Центральная Азия и Кавказ 2006 №05(47)
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
1/196
5(47), 2006
1
CA&CC Press
20065(47)
-
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
2/196
5(47), 2006
2
/: (994 - 12) 497 12 22 E-mail: [email protected]
/: (46) 920 62016 E-mail: [email protected]
(, )/: (994 - 12) 499 11 73 E-mail: [email protected]
()/: (+7 - 701) 531 61 46 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (+996 - 312) 65-48-33 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (992 - 917) 72 81 79 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (998 - 71) 184 94 91 E-mail: [email protected]
(): (+994 50) 3006694 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (374 - 1) 54 10 22 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (995 - 32) 98 96 33 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (972) 2 5882332 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (49 - 89) 3003132 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (86) 10-64039088 E-mail: [email protected]
(). (7 - 495) 3163146 E-mail: [email protected]
().: (380-44) 524 79 13 E-mail: [email protected]
: 620720-0459
: 22 339
: M-770
CA&CC Press.
: 969713-2695
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
3/196
5(47), 2006
3
, , ()
, ()
, ( )
, , ()
- () , , -
() ()
, ()
, , , ()
, , . .. ,
( )
, , ()
, () , ()
, , () . ()
() ,
() ,
- ( ) , ()
, , ()
, , ( ) , , () , , - , () ,
. c () ,
()
, ()
, ,
:
CA&CC Press ABHubertusstigen 9. 97455 Lule
SWEDEN : www.ca-c.org , 2006
CA&CC Press, 2006
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
4/196
5(47), 2006
4
-
5(47) 2006 .
. . -- ......... 7
. . : ........ 23
. . . ............................................................................ 41
. . : ...................... 54
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
5/196
5(47), 2006
5
. . .................................. 70
. . : ?( ) ............................. 81
. . : .......................... 93
. . / ............................ 107
. . : ................................................................ 115
. . : .................................................................... 130
. . :- ....... 145
. . - - ............................. 159
. . : ....................................... 167
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
6/196
5(47), 2006
6
:
- .
15 : .
. . : ............................ 180
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
7/196
5(47), 2006
7
--
(, )
- -. , - . - -
, .
- , - -, , - , - .
, - ,
, - - - , - -. -
- , . - , - - . - ; -
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
8/196
5(47), 2006
8
:
, . -, 25 ? -, , , , ?
, 2030 -
39% 38% . ( 3%) 2001 . 2030 - 30% , . -, . 6,6% 2001 4% 2030- - ( 7%)2.
25 - . - ( 1 ), - . (1,1 ) , - 3.
, - , - . ,
,
- , - 1. - , - -, - .
--, -
- , - , - -. - , -.
1 .: . - // - , 2006, 2. . 103.
2 .: Energy and Security: Toward a New oreign Policy Strategy / Ed. by Jan H. Kalicki and David L.Goldwyn. Washington Baltimore: Woodrow Wilson Center Press, Johns Hopkins University Press, 2005. . 25.
3 Ibid. P. 21.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
9/196
5(47), 2006
9
- ( )4. -
, . - -, , - . . . - , 5.
, - -
, , - ( -, ), - , 6.
- -, , . - .
- , -. , -
, - , - .
, . , - - . - , , - .
, - . , -
. , - , .
4 Ibid. P. 22.5 .: . // : ,
, 2006, 4. . 57.6 .: Yergin D. The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil, Money, and Power. Cambridge: Cambridge Energy
Research Associates, 1999.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
10/196
5(47), 2006
10
,
7
. - , -- - , 1970- . , , 1973 - , - . - , , -, -. , -- 1975
G-7, - -. , (1975 .), - (1976 .) (1977 .) , - - 8.
, , - G-8 ( - ), - . , , , G-8 2006 - . , , - ( ) .
- , , , , (, ,- - ), (- ) ..
, , -- - , ?
, - , . , - , . , ,
4 (2,6% )9. , 1 850 . 2 900 . 10.
7 .: . G-8 // , 2002, 3. . 39.
8 .: . G-8 // , 2002, 3. . 33.
9 .: . // Analytic, 2005, 1. . 20.10 .: Energy and Security: Toward a New oreign Policy Strategy. P. 190.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
11/196
5(47), 2006
11
, , - , -
XXI , - -, - . , . , - .
, - .
. - , , , . -
, - 11. - .
, , - , - , , . -- , , - , . :
, , . - , , , , - , - .
, - - . 10 14% ( 2%). , . 30%. . - 12.
, .., , . ,
11 .: . // : , -, 2000, 2. . 72.
12 .: . // Analytic, 2005, 2. . 13.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
12/196
5(47), 2006
12
( 2005 .) . .
. , . , - , .. ,
. - -- - , - .
, 13. , , .
, - , - . 2006 - . - . - , - .
, . - - . , , .. , ( -) , -
14.. 20 -
, - . , - . 2004 - 120 , 2005- - 50%. , 2010- 400 , 160170 15. - - - .
- , - - , -
, . -
,
13 .: . // , 2003, 5. . 60, 64.
14 .: ., . G8 [http://www.inopressa.ru/wsj/2006/07/06/11:46:16/g8].
15 .: . -- // , 2006, 1. . 32.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
13/196
5(47), 2006
13
. , -
16
. , . - , -, .
. - , - - , , - 25 .
, , - . , 2030 - 70% . , ,
50%. , . .. , , ,
, - . , . , - . , 2006 , 17.
, , , -, --
. 2005 ( - ) , .
, , ( ), - 18.
-- , - , , - . - . , -
, ( - ) . - , , - , , - .
16 .: . // , 2005, 6.. 154.
17 .: [http://www.inopressa.ru/faz/2006/03/09/12:43:10/eu].
18 .: . . . . 157.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
14/196
5(47), 2006
14
. . , , , -
. - - -, .
. . :
n -, , - ;
n -, -
;n -, , -
, .
. - . , - . , , - -, , , - .
. , , -
. 90% , , . - , . , : - , - 19.
-- - , , , .
, ,
19 .: . // -, 2006, 5. . 7275.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
15/196
5(47), 2006
15
, - . , -
, . , , 20.
, , , - , , .
2006 - , - . - - -: ,
, , , , - , . - , , - , . , , , .
, -, . - , , - . , , , - , : . -
, - , - , - . : 25% - , - 21.
, -- - ; , , - . - , , .
- , (), , . -- - .
, - ( ) -- (). -
20 .: . // Analytic, 2005, 1. . 20.21 .: // The Washington Post, 4 2006 [http://www.inosmi.ru/
text/translation/224661.html].
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
16/196
5(47), 2006
16
, , - -
. - , - , ., - , - -.
, , - . , - () , . - , - , ,
. - ; , - ( ).
- - . ,, , - . , , , . , ,
( - ), , .
, , - . , - - . , . , , -, , - 22.
, -
. - . -, . ( ) - . ( ) -- ,
22 .: . // , 10 2006, 26. . 46.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
17/196
5(47), 2006
17
, . - (, -
) . , , , , - , 23. , , 12 ( ), 24.
, - , , ( ) . , ,
. , , , ( ) . , . , 2007 - . , - , , , 2007 -. 25.
,, , - . , . , , , . , - . , , , -26. - , .
,
- . - , - ,
23 .: . // Analytic, 2005, 1. . 2124 .: . . . . 47.25 .: // , 30 2006.26 .: , 30 2006 [www.eurasianet.org].
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
18/196
5(47), 2006
18
. , , , , -
. - , - , . : - , , - , - , 27?
, , - : - . : - ,
28
. , (, , ) - , , - , , , - . -, , , - , , .. , .
- , : . ,
., -
. , - , - , . - , .
, - , - . . , - . ,
, , , . , , 29.
27 .: Energy and Security: Toward a New oreign Policy Strategy. P. 162.28 . 6 2006 . [http://ria-arbitr.ru/news.htm?id=20024].29 .: . // Analytic, 2005, 1. . 24.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
19/196
5(47), 2006
19
- ,
. 19911994 , -, , , - . , , , - .
., - , . , 2000 - 23%; , 2030- 32%. ,
, . - - . - ( ). , -, .
, - -. , - -. -- , , , .
-- , -. , , , - , - :
( , , -);
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
20/196
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
21/196
5(47), 2006
21
, , . -
: , - , , . - , , , - . : - , ; - .
, , , - . , , -- ,
, .
, , . - , - , - . , , - . - , . , .
. , , , - . , 20032004 - . , - . , , , , . , , - -, , 32.
, - .
, - , , , 2005 . , - , ,
32 .: . // Analytic, 2005, 2. . 17.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
22/196
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
23/196
5(47), 2006
23
, -
. -, . , , . - .
, - - . , - - , () .
, , , , , -, .
, , - , - .
:
,
(, )
( ) - . -, - 100 . ,
2006 -
, . ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
24/196
5(47), 2006
24
: - ,
.
- . - , - , .
* * * -
, - . 4% .
- , - . -
2,44,6 , . - , , .
- , - - , -. - ( - ) - . - , , , - -. , -
. ,
-, , - - , .
- XIX , , . -
, - . - - , -. : , , . , - 1990-, -
. - - XIX .
- , , -, , , ( , ), - , - ,
, - .
- - , , -, .. -
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
25/196
5(47), 2006
25
. , , (. . 26)1.
-
3,611,0
0,72,2
0
0
10,016,0
2,03,2
0,2
0,04
1,41,5
0,30,3
15,228,7
3,05,7
15,028,5
3,05,7
-
27
5,4
12
2,4
85
17
5
1,0
32
6,4
16,1
32,2
156
31,2
3138
6,17,6
12
2,4
95101
19,020,2
5
1,0
34
6,7
176,2189,7
35,237,9
171184,5
34,236,9
-
11
0,4
0
0
5383
2,03,1
98155
3,75,8
162249
6,19,3
-
35
1,3
11
0,4
88
3,3
159
5,9
293
10,9
46
1,7
11
0,4
141171
5,36,4
257314
9,611,7
455542
17,020,2
1
+
.
. .
...
*
.
. .
...
.
. .
...
*
.
. .
...
.
. .
...
.
. .
...
( )
.
. .
...
* .
1 .: , 1 2004, 41 (441).
1991 643 . , 2004- 634 . ; 8 20 . , 42 60 . .
7,89,3
2,8
24,326,6
16,318,4
626727
51,257,1
-
1,12,6
0
4,06,3
4,06,1
177278
9,115,0
-
6,7
2,8
20,3
12,3
449
42,1
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
26/196
5(47), 2006
26
, - . :
1991 462 , 2004 459 ; - 27 59 (20062007 . 80 ). 19912004 - 8 16 .
. , ( -) 10 - . , ,
3
2,5
2
1,5
1,0
0,5
01990 1996 2000 2004 2010
- . ,
70% -;50% - - 2.
-. - , 7080 . - . 2010 - 100
, 50 . , 10 - 100150 (23 . ), 46 3. - , - - 2015 200230 . , - 3 ,
7%, , , - 4.
2 .: - , 25 - 2002; , 17 2004.
3 .: [http://www.context-ua.com], 15 2002.
4 .: . : . . 4(. : [www.caspiy.net]).
: .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
27/196
5(47), 2006
27
, - . ,
, , - 5.
, , - . , Business Weekly, : , - , , , -. , , -. -, , - 6.
- , - . -
, -, --, , . 30 .( ). , - .
. 1998 - , - , : , - , 7.
, . , . , , .
- . , , - . , -
, . . - - , 8.
5 . : , 1 2004, 41 (441).6 Business Weekly, 15 May 2002.7 , 14 2002, 43 (2412).8 .: -, 5 2004.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
28/196
5(47), 2006
28
, . , (, , ), -. () - ( ) - : , , , , - .
,
, . , 20022003 .
, , - , . - 20012002 , 1990 2000- . , . . (
) . ( ) . - , , - 9. - 2001 . : .
- . ( , -- ). , - 1/5 1/6 .
(). , , . , , , - . , .
9 (), 922 2004, 11 (129).
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
29/196
5(47), 2006
29
. 1990- -
( ) ( ), -. , ( - ).
, -, , . - , . , ?
, - , , , -
, . - - 10. : -, , , .
, . , - . - , , , . -, , - . -
. - , , , , , , , .
2006 - . - , , - . , .
, . , . -
(- - ), , - .
, , . ( 2015 .) (, , -
10 .: Gazeta Kz, 3 2003.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
30/196
5(47), 2006
30
) . -
. - , - . - (94 . 2005 .) , . 20052006 1 . . - 1 200 . ( 250270 .).
. - (10% ) -. 2005 14 . 2004 .
2000 20% ; , - . , , ; .
, ( ). 2006 - , . , . - , - , ( ) .
. . -, . , , - .
, - - 1216 ( ). Rzeczpospolita, 5 . - . -, .
, 8 ,
, . , - . -11, . .
11 // -, 9 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
31/196
5(47), 2006
31
, , . - 140 . 1 . . (
65 .) . , - .
, - , 100 . 1 . . . . : . , - . - .
, - . , - . , ,
. , - , - . , . , - , : - . , . , - ( ) .
(, , -).
:
. , ( ). , 2010 120 , 2002 .
. , - , .
: - , , -. , (-- ) ( + - ). , , . -
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
32/196
5(47), 2006
32
. , - .
, () - , , , , , , , . - 40 .12
. , , - . .
- , ( ) - , -
. - , - . (). - .
. , - , - .
, , - . , ( ), - . , 2006 30 . - 30 ( 2009 .). - . - ( ) . 60 . . - , .
, - . , . -
. - , , 2006 - .
. 2005 - , . , -, 2 . .
12 .: The inancial Times, 17 November 2004.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
33/196
5(47), 2006
33
2006 ,
. -, - -- ( ); -, . , . , - , ; -, - , - .
, - , - . - , . -
, ( , , ).
, - . - - , . -, , - . - - ( ) , , . , -
, : , . , .
, - 12% , ( 34%). , 2006 70% - - , 15 85%; 100 . 400
( 33 . ). ,
. 80% . , , , 2010 - 20 .
, , ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
34/196
5(47), 2006
34
. , Oil and Natural GasCorporation
( ), , , , , . 2000 3,5 . - . Oil and Natural GasCorporation .
. , (), - (20% ) ( / ). - 1 ; -- , .
, , 13.
, - . , () - - () (, ) -, . , - , , : - .
- . ,
, . 2005 -, - . , .
, - - . ., - .,
.
. , -
13 .: RusEnergy, 5 2004.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
35/196
5(47), 2006
35
( ) . , 2003 -
- , . - , , 2001 280 , 2020 320 , 100% -14.
-, 55% ( 85%) , - : , , , ( ).
. ( 15) - . 1993 (). , 38 , - 9 . , .
- , . ( ) . ( ), . , , . , , , - . - .
:
, , , , , - . ,
14 .: . - : . [http://www.carnegie.ru/ru/print/70488-print.htm], 11 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
36/196
5(47), 2006
36
. .
: - - - - 15. , , . , . - . , : - . , - .
1990- . , . - , -
, . , , , . , - 4,5 (32,9 ). : ( 2004 .) 2,75 (20,1 )16.
- . , - , ( ?) .
-
, . , - , . , - , - .
, . - . - . , - ( ). , .
, - , . , - .
2003 , - , 2006- -
15 , 1 2004, 41 (441).16 .: RusEnergy, 8 2004.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
37/196
5(47), 2006
37
15 . ,
7,7 . . , - 44%- , .
2004 , , , 35 . - 283 . . - 150 . . , .
. 2004 , , . (- ), -
( , -, ).
- - . - , - . : ( 5,5 ) ( 6,5 134 . ). . 400 . . , , - , 17.
-
. 20072009 100 .
1 . . . - 5 2006 . 2006 12 . 50 . 20072009 . 6 . , , 2010 .
, -. , 100 . 1 . . , , . , - - , - . , -
. -
. , . , - . , , , . -
17 .: , 14 2004.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
38/196
5(47), 2006
38
2006 2,5% ( 2005-) 24,9%.
( , - ), . , .
, - , -, . , , . , - . (, , -
) , . . -
- , . - , , - . -: , - . -, .
- . ,, ( 2002 .)
, , . - : , , , , , . 16% 40% .
, , 2001 - - , , , . -, , , - , - - .
, , . - (GEC) , (
2004 .) : , - , 18. ( .. ) . - . -
18 , 13 2004.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
39/196
5(47), 2006
39
. , , -
. 19.
2006 , . , -, . (10 ), . 1,5 ( ). - - . -, , , . . , - , , , . . - ( , ) ( 1012%, 25%).
(15 2006 .) . . . . , - , . - , . ( , ; , , ,, .)
, ( ) . , - , . - 43% (75,5 . ) - .
, - . , . - : , . - - .
19 .: .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
40/196
5(47), 2006
40
- , ,
. , , . - ( ) , .
, , , , . (, , , ..) . , - . -
. . , .
, . -
(). , -- , - ( ). - - . -- - - . - . -, , , - . - ( , , ) - .
- , - - . 2001 - , 2002- - (17,5 ). , .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
41/196
5(47), 2006
41
- : , .
- ( ), . - - .
2003 - , , , -, , - . - . - - , - .
, -. , .
, . , - , .
,
(, )
- , . -
: - 10% -
(27% ). -
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
42/196
5(47), 2006
42
-
- . - , - -.
() - , -
, -, - . - . - , - - . , - , .
-
- - , - . 2005 , - -- , , - - - .
I -
. - . - , - .
, - -
, 30% , - -.
- - : . 2004 10,97% . -
, 2006 253 , 2007- 260 .
, - - , - .
- , - (, - ) -
, . - , ( ). - . , - .
-
:, . - , - - , - .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
43/196
5(47), 2006
43
, - - , , . 2005 - -, - 1.
, - . -
, - -, .
. - , -. - ( ) . , - - . : .
- . , .
, , - .- . , , . ,
- ,
-. - :, . , -, . - : , -
-
. - - , - , . - , , - .
1 .: . // , 2004, 4 (34). . 130143.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
44/196
5(47), 2006
44
- .
. ( ) .
- . , - () .
. . - : - ( ), - ( - ) ( - ).
,
, , , :
1) - ;
2) , - ;
3) , , .
, , -
, . , , , - . , : - ( 30 ) , ( -) - 25-- .
, , , . -
.
2005 : .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
45/196
5(47), 2006
45
( ) . 60 . 160 .
. - - - . - ENI, - .
- . . . , , , . . . -
, , ; - . - ( ), - , -.
, : - , , , - . . .
. , -
- . , -. - . - , . - , 2%.
:
, () :
, . . , . , , , . , - -: .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
46/196
5(47), 2006
46
, ,
. : - , . , , . , . -, , - 30% - .
-, , - .
, , . - : - ( - ). , - . . 20 ., 7,5 , - 20102012 .
2005 , - -
-. : - ( Norsk Hydro Statoil, - ), , , .
, - . - , . - .
-
--. .
2006 50 160 . 1 . . , 230 . ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
47/196
5(47), 2006
47
. (
45%), - , 2006 . -, ( ) - 2.
- . - . , , 1,33,2 . ( ) - , -: 70% .
, . - .
- , , , , ,. . 2006 -, . - , - .
:
( ), - . 2006 - .
( ) - , - 3.
- , .
2003 - , ,
2 .: , 28 2005, 45 (491); 12 2005, 47 (493); 26 2005, 49 (495).3 .: . // -
, 2003, 4 (28). . 102108.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
48/196
5(47), 2006
48
. 25 , : , -
, - . -
- - ( ). - - , , . , , - . , ().
:
. , . - . , .
, -, . , , . - , , . , . , . : , , - .
, , - . , - ( ), . - : , .
: ?
- . , - , , , - .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
49/196
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
50/196
5(47), 2006
50
, - , - .
, 2004 , - . , -. , - .
-, - . -
, , 810 . , - -. , - . ; . , - 1,3 ., 300 .
- ( ). - . , ( , ), .
, -
. , - (4550 . ): 2003 - , 2007 - 70 . . 2004- , 1 . .
, - , . - 6,5 . , ( - ).
, - ,
.
- , , - . - 12,66 . , 25
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
51/196
5(47), 2006
51
. - ( ),
. , . : ( ), -. , . -, 2010 - 70 . 4.
- , -. 5 300 , 480 5 095 . . 51 , 27, 17. - 123,9 . : (68,6 ), - (18,4 ). 22 17 , 16 11 .
() - 100 . , - .
- , . , 1998 . - , , :, , . 2002 - , , . 2002 125 . . .
2005 6 7,3 2002-, 3,2 (3,5 ). 5%, 2005 700 . - 600 . . - , - .
, - . : , 2003 1 . 200 , , , , --, .
4 .: . // , 2004, 9.. 1318.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
52/196
5(47), 2006
52
2001 -
, 45% , 10%. , - 3035 . , 2004 . : 90% , 10% , - - . ( ) 1 ., 8,8 . . .
2004 , . -. ( ) . , ,
, 2002 - . 2002
2012 . , ( - 1998 ., 60,1% , 24,9% 15% ) (, 14 2004 .) - -. 1962 , 39,9 . . 8 . . 2002 - .
15 . . -
. - 2004 , , 13 . , . 200 . () . 2005 400 . .
, , , , . , (2003 .) 2012 , - (5 . 2005 . 10 . 2010-). -
, , .
, , - . - , , , - - .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
53/196
5(47), 2006
53
, 2002 , .
n . 2012 . ( 2003 . 2004-) 5 . , 2005- - 10 . 40 . 1 000 . .
n . - . , 2004 - Gas ProjectDevelopment Central -. 15 . , 20042007 15 .,
. - 0,5 . ; 50 50%.
n . - . 130 . (48 . ). - 36 . (4 . , - ), , . - : 5152 . 2005 56 2006-. 100 . .
,
, ( ) - - . , , - , . , , . 283 . . ; 150 . . 2003 , , , , .
, , 16 2004 ,
. , , - - ( - ). - , 90%, 10%. 90% ( 70%) . 35 ; 1 .; 2007. , , .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
54/196
5(47), 2006
54
- 9 . ,
207 . . , - 6 . , 2010 . 240 1 500 , - , , , 40 , . , - , - . - - -, . - , -
. , - ( , - ). - ( - ) . - , , .
( )
:
.
, -
(, )
- 1,62 . , 10- .
- 5,16,25 . ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
55/196
5(47), 2006
55
.
n , . - , - , 23 - 1994 .
n - () . . , -, (, ) , , 25 .
n 7 2001 () 312-II ( ). ,
, , . , , - () .
n 400 . . , 78 80, , - 16 .
- -
. , , 23% , - . - - , - . , , - - . -
( 28 -
2000 .), , - . -, - (), ,, -, , , - , .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
56/196
5(47), 2006
56
8 1,2 . -
. - , , , -. - . -.
n 2001 , , :
l - , -.
1) ;
2) ;
3) - -- .
l - . - , .
l
- - .
l 80% ( ) .
l , , - .
l -. - , , , .
l - , , - .
n , , . :
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
57/196
5(47), 2006
57
l . 5 , .
l , - , , - , . -2598 - , - , .
l . 14 , , , - - .
l , : 1) , , , -, 2) , , -, - .
n -, . , : , . , ,, , , -
.
. ,
- 1. - , . : , - , , - . , , .
, : ; -
1 .: Ellinidis G.Th. oreign Direct Investment in Developing and Newly Liberalized Nations // Journal ofInternational Law and Practice, Summer 1995, 4 J. Intl L. & Prac. 299.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
58/196
5(47), 2006
58
; , , , -
, . , - . - , , . , , , , , :
1) ;
2) ;
3) ;
4) , 2.
. . , , , - . , . , - , - 3. - , , ,
. , - . 1997 , 200 . , , , , . . 4. - , , - . , .
, -
, . : , - , , - , 5.
2 .: Ellinidis G.Th. Op. cit.3 .: Quest Information Limited, Uzbekistan Economy: Regional Overview, Country Report 1, 5 eb-
ruary 2004.4 .: Ibidem.5 .: Ellinidis G.Th. Op. cit.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
59/196
5(47), 2006
59
.
, -
: - . - 500 . , , -; , - ; -, -, ; , - ; , . - 6.
2003 , -, - . - . , - . , . VIII [ - ]. . -, , - , , - . . , -
7.
.
34 7 - , ( - ), , , - , -
8 . . 4 - - : 1) , , 2) - , 9.
6 .: U.S Department of State, Background Note: Uzbekistan [www.state.gov], October 2004.7 .: Asian Development Bank, Asian Development Outlook 2004: Economic Trends and Prospects in
Developing Asia, Uzbekistan [www.adb.org], March 2004.8 , 23 1994 . [http://www.bir.uz/law/].9 , 398-I, 24 1997 . [http://www.bir.uz/law/].
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
60/196
5(47), 2006
60
, - 10. -
, - . - , , - , . - , - -11. (- )12 , , 14 1994 13.
. , - ( ,
). , 1014 - , - 14. , , 15. - (. 12) , (), , . 16.
-. , , , [] , - [ ] 17.
(. 19) , - . :
1) , ;
2) , - , ;
3) - 18;
10 .: .11 .: .12 .: 71-II 25 2000 . (-
15 2000 .) [http://www.bir.uz/law/].13
.: 19 1994 . 215 - () -.
14 .: .15 .: Hines J., Sievers E. Legal Regime for Hydrocarbon Development in Uzbekistan // The Journal of The
Centre for Energy, Petroleum and Mineral Law and Policy, 11 August 2001.16 (.: [http://
www.bir.uz/law/obj1134723580/obj1135138247/obj1135858805/obj1135940285.html]).17 2395-1 [http://www.consultant.ru/popular/nedr/].18 . 34 23.09.1994 . (
13.12.2002 . 444-II), -, . .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
61/196
5(47), 2006
61
4) , , ;
5) , - ;
6) ( 22 )19.
, , , 20. , - - . - , :
1) . 5 21;
2) 1998 , - - 22;
3) , - 23.
, 24.
.
- , , , 4 , 1998 25.
28 2000 () . -, 4 2000 , , - 1718 26. . , -
19
.: .20 . . 50.21 .: . . 5.22 .: , 609-I 30 1998 .
(. : , 611-I 30 1998 .).
23 .: . . 26.24 . 24 ( 30 1995 .).25 .: ., . // ,
, 2002, 4. . 3941.26 .: -
28 2000 . [www.qonun.uz/laws.php?p=46].
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
62/196
5(47), 2006
62
, (, ), -
25 -27. -
, , . , , :
1) - ;
2) - , -
, , - ;
3) - - , ;
4) - , , 28.
, ,
, , , -; ( ) -, - , -, 29.
25 2000 () - ( , 15 2000 .). 1 2000 30.
.
-2598 , -
.
27 .: - .
28 .: .29 .: .30 . [http://www.bir.uz/law/].
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
63/196
5(47), 2006
63
2001 . 7 2001
312-II ( )31. , - , , -. , , - () 32.
400 . . 80 , - , 78 16 -. 8 1,2 . - -
33
., , : -, , . . 34.
., , . , , , 1990- , 2001- 450 000 , - 171 000 35.
.
, - . , , . , , , - , , - . -
, , - . , - , -
31 .: [http://www.bir.uz/law/].32 .: .33 .: APS Review Gas Market Trends, Uzbekistan: Privatization, 11 October 2004, Vol. 63, Issue 15.34 .: Ibidem.35 .: Ibidem.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
64/196
5(47), 2006
64
. , ,
, 36. . -
. --, . , - . ; , -, , . , , , .
, , - ,
. , - , , -. , , , , , ; , ; - , -, , . - , , .
,
: , , - 37. - , , , . , -.
- . - , .
. -
(), ,
36 .: lores M. A Practical Approach to Allocating Environmental Liability and Stabilizing oreignInvestments in the Energy Sectors of Developing Countries // Colorado Journal of International Law and Policy,Winter 2001.
37 .: Ibidem.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
65/196
5(47), 2006
65
. , - -
. , , , , 38
. , 39. - .
, - , . - -. - , - 40. - .
, ,
, , :
1) , -, ;
2) , ;
3) .
, , - , - . -. -
( ) ( ). - 41.
, , - , 42. - : , , - . , , , [-] 43.
, ,
38 .: Conine G.B. Petroleum Licensing: ormulating an Approach for the New Russia, 15 HOUS. J. INTL.L. 362, 1993.
39 .: Ibidem.40 .: Moss G.C. Petroleum Investments in Russia: Newly Enacted Law On Production-Sharing Agreements
Does Not Solve All Problems, 10 January 1996.41 .: Smith E., Dzienkowski J.S. A ifty-Year Perspective on World Petroleum Arrangements, 24 TEX.
INTL L.J. 13, 28, 1989.42 .: Investment at an Impasse: Russias Production Sharing Agreement Law and the Continuing Barriers
to Petroleum Investment in Russia. 7 Duke J. of Comp. & Intl L. 671, 1997.43 Ibidem.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
66/196
5(47), 2006
66
44. , , -
45
.
.
.
n - , 46. - - , :
1) ;
2) ;
3) , -47.
n . - 48.
n , ,
49.
n 80% ( ) - 50.
n , - , - - 51.
n . , - , , -52.
44 .: Skelton J.W. Jr. Investing in Russias Oil and Gas Industry: The Legal and Bureaucratic Obstacles,8 NAT. RESOURCES & ENVT. 26, 1993.
45 .: Smith E.E. rom Concessions to Service Contracts, 27 TULSA L.J. 493, 527, 1992.46 . 5. . [http://www.bir.uz/law/].47 .: .48 .: . . 6.49 .: . . 9.50 .: . . 12.51 .: . . 16.52 .: . . 24.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
67/196
5(47), 2006
67
n , , 53.
. ,
(, , ), - . 2001 ( - ). ( ) . 5, , . , , , , . -, , - .
. -, . . 26 , , - ,
54
.-, , - , - . , -, . , , 5 55, , , . - , , -56.
, , - , -2598. -
, . - 57. ,
, , -
53 .: . . 28.54 . . 26.55 .: . . 9.56 23 1994 .57 .: ., . . .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
68/196
5(47), 2006
68
2001 , . -
, - . , , , 58. , - . , - 59. , , 60.
, . -, ( ) , , . -, , -
, 61.
. !
, , - , , , . - .
. - . , ( ) , - 62.
, ( ) , 63.
30 1998 - 30 1998 ( ) - , -
64
. - -
58 .59 .: ., . . .60 . 14.61 .: ., . . .62 30 1995 . [http://www.bir.uz/law/].63 -1652 30 1996 . [http://www.bir.uz/law/].64 609-I [http://www.bir.uz/law/].
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
69/196
5(47), 2006
69
. ,
, , 65.
.
2003 - , , , - -. -
, , -, . 66 .
- . , 31 , , - , . -, , - , - . , , , 67.
.
, -. 7 - 2001 . . , , - - .
65 -2598 28 2000 . [http://www.bir.uz/law/].66 .: Interfax Petroleum Report, Uzbekistan Working to Speed UP PSA Projects, 30 July 2003.67 .: , ,
31 2003 .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
70/196
5(47), 2006
70
,
(, )
- . -, - , -
- . , , , . , - , , - .
-
, , 19601990- , , -. , - -, , -, . - , -, - . - - - .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
71/196
5(47), 2006
71
, ,
. , - , - , - .
, , - -, . - , , , - , , . , - , -
, - . (1991 .), ,
, : 21%; 45%; 19,7%; 14,3%1.
, 1990- - .
1. -, - - , - ; -, .
2. -
.3. .
4. -, , .
. , 4060% , - , , - . , , -, - 47% 51% ( 19912001 .) (, 2001 .).
, - :
n 50%.
n 2,75% (, 19972001 .) 1/3 ( , 2000 .).
1 .: . . : , 2001.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
72/196
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
73/196
5(47), 2006
73
2003
6 640
3 740
2 900
1 758
4 882
55
3 644
481
542
863
47
399
1 313
2002
6 507
3 573
2 933
1 720
4 787
53
3 477
517
511
830
47
395
1 178
2001
6 376
3 397
2 979
1 691
4 685
55
3 301
520
550
760
43
357
1997
5 876
2 929
2 947
1 566
4 310
63
2 909
761
411
620
51
192
875
1992
5 567
2 597
2 970
1 653
3 914
73,6
2 675
1 110
397
403
8
230
530
1990
5 361
2 514
2 847
1 677
3 684
77,3
2 469
1 255
315
369
231
299
1985
4 631
2 209
2 422
1 519
3 112
76,1
2 175
1 173
238
270
216
278
n , , -, , 300 000 ,
, - , 600 000800 000 , - 2. , , 1997 , 1 839,7 . .(30,4% ), , - ( ), 1/3 .
1
, 19852004 .(. .)
:
:
: [www.imf.tajik.net]
. , 1% 2% , - - , .
2 .: ., . . , 2003.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
74/196
5(47), 2006
74
, , , 1991 1997 60%,
1/3 - ( , -).
, , , . , , , , -.
, ( -) , , - , .
, , - . - , - . - , ; , .
- ( , -) , -
.
-, , , . , - ( ). , - , - .
- - ,
, , - -. - - - .
2002 , , 60100 . , . ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
75/196
5(47), 2006
75
( 2540% ) (
). , , - ( 20002003 . 200300%); - , - (), - , (.. ). , ( 2003 .), , , - , , . ,
. 2003 , , , , - , - , , - . , 2003 80 . - . : , ..
-
( ), 2002 :() 30% ; () .
, 2004 433 . ( , ) 1 ( , - ), 2150% .
, - . , 1 2005 441 171 ( -). 412 123 , 29 000 . ,
2005 400 000 , 2 000 3 000 . 156 , , - .
, 18 2005 620 000 , -, , 600 000 800 000 .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
76/196
5(47), 2006
76
600 ., 25% 2004 -
2005 (320 .) ODA ( ). - , . - , - - - , () - .
, 46% ( ), 29% , 14% , 3% 5% . 100 . . 60% -
, ,, (12%); 7% . (),
100150 . , -
, 600 ., 2005 , 400500 , , , (), - - . 20032004 , , .
, 2005 25 30%
, 4575% 136226% - . ; , 25% , 19% , - 18% ( , 2005 .).
, . - , - , , , , , . - ( ) ,
, . 94% -
. , ( 89% 1999 . 63% 2004-)3. -, , -
3 .: . , 2005.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
77/196
5(47), 2006
77
, . . - (-
). 2 4
( .)
3 5
: 2004 ( % )
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
4 .: Kireyev A. The Macroeconomic of Remittances. Case of Tajikistan // IM working paper 06/2.5 Ibidem.
()
..
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
78/196
5(47), 2006
78
2
6( .)
()
, :
, :
( )
4 7
300
105
60
25
15
5
150
2 700
410
330
30
50
945
540
225
135
45
1 345
6 . , 2005( , 2004).
7 .
52% 23%
20%
4%
49% 23%
20%
9%
75%
25%
67%
33%
83%
1% 2% 14%
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
79/196
5(47), 2006
79
, ,
, - , , .
- , , - . , - , .
- , - .
- ( , ),
, .
, , , - - . - - -, , , - . - , ( ) - ,
. - , . , , , -, .
( , - ) , - , .
, : 20 . 150 . -
; . 1 000 .,
. , , - 79% 1999 64% 2004-. - . - , 50% ( ).
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
80/196
5(47), 2006
80
, - :
n - - 1990- , , , .
n , . 2004 , (GNDI) 342 ., 15% , , .
n 80% (19% 2004 .) (.. - ).
n - .
n , , - .
- . - , . - ( , - ), , . - , , , - . , ( - ).
- , - , , - - , - .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
81/196
5(47), 2006
81
:
?( )
(, )
. - , -
. - , , -, - , , , -, .
, -
, . ,, , - .
* * *
- ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
82/196
5(47), 2006
82
, .
, -, -, , - . , (- ), ( 1954 .) , , - - . , - , , ( , -) .. - -, - . , , -
, , , . - 75%, , , -, , . , - ( ) , , - .
, . - ( -
). - , . , 42%. , - , . , , - , .
- , , - - . , - , , ; - 1. -, . , .
1 , -, - .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
83/196
5(47), 2006
83
: - ( ) -
, 2
/3 , 1
/3 - 2. , , ( ).
, - , . , . (-) - , , , , - , , , -. , , . , ,
. - , - , . , - , -, . , - .
-. (-) , ( - , XIX , ). -, ,
, . , , , -
(), -: ; - ( ); - - - . - , - - , - . , , , - .
* * *
-, .
2 .: // / .:.. (. .) . 3 . . 12. ., 1973. . 166.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
84/196
5(47), 2006
84
- () ,
, . -. . , , 1991 - , . . , -, , - : 1991 . . -; 1994 . - . ;1999 - . .
. , - , - ( ). , - ( . . ) - , . , - : , . (2004 .) : ( . - . ) - . , . . , -
, .
, , , - . . - , ( , - ). - , , - . - -, . !, ,
. , - . , ( - - . - . ), . . .
, - -
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
85/196
5(47), 2006
85
-,
, . : . , . , . , (2004 .) . -, - , , . , - . -, (. ) . - . - . , -,
(, , - ), -, - . - .
, . . , - , . - - (, , , , , - 15% ). , - ,
, -, - . - . . , , - ( , , ) .
, -, , , , ,
- . , , - , , . , , ( : , . - , , . - ). - ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
86/196
5(47), 2006
86
(
). , -, , - , , . ( ): ( - ) (- ). , . , - , , ( - ). -
: . - -, - : - , - . -; , ( ) - . - , , .
, - . , -
, . 1980- -, ; - ( ), (). 24 - () - . 1990 - , , , . , - . - , .
( 1990 .), . . . . , - . - (19901991 .) . . 1991 - .
, : ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
87/196
5(47), 2006
87
, . ( . -
, . , . , . ,. ; , , , .) , . (-) , .
. -, . - . ( 1995 .) . , .
. , , , . , - (1994 .), - (1996 .), (2000 .). , , . . , , - . 1995 . . ( 24,4% ) . (1,7%). . - , , , . .
2000 . . , 10% , , ( . - . ).
, , - , , - , - , - , . , - , . - ; -
( ) - . 2000 , - . ( ) - , , , 3. , -
3 .: . 90- XX XXI : // , 2005, 6.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
88/196
5(47), 2006
88
, ( ) , 20022003 , , - ,
, , - , . . -- . . ( -). , , , , . . ( ) - . . - , - , . 2003 . , - - 2005 .
2005 . . -
. , , -. , , . , (, , . , , 4). , , , . -, , - ( . , , ).
( . - . ) , - - .
, , . , . , . , , . - . , . , -, , . - ( ) , -
, , , . ( , -, -) - . . ,
4 ., : . : // , 28 2005. . 6.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
89/196
5(47), 2006
89
, , 5, .
( , - , ). ; , - - .
, , - : -- - , - , - ( , - . . ) ( ) -
, (). , - , , , - . , , .
* * *
, .
. , . . , - ( - ), - - .
, , -, -, ( -, , .. - ). - -, . ,
, - ( , 6); - , - . - . , .
5 .: . // , 2005, 4.6 , . ,
. , , , , ( ) .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
90/196
5(47), 2006
90
, , , .. -
, . : , . - 7. - , , , - , , - . -, , - , .. .
(. . ) -
, . . . - 2005 (. - ). - . . , -.
, - , , . , - . , - . - , , -, - . - 2006 - . 8 . , - : , - ( ), -. . , 2005 . , .
2006 , - . , - . , , (
, , ). , - , ( , . ),
7 .: . : - // , 22 2006. . 8.
8 , - , .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
91/196
5(47), 2006
91
. , -, ,
, -. : , - . - : - . - ( . ). 2006 ( ) - , (,, ), . - , - .
, . - , . .
, , -, , , , -. - , -, ( 2004 .), . - ( 2005-). , . - . , , .
,
- , , . , - , - , , , - . ( ) - - , .
, - ? , , , -
. -, , , , , , . , - (, ), , , . ,
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
92/196
5(47), 2006
92
. ( - , -
, .) - , - , - , . , - , , . -, - - . - , , . -, -
. - . , - : - ( ); . ( . , , , - ); , , ; ( ). , , , , , -
, .
: - ; ; - , - ; , , , ; , ; ; - (-) ; -
, - . - ; ; , .
. , -
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
93/196
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
94/196
5(47), 2006
94
, . , - , . -, - - .
, . - . - , -
. , . , . - 1 206 1, 7442, 1373. - , - .
, -. , , - (). -
(19992000 .) - , . - - , , . , - 4.
- ( ) - . , , , . , 1986 30 . , 1993- 60 ., 2000-
1 .: The World actbook, Tajikistan, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/ti.html], 5 2006.
2 .: The World actbook, Turkmenistan, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/tx.html], 5 2006.
3 .: The World actbook, Uzbekistan, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/uz.html], 5 2006.
4 , - [http://www.asiaplus.tj/news/1/5187.html], 5 2006.
5 .: UN Warns of Afghan Drug State // BBC, 18 November 2004 [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4022197.stm#map], 5 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
95/196
5(47), 2006
95
( . )11
1,84
2
1,87
5,71
( )10
9
0,55
0,59
10,14
80 .5 2005 89% , -, 6.
, , 2530% - 7 ( ), , , 1% 8. - , 0,75% ( 0,41%) 0,32%9.
- , . , - . , .
( ) -
. . , - , .
, - , ., - , , . : - , .
-, (. . 1); , .
1
,
6
.: World Drug Report 2006, United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. Vol. 1: Analysis. P. 12 [http://www.unodc.org/pdf/WDR_2006/wdr2006_volume1.pdf], 5 2006.7 .: 20042007. -
[http://www.unodc.org/uzbekistan/en/spf.html], 5 2006.8 .9 .10 World Proved Crude Oil Reserves, 1 January 1980 1 January 2006
Estimates, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iealf/crudeoilreserves.xls], 5 2006.
11 World Crude Oil and Natural Gas Reserves, 1 January 2005, the EnergyInformation Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iea2004/table81.xls], 5 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
96/196
5(47), 2006
96
12 World Proved Crude Oil Reserves, 1 January 1980 1 January 2006Estimates, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iealf/crudeoilreserves.xls], 5 2006.
13 World Crude Oil and Natural Gas Reserves, 1 January 2005, the EnergyInformation Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iea2004/table81.xls], 5 2006.
14
the CIA World actbook [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/index.html], 5 2006.15 .: // Turkmenistan.ru, 17 -
2005 [http://www.turkmenistan.ru/?page_id=3&lang_id=ru&elem_id=5880&type=event&highlight_words=%D0%A2%D0%AD,%D0%A2%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%81%D0%B0%D1%84%D0%B3%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B3,%D0%B3%D0%B0%D0%B7%D0%BE%D0%B%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B4&sort=date_desc], 5 2006.
16 .: Central Asian Leaders Seal Deal on Trans-Afghanistan Pipeline // Radio ree Europe, 27 2002 [http://www.rferl.org/newsline/2002/12/6-SWA/swa-271202.asp?po=y], 5 2006.
17 .: Press Conference in Islamabad, Pakistan. - [http://www.state.gov/p/sca/rls/rm/2006/64319.htm], 5 2006.
( . )13
0,85
0,76
1,61
( )12
5,8
0,28
6,08
2
- . - . 1 2 ,
60 - 1 261 14. -
. -- , , -, 33 . , 3,3 . 1 680 - 15.
2002 - , , , , 16. - ,
, - .
, - (5 2006 .) - , ( ) , 17.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
97/196
5(47), 2006
97
- ,
, , .18 2006
, , -, 18. , , .
, , . 11 2006 -, , , -
, , , - - [-] 19.
- . - . - , , - .
-, (- 198 .)20. - - . , -, . ,
1,5 / , - 21.
, - , , (10 ) , 22. , - 700 . 900 1 . 23. -, 24.
- , . ,
18
.: India to Join U.S.-Backed Gas Pipeline Project // The Hindu, 19 2006 [http://www.hindu.com/2006/05/19/stories/2006051919811600.htm], 5 2006.19 .: Iran Pipeline Not Easy, Delhi Turns to Turkmen Gas ields // The Indian Express, 11 2006 [http://
www.indianexpress.com/story/4187.html], 5 2006.20 .: // Afghanistan.ru, 9 2006 [http://www.
afghanistan.ru/doc.xhtml?id=4879], 5 2006.21 .: // Afghanistan.ru, 16 2006
[http://www.afghanistan.ru/doc.xhtml?id=4938], 5 2006.22 .: , , 900-
// -, 10 2006 [http://www.prime-tass.ru/news/show.asp?id=590531&ct=news].23 .24 .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
98/196
5(47), 2006
98
, , , - , -
. , - . -, , , - . , .
- - , , . , , .
, , , , - , , , - - .
, . , , - . , , .
, - , , . , , , , .
, - , , . - , , - ( ) - .
. , , . .
, , , - - , .
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
99/196
5(47), 2006
99
, ,
. - , - - .
-
, . , , - . , ( ) , - .
: 2004 109 133 25. , - , 289 26. , , , - 2,1 .
2003 , , 23,8 . 27. 759,7 . 28, 32 .
, - , 2004 2005 7% 29, 30. - , - , 49% 31. , - , ,
25
the World actbook, Pakistan, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/pk.html], 5 2006.26 .: World Proved Crude Oil Reserves, 1 January 1980 1 January 2006 Estimates, the Energy
Information Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iealf/crudeoilreserves.xls], 5 2006.
27 .: The World actbook, Pakistan, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/pk.html], 5 2006.
28 Ibidem.29 Ibidem.30 .: Country Analysis Briefs, Pakistan, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department of
Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/Pakistan/ull.html], 5 2006.31 Ibidem.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
100/196
5(47), 2006
100
- 32.
( 2005 .) , . . . , - , , 33. , - , , - . , - .
, , . - - . ,
, . -, , - .
. ( 2006 .) , - , - , -, .
(4 2006 .) : , - -
. , - . , -, - 34.
5 2006 - , : - , - 35. , - , .
, -
, . , , -
32 .: Country Analysis Briefs, Pakistan, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department ofEnergy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/Pakistan/ull.html], 5 2006.
33Burnett V. Energy: Three Routes to Meet Rising Demand for Gas // inancial Times, 31 May 2005.34 .: Bush, Pakistans Musharraf Outline Bright uture for Alliance [http://usinfo.state.gov/sa/Archive/
2006/Mar/04-804574.html], 5 2006.35 .: Press Conference in Islamabad, Pakistan.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
101/196
5(47), 2006
101
-.
, 2003 846 36
, - 37, 762,8 . , , - 5,8 38. , - 6,8 . - . , , 2003 , 27,1 . 39. (853,5 . ) 31,5 40.
, 7% 41. , 2010 3,1 ( 2,5 2005-)42. , -
. 1995 0,63 . , 2003- 0,96 . ( 27 . ), -, 2010- 1,4 , 2015- 1,8 . -, , 43.
- , - , -44. : , - , , , -
, -, 45. 7 2006 , -
, , . , , : , , ,
36 the World actbook, India, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/in.html], 5 2006.
37 .: Rank Order Oil Consumption, the World actbook, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/rankorder/2174rank.html], 5 2006.
38 .: World Proved Crude Oil Reserves, 1 January 1980 1 January 2006 Estimates, the EnergyInformation Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iealf/
crudeoilreserves.xls], 5 2006.39 .: The World actbook, India, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/in.html], 5 2006.
40 Ibidem.41 Ibidem.42 .: Country Analysis Briefs, India, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department of
Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/India/ull.html], 5 2006.43 Ibidem.44Luce E. Head to Head in the Quest for National Energy Security: Indias Overseas Competition with China
has an Effect on Diplomacy // inancial Times, 17 November 2004.45 Blank St. Indias Energy Offensive in Central Asia // Central Asia Caucasus Analyst, 9 2005
[http://www.cacianalyst.org/view_article.php?articleid=3117&SMSESSION=NO], 5 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
102/196
5(47), 2006
102
46. -, .
, - 47. .
, , - , , - . , , , , .
- , : . , , - . , ,
. - .
, - 48, - -, . , 49. - 2005 ( 3,6 .) - , . - , , - 4,2 .
, - , , - .
, , . , ( ) . , - . , - , . , - , . , - . -
, 2005. , .
46 .: The U.S.-India riendship: Where We Were and Where Were Going. - [http://www.state.gov/p/sca/rls/rm/2006/64230.htm], 5 2006.
47 Ibidem.48Blank St. Op. cit.49 Ibidem.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
103/196
5(47), 2006
103
, - . , - -, 5 2006 : ( . ..) 50.
, 60
(4,6% )51
. -. Oil and Gas Journal World Oil, 47,6 66,26 . 52, 27,8 33,7% 53.
2004 1,87 157,2 . ( ), 27,3 12 . 54. , 55.
- ( ) . 2003 25- , 2007 - 60 70 . 56. 2006 30 . 50 .
57. , -
, 2012 , - 58.
, , : , , ,
50 .: Press Conference in Islamabad, Pakistan.51 World Proved Crude Oil Reserves, 1 January 1980 1 January 2006
Estimates, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iealf/crudeoilreserves.xls], 5 2006.
52
Ibidem.53 Ibidem.54 .: The World actbook, Russia, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/
factbook/geos/rs.html], 5 2006.55 .: Top World Oil Producers 2004, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department of
Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/topworldtables1_2.html], 5 2006.56 .: Torbakov I. Russian-Turkmen Pacts Mark Strategic Shift for Moscow in Central Asia // Eurasianet,
15 2003 [http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/insight/articles/eav041503.shtml], 5 2006.57 .: 50 . // ,
19 2006 [http://top.rbc.ru/index.shtml?/news/policy/2006/04/19/19004430_bod.shtml], 5 2006.58 .: 2005 5 . // [http://www.
gazexport.ru/default.asp?pkey1=0000200017&id=107718], 5 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
104/196
5(47), 2006
104
. 1012 . ,
, - . , , 59.
- . , , - , ., .
, - ,
560 . 60
. , , - . , . , - . , - .
, , , , . , - - ,
. , .
, , - . - , - .
, , - . , .
, - , . -, , - .
59Ostrovsky A. Oil and Gas Bring Influence // inancial Times, 21 April 2006.60 .: Country Analysis Briefs, Caspian Sea, the Energy Information Administration of the U.S.
Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/Caspian/ull.html], 5 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
105/196
5(47), 2006
105
, , - ,
18,2 61
, 2004 1,27 , - 2,29 62; (1 ) . , ( )63 2003 64. , , - 7,9 .
Oil and Gas Journal World Oil, 1,5 1,45 . 65. 2003 35 . , 33,44 . ( 2,79 . )66. , - , 4345 . , , 2005 9,3%, .
, 2025 - 5,18 , 3,97 67. , ; , 2010 68.
- . - , 69, , , 4 .70
- () , -, , , , 71, ( 18,5 .) 72.
61 .: World Proved Crude Oil Reserves, 1 January 1980 1 January 2006 Estimates, the EnergyInformation Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iealf/crudeoilreserves.xls], 5 2006.
62 the World actbook, China, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/ch.html], 5 2006.
63 .: Rank Order Oil Consumption, the World actbook, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/rankorder/2174rank.html], 5 2006.
64 .: Country Analysis Briefs, China, theEnergy Information Administration of the U.S. Department ofEnergy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/china.html], 5 2006.
65 .: World Crude Oil and Natural Gas Reserves, 1 January 2005, theEnergy Information Administration
of the U.S. Department of Energy [http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/international/iea2004/table81.xls], 5 2006.66 .: The World actbook, China, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency [https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/ch.html], 5 2006.
67 .: Country Analysis Briefs, China.68 Ibidem.69 .: Koliandre A. Russia Keeps China Energy Options Open // BBC, 21 2006 [http://news.
bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/4830768.stm], 5 2006.70 .: Chinas Hu Urges More Africa Ties // BBC, 27 2006 [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/
4949688.stm], 5 2006.71 .: Country Analysis Briefs, China.72 .: Chinese irm Abandons Unocal Bid // BBC, 2 2005 [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/
4738939.stm], 5 2006.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
106/196
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
107/196
5(47), 2006
107
. , :
, - , - .
, - , - , , - . .
/
(, )
, - , - - , - . - - , -, , - - - . , -, 1924 . -, .,
- - -
- . , - , : - , - ?
, - . 1991 , - , -
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
108/196
5(47), 2006
108
: /
: (- ) ( - )1. : (
, ) (- ). , : - , , . - , .
- -, . - .
. , , - .., - .
. , , -, , .. -. ,
-.
, - . -
, - . - - , - .
-
, - -.
- - , - , - . - -
1 .:Robinson N. Russia: A State of Uncertainty. N.Y.: Routledge, 2002.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
109/196
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
110/196
5(47), 2006
110
, -
, . - , 3.
1991 , - , - , - 4. -, , (, , , ), - . , -, ,
, 5.
1991 - . - - . , ,
. , , - , . . . -, , , -, . , , - , ; . - , - 6.
3 .: Aa M., Durgut H. Kreselleen Dnya ve Trk Kimlii (Globalized World and Turkish Identity). stanbul:Toplumsal Dnm Yaynlar, 2004.
4 .: Efegil E., olak Y. Central Asia in Transition: Deteriorating Policies of theCentral Asian Leaders. .: Security of the Post-Soviet Space: Realities and Stereotypes / Ed. by S. Golunov.Volgograd: Volgograd State University Regional and Transboundary Studies Center, 2003. P. 2835.
5 .: International Crisis Group. Repression and Regression in Turkmenistan: A New InternationalStrategy // Asia Report, 4 November 2004, No. 85. P. 8.
6 .: Melvin N.J. Uzbekistan: Transition to Authoritarianism on the Silk Road. Canada: HarwoodAcademic Publications, 2000.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
111/196
5(47), 2006
111
, , , ,
. . -
, -, - . , , , . - , -. , . - . - 7.
, , 1990- , -
- . 1990- . . , - , . , -, , -, - . , . - -8.
. -, , - . - . , - , , - .
, . - . , . , , , - 9.
7 .: International Crisis Group. Cracks in the Marble: Turkmenistans ailing Dictatorship // Asia Group,17 January 2003, No. 44. P. 35, 21; International Crisis Group. Repression and Regression in Turkmenistan: ANew International Strategy. P. 35, 910.
8 .: Anderson J. Kyrgyzstan: Central Asias Island of Democracy. Canada: Harwood Academic Publishing,1999; International Crisis Group. Kyrgyzstans Political Crisis: An Exit Strategy // Asia Report, 20 August 2002, No. 37.P. 714; International Crisis Group. Political Transition in Kyrgyzstan: Problems and Prospects // Asia Report,11 August 2004, No. 81. P. 410.
9 .: International Crisis Group. Tajikistan: A Roadmap for Development // Asia Report, 24 April 2003,No. 51. P. 10; International Crisis Group. Tajikistans Politics: Confrontation or Consolidation? // Asia Briefing,19 May 2004. P. 24.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
112/196
5(47), 2006
112
- , . - , , , .
. , . , -, . , - . - ; - , ; - .
, , - , , , . -, .
, -
, . , , , - . , -, . . 100 . 2003 . -, ( ) . . - , , - . - - . -, , , , , 10.
10 International Crisis Group. Uzbekistans Reform Program: Illusion or Reality? // Asia Report, 18 ebruary2003, No. 46. P. 35, 2224; International Crisis Group. The ailure of Reform in Uzbekistan: Ways orwardor the International Community. P. 610.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
113/196
5(47), 2006
113
2003 , .
, . . , 11.
: - . , - , -, . 12.
10% - . , , - 13.
- , - . -, - , , - , , , / .
14
, - , - , , - , . - . , 92% , 95% 79,9% , - . 45% 30% - , - 15.
, : -
, , , , , -
11 .: International Crisis Group. Cracks in the Marble: Turkmenistans ailing Dictatorship. P. 89;International Crisis Group. Repression and Regression in Turkmenistan: A New International Strategy. P. 1112.
12 .: International Crisis Group. Tajikistan: A Roadmap for Development. P. 1415; International CrisisGroup. Tajikistans Politics: Confrontation or Consolidation? P. 1114.
13 .: International Crisis Group. Kyrgyzstans Political Crisis: An Exit Strategy. P. 23.14 .: International Crisis
Group. Is Radical Islam Inevitable in Central Asia? Priorities for Engagement // Asia Report, 22 December 2003,No. 22. P. 59, 2024.
15 .: Ibid. P. 35, 1016.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
114/196
5(47), 2006
114
, , , , -,
., , -, - -. . -, 16.
, 17. 11 2001 - , - - 18. -
. 2002 . -
- , . , - . ,, , - . - , , , . , . - . , , -
; -, 5% , 19.
- . - , - , -. : , , ,
. -
16 .: International Crisis Group. Repression and Regression in Turkmenistan: A New InternationalStrategy. P. 6.
17 .: International Crisis Group. The ailure of Reform in Uzbekistan: Ways orward or theInternational Community. P. 4.
18 .: International Crisis Group. Tajikistans Politics: Confrontation or Consolidation? P. 1012.19 .: Efegil E. 11 Eyll Sonras Byk Devletler Arasnda Artan birlii // KKAratrmalar, Winter 2002,
Vol. IV, No. 1. P. 163176; Efegil E. New Chapter in the Eurasia Politics After the 11 September Attacks: Reactionsto the American Attempts // Review of Social, Economic and Business Studies, Winter 20022003, Vol. 2. P. 6589;International Crisis Group. Is Radical Islam Inevitable in Central Asia? Priorities for Engagement. P. 1016.
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
115/196
5(47), 2006
115
: - ,
, . , . ( ), . , , - . . -, . , - .
, . , , -. . -
, - , . ? : , , .
, , , . , . , .
:
, ,
(, )
- , - ,
-
-
7/30/2019 2006 05(47)
116/196
5(47), 2006
116
- -
, - . - , , - - . , , , - ( ), - , - -
.. , 1970- - ( - )