

1 2 3 192215132516503535 B7-1012510101520 14201018122202540 . . :. , .200.\. . ( ) 1347347424622483330 2525292568428377130 3631222762262488165 ,, .A,BC( ) 0.18, 0.12 0.06 , . ,C, 16 . , , . a., , .., .. 263 ( . b. . c. , ? # 2.25. . Il-96- 300 Il-62M Il-86 Tu-154 Tu-134 A-310 B737-400 B767-300ER B777-200 , 23516235015876191137269400 , 613152412111042 , . . - 100050008501300500 , . , Il-96-300 Il-86,Il-62M,Tu-154,Tu-134 . , , , 10%. a. . , . b.. . ( ,. 2-3 .) # 2.26. , . 9. .45 . ., 123456789 0202214141015111324 . 12001177221610337 . 222110149281016346 . 31471406161532713 . 414796019982710 . 51022281619024121628 . 6151610159240162615 . 711101638121602416 . 81333342727162624037 . 924761310281516370 a., , 9. . ? b.,60 \ 10 . c.5. ? ? # .., .. 265 2.2. 2.27.7 7 . , . 1()15( ), . , . 1 2 3 4 5 6 7M 11013711166 M 273518213 M 3164121149 M 4411351143 M 574517312 M 6811135819 M 7613213952 a.? ? b.?? ? # 2.28.8 8 .8. , .1( )20(), . - - - - 1310799121310 1010111210111111 1315151412161616 131814141191814 8678121198 1615171711111613 7612811697 1715121412171415 a. .b.? ? c.?? ? d.- . ,. ?e.. , . # 2.29.9 9 .9. , .1( )20(), . 131116141713181513 647566454 97121111101096 71213810121086 141212141311121112 81810171313111014 1391410136141410 161117181910172017 1381419181016189 a. .b.? ? c.?? ? d., 11. , .., .. 267. ? # 2.30. 200 , 2000. ,, . ,50 : 137.7 32.933.8 37.0 35.4 243.4 33.1 42.234.7 41.8 333.3 28.5 38.930.4 33.6 429.2 26.4 29.628.531.1 a., , .b. ? # 2.31. 7-(,B,H) (-701, -150..), . (), (),. , . -701-150-150-80-40 -100-1500 A1214141091521 B1513121082123 C-1611101121- D16--89-21 E131113981521 F1313111192228 H1213139102227 a., ? b.?, . c.,- -701-40,.. . . , . # 2.32. 6-8-(D1,D2,...D8)7 (S1,S2..S7) . , .1( )20(), . D1D2D3D4D5D6D7D8 S11512166291115 S211131510214620 S31281610113411 S4167147110619 S51261312110516 S61311121119517 S713111364131215 , .S2 D1. # 2.33. -48 . .,, . . ( A: B; D) ( 1; 2; 8) , . -, . 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 A185185210200200195185190 B180165180165170190165195 C170170180210200170235210 D200190190220195220190190 . # .., .. 269 2.34. 4(), 28(). , . . , . 7 . . 12345678910 11121314 13455410 911 810 10131920 216141521 20 17 18 19 16 15 19221517 311911810 10 13 19 20 18 15161415 419161519 22 345543455 15161718 19 20 21 22 23 24 25262728 118151614 15 21 20 17 18 19 16151922 234554345310 10131816 321201718 21 20 17 18 19 34554 4410911 810 10 13 10 91181010 a. ., . b., 10. ? ? c., 78, . 10 9.,5. ? - ( ), . d. . . # 2.35. . . ,. ,, ,,.7 24. , ( ), 3, 6 9 . 24- : 12345678910111213.91018.56.717.2 13.6 10.8 75.912.4012 28.109.51211.8 917.6 11.8 126.47.218.9313.615.319.1014.9 18.6 1.810.7 15.3 9.45.112.6412.811.410.46.31596.115.3 016.35.314.759.13.612.41211.9 7.215.4 2.58.112.68.20 611.712.115.814.7 8.410.5 13.2 010.3 17.818.414.7710.710.714.213.2 10.7 912.7 8.111.7 5.716.412.4

13141516 17 18 19 20 21 222324110.49.511.813.4 9.67.816.2 15.5 9.412.96.715.5212.82.510.816.7 10.9 8.84.87.115.8 13.216.716.7313.713.61013.3 19.5 1614.7 9.414.8 15.7124.2 414.59.19.511.6 10.1 101114.9 13.8 1214.414.3513.613.27.311.4 10.6 10.4 8.915.7 97.113.111.3616.1137.18.414.8 15.3 9.211.9 16.3 12.619.69.9 712.28.815.2169.416.1 010.8 5.37.617.714.6 a., , . ? b., 3.? , 6 9 ? c. , . # 2.36. 22 :-3,-1,-5, -1,-3,-2,-1, -5 -1. .., .. 271 , . . . - - . - .- 0232660236528334709399504 2320436400582229619424304 6604360797880424787657229 .2364007970292380550632704 5285828802920462388929866 3342294243804620419404652 70961978755038841901070822 .- 39942465763292940410700424 5043042297048666528224240 a.,\ ,, . ? b.? ?c. , ., 9. ?# 2.37. 8(D1,D2,...D8)810 (S1,S2..S10)., . , . D1D2D3D4D5D6D7D8 S12157594754392467 S22647574853382362 S32352535743302461 S42953604449342369 S52745495743372768 S63149495546282669 S72852575653353056 S82645534945402969 S93049505653352068 S103244514446292365 a. , . ? b.,S9 D7. . ? # 2.38. 1010 (1,2,... 10), 7 (M1,M2.M7). , , . , , 2 . C1C2C3 C4C5 C6 C7C8 C9 C10 M1155135140 180 205 -210 275 290 270 M2145135130 205 205 -210 260 245 295 M3140140140 180 205 200 180 285 255 - M4130120125 205 200 195 210 265 250 - M5125120135 210 180 195 200 255 275 - M6150145135 200 -195 230 280 255 245 M7145125120 190 -205 230 285 245 295 a., .. ?b. , . c. , , ? # 2.39. 14(1,2,14)4 . , 14 (O A, O , O , O ), , . P 1 P 2 P 3 P 4 P 5 P 6 P 7 P 8 P 9 P 10 P 11 P 12 P 13 P 14 O A4832535555413931444824433132 O 4151485222513231595960242258 .., .. 273O 4321223558224553563047243259 O 3250375835444653294121523536 a.. , ? b. 4 , , . . ? # 2.40. 7 .7. , (810 . 20 ( ) 1 ( ), . 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 17121110871091215 21011131613914131618 3713107131213121218 491115915716111119 551114811817181716 6141110137168101412 77121011101511161318 8814151681315171217 a., .b.. 7? ? c.10 3, 7 8. 7? ? # 2.41. . . 9-. (-701, -150..), , 3 .(), ( ). . -701-150-80-40-100-1500 18161472228 14131171631 19151091631 17129102024 17121491826 201310102031 191611111926 141713101826 19171192028 - (, ,,,,). . ,, ,. . 234224 334322 234222 225324 244223 244222 234225 223322 223222 a., . , -. , , . b., ? c. ( )?d.?, . # .., .. 275 2.42. (-)15 , ,-11 . . ,6. 2-,3-,4- 5-., .() . 2345 , .1000230025001375 -11 10 , .-. -, ., , 127.5 2333 3-444 423.8 5-457.5 635.4 7534.5 836.5 930.5 10315.8 , . ,, ., ,20% ., 15 MBA -(20)2004.( ""). , 40% . , , . , . 20%, . (,2-4- ). (40 ). a., . ? b.. ( ) , ?# 2.43. 10(1,2..10) 8 (1,2,...8) : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 , .112102105878811671116 , , , . 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 12221192024151716 22013161821181617 31319171922151414 41217131815221713 520201921-211323 61111211517121213 71120171813172020 81622201119201016 916-242120162014 101516231219151213 a. , , 5 9 5 2 . b. ? # .., .. 2772.44. . . . . . 4 : A, B, C D. ABCD , 60687560 , 108611 D , . AD ,BC. , . . , . .,, . , , . ABCDABCD 1250400--3.22.5 2-300--2.4 3--1000-2.1 4-200500-2.52 5---4003.5 6300500--3.22.6 7500---3.1 8-1000500-2.52.1 9---10003.6 10500---3 11--5008002.13.5 12100300500-3.12.42.1 , . 6 . 38.. 4. .a., .b. D, . 1600. , ?c., ?, . ,(a). ,(a),, ,?(, (a), .) d., ,? ? e.:, , .. . # 3. . (,), , . , . , . , . ,, , ,, , . CPM(CriticalPath Method,..)PERT(ProgramEvalUationandReview TechniqUe,).PERT, , , . ,CPM, .., .. 279, . ,, -(/Cost), ., MSProject2003 ( )., . , (. 121). - - - () A -5 B -4 C -3 D A,B1 E C,D 7 F E12 G E15 H F10 I F,G8 J I15 K I20 L I7 M H,J,K,L14 . 121 ( ), , . ,. , ( ), . , ,? , , ,(121). ,, . , , , .,, . , (C)A,BD, E ( )., - .,, , -(. ).,MSProject . MSProject. , . (, Word Excel), ,. , (. 122). , ., . ,. .,MSProject ,,(,[1-4,6,8,11-15]), ,, , . , , . ,,, . 122 .., .. 281 . , . . 123 (. 123), , (,). . , , .. ,., , . . 124 ,, (. 125). (). (//, []). () (.125)., ,,, . . 1 A 5 2 4 3 3 4 D 1 1;25 E 7 3;46 F 12 57 G 15 58 H 10 69 I 8 6;710 J 15 911 K 20 912 L 7 913 M 14 8;10;11;1227 03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 '05 '05 '05 . 125 ,, , / (. 126). . 126 , - 70 .,, , , (), .,L 13 . . , K(), ,K, M, ., . .., .. 283 . ( ), , . , MS Project ,-. ,. . .(.127) - . (. 127 ) . (. 128 ) , , , . . 127 ,(.128 ). . . 128 (. 129). . 129 ,A,D,E,G,I,KM ( ,,.. ). (,[1-4,6,8,11-15]),, , . , . .., .. 285 . , (. 130) ,( ),( ). . 130 (. 131). . 131 , ADEGIKM ( ). - . ,. (. 132) [1] (, ), ., ,. , , . , . F . ,,.131. F ( 6) 3 . ,,3 ,,G( 7). : F 12 , G 15 . ,F1, H ( 8 . 131) , 21,1. , ,( ). . ,,CJ 3 4 , . 132 , , .,, , F H 3 20 (.. ,), . F H ( F), :FH23 , F-H 21 . . 132 .., .. 287, : -(.. ); - ( ) ; -() ; -(), . -, ., , . [1-4,6,8,11-15]. . 3.-1. - . , , . - () (..) () (..) A-612422 BA3425 CB3535 DA2101,512 ED710419 FB,D820532 GE8124,526 HD3122 16 .a. ? ? b.80.., ? . MSProject, , , , . Project . ,, ., .. .(. 133)- . (. 133 ) . (. 134 ) , ,, . .., .. 289 . 133 ,(.134 ). . . 134 (. 135). .1 A 6 2 B 3 13 C 3 24 D 2 15 E 7 46 F 8 2;47 G 8 58 H 3 4ABCDEFGH03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 . 135 ,A,D,EG ., ,, ,. , . . , , () , ( ). (. 136). 2 34 56781 . 136 , ADEG ( ). (. 137). -> -> (.137), 115 , , , 23 (5 ). . , . (4040 ). . 138 , . H5, . . 137 .., .. 29112345678910A B C D E F G H () (..) () (..)A 6 12 4.0 22=C3/B3 =(E3-C3) /(B3-D3)+F3=G3-F3B 3 4 2.0 5 1.33 2.33 1.00C 3 5 3.0 5 1.67--D 2 10 1.5 12 5.00 9.00 4.00E 7 10 4.0 19 1.43 4.43 3.00F 8 20 5.0 32 2.50 6.50 4.00G 8 12 4.5 26 1.50 5.50 4.00H 3 1 2.0 2 0.33 1.33 1.00 - - . 138 , , , . . ,, .,, ., (), (. 139). ->. . , (.140), ,,(. 141). . 140 . .. . 139 (.142). () ( ). . 141 . , , - . . 142 .- .. ,. ,. . -, 999./.,, . ,, .74 . , D3:D10 , . 138. , ., , . , . , . .., .. 293 , , . ,(.138). H,. A, D, E, G 3 E., ,.40 (5 ). 76. .: 110 (22 ), 77 , 1.43 4.43 (. 143). .E, , .80E.-5 ,-21(105),-80 . . . 120 E. - 4 ,-20(100),-83 ..,, . A,D,GG D4.D 0.5 , G 3.5 . , , D, . 20(0.5)D. 1.5 , 19.5 (97.5 ), - 85 . G.20, . 7.5,-19(95), - 87 . . . . 143 60G. 6.5,-18(90), -91..G . . 1 A 6 12.002 B 3 3.993 C 3 5.014 D 1.5 12.005 E 4 19.016 F 8 20.007 G 5.5 22.008 H 3 0.99ABCDEFGH03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 '05 '05 '05 '05 '0 . 144 100.5.5, - 17 (85 ), - 95 . (.144), . (. 145), , . 2 34 56781 . 145 ,,: ABF(1-2-6)ADEG(1-4-5-7).(,ADF (1-4-6) Project . D 1.5 , B3,ADF15.5, ABFADEG17,. ,, :, . , , , . ) ,,, , G ( 140 ). (.146),ADEG. , 17 (85 ), 99 . .., .. 295. 1 A 6 12.002 B 3 3.993 C 3 5.014 D 1.5 12.005 E 4 19.016 F 8 20.007 G 4.5 26.008 H 3 0.99ABCDEFGH03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 '05 '05 '05 '05 '0 . 146 (4.5 ), . G100 . . , , . , , , ( , )! A. 5.(.138), , .40 16(80). 100 (. 147). .,80 ,E. 21., . . 147 3.-2. . . () (..) A-624 BA430 CA315 DB354 EB,C1090 FD,E230 GF6135 HB645 IF,H8105 a. ? b. , i. , ; ii. , ; ? c., 25 .. ? . , MS Project. (. 148). ,,. MSProject, . , 5.. 1 A 6 2 B 4 13 C 3 14 D 3 25 E 10 2;36 F 2 4;57 G 6 68 H 6 29 I 8 6;8 . 148 .., .. 297 . (. 149). ABCDEFGHI03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 20 27 04 11 18 25 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 . 149 ,\ \,150 . A, B, E, F I. (. 150) , 5 - ABEFI. 23456 78 91 . 150 ( ), , , . , MS Project . . 1234567891011A B C D E F % 25A - 6 24 4 16.0%B A 4 30 7.5 30.0%C A 3 15 5 20.0%D B 3 54 18 72.0%E B,C 10 90 9 36.0%F D,E 2 30 15 60.0%G F 6 135 22.5 90.0%H B 6 45 7.5 30.0%I F,H 8 105 13.125 52.5%--, . 151 Excel(.151) (,) (E3:E11)25 ( F3:F11). 25 - , . . (G.153)., , MS Project , . , . . 153 , , ( 25 ). . (.154), 9 . . 152 .., .. 29920%40%60%80%100%120%140%160%:M . .: :27 03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 20 27 04 11 18 25 01 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '0516% 16% 16% 16% 16% 16% 50% 50% 50% 30% 138% 138% 138% 66% 66% 66% 36% 36% 36% 36% 60% 60% 143% 143% 143% 143% 143% 143% 53% 53% . 154 138% 25 (34.5), 6 143% (35.75).,, ,., ,,., , . . , . (.155) . . 155 , . , , , , , , , , . . , , (. 156). 20%40%60%80%100%120%140%160%:M . .: :27 03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 20 27 04 11 18 25 01 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '0516% 16% 16% 16% 16% 16% 30% 50% 50% 50% 36% 36% 36% 36% 36% 36% 66% 138% 138% 138% 90% 90% 53% 53% 143% 143% 143% 143% 143% 143% . 156 ,, . , , . ,MSProject ,,, . . (. 157). . 157 , . 157. . , , , , . . ,, .. (.158),, .., .. 301, . ABCDEFGHI27 03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 20 27 04 11 18 25 01 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 . 158 ,, . 20%40%60%80%100%120%140%160% :M . .: :27 03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 20 27 04 11 18 25 01 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '0516% 16% 16% 16% 16% 16% 50% 50% 50% 30% 66% 66% 66% 66% 66% 66% 36% 108% 108% 108% 60% 60% 53% 53% 143% 143% 143% 143% 143% 143% . 159 (.159). - . , . (.157). (. 160). ,. , 195 .ABCDEFGHI03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 20 27 04 11 18 25 01 08 15 22 29 05 12 19 26 03 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 . 160 , . (. 161). 20%40%60%80%100%:M . .: :27 03 10 17 24 31 07 14 21 28 07 14 21 28 04 11 18 25 02 09 16 23 30 06 13 20 27 04 11 18 25 01 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '05 '0516% 16% 16% 16% 16% 16% 50% 50% 50% 30% 66% 66% 66% 66% 66% 66% 36% 36% 36% 36% 72% 72% 72% 60% 60% 53% 53% 53% 53% 53% 53% . 161 ,., . 3.-3. - . , 20., ,AT. , . . ABCDEF G H IJK L M N O P QRST 69111015920 915 12 11 11 13 814 612101212 87588-31691427425367 11 1191312-7810 -110 616 62941013 ,20 . , . ., ,. .,() B, G, F A. D B, C E A .. .., .. 303*, ,R,OS. , , .a.Excel, , - R, O S. , . 5. ,, 2. , .(.) .,, ., , .b. ,, 5., ,, (OL) . , . c. , , , 200. . ? d., , ? ? . . . ,- . ,,, . . , , . ., , . -B-D-I-Q-R--A-C-J-M-S-. 8 . . , . ,, ,,, -A-C-J-M-S-, , ,51., , .(, )., , . (. 162). ABCD E F G H IJK L M N OPQRST U V1 AB C D E F G H IJ K L MNOPQR S T2 69 11 10 15 9 20 9 15 12 11 11 13814612 10 12 123BDIQR5601 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 000011 0 04BHPR3401 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 000101 0 05GLO4200 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 001000 0 06GKNS5100 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 010000 1 07FKNS4000 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 010000 1 08AEMS4610 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 100000 1 09ACJMS5410 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 100000 1 010ACJTS 531 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 000000 1 111 1256_ =($C$2:$V$2;C3:V3) =(B11:B23) . 162 12. A3:A108( ).C3:V10, ( A3:A10 ), =($C$2:$V$2;C3:V3)B3:B10 . , .., .. 305 , . , , . C3:V10 , Excel. C3, , =(((C$1;$A3));0;1).(C$1;$A3) C1A3., A3C1,,A3 #., ,()., ()#,, .,30, , , ().,, :()(),0 (),()(),1(). Excel,,, .$, C3:V10., 1.28.B3:B10 3256.BDIQR. 56. a.B12=(B11:B23),, , . . , OL- BDIQR., ,., BDIQR!, , . ! B 9 8 , D 10 9 .. B12 54 . 51.,ACJMS, BDIQR, 1 . , BDIQR 2 ACJMS ., BDIQR,ACJMS. . , ,2 (). , , ., 3? , , . . (.163).-, 62-3-C3:V3C4:V4 .999. ,, . . 7 8 . , ( 1 2 ). . ,, .C6:V6=C7+C8 . C2:V2 .B9:B16,, , . ABCD E F G H IJK L M N OPQRST U V156AB C D E F G H IJ K L MNOPQR S T2 69 11 10 15 9 20 9 15 12 11 11 13814612 10 12 123. . 1 . 87 5 8 8 -3 1 6 9 1 4 274253 6 74. . 2 . 1111 9 13 12 -7 8 10 -1 10 6166294 10 135 . 69 11 10 15 9 20 9 15 12 11 11 13814612 10 12 126. . 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000000 0 071- . 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000000 0 082- . 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000000 0 09BDIQR5601 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 000011 0 010BHPR3401 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 000101 0 011GLO4200 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 001000 0 012GKNS5100 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 010000 1 013FKNS4000 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 010000 1 014AEMS4610 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 100000 1 015ACJMS5410 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 100000 1 016ACJTS5310 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 000000 1 117 1856 0 1951 =(B11:B23)=($C$2:$V$2;C9:V9) . 163 , .. =(C3:V3;C7:V7) . C4:V4 .., .. 307C8:V8. V18 : =(C3:V3;C7:V7) + (C4:V4;C8:V8). . . - , B19.,,56 A1. . ,C9:V16 , . ?. , . , - , ,, . . ,, .V18, . C7:V8.., : C7:V8 = . . =(B9:B16),, :B9:B16 = C8:V8. ,, .(K P)., , . . (.164).5 -380000.B,C,I,M,Q,S R . 56ABC D E F G H IJ K L M NOPQRS T 6911 10 15 9 20 9 15 12 11 11 13 8146121012 12. . 1 . 875 8 8 - 3 1 6 9 1 4 2 742536 7. . 2 . 11119 13 12 - 7 8 10 -1 10 6 16629410 13 . 6911 10 15 9 20 9 15 12 11 11 13 8146121012 12. . 011 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 000121 01- . 011 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 000111 02- . 000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000010 0BDIQR51010 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 000110 0BHPR31010 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 001010 0GLO42000 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 010000 0GKNS50000 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 100001 0FKNS39000 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 100001 0AEMS44100 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 000001 0ACJMS51101 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 000001 0ACJTS51101 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 000001 1 51 3851 . 164 , . (. 164), , 51 , . (b) . ,. 2, 5,,10 . , . ,. , ,, , . 1 .55. ,R. 3 (30000). 54 . .,R. 4(40000),70000. 330000. , ,., 45,. (. 165). .., .. 309 551R3030170 542R4070330 533QM70140460 524CI110250550 515BS130380620 506AD160540660 497QS190730670 488IJK200930670 479BCK2101140660 4610ADG2701410590 . 165 ,,. ,(670.) () (7 ). 49 . 8-200. ,910 ,., 49 . 10 ()590 . 3.-4.- . ,. , , , - ., . :(1)(2). -, .,,. , ,, . () - A 52 B 73 C 52 D A31 E A74 F B,E21 G A, B32 H C106 I H73 J D,F,G,I150 K J300 ,, 60., , . 94 . , - . -- . ,-- 10 ..,,, ,, , , , $2500 , , . .( ) . $$$ A 54002700100 B 7100041450150 C 5400350050 D 3250013000250 E 74004850150 F 21000120001000 G 3150022000500 H 10300064000200 .., .. 311I 7200260080 J 155000107000400 K 30100002014000400 a. , ?b. . ?c. , ? ? . ,MSProject, -. , .,, ., .. (1)r1,r2r10, ( J K ): ABCDEFGHI r1, r2 r3, r4, r5 r6, r7r8r9, r10, r1, r2 r3r4, r5r6, r7, r8, r9, r10, r1 r2, r3, r4 , . . ( ,,, ) (. 166) ,CHIJK, 67. (), 60,$2500. , ( , )?MSProject3:, , . ,r1,r8,r9,r10 (. 167), . 167 200%...168r1. r8,r9,r10. . 166 .., .. 313 . 168 , , , . . 169 .169,r1,r9,r10, EH,r8 ,DH ( D E). , , . (), ; ,, ; . , . 170 ,76,DE H. .AEFJK,C,HI ., . 76. 60.,, . A.1(8 ).75,, , r1,r3,r8,r9,r10. . 171 .., .. 315, D E . (E), F,JK,60 . , ,. .166C($50)I($80). C 3 I 2 60$500. ,r1,r3,r8,r9,r10. 71., , AEFJK., A .,, (-) ,$2500. , () . ,, , DEH,, ,DEH. H E?,.169, , ., MSProject,H- DE,..,. -, . , (. 172) . 172 , 74 ( 76,), AEHIJK. I 5,3,3H360 ,,$1750 ($80*5+$100*3+$150*3+$200*3)., ., . , , ,, ., : H D E, D E H. ,( ,, ), 2,, . , ,.. (H,,!). (DE) ,,-,, . , ,, . ,, ,H, DE.,, , ,,, ,, . .., .. 317 3.1. ( A, B, C, D., Fin). . , . 2 . ABCDE F G H I J K L M N O PQRST () 69111015 9 10 9 15 12 11 9 10 6 14 612 101212 1 76867 - 9 7 8 7 9 5 7 8 6 105989 2- 1214 18 13 12 - 15 14 15 17 16 15 - 14 13 20 10 18 17 19 . J Fin Start A B C D E F G H K L M N O P Q R S T I * a. . (,), . b.1, . . . c., 1 15 . ? # 3.2. .23 ,, . , , , . , ,., ,. 280.( ). -, . , ,., .